B. F. Westcott · The Gospel According to St. John: The Authorised Version with Introduction and Notes
John 5
69 excerpts on John 5, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
After this...
There is a slight difference between after this ..., and after these things .... The former implies a connexion of some kind (of time or dependence) between the preceding and subsequent events, which is not suggested by the latter.
a feast] The evidence for the identification of this unnamed feast is very slight. The tradition of the early Greek Church identified it with Pentecost Most modern commentators suppose it to be the Feast of Purim (March), from a comparison of iv. 35 and vi. 4. But see Additional Note.
went up to Jerusalem] If the feast were that of Purim, this journey was not of obligation ; but compare x. 22 (the Feast of Dedication).
John 5:1 · Open Word Bible
1Some time after this there was a Jewish festival, and Jesus went up to Jerusalem.
The sign (vv. 2—9 a).
The healing of the impotent man was a work wrought by the Lord spontaneously. He chose both the object of it and the occasion. The malady of the sufferer was not urgent in such a sense that the cure could not have been delayed. The cure therefore was not wrought on a Sabbath although it was a Sabbath, but because it was Sabbath, with the view of bringing out a deeper truth (comp. vii. 21 ff.).
John 5:2–9 · Open Word Bible
2In Jerusalem, by the Sheep Gate, there is a pool with five porticoes; in Hebrew it is called Bethesda. 3Many sick people used to lie in these porticoes: the blind, the lame and the paralyzed. …
there is at Jerusalem
The use of the present tense does not prove that the narrative was written before the destruction of Jerusalem. It is quite natural that St John in recalling the event should speak of the place as he knew it. It has indeed been conjectured that a building used for a benevolent purpose might have been spared in the general ruin, but this explanation of the phrase is improbable.
Jjj the sheep market] by the sheep gate ..., super probatica Am.), which lay near the temple on the east of the city (Neh. iii. 1, 32, xii. 39), though it cannot now be certainly fixed (' Dict. of Bible,' s. v.). The ellipsis, which is most naturally supplied by gate, is (apparently) without parallel.
a pool] This has been identified by some with an intermittent spring known as the Fountain of the Virgin, in the Valley of Kidron. The traditional site is the Birket Israil by the modern gate of St Stephen, on the north-east of the city. But neither spot fully answers to the conditions of the pool.
John 5:2 · Open Word Bible
2In Jerusalem, by the Sheep Gate, there is a pool with five porticoes; in Hebrew it is called Bethesda.
in the Hebrew
that is, in the language " of those beyond the river " brought from Babylon, and not in the classical language of the Old Testament. Compare Lightfoot ad loc. Bethesda] The original reading and the meaning of the name are both very uncertain. ... See Delitzsch, ' Ztschr. f. Luth. ... The pool is not mentioned by any Jewish writer.
five porches] Cloisters, or covered spaces round the pool, such as are commonly found by tanks in India.
3—4.
The words from waiting for. ..he had are not part of the original text of St John, but form a very early note added to explain v. 7, while the Jewish tradition with regard to the pool was still fresh. Some authorities add the last clause of v. 3 only ; others v. 4 only ; others add both, but with considerable verbal variations. See Additional Note.
John 5:3–4 · Open Word Bible
3Many sick people used to lie in these porticoes: the blind, the lame and the paralyzed.
A similar scene is still presented by the hot sulphureous springs near Tiberias (Hammath, Josh. xix. 35) : Tristram, ' Land of Israel,' 416.
John 5:3 · Open Word Bible
3Many sick people used to lie in these porticoes: the blind, the lame and the paralyzed.
an angel
Comp. Rev. xvi. 5.
thirty and eight years
This period of time, corresponding with the period of the punishment of the Israelites in the wilderness, has led many, from a very early date, to regard the man as a type of the Jewish people paralysed by faithlessness at the time of Christ's coming. The detail may however be added simply to mark the inveteracy of the disease (ix. 1, blind from his birth).
John 5:5 · Open Word Bible
5One man there had been ill for thirty-eight years.
saw him lie, and knew
by the information of bystanders, or (more probably) by His divine intuition (see p. 46). The life of this sick man was open to Him (v. 14), just as the life of the Samaritan woman (iv. 1 8). It is to be noticed that all the miracles recorded by St John, except the healing of the nobleman's son, were wrought spontaneously by Christ. But the question with which this work is prefaced is a peculiar feature.
Wilt thou] i.e. hast thou the will? desirest thou ? The word is often ambiguous, as for example, v. 40, vi. 11, 67, vii. 17, viii. 44, ix. 27. The question was suggested by the circumstances of the man's case. It might seem that he acquiesced in his condition, and was unwilling to make any vigorous effort to gain relief. If it was so, the words were fitted to awaken attention, hope, effort, in one who had fallen into apathy. Comp. Acts iii. 4.
John 5:6 · Open Word Bible
6Jesus saw him lying there and knew that he had been in that condition for a long time, so He asked him, "Do you want to be well?"
The sufferer answers the thought which underlay the inquiry. The delay in his healing was due, as he explains, not to want of will but to want of means.
is troubled] The popular explanation of the phenomenon of an intermittent spring.
put] The original word ... is that which is commonly translated cast. In late Greek it is used very widely (e.g. xiii. 2, xviii. 11, xx. 25, 27), but it may express the necessary haste of the movement according to the gloss in v. 4.
John 5:7 · Open Word Bible
7The sick man answered Him, "Sir, when the water is stirred up, there is no one to put me into the pool. And while I am on my way, someone else steps down before I do."
bed
The word ..., said to be of Macedonian origin, which is used here, occurs Mark ii. 4 ff. (note), vi. 55; Acts v. 15, ix. 33. It describes technically the bed of the poor — "a pallet."
John 5:8 · Open Word Bible
8Jesus told him, "Get up, pick up your mat, and start walking."
The immediate sequel of the sign (9^—18).
