Frédéric Louis Godet · Commentary on St. Paul's Epistle to the Romans
Romans 11
80 excerpts on Romans 11, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
The partial character of the rejection of God's people is proved, first, by the conversion of St Paul himself (ver. 1) ; then by the existence of a whole Judeo-Christian church (w. 2-6). And if this church does not contain the entire Jewish people, it is the effect of a judgment of a partial hardening rendered necessary by the moral state of the people (w. 7-1 0).
Romans 11:1–10 · Open Word Bible
1So I ask: has God rejected His people? Certainly not! I myself am an Israelite, descended from Abraham, of the tribe of Benjamin. 2God has not rejected His people, whom He foreknew. Or do you not know what Scripture says in the story of Elijah, how he appealed to God against Israel? 3"Lord, they have killed Your prophets and demolished Your altars. I alone am left, and now they are trying to take my life." …
The apostle has proved in chap. ix. that when God elected Israel, He did not lose the right one ... to take the severest course against them, if it should be necessary. Then he has showed in chap. x. that in fact there was a real ground and moral necessity for this measure. He proceeds, finally to establish in chap. xi. that it was only taken in accordance with all due regard to the position of this people, and within the limits in which it should subserve the salvation of mankind and that of Israel themselves.
This chapter embraces the development of two principal ideas, and then a conclusion. The first idea is this : The rejection of Israel is not total, but partial (w. 1-10). It bears only on that portion referred to in the demonstration of God's right, given in chap. ix. The second : This partial rejection even is not eternal, but temporary (w. 11-32). For after it has served the various ends which God had in view in decreeing it, it shall come to an end, and the entire nation shall be restored, and with the Gentiles shall realize the final imity of the kingdom of God. The conclusion ... a glance at this whole vast plan of God, and the expression of the feeling of adoration which is inspired by the contemplation, vv. 33-36.
Romans 11:1 · Open Word Bible
1So I ask: has God rejected His people? Certainly not! I myself am an Israelite, descended from Abraham, of the tribe of Benjamin.
Ver. 1. / say, then. Hath God cast away His people t Let it not he ! For I also am an Israelite, of the seed of Abraham, of the tribe of Benjamin.'' — From all that preceded, chaps, ix. and X., the reader might have concluded that God had completely and finally broken with all that bore the name of 222 THE ... or the jews.
Israel ; hence the then. — The form of the question is such ... that ... can be expected. This is likewise indicated by the pronoun ... his, which of itself implies the maral impossibility of anch a measure. — The expression His people does not refer, as some have thought, to the elect part of the people only, but as the ... itself shows, to the Tiaiion as a whola It is evident, indeed, that the rest of the chapter treats not of the lot of the Israelifces who have believed in Jesus, but of the lot of the nation in its entixety. ... then, this question of ver. 1 is the theme of the whole chapter. — The apostle takes a first answer, by way of preface, from his own case. Is not he, a Jew of ... Israelitish descent, by the call which he has received from above, a living proof that ... has not cast away ... masse and without distinction the totality of His ancient people? De Wette and Meyer give a wholly different meaning to this answer. According to them, Paul would say: "I am too good an Israelite, too zealous a patriot, to be capable of affirming a thing so contrary to the interests of my people." ... if the interests of truth were not supreme, in Paul's view, over national affections I And what in this case would be meant by the epithets ... and of Benjamin, which Meyer allies against our explanation ? ...
... May not one, with his civil status as an Israelite perfectly unquestionable, ... port himself as a bad patriot 1 What Paul means by them is this : '' It is nothing my being an Israelite of the purest blood ; God has nevertheless made of me such as you see me, a true believer." Meyer still urges the objection of the exceptional position of a man like Paul ; but the apostle does not confine himself to pleading this personal fact; he adds to it immediately, from ver. 2 onwards, the patent fact of the whole Judeo-Ghristian portion of the church. — Weizsacker makes the important remaric on this ver. 1 : " Paul could not possibly take his proof from his own person, if the mass of the Christians of Rome were Judeo-Ghristian, and so themselves the best refutation of the objection raised."
Yv. 2, 3. God hath not east away His people which He ... Or wot ye not what the Scripture saith in the passage about Elias ; how he ... intercession to €hd ... Israel : Lord J they have killed Thy ... digged dawn Thine altars, and I am left alons, and they ... my lifer — The foimal denial whieh begina er. 2 is intended to ... the more general proofs the exposition of which ... with the words : Or wot ye not 1 Several commentatois ... explained the words; whom He ... as a ... narrowing the general notion of the people of Israel: ''He conld ... cast away the mass of the people, but not the foreknown elect who finm, strictly speaking, Hie people.'* This meaning is inadmissible ; for, as we have already ... in ver. 1, the matter in question here is not the lot of this elect portion, but that of the people as a whola Is it not of the entire people that the apostle speaks when, in yy. 28 and 29, he ... the election, they are loved for the ... sake ; for the ... and calling of God are without repentance"? These words are the authentic explanation of the expression in vex. 2 : ... people whom He foreknew. Of all the peoples of the earth one only was chosen and known beforehand, by an act of divine foreknowledge and love, as the people whose history would be identified with the realization of salvation. In all others salvation is the ... but here the notion of salvation is attached to the ... itself; not that the liberty of individuals is in the least compromised by this collective destination. The Israelites contemporary with Jesus might reject Him ; an indefinite series of generations may for ages perpetuate this fact of national unbelief. God is under no pressure ; time can stretch out as long as He pleases. ...
Romans 11:2–3 · Open Word Bible
2God has not rejected His people, whom He foreknew. Or do you not know what Scripture says in the story of Elijah, how he appealed to God against Israel? 3"Lord, they have killed Your prophets and demolished Your altars. I alone am left, and now they are trying to take my life."
... He will add, ... need be, ages to ages, until there come at length the generation disposed to open their eyes and freely welcome their Messiah. God foreknew this nation as believing and saved, and sooner or later they cannot ... to be botL As usual, the form : or know ye not, signifies : Or if ye allege the contrary, do ye forget" . . . — The expression ... literally, in ... is a form of quotation frequent in the N. T. (Mark xii 26 ; Luke xx. 37) and in the Babbins to denote : " in the passage of the Scriptures which contains the history of ... The preposition ... can signify nothing else here than against. To intercede against is a Strange expression, but fitted to bring out the abnormal state of the people in regard to whom the prophet could only pray thus, that is to say, protesting before God against their conduct. Gomp. 1 Kings xix. 10, 14, 18.
Ver. 3. In the Hebrew text the second clause of the verse is put first ; it is needless to seek an intention for this inversion.— Mention is made of " altars of God," though according to the law there was, properly speaking, only one legitimate altar, that of the sanctuary. But the law itself authorized, besides, the erection of altars in the places where God had visibly revealed ... (Ex. xx. 24), as at Bethel, for example. Moreover, participation in the legitimate altar being interdicted within the kingdom of the ten tribes, it is probable that in such circumstances the faithful ventured to sacrifice elsewhere than at Jerusalem (1 Kings viii 29). — Meyer interprets the word ... in this sense : '' alone of all the prophets." This meaning seems to us incompatible with God's answer. The seven thousand are not prophets, but simple worshippers. Elijah, in that state of deep discouragement into which foregoing events had plunged him, no longer saw in Israel any others than idolaters, or believers too cowardly to deserve the name.
Romans 11:3 · Open Word Bible
3"Lord, they have killed Your prophets and demolished Your altars. I alone am left, and now they are trying to take my life."
Vv. 4, 5. " But what saith the answer of God unto him t I have reserved to myself seven thousand men, who have not lowed the knee to Baal. Even so then, at this present time also there is a remnant ... to the election of grace," — ... the direction of a matter, and hence : a decision of authority ; then: a divine declaration, an oracle (Matt ii 12). — It is impossible to apply the words : '' I have reserved to myself," to the temporal preservation of this elect body of pious Israelites, in the midst of the judgments which are soon to burst on Israel. It is in the spiritual sense, as faithful worshippers in the midst of reigning idolatry, that God reserves them to Himself. They are the leaven kept by His ... in the midst of His degenerate people. — It is impossible to understand what leads Hofmann to take ... as the third person plural : *' They (the persecutors) have left me seven thousand men." This cannot be the meaning in the Hebrew, where the grammar is opposed to it ; and as little the sense meant by Paul, where the words to myself and according to the ... of grace, ver. 5, prove that lie is speaking of the action of God Himself. The ... does not belong to the Hebrew text ; it is added by Panl to bring more into relief the settled purpose of grace in this preservation. — The substantive ... Baal, is preceded by the feminine if: "the (female) ... This form is surprising, for Baal, the god of the sun among the Phoenicians, was a masculine divinity, to whom Astarte, the goddess of the moon, corresponded, as the female divinity. By the LXX. the name Baal is sometimes used as feminine, sometimes as masculina In our passage this version uses it in the latter way. To explain the female form as used here by Paul, it has been thought that Baal was sometimes ... as a hermaphrodite divinity. ...
Romans 11:4–5 · Open Word Bible
4But what was God's answer to him? "I have kept for Myself seven thousand people who have not bent the knee to Baal." 5In the same way, at the present time too there is a remnant, chosen by grace.
... But in 1 Sam. vii 4, we find Baal put along with Astarte, and both in the feminine form. It seems to us more natural simply to understand the feminine substantive ... the image, in the sense of: ''the statue ... Meyer objects that in that case the article ... would be required before ... But the Jews took pleasure in identifying false gods with their images, as if to say that the god was nothing more than his material representation. The Babbins, in this same contemptuous spirit, had invented the term Elohoih to designate idols, a feminine plural of Elohim, and several have been thereby led to suppose that our feminine article might be explained by a feeling of the same kind. This explanation is not impossible ; but the previous one seems to me the more simpla
Ver. 5. This verse applies the case of the seven thousand to present circumstances. The remnant, of whom the apostle speaks, evidently denotes the small portion of the Jewish people who in Jesus have recognised the Messiah. The term ... remnant, is related to the preceding verb ... I have reserved to ... kept. There is no reference whatever to the members of the Jewish people who shall survive the destruction of Jerusalem, and shall be preserved to go into exila These form, on the contrary, the rejected portion to whom the words, w. 7-1 0, apply. — The three particles which connect this verse with the preceding context : so, then, also, refer, the first, to the internal resemblance of the two facts, for the same principle is realized in both; the second, to the moral necessity with which the one follows from the other in ... of this analogy. The third ... indicates the addition of a new example to the fonner. — The words: ... to the deetion of grace, might apply to the individuah more or less numerous who are embraced in this remnant, now become the ... of the ... The word dedion would in that case be explained, as in the case of the elect in general, via 29, 30, by the fact of the foreknowledge which God had of their fetith. But the matter in question throughout the whole of this chapter is the lot of the Jewish people in general ; it is therefore to them in their entirety that the idea of the divine election refers; comp. w. 2 and 28. One thing indeed follows from the election of grace applied to the whole of Israel ; not the salvation of such or such individuals, but the indestructible existence of a believing remnant at all periods of their history, even in the most disastrous crises of unbeUef, as at the time of the ministry of Elias, or of the coming of Jesus Christ. ...
Romans 11:5 · Open Word Bible
5In the same way, at the present time too there is a remnant, chosen by grace.
