Logia

B. F. Westcott · The Gospel According to St. John: The Authorised Version with Introduction and Notes

John 8

79 excerpts on John 8, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

John 8:1

the mount of Olives

The Mount of Olives is nowhere mentioned by name in St John's Gospel. It is mentioned several times in each of the other Gospels in connexion with the last scenes of the Life of the Lord.

Report a mistake

John 8:2

he sat down

assumed the position of the authoritative teacher. Compare Matt. v. 1, xxiii. 2; Mark ix. 35.

Report a mistake

John 8:3

the scribes and Pharisees

This is a common title in the Synoptists for the body summarily described by St John as the Jews. Compare Luke v. 30, vi. 7, xi. 53, xv. 2. St John never names "the scribes."

brought (bring) unto him] We may suppose that the guilty woman had been brought first to them as a preparatory step to her trial.

Report a mistake

John 8:4

was taken

hath been taken. The original ... brings the present reality of guilt vividly before the reader ....

Report a mistake

John 8:5

Now Moses in the law...that such should be stoned

Deut. xxii. 43 f. The punishment of stoning was specified in the case of a betrothed bride. The form of death in other cases was not laid down, and according to Talmudic tradition it was strangulation. It seems better therefore to suppose that this exact crime had been committed than to suppose any inaccuracy in the statement. It is said also that a priest's daughter was stoned if she committed adultery ; but this was not a provision of the Law. Compare Lightfoot, ad loc.

but what] what therefore. .. Assuming this enactment as explicit, what conclusion canst thou draw for the guidance of our action in the present case ? Thou claimest to speak with authority and to fulfil the Law : solve our difficulty now.

Report a mistake

John 8:6

This...tempting him

Compare Matt. xxii. 18. The dilemma corresponds to that in the question as to the tribute money. To affirm the binding validity of the Mosaic judgment would be to counsel action contrary to the Roman law. To set the Mosaic judgment aside would be to give up the claim to fulfil the Law. In either case there was material for accusation, practically fatal to the assumption of the Messiahship to which the Lord's teaching evidently pointed. He might be carried away into a premature declaration of His claims, and fall under the civil power; or he might disparage Moses, and lose the favour of the people. The "temptation" lay in the design to lead the Lord to one of these two answers.

wrote] Both here ..., and in v. 8 ..., the tense in the original presents the action as going on before the witnesses. It is quite vain to conjecture what was written, if indeed we are to understand anything more than the mere mechanical action of writing. The attitude represents one who follows out his own thoughts and is unwilling to give heed to those who question him. The very strangeness of the action marks the authenticity of the detail. ...

Report a mistake

John 8:7

He that is without sin

The colour of the word "sinless" is caught from the context. Though it would be unnatural to assume that all in the group of accusers were actually guilty of adultery, there is nothing unnatural in supposing that each could feel in himself the sinful inclination which had here issued in the sinful act. In this way the words of the Lord revealed to the men the depths of their own natures, and they shrank in that Presence from claiming the prerogative of innocence. At the same time the question as to the woman's offence was raised at once from a legal to a spiritual level. The judges were made to feel that freedom from outward guilt is no claim to sinlessness. And the offender in her turn was led to see that flagrant guilt does not bar hope. The Law as in a figure dealt with that which is visible; the Gospel penetrates to the inmost soul.

first] taking, as it were, the place of the witness ; Deut. xvii. 7. For here the guiltless was required to take the place of a witness in a higher sense. There is nothing in the words which disparages legal punishment. These men were not the appointed instruments of the law.

Report a mistake

John 8:9

And they which heard...conscience, went out one by one

And they when they heard went out one by one, as they felt the power of Christ's sentence. The interpolated clause (being convicted by their own conscience) is a true explanation of the sense.

beginning at the eldest ... (the elders)] whose sorrowful experience of life was the fullest. The word is not a title of office, but simply of age.

the woman standing (being) in the midst] She still remained bound as it were by her sin in the presence of Christ. " Two persons were left," Augustine says ..., " the unhappy woman and Compassion Incarnate " ....

Report a mistake

John 8:10

When Jesus had...unto her

And Jesus lifting himself up said unto her.

Woman ... thine accusers? hath ... thee?] Woman, where are they? Did no one condemn thee ? The question marks the interval during which the Lord had waited for the effect of His words.

Report a mistake

John 8:11

She said...And Jesus said unto her

And she said ... And Jesus said.

Neither do I condemn thee] though I am truly sinless. The words are not words of forgiveness (Luke vii. 48), but simply of one who gives no sentence (comp. Luke xii. 14). The condemnation has reference to the outward punishment and not to the moral guilt : that is dealt with in the words which follow. " Ergo et Dominus damnavit, sed peccatum non hominem " ....

go, and sin no more] go thy way: from henceforth sin no more. Comp. v. 14.

Report a mistake

John 8:12–20

4. The after teaching (viii. ia—20).

The Lord had applied to Himself one of the typical miracles of the Exodus (vii. 37 ff.): in this section He seems to apply to Himself that of the fiery pillar. As " the light of the world" He is self-attested (v. 12 f.). But for the apprehension of His nature sympathy is needed (14, 15). At the same time even as the Lord's judgment was an expression of the divine will, so His witness included that of the Father ..., who could be recognised by those who truly knew Christ (v. 19).

John 8:12–20 · Open Word Bible

12Jesus spoke to them once more: "I am the light of the world. Those who follow Me will never walk in the darkness; they will have the light of life." 13The Pharisees then said to Him, "You are testifying on Your own behalf; Your testimony is not true." 14Jesus replied, "Even if I do testify on My own behalf, My testimony is true, since I know where I came from and where I am going. You, however, have no idea where I come from or where I am going. …

Report a mistake

John 8:12

Then spake Jesus again

Jesus therefore again spake. . . The opinions about Jesus were divided. The rulers were blinded by their prejudices. Jesus therefore traces back doubt and unbelief to want of inner sympathy with Himself. At the same time (again, vii. 37) the second symbol of the festival was interpreted.

spake] This word compared with cried (vii. 37) suggests an occasion of less solemnity, probably after the Feast, but the time cannot be certainly determined.

John 8:12 · Open Word Bible

12Jesus spoke to them once more: "I am the light of the world. Those who follow Me will never walk in the darkness; they will have the light of life."

