B. F. Westcott · The Gospel According to St. John: The Authorised Version with Introduction and Notes
John 7
69 excerpts on John 7, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
1—13.
In these verses there is a lively picture of the position which the Lord held at the time. Continued teaching in Judaea had become impossible (v. 1). His brethren impatiently pressed for some more decisive public manifestation of His power (vv. 3 — 9). The multitudes gathered at Jerusalem were divided between faith and distrust (vv. 11, 12). But the dominant party kept down all open discussion of His claims (v. 13). The description brings out distinctly various aspects of a work and a Person not yet fully revealed.
John 7:1–13 · Open Word Bible
1After this Jesus went from place to place in Galilee. He did not want to travel around Judea, because the Jewish leaders there were looking for a way to kill Him. But Jesus went to the Mount of Olives. 2Now the Jewish Festival of Tabernacles was near. At daybreak He returned to the temple courts. All the people kept coming to Him, and He sat down and taught them. 3So His brothers said to Him, "Leave this place and go to Judea, so that Your disciples there can also see the works You are doing. The scribes and the Pharisees brought to Him a woman caught in adultery and made her stand in the middle of the gathering. …
After these things
And after these things, that is, the whole crisis brought about by the miracle of feeding.
walked] ch. vi. 66, note.
would not walk in Jewry (Judaea, as v. 3)] The words imply a previous work in Judaea corresponding to that now accomplished in Galilee.
to kill him] See v. 18.
John 7:1 · Open Word Bible
1After this Jesus went from place to place in Galilee. He did not want to travel around Judea, because the Jewish leaders there were looking for a way to kill Him. But Jesus went to the Mount of Olives.
the Jews’ feast of tabernacles
the feast of the Jews, the feast of Tabernacles. This feast was pre-eminent among the festivals "as the holiest and greatest" (Jos. ' Ant.' viii. 4. 1). ... The record of some details of this period is given in Matt. xii. — xvii., xxi.
John 7:2 · Open Word Bible
2Now the Jewish Festival of Tabernacles was near. At daybreak He returned to the temple courts. All the people kept coming to Him, and He sat down and taught them.
His brethren
See Lightfoot, Excursus II. on ' Galatians.' Perhaps we may conclude even from this notice, compared with Mark iii. 21, 31, that the brethren were elder brethren (i.e. sons of Joseph by a former marriage) who might from their age seek to direct the Lord.
therefore] since Jesus had not gone up to the last Passover.
thy disciples also may see (behold)...] not only those disciples who would be gathered from all parts to Jerusalem, but specially those who had been gained by earlier teaching in Judaea and Jerusalem, and who still remained there. From this notice it appears that miracles were wrought chiefly among strangers to arrest attention ; and also that the Lord was accompanied only by a small group of followers in His Galilaean circuits.
John 7:3 · Open Word Bible
3So His brothers said to Him, "Leave this place and go to Judea, so that Your disciples there can also see the works You are doing. The scribes and the Pharisees brought to Him a woman caught in adultery and made her stand in the middle of the gathering.
For there is no man that doeth any thing in secret
as Christ did, for His works in Galilee and even beyond the borders of Galilee were practically withdrawn (such is the argument) from the observation of those who could best judge of their worth.
and he. ..seeketh (and seeketh) to be known openly] Literally, "to be in boldness" ..., to stand forth boldly as one urging his claims before the world without reserve or fear. Comp. Wisd. v. 1 ; Col. ii. 15. The words refer to the position claimed and not to the position gained ("to be publicly known''). ...
John 7:4 · Open Word Bible
4No one who wants to be known openly does things in secret. If You are doing these things, show Yourself to the world." Then they said to Him, to test Him, "Teacher, this woman was caught in the very act of committing adultery.
If thou do
The words do not carry with them any definite denial of the fact (v. 3), but simply place the fact as the basis for the conclusion.
shew thyself] manifest thyself. The word ... is characteristic of St John. Comp. xxi. 1, note, i. 31, ix. 3, xvii. 6.
to the world] viii. 26. ...
For neither did his brethren believe in him
The phrase need not mean more than that they did not sacrifice to absolute trust in Him all the fancies and prejudices which they cherished as to Messiah's office. Thus their belief could not be a constant power (OVK ... influencing their whole mode of thinking. They ventured to advise and urge when Faith would have been content to wait.
believe in him] Compare viii. 30, note.
John 7:5 · Open Word Bible
5For even His own brothers did not believe in Him. In the Law, Moses ordered that women like this be stoned. What do You say, then?"
Then Jesus said
Therefore Jesus saith...
My time] the seasonable moment for the revelation of myself .... The word ... occurs in St John's Gospel only in this passage [v. 4 is a gloss]. As compared with "hour" ... "season '' appears to mark the fitness of time in regard to the course of human events, while " the hour" has reference to the divine plan.
your time ... is alway ready] Christ's brethren had no new thoughts to make known. What they had to say was in harmony with what others were feeling. Their time was always ready. They were in sympathy with the world; while Christ was in antagonism with the world. They risked nothing by joining in the festival pilgrimage ; He kept back not only from the danger of open hostility, but also from the violence of mistaken zeal, lest some should "make Him a king" (vi. 15). The thought which underlies the verse corresponds with that in v. 17.
