Logia

Johann Albrecht Bengel · Gnomon of the New Testament, Vol. III (Romans, I and II Corinthians)

Romans 9

41 excerpts on Romans 9, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

Romans 9:1

truth) Concerning the connexion, see on ch. i. 16, note. The article is not added here; comp. 2 Cor. vii. 14, xi. 10, because his reference is not to the whole truth, but to something true in particular [a particular truth], and in this sense also ... in the plural is used in Ps. xii. 2, LXX.; 2 Mace. vii. 6. This asseveration chiefly relates to ver. 3, where for is put as in Matt. i. 18. Therefore in ver. 2 on denotes because [not as Engl. Vers. that], and indicates the cause of the prayer. For verse 2 was likely to obtain belief of itself without so great an asseveration [being needed; therefore ... is not ... that in ver. 2.] ... speak) The apostle speaks deliberately. ... 3 ... has sometimes the same force as an oath. ... lie not) This is equivalent to that clause ... speak the truth. Its own confirmation is added to each [both to ... lie not, and to ... speak the truth]. This chapter throughout in its phrases and figures comes near to the Hebrew idiom. ... conscience) The criterion of truth lies in the conscience and in the heart, which the internal testimony of the Holy Spirit enlightens and confirms.

Romans 9:1 · Open Word Bible

1I am telling the truth in Christ; I am not lying. My conscience, in the Holy Spirit, bears witness with me

Report a mistake

Romans 9:2

grief, [heaviness]) In spiritual things grief and (see the end of the eighth chapter) joy in the highest degree may exist together. Paul was sensible, from how great benefits, already enumerated, the Jews excluded themselves, and at the same time he declares [makes it evident], that he does not say those things, which he has to say, in an unfriendly spirit towards his persecutors. ... to me — in my heart) These are equivalent in each half of the verse.

Romans 9:2 · Open Word Bible

2that my sorrow is great and the pain in my heart never stops.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:3

could wish) A verb in the imperfect tense, involving in it a potential or conditional signification, involving the condition, if Christ would permit. His grief was unceasing [continual], but this prayer does not seem here to be asserted as unceasing, or absolute. Human words are not fully adequate to include in them [to express frilly] the emotions of holy ... nor are those emotions always the same; nor is it in the power of those souls always to elicit from themselves such a prayer as this. If the soul be not far advanced, it is incapable of [cannot comprehend] this. It is not easy to estimate the measure of love, in a Moses and a Paul. For the narrow boundary of our reasoning powers does not comprehend it; as the little child is unable to comprehend the courage of warlike heroes. In the case of those two men [duumvirs] themselves, the intervals in their lives, which may be in a good sense called extatic, were something sudden and extraordinary. It was not even in their own power to elicit from themselves such acts as these at any time they chose. Grief [heaviness] and sorrow for the danger and distress of the people; shame for their fault; zeal for their salvation, for the safety of so great a multitude, and for still farther promoting the glory of God through the preservation of such a people, so carried them away, as to make them for a time forget themselves, Exod. xxxii. 32. I am inclined to give this paraphrase of that passage: Pardon them; if thou dost not pardon them, turn upon me the punishment destined for them, that is, as Moses elsewhere says, kill me, Num. xi. 15. It is therefore the book of temporal life, as distinguished from that of eternal life, according to the point of view, economy, and style of the Old Testament; comp. Ex. xxxiii. 3, 5. The book of temporal life is intended in Ps. cxxxix. 16. ... I myself") construe these words with to be [were].

Romans 9:3 · Open Word Bible

3I could even wish that I myself were under a curse, cut off from Christ, on behalf of my brothers and sisters, my own people by human descent.

Report a mistake

to be accursed

It will be enough to compare this passage with Gal. iii. 13, where Christ is said to have been made a curse for us. The meaning is, I could have wished to bring the misery of the Jews on my own head, and to be in their place. The Jews, rejecting the faith, were accursed from Christ; comp. Gal. i. 8, 9, v. 4. Whether he would have wished only the deprivation of all good, and his own destruction, and annihilation, or the suffering also of every evil, and that too both in body and in soul, and for ever, or whether, in the very excitement [paroxysm] of that prayer, he had the matter fully present before his understanding, who knows whether Paul himself, had he been questioned, would have been able exactly to define ? At least that word [Ego~] I [all thought of self] was entirely suppressed in him; he was looking only to others, for the sake of the Divine glory; comp. 2 Cor, xii. 15. From the loftiest pinnacle of faith (chap, viii.) he now shows the highest degree of love, which was kindled by the Divine love. The thing, which he had wished, could not have been done, but his prayer was pious and solid, although under the tacit condition, if it were possible to be done; comp. Rom. viii. 38, I am persuaded; Ex. xxxii. 33.