Report a mistake

am the light of the world

In the court of the women, where this discourse was held (see v. 20), were great golden candelabra which were lighted on the first night of the Feast of Tabernacles, and perhaps on the other nights. The sight of these and the remembrance of the light which they had cast over the otherwise unbroken gloom of the city seems to have suggested the figure. But the lamps themselves were only images of the pillar of light which had guided the people in the wilderness, just as the libations (vii. 38) recalled the supply of water from the Rock. And it is to this finally that the words of the Lord refer. The idea of that light of the Exodus — transitory and partial — was now fulfilled in the living Light of the world. Compare Isai. xlii. 6, xlix. 6 ; Mal. iv. 2 ; Luke ii. 32. According to tradition " Light" was one of the names of Messiah. Compare Lightfoot and Wünsche, ad loc. The same title in all its fulness was given by the Lord to His disciples (Matt. v. 14) ; and St Paul (Phil. ii. 15) speaks of Christians as "luminaries " ( .... God is " Light " absolutely (1 John i. 5).

light) Compare Introd. p. xlvii.

of the world] not of one nation only. This thought went beyond the popular hope. Buxtorf ... quotes a remarkable saying from Talm. Hieros. 'Sabb.' ch. 2, that "the first Adam was the light of the world."

that followeth] The thought of the pilgrimage still remains. The light is not for self-absorbed contemplation. It is given for action, movement, progress.

Report a mistake

in darkness

in the darkness. The phrase does not simply describe an accompanying circumstance of the movement, but the sphere in which it takes place. "The darkness" is opposed to "the light" (compare i. 5, xii. 46; 1 John ii. 9, 11), and includes the conceptions of ignorance, limitation, death.

shall have] not only shall look upon, or regard from a distance, but receive so that it becomes his own, a part of his true self. Comp. iv. 14, vi. 57. The Pauline phrase " in Christ," or conversely " Christ in me," expresses the fundamental thought.

the light of life] the light which both springs from life and issues in life ; of which life is the essential principle and the necessary result. Compare i. 4. Parallel phrases are The bread of life (vi. 35, note) ; the -water of life (Rev. xxi. 6) ; the tree of 'life, Rev. xxii. 14 ; and perhaps the crown of life, James i. 12.

Report a mistake

John 8:13

Thou bearest record of thyself

This objection points to the very characteristic of Christ's Being. It must be as they say because Christ is the light. The reality, the character of light, is attested by its shining. If men deny that it does shine, then there is no more room for discussion.

thy record (witness) is not true] This is perhaps as much an independent assertion as a consequence from the fact that the witness to Christ was from Himself, and so formally imperfect. The Pharisees set their judgment against His assertion. He affirms a truth ; they, as claiming equal right of knowledge, deny it. Lightfoot (ad loc.) gives some interesting examples of the application of the law of witness to a particular case (' Rosh Hashanah,' i ff.). "No man," it is said, "can give witness for himself" (Mishnah,- ' Ketub.' ii. 9).

John 8:13 · Open Word Bible

13The Pharisees then said to Him, "You are testifying on Your own behalf; Your testimony is not true."

Report a mistake

John 8:14

Though I bear record of myself, yet my record is true

The reply meets the objection of the Pharisees. The witness of Christ to Himself was essentially complete, and they had not that equality of knowledge on which they presumed to rely. A strong emphasis is thrown upon the pronoun ..., to mark at once the peculiarity in the source and in the foundation of the witness. Compare v. 31. The " I " in the earlier passage marked the separate individuality ; here it marks the fulness of the whole Person.

is true] in point of fact ..., and not, as in xix. 35, in formal validity ....

for (because) I know...] True witness even to a single fact in the spiritual life involves a knowledge of the past and of the future. In the past lie the manifold elements out of which the present grew ; in the future lies the revelation of what the present implicitly contains. He can bear witness to himself who has such knowledge of his own being. This no man has, but the Son has it, and in virtue of it He can reveal the Father. Comp.xvi. 28.

John 8:14 · Open Word Bible

14Jesus replied, "Even if I do testify on My own behalf, My testimony is true, since I know where I came from and where I am going. You, however, have no idea where I come from or where I am going.

Report a mistake

John 8:15

The thought of "knowledge" passes into that of "judgment." The Pharisees had not the knowledge, nor could they in their present state gain the knowledge. They judged after the flesh (comp. 2 Cor. v. 16). They were content to form their conclusions on an imperfect, external, superficial examination. Without feeling any necessity for deeper or wider insight, they decided according to the appearance of things; and so by that part of our nature which deals with appearances. Christ, on the other hand, though He embraced in this knowledge all the circumstances, and aspects, and issues of life, judged no man. The time for this was not yet ; nor was this His work (xii. 47).

The contrast in these words may be compared with that below in v. 23, (26 ?).

John 8:15 · Open Word Bible

15You judge by human standards; I am not judging anyone.

Report a mistake

John 8:16

But this absence of judgment on Christ's part was not from any defect in the completeness of His knowledge. For He adds, And yet (even, vi. 51, note) if I judge, my judgment is true...

is true., for (because)...] Not only true as answering to the special facts ..., but true as satisfying our perfect conception of what judgment ought to be ..., because it is not an isolated or personal judgment, but a judgment springing out of a conscious union with the Author of all Truth. A saying given in ' Pirke Aboth' (iv. 12) gives the characteristic thought which the Lord meets : " Judge not alone ..., for none may judge alone save ONE."

John 8:16 · Open Word Bible

16Yet even if I do judge, My judgment is true, because I am not alone in it: it is I together with the Father who sent Me.

Report a mistake

John 8:17

is also written in your law, that the testimony

And even In your law — the Law which is your law — it is written. ..that the witness... The Pharisees had appealed to the Law ; the Law then of which they claimed absolute possession (vii. 49) is shewn to decide against them (Deut. xix. 15). The phrase does not in any way disparage or set aside the Law as a divine revelation, but marks the Jewish claim (v. 56, your father).

It is. ..written] The exact form used here ... is found in St John of the old Scriptures only in this place (compare xx. 31). It is the common form of citation in other books. St John elsewhere uses the resolved form ..., which is read here by Cod. Sin.; ii. 17, note, x. 34, (xv. 25).

of two men] The word "men" ... does not occur in the original text or in the LXX. It appears to be introduced here to indicate the superior force of the divine witness.

John 8:17 · Open Word Bible

17Even in your own law it is written that the testimony of two people is true.

Report a mistake

John 8:18

am one that bear witness...beareth witness

I am he that beareth witness ...... The change in the form of the two clauses presents the difference of the mode in which the two witnesses give their testimony. He that gave the witness was one, but through Him the Father also spake and wrought: " I am he that beareth witness ; and, at the same time, in and through me, the Father beareth witness of me, so that your objection loses its point." The witness of the Father from whom Christ came was given not merely in the miracles done but in the whole ministry of the Son.

John 8:18 · Open Word Bible

18I am one who testifies about Myself, and the Father who sent Me also testifies about Me."

Report a mistake

John 8:19

Then said they

They said therefore... The appeal to an absent, unseen, witness did not satisfy the Pharisees.

Where is thy Father?] The form of the question shews the spirit of the questioners. They do not say "Who is thy Father?" as if they were in uncertainty as to the reference, but "Where...?" implying that a reference to one whom they could not look upon and interrogate was of no avail for the purpose of the argument.

Ye neither know me, nor...] Rather, Ye know neither me nor... The question was futile. The mere fact that it was put shewed that the true answer to it could not be given or received. ...

