Logia

Romans · Chapter 9 · Paul's grief for Israel

Romans 9:19

So you will say to me, "Why does God still find fault, then?" For who can stand against His will?

Ἐρεῖς μοι οὖν· Τί οὖν ἔτι μέμφεται; τῷ γὰρ βουλήματι αὐτοῦ τίς ἀνθέστηκεν; Word by word ↓

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

7 commentators in Logia comment on Romans 9:19, from John Calvin (1509–1564) to Frédéric Louis Godet (1812–1900): Calvin, Evans, Bengel, Wesley, Haydock, Hodge and Godet.

Topics: Election and predestination

Two voices on Romans 9:19

Choose two:

What the church has said

See all 7 voices as a grid

Eras across, traditions down, each with its first words. An empty cell is a place the library has no voice yet.

ReformationPuritans and the 1700sThe 1800s
Catholic––
  • Haydock Ver. 19. &c. Thou wilt say, therefore, to me,…
Protestant
  • Calvin 19. Thou wilt then say, etc. Here indeed the…
  • Evans II. It might be objected, Why doth he yet…
  • Bengel "En, as yet) even still. This particle well expresses…
  • Wesley 19. Why doth he still find fault - The…
  • Hodge (19) Thou wilt then say unto me, why doth…
  • Godet Vv. 19-21: ... wUt say then unto me, Why…

What does Calvin say about Romans 9:19?

John Calvin

1509–1564 · Reformed · Commentaries on the Epistle of Paul the Apostle to the Romans

Thou wilt then say

19. Thou wilt then say, etc. Here indeed the flesh especially storms, that is, when it hears that they who perish have been destined by the will of God to destruction. Hence the Apostle adopts again the words of an opponent; for he saw that the mouths of the ungodly could not be restrained from boldly clamouring against the righteousness of God: and he very fitly expresses their mind; for being not content with defending themselves, they make God guilty instead of themselves; and then, after having devolved on him the blame of their own condemnation, they become indignant against his great power. They are indeed constrained to yield; but they storm, because they cannot resist; and ascribing dominion to him, they in a manner charge him with tyranny. In the same manner the Sophists in their schools foolishly dispute on what they call his absolute justice, as though forgetful of his own righteousness, he would try the power of his authority by throwing all things into confusion. Thus then speak the ungodly in this passage, — “What cause has he to be angry with us? Since he has formed us such as we are, since he leads us at his will where he pleases, what else does he in destroying us but punish his own work in us? For it is not in our power to contend with him; how much soever we may resist, he will yet have the upper hand. Then unjust will be his judgment, if he condemns us; and unrestrainable is the power which he now employs towards us.” What does Paul say to these things?

Report a mistake

What does Evans say about Romans 9:19?

John Evans

1680–1730 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume VI (Acts to Revelation): Romans, by John Evans

On Romans 9:14–24

This comment begins at Romans 9:14:

The apostle, having asserted the true meaning of the promise, comes here to maintain and prove the absolute sovereignty of God, in disposing of the children of men, with reference to their eternal state. And herein God is to be…

It might be objected, Why doth he yet find fault

II. It might be objected, Why doth he yet find fault? For who hath resisted his will? v. 19. Had the apostle been arguing only for God's sovereignty in appointing and ordering the terms and conditions of acceptance and salvation, there had not been the least colour for this objection; for he might well find fault if people refused to come up to the terms on which such a salvation is offered; the salvation being so great, the terms could not be hard. But there might be colour for the objection against his arguing for the sovereignty of God in giving and withholding differencing and preventing grace; and the objection is commonly and readily advanced against the doctrine of distinguishing grace. If God, while he gives effectual grace to some, denies it to others, why doth he find fault with those to whom he denies it? If he hath rejected the Jews, and hid from their eyes the things that belong to their peace, why doth he find fault with them for their blindness? If it be his pleasure to discard them as not a people, and not obtaining mercy, their knocking off themselves was no resistance of his will. This objection he answers at large,

Report a mistake

What does Bengel say about Romans 9:19?

