Logia

John · Chapter 7 · Jesus and his brothers

John 7:19

Did not Moses give you the law? Yet not one of you keeps the law. Why are you trying to kill Me?"

Οὐ Μωϋσῆς δέδωκεν ὑμῖν τὸν νόμον; καὶ οὐδεὶς ἐξ ὑμῶν ποιεῖ τὸν νόμον. τί με ζητεῖτε ἀποκτεῖναι; Word by word ↓

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

10 commentators in Logia comment on John 7:19, from John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) to B. F. Westcott (1825–1901): Chrysostom, Augustine, Cyril, Calvin, Lapide, Henry, Bengel, Wesley, Ryle and Westcott.

Two voices on John 7:19

Choose two:

What the church has said

See all 10 voices as a grid

Eras across, traditions down, each with its first words. An empty cell is a place the library has no voice yet.

Early churchReformationPuritans and the 1700sThe 1800s
Catholic–
  • Lapide ... For it strictly forbids murder (Ex. xxiii. 7).…
––
Protestant–
  • Calvin 19. Did not Moses give you the Law? The…
  • Henry (1.) He argues against them by way of recrimination,…
  • Bengel Moses) whom ye believe. ... to you) not to…
  • Wesley 19. But ye are unrighteous; for ye violate the…
  • Ryle This would be more literally rendered, " none of…
  • Westcott The principle laid down is applied to the condemnation…
Church Fathers
  • Chrysostom Ver. 19. “Did not Moses give you the Law?…
  • Augustine 2. “Did not Moses,” saith He, “give you the…
  • Cyril By many devices cometh about the discourse of the…
–––

What does Chrysostom say about John 7:19?

John Chrysostom

c. 347–407 · Patristic (Greek East) · Homilies on the Gospel of St. John

Homily XLIX. John vii. 9, 10

Ver. 19. “Did not Moses give you the Law? and yet none of you keepeth the Law? Why go ye about to kill Me?”

“And what connection,” saith some one, “has this, or what has this to do with what was said before?” The Jews brought against Him two accusations; one, that He broke the Sabbath; the other, that He called God His Father, making Himself equal with God. And that this was no imagination of theirs, but His own declared judgment, and that He spake not as do the many, but in a special and peculiar sense, is clear from this circumstance. Many often called God their Father; as “Have we not all one Father, hath not one God created us?” ( Mal. ii. 10 ), but not for that was the people equal to God, on which account the hearers were not offended. As then when the Jews said, “This man is not from God,” He often healed them, and made defense for the violation of the Sabbath; so now had the sense they assigned to His words been according to their imagination, not according to His intention, He would have corrected them, and said, “Why suppose ye Me equal to God? I am not equal”; yet He said nothing of the kind, but, on the contrary, declared by what followed, that He is equal. For, “As the Father raiseth up the dead, and quickeneth them, so also the Son” ( c. v. 21 ); and “That all may honor the Son as they honor the Father”; and “The works which He doeth, the same doeth the Son likewise;” all these go to establish His equality. ...

Report a mistake

What does Augustine say about John 7:19?

Augustine of Hippo

354–430 · Patristic (Latin West) · Lectures or Tractates on the Gospel According to St. John

Tractate XXX. Chapter VII. 19–24

2. “Did not Moses,” saith He, “give you the law, and yet none of you doeth the law? Why do ye seek to kill me?” For ye seek to kill me just for this reason, that none of you doeth the law; for if ye did do the law, ye would recognize Christ in its very letters, and ye would not kill Him when present with you. And they answered: “The crowd answered Him;” answered as a tumultuous crowd, things not pertaining to order, but to confusion; in a word, the crowd was disturbed. See what answer it made: “Thou hast a devil: who seeks to kill thee?” As if it were not worse to say, “Thou hast a devil,” than to kill Him. To Him, indeed, was it said, that He had a devil, who was casting out devils. What else can a turbulent disorderly crowd say? What else can filth stirred up do but stink? The crowd was disturbed; by what? By the truth. For the eyes that have not soundness cannot endure the brightness of the light.

Report a mistake

What does Cyril say about John 7:19?

Cyril of Alexandria

c. 376–444 · Patristic (Greek East) · Commentary on the Gospel according to S. John

Hath not Moses given you the law, and no one of you keepeth the law? why are ye seeking to kill Me?