In this section the various elements of the coming conflict .are brought out distinctly; the significance of the cure as a work of power and judgment (v. 14), the accusations of the Jews (vv. 10, 1 6, 1 8), the self-vindication of Christ (v. 17).
John 5:9–18 · Open Word Bible
9Immediately the man became well. He picked up his mat and began walking about. And this happened on a Sabbath. 10So the Jewish leaders kept telling the man who had been healed, "It is the Sabbath. It is against the law for you to carry your mat." 11But he answered them, "The one who made me well is the one who told me, 'Pick up your mat and start walking.'" …
and on...the sabbath
A new paragraph begins with these words : Now on that day was a sabbath, which prepares the way for the subsequent discourse. The form of the phrase is very remarkable (comp. ix. 14, xix. 31), and suggests the idea that the sabbath was a day of rest other than the weekly sabbath.
John 5:9 · Open Word Bible
9Immediately the man became well. He picked up his mat and began walking about. And this happened on a Sabbath.
The Jews
See Introd. pp. ix, x. unto him that was (had been) cured] The word and tense are contrasted with those found in v. 13.
It is the sabbath: and it is not... to carry] Rather, to take up, as in vv. 8, 9, 11, 12. ...
John 5:10 · Open Word Bible
10So the Jewish leaders kept telling the man who had been healed, "It is the Sabbath. It is against the law for you to carry your mat."
He answered them
... The authority of One who had wrought the miracle seemed to him to outweigh any legal enactment. He felt instinctively the presence of that which was greater than the sabbath.
the same] even he, with a marked emphasis on the pronoun .... This usage is characteristic of St John, i. 18, 33, ix. 37, x. 1, xii. 48, xiv. 21, 26. Compare also Mark vii. 15, 20; Rom. xiv. 14 ; 2 Cor. x. 18.
John 5:11 · Open Word Bible
11But he answered them, "The one who made me well is the one who told me, 'Pick up your mat and start walking.'"
Then asked they...What man...which said
They asked, Who Is the man that said... The introduction of the man marks the spirit of the inquiry, and suggests the contrast between the Divine Law and this (assumed) human teacher, who claimed to deal with it by his own power. Moreover, as the sufferer had spoken of his healing, these speak only of the technical offence, and pass by that work of power and mercy. ...
John 5:12 · Open Word Bible
12So they asked him, "Who is this man who told you to pick it up and walk?"
And he that...in that place
But he that... in the place.
for Jesus had conveyed himself away] for Jesus retired — withdrew — silently and unperceived, from a place where He might be exposed to embarrassment; for this appears to be the force of the reference to the multitude, and not that the crowd made escape easier. The word ... expresses literally, "to bend the head aside, to avoid a blow" .... ...
John 5:13 · Open Word Bible
13But the healed man had no idea who it was, since there was a crowd in the place and Jesus had moved off without being noticed.
Afterward
After these things. Comp. v. 1, note.
findeth] The healing was incomplete till its spiritual lesson was brought out clearly. Though Christ had withdrawn from the multitude He sought (comp. i. 43, ix. 35) the object of His mercy ; and so much at least the man had already learnt, that he repaired to the temple, as we must suppose, to offer thanks there for his restoration directly after his cure.
a worse thing] even than the sickness of thirty-eight years, by which the greater part of his life had been saddened.
John 5:14 · Open Word Bible
14Afterward Jesus found him in the temple area and said to him, "Look, you are well now. Do not sin any longer, or something worse could come upon you."
The man departed
It is difficult to understand the motive of the man in conveying this information to the Jews, since he knew the hostile spirit in which they regarded the cure. He was certainly not ungrateful, for he still speaks of Jesus as having cured him (which had made him whole, v. 11, and not which had told him to take up his bed, v. 12). He may have wished to leave the responsibility of his illegal act on the sabbath with One who had power to answer for it ; or it may be simplest to suppose that he acted in obedience to the instructions of those whom, as a Jew, he felt bound to obey.
John 5:15 · Open Word Bible
15The man went off and told the Jewish leaders that the one who had made him well was Jesus.
And therefore
This is the first open declaration of hostility to Christ (though the words and sought to slay him, which are wrongly added in this verse from v. 18, must be omitted) ; and it is based upon the alleged violation of the letter of the Law with regard to the sabbath, as in the other Gospels, Matt. xii. 2 ff. and parallels. The miracle just recorded called out the settled enmity of the Jews, but the phrase because he did, or rather used to do, (was in the habit of doing, these things (acts of mercy which involved offences against the traditional interpretations of the Law) on a sabbath, shews that the feeling was not due to a solitary act, but to an obvious principle of action.
John 5:16 · Open Word Bible
16For this reason the Jewish leaders began to persecute Jesus, since He kept doing such things on the Sabbath.
The answer (see v. 19, note) of Christ contains in the briefest possible space the exposition of His office: My Father (ii. 16, xx. 17) worketh hitherto ..., even until now, and I work. That is to say, the rest of God after the creation, which the sabbath represents outwardly, and which I am come to realise, is not a state of inaction, but of activity, and man's true rest is not a rest from human earthly labour, but a rest for divine heavenly labour. Thus the merely negative, traditional, observance of the sabbath is placed in sharp contrast with the positive, final, fulfilment of spiritual service, for which it was a preparation. The works of Christ did not violate the Law, while they brought out the truth to which that tended. Cf. Matt. xii. 1 ff. and parallels. By the u work " of the Father we must understand at once the maintenance of the material creation and the redemption and restoration of all things, in which the Son co-operated with Him (Hebr. i. 3 ; Eph. i. 9 f.).
The form of the sentence is remarkable. Christ places His work as co-ordinate with that of the Father, and not as dependent on it. Comp. Mark ii. 27, 28 (The Son of man is Lord also of the sabbath*).
The question of the action of God upon the Sabbath was much debated in the Jewish schools. "Why does not God," said a caviller, "keep the sabbath?" "May not a man," was the answer, " wander through his own house on the sabbath? The house of God is the whole realm above and the whole realm below" ('Shem. R.' xxx.). ... Alleg.' I. p. 46 M.
