B. F. Westcott · The Gospel According to St. John: The Authorised Version with Introduction and Notes
John 16
48 excerpts on John 16, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
1—11.
In the last section the hatred of the world was exhibited in its general character as inevitable and inexcusable, in contrast to the witness to Christ ; it is now shewn in its intense activity as the expression of a false religious zeal.
John 16:1–11 · Open Word Bible
1I have told you all this so that you will not stumble and fall away. 2They will expel you from the synagogue. In fact, an hour is coming when anyone who kills you will think they are doing God a sacred service. 3They will do these things because they have never known the Father or Me. …
These things
The reference appears to be to the whole revelation of the vital union of the believer with Christ, of the self-sacrifice of Christians, of their power of devotion, of their suffering as sharers with Christ, of their witness coincident with the witness of the Spirit ; and not only to the last section (xv. 17 — 37). Compare xv. ii.
not be offended ...Tf)] Comp. vi. 61. The image of stumbling over some obstacle in the way ..., which is common in the first two Gospels (e.g. Matt. xiii. 21) and is found more rarely in St Luke, occurs in this form only in these two places in the Gospel of St John. It is expressed otherwise in xi. 9 f. (comp. Rom. ix. 33). ...
John 16:1 · Open Word Bible
1I have told you all this so that you will not stumble and fall away.
out of the synagogues
I.e. excommunciate you. Comp. ix.
yea ...] The exclusion from religious fellowship might seem the climax of religious hostility, but there was something more formidable still. The contrast is between what the disciples could perhaps anticipate, and the real extremity of hatred. They shall put you out of the synagogue ; this, indeed, however grievous, you may be prepared to bear ; but far more than this; The hour cometh that their full malignity may be shewn, when putting you to death will seem to be the performance of a religious duty.
whosoever. ..] every one who... This will be the universal spirit, not only among Jews, who will be the first adversaries of the Church, but among Gentiles, who will accuse you of impious crimes (Tac. 'Ann.' XV. 44; Suet. ' Nero,' 16).
doeth God service] offereth service unto God .... The phrase expresses the rendering of a religious service ..., and more particularly the rendering of a sacrifice as service .... The slaughter of Christians, as guilty of blasphemy (Acts vii. 57 f., vi. 13), would necessarily be regarded by zealots as an act of devotion pleasing to God, and not merely as a good work. The Midrash on Num. xxv. 13 ([Phinehas'] made an atonement) may serve as a commentary. " Was this said because he offered an offering ... ? No ; but to teach them that every one that sheds the blood of the wicked is as he that offereth an offering " (' Midrash R.' ad loc.).
John 16:2 · Open Word Bible
2They will expel you from the synagogue. In fact, an hour is coming when anyone who kills you will think they are doing God a sacred service.
do unto you
Omit unto you. The action itself, without regard to the particular objects of it, is the central thought.
because they have not known...] because they knew not... This fatal error was the consequence of a failure to know God. The evil act followed upon the blinded thought. The Jews in their crisis of trial " did not recognise" ... the Father and Christ. Their sin is not placed in the want of knowledge in itself ..., but in the fact that when the opportunity of learning was given to them they did not gain the knowledge which was within their reach (comp. xvii. 25, i. 10).
In this connexion the change from "Him that sent me" (xv. 21) to "the Father" (not " my Father ") is significant. " The Father " marks an absolute and universal relation of God to man which Christ came to reveal ; " Him that sent me" marks the connexion of Christ with the Old Covenant.
John 16:3 · Open Word Bible
3They will do these things because they have never known the Father or Me.
But these things have I told you
But these things have I spoken unto you. The strong adversative ... is difficult to explain. The reference has been supposed to be to the words immediately preceding; as though it were implied that careful reflection might have shewn the disciples after Christ's death what must be their position. This being so, their Master might have left them to the teaching of experience, but for their sake He forewarned them. It is however perhaps more simple to take the but as abruptly breaking the development of thought; "but, not to dwell on the details of the future..."
these things] See v. 1, note.
ye may... of them] ye may remember them how that I ... told you. Comp. xiii. 19. The pronoun I is emphatic. Christ Himself had foreseen what caused His disciples perplexity. As knowing this they could be patient.
And ... these things I said not unto you (told you not) at (from) the beginning} The exact phrase ... occurs in the New Testament only here and in ch. vi. 64. The preposition suggests the notion of that which flows "out of" a source in a continuous stream, rather than of that which first began from a certain point. Comp. Isai. xl. 21, xli. 26, xliii. 9 (LXX.); Ecclus. xxxix.
John 16:4 · Open Word Bible
4But I have said these things to you so that when the hour for them comes, you will remember that I told you of them. I did not tell you these things at the start, because I was with you.