By many devices cometh about the discourse of the Saviour to one aim. For having in the preceding, indirectly blamed (as was meet) the Pharisees who supposed that they ought not to obey the commands from above, but to introduce their own opinions, and were zealous rather to gain honour from those under them, and did not offer it to the Lord of all, but diverted it to their own persons, that thence they were daring to transgress more freely:----He again, in other and severest wise, prepares for them open at length and unveiled reproof. For He being condemned for breach of the sabbath, and enduring the most unjust accusation of lawlessness for this, convicted them not of individually transgressing the law, but that the whole nation of the Jews had made the law of Moses of no account. For tell Me (He saith) ye who condemn the man who is zealous to shew mercy on the sabbath day, who have passed foullest censure upon those who do well, and freely condemn the compassionate, hath not the commandment not to murder been delivered you by Moses, whom ye admire? did ye not hear him say, The innocent and righteous slay thou not? why then do ye grieve even your own Moses, by so readily transgressing the Law that was appointed through him? An argument and clear proof of this, is that ye persecute Me who have done no wrong, and are unjustly eager to slay Him who can never be accused of that whereby He should suffer this.

Report a mistake

What does Calvin say about John 7:19?

John Calvin

1509–1564 · Reformed · Commentary on the Gospel According to John

Did not Moses give you the Law?

19. Did not Moses give you the Law? The Evangelist does not give a full and connected narrative of the sermon delivered by Christ, but only a brief selection of the principal topics, which contain the substance of what was spoken. The scribes mortally hated him, and the priests had been kindled into rage against him, because he had cured a paralytic; and they professed that this arose from their zeal for the Law. To confute their hypocrisy, he reasons, not from the subject, but from the person. All of them having freely indulged in their vices, as if they had never known any law, he infers from it that they are not moved by any love or zeal for the Law. True, this defense would not have been sufficient to prove the point. Granting that — under a false pretense — they concealed their wicked and unjust hatred, still it does not follow that Christ did right, if he committed any thing contrary to the injunction of the Law; for we must not attempt to extenuate our own blame by the sins of others.

But Christ connects here two clauses. In the former, he addresses the consciences of his enemies, and, since they proudly boasted of being defenders of the Law, he tears from them this mask; for he brings against them this reproach, that they allow themselves to violate the Law as often as they please, and, therefore, that they care nothing about the Law. Next, he comes to the question itself, as we shall afterwards see; so that the defense is satisfactory and complete in all its parts. Consequently, the amount of this clause is, that no zeal for the Law exists in its despisers. Hence Christ infers that something else has excited the Jews to so great rage, when they seek to put him to death. In this manner we ought to drag the wicked from their concealments, whenever they fight against God and sound doctrine, and pretend to do so from pious motives.

Report a mistake

Those who, in the present day, are the fiercest enemies of the Gospel and the most strenuous defenders of Popery, have nothing more plausible to urge in their behalf than that they are excited by ardor of zeal. But if their life be narrowly examined, they are all filled with base crimes, and openly mock at God. Who knows not that the Pope’s court is filled with Epicureans? And as to Bishops and Abbots, have they as much modesty as to conceal their baseness, that some appearance of religion may be observed in them? Again, as to monks and other brawlers, are they not abandoned to all wickedness, to uncleanness, covetousness, and every kind of shocking crimes, so that their life cries aloud that they have altogether forgotten God? And now that they are not ashamed to boast of their zeal for God and the Church, ought we not to repress them by this reply of Christ?

Report a mistake

What does Lapide say about John 7:19?

Cornelius a Lapide

1567–1637 · Roman Catholic (Jesuit) · The Great Commentary: S. John's Gospel

On John 7:19–20

... For it strictly forbids murder (Ex. xxiii. 7). So S. Augustine and others. But secondly, F. Lucas thus explains it more profoundly and more closely to the context : " Ye accuse Me of disregarding the law, and breaking the Sabbath by healing the paralytic. But ye equally break it by circumcising a man, which is a longer and more cruel act than healing with a word. Ye are therefore more deserving of death than I am."

Report a mistake

What does Henry say about John 7:19?

Matthew Henry

1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume V (Matthew to John)

He argues against them by way of recrimination, convicting them of far worse practices

(1.) He argues against them by way of recrimination, convicting them of far worse practices, v. 19. How could they for shame censure him for a breach of the law of Moses, when they themselves were such notorious breakers of it? Did not Moses give you the law? And it was their privilege that they had the law, no nation had such a law; but it was their wickedness that none of them kept the law, that they rebelled against it, and lived contrary to it. Many that have the law given them, when they have it do not keep it. Their neglect of the law was universal: None of you keepeth it: neither those of them that were in posts of honour, who should have been most knowing, nor those who were in posts of subjection, who should have been most obedient. They boasted of the law, and pretended a zeal for it, and were enraged at Christ for seeming to transgress it, and yet none of them kept it; like those who say that they are for the church, and yet never go to church. It was an aggravation of their wickedness, in persecuting Christ for breaking the law, that they themselves did not keep it: "None of you keepeth the law, why then go ye about to kill me for not keeping it?" Note, Those are commonly most censorious of others who are most faulty themselves. Thus hypocrites, who are forward to pull a mote out of their brother's eye, are not aware of a beam in their own. Why go ye about to kill me? ...

