Logia

Romans · Chapter 11 · The remnant of Israel

Romans 11:6

And if it is by grace, it does not come from works; otherwise grace would no longer be grace.

εἰ δὲ χάριτι, οὐκέτι ἐξ ἔργων, ἐπεὶ ἡ χάρις οὐκέτι γίνεται χάρις. Word by word ↓

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

8 commentators in Logia comment on Romans 11:6, from John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) to Frédéric Louis Godet (1812–1900): Chrysostom, Calvin, Evans, Bengel, Wesley, Haydock, Hodge and Godet.

Topics: Election and predestination

Two voices on Romans 11:6

Choose two:

What the church has said

See all 8 voices as a grid

Eras across, traditions down, each with its first words. An empty cell is a place the library has no voice yet.

Early churchReformationPuritans and the 1700sThe 1800s
Catholic–––
  • Haydock Ver. 6. It is not now by works: otherwise…
Protestant–
  • Calvin 6. If through grace, it is no more by…
  • Evans I. The Jews, it is true, were many of…
  • Bengel then) The conclusion drawn from the Old to the…
  • Wesley 6. And if by grace, then it is no…
  • Hodge (6) And if by grace, then it is no…
  • Godet Ver. 6. " Now, if it is by grace,…
Church Fathers
  • Chrysostom Ver. 6. “And if by grace, then it is…
–––

What does Chrysostom say about Romans 11:6?

John Chrysostom

c. 347–407 · Patristic (Greek East) · Homilies on the Epistle of St. Paul the Apostle to the Romans

Homily XVIII. Rom. X. 14, 15

Ver. 6. “And if by grace, then it is no more of works, otherwise grace is no more grace: but if it be of works, then is it no more grace, otherwise work is no more work.”

He again springs upon the disputatiousness of the Jews, in what has just been quoted; and on this ground bereaves them of excuse. For you cannot, he means, so much as say, that the Prophets called indeed, and God invited, and the state of things cried aloud, and the provoking to jealousy was enough to draw us to Him, but what was enjoined was grievous, and this is why we could not draw nigh, since we had a display of works demanded of us, and laborious well-doings. For you cannot even say this. For how should God have demanded this of you, when this would just throw His grace into the shade? And this he said out of a wish to show that He was most desirous that they might be saved. (Deut. v. 29.) For not only would their salvation be easily brought about, but it was also God’s greatest glory to display His love toward man. Why then are you afraid of drawing nigh, since you have no works demanded of you? Why are you bickering and quarrelsome, when grace is before you, and why keep putting me the Law forward to no purpose whatsoever? For you will not be saved by that, and will mar this gift also; since if you pertinaciously insist on being saved by it, you do away with this grace of God. Then that they might not think this strange, having first taken those seven thousand; he said that they were saved by grace. For when he says, “Even so then at this present time also there is a remnant according to the election of grace;” he shows that they also were saved by grace. And not hereby only, but likewise by saying, “I have reserved unto Myself.” For this is the language of One Who showeth that He Himself was the chief Contributor. ...

Report a mistake

... And if by grace, it will be said, how came we all not to be saved? Because ye would not. For grace, though it be grace, saves the willing, not those who will not have it, and turn away from it, who persist in fighting against it, and opposing themselves to it. Observe how throughout the point he is proving is, “Not as though the Word of God had taken none effect,” by showing that the worthy were those to whom the promise came, and that these, few though they be, may yet be the people of God; and indeed he had stated it in the beginning of the Epistle with much force, where he says, “For what if some did not believe” (Rom. iii. 3), and did not even stop at this, but proceeded, “Yea, let God be true, and every man a liar.” (ib. 4.) And here again he confirms it another way, and shows the force of grace, and that always the one were being saved, the other perished.

Report a mistake

What does Calvin say about Romans 11:6?

John Calvin

1509–1564 · Reformed · Commentaries on the Epistle of Paul the Apostle to the Romans

If through grace, it is no more by works

6. If through grace, it is no more by works, etc. This amplification is derived from a comparison between things of an opposite character; for such is the case between God’s grace and the merit of works, that he who establishes the one overturns the other.