... The idea contained in the words : according to the election of grace," is therefore this : In virtue of the election of Israel as the salvation-people, God has not left them in our days without a faithful remnant, any more than He did in the kingdom of the ten tribes at the period when a far grosser heathenism was triumphant
Ver. 6. " Now, if it is by grace, then is it no mare of works ; since grace would he no more grace'* — The apostle wishes to express the idea, that if Israel possess this privilege of always preserving within their bosom a faithful remnant, it is not because of any particular merit they have acquired before God by their works ; it is purely a matter of grace on the part of Him who has chosen them. The instant there was introduced into this dispensation a meritorious cause, whether for little or for much, there would be taken away from grace its character of freeness ; it would no longer be what it is. Why add this idea here ? ... This is to do them too much honour. We should have had much graver and more numerous variants in the N. T. if copyists had proceeded so freely. It is much more probable that a reader composed a proposition parallel and antithetic to the former, and wrote it on the margin, whence it passed into the text Gases of this kind are frequent.
It is obviously wholly unnecessary, in order to explain this verse to hold, with the Tubingen school, that the apostle means to refute the Judeo-Christian principle of the mixing up of works and grace. Besides, would not the apostle have addressed himself directly in this case as he does to his (Gentile-Christian readers in the passage w. 13 and 14, which Yolkmar himself puts parallel to this ?
Romans 11:6 · Open Word Bible
6And if it is by grace, it does not come from works; otherwise grace would no longer be grace.
Let us again remark the correlation between this passage, w. 1-6 and the preceding, ix. 6-13. The latter referred to the carnal portion of the nation, and proved the right God had to reject them (as much as Ishmael and Esau) ; the present passage refers to the faithful portion, and establishes the fact that ... has not failed to maintain a similar elect number in ... These two points of view taken together form the complete truth on the subject Beuss finds in tins passage two theories placed side by side with one another, biit which logic deems contradictoiy.'* The one, he thinks, is that of unconditional grace by which the holy renmant are kept in their fidelity ; the other that of works, by which Paul explains the rejection of the nation in general But there is no contradiction between these two points of view ; for if the faithfulness of the elect supposes the initiative of grace, it nevertheless implies faith on their part ; and if the mass of the nation are rejected, this rejection only arises from their voluntaiy and persevering resistance to the solicitations of grace.
The apostle put the question whether the present relation between God and Israel was that of an absolute divorce ; and he began by answering : no, in the sense that a portion at least of Israel have obtained grace, and form henceforth the nucleus of the church. But, he adds, — for this is the other side of the truth, — it is certainly true that the greater part of the people have been smitten with hardness. This is what he expounds in w. 7-10, showing, as his habit is, that this severe measure was in keeping with the antecedents of the theocratic history and the declarations of Scripture. ... V. 7, 8. " What then i Israel hath not obtained that which he ... while the election hath ... it ; but the rest "Were hardened. According as it is toritten, God hath given them a spirit of torpor, eyes that they should not see, and ears that they should net hear, unto this day!* — By the question : What then t Paul means : If Israel are not really rejected, what then ? What has happened ? As he has elucidated this question in chap, x., he confines himself to summing up in a word all that he has explained above regarding the foolish conduct of Israel The object of their search, the justification to be obtained from God, having been pursued by them in a chimerical way (by means of human works), they have not attained the end which the elect have reached without trouble by faith. The present ... seekeih, for which there must not be substituted, with the oldest translations (see the critical note), the ... sought, indicates what Israel has done and is still doing at the very moment when the apostle is writing. — The elect then being once excepted, it is 'MB: ... instead of ... quite true that all {he rest, ... have been rejected, and that in the severest way : a judgment of hardening with which God has visited them. ...
... The term ... to hardm, signifies in the strict sense : to deprive an organ of its natural sensibility ; morally : to take away from the heart the faculty of being touched by what is good or divine, from the understanding the faculty of discerning between the true and the false, the good and the bad. The sequel will explain how it is possible for such an effect to be ascribed to divine operation.
Yer. 8. Holy Scripture had already either witnessed to an operation of God in this direction in certain cases, or had raised the foreboding of it in regard to the Jews. So when Moses said to the people after their exodus from Egypt, Deut. xxix. 4 : *' The Lord hath not given you an heart to perceive, and eyes to see, and ears to hear, unto this day." And yet (ver. 2) ''they had seen all that the Lord did before their eyes." All the wonders wrought in the wilderness they had seen in a sort without seeing them ; they had heard the daily admonitions of Moses without hearing them, because they were under the weight of a spirit of insensibility ; and this judgment which had weighed on them during the forty years of their rejection in the wilderness continued still at the time when Moses spoke to them in the plains of Moab, when they were preparing to enter Canaan : until thia day. In quoting this remarkable saying, Paul modifies it slightly; for the first words : *' God hath not given ... a heart to perceive,** he substitutes a somewhat different expression, which he borrows from Isa. xxix. 10 : ''The Lord hath ... upon you the spirit of deep sleep." The negative form of which Moses had made use (" God hath not given you " . . . ) perfectly suited the epoch when this long judgment was about to close : " God hath not yet bestowed on you this gracious gift to this day ; but He is about to grant it at length ! " . While, when the apostle wrote, the ... form used by Isaiah to express the same idea was much more appropriate : " God hath poured out on you" . . . The state of Israel indeed resembled in an respects that of the people when in Isaiah's time they ran blindfold into the punishment of captivity. ...
Romans 11:8 · Open Word Bible
8as it is written, "God has given them a spirit of numbness, eyes that do not see and ears that do not hear, to this very day."
... Hence it is that Paul prefers for those first words the form of Isaiah to that of Moses. — There is something paradoxical in the expres- 2S0 THE ... the jews. sion: a ... torpor; for usually tiie spiiit loases and ... instead of ... insensible. Bat God can also put in opeiation a paralysing ... It is peihaps in this second sense that the LXX. have taken it, who use it pretty frequently, as in our passage, to translate the Hebrew term Tnardema, deep deep. This second derivation is learnedly combated by Fritzsche ; but it has again quite recently been defended by Yolkmar, If we bring into dose connection, as St Paul does here, the saying of Isaiah with that of Deuteronomy, we must prefer the notion of torpor or stupor to that of deep; for the subject in question in the context is not a man who is sleeping, but one who, while having his eyes open and seeing, sees not — The works of God have two aspects, the one external, the material fact ; the other internal, the divine thought contained in the fact And thus it comes about, that when the eye of the soul is paralysed, one may see those works without seeing them; comp. Isa. ... Matt xiiL 14, 15; ... xii 40, etc — Tbe apostle adds in the following verses a seoond ... taken from Ps. Ixix. 22 and 23.
Yv. 9, 10. ''And Damd mith. Let their table he made a snare and a trap and a ... and [so'] a recompense unto them ! Let their eyes he darkened that they may not see ; and how down ... hade alway ! " — Paul ascribes this psalm to David, according to the title and Jewish tradition ; he does not trouble with criticism. Is this title erroneous, as is alleged by our modem ... They ... which dose the psalm, and in which we have mention made of the liberated captives who shall rebuild and possess the cities of Judah, expressions which naturally apply to the time of tiie ... on the other hand, the ... speaks of that zeal for the hoose of God which eats him up ; which. ... the existence of the temple. ... more, the ... who oppress him are expressly designated as ... of God's ... they are his ... his mother's children" ... they shall be blotted oat of the book of life" (ver. 28) ; their name was therefore inscribed in it; they are not the ... Einally, what is stronger : those enemies, his ... enjoy perfect external weU-being ; while they give the Psalmist, the object of their hatred, gaU to ... they ... sit at table and sing as they drink strong drink (yy. 22 and 11, 12); a singular description of the state of the Jews in captivity ! It must therefore be held that the last verses of the ... (w. 33-36) were, like the last and perfectly similar verses of Ps. li (w. 16 and 19), added to the hymn later, when the exiled people applied it to their national sufferings. The original description is that of the ... ...
Romans 11:9–10 · Open Word Bible
9And David says, "May their table turn into a snare and a net, a stumbling block and a just penalty for them. 10May their eyes grow dark so that they cannot see, and keep their backs bent forever."
... Israelite suffering for the cause of God ; and his adversaries, to whom the curses contained in the two verses quoted by Paul refer, are all the enemies of this just one within the theocracy itself, from Saul persecuting David down to the Jewish enemies of Jesus Christ and His Ghurck— The ... is, in the Psalmist's sense, the emblem of the material pleasures in which the ungodly live. Their life of gross enjoyments is to become to them what the snares of all sorts with whidi men catch them are to the lower animals. It is ... to avoid thinking that the apostle is here applying tills figure in a spiritual sense ; for the punishment which he has in view is of a spiritual nature ; it is, moral hardening. The cause of such a judgment must therefore be something else than simple worldly enjoyment; it is, as we have seen, the proud confidence of Israel in their ceremonial works. The ... is therefore, in Paul's sense, the emblem of pre sumptuous ... founded on their fidelity to acts of worship, whether the reference be to the table of show-bread as a ... of the Levitical ... in general, or to the sacrificial feasts. These works, on which they reckoned to save them, ... precisely what is mining ... Psalmist expresses the idea of ruin only by two terms : those of mare and net (in the LXX. ... net, and ... . Paul adds a tinid, ... strictly prey, and hence : every means of catching prey. This third term is taken from Ps. ... 8 (in the LXX.), where it is used as a parallel to ... net, in a passage every way similar to that of Ps, ... ...
... By this accumulation of almost synonymous terms, Paul means forcibly to express the idea that it will be impossible for them to escape, because no kind of snare will be wanting; first the Tiet ... then the weapons of the chase ... and finally the trap which causes the prey to faU into the pit ... . — The Hebrew and the LXX., as we have said, contain only two of these terms, the first and the third. Instead of the second, the ... read another regimen: ... for a recompense. Whence comes this expression? They have evidently meant thereby to render the word ... for those who are in security, which in the Hebrew text is put between the words ... and ... Only, to render it as they have done, they must have read ... (probably after another reading). This substantive is derived from the verb ... to he complete, whence in the ... to recompense It therefore signifies recompense ; hence this ... for a recompense, in the LXX. Paul borrows from them this expression ; but he puts it at the end as a sort of conclusion : and so in just retribution/' In ver. 10 the apostle continues to apply to the present judgment of Israel (hardening) the expressions of the Psalmist. The reference is to ... darkening of the imderstanding which follows on the insensibility of the heart (ver. 9), to such a ... that the Gentiles, with their natural good sense, understand the gospel better than those Jews who have been instructed and cultivated by divine revelation. — The last words : low down their reins, are an invocation ; they refer to the state of slavish fear in which the Jews shall be held as long as this judgment of hardening which keeps them outside of the gospel shall last They are slaves to their laws, to their Babbins, and even to their God (viii 15). We must beware of thinking, as Meyer does, that this chastisement is their punishment for the rejection of the Messiah. ...
