Logia

Charles Hodge · A Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, designed for students of the English Bible

Romans 9

70 excerpts on Romans 9, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

Romans 9:1

L say the truth in Christ, I lie not

(1) L say the truth in Christ, I lie not, &c. There are three ways in which the words in Christ, or by Christ, may here be understood. 1. They may be considered as part of the formula of an oath, Z say the truth, by Christ. The preposition rendered zm is so used in Matt. 5: 34, &c. Rev. 10: 6. But in these and similar cases it is always in connexion with a verb of swearing. In addition to this objection, it may be urged that no instance occurs of Paul’s appealing to Christ in the form of an oath. The instance which looks most like such an appeal is 1 Tim. 5: 21, “I charge thee before God, and the Lord Jesus Christ, and the elect angels, &c.’’ But it is evident from the mention of the angels, that this is not of the nature of an oath. Paul merely wishes to urge Timothy to act as in the presence of God, Christ and angels. This interpretation, therefore, is not to be approved. 2. The words 7m Christ may be con- nected with the pronoun 1 ‘Zin Christ, i. e. as a Christian, or, ‘In the consciousness of my union with Christ, I declare, &c.? So the words are used in a multitude of cases, “ You in Christ,”’ “I in Christ,”? “ We in Christ,” being equivalent with you, I, or we, as Christians, i. e. considered as united to Christ. See 1 Cor. 1: 20, “ Of whom are ye in Christ,” i. e.‘ By whom ye are Christians, or united to Christ;’? Rom. 16: 3, 7, 9. 1 Cor. 3: 1, and frequently elsewhere. 3. The words may be used adverbially, and be translated after a Christian manner. ‘This also is a frequent use of this and analogous phrases. See 1 Cor. 7: 39, “Only in the Lord,” i. e. only after a religious manner. After the Lord being equivalent with in a manner becoming, or suited to the Lord. Rom. 16: 22, “I salute you in the Lord.”? ...

Romans 9:1 · Open Word Bible

1I am telling the truth in Christ; I am not lying. My conscience, in the Holy Spirit, bears witness with me

Report a mistake

... Phil. 2: 29, “Receive him therefore in the Lord;’’ Eph. 6: 1. Col. 3: 18. The sense of the passage is much the same whether we adopt the one or the other of the last two modes of explanation. Paul means to say that he speaks in a solemn and religious manner, as a Christian, conscious of his intimate relation to Christ.

I say the truth, I lie not. This mode of assertion, first affirmatively and then negatively, is common in the scriptures. “Thou shalt die, and not live,” Is. 38: 1; “ He confessed and denied not,’? John 1: 20. My conscience also bearing me witness in the Holy Ghost. There are also three ways in which the words in the Holy Ghost may be connected and explained. 1. They are often considered as belonging to the first clause and standing in a parallelism with the words in Christ, and being also an oath. But in this way the construction is unnatural, and the sense not only unusual but revolting. 2. They may be connected with the words bearing me witness. The sense would then be, ‘ My conscience beareth me witness together with the Holy Ghost.’ That is, not only my own conscience, but the Holy Spirit assures me of my sincerity. 3. They may be connected with the word conscience. ‘My conscience under the influence of the Holy Ghost;’t my sanctified conscience. There seems little ground of preference between the last two; either gives a good sense.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:2

That Ihave great heaviness

(2) That Ihave great heaviness, &c. This it is which Paul so solemnly asserts. He was not an indifferent spectator of the sorrew, temporal and spiritual, which was about to come on his countrymen. All their peculiar national advantages, and the blessings of the Messiah’s kingdom which they had wickedly rejected, were to be taken away; they were, therefore, left without hope either for this world or the next. The consideration of their condition filled the apostle with great and constant heaviness. The sincerity and strength of this sorrow for them he asserts in the strongest terms in the next verse.

Romans 9:2 · Open Word Bible

2that my sorrow is great and the pain in my heart never stops.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:3

(3) #or I could wish that myself were accursed from Christ for my brethren, &c. The word anathema, which is used in this verse by the apostle, properly means something set up or consecrated, and is applied frequently to votive offerings. A secondary application of the word was to those persons who were devoted to destruction as sacrifices for the public good. And as, among the Greeks, the lowest and vilest of the people were selected for that purpose, it became a term of execration, and expressed the idea of exposure to divine wrath. In the Old Testament, the Hebrew word to which it answers, occurs very frequently, and probably the root originally meant fo cut off, to separate. UHence, the substantive derived from it, meant something separated or consecrated. In usage, however, it was applied only to such things as could not be redeemed, and which, when possessed of life, were to be put to death. It is evident from the passages quoted in the margin, Deut. 7 : 26, “ Neither shalt thou bring an abomination into thy house, lest thou be a cursed thing ... like it, but thou shalt utterly detest it, and utterly abhor it; for it is a cursed thing.’ The sacred writer is here speaking of the images, &c. of the heathen, which were devoted to destruction.

Joshua 6: 17, “ And the city shall be ... accursed, even it and all that is therein, to the Lord, &c.” Verse 18,“ And ye, in any wise keep yourselves from the accursed thing, lest ye make yourselves accursed, when ye take of the accursed thing, and make the camp of Israel a curse, and trouble it.”

1 Sam. 15: 21, “ And the people took of the spoil, sheep and oxen, the chief of the things which should have been utterly destroyed, &c.” In Hebrew, simply Donn of which the words in italics are a paraphrase. that the word usually designates a person or thing set apart to destruction on religious grounds; something accursed.

Romans 9:3 · Open Word Bible

3I could even wish that I myself were under a curse, cut off from Christ, on behalf of my brothers and sisters, my own people by human descent.

Report a mistake

In the New Testament the use of the Greek word is very nearly the same. The only passages in which it occurs besides the one before us, are the following; Acts 23: 14, “ We have bound ourselves under a great curse, (we have placed ourselves under an anathema) that we will eat nothing until we have slain Paul.”? The meaning of this passage evidently is, owe have imprecated on ourselves the curse of God, or we have called upon him to consider us as anathema.’ 1 Cor. 12: 3, “ No man speaking by the Spirit of God calleth Jesus accursed (anathema); 1 Cor. 16: 22, “ Let him be anathema maranatha;”’ Gal. 1: 8, 9, “ Let him be accursed (anathema).’’ In all these cases it is clear that the word is applied to those who were regarded as deservedly exposed, or devoted to the curse of God. In this sense it was used by the early Christian writers, and from them passed into the use of the church. “ Let him be anathema,”’ being the constant formula of pronouncing any one, in the judgment of the church, exposed to the divine malediction.

Among the later Jews this word, or the corresponding Hebrew term, was used in reference to the second of the three degrees into which they divided excommunication (see Buxtorf’s Rabbinical Lexicon). But no analogous use of the word occurs in the bible. Such being the meaning of this word in the scriptures, its application in this case by the apostle admits of various explanations. The most common interpretations of the passage are the following.

Report a mistake

1. As those men or animals pronounced anathema in the Old Testament were to be put to death, many consider the apostle as having that idea in his mind, and meaning nothing more than “I could wish to die for my brethren,’ &c. But the objections to this interpretation are serious. 1. Even in the Old Testament the word expresses generally something more than the idea of devotion to death. An anathema was a person devoted to death as accursed; see the passages quoted above. And in the New Testament this latter idea is always the prominent one. 2. The connexion is unfavourable to this interpretation. The phrase is, “accursed from Christ.” How are the words from Christ to be explained? Some say they should be rendered by Christ. ‘I could wish myself devoted to death by Christ.’ But this isan unusual use of the preposition ... which our version correctly renders from; and the whole expression is besides unusual and unnatural. Others, therefore, say that the passage should be rendered thus, ‘I could wish from Christ, that I might be devoted to death.’ But this, too, is an unusual and forced construction.

2. Others think that Paul has reference here to the Jewish use of the word, and means only that he would be willing to be cut off from the church or excommunicated. In this view the word Christ is commonly taken for the body of Christ or the church. But, in the first place, this is not a scriptural use of the word anathema, and is clearly inapplicable to the other cases in which it is used by the apostle; and, in the second place, it gives a very inadequate sense. HExcommunication from the church would not be a great evil in the eyes of the Jews.

Report a mistake

3. Others render the verb which, in our version, is translated *T could wish,’ J did wish. The sense would then be, ‘I have great sorrow on account of my brethren, because I can sympathize in their feelings, for I myself once wished to be accursed from Christ on their account.’ But, in the first place, had Paul intended to express this idea he would have used the aorist, the common tense of narration, and not the imperfect. 2. It is no objection to the common translation, that the imperfect indicative, instead of some form of the optative, is here used, and that too without an optative particle; for such cases are common,t e. g. Acts 25: 22. 3. This interpretation does not give a sense pertinent to the apostle’s object. He is not expressing what was his state of mind formerly, but what it was when writing. It was no proof of his love for his brethren that he once felt as they then did, but the highest imaginable, if the ordinary interpretation be adopted. 4. The language will hardly admit of this interpretation. No Jew would express his hatred of Christ and his indifference to the favours which he offered, by saying, he wished himself accursed from Christ. Paul never so wished himself before his conversion, for this supposes that he recognized the power of Christ to inflict on him the imprecated curse, and that his displeasure was regarded as a great evil.