Report a mistake

... Some take this as the evidence of their not keeping the law: "You keep not the law; if you did, you would understand yourselves better than to go about to kill me for doing a good work." Those that support themselves and their interest by persecution and violence, whatever they pretend (though they may call themselves custodes utriusque tabulæ—the guardians of both tables), are not keepers of the law of God. Chemnitius understands this as a reason why it was time to supersede the law of Moses by the gospel, because the law was found insufficient to restrain sin: "Moses gave you the law, but you do not keep it, nor are kept by it from the greatest wickedness; there is therefore need of a clearer light and better law to be brought in; why then do you aim to kill me for introducing it?"

Report a mistake

What does Bengel say about John 7:19?

Johann Albrecht Bengel

1687–1752 · Lutheran Pietist · Gnomon of the New Testament, Vol. II (Gospels according to St Luke and St John)

Moses) whom ye believe. ... to you) not to me.— ... the law) There is much mention of the Law made here ; ver. 23, 49, 51; appropriately so: for ... the joy of the law, completed in the public reading of it, is on the day following the last day of the Feast of Tabernacles.'!. The eighth day, according to the different points of view, in which it was regarded, was either part of the Feast of Tabernacles, or a distinct feast. The former is the view of it, which holds good in John: and in the same feast, every seventh year, the Law used to be read; Deut, xxxi. 10, “ At the end of every seven years, in the solemnity of the year of release, in the Feast of Tabernacles, thou shalt read this law before all Israel, in their hearing.” ... none) Ye assail Me as guilty of violating the law, ver. 21, etc. But yet ye all violate it.—ri us, why ... as though I Had violated the Sabbath. ... ye seek) Ye seek to kill Me. Therefore ye fulfil not the law. Therefore ye do not the will of God. Therefore ye cannot reach the knowledge of My doctrine, because ye are altogether unlike Me, and hate Me.

Report a mistake

What does Wesley say about John 7:19?

John Wesley

1703–1791 · Anglican (Methodist) · Explanatory Notes upon the New Testament: St. John

19. But ye are unrighteous; for ye violate the very law which ye profess so much zeal for.

Report a mistake

What does Ryle say about John 7:19?

J. C. Ryle

1816–1900 · Anglican (Evangelical) · Expository Thoughts on the Gospels: St. John, Vol. I

On John 7:14–24

This comment begins at John 7:14:

We learn first in this passage, that honest obedience to God's will is one ivay to obtain clear spiritual knowledge. Our Lord says, " If any man will do His will, he shall know of the doctrine, whether it be…

none of you keepeth the law, &c.

This would be more literally rendered, " none of you doeth the law." It is the same word that is used in the expression, " if any man will do His will," (v. 17.) The meaning seems to be, " You reject me and my doctrine, and profess to be zealous for the honour of Moses and the law. And yet none of you really obey the law in heart and in spirit. For instance : why do you seek to kill me? You are full of hatred of me, and want to put me to death unjustly, in the face of the sixth commandment. This is not keeping the law."

The Greek word rendered " go about," is the same that is rendered " seek" in v. 1 of this chapter, and ch. v. 16, 18.

Report a mistake

What does Westcott say about John 7:19?

B. F. Westcott

1825–1901 · Anglican · The Gospel According to St. John: The Authorised Version with Introduction and Notes

On John 7:14–24

This comment begins at John 7:14:

In the first scene in the temple Christ shews the source and the test of His teaching (16 — 18) as against the false interpretations of the Law (v. 19), which were against the spirit and history of the Law…

On John 7:14–36

This comment begins at John 7:14:

The discussions at "the midst of the feast " lay open thoughts of three groups of men: "the Jews" (14 — 24), "some of the inhabitants of Jerusalem" (25 — 31"), the envoys of " the chief priests and the…

The principle laid down is applied to the condemnation of the Jews. They professed unbounded devotion to Moses, and yet they broke the Law because they were estranged from its spirit. Their ignorance of the Law had at last grown so great that they were prepared to murder Him who came to fulfil the Law.

Did not... the law, and yet none.,. the law] Did not.. .the law? and none. ..the law. The question is an appeal to their own proud boast. Then follows their condemnation by the Lord.

Why go ye about (seek ye, and so v. 20) to kill me] v. 1.

Report a mistake

Cited on other verses

Commentators citing John 7:19 while explaining another verse. The sentence is copied as the excerpt reads.

  • John Chrysostom · John 4:16–19

    ( c. vii. 19 ), they not only did not admire as the woman did but even mocked at and insulted Him; yet they had a demonstration from other miracles, she had only heard this speech.

  • John Chrysostom · John 11:53–54

    And, in truth, had sought to do so before; for the Evangelist saith, “Therefore the Jews sought to kill Him” ( c. v. 18 ); and, “Why seek ye to kill Me?” ( c. vii. 19.

