Logia

Romans · Chapter 9 · Paul's grief for Israel

Romans 9:20

But who are you, a mere human being, to answer back to God? Will what was shaped say to the one who shaped it, "Why did you make me this way?"

ὦ ἄνθρωπε, μενοῦνγε σὺ τίς εἶ ὁ ἀνταποκρινόμενος τῷ θεῷ; μὴ ἐρεῖ τὸ πλάσμα τῷ πλάσαντι Τί με ἐποίησας οὕτως; Word by word ↓

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

7 commentators in Logia comment on Romans 9:20, from John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) to Frédéric Louis Godet (1812–1900): Chrysostom, Calvin, Evans, Bengel, Wesley, Hodge and Godet.

Topics: Election and predestination

Two voices on Romans 9:20

Choose two:

What the church has said

See all 7 voices as a grid

Eras across, traditions down, each with its first words. An empty cell is a place the library has no voice yet.

Early churchReformationPuritans and the 1700sThe 1800s
Protestant–
  • Calvin 20. But, O man! who art thou? etc. As…
  • Evans 1. By reproving the objector (v. 20): Nay but,…
  • Bengel Oman) weak, ignorant of righteousness [i.e. the true way…
  • Wesley 20. Nay, but who art thou, O man -…
  • Hodge (20) Nay, but, O man, who art thou that…
  • Godet Yer. 20. Most commentators do not hold that in…
Church Fathers
  • Chrysostom Ver. 20. “Nay but, O man, who art thou…
–––

What does Chrysostom say about Romans 9:20?

John Chrysostom

c. 347–407 · Patristic (Greek East) · Homilies on the Epistle of St. Paul the Apostle to the Romans

Homily XVI. Rom. IX. 1

Ver. 20. “Nay but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God?”

This he does to take down the objector’s unseasonable inquisitiveness, and excessive curiosity, and to put a check upon it, and teach him to know what God is, and what man, and how incomprehensible His foreknowledge is, and how far above our reason, and how obedience to Him in all points is binding. So when he has made this preparatory step in his hearer, and has hushed and softened down his spirit, then with great felicity he introduces the answer, having made what he says easy of admittance with him. And he does not say, it is impossible to answer questions of this kind, but that (5 mss. No, but what? that) it is presumptuous to raise them. For our business is to obey what God does, not to be curious even if we do not know the reason of them. Wherefore he said, “Who art thou that repliest against God?” You see how very light he makes of him, how he bears down his swelling spirit! “Who art thou?” art thou a sharer of His power? (compare Job xxxviii.) nay, art thou sitting in judgment upon God? Why in comparison with Him thou canst not have a being even! nor this or that sort of being, but absolutely none! For the expression, “who art thou?” doth much more set him at naught than “thou art nothing.” And he takes other ways of showing further his indignation in the question, and does not say, “Who art thou that” answerest “God?” but, “that repliest against,” that is, that gainsayest, and that opposest. For the saying things ought to be so, and ought not to be so, is what a man does that “replieth against.” See how he scares them, how he terrifies them, how he makes them tremble rather than be questioning and curious. ...

Report a mistake

... This is what an excellent teacher does; he does not follow his disciples’ fancy everywhere, but leads them to his own mind, and pulls up the thorns, and then puts the seed in, and does not answer at once in all cases to the questions put to him.

Ver. 20, 2l. “Shall the thing formed say to Him that formed it, Why hast Thou made me thus? Hath not the potter (Read Jer. xviii. 1–10) power, of the same lump to make one vessel unto honor, and another unto dishonor?”

