Logia

Luke · Chapter 20 · A question about authority

Luke 20:27

Then some Sadducees came up, men who say there is no resurrection, and put a question to Him:

Προσελθόντες δέ τινες τῶν Σαδδουκαίων, οἱ ἀντιλέγοντες ἀνάστασιν μὴ εἶναι, ἐπηρώτησαν αὐτὸν Word by word ↓

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

3 commentators in Logia comment on Luke 20:27, from Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274) to David Brown (1803–1897): Aquinas, Henry and Brown.

Two voices on Luke 20:27

Choose two:

What the church has said

See all 3 voices as a grid

Eras across, traditions down, each with its first words. An empty cell is a place the library has no voice yet.

Middle AgesPuritans and the 1700sThe 1800s
Catholic
  • Aquinas BEDE; There were two heresies among the Jews, one…
––
Protestant–
  • Henry This discourse with the Sadducees we had before, just…
  • Brown 27-34. no resurrection—"nor angel nor spirit" (Ac 23:8); the…

What does Aquinas say about Luke 20:27?

Thomas Aquinas

1225–1274 · Medieval Catholic · Catena Aurea: Commentary on the Four Gospels, Collected out of the Works of the Fathers. Vol. III: St. Luke

Then came to him certain of the Sadducees, which deny that there is any resurrection ; and they asked him,

BEDE; There were two heresies among the Jews, one of the Pharisees, who boasted in the righteousness of their traditions, and hence they were called by the people, separated the other of the Sadducees, whose name signified " righteous," claiming to themselves that which they were not. When the former went away, the latter came to tempt Him. ORIGEN; The heresy of the Sadducees not only denies the resurrection of the dead, but also believes the soul to die with the body. Watching then to entrap our Saviour in His words, they proposed a question just at the time when they observed Him teaching His disciples concerning the resurrection; as it follows, And they asked him, saying, Master, Moses to us, If a brother, &c. AMBROSE; According to the letter of the law, a woman is compelled to marry, however unwilling, in order that a brother may raise up seed to his brother who is dead. The letter therefore killeth, but the Spirit is the master of charity. THEOPHYL. Now the Sadducees resting upon a weak foundation, did not believe in the doctrine of the resurrection. For imagining the future life in the resurrection to be carnal, they were justly misled, and hence reviling the doctrine of the resurrection as a thing impossible they invent the story, There were seven brothers, &c. BEDE; They devise this story in order to convict those of folly, who assert the resurrection of the dead. Hence they object a base fable, that they may deny the truth of the resurrection.

Report a mistake

AMBROSE; ... And from none of them has she received the seed of an hereditary offspring, and so can have no part with her husbands in the resurrection, because she perverts the spiritual meaning of the precept into a carnal. For not any carnal brother is pointed at, who should raise seed to his deceased brother, but that brother who from the dead people of the Jews should claim unto himself for wife the wisdom of the divine worship, and from it should raise up seed in the Apostles, who being left as it were unformed in the womb of the synagogue, have according to the election of grace been thought worthy to be preserved by the admixture of a new seed. BEDE; Or these seven brothers answer to the reprobate, who throughout the whole life of the world, which revolves in seven days, are fruitless in good works, and these being carried away by death one after another, at length the course of the evil world, as the barren woman, itself also passes away.

Report a mistake

What does Henry say about Luke 20:27?

Matthew Henry

1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume V (Matthew to John): Luke

On Luke 20:27–38

This discourse with the Sadducees we had before, just as it is here, only that the description Christ gives of the future state is somewhat more full and large here. Observe here,

I. In every age there have been men of corrupt minds, that have endeavoured to subvert the fundamental principles of revealed religion. As there are deists now, who call themselves free-thinkers, but are really false-thinkers; so there were Sadducees in our Saviour's time, who bantered the doctrine of the resurrection of the dead and the life of the world to come, though they were plainly revealed in the Old Testament, and were articles of the Jewish faith. The Sadducees deny that there is any resurrection, any future state, so anastasis may signify; not only no return of the body to life, but no continuance of the soul in life, no world of spirits, no state of recompence and retribution for what was done in the body. Take away this, and all religion falls to the ground.

II. It is common for those that design to undermine any truth of God to perplex it, and load it with difficulties. So these Sadducees did; when they would weaken people's faith in the doctrine of the resurrection, they put a question upon the supposition of it, which they thought could not be answered either way to satisfaction. The case perhaps was matter of fact, at least it might be so, of a woman that had seven husbands. Now in the resurrection whose wife shall she be? whereas it was not at all material whose she was, for when death puts an end to that relation it is not to be resumed.