But if no regard to works can be admitted in election, without obscuring the gratuitous goodness of God, which he designed thereby to be so much commended to us, what answer can be given to Paul by those infatuated persons, (phrenetici — insane,) who make the cause of election to be that worthiness in us which God has foreseen? For whether you introduce works future or past, this declaration of Paul opposes you; for he says, that grace leaves nothing to works. Paul speaks not here of our reconciliation with God, nor of the means, nor of the proximate causes of our salvation; but he ascends higher, even to this, — why God, before the foundation of the world, chose only some and passed by others: and he declares, that God was led to make this difference by nothing else, but by his own good pleasure; for if any place is given to works, so much, he maintains, is taken away from grace.

It hence follows, that it is absurd to blend foreknowledge of works with election. For if God chooses some and rejects others, as he has foreseen them to be worthy or unworthy of salvation, then the grace of God, the reward of works being established, cannot reign alone, but must be only in part the cause of our election. For as Paul has reasoned before concerning the justification of Abraham, that where reward is paid, there grace is not freely bestowed; so now he draws his argument from the same fountain, — that if works come to the account, when God adopts a certain number of men unto salvation, reward is a matter of debt, and that therefore it is not a free gift.

Report a mistake

Now, though he speaks here of election, yet as it is a general reasoning which Paul adopts, it ought to be applied to the whole of our salvation; so that we may understand, that whenever it is declared that there are no merits of works, our salvation is ascribed to the grace of God, or rather, that we may believe that the righteousness of works is annihilated, whenever grace is mentioned.

Report a mistake

What does Evans say about Romans 11:6?

John Evans

1680–1730 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume VI (Acts to Revelation): Romans, by John Evans

On Romans 11:1–32

This comment begins at Romans 11:1:

I. The Jews, it is true, were many of them cast off, but not all. The supposition of this he introduces with a God forbid. He will by no means endure such a suggestions. God had made a distinction between…

On Romans 11:1–32

This comment begins at Romans 11:1:

II. Another thing which qualified this doctrine of the rejection of the Jews was that though they were cast off and unchurched, yet the Gentiles were taken in (v. 11-14), which he applies by way of caution to the Gentiles,…

On Romans 11:1–32

This comment begins at Romans 11:1:

III. Another thing that qualified this doctrine of the Jews' rejection is that, though for the present they are cast off, yet the rejection is not final; but, when the fulness of time is come, they will be taken in…

On Romans 11:1–7

This comment begins at Romans 11:1:

1. There was a chosen remnant of believing Jews, that obtained righteousness and life by faith in Jesus Christ, v. 1-7. These are said to be such as he foreknew (v. 2), that is, had thoughts of love to, before…

On Romans 11:1–7

This comment begins at Romans 11:1:

(2.) He suggests that as in Elias's time, so now, this chosen remnant was really more and greater than one would think it was, which intimates likewise that it is no new nor unusual thing for God's grace and favour…

On Romans 11:1–7

This comment begins at Romans 11:1:

... So it was in Elijah's time. That which makes the show of a nation is the powers and the multitude. The powers of Israel were then persecuting powers: They have killed thy prophets, and digged down thine altars, and…

On Romans 11:1–7

This comment begins at Romans 11:1:

... It is his free and almighty grace that makes the difference between them and others.—Seven thousand: a competent number to bear their testimony against the idolatry of Israel, and yet, compared with the many thousands of Israel, a very…

On Romans 11:1–7

This comment begins at Romans 11:1:

... This is called a remnant according to the election of grace; they are such as were chosen from eternity in the counsels of divine love to be vessels of grace and glory. Whom he did predestinate those he called.…

On Romans 11:1–7

This comment begins at Romans 11:1:

... He calls the remnant of believers, not the elect, but the election, to show that the sole foundation of all their hopes and happiness is laid in election. They were the persons whom God had in his eye in…

What does Bengel say about Romans 11:6?