Here it is not to do away with free-will that he says this, but to show, up to what point we ought to obey God. For in respect of calling God to account, we ought to be as little disposed to it as the clay is. For we ought to abstain not from gainsaying or questioning only, but even from speaking or thinking of it at all, and to become like that lifeless matter, which followeth the potter’s hands, and lets itself be drawn about anywhere he may please. And this is the only point he applied the illustration to, not, that is, to any enunciation of the rule of life, but to the complete obedience and silence enforced upon us. And this we ought to observe in all cases, that we are not to take the illustrations quite entire, but after selecting the good of them, and that for which they were introduced, to let the rest alone. As, for instance, when he says, “He couched, he lay down as a lion;” (Numb. xxiv. 9) let us take out the indomitable and fearful part, not the brutality, nor any other of the things belonging to a lion. And again, when He says, “I will meet them as a bereaved bear” (Hos. xiii. 8), let us take the vindictiveness. And when he says, “our God is a consuming fire” (Deut. iv. 24; and Heb. xii. 29), the wasting power exerted in punishing. So also here must we single out the clay, the potter, and the vessels. ...

Report a mistake

... And when he does go on to say, “Hath not the potter power over the clay, of the same lump to make one vessel unto honor, and another unto dishonor?” do not suppose that this is said by Paul as an account of the creation, nor as implying a necessity over the will, but to illustrate the sovereignty and difference of dispensations; for if we do not take it in this way, divers incongruities will follow, for if here he were speaking about the will, and those who are good and those not so, He will be Himself the Maker of these, and man will be free from all responsibility. And at this rate, Paul will also be shown to be at variance with himself, as he always bestows chief honor upon free choice. There is nothing else then which he here wishes to do, save to persuade the hearer to yield entirely to God, and at no time to call Him to account for anything whatever. For as the potter (he says) of the same lump makes what he pleaseth, and no one forbids it; thus also when God, of the same race of men, punisheth some, and honoreth others, be not thou curious nor meddlesome herein, but worship only, and imitate the clay. And as it followeth the hands of the potter, so do thou also the mind of Him that so ordereth things. For He worketh nothing at random, or mere hazard, though thou be ignorant of the secret of His Wisdom. Yet thou allowest the other of the same lump to make divers things, and findest no fault: but of Him you demand an account of His punishments and honors, and will not allow Him to know who is worthy and who is not so; but since the same lump is of the same substance, you assert that there are the same dispositions. And, how monstrous this is! ...

Report a mistake

... And yet not even is it on the potter that the honor and the dishonor of the things made of the lump depends, but upon the use made by those that handle them, so here also it depends on the free choice. Still, as I said before, one must take this illustration to have one bearing only, which is that one should not contravene God, but yield to His incomprehensible Wisdom. For the examples ought to be greater than the subject, and than the things on account of which they are brought forward, so as to draw on the hearer better. Since if they were not greater and did not mount far above it, he could not attack as he ought, and shame the objectors. However, their ill-timed obstinacy he silenced in this way with becoming superiority. And then he introduces his answer. Now what is the answer?

Ver. 22, 23, 24. “What if God, willing to show His wrath, and to make His power known, endured with much long-suffering the vessels of wrath fitted to destruction: and that He might make known the riches of His glory on the vessels of mercy, which He had afore prepared unto glory, even us, whom He hath chosen, not of the Jews only, but also of the Gentiles.”

Report a mistake

What he means is somewhat as follows. Pharaoh was a vessel of wrath, that is, a man who by his own hard-heartedness had kindled the wrath of God. For after enjoying much long-suffering, he became no better, but remained unimproved. Wherefore he calleth him not only “a vessel of wrath,” but also one “fitted for destruction.” That is, fully fitted indeed, but by his own proper self. For neither had God left out aught of the things likely to recover him, nor did he leave out aught of those that would ruin him, and put him beyond any forgiveness. Yet still, though God knew this, “He endured him with much long-suffering,” being willing to bring him to repentance. For had He not willed this, then He would not have been thus long-suffering. But as he would not use the long-suffering in order to repentance, but fully fitted himself for wrath, He used him for the correction of others, through the punishment inflicted upon him making them better, and in this way setting forth His power. For that it is not God’s wish that His power be so made known, but in another way, by His benefits, namely, and kindnesses, he had shown above in all possible ways. For if Paul does not wish to appear powerful in this way (“not that we should appear approved,” he says, “but that ye should do that which is honest,”) (2 Cor. xiii. 7), much less doth God. ...

