B. F. Westcott · The Gospel According to St. John: The Authorised Version with Introduction and Notes
John 21
35 excerpts on John 21, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
I. The Lord and the body of disciples. Their work : His gift (xxi. i—14).
II. The Lord and individual disciples. His determination of their work (xxi. 15 — 23). The two last verses (24, 25) contain an identification of the writer of the Gospel, and a renewed testimony (comp. xx. 30) to the infinite multiplicity of Christ's works.
John 21:1–14 · Open Word Bible
1After this Jesus revealed Himself to the disciples once more, by the Sea of Tiberias. It happened in this way. 2Simon Peter was there with Thomas (called Didymus, which means Twin), Nathanael from Cana in Galilee, Zebedee's sons, and two more of His disciples. 3Simon Peter said to them, "I am going out fishing." They answered, "We will come with you." They went out and got into the boat, but all that night they caught nothing. …
After these things
Comp. v. 1, vi. i. Such an indefinite mark of time is not unsuitable to the character of this narrative as an appendix to the original plan of the Gospel.
shewed himself] Rather, manifested himself. The same word ... is used of the appearances of the Lord after the Resurrection in the conclusion of St Mark's Gospel, xvi. 12, 14. The active form, which occurs in this verse only (contrast i). 14), marks the appearance as depending on the Lord's will. He was so pleased to reveal Himself. Comp. ii. 11, vii. 4. This special manifestation of the Risen Christ is part of the whole "manifestation" through the Incarnation (ch. i. 31 ; 1 John i. 2, in. 5, 8; comp. 1 Tim. iii. 16; 1 Pet. i. 20) which is consummated at the Return (1 John ii. 28, iii. 2 ; comp. Col. iii. 4; 1 Pet. v. 4).
again] The word does not exclude the idea of other intervening manifestations, but places the narrative which follows as parallel with the former narratives in being a manifestation to "the disciples" (xx. 19, 24 f.), that is, in all probability, the apostles, the disciples in the narrower sense, though "the twelve " were not all assembled on this occasion, but at most "seven" only. ...
John 21:1 · Open Word Bible
1After this Jesus revealed Himself to the disciples once more, by the Sea of Tiberias. It happened in this way.
On 13. 2.
at the sea of Tiberias] Comp. vi. i. This name does not occur elsewhere in the Gospels. The return of the disciples to Galilee is indicated in Matt, xxviii. 7 ; Mark xvi. 7. Before the Ascension they came again to Jerusalem and continued there till after Pentecost (Acts i. 4). The words in Luke xxiv. 44 ff. appear to be a summary of teaching at different times during the forty days. It is important to observe that St John takes account of both groups of appearances of the Risen Lord. St Matthew only notices the appearance to " the eleven " in Galilee, and St Luke only appearances at Jerusalem.
and on this wise shewed he himself] More exactly, andln.6 manifested himself on this wise. The repetition of a prominent word is characteristic of St John's style. ...
There were together
The enumeration which follows seems to shew that all present belonged to the same neighbourhood.
Thomas] In Acts i. 13, Thomas is joined with Philip, so that he may have been of Bethsaida (i. 44).
Nathanael] See i. 45. ...
John 21:2 · Open Word Bible
2Simon Peter was there with Thomas (called Didymus, which means Twin), Nathanael from Cana in Galilee, Zebedee's sons, and two more of His disciples.
J L- XT Slrsanswered him, JNo.
the sons of Zebedee] Matt. xx. 20, xxvi. 37, xxvii. 56.
two other] The record of the first chapter suggests that these two may have been Andrew (i. 41) and Philip (i. 43 ff.). Yet it is more probable that these two were "disciples " in the wider sense, and that St John places himself and his brother last among the apostles. Under any circumstances the position of "the sons of Zebedee" in the enumeration is not that which any other writer than St John would have given to them.
Simon Peter
Even here St Peter takes the lead in action. The disciples seem to have continued their ordinary work, waiting calmly for the sign which should determine their future. Comp. Luke xxii. 36; 2 Thess. iii. 8; Acts xviii. 3.
We also go] Literally, come.
