Logia

Genesis · Chapter 32 · Passages

Gifts for Esau, and a struggle at Peniel (Genesis 32:4–33)

4 Jacob then sent messengers ahead to his brother Esau, to the land of Seir in the region of Edom. 5 He instructed them, "Tell my lord Esau this: 'Your servant Jacob sends word: I have lived as a guest with Laban and stayed on there until now. 6 I own oxen and donkeys and flocks, and servants, men and women. I am sending to let my lord know, hoping you will look on me with favor.'" 7 The messengers returned and told Jacob, "We reached your brother Esau. He is already coming out to meet you, with 400 men at his side." 8 Jacob was badly frightened and anxious. He divided his people into two camps, along with the flocks, the herds and the camels. 9 His thought was, "If Esau falls on one camp and strikes it, the camp that is left will be able to escape." 10 And Jacob prayed: "God of my father Abraham, God of my father Isaac, LORD, it was You who said to me, 'Return to your land and your family, and I will make things go well for you.' 11 I am far too small for all the faithful love and truth You have shown your servant. I had only a staff in my hand when I crossed this Jordan, and now I have become two camps. 12 Rescue me from my brother, from Esau's hand. I fear that he will come and strike us all down, mothers and children together. 13 Yet You Yourself said, 'I will surely make things go well for you, and I will make your descendants like the sand of the sea, beyond counting for their number.'" 14 After spending the night there, he chose from his possessions a present for his brother Esau: 15 200 female goats and twenty male goats, 200 ewes and twenty rams, 16 thirty camels with their nursing young, forty cows and ten bulls, twenty female donkeys and ten male donkeys. 17 He handed them over to his servants, one drove at a time, and told them, "Cross ahead of me, and leave a gap between each drove and the next." 18 To the leading servant he said, "My brother Esau will meet you and ask, 'Whose man are you? Where are you headed? And whose animals are these you are driving?' 19 Then you will say, 'Your servant Jacob's. This is a present he is sending to my lord Esau, and Jacob himself is following us.'" 20 He gave the same command to the second, to the third, and to everyone who walked behind the droves: "This is what you are to tell Esau when you come upon him. 21 Add this: 'Your servant Jacob is right behind us.'" His plan was, "I will win him over with the present that goes ahead of me, and then I will meet him face to face. It may be that he will receive me kindly." 22 So the gift went on ahead of him, while he stayed the night in the camp. 23 During that night he rose, took his two wives, his two female servants and his eleven sons, and crossed at the ford of the Jabbok. 24 He took them and sent them over the stream, along with everything he owned. 25 Jacob stayed behind by himself. And a man wrestled with him there until dawn began to break. 26 The man, seeing that he could not get the upper hand over Jacob, struck him at the hip socket, and Jacob's hip was wrenched out of joint while they wrestled. 27 "Let me go," said the man, "for the dawn is coming up." Jacob said, "I will not let you go unless you bless me." 28 The man asked him, "What is your name?" He said, "Jacob." 29 He said, "You will be called Jacob no longer. Your name is Israel, for you have contended with God and with people and have come through victorious." 30 Then Jacob asked him, "Tell me, please, what your name is." He replied, "Why is it that you ask for my name?" And there he blessed Jacob. 31 Jacob named the place Peniel. "I have seen God face to face," he said, "and my life has been rescued." 32 The sun was rising on him as he went past Penuel, and he went limping on his injured hip. 33 This is the reason the people of Israel still do not eat the sinew on the hip socket: Jacob's hip socket was struck at that sinew.

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

84 excerpts from 5 commentators on Genesis 32:4–33, from John Calvin (1509–1564) to C. F. Keil (1807–1888).

Two voices on Gifts for Esau, and a struggle at Peniel (Genesis 32:4–33)

Choose two:

What the church has said

Each excerpt opens with its first words. Follow its verse to read it in full.

What does Calvin say about Genesis 32:4–33?