Report a mistake

... But after that he had shown long-suffering, that He might lead to repentance, but he did not repent, He suffered him a long time, that He might display at once His goodness and His power, even if that man were not minded to gain anything from this great long-suffering. As then by punishing this man, who continued incorrigible, He showed His power, so by having pitied those who had done many sins but repented, He manifested His love toward man. But it does not say, love towards man, but glory, to show that this is especially God’s glory, and for this He was above all things earnest. But in saying, “which He had afore prepared unto glory,” he does not mean that all is God’s doing. Since if this were so, there were nothing to hinder all men from being saved. But he is setting forth again His foreknowledge, and doing away with the difference between the Jews and the Gentiles. And on this topic again he grounds a defence of his statement, which is no small one. For it was not in the case of the Jews only that some men perished, and some were saved, but with the Gentiles also this was the case. Wherefore he does not say, all the Gentiles, but, “of the Gentiles,” nor, all the Jews, but, “of the Jews.” As then Pharaoh became a vessel of wrath by his own lawlessness, so did these become vessels of mercy by their own readiness to obey. For though the more part is of God, still they also have contributed themselves some little. Whence he does not say either, vessels of well-doing, or vessels of boldness (παρρησίας), but “vessels of mercy,” to show that the whole is of God. For the phrase, “it is not of him that willeth, nor of him that runneth,” even if it comes in the course of the objection, still, were it said by Paul, would create no difficulty. ...

Report a mistake

... Because when he says, “it is not of him that willeth, nor of him that runneth,” he does not deprive us of free-will, but shows that all is not one’s own, for that it requires grace from above. For it is binding on us to will, and also to run: but to confide not in our own labors, but in the love of God toward man. And this he has expressed elsewhere. “Yet not I, but the grace which was with me.” (1 Cor. xv. 10.) And he well says, “Which He had afore prepared unto glory.” For since they reproached them with this, that they were saved by grace, and thought to make them ashamed, he far more than sets aside this insinuation. For if the thing brought glory even to God, much more to them through whom God was glorified. But observe his forbearance, and unspeakable wisdom. For when he had it in his power to adduce, as an instance of those punished, not Pharaoh, but such of the Jews as had sinned, and so make his discourse much clearer, and show that where there were the same fathers, and the same sins, some perished, and some had mercy shown them, and persuade them not to be doubtful-minded, even if some of the Gentiles were saved, while the Jews were perishing; that he might not make his discourse irksome, the showing forth of the punishment he draws from the foreigner, so that he may not be forced to call them “vessels of wrath.” But those that obtained mercy he draws from the people of the Jews. And besides, he also has spoken in a sufficient way in God’s behalf, because though He knew very well that the nation was fitting itself as a vessel of destruction, still He contributed all on His part, His patience, His long-suffering, and that not merely long-suffering, but “much long-suffering;” yet still he was not minded to state it barely against the Jews. Whence then are some vessels of wrath, and some of mercy? Of their own free choice. ...

Report a mistake

... God, however, being very good, shows the same kindness to both. For it was not those in a state of salvation only to whom He showed mercy, but also Pharaoh, as far as His part went. For of the same long-suffering, both they and he had the advantage. And if he was not saved, it was quite owing to his own will: since, as for what concerneth God, he had as much done for him as they who were saved. Having then given to the question that answer which was furnished by facts, in order to give his discourse the advantage of other testimony in its favor, he introduces the prophets also making the same declarations aforetime. For Hosea, he says, of old put this in writing, as follows:

Report a mistake

What does Calvin say about Romans 9:20?

John Calvin

1509–1564 · Reformed · Commentaries on the Epistle of Paul the Apostle to the Romans

But, O man! who art thou?

20. But, O man! who art thou? etc. As it is a participle in Greek, we may read what follows in the present tense, who disputest, or contendest, or strivest in opposition to God; for it is expressed in Greek according to this meaning, — “Who art thou who enterest into a dispute with God?” But there is not much difference in the sense. In this first answer, he does nothing else but beat down impious blasphemy by an argument taken from the condition of man: he will presently subjoin another, by which he will clear the righteousness of God from all blame.

