Logia

Luke · Chapter 9 · The Twelve sent out with power

Luke 9:18

One time Jesus was praying in a quiet place, and only the disciples were with Him. He asked them, "Who do the people in the crowds say I am?"

Καὶ ἐγένετο ἐν τῷ εἶναι αὐτὸν προσευχόμενον κατὰ μόνας συνῆσαν αὐτῷ οἱ μαθηταί, καὶ ἐπηρώτησεν αὐτοὺς λέγων· Τίνα με οἱ ὄχλοι λέγουσιν εἶναι; Word by word ↓

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

3 commentators in Logia comment on Luke 9:18, from Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274) to David Brown (1803–1897): Aquinas, Henry and Brown.

Two voices on Luke 9:18

Choose two:

What the church has said

See all 3 voices as a grid

Eras across, traditions down, each with its first words. An empty cell is a place the library has no voice yet.

Middle AgesPuritans and the 1700sThe 1800s
Catholic
  • Aquinas CYRIL; Our Lord having retired from the multitude, and…
––
Protestant–
  • Henry In these verses, we have Christ discoursing with his…
  • Brown Lu 9:18-27. Peter's Confession of Christ—Our Lord's First Explicit…

What does Aquinas say about Luke 9:18?

Thomas Aquinas

1225–1274 · Medieval Catholic · Catena Aurea: Commentary on the Four Gospels, Collected out of the Works of the Fathers. Vol. III: St. Luke

And it came to pass, as he was alone praying, his disciples were with him: and he asked them, saying, Whom say the people that I am ?

CYRIL; Our Lord having retired from the multitude, and being in a place apart, was engaged in prayer. As it is said, And it came to pass, as he was alone praying. For He ordained Himself as an example of this, instructing His disciples by an easy method of teaching. For I suppose the rulers of the people ought to be superior also in good deeds, to those that are under them, ever holding converse with them in all necessary things, and treating of those things in which God delights. BEDE; Now the disciples were with the Lord, but He alone prayed to the Father, since the saints may be joined to the Lord in the bond of faith and love, but the Son alone is able to penetrate the incomprehensible secrets of the Father's will. Every where then He prays alone, for human wishes comprehend not the counsel of God, nor can any one be a partaker with Christ of the deep things of God. CYRIL; Now His engaging in prayer might perplex His disciples. For they saw Him praying like a man, Whom before they had seen performing miracles with divine power. In order then to banish all perplexity of this kind, He asks them this question, not because He did not know the reports which they had gathered from without, but that He might rid them of the opinion of the many, and instil into them the true faith. Hence it follows, And he asked them, saying. Whom say the people that I am?

Report a mistake

BEDE; Rightly does our Lord, when about to enquire into the faith of the disciples, first inquire into the opinion of the multitudes, lest their confession should appear not to be determined by their knowledge, but to be formed by the opinion of the generality, and they should be considered not to believe from experience, but like Herod to be perplexed by different reports which they heard. AUG. Now it may raise a question, that Luke says that our Lord asked His disciples, Whom do men say that am, at the same time that He was alone praying, and they also were with Him; whereas Mark says, that they were asked this question by our Lord on the way; but this is difficult only to him who never prayed on the way.

Report a mistake

What does Henry say about Luke 9:18?

Matthew Henry

1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume V (Matthew to John): Luke

On Luke 9:18–27

In these verses, we have Christ discoursing with his disciples about the great things that pertained to the kingdom of God; and one circumstance of this discourse is taken notice of here which we had not in the other evangelists-that Christ was alone praying, and his disciples with him, when he entered into this discourse, v. 18. Observe, 1. Though Christ had much public work to do, yet he found some time to be alone in private, for converse with himself, with his Father, and with his disciples. 2. When Christ was alone he was praying. It is good for us to improve our solitude for devotion, that, when we are alone, we may not be alone, but may have the Father with us. 3. When Christ was alone, praying, his disciples were with him, to join with him in his prayer; so that this was a family-prayer. Housekeepers ought to pray with their households, parents with their children, masters with their servants, teachers and tutors with their scholars and pupils. 4. Christ prayed with them before he examined them, that they might be directed and encouraged to answer him, by his prayers for them. Those we give instructions to we should put up prayers for and with. He discourses with them,

Report a mistake

On Luke 9:18–27

Concerning himself

I. Concerning himself; and enquires,

1. What the people said of him: Who say the people that I am? Christ knew better than they did, but would have his disciples made sensible, by the mistakes of others concerning him, how happy they were that were led into the knowledge of him and of the truth concerning him. We should take notice of the ignorance and errors of others, that we may be the more thankful to him who has manifested himself to us, and not unto the world, and may pity them, and do what we can to help them and to teach them better. They tell him what conjectures concerning him they had heard in their converse with the common people. Ministers would know better how to suit their instructions, reproofs, and counsels, to the case of ordinary people, if they did but converse more frequently and familiarly with them; they would then be the better able to say what is proper to rectify their notions, correct their irregularities, and remove their prejudices. The more conversant the physician is with his patient, the better he knows what to do for him. Some said that he was John Baptist, who was beheaded but the other day; others Elias, or one of the old prophets; any thing but what he was.