Report a mistake

4, The common interpretation, and that which seems most natural, is, ‘I am grieved at heart for my brethren, for I could wish myself accursed from Christ, that is, I could be willing to be regarded and treated as anathema, a thing accursed, for their sakes.’ That this interpretation suits the force and meaning of the words and is agreeable to the context, must, on all hands, be admitted. The only objection to it is of a theological kind. It is said to be inconsistent with the apostle’s character to wish that he should be accursed from Christ. But to this it may he answered, 1. Paul does not say that he did deliberately and actually entertain such a wish. The expression is evidently hypothetical and conditional, ‘I could wish, were the thing allowable, possible or proper.’ So far from saying he actually desired to be thus separated from Christ, he impliedly says the very reverse. ‘I could wish it, were it not wrong; or, did it not involve my being unholy as well as miserable, but as such is the case, the desire cannot be entertained.’ This is the proper force of the imperfect indicative when thus used; it implies the presence of a condition which is known to be impossible.t 2. Even if the words expressed more than they actually do, and the apostle were to be understood as saying that he could wish to be cut off from Christ, yet, from the nature of the passage, it could fairly be understood as meaning nothing more than that he was willing to suffer the utmost misery for the sake of his brethren. The difficulty arises from pressing the words too far, making them express definite ideas, instead of strong and indistinct emotions. The general idea is, that he considered himself as nothing, and his happiness as a matter of no moment, in view of the salvation of his brethren.t

Report a mistake

Romans 9:4

The object of the apostle in the introduction to this chapter

(4) The object of the apostle in the introduction to this chapter, contained in the first five verses, is to assure the Jews of his love and of his respect for their peculiar privileges. The declaration of his love he had just made, his respect for their advantages is expressed in the enumeration of them contained in this verse. Who are Israelites, i. e. the peculiar people of God. This includes all the privileges which are afterwards mentioned. ‘The word Jsraed means one who contends with God, or a prince with God. Hos. 12: 3, “ He took his brother by the heel in the womb, and by his strength he had power with God.”’ As it was given to Jacob as an expression of God’s peculiar favour, Gen. 32: 28, its application to his descendants implied that they, too, were the favourites of God. To whom pertaineth the adoption. As Paul is speaking here of the external or natural Israel, the adoption or sonship which pertained to them, as such, must be external also, and is very: different from that which he had spoken of in the preceding chapter. They were the sons of God, i. e. the objects of his peculiar favour, selected from the nations of the earth to be the recipients of peculiar blessings, and to stand in a peculiar relation to God. Ex. 4: 22, “ Thou shalt say unto Pharoah, Israel is my son, even my first born;’? Deut. 14: 1, “ Ye are the children of the Lord your God;” Jer. 31: 9, “Iam a father to Israel, and Ephraim is my first born.”

Romans 9:4 · Open Word Bible

4They are Israelites. Theirs is the adoption as God's children, theirs the glory, the covenants, the giving of the law, the worship and the promises.

Report a mistake

“ind the glory. ‘These words are variously eesti They may be connected with the preceding, as explanatory of the adoption or as qualifying it, and the two words be equivalent to glorious adoption. But as every other specification in this verse is to be taken separately, so should this be. In the Old Testament that symbolical manifestation of the divine presence which filled the tabernacle and rested over the ark, is called the glory of the Lord. Ex. 40: 34, “ A cloud covered the tent of the congregation; and the glory of the Lord filled the tabernacle;”? Ex. 29: 43, “ There will I meet with the children of Israel, and the tabernacle shail be sanctified by my glory;”’ Lev. 16: 2, “I will appear in the cloud upon the mercy seat;’’ 1 Kings 8: 11, “The glory of the Lord had filled the house of the Lord;” 2 Chron. 5:14. Hag. 2: 7. Rev. 15: 8.

By the Jews this symbol was called the Shekinah, i. e. the presence of God. Besides this, the manifestation of God’s presence in general is called his glory; Is. 6: 4, “ The whole earth is full of his glory,’’ &c. It is probable, therefore, that Paul intended by this word to refer to the fact that God dwelt in a peculiar manner among the Jews, and in various ways manifested his presence, as one of their peculiar privileges.

Report a mistake

The covenants. The plural is used because God at various times entered into covenant with the Jews and their forefathers; by which he secured to them innumerable blessings and privileges; see Gal. 3: 16,17. Eph. 2:12. The giving of the law, ... the legislation. ‘The word is sometimes used for the law itself (see the Lexicons); it may here be taken strictly, that giving of the law, i.e. the solemn and glorious annunciation of the divine will from Mount Sinai. The former is the most probable; because the possession of the law was the grand distinction of the Jews, and one on which they peculiarly relied; see ch. 2:17. The service means the whole ritual, the pompous and impressive religious service of the tabernacle and temple. The promises relate, no doubt, specially to the promises of Christ and his kingdom. This was the great inheritance of the nation. This was the constant subject of gratulation and object of hope. See Gal. 3: 16, “ Now to Abraham and his seed were the promises made;” v. 21, “Is the law against the promises of God?’ So in other places the word promises is used specially for the predictions in reference to the great redemption, Acts 26: 6.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:5

Whose are the fathers

(5) Whose are the fathers, and of whom, as concerning the flesh, Christ came, &c. The descent of the Jews from men so highly favoured of God as Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, was justly regarded asa great distinction. “&ndofwhom. The and here shows that whom refers, not to the fathers, but to the Israelites, to whom pertained the adoption, the law, the service, and of whom Christ came. This was the great honour of the Jewish race. For this they were separated as a peculiar people, and preserved amidst all their afflictions. As it was true, however, only in one sense, that Christ was descended from the Israelites, and as there was another view of his person, according to which he was infinitely exalted above them and all other men, the apostle qualifies his declaration by saying as concern- ing the flesh. The word flesh is used so often for human nature in its present state, or for men, that the phrase as to the Jlesh, in such connexions, evidently means in as far as he was a man, or as to his human nature, ch. 1: 3. In like manner, when it is said Christ was manifested or came in the flesh, it means, he came in our nature, 1 Tim. 3: 16. 1 John 4: 2, &c. Who is over all, God blessed for ever. Amen. There is but one interpretation of this important passage which can, with the least regard to the rules of construction, be maintained. Paul evidently declares that Christ who, he had just said, was, as to his human nature, or as a man, descended from the Israelites, is, in another respect, the supreme God, or God over all, and blessed for ever. That this is the meaning of the passage is evident from the following reasons. 1. The relative who must agree with the nearest antecedent. There is no other subject in the context sufficiently prominent to make a departure from this ordinary rule, in this case, even plausible. ““ Of whom Christ came, who is, &c.”? Who is? ...

Romans 9:5 · Open Word Bible

5The patriarchs are theirs, and from them, by human descent, comes Christ, who is God over all, blessed forever. Amen.

Report a mistake

... Certainly Christ, as every one must acknowledge.t 2. The context requires this interpretation, because, as Paul was speaking of Christ, it would be very unnatural thus suddenly to change the subject and break out into a doxology to God. Frequently as the pious feelings of the apostle led him to use such exclamations of praise, he never does it except when God is the immediate subject of discourse. See ch. 1: 25, “ Who worship and serve the creature more than the Creator, who is blessed for evermore;”’ Gal. 1: 5. 2 Cor. 11: 31. Besides, it was the very object of the apostle to set forth the great honour to the Jews of having Christ born among them, and this, of course, would lead to his presenting As this is one of the most explicit and incontrovertible passages in support of the deity of Christ, it is a matter of thankfulness that there is not the shadow of reason for doubting the accuracy of the reading. All the MSS., all the versions and fathers give the passage precisely as in the common text. See Muxx’s note in his New Testament. the dignity of the Redeemer in the strongest light. For the greater he was, the greater the honour to those of whose race he came. 3. The antithesis, which is evidently implied between the two clauses of the verse, is in favour of this interpretation. Christ, according to the flesh, was an Israelite, but, according to his higher nature, the supreme God. See the strikingly analogous passage in ch. 1: 3, 4, where Christ is said, according to one nature, to be the Son of David, according to the other, the Son of God. 4. No other interpretation is at all consistent with the grammatical construction, or the relative position of the words. One proposed by Erasmus is to place a full stop after the words Christ came, and make all the rest of the verse refer to God. The passage would then read thus, “ Of whom, as concerning the flesh, Christ came. God blessed for ever. Amen.’? ...

Report a mistake

... But this is not only opposed by the reasons already urged, that such doxologies suppose God to be the immediate subject of discourse, or are preceded by some particle which breaks the connexion, and shows plainly what the reference is, &c.; but, apart from these objections, no such doxology occurs in all the bible. That is, the uniform expression is, “ Blessed be God,” and never “God be blessed.’”?* The word for blessed always stands first, and the word for God after it with the article. Often as such cases occur in the Greek and Hebrew scriptures, there is, it is believed, no case of the contrary arrangement. In Psalm 68: 20 (Septuagint 67: 19), the only apparent exception, the first clause is probably not a doxology, but a simple affirmation as in the Old Latin version, Dominus Deus benedictus est. In the Hebrew it is, as in all other cases, Blessed be the Lord, and so in our version of that Psalm. See also, Ps. 31: 21. 72: 18, 19. 41: 13. 68: 35. 89: 52. Gen. 9: 26. Ex. 18: 10, and a multitude of other examples. In all these and similar passages, the expression is blessed be God, or blessed be the Lord, and never God blessed, or Lord blessed. This being the case, it is altogether incredible, that Paul, whose ear must have been perfectly familiar with this constantly recurring formula of praise, should, in this solitary instance, have departed from the established usage. This passage, therefore, edroynros 0 Oss, or evAoyyros xvelog 6 ©ss¢, never the reverse. And so in Hebrew, always 777? 72, cannot be considered as a doxology, or an ascription of praise to God, and rendered God be blessed, but must be taken as a declaration, who is blessed; see ch. 1: 25, “ The Creator, who is blessed for ever.” ...

Report a mistake

... 2 Cor. 11: 31, “The God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who is blessed for evermore.”? <A second method of pointing the verse, also, proposed by Erasmus, and followed by many others, is to place the pause after the word all. ‘The verse would then read, “Of whom, as concerning the flesh, Christ came, who is over all. God be blessed for ever.’? This avoids some of the difficulties specified above, but it is subject to all the others. It breaks unnaturally the connexion, and makes a doxology out of a form of expression which, in the scriptures, as just_ stated, is never so used. 5. There is no reason for thus torturing the text to make it speak a different language from that commonly ascribed to it; because the sense afforded, according to the common interpretation, is scriptural, and in perfect accordance with other declarations of this apostle. Titus 1:3, “ According to the commandment of God our Saviour.”’ “Looking for that blessed hope, and the glorious appearing of the great God and (even) our Saviour Jesus Christ,’’ Tit. 2: 13; see Phil. 2: 6. Col. 2: 9, &c. &c. Over all is equivalent with most high, supreme. The same words occur in Eph. 4: 6, “ One God, who is above all.”? This passage, therefore, shows that Christ is God in the highest sense of the word. 42men isa Hebrew word signifying érue. It is used as inthe New Testament often adverbially, and is rendered verily; or, at the close of a sentence, as expressing desire, let it be, or merely approbation. It does not, therefore, necessarily imply that the clause to which it is attached contains a wish. It is used here, as in Rom. 1: 25, for giving a solemn assent to what has been said. “ God who is blessed for ever, Amen.” ‘To this declaration we say, Amen. It is true.’