It is indeed evident that no cause is adduced higher than the will of God. Since there was a ready answer, that the difference depends on just reasons, why did not Paul adopt such a brief reply? But he placed the will of God in the highest rank for this reason, — that it alone may suffice us for all other causes. No doubt, if the objection had been false, that God according to his own will rejects those whom he honors not with his favor, and chooses those whom he gratuitously loves, a refutation would not have been neglected by Paul. The ungodly object and say, that men are exempted from blame, if the will of God holds the first place in their salvation, or in their perdition. Does Paul deny this? Nay, by his answer he confirms it, that is, that God determines concerning men, as it seems good to him, and that, men in vain and madly rise up to contend with God; for he assigns, by his own right, whatever lot he pleases to what he forms.

Report a mistake

But they who say that Paul, wanting reason, had recourse to reproof, cast a grievous calumny on the Holy Spirit: for the things calculated to vindicate God’s justice, and ready at hand, he was at first unwilling to adduce, for they could not have been comprehended; yea, he so modifies his second reason, that he does not undertake a full defence, but in such a manner as to give a sufficient demonstration of God’s justice, if it be considered by us with devout humility and reverence.

He reminds man of what is especially meet for him to remember, that is, of his own condition; as though he had said, — “Since thou art man, thou ownest thyself to be dust and ashes; why then doest thou contend with the Lord about that which thou art not able to understand?” In a word, the Apostle did not bring forward what might have been said, but what is suitable to our ignorance. Proud men clamour, because Paul, admitting that men are rejected or chosen by the secret counsel of God, alleges no cause; as though the Spirit of God were silent for want of reason, and not rather, that by his silence he reminds us, that a mystery which our minds cannot comprehend ought to be reverently adored, and that he thus checks the wantonness of human curiosity. Let us then know, that God does for no other reason refrain from speaking, but that he sees that we cannot contain his immense wisdom in our small measure; and thus regarding our weakness, he leads us to moderation and sobriety.

Report a mistake

Does what is formed?

Does what is formed? etc. We see that Paul dwells continually on this, — that the will of God, though its reason is hid from us, is to be counted just; for he shows that he is deprived of his right, if he is not at liberty to determine what he sees meet concerning his creatures. This seems unpleasant to the ears of many. There are also those who pretend that God is exposed to great reproach were such a power ascribed to him, as though they in their fastidiousness were better divines than Paul, who has laid down this as the rule of humility to the faithful, that they are to admire the sovereignty of God, and not to estimate it by their own judgment.

But he represses this arrogance of contending with God by a most apt similitude, in which he seems to have alluded to Isaiah 45:9, rather than to Jeremiah 18:6; for nothing else is taught us by Jeremiah, than that Israel was in the hand of the Lord, so that he could for his sins wholly break him in pieces, as a potter the earthen vessel. But Isaiah ascends higher, “Woe to him,” he says, “who speaks against his maker;” that is, the pot that contends with the former of the clay; “shall the clay say to its former, what doest thou?” etc. And surely there is no reason for a mortal man to think himself better than earthen vessel, when he compares himself with God. We are not however to be over-particular in applying this testimony to our present subject, since Paul only meant to allude to the words of the Prophet, in order that the similitude might have more weight.

Report a mistake

What does Evans say about Romans 9:20?

John Evans

1680–1730 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume VI (Acts to Revelation): Romans, by John Evans

On Romans 9:14–24

This comment begins at Romans 9:14:

The apostle, having asserted the true meaning of the promise, comes here to maintain and prove the absolute sovereignty of God, in disposing of the children of men, with reference to their eternal state. And herein God is to be…

By reproving the objector

1. By reproving the objector (v. 20): Nay but, O man. This is not an objection fit to be made by the creature against his Creator, by man against God. The truth, as it is in Jesus, is that which abases man as nothing, less than nothing, and advances God as sovereign Lord of all. Observe how contemptibly he speaks of man, when he comes to argue with God his Maker: "Who art thou, thou that art so foolish, so feeble, so short-sighted, so incompetent a judge of the divine counsels? Art thou able to fathom such a depth, dispute such a case, to trace that way of God which is in the sea, his path in the great waters?" That repliest against God. It becomes us to submit to him, not to reply against him; to lie down under his hand, not to fly in his face, nor to charge him with folly. Ho antapokrinomenos—That answerest again. God is our master, and we are his servants; and it does not become servants to answer again, Tit. ii. 9.