John 5:17 · Open Word Bible
17Jesus answered them, "My Father has been at work right up to now, and I am at work as well."
hitherto
even until now. The work of Christ which had excited the hostility of the Jews was, however little they could see it, really coincident with a working of God which knows no interruption.
The Jews rightly interpreted the words of the Lord. They saw that He claimed the power of abrogating the law of the Sabbath in virtue of His absolutely special relation to God: He called God His own Father (Rom. viii. 32) — His Father in a peculiar sense — making Himself equal with God, by placing His action on the same level with the action of God. Comp. x. 33. For this reason the more they (not only persecuted Him, v. 16, but) sought to kill Him. Comp. Matt. xii. 14, and parallels. Matt. xxvi. 65, note. Comp. viii. 59, x. 33; Mark ii. 7.
he... had broken] Literally, he was loosing ..., i.e. he declared that the law of the sabbath was not binding. The word ... expresses not the violation of the sanctity of the day in a special case, but the abrogation of the duty of observance. Comp. Matt. v. 19, xviii. 18. A prophet might absolve from the obligation of the law in a particular instance, but not generally.
John 5:18 · Open Word Bible
18So the Jewish leaders were even more determined to kill Him. Besides breaking the Sabbath, He was speaking of God as His own Father, and so was making Himself equal to God.
The Nature and Prerogatives of the Son (19—29).
The first part of the comprehensive answer of the Lord to the Jews deals with His Nature and prerogatives (1) in relation to the Father (19 — 23), and (2) in relation to men (24—29).
The fact that the discourse was addressed to a small, trained, audience (see preliminary note) explains the close brevity of the reasoning.
The exposition of these thoughts is made in a series of statements bound together by u for" ... four times repeated.
The Son doeth nothing self-determined of Himself, which would be impossible (19^) ; for His action is absolutely coincident in range with that of the. ...
John 5:19–29 · Open Word Bible
19So Jesus gave them this answer: "Truly, truly, I tell you, the Son cannot do anything on His own; He does only what He sees the Father doing. For what the Father does, the Son does as well, and in the same way. 20For the Father loves the Son and shows Him everything He Himself is doing. And there are greater works than these that He will show Him, so that you will be astonished. 21For the Father raises the dead and brings them to life, and in the same way the Son brings to life whomever He chooses. …
Then answered Jesus
Jesus therefore answered.... He met their thoughts and their actions (comp. ii. 18, n.) by a justification of His own works and His divine claims as Messiah. This "answer" is not to be placed in immediate temporal connexion with what precedes.
Verily, verily] See i. 5 1 , note. The teaching is "with authority" (Matt. vii. 28 f.).
The Son] iii. 35. ...
John 5:19 · Open Word Bible
19So Jesus gave them this answer: "Truly, truly, I tell you, the Son cannot do anything on His own; He does only what He sees the Father doing. For what the Father does, the Son does as well, and in the same way.
can do nothing
The eternal law of right is (in human language) the definition of divine power. The words do not convey any limitation of the Son's working, but explain something as to its character. Comp. v. 30, iii. 27 ; Mark vi. 5; (Gen. xix. 22). For another aspect of this "cannot" see vii. 7, note.
of himself] v. 30, note; Num. xvi. 28 (LXX.). The truth lies in the very idea of Sonship.
for what things soever...] The negative statement is supplemented by a positive one ... The Son can do nothing ...for ... His action is not only coincident but coextensive with the action of the Father : what things soever He doeth these also the Son doeth in like manner, not in imitation, but in virtue of His sameness of nature.
For the Father
The action of the Son, as coincident and coextensive with that of the Father, depends upon the continuous revelation which the Father makes to Him in accordance with His eternal love: for the Father loveth the Son;... and this revelation, regarded under the limitations of human existence, is progressive, and signs of healing are only preparatory to greater works; for as the Father . . . quickeneth, even so the Son also quickeneth whom He (unemphatic) will.
Thus we can see that there is a divine coherence, a divine meaning, in all nature and all history. The Son sees all, for the Father shews all to Him ; and we also can see parts at least in Him. Comp. Matt. xi. 27.
loveth (the Son)] The word ... marks personal affection based upon a special relation (xi. 3, 36 ; comp. Matt. x. 37), and not the general feeling of regard, esteem, consideration ... which comes from 'reflection and knowledge : the former feeling answers to nature, the latter to experience and judgment (iii. 35, x. 17), and so is specially appropriate to spiritual relations. This love expresses (so to speak) the moral side of the essential relation of the Father to the Son. And so it is through the Son that the personal love of God is extended to believers: xvi. 27 ; comp. Rev. iii. 19.
The sign of love is the perfect revelation of thought and feeling : xv. 15.
John 5:20 · Open Word Bible
20For the Father loves the Son and shows Him everything He Himself is doing. And there are greater works than these that He will show Him, so that you will be astonished.
he will...than these
The Original order is more expressive: greater works (comp. xiv. 12) than these will He shew (comp. x. 32) Him; and He (so it is implied, v. 19) when He seeth them will do them in like manner, that ye (emphatic) may marvel. It cannot but appear strange at first sight that wonder is given as the object of Christ's works. The difficulty is removed by taking account of the pronoun : that^<? who question my authority and are blind to my divine Sonship may marvel. Till Christ was recognised His works could at the most appeal only to be prodigies : their effect would be astonishment, not belief. But wonder might give occasion for faith. Under this aspect "wonder" is presented in two remarkable traditional sayings of the Lord preserved by Clement of Alexandria ('Strom.' ii. 9, 45): "He that wonders shall reign, and he that reigns shall rest:" "Wonder at that which is before you." This partial object of wonder, however, is contrasted with the general object in v. 23. Works — outward signs — may produce wonder, but judgment completed enforces honour. Comp. Plat. 'Theaet.' p. 155 D. shew] x. 32. The divine works require the interpretation of sympathy. Such sympathy the Son has absolutely.
works] This is a characteristic term in St John (comp. Matt. xi. 2) in which Christ includes under the same category the manifold forms of His action. ...
