Logia

Luke · Chapter 17 · Stumbling, forgiveness and faith

Luke 17:36

Verse 36 is not in the Greek text the Open Word Bible translates, which follows the oldest manuscripts; many later manuscripts and older translations have it.

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

3 commentators in Logia comment on Luke 17:36, from Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274) to David Brown (1803–1897): Aquinas, Henry and Brown.

Two voices on Luke 17:36

Choose two:

What the church has said

See all 3 voices as a grid

Eras across, traditions down, each with its first words. An empty cell is a place the library has no voice yet.

Middle AgesPuritans and the 1700sThe 1800s
Catholic
  • Aquinas AMBROSE; Or out of the same bed of human…
––
Protestant–
  • Henry We have here a discourse of Christ's concerning the…
  • Brown Lu 17:20-37. Coming of the Kingdom of God and…

What does Aquinas say about Luke 17:36?

Thomas Aquinas

1225–1274 · Medieval Catholic · Catena Aurea: Commentary on the Four Gospels, Collected out of the Works of the Fathers. Vol. III: St. Luke

AMBROSE; Or out of the same bed of human infirmity, one is left, that is, rejected, another is taken up, that is, is caught to meet Christ in the air. By the two grinding together, he seems to imply the poor and the oppressed. To which belongs what follows. Two men shall be in the field, &c. For in these there is no slight difference. For some nobly bear up against the burden of poverty, leading a lowly but honest life, and these shall be taken up; but the others are very active in wickedness, and they shall be left. Or those grinding at the mill seem to represent such as seek nourishment from hidden sources, and from secret places draw forth things openly to view. And perhaps the world is a kind of corn mill, in which the soul is shut up as in a bodily prison. And in this corn mill either the synagogue or the soul exposed to sin, like the wheat, softened by grinding and spoilt by too great moisture, cannot separate the outward from the inner parts, and so is left because its flour dissatisfies. But the holy Church, or the soul which is not soiled by the stains of sin, which grinds such wheat as is ripened by the heat of the eternal sun, presents to God a good flour from the secret shrines of the heart. Who the two men in the field are we may discover if we consider, that there are two minds in us, one of the outer man which wasteth away, the other of the inner man which is renewed by the Sacrament. These are then the labourers in the field, the one of which by diligence brings forth good fruit, the other by idleness loses that which he has. Or those who are compared we may interpret to be two nations, one of which being faithful is taken, the other being unfaithful is left.

Report a mistake

AUG. Or there are three classes of men here represented. ut sup! The first is composed of those who prefer their ease and quiet, and busy not themselves in secular or ecclesiastical concerns. And this quiet life of theirs is signified by the bed. The next class embraces those who being placed among the people are governed by teachers. And such he has described by the name of women, because it is best for them to be ruled by the advice of those who are set over them; and he has described these as grinding at the mill, because in their hands revolves the wheel and circle of temporal concerns. And with reference to these matters he has represented them as grinding together, inasmuch as they give their services to the benefit of the Church. The third class are those who labour in the ministry of the Church as in the field of God. In each of these three classes then there are two sorts of men, of which the one abide in the Church and are taken up, the other fall away and are left. AMBROSE; For God is not unjust that He should separate in His reward of their deserts men of like pursuits in life, and not differing in the quality of their actions. But the habit of living together does not equalize the merits of men, for not all accomplish what they attempt, but he only who shall persevere to the end shall be saved. CYRIL; When He said that some should be taken up, the disciples not unprofitably inquire, ' Where, Lord?'

Report a mistake

BEDE; Our Lord was asked two questions, where the good should be taken up, and where the bad left; He gave only one answer, and left the other to be understood, saying, Wheresoever the body is, thither will the eagles be gathered together. CYRIL; As if He said, As when a dead body is thrown away, all the birds which feed on human flesh flock to it, so when the Son of man shall come, all the eagles, that is, the saints, shall haste to meet Him. AMBROSE; For the souls of the righteous are likened to eagles, because they soar high and forsake the lower parts, and are said to live to a great age. Now concerning the body, we can have no doubt, and above all if we remember that Joseph received the body from Pilate. And do not you see the eagles around the body are the women and Apostles gathered together around our Lord's sepulchre? Do not you see them then, when he shall come in the clouds, and every eye shall him? ... And this body is the Church, in which by the grace of baptism we are renewed in the Spirit. EUSEB. Or by the eagles feeding on the dead animals, he has here described the rulers of the world, and those who shall at that time persecute the saints of God, in whose power are left all those who are unworthy of being taken up, who are called the body or carcase. Or by the eagles are meant the avenging powers which shall fly about to torment the wicked. AUG. Now these things which Luke has given a different place from Matthew, he either relates by anticipation, so as to mention beforehand what was afterwards spoken by our Lord, or he means us to understand that they were twice uttered by Him, XVIII.

Report a mistake

What does Henry say about Luke 17:36?

Matthew Henry

1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume V (Matthew to John): Luke

On Luke 17:20–37

This comment begins at Luke 17:20:

We have here a discourse of Christ's concerning the kingdom of God, that is, the kingdom of the Messiah, which was now shortly to be set up, and of which there was great expectation.

On Luke 17:34–36

This comment begins at Luke 17:34:

7. That all good Christians should certainly escape, but many of them very narrowly, from that destruction, v. 34-36. When God's judgments are laying all waste, he will take an effectual course to preserve those that are his, by remarkable…

What does Brown say about Luke 17:36?

David Brown

1803–1897 · Reformed (Free Church of Scotland) · A Commentary, Critical and Explanatory, on the Old and New Testaments: Luke

On Luke 17:20–37

This comment begins at Luke 17:20:

Lu 17:20-37. Coming of the Kingdom of God and of the Son of Man.

Read Luke 17 with all its commentary