B. F. Westcott · The Gospel According to St. John: The Authorised Version with Introduction and Notes
John 6
93 excerpts on John 6, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
The signs on the land and on the lake (i—ai).
Thousand (i — 15), and the Walking on the Sea (15 — 21), combine to shew Christ as the support of life and as the guide and strengthener of the toiling. Through His disciples He first satisfies the multitudes, and then He Himself, at first unseen and unrecognised, brings His labouring disciples to the haven of rest.
1 — 15. The sign on the land, the feeding of the five thousand.
The feeding of the five thousand is the only incident in the Lord's life, before His last visit to Jerusalem, which is recorded by all four Evangelists. The variations of detail in the four narratives are therefore of the deepest interest (Matt. xiv. 13 — 21; Mark vi. 30 — 44; Luke ix. 10 — 17 ; John vi. 1 — 15).
Generally it may be said that the Synoptic narratives are given in broad outline, as part of a prolonged ministry. St John's narrative is part of an isolated episode, but at the same time individual in detail. ...
John 6:1–21 · Open Word Bible
1Some time later Jesus went away across the Sea of Galilee, which is also called the Sea of Tiberias. 2A large crowd kept following Him, because they kept seeing the signs He was doing by healing the sick. 3Jesus climbed up into the hills and sat there with His disciples. …
It follows that the two narratives are derived from two distinct sources ; for it is not possible that the narrative of St John could h.ave been derived from any one of the Synoptists, or from the common original from which they were finally derived.
The chronology of the event cannot be determined with absolute certainty. ...
Against (1) ... it must be urged that all direct documentary evidence whatever supports the disputed words. The ground for suspecting them is derived indirectly from patristic citations, and it is by no means clear that there is not in the passages quoted a confusion between vi. 4 and vii. 2. Irenaeus ... appears to interpret nigh ... retrospectively. Comp. Mark vi. 39, note.
The transposition (2) ... would give a simple connexion of events, but in the absence of all external evidence it cannot be maintained.
Our knowledge of the details of the Lord's life is far too fragmentary to justify us in the endeavour to make a complete arrangement of those which have been recorded. The very abruptness of the transition in vi. 1 is characteristic of St John ; comp. iii. 22, x. 22, xii. 1.
After these things
See v. 1, note.
went] Rather, departed, went away, th'at is from the scene of His ministry at the time, which is left undetermined, and not from Jerusalem, as if this verse stood in immediate connexion with ch. v. The abruptness with which the narrative is introduced is most worthy of notice. All we read is that the departure "over the sea of Galilee" (i.e. to the east side of it) took place at sometime after the visit to Jerusalem, which, as we have seen, probably took place at the feast of the New Year. The Passover also was near, if the present text in v. 4 is correct ; but we learn nothing from St John as to the facts by which the incident was immediately preceded. This information must be sought from the other Gospels. And it is very significant that the Synoptists set the withdrawal of the Lord in connexion with, two critical events. They all agree in stating that it followed upon tidings brought from without. St Matthew makes it consequent upon the account of the death of the Baptist brought by his disciples (xiv. 13). St Luke places it immediately after the return of the twelve from their mission, but without any definite combination of the two events (ix. 10). St Mark brings out more clearly that at least one object of the retirement was rest from exhausting labour (vi. 30, 31). These indications of a concurrence of motives exactly correspond to the fulness of life. And St Luke has preserved the link which combines them. "Herod," he says, "sought to see [Jesus]," troubled by the thought of a new John come to take the place of him whom he had murdered (ix. 9). The news of the death of the Baptist, of the designs of Herod, of the work of the twelve, coming at the same time, made a brief season of quiet retirement, and that outside the dominions of Herod, the natural counsel of wisdom and tenderness. St Luke alone gives the name of the place which was chosen for this object, " a city called Bethsaida" (ix. 10), that is the district of Bethsaida Julias in Gaulonitis, at the N.E. of the lake (Jos. 'Ant.' xviii. 2. 1). This second city of the same name was probably present to the mind of St John when he spoke of "Bethsaida of Galilee" (xii. 21 ; but not i. 44) as the home of Philip. Perhaps we may add, that this withdrawal for calm devotion would be still more necessary, if it was intended to cover the period of the Passover, which the Lord could not celebrate at Jerusalem owing to the hostility shewn towards Him there not long before.
John 6:1 · Open Word Bible
1Some time later Jesus went away across the Sea of Galilee, which is also called the Sea of Tiberias.
the sea of Tiberias
This is the name by which the lake was known to classical writers .... The title occurs only here and in ch. xxi. 1 in the New Testament; and it will be noticed that in xxi. 1 no second name is given. The later incident was not contained in the common basis of the Synoptic accounts, and was not therefore connected with the Synoptic title of the lake. The name of Tiberias, the splendid but unholy capital tain, and there he sat with his dis- Whence shall we buy bread, that ciples. these may eat?
followed
not simply on this occasion but generally .... The verse describes most vividly the habitual work and environment and influence of Christ. ...
saw] beheld ..., v. 19. See ii. 23, note.
his miracles...] the signs which he did... This verb ..., like those which precede, marks a continued ministry.
John 6:2 · Open Word Bible
2A large crowd kept following Him, because they kept seeing the signs He was doing by healing the sick.
into a mountain
into the mountain, and... So v. 15. The use of the definite article implies an instinctive sense of the familiar landscape, the mountain range closing round the lake. This use is found also in the Synoptic narrative, Matt. v. 1, xiv. 23, xv. 29 ; Mark iii. 13, vi. 46; Luke vi. 12, ix. 28. St Matthew adds that it was " a desert spot" (xiv. 13).
sat] Literally, was sitting. The word has a life-like distinctness when taken in connexion with v. 5. Comp. Matt. xiii. 1, xv. 29.
John 6:3 · Open Word Bible
3Jesus climbed up into the hills and sat there with His disciples.
And the passover...was nigh
i.e. "near at hand" (ii. 13, vii. 2, xi. 55), and not as Irenaeus (?) and some moderns have taken it, "lately past." The notice of the feast is probably designed to give a clue to the understanding of the spiritual lessons of the miracle which are set forth in the discourse which followed (1 Cor. v. 7) ; and at the same time it serves to explain how trains of pilgrims on their way to Jerusalem may have been attracted to turn aside to the new Teacher, in addition to " the multitude" who were already attached to Him.
the feast of the Jews] i.e. "the well-known feast." The phrase when it stands alone signifies the Feast of Tabernacles, "the one great national feast." Compare vii. 2 (where the order is different), and v. 1, note.
John 6:4 · Open Word Bible
4It was nearly time for Passover, the Jewish festival.
When Jesus then lifted up...and saw...come...he saith
Jesus therefore having lifted up his eyes and seen that... cometh... saith. Comp. iv. 35, (i. 38).
come (cometh)] Literally, is coming. ...
(Mark vi. 33). The point of time here is evidently the first arrival of the people. A day of teaching and healing must be intercalated before the miracle of feeding was wrought (Matt. xiv. 14 ; Mark vi. 34 ; Luke ix. 11). St John appears to have brought together into one scene, as we now regard it, the first words spoken to Philip on the approach of the crowd, and the words in which they were afterwards taken up by Andrew, when the disciples themselves at evening restated the difficulty (Matt. xiv. 15 ; Mark vi. 35; Luke ix. 12). If this view be true, so that the words addressed to Philip with his answer preceded the whole day's work, then the mention of '• two hundred pennyworth of bread " made by the disciples in St Mark (v'- 3?) gains great point, and so too the phrase "what He was about to do" (v. 6), which otherwise appears to be followed too quickly by its fulfilment. It appears also from v. 15 that the Lord came down from the mountain before the miracle was wrought.
Whence shall we...] The words are one expression of the feeling of tender compassion noticed by the Synoptists (Matt. xiv. 14 ; Mark vi. 34).
John 6:5 · Open Word Bible
5Jesus looked up and saw that a large crowd was making its way toward Him. So He asked Philip, "Where are we going to buy bread to feed these people?"
to prove
Literally, trying him, to see whether he could meet the difficulty. Comp. 2 Cor. xiii. 5 ; Rev. ii. 2. The word does not necessarily carry with it (as these passages shew) the secondary idea of temptation (comp. also Matt. xxii. 25 ; Mark xii. 28) ; but practically in the case of men such trial assumes for the most part this form, seeing that it leads to failure, either as designed by him who applies it (Matt. xvi. 1, xix. 3, xxii. 18, &c.), or consequent upon the weakness of him to whom it is applied (Hebr. xi. 17 ; 1 Cor. x. 1.3). Comp. Deut. xiii. 3.
for he himself knew. ..would (was about to) do] Throughout the Gospel the Evangelist speaks as one who had an intimate knowledge of the Lord's mind. He reveals both the thoughts which belong to His own internal, absolute knowledge ..., and also those which answered to actual experience and insight ....