John Calvin

1509–1564 · Reformed · Commentaries on the First Book of Moses called Genesis · 28 excerpts

  • Genesis 32:4 And Jacob sent messengers

    3. And Jacob sent messengers. It now happened, by the providence of God, that Esau, having left his father, had gone to Mount Seir of his own accord; and had thus departed from the land of promise, by which means…

  • Genesis 32:4

    ... I have said that this was done by the divine will: for God himself declares by Malachi, that it was by a species of banishment that Esau was led to Mount Seir. (Malachi 1:3) For although he departed voluntarily,…

  • Genesis 32:5 Thus shall ye speak unto my lord Esau

    4. Thus shall ye speak unto my lord Esau. Moses here relates the anxiety of Jacob to appease his brother. For this suppliant deprecation was extorted only by great and severe torture of mind. It seems, however, to be an…

  • Genesis 32:6 I have oxen

    5. I have oxen. Jacob does not proclaim his riches for the sake of boasting, but that by this method Esau might be inclined to humanity. For it would have been exceedingly disgraceful, cruelly to drive away one who had…

  • Genesis 32:7 And the messengers returned

    6. And the messengers returned. Esau advances to meet his brother with a feeling of benevolence: but Jacob, reflecting on his cruel ferocity, inflated spirits, and savage threats, expects no humanity from him. And the Lord willed that the mind…

  • Genesis 32:8 And he divided the people

    7. And he divided the people. Moses relates that Jacob formed his plans according to the existing state of affairs. He divides his family into two parts, and puts his maids in the foremost place, that they may bear the…

  • Genesis 32:10 O God of my father Abraham

    9. O God of my father Abraham. Having arranged his affairs as the necessity of the occasion suggested, he now retakes himself to prayer. And this prayer is evidence that the holy man was not so oppressed with fear as…

  • Genesis 32:10

    ... And indeed we must seek the true rule of prayer in the word of God, that we may not rashly break through to Him, but may approach him in the manner in which he has revealed himself to us.…

  • Genesis 32:11 I am not worthy of the least of all the mercies

    10. I am not worthy of the least of all the mercies Although this expression sounds harsh to Latin ears, the sense is not obscure. Jacob confesses, that greater mercies of God had been heaped upon him than he had…

  • Genesis 32:11 For with my staff

    For with my staff Jacob does not enumerate separately the mercies of God, but under one species comprises the rest; namely, that whereas he had passed over Jordan, a poor and solitary traveler, he now returns rich, and replenished with…

  • Genesis 32:12 Deliver me

    11. Deliver me. After he has declared himself to be bound by so many of God’s benefits that he cannot boast of his own merits, and thus raised his mind to higher expectation, he now mentions his own necessity, as…

  • Genesis 32:14 And took of that which came to his hand

    13. And took of that which came to his hand. In endeavoring to appease his brother by presents, he does not act distrustfully, as if he doubted whether he should be safe under the protection of God. This, indeed, is…

  • Genesis 32:15 Two hundred she-goats

    14. Two hundred she-goats. Hence we perceive the value which Jacob set upon the promise given to him, seeing he does not refuse to make so great a sacrifice of his property. We know that those things which are obtained…

  • Genesis 32:23 And he rose up that night

    22. And he rose up that night. After he has prayed to the Lord, and arranged his plans, he now takes confidence and meets the danger. By which example the faithful are taught, that whenever any danger approaches, this order…

  • Genesis 32:25 There wrestled a man with him

    24. There wrestled a man with him Although this vision was particularly useful to Jacob himself, to teach him beforehand that many conflicts awaited him, and that he might certainly conclude that he should be the conqueror in them all;…

  • Genesis 32:25

    ... He is said, indeed, to tempt us in a different manner from Satan; but because he alone is the Author of our crosses and afflictions, and he alone creates light and darkness, (as is declared in Isaiah,) he is…

  • Genesis 32:25

    ... And although these forms of expression are harsh, yet their harshness will be easily mitigated in practice. For if temptations are contests, (and we know that they are not accidental, but are divinely appointed for us,) it follows hence,…

  • Genesis 32:25

    ... Jacob, therefore, having been accustomed to bear sufferings, is now led forth to real war. Perhaps also, the Lord had reference to the conflict which was then approaching. But I think Jacob was admonished, at his very entrance on…