John 8:19 · Open Word Bible

19So they asked Him, "Where is Your father?" Jesus answered, "You do not know Me, and you do not know My Father either. If you knew Me, you would know My Father as well."

Report a mistake

John 8:20

These words spake Jesus in the treasury

The Treasury was in the Court of the women, the most public part of the temple (compare Mark xii. 41 ff. ; Luke xxi. 1). ...

John 8:20 · Open Word Bible

20He spoke these words in the treasury area while He was teaching in the temple courts. Yet no one arrested Him, because His hour had not yet come.

Report a mistake

taught

Contrast Acts xxiv. 12.

and no man...] and yet no man... ...

laid hands on him] took him, as in vii. 30, 32, 44, &c.

his hour] Comp. ii. 4, vii. 30, xiii. 1, note.

Report a mistake

John 8:21–30

21—30.

The subject of these verses is that which had been already partly announced at the feast (vii. 33 ff.). Christ shews the momentous issues which hang upon His brief sojourn with the Jews (v. 21), who are essentially opposite to Him in character ..., and therefore only to be delivered by transforming faith in Him (v. 24). At present a plainer revelation of Himself was impossible (v. 25 f.) ; but hereafter all would be made clear (v. 28). Meanwhile His work was His witness .... And this some were enabled to accept (v. 30).

John 8:21–30 · Open Word Bible

21Once more He said to them, "I am going away, and you will search for Me, and you will die in your sin. You cannot come where I am going." 22At this the Jewish leaders said, "Surely He is not going to kill Himself? Is that why He says, 'You cannot come where I am going'?" 23He went on to say to them, "You come from below; I come from above. You are from this world; I am not from this world. …

Report a mistake

John 8:21–59

5. The trial of true and false faith (21—59).

This section describes the spiritual crisis in the preaching to Israel. It consists of two parts. The first part (21 — 30) contains the distinct presentation of the one object of faith with the declaration of the consequences of unbelief (v. 24). This is closed by the notice of a large accession of disciples (v. 30). The second part (31 — 58) gives an analysis of the essential character and issues of selfish belief and false Judaism. ...

John 8:21–59 · Open Word Bible

21Once more He said to them, "I am going away, and you will search for Me, and you will die in your sin. You cannot come where I am going." 22At this the Jewish leaders said, "Surely He is not going to kill Himself? Is that why He says, 'You cannot come where I am going'?" 23He went on to say to them, "You come from below; I come from above. You are from this world; I am not from this world. …

Report a mistake

John 8:21

unto them

v. 12, note.

ye shall seek me] The emphasis lies (as in vii. 34) upon the word seek. There is no contrast here between "ye" and "me." The search was the search of despair under the pressure of overwhelming calamity; and the issue was not failure only but death, and death in sin, for the search under false motives, with false ends, was itself sin, an open, utter abandonment of the divine will.

your sin] The sin was one in its essence, though its fruits were manifold (i;. 24). Hence the order here is, " in your sin shall ye die," while in v. 24 the emphasis is transposed (" ye shall die in your sins").

whither I ... go, ye ... cannot come] Compare vii. 34 (where I am...). Here the contrast of persons ... is distinctly marked, as containing the ground of the separation. When the same words are applied to the disciples (xiii. 33) the impossibility of following is shewn to be for a time only (xiii. 36).

John 8:21 · Open Word Bible

21Once more He said to them, "I am going away, and you will search for Me, and you will die in your sin. You cannot come where I am going."

Report a mistake

John 8:22

Then said the Jews

The Jews, who were the speakers also in vii. 35, therefore said, in scornful contempt of such an assumption of superiority. The repetition of the imperfect ... marks the record as a compressed summary.

Will he ... kill himself? because (that)...] The bitterness of the mockery, like the sternness of the denunciation, is increased (vii. 35). The questioners assume that no way can be open to Jesus which is not equally open to them, unless it be the way to Gehenna opened by self-murder. Thither indeed they could not follow Him. By the Jews suicide was placed on the same level with murder, Joseph. ' B. J.' in. 8 (14). 5 ; and the darkest regions of the world below were supposed to be reserved for those who were guilty of the crime ... ....

John 8:22 · Open Word Bible

22At this the Jewish leaders said, "Surely He is not going to kill Himself? Is that why He says, 'You cannot come where I am going'?"

Report a mistake

John 8:23

The Lord meets the taunt of His opponents by developing that difference of nature in which lay at once the cause of their inability to follow Him, and the cause of their inability to understand Him. He and they belonged essentially to different regions; the spring of their life, the sphere of their thoughts, were separated from the spring and the sphere of His by an infinite chasm. The difference was equally great whether it was regarded in its final source or in its present manifestation. The circumstances of earthly life give scope for the embodiment of two characters absolutely opposed. For earthly life lies between and in connexion with two orders, and it includes in itself two orders. It may be swayed by higher or lower influences; it may be fashioned on a fleeting or on an eternal type. And between these there can be no fellowship.

There can be in the way of nature no passage from the one to the other.

Ye are from beneath] Your whole being in its deepest principles is drawn from the powers of the lower, sensual, realm ...-, you are "flesh of flesh" (iii. 6). ... Comp. Col. iii. 1 f.).

ye are of this world] true children of the fleeting order which you can see.

I am not of this world] but the bringer in of a new and spiritual order, to which entrance can be gained only by a new birth.

John 8:23 · Open Word Bible

23He went on to say to them, "You come from below; I come from above. You are from this world; I am not from this world.

Report a mistake

John 8:24

said therefore

because this fatal chasm separates you from my true home and from the region of life, that ye shall die — here the emphasis is changed and lies upon the end "death," and not upon the state "sin" — in your sins, which in their varied form reveal the presence of the one fatal source (v. 21). For there is but one mode of escape from death, one means of obtaining life, one " way " of approaching the Father by which earth and heaven are united, even fellowship by Faith with Him who is, and who has become man, and if ye believe not (unless ye believe) that I am, ye shall die in your sins.

that I am] not simply " that I am the Messiah," such as your imagination has drawn for you- ; but far more than this, that I am, that in me is the spring of life and light and strength ; that I present to you the invisible majesty of God ; that I unite in virtue of my essential Being the seen and the unseen, the finite and the infinite.

The phrase "I am " ... occurs three times in this chapter (vv. 24, 28, 58; comp. xiii. 19), and on each occasion, as it seems, with this pregnant meaning. Compare Deut. xxxii. 39 ; Isai. xliii. 10.

Elsewhere, in cases where the predicate is directly suggested by the context, this predicate simply is to be supplied : ch. ix. 9, xviii. 5, 6, 8. Comp. vi. 20; Matt. xiv. 27; Mark vi. 50, xiv. 62 ; Luke xxii. 70. And so it is used of the Messiah : Mark xiii. 6 ; Luke xxi. 8. Cf. Acts xiii. 25.