Report a mistake

Romans 9:6

It has already been remarked (ch

(6) It has already been remarked (ch. 3: 3), that it was a common opinion among the Jews, that the promises of God being made to Abraham and to his seed, all connected with him as his natural descendants, and sealed, as such, by the rite of circumcision, would certainly inherit the blessings of the Messiah’s reign. It was enough fer them, therefore, to be able +~ say, “We have Abraham to our father.” This being the case, it was obvious that it would at once be presented as a fatal objection to the apostle’s doctrine of the rejection of the Jews, that it was inconsistent with the promises of God. Paul, therefore, without even distinctly announcing the position which he intended to maintain, removes this preliminary objection. In vs. 2, 3, in which he professed his sorrow for his brethren and his readiness to suffer for them, it was, of course, implied that they were no longer to be the peculiar people of God, heirs of the promises, &c. &c. This, Paul shows, involves no failure on the part of the divine promises. Not as though the word of God hath taken none effect, &c. That is, ‘I say nothing which implies that the word of God has failed.’t_ The word of God means any thing which God-has spoken, and here, from the connexion, the promise made to Abraham, including the promise of salvation through Jesus Christ. Hath taken none effect, literally, hath fallen, i. e. failed. “It is easier for heaven and earth to pass, than one tittle of the law to fail,’ literally, to fall, Luke 16:17. So this word is used frequently. ...

Romans 9:6 · Open Word Bible

6But this does not mean that God's word has failed. For not everyone descended from Israel truly belongs to Israel.

Report a mistake

... The reason why the rejection of the Jews involved no failure on the part of the divine promise, is, that the promise never contemplated the mere natural descendants of Abraham. or they are not all Israel which are of Israel, i. e. all the natural descendants of the patriarch are not the true people of God, to whom alone the promises properly belong.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:7

Neither because they are the seed of Abraham are they all children

(7) Neither because they are the seed of Abraham are they all children. In this and the following verses the sentiment is confirmed, that natural descent from Abraham does not secure a portion in the promised inheritance. The language of this verse is, from the context, perfectly intelligible. The seed or natural descendants of Abraham are not all his children in the true sense of the term; i.e. like him in faith and heirs of his promise. So in Gal. 3: 7, Paul says, “ They which are of faith, the same are the children of Abraham.”’

But in Isaac shall thy seed be called. As the word rendered called sometimes means to choose, Is. 48: 12. 49: 1, the meaning of the phrase may be, ‘In Isaac shall thy seed be chosen.’ ‘I will select him as the recipient of the blessings promised to you.’ 2. To be called is often equivalent to to be, to be regarded, as Is. 62: 4, “ Thou shalt not be called desolate,’ i. e. thou shalt not be desolate. Hence, in this case, the text may mean, ‘In Isaac shall thy seed be,’ i. e. he shall be thy seed. Or, 3. ‘ @fter Isaac shall thy seed be called,’ they shall derive their name from him. Whichever explanation be preferred, the meaning of the verse is the same. ‘ Not all the children of Abraham were made the heirs of his blessings, but Isaac was selected by the sovereign will of God to be the recipient of the promise.’

Romans 9:7 · Open Word Bible

7Nor are they all Abraham's children just because they are his descendants. Rather, "It is through Isaac that your offspring will be named."

Report a mistake

Romans 9:8

That ts

(8) That ts, they which are the children of the flesh, these are not the children of God. The simplest view of this verse would seem to be, to regard it as an explanation of the historical argument contained in the preceding verse. ‘The scriptures declare that Isaac, in preference to Ishmael, was selected to be the true seed and heir of Abraham, that is, or this proves, that it is not the children of the flesh that are regarded as the children of God, &c.’? This suits the immediate object of the apostle, which is to show that God, according to his good pleasure, chooses one and rejects another, and that he is not bound to make the children of Abraham, as such, the heirs of his promise. It is very common, however, to consider this passage as analogous to that in Gal. 4: 2231; and to regard the apostle as unfolding the analogy between the history of Isaac and Ish- mael, and that of the spiritual and natural children of Abraham; Isaac being the symbol of the former, and Ishmael of the latter. As Ishmael, “who was born after the flesh’ (Gal. 4: 23), 1. e. according to the ordinary course of nature, was rejected, so also are the children ‘of the flesh; and as Isaac, who was born “by promise,” i. e. in virtue of the promised interference of God, was made the heir, so also are they heirs, who in like manner are the children of the promise, that is, who are the children of God, not by their natural birth, but by his special and effectual grace. The point of comparison, then, between Isaac and believers is, that both are born, or become the children of God, not in virtue of ordinary birth, but in virtue of the special interposition of God. In favour of this view is certainly the strikingly analogous passage referred to in Galatians, and also the purport of the next verse. ...

Romans 9:8 · Open Word Bible

8This means that it is not the children born by natural descent who are God's children. It is the children of the promise who are counted as Abraham's offspring.

Report a mistake

... Besides this, if Paul meant to say nothing more in this and the following verse, than that it appears from the choice of Isaac that God is free to select one from among the descendants of Abraham and to reject another, these verses would differ too little from what he had already said in vs. 6, 7. It is best, therefore, to consider this passage as designed to point out an instructive analogy between the case of Isaac and the true children of God, he was born in virtue of a special divine interposition, so now, those who are the real children of God, are born not after the flesh, but by his special grace.

Report a mistake

The children of the promise. This expression admits of various explanations. 1. Many take it as meaning merely the promised children, as child of promise is equivalent to child which is promised. But this evidently does not suit the application of the phrase to believers as made here, and in Gal. 4: 28. 2. It may mean, according to a common force of the genitive, children in virtue of a promise. This suits the context exactly. Isaac was born not after the ordinary course of nature, but in virtue of a divine promise; Gal. 4: 23, where the expressions born after the flesh, and born by promise are opposed to each other. It is of course implied in the phrase children in virtue of a promise that it is by a special interposition that they become children, and this is the sense in which Paul applies the expression to believers generally. “ Who are born not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God,’”’ John 1:13. 3. There is a third explanation of the phrase which is more comprehensive, those to whom the promise pertains. This would include both the others just mentioned, and also a third idea, those to whom the promise belongs, or who are the heirs of the promised blessing. This idea seems to be included in the apostle’s use of the expression. Gal. 4: 28, “ Now we, brethren, as Isaac was, are the children of promise,’”’ and 3: 29, “Ye are Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise;’’ see too Gal. 3: 18, 22. Rom. 4: 16, “ To the end the promise might be sure to all the seed.’’? Though this idea seems to have been in the apostle’s mind, the second explanation is most in accordance with the context. 47e counted Jor the seed, i. e. are regarded and treated as such. ‘ Not the natural descendants of Abraham are the children of God, but those who are born again by his special interposition, are regarded and treated as his true childven.? See the same form of expression in Gen. 31: 15.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:9

For this is the word of promise

(9) For this is the word of promise, at this time will I come and Sarah shall have a son. This verse is evidently designed to show the propriety, and to explain the force of the phrase children of the promise.. Isaac was so called because God said at this time I with, &e. This is not only a prediction and promise that Isaac should be born, but also a declaration that it should be in consequence of God’s coming, i. e. of the special manifestation of his power; as, in scriptural language, God is said to come, wherever he specially manifests his presence or favour, John 14: 23. Luke 1: 68, &c.

Romans 9:9 · Open Word Bible

9For this is what the promise said: "At this time I will come back, and a son will be born to Sarah."

Report a mistake

Romans 9:10

And not only this, but when Rebecca also had conceived by one

(10) And not only this, but when Rebecca also had conceived by one, &c. Not only the case of Isaac and Ishmael demonstrates the sovereignty of God in the choice of the recipients of his favour, but that of Rebecca evinces the same truth in a still clearer light. It might be supposed that Isaac was chosen on account of his mother, but in the case of Jacob there is no room for such a supposition. Jacob and Esau had the same mother, the same father, and were born at one birth. The choice here was certainly a sovereign one.

Romans 9:10 · Open Word Bible

10And that is not all. Rebecca also conceived children by one man, our forefather Isaac.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:11

For the children being not yet born

(11) For the children being not yet born, neither having done any good or evil, &c. The force of for is clear by a reference to the preceding verse, and the object of the apostle. Not only does the case of Isaac and Ishmael evince the sovereignty of God, but that of Rebecca and her children does the: same, in a still more striking manner, for the decision between her children was made previous to their birth, for the very purpose of showing that it was not made on the ground of works, but of the sovereign pleasure of God.’ This is an example which cannot be evaded. With regard to Ishmael, it might be supposed that either the circumstances of his birth or his personal character was the ground of his rejection, but with regard to Esau neither of these suppositions can be made. The circumstances of his birth were identical with those of his favoured brother, and the choice was made before either had done any thing good or evil. The case of Ishmael was, indeed, sufficient. to prove that having Abraham for a father was not enough to secure the inheritance of the promises, but it could not prove the entire sovereignty of the act of election on the part of God, as is so fully done by that of Jacob and Esau.

Neither having done good or evil. The design of the introduction of these words is expressly stated in the next clause. taken as the case absolute, ‘Not only so, but also as to Rebecca, when she had conceived, &c.; it was said to her, &c.’ 3. The most common method, probably, is to supply simply his, ‘ Not only this (happened) but Rebeeca also, when she had conceived, &c.; it was said to her, &c.’ The regular construction would be, ‘ Not only so, but also to Rebecca it was said.’ Paul having interrupted himself by the parenthesis in v. 11, changes the grammatical construction at the beginning of vy, 12. This with him is not unfrequent; see Rom. 2: 8, Gal. 2: 5.

Romans 9:11 · Open Word Bible

11The children were not yet born and had done nothing good or bad. Yet so that God's purpose in choosing might stand,

Report a mistake

It was to show that the ground of choice was not in them, but in God; and this is the main point in regard to the doctrine of election, whether the choice be to the privileges of the external theocracy, or to the spiritual and eternal blessings of the kingdom of Christ.

That the purpose of God, according to election, might stand. This is the reason why the choice was made prior to birth. The original here admits of various interpretations, which, however, do not materially alter the sense. The word rendered purpose is that which was used in the previous chapter, v. 28, and means here, as there, a determination of the will, and of itself expresses the idea of its being sovereign, 1. e. of having its ground in the divine mind and not in its objects. Hence, in 2 Tim. 1: 9, it is said, “ Who hath called us not according to our works, but according to his own purpose, &c.; see Eph. 1:11. 3:11. The words according to election are designed to fix more definitely the nature of this purpose. 1. The word election often means the act of choice itself, as 1 Thess. 1: 4, “ Knowing, brethren beloved, your election of God.’’ In this sense, the clause means, ‘ The purpose of God in reference to election, or in relation to this choice.’ This view of the passage is perfectly consistent with the context. The choice was made prior to birth, in order that the true nature of the purpose of God in reference to it might appear. Or, 2. The word may mean liberty or freeness, and may here qualify adjectively the term purpose. The purpose according to liberty being the free purpose; see similar modes of expression in Rom. 11: 21, “ branches according to nature”’ for natural branches; 2 Cor. 8: 2, “deep poverty,” literally, “ poverty according to deepness.’’ ...