... It is, on the contrary, that rejection which is in the apostle's eyes the realization of the doom of hardening previously pronounced upon them. As St John shows, xii 37 ... seq., the Jews would not have rejected Jesua if their eyes had not been already blinded and their ears stopped. It could only be under the weight of one of those judgments which visit man with a spirit of torpor, that any could fail to discern the raying forth of the gloiy of God in the person of Jesus Christ, as the apostle declares, 2 Cor. iv. 4, In this passage he ascribes the act of blinding to the god of this world, who has cast a veil over the spirit of his subjects. This means, as is seen in. the book of Job, that God proves or punishes by leaving Satan to act, and it may be by the spirit of torpor mentioned in ver. 8, as with that spirit of lying whom the Lord sent to seduce Ahab in the vision of the prophet Micaiah, 1 Kings xxii. 10 ... seq. However this may be, the rejection of Jesus by the Jews was the effect, not the ... of the hardening. The cause — Paul has clearly enough said, ix. 31-33 — was the obstinacy of their self-righteousness,
Yv. 11, 12. "I say then, Have iheg ... (hat they ... fail t Let it riot he ! But ... Uieir fail ... is come unto the ... to provoke theni to ... Now, if the fall of them he the riches of the world, and the ... of them the riches of the ... how much more will he their fidness ! " — The then indicates that this new question is occasioned by the preceding development : '' A portion have been hardened; is it then for ever?" The question with ... anticipates a negative answer. ... According to Beuss, the apostle means to say, God has for the present hardened the Jews that the gospel ... be carried to the (jentiles." If by this the author means anew to ascribe to Sb Paul the idea of die ... decree in virtue of which God disposes of saen ... of their moral ... tibe apostie's ... It is through the fault of Iscael that it has been impossible for the proaching of the gospd to the Gentiles to be earned out except by God's Ineaking vith the chosen people. I indeed, this ... had lent themselyes ... intelligenoe and love to God's purpose toward the rest of mankind, they would willingly have let fall their theocratic pretensions ; and, substituting the righteousness of faith for that of the law, they would themselves have become God's ... to the ... the grace they enjojed. But as their national ... did not permit them to enter on this path, and as they wished at any cost to maintain their ... system, God was obliged to blind them, so that they should not in Jesus recognise their Messiah. Otherwise the gospel would have been Judaized ; believing Grentiles would have required to become the proselytes of Isxael, and this would have been an end of salvation for the world, and of the world for salvation. ...
Romans 11:11–12 · Open Word Bible
11So I ask: did they stumble so as to fall for good? Certainly not! Rather, through their wrongdoing salvation has come to the Gentiles, so that Israel would become jealous. 12Now if their wrongdoing means riches for the world, and their loss means riches for the Gentiles, how much greater riches their fullness will bring!
... Moreover, in consequence of the proud contempt of the Jews for the Gentiles, there would have been fanned between them and the latter such a relation of enmity, that if Christianity offered itself to the world under cover of this detested Judaism, it would, no doubt, have gained some adherents, but it would have been the object of the antipathy which the Grentile world felt to the Jewish peopla In these circumstances, God, who wished the salvation of the world, necessarily required to disentangle the cause of the ... from that of Judaism, and even to oppose them to cme another. And this is what was brought about by the refusal of Israel to recognise Jesus as the Messiah. The preaching of the Christ, delivered by this veiy separation, was able, free from all hindrance, to inike its flight over the woxld. Once, then, Israel had become by their own fault what they were God could evidently not act otherwise, if He would save the Gentiles ; but nothing forced Israel to beoome tuck. There is nothing here, therefore, of an unconditional decree ; it is ever the same law we meet with: God's plan embracing the ... of human liberty, and making them turn to its own fulfilment.
Bnt that is not ... Wonderful result! Israel, haviug been unwilling to concur with God in saving the Gentiles must end by being themselves saved through their salvation. It is undoubtedly a humiliation for them to be the last to enter where they should have introduced all others ; but on God's part it is the height of mercy. Here is the more remote end (for which the conversion of the Gtentiles becomes a means), which Paul indicates in the words borrowed from the passage of Moses quoted above, ... 19: "to provoke them to jealousy" Seeing aU the blessings of the kingdom, ... justification, the Holy Spirit, adoption, shed down abundantly on the Gentile nations through faith in Him whom they have rqected, how can they help saying at length : These blessings are ours ? And how can they help opening their eyes and recognising that Jesus is the Messiah, since in Him the works predicted of the Messiah are accomplished ? How shall the elder son, seeing his younger brother seated and celebrating the feast at his ... table, fail to ask that he may re-enter the paternal home and come to sit down side by side with his brother, after throwing himself into the arms of their common father? Such is the spectacle of which Paul gives us a glimpse in the words : to provoke them to jealousy. The sin of the Jews could modify God's plan, but by no means prevent it
God has not then, absolutely speaking, rejected His people ; but it is perfectly true that He has hardened and rejected a portion of tiiem. Yet there are two restrictions to be noted here : This chastisement is only partial ; and, besides, it is only temporary. It is this second idea which is developed in the following passage. It is obvious how far Beuss is mistaken when he calls this second passage, in relation to the former, a second explanation." This critic's constant idea is that of contradictoiy points of view placed in juxtaposition in the apostle's writing. On the contrary, the following passage is the logical complement of the preceding : ' And this chastisement, which has fallen on Israel only partially, is itself only for a time."
This passage includes four sections, having each a distinct subject The first, w. 11—15, points out the two ... the proximate and the Jiruil, of the rejection of the Jews. The proximate end was to ... the ... of the ... the final end is to restore the Jews themselves by means of the converted Gentiles, and that to bring down at length on the latter the fulness of divine blessing, 234 THE ... or the jews.
to pat tiie Gentiles on their goaid against the pride ... they might he inspixed by the position which is made theirs to the present in the ... of God, as well as against oontempt of the Jews into which they might be carried In the third, ... 25-29, Paul announces positively, as a matter of revelation, the ... of the final ... of Israd.
'finally, the fourth, w. 30-32, contains a general view of the course of divine work in the accomplishment of salvation.
It is impossible, in a subject so difficult, to imagine a simpler and more logical order.
Romans 11:11–32 · Open Word Bible
11So I ask: did they stumble so as to fall for good? Certainly not! Rather, through their wrongdoing salvation has come to the Gentiles, so that Israel would become jealous. 12Now if their wrongdoing means riches for the world, and their loss means riches for the Gentiles, how much greater riches their fullness will bring! 13Now I am speaking to you who are Gentiles. So since I am an apostle to the Gentiles, I make much of my ministry, …
Yer. 12. The ... ia that of gradation: well then. It is a new and more joyous perspective still which the apostle opens up. If the exclusion of the Jews, by allowing the gospel to be presented to the world freed from every legal form, has opened for it a large entrance among the Gentiles, what will be the result of the restoration of this people, if it shall ever be realized? What blessings of higher excellence for the whole world may not be expected from it ! Thus the apostle advances from step to step in the explanation of this mysterious decree of rejection. This inferiority may be one in relation to an enemy ; in this case the verb means : to he overcome (2 Pet ii. 19), and the substantive derived from it signifies defeat (clades). Or the inferiority may refer to a state fixed on as normal, and below which one falls. The substantive in this case denotes a deficit, a fall Of these two meanings the first is impossible here ; for the enemy by whom Israel would be beaten could be no other than God ; now in the context this thought is inapplicable. The second and only admissible sense may be applied either qualitatively or numerically. In the former case, the subject in question is a level of spiritual life beneath which Israel has fallen; ... 1 Cor. vi 7: ''There is utterly an inferiority, ... (a moral deficit), among you because ye go to law one with another," and 2 Cor. xiL 13. Applied here, this meaning would lead to the following explanation : " The moral degradation of Israel has become the cause of the enriching of the Gentiles.'' But there is something repugnant in this idea, and, besides, we should be obliged by it to take the substantive ... the fulness, which corresponds to it, also in the moral sense : the perfect spiritual state to which the Jews shall one day be restored. ...
Romans 11:12 · Open Word Bible
12Now if their wrongdoing means riches for the world, and their loss means riches for the Gentiles, how much greater riches their fullness will bring!
... Now this meaning is impossible in view of ver. 25, where this expression evidently denotes the totality of the ... xiations. We are therefore led by this antithesis to the numerical meaning of ... to a small nuniber (of believers) : If their diminishing as God's people to a very small number of individuals (those who have received the Messiah) has formed the riches of the world, how much more their restoration to the complete state of a people" . .! ... In the application of this term to the people of Israel, we must regard the abstract notion of a people as the empty frame to be fiUed, and the totality of the individuals in whom this notion is realized, as that which fills the frame. — 'From what we have said above, we must set aside meanings of a qualitative nature, such as: *'the fulness of the Messianic salvation," or the restoration of Israel to ... normal position," or the state of spiritual perfection to which it is destined (Fritza, Stick., Hofm.). Neither can the meaning be admitted which Philippi ascribes to the two words ... and ... he supplies as their understood complement the idea of the kingdom of God, and explains: the blank produced in the kingdom of God by their rejection," and " the filling up of this blank by their readmisaion." This is to do violence to the meaning of the genitives ... and to introduce into the text an idea (that of the kingdom of God) which is nowhere indicated.
Yv. 13—16 are a more particular application to St Paul's ministry of the ideas expounded w. 11 and 12; for this nunis had a decisive t to play in ... the plan of God sketched in these two last verses; and the feelings with which Paul discharged his apostleship must be in harmony with the course of God's work. This is exactly what he shows in these three verses.
Vv. 13-15. " For I say it to you, you Gentiles, Inas- ... T. R reads ... {/or), with D E F G L, It, while K A B P, Syr. read ... (row then), and G : ... apodle of the Gfentilu, I ... mine office: if by ... means I may frovoke to ... whitih are my ... and ... iome of them. For if the, casting ... of them ie ... of the world, what shall ths restoring of thein, he, but a ... from the dead t "—It is somewhat difficult to decide between the two readings ... {for) and ... The authortties aie balanced ; but it is probable that the 84 ... has been substitnted for for, because the observation which begins ver. 13 was connected with the preceding veise in this sense: Now I tell you that (the preceding) specially yon Gentiles." And as this ... is decidedly mistaken and the apostle's observation refers manifestly to what follows (w. 13-15), there is reason to believe that the true connection is that which is expressed by for. And in fact the natural transition from w. 11 and 12 to w, 13-15 is this: "What I have just told you of the magnificent effects which will one day be produced among you Gentiles by the restoration of the Jews, is so true that it is even in your interest and as your apostle, the apostle to you Gentiles, that I ... to labour for the salvation of the Jews ; for I know aU that will one day accrue to you from their national conversion, a true spiritual resurrection (ver. 15)." There is a wholly different and widespread way of imderstanding the meaning of these three verses. It is to take vy. 13 and 14 as a sort of parenthesis or episode, and to regard ver. 15 as a somewhat more emphatic repetition of ver. 12; comp. for example, w. 9 and 10 of chap. ... ...
Romans 11:13–15 · Open Word Bible
13Now I am speaking to you who are Gentiles. So since I am an apostle to the Gentiles, I make much of my ministry, 14in the hope that somehow I may make my own flesh and blood jealous and save some of them. 15For if their rejection means the reconciliation of the world, what will their acceptance mean? Nothing less than life from the dead!
... In that case, what the apostle would say in this parenthesis (w. 13 and 14) would be this ; '' If I labour so ardently in my mission to the Gentiles, it is that I may thereby stimulate my ... the Jews, to seek conversion." It is the opposite thought from that which we have been expressing. This meaning occurs in almost all the commentaries. But, 1st It is impossible to understand how Paul could say that as the apostle of the OentUes; he would rather say it though their apostle and as a Jew by birtL 2d. After an interruption like that of w. 13 and 14, it would be unnatural to make the /or of ver. 16 bear on rer. 12. This is what renders the case so different from that of chap. v. 9 10. Let us study our text more closely, and we shall certainly be led to the first meaning which we have stated The emphasis is not on the fact that in labouring for the conversion of the Oentiles he is labouring in the end for that of the Jews, — which is qndoubtedly true, w. 13 and 14, — but on the fact that in labouring thus for the conversion of the Jews he is in that veiy way labouring for the good of the Gentiles, who are his proper charge, w. 13-15. , To you, ... Baur and his disciples ... and ako Mangold, allege that this style of address embiaces only a fraction of the church, the members of Gentile origin, who are only a weak minority. Meyer rightly answers that in that case Paul must have written : ... I address ihose of you who are of Gentile origin." ...