John 8:24 · Open Word Bible

24That is why I told you that you will die in your sins. For unless you believe that I am, you will die in your sins."

Report a mistake

John 8:25

Then said they

They said therefore...

Who art thou f] The question corresponds with the general translation " I am." The wish of the questioners is evidently to draw from the Lord an open declaration that He is "the Christ," that is the Deliverer such as they conceived of him.

And Jesus saith... ,] Jesus saith...

(1) Altogether, essentially, I am that which I even speak to you. That is to say, My Person is my teaching. ...

John 8:25 · Open Word Bible

25So they asked Him, "Just who are You?" Jesus said to them, "Why am I even talking to you at all?

Report a mistake

(2) How is it that I even speak to you at all? How is it that I so much as speak with you? That is to say, The question which you ask cannot be answered. The very fact that it is proposed makes it clear, as it has been clear before, that it is vain for me to seek to lead you by my words to a better knowledge of myself.

Of these two the second interpretation, which was in the main that of the Greek fathers, seems to fall in best with the general sense of the dialogue. See Additional Note.

Report a mistake

John 8:26

We must suppose a pause after the last words, if they are taken interrogatively, and then the sad train of thought is continued. The Jews, even if they had misunderstood the revelation which Christ had given of Himself, and were unworthy of any further manifestation of His Person — and indeed in virtue of this their grievous fault — furnished many subjects for teaching and judgment. In them unbelief was embodied. So the sentence follows : I have many things to say and to judge of (concerning) you. The utterance of these judgments will widen the chasm between us. But they must be spoken at all cost ; they are part of my divine charge ; he that sent me is true', in His message there is no superfluity and no defect, and the things which I heard from Him, when I came on earth to do His will, these speak I unto the world.

but he...] .It seems best to find the opposition (as above) in the anticipated failure of these further revelations. ...

John 8:26 · Open Word Bible

26I have much to say about you, and much to judge. But the one who sent Me is true, and I tell the world what I have heard from Him."

Report a mistake

speak to

The construction is very remarkable .... It is not simply "address to the world," but "speak into, so that the words may reach as far as, spread through, the world." Christ stands, as it were, outside the world, mediating between two worlds. Comp. 1 Thess. ii. 9 ..., iv. 8; Hebr. ii. 3.

I have heard] I heard. Comp. v. 28, note, xv. 15, note.

Report a mistake

John 8:27

They understood not

preoccupied as they were with thoughts of an earthly deliverer, and perhaps with doubts as to the possibility that Jesus might have come to them from some one such as they looked for, who awaited the favourable time for his appearance.

John 8:27 · Open Word Bible

27They did not understand that He was speaking to them about the Father.

Report a mistake

John 8:28

lifted up

Compare xii. 32, note.

shall ye know] Compare Ezek. vii. 4, xi. 12, xii. 20.

that I do] It is not unlikely that the verb begins a new sentence, and does not depend on the "that" of the previous clause : "you shall then perceive my true Nature. Yes, and in fact my whole work answers to a divine guidance."

of myself] Compare v. 30, note, xv. 4, note.

do... speak these things] The present teaching was part of the appointed work of Christ. The last phrase is not general, as if it were equivalent to "so I speak," but is used with a specific reference to the revelations which the Lord was even now making.

my Father hath taught] the Father taught. The mission of the Son is regarded as the point when He received all that was required for His work. The teaching is so far looked upon as compressed into one supratemporal act, and gradually realised under the conditions of human life.

Compare the use of I heard .... On the other hand I hear is used in regard to special acts (v. 30).

John 8:28 · Open Word Bible

28So Jesus said, "When you have lifted up the Son of Man, then you will know that I am, and that I do nothing on My own, but I say these things just as the Father taught Me.

Report a mistake

John 8:29

The whole being of the Son was in absolute harmony with the being of the Father, and the Father was personally present with the Son. In one sense there was a separation at the Incarnation: in another sense there remained perfect unbroken fellowship. There was a " sending " and yet a " remaining together." He that "sent" was still with Him that " was sent." The pregnancy of the phrase must be observed.

the Father ...alone] He, even He that sent me (so the words run, omitting the Father), at that crisis left me not alone — the new relation was superadded to and did not destroy the old relation — and men themselves can see the signs of this abiding communion, for (because) 7 — I ...> in the complete Person on which you look — do always — not fitfully, Uncertainly, partially — the things that please Him.

for] The word seems to be used here as In Luke vii. 47, to indicate the sign of the truth of the statement made, and not to give the ground of the fact stated. The perfect coincidence of the will of the Son with the will of the Father is presented as the effect, and not as the reason of the Father's Presence. And yet here as always the two thoughts run into one another.

those things that please him] The service is positive, active, energetic, and not only a negative obedience, an abstention from evil. Comp. 1 John iii. 22; Exod. xv. 26; Isai. xxxviii. 3 ; Wisd. ix. 18.

John 8:29 · Open Word Bible

29The one who sent Me is with Me. He has not left Me alone, because at all times I do what is pleasing to Him."

Report a mistake

John 8:30

believed on him

in the fullest sense : cast themselves upon Him, putting aside their own imaginations and hopes, and waiting till He should shew Himself more clearly. This energy of faith in a person ... is to be carefully distinguished from the simple acceptance of a person's statements as true (irio-Ttvfiv ru-i, " to tinue in my word, then are ye my 32 And ye shall know the truth, disciples indeed ; and the truth shall make you free.

John 8:30 · Open Word Bible

30While He was saying this, many people came to believe in Him.

Report a mistake

John 8:31–59

31—59.

This conversation lays open the essential differences between the men who would have given permanence to the Old Dispensation and Christ who fulfilled it. The historical and the spiritual, the external and the moral, the temporal and the eternal, are placed side by side. The contrast is made more complete because Abraham and not Moses is taken as the representative of Judaism.

. The successive pleas of the Jews give in a natural order the objections which they took I to Christ's claims. " We are Abraham's seed :...how sayest thou, Ye shall be made free?" (v. 33). ...

John 8:31–59 · Open Word Bible

31Then Jesus said to the Jews who had believed Him, "If you remain in My word, you really are My disciples. 32You will know the truth, and the truth will free you." 33They answered Him, "We are descended from Abraham, and we have never been slaves to anybody. What do You mean, 'You will become free'?" …

Report a mistake

With the help of the clue thus given it is more easy to follow the course of the argument. At the outset Christ promises freedom to those who honestly follow out an imperfect faith (31 f.). "But we are free" is the answer (v. 33). Not spiritually (vv. 33 — 36) ; nor does descent carry with it religious likeness (vv. 37 — 42). Inability to hear Christ betrays and springs from a close affinity with the powers of evil (vv. 43 — 47). Such a judgment is sober and true (in.'. 48 — 50). The word which Christ brings is life-giving ...; and He Himself was before Abraham (vv. 54 — 58).