Report a mistake

... This is, perhaps, the most common that man’s nature is depraved, and the truth of the doctrine is evinced by the certainty and uniformity with which men sin, as soon as they are capable of moral action. In like manner, the uniformity with which anger, pride and self-love manifest themselves, is regarded as proof that these are natural passions, All that Paul means to say is, that there was no ground of distinction in the conduct of the children which could account for the choice of one in preference to the other. Whether both were possessed of natures prone to sin as the sparks to fly upward; or, on the contrary, prone to love and obedience towards God, his language leaves entirely undecided, ‘ interpretation. But as the word does not occur in this sense in the New Testament, the former mode of explanation is perhaps to be preferred. Should stand, i. e. should be established and recognized in its true character, that is, that it might be seen it was not of works, but of him that calleth. This purpose of God, in reference to election, or the choice itself, is not of works, i. e. does not depend on works, but on Aim that calleth. That is, as plainly as language can express the idea, the ground of the choice is not in those chosen, but in God who chooses. In the same sense our justification is said to be “ not of works,”’ Gal. 2: 16, and often; i. e. is not on the ground of works; see Rom. 11: 6.2 Tim. 1: 9. The language of the apostle in this verse, and the nature of his argument are so perfectly plain, that there is little diversity of opinion as to his general meaning.t It is almost uniformly admitted that he here teaches that the election spoken of is perfectly sovereign, that the ground on which the choice is made is not in men, but in God. ...

Report a mistake

... The opposers of the doctrine of personal election endeavour to escape the force of this passage, by saying that the choice of which the apostle speaks, is not to eternal life, but to the external advantages of the theocracy; and that it was not so much individuals as nations or communities which were chosen or rejected. With regard to this latter objection, it may be answered, 1. That the language quoted by the apostle from the Old Testament, is there applied to the individuals Jacob and ... And even Tuotucx makes Paul argue thus, “Dass wie Gott, ohne Anrechte anzuerkennen, die diussere Theokratie wad mancherlei Vortheile tibertrug wem er wollte, er so auch jetzt die innere dem iibertragt, oder den darein eingehen lasst welchen er will.” ‘That as God, without recognizing any claims, committed the external theocracy and many advantages to whom he pleased, so also now he commits the internal to whom he will, or allows whom he will to enter it.’

Report a mistake

Esau; and that Jacob, as an individual, was chosen in preference to his brother; and that Paul’s whole argument turns on this very point. 2. That the choice of nations involves and consists in the choice of individuals; and that the same objections obviously. lie against the choice in the one case as in the other. With regard to the former objection, that the choice here spoken of is to the external theocracy and not to eternal life, it may be answered, 1. Admitting this to be the case, how is the difficulty relieved? Is there any more objection to God’s choosing men to a great than to a small blessing, on the ground of his own good pleasure? The foundation of the objection is not the character of the blessings we are chosen to inherit, but the sovereign nature of the choice. Of course it is not met by making these blessings either greater or less. 2. A choice to the blessings of the theocracy, i. e. of a knowledge and worship of the true God, involved, in a multitude of cases at least, a choice to eternal life; as a choice to the means is a choice to the end. And it is only so far as these advantages were a means to this end, that their value was worth consideration. 3. The whole design and argument of the apostle show that the objection is destitute of force. The object of the whole epistle is to exhibit the method of obtaining access to the Messiah’s kingdom. The design here is to show that God is at liberty to choose whom he pleases to be the recipients of the blessings of this kingdom, and that he was not confined in his choice to the descendants of Abraham. His argument is derived from the historical facts recorded in the Old Testament. ...

Report a mistake

... As God chose Isaac in preference to Ishmael, and Jacob in preference to Esau, not on the ground of their works, but of his own good pleasure, so now he chooses whom he will to a participation of the blessings of the kingdom of Christ: these blessings are pardon, purity and eternal life, &c. &e. That such is the apostle’s argument and doctrine becomes, if possible, still more plain, from his refutation of the objections urged against it, which are precisely the objections which have ever been urged against the doctrine of election.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:12

Zt was said to her the elder shall serve the younger

(12) Zt was said to her the elder shall serve the younger. These words are to be connected with the 10th verse, according to our version, in this manner, “ Not only this, but Rebecca also, when she had conceived, &c., it was said to her, &c.’’

According to this view, although the construction is irregular, the sense is sufficiently obvious. As it was said to Rebecca that the elder of her sons should serve the younger, prior to the birth of either, it is evident that the choice between them was not on account of their works. It has been said that this declaration relates not to Jacob and Esau personally, but to their posterity, 1. Because in Gen. 25: 23, whence the quotation is made, it is said, “Two nations are within thy womb, and the one people shall be stronger than the other people; and the elder shall serve the younger.”” 2. Because Esau did not personally serve Jacob, although the descendants of the one were subjected to those of the other. It is no doubt true that the prediction contained in this passage has reference not only to the relative standing of Jacob and Hsau as individuals, but also to that of their descendants. It may even be allowed that the latter was principally intended in the annunciation to Rebecca. But it is too clear to be denied, 1. That this distinction between the two races presupposed and included a distinction between the individuals. Jacob was made the special heir to his father Isaac, obtained as an individual the birth-right and the blessing, and Esau as an individual was cast off. The one, therefore, was personally preferred to the other. 2. In Paul’s application of this event to his argument, the distinction between the two as individuals was the very thing referred to. ...

Romans 9:12 · Open Word Bible

12a purpose that rests not on works but on the one who calls, Rebecca was told, "The older will serve the younger."

Report a mistake

... This is plain from the 11th verse, in which he says, “ The children being not yet born, neither having done any good or evil, &c.” It is, therefore, the nature of the choice between the children that is the point designed to be presented. As to the objection that Hsau never personally served Jacob, it is founded on the mere literal sense of the words. Esau did acknowledge his inferiority to Jacob, and was in fact postponed to him on various occasions. This is the real spirit of the passage. This prophecy, as is the case with all similar predictions, had various stages of fulfilment. The relation between the two brothers during life; the loss of the birth-right blessing and promises on the part of Esau; the temporary subjugation of his descendants to the Hebrews under David, their final and complete subjection under the Maccabees; and especially their exclusion from the peculiar privileges of the people of God, through all the early periods of their history, are all included. Compare the prediction of the subjection of Ham to his brethren; and of Japheth’s dwelling in the tents of Shem, Gen. 9: 25—27.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:13

As it is written

(13) As it is written, Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I hated. These words are quoted from Malachi 1: 2, 3, where the prophet is reproving the Jews for their ingratitude. Asa proof of his peculiar favour, God refers to his preference for them from the first, “ Was not Esau Jacob’s brother, saith the Lord; yet I loved Jacob, and I hated Hsau, &c.’? This passage, as well as the one quoted in v. 12, and just referred to, relates to the descendants of Jacob and Esau, as well as to the individuals themselves; the favour shown to the posterity of the one, and withheld from that of the other, being founded on the distinction originally made between the two brothers. The meaning, therefore, is, that God preferred one to the other, or chose one instead of the other. As this is the idea meant to be expressed, it is evident that in this case the word hate means to love less, to regard and treat with less favour. 'Thus in Gen. 29: 33, Leah says, she was hated by her husband; while in the preceding verse, the same idea is expressed by saying, “ Jacob loved Rachael more than Leah,’’ Matt. 8:24. Luke 14: 26, “If a man come to me and hate not his father and mother, &e.” John 12: 25. The quotation from the Prophet may be considered either as designed in confirmation of the declaration that the elder should serve the younger; or it may be connected in sense with the close of the 11th, ‘God is sovereign in the distribution of his favours, as it is written, Jacob have I loved, and Esau have I hated;’ the distinction made between these two individuals being cited as an illustration and confirmation of the apostle’s doctrine.

Romans 9:13 · Open Word Bible

13As it is written, "I loved Jacob, but Esau I hated."

Report a mistake

The doctrine of the preceding verses is that God is perfectly sovereign in the distribution of his favours, that the ground of his selecting one and rejecting another is not their works, but his own good pleasure. ‘To this doctrine there are two plausible objections; first, it is not consistent with the divine justice, v. 14; second, it is incompatible with human responsibility, v. 19. To the former the apostle answers first, God claims distinctly in his word this prerogative, v. 15; and secondly, he obviously exercises it, as is seen in the dispensations of his providence, Vo Lis

Report a mistake

Romans 9:14

What shall we say then, is there unrighteousness with God

(14) What shall we say then, is there unrighteousness with God? God forbid.t The apostle, according to his usual manner, proposes the objection to his own doctrine in the form of a question, denies its validity, and immediately subjoins his reason; see Rom. 3: 5. Gal. 3: 21. The obvious objection here presented is, that it is unjust in God, thus, according to his own purpose, to choose one and reject another. This Paul denies, and supports his denial by an appeal, in the first place, to seripture, and the second, to experience. It will be remarked that these arguments of the apostle are founded on two assumptions. The first is, that the scriptures are the word of God; and the second, that what God actually does cannot be unrighteous. Consequently any objection which can be shown to militate against either an express declaration of scripture, or an obvious fact in providence, is fairly answered. And if, as is almost always the case, when it militates against the one, it can be shown to militate against the other, the answer is doubly ratified.

Romans 9:14 · Open Word Bible

14What then are we to say? Is there injustice on God's part? Certainly not!

Report a mistake

Romans 9:15

For God saith to Moses

(15) For God saith to Moses, [will have mercy on whom Iwill have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion. 'The connexion and argument are obvious. ‘It is not unjust in God to exercise his sovereignty in the distribution of his mercies, for he expressly claims the right.? The passage quoted is from the account of the solemn interview of Moses with God. In answer to the prayer of the prophet for his people and for himself, God answered, “I will proclaim my name before thee, and will be gracious to whom I will be gracious, &c.”? Ex. 33:19. It is, therefore, a formal declaration of a divine prerogative. The form of expression J will do what I do, or Ido what Ido, is here, as in Ez. 16: 23. 2 Sam. 15: 20, designed to convey the idea, that it rests entirely with the agent to act or not, at his pleasure. The ground of decision is in himself. In the connexion of this verse with the former, therefore, it is obvious that Paul quotes this declaration to prove that God claims the sovereignty, which he had attributed to him. In order to avoid the force of this passage many deny that it expresses the sentiment of the apostle. They consider this and the following verses as the objections of a Jewish fatalist. A mode of interpretation so obviously inconsistent with the context, and even the proper force of the words, that it is mentioned only to show how hard it is to close the eyes against the doctrine which the apostle so clearly teaches.