... Weizsacker, in the often quoted work (p. 257), likewise observes with reason, that the form employed being the only direct style of address used to the readers in this whole passage, it is natural to apply it to the entire church ; that one may consequently conclude from these words with the utmost certainty that members of Gentile origin formed the preponderating element in this church. We shall ask further, if in the opposite case Paul could have called the Jews my flesh, as ... in his own name only, while the great majority of his readers shared with him the characteristic of being ... And what does the apostle say to those Gentiles who have become believers ? The conjunction ... may signify as long as, or inasmuch as. It is clear that the notion of time has no application here, and that the second sense is the only possible one; comp. Matt xxv. 40. By this expression Paul distinguishes in his own person two men : one, in whose name he is here speaking ; that is, as he says, the ... Oentiles. Who is the other ? That is understood of itself, and the following expression : /tot; ... which should be translated by : my own fl>esh (in consequence of the prominent position of the pronoun ... reveals it clearly enough : it is A Jew in him. What does he mean then ... That if as a Jew who has become a believer he certainly feels the desire to labour for the salvation of ... fellow-countrymen ... flesh), he strives all the more to do so as the apostle of the Gentiles, because the conversion of his people must end in loading the Grentiles with all the riches of the blessings of the gospel The sequel will explain how (ver. 15). In this connection of ideas there is no doubt that the ... which the T. R reads after ... ocop, and which ia rejected by the ... reading, belongs really to the text. ...
... For this particle is intended to fix and bring out forcibly the character belonging to Paul of apostle to the Gentiles, in opposition to the other which he also possesses. The word is supported, besides, even by the Alexs., which read fihf ... As to this ... added by the latter, it is evidently, as Meyer himself acknowledges, a gloss, occasioned by the fact that the first proposition was connected with ver. 12, in order to begin afterwards a wholly new sentence.
What does Paul understand by the expression : I magnify mine office t These words might be applied to the defences which he was constantly obliged to make of his apostleship, to the narratives in which he proclaimed before the churches the marvellous successes which God granted him (Acts xv. 12, xxi. 19 ; 1 Cor. xv. 9, 10). But instead of contributing to bring the Jews to faith (ver. 14), such recitals could only embitter them. It is therefore of the zeal and activity displayed by him in the service of his mission that the apostle is thinking. To magnify his ministry as the apostle of the Gentiles, is to convert as many heathens as possible. And thereby at what remoter result is he aiming ? He tells us in ver. 14.
Ver. 14. He would try if in any way ... comp. Phil, iii. 11) he may reach the end, by dint of success, of awakening his people, whom he loves as his own ... from their torpor, should it only be by jealousy ! Here, as in ver. 11, he uses the expression which Moses had employed (x. 19). No doubt he does not deceive himself; he does not reckon on a conversion of Israel ... Tnasse before the last times; but he would like at least, he adds, to save some of them, as first-fruits of the harvest But we are not at the goal. That even is only a means. The final aim is declared in ver. 15.
Romans 11:14 · Open Word Bible
14in the hope that somehow I may make my own flesh and blood jealous and save some of them.
Ver. 15. In truth, it will not be tUl the national conversion of Israel take place, that the work of God shall reach its perfection among the Gentiles themselvee, and tihat the frait of his labour as their apostle ... break forth in all its beanty. Such IB the explanation of the words of Ter. 13 : ... as I am the apostle of the ... As a Jew, he certainly desires the ... 'of the Jews; bat he desires it still move, if possible, as the apostle of the Gentiles, becaose he knows what this event will be for the entire ... It is dear how closely the for at the beginning of this verse joins it to w. 13 and 14, and how ... it is to guard against making these two last a parenthesis, and ven 15a repetition of ver. 12. It is also dear how wide of the truth are Baur and his school, when they find in these verses a dever artifice by which Paul seeks to render his mission among the Gentiles acceptable to the so-called Judeo-Christian ... of Soma According to this interpretation, his meaning would be : You are wrong in taking offence at my mission to the Gentiles ; it is entirely to the profit of the Jews, whom it must end by bringing to the gospd ; " an adroit way, if one dared say so, of gilding the pill for them ! ... only is such a supposition unworthy of the apostle's character, but it is just the opposite -of his real — Here it is as it results from the three verses combined : '' To take it rightly, it is as your apostle, you Gentiles, that I labour in seeking to provoke the Jews to jealousy by your conversion ; for it is not till they shall be restored to grace that you yourselves shall be crowned with fulness of life." This saying is not therefore a ... indirectly appealing to Judeo-Christian readers; it is a jet of light for the use of Gentile-Christians.
Romans 11:15 · Open Word Bible
15For if their rejection means the reconciliation of the world, what will their acceptance mean? Nothing less than life from the dead!
The term ... strictly denotes the act of throwing far from oneself (Acts zzviii. ... How is the rejection of the Jews the reconciliation of the world ? Inasmuch as it brings down that waU of law which kept the Gentiles outside of the divine covenant, and opens wide to them the door of grace by simple fedth in the ... if such is the ... of their rejection, what shall be the effect of their ... The word ... (translated by Osterv. their recaU, by Oltram. ... restoration, by Segond, their admission) strictly signifies the act of wdcoming. When cursed, they have contributed to the restoration of the world ; what ... they not do when Uessed ?
In Christ's people there is ... something of Christ Himself, ... A host of commentators, from Origen and Ohrysostom down to Meyer and Hofmann (two men who do ... often agree, and who unfortunately concur in this case), apply the expression : a life from the dmd, to the ... of ihe dead, in the strict sense. But — 1st. Why use the expression a life, instead of saying as usual ... the resurrection ? 2d. Why omit the article before the word life, and not say as usual the life, life eternal, instead of a life ? And more than all, 3d. What so close relation could there be between the {act of the conversion of the Jews and that of the bodily resurrection ? Again, if Paul confined himself to saying that the second event will closely follow the first, this temporal relation would be intelligible, though according to him the signal for the resurrection is the return of the Lord (1 Cor. XV. 23), and not at all the conversion of Israel. But he goes the length of identifying the two facte of which he speaks : What shall their return be but a life 1 It is evident, therefore, for all these reasons, that the expression : a life from the dead, must be applied to a powerful spiritual revolution which will be wrought in the heart of ... Christendom by the fact of the ... of the Jews. So it has been understood by Theoph., Mel., Calv., Beza, Philip., etc. The light which converted Jews bring to the church, and the power of life which they have sometimes awakened in it, are the pledge of that spiritual renovation which will be produced in Gentile Christendom by their entrance ... masse. ...
... Do we not then feel that in our present condition there is something, and that much, wanting to us that the promises of the gospel may be realized in all their fulness ; that there is, as it were, a mysterious hindrance to the efficacy of preaching, a debiliiy inherent in our spiritual life, a lack of joy and force which contraste strangely with the joyful outburste of prophete and ... that, in fine, the feast in the father's house is not complete • . • why ? because it cannot be so, so long as the family is not ... reconstituted by the return of the elder son. Then shall come the Pentecost of the last times, the latter raia We are little affected ... the objection of Meyer, who alleges that, according to St Paul, the last times will be times of tribulation (those of Antichrist), and not an epoch of spiritual prosperity. We do not know how the apostle conceived the succession of events; it seems to us that, according to the Apocalypse, the conversion of the Jews (chap. XL 13 and xiv. 1 ... seq.) must precede the coming of the Antichrist, and consequently also Christ's coming again. Paul does not express himself on this point, because, as always, he only brings out what belongs rigorously to the subject he is treating.
The apostle proves in this passage the perfect congruity, from the ... of Israelitish antecedents, of the event which he has just announced as the consummation of Israel's history. Their future restoration is in conformity with the holy character impressed on them from the first ; it is therefore not only possible, but morally necessaiy (ver. 16). This thought, he adds, should inspire the Gentiles, on the one hand, with a feeling of profound regard for Israel, ... in their lapsed state (w. 17, 18) ; on the other, with a feeling of watchful fear over themselves ; for if a judgment of rejection overtook such a people, how much more easily may not the same chastisement descend on them (w. 19-21) 1 He finishes with a conclusion confirming the principal idea of the passage (w. 22-24).
Romans 11:16–24 · Open Word Bible
16If the portion of dough offered as firstfruits is holy, so is the whole batch; and if the root is holy, so are the branches. 17Now if some of the branches were broken off, and you, though a wild olive shoot, were grafted in among them and now share in the rich root of the olive tree, 18do not boast over the branches. If you do boast, remember: you do not hold up the root; the root holds you up. …
Ver. 16. "But ... the ... be Jioly, ihe ... is also holy; and the root be holy, so are the — The Jewish people are ... to God by their very origin, — that is to say, by the call of Abraham, which included theirs (ver. 29). — According to Num. xv. 18-21, eveiy time the Israelites ate of the bread of the land which God had given them, they were first of all to set aside a portion of the dough to make a cake intended for the priests. This cake bore the name of ... first-fruits ; it is to this usage the apostle alludes in the first part of our versa It has sometimes been alleged that he took the figure used here from the custom of ... in the temple, on the 16th Ifisan, on the morrow after the Passover, the sacred sheaf gathered in one of the fields of Jerusalem, as first-fruits and as a consecration of the entire harvest. But the subject in question here is a portion of dotigh ... which necessarily leads to the first meaning. This cake offered to God's representative impressed the seal of consecration on the entire mass from which it had been taken. What is it that corresponds to this emblem in the apostle's view ? Some answer: the Jews ... in the first times of the church ; for thej are the pledge of the final conversion of the whole people. But exactly the same thing might be said of the first Gentile converts, as being the pledge of the successive conversion of all the Gentiles. Now, by this figure Paul's very object is to express a characteristic peculiar to the Jews. Some Fathers (Or., Theod.) apply this emblem to Christ, as assuring the conversion of the people from whom He sprang. But this reasoning would apply equally to Gentile humanity, since Jesus is a man, not only a Jew. We must therefore, with the majority of commentators, take these holy first-fruits as the patriarcJis, in whose person all their posterity are radically consecrated to the mission of being the salvation-people ; comp. ix. 5 and xi. 28.
Romans 11:16 · Open Word Bible
16If the portion of dough offered as firstfruits is holy, so is the whole batch; and if the root is holy, so are the branches.
But this figure, by which the ... nation was compared to a lump of dough consecrated to God, did not furnish the apostle with the means of distinguishing between Jews and Jews, between those who had faithfully preserved this national character and those who had obliterated it by their personal unbelief. Thus he is obliged to add a second figure, that he may be able to make the distinction which he must here lay down between those two so different portions of the nation. There is therefore no need to seek a different meaning for the second figure from that of the first. — Origen, again, applies the emblem of the root to Christ, inasmuch as by His heavenly origin He is the true author of the Jewish people ; but this notion of ... pre-existence is foreign to the context — It follows from these two comparisons, that to obtain salvation the Jewish people had only to remain on the soil where they were naturally rooted, while the salvation of the Gentile demands a complete transplantation. Hence a double warning which Paul feels himself forced to give to the latter. And first the warning against indulging pride.
Yv. 17, 18. '' Ifow, if some of the brandies be broken off, and ... ieing a wild olive tree, wert graffed in, their place, and ... them ... of the root ... fatness of the olive tree, boasi not against the branches ; and if Hum toast, it is not thou that bearest the root, but the root thee'* — We might ... ii the senae of but (" but if, notwithstanding their natnial eonsecration, the branches were broken off") ; or that of ... which is better, as the argument continues down to the inference drawn in ver. 18. — Undoubtedly an event has happened which seems to be in contradiction to this people's character of holiness ; a certain number of its members, like branches struck down with an axe, have been rejected. The term some indicates any fraction whatever, small or considerable matters not (see on iii. 3). — ... and if thou. Some commentators think that this style of address applies to the Grentile-Christian church personified. , But in that sense would not the article 6 have been needed before ... the wild olive ? Without an article the word is an adjective, and denotes the quality, not the tree itself Besides, it is not one tree that is engrafted on another. ...
