The healing at the pool (John 5:1–18)
1 Some time after this there was a Jewish festival, and Jesus went up to Jerusalem. 2 In Jerusalem, by the Sheep Gate, there is a pool with five porticoes; in Hebrew it is called Bethesda. 3 Many sick people used to lie in these porticoes: the blind, the lame and the paralyzed. 5 One man there had been ill for thirty-eight years. 6 Jesus saw him lying there and knew that he had been in that condition for a long time, so He asked him, "Do you want to be well?" 7 The sick man answered Him, "Sir, when the water is stirred up, there is no one to put me into the pool. And while I am on my way, someone else steps down before I do." 8 Jesus told him, "Get up, pick up your mat, and start walking." 9 Immediately the man became well. He picked up his mat and began walking about. And this happened on a Sabbath. 10 So the Jewish leaders kept telling the man who had been healed, "It is the Sabbath. It is against the law for you to carry your mat." 11 But he answered them, "The one who made me well is the one who told me, 'Pick up your mat and start walking.'" 12 So they asked him, "Who is this man who told you to pick it up and walk?" 13 But the healed man had no idea who it was, since there was a crowd in the place and Jesus had moved off without being noticed. 14 Afterward Jesus found him in the temple area and said to him, "Look, you are well now. Do not sin any longer, or something worse could come upon you." 15 The man went off and told the Jewish leaders that the one who had made him well was Jesus. 16 For this reason the Jewish leaders began to persecute Jesus, since He kept doing such things on the Sabbath. 17 Jesus answered them, "My Father has been at work right up to now, and I am at work as well." 18 So the Jewish leaders were even more determined to kill Him. Besides breaking the Sabbath, He was speaking of God as His own Father, and so was making Himself equal to God.
Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.
191 excerpts from 11 commentators on John 5:1–18, from John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) to B. F. Westcott (1825–1901).
What the church has said
Each excerpt opens with its first words. Follow its verse to read it in full.
What does Chrysostom say about John 5:1–18?
John Chrysostom
John 5:1–3 Homily XXXVI. John iv. 54; v. 1
“After this there was a feast of the Jews.” What “feast”? Methinks that of Pentecost. “And Jesus went up to Jerusalem.” Continually at the feasts He frequenteth the City, partly that He might appear to feast with them, partly that…
John 5:2–4 Homily XXXVI. John iv. 54; v. 1
First then, as I before said, He causeth defilements of our bodies, and afterwards infirmities of different kinds, to be done away by water. Because God, desiring to bring us nearer to faith in baptism, no longer healeth defilements only,…
John 5:5–6 Homily XXXVI. John iv. 54; v. 1
But why did Jesus, leaving the rest, come to one who was of thirty-eight years standing? And why did He ask him, “Wilt thou be made whole?” Not that He might learn, that was needless; but that He might show…
John 5:7 Homily XXXVII. John v. 6, 7
... Since this man who had been paralytic for thirty and eight years, and who saw each year others delivered, and himself bound by his disease, not even so fell back and despaired, though in truth not merely despondency for…
John 5:8–9 Homily XXXVII. John v. 6, 7
Consider now, I pray you, the exceeding wisdom of God. He raised not up the man at once, but first maketh him familiar by questioning, making way for the coming faith; nor doth He only raise, but biddeth him “take…
John 5:8 Homily XXXVII. John v. 6, 7
Ver. 8. “Rise, take up thy bed, and walk.”
John 5:9 Homily XXXVII. John v. 6, 7
[2.] But why did not Jesus require faith of this man, as He did in the case of others, saying, “Believest thou that I am able to do this?” It was because the man did not yet clearly know who…
John 5:10–11 Homily XXXVII. John v. 6, 7
Ver. 10. “It is the Sabbath day, it is not lawful for thee to carry thy bed”; hear what he saith:
John 5:12–13 Homily XXXVII. John v. 6, 7
Ver. 12, 13. “What man is that which said unto thee, Take up thy bed and walk? And he that was healed wist not who it was: for Jesus had conveyed Himself away, a multitude being in that place.”