Report a mistake

from Christ) So ... from 1 Cor. i. 30; or, as Christ, being made a curse, was abandoned by the Father; so Paul, filled with Christ, wished in place of the Jews to be forsaken by Christ, as if he had been accursed. He is not speaking of excommunication from the everlasting society of the church. There is a difference between these two things, for ... curse, has the greater force of the two, and implies something more absolute: Din, anathema, something relative, Gal. i. 8, 9, 1 Cor. xvi. 22, the former is rather more severe, the latter milder; the former expresses the power of reconciliation by the cross of Christ; the latter is more suitable to [more applicable as regards] Paul; nor can the one be substituted for the other, either here, or in the passages quoted. ... The apostle is speaking of the whole multitude, not of individuals. ... for my brethren) This expresses the cause of his so great love toward them. ... my kinsmen according to the flesh) This expresses the cause of his prayer, showing why the prayer, other things being supposed to be equal [c&teris paribus, supposing there were no objection on other grounds], was right; and by adding kinsmen, he shows that the word brethren is not to be understood, as it usually is, of Christians, but of the Jews. Christ was made a curse for us, because we were his kinsmen.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:4

inasmuch as being those icho) He now explains the cause of his sorrow and grief: viz. the fact that Israel does not enjoy so great benefits. He uses great ... euphemia' [softening of an unwelcome truth. Append.] in words. ... whose is the adoption of [as] sons — the promises) Six privileges are enumerated by three pairs of correlatives; and in the first pair, regard is had to God the Father; in the second, to Christ; in the third, to the Holy Spirit: with which comp ... . iii. G, note. — 35 ... the adoption of son# and the ... that Israel is the first-born son of God, and the God of glory is their God, Deut, iv. 7, 33, 34; Ps. cvi. 20, (xlvii. 5); but by the force of the correlatives, God is at the same time the Father of Israel, and Israel is the people of God. In like manner this relation is expressed in abbreviated form (the two respective correlatives being left to be supplied. See Append, on locutio concisa) in Rev. xxi. 7; comp. Rom. viii. 18, 19. Some understand ... the glory, of the ark of the covenant; but Paul is not speaking here of anything corporeal. God Himself is called the Glory of His people Israel, by the same metonymy, as He is called the Fear, instead of the God [the Object of fear], of Isaac, Gen. xxxi. 42, 54. ... and the covenants and the giving of the law) comp. Heb. viii. 6. The reason why the covenants are put before the giving of the law, is evident from Gal. iii. 17 ... . is plural, because the testament, or covenant, both was frequently repeated, Lev. xxvi. 42, 45; Eph. ii. 12; and was given in various modes ... dispositions [one, the law received by the disposition of angels, the other the Gospel covenant under Jesus], Heb. i. 1; and because there were two administrations of it, Gal. iv. 24, the one promising, the other promised [the subject of the promise].

Romans 9:4 · Open Word Bible

4They are Israelites. Theirs is the adoption as God's children, theirs the glory, the covenants, the giving of the law, the worship and the promises.

Report a mistake

and the service of God and the promises

Acts xxvi. 6, 7; Eph. i. 13; Heb. viii. 5, 6. Here the giving of the law and the service of God, the covenants and the promises correspond by chiasmus. For the promises flow from the covenants; and the service of God was instituted by the giving of the law. [It was the promises that procured (gained) for the service of God its peculiar dignity. Moreover, the Holy Spirit was promised, Gal. iii. 14. — V ... .

Report a mistake

Romans 9:5

whose are the fathers, etc ... . has both written a dissertation on this passage, and has added it to his Exposition of this Epistle. All, that is of importance to me in it, I have explained ... 157, etc. (ed. 1748), [c. 11, 28]. ... and of whom, i.e. of the Israelites, Acts iii. 22. To the six privileges of the Israelites lately mentioned are added the seventh and eighth, respecting the fathers, and respecting the Messiah Himself. Israel is a noble and a holy people. — 6 ... but the participle has a more narrow meaning. Artemonius with great propriety proves from the grief of Paul, that there is no doxology in this passage: Part I. cap. 42; but at the same time he along with his associates contends, that Paul wrote ... 6 ... So that there may be denoted in the passage this privilege of the Israelites, that the Lord is their God; and he interprets the clause, 6 ... thus: that this privilege is the greatest of all the honours conferred upon Israel. But such an interpretation of the 6 ... with which comp. Eph. iv. 6 (that we may remove this out of our way in the first place), implies a meaning, which owes its birth merely to the support of an hypothesis, and which requires to be expressed rather by a phrase of this sort ... The conjecture itself ... 6, carries with it an open violation of the text. For I. it dissevers ... from the antithetic member of the sentence ... which is usually everywhere mentioned [expressed]. II. It at the same time divides the last member of the enumeration [of the catalogue of privileges], before which ... and, is suitably placed ... into two members, and in the second of these the conjunction is by it harshly suppressed.

Romans 9:5 · Open Word Bible

5The patriarchs are theirs, and from them, by human descent, comes Christ, who is God over all, blessed forever. Amen.

Report a mistake

Artemonius objects: I. Christ is nowhere in the sacred Scriptures expressly called God. Ans. Nowhere? Doubtless because Artemonius endeavours to get rid of all those passages either by proposing a different reading, or by a different mode of interpreter tion. He himself admits, that too many proofs of one thing ought not to be demanded, page 225. In regard to the rest, see note on John i. 1. He objects, II. If Paul wrote 6 ... he omitted the principal privilege of the Israelites, that God, who is the Best and Greatest of all, was their God. Ans. The adoption and the glory had consisted in that very circumstance; therefore he did not omit it; nor is that idea, the Lord is the God of Israel, ever expressed in these words, Thine, 0 Israel, is God blessed for ever. He urges further; Christ is included even in the covenants, and yet Paul presently after makes mention of Christ; how much more would he be likely to make mention of God the Father Himself? Ans. The reason in the case of Christ for His being mentioned does not equally hold good in the case of God. Paul mentions in the order of time all the privileges of Israel (the fathers being by the way [incidentally] joined with Christ). He therefore mentions Christ, as He was manifested [last in order of time]; but it was not necessary that that should be in like manner mentioned of God. Moreover, Christ was in singularly near relationship to the Israelites; but God was also the God of the Gentiles, ch. iii. 29: and it was not God, but Christ, whom the Jews rejected more openly. What? In the very root of the name Israel, and therefore of the Israelites, to which the apostle refers, ver. 4, 6, the name ... God, is found. He objects, III. The style of the Fathers disagrees with this opinion: nay, the false Ignatius [pseudoignatius] reckons among the ministers of Satan those, who said, that Jesus Himself is God over all. Ans. ...