2. By resolving all into the divine sovereignty. We are the thing formed, and he is the former; and it does not become us to challenge or arraign his wisdom in ordering and disposing of us into this or that shape of figure. The rude and unformed mass of matter hath no right to this or that form, but is shaped at the pleasure of him that formeth it. God's sovereignty over us is fitly illustrated by the power that the potter hath over the clay; compare Jer. xviii. 6, where, by a like comparison, God asserts his dominion over the nation of the Jews, when he was about to magnify his justice in their destruction by Nebuchadnezzar.

Report a mistake

What does Bengel say about Romans 9:20?

Johann Albrecht Bengel

1687–1752 · Lutheran Pietist · Gnomon of the New Testament, Vol. III (Romans, I and II Corinthians)

Oman) weak, ignorant of righteousness [i.e. the true way of justification]. ... Isa. xxix. 16 ... . The same prophet, ch. xlv. 9 ... Touts ... 6? ... Shall ye not be reckoned as the potter's clay ? Shall the thing formed say to Him that formed it, Thou hast not formed me ? Is. xlv. 9, Shall the clay say to the potter, what art thou doing, that thou dost not work, thou hast no hands ? Shall the thing formed answer Him that formed it ? — (Vers. LXX.)

Report a mistake

What does Wesley say about Romans 9:20?

John Wesley

1703–1791 · Anglican (Methodist) · Explanatory Notes upon the New Testament: Romans

On Romans 9:1–33

This comment begins at Romans 9:1:

In this chapter St. Paul, after strongly declaring his love and esteem for them, sets himself to answer the grand objection of his countrymen; namely, that the rejection of the Jews and reception of the gentiles was contrary to the…

Nay, but who art thou, O man

20. Nay, but who art thou, O man - Little, impotent, ignorant man. That repliest against God - That accusest God of injustice, for himself fixing the terms on which he will show mercy? Shall the thing formed say to him that formed it, Why hast thou made me thus - Why hast thou made me capable of honour and immortality, only by believing?

Report a mistake

What does Hodge say about Romans 9:20?

Charles Hodge

1797–1878 · Reformed (Presbyterian) · A Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, designed for students of the English Bible

Nay, but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God

(20) Nay, but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God? Shall the thing formed, &c. In these words we have both a reproof and an answer. The reproof is directed against the irreverent spirit, whence such cavils always arise. After the clear proof given in the preceding verses, that God claims this sovereignty in his word, and exercises it in his providence, it argues great want of reverence for God to assert that this claim involves the grossest injustice. It is very common with the sacred writers, and with Christ himself, when questions or cavils are presented, to direct their answers more to the feeling which the question indicated, than to the question itself. Tholuck refers, in illustration of this remark, to John 3: 3. Matt. 8:19, 20, 22. 19: 16. 22: 29. But in this case, besides this reproof for a miserable mortal attempting to call his Maker to account, instead of considering that the mere fact that God claims any thing as his right, is evidence enough that it is just, there is a direct answer to the difficulty. The objection is founded on ignorance or misapprehension of the true relation between God and his sinful creatures. It supposes that he is under obligation to extend his grace to all. Whereas he is under obligation to none. All are sinners, and have forfeited every claim to his mercy; it is, therefore, perfectly competent to God to spare one and not another; to make one vessel to honour, and another to dishonour. He, as their sovereign Creator, has the same right over them that a potter has over the clay. It is to be borne in mind, that Paul does not here speak of the right of God over his creatures as creatures, but as sinful creatures; as he himself clearly intimates in the next verses. ...

Report a mistake

... It is the cavil of a sinful creature against his Creator, that he is answering; and he does it by showing that God is under no obligation to give his grace to any, but is as sovereign as the potter in fashioning the clay.