He came to finish (iv. 34, xvii. 4), and these He must needs work while it was day (ix. 4). Miracles from this point of view are regarded on the same level with the other works of Christ, though " miraculous" works may in a peculiar sense move to faith (v. 36, x. 35, 32, xiv. 10, 12, xv. 24). All works alike are designed to contribute to the redemption of the world (comp. ch. xvii. 21, note). ...
The progress in the dignity of the works of the Son follows from the extent of their sphere, for as the Father raiseth the dead ...even so the Son also ... The restoration of an impotent man is then but a beginning of that giving of life of which it was a sign. The vivifying power of the Father is described in its twofold physical aspect, He raiseth up the dead and quickeneth : that of the Son in reference to its moral law, He quickeneth whom He twill. The "quickening" as it stands in the second clause is necessarily coextensive with the raising the dead and quickening in the first, which is not to be limited to any isolated "miraculous" acts, but extends to all communication of life, natural and spiritual. The main forms of "quickening " are distinguished afterwards, vv. 25, 28.
The definition whom He will marks (1) the efficacy of Christ's power, and (2) connects this communication of higher life with the counsels of infinite wisdom and love, and (3) shews its independence of outward descent (as from Abraham). There is no emphasis on the personal will of the Son (whom He twill) as in v. 20 (which He Himself doeth).
John 5:21 · Open Word Bible
21For the Father raises the dead and brings them to life, and in the same way the Son brings to life whomever He chooses.
The full significance of this claim of Christ to "quicken whom he will" is illustrated by the second of the ' Shemoneh Esreh,' the ' Eighteen [Benedictions],' of the Jewish Prayer Book. It is probable that this thanksgiving was used in substance in the apostolic age: "Thou, O Lord, art mighty for ever: Thou quickenest the dead: Thou art strong to save. Thou sustainest the living by Thy mercy : Thou quickenest the dead by Thy great compassion. Thou...makest good Thy faithfulness to them that sleep in the dust ... Thou art faithful to quicken the dead. Blessed art Thou, O Lord, who quickenest the dead."
The fact that the Son possesses and exercises this quickening power is established by the fact that He has a still more awful prerogative. The quickening of men is contrasted with the judgment of men, which is the correlative of sin (iii. 17 ff.). And this judgment belongs to the Son (as Son of man, v. 27), For not even doth the Father judge any man, but hath committed (given) all judgment (or literally, the judgment which comes and will come, wholly, in all its parts, now in its first beginning and hereafter in its complete accomplishment) unto the Son.
the Father ...no man] The exact phrase of the original marks a climax: not even doth the Father — to whom this office might seem to pertain — judge any man.
John 5:22 · Open Word Bible
22Nor does the Father judge anyone; He has given the whole work of judging to the Son,
The Son has received the prerogative of judgment, and it is through the exercise of this power that men come to perceive His true majesty. For it was committed to Him for this end, that all men should honour (not future, but present) the Son even . as they honour the Father (x. 37, 38). Sooner or later, in loss or in sorrow, this must be. And there is also a converse form of the Truth. ...
John 5:23 · Open Word Bible
23so that everyone will honor the Son just as they honor the Father. Whoever refuses honor to the Son refuses it to the Father who sent Him.
which hath sent him
which sent Him. These words mark the transition from the conception of the Son essentially to that of the Son revealed by the incarnation. The phrase He that sent me is peculiar to St John (comp. Rom. viii. 3). It is used only by the Lord absolutely of the Father, iv. 34, vv. 24, 30, vi. 38, 39, vii. 16, 28, 33, viii. 26, 29, ix. 4, xii. 44, 45, xiii. 20, xv. 21, xvi. 5. Elsewhere the full form, the Father that sent me, occurs, v. 37, vi. 44, viii. 16, 18, xii. 49, xiv. 24. Comp. i. 33 (He that sent me to baptize).
24—29.
In these verses we pass from the consideration of the relation of the Son to the Father to that of the relation of Christ to men. The conception of the " greater works" of the Son, the quickening and the judgment of men, is defined more exactly in connexion with the Son as revealed by the Incarnation. At the same time, though the oblique form is generally preserved, the work and the mission of Christ are referred to directly (my word, Him that sent me, v. 24). In v. 24 the general ideas of all life and all judgment in connexion with the Son (ai, 22) are restated : in vv. 25, 26, they are applied to the present order; in 28, 29, they are applied to the future order.
John 5:24–29 · Open Word Bible
24Truly, truly, I tell you, anyone who hears My word and believes the one who sent Me has eternal life. Such a person does not come under condemnation, but has already moved out of death into life. 25Truly, truly, I tell you, an hour is coming, and in fact it has already begun, when the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear it will live. 26For just as the Father has life in Himself, so He has given the Son life in Himself as well. …
Verily, verily
vv. 19, 25. Comp. i. 51, note.
He that . . . believeth on him . . . everlasting life, and shall not come into condemnation ...] He that heareth my word and believeth Him that sent me hath life eternal and cometh not into judgment, but is passed out of death (the death that is truly death) into life (the life that is truly life). (Comp. 1 John iii. 14.) The two conditions of eternal life are (1) knowledge of the revelation made by the Son, and (2) belief in the truth of it, that is, belief in the word of the Father who speaks through the Son. Comp. xvii. 3. He who knows the Gospel and knows that the Gospel is true cannot but have life. Eternal life is not future but present, or rather it is, and so is above all time. Comp. iii. 1 8 f. For him who hath this life judgment is impossible. He has already gone beyond it. Comp. 1 John ii. 28, iv. 17.