Report a mistake

... By this phrase, he has somewhat incautiously described the Sabellians, and next to them he immediately places the Artemonites in the same class. In other respects the fathers often apply the phraseology of Paul respecting Christ to the Father, and by that very circumstance prove the true force of that phraseology [as expressing Divinity]; and yet the apostle is superior to [should have more weight than] the fathers. Wolfius refutes Artemonius at great length in vol. ii ... . N. T., p. 802, etc.

Report a mistake

over all) The Father is certainly excepted, 1 Cor. xv. 27. Christ is of the fathers, according to the flesh; and at the same time was, is, and shall be over all, inasmuch as fie is God blessed for ever. Amen ! The same praise is ascribed to the Father and the Son, 2 Cor. xi. 31. Over all, which is antithetic to, of whom, shows both the ... of Christ before the fathers, in opposition to His descent from the fathers according to the flesh, and His infinite majesty and dominion full of grace over Jews and Gentiles; comp. as to the phrase, Eph. iv. 6; as to the fact itself, John viii. 58; Matt. xxii. 45. They are quite wrong, who fix the full stop either here [after ... (for the comma may be placed with due respect to religion); for in that case the expression should have been ... 6 ... [not o ... if only there had been here any peculiar occasion for such a doxology; or [who fix a full stop] after ... for in this case ... would be without its proper antithesis [which is, " who in His divine nature is God over all"]. — Owe,, God) We should greatly rejoice, that in this solemn description Christ is so plainly called God. The apostles, who wrote before John, take for granted the deity of Christ, as a thing acknowledged; whence it is that they do not directly treat of it, but yet when it comes in their way, they mark it in a most glorious manner. Paul, ch. v. 15, had called Jesus Christ man; but he now calls Him God; so also 1 Tim. ii. 5, iii. 16. The one appellation supports the other. ... blessed) ... By this epithet we unite in giving all praise to God, 2 Cor. xi. 31. ... for ever) [He] Who is above all — -for ever, is the first and the last, Rev. i. 17.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:6

The Jews were of opinion, that, if all the Jews were not saved, the word of God becomes of none effect. Paul refutes this opinion, and at the same time intimates, that the apostacy of the Jews had been foretold, rather than otherwise, by the word of God. ... but; namely, although I profess great sorrow for Israel, who continue without Christ. ... hath taken none effect) A suitable expression, 1 Cor. xiii. 8, note. If all Israel had failed, the word of God would have failed; but the latter cannot occur, so neither can the former: for even now there are some, [Israelites believers], and in future times there will be all. For this sentence comprehends all the statements in Chapters ix ... . xi., and is most aptly expressed. It is closely connected with what goes before in ver. 2, and yet in respect of what follows, where the word ... occurs again, there is a studied gentleness of expression and anticipatory caution that whatever is said of a disagreeable description may be softened before it is expressed; as in 1 Cor ... . 13. — 6 ... the ... of promise, which had been given to Israel.

Romans 9:6 · Open Word Bible

6But this does not mean that God's word has failed. For not everyone descended from Israel truly belongs to Israel.

Report a mistake

for not all) ... for begins the discussion, not all, is mildly said instead of, there are not many. This was what the Jews held: We all and we alone are the people of God. Wherefore the all is refuted here; and the alone at ver. 24, etc. The Jews were Particularists (' ... therefore Paul directly refutes them. His whole discussion will not only be considered as tolerable, but will even be much admired by those, and those alone, who have gone through the former chapters in faith and repentance; for in this the prior regard is had to faith [rather than to repentance]. The sum of this discussion, in the opinion of those who deny universal grace, is as follows. GOD gives FAITH to whom He will; He does not give it, to whom He will not; according to the mind of Paul, it is this: God gives RIGHTEOUSNESS to them that believe, He does not give it to them that work; and that is by no means contrary to His word. Nay, He himself has declared by types and testimonies, that those, the sons of the promise are received; that these, the children of the flesh are rejected. This decree of God is certain, irrefragable, just; as any man or people listens to this decree or strives against it, so that man or that people is either accepted in mercy or rejected in wrath. The analysis of Arminius, which has been gleaned from Calovius ... Rom ... . Ixviii., and adopted ... Ixix., comes back to this [amounts to this at last]. Compare by all means i. 16, note. In the meantime Paul, in regard to those, whom he refutes, does not make any very wide separation between the former chapter [or head] concerning faith and the latter concerning righteousness; nor indeed was it necessary. ... Israel, Israel) Ploce.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:7

because; this particle makes an epitasis in respect of the preceding sentence. ... of Abraham) That, which happened to the children of the Fathers in the most ancient times, may much more happen to their later descendants. ... iv ... but in Isaac, etc.) This statement is made by taking for granted the essential point, for we supply, it was written, and it is being fulfilled, LXX., Gen. xxi. 12: on ... Here we even find a suitableness in the origin of the name Isaac; for they are the seed, who embrace the covenant of grace with a pure and ... joy, Gen. xvii. 19 [Isaac Heb ... . laughter, joy],

Romans 9:7 · Open Word Bible

7Nor are they all Abraham's children just because they are his descendants. Rather, "It is through Isaac that your offspring will be named."