John 21:3 · Open Word Bible
3Simon Peter said to them, "I am going out fishing." They answered, "We will come with you." They went out and got into the boat, but all that night they caught nothing.
a fishing. They say
Omit immediately. Comp. vi. 17 ff. In the first place where the word occurs (vi. 17) there is no article according to the true reading. Here "the ship " is mentioned as part of the ordinary equipment for the fisher's work. It may be naturally supposed that when St Peter " left all" (Luke v. 11) those who retained possession of his property respected his right when he reclaimed it. The word "immediately" must be omitted.
In that night] The emphatic pronoun ... perhaps implies that the want of success was unusual with them. The night was the most favourable time for fishing. Comp. Luke v. 5.
when the morning was now come
The true reading ... gives the more vivid picture: when the day was now breaking. The exact time is significant for the interpretation of the incident.
stood... on... ,] Came, as the phrase implies ..., from some unknown quarter, and stood on the beach .... See Acts xxvii. 39 f., xxi. 5 ; Matt. xiii. 2, 48. Comp. xx. 19, 26. Interpreters at all times have pointed to the significant contrast in the positions of the Lord and the disciples, He on the firm ground, they on the restless waters.
... The clause is added as something strange .... It is vain to give any simply natural explanation of the failure of the disciples to recognise Christ. After the Resurrection He was known as He pleased, and not necessarily at once (ch. xx. 14 ff. ; Luke xxiv. 31). Yet it is easy to understand that the disciples were preoccupied with their work, as Mary Magdalene with her sorrow (xx. 14, an exact parallel), so that the vision of the divine was obscured.
John 21:4 · Open Word Bible
4Just as day was breaking, Jesus stood on the shore, though the disciples did not realize that it was Jesus.
Then Jesus
as desiring to bring them to a knowledge of Himself. The words might be taken as the question of one who wished to buy what they had.
Children] The original word (7701810) marks the difference of age or position, and not the tie of relationship .... ... Here it is probably no more than a familiar address. The form of the question in the original ... suggests a negative answer. See iv. 29.
meat] Probably something to eat with bread .... This was commonly fish, so that the synonymous word ... came to be used for fish (ch. vi. 9 f.).
John 21:5 · Open Word Bible
5So Jesus called out to them, "Friends, you have no fish to eat, have you?" They answered Him, "No."
on the right side
The definiteness of the command (contrast Luke v. 4) explains the readiness with which it was obeyed.
to draw it] up into the boat ..., as contrasted with the "dragging" ... it after the boat. In the end it was "drawn" up to the land (v. 11). Wilson speaks of the fish in the lake as being seen "in dense masses" (' Recovery of Jerusalem,' p. 341).
John 21:6 · Open Word Bible
6He said to them, "Throw the net out on the boat's right side, and you will find fish." So they threw it out, and now they could not haul it in because there were so many fish.
Therefore that disciple
He was able to read in a moment by a certain sympathy with Christ the meaning of the sign. ...
Now when Simon Peter heard...] Simon Peter therefore having heard... The revelation came to him from without, and no longer from within (Matt. xvi. 17), but he at once acted upon it. He could not wait for the slow progress of the boat, but with swift resolve "cast himself into the sea" (contrast .Matt. xiv. 28 ff.), having first "girt his coat ((irtvdvrns, an upper garment. See LXX. 1 S. xviii. 4, "robe;" 2 S. xiii. 18; the word was adopted in later Hebrew for the " frock" of labourers) about him," with instinctive reverence for the presence of his Master. While engaged in his work he was " naked," that is, probably, stripped of all but his light under-garment (comp. 1 S. xix. 24 ; Isai. xx. 2 ; Amos ii. 16), though at present the word applies literally to Galilaean fishermen ; but these poor men, who have no boats, occupy a different position from the apostles (Tristram, ' Land of Israel,' pp. 425 ff. ed. 3).
John 21:7 · Open Word Bible
7Then that disciple whom Jesus loved told Peter, "It is the Lord!" Hearing that it was the Lord, Simon Peter tied his outer garment around himself, since he had stripped for work, and threw himself into the sea.
in a little ship
in the boat .... The change of word may point to the use of some smaller vessel which was attached to the " ship," as the words are distinguished in vi. 22 ; or it may be a more exact description of the vessel.
for they...] The clause explains how they could easily do what is described, and soon gain the shore. The distance was about a hundred yards.