John 6:6 · Open Word Bible
6Jesus said this to test Philip; He already knew what He was going to do.
Two hundred pennyworth
*'.?. between six and seven pounds worth. See Mark vi. 37. ...
John 6:7 · Open Word Bible
7Philip answered Him, "Bread costing more than half a year's wages would not go far enough to give each of them even a little."
Andrew
He appears elsewhere in connexion with Philip, i. 44, xii. 22.
John 6:8 · Open Word Bible
8Then Andrew, one of His disciples and the brother of Simon Peter, said to Him,
barley loaves
v. 13. The detail is peculiar to St John. Comp. 2 K. iv. 42. Barley bread was the food of the poor. Wetstein ... has collected a large number of passages to shew the small account in which it was held. See Judg. vii. 13 f. ; Ezek. xiii. 19.
small fishes] Rather, fishes. ... It may have been a familiar Galilaean word.
John 6:9 · Open Word Bible
9"There is a young boy here who has five loaves of barley bread and two small fish. But what good is that with so many people?"
And Jesus
Omit And.
the men... the men] //.v people ....../Af men ...... about five thousand. The change of word in the latter case implies the remark added by St Matthew (xiv. 21) beside women and children.
much grass] See note on Mark vi. 39. The difference of the form in which the detail is introduced marks apparently the testimony of two eye-witnesses. This detail corresponds with the date, which is fixed (vi. 4) in the early spring.
John 6:10 · Open Word Bible
10Jesus said, "Tell the people to sit down." Grass grew thickly in that spot. So the men sat down, about 5,000 of them.
And Jesus
Jesus therefore, answering the obedience of faith.
when he had given thanks (v. 23)] By this act the Lord takes the place of the head of the family (comp. Luke xxiv. 30). The word itself is found elsewhere in St John only, xi. 41. This second passage suggests that the thanksgiving was rendered in acknowledgment of the revelation of the Father's will in accordance with which the miracle was wrought. In the parallels the word is blessed (yet comp. Matt. xv. 36 ; Mark viii. 6). The two words preserve the two aspects of the action in relation to the source and in relation to the mode of its accomplishment. ...
he distributed to. ..them that...] The words to the disciples... and the disciples must be omitted. They are an obvious gloss introduced from St Matthew xiv. 19.
John 6:11 · Open Word Bible
11So Jesus took the loaves, gave thanks, and shared them out among the people sitting there, and the fish too, as much as anyone wanted.
When they...said
And when they... saith...
fragments] i.e. the pieces broken for distribution (Ezek. xiii. 19). The command to collect these is preserved by St John only.
that remain] that remain over, and so in v. 13 ..., where the same word is used.
John 6:12 · Open Word Bible
12Once they were all full, He told His disciples, "Pick up the broken pieces that remain, so that nothing is lost."
gathered...together
gathered... up. The word is the same as in v. 12. The simple repetition gives character to the narrative.
twelve] The number implies that the work was given to the apostles, though they have riot been specially mentioned. Comp. v. 70.
baskets] The stout wicker baskets ... as distinguished from the soft, flexible "frails" .... Juv. ' Sat.' iii. 14, VI. 542.
John 6:13 · Open Word Bible
13They did so, and from the five barley loaves they filled twelve baskets with the pieces that remained after everyone had eaten.
14—15.
15. This incident is peculiar to St John, but St Luke has preserved a detail which illustrates it. He notices that Christ spoke to the multitudes " concerning the kingdom of God" (ix. 11) ; and it is natural to suppose that the excitement consequent upon the death of the Baptist, which in part led to the Lord's retirement, may have moved many to believe that He would place Himself at the head of a popular rising to avenge the murder.
John 6:14–15 · Open Word Bible
14The people who had seen the sign He did kept saying, "This really is the Prophet, the one who is coming into the world!" 15Jesus realized that they were about to come and carry Him off to make Him king, so He went back up into the hills, alone.
Then those men...Jesus did
The people ... therefore. ..he did...
that prophet that should come...] the prophet that cometh... Comp. i. 21, 25, vii. 40. The phrase is peculiar to St John. Yet see Matt. xxi. 11, and Acts vii. 37.
[v. 1 6 — 21.
John 6:14 · Open Word Bible
14The people who had seen the sign He did kept saying, "This really is the Prophet, the one who is coming into the world!"
would...take him by force
Comp. Acts xxiii. 10; (Judg. xxi. 21, LXX.) ; Matt. xi. 12. The multitude wished to use Christ to fulfil their own ends even against His will. In this lies the foreshadowing of the sin of Judas, ch. xviii. 6.
make him a king] make him king.
departed] withdrew .... Comp. Matt. ii. 12 ff., xiv. 13, xv. 21, &c. ; Acts xxiii. 19.
again] It follows (v. 3) that He had descended towards the shore when the miracle took place.
himself alone] to pray, as is added in the parallel narratives (Matt. xiv. 23 ; Mark vi. 46). The dismissal of the apostles mentioned in Matt. xiv. 22 ; Mark vi. 45, is involved in these words (contrast "v. 3). The apostles were first withdrawn from the influence of the multitude, and the mass of the people were then sent away ; but some (T;. 22) still lingered with vain hopes till the morning.
John 6:15 · Open Word Bible
15Jesus realized that they were about to come and carry Him off to make Him king, so He went back up into the hills, alone.
16—21.
The sign upon the lake.
This incident is related also by St Matthew (xiv. 22 ff.) and by St Mark (vi. 45 ff.). The change in time, scene, persons, belongs to the significance of the sign.
John 6:16–21 · Open Word Bible
16At evening His disciples went down to the shore. 17They boarded a boat and were making their way over the sea to Capernaum. Darkness had already fallen, and still Jesus had not come out to them. 18The sea was getting rough, whipped up by a strong wind. …
Comp. Matt. xiv. 22 ff.; Mark vi.
John 6:16 · Open Word Bible
16At evening His disciples went down to the shore.
into a ship
The definite article is omitted in the true text, so that A. V. is correct.
went... toward] Literally, set out on their way to... Comp. iv. 30. This continuous toil is contrasted by the tense with the simple act which preceded it ....
was not yet come...] at the time when they finally started. It appears that some incidents are here omitted. Probably Jesus had directed the apostles to meet Him at some point on the eastern shore on their way to Capernaum.
John 6:17 · Open Word Bible
17They boarded a boat and were making their way over the sea to Capernaum. Darkness had already fallen, and still Jesus had not come out to them.
The singular vividness of the description is to be noticed. ...
John 6:18 · Open Word Bible
18The sea was getting rough, whipped up by a strong wind.
five and twenty...furlongs
The lake is at its broadest about forty stades ("furlongs"), or six miles. Thus they were "m the middle" of the lake (Mark vi. 47), having for a time kept to the shore.
see] behold. The word marks the arrested, absorbed attention of the disciples. Comp. v. 2.
on the sea] The words might mean (as xxi. 1) "on the sea-shore," but the context and parallels determine the sense here. Comp. Job ix. 8 (LXX.).
were afraid] Comp. Matt. xiv. 26 ; Mark vi. 49; Luke xxiv. 37.
John 6:19 · Open Word Bible
19After they had rowed about 3 or 3½ miles, they caught sight of Jesus walking on the sea and getting close to the boat, and fear took hold of them.
It is
Comp. iv. 26, viii. 24, 28, 58, (ix. 9), xiii. 19, xviii. 5, 6, 8; Mark xiii. 6; Luke xxi. 8.
John 6:20 · Open Word Bible
20But He told them, "It is I. Do not be afraid."
willingly received
Literally, they willing to take .... The imperfect in the original expresses a continuous state of feeling as distinguished from an isolated wish. It is commonly used of a desire which is not gratified (vii. 44, xvi. 19; Mark vi. 19, 48; Gal. iv. 20, &c.) but this secondary idea does not necessarily lie in the word. Here the force of the tense is adequately given by A. V., though in Mark vi. 48 the same word is used of the supposed purpose of the Lord to " pass by" the disciples, which was not fulfilled. Comp. Mark xii. 38 ; Luke xii. 46. Fear passed into joy. Compare Luke xxiv. 37 with John xx. 20.
at the land] The original phrase ... may mean in the direction of the land, that is, "moving straight towards the land;" but it more probably means on the land, being used of the vessel run up on the beach. Comp. Ps. cvii. (cvi.) 30. The Synoptists notice that the opposing forces were removed (Matt. xiv. 32 ; Mark vi. 51, the wind ceased ; St John that the desired end was gained. Both results followed at once from the presence of Christ welcomed.