John 7:6 · Open Word Bible
6So Jesus told them, "My time has not yet arrived, but for you the time is always right. They said this to test Him, so that they would have something to accuse Him of. But Jesus bent down and, with His finger, began writing on the ground. He took no notice of them.
cannot hate you
This " cannot " answers to the law of moral correspondence. It is of frequent occurrence in St John's Gospel and in different relations. Thus it is used of the relation of "the Jews" to Christ (vii. 34, 36, viii. 21 f., 43 f., xii. 39), and of "the world" to the Paraclete (xiv. 17); and in another aspect of the relation of the believer to Christ, in his first approach (vi. 44, 65, iii. 3, 5), and in his later progress (xiii. 33, 36, xvi. 12) ; and yet again of the relation of the Son to the Father (v. 19, note). In each case the impossibility lies in the true nature of things, and is the other side, of the divine "must" (xx. 9, note).
John 7:7 · Open Word Bible
7The world cannot hate you, but it hates Me, because I testify that its works are evil. As they went on asking Him, He stood up straight and said to them, "Whoever among you has no sin, let that person throw the first stone at her."
Go ye up unto this feast
The pronoun is emphatic : Do ye, with your thoughts and hopes, go up ....
I go not up yet unto this feast] The sense may be " I go not up with the great train of worshippers." Nor indeed did Christ go to the feast as one who kept it. He appeared during the feast (v. 14), but then as a prophet suddenly in the temple. ...
is not yet full come] Literally, is not yet fulfilled .... Comp. Luke xxi. 24 ; Acts vii. 23 ... ; Eph. i. 10 ; Gal. iv. 4.
John 7:8 · Open Word Bible
8You go up to the festival. I am not going up to this festival, because My time has not yet fully come." Then He bent down again and went on writing on the ground.
When he had said
And having said...
John 7:9 · Open Word Bible
9After saying this, He stayed on in Galilee. When they heard this, convicted by their conscience, they left one after another, the oldest first. Jesus was left by Himself, and the woman was still there in the middle.
but as it were in secret
hidden as one solitary stranger and not the centre of an expectant band. ...
John 7:10 · Open Word Bible
10But after His brothers had gone up to the festival, He went up too, not publicly but in secret, as it were. Jesus straightened up and, seeing no one there but the woman, said to her, "Where are they, the people who were accusing you? Did no one condemn you?"
Then the Jews sought him
in the parties of Galilaean worshippers, asking of them Where is he? that famous teacher ... whom we saw, and of whom we have since heard (ix. 12) ? The question was asked half perhaps in ill-will and half in curiosity.
John 7:11 · Open Word Bible
11So the Jewish leaders were looking for Him at the festival, asking, "Where is that man?" She said, "No one, Sir." Then Jesus said, "I do not condemn you either. Go, and from now on do not sin any more."]
murmuring
Or perhaps here muttering ..., as of men who did not dare to speak plainly and loudly what they felt. Comp. v. 32.
among the people] among the multitudes, that is, among the different groups of strangers who had come up to the festival, and such as consorted with them. ...
John 7:12 · Open Word Bible
12Among the crowds there was a great deal of muttering about Him. Some said, "He is a good man." Others said, "No, He is leading the people astray."
for some said
some said. The omission of the particle gives vividness to the description.
a good man] unselfish and true. Compare Mark x. 17.
deceiveth the people] leadeth the multitude astray .... Comp. v. 47. The thought is of practical and not of intellectual error.
no man
whether he thought well or ill of Christ, spake openly (boldly) of him for fear — an all-pervading fear ... — of the Jews, the leaders or the "national" party, who had as yet not pronounced judgment openly though their inclination was plain.
openly] boldly. The original word ... has a double sense. It may mean either without reserve or veil, giving free utterance to every thought plainly (x. 24, xi. 14, xvi. 25, 29, xviii. 20), or without fear (xi. 54). Here, and so probably in v. 26, it is used in the latter sense.
John 7:13 · Open Word Bible
13Yet no one would speak openly about Him, because they were afraid of the Jewish leaders.
14—24.
In the first scene in the temple Christ shews the source and the test of His teaching (16 — 18) as against the false interpretations of the Law (v. 19), which were against the spirit and history of the Law itself (20—24).
John 7:14–24 · Open Word Bible
14When the festival was already half over, Jesus went up to the temple courts and began to teach. 15The Jewish leaders were amazed and asked, "How does this man know the Scriptures when He has never studied under a teacher?" 16Jesus answered them, "The teaching I give is not My own. It comes from the one who sent Me. …
14—36.
The discussions at "the midst of the feast " lay open thoughts of three groups of men: "the Jews" (14 — 24), "some of the inhabitants of Jerusalem" (25 — 31"), the envoys of " the chief priests and the Pharisees" (32 — 36). Each discussion constitutes a separate scene. "The multitude" is swayed to and fro by conflicting fears and hopes (20, 31 f.). In dealing with the successive questioners the Lord indicates the authority of His teaching, His connexion with the old dispensation, the brief space of the people's trial.