Report a mistake

Romans 9:8–9

The apostle, using boldness in speaking, puts that is for therefore. ... that is, are. The substantive pronoun for the substantive verb; so ... these, ver. 6: and frequently ... this, ver. 9. The mode of expression in this chapter becomingly assumes the Hebrew idiom, so ver. 28 etc. ... of promise) It corresponds to the expression, of the promise, ver. 8. ... this) viz., is. ... At this time will I come, and Sarah shall have a son. LXX., Gen. xviii. 10 ... comp. Gen. xvii. 21.

Romans 9:8–9 · Open Word Bible

8This means that it is not the children born by natural descent who are God's children. It is the children of the promise who are counted as Abraham's offspring. 9For this is what the promise said: "At this time I will come back, and a son will be born to Sarah."

Report a mistake

Romans 9:10

0-j ... 61, and not only so) That is: it is wonderful, what I have said; what follows is still more wonderful. Ishmael under Abraham, Esau under Isaac, and those, who resembled Ishmael and Esau under Israel, rebelled. ... Rebecca) viz. ... is, i.e. occurs in this place. She, the mother, and presently after Isaac the father, are named. ... one^ Isaac was now separated from Ishmael, and yet under Isaac himself, in whom Abraham's seed is called ... is separated from Jacob. Ishmael and Isaac were born not of the same mother, nor at the same time,— and Ishmael was the son too of a ... Isaac of a free woman. Jacob and Esau were born both of the same mother, and she a free woman, and at the same time. ... so LXX. for rose*; it often occurs ... Lev. xviii. 20 ... said of the man, which is opposed to the phrase ... of the woman in this passage.

Romans 9:10 · Open Word Bible

10And that is not all. Rebecca also conceived children by one man, our forefather Isaac.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:11

they were not yet born) Carnal descent profiteth nothing, John i. 13. ... and when they had done nothing) This is added, because some one might think as to Ishmael, that he was driven out, not so much because he was the son of a ... as because he was a mocker; although this slave-like scurrility afterwards shows itself in [lays hold of] the son of the ... so that he ... and ... laughs and mocks at Isaac, whom he envies and insults. ... The purpose, which is quite free, has its reason founded on election alone; comp ... . ch. xvi. 25; Tit. i. 9. It might be said, in Latin, propositum ... the elective purpose of God. ... might stand [remain]) incapable of being set aside. It is presupposed that the ... the purpose, is prior to the, might stand. ... not of works) not even of works foreseen. Observe, it is not faith, which is opposed to election, but works. ... of Him that ... even Him, who called Jacob to be the superior, Esau to be the servant: comp. ver. 25.

Romans 9:11 · Open Word Bible

11The children were not yet born and had done nothing good or bad. Yet so that God's purpose in choosing might stand,

Report a mistake

Romans 9:12–13

to her) It was often foretold to mothers before conception or birth, what would happen to their sons. — on 6 ... Gen. xxv. 23, LXX. ... I ... the elder, who, it might be reasonably thought, should command, as the younger should obey. ... shall serve) and yet not so for ever, Gen. xxvii. 40. ... as) The word spoken by Malachi, at a period so long subsequent, agrees with that spoken in Genesis. ... l. 2, LXX. ... have loved ... have hated) The reference is not to the spiritual state of each of the two brothers: but the external condition of Jacob and Esau, in like manner as the corporeal birth of Isaac is a type of spiritual things, ver. 9. All Israelites are not saved, and all Edomites are not damned. But Paul intimates, that as there was a difference between the sons of Abraham and Isaac, so there was a difference among the posterity of Israel. So far has he demonstrated what he purposed; he in the next place introduces an objection, and refutes it ... properly signifies to hate, nay, to hate greatly. See ... i. 4, at the end.

Romans 9:12–13 · Open Word Bible

12a purpose that rests not on works but on the one who calls, Rebecca was told, "The older will serve the younger." 13As it is written, "I loved Jacob, but Esau I hated."

Report a mistake

Romans 9:14

what then ?

Can we then on this ground be accused of charging God with unrighteousness and iniquity by this assertion ? By no means; for what we assert is the irrefragable assertion of God; see the following verse.

Romans 9:14 · Open Word Bible

14What then are we to say? Is there injustice on God's part? Certainly not!

