Logia

Matthew · Chapter 7 · Judging others

Matthew 7:9

Would any of you give your child a stone when they asked for bread?

ἢ τίς ἐστιν ἐξ ὑμῶν ἄνθρωπος, ὃν αἰτήσει ὁ υἱὸς αὐτοῦ ἄρτον μὴ λίθον ἐπιδώσει αὐτῷ; Word by word ↓

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

5 commentators in Logia comment on Matthew 7:9, from John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) to J. C. Ryle (1816–1900): Chrysostom, Aquinas, Calvin, Henry and Ryle.

Topics: Prayer

Two voices on Matthew 7:9

Choose two:

What the church has said

See all 5 voices as a grid

Eras across, traditions down, each with its first words. An empty cell is a place the library has no voice yet.

Early churchMiddle AgesReformationPuritans and the 1700sThe 1800s
Catholic–
  • Aquinas Aug., Serm. in Mont., ii, 21: As above He…
–––
Protestant––
  • Calvin 9. Is there any man among you? It is…
  • Henry 3. It is illustrated, by a similitude taken from…
  • Ryle The first portion of these verses is one of…
Church Fathers
  • Chrysostom “For what man is there of you,” saith He,…
––––

What does Chrysostom say about Matthew 7:9?

John Chrysostom

c. 347–407 · Patristic (Greek East) · Homilies on the Gospel of Saint Matthew

Homily XXIII. Matt. VII. 1

“For what man is there of you,” saith He, “whom if his son ask bread, will he give him a stone?”

Because, as among men, if thou keep on doing so, thou art even accounted troublesome, and disgusting: so with God, when thou doest not so, then thou dost more entirely provoke Him. And if thou continue asking, though thou receive not at once, thou surely wilt receive. For to this end was the door shut, that He may induce thee to knock: to this end He doth not straightway assent, that thou mayest ask. Continue then to do these things, and thou wilt surely receive. For that thou mightest not say, “What then if I should ask and not receive?” He hath blocked up thy approach with that similitude, again framing arguments, and by those human things urging us to be confident on these matters; implying by them that we must not only ask, but ask what we ought.

“For which of you is there, a father, of whom if his son shall ask bread, will he give him a stone?” So that if thou receive not, thy asking a stone is the cause of thy not receiving. For though thou be a son, this suffices not for thy receiving: rather this very thing even hinders thy receiving, that being a son, thou askest what is not profitable.

Report a mistake

Do thou also therefore ask nothing worldly, but all things spiritual, and thou wilt surely receive. For so Solomon, because he asked what he ought, behold how quickly he received. Two things now, you see, should be in him that prays, asking earnestly, and asking what he ought: “since ye too,” saith He, “though ye be fathers, wait for your sons to ask: and if they should ask of you anything inexpedient, ye refuse the gifts; just as, if it be expedient, ye consent and bestow it.” Do thou too, considering these things, not withdraw until thou receive; until thou have found, retire not; relax not thy diligence, until the door be opened. For if thou approach with this mind, and say, “Except I receive, I depart not;” thou wilt surely receive, provided thou ask such things, as are both suitable for Him of whom thou askest to give, and expedient for thee the petitioner. But what are these? To seek the things spiritual, all of them; to forgive them that have trespassed, and so to draw nigh asking forgiveness; “to lift up holy hands without wrath and doubting.” If we thus ask, we shall receive. As it is, surely our asking is a mockery, and the act of drunken rather than of sober men.

“What then,” saith one, “if I ask even spiritual things, and do not receive?” Thou didst not surely knock with earnestness; or thou madest thyself unworthy to receive; or didst quickly leave off.

“And wherefore,” it may be inquired, “did He not say, what things we ought to ask”? Nay verily, He hath mentioned them all in what precedes, and hath signified for what things we ought to draw nigh. Say not then, “I drew nigh, and did not receive.” For in no case is it owing to God that we receive not, God who loves us so much as to surpass even fathers, to surpass them as far as goodness doth this evil nature.

Report a mistake

What does Aquinas say about Matthew 7:9?