John 21:8 · Open Word Bible
8The other disciples came in the boat, towing the net full of fish. They were not far out, only about 100 yards from land.
As soon then as...they saw
So •when. ../Ay see... They hasten to meet the Lord before they have secured their prize (v. 10). The fire of coals, i.e. of charcoal ..., the/jA ..., and the bread (loaf, apros), are spoken of in such a way as to suggest the thought that they were provided supernaturally. The Lord provides as He will, through human labour naturally, or otherwise.
fish. ..bread...-] Rather, a fish.. .a loaf Compare v. 13, the fob. ..the loaf... The thought of unity seems to be distinctly presented (1 Cor. x. 17).
John 21:9 · Open Word Bible
9When they came ashore, they saw a charcoal fire already there, with fish laid on it, and bread.
The command was probably given in order to mark the gifts of the Lord as gifts to be used. Perhaps the use of tydpiov (fish as food) here as contrasted with l^Bvs (fish generally) in the next verse emphasizes the idea.
John 21:10 · Open Word Bible
10Jesus said to them, "Bring some of the fish that you have just caught."
Simon Peter went up
Peter at once — again first in action — enters the vessel to which the net was fastened, and then draws it up after him on to the land.
an hundred and fifty and three] Jerome quotes an opinion that there were so many kinds of fish, and adds that one of each kind was taken to shew the universality of the work of the apostles ('In Ezech.' xlvii. 9). For other interpretations see Additional Note. The record of the exact number probably marks nothing more than the care with which the disciples reckoned their wonderful draught. The significant differences between the circumstances of the miraculous draught of fishes at the beginning of the Lord's ministry (Luke v. 1 ff.), and of this after the Resurrection, have frequently been noted. Augustine draws them out very well. The one miracle, he says, was the symbol of the Church at present, the other of the Church perfected ; in the one we have good and bad, in the other good only ; there Christ also is on the water, here He is on the land ; there the draught is left in the boats, here it is landed on the beach ; there the nets are let down as it might be, here in a special part ; there the nets are rending, here they are not broken ; there the boats are on the point of sinking with their load, here they are not laden ; there the fish are not numbered, here the number is exactly given ('In Joh.' cxxii. 7). It seems impossible not to acknowledge that there is a spiritual meaning in these variations of the two narratives which consistently converge to distinct ends.
John 21:11 · Open Word Bible
11So Simon Peter went aboard and hauled the net ashore, full of large fish, 153 of them. Even with so many, the net did not tear.
dine
Rather, breakfast .... ... In St Matthew xxii. 4 ff., the guests invited to " the breakfast " refuse the invitation and go away to their day's work.
The Lord seems to have been still standing at some little distance when He gave the invitation. The disciples held back in awe. They " knew that it was the Lord;" and still it is evident that He was in some way changed.
And none ... ask] Omit And. The original word for ask ... describes precise and careful inquiry and examination, Matt. ii. 8, x. ii. There is a conviction of reality which (in a sense) precludes certain forms of investigation as unfitting.
John 21:12 · Open Word Bible
12Jesus said to them, "Come, eat your breakfast." Not one of the disciples dared ask Him, "Who are You?" They knew it was the Lord.
Jesus then
Omit then. As the disciples hang back "Jesus cometh," and gives to them of "the bread" and "the fish" which He had Himself provided. The articles in the original ... point back to v. 9. Nothing is said either as to the use of the fish caught ... or of the Lord Himself sharing the meal. He appears only as the Giver of the food which He brings, and this fact probably explains the absence of the customary " blessings" or "thanksgiving" (vi. 11; Luke xxiv. 30).
John 21:13 · Open Word Bible
13Jesus came, took the bread and gave it to them, and the fish in the same way.
This is now
2 Pet. iii. i. Comp. v. i. The "third" time most probably refers to manifestations to " the disciples " in a body. ...
John 21:14 · Open Word Bible
14This was now the third time that Jesus was revealed to the disciples after He had been raised from the dead.
