B. F. Westcott · The Gospel According to St. John: The Authorised Version with Introduction and Notes
John 9
50 excerpts on John 9, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
The Sign (i—12).
The narrative of the healing is marked by the same kind of vivid details as we have noticed before. The occasion of the miracle, the peculiarity of the mode of cure, the reference to Siloam, are without direct parallels, and yet in perfect harmony with other narratives. The variety of opinion among the people and the mention of "the man called Jesus" belong to the experience of an immediate witness.
CHAP. IX. 1. as Jesus passed by] perhaps in the neighbourhood of the temple where the man was waiting for the alms of worshippers (Acts iii. 2). The word ..., which is rarely used (Matt. ix. 9 ; Mark ii. 14; Matt. ix. 27, xx. 30; Mark xv. 21), directs notice to the attendant circumstances. The narrative has been generally connected with the events of the preceding chapter owing to the false reading in viii. 59. It stands really as an independent record.
he saw] Something in the man's condition seems- to have arrested the attention of the Lord. The word is significant. Naturally we should have expected "the disciples saw and asked."
blind from his birth] The miracles recorded in St John's Gospel stand out each as a type of its class. Hence stress is laid upon this special fact.
John 9:1–12 · Open Word Bible
1As Jesus was passing by, He saw a man who had been blind from birth. 2His disciples asked Him, "Rabbi, who sinned, so that this man was born blind? Was it he, or his parents?" 3Jesus answered, "It was not that this man sinned, or his parents. It was so that the works of God might be made visible in him. …
The thoughts of the controversy recorded in ch. viii. seem to have passed away. At once "a great calm" has come. The Lord stands in the centre of His disciples, and not of an angry crowd. Yet the question of the disciples moves in the same spiritual region as the speculations on inherited religious privileges and divine Sonship. ...
John 9:2 · Open Word Bible
2His disciples asked Him, "Rabbi, who sinned, so that this man was born blind? Was it he, or his parents?"
Master
Rabbi. Comp. i. 38, 49, iii. 2, iv. 31, vi. 25, xi. 8. The use of the Aramaic term is characteristic of St John, though it is found Matt. xxvi. 25, 49; Mark ix. 5, xi. 21, xiv. 45.
Perhaps it is most natural to suppose that the question, which in itself belongs to a Jewish mode of thought, was asked without any distinct apprehension of the alternatives involved in it. Lightfoot ... has a curious collection of Rabbinical passages illustrating different forms of opinion on this subject.
born blind] From the disciples' acquaintance with this fact it may be supposed that the history of the man was popularly known.
The Lord's answer deals only with the special case (comp. Luke xiii. 1 ff., and for the general idea towards which it is directed, Acts xxviii. 4) ; and that only so far as it is an occasion for action and not a subject for speculation. We are not concerned primarily with the causes which have determined the condition or circumstances of men, with the origin of evil in any of its forms, but with the remedying of that which is amiss and remediable. It is true always, in one way or other, that for us evil is an opportunity for the manifestation of the works of God. ...
John 9:3 · Open Word Bible
3Jesus answered, "It was not that this man sinned, or his parents. It was so that the works of God might be made visible in him.
in him
The man is not treated as an instrument merely, but as a living representative of the mercy of God. His suffering is the occasion and not the appointed preparation for the miracle, though when we regard things from the divine side we are constrained to see them m their dependence on the will of God.
must...sent me
According to the more probable reading: we must (work the works of Him that sent me. So the Lord associates His disciples with Himself as before in iii. 1 1. The truth is general and holds good of the Master and of the servants. They are sent for the manifestation of the works of God. But the obligation of the servant's charge comes from the Master's mission. The works are no longer regarded as "the works of God" generally, but "the works of Him that sent" the Son.
while it is day] while the appointed time for working still remains: Ps. civ. (ciii.) 23. "Day" and "night" are taken in their most general sense as the seasons for labour and rest in regard to the special end in view. After the Passion there was no longer the opportunity for the performance of the works characteristic of the historic Life of Christ. Then in one sense "night" came, and in a yet fuller sense a new day dawned for new works, to be followed by another night, another close. It is not to be supposed that the "night" here describes an abiding and complete rest of Christ: it presents rest only from the works which belong to the corresponding "day."