John 7:14–36 · Open Word Bible
14When the festival was already half over, Jesus went up to the temple courts and began to teach. 15The Jewish leaders were amazed and asked, "How does this man know the Scriptures when He has never studied under a teacher?" 16Jesus answered them, "The teaching I give is not My own. It comes from the one who sent Me. …
the midst of the feast
The feast properly lasted seven days, but to these an eighth day was added as "the last day" of the feast (v. 37), Lev. xxiii. 36 ; 2 Mace. x. 6.
into the temple, and taught] This is the first mention of the appearance of the Lord as a public teacher at Jerusalem. ...
John 7:14 · Open Word Bible
14When the festival was already half over, Jesus went up to the temple courts and began to teach.
And the Jews
The Jews therefore, v. 10. Introd. p. ix.
marvelled] Matt. xxii. 22 ; Luke iv. 22.
knoweth... letters] Compare Acts xxvi. 24. The marvel was that Jesus shewed Himself familiar with the literary methods of the time, which were supposed to be confined to the scholars of the popular teachers.
... Christ was in the eyes of the Jews a merely self-taught enthusiast. They marvelled at His strange success, while they did not admit His irregular claims.
John 7:15 · Open Word Bible
15The Jewish leaders were amazed and asked, "How does this man know the Scriptures when He has never studied under a teacher?"
Jesus answered
Jesus therefore answered. The Lord's reply meets the difficulty of the questioners. His teaching was not self-originated (My doctrine (teaching) is not mine), but derived from a divine Master; infinitely greater than the popular Rabbis. And it had a twofold attestation — an inward criterion and an outward criterion ; the first from its essential character, and the second from the character of Him who delivered it. He whose will was in harmony with the will of God could not but recognise the source of the teaching. And again, the absolute devotion of Christ to Him who sent Him was a sign of His truth.
John 7:16 · Open Word Bible
16Jesus answered them, "The teaching I give is not My own. It comes from the one who sent Me.
If any man will do
i.e. If it 'be any man's will to do His will. The force of the argument lies in the moral harmony of the man's purpose with the divine law so far as this law is known or felt. If there be no sympathy there can be no understanding. Religion is a matter of life and not of thought only. The principle is universal in its application. The will of God is not to be limited to the Old Testament revelation, or to the claims of Christ, but includes every manifestation of the purpose of God. A fine saying is attributed to " Rabban Gamaliel, the son of R. Jehudah ha-Nasi:" "Do His will as if it were thy will, that He may do thy will as if it were His will " (' A both,' II. 4).
speak of myself] Compare v. 30 note, xv. 4, note.
John 7:17 · Open Word Bible
17If anyone is resolved to do His will, they will know whether this teaching comes from God or whether I am speaking on My own authority.
For the connexion of "falsehood" and "unrighteousness" see Rom. ii. 8; 1 Cor. xiii. 6 ; 2 Thess. ii. 12. Injustice is falsehood in deed.
John 7:18 · Open Word Bible
18Whoever speaks on their own authority is after their own glory. But the one who seeks the glory of the one who sent Him is true, and there is nothing false in Him.
The principle laid down is applied to the condemnation of the Jews. They professed unbounded devotion to Moses, and yet they broke the Law because they were estranged from its spirit. Their ignorance of the Law had at last grown so great that they were prepared to murder Him who came to fulfil the Law.
Did not... the law, and yet none.,. the law] Did not.. .the law? and none. ..the law. The question is an appeal to their own proud boast. Then follows their condemnation by the Lord.
Why go ye about (seek ye, and so v. 20) to kill me] v. 1.
John 7:19 · Open Word Bible
19Did not Moses give you the law? Yet not one of you keeps the law. Why are you trying to kill Me?"
The people
The multitude, made up chiefly of pilgrims, and therefore unacquainted with the full designs of the hierarchy. Omit and said.
Thou hast a devil] Compare Matt. xi. 18 ; Luke vii. 33, where the same phrase is used of John the Baptist, as one who sternly and, in men's judgment, gloomily and morosely withdrew himself from the cheerfulness of social life. So here perhaps the words mean no more than "thou art possessed with strange and melancholy fancies ; thou yieldest to idle fears." In a different context they assume a more sinister force, viii. 48 f., 52, x. 20. Yet even in these cases the sense does not go beyond that of irrationality.
John 7:20 · Open Word Bible
20The crowd answered, "You must have a demon! Who is trying to kill You?"
Jesus answered
The point of the answer lies in the indication of the ground of the hostility which ended in murderous designs. All alike — "the Jews" and "the multitude" — marvelled at that which should have been an intelligible illustration of the Law. This wonder contained the germ of open misunderstanding and opposition which, if followed to its legitimate development, could not but end in deadly enmity. If men failed to see the inner significance of the Law they must persecute Christ who came to interpret it and offer its fulfilment in the Gospel.
I have done (did) one work] ch. v. 1 ff. This special healing on the Sabbath is singled out of the many which Christ wrought (ii. 23, iv. 45) from its exceptional circumstances.
marvel] Yet even wonder may be a first step towards a truer apprehension of the divine lesson. Compare v. 20.
John 7:21 · Open Word Bible
21Jesus answered them, "I did one work, and you are all amazed.