The remarks with which Augustine opens his explanation of the narrative are of permanent value. " Miracula quae fecit Dominus noster Jesus Christus sunt quidem divina opera et ad intellegendum Deum de visibilibus admonent humanam mentem . . . Nec tamen sufficit haec intueri in miraculis Christi. Interrogemus ipsa miracula, quid nobis loquantur de Christo : habent enim si intellegantur linguam suam. Nam quia ipse Christus Verbum Dei est, etiam factum Verbi verbum nobis est" (August. ' in Johann. Tract.' xxiv.
John 6:21 · Open Word Bible
21Now they wanted to take Him into the boat, and right away the boat arrived at the land they were heading for.
The discounts at Capernaum (22—59).
The discourses which followed the feeding of the five thousand serve in part as an answer to the mistaken expectations of the multitude (vv. 14, 15), while they unfold those views of Christ's Person and work which became a decisive trial for the faith of the disciples who were already attached to Him. The short absence had been sufficient to remove the fear of immediate violence on the part of Herod ; though it appears that the Lord withdrew not long afterwards to " the coasts of Tyre and Sidon" (Matt. xv. 21 ff.).
The discourses fall into three groups : vv. 26 — 40, vv. 41 — 51, vv. 52 — 58. Each group is introduced by some expression of feeling on the part of those to whom the words are addressed, a simple question ..., a murmuring (v. 41), a contention among themselves (v. 52). The thoughts successively dealt with are distinct : (1) the search after life, (2) the relation of the Son to God and man, (3) the appropriation by the individual of the Incarnate Son ; and it appears that the audience and place do not remain the same. There are evident breaks after v. 40, and v. 51. The "Jews" are introduced in vv. 41, 52, but not before. The last words were spoken "in synagogue" (v. 59), but it is scarcely conceivable that the conversation began there.
John 6:22–59 · Open Word Bible
22The next day the crowd that had stayed on the other side of the sea saw that there had been only one boat there, and that Jesus had not gone on board with His disciples. The disciples had left by themselves. 23Some boats from Tiberias, however, came in near the place where they had eaten the bread after the Lord gave thanks. 24So when the crowd saw that neither Jesus nor His disciples were there, they got into the boats and went to Capernaum to look for Him. …
the people which stood
the multitude...(and so in v. 24), some, that is, who still lingered when the rest were dismissed (Matt xiv. 23), the more eager zealots, as it seems, who wished still to make Christ fulfil their designs. They were not more than could cross the lake in the boats which came over (v. 23).
John 6:22 · Open Word Bible
22The next day the crowd that had stayed on the other side of the sea saw that there had been only one boat there, and that Jesus had not gone on board with His disciples. The disciples had left by themselves.
Howbeit there came other boats
Omit other .... These boats, perhaps, were driven by the "contrary wind " (Matt. xiv. 24) across the lake. Their coming probably explains the reference to the "disciples" in v. 24. ...
nigh unto the place] that is, to some unfrequented part of the shore, as driven by stress of weather.
the Lord] Comp. iv. 1, xi. 2, xxi. 7.
John 6:23 · Open Word Bible
23Some boats from Tiberias, however, came in near the place where they had eaten the bread after the Lord gave thanks.
they also
they themselves. The force of the word is that they also did what they found the disciples had done.
John 6:24 · Open Word Bible
24So when the crowd saw that neither Jesus nor His disciples were there, they got into the boats and went to Capernaum to look for Him.
when camest
The idea suggested by when, as contrasted with the more natural bow, is that of the separation from Christ ; as if the people had pleaded, " We sought thee long and anxiously on the other side. Could it be that even then thou hadst left us?" If this turn is given to the words the connexion of the answer is obvious: "It is not me ye seek, but my gifts."
John 6:25 · Open Word Bible
25When they found Him on the other side of the sea, they asked Him, "Rabbi, when did You get here?"
26—40.
The first part of the discourses consists of answers to successive questions .... The conversation is natural and rapid ; and deals in succession with the aim of religious effort (26, 27) ; the method (28, 29) ; the assurance (30 — 33) ; the fulfilment (34 — 40).
22 — 24. This long sentence is complicated and irregular in construction. The irregularity is due to the mention of two facts which are intercalated between the beginning and end of the sentence. ...
John 6:26–40 · Open Word Bible
26Jesus answered them, "Truly, truly, I tell you, you are looking for Me, not because you saw signs, but because you ate your fill of the loaves. 27Do not work for food that passes away, but for the food that remains for eternal life, the food the Son of Man will give you. For He is the one God the Father has marked with His seal." 28So they asked Him, "What are we to do, to be doing the works that God asks of us?" …
not because ye saw the miracles
not because ye saw signs..., not because my works of healing and sustaining led you to look for other manifestations of spiritual glory. That one last miracle — a speaking sign — was to you a gross material satisfaction, and not a pledge, a parable of something higher. You failed to see in it the lesson which it was designed to teach, that I am waiting to relieve the hunger of the soul.
were filled] Literally, " were satisfied with food as animals with fodder" .... The original word is different from that used in v. 12. It is however used in connexion with the narrative in the other Gospels (Matt. xiv. 20, and parallels) without any disparaging sense ; and it is not therefore possible to press the material idea which predominates in it (Luke xv. 16, xvi. 21). See Matt. v. 6 ; Luke vi. 21.
John 6:26 · Open Word Bible
26Jesus answered them, "Truly, truly, I tell you, you are looking for Me, not because you saw signs, but because you ate your fill of the loaves.
Labour not for
Work not for... The verb stands emphatically at the head of the sentence. " Work, yea win by work, not..." Thus perhaps there is a contrast between "seeking" and "working." ...
John 6:27 · Open Word Bible
27Do not work for food that passes away, but for the food that remains for eternal life, the food the Son of Man will give you. For He is the one God the Father has marked with His seal."
give
The contrast of these verbs is essential to the sense of the passage. The believer's work does not earn a recompense at the last, but secures a gift. Even common work may bring more than its natural result, "the meat which perisheth." And no work brings more than the possibility of blessings to be used. Comp. i. 12 f., note.
... It is possible too that there may be even at this point a reference to the manna: Exod. xvi. 20.
that (the) meat which endureth (abide th) unto everlasting (eternal) life] that food which suffers no change, but remains in the man as a principle of power issuing in eternal life. Comp. iv. 14.
the Son of man] This title suggests the thought which underlies the whole discourse. Christ is speaking of His relation to men in virtue of His perfect humanity. He, as the absolute representative of mankind, will give this food of the higher life — the life also being His gift, v. 25— for Him the Father (not my Father, v. 32), His Father and the Father of men, sealed, even God (ch. x. 36. See also v. 36 ff.).
shall give] as the issue of His work (v. 5 1) ; or perhaps as the crown of your work of faith in Him.
God the Father] the Father.. .even God. The addition of the divine name at the close of the sentence emphasizes the identification of God with "the Father" of "the Son of man." Comp. viii. 19.
sealed] solemnly set apart for the fulfilment of this charge and authenticated by intelligible signs. Comp. iii. 33, note.
Then said they...What shall we do, that we might
They said therefore. ..What must we do, that we may... ...
John 6:28 · Open Word Bible
28So they asked Him, "What are we to do, to be doing the works that God asks of us?"
The Lord deals with the error and the truth in the question which was put to Him. In the one work which God requires of man and man owes to God, all fragmentary and partial works are included. It is a true work as answering to man's will, but it issues in that which is not a work. ...
John 6:29 · Open Word Bible
29Jesus answered them, "This is the work of God: that you believe in the one He sent."
This simple formula contains the complete solution of the relation of faith and works. Faith is the life of works; works are the I necessity of faith.
What sign shewest thou then
Literally, What then doest thou as a sign... thou, with thy commands to us, peremptory as a second Moses? Christ had charged the questioners with misunderstanding His signs before (v. 26) ; they ask therefore for some clear attestation of His claims. And in this there is nothing inconsistent with the effect which the feeding of the multitude had produced on some. Great as that work was, their history taught them to look for greater. They ask, as in the Synoptists, for "a sign from heaven" (Matt. xvi. 1).
that we may see, and believe thee] In these 1 words faith is reduced to simple belief in the truth of a message, and grounded upon the testimony of the senses. The " believing on Christ" (v. 29) is reduced to "believing Christ." Comp. viii. 30, 31, note.
what dost thou work?] The words take up the demand made on themselves. There is a work, they plead, for the teacher as well as for the hearer. The question expresses what was suggested by the emphatic pronoun (thou) just before. Words must be justified by works.
