Logia

Matthew · Chapter 28 · The tomb is empty

Matthew 28:16

The eleven disciples made their way to Galilee, to the mountain Jesus had appointed for them.

Οἱ δὲ ἕνδεκα μαθηταὶ ἐπορεύθησαν εἰς τὴν Γαλιλαίαν εἰς τὸ ὄρος οὗ ἐτάξατο αὐτοῖς ὁ Ἰησοῦς, Word by word ↓

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

5 commentators in Logia comment on Matthew 28:16, from John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) to J. C. Ryle (1816–1900): Chrysostom, Aquinas, Calvin, Henry and Ryle.

Two voices on Matthew 28:16

Choose two:

What the church has said

See all 5 voices as a grid

Eras across, traditions down, each with its first words. An empty cell is a place the library has no voice yet.

Early churchMiddle AgesReformationPuritans and the 1700sThe 1800s
Catholic–
  • Aquinas Bede, Beda in Hom., non occ.: When Saint Matthew…
–––
Protestant––
  • Calvin Matthew 28:16. And the eleven disciples went into Galilee.…
  • Henry This evangelist passes over several other appearances of Christ,…
  • Ryle These verses form the conclusion of the Gospel of…
Church Fathers
  • Chrysostom “Then the eleven disciples went away into Galilee, and…
––––

What does Chrysostom say about Matthew 28:16?

John Chrysostom

c. 347–407 · Patristic (Greek East) · Homilies on the Gospel of Saint Matthew

On Matthew 28:16–17

Homily XC. Matt. XXVIII. 11-14

“Then the eleven disciples went away into Galilee, and some worshipped, and some when they saw Him doubted.”

This seems to me to be the last appearance in Galilee, when He sent them forth to baptize. And if “some doubted,” herein again admire their truthfulness, how they conceal not even their shortcomings up to the last day. Nevertheless, even these are assured by their sight.

What then saith He unto them, when He seeth them? “All power is given unto me in heaven and on earth.” Again He speaketh to them more after the manner of man, for they had not yet received the spirit, which was able to raise them on high. “Go ye, make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost: teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you;” giving the one charge with a view to doctrine, the other concerning commandments. And of the Jews He makes no mention, neither brings forward what had been done, nor upbraids Peter with his denial, nor any one of the others with their flight, but having put into their hands a summary of the doctrine, that expressed by the form of baptism, commands them to pour forth over the whole world.

Report a mistake

On Matthew 28:16–17

After that, because he had enjoined on them great things, to raise their courage, He says, “Lo! I am with you alway, even unto the end of the world.” Seest thou His own proper power again? Seest thou how those other things also were spoken for condescension? And not with those men only did He promise to be, but also with all that believe after them. For plainly the apostles were not to remain here unto “the end of the world;” but he speaks to the believers as to one body. For tell me not, saith He, of the difficulty of the things: for “I am with you,” who make all things easy. This He said to the prophets also in the Old Testament continually, as well to Jeremiah objecting his youth, as to Moses and Ezekiel shrinking from the office, “I am with you,” this here also to these men. And mark, I pray thee, the excellence of these, for the others, when sent to one nation, often excused themselves, but these said nothing of the sort, though sent to the world. And He reminds them also of the consummation, that He may draw them on more, and that they may look not at the present dangers only, but also at the good things to come that are without end.

“For the irksome things, saith He, that ye will undergo are finished together with the present life, since at least even this world itself shall come to an end, but the good things which ye shall enjoy remain immortal, as I have often told you before.” Thus having invigorated and roused their minds, by the remembrance of that day, He sent them forth. For that day to them that live in good works is to be desired, even as on the other hand to those in sin, it is terrible as to the condemned.

Report a mistake

On Matthew 28:16–17

But let us not fear only, and shudder, but let us change too, while there is opportunity, and let us rise out of our wickedness, for we can, if we be willing. For if before grace many did this, much more after grace.

3. For what grievous things are we enjoined? to cleave mountains asunder? to fly into the air? or to cross the Tuscan sea? By no means, but a way of life so easy, as not so much as to want any instruments, but a soul and purpose only. For what instruments had these apostles, who effected such things? Did they not go about with one vestment and unshod? and they got the better of all.

For what is difficult of the injunctions? Have no enemy. Hate no man. Speak ill of no man. Nay, the opposites of these things are the greater hardships. But He said, you reply, Throw away thy money. Is this then the grievous thing? In the first place, He did not command, but advised it. Yet even if it were a command, what is it grievous not to carry about burdens and unseasonable cares?