Shall the thing formed, say to him that formed it, why hast thou made me thus? See Isaiah 45: 9. In this clause Paul presents mainly the idea of God’s right, and in the subsequent verses he shows that nothing unjust is included in the right here claimed. We are justly in his hands; and it is the height of irreverence and folly for us to call him to account for the manner in which he may see fit to dispose of us.

Report a mistake

What does Godet say about Romans 9:20?

Frédéric Louis Godet

1812–1900 · Reformed (Swiss Protestant) · Commentary on St. Paul's Epistle to the Romans

On Romans 9:1–29

This comment begins at Romans 9:1:

The apostle opens this passage with a preface expressing the profound grief he feels in view of the mysterious fact which is about to occupy him (w. 1-5) ; then he shows how the liberty of God is set in…

On Romans 9:19–21

This comment begins at Romans 9:19:

Vv. 19-21: ... wUt say then unto me, Why doth he yet ... t For who can resist His mil t Much ... 0 man, who art thou (hat ... Shall the vessd of day ... to him that formed…

Yer. 20. Most commentators do not hold that in the following answer Paul comes seriously to discuss the objection. Abrumpit ... says Melanchthon. ... observes that Paul raises the question, not to resolve it, which would be impossible, but to crush it We acknowledge that in w. 19 and 20 Paul pleads solely man's incompetency to discuss the dealings of God. But we shall see that he does not stop there, and that he enters more profoundly into the marrow of the question than is generally thought It would be surprising, indeed, if a oondusion notto-be received should be found to be the last word of Paul's logic. It would have been better for him in that case not to have made his interlocutor bring him to such a strait S ... mori)} It ... signifies hero : I do not ... tba intrinsic truth of what thou ... but, howevar that may be, what is moie certain is, that ... not in a position to dispute with God." The ... 0 wau! reminds the adversary of the reason of his ... it is his absolute inferiority in relation to the Creator. The exclamation ... 0 man, is placed by the Byzs. at the beginning of the sentence, but by the ... after ... which is undoubtedly preferable; For the address : 0 man ! justifies the use of this particle ; and the two terms ... and God placed, the one at the beginning of the sentence, the other at the end, ... a better antithesis. The term ... does not simply mean : to reply ; but, as is proved by the only parallel in the N. T. (Luke xiv. 6) : to reply to a reply, to ... as it were. God, indeed, had already answered once in the previous sayings. This word implies the spirit of conten tion. — The comparison of the relation between God and man to that between the vessel and the potter seems logically defective. Man free and responsible cannot be a mere instrument in the hands of God. ...

Report a mistake

... Moreover, endowed as he is with sensibility to pleasure and pain, he cannot be manipulated like worthless matter. And certainly, if the question addressed by the vessel to the potter : " Why hast thou made me thus?" signified: ''Why hast thou created me good day or bad clay?'* and in the application to man's relation to God : " Why hast thou created me with the disposition to good or to evil 7 " the comparison would have no meaning. For the potter does not commit the absurdity of holding the day responsible for its superior or ... quality. But the questipn is not in the least about the production of the day, and consequently about its qualiiies, but solely about tbe use which is made of it bj the ... He does not create the clay ; he takes it as he finds it and adapts it as best he can to the different uses he proposes to himself. And besides, it is not the yet shapeless day which asks : '' Why hast thou made me thus (with or without such or such qualities) ? " it is the fully manufactured vessd ... which thus interrogates him wJio has given it its present form ... . Consequently, in the application made of this to the relation between man and God, this same question does not signify: ''Why hast Thou created me good or evil ? " — in that case the question could not be summarily set aside by Paul — but: "Why, in the development of Thy work here below, hast Thou assigned me an honourable use (by favouring me with Thy grace, like Moses) or a vile use (by hardening me like Pharaoh) ? Why does such a man serve the end of Thy glory by his salvation ; such another the end of Thy glory by his dishonour 1 " This is the question in regard to which Paul reminds his Israelitish disputant of man's incompetency as before God. ...