John 6:30 · Open Word Bible
30So they said to Him, "Then what sign will You perform for us to see, so that we will believe You? What work are You doing?
did eat manna
the manna [Ps. lxxvii. (lxxviii.) 24]. The miracle which Christ had wrought suggested the greater miracle of Moses, by which the people were sustained for forty years. There was a tradition (' Midrash Koheleth,' p. 73, quoted by Lightfoot and Wünsche) that "as the first Redeemer caused the manna to fall from heaven, even so should the second Redeemer ... cause the manna to fall." For this sign then, or one like this, the people looked from Him whom they were ready to regard as Messiah. Compare Matt. xvi. 1 ; Mark viii. 11. The manna was a favourite subject with Jewish expositors. A single passage from Philo ... may serve as an example of their interpretations : " [When the people] sought what it is which feeds the soul, for they did not, as Moses says, know what it was, they discovered by learning that it is the utterance ... of God and the divine word ... from which all forms of instruction and wisdom flow in a perennial stream. And this is the heavenly food which is indicated in the sacred records under the Person of the First Cause ... saying, Behold I rain on you bread ... out of heaven (Exod. xvi. 4). For in very truth God distils from above the supernal wisdom on noble and contemplative minds ; and they when they see and taste, in great joy, know what they experience, but do not know the Power which dispenses the gift. Wherefore they ask, What is this which is sweeter than honey and whiter than snow ? But they shall be taught by the prophet that this is the bread which the Lord gave them to eat " (Exod. xvi. 15). Comp. Siegfried, ' Philo v. Alex.' s. 229.
from heaven] out of heaven (and so throughout), which came out of the heavenly treasures, and did not simply descend from a higher region.
John 6:31 · Open Word Bible
31Our ancestors ate the manna in the wilderness; as it is written, 'He gave them bread from heaven to eat.'"
Then Jesus
Jesus therefore... Moses gave... not that (the) bread] There is a double contrast. It was not Moses but God revealing Himself through Moses who gave the manna ; and again the manna — the perishable bread — was not in the highest sense " bread from heaven," but rather the symbol of spiritual food.
gave you] The people are identified with their ancestors. ...
John 6:32 · Open Word Bible
32Jesus told them, "Truly, truly, I tell you, Moses was not the one who gave you the bread from heaven; My Father is the one who gives you the true bread from heaven.
but my Father giveth
not in one miraculous act only, but now and at all times.
the true bread] that which fulfils absolutely, ideally, the highest conception of sustaining food .... Comp. iv. 23, note. The exact form of the original is emphatic : the bread out of heaven, the true bread ....
the bread of God
the bread which God gives directly ; not simply that which He gives by the hand of His servants. Comp. i. 29 (the Lamb of God), note.
he which cometh down..] that which cometh down... Christ does not identify Himself with "the bread" till the next answer; and the request of the Jews which follows shews that nothing more than the notion of heavenly bread was present to them (comp. vv. 41, 50). This new manna was distinguished from the old in that it was continuous in its descent and not for a time ; and again it was not confined to one people, but was for the world.
cometh down] The phrase prepares the way for the interpretation which follows, vv. 38, 41.
unto the 'world'] Without the Word, without Christ, the world can have no life. He makes the blessing, which was national, universal.
John 6:33 · Open Word Bible
33For the bread of God is the one that comes down from heaven and gives life to the world."
Then said they
They said therefore... The Jews see in the words of Christ a mysterious promise which they cannot understand ; but they interpret it according to their material hopes. Lord, evermore, not on one rare occasion but always, give us this bread. They acknowledge that the gift must be constant (1 Thess. v. 15, Trajrore), though its effects are lasting.
John 6:34 · Open Word Bible
34Then they said to Him, "Sir, give us this bread all the time."
Jesus said
said...] The Jews asked for something from Christ: He offers them Himself. The great gift, if only it were rightly perceived, was already made.
I am the...] This form of expression is not found in the Synoptists. It occurs not unfrequently in St John's Gospel, and the figures with which it is connected furnish a complete study of the Lord's work. Compare vv. 41, 48, 51, viii. 12 (the Light of the world), x. 7, 9 (the Door), x. 11, 14 (the good Shepherd), xi. 25 (the Resurrection and the Life), xiv. 6 (the Way, the Truth, and the Life), xv. 1, 5 (the true Vine).
the bread of life] the food which supplies life: of which life is not a quality only (v. 51, the living bread), but (so to speak) an endowment which it is capable of communicating. Compare the tree of life (Gen. ii. 9, iii. 22, 24; Prov. iii. 18, xi. 30, xiii. 12, xv. 4; Rev. ii. 7, xxii. 2, &c.) ; the water of life (Rev. xxi. 6, xxii. 1, &c. Comp. Ps. xxxvi. (xxxv.) 9; Prov. x. 11, xiii. 14, xiv. 27, xvi. 22, fountain of life). The phrases " words (distinct utterances, sayings, p^/iara) of life" (v. 68), and "the word (the whole revelation, Xoyos) of life " (1 John i. 1) are nearly connected.
cometh.. .believeth] The. first word presents faith in deed as active and outward ; the second presents faith in thought as resting and inward. Each element is, it is true, implied in the other, but they can be contemplated apart. For coming to me see v. 40, vv. (37), 44 f., 65, vii. 37.
John 6:35 · Open Word Bible
35Jesus said to them, "I am the bread of life. Those who come to Me will never be hungry, and those who believe in Me will never at any time be thirsty.
shall never hunger...shall never thirst
The double image, suggested it may be by the thought of the Passover, extends the conception of the heavenly food, and prepares the way for the double form under which it is finally described (v. 53). The gift of strength corresponds with the effort to reach to Christ ; the gift of joy with the idea of repose in Christ.
... Contrast iv. 14, ov fif/ Sct/rijcrft fls TOV al<a>vd). Perhaps it suggests the image of Christ present in all time and regarding the unfailing satisfaction of those who come to Him, as distinguished from a simple future.
But
The gift was indeed made, but the presence of the gift was unavailing, for the condition required of those who should receive it was unfulfilled.
I said unto you...] The thought is contained in v. 26, and the reference may be to those words ; but more probably the reference is to other words like them spoken at some earlier time.
That ye (omit also) have seen me, and. . .] The first conjunction ... emphasizes the fact : that ye have indeed seen and... Comp. ix. 37. The Lord returns to the words in i;. 30 (see, believe), now that the question in v. 34 has been answered. He Himself was the sign which the Jews could not read. No other more convincing could be given.
John 6:36 · Open Word Bible
36But I said it already: you have seen Me, yet you do not believe.
There is a pause in the discourse before this verse. The unbelief of the people was not a proof that the purpose of God had failed. Rather it gave occasion for declaring more fully how certainly the Son carried out the Fathers will.
All that (All that which) the Father... him that cometh...] The first clause is a general and abstract statement ... ; the second gives the concrete and individual realisation of it .... Believers are first regarded as forming a whole complete in its several parts, a gift of the Father ; and then each separate believer is regarded in his personal relation to the Son. In the first case stress is laid upon the successful issue of the coming, the arrival ...; in the second case on the process of the coming ... and the welcome.
The same contrast between the abstract conception and the concrete fulfilment of it is found in vv. 39 f. and xvii. 2. Compare also the use of the abstract form, 1 John v. 4 contrasted with v. 5, 18 ; and ch. iii. 6 contrasted with iii. 8.
giveth] Compare xvii. 2, 6, 9, 12, 24, xviii. 9.
I will in no wise. . .] The stern words to the Galilaeans might have seemed to be a casting out, but the Lord shews that, on the contrary, they were not truly coming to Him.
John 6:37 · Open Word Bible
37Everyone the Father gives Me will come to Me, and I will never send away anyone who comes to Me.
For
For this is the Father's will, as is implied in the gift (v. 39), and I am come down...
I came down] lam come down. Comp. iii. 13 ; (Eph. iv. 9 f. ?). With these exceptions the word is used of Christ's descent only in this discourse.
from heaven] In this verse the original preposition (according to the true reading) expresses the idea of leaving (ano), in v. 42 (as iii. 13) of proceeding out of .... In the one case the thought is that of sacrifice; in the other that of divinity.
John 6:38 · Open Word Bible
38For I have come down from heaven not to carry out My own will, but the will of the one who sent Me.
this is the Father’s will which hath
According to the true reading, this is the will of him that...
that of all...] The construction in the original is broken : " that as for all that which he has given me I should not lose of /V..." Comp. vii. 38, (1 John ii. 24, 27), Luke xxi. 6.
hath given] The present used in v. 37 (giveth) is here changed into the past when the gift is looked at in relation to the will of the Father, and not to the waiting of the Son.
should lose nothing, but should raise it up] filled with a new life, transfigured and glorified. This is the issue of the communication of Christ to the Church. In this place the effect is represented as dependent on the Father's will ; but when the words are repeated (vv. 40, 44, 54) — once in each great division of the discourses — the effect is referred to the will of the Son (and I twill raise him up).
at the last day] The phrase is found only in St John, vv. 40, 44, 54, xi. 24, xii. 48. Comp. 1 John ii. 18. The plural occurs Acts ii. 17 ; James v. 3 ; 2 Tim. iii. 1.