Report a mistake

John 8:31

His claims to Messiahship as true, who were convinced by what He said, but who still interpreted His promise and words by their own prepossessions (comp. vi. 15). They believed Him and did not believe In Him. The addition of the word "Jews" and the change in the construction of the verb distinguish sharply this group from the general company in v. 30 ; and the exact form of the original makes the contrast more obvious ....

Then said Jesus. ..] Jesus therefore said ...which had believed Him. See v. 30, note.

If ye... disciples indeed] If ye — even ye with your inveterate prejudices and most imperfect faith — abide in my word ye are truly my disciples. The emphasis lies on the pronoun (ye) and not, as we are inclined to place it, on the verb (abide). The sentence is a gracious recognition of the first rude beginning of faith. Even this, if it were cherished with absolute devotion, might become the foundation of better things. It included the possibility of a true discipleship, out of which knowledge and freedom should grow ; for there is a discipleship of those who for the time are in ignorance and in bondage.

John 8:31 · Open Word Bible

31Then Jesus said to the Jews who had believed Him, "If you remain in My word, you really are My disciples.

Report a mistake

continue in my word

The word, the revelation of Christ, is at once the element in which the Christian lives, and the spring of his life. He abides in the word, and the word abides in him (v. 38; 1 John ii. 14, i. 10). Just so, in the language of St Paul, the believer lives in Christ and Christ in the believer (Gal. ii. 20). The phrase which is used here and in vv. 37, 43 ... expresses the word which is tputy characteristic of Christ and not simply that which He utters. Comp. xv. 9 note. ...

Report a mistake

John 8:32

ye shall know the truth

Comp. i. 17, v. 33. This Truth is no mere abstract speculation. It is living and personal. Comp. v. 36, and xiv. 6.

the truth shall make you free] The freedom of the individual is perfect conformity to the absolute— to that which is. Intellectually, this conformity is knowledge of the Truth: morally, obedience to the divine Law. This principle is that which Socrates (for example) felt after when he spoke of vice as ignorance; and the Stoics when they maintained that "the wise man alone is free." The Jews also had a saying, " Thou wilt find no freeman but him who is occupied in learning of the Law," and hence they substituted mystically cheruth (freedom) for charuth (graven) in Exod. xxxii. 16 ('Perek R. Meir,' 2. ...

Taylor, ad loc.~). These different thoughts are summed up in the noble paradox Deo servire at libertas.

John 8:32 · Open Word Bible

32You will know the truth, and the truth will free you."

Report a mistake

John 8:33

They answered

i.e. the Jews who believed Him who have just been characterized.

We be Abraham's seed] to whom the sovereignty of the world has been assured by an eternal and inalienable right. Comp. Matt. iii. 9 ; Luke iii. 8.

and were never (have never yet been) in bondage to any man] The episodes of Egyptian, Babylonian, Syrian and Roman conquests were treated as mere transitory accidents, not touching the real life of the people, who had never accepted the dominion of their conquerors or coalesced with them.

John 8:33 · Open Word Bible

33They answered Him, "We are descended from Abraham, and we have never been slaves to anybody. What do You mean, 'You will become free'?"

Report a mistake

John 8:34

The answer to the national boast of the Jews lies in the affirmation of the true principle of freedom (Verily, verily. Comp. vv. 51, 58).

Whosoever (Every one that) committeth sin] "To commit sin" ... is not simply to commit single, isolated, acts of sin, but to live a life of sin (1 John iii. 4, 8). The exact contrast is doing the Truth (iii. 21; 1 John i. 6) on one side and doing righteousness on the other (1 John ii. 29, iii. 7). Sin as a whole — complete failure, missing of the mark, in thought and deed — is set over against Truth and Righteousness.

the servant] "the slave," "the bondservant" .... The same image occurs in St Paul (Rom. vi. 17, 20).

John 8:34 · Open Word Bible

34Jesus answered, "Truly, truly, I tell you, everyone who goes on sinning is a slave of sin.

Report a mistake

John 8:35

The transition from the thought of bondage to sin to that of freedom through the Son is compressed. Bondage to sin is the general type of a false relationship to God. He who is essentially a bondman cannot be a son of God. Whatever may be his outward connexion with God it can last only for a time. Permanent union with God must rest upon an abiding and essential foundation. Even the history of Abraham shewed this: Ishmael was cast out; the promises centred in Isaac. Thus there is a two-fold change in thought, (1) from bondage to sin to the idea of bondage, and (2) from the idea of sonship (contrasted with the idea of bondage) to the Son. ...

the house] Comp. xiv. 2 ; Hebr. iii. 6 but the Son... ever] the Son abideth for ever.

John 8:35 · Open Word Bible

35A slave does not remain in the household for good; a son remains for good.

Report a mistake

John 8:36

This general principle, illustrated in the origin of the Jewish people by the parable of Isaac and Ishmael, has one absolute fulfilment. The Son, the true Son, is one. Through Him alone — in Him, in fellowship with Him — can lasting freedom be gained, seeing that He alone is free, and abideth unchangeable for ever.

If the Son therefore] The Son and not the Father is represented as giving freedom, in so far as He communicates to others that which is His own.

free indeed] The word translated indeed ... occurs here only in St John. ... The conception of freedom which is given in this whole passage presents the principle which St Paul applied to the special case of external ordinances.

John 8:36 · Open Word Bible

36So if the Son frees you, you will be truly free.

Report a mistake

John 8:37

The conception of freedom having been thus illustrated, the Lord goes back to the claim of the Jews, and admits it in its historical sense.

I know that ye are Abraham's seed; but...] Outwardly ye are sons; but in fact you seek to destroy the true Son. Your conceptions of the Father's will and purpose are so fatally wrong that they place you — however little the final issue may be apparent now — in deadly hostility to me. You believe me, but you would make me fulfil your thoughts. When you find that this cannot be, you too will see the murderous spirit revealed in you.

The ground of the hostility of the Jews was the fact that the revelation of Christ (my word) made no way, no progress in them. It had in some sense found an entrance, but it made no successful progress in their hearts.

hath no place] maketh no way in you, hath not free course in you (Ow x^P*^ Vulg. non capit). The sense given in A.V.

John 8:37 · Open Word Bible

37I know that you are descended from Abraham. Yet you are trying to kill Me, because My word is making no headway in you.

Report a mistake

John 8:38

And yet the word of Christ justly claimed acceptance, for it was derived from immediate knowledge of God. The things which I ... — I myself directly, in my own Person — have seen with (in the presence of) the Father I speak. ...

John 8:38 · Open Word Bible

38I speak of what I have seen in the Father's presence, and you, in the same way, do what you have heard from the father."