Report a mistake

... As it belongs only to the potter, in virtue of the knowledge he has of his art, to determine the use which he shall make of the different parts of the mass in his hands to extract from each the best result possible, so it belongs to God alone to assign to the different portions of humanity, to the Jews no less than to the rest of men, the use which suits Him best, with a view to His final aim. The question whether, in determining the use of one and another. He will act without rhyme or reason, or whether, on the contrary. He will adapt the use made of each to His moral predispositions, finds no place in the mind of any one who understands that God's perfections always act in harmony, and that consequently His power is ever the servant of His goodness, justice, and wisdom. As that which justifies the power of the potter over the lump of day is not only the superiority of his strength, but that of his understanding; so, with stronger reason, what explains the sovereignty of God and His right over mankind is not only His almightiness, but His supreme understanding and His infinite moral perfection. And what follows w. 22-24| proves that such is the view of the apostle. For to what purpose are the expressions ... wUling (ver. 22), and ... that (ver. 23), if not to bring out, as we shall see, God's perfect wisdom in the choice of His ends and the employment of His means? It is obvious, therefore, that the use God makes of noan at a given moment (a Pharaoh, for example, as a vessel of dishonour), far from excluding his moral liberty, supposes and involves it For the honour or dishonour to which God turns him in the execution of His work is not independent, as appears from this example, of the attitude taken by man in relation to God. ...

Report a mistake

... The work of the skilful potter 13 not the emblem of an arbitrary use of strength; but, on the contrary, of a deliberate and intelligent employment of the matter at his disposal Such is the apostle's complete view. But it is quite true, as Lange says : " When man goes the length of making to himself a god whom he affects to bind by his own rights, God then puts on His majesty, and appears in all His reality as a free God, before whom man is a mere nothing, like the clay in the hand of the potter." Such was Paul's attitude when acting as God's advocate, in his suit with Jewish Pharisaism. This is the reason why he expresses only ... side of the trutL The following passage, ver. ... 21, will show that he is very far from mistaking or forgetting the other.

The , or, of ver. 21, means : *' Or, if it were otherwise, it must be admitted the potter has not ?" . . . Comp. Matt. xx. 15. The genitive rod ... of the lump of day, is dependent not on o ... the potter, but on ... lav, power : the power which he has to use the day. The subject, the potter, is placed between the two words, the better, as it were, to command them. — What does the lump represent ? Some think that it is the people of Israel, and that God is described as having the right to make them either His elect people, or a rejected nation. This meaning breaks down on w. 23 and 24, where we see that the vessels imto honour are elected from among the Gentiles as well as from among the Jews. The lump therefore represents the whole of humanity, not humanity as God creates it, but in the state in which He finds it every moment when He puts it to the service of His kingdom. This state includes for each individual the whole series of free determinations which have gone to make him what he is.

Report a mistake

Let not Israel therefore say to ... Thoa iiast no right to make of me ... else than a Tessel of honour ; and Thou hast no ... to make of that other ... the Gentiks, anything else than a base ressel It belongs to God Himself to decide, ... to His wisdom, the part which He will assign to every human being. ... 16, xlv. 9, 10 ; Jer. xviii. 6, etc.), and thus had the foroe of a quotation. Application of the figure, w. 22-24.

Report a mistake

Cited on other verses

Commentators citing Romans 9:20 while explaining another verse. The sentence is copied as the excerpt reads.

  • John Chrysostom · Hebrews 5:7–8

    For there too, when he had first stopped the mouths of the gainsayers, and said, “Nay but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God?” ( Rom. ix. 20 ), he then subjoined the solution.

  • John Evans · Romans 9:6–13

    By asserting and proving the absolute sovereignty of God, in disposing of the children of men, v. 14-24. 3.

  • Johann Albrecht Bengel · Romans 9:15

    (rejoinder of the opponent), which is censured at ver. 20, and is subsequently refuted by taking up the words themselves or their synonyms.

  • Johann Albrecht Bengel · Romans 9:19

    The power of God over men is greater than the power of the potter over the clay, ver. 20, 21.