John 5:24 · Open Word Bible
24Truly, truly, I tell you, anyone who hears My word and believes the one who sent Me has eternal life. Such a person does not come under condemnation, but has already moved out of death into life.
believeth on him
believeth him... .... The difference between "believing a person or statement" ... and " believing on a person " ... is as clearly marked in Greek as in English, though it is destroyed here in A. V. and in viii. 31 ; Acts xvi. 34, xviii. 8 ; Tit. iii. 8 ; while it is preserved vv. 38, 46, viii. 45, 46 ; Rom. iv. 3 ; Acts xxvii. 25. The two phrases are contrasted in vi. 29, 30, viii. 30, 31 ; 1 John v. 10. To believe God or to believe the Lord is to acknowledge as true the message which comes from Him or the words which He speaks. It is assumed that the message does come from Him, and therefore to believe the message is to believe Him. So here Christ refers His word to the authority of the Father: compare v. 37.
shall not come] cometh not. The issues of action are regarded in their potential accomplishment in the present.
from death unto
out of death into... 1 John iii. 14. In his epistle St John speaks of "love to the brethren" as the personal proof of this transition. Such love flows from an acceptance in faith of Christ's word (1 John ii. 7, iii. 11). Death and life are, as it were, two spheres of existence, like darkness and light: 1 John v. 19, 20, ch. viii. 31, note.
The present manifestation of Christ's vivifying power in the spiritual resurrection (is coming and now is) is stated in contrast with the future manifestation in the general resurrection (is coming, v. 28). See iv. 23, 21. The hour was " coming," so far as the Christian dispensation truly began with the gift of Pentecost: but it "was" already while Christ openly taught among men.
the dead] the spiritually dead: this is the predominant idea, but at the same time we cannot exclude the outward signs of it as in the raising of Lazarus : comp. xi. 23 ff. For this use of the word see Matt. viii. 22 ; Luke xv. 24, 32; Rom. vi. 11 ; Eph. v. 14. It will be observed that the voice of power is attributed to the Son of God. Comp. xi. 4 ; contrast ix. 35.
they that hear] This phrase is not coextensive with the dead. ... As yet the thought is of life only, and not of judgment, except so far as that is expressed in the want of life.
John 5:25 · Open Word Bible
25Truly, truly, I tell you, an hour is coming, and in fact it has already begun, when the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear it will live.
as...so
The particles mark the fact of the gift and not the degree of it. Comp. v. 21 ; Matt. xiii. 40, &c.
so hath he given ....] so gave He also... ... Ille autem Pater vitam in semetipso habet ; et talem genuit Filium qui haberet vitam in semetipso; non fieret vitae particeps, sed ipse vita esset, cujus nos vitae participes essemus " (August. 'Serm.' cxxvil. 9). The tense (gave) carries us back beyond time; and yet it has a further application to the incarnation, wherein the Son became also the Son of man (v. 27). The sovereignty of life is followed by the authority to judge, as in vv. 21, 22. Comp. vi. 57 ; Rev. i. 17.
John 5:26 · Open Word Bible
26For just as the Father has life in Himself, so He has given the Son life in Himself as well.
And hath given him...judgment also, because he is the Son of man
The prerogative of judgment is connected with the true humanity of Christ (Son of man) and not with the fact that He is the representative of humanity (the Son of man). ...
John 5:27 · Open Word Bible
27He has also given Him authority to pass judgment, since He is the Son of Man.
Him. The omission of the article concentrates attention upon the nature and not upon the personality of Christ. ... The phrase (son of man) is found here only in the Gospel, but it occurs also Rev. i. 13, xiv. 14 : the Son of Man occurs i. 51, iii. 13, 14, vi. 27, 53, 62, as often in the other Gospels. Comp. i. 51, additional note.
Marvel not at this: for
The partial spiritual quickening and judgment is consummated in a universal quickening and judgment. There is a marked contrast between the corresponding clauses of vv. 25, 28 : the dead (v. 25), all that are in the tombs (v. 28) : cometh and now is (v. 25), cometh (v. 28). Here the quickening is the inevitable result of the divine action (all... shall hear) ; before it followed from the concurrence of faith with the divine message (they that hear shall live).
Marvel not...] Comp. v. 20. Wonder is at most only a stage of transition. Each manifestation of Christ's power is a preparation for something greater.
John 5:28 · Open Word Bible
28Do not be astonished at this. An hour is coming when everyone in the tombs will hear His voice
It will be observed that there is a contrast between the one result of the present action of the Son, shall live (v. 25), and the complex result of His future action : shall go forth...
they that have done (that wrought) good...] ... The same words ... are contrasted, ch. iii. 20, 21, note; Rom. i. 32, vii. 15, 19, xiii. 4. The distinction is well preserved in the Vulgate, bona fecerunt... mala egerunt.
For the contrast of a resurrection of life (2 Mace. vii. 14), and a resurrection of judgment, see v. 24. In one case the resurrection is accompanied by the full fruition of life, judgment being past: in the other resurrection issues in judgment.
of damnation] of judgment .... ...
John 5:29 · Open Word Bible
29and come out. Those who have done good will come out to a resurrection that brings life; those who have done evil, to a resurrection that brings condemnation.
This verse forms a transition from the first section of the discourse to the second. At the same time it marks the passage from the indirect (the Son) to the personal (7) revelation of Christ. The truth of the divine Sonship, with which the discourse opened, is first repeated in a new form, / ... can of mine own self do nothing; and then the principle of Christ's judgment is laid down (as I hear, I judge), which is the ground of all true judgment.