III. There is a great deal of difference between the state of the children of men on earth and that of the children of God in heaven, a vast unlikeness between this world and that world; and we wrong ourselves, and wrong the truth of Christ, when we form our notions of that world of spirits by our present enjoyments in this world of sense.

Report a mistake

On Luke 20:27–38

1. The children of men in this world marry, and are given in marriage, hyioi tou aionos toutou—the children of this age, this generation, both good and bad, marry themselves and give their children in marriage. Much of our business in this world is to raise and build up families, and to provide for them. Much of our pleasure in this world is in our relations, our wives and children; nature inclines to it. Marriage is instituted for the comfort of human life, here in this state where we carry bodies about with us. It is likewise a remedy against fornication, that natural desires might not become brutal, but be under direction and control. The children of this world are dying and going off the stage, and therefore they marry and give their children in marriage, that they may furnish the world of mankind with needful recruits, that as one generation passeth away another may come, and that they may have some of their own offspring to leave the fruit of their labours to, especially that the chosen of God in future ages may be introduced, for it is a godly seed that is sought by marriage (Mal. ii. 15), a seed to serve the Lord, that shall be a generation to him.

2. The world to come is quite another thing; it is called that world, by way of emphasis and eminency. Note, There are more worlds than one; a present visible world, and a future invisible world; and it is the concern of every one of us to compare worlds, this world and that world, and give the preference in our thoughts and cares to that which deserves them. Now observe,

Report a mistake

On Luke 20:27–38

Who shall be the inhabitants of that world

(1.) Who shall be the inhabitants of that world: They that shall be accounted worthy to obtain it, that is, that are interested in Christ's merit, who purchased it for us, and have a holy meetness for it wrought in them by the Spirit, whose business it is to prepare us for it. They have not a legal worthiness, upon account of any thing in them or done by them, but an evangelical worthiness, upon account of the inestimable price which Christ paid for the redemption of the purchased possession. It is a worthiness imputed by which we are glorified, as well as righteousness imputed by which we are justified; kataxiothentes, they are made agreeable to that world. The disagreeableness that there is in the corrupt nature is taken away, and the dispositions of the soul are by the grace of God conformed to that state. They are by grace made and counted worthy to obtain that world; it intimates some difficulty in reaching after it, and danger of coming short. We must so run as that we may obtain. They shall obtain the resurrection from the dead, that is, the blessed resurrection; for that of condemnation (as Christ calls it, John v. 29), is rather a resurrection to death, a second death, an eternal death, than from death.

Report a mistake

On Luke 20:27–38

(2.) What shall be the happy state of the inhabitants of that world we cannot express or conceive, 1 Cor. ii. 9. See what Christ here says of it. [1.] They neither marry nor are given in marriage. Those that have entered into the joy of their Lord are entirely taken up with that, and need not the joy of the bridegroom in his bride. The love in that world of love is all seraphic, and such as eclipses and loses the purest and most pleasing loves we entertain ourselves with in this world of sense. Where the body itself shall be a spiritual body, the delights of sense will all be banished; and where there is a perfection of holiness there is no occasion for marriage as a preservative from sin. Into the new Jerusalem there enters nothing that defiles. [2.] They cannot die any more; and this comes in as a reason why they do not marry. In this dying world there must be marriage, in order to the filling up of the vacancies made by death; but, where there are no burials, there is no need of weddings. This crowns the comfort of that world that there is no more death there, which sullies all the beauty, and damps all the comforts, of this world. Here death reigns, but thence it is for ever excluded. [3.] They are equal unto the angels. In the other evangelists it was said, They are as the angels—os angeloi, but here they are said to be equal to the angels, isangeloi—angels' peers; they have a glory and bliss no way inferior to that of the holy angels. They shall see the same sight, be employed in the same work, and share in the same joys, with the holy angels. ...

Report a mistake

On Luke 20:27–38

... Saints, when they come to heaven, shall be naturalized, and, though by nature strangers, yet, having obtained this freedom with a great sum, which Christ paid for them, they have in all respects equal privileges with them that were free-born, the angels that are the natives and aborigines of that country. They shall be companions with the angels, and converse with those blessed spirits that love them dearly, and with an innumerable company, to whom they are now come in faith, hope, and love. [4.] They are the children of God, and so they are as the angels, who are called the sons of God. In the inheritance of sons, the adoption of sons will be completed. Hence believers are said to wait for the adoption, even the redemption of the body, Rom. viii. 23. For till the body is redeemed from the grave the adoption is not completed. Now are we the sons of God, 1 John iii. 2. We have the nature and disposition of sons, but that will not be perfected till we come to heaven. [5.] They are the children of the resurrection, that is, they are made capable of the employments and enjoyments of the future state; they are born to that world, belong to that family, had their education for it here, and shall there have their inheritance in it. They are the children of God, being the children of the resurrection. Note, God owns those only for his children that are the children of the resurrection, that are born from above, are allied to the world of spirits, and prepared for that world, the children of that family.