But oh covetousness! All things are become money; for this cause all things are turned upside down. If anyone declares another happy, he mentions this; should he pronounce him wretched, hence is derived the description of wretchedness. And all reckonings are made on this account, how such an one gets rich, how such an one gets poor. Should it be military service, should it be marriage, should it be a trade, should it be what you will that any man takes in hand, he does not apply to what is proposed, until he see these riches are coming in rapidly upon him. After this shall we not meet together and consult how we shall drive away this pest? Shall we not regard with shame the good deeds of our fathers? of the three thousand, of the five thousand, who had all things common?

Report a mistake

On Matthew 28:16–17

What is the profit of this present life, when we do not use it for our future gain? How long do ye not enslave the mammon that hath enslaved you? How long are ye slaves of money? How long have ye no love for liberty, and do not rend in pieces the bargains of covetousness? But while, if ye should have become slaves of men, you do all things, if any one should promise you liberty; yet being captives of covetousness, ye do not so much as consider how ye may be delivered from this bitter bondage. And yet the one were nothing terrible, the other is the most bitter tyranny.

Consider how great a price Christ paid for us. He shed His own blood; He gave up Himself. But ye, even after all this, are grown supine; and the most grievous thing of all is, that ye even take delight in the slavery, ye luxuriate in the dishonor, and that, from which ye ought to flee, is become an object of desire to you.

Report a mistake

On Matthew 28:16–17

But since it is right not only to lament and to blame, but also to correct, let us see from what cause this passion and this evil have become an object of desire to you. Whence then, whence hath this come to be an object of desire? Because, thou sayest, it makes me to be in honor and in security. In what kind of security, I pray thee? In the confidence, not to suffer hunger, nor cold, not to be harmed, not to be despised. Wilt thou then, if we promise thee this security, refrain from being rich? For if it is for this that riches are an object of desire, if it be in your power to have security without these, what need hast thou of these any more? “And how is it possible,” thou sayest, “for one who is not rich to attain to this?” Nay, how is it possible (for I say the opposite thing) if one is rich? For it is necessary to flatter many, both rulers and subjects, and to entreat countless numbers, and to be a base slave, and to be in fear and trembling, and to regard with suspicion the eyes of the envious, and to fear the tongues of false accusers, and the desires of other covetous men. But poverty is not like this, but altogether the contrary. It is a place of refuge and security, a calm harbor, a wrestling ground, and school of exercise to learn self-command, an imitation of the life of angels.

Report a mistake

On Matthew 28:16–17

Hear these things, as many as are poor; or rather also, as many as desire to be rich. It is not poverty that is the thing to be feared, but the not being willing to be poor. Account poverty to be nothing to fear, and it will not be to thee a matter for fear. For neither is this fear in the nature of the thing, but in the judgment of feeble-minded men. Or rather, I am even ashamed that I have occasion to say so much concerning poverty, to show that it is nothing to be feared. For if thou practise self-command, it is even a fountain to thee of countless blessings. And if any one were to offer thee sovereignty, and political power, and wealth, and luxury, and then having set against them poverty, were to give thee thy choice to take which thou wouldest, thou wouldest straightway seize upon poverty, if indeed thou knewest the beauty thereof.

4. And I know that many laugh, when these things are said; but we are not troubled but we require you to stay, and soon ye will give judgment with us. For to me poverty seems like some comely, fair, and well-favored damsel, but covetousness like some monster shaped woman, some Scylla or Hydra, or some other like prodigies feigned by fabulous writers.

For bring not forward, I pray thee, them that accuse poverty, but them that have shone thereby. Nurtured in this, Elias was caught up in that blessed assumption. With this Eliseus shone; with this John; with this all the apostles; but with the other, Ahab, Jezebel, Gehazi, Judas, Nero, Caiaphas, were condemned.

Report a mistake

On Matthew 28:16–17

But if it please you, let us not look to those only that have been glorious in poverty, but let us observe the beauty itself of this damsel. For indeed her eye is clear and piercing, having nothing turbid in it, like the eye of covetousness, which is at one time full of anger, at another sated with pleasure, at another troubled by incontinence. But the eye of poverty is not like this, but mild, calm, looking kindly on all, meek, gentle, hating no man, shunning no man. For where there are riches, there is matter for enmity, and for countless wars. The mouth again of the other is full of insults, of a certain haughtiness, of much boasting, cursing, deceit; but the mouth and the tongue of this are sound, filled with continual thanksgiving, blessing, words of gentleness, of affection, of courtesy, of praise, of commendation. And if thou wouldest see also the proportion of her members, she is of a goodly height, and far loftier than wealth. And if many flee from her, marvel not at it, for indeed so do fools from the rest of virtue.