Moses therefore gave unto you
For this cause Moses hath given you, as an abiding ordinance... The cause referred to is the typical realisation of the lesson which underlies the restoration of the impotent man, as it is brought out in v. 23.' The words for this cause certainly commence a new sentence, and do not close v. 21. In this respect the usage of St John is decisive, vi. 65, viii. 47.
not because (that) it is... but...] The words are parenthetical. The case was not simply a conflict of two Mosaic precepts. The law of circumcision was not in origin Mosaic ; and thus in itself it carried men's thoughts back to the great ideas which the Mosaic Law was designed to embody. The Mosaic Law of the Sabbath was, on the other hand, new.
The connexion of for this cause with not because (that) appears to be against the usage of the language (vi. 46) ; 2 Cor. i. 24, iii. 5 ; Phil. iv. 17 ; 2 Thess. iii. 9 : I do not mean that... but... ; yet see xii. 6 (where ort is repeated); and against the argument, for the point in question was not the origin of circumcision, though this furnished a subsidiary thought, but the fact of conflicting enactments in the Law which were adjusted in a particular manner.
John 7:22 · Open Word Bible
22So consider this: Moses gave you circumcision (though it did not begin with Moses but with the patriarchs), and you circumcise a boy even on the Sabbath.
on the sabbath
if that happened to be the eighth day. The principle is distinctly recognised in the Mishna, 'Sabb.' xix. 1. R. Akiva said: "Every work which can be done on the eve of the Sabbath does not set aside the Sabbath ; but circumcision, which cannot be done on the eve of the Sabbath [if the eve be the seventh day], sets aside the Sabbath." Compare Lightfoot and Wetstein, ad loc, 23. should not be broken] by the violation of the commandment which enjoined circumcision on the eighth day. Comp. x. 35, v. 18, note.
are ye angry...because I have made
The contrast is between the effect of circumcision which made (as it were) one member sound, and that of the miracle which made the whole paralysed man sound. If then the Law itself ratified the precedence of this act of partial healing over the ceremonial observance of the Sabbath, how much more lawful was the complete healing.
John 7:23 · Open Word Bible
23If a boy is circumcised on the Sabbath so that the law of Moses is not broken, why are you angry with Me for making a man entirely well on the Sabbath?
I have made...on the sabbath
I made... on a sabbath.
a man every whit whole... ,] More exactly, a whole man sound .... A whole man regarded from the physical side, and not with the subordinate distinction of "soul and body." Comp. v. 14.
Judge not according to the appearance
superficially, by the external aspect, as the matter first presents itself ... .
righteous judgment] Or rather, the righteous judgment ; give the one true and complete decision of which the case admits. The truth is one.
John 7:24 · Open Word Bible
24Stop judging by what things look like on the surface; make a judgment that is just."
25—31.
In the second scene, which is still in the temple (v. 28), the Lord meets the popular objection which was urged against the belief that He was the Christ (vv. 25 — 27). He had perfect authority for His work, from Him whom the Jews " knew not" (v. 28 f.). So the people were divided by His words and works (v. 31).
John 7:25–31 · Open Word Bible
25So some who lived in Jerusalem were saying, "Is this not the one they are out to kill? 26Look, He is speaking in the open, and they say nothing to Him! Can it be that our leaders really know that this man is the Christ? 27But we know where this man comes from. When the Christ comes, though, no one will know His origin." …
Then said some...Jerusalem
Some therefore of them of Jerusalem said, who were acquainted with the designs of the hierarchy, and yet not committed to them. ... The chain of sequence (therefore) is that the Lord had taken up the position of accuser when He was Himself accused.
John 7:25 · Open Word Bible
25So some who lived in Jerusalem were saying, "Is this not the one they are out to kill?
But, lo, he speaketh boldly
Comp. v. 13.
Do the... know.., the very Christ?] Can it be that the rulers indeed know (/i^Vorf ?yj/ ......the Christ ? Can it be that they have learnt, come to know... ? The words seem to mark some point of transition, as if a change might have passed over the Sanhedrin. Possibly (so the people argue) they have examined the matter, and found reason to decide in favour of Him whom they before opposed. ...
John 7:26 · Open Word Bible
26Look, He is speaking in the open, and they say nothing to Him! Can it be that our leaders really know that this man is the Christ?
Howbeit ......J The suspicion is at once set aside as impossible: we know.. .no man knoweth. The two words know, knoweth ... offer a contrast between the knowledge which is full and abiding, and that which comes by progress and observation. Compare xiv. 7, ii. 24, note.
whence he is] i.e. we know His family and His home. Yet even so they thought of Nazareth and not of Bethlehem, David's city, v. 42. Compare Matt. xiii. 54 f. It seems to have been expected that Messiah would appear suddenly (perhaps from Dan. vii. 13, or from Isai. liii. 8), no one knew whence, while Christ had lived long among His countrymen in obscurity and yet known to them. According to a Jewish saying ... "three things come wholly unexpected, Messiah, a god-send and a scorpion." According to another tradition, Messiah would not even know his own mission till he was anointed by Elijah. Just. ...
when Christ (the Christ) cometh] The exact expression (Zrav cp^i/rat contrasted with orav ... marks the actual moment when the' coming is realised. The appearance is a surprise.