I can... do nothing] Comp. v. 19, note.
of mine own self] Comp. vii. 17 f., 28, viii. 28, 42, ...> xi.v- Io> (xi- 5J)» xv. 4, note, xvi. 13. The very idea of Sonship involves (in some sense) that of dependence. There is but one " fountain " of Deity. But under another aspect the Son "lays down His life of Himself " (x. 18).
as I hear, I judge] The judgment of the Son is based upon the perfect knowledge of the thoughts of the Father, as the action of the Son is based upon the perfect vision of His works. The " hearing " in this verse with regard to judgment corresponds to the "seeing" in v. 19 with regard to action.
because I seek... the will of the Father which hath sent mi] of Him that sent me (iv. 34, vi. 38, 39). The two conditions of absolute justice are (1) negative : absence of all respect of self; and (2) positive : devotion to the will of the Father. In both these respects the just judgment of the Son is contrasted with the false judgment of the Jews, vv. 41 — 44.
John 5:30 · Open Word Bible
30I cannot do anything on My own. I judge according to what I hear, and the judgment I give is just, because I am not seeking to do My own will, but the will of the one who sent Me.
The connexion between the obedience rendered by the Son, and the honour rendered to the Son (v. 23), must be noticed.
It will be observed that the "will" of Christ corresponds with His one unchanged personality .... Comp. Matt. xxvi. 39, and parallels. The thought of the verse is partially illustrated by a noble saying of R. Gamaliel: "Do His will as if it were thy will, that He may do thy will as if it were His will." But he continues: "Annul thy will before His will, that He may annul the will of others before thy will" (' Aboth,' n. 4).
31—40.
Christ appeals to a witness separate from His own, and yet such that He has immediate knowledge of its truth. Such wit'Matt. 3.
John 5:31–40 · Open Word Bible
31If I testify on My own behalf, My testimony is not true. 32Someone else is testifying about Me, and I know that the testimony He gives about Me is true. 33You yourselves sent messengers to John, and he has testified to the truth. …
The witness to the Son and the ground of unbelief (31—47).
This second main division of the discourse consists, like the first, of two parts. The witness to the Son is first laid open (31 — 40), and then the rejection of the witness in its cause and end (41 — 47).
John 5:31–47 · Open Word Bible
31If I testify on My own behalf, My testimony is not true. 32Someone else is testifying about Me, and I know that the testimony He gives about Me is true. 33You yourselves sent messengers to John, and he has testified to the truth. …
If I bear witness of
The stress lies on the pronoun , " If I alone and in fellowship with no other..." Comp. viii. 14.
is not true] The words anticipate an objection, and define the amount of truth which it contains. According to legal usage the testimony of a witness was not received in his own case. This principle the Jews might urge against Christ ; and He acknowledges the deeper meaning which lay beneath it. If He asserted His claims self-prompted (of Himself) He would violate the absolute trust which the Son owed to the Father; though there was a sense in which He could bear witness of Himself (viii. 12 ff.) when the Father spoke through Him (viii. 18).
John 5:31 · Open Word Bible
31If I testify on My own behalf, My testimony is not true.
There is another
In due time and in due manner another bears witness. The whole i scope of the statement decides that this other is " the Father " and not the Baptist. In the ' verses which follow the testimony of the Baptist is treated as provisional, and as being in a certain degree an accommodation. The testimony of the Father is that upon which the Son rests, v. 37, viii. 18.
that beareth witness] The action is present and continuous ....
I know...] In the certainty of this knowledge Christ could repose. Such witness could not but produce its true effect. The absolute knowledge spoken of here ... is to be distinguished from the knowledge of experience ... in v. 42.
the (witness which he witnesseth] This full form of expression, as distinguished from " his witness," emphasizes the idea of the continuity of the witness as a matter of actual experience.
John 5:32 · Open Word Bible
32Someone else is testifying about Me, and I know that the testimony He gives about Me is true.
Ye sent...and he bare
Ye have sent. ..and he hath borne... The mission and the testimony are spoken of as abiding in their results. The prominent idea is not the historic fact (i. 32), but the permanent and final value of the witness (i. 34, iii. 26, v. 37, xix. 35).
The emphatic pronoun (Ye have sent...)
John 5:33 · Open Word Bible
33You yourselves sent messengers to John, and he has testified to the truth.
But I receive not testimony from man
But though the witness of John was decisive according to your view, I (emphatic as distinguished from you) receive not my witness ...v paprvpiav, the witness which characterizes the reality of my work and answers to it) from a man (even though he be a prophet), but these things I say — I appeal even to this imperfect witness, 1 urge every plea which may be expected to prevail with you — that ye — even ye — might (may) be saved.
John 5:34 · Open Word Bible
34Yet I do not accept testimony from a human being; I say these things so that you may be saved.
He was a burning and a shining light...] He was — though now his work is ended by imprisonment or death — the lamp that burneth and shineth (giveth light)... The phrase may also be rendered, the lamp that is kindled and shineth, by the analogy of Matt. v. 15 ; but Luke xii. 35, Rev. iv. 5, viii. 10, are strongly against this interpretation. John the Baptist was the lamp, the derivative and not the self-luminous light (i. 8). Comp. Matt. vi. 22 ; 2 Pet. i. 19 ; but the word is used also of the Lamb, Rev. xxi. 23, where the glory of God, as the source of light, is placed in connexion with the Lamb, through whom (as the lamp of this vast temple) the light is conveyed in the city of God. The definite article (the lamp) simply marks the familiar piece of household furniture (comp. Mark iv. 21 ; Luke xi. 36). The epithets complete the image. The lamp is exhausted by shining; its illuminating power is temporary, and sensibly consumed. John the Baptist necessarily decreased (iii. 30). The title is eminently appropriate to the Baptist in his relation to Christ (the Light) ; but there is no evidence to shew that it was given to the herald of Messiah by tradition, though it was applied to several distinguished teachers. ... But while his glory lasted the Jews (ye emphatic) were willing for a season (an hour, 1 Cor. vii. 8 ; Gal. ii. 5 ; Philem. 15) to rejoice (dya\\ia ... in his light. ...
John 5:35 · Open Word Bible
35John was the lamp that burned and shone, and for a little while you were glad to rejoice in his light.
36—37.