Report a mistake

What does Brown say about Luke 20:27?

David Brown

1803–1897 · Reformed (Free Church of Scotland) · A Commentary, Critical and Explanatory, on the Old and New Testaments: Luke

On Luke 20:20–40

This comment begins at Luke 20:20:

Lu 20:20-40. Entangling Questions about Tribute and the Resurrection—The Replies.

On Luke 20:27–34

27-34. no resurrection—"nor angel nor spirit" (Ac 23:8); the materialists of the day.

Report a mistake

Cited on other verses

Commentators citing Luke 20:27 while explaining another verse. The sentence is copied as the excerpt reads.

  • Matthew Henry · Luke 21:1–4

    He had just mentioned the barbarity of the scribes, who devoured poor widows (ch. xx.); and perhaps this is designed as an aggravation of it, that the poor widows were the best benefactors to the public funds, of which the scribes had the disposal. 2.

The Greek words

WordDictionary formGlossGrammar
ΠροσελθόντεςπροσέρχομαιHaving approachedVerb · second aorist active participle · nominative plural masculine
δέδέthenConjunction
τινεςτιςsomeIndefinite pronoun · nominative plural masculine
τῶνὁof theArticle · genitive plural masculine
ΣαδδουκαίωνΣαδδουκαῖοςSadduceesNoun · genitive plural masculine
οἱὁthe onesArticle · nominative plural masculine
ἀντιλέγοντεςἀντιλέγωdenyingVerb · present active participle · nominative plural masculine
ἀνάστασινἀνάστασιςa resurrectionNoun · accusative singular feminine
μὴμήnotParticle · negative
εἶναιεἰμίthere isVerb · present active infinitive
ἐπηρώτησανἐπερωτάωthey questionedVerb · aorist active indicative · 3rd person plural
αὐτὸναὐτόςHimPersonal pronoun · accusative singular masculine

From MACULA (CC BY 4.0), as the Open Word Bible reads them.

How the Open Word Bible translates Luke 20:27

Word for word: Having come then some of the Sadducees, the [ones] denying a resurrection not to be, they asked him \v 28 saying, Teacher, Moses wrote to us, if of anyone a brother dies having a wife, and this one childless is, that should take the brother of him the wife and raise up seed to the brother of him.

Sadducees: a party of leading priestly families who denied that the dead will rise Culture

Not: a group of teachers like the Pharisees

This is their only appearance in Luke's Gospel. They held power in the temple and gave the five books of Moses the highest authority. They said there was no resurrection, angel or spirit (Acts 4:1-2; 23:8). So they quote Moses.

Moses wrote: the law of marriage to a brother's widow, Deuteronomy 25:5-6 Allusion

Not: a custom not found in the law

If a man died without a son, his brother was to marry the widow, and the first son would carry on the dead man's name, so that it would not be wiped out of Israel (Deuteronomy 25:5-6; compare Genesis 38:8; Ruth 4:5, 10).

raise up seed: father children Idiom

Not: plant crops

"Seed" means descendants. The children would count as the dead brother's.

resurrection: the raising of the dead to life at the end of the age Word sense

Not: life of the soul after death

The word means rising up, and here the bodily raising of the dead (14:14; Acts 23:6-8).

the quotation opens here and closes at the end of 20:33 Word order

Not: a new quotation in each sentence

The Sadducees' case runs over several sentences.

Cross-references

  • Acts 4:1-2 Peter and John were still speaking to the people when the priests, the commander of the temple guard and the Sadducees confronted them.
  • 1 Corinthians 15:12 Now if what we proclaim about Christ is that He has been raised from the dead, how can some among you be saying there is no such thing as a resurrection of the dead?
  • Matthew 22:23-33 4 voices That same day some Sadducees, who say there is no resurrection, came to Him with a question.
  • Mark 12:18-27 1 voice Then some Sadducees came to Him. They say there is no resurrection, and they put a question to Him:
  • Matthew 16:1 4 voices Pharisees and Sadducees came to put Jesus to the test. They asked Him to show them a sign from heaven.

Cross-references from OpenBible.info (CC BY), most voted first.

Read Luke 20 with all its commentary