If this difference be regarded, the relation of this statement to the warnings of future trials given at earlier times as recorded by the Synoptists (Matt. v. 10, x. 16 ff.; Luke vi. ^^ f.) becomes intelligible. The future fate of the disciples had not been unfolded little by little in unbroken order as a necessary consequence of their relation to Christ. Here and there t had been indicated before, but now it was shewn in its essential relation to their faith. But these things must not be limited to the prediction of sufferings only. Christ had spoken also of the new relation of the disciples to Himself through the Paraclete. This fresh revelation was part of the vision of the future now first unfolded.
because I was with you] Comp. Matt. ix. 15.
But now I go my way to
Hitherto Christ had Himself borne the storm of hostility, and shielded the disciples : now He was to leave them, and the wrath of His enemies would be diverted upon them, though they would have another Advocate. The clause is to be closely connected with that which follows : " I go my way and yet none of you..."
to him that sent me] My mission, in other words, is completed.
and none of you...] Christ was going; so much the disciples realised. But their thoughts were bent upon their own immediate loss, and no one asked how this departure affected Him; so completely had their own sorrow absorbed them. Thus they missed the abiding significance of His departure for themselves. The isolated questions of St Peter and St Thomas (xiii. 36, xiv. 5) are not inconsistent with these words. Those questions were not asked with a view to the Lord's glory ; and much had been said since which might have moved the disciples to a persistency of inquiry.
John 16:5 · Open Word Bible
5But now I am going to the one who sent Me, and not one of you asks Me, 'Where are You going?'
because I have said these things
Comp. vv. 1, 4. The prospect of misunderstanding and suffering and separation to be faced shut out all thoughts of consolation and strength.
John 16:6 · Open Word Bible
6Instead, sorrow has filled your hearts because I have said these things to you.
is expedient
Comp. xi. 50, xviii. 14. From opposite sides (" it is expedient for KJ," xi. 50 ; but here "it is expedient for you") the divine and human judgments coincide. Comp. vii. 39 note.
The personal pronoun in the first case (that I go) is emphatic. Attention is fixed upon the Person of the Lord as He was known, in order to prepare the hearers for the thought of "another Advocate" (xiv. 16).
for if I go not away] Here the emphasis is changed. The stress is laid upon the thought of departure. To bring out this idea still more clearly, that which is first spoken of as a "departure" with the predominant notion of separation ... is afterwards spoken of as a "journey," with the predominant notion of an end to be gained .... In v. 10 the idea is that of a " withdrawal " .... Comp. vii. 33, note. the Comforter (Advocate) will not come... I will send him...'] The absence of the pronoun before the verb here ... gives predominance to the thought of the Mission of the Spirit as a fact. Comp. Luke xxiv. 49 ; Acts i. 4. The departure of Christ was in itself a necessary condition for the coming of the Spirit to men. The withdrawal of His limited bodily Presence necessarily prepared the way for the recognition of a universal Presence. Comp. vii. 39. And again the presence of Christ with the Father, the consummation of His union with the Father as God and Man, was the preliminary to the Mission of the Spirit. He sent the Spirit in virtue of His ascended Manhood.
John 16:7 · Open Word Bible
7But I am telling you the truth: my going away is to your advantage. For if I do not go away, the Advocate will not come to you at all; but if I go, I will send Him to you.
And yet again the mission and the reception of the Spirit alike required a completed atonement of Man and God (Hebr. ix. 26 ff.), and the glorifying of perfect humanity in Christ.
8—18.
The promise of the Paraclete is followed by the description of His victory. The synagogue has become the world; and the world finds its conqueror.
8 . And when he is come, he...] And h e ... when he is come... ...
John 16:8–18 · Open Word Bible
8When He comes, He will show the world to be in the wrong about sin, about righteousness and about judgment: 9about sin, because they do not believe in Me; 10about righteousness, because I go to the Father and you will see Me no longer; …
The idea of "conviction" is complex. It involves the conceptions of authoritative examination, of unquestionable proof, of decisive judgment, of punitive power. Whatever the final issue may be, he who "convicts" another places the truth of the case in dispute in a clear light before him, so that it must be seen and acknowledged as truth. He who then rejects the conclusion which this exposition involves, rejects it with his eyes open and at his peril. Truth seen as truth carries with it condemnation to all who refuse to welcome it. The different aspects of this "conviction" are brought out in the usage of the word in the N.T. There is first the thorough testing of the real nature of the facts (ch. iii. 20 ; Eph. v. 13) ; and then the application of the truth thus ascertained to the particular person affected (James ii. 9 ; Jude 15, (aa) , 1 Cor. xiv. 24 ; 2 Tim. iv. 2 ; comp. Matt, xviii. 15 ; John viii. 9) ; and that in chastisement (1 Tim. v. 20 ; Titus i. 9, ii. 15 ; comp. Eph. v. 11); or with a distinct view to the restoration of him who is in the wrong (Rev. iii. 19 ; Hebr. xii. 5 ; Titus i. 13).