John 7:27 · Open Word Bible
27But we know where this man comes from. When the Christ comes, though, no one will know His origin."
Then cried Jesus...as he taught, saying
Jesus therefore, as being acquainted with their partial knowledge and the conclusions which they drew from it, cried aloud ... in the temple, teaching and saying. The testimony is given publicly and with solemn emphasis. Comp. v. 37, xii. 44, i. 15. The original word ... occurs only in these places in the Gospel (xii. 13, xix. 12, are false readings).
The repetition of the words in the temple (comp. v. 14) seems to indicate a break between this scene and the last.
Ye both know me, and ye know (and know) . . .] The claim of the people of Jerusalem is drawn out at length (me, and whence I am), and its superficial truth is conceded. ...
John 7:28 · Open Word Bible
28So Jesus, as He was teaching in the temple courts, cried out, "You know Me, and you know where I come from! Yet I have not come on My own. The one who sent Me is true, and you do not know Him.
and I am not
The facts which the people knew and the facts which they did not know are simply set side by side. Comp. v. 30, viii. 20, ix. 30; Mark xii. 12.
it true] The word rendered true ... retains its proper meaning. God is described as true not merely in so far as He gave a true message, but as one who really sent a messenger; a real Father, as it were, sending a real Son. The question was as to the authority of Christ.
know him: for I am from him
Now as always I rest upon Him, deriving my whole being from Him, and he bath tent (sent) me. The continuance of being and the historic mission are set side by side ; and both are referred to God.
John 7:29 · Open Word Bible
29But I know Him, because I come from Him, and He is the one who sent Me."
Then they sought
They sought therefore— because of His claim to be sent from God — to take him. The subject is taken from "some of them of Jerusalem" (v. 25), those among them who are specially called " Jews." Compare vv. 32, 44, (viii. 20, 59), (x. 31), x. 39, xi. 57 but no man...] and no man... Compare v. 28, note. his hour] Compare xiii. 1, note.
John 7:30 · Open Word Bible
30So they tried to arrest Him. Yet no one took hold of Him, since His hour had not yet come.
And many of the people
But of the multitude — in contrast with the leaders of Jerusalem — many believed on him, not only gave credence to what He said ("believed Him"), but surrendered themselves to His guidance. ...
John 7:31 · Open Word Bible
31Many people in the crowd, though, believed in Him, and they kept saying, "When the Christ comes, He will not do more signs than this man has done, will He?"
(^17, Vulg. num quid) suggests the inference that Jesus must be the Christ, though the inference is not drawn.
this man hath done] this man did. They look back upon the "signs" which Christ had wrought as a whole, now seen dispassionately far off.
32—36.
These verses describe the third scene in the controversy. The wishes of Christ's enemies (v. 30) soon found active expression. The Sanhedrin sent public officers to seize Him ; and in their presence for the first time He announces His speedy and irrevocable departure from "the Jews" ..., to their bewilderment ....
John 7:32–36 · Open Word Bible
32The Pharisees heard the crowd talking quietly about Him in this way, so the chief priests and the Pharisees sent temple police to arrest Him. 33So Jesus said, "For a little while more I am with you; then I go away to the one who sent Me. 34You will search for Me and not find Me, and you cannot come where I am." …
The Pharisees
Comp. iv. i.
heard that the people murmured such things] heard the multitude murmuring these things, as being inwardly dissatisfied and irresolute.
the Pharisees and the chief priests] the chief priests and Pharisees. The combination occurs also in St Matthew: Matt. xxi. 45, xxvii. 62. The phrase probably describes the Sanhedrin under the form of its constituent classes. Comp. v. 45, note, xi. 47, 57, xviii. 3.
chief priests] The title appears to be given not only to those who had held the office of high-priest, like Annas (see ch. xviii. 13, note), and his son Eleazar, and Simon the son of Kamhit, and Ishmael the son of Phabi, who may all have been alive at the time, but also to members of the hierarchical families which were represented by these men, alike infamous in Jewish tradition. Comp. Derenbourg, 'Histoire de Palestine,' pp. 230 ff. Thus the title describes rather a political faction than a definite office. Comp. Acts iv. 6 (as many as were of the kindred of the high priest). See v. 45, xi. 47, 57, xii. 10, xviii. 3, (35), xix. 6, 15, 21.
Compare also Matt, xxvii. 1, note.
officers ...] clothed with legal authority and obeying the instructions of the Council. ...
John 7:32 · Open Word Bible
32The Pharisees heard the crowd talking quietly about Him in this way, so the chief priests and the Pharisees sent temple police to arrest Him.
Then said Jesus unto them
Jesus therefore said. The words have a wider application than to the officers.
am, a little Awhile] It was about six months to the Last Passover.
with you] The "multitude," the "Jews," the " officers," are all grouped together in one body.
I go...] Three Greek words are thus translated in St John, and two of them in similar connexions. Each word expresses a distinct aspect of departure, and its special force must be taken into account in the interpretation of the passage in which it is found. The first word ...), which is used here, emphasizes the personal act of going in itself, as a withdrawal (viii. 14, 21 f., xiii. 3, 33, 36, xiv. 4 f., 38, xvi. 5, 10, 16 f.).