  • Genesis 32:26 And when he saw that he prevailed not against him

    25. And when he saw that he prevailed not against him. Here is described to us the victory of Jacob, which, however, was not gained without a wound. In saying that the wrestling angel, or God, wished to retire from…

  • Genesis 32:26 He touched the hollow of his thigh

    He touched the hollow of his thigh. Though Jacob gains the victory; yet the angel strikes him on the thigh, from which cause he was lame even to the end of his life. And although the vision was by night,…

  • Genesis 32:27 Let me go

    26. Let me go. God concedes the praise of victory to his servant, and is ready to depart, as if unequal to him in strength: not because a truce was needed by him, to whom it belongs to grant a…

  • Genesis 32:27 I will not let thee go, except

    I will not let thee go, except. Hence it appears, that at length the holy man knew his antagonist; for this prayer, in which he asks to be blessed, is no common prayer. The inferior is blessed by the greater;…

  • Genesis 32:29 Thy name shall be called no more Jacob

    28. Thy name shall be called no more Jacob. Jacob, as we have seen, received his name from his mother’s womb, because he had seized the heel of his brother’s foot, and had attempted to hold him back. God now…

  • Genesis 32:30 Tell me, I pray thee, thy name

    29. Tell me, I pray thee, thy name. This seems opposed to what is declared above; for I have lately said, that when Jacob sought a blessing, it was a token of his submission. Why, therefore, as if he were…

  • Genesis 32:30

    ... This is the reason why he rendered himself more conspicuous to Moses, who nevertheless was only permitted to behold his glory from behind: yet because he occupied an intermediate place between patriarchs and apostles, he is said, in comparison…

  • Genesis 32:31 And Jacob called the name of the place

    30. And Jacob called the name of the place The gratitude of our father Jacob is again commended, because he took diligent care that the memory of God’s grace should never perish. He therefore leaves a monument to posterity, from…

  • Genesis 32:31

    ... It may however be asked, “Why, when he had obtained so slight a taste only of God’s glory, he should boast that he had seen him, face to face?” I answer, it is in no way absurd that Jacob…

  • Genesis 32:32 And he halted upon his thigh

    31. And he halted upon his thigh. It is probable, and it may be gathered even from the words of Moses, that this halting was without the sense of pain, in order that the miracle might be the more evident.…

What does Henry say about Genesis 32:4–33?

Matthew Henry

1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume I (Genesis to Deuteronomy): Genesis · 22 excerpts

  • Genesis 32:4–9

    Now that Jacob was re-entering Canaan God, by the vision of angels, reminded him of the friends he had when he left it, and thence he takes occasion to remind himself of the enemies he had, particularly Esau. It is…

  • Genesis 32:4–9 He sends a very kind and humble message to Esau

    I. He sends a very kind and humble message to Esau. It does not appear that his way lay through Esau's country, or that he needed to ask his leave for a passage; but his way lay near it, and…

  • Genesis 32:7 He receives a very formidable account of Esau's warlike preparations against him

    II. He receives a very formidable account of Esau's warlike preparations against him (v. 6), not a word, but a blow, a very coarse return to his kind message, and a sorry welcome home to a poor brother: He comes…

  • Genesis 32:7

    ... Out he marches, spurred on with rage, and intent on blood and murders; four hundred men he had with him, probably such as used to hunt with him, armed, no doubt, rough and cruel like their leader, ready to…

  • Genesis 32:8–9 He puts himself into the best posture of defence that his present circumstances will admit

    III. He puts himself into the best posture of defence that his present circumstances will admit. It was absurd to think of making resistance, all his contrivance is to make an escape, v. 7, 8. He thinks it prudent not…

  • Genesis 32:10–13

    Our rule is to call upon God in the time of trouble; we have here an example to this rule, and the success encourages us to follow this example. It was now a time of Jacob's trouble, but he shall…

  • Genesis 32:10 He addresses himself to God as the God of his fathers

    1. He addresses himself to God as the God of his fathers, v. 9. Such was the humble self-denying sense he had of his own unworthiness that he did not call God his own God, but a God in covenant…