John 6:39 · Open Word Bible
39And the will of the one who sent Me is this: that I should lose nothing of all that He has given Me, but raise it all up on the last day.
And...the will of him that sent me, that
TOT. ..the will of my Father, that... The general fulfilment of the will of the Father passes into this further truth, that the contemplation of the Son and belief on Him brings with it eternal life.
seeth (beholdeth) the Son] Comp. xii. 45, xiv. 19, xvi. 10, 16, 19. The act of contemplation and faith is not momentary or past, but continuous.
have everlasting (eternal) life] not as future, but as present already as a divine power. Comp. v. 47, xvii. 3.
The possession of eternal life is followed by the crowning action of the Son: and I — I the Incarnate Son — will raise him up. Eternal life is consummated in the restoration to the believer of a transfigured manhood. So far from the doctrine of the Resurrection being, as has been asserted, inconsistent with St John's teaching on the present reality of eternal life, it would be rather true to say that this doctrine makes the necessity of the Resurrection obvious. He who feels that life is now, must feel that after death all that belongs to the essence of its present perfection must be restored, however much ennobled under new conditions of manifestation.
John 6:40 · Open Word Bible
40For what My Father wills is this: everyone who sees the Son and believes in Him will have eternal life, and I Myself will raise them up on the last day."
This verse seems to mark the presence of new persons and a new scene, as well as a new stage in the history. The verses 37 — 40 were probably addressed specially to the immediate circle of the disciples. Thus we can understand how the Jews dwelt on the words in which Christ identified Himself with the true spiritual food of the world, while they took no notice of the loftier prerogatives which followed from this truth, since the exposition of these was not directed to them.
The Jews then] The Jews therefore..., the representatives of the dominant religious party, full of the teaching of the schools.
murmured at (concerning) him] half in doubt (vii. 32, [12]) and half in dissatisfaction (v. 61 ; Luke v. 30). These murmurings probably found expression for some little time before they were answered. . There is nothing to shew that they were first uttered in Christ's presence.
John 6:41 · Open Word Bible
41Then the Jews started grumbling about Him, because He had claimed, "I am the bread that came down from heaven."
Is not this
There is perhaps a tinge of contemptuous surprise in the pronoun ... as in v. 52, vii. 15, iii. 26, though it does not necessarily lie in the word, iv. 14, ix. 33, &c.
the son of Joseph] ch. i. 46. Comp. Luke iv. 22.
how is it then that he saith] how doth he now say — now, at last, when for so long he has lived as one of ourselves ?
I came down (am come down) from heaven] See v. 38, note.
John 6:42 · Open Word Bible
42They kept saying, "Surely this is Jesus, the son of Joseph? We know His father and mother. So what does He mean by saying now, 'I have come down from heaven'?"
Jesus therefore answered
Jesus answered... The answer corresponds in some way with that given to Nicodemus (iii. 3). The false claim to knowledge, and the assertion of unsubstantial objections, are both met in the same manner. The Jews were unable to understand the divine descent of the Lord, which seemed irreconcileable with His actual circumstances. He replies that a spiritual influence is necessary before His true Nature can be discerned, and that such influence was promised by the prophets as one of the characteristic blessings of the Messianic age.
John 6:43 · Open Word Bible
43Jesus answered them, "Stop your grumbling to one another.
No man can...draw him
Compare v. 40, ye will not come to me. As in all similar cases this "coming to Christ" may be regarded from its human side, as dependent on man's will ; or from its divine side, as dependent on the power of God. So St Bernard remarks in connexion with these words : "nemo quippe salvatur invitus" (' De grat.et lib. act.' XI.). Yet even the will itself comes from a divine nature, a divine gift .... The " drawing" of the Father is best illustrated by the " drawing " of the Son, xii. 32. The constraining principle is love stirred by self-sacrifice, a love which calls out, and does not destroy, man's freedom and issues in self-sacrifice. The mission of the Son by the Father (which sent [omit hath'] me), the sovereign act of love (iii. 16), is thus brought into close connexion with the power exerted by the Father on men. Augustine ... puts the thought most forcibly: " 'Trahit sua quemque voluptas;' non trahit revelatus Christus a Patre ? Quid enim fortius desiderat anima quam veritatem?" ...
John 6:44 · Open Word Bible
44Nobody can come to Me unless the Father who sent Me draws them. And on the last day I will raise them up.
No man can come
This divine impossibility is the expression of a moral law. It is not anything arbitrary, but inherent in the very nature of things ; it does not limit but it defines the nature of human power. Comp. v. 19 (note), 30 (of the Son), xii. 39, note.
come] Here and in v. 65 the "coming" ... is regarded as complete, and not in progress as in f. 37, vii. 37 ....
and I. ..] The Son takes up and completes what the Father has begun. The change in the position of the pronoun slightly modifies the force of this repeated clause. In v. 40 the believer and Christ are placed in remarkable juxta-position ... ; here the I stands first with a reference to the whole preceding clause ....
The " drawing " of the Father is illustrated by a prophetic promise. And under this new image of " teaching " the power is seen in its twofold aspect; the divine and human elements are combined. The " hearing " brings out the external communication, the learning the internal understanding of it. " Videte quomodo trahit Pater: docendo delectat, non necessitatem imponendo" ....
in the prophets] i.e. in the division of the Scriptures which is so called. Compare Acts xiii. 40, vii. 42 (the book of the prophets)', ch. i. 45, note. The phrase is found substantially in Isai. liv. 13 ; and the central idea of it is the promise of direct divine teaching. Thus the emphasis lies on "taught of God" and not on " all." This teaching lies for us in the Person and Work of Christ interpreted by the Spirit taught of God ...~\ Comp. 1 Cor. ii. 13 ; 1 Thess. iv. 9 .... The phrase describes not only one divine communication, but a divine relationship. ...
Every man therefore that hath heard, and hath learned of the Father ...] Every one that heareth from the Father and learneth ...... The fulfilment of the promise is followed by its proper consequence. The "hearing" and " learning " are presented as single events corresponding to a definite voice and revelation. The call is obeyed at once, though it may be fulfilled gradually ; the fact of the revelation is grasped at once, though it may be apprehended in detail little by little.
from the Father] the message which comes from the Father .... Compare i. 40, vii. 51, viii. 26, 40, xv. 15.
John 6:45 · Open Word Bible
45In the Prophets it is written, 'They will all be taught by God.' Everyone who has heard the Father's teaching and learned it comes to Me.
But though the revelation made by the Father is direct in one sense, yet it must not be understood to be immediate. " Hearing" and "learning" fall short of seeing. The Father is seen only by the Son (i. 18. Comp. Matt. xi. 27, and parallels). He alone who is truly God can naturally see God. The voice of God came to men under the old Covenant, but in Christ the believer can now see the Father (xiv. 9) in part, and will hereafter see God as He is (1 John iii. 2).
he which is of (from, irapa)...] Comp. vii. 29, ix. 1 6, 33. The phrase implies not only mission (xvi. 27 f., came forth from), but also a present relation of close dependence.
be hath seen] when He was "with God" (i. 1) before He "became flesh." The words mark emphatically the unchanged personality of Christ before and after the Incarnation. The substitution God for the Father in some early texts (N*D) is a kind of gloss which is not unfrequent in the group.
John 6:46 · Open Word Bible
46This does not mean that anyone has seen the Father. Only the one who has come from God has seen Him.
At this point the discourse takes a fresh start. The objection of the Jews has been met, and the Lord goes on to develope the idea set forth in vv. 35, 36, taking up the last word : He that believeth (omit en me, the phrase stands absolutely) hath eternal life. The actual existence of true faith implies the right object of it. Comp. c. 111. 3, note.
hath] See v. 40, note.
John 6:47 · Open Word Bible
47Truly, truly, I tell you, anyone who believes has eternal life.
48—51.
There is a close parallelism and contrast between vv. 48 — 50 and 51. The bread of life : the living bread — which comet h down . . . that. . . : which came down ; if... may . . . not die: shall live for ever. In the first case the result is given as part of the divine counsel (that cometh down, that [<W]...); in the second as a simple historical consequence (came down. ..if a man...).
John 6:48–51 · Open Word Bible
48I am the bread of life. 49Your ancestors ate the manna in the wilderness, and yet they died. 50Here, by contrast, is bread coming down from heaven: whoever eats it will not die. …
that bread of life
See v. 35, note.
John 6:48 · Open Word Bible
48I am the bread of life.