The image partially finds place in the 'Sayings of the Jewish Fathers:' "R. Tarphon ... said, The day is short, and the task is great, and the workmen are sluggish, and the reward is much, and the Master of the house is urgent" ('Pirke Aboth,' ii. 19).
John 9:4 · Open Word Bible
4While it is still day, we have to do the works of the one who sent Me. Night is on its way, and then no one can work.
the night cometh
night cometh... The order is significant. The emphasis is laid upon the certain and momentary advance of that which ends all successful efforts in the present order: there cometh swiftly and inevitably night, when no man (one) can work. The necessary cessation of labour is expressed in its completest form.
As long as...world
Whensoever I am in the world ...... The indefinite form of the statement suggests the thought of the manifold revelations of the Word. " Whensoever" and not only during that revelation which was then in the course of being fulfilled, but also in the time of the Patriarchs, and of the Law, and of the Prophets, and through the later ages of the Church, Christ is the light of the world. ...
John 9:5 · Open Word Bible
5While I am in the world, I am the light of the world."
the light of the world
... The character is unchangeable, but the display of the character varies with the occasion. In this case it is shewn in personal illumination. Bodily sight is taken as the representation of the fulness of human vision ....
he spat on the ground
Com p. Mark vii. 33, viii. 23. We must suppose that the attention of the blind man was by this time fully roused, perhaps by the conversation just recorded, or by some words addressed to him.
The application of spittle to the eyes, which was considered very salutary (comp. Tac. 'Hist.' IV. 81), was expressly forbidden by Jewish tradition , on the Sabbath. See Wetstein or Lightfoot, ad loc. The kneading of the clay further aggravated the offence.
be anointed... the clay] He anointed his eyes with the clay. At first Christ may seem to work against the end for which His help is sought. Here He sealed, so to speak, the eyes which He designed to open. It is impossible to determine why the Lord chose this method of working the cure. In the end the mode proved all-important.
John 9:6 · Open Word Bible
6When He had said this, He spat on the ground, made mud with the saliva, and spread the mud on the man's eyes.
wash
i.e. thine eyes ..., Matt. vi. 17; ch. xiii. 6, note.
in (m) the pool] i.e. go to the pool and wash thine eyes there.
Siloam, (which is by interpretation (which is Interpreted), Sent] The idea which underlies this note of the Evangelist appears to be that in vii. 37 f. The stream which issued from the heart of the rock was an image of Christ. In the passage of Isaiah (viii. 6) "the waters of Siloah that go softly" are taken as the type of the divine kingdom of David resting on Mount Zion, in contrast with "the waters of the river [Euphrates], strong and mighty, even the king of Assyria and all his glory," the symbol of earthly power. ...
John 9:7 · Open Word Bible
7Then He told him, "Go and wash in the pool of Siloam" (the name means Sent). So the man went and washed, and he came back able to see.
His working with the promises of the prophets. Thus, in some sense, God Himself, whose law Christ was accused of breaking, was seen to cooperate with Him in the miracle. At the same time the charge tried the faith of the blind man.
Siloam] The name of the pool properly indicates a discharge of waters ... "sent," in this case, from a subterranean channel. For the form see Ewald, ' Gramm.' § 156, 2, a. The pool, which still retains its old name, Birket Silwan, is one of the few undisputed sites at Jerusalem. It lies at the mouth of the Tyropoeon Valley, south of the temple, "at the foot of Mount Moriah," in Jerome's words. " The two pools of Siloam were probably made for the irrigation of the gardens below, and seem always to have been a favourite place for washing purposes; besides the surface drainage they received a supply of water from the Fountain of the Virgin by means of a subterranean channel. The upper pool is small " [an oblong reservoir cut in the rock, about fifty feet long, sixteen feet broad, and eighteen feet deep], "and at the south-west corner has a rude flight of steps leading to the bottom ; but the whole is fast going to ruin, and the accumulation of rubbish around is very great ; a little below this a dam of solid masonry has been built across the valley, forming the end of the lower and larger pool, now nearly filled up with rich soil and covered with a luxuriant growth of fig trees " (Wilson, ' Notes on the Ordnance Survey of Jerusalem,' p. 79). See Ritter, 'Palestine,' IV. 148 ff (Eng. Tr.), and ' Dict. of Bible,' s. v., for notices of the site in earlier writers.