  • Johann Albrecht Bengel · Romans 9:22

    but if) This particle has this as its apodosis to be supplied at the end of ver. 23 from ver. 20: God has much greater cause to complain concerning man, and man has less cause to expostulate with God [than the potter concerning the clay, and the clay with the potter] ... .

  • Charles Bridges · Ecclesiastes 6:10

    ‘“ Nay, but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God !” (Rom. ix. 20.

  • Frédéric Louis Godet · Romans 9:13

    Then in vv. 19-24 he shows by a figure that the superiority of God to man should impose silence on the proud pretensions of the latter, and he applies this principle to the relation between God and

Whole homilies and tractates on Romans 9:20

In the creeds and councils on Romans 9:20

Creeds, conciliar decrees and confessions that cite this verse, oldest first. They are not commentary; each links to the whole document.

The Greek words

WordDictionary formGlossGrammar
ὦὦOInterjection
ἄνθρωπεἄνθρωποςmanNoun · vocative singular masculine
μενοῦνγεμενοῦνγεbut ratherParticle
σὺσύyouPersonal pronoun · 2nd person nominative singular
τίςτίςwhoInterrogative pronoun · nominative singular masculine
εἶεἰμίareVerb · present active indicative · 2nd person singular
ὁὁ-Article · nominative singular masculine
ἀνταποκρινόμενοςἀνταποκρίνομαιanswering againstVerb · present middle or passive (deponent) participle · nominative singular masculine
τῷὁ-Article · dative singular masculine
θεῷθεόςGodNoun · dative singular masculine
μὴμήNotParticle · negative
ἐρεῖλέγωwill sayVerb · future active indicative · 3rd person singular
τὸὁtheArticle · nominative singular neuter
πλάσμαπλάσμαthing formedNoun · nominative singular neuter
τῷὁto the [One]Article · dative singular masculine
πλάσαντιπλάσσωhaving formed [it]Verb · aorist active participle · dative singular masculine
ΤίτίςWhyInterrogative pronoun · accusative singular neuter
μεἐγώmePersonal pronoun · 1st person accusative singular
ἐποίησαςποιέωhave you madeVerb · aorist active indicative · 2nd person singular
οὕτωςοὕτω(ς)like thisAdverb

From MACULA (CC BY 4.0), as the Open Word Bible reads them.

How the Open Word Bible translates Romans 9:20

Word for word: O man, rather you who are, the [one] answering back to the God?

O man: a human being, in contrast to God Word sense

ἄνθρωπος here is a human being of either sex; the point is the difference between creature and Creator.

rather: correcting the objector Word sense

μενοῦνγε turns the question around: rather than calling God to account, who are you?

answering back: disputing with God Word sense

ἀνταποκρίνομαι is to reply against, to contradict or dispute (compare Job 40:2).

a mere human being (B); only a human being (R) Supplied words

Balanced and Readable bring out the contrast with God, which the address "O man" carries.

Word for word: Not will say the thing formed to the [one] having formed: Why me did you make thus?

Isaiah 29:16 and 45:9 Allusion

Isaiah twice pictures a pot speaking back to the potter who made it, to show how foolish it is for people to question their Maker. Paul uses the wording of Isaiah 29:16 in its Greek form.

a question expecting the answer no Grammar

The question begins with μὴ: the thing made has no ground to complain to its maker.

Cross-references

  • Isaiah 29:16 How you turn everything on its head! Is the potter to be counted the same as the clay? Should the thing that was made say of its maker, "He did not make me"? Should the vessel say of the one who shaped it, "He has no sense"?
  • Isaiah 45:9-11 Woe to anyone who argues with the one who shaped him, one shard among the shards of earthenware! Does the clay ask its potter, "What do you think you are making?" Does your handiwork say of you, "He has no hands"?
  • Isaiah 64:7 But now, LORD, You are our Father. We are the clay, and You the potter who shaped us; every one of us is what Your hand has made.
  • Job 33:13 1 voice Why do you complain against Him that He answers none of a person's words?
  • Job 40:2 Will the one who finds fault contend with the Almighty? Let the one who argues against God give an answer.

Cross-references from OpenBible.info (CC BY), most voted first.

Read Romans 9 with all its commentary