Report a mistake

God forbid

The Jews thought, that they could by no means be rejected by God; that the Gentiles could by no means be received. As therefore an honest man acts even with greater severity ... towards those who are harshly and spitefully importunate, than he really feels (that he may defend his own rights, and those of his patron, and may not at an unseasonable time betray and cast away his character for liberality) so Paul defends the power and justice of God against the Israelites, who trusted to their mere name and their own merits; and on this subject, he sometimes uses those appropriate phrases, to which he seems to have been accustomed in former times in the school of the Pharisees. This is his language ... man can prescribe anything to the ... God, nor demand and someiehat insolently extort anything from Him as a debt, nor can he interdict Him in anything [which He pleases to do] or require a reason, why He shows Himself kind also to others [as well as to himself]. Therefore Paul somewhat abruptly cheeks by a rather severe answer the peevish and spiteful objectors. Luke xix. 22, 23, is a similar case. For no man is allowed to deal with God as if by virtue of a bond of agreement, [as if he were His creditor], but even if there were such a bond, God even deals more strictly with man [i.e. with a man of such a hireling spirit]; let the parable, Matt. xx. 13—15, which is quite parallel, be compared ... do thee no wrong, etc. There is therefore one meaning of Paul's language, by which he gives an answer to those who contend for good works: another, of a milder description, in behalf of believers, lies hid under the veil of the words. ...

Report a mistake

... In the Sacred Scriptures too, especially when we have come from the thesis [the proposition] to the hypothesis [that on which the proposition rests], the manners ... as well as the reasonings ... ought to be considered; and yet there can be no commentary so plain, which he, who contends for justification by good works, may more easily understand than the text of Paul.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:15

far to Moses) Many are of opinion, that the objection extends from this verse to ver. 18; in which view the for, is used, as in ch. iii. 7, and thus thou wilt say then, ver. 19, concludes the objection, which was begun at ver. 14. And indeed by this introduction of a person speaking there would be a fitting expression of that ... (rejoinder of the opponent), which is censured at ver. 20, and is subsequently refuted by taking up the words themselves or their synonyms. In the meantime Paul so expresses himself, as to make 6 ... the objector whilst replying at the same time answer himself; and therefore the words in this verse may be also taken, without injury to the sense, as spoken in the person of the apostle, as we shall now endeavour to show. Moses, Exod. xxxiii., had prayed for himself and the people by ... the grace of the Lord, ver. 1 2, 13, 16, 17, and had concluded with, show me thy glory. The Lord answered ... will make all My goodness pass in the presence of thy face, and I will proclaim the name of the Lord before thy face ... . Turn, And will be gracious, to whom I will be gracious, and will ... mercy, to whom J will show mercy, ver. 19. The Lord did not disclose even to Moses without some time intervening, to whom He would show grace and mercy, although the question was respecting Moses and the people of Israel alone, not respecting the Gentiles. To this Moses, then, not merely to others by Moses ... says Paul, as presently after, r& ... the Lord spoke thus: By My proclamation, and by My most abundant working, subsequently, I will designate [mark out] him, as the object of grace and mercy, whosoever he be, whom 1 make the object of grace and mercy. By these words He intimated, that He would make proclamation [would reveal His own character] as regards grace arid mercy; and He shortly after accordingly made proclamation, Ex. xxxiv. ...

Romans 9:15 · Open Word Bible

15For God says to Moses, "I will have mercy on whomever I have mercy, and I will show compassion to whomever I show compassion."

Report a mistake

... 5 ... merciful and gracious, etc., to thousands; and added ... and He will not clear the guilty, etc. Therefore according to the subsequent proclamation itself, the following meaning of the previous promise comes clearly out ... will show thee the most abundant grace, even to that degree that thou mayest see concerning Me [see centred in Me] all whatsoever thou dost both desire and canst receive [comprehend] in order that thou mayest furthermore understand, that it is [all of] grace; and for this reason inasmuch as I have once for all embraced thee in grace, which thou acknowledgest to be grace; and as to the rest of the people, I will show them the most abundant mercy, in not visiting them with immediate destruction for their idolatry, that they may further understand it to be mercy; and for this reason inasmuch as I have once for all embraced them in mercy, which thou in their behalf acknowledgest to be mercy. The LXX ... . and Paul have expressed the meaning of this sentence by the difference between the present and future tense ... I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion. And there is the figure Ploce [see ... which nearly signifies the same as below, ch. xiii. 7, and here it expresses the liberty of the Agent, of whom the apostle is speaking, as in Ex. xvi. 23. Moreover, each of the two verbs, placed in the two clauses [i.e. repeated twice], contains the emphasis in the former clause; [i.e. the emphasis is on the verb in each of the two clauses on its first mention, not on it when repeated; I will have mercy, on whom I have mercy, etc.]: although generally in other passages the emphasis is on the verb in the latter clause [i.e. on its repetition] Gen. xxvii. 33, xliii. ...

Report a mistake

... 14; 2 Kings vii. 4. That the acknowledgment of grace and mercy, on the part of Moses, and the true Israelites, is entwined together, is evident from this, that Paul, ver. 16, speaks, on the opposite side, of the man that willeth and that runneth, to whom grace is not grace, and mercy is not mercy ... . &v is put twice, and intimates in the former passage that Moses (to whom the word ... grace, is repeated in reply, taken from his own very prayers from Ex. xxxiii. ver. 13: where there occurs the same Ploce), and that in the latter passage, the others, were ... among the thousands [as to whom God said of Himself, keeping mercy for thousands], to whom sinners, their children ... etc., are opposed, Ex. xxxiv. 7. And thus, this testimony is extremely well fitted to prove, that there is no unrighteousness with God. This sentiment is manifest to believers. But in regard to those, who maintain the efficacy of good works, it sounds too abrupt: the reason why God should be merciful, is none other than His own mercy, for no other is mentioned in the writings of Moses, concerning Moses and Israel ... . will have mercy, i.e. no one can extort anything by force; all things are in My hand, under My authority, and dependent on My will, if I act otherwise, no one can charge Me with injustice. This answer is sufficient to give to the defender of good works; and if any farther answer is given to him, it is superfluous.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:16

therefore

so also ver. 18. ... I have mercy, and I have compassion. ... not of the man that willeth, nor of him that runneth, supply it is, the business, or, will, course [the race is not of him that runneth, etc.]; not that it is in vain to will rightly, and, what is of greater importance, to run, or strive rightly, 1 Cor< ix. 26; Phil. iii. 14: but because to will and to run produce none of the things aimed at by those, who trust to their works. The human will is opposed to divine grace, and the course [the run] of human conduct to divine operation. — Comp. ver. 30, 31.