The effect of the conviction of the world by the Spirit is left undecided so far as the world is concerned; but for the Apostles themselves the pleading of the Advocate was a sovereign vindication of their cause. In the great trial they were shewn to have the right, whether their testimony was received or rejected. The typical history recorded in the Book of the Acts illustrates the decisive twofold action of the divine testimony (2 Cor. ii. 1 6) ; for the presentation of the Truth in its power must always bring life or death, but it may bring either; and in this respect the experience of the Apostles on the Day of Pentecost (Acts ii. 13, 41) has been the experience of the Church in all ages. The divine reproof is not simply a final sentence of condemnation ; it is also at the same time a call to repentance, which may or may not be heard. The Gospel of St John itself, as has been well pointed out ... is a monument of the Spirit's conviction of the world concerning sin (iii. 19 — ai, v. 28 f., 38 — 47, viii. 21 ff., 34 — 47, ix. 41, xiv. a?, xv. 18 — 24); righteousness (v. 30, vii. 18, 24, viii. 28.
Of sin, because they believe not on me
The want of belief in Christ when He is made known, lies at the root of all sin, and reveals its nature. Sin is essentially the selfishness which sets itself up apart from, and so against God. It is not defined by any limited rules, but expresses a general spirit. Christ is thus the touchstone of character. To believe in Him, is to adopt the principle of self-surrender to God. Not to believe in Him, is to cleave to legal views of duty and service which involve a complete misunderstanding of the essence of sin. The Spirit therefore, working through the written and spoken word, starts from the fact of unbelief in the Son of Man, and through that lays open what sin is. In this way the condition of man standing alone is revealed, and he is left without excuse. Comp. viii. 21, ix. 41.
John 16:9 · Open Word Bible
9about sin, because they do not believe in Me;
Of righteousness, because I go
The Person of Christ, offered as the object of man's faith, serves as a test of the true appreciation of sin. The historical work of Christ, completed at His Ascension, serves as a test of the true appreciation of righteousness. The Life and Death and Resurrection of the Son of God placed righteousness in a new light. By these the majesty of law and the power of obedience and the reality of a divine fellowship, stronger than death, were made known once for all. For a time the Lord had shewn in an outward form the perfect fulfilment of the Law, and the absolute conformity of a human life to the divine ideal. He had shewn also how sin carries with it consequences which must be borne; and how they had been borne in such a way that they were potentially abolished. In that life, closed by the return to the Father, there was a complete exhibition of righteousness in relation to God and man. The Son had received a work to do, and having accomplished it He returned not simply to heaven but to the Father who sent Him, in token of its absolute fulfilment. This revelation once given was final. Because nothing could be added to it (I go to the Father) ; because after that Christ was withdrawn from human eyes He had passed into a new sphere (ye see me no more), there was fixed for all time that by which men's estimate of righteousness might be tried. On the other hand, till Christ had been raised to glory "righteousness" had not been vindicated. The condemnation of Christ by the representatives of Israel shewed in the extremest form how men had failed to apprehend the nature of righteousness. The Spirit, therefore, starting from the fact of Christ's life, His suffering, and His glory, regarded as a whole, lays open the divine aspects of human action as concentrated in the Son of Man. In this way the possibilities of life are revealed in fellowship with Him who has raised humanity to heaven.
John 16:10 · Open Word Bible
10about righteousness, because I go to the Father and you will see Me no longer;
righteousness
The word occurs only in this passage in St John's Gospel. In his first Epistle it is found in the phrase " do righteousness" (ii. 39, iii. 7, 10; comp. Rev. xxii. 11, [xix. nj). "Righteousness" is evidently considered in its widest sense. Each limited thought of righteousness, as of God's righteousness in the rejection of the Jews, or of man's righteousness as a believer, or even of Christ's righteousness, otherwise than as the fulfilment of the absolute idea in relation both to God and man, is foreign to the scope of the passage. The world is examined, convicted, convinced, as to its false theories of righteousness. In Christ was the one absolute type of righteousness ; from him a sinful man must obtain righteousness. Just as sin is revealed by the Spirit to be something far different from the breaking of certain specific injunctions, so righteousness is revealed to be something far different from the outward fulfilment of ceremonial or moral- observances. Comp. Matt. v. 20, vi. 33 ; Rom. iii. 21 f., x. 3.