But I have greater witness...] ...
the works ...given] "The works" of j Messiah from the divine side were a complete whole (hath given) ; but they were gradually wrought out on earth (that I should accomplish, v. 34) ; and this accomplishment was the end proposed in the divine gift ....
the works] This phrase is used, as generally in St John's Gospel (v. 20, n.), to describe the whole outward manifestation of Christ's activity, both those acts which we call supernatural and those which we call natural. All alike are wrought in fulfilment of one plan and by one power. The many "works" (vii. 3, ix. 3, x. 25, 32, 37 f., xiv. 10 ff., xv. 24) are parts of the one "work" (iv. 34, xvii. 4). The phrase occurs elsewhere in Matt. v. 16.
hath given ...] The declaration of this relation of the Father to the Son (Incarnate) is characteristic of St John. The Father hath given all things in His hand (iii. 35, xiii. 3) ; He hath given Him all judgment (vv. 22, 27) ; He gave Him to have life in Himself (v. 26) ; He hath given Him a company of faithful servants (vi. 39 ; comp. vi. 65, xvii. 2, 6, 9, 12, 24, xviii. 9) ; He hath given Him commandment what to say (xii. 49) and to do (xiv. 31, xvii. 4 ; comp. xvii. 7 f.). He gave Him authority over all flesh (xvii. 2) ; He hath given Him His name (xvii. 11 f.) and glory (xvii. 24; comp. v. 22). finish] accomplish. Comp. iv. 34, note.
that I do] The pronoun ... which is inserted in the common text must be omitted. It stands in x. 25, xiv. 12, and xiii. 7.
John 5:36–37 · Open Word Bible
36But I have a testimony greater than John's. The works the Father has given Me to bring to completion, the works themselves that I am doing, testify about Me: they show that the Father has sent Me. 37And the Father who sent Me has testified about Me Himself. Not once have you heard His voice or seen His form.
37—38.
But still the double witness was unavailing. The words and visions of the Old Testament were fulfilled in Christ (i. 17). If He was rejected at His coming, they were inarticulate and unreal to the faithless. So too it was with the last witness at the Baptism (i. 32 ff.). Since therefore it is only through the Son that men can hear or see God (xiv. 9), the Jews by their disbelief of Christ failed to hear and see Him (ye is unemphatic) ; nor was His word, which answers from within to the revelation without, abiding in them (1 John ii. 14). This all follows from the words which are emphasized in the original by their position : whom He sent, Him ye ... believe not.
The passage is a summary of the mode and conditions of revelation. The teaching and the character of God can be discovered in nature and history, but His Word must be welcomed and kept in the soul in order that that which is without may be intelligible.
his voice... shape...] Comp. Luke iii. 22 (voice, shape), ix. 35. Comp. ch. xii. 28 ; Acts vii. 31, ix. 4, x. 13.
John 5:37–38 · Open Word Bible
37And the Father who sent Me has testified about Me Himself. Not once have you heard His voice or seen His form. 38And His word does not remain in you, since you do not believe the very one He sent.
the Father...me, hath borne witness
Side by side with the continuous witness of the Father (v. 32) there is a witness which is complete. This was given, in its outward form, in the prophetic teaching of the Old Testament closed by the work of the Baptist ; and in its spiritual form, in the constitution of man whereby he recognises in Christ the fulfilment of the providential teaching of God. ...
John 5:37 · Open Word Bible
37And the Father who sent Me has testified about Me Himself. Not once have you heard His voice or seen His form.
his word
Compare xvii. 6 ff. ; 1 John i. 10, ii. 14, (Hebr. iv. 12). The word of God is a power within man, speaking to and through his conscience; not simply the sum of the earlier revelation under the old Covenant as an outward power; nor yet an independent illumination ; but the whole teaching of Providence felt to be a divine , message.
for (because)...] This is not alleged as the ground, but as the sign of what has been said. Comp. Luke vii. 47; 1 John iii. 14. he hath sent] he sent. Comp. xx. 21, note.
John 5:38 · Open Word Bible
38And His word does not remain in you, since you do not believe the very one He sent.
Search the scriptures
Ye search the Scriptures... The original word may be either imperative (A.V.) or indicative. The indicative rendering is strongly recommended by the (1) immediate connexion, ye search... and they... ; (2) the sense of for in them ye think..., which rather explains a practice than recommends a precept; (3) the general form of the passage: ye have... ye have not... ye will not; (4) the character of the Jews who reposed in the letter of the Old Testament instead of interpreting it by the help of the living Word. On the other side the position of the verb at the beginning of the sentence, and the omission of the pronoun, which occurs in the second clause, are in favour of the imperative rendering. But on the whole, tNe former view is the most probable. The insertion of the pronoun would weaken the stress which is laid on the idea of searching, and this is the central thought. The intense, misplaced diligence of search is contrasted with the futile result.
Search] ch. vii. 52 ; 1 Pet. i. 11. Comp. Rom. viii. 27; 1 Cor. ii. 10; Rev. ii. 23. The original word ... describes that minute, intense investigation of Scripture ... which issued in the allegorical and mystical interpretations of the Midrash. A single example of the stress laid upon the written word will suffice: " Hillel used to say ...more Thorah (Law), more life (Prov. iii. 1 f.)... He who has gotten to himself words of Thorah, has gotten to himself the life of the world to come" (' Aboth,' ii. 8. Compare 'Perek R. Meir' throughout; Taylor, 'Sayings of the Fathers,' pp. 113 ff.). The knowledge of God, it was thought, without repentance brought forgiveness of sins (Just. M. 'Dial.' § MI).
John 5:39 · Open Word Bible
39You pore over the Scriptures, since you think that eternal life is to be found in them; and they are the ones that testify about Me.
the scriptures
the book as distinguished from the living word (v. 38).
and they... and ye will not...] The words mark a double failure. The scriptures witnessed of One whom the Jews rejected ; they pointed to life which the Jews would not seek. There is a deep pathos in the simple co-ordination: and... and...
and they ......] those very scriptures which you idolize. Comp. i. 18, note.