Johann Albrecht Bengel

1687–1752 · Lutheran Pietist · Gnomon of the New Testament, Vol. III (Romans, I and II Corinthians)

"En, as yet) even still. This particle well expresses the peevish outcry. To the objection here put, Paul answers in two ways. I. The power of God over men is greater than the power of the potter over the clay, ver. 20, 21. Then II. He answers more mildly: God has not exercised His power, not even over the vessels of wrath, ver. 22. ... His) It is put for, of God, and expresses the feeling, by which objectors of this description show their aversion from God.

Report a mistake

What does Wesley say about Romans 9:19?

John Wesley

1703–1791 · Anglican (Methodist) · Explanatory Notes upon the New Testament: Romans

On Romans 9:1–33

This comment begins at Romans 9:1:

In this chapter St. Paul, after strongly declaring his love and esteem for them, sets himself to answer the grand objection of his countrymen; namely, that the rejection of the Jews and reception of the gentiles was contrary to the…

Why doth he still find fault

19. Why doth he still find fault - The particle still is strongly expressive of the objector's sour, morose murmuring. For who hath resisted his will - The word his likewise expresses his surliness and aversion to God, whom he does not even deign to name.

Report a mistake

What does Haydock say about Romans 9:19?

George Leo Haydock

1774–1849 · Roman Catholic · Catholic Family Bible and Commentary: Romans

Ver. 19. &c. Thou wilt say, therefore, to me, &c. The apostle makes objection, that if God call some, and harden, or even permit others to be hardened, and no one resisteth, or can hinder his absolute will, why should God complain that men are not converted? S. Paul first puts such rash and profane men in mind, that is unreasonable and impertinent for creatures to murmur and dispute against God their Creator, when they do not comprehend the ways of his providence.— O man, who art thou that repliest against God? This might stop the mouths, and quiet the minds of every man, when he cannot comprehend the mysteries of predestination, of God’s foreknowledge, his decrees and graces, or the manner of reconciling them with human liberty. He may cry out with S. Paul again, (c. 11:33) O the riches of the wisdom, and of the knowledge of God! how incomprehensible are his judgments, and how unsearchable his ways!—Shall the thing formed, &c. Hath not the potter power, &c. (51 To teach men that they ought not to complain against God and his providence, when they cannot comprehend his works, he puts them in mind of their origin. Every one may say to God, with the prophet Isaias, (64:8.) Lord, thou art our Father, and we are but clay; thou art our Maker who framed us, and we are all of us the work of thy hands. Hath not the potter power as he pleaseth, out of the same lump of clay to make some vessels for honourable uses, and some for less honourable. S. Chrys. observes very well, that this comparison must not be extended further than the apostle designed; which was to teach us, how submissive we ought to be to God, in what we do not understand; but we must not pretend from hence, nor from any expression in this chapter, as divers heretics have done, that as vessels of clay are destitute of free will and liberty, so are men.

Report a mistake

What does Hodge say about Romans 9:19?

Charles Hodge

1797–1878 · Reformed (Presbyterian) · A Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, designed for students of the English Bible

Thou wilt then say unto me, why doth he yet find fault

(19) Thou wilt then say unto me, why doth he yet find fault? for who hath resisted his will? This is the second leading objection to the apostle’s doctrine. If it is true, as he had just taught, that the destiny of men is in the hands of God, if it is not of him who willeth, or of him that runneth, but of God that showeth mercy; what can we do? If the fact that one believes and is saved, and another remains impenitent and ... is lost, depends on God, how can we be blamed? Can we resist his will? It will at once be perceived that this plausible and formidable objection to the apostle’s doctrine is precisely the one which is commonly and confidently urged against the doctrine of election. There would be no room either for this objection, or for that contained in the 14th verse, if Paul had merely said that God chooses those whom he forsees would repent and believe; or that the ground of distinction was in the different conduct of men. It is very evident, therefore, that he taught no such doctrine. How easy and obvious an answer to the charge of injustice would it have been to say, God chooses one and rejects another according to their works. But teaching as he does the sovereignty of God in the selection of the objects of his mercy and of the subjects of his wrath, declaring as he does so plainly, that the destiny of men is determined by his sovereign pleasure, the objection, how can he yet find fault ? is plausible and natural. ...