Of judgment, because the prince of this world is judged
The world hitherto had passed sentence on success and failure according to its own standard. At length this standard had been overthrown. He in whom the spirit of the world was concentrated had been judged at the very moment and in the very act by which he appeared to common eyes to have triumphed. ...
John 16:11 · Open Word Bible
11and about judgment, because the ruler of this world stands judged.
the prince of this world
Ch. xii. 31, xiv. 30.
5. The Paraclete and the disciples ....
The office of the Paraclete is not confined to the conviction of the world. He carries forward the work which Christ had begun for the disciples, and guides them into all the Truth (vv. 12, 13). ...
This section distinctly marks the position of the apostles with regard to revelation as unique; and so also by implication the office of the apostolic writings as a record of their teaching. The same trust which leads us to believe that the apostles were guided into the Truth, leads us also to believe that by the providential leading of the Spirit they were so guided as to present it in such a way that it might remain in a permanent form.
I have yet
The principles had been fully laid down (xv. 15) ; yet there was still need of a divine commentary to apply these to individual life, and to the formation of a universal Church. In especial the meaning of the Passion had to be unfolded, for though the Passion was potentially included in the Incarnation, neither the one nor the other could be grasped by the disciples till the Son of man was outwardly glorified.
bear] The original word ... implies that such teaching as that of the Cross would have been a crushing burden. Comp. ch. xix. 17; Luke xi. 46, xiv. 27, Gal. vi. 2, 5 ; Acts xv. 10. ...
now] at this point in your spiritual growth (aprt). The word stands emphatically at the end. Compare xiii. 33, note.
John 16:12 · Open Word Bible
12There is much more I have to tell you, but it is more than you can bear right now.
when he
The whole verse describes an essentially personal action. ...
Spirit continues under new conditions that which Christ began.
the Spirit of truth... into all truth (the truth)] He who gives expression to the Truth (see xiv. 17) guides men into its fulness. He leads them not (vaguely) " into all truth," but "into all the Truth" ..., into the complete understanding of and sympathy with that absolute Truth, which is Christ Himself. The order of the original is remarkable ; the truth in all its parts .... Comp. v. 22 ; Matt. ix. 35 ; Acts xvi. 26 ; Rom. xii. 4.
Comp. Ps. xxv. (xxiv.) 5; Rev. vii. 17; (Acts viii. 31).
guide] Christ is " the way " by which men are led to " the truth." By Him we go to Him. The Spirit "guides" men who j follow His leading ; He does not " tell " His I message without effort on their part. He also guides them "into the Truth," which is the domain upon which they enter, and not something to be gazed upon from afar.
Philo, commenting upon Ex. xvi. 23, has a corresponding phrase: "The mind [of Moses] would not have gone thus straight to the mark unless there had been a divine Spirit which guided it ... to the truth " ('De Vit. Mos.' iii. 36, ii. p. 176).
John 16:13 · Open Word Bible
13But when He, the Spirit of truth, comes, He will guide you in all the truth. What He says will not come from Himself; He will speak what He hears, and He will make known to you what is yet to come.
for he shall not
The test of His true guidance lies in the fact that His teaching is the perfect expression of the one will of God: it is not "of Himself" (see xv. 4, note). That which is affirmed of the Son is affirmed also of the Spirit. Comp. ch. viii. 26, 40, xv. 15. ... The interpretation of that message by the Spirit goes forward to the end of time.
shall hear] The verb is left absolute. The fact which is declared is that the teaching of the Spirit comes finally from the one source of Truth. The words that follow shew that no distinction is made in this respect between that which is of the Father and that which is of Christ.
St. JOHN. XVI.
shew] Rather, declare. ...
He...shall glorify me
The work of the Spirit in relation to the Son is presented as parallel with that of the Son in relation to the Father. Comp. xiv. 26, xvii. 4. He "glorifies" the Son, that is, makes Him known in His full majesty by gradual revelation, taking now this fragment and now that from the whole sum of Truth. For the manifestation of the Truth is indeed the glorification of Christ. The pronoun ... is placed emphatically before the verb. It was Christ, and none other, who was the subject of the Spirit's teaching.
for (because) be shall...] To make Christ better known is assumed to be the same as spreading His glory.
shall receive] shall take (as in v. 15). The original verb may be rendered either "receive" or " take." ... Comp. xx. 22, note.
of mine] All that is Christ's is at first contemplated in its unity (TO (pots'), and then in its manifold parts (all things).
John 16:14 · Open Word Bible
14He will glorify Me, because He will receive from what is Mine and make it known to you.
All things...mine
Comp. xvii. 10. therefore said I...] ...