But the poor man, thou wilt say, is insulted by him that is rich. Again thou art declaring to me the praise of poverty. For who, I pray thee, is blessed, the insulter, or the insulted? It is manifest that it is the insulted person. But then, the one, covetousness, urges to insult the other; poverty persuades to endure. “But the poor man suffers hunger,” thou wilt say. Paul also suffered hunger, and was in famine. “But he has no rest.” Neither “had the Son of Man where to lay His head.”

Report a mistake

On Matthew 28:16–17

Seest thou how far the praises of poverty have proceeded, and where it places thee, to what men it leads thee on, and how it makes thee a follower of the Lord? If it were good to have gold, Christ, who have the unutterable blessings, would have given this to His disciples. But now so far from giving it them, He forbad them to have it. Wherefore Peter also, so far from being ashamed of poverty, even glories in it, saying, “Silver and gold have I none; but what I have give I thee.” And who of you would not have desired to utter this saying? Nay, we all would extremely, perhaps some one may say. Then throw away thy silver, throw away thy gold. “And if I throw it away, thou wilt say, shall I receive the power of Peter?” Why, what made Peter blessed, tell me? Was it indeed to have lifted up the lame man? By no means, but the not having these riches, this procured him Heaven. For of those that wrought these miracles, many fell into hell, but they, who did those good things, attained a kingdom. And this you may learn even of Peter himself. For there were two things that he said, “Silver and gold have I none;” and, “In the name of Jesus Christ rise up and walk.”

Report a mistake

On Matthew 28:16–17

Which sort of thing then made Him glorious and blessed, the raising up the lame man, or the casting away his money? And this you may learn from the Master of the conflicts Himself. What then doth He Himself say to the rich man seeking eternal life? He said not, “raise up the lame,” but, “Sell thy goods, and give to the poor, and come and follow me, and thou shalt have treasure in Heaven.” And Peter again said not, “Behold, in Thy name we cast out devils;” although he was casting them out, but, “Behold, we have forsaken all and followed Thee what shall we have?” And Christ again, in answering this apostle, said not, “If any man raise up the lame,” but, “Whosoever hath forsaken houses or lands, shall receive an hundredfold in this world, and shall inherit everlasting life.”

Report a mistake

What does Aquinas say about Matthew 28:16?

Thomas Aquinas

1225–1274 · Medieval Catholic · Catena Aurea: Commentary on the Four Gospels, Collected out of the Works of the Fathers. Vol. I: St. Matthew

Then the eleven disciples went away into Galilee, into a mountain where Jesus had appointed them.

Bede, Beda in Hom., non occ.: When Saint Matthew has vindicated the Lord’s Resurrection as declared by the Angel, he relates the vision of the Lord which the disciples had, “Then the eleven disciples went into Galilee into a mountain where Jesus had appointed them.”

For when coming to His Passion the Lord had said to His disciples, “After I am risen I will go before you into Galilee;” [Matt 26:32] and the Angel said the same to the women. Therefore the disciples obey the command of their Master. Eleven only go, for one had already perished.

Jerome: After His Resurrection, Jesus is seen and worshipped in the mountain in Galilee; though some doubt, their doubting confirms our faith.

Remig.: This is more fully told by Luke; how when the Lord after the Resurrection appeared to the disciples, in their terror they thought they saw a spirit.

Report a mistake

Bede, Hom. Aest. in Fer., vi., Pasch. ... : The Lord appeared to them in the mountain to signify, that His Body which at His Birth He had taken of the common dust of the human race, He had by His Resurrection exalted above all earthly things; and to teach the faithful that if they desire there to see the height of His Resurrection, they must endeavour here to pass from low pleasures to high desires.

And He goes before His disciples into Galilee, because “Christ is risen from the dead, the first fruits of them that slept.” [1 Cor 15:20] And they that are Christ’s follow Him, and pass in their order from death to life, contemplating Him as He appears with His proper Divinity. And it agrees with this that Galilee is interpreted ‘revelation.’

Aug., de Cons. Ev., iii, 25: But it is to be considered, how the Lord could be seen bodily in Galilee. For that it was not the day of the Resurrection is manifest; for He was seen that day in Jerusalem in the beginning of the night, as Luke and John evidently agree. Nor was it in the eight following days, after which John says that the Lord appeared to His disciples, and when Thomas first saw Him, who had not seen Him on the day of the Resurrection.