So when they had dined
After the common meal the personal charge followed naturally.
saith to Simon Peter, Simon, son of Jonas (John, and so vv. 16, 17; see i. 42, note)] The contrast of the names is significant. The address of the Lord, thrice repeated, recalls the first words addressed to St Peter (i. 42), when he received the surname Cephas (Peter). At the same time it must be observed that the Lord never addresses St Peter by his new surname ; nor does St Paul speak of him by the Greek form of it (Peter) according to the true text, but only as Cephas. On the other hand, the surname is commonly used either alone or with Simon in the narrative of the Gospels, and always in the Greek form. This varying usage, which exactly corresponds with the circumstances under which the title was substituted for the original name, is a striking indication of the exactness of the records, and specially of the exactness of the record of the Lord's words (Matt. xvi. 17, xvii. 25 ; Mark xiv. 37 ; Luke xxii. 31 ; comp. Acts x. 5 ff.).
son of Jonas (John)] The mention of St Peter's natural descent here (comp. i. 42 ; Matt, xvi. 17) appears to direct attention in the first place to the man in the fulness of his natural character, as distinguished from the apostle.
John 21:15 · Open Word Bible
15After they had eaten breakfast, Jesus said to Simon Peter, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me more than these?" Peter said to Him, "Yes, Lord, You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Feed My lambs."
lovest thou me more than these
i.e. more than these, thy fellow-disciples, love me. The reference is probably to St Peter's words (ch. xiii. 37 ; Matt. xxvi. 33), in which he had claimed for himself the possession of supreme devotion (comp. xv. 12 ff.). In the record of St Matthew (I.e.) this profession is placed in immediate connexion with the Lord's promise of an appearance in Galilee after His Resurrection, which gives peculiar force to the question. It is unnatural to suppose that " these " is neuter, and that the Lord refers to the instruments or fruits of the fisher's craft.
lovest ...] It will be noticed that the foundation of the apostolic office is laid in love and not in belief. Love ... in its true form includes Faith (comp. 1 Cor. xiii. 13).
Yea, Lord...] St Peter in his answer affirms his personal attachment to the Lord, appealing to the Lord's own knowledge; but his v. 1 6— 1 8.]
thou (emphatic) knowest] Experience had taught St Peter to distrust his own judgment of himself. Even when the fact is one of immediate consciousness he rests his assertion on the Lord's direct insight.
Feed my lambs
In response to the sincere confession the Lord imposes a charge which shews that He accepts the apostle's answer. The privilege and the work of love are identical. The image is now changed. The fisher's work is followed by the shepherd's work. Those who are brought together and taken out of u the many waters " need to be fed and tended. This office of the shepherd with which St Peter is entrusted is regarded under three different aspects. The first portrayed here is the simplest and humblest. The little ones in Christ's flock need support, which they cannot obtain of themselves ; this the apostle is charged to give them.
Feed] The original word ..., which occurs again in v. 17, is found elsewhere in the New Testament only of swine (Matt. viii. 30, 33; Mark v. 11, 14; Luke viii. 32, 34, xv. 15). As distinguished from the word which follows ... it expresses the providing with food.
A short pause, as we must suppose, followed ; and then the question was repeated a second time, but so that the thought of comparison is omitted: Simon, son of John, lovest ... thou me? St Peter's answer is identically the same as before. He still shrinks from taking to himself the loftier word. In reply the Lord lays upon him a new part of the shepherd's duty: Tend— be shepherd of— my sheep. The lambs require to be fed ; the sheep require to be guided. The watchful care and rule to be exercised over the maturer Christians calls for greater skill and tenderness than the feeding of the young and simple.
Feed] Tend' ..., Acts xx. 28; 1 Pet. v. 2 ; Matt. ii. 6. Comp. Rev. ii. 27, &c. ; Jude 12. The Vulgate does not distinguish feed and tend (pasce, pasce).
John 21:16 · Open Word Bible
16A second time he asked him, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me?" Peter said to Him, "Yes, Lord, You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Shepherd My sheep."
lovest thou me
When the Lord puts the question "the third time," He adopts the word which St Peter had used. Just as the idea of comparison was given up before, so now the idea of the loftiest love is given up. It is as if the Lord would test the truth of the feeling which St Peter claimed.