The second word ... marks the going as connected with a purpose, a mission, an end to be gained, a work to be done (v . 35, xiv. 3, 12, 28, xvi. 7, 38).
The third word ... expresses simple separation, the point left (vi. 68, xvi. 7, go away).
Their differences are very clearly seen in a comparison of xvi. 10 ... with xiv. 28 ..., and the succession of words in xvi. 7 — 10 ....
unto him that sent me] During the discourses in this chapter the reference is to the authority of mission (him that sent me) and not of nature (the Father). The thought of the Father is added in ch. viii. 16, 18. These words themselves leave a riddle unsolved.
John 7:33 · Open Word Bible
33So Jesus said, "For a little while more I am with you; then I go away to the one who sent Me.
Ye shall seek me
not in penitence nor yet in anger, but simply in distress. You shall recall my words and works, and wish once again to see if it might be that in me there were deliverance. The thought is not of the Christ generally, but of the Lord Himself, whose power and love they had experienced. Comp. Luke xvii. 22. Contrast this ineffectual seeking with Matt. vii. 7.
and where I am...] The fact of failure is referred to the cause of failure. Christ is essentially there whither He goes. The stress in this place is laid upon the difference of character ... which involves separation, and not upon the simple historical separation. Comp. viii. 21, xiii. 33 (I go). ...
John 7:34 · Open Word Bible
34You will search for Me and not find Me, and you cannot come where I am."
Then said the Jews
The Jews therefore said... Those who claimed the monopoly of religious privileges are separated from the rest. Hence we have among themselves (xii. 19) and not one to another.
will he go] will this man go, this strange pretender (ovros). The pronoun here carries an accent of surprise and contempt. ...
John 7:35 · Open Word Bible
35So the Jewish leaders said to one another, "Where is this man going to go, that we will not find Him? Surely He does not intend to go to the Jews scattered among the Greeks, and teach the Greeks?
that we shall not
that we ... who stand in the closest connexion with all the people of God.
the dispersed among the Gentiles] the dispersion among the Greeks ..., the Jews, that is, who are scattered among the heathen Greek-speaking nations. ... The first marks their relation to their own land; the second their relation to the lands which they occupied. Their own land was stripped of them, and they were separated from their national privileges. On the other hand, they were so scattered among the nations as to become the seed of a future harvest. This thought is recognised in a striking comment on Hos. ii. 34, quoted by Wünsche: R. Eliezer said the Eternal has therefore scattered the Israelites among other nations that the heathen may attach themselves to them ('Pesach.' 87 b). Diaspora first occurs Deut. xxviii. 35. Comp. Isai. xlix. 6 ; Jer. xv. 7 ; a Mace. i. 37 ; 1 Pet. i. 1 ; James i. i. For the genitive see 1 Pet. i. i. This usage seems to be quite decisive against the interpretation "the dispersed Greeks."
and teach the Gentiles (Greeks)] make these isolated groups of Jews the startingpoint (as the apostles actually did) of teaching among the Gentiles. This is the climax of irrationality. No true Messiah, no one seriously claiming the title, could (it is argued) entertain such a plan.
What manner of saying is this
What Is this word... In spite of all, Christ's words cannot be shaken off. They are not to be explained away. A vague sense remains that there is in them some unfathomed meaning.
John 7:36 · Open Word Bible
36What is this saying of His, 'You will search for Me and not find Me, and you cannot come where I am'?"
3. The discussions on the last day of the Feast (vv. 37—52).
The record of the circumstances of the last day of the Feast consists of a fragmentary utterance containing a most significant promise (37 — 39), together with its effect upon the multitude (40 — 44); and then more remotely upon the Sanhedrin (45 — 52).
John 7:37–52 · Open Word Bible
37On the last day of the festival, the great day, Jesus stood and called out, "If anyone is thirsty, they should come to Me and drink. 38As for the one who believes in Me, it is just as the Scripture said: 'Rivers of living water will pour out from deep within him.'" 39He was speaking about the Spirit, whom those who believed in Him were soon to receive. The Spirit was not yet given, because Jesus had not yet been glorified. …
the...the feast
Now on the last day, the great day of the feast. The peculiar greatness of the eighth day lay in the fact that it was the close of the whole festival and kept as a Sabbath (Lev. xxiii. 36). It has been conjectured that it was observed in memory of the entrance into Canaan. At present it is treated as a separate Festival. Compare Lightfoot, ad loc.
stood] The original ... is singularly vivid: Jesus was standing, watching, as it might be, the procession of the people from their booths to the temple, and then, moved by some occasion, he cried... Comp. i. 35, note, xviii. 5, note.
If any man thirst] The image appears to have been occasioned by the libations of water brought in a golden vessel from Siloam which were made at the time of the morning sacrifice on each of the seven days of the feast while Isai. xii. 3 was sung. It is uncertain whether the libations were made on the eighth day. If they were not made, the significant cessation of the striking rite on this one day of the feast would give a still more fitting occasion for the words.
unto me] The satisfaction lies in the access to Christ. Comp. vi. 35.