  • Genesis 32:10 He insists especially upon the promise God had made him

    6. He insists especially upon the promise God had made him (v. 9): Thou saidst, I will deal well with thee, and again, in the close (v. 12): Thou saidst, I will surely do thee good. Note, (1.) The best…

  • Genesis 32:11 He humbly acknowledges his own unworthiness to receive any favour from God

    3. He humbly acknowledges his own unworthiness to receive any favour from God (v. 10): I am not worthy; it is an unusual plea. Some would think he should have pleaded that what was now in danger was his own,…

  • Genesis 32:11

    4. He thankfully owns God's goodness to him in his banishment, and how much it had outdone his expectations: "With my staff I passed over this Jordan, poor and desolate, like a forlorn and despised pilgrim;" he had no guides,…

  • Genesis 32:12 The request itself is one, and very express

    I. The request itself is one, and very express: Deliver me from the hand of my brother, v. 11. Though there was no human probability on his side, yet he believed the power of God could rescue him as a…

  • Genesis 32:12 He urges the extremity of the peril he was in

    5. He urges the extremity of the peril he was in: Lord, deliver me from Esau, for I fear him, v. 11. The people of God have not been shy of telling God their fears; for they know he takes…

  • Genesis 32:14–16 Jacob sent him a very noble present, not of jewels or fine garments

    I. Jacob sent him a very noble present, not of jewels or fine garments (he had them not), but of cattle, to the number of 580 in all, v. 13-15. Now, 1. It was an evidence of the great increase…

  • Genesis 32:14–24

    Jacob, having piously made God his friend by a prayer, is here prudently endeavouring to make Esau his friend by a present. He had prayed to God to deliver him from the hand of Esau, for he feared him; but…

  • Genesis 32:18–19

    II. He sent him a very humble message, which he ordered his servants to deliver in the best manner, v. 17, 18. They must call Esau their lord, and Jacob his servant; they must tell him the cattle they had…

  • Genesis 32:25–33

    We have here the remarkable story of Jacob's wrestling with the angel and prevailing, which is referred to, Hos. xii. 4. Very early in the morning, a great while before day, Jacob had helped his wives and his children over…

  • Genesis 32:25 How Jacob and this angel engaged

    I. How Jacob and this angel engaged, v. 24. It was a single combat, hand to hand; they had neither of them any seconds. Jacob was now full of care and fear about the interview he expected, next day, with…

  • Genesis 32:26 What was the success of the engagement

    II. What was the success of the engagement. 1. Jacob kept his ground; though the struggle continued long, the angel, prevailed not against him (v. 25), that is, this discouragement did not shake his faith, nor silence his prayer. It…

  • Genesis 32:26

    ... The angel, by an admirable condescension, mildly requests Jacob to let him go (v. 26), as God said to Moses (Exod. xxxii. 10), Let me alone. Could not a mighty angel get clear of Jacob's grapples? He could; but…

  • Genesis 32:26

    ... Note, Those that would have the blessing of Christ must be in good earnest, and be importunate for it, as those that resolve to have no denial. It is the fervent prayer that is the effectual prayer. 5. The…

  • Genesis 32:26

    ... But that request was denied, that he might not be too proud of his conquest, nor think he had the angel at such an advantage as to oblige him to what he pleased. No, "Wherefore dost thou ask after…

  • Genesis 32:26

    ... He does not say, "In this place I wrestled with God, and prevailed;" but, "In this place I saw God face to face, and my life was preserved;" not, "It was my praise that I came off a conqueror,…

What does Haydock say about Genesis 32:4–33?

George Leo Haydock

1774–1849 · Roman Catholic · Catholic Family Bible and Commentary: Genesis · 15 excerpts

  • Genesis 32:6 Men

    Ver. 6. Men. Jonathan has Polemarchoi; officers or warriors, either to punish Jacob, (Wisd. 10:12) as the latter feared, v. 11; or to do him honour, as Esau protested. C. 33:15. C.