  • Johann Albrecht Bengel · John 7:1

    … He had not only broken the Sabbath, but said also that God was His Father, making Himself equal with God”), and which revived at this feast of Tabernacles, and subsequently blazed out more furiously.—Harm., p. 352]; ver. 19, “Why go ye about to kill Me?” 30, 44; viii. 40, 59, “ Then took they up stones to cast at Him; but Jesus hid Himself.”

  • J. C. Ryle · John 3:32

    As God, He declares with authority truths which Ho had seen, and heard, and known from all eternity with the Father. (John 7. 19, 30 ; viii. 38.)

  • B. F. Westcott · John 7:7

    … in another aspect of the relation of the believer to Christ, in his first approach (vi. 44, 65, iii. 3, 5), and in his later progress (xiii. 33, 36, xvi. 12) ; and yet again of the relation of the Son to the Father (v. 19, note).

Whole homilies and tractates on John 7:19

The Greek words

WordDictionary formGlossGrammar
ΟὐοὐNotParticle · negative
ΜωϋσῆςΜωϋσῆςMosesNoun · nominative singular masculine
δέδωκενδίδωμιVerb · perfect active indicative · 3rd person singular
ὑμῖνσύto youPersonal pronoun · 2nd person dative plural
τὸνὁtheArticle · accusative singular masculine
νόμοννόμοςlawNoun · accusative singular masculine
καὶκαίandConjunction
οὐδεὶςοὐδείςno oneAdjective · nominative singular masculine · negative
ἐξἐκofPreposition
ὑμῶνσύyouPersonal pronoun · 2nd person genitive plural
ποιεῖποιέωkeepsVerb · present active indicative · 3rd person singular
τὸνὁtheArticle · accusative singular masculine
νόμοννόμοςlawNoun · accusative singular masculine
τίτίςWhyInterrogative pronoun · accusative singular neuter
μεἐγώMePersonal pronoun · 1st person accusative singular
ζητεῖτεζητέωdo you seekVerb · present active indicative · 2nd person plural
ἀποκτεῖναιἀποκτείνωto killVerb · aorist active infinitive

From MACULA (CC BY 4.0), as the Open Word Bible reads them.

How the Open Word Bible translates John 7:19

Word for word: Not Moses has given you the law?

a question that expects the answer yes Grammar

Not: a real question

The negative at the start of the question expects agreement. The perfect tense means a gift once given and still in force.

the law: the law of Moses, given at Sinai Word sense

Not: law in general

The law God gave Israel through Moses (1:17), which they honored and claimed to keep (5:45-47). Jesus's argument in 7:22-23 turns on two of its commands.

Word for word: And no one of you does the law.

and: and yet Grammar

Not: and also

The simple "and" joins two facts that do not fit together: they have the law, and they do not do it.

none of you keeps the law: shown by their plan to kill him Theology

Not: no one can keep the law perfectly

The next sentence makes the point: the law forbids murder (Exodus 20:13), and they are trying to kill him. As 7:22-24 will show, they also judge him by a rule they themselves set aside for circumcision.

keeps (B); obeys (R) Word choice

Not: does (Literal)

"Doing" the law is the Greek way of saying keeping or obeying it.

Word for word: Why me are you seeking to kill?"

seeking to kill me: the authorities' plan, known since the healing on the Sabbath Culture

Not: a threat from the whole crowd

John has already said that the authorities were seeking to kill Jesus because he healed on the Sabbath and called God his Father (5:16-18), and that this is why he stayed away from Judea (7:1). The same verb is used each time. Jesus says it openly to those who asked about his learning (7:15-16).

why: a real question that exposes them Grammar

Not: a rhetorical exclamation

Jesus asks for their reason. Since they claim to keep the law of Moses, a plan to kill an innocent man condemns them by that law.

trying to (B, R); So (R) Word choice

Not: seeking to (Literal)

"Seeking to" means trying to. Readable adds "So" to show that the question follows from the one before.

Cross-references

  • John 1:17 12 voices For the law was given through Moses; grace and truth came through Jesus Christ.
  • Matthew 12:14 4 voices The Pharisees left and met together to plot against Him, looking for a way to put Him to death.
  • John 7:1 9 voices After this Jesus went from place to place in Galilee. He did not want to travel around Judea, because the Jewish leaders there were looking for a way to kill Him. But Jesus went to the Mount of Olives.
  • John 11:53 9 voices So from that day on they plotted together to kill Him.
  • Exodus 24:2-3 Moses by himself is to approach the LORD. The rest are to stay back, and the people are not to climb the mountain with him."

Cross-references from OpenBible.info (CC BY), most voted first.

Read John 7 with all its commentary