Report a mistake

... To this objection the apostle gives two answers; 1. That it springs from ignorance of the true relation between God and men, as Creator and creatures, and of the nature and extent of the divine authority over us, vs. 20, 21; 2. That there is nothing in his doctrine inconsistent with the divine perfections; since he does not make men wicked, but from the mass of wicked men, he pardons one and punishes another, for the wisest and most benevolent of reasons, vs. 22, 23.

Report a mistake

What does Godet say about Romans 9:19?

Frédéric Louis Godet

1812–1900 · Reformed (Swiss Protestant) · Commentary on St. Paul's Epistle to the Romans

On Romans 9:1–29

This comment begins at Romans 9:1:

The apostle opens this passage with a preface expressing the profound grief he feels in view of the mysterious fact which is about to occupy him (w. 1-5) ; then he shows how the liberty of God is set in…

On Romans 9:19–21

Vv. 19-21: ... wUt say then unto me, Why doth he yet ... t For who can resist His mil t Much ... 0 man, who art thou (hat ... Shall the vessd of day ... to him that formed it, Why had ... made ... thus f Or haih not the potter power over the day, of the same lump to ... one veaed unto ... amd another unto dishonour f" — The word then proves that the ... accepts the answer made to his first objection (ver. 14) bnt that he starts from it to raise a new one Hie ... yet, after ... signifies : yet, after hardening me. The verb ... to find fault, to speak with anger, applies to the perdition with which God threatens sinners who are hardened by Him. When He hardens any one, God cannot ask that ... should not harden himself. The question, Who can resist His ... literally signifies, Who hath resisted, or rather Who resisteth / . . . For the perfect of the verb ... and its compounds has really the sense of the present : ' I have placed myself there, and continue there.'' It is therefore dear that the question: "Who is he that resisteth Him?" signifies: ''Who is he that eon resist Him?" Hofinami thinks that the interlocutor means : Who, in this case (that of my hardening), hath resisted God ? Answer : " Nobody ; for in hardening myself I have done nothing but obey Him." This meaning is not impossible ; it is ingenious, but more far-fetched than the preceding.

Report a mistake

Cited on other verses

Commentators citing Romans 9:19 while explaining another verse. The sentence is copied as the excerpt reads.

  • John Chrysostom · Hebrews 7:5

    “Thou wilt say then unto me, why doth He yet find fault?” ( Rom. ix. 16, 19.

  • John Chrysostom · Romans 9:18

    Ver. 18, 19.

  • John Evans · Romans 9:6–13

    By asserting and proving the absolute sovereignty of God, in disposing of the children of men, v. 14-24. 3.

  • John Evans · Romans 9:22–24

    I will make all my goodness to pass before thee, says God (v. 19), and that given out freely: I will be gracious to whom I will be gracious.

  • Johann Albrecht Bengel · Romans 3:7

    Comp. ri In, ch. ix. 19; Gal. v. 11. ...

  • Johann Albrecht Bengel · Romans 9:15

    far to Moses) Many are of opinion, that the objection extends from this verse to ver. 18; in which view the for, is used, as in ch. iii. 7, and thus thou wilt say then, ver. 19, concludes the objection, which was begun at ver. 14.

  • Johann Albrecht Bengel · Romans 9:22

    It is a question, but one implied, not expressed, with an ellipsis, What reply hast thou to make [if God willing to show, etc., endured, etc.]. ... willing) Corresponds to the, His will, ver. 19, and to, He will, ver. 18.