Spirit was a message of absolute divine Truth ; that Truth which belonged to the Father belonged also to the Son ; therefore Christ could say that the Spirit would take of that which was His in order to fulfil His works.
shall take] According to the true reading, taketh. The work is even now begun ..., and not wholly future (shall take, i, v. 14).
John 16:15 · Open Word Bible
15Everything the Father has is Mine. That is why I said that He will receive from what is Mine and make it known to you.
6. Sorrow turned to joy (xvi. 16—24).
The prospect of the fulfilment of the work of the Paraclete for the world and for the disciples is followed by a revelation of the condition in which the disciples themselves will be. They are to stand in a new relation to Christ (16 — 18). A time of bitter sorrow is to be followed by joy (19, 20), by joy springing (so to speak) naturally out of the sorrow (21, 22) ; and this joy is to be carried to its complete fulfilment (23, 24).
In this and the following section the disciples again, though in a body and at first indirectly, appear as speakers. The form of the first part of the discourses is partly resumed at the close, though under new conditions.
John 16:16–24 · Open Word Bible
16In a little while you will no longer see Me, and then after another little while you will see Me." 17Then some of His disciples said to one another, "What does He mean by telling us, 'In a little while you will no longer see Me, and then after another little while you will see Me'? And what about 'because I am going to the Father'?" 18So they kept saying, "What does He mean by 'a little while'? We do not understand what He is talking about." …
ye shall not see me...ye shall see me
ye behold me no more. ..ye shall see me. The last clause, because I go unto the Father, must be omitted in accordance with a very strong combination of authorities. The words have evidently been introduced from v. 17; and they do not occur in the Lord's repetition of the sentence, v. 19. This verse offers a superficial contradiction to xiv. 19, which may perhaps have arrested the attention of the disciples. Comp. v. 12, viii. 14. In xiv. 19 the thought is of the contrast between the world and the disciples ; here the thought is of the contrast between two stages in the spiritual history of the disciples themselves. As contrasted with the world the disciples never lost the vision of Christ. Their life was unbroken even as His life, and so also their direct relation to Him. But on the other hand, the form of their vision was altered. The vision of wondering contemplation, in which they observed little by little the outward manifestation of the Lord ..., was changed and transfigured into sight ..., in which they seized at once intuitively all that Christ was. As long as His earthly presence was the object on which their eyes were fixed, their view was necessarily imperfect. His glorified presence shewed Him in His true nature.
John 16:16 · Open Word Bible
16In a little while you will no longer see Me, and then after another little while you will see Me."
Then said some of his disciples
Some of his disciples therefore said. .. The particularity of the expression, as compared with v. 29, iv. 33, seems to mark a distinct impression on the mind of the Evangelist as to the actual scene. He, we may suppose, was himself silent.
among themselves] Rather, one to another ..., iv. 33, and so xix. 24. ...
What is this...] The difficulty of the disciples was twofold, (1) as to the fact itself which was announced, and (2) as to the reason which they felt to be alleged in explanation of it. It is best to keep the rendering because, for the conjunction ... which introduces the second clause. It may however serve simply to introduce the words quoted: and I go to the Father. But v. 10 seems to shew that it was not only the departure which was perplexing, but also the consequences connected with it ; and it is from this verse that the words are quoted, since they are not found in the true text of v. 16.
ye shall not see me] ye behold me not.
John 16:17 · Open Word Bible
17Then some of His disciples said to one another, "What does He mean by telling us, 'In a little while you will no longer see Me, and then after another little while you will see Me'? And what about 'because I am going to the Father'?"
What is this that he saith, A little while
What is this little while whereof he speaketh? What are these strange intervals, marked by separation and change, which break the tenour of our intercourse ?
(we cannot tell] we know not.
John 16:18 · Open Word Bible
18So they kept saying, "What does He mean by 'a little while'? We do not understand what He is talking about."
Now Jesus knew
The word used probably indicates an outward occasion for the Lord's words, though indeed He read the heart. The anxious looks and whisperings of the disciples would alone be sufficient to reveal their wish. ... Comp. ii. 24, note.
of that 1 said] concerning this, that ... I said. ye shall not see me] ye behold me not.
John 16:19 · Open Word Bible
19Jesus knew that they wanted to ask Him about it, so He said to them, "Are you discussing with one another what I meant when I said, 'In a little while you will no longer see Me, and then after another little while you will see Me'?
20—30.
The Lord in His answer takes for granted that which He had already made known, and reveals the character of the double interval (20—22), and the new relation to the Father realised for the disciples by His departure (23, 24).