Your fathers did eat manna...and are dead
The words are quoted from the argument of the Jews, v. 31. The heavenly food under the old Dispensation could not avert death. ...
John 6:49 · Open Word Bible
49Your ancestors ate the manna in the wilderness, and yet they died.
This is the bread which cometh...that
This bread — the true manna — is the bread which cometh.. .that... It is best to take this [bread] as the subject (v. 48, I am the bread of life, further defined in v. 51), and the bread which cometh down from heaven as the predicate; compare vv. 33, 58. The interpretation which makes this the predicate (the bread which cometh... is this, that is, is of such a nature, that...) appears to destroy the connexion.
not die] Comp. viii. 51, note.
John 6:50 · Open Word Bible
50Here, by contrast, is bread coming down from heaven: whoever eats it will not die.
am the living bread
able to communicate the life which I possess. He therefore who receives me receives a principle of life.
eat of this bread] Some ancient authorities read eat of my bread.
and the bread...] yea and (and in fact) the bread ...... Comp. viii. 16 f., xv. 27 ; 1 John i. 3.
the bread... which I ... will give] The pronoun is emphatic, and brings out the contrast between Christ and Moses. At the same time a passage is made from the thought of Christ as the living bread (7 am.. ) to the thought of the participation in Him .... This participation is spoken of as still future, since it followed in its fulness on the completed work of Christ. There is also a difference indicated here between that which Christ is and that which He offers. He is truly God and truly man ... ; He offers His "flesh," His perfect humanity, for the life of the world.
my flesh] " Flesh " describes human nature in its totality regarded from its earthly side. Comp. i. 14. See also i. 13, iii. 6, vi. 63, viii. 15, xvii. 2 ; 1 John ii. 16, iv. 2 ; 2 John 7 ; Rom. viii. 3 ; 1 Tim. iii. 16 ; Hebr. v. 7. The thought of death lies already in the word, but that thought is not as yet brought out, as afterwards by the addition of blood. Comp. Eph. ii. 14 ff. ; Col. i. 22 ; 1 Pet. iii. 18.
John 6:51 · Open Word Bible
51I am the living bread, come down from heaven. If anyone eats this bread, they will live forever. The bread I will give is My flesh, and I give it so that the world may have life."
The life of the world in the highest sense springs from the Incarnation and Resurrection of Christ. By His Incarnation and Resurrection the ruin and death which sin brought in are overcome. The thought here is of support and growth, and not of atonement (I lay down my life for.., x. 11, 15, note). The close of the earthly life, the end of the life which is, in one aspect, of self for self, opens wider relations of life. Comp. xii. 24. At this point no more than the general truth is stated. It is not yet indicated how the " flesh" of Christ, the virtue of His humanity, will be communicated to and made effectual for mankind or men. That part of the subject is developed in the last division of the whole argument.
my flesh, which I will give for the life...] The true text gives simply my flesh for the life... For this shortened form compare 1 Cor. xi. 24. The omission of the clause which I will give turns the attention to the general action of Christ's gift rather than to the actual making of it. The special reference to the future Passion would distract the thought at this point, where it is concentrated upon the Incarnation and its consequences generally. See Additional Note.
52—59.
This last section of the teaching on " the true bread from heaven " carries forward the conceptions given in vv. 41 — 51 to a new result. The question before was as to the Person of the Lord : "Is not this the son of Joseph ? " The question now is as to the communication of that which He gives : " How can this man give us his flesh to eat ? " How can one truly man impart to others his humanity, so that they may take it to themselves and assimilate it ? The answer is in this case also not direct but by implication. The fact, and the necessity of the fact, dispense with the need for further inquiry. The life is a reality.
John 6:52–59 · Open Word Bible
52At this the Jews began to quarrel fiercely among themselves. "How can He give us His flesh to eat?" they said. 53Jesus answered them, "Truly, truly, I tell you, if you do not eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood, there is no life in you. 54Anyone who eats My flesh and drinks My blood has eternal life, and on the last day I will raise them up. …
The Jews...strove among themselves
... There were divisions among them ; and they discussed from opposite sides the problem raised by the last mysterious words which they had heard (comp. vii. 12, 40 ff., x. 19 ff.). It is important to notice how the Evangelist records the varying phases of contemporary feeling. " The Jews " were not yet all of one mind.
How can...] The old question (iii. 4, 9), which is again left without an explicit answer. The simple reassertion of the fact is opposed both in a negative (v. 53) and in a positive statement to the difficulty as to the manner.
John 6:52 · Open Word Bible
52At this the Jews began to quarrel fiercely among themselves. "How can He give us His flesh to eat?" they said.
The thought indicated in v. 51 is now developed in detail. The " flesh " is presented in its twofold aspect as " flesh " and " blood," and by this separation of its parts the idea of a violent death is presupposed. Further "the flesh " and " the blood " are described as " the flesh " and " the blood" " of the Son of man," by which title the representative character of Christ is marked in regard to that humanity which He imparts to the believer. And once again both elements are to be appropriated individually ("eat," "drink"). By the "flesh" in this narrower sense we must understand the virtue of Christ's humanity as living for us ; by the " blood " the virtue of His humanity as subject to death. The believer must be made partaker in both. The Son of man lived for us and died for us, and communicates to us the effects of His life and death as perfect man. Without this communication of Christ men can have " no life in themselves." But Christ's gift of Himself to a man becomes in the recipient a spring of life within. Comp. iv. 14.
Then Jesus said... ,] Jesus therefore said.,. meeting the difficulty which was raised by an appeal to what is really a fact of experience.
eat. ..drink] To "eat" and to "drink" is to take to oneself by a voluntary act that which is without, and then to assimilate it and make it part of oneself. It is, as it were, faith regarded in its converse action. Faith throws the believer upon and into its object ; this spiritual eating and drinking brings the object of faith into the believer.
John 6:53 · Open Word Bible
53Jesus answered them, "Truly, truly, I tell you, if you do not eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood, there is no life in you.
in you
Literally, in yourselves. Compare v. 26 ; Matt. xiii. 21. Without the Son men have no life ; for in men themselves there is no spring of life. Even to the last their life is " in Christ" and not " in themselves."
Whoso eateth
The verb used here ... expresses not only the simple fact of eating but the process as that which is dwelt upon with pleasure (Matt. xxiv. 38. Comp. ch. xiii. 18). ...
John 6:54 · Open Word Bible
54Anyone who eats My flesh and drinks My blood has eternal life, and on the last day I will raise them up.
For my flesh
The possession and the highest manifestation of life follow necessarily from participation in Christ's " flesh " and " blood :" such is their power.
it meat indeed...] My flesh is true ... meat... It stands in the same relation to man's whole being, as food does to his physical being. It must first be taken, and then it must be assimilated.
John 6:55 · Open Word Bible
55For My flesh is genuine food, and My blood is genuine drink.
The truth of v. 54 is traced to its necessary foundation. In virtue of Christ's impartment of His humanity to the believer, the believer may rightly be said to " abide in Christ " and Christ to " abide in the believer." The believer has therefore "eternal life," and in that, the certainty of a resurrection, a restoration in glory of the fulness of his present powers.
dwelleth] abideth, as the word is commonly rendered. So also xiv. 10, 17 ; 1 John iii. 17, 24, iv. 12, 13, 15, 16. The word is singularly frequent in St John (Gospel, Epistles), and the phrases "abide in {Christ"] " and the like are peculiar to him (yet compare 1 Tim. ii. 15 ; 2 Tim. iii. 14).
in me, and I in him...] There is, so to speak, a double personality. The believer is quickened by Christ's presence, and he is himself incorporated in Christ. Compare xv. 4, xvii. 23 ; 1 John iii. 24, iv. 15 f. This twofold aspect of the divine connexion is illustrated by the two great images of the " body" and the " temple." " Manemus in illo cum sumus membra eius: manet autem ipse in nobis cum sumus templum eius" ....
Some early authorities (D, &c.) add a remarkable gloss at the end of the verse: even as the Father is in me and I in the Father. Verily, verily, I say unto you, unless ye receive ... the body of the Son of man as the bread of life ye have not life in him.
John 6:56 · Open Word Bible
56Anyone who eats My flesh and drinks My blood remains in Me, and I remain in them.
As...so
The same combination occurs xiii. 15 ; 1 John ii. 6, iv. 17.
the living Father] The title is unique. Compare the phrase the living God, Matt. xvi. 16; 2 Cor vi. 16; Hebr. vii. 25, &c.
hath sent me (sent me)] The introduction of these words marks the fact that Christ speaks of His vital fellowship with the Father not as the Word only, but as the Son Incarnate, the Son of man. Comp. v. 23. And thus the acceptance of the divine mission by the Son, and His dependence in His humanity on the Father, are placed in some sense in correlation with the appropriation of the Incarnate Son (he that eateth me) by the Christian ; so that the relation of the believer to Christ is prefigured in the relation of the Son to the Father. Compare x. 14, 15, note.
