Logia

Genesis · Chapter 44 · The silver cup

Genesis 44:17

But Joseph answered, "I would never do such a thing! Only the one who had the cup will be my slave. The rest of you may return safely to your father."

וַיֹּ֕אמֶר חָלִ֣ילָה לִּ֔י מֵעֲשׂ֖וֹת זֹ֑את הָאִ֡ישׁ אֲשֶׁר֩ נִמְצָ֨א הַגָּבִ֜יעַ בְּיָד֗וֹ ה֚וּא יִהְיֶה־לִּ֣י עָ֔בֶד וְאַתֶּ֕ם עֲל֥וּ לְשָׁל֖וֹם אֶל־אֲבִיכֶֽם׃פ Word by word ↓

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

3 commentators in Logia comment on Genesis 44:17, from John Calvin (1509–1564) to Robert Jamieson (1802–1880): Calvin, Henry and Jamieson.

Two voices on Genesis 44:17

Choose two:

What the church has said

See all 3 voices as a grid

Eras across, traditions down, each with its first words. An empty cell is a place the library has no voice yet.

ReformationPuritans and the 1700sThe 1800s
Protestant
  • Calvin 17. God forbid that I should do so If…
  • Henry Joseph heaps further kindnesses upon his brethren, fills their…
  • Jamieson 16-34. Judah said, What shall we say?—This address needs…

What does Calvin say about Genesis 44:17?

John Calvin

1509–1564 · Reformed · Commentaries on the First Book of Moses called Genesis

God forbid that I should do so

17. God forbid that I should do so If Joseph intended to retain Benjamin alone, and to dismiss the others, he would have done his utmost, to rend the Church of God by the worst possible dissension. But I have previously shown (what may also be elicited from the context) that his design was nothing else than to pierce their hearts more deeply. He must have anticipated great mischief, if he had perceived that they did not care for their brother: but the Lord provided against this danger, by causing the earnest apology of Judah not only to soften his mind, but even to draw forth tears and weeping in profusion.

Report a mistake

What does Henry say about Genesis 44:17?

Matthew Henry

1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume I (Genesis to Deuteronomy): Genesis

On Genesis 44:1–17

This comment begins at Genesis 44:1:

Joseph heaps further kindnesses upon his brethren, fills their sacks, returns their money, and sends them away full of gladness; but he also exercises them with further trials. Our God thus humbles those whom he loves and loads with benefits.…

On Genesis 44:1–17

This comment begins at Genesis 44:1:

III. How the theft was fastened upon Benjamin. In his sack the cup was found to whom Joseph had been particularly kind. Benjamin, no doubt, was ready to deny, upon oath, the taking of the cup, and we may suppose…

On Genesis 44:1–17

This comment begins at Genesis 44:1:

V. Joseph, with an air of justice, gives sentence that Benjamin only should be kept in bondage, and the rest should be dismissed; for why should any suffer but the guilty? Perhaps Joseph intended hereby to try Benjamin's temper, whether…

What does Jamieson say about Genesis 44:17?

Robert Jamieson

1802–1880 · Church of Scotland (Presbyterian) · Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible: Genesis

On Genesis 44:16–34

This comment begins at Genesis 44:16:

16-34. Judah said, What shall we say?—This address needs no comment—consisting at first of short, broken sentences, as if, under the overwhelming force of the speaker's emotions, his utterance were choked, it becomes more free and copious by the effort…

The Hebrew words

WordDictionary formGlossGrammar
וַ
wa
וְandConjunction
יֹּ֕אמֶר
yyōʾmer
אָמַרhe.saidVerb · Qal · past narrative (wayyiqtol) · 3rd person masculine singular
חָלִ֣ילָחָלִילָהfarParticle · interjection
ההbe.itSuffix · paragogic he
לִּ֔לְtoPreposition
יהוּאmeSuffix · pronoun · 1st person common singular
מֵ
mē
מִןfromPreposition
עֲשׂ֖וֹת
ʿăśôṯ
עָשָׂהdoingVerb · Qal · infinitive construct
זֹ֑את
zōʾṯ
זֹאתthisPronoun · demonstrative · feminine singular
הָ
hā
הַtheParticle · definite article
אִ֡ישׁ
ʾiyš
אִישׁmanNoun · common · masculine singular absolute
אֲשֶׁר֩
ʾăšer
אֲשֶׁרwhomParticle · relative
נִמְצָ֨א
nimṣāʾ
מָצָאit.was.foundVerb · Niphal · perfect (qatal) · 3rd person masculine singular
הַ
ha
הַtheParticle · definite article
גָּבִ֜יעַ
gāḇiyᵃʿ
גָּבִיעַcupNoun · common · masculine singular absolute
בְּ
bə
בְּinPreposition
יָד֗יָדhandNoun · common · masculine or feminine singular construct (of ...)
וֹהוּאhisSuffix · pronoun · 3rd person masculine singular
ה֚וּא
hûʾ
הוּאhePronoun · personal · 3rd person masculine singular
יִהְיֶה
yihyeh-
הָיָהhe.will.beVerb · Qal · imperfect (yiqtol) · 3rd person masculine singular
לִּ֣לְPreposition
יהוּאmySuffix · pronoun · 1st person common singular
עָ֔בֶד
ʿāḇeḏ
עֶבֶדslaveNoun · common · masculine singular absolute
וְ
wə
וְandConjunction
אַתֶּ֕ם
ʾattem
אַתֶּםyouPronoun · personal · 2nd person masculine plural
עֲל֥וּ
ʿălû
עָלָהgo.upVerb · Qal · imperative · 2nd person masculine plural
לְ
lə
לְtoPreposition
שָׁל֖וֹם
šālôm
שָׁלוֹםpeaceNoun · common · masculine singular absolute
אֶל
ʾel-
אֶלtoPreposition
אֲבִיאָבfatherNoun · common · masculine singular construct (of ...)
כֶֽםהוּאyourSuffix · pronoun · 2nd person masculine plural

From MACULA (CC BY 4.0), as the Open Word Bible reads them.

How the Open Word Bible translates Genesis 44:17

Word for word: And he said, far be it to me from doing this; the man in whose hand the cup was found, he will be my slave; and you, go up in peace to your father.

go up in peace to your father: the test Theology

Joseph offers the brothers the same choice they once made: to go home free and leave Rachel's son behind as a slave in Egypt (37:28). What they do now shows whether they have changed.

slave Word choice

Not: servant

"Slave" at every level: one man stays as a slave and the rest go home free (m1), so the style guide keeps the word.

Read Genesis 44 with all its commentary