The three questions could not but recall the three denials ; and the form of this last question could not but vividly bring back the thought of the failure of personal devotion at the moment of trial. So Peter was grieved not only that the question was put again, but that this third time the phrase was changed ; that the question was not only put once again, but at the same time put so as to raise a doubt whether he could indeed rightly claim that modified love which he had professed. His "grief" lay in the deep sense that such a doubt might well be suggested by the past, even if it were at the time ungrounded. Men might reasonably distrust his profession of sincerity after his fall, but he appealed to the Lord (Thou ... knowest..?).
The answer of St Peter meets the points in the changed question. He leaves out the affirmation (Tea, Lord) of his former reply and throws himself wholly on the Lord, upon His absolute knowledge, and upon His special knowledge. Lord, Thou knowest ... all things, and at this moment Thou seest ... that I love Thee. The knowledge to which he appeals is not only that of divine intuition, but of immediate observation. Comp. ii. 25, note. The Vulgate again fails to distinguish the two words.
John 21:17 · Open Word Bible
17A third time he asked him, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me?" Peter was hurt because Jesus asked him a third time, "Do you love Me?" Peter replied, "Lord, You know everything; You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Feed My sheep.
In reply the Lord completed His commission, Feed ... my sheep. The mature no less than the young Christians require their appropriate sustenance. Provision must be made for their support as well as for their guidance. And this is the last and most difficult part of the pastor's office.
my lambs. ..my sheep. ..my sheep. ..] It will be noticed that the Lord retains His own right to those who are committed to the apostle's care. Comp. 1 Pet. v. 2 f. Augustine paraphrases admirably : " Si me diligis, non te pascere cogita, sed oves meas sicut meas pasce, non sicut tuas; gloriam meam in eis quaere, non tuam, dominium meum non tuum..." ('In Joh.' cxxiii. 5).
Verily, verily
The threefold apostolic charge resting on the assurance of personal love was given. The revelation of the personal issues of that love followed. ...
Verily, verily] The Risen Christ uses once more His familiar formula.
When thou wast young ...] The earlier outward freedom of St Peter in his youth is contrasted with his final complete outward bondage. At the moment he stood between the two states. Perhaps the thought of a converse growth of spiritual freedom underlies the image.
when thou shalt be old] The martyrdom of St Peter is placed in the year A.D. 64, and he seems to have been already of middle age (Matt. viii. 14).
stretch forth thy hands] as helpless and seeking help.
gird thee] bind thee as a condemned criminal.
whither thou wouldest not] The way to a violent death must always be terrible, because unnatural ; and that exactly in proportion as the violation of nature by such an end is realised. Comp. xii. 27.
John 21:18 · Open Word Bible
18Truly, truly, I tell you, when you were younger you fastened your own belt and went wherever you wished. But when you have grown old, you will stretch out your hands, and then someone else will fasten a belt on you and take you where you do not wish to go."
This spake he, signifying by what death
The crucifixion of St Peter at Rome is attested by Tertullian ... and later writers. Origen further stated that he was crucified with his head downwards at his own request (Euseb. 'H. E.' in. i). Though the language of the Lord has very commonly been adapted to the details of crucifixion, it does not appear that it points directly to anything more than martyrdom, when " another girded him," and he was taken " whither he would not." The "stretching forth the hands" can hardly be referred primarily to the position on the cross, since this detail is placed first.
he should glorify God] Literally, he shall glorify. The construction in xviii. 32 is different. The Evangelist throws himself back to the time when the death of St Peter was as yet future. As martyrdom was a " glorifying God," so conversely the martyr himself was said to be "glorified" by his death. ...
Follow me] The end of martyrdom having now been shewn, the Lord repeated the command given before under different circumstances to others (i. 43 ; Matt. viii. 22, ix. 9, xix. 21), " Follow me." What had been impossible before the apostle's fall became possible for him now (xiii. 36 ff.).
John 21:19 · Open Word Bible
19He said this to show by what kind of death Peter would glorify God. After saying this, He told him, "Follow Me."