John 5:14 Homily XXXVIII. John v. 14
Now what do we learn from this? First, that his disease had been produced by his sins; secondly, that the accounts of hell fire are to be believed; thirdly, that the punishment is long, nay endless. Where now are those…
John 5:14 Homily XXXVIII. John v. 14
But why is it that in the case of these paralytics Christ bringeth forward their sins? For He saith also to him in Matthew who lay on a bed, “Son, be of good cheer, thy sins are forgiven thee” (…
John 5:14 Homily XXXVIII. John v. 14
And observe the absence of boasting. He said not, “Behold, I have made thee whole,” but, “Thou art made whole; sin no more.” And again, not, “lest I punish thee,” but, “lest a worse thing come unto thee”; putting both…
John 5:15 Homily XXXVIII. John v. 14
Ver. 15. “The man departed, and told the Jews that it was Jesus that had made him whole.”
John 5:16–17 Homily XXXVIII. John v. 14
Ver. 16. “Therefore did the Jews persecute Jesus, and sought to slay Him, because He had done these things on the Sabbath day.” What then saith Christ?
John 5:17 Homily XXXVIII. John v. 14
If any one say, “And how doth the Father ‘work,’ who ceased on the seventh day from all His works?” let him learn the manner in which He “worketh.” What then is the manner of His working? He careth for,…
John 5:18 Homily XXXVIII. John v. 14
Ver. 18. “Therefore the Jews sought the more to kill Him, because He not only had broken the Sabbath, but said also that God was His Father, making Himself equal with God.”
What does Augustine say about John 5:1–18?
Augustine of Hippo
John 5:2–4 Tractate XVII. Chapter IV. 1–18
He entered a place where lay a great multitude of sick folk—of blind, lame, withered; and being the physician both of souls and bodies, and having come to heal all the souls of them that should believe, of those sick…
John 5:2–4 Tractate XVII. Chapter IV. 1–18
2. Of this pool, which was surrounded with five porches, in which lay a great multitude of sick folk, I remember that I have very often treated; and most of you will with me recollect what I am about to…
John 5:4 Tractate XVII. Chapter IV. 1–18
3. What was done, then, that they who could not be healed in the porches might be healed in that water after being troubled? For on a sudden the water was seen troubled, and that by which it was troubled…
John 5:5 Tractate XVII. Chapter IV. 1–18
4. Now let us see what He intended to signify in the case of that one whom He Himself, keeping the mystery of unity, as I said before, deigned to heal out of so many sick folk. He found in…
John 5:8 Tractate XVII. Chapter IV. 1–18
7. Therefore let us now see the sacred mystery whereby this impotent man is healed by the Lord. The Lord Himself came, the Teacher of love, full of love, “shortening,” as it was predicted of Him, “the word upon the…
John 5:8 Tractate XVII. Chapter IV. 1–18
8. How, then, do we find the two precepts of love indicated in these two commands of the Lord? “Take up thy bed,” saith He, “and walk.” What the two precepts are, my brethren, recollect with me. For they ought…
John 5:9–10 Tractate XVII. Chapter IV. 1–18
10. The man did this, and the Jews were offended. For they saw a man carrying his bed on the Sabbath-day, and they did not blame the Lord for healing him on the Sabbath, that He should be able to…
John 5:13–14 Tractate XVII. Chapter IV. 1–18
11. “But he that was made whole knew not who it was” that had said this to him. “For Jesus,” when He had done this, and given him this order, “turned away from him in the crowd.” See how this…
John 5:15–16 Tractate XVII. Chapter IV. 1–18
12. The man, then, after he saw Jesus, and knew Him to be the author of his healing, was not slothful in preaching Him whom he had seen: “He departed, and told the Jews that it was Jesus that had…
John 5:17 Tractate XVII. Chapter IV. 1–18
14. Let us see, then, the answer made by the Truth: “My Father worketh hitherto, and I work.” Is it false, then, which the Scripture has said, that “God rested from all His works on the seventh day”? And does…
John 5:18 Tractate XVII. Chapter IV. 1–18
16. Further, what said the evangelist as he went on? “Therefore the Jews sought the more to kill Him, because He not only broke the Sabbath, but said also that God was His Father;” not in any ordinary manner, but…
John 5:18 Tractate XVIII. Chapter V. 19
2. Now the Jews were moved and indignant: justly, indeed, because a man dared to make himself equal with God; but unjustly in this, because in the man they understood not the God. They saw the flesh, the God they…
What does Cyril say about John 5:1–18?