Report a mistake

have seen

The perfect revelation through the Son rests upon perfect and direct knowledge. He speaks to men in virtue of His immediate and open vision of God, which no man could bear (i. 18). The appeal to this Vision of God is peculiar to St John. Comp. iii. 34, vi. 46 (the Father); and though man naturally is unable to attain to the sight of God (v. 37; 1 John iv. 20), yet in Christ the believer does see Him now (xiv. 7, 9. Comp. iii. 11; 1 John iii. 6; 3 John IT), and shall see Him more completely (1 John iii. 2. Comp. Matt. v. 8; 1 Cor. xiii. 12).

and ye do that which ye have seen with your father] Or, according to the more probable reading, the things which ye heard from... The verb in the original ... is ambiguous. It may be imperative do ye, or indicative ye do. If it be taken as an imperative the sense will be: and do ye therefore the things which ye heard from the Father: fulfil in very deed the message which you have received from God, and in which you make your boast. If it be taken as an indicative "the father" must receive opposite interpretations in the two clauses (my Father, even God, and your father, even the devil: rov irarpos is to be read in both places). The sense will then be : and ye therefore, tragically consistent, do the things which ye heard from your father, the devil, whose spiritual offspring ye are. This thought has not yet been distinctly expressed, and in v. 41 your father is distinctly written ..., but on the other hand v. 39 may be supposed to imply a special reference.

Report a mistake

John 8:39

If ye were...ye would do...Abraham

There is great variety of reading in the Greek texts in this passage. The most probable reading gives the sense : If ye are children of Abraham, do ... the works of Abraham. Or perhaps it may be rendered: Ifjrea.ro children of Abraham, ye do the works of Abraham, a supposition which is obviously false. The emphasis is laid upon the community of nature (children), and not upon the inheritance of privilege (sons).

For the use of children see i. 12, xi. 52; 1 John iii. 1, 2, 10, v. 2; and for sons, xii. 36 (of light); xvii. 12 (of destruction). ...

John 8:39 · Open Word Bible

39They replied, "Abraham is our father." Jesus said to them, "If you are Abraham's children, then you would be doing what Abraham did.

Report a mistake

John 8:40

But now

As things really are.

a man] The word man ... stands in contrast with of God, and so brings out the element of condescension in the Lord's teaching which exposed Him to the hostility of the Jews ; and at the same time it suggests the idea of human sympathy, which He might claim from them (a man), as opposed to the murderous spirit of the power of evil. The title is nowhere else used by the Lord of Himself. Compare Rom. v. 15 ; 1 Tim. ii. 5; Acts ii. 22. xvii. 31 ....

the truth, which I have heard (which I heard)] Compare v. 28 note.

this did not Abraham] who faithfully obeyed each word of God, and paid honour to those who spoke in His name, as to Melchizedek and the angels (Gen. xiv., xviii.). In the traditions of the East, Abraham, "the Friend," is still spoken of as "full of loving-kindness."

John 8:40 · Open Word Bible

40But now you are trying to kill Me, a man who has spoken to you the truth I heard from God. That is not what Abraham did.

Report a mistake

John 8:41

Ye do the deeds

Ye are doing the v. 38 the connexion is: "Do not speak to works (as v. 38). ...

Then said they...] They said... The line of thought seems to be this. You admit, the Jews argue, that we are historically descended from Abraham (v. 37), but you deny that we are spiritually like Abraham .... You speak of another father whose spiritual seed we are. But we appeal to facts. Just as we are literally Abraham's true seed, so are we spiritually. We, with a proud emphasis, we be (were) not born of fornication. We do not owe our position to idolatrous desertion of Jehovah. We are the offspring of the union of God with His chosen people. Our spiritual descent is as pure as our historical descent.

John 8:41 · Open Word Bible

41You are doing the works of your own father." They said to Him, "We were not born out of sexual sin. We have one Father: God."

Report a mistake

John 8:42

The answer to the boast lies in the natural conditions of all kinsmanship. The true children of God in virtue of their nature can always recognise Him however He shews Himself. The Jews by their misunderstanding destroyed the claim which they set up. Cf. 1 John v. i.

and came] and I am come .... Comp. 1 John v. 20. In this word the stress is laid wholly on the present.

neither came I...] for neither have I come ...... Comp. iii. 2, 19, v. 43, vii. 28, xii. 46, xvi. 28, xviii. 37. Here the present is connected with the past act on which it rests. The deeper meaning of the first clause explains the form of the second. My Being is inherently divine in its derivation ; and so it is also in its manifestation to the world, for neither — not even — on this mission of infinite love have I come of myself. . . This act of supreme sacrifice is in absolute dependence on the Father's will. That which causes offence to you is done in obedience to Him.

of myself] Comp. v. 30, note.

John 8:42 · Open Word Bible

42Jesus said to them, "If God were your Father, you would love Me, because I came out from God and have arrived here. I have not come on My own authority; it was He who sent Me.

Report a mistake

John 8:43

If the Jews had been true children of God they would have recognised His Son. But yet more than this. They failed not only in instinctive feeling towards Christ, but also in intellectual apprehension of His teaching. They had no love for Him, and therefore they had no understanding of His Gospel. They could not perceive the meaning or the source of His speech, in which little by little He familiarly set forth His work (comp. iv. 42), because they could not grasp the purport of His Word, the one revelation of the Incarnate Son in which all else was included.

ye cannot] inasmuch as the wilful service of another power hinders you (v. 44). The fatal obstacle was one of their own making. Comp. vii. 7, note.

For the form of the sentence see vv. 46, 47.

John 8:43 · Open Word Bible

43Why do you not understand what I am saying? It is because you cannot bear to listen to My word.

Report a mistake

John 8:44

the

There is a strong emphasis on the pronoun in answer to the we, v. 41, Ye so-called children of Abraham, children of God, are of your father, true children of your true father, the devil, and the lusts (desires) of your father it Is your will to do ... ; you deliberately choose as your own the feelings, passions, ends, which belong to him. You are, so to speak, his voluntary organs ; what he desires, that you carry out. ...

John 8:44 · Open Word Bible

44Your father is the devil, and you choose to do what your father wants. He was a murderer from the beginning, and he never stood in the truth, because there is no truth in him. Whenever he tells a lie, he is speaking from what is his own, because he is a liar and the father of lies.

Report a mistake

John been put forward by a few recent critics, found some support in early times, and is adopted by Macarius Magnes without remark (n. c. 21): "ye are of the father of the devil;" as if the Jews and the devil were alike the offspring of another spiritual progenitor. According to this view the Jews are said to be murderers and liars like the devil, who followed the pattern of his (and their) father. But the interpretation finds no support elsewhere in Scripture.

are of] draw your being from, and so reproduce in your character. Comp. iii. 31, viii. 23, 47, xv. 19, xvii. 14, 16, xviii. 36, 37 ; 1 John ii. 1 6, iii. 8, 10, 12, iv. 1 ff., v. 19.

the devil] xiii. 2; 1 John iii. 8, 10; Rev. xii.g.