For if within these eight days the eleven had seen Him on a mountain in Galilee, Thomas, who was one of the eleven, could not have seen Him first after the eight days. Unless it be said, that the eleven there spoken of were eleven out of the general body of the disciples, and not the eleven Apostles.

But there is another difficulty. John having related that the Lord was seen not in the mountain, but at the sea of Tiberias, by seven who were fishing, adds, “This is now the third time that Jesus shewed himself to his disciples after he was risen from the dead. [John 21:14]

Report a mistake

So that if we understand the Lord to have been seen within those eight days by eleven of the disciples, this manifestation at the sea of Tiberias will be the fourth, and not the third, appearance. Indeed, to understand John’s account at all it must be observed, that he computes not each appearance, but each day on which Jesus appeared, though He may have appeared more than once on the same day; as He did three times on the day of His Resurrection. We are then obliged to understand that this appearance to the eleven disciples on the mountain in Galilee took place last of all.

In the four Evangelists we find in all ten distinct appearances of Our Lord after His Resurrection.

1. At the sepulchre to the women.

2. To the same women on their way back from the sepulchre.

3. To Peter.

4. To two disciples as they went into the country.

5. To many together in Jerusalem;

6. when Thomas was not with them.

7. At the sea of Tiberias.

8. At the mountain in Galilee, according to Matthew.

9. To the eleven as they sat at meat, because they should not again eat with Him upon earth, related by Mark. [Mark 16:14]

10. On the day of His Ascension, no longer on the earth, but raised aloft in a cloud, as related by both Mark and Luke.

But all is not written, as John confesses, for He had much conversation with them during forty days before His ascension, “being seen of them, and speaking unto them of the things pertaining to the kingdom of God.” [Acts 1:3]

Report a mistake

What does Calvin say about Matthew 28:16?

John Calvin

1509–1564 · Reformed · Commentary on a Harmony of the Evangelists, Matthew, Mark, and Luke: Matthew

And the eleven disciples went into Galilee

Matthew 28:16. And the eleven disciples went into Galilee. Matthew, passing by those occurrences which we have taken out of the other three Evangelists, mentions only in what place the eleven disciples were appointed to the apostolic office. For—as we have already had frequent opportunities of perceiving—it was not the intention of the Evangelists to embrace every part of the history; because the Holy Spirit, who guided their pen, has thought fit to compose such a summary as we see out of their united testimonies. Matthew has therefore selected what was of the greatest importance to us, namely, that when Christ appeared to the disciples, he likewise commissioned them to be apostles, to convey into every part of the world the message of eternal life.

Report a mistake

To the mountain where Jesus had appointed them

To the mountain where Jesus had appointed them. Though the mountain is not mentioned any where else, yet we con-elude that this spot in Galilee was known to Mary.

Report a mistake

What does Henry say about Matthew 28:16?

Matthew Henry

1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume V (Matthew to John): Matthew

How the disciples attended his appearance, according to the appointment

This evangelist passes over several other appearances of Christ, recorded by Luke and John, and hastens to this, which was of all other the most solemn, as being promised and appointed again and again before his death, and after his resurrection. Observe,

I. How the disciples attended his appearance, according to the appointment (v. 16); They went into Galilee, a long journey to go for one sight of Christ, but it was worth while. They had seen him several times at Jerusalem, and yet they went into Galilee, to see him there.

1. Because he appointed them to do so. Though it seemed a needless thing to go into Galilee, to see him whom they might see at Jerusalem, especially when they must so soon come back again to Jerusalem, before his ascension, yet they had learned to obey Christ's commands and not object against them. Note, Those who would maintain communion with Christ, must attend him there where he has appointed. Those who have met him in one ordinance, must attend him in another; those who have seen him at Jerusalem, must go to Galilee.

2. Because that was to be a public and general meeting. They had seen him themselves, and conversed with him in private, but that should not excuse their attendance in a solemn assembly, where many were to be gathered together to see him. Note, Our communion with God in secret must not supersede our attendance on public worship, as we have opportunity; for God loves the gates of Zion, and so must we. The place was a mountain in Galilee, probably the same mountain on which he was transfigured. There they met, for privacy, and perhaps to signify the exalted state into which he was entered, and his advances toward the upper world.

Report a mistake

What does Ryle say about Matthew 28:16?