Romans 9:15 · Open Word Bible

15For God says to Moses, "I will have mercy on whomever I have mercy, and I will show compassion to whomever I show compassion."

Report a mistake

Romans 9:16

So then it is not of him that willeth

(16) So then it is not of him that willeth, nor him that runneth, &c. If the ground of the decision or choice of the objects of mercy be in God, as asserted in v. 15, then it is not in man, isa conclusion which flows of course from the previous declarations. The word 7¢ refers to the result contemplated in the context, viz. the attainment of the divine favour, or more definitely, admission into the Messiah’s kingdom. This result, when attained, is to be attributed not to the wishes or efforts of man, but to the mercy of God. That one, therefore, is taken, and another left, that one is introduced into this kingdom and another not, is to be referred to the fact asserted in the preceding verse, that “ God will have mercy on whom he will have mercy.’? This seems plainly to be the apostle’s meaning. It is said, however, that the efforts here declared to be vain are those of the self-righteous; that Paul intends to say that the Jews, by the works of the law, could not attain the favour of God, &c. But no such sentiment is expressed by the apostle; it is allsupplied by the commentator. The sentiment, moreover, is not only not expressed, but it is in direct contradiction to the language and design of the apostle. He says the ground of choice, or of admission into the kingdom of Christ is not in us; this interpretation says it isin us. Paul says it is in God; this interpretation says, it is not in God. These words, however, are not intended to teach that the efforts of men for the attainment of salvation are useless; much less do they teach that such efforts should not be made. They simply declare that the result is not to be attributed to them; that the reason why one man secures the blessing, and another does not, is not to be found in the greater ardour of desire, or intensity of effort in the one, than in the other, but the reason isin God. ...

Romans 9:16 · Open Word Bible

16So it is not a matter of what a person wants or how hard a person strives, but of God, who shows mercy.

Report a mistake

... This doctrine is consistent, not only with the duty of all to strive to enter into life, but also with the connexion between these efforts and the desired end. Because although the result depends on God, he may and does bring it to pass in the use of the means which he has appointed for the purpose. The question, however, of the use of means, is foreign to this discussion. Paul has no reference to that subject. He simply declares that election is founded on the good pleasure of God, and not on any thing in man.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:17

For the scripture saith unto Pharaoh

(17) For the scripture saith unto Pharaoh, &c. The connexion of this verse is with the 14th, rather than with the one immediately preceding. Paul is still engaged in answering the objection proposed in the 14th verse. There is no injustice with God, because he saith to Moses, ‘I will have mercy, &c.’ v. 15, and because the scripture saith to Pharaoh, for this purpose, &c. v. 17. His second answer to the objection is, that God, in point of fact, does exercise this sovereignty, as is evident from the case of Pharaoh. Pharaoh was no worse than many other men who have obtained mercy; yet God, for wise and benevolent reasons, withheld from him the saving influences of his grace, and gave him up to his own wicked heart, so that he became more and more hardened, until he was finally destroyed. God did nothing to Pharaoh beyond his strict deserts. He did not make him wicked; he only forebore to make him good, by the exertion of special and altogether unmerited grace. The reason, therefore, of Pharaoh’s being left to perish, while others were saved, was not that he was worse than others, but because God has mercy on whom he will have mercy; it was because, among causa est; sic etiam vicissim dicere licebit, non esse misericordiae, sed volentis et currentis.—-C aLvin. the criminals at his bar, he pardons one and not another, as seems good in his sight. He, therefore, who is pardoned cannot say it was because I was better than others; while he who is condemned must acknowledge that he receives nothing more than the just recompense of his sins. In order to establish his doctrine of the divine sovereignty, Paul had cited from scripture the declaration that God shows mercy to whom he will; he now cites an example to show that he punishes whom he will.

Romans 9:17 · Open Word Bible

17For Scripture says to Pharaoh, "This is the very reason I raised you up: to display My power in you, and so that My name would be made known through the whole earth."

Report a mistake

Even for this same purpose have I raised thee up. ‘This is what God said to Pharaoh, as recorded in Ex. 9:16. The meaning of the declaration may be variously explained. In the Old Testament, the Hebrew word used in the passage quoted, means | literally, Z have caused thee to stand. This is understood by some as meaning J have called thee into existence. 2. By others, J have preserved thee. 3. By others, J have raised thee up asking. 4. By others, J have placed and continued thee as my adversary. Wither of these interpretations admits of being defended on philological grounds.more or less satisfactory. The first is sufficiently suitable to the force of the word used by the apostle, but does not agree so well with the original passage in Exodus. For the second, it may be urged that verbs in the form (Hiphil) used in the passage quoted, signify frequently the continuance of a thing in the state which the simple form of the verb expresses. Thus the verb meaning to live, in this form, signifies to preserve alive, Gen. 6: 19, 20. 19: 19, &c. Besides, the particular word used in Ex. 9: 16, signifies to preserve, to cause to continue, in 1 Kings 15: 4. 2 Chron. 9: 8. Prov. 29: 4, &c. The third interpretation is too definite, and supplies an idea not in the text. The fourth, which is only a modification of the second, is perhaps the nearest to the apostle’s intention. ‘ For this purpose have I raised you up, and placed you where you are; and instead of cutting you off at once, have so long endured your obstinacy and wickedness.’ That I might show my power in thee, and that my name might be declared in all the earth. This is the reason why God dealt with Pharaoh in the manner described. It was not that he was worse than others, but that God might be glorified. This is precisely the principle on which all punishment is inflicted. ...

Report a mistake

... Itis that the true character of the divine lawgiver should be known. This is of all objects, when God is concerned, the highest and most important; in itself the most worthy, and in its results the most beneficent. The ground, therefore, on which Pharaoh was made an object of the divine justice, or the reason why the law was in his case allowed to take its course, is not to be sought in any peculiarity of his character or conduct in comparison with those of others, but in the sovereign pleasure of God. This result of the argument Paul formally states in the next verse.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:18

Therefore hath he mercy on whom he will have mercy

(18) Therefore hath he mercy on whom he will have mercy, and whom he will he hardeneth. 'This is the conclusion, not merely from the preceding verse, but from the whole passage, vs. 14—17. This perfect sovereignty in the selection of the objects of his mercy and of his judgment, Paul had attributed to God in y. 11, and, in the subsequent verses, had proved that he claims and exercises it, both in reference to the recipients of his favour, v. 15, and the subjects of his wrath, v. 17. The doctrine, therefore, is fully established.

The latter clause of this verse, whom he will he hardeneth, admits of various explanations. The word may be taken either in its ordinary meaning, or it may be understood in its secondary sense. According to the latter view, it means to treat harshly, to punish. This interpretation, it must be admitted, is peculiarly suited to the context, ‘He hath mercy on whom he will, and he punishes whom he will.’ Nor is it entirely destitute of philological support. In Job 39: 16, it is said of the ostrich, “ She treateth hardly her young.’’ But, on the other hand, it is liable to serious objections. 1. It is certain that it is a very unusual sense of the word, and opposed to the The interpretation mentioned in the text is given by Want in his Lexicon, and is defended by Buneex thus, “ Indurat dicit pro non miseretur, per metonymiam consequentis, etsi 7) non misereri quodammodo durius sonat. Sic, sanctificatus est, pro, non est impurus, 1 Cor.’7: 14, eepUdaoNS, pro, non tradidistis, Jos. 22:31. meaning in which it frequently occurs. There should be very strong reasons for departing from the usual meaning of an expression so common in the scriptures. 2. It is inconsistent with those passages in the Old Testament which speak of the hardening of Pharaoh’s heart. 3. It removes no difficulty; for what, according to the usual sense of the word, is here said, is frequently said elsewhere.

Romans 9:18 · Open Word Bible

18So then God has mercy on whomever He chooses, and He hardens whomever He chooses.

Report a mistake

The common sense of the word is, therefore, doubtless, to be preferred, whom he will he hardens. This is by. many understood to express a direct and positive influence of God on the soul in rendering it obdurate. But, in the first place, this interpretation is by no means necessary, as will presently be shown; and, in the second, it can hardly be reconciled with our ideas of the divine character.

2. Others think that this phrase is to be explained by a reference to that scriptural usage, according to which God is said to do whatever indirectly and incidentally results from his agency; on the same principle that a father is said to ruin his children, or a master his servants; or that Christ is said to produce wars and divisions. Thus Is. 6: 10, the prophet is commanded to make the heart of the people fat, and their ears heavy, and shut their eyes, &c., as though to him were to be ascribed the incidental results of his preaching. In the same way the gospel is the cause of death (not of misery only, but of insensibility also), to those who hear and disregard it. 3. Nearly allied to this mode of explanation is that which rests on the assumption that God is said to do what he permits to be done. Reference is made to such passages as the following. 2 Sam. 12: 11, “I will give thy wives unto thy neighbour,” i. e. I will permit him to take them. 2 Sam. 16:10, “The Lord hath said unto him, curse David.”’ Is. 63: 17, “O Lord why hast thou caused us to err from thy ways, and hardened our hearts from thy fear.”? Deut. 2: 30, “ For the Lord thy God hardened his spirit (Sihon’s), that he might deliver him into thy hand.” 1 Kings 11: 23,“ The Lord stirred up another adversary.” Ps. 105: 25, “ He turned their hearts to hate his people.””? ...