  • Genesis 32:9 God of

    Ver. 9. God of ... Isaac. It is not true, therefore, that God never has the title of God of any man, while living, as some assert. C. 31:42. Jacob addresses him by those very titles which he had assumed…

  • Genesis 32:10 Not worthy

    Ver. 10. Not worthy. Chal. “my merits are beneath all thy kindnesses.” S. Aug. reads, with S. Cyril, idoneus es, &c. “thou art sufficient for me.”

  • Genesis 32:11 The children

    Ver. 11. The children; sparing neither sex nor age, but destroying all. C.—Jacob insists on the promises of God; yet fears lest he should, by some offence, have deserved to forfeit his protection; particularly, as he had been living 20…

  • Genesis 32:15 Camels

    Ver. 15. Camels. The milk of these animals is most exquisite, being mixed with three parts water. Pliny xi. 41, who says, “They give milk till they be with young again.” The Arabs feed chiefly on their milk and flesh.…

  • Genesis 32:20 He said

    Ver. 20. He said, &c. These words were not to be related to Esau; they are the words of the sacred historian. There were probably five droves of goats, sheep, camels, kine and asses; by the successive presenting of which,…

  • Genesis 32:22 Sons

    Ver. 22. Sons, with Dina his daughter, and all his household.

  • Genesis 32:23 All things

    Ver. 23. All things. Grotius thinks this has been lost in the Heb. copies; as it occurs in the Sam. Sept. and Syriac.

  • Genesis 32:24 A man

    Ver. 24. A man, &c. This was an angel in human shape, as we learn from Osee 12:4. He is called God, v. 28 and 30, because he represented the person of the Son of God. This wrestling, in which…

  • Genesis 32:25 Sinew

    Ver. 25. Sinew, near the coxendix, or huckel-bone. D. This was to convince Jacob, how easily he could have gained the victory over him; and to make him remember, that it was not simply a vision, but a real wrestling.…

  • Genesis 32:28 Israel

    Ver. 28. Israel. This name was more honourable, and that by which his posterity were afterwards known; being called Israelites, and not Jacobites. God ratifies the title. C. 35:10. It means a prince of God. S. Jer. q. Heb. (…

  • Genesis 32:29 Why

    Ver. 29. Why, &c. He represses Jacob’s curiosity, ( H.) perhaps because God did not as yet choose to reveal his name. Ex. 6:3. Some Greek and Latin copies add, which is wonderful, taken from Jud. 13:6. 18. C.

  • Genesis 32:30 Phanuel

    Ver. 30. Phanuel. This word signifies the face of God, or the sight, or seeing of God. Ch.—Hebrew reads here Peni-el, though it has Phanuel in the next verse. Jacob thus returns thanks to God for the preservation of his…

  • Genesis 32:31 Halted

    Ver. 31. Halted, or was lame. Alulensis thinks the angel healed him very soon. M.

  • Genesis 32:32 The sinew in beasts of any kind

    Ver. 32. The sinew in beasts of any kind, corresponding with that part of Jacob’s thigh. H—Some refrain from the whole quarter, others extract the sinew. This they do, without any command, in memory of this transaction. C.

What does Jamieson say about Genesis 32:4–33?

Robert Jamieson

1802–1880 · Church of Scotland (Presbyterian) · Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible: Genesis · 14 excerpts

  • Genesis 32:4 Thus shall ye speak unto my lord Esau

    4. Thus shall ye speak unto my lord Esau—The purport of the message was that, after a residence of twenty years in Mesopotamia, he was now returning to his native land, that he did not need any thing, for he…

  • Genesis 32:6 The messengers returned to Jacob

    6. The messengers returned to Jacob—Their report left Jacob in painful uncertainty as to what was his brother's views and feelings. Esau's studied reserve gave him reason to dread the worst. Jacob was naturally timid; but his conscience told him…

  • Genesis 32:9–12 Jacob said, O God of my father Abraham

    9-12. Jacob said, O God of my father Abraham—In this great emergency, he had recourse to prayer. This is the first recorded example of prayer in the Bible. It is short, earnest, and bearing directly on the occasion. The appeal…