The command itself, as given before and after the Resurrection, has necessarily different though analogous meanings. During the Lord's earthly life following Him implied the abandonment of previous occupations (Matt, ix. 9) and duties (Matt. viii. 22); attendance upon Him even when He entered on strange and mysterious paths ; participation in disgrace and danger (Matt. x. 38). Now to "follow Christ " required further the perception of His course ; the spiritual discernment by which His movements can still be discovered ; and yet further the readiness to accept martyrdom as the end.
These different thoughts appear to have a place in the words follow me, but the command had also, as appears from the next verse (following), a literal meaning also, though it is impossible to decide for what purpose the Lord called St Peter away from the other disciples.
Augustine's comment on the, promise of the glory of future martyrdom to the penitent and restored apostle is pregnant with thought : " Hunc invenit exitum ille negator et amator ; praesumendo elatus, negando prostratus, flendo purgatus, confitendo probatus, patiendo coronatus; hunc invenit exitum ut pro ejus nomine perfecta dilectione moreretur, cum quo se moriturum perversa festinatione promiserat. Faciat ejus resurrectione firmatus, quod immature pollicebatur infirmus. Hoc enim oportebat ut prius Christus pro Petri salute, deinde Petrus pro Christi praedicatione moreretur. Praeposterum fuit quod audere coeperat humana temeritas, cum istum disposuisset ordinem veritas. Animam suam se positurum pro Christo Petrus putabat, pro liberatore liberandus; cum Christus venisset animam suam positurus pro suis ovibus in quibus erat et Petrus ; quod ecce jam factum est...Jam pretio pro te fuso, nunc est [Petre] ut sequaris emptorem, et sequaris omnino usque ad mortem crucis" ('In Joh.' cxxiii.
"3.J " cbap. 13. 23. <i 20. 2.
Peter, turning about
The command of the Lord appears to have been accompanied by some symbolic action. As St Peter literally obeyed the call thus expressed under a figure, and moved away from the group of the apostles, something attracted his attention, and he " turned about " to the direction indicated .... The whole picture is full of life.
the disciple...] Comp. xiii. 23, note.
which also leaned (leaned back). ..the supper] The reference is to the special act of the apostle ..., and not to the position which he occupied at the table .... The notice is added here to explain the close connexion of St John with St Peter, and the confidence with which St John ventured to follow even without a special invitation.
John 21:20 · Open Word Bible
20Peter turned around and saw the disciple whom Jesus loved following them, the same disciple who at the supper had leaned back against Jesus's chest and said, "Lord, who is it that is going to betray You?"
Peter therefore
No question could be more natural. The fact that St John was following was itself an unspoken question as to the future, an asking of the Lord's will.
Lord, and.,.] The original is singularly brief and pregnant, " Lord, and this man, what?" ... What of him ? What shall he suffer or do ? what shall be his lot ?
John 21:21 · Open Word Bible
21When Peter saw him, he said to Jesus, "Lord, and what about him?"
In the Lord's answer the emphasis is laid upon the pronouns "him" and "thou" (tav avrov 6.. . .... The thought is of the individual offices of disciples. St Peter's fortune corresponded with his work, and so too St John's.
If I will (comp. xvii. 24, note) that...] The hypothetical form of the sentence veils the divine counsel. Experience has shewn what that was.
abide till I come] The exact force of the original is rather "while I am coming" .... The "coming" is not regarded as a definite point in future time, but rather as a fact which is in slow and continuous realisation. The prominent idea is of the interval to be passed over rather than of the end to be reached. Comp. ix. 4, xii. 35 f. ; Mark vi. 45 ... ; 1 Tim. iv. 13 ; Luke xix. 13 ... ; Matt. v. 25. "Abiding" is the correlative to "following ;" and according to the manifold significance of this word it expresses the calm waiting for further light, the patient resting in a fixed position, the continuance in life.
John 21:22 · Open Word Bible
22Jesus said to him, "If I want him to remain until I come, what is that to you? As for you, follow Me!"