John 16:20–30 · Open Word Bible
20Truly, truly, I tell you, you will weep and mourn aloud, but the world will rejoice. You will be full of sorrow, but your sorrow will become joy. 21When a woman is giving birth she has sorrow, because her hour has come. But once her child is born, she no longer remembers the anguish, for joy that a human being has been born into the world. 22So it is with you: now you have sorrow, but I will see you again. Then your hearts will rejoice, and no one takes your joy away from you. …
ye shall
The order in this first clause is very remarkable .... Attention is at once fixed on the sadness of the immediate future for the disciples. ... And they shall be your lot. Meanwhile the world shall rejoice. Yes : this shall be the issue of that first 'little while.' Ye (omit and) shall be sorrowful; but your sorrow, in that you think that you have lost me, shall be turned into joy. ...
John 16:20 · Open Word Bible
20Truly, truly, I tell you, you will weep and mourn aloud, but the world will rejoice. You will be full of sorrow, but your sorrow will become joy.
ye shall weep and lament
The words mark the open expression of intense sorrow. Such lamentation was the natural accompaniment of Christ's death. Comp. Luke xxiii. 27 f., ch. xx. ii.
the world shall rejoice] as having been freed from one who was a dangerous innovator as well as a condemner of its ways.
and (omit) ye ... shall be sorrowful] The inward feeling is now substituted for the outward expression of grief. The first sharp utterance or lamentation was to be followed by a more permanent sorrow. The words, which had an immediate fulfilment in the experience of the Apostles before the Resurrection, and again before Pentecost, have also a wider application. ...
turned into ...] Comp. Matt. xxi. 42 ; Luke xiii. 19 ; Acts iv. 11, v. 36 ; 1 Pet. ii. 7; Rom. xi. 9; 1 Cor. xv. 45; Rev. viii. 11, xvi. 19. The sorrow itself is transformed.
A woman
The exact form of expression ... marks not simply a single case, but the universal law. The illustration is not taken from any one woman, but from woman as such.
for joy] for the joy, the special joy which answered to her pangs.
a man] a being endowed with all the gifts of humanity .... The potential fulness of the completed life is regarded as present to the mother's mind.
born into the world] The complex phrase marks not only the fact but the sphere of the new life. The man is introduced to a place in the great order in which he has a part to play. Comp. viii. 26.
The image of a new birth is constantly applied to the institution of Messiah's kingdom. Comp. Matt. xxiv. 8 ; Mark xiii. 8 ... ; Rom. viii. 22 .... And it is applied more generally to the passage to joy through sorrow: Isai. lxvi. 6 ff.; Hos. xiii. 13. St Paul uses the same image to describe the relation of an apostle to his converts, Gal. iv. 19.
John 16:21 · Open Word Bible
21When a woman is giving birth she has sorrow, because her hour has come. But once her child is born, she no longer remembers the anguish, for joy that a human being has been born into the world.
And ye now therefore
Or, Ye also therefore now.... The application or the image (therefore) clearly indicates that something more is intended by it than the mere passage of the disciples through suffering to joy. The proper idea of birth-throes is not that of the transition from suffering to joy, but of suffering as the necessary condition and preparation for joy. Under this aspect the disciples in some sense occupied the position of the mother. It was their office, as the representatives of the Church, to realise the Christ of the Resurrection and present Him to the world (comp. Rev. xii. 2 ff.). The time of transition from their present state to that future state was necessarily a period of anguish, and that time was even now come (now ye have). But the image is not exhausted by this application. It appears also to have a reference to Christ Himself. For Him death was as the travail-pain issuing in a new life (Acts ii. 24). His passage through the grave was as the new birth of humanity brought about through the extremity of sorrow.
have sorrow] The phrase is not identical with be sorrowful, but expresses the full realisation of sorrow. See iii. 15, note.
I (will see you again] The implied reference to Christ as Himself rising through the Passion to His glory seems to have led to the use of the first person here, as contrasted with the second person which was used before ...J"? shall see me). The highest blessing lies not in the thought that God is the object of our regard, but that we are objects of God's regard. Comp. Gal. iv. 9 ; 1 Cor. viii. 3; (ch. x. 14, 15).