J. C. Ryle

1816–1900 · Anglican (Evangelical) · Expository Thoughts on the Gospels: St. Matthew

On Matthew 28:11–20

This comment begins at Matthew 28:11:

These verses form the conclusion of the Gospel of St. Matthew. They begin by showing us what absurdities blind prejudice will believe, rather than believe the truth; they go on to show us what weakness there is in the hearts…

On Matthew 28:11–20

This comment begins at Matthew 28:11:

Let us embrace this truth reverently and cling to it firmly. Christ is He has the keys of death and hell; Christ is the anointed priest, who alone can absolve sinners; Christ is the fountain of living waters, in whom…

On Matthew 28:11–20

This comment begins at Matthew 28:11:

It is very difficult to conceive, when we read this last command of our Lord’s, how men can avoid the conclusion that baptism is necessary, when it may be had. It seems impossible to explain the word that we have…

On Matthew 28:11–20

This comment begins at Matthew 28:11:

This is a searching expression. It shows the uselessness of a mere name and form of Christianity; it shows that they are to be counted true Christians who live in a practical obedience to his word, and strive to do…

On Matthew 28:11–20

This comment begins at Matthew 28:11:

This truth is a great mystery. Let it be enough to receive and believe it, and let us ever abstain from all attempts at explanation. It is childish folly to refuse assent to things that we do not understand. We…

On Matthew 28:11–20

This comment begins at Matthew 28:11:

Let all true Christians lay hold on these words and keep them in mind. Christ is “with us” always: Christ is “with us” wherever we go. He came to be “Emmanuel, God with us” when he first came into the…

The Greek words

WordDictionary formGlossGrammar
Οἱὁ-Article · nominative plural masculine
δὲδέAndConjunction
ἕνδεκαἕνδεκαthe elevenAdjective · number, indeclinable
μαθηταὶμαθητήςdisciplesNoun · nominative plural masculine
ἐπορεύθησανπορεύομαιwentVerb · aorist passive (deponent) indicative · 3rd person plural
εἰςεἰςintoPreposition
τὴνὁ-Article · accusative singular feminine
ΓαλιλαίανΓαλιλαίαGalileeNoun · accusative singular feminine
εἰςεἰςtoPreposition
τὸὁtheArticle · accusative singular neuter
ὄροςὄροςmountainNoun · accusative singular neuter
οὗοὗwhereAdverb
ἐτάξατοτάσσωassignedVerb · aorist middle indicative · 3rd person singular
αὐτοῖςαὐτόςthemPersonal pronoun · dative plural masculine
ὁὁ-Article · nominative singular masculine
ἸησοῦςἸησοῦςJesusNoun · nominative singular masculine

From MACULA (CC BY 4.0), as the Open Word Bible reads them.

How the Open Word Bible translates Matthew 28:16

Word for word: The and eleven disciples went into Galilee to the mountain where had appointed them Jesus, \v 17 and having seen him they worshiped, some but doubted.

the eleven: the Twelve without Judas Culture

Not: a different group of disciples

Judas had betrayed Jesus and hanged himself (27:3-5).

the mountain Jesus had appointed: a place he had named to them Word sense

Not: a mountain they chose

The verb means to arrange or appoint. Matthew has not told us when Jesus named the place, and he does not name the mountain. In Matthew mountains are places where Jesus teaches and is revealed (5:1; 17:1).

some doubted: some of the eleven hesitated GrammarUncertain

Not: they all worshiped, though they doubted · others who were present doubted

The words can mean that some of the eleven doubted, that all of them worshiped and yet wavered, or that others there doubted. The verb means to waver or hesitate, as of Peter on the water (14:31); it is not refusal to believe. Matthew does not explain it, and Jesus comes to them all (28:18).

worshiped: bowed down before him Word sense

Not: paid him respect

As in 28:9, the women's response is now the disciples' (compare 14:33).

had doubts Word choice

Not: doubted · hesitated

Balanced uses a phrase that leaves room for wavering rather than unbelief.

Cross-references

  • Matthew 26:32 3 voices But after I have been raised, I will go to Galilee ahead of you."
  • Matthew 28:10 4 voices Then Jesus told them, "Have no fear. Go and take word to My brothers: they are to set out for Galilee, and there they will see Me."
  • Matthew 28:7 4 voices Hurry now, and give His disciples this message: 'He has been raised from the dead! He is on His way to Galilee ahead of you, and that is where you will see Him.' That is my message to you."
  • Mark 16:14 1 voice Later He appeared to the eleven themselves as they were eating. He rebuked them for their unbelief and their stubborn hearts, because they had not believed those who had seen Him risen.
  • Acts 1:13-26 Back in the city, they climbed to the upstairs room where they had been lodging. Peter was there, with John, James and Andrew, Philip and Thomas, Bartholomew and Matthew, James son of Alphaeus, Simon the Zealot, and Judas son of James.

Cross-references from OpenBible.info (CC BY), most voted first.

Read Matthew 28 with all its commentary