  • Johann Albrecht Bengel · Romans 9:22

    … is not wont to be exercised until He is about to show His wrath]: wherefore ... should be translated, had endured [previous to His will to show His wrath.] By this very circumstance the question, who hath resisted1? ver. 19, is most powerfully refuted. ... of wrath, which is not indeed without cause, but presupposes sins; he does not say, of disgrace, nor unto wrath, but of wrath, [i.e. the fault is in themselves^] ... fitted) It denotes …

  • Charles Bridges · Ecclesiastes 9:3

    Or “ who hath resisted his will?” (Job, ix. 4. Rom. ix. 19.

  • Charles Hodge · Romans 9:13

    ‘To this doctrine there are two plausible objections; first, it is not consistent with the divine justice, v. 14; second, it is incompatible with human responsibility, v. 19.

  • Frédéric Louis Godet · Romans 9:13

    Then in vv. 19-24 he shows by a figure that the superiority of God to man should impose silence on the proud pretensions of the latter, and he applies this principle to the relation between God and

Whole homilies and tractates on Romans 9:19

The Greek words

WordDictionary formGlossGrammar
ἘρεῖςλέγωYou will sayVerb · future active indicative · 2nd person singular
μοιἐγώto mePersonal pronoun · 1st person dative singular
οὖνοὖνthenConjunction
ΤίτίςWhyInterrogative pronoun · accusative singular neuter
οὖνοὖνConjunction
ἔτιἔτιstillAdverb
μέμφεταιμέμφομαιdoes He find faultVerb · present middle or passive (deponent) indicative · 3rd person singular
τῷὁTheArticle · dative singular neuter
γὰργάρforConjunction
βουλήματιβούλημαpurposeNoun · dative singular neuter
αὐτοῦαὐτόςof HimPersonal pronoun · genitive singular masculine
τίςτίςwhoInterrogative pronoun · nominative singular masculine
ἀνθέστηκενἀνθίστημιis resistingVerb · perfect active indicative · 3rd person singular

From MACULA (CC BY 4.0), as the Open Word Bible reads them.

How the Open Word Bible translates Romans 9:19

Word for word: You will say to me then: Why then still does he find fault?

an imagined objector Grammar

Paul answers an objection in the voice of an imagined speaker, as he does in 2:1-5, 3:1-8 and 11:19. The objection follows from verse 18.

find fault: blame, hold people guilty Word sense

μέμφομαι is to find fault with someone and hold them to blame.

God Supplied words

Balanced and Readable name God as the one who blames.

Word for word: For the will of him who has resisted?

a rhetorical question: no one has ever resisted Grammar

The perfect tense ἀνθέστηκεν means "who has taken a stand against". The objector means that no one can, so people cannot be blamed.

his will: his settled purpose Word sense

βούλημα is an intention or decision, here what God has decided to do.

Cross-references

  • Daniel 4:32 All the people of the earth count as nothing before Him; He does as He pleases with the armies of heaven and with the people of the earth. No one can hold back His hand or say to Him, "What have You done?"
  • 2 Chronicles 20:6 He said, "LORD, God of our ancestors, are You not God in heaven? You rule over every kingdom of the nations. In Your hand are power and might, and no one is able to withstand You.
  • 1 Corinthians 15:12 Now if what we proclaim about Christ is that He has been raised from the dead, how can some among you be saying there is no such thing as a resurrection of the dead?
  • 1 Corinthians 15:35 But someone will object, "How are dead people raised? And what sort of body will they have when they come back?"
  • Genesis 50:20 4 voices Evil was what you planned against me; good was what God planned by it, so as to bring about what you see today: the lives of a great many people saved.

Cross-references from OpenBible.info (CC BY), most voted first.

Read Romans 9 with all its commentary