Report a mistake

On Luke 9:18–27

What they said of him

2. What they said of him. "Now see what an advantage you have by your discipleship; you know better." "So we do," saith Peter, "thanks be to our Master for it; we know that thou art the Christ of God, the Anointed of God, the Messiah promised." It is matter of unspeakable comfort to us that our Lord Jesus is God's anointed, for then he has unquestionable authority and ability for his undertaking; for his being anointed signifies his being both appointed to it and qualified for it. Now one would have expected that Christ should have charged his disciples, who were so fully apprized and assured of this truth, to publish it to every one they met with; but no, he strictly charged them to tell no man that thing as yet, because there is a time for all things. After his resurrection, which completed the proof of it, Peter made the temple ring of it, that God had made this same Jesus both Lord and Christ (Acts ii. 36); but as yet the evidence was not ready to be summed up, and therefore it must be concealed; while it was so, we may conclude that the belief of it was not necessary to salvation.

Report a mistake

What does Brown say about Luke 9:18?

David Brown

1803–1897 · Reformed (Free Church of Scotland) · A Commentary, Critical and Explanatory, on the Old and New Testaments: Luke

On Luke 9:18–27

Lu 9:18-27. Peter's Confession of Christ—Our Lord's First Explicit Announcement of His Approaching Death, and Warnings Arising Out of It.

(See on Mt 16:13-28; and Mr 8:34).

Report a mistake

Cited on other verses

Commentators citing Luke 9:18 while explaining another verse. The sentence is copied as the excerpt reads.

  • Matthew Henry · Luke 11:1

    … when he was baptized (ch. iii. 21), he was praying; he withdrew into the wilderness, and prayed (ch. v. 16); he went out into a mountain to pray, and continued all night in prayer (ch. vi. 12); he was alone praying (ch. ix. 18); soon after, he went up into a mountain to pray, and as he prayed he was transfigured (ch. ix. 28, 29); and here he was praying in a certain place.

  • J. C. Ryle · John 6:15

    Luke's account of this miracle, he immediately relates that our Lord asked the disciples, "Whom say the people that I am?" (Luke ix. 18.

The Greek words

WordDictionary formGlossGrammar
ΚαὶκαίAndConjunction
ἐγένετογίνομαιit came to passVerb · second aorist middle (deponent) indicative · 3rd person singular
ἐνἐνasPreposition
τῷὁ-Article · dative singular neuter
εἶναιεἰμίwasVerb · present active infinitive
αὐτὸναὐτόςHePersonal pronoun · accusative singular masculine
προσευχόμενονπροσεύχομαιprayingVerb · present middle or passive (deponent) participle · accusative singular masculine
κατὰκατάinPreposition
μόναςμόνοςsolitaryAdjective · accusative plural feminine
συνῆσανσύνειμιwere withVerb · imperfect active indicative · 3rd person plural
αὐτῷαὐτόςHimPersonal pronoun · dative singular masculine
οἱὁtheArticle · nominative plural masculine
μαθηταίμαθητήςdisciplesNoun · nominative plural masculine
καὶκαίandConjunction
ἐπηρώτησενἐπερωτάωHe questionedVerb · aorist active indicative · 3rd person singular
αὐτοὺςἑαυτοῦthemPersonal pronoun · accusative plural masculine
λέγωνλέγωsayingVerb · present active participle · nominative singular masculine
ΤίνατίςWhomInterrogative pronoun · accusative singular masculine
μεἐγώMePersonal pronoun · 1st person accusative singular
οἱὁtheArticle · nominative plural masculine
ὄχλοιὄχλοςcrowdsNoun · nominative plural masculine
λέγουσινλέγωdo pronounceVerb · present active indicative · 3rd person plural
εἶναιεἰμίto beVerb · present active infinitive

From MACULA (CC BY 4.0), as the Open Word Bible reads them.

How the Open Word Bible translates Luke 9:18

Word for word: And it came to pass as was he praying in solitary, were with him the disciples, and he questioned them saying, Whom me the crowds pronounce to be?

alone: away from the crowds Idiom

Not: with no one at all near him

Luke says in the same breath that the disciples were with him. Alone means apart from the crowds, with only the disciples near.

while he was praying: Luke's turning points come in prayer Theology

Not: a detail of no importance

Luke shows Jesus praying at his baptism (3:21), before choosing the Twelve (6:12), here, and on the mountain (9:28-29).

Who do the crowds say that I am: a question about public opinion Grammar

Not: a question testing the disciples' own faith

The first question is about what others say; the personal question follows in 9:20.

in a quiet place (B); away from the crowds (R) Word choice

Not: alone

"Alone" would contradict the disciples' presence in the same sentence.

Cross-references

  • Matthew 16:13-16 5 voices When Jesus reached the district around Caesarea Philippi, He put a question to His disciples: "Who do people say that the Son of Man is?"
  • Matthew 26:36 4 voices Jesus then came with them to a place named Gethsemane. He told the disciples, "Stay seated here while I go on over there and pray."
  • Mark 8:27-30 1 voice Jesus and His disciples set out for the villages of the Caesarea Philippi area. As they went, He asked them, "Who do people say I am?"
  • Luke 11:1 4 voices Once Jesus was praying in a certain place. When He had finished, one of His disciples asked Him, "Lord, teach us how to pray, the way John taught his own disciples."

Cross-references from OpenBible.info (CC BY), most voted first.

Read Luke 9 with all its commentary