Sent
The interpretation of the name connects the pool with Christ (xvii. 3, &c.), and not with the man. See above.
He went his way] He went away.
came] to his own home, as it appears from the context (the neighbours).
The neighbours therefore
No mark of time is given. This scene may belong to the following day, as v. 13 ff. certainly do (v. 14).
... The particle is capable of both meanings (that, because). In other passages (iv. 19, xii. 19) St John uses the phrase certainly for " see. . .that. ..;" here however "because" suits the context better: because he was a beggar in a public spot, they were familiar with his appearance.
The circumstantiality of the narrative which follows seems to shew that the man himself related the events to the evangelist.
John 9:8 · Open Word Bible
8His neighbors, and others who had seen him earlier as a beggar, began asking, "Is this not the man who sat begging?"
Some said...others said , He
Others said. ..others said No, but he.. . Two classes of people apparently are mentioned different from the first group.
he said] The pronoun here and in vv. 1 1, 12, 28, 36 is remarkable .... It presents the man as the chief figure in a scene viewed from without. " He, that signal object of the Lord's love...." (comp. ii. 21, v. 11, (x. 6), (xiii. 30), xix. 21), and not "He himself," in contrast with the opinions of others.
John 9:9 · Open Word Bible
9Some said, "That is the man." Others said, "No, it is someone who looks like him." The man himself kept saying, "I am the one."
How
How then.... It is to be observed that all the stress is laid upon the manner and not upon the fact. Comp. vv. 15, 19, 26.
John 9:10 · Open Word Bible
10So they asked him, "How were your eyes opened?"
He...and said
He answered.
A man (The man, Vulg. Hic homo) that is called Jesus] Not "that is called the Christ." He had learnt the personal name of the Lord, but says nothing of His claims to Messiahship. The form of the sentence, however, points to the general attention which was directed to the Lord. It is "the man" not '-a man; " the man of whom report speaks often.
Go to... of Siloam] Go to Siloam.
and I went. . . ] so I went.
I received sight] Strictly, I recovered my sight ... (Matt. xi. 5 ; Mark x. 51 f. ; Luke xviii. 41 ff.), for sight by nature belongs to a man even though he has been born blind. This sense appears to us better than: " I looked up" (Mark xvi. 4).
John 9:11 · Open Word Bible
11He answered, "The man named Jesus made mud and spread it on my eyes. He told me, 'Go to Siloam and wash.' So I went off and washed, and I began to see."
Then said they...Where is he
that strange, unwelcome teacher, of whom we hear so much. Comp. vii. 11, v. 10 note.
He said] He saith.
John 9:12 · Open Word Bible
12They asked him, "Where is He?" "I do not know," he said.
$ The judgments on the sign (13—34).
The examination of the man who was healed offers a typical example of the growth of faith and unbelief. On the one side the Pharisees, who take their stand on a legal preconception, grow more determined and violent : 1 6 (debate, division) ; 24 (Judgment); 34 (disgraceful expulsion). On the other side the man gains courage and clearness in his answers: 17 (He is a prophet. Opinion) ; 30 ff. (acceptance of discipleship~)\ and finally he openly confesses Christ, v. 38.
The characters thus live and move, and shew marked traits of individuality. There is nothing vague, nothing conventional, in the narrative. The record includes three scenes : the first examination of the man (13 — 17); the examination of his parents (18 — 23); the final examination and expulsion of the man (24—34).