Thomas Aquinas

1225–1274 · Medieval Catholic · Catena Aurea: Commentary on the Four Gospels, Collected out of the Works of the Fathers. Vol. I: St. Matthew

“Or what man is there of you, whom if his son ask bread, will he give him a stone?

Aug., Serm. in Mont., ii, 21: As above He had cited the birds of the air and the lilies of the field, that our hopes may rise from the less to the greater; so also does He in this place, when He says, “Or what man among you?”

Pseudo-Chrys.: Lest perchance any one considering how great is the difference between God and man, and weighing his own sins should despair of obtaining, and so never take in hand to ask; therefore He proposes a comparison of the relation between father and son; that should we despair because of our sins, we may hope because of God’s fatherly goodness.

Chrys.: There are two things behoveful for one that prays; that he ask earnestly; and that he ask such things as he ought to ask. And those are spiritual things; as Solomon, because he asked such things as were right, received speedily.

Pseudo-Chrys.: And what are the things that we ought to ask, he shews under the likeness of a loaf, and a fish. The loaf is the word concerning the knowledge of God the Father. The stone is all falsehood that has a stumbling-block of offence to the soul.

Remig.: By the fish we may understand the word concerning Christ, by the serpent the Devil himself.

Or by the loaf may be understood spiritual doctrine; by the stone ignorance; by the fish the water of Holy Baptism; by the serpent the wiles of the Devil, or unbelief.

Rabanus: Or; bread which is the common food signifies charity, without which the other virtues are of no avail. The fish signifies faith, which is born of the water of baptism, is tossed in the midst of the waves of this life and yet lives. Luke adds a third thing, “an egg,” [Luke 11:12] which signifies hope; for an egg is the hope of the animal. To charity, He opposes “a stone,” that is, the hardness of hatred; to faith, “a serpent,” that is, the venom of treachery; to hope, “a scorpion,” that is, despair, which stings backward, as the scorpion.

Report a mistake

Remig.: The sense therefore is: we need not fear that should we ask of God our Father bread, that is doctrine or love, He will give us a stone; that is, that He will suffer our heart to be contracted either by the frost of hatred or by hardness of soul; or that when we ask for faith, He will suffer us to die of the poison of unbelief.

Report a mistake

What does Calvin say about Matthew 7:9?

John Calvin

1509–1564 · Reformed · Commentary on a Harmony of the Evangelists, Matthew, Mark, and Luke: Matthew

Is there any man among you?

9. Is there any man among you? It is a comparison from the less to the greater. First, our Lord contrasts the malice of men with the boundless goodness of God. Self-love (φιλαυτία) renders us malicious: for every man is too much devoted to himself, and neglects and disregards others. But this vice yields to the stronger feelings of a father’s love, so that men forget themselves, and give to their children with overflowing liberality. Whence comes this, but because God, of whom the whole family in heaven and earth is named, (Ephesians 3:15,) drops into their hearts a portion of his goodness? But if the little drops produce such an amount of beneficence, what ought we to expect from the inexhaustible ocean? Would God, who thus opens the hearts of men, shut his own? Let us also remember that passage of Isaiah, “Though a mother forget her children,” (Isaiah 49:15,) yet the Lord will be like himself, and will always show himself to be a Father.

Report a mistake

What does Henry say about Matthew 7:9?

Matthew Henry

1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume V (Matthew to John): Matthew

On Matthew 7:7–11

This comment begins at Matthew 7:7:

Our Saviour, in the foregoing chapter, had spoken of prayer as a commanded duty, by which God is honoured, and which, if done aright, shall be rewarded; here he speaks of it as the appointed means of obtaining what we…

On Matthew 7:7–11

This comment begins at Matthew 7:7:

II. Here is a promised annexed: our labour in prayer, if indeed we do labour in it, shall not be in vain: where God finds a praying heart, he will be found a prayer-hearing God; he shall give thee an…

On Matthew 7:9–10

3. It is illustrated, by a similitude taken from earthly parents, and their innate readiness to give their children what they ask. Christ appeals to his hearers, What man is there of you, though never so morose and ill-humoured, whom if his son ask bread, will he give him a stone? v. 9, 10. Whence he infers (v. 11), If ye then, being evil, yet grant your children's requests, much more will your heavenly Father give you the good things you ask. Now this is of use,