  • Genesis 32:13–23 took … a present for Esau

    13-23. took … a present for Esau—Jacob combined active exertions with earnest prayer; and this teaches us that we must not depend upon the aid and interposition of God in such a way as to supersede the exercise of prudence…

  • Genesis 32:16 every drove by themselves

    16. every drove by themselves—There was great prudence in this arrangement; for the present would thus have a more imposing appearance; Esau's passion would have time to cool as he passed each successive company; and if the first was refused,…

  • Genesis 32:17 he commanded the foremost

    17. he commanded the foremost—The messengers were strictly commanded to say the same words [Ge 32:18, 20], that Esau might be more impressed and that the uniformity of the address might appear more clearly to have come from Jacob himself.

  • Genesis 32:21 himself lodged

    21. himself lodged—not the whole night, but only a part of it.

  • Genesis 32:22 ford Jabbok

    22. ford Jabbok—now the Zerka—a stream that rises among the mountains of Gilead, and running from east to west, enters the Jordan, about forty miles south of the Sea of Tiberias. At the ford it is ten yards wide. It…

  • Genesis 32:24–25 There wrestled a man with him

    24, 25. There wrestled a man with him—This mysterious person is called an angel (Ho 12:4) and God (Ge 32:28, 30; Ho 12:5); and the opinion that is most supported is that he was "the angel of the covenant," who,…

  • Genesis 32:26 I will not let thee go, except thou bless me

    26. I will not let thee go, except thou bless me—It is evident that Jacob was aware of the character of Him with whom he wrestled; and, believing that His power, though by far superior to human, was yet limited…

  • Genesis 32:28 Thy name shall be called no more Jacob, but Israel

    28. Thy name shall be called no more Jacob, but Israel—The old name was not to be abandoned; but, referring as it did to a dishonorable part of the patriarch's history, it was to be associated with another descriptive of…

  • Genesis 32:29 Jacob asked, Tell me … thy name

    29. Jacob asked, Tell me … thy name—The request was denied that he might not be too elated with his conquest nor suppose that he had obtained such advantage over the angel as to make him do what he pleased.

  • Genesis 32:31 halted upon his thigh

    31. halted upon his thigh—As Paul had a thorn in the flesh given to humble him, lest he should be too elevated by the abundant revelations granted him [2Co 12:7], so Jacob's lameness was to keep him mindful of this…

  • Genesis 32:32 the sinew which shrank

    32. the sinew which shrank—the nerve that fastens the thigh bone in its socket. The practice of the Jews in abstaining from eating this in the flesh of animals, is not founded on the law of Moses, but is merely…

What does Keil say about Genesis 32:4–33?

C. F. Keil

1807–1888 · Lutheran · Biblical Commentary on the Old Testament: The Pentateuch, Vol. I (Genesis) · 5 excerpts

  • Genesis 32:4–13

    Vers. 4-13. ... The statement that Esau was already in the land of Seir (ver. 4), or, as it is afterwards called, the field of Edom, is not at variance with chap, xxxvi. G, and may be very naturally explained…

  • Genesis 32:14–22

    Vers. 14-22. Although hoping for aid and safety from the Lord alone, Jacob neglected no means of doing what might help to appease his brother. ... The selection was in harmony with the general possessions of nomads (cf. Job i.…

  • Genesis 32:23–33

    Vers. 23-33. The wrestling with God. — The same night, he conveyed his family with all his possessions across the ford of the Jabbok. Jabbok is the present Wady es Zerlca (i.e. the blue), which flows from the east towards…

  • Genesis 32:25

    Ver. 25. When Jacob was left alone on the northern side of the Jabbok, after sending all the rest across, "there wrestled a man with him until the breaking of the day." ... 26. ... Still Jacob would not let…

  • Genesis 32:32–33

    Vers. 32, 33. With le rising of the sun after the night of his conflict, the night ? anguish and fear also passed away from Jacob's mind, so lat he was able to leave Pnuel in comfort, and go forward…

Read Genesis 32 with all its commentary