He was a murderer from the beginning] When creation was complete he brought death upon the race of men by his falsehood (Rom. v. 12). For even before he had fallen through want of truth. ...

The reference appears to be to the Fall and not to the death of Abel (1 John iii. 12). The death of Abel was only one manifestation of the ruin wrought by selfishness (see 1 John iii. 8 ff.). Comp. Wisd. ii. 24 and abode not...] and stood not... See Additional Note.

When he speaketh a lie...] ...

Report a mistake

It is however most probable that this very difficult sentence should be translated quite differently: Whenever a man speaketh a lie, he speaketh of his own, for his father also is a liar. A man, that is, by lying reveals his parentage and acts conformably with it. The omission of the subject with the verb is certainly harsh ..., but scarcely more so than the other renderings of the pronoun ....

Report a mistake

John 8:45

And because

But because... If I had spoken falsehood, such is the argument, you would have recognised that which is kindred to yourselves, but... The final opposition between Christ and the devil lies in the opposition of Truth to Falsehood. And this opposition repeats itself in the children of the two spiritual heads. There must be that which is akin to Truth in us, if we are to believe Truth. ...

John 8:45 · Open Word Bible

45But as for Me, it is because I tell the truth that you do not believe Me.

Report a mistake

John 8:46

Falsehood in action is sin. Falsehood within must shew itself. From words then the appeal is made to acts. Which of you convinceth (convict eth) me of sin? Who. that is, arraigneth me on a just charge of sin ? The word sin ... is not to be taken for error or falsehood, but for "sin" generally, according to the uniform usage of the New Testament, and here probably, from the connexion, as measured by the Law. The words suggest but they do not prove the sinlessness of Christ. ...

John 8:46 · Open Word Bible

46Which of you can prove that I have sinned? If it is the truth I speak, why do you not believe Me?

Report a mistake

convinceth

convicteth. Compare xvi. 8, note.

And if I say the truth...] If I say truth, that which is true : truth, and not the Truth, the part and not the whole revelation. The absence of sin includes necessarily the absence of falsehood. Hence the Lord takes it as proved that His words are true.

Report a mistake

John 8:47

We must suppose a pause after 46a, and again after 46b. Then follows the final sentence. The true child of God alone can hear the words ..., each separate message, of God. For this reason, because the power of hearing (v. 43) depended on inward affinity, the Jews could not hear, because they were not of God. Comp. xviii. 37, vii. 17, xii. 48 f., xiv. 23, note; 1 John iv. 6.

He that is of God] the true child of God, who draws his life and support from Him.

John 8:47 · Open Word Bible

47Anyone who comes from God listens to God's words. You do not listen, and this is why: you are not from God."

Report a mistake

ye therefore...because

for this cause ye .because. This combination in St J ohn comthem not, because ye are not God.

ye are not of God] The whole scope of the argument proves that this state does not exclude true moral responsibility. ...

Report a mistake

John 8:48

Then answered the Jews

The Jews answered... The key- word (the Jews) is introduced again in this new phase of the argument.

Say we not well...?] The form of expression shews that the reproach was a current one ; so that a glimpse is here offered of the common judgment on Christ. He was in the eye of "the Jews" a Samaritan, a bitter foe of their nationality, and withal a breaker of the Law, and a frantic enthusiast, who was not master of his own thoughts and words. Thus the Jews turned back upon Christ both the charges which He had brought against them, that they were not legitimate children of Abraham, and that they were of the devil as their spiritual father. The pronoun is emphatic ... : "Are not we at last right...?"

thou art a Samaritan] There is bitter irony in the original words, from the position of the pronoun at the end of the clause, which it is difficult to reproduce. "Thou that boastest great things of a kingdom and a fulfilment of the Law, after all art but a Samaritan."

John 8:48 · Open Word Bible

48The Jews who were arguing with Him answered, "Are we not right to say that You are a Samaritan and have a demon?"

Report a mistake

John 8:49

The contrast is between the persons I and you. "I ..., even in these bold mysterious utterances which move your wonder, have not a demon, but speak only words of soberness, which I must speak that I may thereby fulfil my mission. ...

John 8:49 · Open Word Bible

49Jesus answered, "I do not have a demon. Rather, I honor My Father, and you dishonor Me.

Report a mistake

The Lord leaves unnoticed the first epithet of reproach (thou art a Samaritan). He would not recognise the meaning which they attached to a difference of race.

Report a mistake

John 8:50

And

But when I speak of dishonour it is not that I shrink from it : I seek not mine own glory ; that quest is not my part, but belongs to another; and there is one that seeketh and judgeth — that seeketh and in the very act of seeking judgeth. For he who has failed in giving to me what is due is thereby condemned ; and the will of the Father is that all men should honour the Son even as they honour the Father (v. 23).

there is] V. 45, v. 54.

that... judgeth] The phrase is superficially opposed to v. 22. But the thought here is of the divine law which is self-executing in the very nature of things.

seeketh] Philo, in a paraphrase of Gen. xlii. 22, his blood is required (LXX. e /cfj/relrai) , writes: " He that requireth (o ... is not man but God, or the Word, or the divine Law" ('de Jos.' 29, II. p. 66).

John 8:50 · Open Word Bible

50But I do not seek My own glory. There is one who seeks it, and He judges.

Report a mistake

John 8:51

Verily, verily

These words (as always) introduce a new turn of thought. The claims of the Jews based upon their historical descent and their spiritual sonship have been met and set aside ; and the Lord now returns to the declaration of vv. 31 f., but with this difference, that what was then regarded in relation to state is now regarded in relation to action. For " abiding in the word '' we have " keeping the word," and for " freedom '' we have "victory over death."

keep my saying] keep my word, "doctrinam credendo, promissa sperando, facienda obediendo," Bengel. The original term for " keep" ... is characteristic of St John. ... The opposite to "keeping ... the word" in this form would be to disregard it ; the opposite to "keeping ... the word" in the other form would be to let it slip. " Keeping the word " of Christ is also to be distinguished from "keeping His commandments" (1 John ii. 3, 5) ; the former marks the observance of the whole revelation in its organic completeness, and the latter the observance of definite precepts.

see death] The exact phrase ... is not found elsewhere in New Testament. ...

John 8:51 · Open Word Bible

51Truly, truly, I tell you, if anyone keeps My word, they will never see death."

Report a mistake

The " sight " described here is that of long, steady, exhaustive vision, whereby we become slowly acquainted with the nature of the object to which it is directed. The words must be compared with Gen. ii. 17. ...

Report a mistake

death

Just as "life" in St John is present, or rather eternal (xvii. 3), so "death" is not an event but a state, that selfish isolation which is the negation of life. Comp. xi. 25 f., vi. 50, v. 24 ; 1 John iii. 14.

Report a mistake

John 8:52

Then said the Jews

The Jews said... The name is repeated here as in v. 48 at the beginning of the answer to the new self-revelation.

we know] The direct statement, made in apparent good faith, and yet (as the hearers thought) obviously and flagrantly false, could only be explained on the supposition of evil possession.