Johann Albrecht Bengel

1687–1752 · Lutheran Pietist · Gnomon of the New Testament, Vol. III (Romans, I and II Corinthians)

On Romans 11:5–6

This comment begins at Romans 11:5:

then) The conclusion drawn from the Old to the New Testament. ... by grace) The meaning of the dative is one, and that of the particle l-x. with the genitive is another [is different]. The former rather indicates the vehicle…

What does Wesley say about Romans 11:6?

John Wesley

1703–1791 · Anglican (Methodist) · Explanatory Notes upon the New Testament: Romans

And if by grace, then it is no more of works

6. And if by grace, then it is no more of works - Whether ceremonial or moral. Else grace is no longer grace - The very nature of grace is lost. And if it be of works, then it is no more grace: else work is no longer work - But the very nature of it is destroyed. There is something so absolutely inconsistent between the being justified by grace, and the being justified by works, that, if you suppose either, you of necessity exclude the other. For what is given to works is the payment of a debt; whereas grace implies an unmerited favour. So that the same benefit cannot, in the very nature of things, be derived from both.

Report a mistake

What does Haydock say about Romans 11:6?

George Leo Haydock

1774–1849 · Roman Catholic · Catholic Family Bible and Commentary: Romans

It is not now by works

Ver. 6. It is not now by works: otherwise grace is no more grace. The election of God, and the first grace at least, are always without any merits on our part; but if we speak of works done in a state of grace, and by the assistance of God’s grace, we co-operate with the graces given, and by thus co-operating, we deserve and merit a reward in heaven. Wi.—If salvation were to come by works, done by nature, without faith and grace, salvation would not be a grace or favour, but a debt; but such dead works are indeed of no value in the sight of God towards salvation. It is not the same with regard to works done with and by God’s grace; for to such works as these he has promised eternal salvation. Ch.

Report a mistake

What does Hodge say about Romans 11:6?

Charles Hodge

1797–1878 · Reformed (Presbyterian) · A Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, designed for students of the English Bible

And if by grace

(6) And if by grace, then it is no more of works; otherwise grace is no more grace. ‘This verse is an exegetical comment on the last clause of the preceding one. If the election spoken of be of grace, it is not founded on works, for the two things are incompatible. It evidently was, in the apostle’s view, a matter of importance that the entire freeness of the election of men to the enjoyment of the blessings of the Messiah’s kingdom, should be steadily kept in view. He would not otherwise have stopped in the midst of his discourse to insist so much on thisidea. This verse serves to illustrate several declarations of the apostle in the preceding chapter. For example, v. 11, in which, as here, men are said to be chosen in a sovereign manner, and not according to their works. It is obvious that foreseen works are as much excluded as any other. For a choice founded upon the foresight of good works, is as really made on account of works as any choice can be, and, consequently, is not of grace, in the sense asserted by the apostle. In the second place, the choice which is here declared to be so entirely gratuitous, is a choice to the kingdom of Christ. This is evident from the whole context, and especially from v. 7. It was from this kingdom and all its spiritual and eternal blessings that the Jews, as a body, were rejected, and to which “the remnant according to the election of grace’? was admitted. The election, therefore, spoken of in the ninth chapter, is not to external privileges merely.

Report a mistake

The latter part of this verse is simply the converse of the former. But if of works then it is no more grace; otherwise work is no more work. If founded on any thing in us, it is not founded on the mere good pleasure of God. If the one be affirmed, the other is denied. This latter clause is left out of so many of the ancient MSS. and versions, and passed over in silence by so many of the fathers, that the majority of editors are disposed to regard it as spurious. Internal evidence, and a comparison with similar passages, as Rom. 4: 4. Eph. 2: 8, 9, are rather in its favour.

Report a mistake

What does Godet say about Romans 11:6?