Romans 11:17–18 · Open Word Bible
17Now if some of the branches were broken off, and you, though a wild olive shoot, were grafted in among them and now share in the rich root of the olive tree, 18do not boast over the branches. If you do boast, remember: you do not hold up the root; the root holds you up.
... By this style of address, therefore, Paul speaks to each Christian of Gentile origin individually, and reminds him that it is in spite of his possessing the quality of a wild tree that he has been able to take a place in this blessed and consecrated organism to which he was originally a stranger. — The words ... which we have translated : in their place, properly signify: ... them, and may be understood in two ways: either in the sense of ... them, — that is to say, among the branches which have remained on the trunk, converts of Jewish origin, — or : in the place which they occupied, and, as it were, in the stump which has been left by them, which would apply solely to the branches which have been cnt down. ... According to it, the Twelve regarded Christians of Gentile origin as simply members by admission, a sort ... in the church ; while Paul made them members of the new people, perfectly equal to the old. The fetct is, that in the view of Paul, as in that of tha Twelve, the believers of Israel are the nucleus round which are grouped the converts from among the Grentiles, and God's ancient people, consequently, the flock with which the Gentiles are incorporated. " I have yet other sheep, said Jesus (Johnx 16), who are not of this fold ; them also I must bring, and there, shall be one flock, one Shepherd." Excepting tha figure, the thought is ... with our passage.
It has been objected to the figure used here by the apostle, that a gardener never ... a wild branch on a stem already brought under cultivation;. ... on the contrary, a stem is taken which still possesses all the vigour of the wild state to insert in it tha graft of tha cultivated tree. There are ... ways of answering this objecstion. It may be.- said that, according totha reports of. some. ... the course ... in the Bast is sometimes that supposed by the figure of the apostla A wild young branch is engrafted in. an old ... olive, and serves to revive it But ... mora natoial answer, viz. that tha apostle usea tha figure finely and ... coneem, to modify it in view of the application. What proves this, is the fact that in ver. 23 he represents the branches broken off as requiring to be engrafted anew. Now this is an impracticable process, taken in the strict sense.
Yer. 18. If it is so. Christians of Gentile origin have no cause to indulge pride as against the natural branchea The. true translation would perhaps be : "Do not despise the branches,. But if, nevertheless, thou despisest " ... Must we understand by the branches those broken off Certainly, for it is on them that the look of disdain might most easily be cast by those who had been called to fill their place. Do we not see Christians at the present day often treating with supreme contempt the members of the Jewish nation who dwell among them ? But this contempt might easily extend even to ... and this, perhaps, is the reason why Paul says simply the branches, without adding the epithet : broken off. It is all that bears the name of Jew which he wished to put imder the protection of this warning. As to the idea Fritzsche had of applying this word ... to Christians of Jewish origin solely, it does not deserve refutation.
Yet the apostle supposes that the presumption of the ... continues, in spite of this warning. This is why he adds: 'But if, notwithstanding, thou despisest" . . . We have not to understand a verb such as : know that or think thai. The idea understood, if there is one, is to this effect : ''Be it! despise! But this, nevertheless, remains the fact." And what is the fact that nothing can change, and with which such a feeling conflicts ? It is, that the salvation enjoyed by this believer has been prepared by a divine history which is one with that of Israel, and that the Christian of Gentile origin enters into possession of a blessing already existing and inherent in this people. As Hodge says : '' It is the Jews who are the channel of blessings to the Gentiles, and not inversely." The Gentiles become God's people by means of the Jews, not the Jews by the instrumentality of the Gentiles. In view of this fact, the contempt of the latter becomes absurd and even perilous.
Romans 11:18 · Open Word Bible
18do not boast over the branches. If you do boast, remember: you do not hold up the root; the root holds you up.
Not only, indeed, should Gentile believers not despise the Jews ; but if they understand their position rightly, the sight of this rejected people should lead them to tremble for themselves.
Vv. 19-21. '' Thou, wilt say then. Branches were broken off, that I ... be graffed in. Well ! "because of ... they were broken off, and thou standest by faith; be not ... but fear ! For if God spared not the natural branches, [U ... that ... unU He spare thee" — The objection Paul puts in the mouth of his reader is taken from the very answer which he had just made to him in yer. 18 ; hence the then : *' Since branches have been cut off the stem to make place for me, who was foreign to it by nature, the preference of God for me appears thereby still more striking than if God had confined Himself to engrafting me on the same stem with them." — The article ... the, before the word branches, is to be rejected, according to the majority of the documents. Paul means, in reality : " beings who had the character of branches." The particular emphasis resting on the ... should be remarked ; literally : that I on my part should be graffed in." To make place for me, even me, God rejected branches !
Romans 11:19–21 · Open Word Bible
19Then you will say, "Branches were broken off to let me be grafted in." 20That is true. They were broken off because of their unbelief, but you stand firm by faith. Do not be proud, but fear. 21For if God did not spare the branches that grew naturally on the tree, He will not spare you either.
Yer. 20. Paul grants the fact; but he denies the inference drawn from it There is no arbitrary favour in God. If the Jews have been rejected, it is in consequence of their unbelief ; and if thou fillest their place for the present, it is a consequence of faith, — that is to say, of divine grace. For there is no merit in faith, since it consists only in opening the hand to receive the gift of God. The term : thou standest, alludes to the favoured position of the engrafted branch which now rises on the stem, while those it has replaced ... on the ground. — The reading ... ought certainly to be pre ferred to the form ... which is substituted for it by the Alexa, probably after xii 16. In the passage 1 Tim. vi 17, where this word again occurs, there is the same variant. — But it is not enough to avoid self-exaltation ; there should be a positive fear.
Romans 11:20 · Open Word Bible
20That is true. They were broken off because of their unbelief, but you stand firm by faith. Do not be proud, but fear.
Yer. 21. May not what has happened to the natural branches, happen to the engrafted branches ? There is even here an a fortiori : For the engrafted branches being less homogeneous with the trunk than the natural branches, their rejection may take place more easily still, in case of unbeliel The Alex, reading rejects the conj. ... from fear that ; thus the ... neither will He spare thee." But the T. B., with the Greco-Latins reads ... before ... and should be translated ... borrowing bom the word fear in the ... verse the notion of leair: ''[fear] that He will no more space thee." It is difficult to believe that a copyist would have introduced this form ... led, whick softens the threat ; it is more probable that this conjunction should have been omitted. Why? The other variant which the last word of this short proposition presents probably explains the reason. The ... will spare, which is read in all the Mj]., seemed incompatible with the conj. ... which usually governs the subjunctive. ... two kinds of corrections in opposite ways : the one (the Alex.) have rejected the conjunction, all the more that it was not dependent on any verb ; and the others, the Byz. Mnn., have changed the indicative ... into the subjunctive ... .
Yv. 22-24 derive for believers of Qentile origin the practical application of all they have been reminded of in w.
Romans 11:21 · Open Word Bible
21For if God did not spare the branches that grew naturally on the tree, He will not spare you either.
Ver. 2 2. '* Behold, therefore, the ... and severity of God : on them which feU, severity ; but toward thee, goodness if thou continue in this goodness : otherwise thou also shalt be ... offr — The readers have just been contemplating two examples, the one of severity, the other of grace ; the first, in the person of the Jews ; the second, in their own. Hence two lessons to be derived which the apostle entreats them not to neglect In opposition to ... (literally : that may be handled), the apostle uses the forcible term ... (from ... to cut right off, to cut short) : a rigour which does not bend. We may read in the second clause the two substantives in the nominative with the Alexs., and then we shall have ... to understand the verb is ( severity is on those who '*), which is excessively clumsy, or to make these two words absolute nominatives, as sometimes happens in Greek appositiona But the Beoeived Beading puts these words in the accusative, which is much simpler. ... For the slightest feeling of self-exaltation which; may take possession of him on occasion of grace received or of its fruits, destcoys in his case grace itself and paralysea it There is nothing more for him to expect in. this condition thaa to be himself also cut off firom the stem. ... It moves on, therefore, to a judgment of rejection like that of Israel, but which shall not have to ... it a promise like that which accompanied the fall of the Jews. — For the rest, I do not think that any conclusion can be drawn from this passage against the doctrine of an uncon ditional decree relative to individuals; for the matter ia question here is Gtentile Christendom in general, and not such or such of its members in particular (see Hodge).
Romans 11:22 · Open Word Bible
22Notice, then, both the kindness and the severity of God: severity toward those who fell, but God's kindness toward you, as long as you continue in His kindness. Otherwise you too will be cut off.
In VT. 23 and 24 the idea of severity is applied, as that of goodness was in the foregoing verse. As the goodness which the Gentiles have enjoyed may througk their fault be transformed into severity, so the severity with which the Jews had been treated may be changed for them into compassionate goodness, if they consent to believe as the Gentiles formerly ... With the dose of this verse the apostle returns to his principal subject, the future of
Yv. 23, 24 'And they also, if they abide vet stiU in ... shall he graffed in ; for God is able to graff them in ... For if thou weri ... out of the olioe tree which is wild by ... and wert graffed ... to rusturs into a good olive tree, haw much more ... these, ... be the natural ... he graffed into their own olive — Severity to the Jews was a threat to the Gentiles ; so the goodness displayed to the Oentiles is a pledge, as it were, of mercy to the Jews. Let them only give up persisting in their unbelief (a contrast to the ... of the Gentiles in faith, ver. 22), and on this one condition the power of God will restore them their place in His kingdom. It will engraft them on Christ, who will become to them a vivifying stem, as well as to the Gentiles. And this transplantation will be efifected more easily still in their case than in the case of the Gentilea
Romans 11:23 · Open Word Bible
23And they too, if they do not remain in unbelief, will be grafted in, for God has the power to graft them back in.
Yer. 24. There is, in fact, between the Jewish nation and the kingdom of God an essential affinity, a sort of preestablished harmony, so that when the hour has come, their restoration will be accomplished still more easily than the incorporation of the Grentiles. — The words: ... much more, seem to us to signify naturally in the context : How much more easily.'' It is objected, no doubt, that one thing is no easier to God than another. That is true in the physical world ; but in the moral world God encounters a factor which He Himself respects — moral freedom. The Jewish people having been raised up only with a view to the kingdom of God, will not have an organic transformation to undeigo in order to return to it ; and if it is objected that a Jew is converted with more difficulty than a Gtentile, that proves notiiing as to the final and collective revolution which will be wrought in the nation at the end of the times. A veil will ... (1 Cor. iiL 14, 15), and all will be done.
Thus far the apostle has shown the moral congruily of the event which he has in view; now he announces the fact positively, and as matter of express revelation.
Romans 11:24 · Open Word Bible
24After all, if you were cut from what is by nature a wild olive tree and grafted, against nature, into a cultivated olive tree, how much more readily will these natural branches be grafted back into their own olive tree!
Yer. 26 contains the announcement of the fact; w. 26, 27 quote some prophecies bearing on it ; w. 28, 29 conclude as to Israel ; finally, w. 30-32 sum up the whole divine plan in relation to Israel and to the Gentiles.