Report a mistake

... In 2 Sam. 24: 1, God is said to have moved David to number the people; but in 1 Chron. 21: 1, Satan is said to have provoked David to number Israel. From these and similar passages it is evident that it is a familiar scriptural usage, to ascribe to God effects which he allows in his wisdom to come to pass. Hence, almost every thing is, at times, spoken of as if it was produced by divine agency, although, in a multitude of other places, these same results are referred, as in some of the examples cited above, to their immediate authors. According to this mode of representation, God is understood as merely permitting Pharaoh to harden his own heart, as the result is often expressly referred to Pharaoh himself, Ex. 8: 15, 32, &c. 4. But there seems to be more expressed by the language of the text than mere permission, because it is evidently a punitive act that is here intended, and because this view does not suit the other passages in which God is said to give sinners up to the evil of their own hearts, Rom. 1; 24, 28.1 It is probable, therefore, that the judicial abandonment of men “to a reprobate mind,” a punitive withdrawing of the influences of his Holy Spirit, and the giving them up to the uncounteracted operation of the hardening or perverting influences by which they are surrounded, are all expressed by the language of the apostle. In this God does no more than what he constantly threatens to do, or which the scriptures declare he actually does, in the case of those who forsake him; and nothing more than every righteous parent does in reference to a reprobate son. This, in connexion with the principle referred to above (in No. 2), seems as much as can fairly be considered as included in the expressions.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:19

Thou wilt then say unto me, why doth he yet find fault

(19) Thou wilt then say unto me, why doth he yet find fault? for who hath resisted his will? This is the second leading objection to the apostle’s doctrine. If it is true, as he had just taught, that the destiny of men is in the hands of God, if it is not of him who willeth, or of him that runneth, but of God that showeth mercy; what can we do? If the fact that one believes and is saved, and another remains impenitent and ... is lost, depends on God, how can we be blamed? Can we resist his will? It will at once be perceived that this plausible and formidable objection to the apostle’s doctrine is precisely the one which is commonly and confidently urged against the doctrine of election. There would be no room either for this objection, or for that contained in the 14th verse, if Paul had merely said that God chooses those whom he forsees would repent and believe; or that the ground of distinction was in the different conduct of men. It is very evident, therefore, that he taught no such doctrine. How easy and obvious an answer to the charge of injustice would it have been to say, God chooses one and rejects another according to their works. But teaching as he does the sovereignty of God in the selection of the objects of his mercy and of the subjects of his wrath, declaring as he does so plainly, that the destiny of men is determined by his sovereign pleasure, the objection, how can he yet find fault ? is plausible and natural. ...

Romans 9:19 · Open Word Bible

19So you will say to me, "Why does God still find fault, then?" For who can stand against His will?

Report a mistake

... To this objection the apostle gives two answers; 1. That it springs from ignorance of the true relation between God and men, as Creator and creatures, and of the nature and extent of the divine authority over us, vs. 20, 21; 2. That there is nothing in his doctrine inconsistent with the divine perfections; since he does not make men wicked, but from the mass of wicked men, he pardons one and punishes another, for the wisest and most benevolent of reasons, vs. 22, 23.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:20

Nay, but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God

(20) Nay, but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God? Shall the thing formed, &c. In these words we have both a reproof and an answer. The reproof is directed against the irreverent spirit, whence such cavils always arise. After the clear proof given in the preceding verses, that God claims this sovereignty in his word, and exercises it in his providence, it argues great want of reverence for God to assert that this claim involves the grossest injustice. It is very common with the sacred writers, and with Christ himself, when questions or cavils are presented, to direct their answers more to the feeling which the question indicated, than to the question itself. Tholuck refers, in illustration of this remark, to John 3: 3. Matt. 8:19, 20, 22. 19: 16. 22: 29. But in this case, besides this reproof for a miserable mortal attempting to call his Maker to account, instead of considering that the mere fact that God claims any thing as his right, is evidence enough that it is just, there is a direct answer to the difficulty. The objection is founded on ignorance or misapprehension of the true relation between God and his sinful creatures. It supposes that he is under obligation to extend his grace to all. Whereas he is under obligation to none. All are sinners, and have forfeited every claim to his mercy; it is, therefore, perfectly competent to God to spare one and not another; to make one vessel to honour, and another to dishonour. He, as their sovereign Creator, has the same right over them that a potter has over the clay. It is to be borne in mind, that Paul does not here speak of the right of God over his creatures as creatures, but as sinful creatures; as he himself clearly intimates in the next verses. ...

Romans 9:20 · Open Word Bible

20But who are you, a mere human being, to answer back to God? Will what was shaped say to the one who shaped it, "Why did you make me this way?"

Report a mistake

... It is the cavil of a sinful creature against his Creator, that he is answering; and he does it by showing that God is under no obligation to give his grace to any, but is as sovereign as the potter in fashioning the clay.

Shall the thing formed, say to him that formed it, why hast thou made me thus? See Isaiah 45: 9. In this clause Paul presents mainly the idea of God’s right, and in the subsequent verses he shows that nothing unjust is included in the right here claimed. We are justly in his hands; and it is the height of irreverence and folly for us to call him to account for the manner in which he may see fit to dispose of us.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:21

Hath not the potter power over the clay

(21) Hath not the potter power over the clay, out of the same lump, to make one vessel, &c. &c. The word rendered power means also authority and right. In this case it means, the lawful power or right; he not only can do it, but he has a perfect right to do it; see the use of the Greek word in Matt. 21: 23. 1 Cor. 8: 9, and frequently elsewhere. This verse is merely an illustration of the idea contained in the last clause of the preceding. The Creator has a perfect right to dispose of his creatures as he sees fit. From the very idea of a creature, it can have no claim on the Creator; whether it exists at all, or how, or where, from the nature of the case, must depend on him, and be at his sovereign disposal. The illustration of this truth which follows, is peculiarly appropriate. When the potter takes a piece of clay into his hands, and approaches the wheel, how entirely does it rest with himself to determine the form that clay shall take, and the use to which it shall be destined? Can any thing be more unreasonable, than that the clay, supposing it endued with intelligence, should complain that the form given it was not so comely, or the use to which it was destined not so honourable as those which fell to the lot of a different portion of the same mass? Are not these points on which the potter has a most perfect right to decide for himself, and regarding which the thing formed can have no right to complain or question? And so it is with God; the mass of fallen men are in his hands, and it is his right to dispose of them at pleasure; to make all vessels unto honour, or all unto dishonour, or some to one and some to the other. These are points on which, from the nature of the relation, we have no right to question or complain.

Romans 9:21 · Open Word Bible

21Has the potter no right over the clay? From one and the same lump he may make one pot for honored use and another for common use.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:22–23

But what if God

(22, 23) But what if God, willing to show his wrath, and to make his power known endured with much long suffering the vessels of wrath fitted to destruction; and that he might make known the riches of his glory on the vessels of mercy, which he had afore prepared unto glory, even us, &c.? These verses contain Paul’s second answer to the difficulty presented in the 19th verse. He had shown in ys. 20, 21, that in virtue of his relation to men as his sinful creatures, God is at perfect liberty to dispose of them at his pleasure, pardoning one and punishing another, as seemeth good in his sight. He now shows that in the exercise of this right there is nothing unreasonable or unjust, nothing of which his creatures have the least right to complain. The punishment of the wicked is not an arbitrary act, having no object but to make them miserable; it is designed to manifest the displeasure of God against sin,and to make known his true character. On the other hand, the salvation of the righteous was designed to display the riches of his grace. Both ‘in the punishment of the one class, and the salvation of the other, most important and benevolent ends were to be answered. And since for these ends it was necessary that some should be punished, while others might be pardoned, as all are equally undeserving, it results from the nature of the case that the decision between the vessels of wrath and the vessels of mercy must be left to God. The apostle would, moreover, have it remarked that even in the necessary: punishment of the wicked, God does not proceed with any undue severity, but, on the contrary, deals with them with the greatest long-suf- fering and tenderness. Such seems to be the general purport and object of these difficult verses.

Romans 9:22–23 · Open Word Bible

22What if God, wanting to show His wrath and to make His power known, has borne with great patience the vessels of wrath, made ready for destruction? 23What if He did this to make known the riches of His glory to the vessels of mercy, which He prepared in advance for glory,

Report a mistake

The attentive reader will perceive that even with the insertion of the word what which has nothing to answer to it in the original, and with a sign of interrogation at the end of y. 24, the construction of the passage in our version remains ungrammatical and the sense incomplete. As the difficulty exists in the Greek text and not merely in our translation, the explanations which have been proposed are very numerous. Many of these are presented and canvassed by Tholuck and Wolf, particularly the latter. There are three views taken of the connexion, which are the most plausible. 1. The two verses are considered as both referring to the rejection of the wicked, for which v. 22 assigns one reason, and v. 23 another. ‘What if God, willing to show his wrath, endured with much long-suffering the vessels of wrath, so that also he might make known the riches of his glory on the vessels of mercy, &c.’ The treatment of the wicked was not only to display the divine displeasure against sin, but also, by contrast, his mercy towards his people. But, in order to make the two verses cohere in this way, it is necessary to transpose the words at the beginning of the 23d verse, and read that also, instead of and that, which alters the sense materially, while for such a transposition there is no authority. Besides this, it makes v. 23 too subordinate to y. 22; that is, it makes God’s dealings towards the vessels of mercy merely an incidental topic, instead of having equal prominence with his treatment of the vessels of wrath. From the context we are led to expect a vindication of his course, not only in the destruction of the latter, but in the salvation of the former.

Report a mistake

Much in the same way Wrner explains the passage, connecting the xol ive of v. 23, immediately with the verb 4 'veyxev of v. 22, “ Wenn Gott beschliessend mit aller Langmuth die Gefiisse seines Zornes trug * auch in der Absicht, den Reichthum * zuerkennen zu geben.” “If God willing * * * bore with all long-suffering the vessels of wrath « * * * also with the view to make known the riches, &c.” Gram. p. 443.

2. A second method is to make the second clause of vy. 22 and the beginning of v. 23 depend on the first words of v. 22. ‘God willing to show his wrath and make his power known, and (willing) that the riches of his glory should be known, &c.’ This gives a good sense, though the construction is suddenly and rather violently changed at the beginning of y. 23, “ that he might make known,’ stand for the infinitive, “to make known.””

3. Tholuck makes v. 24 parallel with v. 23, and explains the passage thus, ‘ God, willing to manifest his wrath, bore with the vessels of wrath; and that he might make known his mercy, called us, &c.? This gives a very good sense, but assumes the construction to be irregular to a very unusual degree. Though the second method be somewhat irregular, it seems, on the whole, the least objectionable, and gives a sense obviously consistent with the context.

Report a mistake

The two objects which Paul here specifies as designed to be answered by the punishment of the wicked, are the manifestation of the wrath af God, and the exhibition of his power. The word wrath is used here as in ch. 1: 18, for the divine displeasure against sin, the calm and holy disapprobation of evil, joined with the determination to punish those who commit it. The power of God is conspicuously displayed in the destruction of the wicked, no matter how mighty or numerous they may be. Though the inherent ill-desert of sin must ever be regarded as the primary ground of the infliction of punishment, a ground which would remain in full force, were no beneficial results anticipated from the misery of the wicked, yet God has so ordered his government that the evils which sinners incur shall result in the manifestation of his character, and the consequent promotion of the holiness and happiness of his intelligent creatures throughout eternity.