John 9:13–34 · Open Word Bible
13They took the man who had been blind to the Pharisees. 14Now it was on a Sabbath that Jesus had made the mud and opened his eyes. 15So the Pharisees in turn asked him how he had gained his sight. He told them, "He put mud on my eyes, I washed, and I can see now." …
They brought to the Pharisees
as the recognised judges in religious questions. There were in Jerusalem two smaller courts, or Synagogue Councils, and the man was probably taken to one of these. In the later sections of the narrative, vv. 18 ff., the general title the Jews is used.
John 9:13 · Open Word Bible
13They took the man who had been blind to the Pharisees.
it was the sabbath day when
The original phrase, according to the oldest text, is remarkable. It reads literally, "It was a sabbath on the day on which," i.e. the day was a Sabbath whereon .... Comp. v. 9.
made the clay] The words mark the feature in the miracle which technically gave offence. Comp. v. 12.
John 9:14 · Open Word Bible
14Now it was on a Sabbath that Jesus had made the mud and opened his eyes.
Then again
Again therefore the Pharisees also... as not content with the report of others (vv. 10, 11).
how he had received...] how he received... The answer is more curt than before (v. 11); and there is already something of impatience in the tone of it, which breaks out afterwards, v. 27. The making of the clay and the command to go to Siloam are passed over.
John 9:15 · Open Word Bible
15So the Pharisees in turn asked him how he had gained his sight. He told them, "He put mud on my eyes, I washed, and I can see now."
Therefore said
because to the legalist no other conclusion seemed to be possible.
Others ... said, How can... a sinner] It is presupposed therefore that Christ had valid authority for the apparent violation of the Sabbath.
a division] as before "in the multitude" (vii. 43) and afterwards "in the Jews" (x. 19). One party, it will be noticed, laid stress upon the fact, the others upon a preconceived opinion by which they judged of the fact.
John 9:16 · Open Word Bible
16Then some of the Pharisees said, "This man does not come from God, because He does not keep the Sabbath." But others said, "How could a sinful man do signs like these?" And they were divided.
They say...again
as hoping to elicit some fresh details.
What...eyes?] What dost thou ... say — we appeal to your own judgment and to the impression made upon you — What do at thou say of him, seeing that he opened thine eyes? For the construction, see ii. 18.
John 9:17 · Open Word Bible
17So they questioned the man who had been blind once more: "And you, what do you say about Him, since it was your eyes He opened?" He answered, "He is a prophet."
18—23.
The examination of the parents of the man follows the examination of the man himself. They shrink with singular naturalness from incurring the displeasure of the dominant party.
John 9:18–23 · Open Word Bible
18The Jewish leaders did not believe that he had been blind and had gained his sight, until they summoned the parents of the man who could now see. 19They asked them, "Is this your son, the one you say was born blind? So how is he able to see now?" 20His parents answered, "We know he is our son, and we know he was born blind. …
But the Jews
The Jews therefore...seeing that they could not reconcile a real miracle with disregard to the Sabbath. They probably suspected some collusion on the part of the man.
The Jews represent the incredulous section of the Pharisees (v. 16). ...
John 9:18 · Open Word Bible
18The Jewish leaders did not believe that he had been blind and had gained his sight, until they summoned the parents of the man who could now see.
And they asked
... And asked.. .The words are closely connected with the preceding clause.
who ye say was...] of whom ye ... •"*/, from whom we may expect certain information, that he was...
John 9:19 · Open Word Bible
19They asked them, "Is this your son, the one you say was born blind? So how is he able to see now?"
But by what means
But how... as in vv. 10, 15, 19, 26.
we know not. . ,we ... know not] The emphatic insertion of the pronoun in the second case gives a new turn to the phrase: "we directly, of our own experience, know not, as you appeal to us, who opened his eyes."
John 9:21 · Open Word Bible
21But how he can see now, we do not know, and we do not know who opened his eyes. Ask him. He is of age and can answer for himself."