Yv. 25, 26a. " For I would not, brethren, that ye should he ignorant of this mystery, lest ye should be wise in your own conceits : that hardness in part is happened to Israel until the fulness of the Oemtiles he come in ; and so all Israel shall he saved'* — The fona of expression : I would not that ye should be ignorant/' always announces a communication the importance of which the apostle is concerned to impress. The style of address : ... leaves no room to doubt that the apostle is here speaking to the church as a whole. "Soyt it is indubitable that in w. 28 and 30 those readers whom he addresses with the word ye are of Gtentile origin. This proof of a (rentile majority in the church of Rome seems to us incontrovertible.— Paul uses the word mystery to designate the fact he is about to announce. He does not mean by this, as might be thought from the meaning this tenn has taken in ecclesiastical language, that this fact presents something incomprehensible to reason. In the K T. the word denotes a truth or fact which can only be known by man through a communication from above, but which, after this revelation has taken place, falls into the domain of the understanding. The two notions mystery and revdalion are correlative ; comp. Eph. ill 3-6. The apostle therefore holds directly from above the knowledge of the event he proceeds to announce ; comp. 1 Cor. xv. 51 and 1 Thess. iv. 15. — Before stating the fact, he explains the object of this communication : " that ye be not wise in your own eyes." ...
Romans 11:25–26 · Open Word Bible
25Brothers and sisters, I want you to understand this mystery, so that you will not think yourselves wise: a hardening has come upon part of Israel until the full number of the Gentiles comes in. 26And in this way all Israel will be saved. As it is written, "Out of Zion will come the Deliverer; He will turn ungodliness away from Jacob."
... The reference here is not, as in ver. 19, to proud thoughts arising from the preference which God seems now to have given to the Gentiles. It is the wisdom of self whose inspirations Paul here sets aside. The converted Gentiles composing the church of Rome might form strange systems regarding Israel's rejection and future history. Paul is concerned to fix their ideas on this important point, and leave no place in their minds for vain and presiimptuous speculations. He borrows his expressions from Prov. iii 7. Instead of ... ieside yourselves, two Alexs. read ... within yourselves. The copyists may possibly have changed the original ... (in) into ... under the influence of the text of the LXX. The meaning is substantially the same.
The contents of the mystery are declared in the end of this verse and the first words of the following: "hardness is happened." Paul had already pointed out this, ver. 7 ; but he adds : in part, ... This word is explained, as it 254 THE ... of the jews. seems to me, ... the expression of ver. 7: the reit were hardened/' and bj the term some, ver. 1 7. Hence it follows that we must here give the word in part a ... sense. Judgment has not fallen on the totality of Israel but on a part only ; such is also the meaning to which we are led by the antithesis of the ... Israd of ver. 26 ; comp. 2 Cor. ii 5. It is a mistake in Calvin to apply this word : ... the degree, of the hardening which according to him still left room for partial blessings ; and in Hofmann, in a more forced way still, to apply it to the restricted tirne during which it is to last. — But even this judgment, which has overtaken one entire portion of the nation, will have an end : to make it cease, God waits till the totality of the Gentile nations shall have made their entiy into the kingdom of Gtod. This is the people which should have introduced all the other peoples into it ; and for their punishment the opposite is what will take place, as Jesus had declared : " The first shall be last.** It is almost incredible how our Iteformers could have held out obstinately, as they have done, against a thought so clearly expressed. But they showed themselves in general rather indifferent about points of eschatology, and they dreaded in particular eveiything that appeared to favour the expectation of the thousand years' reign which had been so much abused in their time. Calvin has attempted to give to the ... untU that, the impossible meaning of in order that; which in sense amounted simply to the idea of w. 11 and 12. ...
... Others gave to this conjunction the meaning of as long as, to get this idea: that while the ... are entering successively into the church, a part of the Jews undoubtedly remain hardened, but yet a certain number of individuals are converted, from which it will follow that in the end the totality of God's people, Jews and Gentiles (all Israel, ... 26), will be made up. This explanation was only an expedient to get rid of the idea of the final conversion of the Jewish people. It is of course untenable — 1st From the grammatical point of view the conj. ... could only signify as long as, if the verb were a present indicative. With the verb in the ... the only possible meaning is : until. 2d. ... 3d. How ... the apostle ... in a manner so ... and as a letct of revelation, the perfectly simple idea that at the same time as the preaching of the gospel shall sound in the ears of the Gentiles, some ... Jews will also he converted? Gomp. Hodge. — The expression: the fulness of the OentUes, denotes the totality of the ... nations passing successively into the church through the preaching of the gospel This same whole epoch of the conversion of the Gentile world is that which Jesus designates, Luke xxL 24, by the remarkable expression : ... the times of the ... which He tacitly contrasts with the theocratic epoch : the times of the Jews (xix. 42, 44). Jesus adds, absolutely in the same sense as Paul, that Jerusalem ... be trodden down mitU those tones of the Gentiles be fulfilled;" which evidently signifies that after those times had elapsed, Jerusalem shall be delivered and lestored. In this discourse of Jesus, as reported by Matthew (xxiv. 14) and Mark (xiii. 10), it is said: "The gospel of the kingdom shall be preached unto the Gentiles throughout all the earth; and then shall the end come." ...
... This end includes the final salvation of the Jewish people. — Olshausen and Philippi suppose that the complement of the word ... fuiness, is : " of the kingdom of God," and that the genitive ... of the ... is only a complement of apposition: "Until the fuU ... of Gentiles necessary to fill up the void in the kingdom of God, made by the loss of Israel, be complete." This is to torture at will the words of the apostle ; their meaning is clear : Till the accomplishment of the conversion of the Gentiles, there will be among the Jews only individual conversions ; but this goal reached, their conversion ... masse will take place.
Yet. 26a. ... cannot be translated ''and then;" the natural meaning is : and thus ; and it is quite suitabla Thus, that is to say, by means of the entrance of the Gentiles into the church, comp. ver. SI. When Israel shall see the promises of the 0. T., which ascribe to the Messiah the conversion of the Gentiles to the God of Abraham, fulfilled throughout the whole world by Jesus Christ, and the Gentiles through His mediation loaded with the blessings which they themselves covet/ they will be forced to own that Jesus is the Messiah ; for if the latter were to be a different personage, what would this other have to do, Jesus having already done all that is expected of the Messiah? — ... aU Israel, evidently signifies Israel taken in its entirety. It seems, it is true, that the Greek expression in this sense is not correct, and that it should be ... But the term ... all (every), denotes here, as it often does, every element of which the totality of the object is composed (comp. 2 Ghron. xiL 1 : ... all Israel was with hirn) ; Acts ii 36 ; EpL ii 21. We have already said that there can be no question here of applying the term Israd to the spirittud Israel in the sense of GaL vi 16. It is no less impossible to limit its application, with Bengel and Olshausen, to the elect portion of Israel, which would lead to a tautology with the verb ... be saved, and would suppose, besides, the resurrection of all the Israelites who had died before. And what would there be worthy of the term mystery (ver. 25) in the idea of the salvation of all the elect Israelites ... Faul, in expressing himself as he does, does not mean to suppress individual liberty in the Israelites who shall live at that epoch. He speaks of a collective movement which shall take hold of the nation in general, and bring them as such to the feet of their Messiah Individual resistance remains possible. Compare the admirable delineation of this period in the prophet Zechaiiah ... . — Two prophetic sayings are alleged as containing the revelation of this mystery.
Vv. 266, 27. "Asiiis written. There shall come out of Sion the Deliverer, and shall turn away ungodliness from Jacob : and this is the covenant I will make with them when I shall take away their sins" — Two passages are combined in this quotation, as we have already foimd so often ; these are Isa. lix. 20 and xxvil 9. As far as the word when, all belong to the first passage ; with this conjunction the second begins. Both in Isaiah refer to the last times, and have consequently a Messianic bearing. Paul follows the LXX. in quoting, with this difference, that instead of ... from Sion, they read ... in favour of Sion." The form of the LXX. would have as well stated the object of the apostle as that which he employs himselfl Why, then, this change ? Perhaps the prep. ... in favour of, was contracted in some ... of the LXX. so as to be easily confounded with ... fronu Or perhaps the apostle was thinking of some other passage, such as ... ex. 2, where the Messiah is represented as setting out from Sion to establish His kingdom. But what is singular is, that neither the one nor the other form corresponds exactly to the Hebrew text, which says : " There shall come to Sion (the ... and to them who turn from their sins in Jacob." It is probable that instead of ... ("them that turn") the LXX. read ... (to turn ... and they have rendered this infinitive of aim by the future : ... urill turn away. Hence the form of our quotation. However that may be, the meaning is that He who shall deliver Sion from its long oppression, will do so by taking away iniquity ... the entire people. Such is, in fact, the bearing of the term ... Jacob, which denotes the whole nation collectively. It is therefore on this second proposition of ver. 26 that the weight of the quotation pioperly rests. ...
Romans 11:26–27 · Open Word Bible
26And in this way all Israel will be saved. As it is written, "Out of Zion will come the Deliverer; He will turn ungodliness away from Jacob." 27"And this will be My covenant with them, when I take their sins away."
... As to the first proposition, it may be regarded as a simple introduction ; or we may find in it the idea, that after setting out from Sion, the preaching of the gospel, having made the round of the world, will return to Israel to purify it, after all the other nations ; or, finally, it may be held, with Hofmann, that the words /rom Sion denote the place whence the Lord will make His gloiy shine forth, when He shall fulfil this last promise on the earth.
Yer. 27. The first proposition of this verse belongs also to the first of the two passages quoted ; but, singular to say, it is almost identical with the clause with which Isaiah begins the second saying used here (xxvii 9): 'And this is the blessing which I shall put on them when " ... This is no doubt what has given rise to the combination of these two passages in our quotation. The meaning is : " Once the sin of Israel (their unbelief in the Messiah) has been pardoned, I shall renew with them my broken covenant" The pronoun ... their, refers to the individuals, as the word Jacob denoted the totality of the people.
In the two following verses the apostle draws from what
258 THE ... or the jews. precedes the conclusion relative to Israel In ver. 28 he expresses it in a strikmg antithesis, and in rer 29 he justifies the final result {28b) by a general principle of the divine
Romans 11:27 · Open Word Bible
27"And this will be My covenant with them, when I take their sins away."
Vv. 28, 29. "As ... the gospel, {key art, it is true, ensmies for your sokes ; ... as touching (he ... they are bdoved for the ... sokes; for the gifts and ... of God are — To sum up, Israel are in a twofold relation to God, at once enemies and beloved ; but the latter character mil cany it in the end over the former. The term ... hated, opposed as it is here to ... beloved, can only be taken in the passive sense : an object of the hatred, that is to say, of the just wrath of God ; ... chap. v. 10. It needs not be said that when the feeling of hatred is applied to God, we must eliminate from it all admixture of personal resentment, or of the spirit of revenge. God hates the sinner in the same sense in which the sinner ought to hate himself, that is to say, his own life. This sentiment is only the hatred of holiness to evil; and then to the wicked man in so far as he is identified with ... The words : as concerning the gospel, refer to what was said above : that the Jews being once determined not to abandon their law and their monopoly founded on it, needed to be struck with blindness, so that they might not discern in Jesus their Messiah ; otherwise a Judaized gospel would have hindered the offer of salvation to the Gentile nations. The apostle might therefore well add to the words : as concerning the gospel, the further clause : for your sokes. — But in eveiy Jew there is not only an object of the wrath of God, there is an object of His love. K it is asked how these two sentiments can co-exist in the heart of God, we must remark, first, that the same is the case up to a certain point with respect to every man. ...