Romans 9:16 · Open Word Bible

16So it is not a matter of what a person wants or how hard a person strives, but of God, who shows mercy.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:17

saith, i.e. exhibits God speaking in this manner, comp. ch. ... for) He proves, that it is of Him who shows mercy, even God. ... to the Pharaoh) who lived in the time of Moses. ... Even for this same purpose have I raised thee up that I might show my power in thee. ... For this cause, thou hast been preserved until now, that I might show my power, etc. ... as) ... LXX ... . (as Exod. xxi. 21 ... to pass one's life}, but Paul according to his custom says more significantly ... as: but it should be carefully observed, that by ... here the meaning of the word ... is not expressed, as it is used in Zech. xi. 16, but ... which in all cases presupposes the subject previously produced. See the difference of these two Hebrew verbs in 1 Kings xv. 4. The meaning then is this: I have raised thee up to be a king very powerful (in whom I might show My power) and illustrious (by means of whom [owing to whom] My name might be proclaimed throughout all the earth). Therefore this ... raising up, includes the ... preserving, as the LXX. render it, using the milder term: and also includes the ... which in ver. 22, is introduced from this very passage of Moses. The predecessor [the former Pharaoh] had previously begun rather to oppress Israel; Exod. ii. 23: nor yet did the successor repent. The ... Temporum, p. 161 [Ed. II. 142], determines his reign to have been very short, and therefore his whole administration was an experiencing of the Divine power. It must be added, that this was told to Pharaoh not at first, but after he had been frequently guilty of excessive obstinacy, and it was not even then intended to discourage him from acknowledging Jehovah and from letting the people go, but to bring about his reformation. ... power) by which Pharaoh with all his forces was drowned. ... might be declared) This is being done even to the present day.

Romans 9:17 · Open Word Bible

17For Scripture says to Pharaoh, "This is the very reason I raised you up: to display My power in you, and so that My name would be made known through the whole earth."

Report a mistake

Romans 9:18

whom He will. Moreover, as regards the question, to whom God wills to show mercy, and whom He wills to harden; Paul shows that in other passages. ... has mercy) as for example on Moses. ... hardens) as He did Pharaoh. He uses, hardens, for, has not mercy, by metonymy of [substituting, for the antecedent,] the consequent, although not to have mercy has a somewhat harsher meaning: so, is sanctified, for, is not unclean, 1 Cor. vii. 14; and, you rescued from, [ep instead of you did not deliver up. Jos. xxii. 31.

Romans 9:18 · Open Word Bible

18So then God has mercy on whomever He chooses, and He hardens whomever He chooses.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:19

"En, as yet) even still. This particle well expresses the peevish outcry. To the objection here put, Paul answers in two ways. I. The power of God over men is greater than the power of the potter over the clay, ver. 20, 21. Then II. He answers more mildly: God has not exercised His power, not even over the vessels of wrath, ver. 22. ... His) It is put for, of God, and expresses the feeling, by which objectors of this description show their aversion from God.

Romans 9:19 · Open Word Bible

19So you will say to me, "Why does God still find fault, then?" For who can stand against His will?

Report a mistake

Romans 9:20

Oman) weak, ignorant of righteousness [i.e. the true way of justification]. ... Isa. xxix. 16 ... . The same prophet, ch. xlv. 9 ... Touts ... 6? ... Shall ye not be reckoned as the potter's clay ? Shall the thing formed say to Him that formed it, Thou hast not formed me ? Is. xlv. 9, Shall the clay say to the potter, what art thou doing, that thou dost not work, thou hast no hands ? Shall the thing formed answer Him that formed it ? — (Vers. LXX.)

Romans 9:20 · Open Word Bible

20But who are you, a mere human being, to answer back to God? Will what was shaped say to the one who shaped it, "Why did you make me this way?"

Report a mistake

Romans 9:21

particle of interrogation [an?]. ... power) construed with, over the clay. The potter does not make the clay but digs it out; God makes man, therefore He has greater power [over man], than the potter [over the clay]. But absolute power and liberty do not imply, that the will and decree are absolute. If God had left the whole human race under the power of sin and death, He would not have done unjustly, but He did not exercise that right. [Man is struck with the vivid exhibition of Divine power, so that he ever after unlearns all the outrageous (unreasonable) suspicions of his thoughts, against the justice [righteousness] of God, Matt. xx. 15; Ex. xx. 20; Job xlii. 2, 6. — V ... . ... lump, which has been prepared from clay and softened by steeping, and has its parts now more homogeneous. ... to dishonour) Paul speaks circumspectly, he does not yet say, to wrath: vessel must be construed with these words [To make one, a vessel unto honour, etc.]