The pouring out of the water (like the use of the great lights, viii. 12), was a commemoration of one conspicuous detail of the life in the wilderness typified by the festival. The water brought from the rock supplied an image of future blessing to the prophets: Ezek. xlvii. 1, 12; Joel iii. 18. And that gift is definitely connected with the Lord by St Paul : 1 Cor. x. 4.
John 7:37 · Open Word Bible
37On the last day of the festival, the great day, Jesus stood and called out, "If anyone is thirsty, they should come to Me and drink.
Christ therefore shews how the promise of that early miracle was completely fulfilled in Himself in a higher form. He who drank of that water thirsted again ; but the water which He gave became a spring of water within. As in iv. 14 the thought passes at once from the satisfaction of personal wants to the satisfaction of the wants of others which follows on this.
St John and the Old Testament, than the manner in which Christ is shewn to transfer to Himself the figures of the Exodus (the brazen serpent, the manna, the water, the fiery pillar).
The sense of thirst — personal want — comes first; then with the satisfaction of this, the fulness of faith; and then, the refreshing energies of faith.
as the scripture hath said (said)] The reference is not to any one isolated passage, but to the general tenour of such passages as Isai. lviii. 1 1 ; Zech. xiv. 8, taken in connexion with the original image (Exod. xvii. 6 ; Num. xx. 11).
shall flow rivers] The reception of the blessing leads at once to the distribution of it in fuller measure. Compare the thought in iv. 14, vi. 57, v. 26. He who drinks of the Spiritual Rock becomes in turn himself a rock from within which the waters flow to slake the thirst of others.
There is a fine passage in Augustine's Commentary on this passage as to the character of Christ's gifts : ' in Joh. Tract.' xxxii. 9.
John 7:38 · Open Word Bible
38As for the one who believes in Me, it is just as the Scripture said: 'Rivers of living water will pour out from deep within him.'"
But this spake he
The inspired activity of the apostles did not commence till after Pentecost. Comp. Luke xxiv. 49.
they that believe on him should receive] they that believed on him were about to receive (were to receive) . . . ... When the term occurs in this form, it marks an operation, or manifestation, or gift of the Spirit, and not the personal Spirit. Compare i. 33, xx. 22; Matt. i. 18, 20, iii. 11, xii. 28; Luke i. 15, 35, 41, 67, ii. 25, iv. i.
because that] Comp. xvi. 7, note, xx. 17. The necessary limitations of Christ's historical presence with the disciples excluded that realiyet given ; because that Jesus was not yet glorified.)
It is impossible not to contrast the mysteriousness of this utterance with the clear teaching of St John himself on the " unction " ... of believers (1 John ii. 20 ff.), which forms a commentary, gained by later experience, upon the words of the Lord.
John 7:39 · Open Word Bible
39He was speaking about the Spirit, whom those who believed in Him were soon to receive. The Spirit was not yet given, because Jesus had not yet been glorified.
glorified
This is the first distinct reference to the Lord's " glorification." The conception is characteristic of St John's Gospel (compare i. 14, ii. 11; Introd. p. xlvii.), and includes in one complex whole the Passion with the Triumph which followed. Thus St John regards Christ's death as a Victory (compare xii. 32 f. note, xi. 4, 40), following the words of the Lord who identified the hour of His death with the hour of His glorification (xii. 23 f.). In accordance with the same thought Christ spoke of Himself as already " glorified " when Judas had gone forth to his work (xiii. 31, note); and so He had already received His glory by the faith of His disciples before He suffered (xvii. 10, note). In another aspect His glory followed after His withdrawal from earth (xvii. 5, xvi. 14). By this use of the phrase the Evangelist brings out clearly the absolute divine unity of the work of Christ in His whole "manifestation " (1 John iii. 5, 8, i. 2), which he does not (as St Paul) regard in distinct stages as humiliation and exaltation.
Many of the people therefore...this saying
Some therefore of the multitude ... these words ..., that is, as it appears, all the discourses at the festival, and not those on the last day only. Probably this judgment marks the general opinion.
said] The original verb in this verse and the next ... describes vividly a repeated expression of opinion.
the Prophet] Comp. i. ar, (Deut. xviii. 15).
John 7:40 · Open Word Bible
40Some in the crowd who heard these words kept saying, "He truly is the Prophet."
Shall Christ come
Why, doth the Christ come ......
John 7:41 · Open Word Bible
41Others said, "This man is the Christ." But some objected, "Surely the Christ does not come from Galilee?
That Christ
That the Christ.
out of the town of Bethlehem, where . . .] From Bethlehem the village where... Comp. Isai. xi. 1 ; Jer. xxiii. 5 ; Mic. v. 2. It seems strange that anyone should have argued from this passage that the writer of the Gospel was unacquainted with Christ's birth at Bethlehem. He simply relates the words of the multitude who were unacquainted with it (comp. Luke iv. 23) ; and there is a tragic irony in the fact that the condition which the objectors ignorantly assumed to be unsatisfied was actually satisfied.
John 7:42 · Open Word Bible
42The Scripture says, does it not, that the Christ comes from the family line of David, and from Bethlehem, David's own village?"
among the people
In the multitude.