Romans 11:28–29 · Open Word Bible
28As far as the gospel is concerned, they are enemies for your sake; but as far as God's choice is concerned, they are loved because of the patriarchs. 29For the gifts and the call of God can never be taken back.
... In every man there co-exist a being whom God hates, the sinner, and a being whom He still loves, the man created in His image, and for whom His Son died. ... It was in the persons of Abiaham, Isaac, ... Jacob that the divine election of Israel was onginally realized, and through them that it was transmitted to the whole ... The love with which God loved the fathers continues towards their descendants even ... a thousand generations'' (Ex. xx. 6). Ooly let the hearts of the children return to their fathers, that is to say, let them return to the sentiments of their ... iv. 6 ; Luke i. 17), and the beneficent doud which is always spread over their head will again distil its dew on tbem.
Yer. 29. This verse justifies the assurance of salvation expressed in favour of Israel in the second proposition of ver. 28. The ... of God might denote divine favours in general ; but it seems to us more in harmony with the context, which refers throughout to the destination of Israel, to give this term the special meaning which it usually has in St. Paul's Epistles. He there uses the word to denote the moral and intellectual aptitudes with which God endows a man with a view to the task committed to him. And who can fedl to see that the people of Israel are really endowed ... singulax qualities for their liussion as the salvation-people ? The Greeks, the Romans, the Phenicians had their special gifts in the different domains of ... and art, law and poUtics, ... and commerce. Israel, without being destitute of the powers related to those spheres of mundane activity, have received a higher gift, the organ for the divine and the intuition of hdiness. — The ... cf God is on the one hand the cause, on the other the ... of those gifts. It is because God called this people in His eternal counsel that He entrusted the gifts to them ; and it is because He enriched them with those gifts that in the course of time He called them to fulfil the task of initiating the world in the way of salvation, and of preparing salvation for the world. Of this august mission thej have for the time been deprived; instead of entering firsts they will enter last But their destination is nevertheless irrevocable ; and through the overflowing of divine mercy (chap. v. 20) it will be realized in them at the period announced by the apostle, when, saved themselves, they will cause a stream of life from above to flow into the heart of Glentile Christendom (w. 12, 15, and 25, 26). — This irrevocable character of Israel's destination has nothing in it contrary to individual liberty ; no constraint vrill be exercised. ...
Romans 11:29 · Open Word Bible
29For the gifts and the call of God can never be taken back.
... God ... let unbelieving generations succeed one another as long as shall be necessary, imtil that generation come which shall at length open its eyes and return freely to Him. And even then the movement in question will only be a ... and collective one, from which those shall be sible to withdraw who refuse decidedly to take part in it. Only it is impossible that the divine foreknowledge in regard to Israel as a people (" the people whom God foreknew,'' ver. 2) should terminate otherwise than by being realized in history.
There is nothing in this passage pointing to a temporal restoration of the Jewish nation, or to an Israelitish monarchy having its seat in Palestina The apostle speaks only of a spiritual restoration by means of a general pardon, and the outpouring of the graces which shall flow from it Will there be a political restoration connected with this general conversion of the people ? Or will it not even precede the latter ? Will not the principle of the reconstitution of races, which in our day has produced Italian unity, German unity, and which is tending to the unity of the Slavs, also bring about Israelitish unity? These questions do not belong to exegesis, which confines itself to establishing these two things-— (1) That, according to apostolical revelation, Israel will be converted in a body ; (2) That this event will be the signal of an indescribable spiritual commotion throughout the whole church.
The theme of the chapter is properly exhausted ; we are furnished with light from all points of view, that of ... that of cause, and that of aim, on the mysterious dispensation of the rejection of Israel Nothing remains but to gather up what has been said of the past and future of this elect people into a general view of God's plan as to the religious progress of humanity. This is what the apostle does in w. 30-32.
Vv. 30, 81. " ... as ye ... in times past disobeyed God, ... have now obtained ... through their disobedience; even so have these also ... teen disobedient, thai through the mercy ... to yon they also may obtain mercy.** — The entire course of the religious history of the world is determined by the antagonism created among mankind by the calling of Abraham, between a people specially destined by God to receive His revelations, and the other nations given over to themselves. From that moment (Gen. xiL) there begin to be described those two immense curves which traverse the ages of antiquity in opposite directions, and which, crossing one another at the advent of Christianity, are prolonged from that period in inverse directions, and shall terminate by uniting and losing themselves in one another at the goal of history. — Yer. 30 describes the rebellion of the Gentiles, then their salvation determined by the rebellion of the Jews ; and ver. 31, the rebellion of the Jews, then their salvation arising from the salvation of the
Romans 11:30–31 · Open Word Bible
30Once you were disobedient to God, but now you have been shown mercy because of their disobedience. 31In the same way they have now been disobedient, so that by the mercy God has shown you, they too may now be shown mercy.
Yer. 30. The Gentiles first had their time of disobedience. The expression in times past carries the reader back to the contents of chap, i., to those times of idolatry when the Gentiles voluntarily extinguished the light of natural revelation, to abandon themselves more freely to their evil propensities. This epoch of disobedience is what the apostle calls at Athens (Acts xviL 30) by a less severe name : 'the times of ignorance." Perhaps we should read with the T. S. ... also, ... for. This little word might easily be omitted ; it reminds the Gentiles from the first that they also, like the Jews, had their time of rebellion. — That time of disobedience has now taken end ; the Gentiles have foimd grace. But at what price ? By means of the disobedience of the Jews. We have seen this indeed : God needed to make the temporary sacrifice of His elect people in oitier to disentangle the gospel from the legal forms in which they wished to keep it imprisoned. Hence it was that Israel required to be given up to unbelief in regard to their Messiah ; hence their rejection, which opened the world to the gospel. Now then, wonderful to tell, an analogous, though in a oertain sense opposite, dispensation will take effect in the case of the Jews.
Romans 11:30 · Open Word Bible
30Once you were disobedient to God, but now you have been shown mercy because of their disobedience.
Yer. 31. The word ... now, strongly contrasts the present period (since the coming of Christ) with the former, ver. 30. Kow it is the Jews who are passing through their time of disobedience, while the Gentiles enjoy the sun of grace. But to what end ? That by the grace which is now granted to the latter, grace may also one day be accorded to die Jews. This time, then, it will not be the disobedience of the one which shall produce the conversion of the others. A new discord in the kingdom of God will not be necessary to bring about the final harmony. In this last phase, the good of the ... not result from the evil of the other, but from their very blessedness. Israel went out that the Gentiles might enter. But the Gentiles shall not go out to make place for the Jews; they will open the door to them from within. Thus are explained at once the analogy and the contrast expressed by the conjunctions ... as, and oirm, even so, which begin and form a close connection between vv. 30 and 31. It cannot be doubted that the regimen ... your mercy (that which has been shown to you), depends on the following verb ... may obtain mercy, and not on the preceding proposition. The apostle places this regimen before the conj. ... that, to set it more in relief; for it expresses the essential idea of the proposition. Comp. the similar inversions, xiL 3 ; 1 Cor. iii 5, ix. 15, etc. — For the form ... these also, in the first proposition, there is substituted in the second the form ... airrol, they, or they themselves also, to bring out the identity of the subject to which those two so opposite dispensations apply. It is impossible to admit the Greco-Latin reading, which has ... both timea We must also reject the reading of some Alex, and of some ancient translations, which in the second proposition repeat the vvv, Tuno. These last words refer evidently to the future.
Romans 11:31 · Open Word Bible
31In the same way they have now been disobedient, so that by the mercy God has shown you, they too may now be shown mercy.
Yer. 32. "For God hath ... them all in diaobedience, that He might have mercy upon ally The prep, ... which ... into the composition of the verb, describes the ... as subsisting on all odes at once. Some commentators have thought that there must be given to this verb a simply ... sense, as in Gal. iii 22, where it is said : The Scripture hath concluded all under sin," in this sense, that it declares all men to be subject to sin and condemnation. But in our passage the action is not ascribed to an impersonal subject like Scripture; the subject is God Himself; it is His ... in the course of history which are explained. The verb can therefore only refer to a real act, in virtue of which the two portions of mankind just spoken of have each had their period of disobedience. And Uie act whereby God has brought about this result, as we know from all that precedes, is the judgment denoted in the case of the Grentiles by the term ... He gave them up, thrice repeated, i. 24, 26, and 28, and in the case of the Jews by the word ... they were hardened, zL 7. Only it must be remarked that this divine action had been provoked in both cases by man's sin ; on the part of the Gentiles through their ingratitude toward the revelation of God in nature, and on the part of the Jews by their ignorant obstinacy in maintaining beyond the fixed time their legal particularism. The Danish theologian Nielsen says with good reason, in his short and spiritual exposition of the Epistle to the Romans: ''The sinful nature already existed in all ; but that the conviction of it might be savingly awakened in individuals this latent sin required to be manifested historically on a great scale in the lot of nations." ...
Romans 11:32 · Open Word Bible
32For God has locked everyone up together in disobedience, so that He may show mercy to everyone.
... To be complete, however, it must be added that this latent sin was already manifested actively and freely on the part both of Gentiles and Jews before taking the form of a passive dispensation and of a judgment from God. Thus the act of ... tip together, is already justified from the ... of cause; but how much more ... still from the ... of end I This end is to make those Jews and Gentiles the objects of universal mercy. The word ... all, is applied by Olshausen solely to the totality of the elect in these two parts of mankind ; and by Meyer, to all the individuals comprehended in these two masses, but solely, according to this author, in respect of their destination, in the divine mind. For that this destination may be realized, there is needed the free act of faith. But it should not be forgotten that this saying does not refer to the time of the last judgment and the eternal future, which would necessarily suppose the resurrection of the dead, of which there is no question here. According to the whole context, the apostle has in view an epoch in the history of the kingdom of God on this earth, an epoch, consequently, which comprehends only the individuals who shall then be in life. Hence it is that he puts the article ... the, before ... all ; for the subject in question is a determined and already known totality, that which comprehends the two portions of mankind which Paul has been contrasting with one another throughout the whole chapter. — The domain of disobedience, within which God has successively shut them all up, leaves both in the end only one issue, that of humbly accepting salvation from the hand of ... As Nielsen again says : ' Divine impartiality, after having been temporarily veiled by two opposite particularisms, shines forth in the final universalism which embraces in a common salvation all those whom these great judgments have successively humbled and abased." ...
... There is therefore no inference to be drawn from this passage in favour of a final universal salvation (de Wette, Farrar, and so many others), or even of a ... system, in virtue of which human liberty would be nothing more in the eyes of the apostle than a form of divine action. St Paul teadies only one thing here : that at the dose of the history of mankind on this ... there will be an economy of grace in which salvation will be extended to the totality of the nations living here below, and that this magnificent result will be the efifect of the humiliating dispensations through which the two halves of mankind shall have successively passed The apostle had begun this vast exposition of salvation with the ... of universal condemnation ; he closes it with that of universal mercy. What could remain to him thereafter but to strike the ... of adoration and praise ? This is what he does in w. 33-36.