Romans 9:21 · Open Word Bible

21Has the potter no right over the clay? From one and the same lump he may make one pot for honored use and another for common use.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:22

but if) This particle has this as its apodosis to be supplied at the end of ver. 23 from ver. 20: God has much greater cause to complain concerning man, and man has less cause to expostulate with God [than the potter concerning the clay, and the clay with the potter] ... . John vi. 62, where also the apodosis is to be supplied. It is a question, but one implied, not expressed, with an ellipsis, What reply hast thou to make [if God willing to show, etc., endured, etc.]. ... willing) Corresponds to the, His will, ver. 19, and to, He will, ver. 18. Paul speaks ... [" after the manner of man:" or, taking advantage of his opponent's unavoidable admission] in the words of his opponent; and so si signifies whereas, [since, as you must grant]. At the same time, we must observe that what he says of the vessels of wrath is more scanty, and of the vessels of mercy more copious; willing to show, he says, not, [willing, putting forth His will] that he might show, comp. next verse [where in the case of the vessels of mercy, he says ... though here ver. 22 in the case of the vessels of wrath, he says ... and Eph. ii. 7. ... to show His power) These words are repeated from ver. 17. ... wrath) He does not say, the riches of his wrath; comp. ver. 23. ... This signifies, what He can do (potentiam 'might') not what He may do (potestatem ( right' ... endured) as He endured Pharaoh.

Romans 9:22 · Open Word Bible

22What if God, wanting to show His wrath and to make His power known, has borne with great patience the vessels of wrath, made ready for destruction?

Report a mistake

with much long -suffering) viz: in order that it might allure the wicked [the reprobate] from their state of alienation from Him to repentance, ch. ii. 4; 2 Pet. iii. 9. God endures many bad men, in the enjoyment of great and long continued good fortune in this life, when He might at the very first have consigned them to death. The gate of mercy and grace is still open to them. This long-suffering, humanly speaking, precedes His " will to show His wrath," nor does it merely follow it. His enduring is not wont to be exercised until He is about to show His wrath]: wherefore ... should be translated, had endured [previous to His will to show His wrath.] By this very circumstance the question, who hath resisted1? ver. 19, is most powerfully refuted. ... of wrath, which is not indeed without cause, but presupposes sins; he does not say, of disgrace, nor unto wrath, but of wrath, [i.e. the fault is in themselves^] ... fitted) It denotes the disposition [fitness] internal and full, but now no longer free [no longer now liable to change], not the destination; he does not say, which He ... previously fitted, although he says in the next verse, which he prepared, comp. ver. 19, ch. xi. 22, note; Matt. xxv. 34, with ver. 41, and Acts xiii. 46, with ver. 48. This is distinct from the efficient cause; what is said merely refers to the state in which God finds the reprobate, when He brings upon them His wrath. ... to destruction) The antithesis is, ver. 2,3, unto glory.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:23

that) Denotes more distinctly the end and aim, without excluding means. ... might make known) This verb is applied to things not formerly known; it is therefore put both here and in the preceding verse, but ... to show, is only used in verse 22 concerning wrath; of which even the Gentiles have some knowledge. — ivl, upon) The sentence is thus quite consistent. But if God that He might make known the riches of His glory, supply, did this, or, in other words, made known the riches [of His glory] on the vessels of mercy; respecting the apodosis, see the beginning of the note, ver. 22. ... of His glory: of His goodness, grace, mercy, wisdom, omnipotence, Eph. i. 6. ... of mercy, ver. 15, 16, 18, 25, which presupposes the former misery of those, styled vessels. ... previously prepared) antecedently to works, ver. 11, by the arrangement of all the external and internal circumstances, which he, who is called, finds tending to his salvation, at the first moment of his call. This is implied by the preposition in ... So a vessel unto honour, prepared, 2 Tim. ii. 21.

Romans 9:23 · Open Word Bible

23What if He did this to make known the riches of His glory to the vessels of mercy, which He prepared in advance for glory,

Report a mistake

Romans 9:24

whom also) ... also, in chap. viii. 30 ... whom (having been previously prepared for glory) He hath also called. ... called) in some respects an antithesis to, He endured, ver. 22. Again ... will call, occurs in the next verse. ... us) This gnome leads Paul to come to the proposition respecting grace, which is laid open to Jews and Gentiles; and lie proceeds to refute the Jewish Particularism, and to defend the universality of grace. ... not only from) The believing Jew is not called on the very ground that he is a Jew, but he is called from the Jews. This is the root of the ... [The epistle to the Ephesians most especially corresponds to this whole section, as well as to the exhortation, chapters xiv. xv., deduced from it. — V ... . ... from the Jews) He treats of this at ver. 27. ... from the Gentiles) He treats of this, ver. 25, etc.

Romans 9:24 · Open Word Bible

24that is, to us, whom He has called not only from among the Jews but also from among the Gentiles?

Report a mistake

Romans 9:25

saith) God. Paul asserted the prior right of God in calling the Gentiles, and their actual calling, and now at last that the event is shown, he brings in one testimony from the Old Testament, and ch. xv. 9, etc., a number more in succession, by a method worthy of notice. The predictions, though numerous and quite clear from their fulfilment, yet in the first instance do not easily obtain belief. The strength of the following quotation is not in the ... will call \name], but in the other part of the expression ... He called, is used as in viii. 30. Nevertheless naming immediately accompanies calling, and in a manner precedes it. ... will call them my people, who were not my people, and her beloved who was not beloved, Hos. ii. 25. The LXX. have, And I will have mercy on her, on whom I have not had mercy, and I will say to them ... are not my people, thou art my people. ... as one betrothed, as a bride.