... Complete devotion to the Father is the essence of the life of the Son ; and so complete devotion to the Son is the life of the believer. It seems better to give this full sense to the word than to take it as equivalent to by reason of; that is, " I live because the Father lives."
the Father] not "my Father." Emphasis is laid upon the universal relationship. Comp. iv. 21, note.
he that eateth me] In this phrase we reach the climax of the revelation. ...
John 6:57 · Open Word Bible
57The living Father sent Me, and I live because of Him; in the same way, anyone who feeds on Me will live because of Me.
even he
he also. The insertion of the emphatic pronoun ... immediately after the subject, which it repeats and emphasizes, is most remarkable. It appears to lay stress upon that relation of dependence which constitutes the parallel between the disciples and the Son. Compare xiv. 12.
shall live] not I'meth. The fulness of the life was consequent upon the exaltation of Christ. Comp. xiv. 19.
These concluding words carry back the discourse to its commencement (vv. 33, 35). The fulfilment of the type of the manna in Christ, after it has been set forth in its complete form, is placed in direct connexion with the earlier event.
This is that (the) bread which came...] This bread, this heavenly food, which has been shewn to be Christ Himself, and His " flesh " (o. 51), is the bread which came... Contrast v. 50 : This is the bread which cometh.... Both aspects of Christ's work must be kept in mind. He came, and He comes.
not as your fathers did eat manna, and are dead] not as the fathers did eat and died. The construction is irregular. Naturally the sentence would have run : This is the bread. . .heaven : he that eateth this bread. . . , but the parenthetical clause expresses in a condensed form the contrast between the true and the typical manna. "The fact and the issue of the fact is not as the fathers ate and died." ... The reference to the "death" of "the generation in the wilderness" would have a fuller meaning if the tradition were already current that this generation "had no part in the world to come" (quoted by Lightfoot on v. 39).
the fathers] This title, as distinguished from the common text your 'fathers , recognises the representative position which the early generation occupied.
John 6:58 · Open Word Bible
58This, then, is the bread that came down from heaven. It is not like the food the ancestors ate, for they died; anyone who eats this bread will live forever."
fathers...he that eateth
There appears to be significance in the passage from the plural to the singular. Throughout the discourses the believer is dealt with as exercising personal faith and not only as one of a society. ... The construction in vv. 26, 50, 51, is different ( ....
in the synagogue
This is the only notice of the kind in St John's Gospel, though the general custom is referred to, xviii. 20; The absence of the definite article in the original here and in xviii. 20, which leads to a form of expression ... not found elsewhere in the New Testament, seems to mark the character of the assemblage rather than the place itself: "when people were gathered for worship," "in time of solemn assembly " (comp. i Mace. xiv. 28). It is a fact of great interest that among the ruins which mark the probable site of Capernaum ... are the remains of a handsome synagogue, of which Wilson says : "On turning over a large block [of stone] we found the pot of manna engraved on its face" .... This very symbol may have been before the eyes of those who heard the Lord's words. It may be added that the history of the manna (Exod. xvi. 4 — 36) is appointed to be read in the Synagogues at morning service.
as he taught] The phrase gives a marked emphasis to the words which have gone before.
The crisis corresponds in character with that at Nazareth, Luke iv. 16 ff. Comp. Matt. xi. 23. Some early authorities add, what may be a true traditional gloss, " on a sabbath."
John 6:59 · Open Word Bible
59All this He said as He taught in the synagogue in Capernaum.
The Issue (60—71).
The discourses proved a trial to the faith of the disciples. The immediate effect was a " murmuring " among them which led to a clear affirmation of the divine conditions of discipleship (60 — 6.5). ...
John 6:60–71 · Open Word Bible
60When they heard this, many of His disciples said, "This message is harsh. Who can bear to listen to it?" 61Jesus was aware that His disciples were grumbling about this, so He said to them, "Does this make you stumble? 62Then what if you were to see the Son of Man going up to where He was before? …
Many therefore
not only of the misunderstanding multitude (28 ff.) and of the ill-disposed Jews (41 ff.), but of the disciples (v. 3) who had hitherto followed Him, when they heard (omit had) this, found the new teaching of life through death a burden too heavy to be borne.
hard saying] that is, difficult to receive, accept, appropriate. The idea is not that of obscurity. The discourse was offensive, and not unintelligible. It made claims on the complete submission, self-devotion, self-surrender of the disciples. It pointed significantly to death. The same word ... occurs Jude 15, in a somewhat similar connexion. Compare Gen. xxi. 11, xlii. 7 ; 1 K. xii. 13 (LXX.).
saying] or rather, speech, discourse (Xoyos, Vulg. sermo). The English representative of the original ('word) is not sufficiently elastic to give its sense in all cases.
bear it] Listen to it ... with patience, as ready to admit it. See vii. 40, x. 3, 16, 27, xii. 47, xviii. 37. The pronoun ... may be taken as personal : who can bear him ? but this is an unlikely rendering.
John 6:60 · Open Word Bible
60When they heard this, many of His disciples said, "This message is harsh. Who can bear to listen to it?"
When Jesus knew in himself
But when Jesus... See ii. 24, note.
murmured] Compare v. 41, note. offend you] Compare xvi. 1, note.
John 6:61 · Open Word Bible
61Jesus was aware that His disciples were grumbling about this, so He said to them, "Does this make you stumble?
What and if ye shall see
What then if ye should behold... This incomplete question, which seems to leave open in some measure the alternatives of greater offence and possible victory, has been interpreted in two very different ways, by supplying in one case a negative answer : " Ye will not then be offended any more; " and in the other a positive: " Ye will then assuredly be still more offended." According to the first interpretation the " ascending up " is the Ascension as the final spiritualizing of the Lord's Person, whereby the offence of the language as to His flesh would be removed by the apprehension of the truth as to His spiritual humanity. In the second the " ascending up " is referred to the "elevation" on the Cross, and the offence caused by the reference to the death of Christ is regarded as increased by the death itself in its actual circumstances. Each of these two interpretations appears to contain elements of the full meaning. The whole context shews ! distinctly that the disciples were to be subjected to some severer trial. The turn of the sentence therefore must be : " If then ye see the Son of man ascending. . .ye will be, according to your present state, more grievously offended; for that trial you must still be disciplined." But, on the other hand, the Crucifixion alone could not be described as an "ascending up where Christ was before;" yet it was the first part of the Ascension, the absolute sacrifice of self which issued in the absolute triumph over the limitations of earthly existence. The Passion, the Resurrection, the Ascension, were steps in the progress of the "ascending up" through suffering, which is the great offence of the Gospel. The difficulty of accepting this completed fact is (though greater) of the same kind as the difficulty of accepting life only through the communicated humanity of the Incarnate Son.
John 6:62 · Open Word Bible
62Then what if you were to see the Son of Man going up to where He was before?
the Son of man ascend up where he was before
Compare viii. 58, xvii. 5, 24; Col. i. 17. No phrase could shew more clearly the unchanged personality of Christ. As " the Son of man " He speaks of His being in heaven before the Incarnation. " Filius Dei et filius hominis unus Christus... Filius Dei in terra suscepta carne, filius hominis in caelo in unitate personae" (Aug. ad loc.).
the spirit...the flesh
The same contrast occurs in iii. 6 (see note), 1 Pet. iii. 18. lust as in man the spirit is that part of his nature by which he holds fellowship with the unseen eternal order, and the flesh that part of it by which he holds fellowship with the seen temporal order, so the two words are applied to the working of Christ. Nothing can carry us beyond the limits of its own realm. The new life must come from that which belongs properly to the sphere in which it moves. Compare 1 Cor. xv. 45, (2 Cor. iii. 6). ...
John 6:63 · Open Word Bible
63The Spirit is the one who gives life; the flesh is of no benefit at all. The words I have spoken to you are spirit, and they are life.
the words
Here the definite utterances ... and not the whole revelation .... The reference is to the clear unfolding of the complete relation of man and humanity to the Incarnate Saviour. Hence a marked emphasis is laid on the pronoun I: the words that I and no prophet, not even Moses (v. 32) before me ; and on the tense : the words that I have spoken ..., and not generally speak, though in some sense all Christ's words are life-giving, as conveying something of this central truth.
For the exact sense of "the words" ... see iii. 34, viii. 47, xvii. 8.
are spirit, and they are life] that is, belong essentially to the region of eternal being, and so are capable of conveying that which they essentially are. Compare v. 68.
But
even so, in the closest circle of my disciples there are some to whom they convey no vivifying influence, because the human condition is unfulfilled : there are of you ... some who believe not. For the order compare v. 70 (of you one).
