Logia

Romans · Chapter 9 · Paul's grief for Israel

Romans 9:12

a purpose that rests not on works but on the one who calls, Rebecca was told, "The older will serve the younger."

οὐκ ἐξ ἔργων ἀλλ’ ἐκ τοῦ καλοῦντος, ἐρρέθη αὐτῇ ὅτι Ὁ μείζων δουλεύσει τῷ ἐλάσσονι· Word by word ↓

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

6 commentators in Logia comment on Romans 9:12, from John Calvin (1509–1564) to Frédéric Louis Godet (1812–1900): Calvin, Evans, Bengel, Wesley, Hodge and Godet.

Topics: Election and predestination

Two voices on Romans 9:12

Choose two:

What the church has said

See all 6 voices as a grid

Eras across, traditions down, each with its first words. An empty cell is a place the library has no voice yet.

ReformationPuritans and the 1700sThe 1800s
Protestant
  • Calvin 12. The elder shall serve the younger See how…
  • Evans The apostle, having made his way to that which…
  • Bengel to her) It was often foretold to mothers before…
  • Wesley 12. The elder - Esau. Shall serve the younger…
  • Hodge (12) Zt was said to her the elder shall…
  • Godet Ver. 12. The oracle quoted is taken from Gen.…

What does Calvin say about Romans 9:12?

John Calvin

1509–1564 · Reformed · Commentaries on the Epistle of Paul the Apostle to the Romans

The elder shall serve the younger

12. The elder shall serve the younger See how the Lord makes a difference between the sons of Isaac, while they were as yet in their mother’s womb; for this was the heavenly answer, by which it appeared that God designed to show to the younger peculiar favor, which he denied to the elder. Though this indeed had reference to the right of primogeniture, yet in this, as the symbol of something greater, was manifested the will of God: and that this was the case we may easily perceive, when we consider what little benefit, according to the flesh, Jacob derived from his primogeniture. For he was, on its account, exposed to great danger; and to avoid this danger, he was obliged to quit his home and his country, and was unkindly treated in his exile: when he returned, he tremblingly, and in doubt of his life, prostrated himself at the feet of his brother, humbly asked forgiveness for his offence, and lived through the indulgence shown to him. Where was his dominion over his brother, from whom he was constrained to seek by entreaty his life? There was then something greater than the primogeniture promised in the answer given by the Lord.

Report a mistake

What does Evans say about Romans 9:12?

John Evans

1680–1730 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume VI (Acts to Revelation): Romans, by John Evans

On Romans 9:6–13

This comment begins at Romans 9:6:

The apostle, having made his way to that which he had to say, concerning the rejection of the body of his countrymen, with a protestation of his own affection for them and a concession of their undoubted privileges, comes in…

On Romans 9:6–13

This comment begins at Romans 9:6:

In this paragraph the apostle explains the true meaning and intention of the promise. When we mistake the word, and misunderstand the promise, no marvel if we are ready to quarrel with God about the accomplishment; and therefore the sense…

On Romans 9:6–13

This comment begins at Romans 9:6:

II. He proves this by instances; and therein shows not only that some of Abraham's seed were chosen, and others not, but that God therein wrought according to the counsel of his own will; and not with regard to that…

On Romans 9:6–13

This comment begins at Romans 9:6:

... There was nothing extraordinary or supernatural in his conception, as there was in Isaac's; he was born after the flesh (Gal. iv. 29), representing those that expect justification and salvation by their own strength and righteousness. (2.) That the…

On Romans 9:10–13

This comment begins at Romans 9:10:

2. The case of Jacob and Esau (v. 10-13), which is much stronger, to show that the carnal seed of Abraham were not, as such, interested in the promise, but only such of them as God in sovereignty had appointed.…

On Romans 9:10–13

This comment begins at Romans 9:10:

... Such a difference did God put between those two nations, that both descended from the loins of Abraham and Isaac, as at first there was a difference put between Jacob and Esau, the distinguishing heads of those two nations.…

On Romans 9:10–13

This comment begins at Romans 9:10:

... The apostle's reasoning for the explication and proof of this is, however, very applicable to, and, no doubt (as is usual in scripture) was intended for the clearing of the methods of God's grace towards particular person, for the…

What does Bengel say about Romans 9:12?

Johann Albrecht Bengel

1687–1752 · Lutheran Pietist · Gnomon of the New Testament, Vol. III (Romans, I and II Corinthians)

On Romans 9:12–13

to her) It was often foretold to mothers before conception or birth, what would happen to their sons. — on 6 ... Gen. xxv. 23, LXX. ... I ... the elder, who, it might be reasonably thought, should command, as the younger should obey. ... shall serve) and yet not so for ever, Gen. xxvii. 40. ... as) The word spoken by Malachi, at a period so long subsequent, agrees with that spoken in Genesis. ... l. 2, LXX. ... have loved ... have hated) The reference is not to the spiritual state of each of the two brothers: but the external condition of Jacob and Esau, in like manner as the corporeal birth of Isaac is a type of spiritual things, ver. 9. All Israelites are not saved, and all Edomites are not damned. But Paul intimates, that as there was a difference between the sons of Abraham and Isaac, so there was a difference among the posterity of Israel. So far has he demonstrated what he purposed; he in the next place introduces an objection, and refutes it ... properly signifies to hate, nay, to hate greatly. See ... i. 4, at the end.