John 16:22 · Open Word Bible
22So it is with you: now you have sorrow, but I will see you again. Then your hearts will rejoice, and no one takes your joy away from you.
and your joy...taketh
The sorrow of the disciples (v. 20) underwent a sudden transformation. Their joy was stable. The turn of the sentence implies that they would have enemies, but that their enemies would not prevail.
in that day
when the new relation is realised, and you enjoy the fulness of my glorified presence .... "That day" begins with Pentecost and is consummated at the Return. The Lord now brings before the disciples the consequences of this "going to the Father" (v. 17), perfect knowledge, the perfect fulfilment of prayer, perfect joy.
ye shall ask me ... nothing] ye shall ask me no question. All will then be clear. The mysteries which now perplex you will have been illuminated. You will not need to seek my guidance when you enjoy that of the Spirit. The verb ... appears to answer directly to the same word used before in v. 19 ..., and so to be used in the same sense. The phrase may however be rendered (as A. V.) ye shall ask me nothing, in the sense " ye shall make no request of me." But the context appears to favour the other interpretation. Thus the change in the position of the disciples as suggested in this clause when compared with the next is twofold. Their relation to Christ (the pronoun me stands in a position of emphasis) is to be fulfilled in the recognition of a relation to the Father. The questioning of ignorance is to be replaced by the definite prayer which claims absolute accomplishment as being in conformity with the will of God. ...
John 16:23 · Open Word Bible
23On that day you will not ask Me any questions. Truly, truly, I tell you, if you ask the Father for anything, He will give it to you in My name.
Verily, verily
According to uniform usage this formula introduces a new thought. The preceding clause must therefore, as it seems, te taken rather with what has gone before than with these words.
Whatsoever ye shall ask ...-"in my name, he...] Rather, according to the true reading: if ye shall ask anything of. ..he shall give it you in my name.
the Father] The return of Christ to the Father restored in its completeness the connexion of man with God, which had been broken.
give it you in my name] Not only is the prayer offered in Christ's name (v. 24, xv. 1 6), but the answer is given in His name. Every divine gift represents in part the working of that Spirit who is sent in His name (xiv. 26).
Hitherto
As yet Christ Himself was not fully revealed. His name in its complete significance was not made known ; nor had the disciples at present the power to enter into its meaning.
ask] The end is assumed to be already reached. The command implies a continuous prayer ..., and not a single petition (Mark vi. 22, atnjo-ov).
may be full (fulfilled)] The phrase implies not only the fact ..., but the abiding state which follows ..., comp. xvii. 13; 1 John i. 4; 2 John 12). This fulness of joy is the divine end of Christ's work according to the Father's will.
John 16:24 · Open Word Bible
24So far you have asked for nothing in My name. Ask and you will receive, so that your joy will be complete.
25—27.
The teaching of vv. 23 f. is unfolded more fully in these verses. There will be hereafter no need of questioning, because the revelation will be plain ("23 a, 25) : the fulfilment of prayer in Christ s name will be absolute, because of the relation established between believers and the Father (23 b, f., 26 f.).
John 16:25–27 · Open Word Bible
25"I have used figures of speech in telling you these things. An hour is coming when I will no longer use them with you; I will tell you about the Father in plain words. 26On that day you will ask in My name, and I do not say that I will ask the Father on your behalf. 27For the Father Himself loves you, since you have loved Me and believed that I came out from God.
7. After failure, victory (xvi. 25—33).
This section forms a kind of epilogue to the discourses. The Lord gathers up in a brief summary His present and future relations to the disciples (25 — 27), and the character of His mission (28). This is followed by a confession of faith on the part of the disciples (29, 30); to which the Lord replies with a warning, and with a triumphant assurance (31 — 33).
John 16:25–33 · Open Word Bible
25"I have used figures of speech in telling you these things. An hour is coming when I will no longer use them with you; I will tell you about the Father in plain words. 26On that day you will ask in My name, and I do not say that I will ask the Father on your behalf. 27For the Father Himself loves you, since you have loved Me and believed that I came out from God. …
These things...in proverbs
All that had been said since they had left the Upper Room. Of these revelations part had been veiled in figures (the Vine, the Woman in travail), and part was for the time only half intelligible. A deeper meaning lay beneath the words, which could not yet be made plain. It seems to be unnatural to limit the reference to the answer to the question in v. 17. The description applies in fact to all the earthly teaching of the Lord. The necessity which veiled His teaching to the multitudes (Matt, xiii. 11 ff.) influenced, in other ways, His teaching to the disciples. He spoke as they could bear, and under figures of human limitation.
proverbs] Comp. x. 6, note.
but the time cometh] the hour cometh. Omit but. Comp. iv. 21, note. From the day of Pentecost, Christ, speaking through the Holy Spirit, has declared plainly the relation of the Father to men ....
shew you] tell you, or declare unto you, vv. 13 ff. ; 1 John i. 2 f. The original word according to the true text ... marks the origin rather than the destination ... of the message.
plainly] without reserve, or concealment. Here the objective sense of the original term (irappr] ... prevails. See vii. 13, note.
John 16:25 · Open Word Bible
25"I have used figures of speech in telling you these things. An hour is coming when I will no longer use them with you; I will tell you about the Father in plain words.