Yer. 33. 0 the ... of the riches both of the wisdom, and ... of God ! ... are His fudgments, and Hie ways past finding out ! " — like a traveller who has reached the summit of an Alpine ascent, the apostle turns and contemplates. Depths are at his feet; hut waves of light illumine them, and there spreads all around an immense horizon which his eye commands. The plan of God in the government of mankind spreads out before him, and he expresses the feelings of admiration and gratitude with which the prospect fills his heart. — The word ... depth, applies precisely to that abyss which he has just been exploring. The genitive ... of riches, by which the word depth is qualified, is regarded by most commentators as a first complement, co-ordinate with the two following : of wisdom and of knowledge. In this case it must be held that the abstract term riches applies to a special divine attribute which can be no other than divine mercy ; comp. x. 1 2 ; Eph. ii. 4, etc. The two ... and • . . and, which follow, would furnish an instance of a construction like that of Luke v. 17. And one might make these three complements, riches, wisdom, knowledge, parallel to the three questions which follow, w. 34 and 33, as in fact the first refers rather to knowledge, the second to wisdom, and the third to grace. But if this latter relation really existed in the apostle's mind, why should the questions be arranged in an opposite order to that of the three terms corresponding to them in our verse ? Then is not the notion ... too diverse in kind from those of wisdom said knowledge to allow of the first being thus co-ordinated with the other two? Finally, would not the abstract term riches have required to be determined by a complement such as ... (mercy, grace)? The apostle is not afraid of such accumulations of genitives (ii 5 and Eph. i 19). ...
Romans 11:33 · Open Word Bible
33How deep are the riches and the wisdom and the knowledge of God! How impossible to search out His judgments, and how impossible to trace His ways!
... It rather seems to me, therefore, that the second of these two abstract terms ... and riches) ought to be regarded as a complement of the other : a depth of riches, for : an infinitely rich depth, that is to say, one which, instead of being an immense void, presents itself as embracing contents of inexhaustible fulness. Calvin has well caught this meaning : This is why,"* says he.
** I doubt not that the apostle exalts the ... riches of wisdom and knowledge which are in God." — This depth is rich, not in darkness, but in light; it is a depth both of ... and knowledge. — Tfae two fcal, ... and . . ., have the ... sense; they distinguish the two following substantives very precisely, howeyer dosely allied their meaning may be. The second, ... knowledge, refers especially in the context to divine foreknowiedge, and in general to the complete view which God has of all the free determinations of men, whether as individuals or as nations. The former, ... denotes the admirable skill with which God weaves into His plan the free actions of man, and transforms them into so many means for the accomplishment of the excellent end which He set originally before Him. We cannot reflect, however little, without seeing that the very marked difference which Paul here establishes between these two divine perfections, is by no means indifferent ; it ia nothing less than the safeguard of human liberty. If the omniscience of God, especially His foreknowledge, were confounded with His wisdom, eveiything in the universe would be directly the woric of God, and the creatures would be nothing more than bliud instruments in His hands.
Paul sees these two attributes of God shine forth in two orders of things "which, combined, constitute the whole government of the world : judgments, ... and toays or paths, ... Here the general sense of decree is sometimes given to the former of these terms. But the word in every case implies the idea of a judicial decree ; and what Paul has just been referring to, those severe dispensations whereby God has successively chastised the iugratitude of the Gtontiles (chap, i) and the haughty presumption of the Jews (chap, x.), shows clearly that we are to keep to its strict sense. — Wags, ... do not really denote different things from ... but the term presents them in a different and more ... light, as so many advances toward the final aim. The term judg ments expresses, if one may so speak, the because of the things, as the word ways points to their in order that. We may thus uiiderstand the twofold relation of the events of history to knowledge on the one hand, and vrisdom on the other. ... The former of these epithets applies to the supreme principle which the mind seeks to approach, but which it does not reach; the latter to an abundance of ramifications and of details in execution which the understanding cannot follow ... the end. These epthets are often quoted with the view of ... the incomprehensibility to man of the divine ... and in particular of that ... predestination (Aug.). But it must not be forgotten that St Paul's exclamation is called forth, not by the obscurity of God's plans, but, on the contrary, by their dazzling deamess. If they are ... hensible and unfathomable, it is to man's natural understanding, and until they have been revealed ; but, says the apostle, 1 Cor. iL 10: ... hath revealed them unto us by His Spirit; for the Spirit searcheth ... all things, even the deep things ... of God." It is therefore in view of the unveiled mystery that the exclamation is raised, as is done by Flaul here : " 0 the depth of the riches !" A fact which does not prevent the mind which understands them in part from having always to discover in them new laws or applications.
Yv. 34, 35. For who hath Jmown the wind of the Lord, or who haih teen His counsellor t Or who hath first given to Sim, and ii shall be recompensed unto him againi — Here ... the Scripture proof that ... designs are impenetrable until He reveal them Himself to His apostles and prophets, and by them to His people. The first passage quoted is Isa. xl. 13, which Paul uses as if it ... his own saying. This question in the mouth of the prophet applies to the wonders of creation. Paul extends it to those of the divine government in general, for the works of God in history are only the continuation of those of nature. — The question: Who hath known t is a challenge thrown down to the naiural understanding. As to those whom God has enlightened on the subject of His designs, Paul himself says 1 Cor. ii 16 : ''But we have the mind of Christ.'' — Ihis first question contrasts the always limited knowledge of man with the infinite ... of God ... ver. 33). The second goes farther, it bears on the relation between human and divine wisdom. It is no longer merely the discovery of the secrets of God by the study of His works which is in question, but some good ... which man might have been called to give to the Creator in the organizing of His plana The word ... denotes one who deliberaies ... another, and can communicate to him something of his wisdom. It is therefore a more exalted position than that supposed by the previous question.
Romans 11:34–35 · Open Word Bible
34For "who has known the mind of the Lord?" "Or who has been His counselor?" 35"Or who has given Him anything first and must be paid back?"
The third question, ver.' 35, would imply a still more exalted part The matter in question is a service rendered to ... a present which man is supposed to have made to Him so as to merit a gift in return. Such, indeed, is the position which the Jews were taking, and by which they claimed especially to limit the freedom of God in the government of the world on account of their meritorious works. There is no difiference," said the Jews of Malachi's day pettishly, ' between the man who serveth God and him who serveth Him not What have we gained by keeping His commandments?" This spirit of pride had been growing; it had reached its apogee in Pharisaism. The preposition ... in advance, which enters into the composition of the first verb, and the preposition ... in exchange, which enters iato that of the second, perfectly describe the relation of dependence on man in which God would be placed, if the former could really be the first to do something for God and thereby constitute Him his debtor. With this third question Paul evidently returns to the special subject of this whole dissertation on the divine government : the rejection of the Jews. By the first question he denied to man the power of understanding God and judging Him till God had explained Himself; by the second, the power of co-operating with Him ; by the third, he refuses to him the power of imposing on Him any obligation whatever. Thus is fully vindicated the liberty of God, that last principle of the mysterious fact to be explained.
This question of ver. 35 is also a Scripture quotation which Paul weaves into his own text It is taken from Job xlL 11, which the LXX. translate strangely ... '' Or who is he that will resist me and abide ? "* It is trae that in the two MSS. ... and Alex, there is found at the close of Isa. xL 14 a saying similar to the apostle's translation. But there it is ... an interpolation taken from onr epistle itselfl
Yer. 36. " For of Hiniy and through Him, and to Him ... things : To wham be glory for ever ! Amen — God's absolute independence, man's totol dependence in eveiything which might be a matter of glory to him : such is the thought of this verse, the termination of this vast survey of the plan of God. The first prep, he, of, refeis to God as Creator ; it is of Him that man holds eveiything: life, breath, and all things/' Acts zviL 25. The second, ... through, refers to the government of mankind Everything, even the free determinations of the human will, are executed only through Him, and are turned immediately to the accomplishment of His designs. The third, ... to, refers to the final ... The word to Him does not refer to God's personal satisfaction, an idea which might undoubtedly be supported ; for, as Beck says, ' the egoism of God is the life of the world." But it is more natural to apply the term to Him to the accomplishment of His will, in which His own gloiy and the happiness of His sanctified creatures blend together as one and the same thing. It has been sometimes attempted to apply these three prepositional clauses to the three persons of the divine Trinity ; modem exegesis (Mey., Gross, Hofm.) has in general departed from this parallel; and rightly. When Paul speaks of God, absolutely considered, it is always the God and Faiher he intends, without, of course, excluding His revelation through Christ and His communication by the Holy Spirit But this distinction is not raised here, and had no place in the context What the apostle was concerned to say in closing, was that all things proceeding from the creative will of God, advancing through His wisdom and terminating in the manifestation of His holiness, must one day celebrate His glory, and His glory only. — The application of the word aU things might be restricted to the two portions of mankind spoken of (as in ver. 32). ...
Romans 11:36 · Open Word Bible
36For all things are from Him and through Him and for Him. To Him be glory forever! Amen.
... But Paul rises here to the general principle of which ver. 32 was only a particular application, and hence also he substitutes the neuter cdl things for the masculine all. What is meant, therefore, is the totality of created things.
For, as Hodge says, " the highest end for which all things can exist and be .ordered, is to display the character of God.'' This goal of history is, as it were, anticipated by the wish and prayer of the apostle : *' To Him be glory ! **
The first part of the doctrinal treatise had terminated in the parallel between the two heads of mankind, a passage in which there was already heard a more exalted ... The second part dosed, at the end of chap, viii with a sort of lyrical passage, in which the apostle celebrated the blessing of sanctification crowning the grace of justification, and thus assuring the state of glory. The third, that which we are concluding here, terminates in a passage of the same ... a hymn of adoration in honour of the divine plan realized in spite o( and even by means o human ... After thus finishing the exposition of salvation in its foundation (justification), in its internal development (sanctification), and in its historical course among ... (the successive calling of the difierent nations, and their final union in the kingdom of God), the apostie puts, as it were, a fuU period, the ... which closes tins part of the episde.
Never was survey more vast taken of the divine plan of the world's history. First, the epoch of primitive unity, in which the human ... forms still only one unbroken whole ; then the antagonism between the two religious portions of the race, created by the special call of Abraham : the Jews continuing in the fathers house, but with a legal and servile spirit, the ... walking in their own ways. At the close of this period, the manifestation of Christ determining the return of the latter to the domestic hearth, but at the same time the departure of the former. Finally, the Jews, yielding to the divine ... and to the spectacle of salvation enjoyed by the Gentiles as children of grace ; and so the final universalism in which all previous discords are resolved, restoring in an infinitely higher form the original unity, and setting before the view of the universe the family of God folly constituted.
The contrast between the Jews and Qentiles appears therefore as the essential moving spring of history. It is the actions and reactions arising from this primary fact which form its key. This is what no philosophy of histoiy has dreamt of, and what makes these chaps, ix.— xl the highest theodicy.
If criticism has thought it could deduce from this passage the hypothesis of a Jndeo-Christian majozity in the church of Home, if it has sought to explain it, as well as the whole of our epistle, by the desire felt by Paul to ... this church to his missionary activity among the Gentiles, it is easy to see from the passage, rightly imderstood, how remote such criticism is from the real thought which inspired this treatise. ... 30-32, in which he addresses the whole church as former Gentiles wbom he expressly distinguishes from Jews, can leave no doubt as to the origin of the Christians of Rome. Supposing even that in ver. 13 he had divided his leaders into two daases, which we have found to be a mistake, from ver. 25 he would in any case be again addressing all his readers. And as to the intention of the whole passage, it is evidendy to show that those who should have been ... though now put ... not, however, exduded, as the Gentiles might proudly imagine, and that if the ... firstly ascribed to the Jews by God's original plan (i 16) has not been historically realized (through their own fault), the divine programme in regard to mankind will nevertheless, though in another way, have its complete execution. Yer. 32 is the coimterpart of L 16. It is therefore to impair the meaning of this passage to see in it an apology for Paul's mission. The thought is more elevated : it is the defence of the plan of God Himself addressed to the whole church.