God treats the wicked, not as a severe judge, but with much long suffering. The expression vessels of wrath no doubt suggested itself from the illustration of the potter used in the preceding verse; though the term vesse/ is used not unfrequently in reference to men, Acts 9:15. 1 Pet. 3:7. Vessels of wrath, i. e. vessels which deserve wrath, or which are to be objects of wrath; as vessels of mercy, are those which are to be the objects of mercy; or these phrases may mean vessels destined to wrath and destined to mercy, corresponding to the expressions vessels unto honour and unto dishonour, of the preceding verse. This last explanation, on account of the context, seems the most probable.

Report a mistake

Fitted to destruction. The word here used admits of being taken either as passive or middle, and may, therefore, be rendered as it is in our version, or who have fitted themselves for destruction. If the passive sense be adopted then, the meaning may be, prepared by God for destruction; or the participle may be taken rather as a verbal adjective, fitted for destruction, expressing merely the idea of being ready for that end. In favour of this latter view, it may be noticed that in the next verse, when speaking of the vessels of mercy, the active voice is used, “which God had before prepared unto glory;”’ as if designedly to mark the difference between the two cases. If the other explanation (prepared by God) be adopted, then, of course, the words must be taken in a sense modified by the nature of the subject, and other passages of scripture. Wicked men are prepared for destruction by God, not as being created for that purpose, but as being devoted to it on account of their sins, and borne with until they are ripe for their doom. This explanation is adopted not only by the stronger Calvinists, but by many of the neological commentators.t There seems, however, no valid objection to the interpretation prepared or fit for destruction; and which is the rather to be preferred, because the apostle, being here engaged in vindicating the divine proceedings, would naturally speak of the objects of the divine ... wrath as being fitted for destruction, in the sense of deserving it, &c.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:23

And that he might make known the riches of his glory

(23) And that he might make known the riches of his glory, &c. See the preceding verse for the different views of the grammatical connexion of this verse with v. 22. The sense is plain, ‘What right have men to complain, if God punishes the wicked, and manifests the riches of his glory on the objects of his mercy ?? The word glory is used in reference to any thing in God which is the foundation of praise. Hence, it is used for each of his attributes, as, for example, for his power, Rom. 6: 4. John 11: 40; for his mercy, Eph. 3: 16, and here; or for all his attributes collectively, as in 2 Cor. 4: 6, “To give us the light of the knowledge of the glory of God, &c.’? Such, too, may be its force in this passage, as it is not mercy only, but wisdom, power, goodness, &c., which are manifested in the salvation of his people. The word is also frequently employed in reference to the future blessedness of the saints. Eph. 1: 18, “To know what are the riches of the glory of his inheritance in the saints.’’ This sense is given to the word, in this case, by Tholuck, but inconsistently with the context.. As the wrath and power of God are manifested in the destruction of the wicked, so are the riches of his glory in the salvation of his people.

Romans 9:23 · Open Word Bible

23What if He did this to make known the riches of His glory to the vessels of mercy, which He prepared in advance for glory,

Report a mistake

On the vessels af mercy, which he had afore prepared unto glory. On the phrase vessels of mercy, see the preceding verse. The word rendered he had afore prepared has this signification frequently; indeed, it is its common and proper meaning. But as to prepare beforehand and to predestine are very nearly related ideas, the word is also used in this latter sense. Eph. 2: 10, “ Which God had before ordained that we should walk in them.’”? This meaning is commonly adopted here,t “ Which God had fore-ordained unto glory;’’ see the parallel passage in Acts 13: 48, “As many as were ordained to eternal life, believed.’? The other signification of the word, however, gives a very good sense. ‘ Which he had before prepared, by his providence and grace unto glory.’

Report a mistake

Romans 9:24

Even us

(24) Even us, whom he hath called, not of the Jews only, but also of the Gentiles. We are the vessels of his mercy, even we whom he hath called, i. e. effectually introducéd by his Spirit into the kingdom of Christ; see ch. 8: 28,30. How naturally does the apostle here return to the main subject of discussion! How skilfully is the conclusion brought out at which he has continually aimed! God chose Isaac in preference to Ishmael, Jacob in preference to Esau, it is a prerogative which he claims and exercises, of selecting from among the guilty family of men whom he pleases as the objects of his mercy, and leaving whom he pleases to perish in their sins, unrestricted in his choice by the descent or previous conduct of the individuals. He has merey upon whom he will have mercy. He calls men, therefore, from among the Gentiles and from among the Jews indiscriminately. This is the result at which the apostle aimed. The Gentiles are admitted into the Messiah’s kingdom, vs. 25, 26; and the great body of the Jews are excluded, v. 27. This conclusion he confirms by explicit declarations of scripture.

Romans 9:24 · Open Word Bible

24that is, to us, whom He has called not only from among the Jews but also from among the Gentiles?

Report a mistake

Romans 9:25

The first part of the general conclusion

(25) The first part of the general conclusion, contained in the 24th verse, is, that the Gentiles are eligible to the blessings of Christ’s kingdom. This the apostle confirms by two passages from the prophecies of Hosea, which express the general sentiment, that those who, under the old economy, were not regarded as the people of God, should hereafter (i. e. under the Messiah) become his people. The first passage cited is from Hosea 2: 23, which in our version is, “I will have mercy on her that had not obtained mercy; and I will say to them which were not my people, thou art my people.’? The Hebrew, however, admits of the rendering given by the apostle, as the word translated to have mercy may signify to love. The difficulty with regard to this passage is, that in Hosea it evidently has reference not to the heathen, but to the ten tribes. Whereas, Paul refers it to the Gentiles as is also done by Peter, 1 Pet. 2: 10. This difficulty is sometimes gotten over by giving a different view of the apostle’s object in the citation, and making it refer to the restoration of the Jews. But this interpretation is obviously at variance with the context. It is more satisfactory to say, that the ten tribes were in a heathenish state, relapsed into idolatry, and, therefore, what was said of them, is of course applicable to others in like circumstances, or of like character. What amounts to much the same thing, the sentiment of the prophet is to be taken generally, ‘those who were excluded from the theocracy, who were regarded and treated as aliens, were hereafter to be treated as the people of God.’ ...

Romans 9:25 · Open Word Bible

25As He says in Hosea, "Those who were not My people I will call 'My people,' and her who was not loved I will call 'loved.'"

Report a mistake

... In this view, it is perfectly applicable to the apostle’s object, which was to convince the Jews, that the blessings of Christ’s kingdom were not to be confined within the pale of the Old Testament economy, or limited to those who, in their external relations, were considered the people of God; on the contrary, those who, according to the rules of that economy, were not the people of God, should hereafter become such. This method of interpreting and applying scripture is both common and correct. A general truth, stated in reference to a particular class of persons, is to be considered as intended to apply to all those whose character and circumstances are the same, though the form or words of the original enunciation may not be applicable to all embraced within the scope of the general sentiment. Thus what is said of one class of heathen, as such, is applicable to all others, and what is said of one portion of aliens from the Old Testament covenant, may properly be referred to others.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:26

And it shall come to pass

(26) And it shall come to pass, that in the place where it was said to them, ye are not my people, &e. This quotation is more strictly conformed to the Hebrew, than the preceding. It is from Hos. 1: 10. The sentiment is the same as before.

Romans 9:26 · Open Word Bible

26"And in the place where they were told, 'You are not My people,' that is where they will be called children of the living God."

Report a mistake

Romans 9:27–28

The second part of the apostle’s conclusion, v

(27, 28) The second part of the apostle’s conclusion, v. 24, is that the Jews, as such, were not to be included in the kingdom of Christ, which of course is implied in all those predictions which speak of them as in general cut off and rejected. Two such passages Paul quotes from Isaiah. The first is from Isaiah 10: 22, 23. Though the number of the children of Israel be as the sand of the sea, a remnant shall be saved, for he will finish the work and cut it short in righteousness: because a short work will the Lord make in the earth. 'This passage is nearer the LXX. translation than the Hebrew. The general sense is the same in both, and also in the apostle’s version, ‘ However numerous the children of Israel might be, only a small portion of them should escape the judgments of God.’ This being the case, it is evident that the mere being a Jew was never considered sufficient to secure the divine favour. The portion of the prophecy contained in vy. 27, is the principal point, ‘Only a few of the Jews were to be saved.’ What is contained in y.

Romans 9:27–28 · Open Word Bible

27And Isaiah cries out about Israel: "Though the people of Israel are as many as the grains of sand by the sea, the remnant will be saved." 28"For on the earth the Lord will carry out His sentence, fully and without delay."

Report a mistake

28, is an amplification, or states the converse of the preceding proposition. ‘ Most of the Jews should be cut off.’ The passage in Isaiah, therefore, is strictly applicable to the apostle’s object. Our version of v. 28 is consistent with the original.t But it may also be rendered, “ He will execute and determine on the judgment with righteousness, for a judgment determined on, will the Lord execute in the earth.”” The word ... rendered work in our version, means properly a@ word, something spoken, and may refer to a promise, or threatening, according to the context. Here of course a threatening is intended; the judgment threatened by the prophet in the context. The word ... rendered he will finish, means bringing to an end, and here perhaps executing at once, bringing to an end speedily. And the term ... translated cutting short, may mean deciding upon. See Dan. 9: 24, “Seventy weeks are determined ... upon my people.”? But the ordinary sense of the word is in favour of our version and so is the context.{ If it were allowable to take the same word in different senses in the same passage, the verse might be rendered thus, ‘For he will execute the judgment, and accomplish it speedily, for the judgment determined upon will the Lord execute in the earth.? This same word is used in one of these senses, Dan. 9: 24, and in the other in v. 26 of the same chapter. See, too, an analogous example in 1 Cor. 3: 17, “If any man ... defile the temple of God, him will God ... destroy.” Here the same word is rendered correctly, first defile, and then destroy. We may, therefore, render the last clause of the verse either as in our version or as given above.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:29

The second passage quoted by the apostle is from Is

(29) The second passage quoted by the apostle is from Is. 1: 9, Except the Lord of hosts had left us a seed we had been as Sodom, been made like unto Gomorrah. The object of this quotation is the same as that of the preceding, viz. to show that being Israelites was not enough to secure either exemption from divine judgments or the enjoyment of God’s favour. The passage is perfectly in point, for although the prophet is speaking of the national judgments which the people had brought upon themselves by their sins, and by which they were well nigh cut off entirely, yet it was necessarily involved in the destruction of the people for their idolatry and other crimes, that they perished from the kingdom of God. Of course the passage strictly proves what Paul designed to establish, viz. that the Jews, as Jews, were as much exposed to God’s judgments as others, and consequently could lay no special claim to admission into the kingdom of heaven.