(1.) To direct our prayers and expectations. [1.] We must come to God, as children to a Father in heaven, with reverence and confidence. How naturally does a child in want or distress run to the father with its complaints; My head, my head; thus should the new nature send us to God for supports and supplies. [2.] We must come to him for good things, for those he gives to them that ask him; which teaches us to refer ourselves to him; we know not what is good for ourselves (Eccl. vi. 12), but he knows what is good for us, we must therefore leave it with him; Father, thy will be done. The child is here supposed to ask bread, that is necessary, and a fish, that is wholesome; but if the child should foolishly ask for a stone, or a serpent, for unripe fruit to eat, or a sharp knife to play with, the father, though kind, is so wise as to deny him. We often ask that of God which would do us harm if we had it; he knows this, and therefore does not give it to us. Denials in love are better than grants in anger; we should have been undone ere this if we had had all we desired; this is admirably well expressed by a heathen, Juvenal, Sat. 10.

Permittes ipsis expendere numinibus, quid

Conveniat nobis, rebusque sit utile nostris,

Nam pro jucundis aptissima quæque dabunt dii.

Carior est illis homo, quam sibi: nos animorum

Impulsu, et cæca, magnaque cupidine ducti,

Conjugium petimus, partumque uxoris; at illis

Notum est, qui pueri, qualisque futura sit uxor.

Entrust thy fortune to the powers above.

Leave them to manage for thee, and to grant

What their unerring wisdom sees thee want:

In goodness, as in greatness, they excel;

Ah, that we lov'd ourselves but half so well!

We, blindly by our headstrong passions led,

Seek a companion, and desire to wed;

Then wish for heirs: but to the gods alone

Our future offspring and our wives are known.

Report a mistake

On Matthew 7:9–10

To encourage our prayers and expectations

(2.) To encourage our prayers and expectations. We may hope that we shall not be denied and disappointed: we shall not have a stone for bread, to break our teeth (though we have a hard crust to employ our teeth), nor a serpent for a fish, to sting us; we have reason indeed to fear it, because we deserve it, but God will be better to us than the desert of our sins. The world often gives stones for bread, and serpents for fish, but God never does; nay, we shall be heard and answered, for children are by their parents. [1.] God has put into the hearts of parents a compassionate inclination to succour and supply their children, according to their need. Even those that have had little conscience of duty, yet have done it, as it were by instinct. No law was ever thought necessary to oblige parents to maintain their legitimate children, nor, in Solomon's time, their illegitimate ones. [2.] He has assumed the relation of a Father to us, and owns us for his children; that from the readiness we find in ourselves to relieve our children, we may be encouraged to apply ourselves to him for relief. What love and tenderness fathers have are from him; not from nature but from the God of nature; and therefore they must needs be infinitely greater in himself. He compares his concern for his people to that of a father for his children (Ps. ciii. 13), nay, to that of a mother, which is usually more tender, Isa. lxvi. 13; xlix. 14, 15. ...

Report a mistake

On Matthew 7:9–10

... But here it is supposed, that his love, and tenderness, and goodness, far excel that of any earthly parent; and therefore it is argued with a much more, and it is grounded upon this undoubted truth, that God is a better Father, infinitely better than any earthly parents are; his thoughts are above theirs. Our earthly fathers have taken care of us; we have taken care of our children; much more will God take care of his; for they are evil, originally so; the degenerate seed of fallen Adam; they have lost much of the good nature that belonged to humanity, and among other corruptions, have that of crossness and unkindness in them; yet they give good things to their children, and they know how to give, suitably and seasonably; much more will God, for he takes up when they forsake, Ps. xxvii. 10. And, First, God is more knowing; parents are often foolishly fond, but God is wise, infinitely so; he knows what we need, what we desire, and what is fit for us. Secondly, God is more kind. If all the compassions of all the tender fathers in the world were crowded into the bowels of one, yet compared with the tender mercies of our God, they would be but as a candle to the sun, or a drop to the ocean. God is more rich, and more ready to give to his children than the fathers of our flesh can be; for he is the Father of our spirits, an ever-loving, ever-living Father. The bowels of Fathers yearn even towards undutiful children, towards prodigals, as David's toward Absalom, and will not all this serve to silence disbelief?