Abraham... death] God had spoken to Abraham and to the prophets, and they had kept His word and yet died, who then was this with a word more powerful ? For the objection is intensified by the fact that the Lord did not simply claim life for Himself, but, what was far more, claimed to communicate eternal life.

is dead] died. The argument rests upon the simple historic fact.

taste of death] The inaccuracy of quotation is significant. The believer, even as Christ (Hebr. ii. 9), does "taste of death," though he does not "see" it in the full sense of v. 51.

... The "cup of death" is an Arabian image. Comp. Gesen. ' Thes.' s. v. DID.

John 8:52 · Open Word Bible

52The Jews there said to Him, "Now we are sure that You have a demon. Abraham died, and so did the prophets, yet You say, 'If anyone keeps My word, they will never taste death.'

Report a mistake

John 8:53

Art thou

the Galilean, the Nazarene. Comp. iv. 12.

which is dead.., are dead] More exactly, seeing that he ... died, and the prophets died. ...

whom makest thou thyself?] Comp. v. 18, x. 33, xix. 7, 12 ; 1 John i. 10.

John 8:53 · Open Word Bible

53Surely You are not greater than our father Abraham? He died. The prophets died too! Who do You think You are?"

Report a mistake

John 8:54–55

54—55.

The Lord prefaces His answer as to the relative dignity of Abraham and Himself by a revelation of the principle in obedience to which the answer is given. It does not come from any personal striving after glory, but in obedience to the will of the Father which the Son knows absolutely and obeys. The Son " makes Himself" to be nothing : He is, and He declares Himself to be that which the Father, so to speak, makes Him.

If I honour myself my honour...] If I, I in obedience to my own impulse, glorify myself my glory... Comp. v. 31.

it is my Father that honour eth me] there is my Father that glorifieth me. I glorify not myself, nor need I to do it ; there is one that glorifieth me... The construction is exactly parallel with v. 50.

your God] as claiming an exclusive connexion with Him.

John 8:54–55 · Open Word Bible

54Jesus answered, "If I glorify Myself, My glory means nothing. The one who glorifies Me is My Father, the one of whom you say, 'He is our God.' 55You have never known Him, but I know Him. If I said that I did not know Him, I would be a liar like you. But I do know Him, and I keep His word.

Report a mistake

John 8:55

I know him

Comp. vii. 29. For the difference between progressive and absolute knowledge see iii. 10 f. The special ignorance of these Jews stands in contrast with the knowledge which was characteristic of the nation: iv. 22.

a liar] for to hide the truth is no less falsehood than to spread error. Compare 1 John ii. 4, 22, iv. 20, v. 10.

but...] even in this crisis of separation, when my words will be misunderstood and so widen the breach between us (cf. v. 26), I proclaim the knowledge which I have and fulfil my mission by keeping His word.

and keep his saying (word)] The relation of the Son to the Father is attested by the same active devotion as the relation of the believer to Christ (v. 51). Comp. xv. 10.

John 8:55 · Open Word Bible

55You have never known Him, but I know Him. If I said that I did not know Him, I would be a liar like you. But I do know Him, and I keep His word.

Report a mistake

John 8:56

This then is the answer. ...

rejoiced ... to see] The peculiar construction ... may be explained by considering that the joy of Abraham lay in the effort to see that which was foreshadowed. It lay not in the fact that he saw, nor was it in order to see ; but partial vision moved him with the confident desire to gain a fuller sight. Winer's translation (' Gramm.' § xciv. 8, c) "that he should see " obscures this, sense.

my day] That is probably the historic manifestation of the Christ (comp. Luke xvii. 22) without any special reference to any particular point in it as the Passion. It may be however that the historic work of Christ is regarded in its consummation in the day which is spoken of emphatically as " that day," " the day of the Son of man" (Luke xvii. 30), " the day of Christ" (Phil. i. 6, 10, ii. 16).

be saw it] The reference cannot be to any present vision in Paradise (comp. Hebr. xi. 13). The tense of the original is decisive against this view. All conjecture must be uncertain, but there is nothing unnatural in the supposition that the faith shewn in the offering up of Isaac may have been followed by some deeper, if transient, insight into the full meaning of the promises then renewed. Such faith was in itself, in one sense, a vision of the day of Messiah.

John 8:56 · Open Word Bible

56Your father Abraham was full of joy at the hope of seeing My day. He saw it, and it made him glad."

Report a mistake

According to the Jewish tradition ('Bereshith R.' 44 Wünsche) Abraham saw the whole history of his descendants in the mysterious vision recorded in Gen. xv. 8 ff. Thus he is said to have " rejoiced with the joy of the Law."

Report a mistake

John 8:57

Then said the Jews

The Jews therefore said..., still persisting in the literal interpretation of the words.

fifty years old] This age was the crisis of completed manhood (Num. iv. 3). There was an early tradition (probably based on this passage) that Christ was about 50 years old at the Passion (Iren. 'Adv. Haer.' ii. 22. 5 f.). This opinion was said to be derived from St John. However strange it may appear, some such a view is not inconsistent with the only fixed historic dates which we have with regard to the Lord's life, the date of His birth, His Baptism, and the banishment of Pilate.

hast thou seen...] The language of the Lord is again (v. 52) misquoted ; and on this occasion the misquotation completely misrepresents the thought.

John 8:57 · Open Word Bible

57So the Jews there said to Him, "You are not even fifty years old, and You have seen Abraham?"

Report a mistake

John 8:58

There can be no doubt as to the meaning of the final answer which follows as a natural climax to what had been said before. Abraham died : Christ was the Giver of life. Abraham was the father of the Jews : Christ was the centre of Abraham's hope. Abraham came into being as a man : Christ is essentially as God. And this closing revelation is prefaced by the solemn words which fix attention upon its substance. Verily, verily, I say unto you? Before Abraham was — was born, came to be — I am ....

I am] The phrase marks a timeless existence. In this connexion "I was" would have expressed simple priority. Thus there is in the phrase the contrast between the created and the uncreated, and the temporal and the eternal. At the same time the ground of the assurance in v. 51 is made known. The believer lives because Christ lives, and lives with an absolute life (comp. xiv. 19).

John 8:58 · Open Word Bible

58Jesus said to them, "Truly, truly, I tell you, before Abraham was, I am."

Report a mistake

John 8:59

Then took they up

They took up therefore..., as understanding rightly the claim which was advanced in the last words. If the sentence had been a simple affirmation of the claim to Messiahship, it would have been welcomed. Comp. x. 24. But it was the affirmation of a new interpretation of Messiah's nature and work. ...

going through... passed by] This clause must be omitted in accordance with a combination of the best authorities.

John 8:59 · Open Word Bible

59At this they picked up stones to throw at Him, but Jesus hid Himself and went out of the temple courts.

Report a mistake