The " coming " of the Lord is no doubt primarily "the second coming" ... ; but at the same time the idea of Christ's "coming" includes thoughts of His personal coming in death to each believer. And yet further the coming of Christ to the Society is not absolutely one. He "came" in the destruction of Jerusalem. Thus St John did tarry till the great "coming," nor is there anything fanciful in seeing an allusion to the course of the history of the Church under the image of the history of the apostles. The type of doctrine and character represented by St John is the last in the order of development. In this sense he abides still. Comp. xiv. 3, note; and Rev. ii. 5, 16, iii. 11, xvi. 15, xxii. 7, 12, 20.
what is that to thee ?] The arrangement of the various parts in the whole body of the Church does not concern men. That rests with the divine will, and the divine will is unfolded in the course of life.
Then went this saying
This saying (word) therefore went ... the words which the Lord had spoken. These were inexactly repeated, and taken to affirm "that that disciple dieth not." The tradition that St John was sleeping in his grave at Ephesus, and that the moving dust witnessed to the breathing of the saint beneath, survived for a long time. Augustine mentions it doubtfully "on the authority of grave men " (' In Joh.' cxxiv. 2). among the brethren] This use of the phrase which is common in the book of the Acts (ix. 30, &c.) is found here only in the Gospels (comp. ch. xx. 17 ; Luke xxii. 32).
yet Jesus...] The manner in which the error is corrected seems to shew clearly that it had not been refuted by fact, or, in other words, that this Epilogue to the Gospel was written by St John. The apostle, still alive and looking to the uncertainty of the future, rests on the simple repetition of the precise language of the Lord. ...
John 21:23 · Open Word Bible
23So the saying spread among the brothers and sisters that this disciple would not die. But Jesus had not told Peter that the disciple would not die; He had said, "If I want him to remain until I come, what is that to you?"
It is obvious that St Peter and St John occupy in this narrative representative positions both as to their work and as to the issue of their work. The one is the minister of action whose service is consummated by the martyrdom of death: the other is the minister of thought and teaching whose service is perfected in the martyrdom of life. Augustine (' In Joh.' cxxiv. 3) has a very interesting comparison of the two charges, which is thus summed up : " Perfecta me sequatur actio, informata meae passionis exemplo: inchoata vero contemplatio maneat donec venio, perficienda cum venero." See also the Preface to the Commentary of Rupert of Deutz.
CONCLUDING NOTES : vv. 24, 25.
These two verses appear to be separate notes attached to the Gospel before its publication. The form of v. 24, contrasted with that of xix. 35, shews conclusively that it is not the witness of the Evangelist. The words were probably added by the Ephesian elders, to whom the preceding narrative had been given both orally and in writing. See Introduction, p. xxxv. The change of person in v. 25 (I suppose, compared with we know) marks a change of authorship. It is quite possible that this verse may contain words of St John (comp. xx. 30), set here by those who had heard them.
testifieth...testimony
beareth witness...witness. The witness is spoken of as present, but the form of the phrase (o /xaprvp&Sj/, contrast o ypd^as) does not in itself shew conclusively that the apostle was alive at the time when the note was written (comp. i. 15), though this is the most natural interpretation (comp. v. 32, 33).
these things] The phrase may be referred to the whole contents of the Gospel (xx. 31), or be limited to the narrative of ch. xxi.
we know] The plural (contrast xix. 35) taken in connexion with this is the disciple and I suppose (v. 25) seems to be undoubtedly a true plural, and not a usage like 1 John i. i. Compare Col. iv. 3, where there is a corresponding change from the apostolic group (Col. i. 1) to St Paul himself.
true] true in fact .... The thought is not brought out here as in xix. 35, that it satisfies the ideal conditions of testimony .... The words read like an echo of 3 John 12.
John 21:24 · Open Word Bible
24This is the disciple who is testifying about these things and who has written them, and we know his testimony is true.
suppose
The word ... is rare intheN.T. (comp. Phil. i. 17; James i. 7). From the form of the sentence (tav •ypd^rat... Xo>pij<r(iv) it appears that the recollection of the other deeds was still fresh, so that the record of them was possible.
could not contain] The bold expression answers to a deep truth. A complete account (every one) of the perfect human (Jesus) life of the Lord would be practically infinite.
Amen] is no part of the original text.
John 21:25 · Open Word Bible
25Jesus did many other things as well. If each one were written down, I suppose that even the world itself could not hold all the books that would be written.