For Jesus knew] Compare ii. 24, note.
from the beginning] Compare xvi. 4, (xv. 27). From the first moment when the public work of Christ began (1 John ii. 7, 24, iii. 11 ; Luke i. 2). The phrase must always be relative to the point present to the mind of the writer or speaker ; and here that seems to be fixed by v. 70.
who should (who it was that should) betray him] This first allusion to the sin of Judas evidently stands in a significant connexion with the first unveiling of the Lord's Passion. The word rendered betray ... means strictly deliver up, to give into the hands of another to deal with as he pleases (ch. xviii. 30, 35 f., xix. 16 ; Matt. v. 25, &c.). The title of " traitor " is only once applied to Judas in the New Testament: Luke vi. 16 .... In other words his act is regarded in relation to the Lord's Passion, and not to his sin.
John 6:64 · Open Word Bible
64Yet some among you do not believe." For Jesus had known from the start who the ones were that did not believe, and who would be the one to betray Him.
Therefore said
For this cause have I said... The divine condition of discipleship was clearly stated, because the disciples would have to bear the trial of treachery revealed in their midst, which might seem to be inconsistent with Christ's claims, and with what they thought that they had found in Him. His choice even of Judas was not made without full knowledge (xiii. 18).
come unto me] Judas then, though "chosen out " (v. 70) and called, had not come to Christ (v. 37). He remained still in himself; and now at this crisis he can keep silence.
were given unto him of my Father] have been (or be) given unto him of the Father. Comp. iii. 27. There is a sense in which all life is the unfolding of the timeless divine will. The Father (not my Father) here is looked upon as the source ... from whom all flows. Comp. x. 32 ; 1 Cor. vii. 7 ; (2 Cor. ii. 2). It must be noticed likewise how here the divine and human elements are placed in close juxtaposition, given, come. The mystery must be left with the assertion of both the concurrent parts, the will of God and the will of man.
John 6:65 · Open Word Bible
65And He added, "This is the reason I told you that no one is able to come to Me unless it has been given to them by the Father."
From that time
Upon this (compare xix. 12), with the notion of dependence on what had now happened. The phrase is not simply temporal (ch. ix. 1 ; Luke x. 20 ; Acts ix. 33, xxiv. 10, xxvi. 4), nor simply causal (Rom. i. 4 ; Rev. xvi. 21, viii. 13).
walked no more (with him] Compare vii. 1, xi. 54. The phrase gives a vivid portraiture of the Lord's life.
John 6:66 · Open Word Bible
66At this, many of His disciples drew back and stopped going about with Him.
Then said Jesus
Jesus therefore said... The test had been applied to the mass, and it was now necessarily applied to the innermost circle of disciples.
the twelve] These are spoken of as known, though they have not been mentioned before.
• Matt. 16.
The number is implied in v. 13. In the earlier part of the record ... no such chosen company is noticed, a fact which is a slight sign of the distinctness with which the course of the work of Christ was impressed on the apostle's mind. He does not record the call of the twelve, yet it lies hidden and implied in his narrative. From another side the reference shews that St John assumes that his readers are familiar with the main facts of the history.
Will ye also...] ... Compare vii. 47, 52, xviii. 17, 25.
go away... go (v. 68)...] Perhaps more exactly, go ... ... go away (dn ...... The first word suggests the notion of the personal act in itself; the second that of separation. See vii. 33, note.
John 6:67 · Open Word Bible
67So Jesus asked the Twelve, "Surely you do not want to leave as well?"
Then Simon Peter
St Peter occupies the same representative place in St John's narrative as in the others. Comp. xiii. 6 ff., 24, 36, xviii. 10, xx. 2, xxi. 3. His reply is the strong confession that the apostles have found in Christ all that they could seek. The thought is of what Christ has, as they have known, and not of Himself: thou (unemphatic) hast in thy spiritual treasury ready to be brought forth according to our powers and necessities (Matt. xiii. 52) the words, or rather words of eternal life. This phrase may mean either ( i ) words — utterances (v. 63) — concerning eternal life ; or (2) words bringing, issuing in, eternal life (1 John i. 1). The usage of St John is on the whole decidedly in favour of the second interpretation. Thus we find the bread of life (vv. 35, &c.), the light of life (viii. 12), the (water of life (Rev. xxi. 6, xxii. 1, 17), the tree of life (Rev. ii. 7, xxii. 2, 14). St Peter does not speak of the completed Gospel ("the word "), but of specific sayings ... which had been felt to carry life with them. ...
John 6:68 · Open Word Bible
68Simon Peter answered Him, "Lord, to whom would we go? You have words that bring eternal life.
And we
The pronoun is emphatic ; we who are nearest to Thee and have listened to Thee most devoutly.
believe and are sure] have believed and know (or rather, have come to know). The vital faith which grasps the new data of the higher life precedes the conscious intellectual appreciation of them. " Non cognovimus et credidimus...Credidimus enim ut cognosceremus ; nam si prius cognoscere et deinde credere vellemus, nec cognoscere nec credere valeremus" .... Comp. ch. x. 38 ; * Pet. i. 5.
In 1 John iv. 16 the words stand in the inverted order, but it will be noticed from the construction there that the words have believed qualify and explain, so to speak, have come to know (know), but do not go closely with the love that God hath to us, which depends directly on know.
that Christ, the Son of the living God] According to the true reading (see additional note), the Holy One of God. Mark i. 24 ; Luke iv. 34. The knowledge of the demoniacs reached to the essential nature of the Lord. Comp. Rev. iii. 7 ; 1 John ii. 20. See also ch. x. 36, and v. 27 of this chapter.
John 6:69 · Open Word Bible
69We have believed, and we know, that You are the Holy One of God."
With this confession of St Peter that which is recorded in Matt. xvi. 16, which belongs to the same period but to different circumstances, must be compared. Here the confession points to the inward character in which the Apostles found the assurance of life ; there the confession was of the public office and theocratic Person of the Lord. To suppose that the one confession is simply an imperfect representation of the other is to deny the fulness of the life which lies behind both. This confession must be compared with the confessions in ch. i. Here the confession is made after the disappointment of the popular hope, and reaches to the recognition of that absolute character of Christ which the demoniacs tried to reveal prematurely.
Jesus answered
Even in those who still clung to Christ there was an element of unfaithfulness. ...
Jesus answered...] The reply is to the confident affirmation of St Peter, who rested his profession of the abiding faithfulness of the apostles upon their perception of the Lord's nature. So far was this from leaving no ground for doubt that the Lord shews that even His own choice (Did not I— even I— choose) left room for a traitor among those whom He had chosen.
them] St Peter spoke for all, and the Lord still speaks to the twelve and not to their representative only.
Have not I chosen you twelve ?] Did not I choose you the twelve? you the marked representatives of the new Israel, the patriarchs of a divine people. The reference is not to the number of the apostles, but to their special position ....
Even out of this chosen body ... one is faithless. There is a tragic pathos in the original order.
a devil] viii. 44, xiii. 2 ; 1 John iii. 8, 10 ; Rev. xii. 9, xx. 2. The fundamental idea seems to be that of turning good into evil (8 .... The two great temptations are the characteristic works of "the devil." Hence Judas, by regarding Christ in the light of his own selfish views, and claiming to use His power for the accomplishment of that which he had proposed as Messiah's work, partook of that which is essential to the devil's nature. "With this term applied to Judas we must compare that of Satan applied at no long interval to St Peter (Matt. xvi. 23). Judas wished to pervert the divine power which he saw to his own ends ; St Peter strove to avert what he feared in erring zeal for his Lord.
John 6:70 · Open Word Bible
70Jesus answered them, "Did I not choose the twelve of you myself? Still, one of you is a devil."
He spake
Now he spake...
Judas Iscariot the son of Simon] Judas the son of Simon Iscariot. The true reading here marks Iscariot as certainly a local name : a man of Kerioth .... The place is commonly identified with Kerioth, a town of Judah (Josh. xv. 25), according to the A. V., so that Judas alone was strictly a Judaean. But it appears that the rendering there is incorrect, and that Kerioth ought to be joined with Hezron .... May not the town be identified with the Kerioth ... of Moab mentioned in Jer. xlviii. 24?
he it was that should] it was he that was about to ...... Compare xii. 4 ; Luke xxii. 23. The phrase in v. 64 is different ....
being one of the twelve] The phrase (eff (K r. 8.) is slightly different from that in Matt. xxvi. 14, 47 and parallels ..., and seems to mark the unity of the body to which the unfaithful member belonged. Compare xx. 24.
John 6:71 · Open Word Bible
71He meant Judas, son of Simon Iscariot. Judas was one of the Twelve, and he was going to betray Him.