These words spake
These things said...
had agreed... that...] had formed a compact among themselves ... to secure this end, that... Comp. Acts xxiii. 20. The idea is not that they had determined on a punishment, but that they had determined on an aim.
that he was Christ] The question had already been publicly debated, vii. 26 ff. ; though the Lord had not so revealed Himself in Jerusalem (x. 34) as He had done in Samaria ....
put out of the synagogue] xii. 42, xvi. 2. This excommunication appears to have been exclusion from all religious fellowship (comp. Matt. xviii. 17) from "the congregation of Israel." In later times there were different degrees of excommunication, the Curse ..., and the Isolation .... Comp. Buxtorf, 'Lex.' s. v. 'HI Lightfoot and Wunsche, ad loc.
John 9:22 · Open Word Bible
22His parents spoke in this way out of fear of the Jewish leaders, who had already agreed that anyone who confessed Him as the Christ would be expelled from the synagogue.
Therefore
For this cause... ..., seeing that the hostility of the Jews was now passing into action.
John 9:23 · Open Word Bible
23This was why his parents said, "He is of age. Question him."
Then again...the man
So they called the man a second time: we must suppose that he was dismissed after the confession in v. 17. ...
Give God the praise] Give glory to God. The phrase ... is a solemn charge to declare the whole truth. Compare Josh. vii. 19 ; 1 Esdr. ix. 8; (1 S. vi. 5). The man by his former declaration (v. 17) had really (so they imply) done dishonour to God. He was now required to confess his error : to recognise in the authoritative voice of "the Jews" his own condemnation, and to admit the truth of it. At the same time under this thought of the rendering of glory to God by the confession of error, lies the further idea that the cure was due directly to God, and that to Him, and not to "the man called Jesus," was gratitude to be rendered. ...
John 9:24 · Open Word Bible
24So they summoned the man who had been blind a second time and said to him, "Give glory to God. We know that this man is a sinner."
we know
We, the guardians of the national honour, the interpreters of the divine will, we know ...... The claim is to absolute knowledge, and no reasons are alleged for the conclusion.
a sinner] by the violation of the Sabbath O. 16).
He answered and said
He therefore answered.
Whether,..! know not] The order in the original is remarkable: If he is a sinner, as you assert, that I know not. The first clause is an echo of the words of the Pharisees, and the man simply states that his knowledge furnishes no confirmation of it. Comp. Luke xxii. 67; Acts iv. 19, xix. 2. In 1 John iv. 1 and elsewhere the order is different.
John 9:25 · Open Word Bible
25He answered, "Whether He is a sinner, I do not know. I do know one thing: I used to be blind, and now I can see."
Then said they...again
They said therefore to him.
What did he...? bow...?] The questions suggest that they were yet willing to believe, if the facts were not decisive against belief.
John 9:26 · Open Word Bible
26Then they asked him, "What did He do to you? How did He open your eyes?"
... The would points the idea suggested by the fresh interrogation.
John 9:27 · Open Word Bible
27He answered them, "I have told you already, and you would not listen. Why do you want to hear it again? Could it be that you want to become His disciples as well?"
Then they reviled him
by questioning his loyalty to the law, and treating him as an apostate. Comp. Acts xxiii. 4.
his disciples] Literally, that man's disciple. Comp. vv. 13, 37. Christ is looked upon as separated from them by a great chasm.
John 9:28 · Open Word Bible
28They insulted him and said, "You are a disciple of that man, but we are disciples of Moses.
We know
The claim to knowledge is repeated (v. 24) with a bitter emphasis. " Moses" and "this man" stand at the head of the two clauses to make the contrast sharper.
spake] hath spoken familiarly, face to face ..., and the words abide still.
as for (but as for)... whence he is] that is, with what commission, by whose authority, he comes. Comp. Matt. xxi. 25. The converse objection is urged, vii. 27. Pilate at last asks the question, xix. 9 ; and the Lord claims for Himself alone the knowledge of the answer, viii. 14.