Frédéric Louis Godet

1812–1900 · Reformed (Swiss Protestant) · Commentary on St. Paul's Epistle to the Romans

On Romans 11:1–10

This comment begins at Romans 11:1:

The partial character of the rejection of God's people is proved, first, by the conversion of St Paul himself (ver. 1) ; then by the existence of a whole Judeo-Christian church (w. 2-6). And if this church does not contain…

Ver. 6. " Now, if it is by grace, then is it no mare of works ; since grace would he no more grace'* — The apostle wishes to express the idea, that if Israel possess this privilege of always preserving within their bosom a faithful remnant, it is not because of any particular merit they have acquired before God by their works ; it is purely a matter of grace on the part of Him who has chosen them. The instant there was introduced into this dispensation a meritorious cause, whether for little or for much, there would be taken away from grace its character of freeness ; it would no longer be what it is. Why add this idea here ? ... This is to do them too much honour. We should have had much graver and more numerous variants in the N. T. if copyists had proceeded so freely. It is much more probable that a reader composed a proposition parallel and antithetic to the former, and wrote it on the margin, whence it passed into the text Gases of this kind are frequent.

It is obviously wholly unnecessary, in order to explain this verse to hold, with the Tubingen school, that the apostle means to refute the Judeo-Christian principle of the mixing up of works and grace. Besides, would not the apostle have addressed himself directly in this case as he does to his (Gentile-Christian readers in the passage w. 13 and 14, which Yolkmar himself puts parallel to this ?

Report a mistake

Let us again remark the correlation between this passage, w. 1-6 and the preceding, ix. 6-13. The latter referred to the carnal portion of the nation, and proved the right God had to reject them (as much as Ishmael and Esau) ; the present passage refers to the faithful portion, and establishes the fact that ... has not failed to maintain a similar elect number in ... These two points of view taken together form the complete truth on the subject Beuss finds in tins passage two theories placed side by side with one another, biit which logic deems contradictoiy.'* The one, he thinks, is that of unconditional grace by which the holy renmant are kept in their fidelity ; the other that of works, by which Paul explains the rejection of the nation in general But there is no contradiction between these two points of view ; for if the faithfulness of the elect supposes the initiative of grace, it nevertheless implies faith on their part ; and if the mass of the nation are rejected, this rejection only arises from their voluntaiy and persevering resistance to the solicitations of grace.

Report a mistake

The apostle put the question whether the present relation between God and Israel was that of an absolute divorce ; and he began by answering : no, in the sense that a portion at least of Israel have obtained grace, and form henceforth the nucleus of the church. But, he adds, — for this is the other side of the truth, — it is certainly true that the greater part of the people have been smitten with hardness. This is what he expounds in w. 7-10, showing, as his habit is, that this severe measure was in keeping with the antecedents of the theocratic history and the declarations of Scripture. ... V. 7, 8. " What then i Israel hath not obtained that which he ... while the election hath ... it ; but the rest "Were hardened. According as it is toritten, God hath given them a spirit of torpor, eyes that they should not see, and ears that they should net hear, unto this day!* — By the question : What then t Paul means : If Israel are not really rejected, what then ? What has happened ? As he has elucidated this question in chap, x., he confines himself to summing up in a word all that he has explained above regarding the foolish conduct of Israel The object of their search, the justification to be obtained from God, having been pursued by them in a chimerical way (by means of human works), they have not attained the end which the elect have reached without trouble by faith. The present ... seekeih, for which there must not be substituted, with the oldest translations (see the critical note), the ... sought, indicates what Israel has done and is still doing at the very moment when the apostle is writing. — The elect then being once excepted, it is 'MB: ... instead of ... quite true that all {he rest, ... have been rejected, and that in the severest way : a judgment of hardening with which God has visited them. ...

Report a mistake

... The term ... to hardm, signifies in the strict sense : to deprive an organ of its natural sensibility ; morally : to take away from the heart the faculty of being touched by what is good or divine, from the understanding the faculty of discerning between the true and the false, the good and the bad. The sequel will explain how it is possible for such an effect to be ascribed to divine operation.