Romans 9:25 · Open Word Bible

25As He says in Hosea, "Those who were not My people I will call 'My people,' and her who was not loved I will call 'loved.'"

Report a mistake

Romans 9:26–27

Hos. ii. 1, LXX ... . ... there: So it is not necessary for them to change their country and betake themselves to ... comp. Zeph. ii. 11. ... crieth. See Isa ... . 22, where the accents also may be compared. Israel utters an opposing reclamation ... against]-. Isaiah with a still louder exclamation [cry] declares, a remnant shall be saved. ... for Israel, Fr. ... Isa. X. 22, 23, LXX. ... 6 ... In the last clause Symmachus and Theodotion have ... The word ... Paul introduced from Hos. ii. 1 [i. 10]. If Israel shall have been [or have been~] as numerous as the sand, a remnant [only] shall be saved, namely, from the misery of the Babylonish captivity and from spiritual misery. That a remnant should remain in the multitude of the remnant [i.e. in a case where the body from which the remnant is taken is a multitude] is less wonderful. The Many are hardened; but the seed implies a small number, ver. 29, note. When the rebellion of Israel reaches its height, at that point salvation begins.

Romans 9:26–27 · Open Word Bible

26"And in the place where they were told, 'You are not My people,' that is where they will be called children of the living God." 27And Isaiah cries out about Israel: "Though the people of Israel are as many as the grains of sand by the sea, the remnant will be saved."

Report a mistake

Romans 9:28

a thing heard, and therefore spoken, Isa. xxviii. 22. ... supply, as is often necessary in Hebrew, the word is, comp. Acts xxiv. ... The Lord ... will consummate His ... word [decree] concerning Israel, in respect to the appointed [fixed] punishment (so that it becomes ... consummated, completed); and at the same time ... short His word, in respect to the termination [will make a speedy termination] of the punishment (so that ... becomes ... this decree becomes consummated). The word Lord is to be supplied from the following clause; and the word ... may be taken either as the subject, or rather, since the article is wanting, as a part of the predicate [the Lord is about to consummate, etc.] — iv ... Is ... . 22.

Romans 9:28 · Open Word Bible

28"For on the earth the Lord will carry out His sentence, fully and without delay."

Report a mistake

Romans 9:29

Is. i. 9, LXX.

said before) Before the event, or before the prophecy quoted at ver. 28. ... In 1 Samuel and in Isaiah ... is put for the Heb. word ... in all the other books it is translated ... Ruler over all. From this circumstance there is strong ground for conjecturing, that one or perhaps several persons were employed to translate those two books, and that different persons translated the rest. And in the same first book of Sam. Scripture begins to give this title to God, although others had been formerly used as it were in its place. — Exod. xxxiv. 23. ... a seed) There is denoted 1) a small number at the present time, 2) the propagation of a multitude after deliverance from captivity. ... as Sodom) where not a single citizen escaped; no seed was left.

Romans 9:29 · Open Word Bible

29And as Isaiah said earlier, "If the Lord of hosts had not left us some descendants, we would have become like Sodom and been made like Gomorrah."

Report a mistake

Romans 9:30

what) He returns from the digression, which he had commenced at the middle of ver. 24, and takes in summarily the whole subject, ver. 30-32. There is a mitigation of the severity of the discussion continued from ver. 6 to ver. 23; but it will only be comprehended by him, who is acquainted with the way of faith. In short, by this tone of feeling the foregoing remarks are judged of. ... have attained [Luke xiii. 29, 24.] ... by faith) ver. 33, at its close.

Romans 9:30 · Open Word Bible

30What then are we to say? That Gentiles, who were not pursuing righteousness, have obtained it, the righteousness that comes by faith.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:31

the law of righteousness to the law of righteousness) He did not use the word ... in the preceding verse, concerning the Gentiles; but now uses it in speaking of the Jews; and there is a ploce or repetition of the words in a different sense; concerning legal and also concerning evangelical righteousness. While Israel is following the one law, he does not attain to the other. The apostle appropriately uses the expression, the law of righteousness, for, the righteousness of the law. The Jews rather looked to the law, than to righteousness ... doctrine, min. ... did not attain.

Romans 9:31 · Open Word Bible

31But Israel, who pursued a law that held out righteousness, did not reach that law.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:32–33

"On because) viz. they sought after it [followed after it]. ... The ... Lexicon says: us in comparing things dissimilar is doubled, and the one us is elegantly understood in the former member, and us is only joined to [expressed in] the latter part. Examples are there subjoined from ... we may compare John vii. 10; 2 Cor. xi. 17; likewise Acts xxviii. 19; Philem. v. 14; Phil. ii. 12. ... LXX., Is. xxviii. 16 ... Such a one will not be made ashamed, and so will obtain glory; comp. ch. v. 2, 5. This denotes eternal life, Is. xlv. 17.

Romans 9:32–33 · Open Word Bible

32Why not? Because they did not pursue it by faith, but as though it came by works. They stumbled over the stone that makes people stumble, 33as it is written, "See, I am setting in Zion a stone to stumble on, a rock that makes them fall, and whoever believes in Him will not be put to shame."

Report a mistake