John 9:29 · Open Word Bible
29We know that God has spoken to Moses. Where this man comes from, we do not know."
Why herein is a marvellous thing
... The particle brings out an affirmation drawn from the previous words. "That being so as you say. then assuredly..."
that ye ...] from whom we look for guidance...
and yet ... he hath opened ......] For the and, see viii. 20 note.
John 9:30 · Open Word Bible
30The man answered them, "Well, here is something to wonder at: you do not know where He comes from, and still He opened my eyes!
Now we know
We know, not you alone, nor I, but all men alike. The simple verb ... is contrasted with the strong personal affirmation in vv. 24, 29 ....
if any man be a (worshipper of God, and doeth (be devout or religious and do)...]
I Or, excommunicated him.
The word ... occurs here only in New Testament (comp. 1 Tim. ii. 10). The two phrases mark the fulfilment of duty to God and man.
John 9:31 · Open Word Bible
31We know that God does not listen to sinners. But if someone reveres God and does His will, He listens to them.
Since the world began
The exact phrase ... does not occur elsewhere in New Testament. ...
John 9:32 · Open Word Bible
32In all the ages, no one has ever heard of anyone opening the eyes of someone born blind.
The order is very significant: "In sins wast thou born altogether." So the Jews at once interpret and apply the question of the disciples, v. 2. Blindness was but a sign of deeper and more prevailing infirmity.
teach us] The emphasis lies on "teach." " Dost thou, marked out as a sinner, assume the prerogative of instruction...."
cast him out] from the place of their meeting, with contempt and contumely, as unworthy of further consideration. Comp. Mark i. 43, note. The word does not describe the sentence of excommunication, which such a body was not competent to pronounce.
John 9:34 · Open Word Bible
34They answered him, "You were born in sin through and through, and now you are teaching us?" And they threw him out.
The beginning of the ne<w Society (35—41).
The ejection of the blind man who had been healed from the council of the Pharisees furnished the occasion for the beginning of a new Society distinct from the dominant Judaism. For the first time the Lord offers Himself as the object of faith, and that in His universal character in relation to humanity, as "the Son of man." He had before called men to follow Him: He had revealed Himself, and accepted the spontaneous homage of believers: but now He proposes a test of fellowship. The universal Society is based on the confession of a new truth. The blind who acknowledge their blindness are enlightened: the seeing who are satisfied with their sight (we know) are proved to be blind.
John 9:35–41 · Open Word Bible
35Jesus heard that they had thrown the man out, and when He found him, He said, "Do you believe in the Son of Man?" 36The man answered, "Who is He, Sir? Tell me, so that I may believe in Him." 37Jesus said to him, "You have seen Him; He is the one who is speaking with you." …
Jesus heard
The man himself may well have spoken of his treatment.
when he had found (having found) him, he said unto him] Omit unto him. Comp. i. 43, v. 14. The "work of God" was not yet completed. Modo lavat faciem cordis in Augustine's words.
Dost thou believe on the Son of God (man) ?] The emphasis of the pronoun is remarkable, and may be contrasted with v. 34. Dost thou, the outcast, thou that hast received outward sight, thou that hast borne a courageous testimony, believe on the Son of Man— cast thyself with complete trust on Him who gathers up in Himself, who bears and who transfigures all that belongs to man? The thought of "the Son of man" stands in true contrast with the selfish isolation of "the Jews." The new Society, seen here in its beginning, rests upon this foundation, wide as humanity itself. ...
John 9:35 · Open Word Bible
35Jesus heard that they had thrown the man out, and when He found him, He said, "Do you believe in the Son of Man?"
Who is he
And who is he... The conjunction marks the eager, urgent, wondering question. The thought which it meets seems to be beyond hope. Comp. Mark x. 26; Luke x. 29.
that I might (may)...] He asks that faith may find its object. His trust in Jesus is absolute.
John 9:36 · Open Word Bible
36The man answered, "Who is He, Sir? Tell me, so that I may believe in Him."