... Comp. v. 32. The teaching of the Old Testament is never exhausted. As we know more of Christ it reveals more to us concerning Him.
And
still, even with this testimony before you, the personal act of faith fails, ye will not (ye have no will to) come unto me (comp. Matt, xxiii. 37, ch. iii. 19) that ye may have life — "life" in its simplest form, the condition of all else (iii. 36, xx. 31), not qualified even as "eternal life" (v. 39).
ye will not] Man has that freedom of determination which makes him responsible. This truth is expressed in various forms in St John's Gospel (comp. vii. 17, viii. 44, vi. 67) side by side with the affirmation of the divine action through which the will is effective for good (vi. 44).
John 5:40 · Open Word Bible
40But you do not want to come to Me so that you can have life.
41—47.
In this section Christ, starting from the fact of a want of will to believe in His hearers, unfolds the cause (41 — 44) and the end (45 — 47) of their rejection of Himself.
The ground of rejection (41 — 44) lies in a want of divine love in the Jews (v. 42), which is shewn by their inability to recognise Christ's self-sacrifice (v. 43), while they themselves pursued selfish ends (v. 44).
John 5:41–47 · Open Word Bible
41Glory from people is not something I accept. 42But I know you, and there is no love for God in you. 43I have come in the name of My Father, yet you do not accept Me. Should someone else come in his own name, him you will accept. …
The connexion of thought with what precedes appears to lie in the anticipation of a natural objection. The condemnation which Christ pronounced might be referred to disappointed hope. It is, He replies, your spiritual life and not my own glory that I seek. ...
John 5:41 · Open Word Bible
41Glory from people is not something I accept.
honour from men
The glory of Messiah lies in His perfect fellowship with the Father (comp. i. 14, "'• "> x»- 4i) ; and men shew their sympathy with Him by " the love of God." This the Jews had not, and their rejection of Christ was the sign of the fatal defect.
know
by the knowledge of experience .... Comp. ii. 24, note.
the love of God] The phrase occurs elsewhere in the Gospels only in Luke xi. 44.
Comp. 1 John ii. 5, iii. 17, iv. 7, 9, v. 3; Rom. v. 5 ; 2 Cor. xiii. 14 ; 2 Thess. iii. 5 ; Jude 21. ...
John 5:42 · Open Word Bible
42But I know you, and there is no love for God in you.
I am come in my Father’s
ch. x. 25, that is, resting absolutely in Him who is my Father and whom I make known to you as such; not simply "as representing" or "by the authority of" my Father, though these ideas are included in that deeper and more comprehensive one. Comp. xiv. 13 f., xv. 16, xvi. 33 f., 26, xvii. 11, 12, xx. 31.
John 5:43 · Open Word Bible
43I have come in the name of My Father, yet you do not accept Me. Should someone else come in his own name, him you will accept.
The Jews offered a complete contrast to Christ (v. 30) ; for they made the judgment of men their standard. Hence the cause of their faithlessness is summed up in the question which represents faith as an impossibility for them : How can ye (emphatic) believe, seeing that ye receive glory (the highest reward of action) one of another (comp. Matt, xxiii. 5); and the glory that cometh from the only God (not from God only) ye seek not? The only God, the one source of all glory, absolutely one in nature, stands in opposition to the "gods many" and to the many common dispensers of praise ; to regard these in themselves is idolatry (comp. xii. 42, 43). The change of construction in the original is remarkable, from a causal participle (seeing that ye receive) to the finite verb (ye seek not). The first clause gives the sufficient reason of unbelief; the second an accompanying fact. Comp. i. 32.
John 5:44 · Open Word Bible
44How could you believe? You accept glory from one another, while the glory that comes from the only God is something you do not seek.
45—47.
The rejection of Christ carries condemnation with it. The accuser is found in the supposed advocate (v. 45) ; and unbelief in the vaunted belief (v. 47).
John 5:45–47 · Open Word Bible
45Do not imagine that I will be the one to accuse you before the Father. You already have an accuser: Moses, in whom you have put your hope. 46If you really believed Moses, you would believe Me, because what he wrote was about Me. 47But if you do not believe the writings of Moses, how will you ever believe My spoken words?"
Do not think
Though I lay bare the cause and nature of your unbelief, do not think that I will accuse you to the Father (not my Father) ; there is one that accuseth you, even Moses on whom you have set your hope. Disbelief in me is disbelief in him, in the record of the promises to the patriarchs (viii. 56), in the types of the deliverance from Egypt (iii. 14), in the symbolic institutions of the Law, iq the promise of a prophet like to himself; for it was of me (the order is emphatic) he wrote. If ye were now at this very time his faithful disciples, you would be mine also. Christ was the essential subject of the Law ^s of the Prophets ; and so of the permanent records of the earlier dispensation.
in whom ye trust] on whom ye have set your hope .... Comp. 2 Cor. i. 10; 1 Tim. iv. 10, v. 5.
John 5:45 · Open Word Bible
45Do not imagine that I will be the one to accuse you before the Father. You already have an accuser: Moses, in whom you have put your hope.
The converse of v. 46 also holds true. Disbelief in Moses involved disbelief in Christ. If ye believe not his writings, the testimony which he has given formally, solemnly, and which you profess to accept as authoritative, how shall ye believe my words, my sayings (iii. 34), which come to you without the recommendation of use and age ? The essence of the disbelief which the Jews shewed to Moses lay in refusing to regard the Law as transitory. They failed to seize the principle of life by which it was inspired, and petrified the form. If they thus allowed their pride to interfere with their acceptance of the real teaching of Moses, they could much less admit the teaching of Christ. Outward zeal became spiritual rebellion.
(writings] The original word ... appears to mark the specific form rather than the general scope of the record (ypa(j)ai). ...
John 5:47 · Open Word Bible
47But if you do not believe the writings of Moses, how will you ever believe My spoken words?"