Report a mistake

What does Ryle say about Matthew 7:9?

J. C. Ryle

1816–1900 · Anglican (Evangelical) · Expository Thoughts on the Gospels: St. Matthew

On Matthew 7:1–11

This comment begins at Matthew 7:1:

The first portion of these verses is one of those passages of Scripture which we must be careful not to strain beyond its proper meaning. It is frequently abused and misapplied by the enemies of true religion. It is possible…

On Matthew 7:1–11

This comment begins at Matthew 7:1:

The second portion of these verses teaches us the importance of exercising discretion as to the persons with whom we speak on the subject of religion. Everything is beautiful in its place and season. Our zeal is to be tempered…

On Matthew 7:1–11

This comment begins at Matthew 7:1:

The last portion of these verses teaches us the duty of prayer, and the rich encouragements there are to pray. There is a beautiful connection between this lesson and that which goes before it. Would we know when to be…

On Matthew 7:1–11

This comment begins at Matthew 7:1:

Do we ever really pray? If not, we shall at last be without excuse before God except we repent. We shall not be condemned for not doing what we could not have done, or not knowing what we could not…

Cited on other verses

Commentators citing Matthew 7:9 while explaining another verse. The sentence is copied as the excerpt reads.

  • Matthew Henry · Luke 6:20–26

    Here begins a practical discourse of Christ, which is continued to the end of the chapter, most of which is found in the sermon upon the mount, Matt. v. and vii..

  • Matthew Henry · Luke 6:37–49

    All these sayings of Christ we had before in Matthew; some of them in ch. vii., others in other places.

  • Matthew Henry · Matthew 9:35

    There it ushers in the more particular record of Christ's preaching (ch. v., vi. and vii.) and of his cures (ch. viii. and ix.), and here it is elegantly repeated in the close of these instances, as the quod erat demonstrandum—the point to be proved; as if the evangelist should say, "Now I hope I have made …

  • B. F. Westcott · John 4:17

    well said] It is possible that there is something of a sad irony in the words, as there is in Matt vii. 9 ; 2 Cor. xi. 4.

The Greek words

WordDictionary formGlossGrammar
ἢἤOrParticle
τίςτίςwhichInterrogative pronoun · nominative singular masculine
ἐστινεἰμίisVerb · present active indicative · 3rd person singular
ἐξἐκofPreposition
ὑμῶνσύyouPersonal pronoun · 2nd person genitive plural
ἄνθρωποςἄνθρωποςa manNoun · nominative singular masculine
ὃνὅςwhomRelative pronoun · accusative singular masculine
αἰτήσειαἰτέωwill ask forVerb · future active indicative · 3rd person singular
ὁὁtheArticle · nominative singular masculine
υἱὸςυἱόςsonNoun · nominative singular masculine
αὐτοῦαὐτόςof himPersonal pronoun · genitive singular masculine
ἄρτονἄρτοςbreadNoun · accusative singular masculine
μὴμήnotParticle · negative
λίθονλίθοςa stoneNoun · accusative singular masculine
ἐπιδώσειἐπιδίδωμιwill he giveVerb · future active indicative · 3rd person singular
αὐτῷαὐτόςhimPersonal pronoun · dative singular masculine

From MACULA (CC BY 4.0), as the Open Word Bible reads them.

How the Open Word Bible translates Matthew 7:9

Word for word: Or who is from you a man, whom will ask the son of him bread, not a stone will he give him?

a question that expects the answer "no one" Grammar

Not: a real question

The Greek form shows the answer expected: no parent would do it.

bread and a stone: a round loaf and a stone of the same shape Culture

Not: any food and any object

A small round loaf looked like a stone (4:3). The cruel trick would be to give something like what was asked for, but useless.

your child Reader setting

Not: your son

The point is a parent's care for any child, so the inclusive form is the default.

Cross-references

  • Luke 11:11-13 3 voices Is there a father among you who would hand his son a snake when the boy asked for a fish?

Cross-references from OpenBible.info (CC BY), most voted first.

Read Matthew 7 with all its commentary