Report a mistake

What does Wesley say about Romans 9:12?

John Wesley

1703–1791 · Anglican (Methodist) · Explanatory Notes upon the New Testament: Romans

On Romans 9:1–33

This comment begins at Romans 9:1:

In this chapter St. Paul, after strongly declaring his love and esteem for them, sets himself to answer the grand objection of his countrymen; namely, that the rejection of the Jews and reception of the gentiles was contrary to the…

The elder

12. The elder - Esau. Shall serve the younger - Not in person, for he never did; but in his posterity. Accordingly the Edomites were often brought into subjection by the Israelites. Gen. xxv, 23.

Report a mistake

What does Hodge say about Romans 9:12?

Charles Hodge

1797–1878 · Reformed (Presbyterian) · A Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, designed for students of the English Bible

Zt was said to her the elder shall serve the younger

(12) Zt was said to her the elder shall serve the younger. These words are to be connected with the 10th verse, according to our version, in this manner, “ Not only this, but Rebecca also, when she had conceived, &c., it was said to her, &c.’’

According to this view, although the construction is irregular, the sense is sufficiently obvious. As it was said to Rebecca that the elder of her sons should serve the younger, prior to the birth of either, it is evident that the choice between them was not on account of their works. It has been said that this declaration relates not to Jacob and Esau personally, but to their posterity, 1. Because in Gen. 25: 23, whence the quotation is made, it is said, “Two nations are within thy womb, and the one people shall be stronger than the other people; and the elder shall serve the younger.”” 2. Because Esau did not personally serve Jacob, although the descendants of the one were subjected to those of the other. It is no doubt true that the prediction contained in this passage has reference not only to the relative standing of Jacob and Hsau as individuals, but also to that of their descendants. It may even be allowed that the latter was principally intended in the annunciation to Rebecca. But it is too clear to be denied, 1. That this distinction between the two races presupposed and included a distinction between the individuals. Jacob was made the special heir to his father Isaac, obtained as an individual the birth-right and the blessing, and Esau as an individual was cast off. The one, therefore, was personally preferred to the other. 2. In Paul’s application of this event to his argument, the distinction between the two as individuals was the very thing referred to. ...

Report a mistake

... This is plain from the 11th verse, in which he says, “ The children being not yet born, neither having done any good or evil, &c.” It is, therefore, the nature of the choice between the children that is the point designed to be presented. As to the objection that Hsau never personally served Jacob, it is founded on the mere literal sense of the words. Esau did acknowledge his inferiority to Jacob, and was in fact postponed to him on various occasions. This is the real spirit of the passage. This prophecy, as is the case with all similar predictions, had various stages of fulfilment. The relation between the two brothers during life; the loss of the birth-right blessing and promises on the part of Esau; the temporary subjugation of his descendants to the Hebrews under David, their final and complete subjection under the Maccabees; and especially their exclusion from the peculiar privileges of the people of God, through all the early periods of their history, are all included. Compare the prediction of the subjection of Ham to his brethren; and of Japheth’s dwelling in the tents of Shem, Gen. 9: 25—27.

Report a mistake

What does Godet say about Romans 9:12?

Frédéric Louis Godet

1812–1900 · Reformed (Swiss Protestant) · Commentary on St. Paul's Epistle to the Romans

On Romans 9:1–29

This comment begins at Romans 9:1:

The apostle opens this passage with a preface expressing the profound grief he feels in view of the mysterious fact which is about to occupy him (w. 1-5) ; then he shows how the liberty of God is set in…

On Romans 9:10–13

This comment begins at Romans 9:10:

Vv. 10-13. " And not only this; but whm Bebecca also had conceived by one, even by our father Isaac {for the children being ... yet bom, neither having done any good or evil, that the purpose of God ...…

Ver. 12. The oracle quoted is taken from Gen. xxv. 23. The question whether it refers to the two brothers personally, or to the two peoples who shall spring from them, is settled by the words preceding : " Two nations are in thy womb, and two manner of people shall issue from thee." Hence it follows that the oracle neither speaks of the two peoples separately from their fathers, nor of the two fathers separately from their descendants. Possibly Genesis gives greater weight to the idea of the two peoples, whereas Paul (ver. 11) thinks chiefly of the two fathers. It matters little ; for a profound solidarity, at once physical and moral, connects the character of the race with that of the father.