And Jesus said (Jesus saith)... Thou hast both seen him — with the eyes which God hath even now opened — and he that talketh with thee IB he .... The natural form of the sentence would have been "Thou hast both seen Him and heard Him;" but the power of the immediate position gives shape to the latter clause. "He that talketh with thee familiarly, as man with man, is He, that sublime Person, who seems to stand far off from thought and experience."
John 9:37 · Open Word Bible
37Jesus said to him, "You have seen Him; He is the one who is speaking with you."
Confession in word and deed follows at once on the revelation. In St John "worship" ... is never used of the worship of mere respect (iv. 20 ff., xii. 20).
Lord, I believe] I believe, Lord. The order is significant.
John 9:38 · Open Word Bible
38He said, "I believe, Lord." And he worshiped Him.
And Jesus said
not directly to any one nor to any group of those about Him, but as interpreting the scene before Him. ...
For judgment I (ryw) am come (I came)...] not to execute judgment ..., but that judgment ... might issue from His Presence. The Son was not sent to judge (iii. 17), but judgment followed from His advent in the manifestation of faith and unbelief (iii. 1 8 f.). The emphatic pronoun carries back the reference to the "Son of man."
this world] the world as made known to us in its present state, full of conflict and sin, and so distinguished from the world which includes all created being. The phrase occurs viii. 23, xi. 9, xii. 45, 31, xiii. 1, xvi. 11, xviii. 36; 1 John iv. 17.
that they... might... might...] that they... may ...may...
they which see not] The true commentary on these verses is Luke x. 21 || Matt. xi. 25, and Matt. xii. 31, 34. The phrase must be taken literally to describe those who have no intellectual knowledge, no clear perception of the divine will and the divine law ; the simple, the little children. These by apprehending the revelation of the Son of man grasp the fulness of the Gospel, and see. Those on the other hand who had knowledge of the Old Covenant, who were so far "wise and understanding," and rested in what they knew, by this very wisdom became incapable of further progress and unable to retain what they had.
be made (become) blind] By wilfully confining their vision men lose the very power of seeing. ... The former have the power of sight though it is unused : the latter have not the power.
John 9:39 · Open Word Bible
39Jesus said, "I came into this world to bring judgment, so that those who cannot see will see, and those who see will become blind."
And some of the Pharisees which were with him
who still followed under the guise of discipleship (Matt. xii. 2 f., 38; Luke vi. 2; Mark xvi. 10, &c.), but clung to their own views of Messiah's work (viii. 31 ff.).
these words] these things.
Are we blind also?] Are we also blind? we who have acknowledged Thy claims in advance — we who in virtue of our insight (iii. 2) have come to know Thee while others are in 'doubt (x. 24)? Can it be that we who saw then have now lost the power of sight ? The question (like the claim of Nicodemus, iii. 2, we know) is inspired by the pride of class. The answer lays open the responsibility of privilege. Better — such is the force of it — is the lack of knowledge, than knowledge real and misused. ...
John 9:40 · Open Word Bible
40Some of the Pharisees who were with Him heard this and said to Him, "You do not mean that we are blind too, do you?"
ye should have no sin
Comp. xv. 22, 24, xix. 11; 1 John i. 8. Sin is regarded as something cleaving to the man himself, which has become (so to speak) part of him, and for which he is responsible.
but now ye say, We see] There seems to be a pathetic pause after these words. Then at last follows the sentence: "You plead the reality of your knowledge, and the plea, in this sense, is just. You are witnesses against yourselves. Then is there no further illumination. ...
John 9:41 · Open Word Bible
41Jesus said to them, "If you were blind, you would have no sin. But you say, 'We can see,' so your sin remains."
There is a remarkable saying assigned to R. Abuhu which expresses the thought of this verse. A Sadducee asked him, When cometh the Messiah? "Go first," was the answer, "and make dark this people." "What sayest thou? That is a reproach to me." "I appeal" answered the Rabbi "to Isai. lx. 2." ('Sanhedrin,' 99a, quoted by Wünsche on John iii. 19.)