Romans 9:29 · Open Word Bible

29And as Isaiah said earlier, "If the Lord of hosts had not left us some descendants, we would have become like Sodom and been made like Gomorrah."

Report a mistake

Paul here again follows the Septuagint. The only difference, however, is that the Greek version has ... a seed, instead of a@ remnant, as it is in the Hebrew. The sense is precisely the same. The Hebrew word means that which remains; and seed, as used in this passage, means the seed preserved for sowing. The figure, therefore, is striking and beautiful. Lord of Hosts is a frequent designation for the Supreme God in the Old Testament. As the word host is used in reference to any multitude arranged in order, as of men in an army, of angels, of the stars, or of all the heavenly bodies including the sun and moon, so the expression Lord of hosts may mean Lord of armies, Lord of angels, or Lord of heaven, or of the universe as a marshalled host; see 1 Kings 22: 19, “I saw the Lord sitting on his throne and all the host of heaven standing by him;” 2 Chron. 18:11. Ps, 103: 21. Ps. 148: 2, “ Praise ye him, all his angels, praise ye him, all his hosts.””? In other passages the reference is, with equal distinctness, to the stars, Jer. 33: 22. Deut. 4: 19, and frequently. It is most probable, therefore, that God is called Lord of hosts in reference to his headship over the whole heavens, and all that they contain, Lord of hosts being equivalent to Lord of the universe.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:30

(30) Having proved that God was free to call the Gentiles as well as the Jews into his kingdom, and that it had been predicted that the great body of the Jews were to be rejected, he comes now to state the immediate ground of this rejection. What shall we say then2 This may mean either, ‘What is the inference from the preceding discussion ?’ and the answer follows, ‘The conclusion is, the Gentiles are called and the Jews rejected;’ or, ‘What shall we say, or object to the fact that the Gentiles are accepted,’ &c. &e. So Flatt and others. But the former explanation is better suited to the context, especially to v. 32, and to the apostle’s common use of this expression; see v. 14, ch. 7: 7. 8: 31.

That the Gentiles, which followed not after righteousness, have attained, &c. The inference is, that what to all human probability was the most unlikely to occur, has actually taken place. The Gentiles, sunk in carelessness and sin, have attained the favour of God, while the Jews, to whom religion was a business, have utterly failed. Why is this? The reason is given in y. 32; it was because they would not submit to be saved on the terms which God proposed, but insisted on reaching heaven in theirown way. To follow after righteousness, is to press forward towards it as towards the prize in a race, Phil. 3: 14. The word ... , rendered righteousness, might more properly be rendered justification, the consequence of having fulfilled the law; a state of favour with God. It, therefore, includes all the blessings consequent on union to Christ; see Gal. 2:21. 3: 21.5: 5. This the Gentiles did not seek after, they cared nothing about the favour of God and the blessings therewith connected. But still they attained to righteousness, i. e. as before, justification, all the consequences of being righteous in the estimation of God.

Romans 9:30 · Open Word Bible

30What then are we to say? That Gentiles, who were not pursuing righteousness, have obtained it, the righteousness that comes by faith.

Report a mistake

Even the righteousness which is of faith, i. e. even that justification which is attained by faith. In all these clauses, however, the word righteousness, as expressing the sum of the divine requisitions, that which fulfils the law may be retained. ‘The Gentiles did not seek this righteousness, yet they attained it; not that righteousness which is of the law, but that which is through the faith of Christ, the righteousness of God (acceptable to God) by faith,’ Phil. 3: 9. They obtained that which satisfied the demands of the law, and was acceptable in the sight of God. It is very probable that Paul included both ideas in the word which he used, that is, both the excellence which satisfied the law, i. e. righteousness, and its consequence, i, e. justification.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:31

What the Gentiles thus attained, the Jews failed to seeure

(31) What the Gentiles thus attained, the Jews failed to seeure. The former he had described as “ not following after righteousness;” the latter he characterizes as those who follow after the law of righteousness. The expression law of righteousness may be variously explained. Law may be taken in its general sense of rwile, as in ch. 3: 27, and elsewhere. The meaning would then be, ‘They followed after, i. e. they attended diligently to, the rule which they thought would lead to their attaining righteousness or being justified, but they did not attain unto that rule which actually leads to such results.’ Or, 2. The word daw may be redundant, and Paul may mean to say nothing more than that ‘ The Jews sought righteousness or justification, but did not attain it.? This, no doubt, is the substance, though it may not be the precise form of the thought. In favour of this view is a comparison with the preceding and succeeding verses, and the fact that the word is elsewhere nearly redundant, as “law of sin,’’ ch. 7: 23, for sin itself. 3. Law of righteousness is often understood here as equivalent to legal righteousness, or, righteousness which is of the law. 'This, however, is rather forced, and not very consistent with the latter clause of the verse, “Have not attained to the law of righteousness,’ which can hardly be so interpreted. The term, however, may have one sense at the beginning of the verse and a different one at the close; and the passage be thus rendered, ‘Israel, following after the righteousness which is of the law, hath not attained to the true rule of righteousness.’ This suits the context, and is in accordance with Paul’s manner. The first interpretation, however, is probably the most correct.

Romans 9:31 · Open Word Bible

31But Israel, who pursued a law that held out righteousness, did not reach that law.

Report a mistake

Romans 9:32

(32) The reason why the Jews failed of securing the divine favour is thus stated. Because they sought it not by faith, but, as it were, by the works of the law. In other words, they would not submit to the method of justification proposed by God, which was alone suitable for sinners, and persisted in trusting to their own imperfect works. The reason why one man believes and is saved, rather than another, is to be sought in the sovereign grace of God, according to Paul’s doctrine in the preceding part of this chapter, and ch. 8: 28. 2 Tim. 1: 9, &c.; but the ground of the rejection and condemnation of men is always in themselves. The vessels of wrath which are destroyed, are destroyed on account of their sins. Noman, therefore, can throw the blame of his perdition on any other than himself. This verse, therefore, is very far from being inconsistent with the doctrine of the divine sovereignty as taught above. The force of the word rendered as it were, may be explained by paraphrasing the clause thus, ‘as though they supposed it could be obtained by the works of the law.’t See 2 Cor. 3: 5. 2: 7, ‘They sought it as (being) of the works of the law.’ For they stumbled at that stumbling stone. 'That is, they did as it had been predicted they would do, they took offence at the Messiah and at . the plan of salvation which he came to reveal.

Romans 9:32 · Open Word Bible

32Why not? Because they did not pursue it by faith, but as though it came by works. They stumbled over the stone that makes people stumble,

Report a mistake

Romans 9:33

What it was they stumbled at

(33) What it was they stumbled at, the apostle declares in this verse, and shows that the rejection of the Messiah by the Jews was predicted in the Old Testament. 42s it is written, Behold I lay in Zion a stumbling stone and a rock of ofSence; and whosoever believeth on him shall not be ashamed. This passage is apparently made up of two, one occurring in Is. 28: 16, the other in Is. 8: 14. In both of these passages mention is made of a stone, but the predicates of this stone, as given in the latter passage, are transferred to the other, and those there mentioned omitted. This method of quoting scrip- ¢ Waut’s Lexicon N. T. p.678. Wuyenr’s Grammatik, 497. ture is common among all writers, especially where the several passages quoted and merged into each other, refer to the same subject. It is obvious that the writers of the New Testament are very free in their mode of quoting from the Old, giving the sense, as they, being inspired by the same Spirit, could do authoritatively, without binding themselves strictly to the words. ‘The former of the two passages here referred to, stands thus, in our version, “ Behold I lay in Zion for a foundation a stone, a tried stone, a precious corner stone, a sure foundation; he that believeth shall not make haste,’’? which is according to the Hebrew. The other passage, Is. 8: 14, is, “ And he shall be for a sanctuary; but for a stone of stumbling and a rock of offence to both houses of Israel.’’

Romans 9:33 · Open Word Bible

33as it is written, "See, I am setting in Zion a stone to stumble on, a rock that makes them fall, and whoever believes in Him will not be put to shame."

Report a mistake

Isaiah 28, is a prophecy against those who had various false grounds of confidence, and who desired a league with Egypt as a defence against the attacks of the Assyrians. God says, he has laid a much more secure foundation for his church than any such confederacy, even a precious, tried corner stone; those who confided on it should never be confounded. The prophets, constantly filled with the expectation of the Messiah, and, in general, ignorant of the time of his advent, were accustomed, on every threatened danger, to comfort the people by the assurance that the efforts of their enemies could not prevail, because the Messiah was to come. Until his advent, they could not, as a people, be destroyed, and when he came, there should be a glorious restoration of all things; see Is. 7: 14d—16, and elsewhere. There is, therefore, no force in the objection, that the advent of Christ was an event too remote to be available to the consolation of the people, when threatened with the immediate invasion of their enemies. This passage, therefore, is properly quoted by the apostle, because it was intended originally to apply to Christ. The sacred writers of the New Testament so understood and explain it; see 1 Peter 2: 6. Matt. 21: 42. Acts 4:11; compare also Ps. 118: 22. 1 Cor. 3: 11. Eph. 2: 20, and other passages, in which Christ is spoken of as the foundation or corner stone of his church. The same interpretation of the passage was given by the ancient Jews. The other passage, Is. 8: 14, is of much the same character.

Report a mistake

God exhorts the people not to be afraid of the combination between Syria and Ephraim. The Lord of hosts was to be feared and trusted, he would be a refuge to those who confided in him, but a stone of stumbling and rock of offence to all others. This passage too, as appears from a comparison of the one previously cited with Ps. 118: 22, and the quotation and application of them by the New Testament writers, refers to Christ. What is said in the Old Testament of Jehovah, the inspired penmen of the New do not hesitate to refer to the Saviour; compare John 12: 41. Is. 6: 1. Heb. 1: 10, 11. Ps. 102: 25. 1 Cor. 10: 9. Ex. 17: 2,7. When God, therefore, declared that he should be a sanctuary to one class of the people, and a rock of offence to another, he meant that he, in the person of his Son, as the Immanuel, would thus be confided in by some, but rejected and despised by others. The whole spirit, opinions and expectations of the Jews were adverse to the person, character and doctrines of the Redeemer. He was, therefore, to them a stumbling block, as he was to others foolishness. They could not recognize him as their fondly anticipated Messiah, nor consent to enter the kingdom of heaven on the terms which he prescribed. In them, therefore, were fulfilled the ancient prophecies, which spoke of their rejection of Christ, and consequent excision from the people of God.

Report a mistake