The theocratic inferiority of Esau resulted historically from his profane spirit, which showed itself in the sale of his birthright ; it was sealed by the blessing of Jacob. As to the people who sprang from Esau, this same inferiority appeared. first, in the faet that their dwelling-place was assigned outside the promised land properly so called, then in their submission to Israel under David, and finally, after several alternations of subjection and independence, in their final incorporation with the Jewish state under John ... and their obliteration firom the number of the nations. — The translation of the words ... and ... by elder and yownger, is rejected by Meyer as opposed to the natural meaning of the two terms;. But it is quite impossible to give a different meaning than elder to the word ... in the passage Gen. xxix. 16, where it is contrasted with the term ... Even in Hebrew the meaning of the narrative is not certainly that Leah was physically greater than her younger sister. And in our passage how can Meyer hold that the term greater signifies that Esau was the stronger of the twins in their mother's womb !

Report a mistake

Cited on other verses

Commentators citing Romans 9:12 while explaining another verse. The sentence is copied as the excerpt reads.

  • John Chrysostom · Romans 9:11

    Ver. 11–13.

  • John Calvin · Genesis 25:23

    (Romans 9:7,8,12.

  • Matthew Henry · Genesis 25:23

    God is a free agent in dispensing his grace; it is his prerogative to make a difference between those who have not as yet themselves done either good or evil. This the apostle infers hence, Rom. ix. 12.

  • Charles Hodge · Romans 8:30

    Heb. 9:15, “ That they which are called may receive the promise of eternal inheritance.” Rom. 9: 12.

  • Charles Hodge · Romans 9:13

    This passage, as well as the one quoted in v. 12, and just referred to, relates to the descendants of Jacob and Esau, as well as to the individuals themselves; the favour shown to the posterity of the one, and withheld from that of the other, being founded on the …

  • Robert Jamieson · Genesis 25:21

    … was divinely informed that she was to be the mother of twins, who should be the progenitors of two independent nations; that the descendants of the younger should be the more powerful and subdue those of the other (Ro 9:12; 2Ch 21:8).

  • Frédéric Louis Godet · Romans 9:5

    … when Isaac alone received the character of the chosen seed, to the exclusion of Ishmael, son of Abraham though he also was, w. 6-9 ; and again, when of Isaac's two sons Jacob was preferred, and his eldest rejected, vv. 10-13.

  • Frédéric Louis Godet · Romans 9:11

    This plan certainly was not arbitrarily conceived, but it contains nothing which gives it the character of an obligation or debt. — Before citing the oracle which he intends to quote here (ver. 12), the apostle explains the object of God's way of acting, announced in the oracle.

  • Frédéric Louis Godet · Romans 9:13

    … subjection of the latter to the former ; or it may be thought that Paul quotes this saying of Malachi as demonstrating by a striking fact in the later history of the two peoples the truth of the relation expressed in ver. 12.

Whole homilies and tractates on Romans 9:12

The Greek words

WordDictionary formGlossGrammar
οὐκοὐnotParticle · negative
ἐξἐκofPreposition
ἔργωνἔργονworksNoun · genitive plural neuter
ἀλλἀλλάbutConjunction
ἐκἐκofPreposition
τοῦὁthe [One]Article · genitive singular masculine
καλοῦντοςκαλέωcallingVerb · present active participle · genitive singular masculine
ἐρρέθηῥέωit was saidVerb · aorist passive indicative · 3rd person singular
αὐτῇαὐτόςto herPersonal pronoun · dative singular feminine
ὅτιὅτι-Conjunction
ὉὁTheArticle · nominative singular masculine
μείζωνμέγαςolderAdjective · nominative singular masculine · comparative
δουλεύσειδουλεύωwill serveVerb · future active indicative · 3rd person singular
τῷὁtheArticle · dative singular masculine
ἐλάσσονιἐλάσσωνyoungerAdjective · dative singular masculine

From MACULA (CC BY 4.0), as the Open Word Bible reads them.

How the Open Word Bible translates Romans 9:12

Word for word: For not yet having been born nor having done anything good or bad, so that the according to election purpose of the God might remain, \v 12 not from works but from the [one] calling, it was said to her that: The greater will serve the lesser;

Genesis 25:23 Allusion

God told Rebecca, while the twins struggled within her, that two nations were in her womb and that the older would serve the younger. Paul quotes the last line of the oracle as it stands in the Greek Old Testament.

God's purpose according to election: his plan, carried out by his choosing Word sense

Not: God's purpose of foreseeing who would choose him

ἐκλογή is choosing or election, and πρόθεσις is purpose or plan (8:28). God's plan works by his own choice, and it "stands", that is, it holds and is carried out.

the choice rests on God who calls, not on anything done Theology

Paul stresses that God spoke before the twins were born or had done good or bad. The choice did not depend on works but on God, "the one who calls" (as in 4:17, 8:30).

the greater, the lesser: the older and the younger Word sense

In Genesis 25:23 the words mean the elder and the younger son, Esau and Jacob.

Rebecca Supplied words

Balanced and Readable name the woman "her" refers to (verse 10).

Cross-references

  • Genesis 25:22-23 4 voices The children inside her crushed against each other, and she said, "If it is like this, what is happening to me?" So she went to seek an answer from the LORD.

Cross-references from OpenBible.info (CC BY), most voted first.

Read Romans 9 with all its commentary