At that day
v. 23, note. The fulness of knowledge leads to the fulness of prayer. The clearer revelation of the Father issues in the bolder petitions "in the Son's name ;" and this revelation is given by the Paraclete after Pentecost.
I say not... that I ...] Your confidence will then rest upon a direct connexion with God. I speak not therefore of my own intercession in support of your requests. This intercession however is still necessary (1 John ii. 1 f.) so far as the disciples realise imperfectly their position as sons.
pray (ask) the Father for you] not directly "in behalf of you," but "about you" ..., as inquiring what was the Father's will, and so laying the case before Him. Comp. Luke iv. 38 ; ch. xvii. 9, 20. This use of ask ... in connexion with prayer addressed to God is peculiar to St John. It expresses a request made on the basis of fellowship and is used in the Gospel only of the petitions of the Lord (contrast alrfiv, xi. 22, note). This peculiarity of sense explains the use of the word in 1 John v. 16, where the circumstances exclude the idea of prayer for a brother in fellowship with the common Father.
27. the Father himself, without any pleading on my part, loveth you with the love which springs from a natural relationship ..., for the disciples are also sons (Rom. viii. 15). Comp. v. 20; Rev. iii. 19. This assurance carries out yet further the promise in xiv. 21, 2 3 ....
John 16:26 · Open Word Bible
26On that day you will ask in My name, and I do not say that I will ask the Father on your behalf.
ye have loved me, and
... Comp. Matt. x. 37. The word is used also 1 Cor. xvi. 22. The love of the disciples is to be regarded no less as the sign than as the cause of the Father's love (xiv. 21, 23). His love made their love possible, and then again responded to it .... ...
came out from God] According to the true reading, came forth from the Father. ... The twofold requirement of true discipleship is laid down to be : (1) personal devotion, (2) belief in the personal ... mission of Christ from heaven (xvii. 8). The recognition of the Son depends on a right sense of His relation to the Father. The common reading (from God) obscures this thought.
John 16:27 · Open Word Bible
27For the Father Himself loves you, since you have loved Me and believed that I came out from God.
came forth from
I came out from.,.. No phrase could express more completely unity of essence than the true original of these words .... Comp. viii. 42, note. Thus the Lord, while He recognises the faith of the disciples, lays before them a revelation of deeper mysteries. The verse is indeed a brief summary of the whole historic work of Christ : clause answers to clause : the Mission, the Nativity; the Passion, the Ascension.
again] This revelation is complementary to the other. Comp. 1 John ii. 8.
leave the world] Comp. iv. 3, note.
go to the Father] That which was before (vv. 10, 17) described as a withdrawal , is now again described as a journey for a purpose .... Comp. xiv. 12, 28.
John 16:28 · Open Word Bible
28I came out from the Father and have come into the world. Now, in turn, I am leaving the world and going to the Father."
29—30.
The Lord had interpreted the disciples' thoughts, atid they openly confess their gratitude and faith, as satisfied with what they can grasp already.
John 16:29–30 · Open Word Bible
29His disciples said, "Look, now You are speaking in plain words and not using any figure of speech! 30Now we know that You know all things and do not need anyone to put questions to You. This is why we believe that You came out from God."
said unto him
say.
Lo, now. ..Now we know...] The revelation seemed to the disciples to have outrun the promise. Their Master had spoken of some future time in which He would give a clear declaration of the Father. They answer, Now thou speakest plainly ; and we need not wait in darkness any longer. Now we know that which makes silent patience easy.
Lo] The sharp interjection is characteristic of St John's narrative. It occurs more often in his Gospel than in all the other books of the N. T. together. Comp. iii. 26, v. 14, xi. 36, xii. 19, xix. 4, 5, 14, &c.
plainly] "In plainness" ... ; the slight change of form from v. 25 ... marks a difference between the sphere of the revelation and the simple manner ; ch. vii. 4 ; Eph. vi. 19 ; Col. ii. 15.
John 16:29 · Open Word Bible
29His disciples said, "Look, now You are speaking in plain words and not using any figure of speech!
Now are we sure
Now we know. The discernment of their thought (v. 19) seemed to the disciples a sure pledge that all was open before Christ. A human helper needs to have the thoughts of those whom he has to help interpreted to him. In such a case the question is the natural prelude to assistance. So the disciples had hitherto stood towards Christ ; but now they had gained a fresh confidence. It was enough for the believer to feel the want. The Lord would satisfy it as was best, without requiring to hear it from him.
earnest forth from God] This common confession of faith shews how little even yet 31 Jesus answered them, Do ye now believe ?
John 16:30 · Open Word Bible
30Now we know that You know all things and do not need anyone to put questions to You. This is why we believe that You came out from God."