Report a mistake

Cited on other verses

Commentators citing Romans 11:6 while explaining another verse. The sentence is copied as the excerpt reads.

  • John Evans · Romans 12:1

    There is the mercy that is in God and the mercy that is from God—mercy in the spring and mercy in the streams: both are included here; but especially gospel-mercies (mentioned ch. ix.), the transferring of what the Jews forfeited and lost by their unbelief unto us Gentiles (Eph. iii. 4-6): the sure mercies of David, Isa. lv. 3.

  • Johann Albrecht Bengel · Romans 3:28

    If one be subtracted from two, one remains [comp. ch. xi. 6].

  • Johann Albrecht Bengel · Romans 11:32

    Vers.] all together; comp. ver. 30, 31. — sheriff ... might have mercy) His mercy being acknowledged by them, ver. 6, when faith is given to them by Himself.

  • Charles Hodge · Romans 9:11

    In the same sense our justification is said to be “ not of works,”’ Gal. 2: 16, and often; i. e. is not on the ground of works; see Rom. 11: 6.2 Tim. 1: 9.

  • David Brown · Luke 21:24

    … full time of that place in the Church which the Jews in their time had before them—after which, the Jews being again "grafted into their own olive tree," one Church of Jew and Gentile together shall fill the earth (Ro 11:1-36).

Whole homilies and tractates on Romans 11:6

In the creeds and councils on Romans 11:6

Creeds, conciliar decrees and confessions that cite this verse, oldest first. They are not commentary; each links to the whole document.

The Greek words

WordDictionary formGlossGrammar
εἰεἰIfConditional conjunction
δὲδέnowConjunction
χάριτιχάριςby graceNoun · dative singular feminine
οὐκέτιοὐκέτιno longerAdverb · negative
ἐξἐκfromPreposition
ἔργωνἔργονworksNoun · genitive plural neuter
ἐπεὶἐπείotherwiseConjunction
ἡὁ-Article · nominative singular feminine
χάριςχάριςgraceNoun · nominative singular feminine
οὐκέτιοὐκέτιno longerAdverb · negative
γίνεταιγίνομαιwould beVerb · present middle or passive (deponent) indicative · 3rd person singular
χάριςχάριςgraceNoun · nominative singular feminine

From MACULA (CC BY 4.0), as the Open Word Bible reads them.

How the Open Word Bible translates Romans 11:6

Word for word: If and by grace, no longer from works, since the grace no longer becomes grace.

if it is by grace: if the remnant is chosen by grace Grammar

The sentence leaves out its subject; it continues verse 5, where the remnant is chosen by grace.

works: anything people do to earn God's choice Word sense

Not: works of the law only

Elsewhere in Romans "works" are often the works the law requires (3:20, 3:28), but here they stand against grace in general, as in 4:4-5 and 9:11-12.

the sentence ends with "grace would no longer be grace" Manuscripts

Not: some later manuscripts add: "But if it is by works, it is no longer grace; otherwise work is no longer work"

The longer text is found in later manuscripts and in the King James Version; the oldest manuscripts do not have it. Reviewers must check the details against the SBLGNT apparatus.

Cross-references

  • 2 Timothy 1:9 He saved us and called us to a holy life, not because of anything we had done but because of His own purpose and grace. This grace was given us in Christ Jesus before eternal ages began,
  • Galatians 2:21 1 voice I do not cancel out God's grace. For if righteousness comes through the law, then Christ died for nothing at all.
  • Romans 4:4-5 8 voices A worker's wages are not counted as grace but as what is owed.
  • Romans 3:27-28 8 voices So what room is left for boasting? It has been shut out. By what law? A law of works? No, by the law of faith.
  • 1 Corinthians 15:10 It is God's grace that has made me what I am, and His grace to me was not wasted. Instead, I have toiled harder than all of them, though it was not I but God's grace working with me.

Cross-references from OpenBible.info (CC BY), most voted first.

Read Romans 11 with all its commentary