John 7:43 · Open Word Bible
43So the crowd was split over Him.
some of them
of the multitude. Part of "the common people" were now dissatisfied with Christ, and would have taken Him, as the people of Jerusalem (v. 30) and the Pharisees (v. 32) before.
John 7:44 · Open Word Bible
44Some of them wanted to take Him into custody, yet nobody laid a hand on Him.
Then...officers
The officers therefore came, because they had found no opportunity for fulfilling their mission.
... The day was a Sabbath and yet the council was gathered.
they said . . . Why have ye not brought f (Why did ye not bring?)] The pronoun ... used in the first clause (they said) is that which generally marks the more remote subject (comp. Acts iii. 13). In the thought of the apostle these enemies of Christ fill up, as it were, the dark background of his narrative, ever present in the distance.
John 7:45 · Open Word Bible
45So the temple police returned to the chief priests and Pharisees, and these men asked them, "Why have you not brought Him?"
Never man spake like this man
Never man so spake, according to the true reading.
John 7:46 · Open Word Bible
46The temple police answered, "No one has ever spoken like this!"
Then...the Pharisees
The Pharisees therefore specially standing out from the whole body answered them. The hostility of opinion is stronger than that of office.
Are. . .deceived?] Are ye also — whose simple duty it is to execute our orders — led astray (v. 12) ? Their fault was in action (led astray) rather than in thought (deceived).
John 7:47 · Open Word Bible
47The Pharisees retorted, "Surely you have not been taken in as well?
of the rulers
of the members of the Sanhedrin (cf. v. 26, iii. 1, xii. 41), whom you are bound to obey, or of the Pharisees whose opinions you are bound to accept. ...
John 7:48 · Open Word Bible
48Is there a single one of the rulers who has believed in Him? Or a single Pharisee?
this people
this multitude of whom we hear, and by whose opinion you are influenced, are cursed. As knowing not the law, they were in the opinion of the wise " a people of the earth," such that he who gave them a morsel merited divine chastisement A saying is given in ' Aboth ' n. 6, " No brutish man is sin fearing, nor is one of the people of the earth pious." Compare Wetstein, ad loc. Men were divided into " people of the earth" and "fellows" ..., i.e. educated men.
John 7:49 · Open Word Bible
49As for this crowd, which does not know the law, they are under a curse."
that came to Jesus by night
that came to him before, according to the true reading.
being one of them] and therefore able to speak from a position of equality. So the question of v. 48 was answered.
John 7:50 · Open Word Bible
50Then Nicodemus, himself one of them, the same man who had earlier come to Jesus, said to them,
Doth our law...hear him
Those who pleaded for the law really broke the law. Compare Deut. i. 16; Exod. xxiii. i.
any man] a man; literally, " the man" ... in each case which comes before them. Cf. ii. 25.
before it bear him] Literally, except It first hear from himself, i.e. "hear what he has to urge on his own side." The Law is personified. The true Judge is a living law.
John 7:51 · Open Word Bible
51"Surely our law does not pass judgment on anyone before it has heard from them and found out what they have done?"
Art thou also of Galilee
and therefore moved by local feeling. At the same time by the choice of this term to characterize Christ's followers, the questioners contrast them contemptuously with the true Jews.
Search, and look: for...] Search, and see that... The particle (on) is ambiguous; but it seems on the whole better to give to it the sense " that " than " for."
ariseth ...] The reference appears to be not so much to the past as to the future. Galilee is not the true country of the prophets; we cannot look then for Messiah to come thence. The words have that semblance of general truth which makes them quite natural in this connexion, though Jonah, Hoshea, Nahum, and perhaps Elijah, Elisha and Amos were of Galilee. Thus it was said by R. Jehuda in the name of Rab that " the law was maintained by the dwellers in Judaea " .... ...
John 7:52 · Open Word Bible
52They answered him, "You are not a Galilean too, are you? Search the Scriptures and see for yourself: no prophet arises from Galilee."
The episode of the woman taken in adultery (vii. 53 — viii. n).
The episode of the woman taken in adultery (vii. 53 — viii. 11).
This account of a most characteristic incident in the Lord's life is certainly not a part of St John's narrative. The evidence against its genuineness, as an original piece of the Gospel, both external and internal, is overwhelming (see Additional Note) ; but on the other hand it is beyond doubt an authentic fragment of apostolic tradition. Probably its preservation was due to Papias. The incident seems to belong to the last visit to Jerusalem; and it is placed in this connexion in some MSS. of St Luke (after Luke xxi.).
The special importance of the narrative lies in the fact that it records the single case in which the Lord deals with a specific sinful act. And this He does (1) by referring the act to the inward spring of action, and (2) by declining to treat the legal penalty as that which corresponds to the real guilt. So there is opened to us a glimpse of a tribunal more searching, and yet more tender, than the tribunals of men.
John 7:53 · Open Word Bible
53[Then each of them went home.
every man went
More closely, they went every man. . . but Jesus (viii. 1) . . . Thus the contrast between the whole gathering in the temple (not the members of the Sanhedrin only) and Christ is made more complete.