Cyril of Alexandria
About the day of the holy Pentecost, Angels coming down from heaven used to trouble the water of the pool, then they would make the plash therefrom the herald of their presence. And the water would be sanctified by the…
John 5:9 Take up thy bed and walk. And immediately the man was made whole, and took up his bed and walked: and on the same day was the sabbath.
God-befitting the injunction, and possessing clearest evidence of power and authority above man. For He prays not for the loosing of his sickness for the patient, lest He too should seem to be as one of the holy Prophets, but…
John 5:10 The Jews therefore said unto him that was cured, It is the sabbath day, it is not lawful for thee to carry thy bed.
Most seasonably (I think) doth He cry over them, Hear now this O foolish people and heartless, which have eyes and see not. For what can be more uninstructed than such people, or what greater in senselessness? For they do…
John 5:11–12 He answered them, He That made me whole, He said unto me, Take up thy bed and walk. They asked him therefore
The sentence is replete with, wisest meaning and repulsive of the stubbornness of the Jews. For in that they say that it is not lawful on the sabbath day to take up his bed and go home, devising an accusation…
John 5:15 The man departed, and told the Jews that it was Jesus Which had made him whole.
He makes Jesus known to the Jews, not that they by daring to do anything against Him should be found to be blasphemers, but in order that, if they too should be willing to be healed by Him, they might…
The narrative does not herein contain the simple relation of the madness of the Jews: for the Evangelist does not shew only that they persecute Him, but why they blush not to do this, saying most emphatically, Because He was…
The mind of the Jews is wound up unto cruelty, and whereby they ought to have been healed, they are the more sick, that they may justly hear, How say ye, WE are wise? For when they ought to have…
What does Aquinas say about John 5:1–18?
Thomas Aquinas
John 5:1–2 After this there was a feast of the Jews; and Jesus went up to Jerusalem.
AUG. After the miracle in Galilee, He returns to Jerusalem: After this there was a feast of the Jews, and Jesus went up to Jerusalem. CHRYS. The feast of Pentecost. Jesus always went up to Jerusalem at the time of…
John 5:3–4 In these lay a great multitude of impotent folk, of blind, halt, withered, waiting for the moving of the water.
CHRYS. This pool was one among many types of that baptism, which was to purge away sin. First God enjoined water for the cleansing from the filth of the body, and from those defilements, which were not real, but legal,…
John 5:3–4 In these lay a great multitude of impotent folk, of blind, halt, withered, waiting for the moving of the water.
AUG. Judging on low and human notions of this miracle, is not at all a striking display of power, and only a moderate one of goodness. Of so many, who lay sick, only one was healed; though, had He chosen,…
John 5:3–5 In these lay a great multitude of impotent folk, of blind, halt, withered, waiting for the moving of the water.
... Though the whole world come, grace fails not, but remains as full as ever; like the sun's rays which give light all day, and every day, and yet are not spent. The sun's light is not diminished by this…
John 5:4–13 For an angel went down at a certain season into the pool, and troubled the water: whosoever then first after the troubling of the water stepped in, was made whole of whatsoever disease he had.
... For the two precepts of our Lord signify love; the love of God being first in order of command, the love of our neighbour, in order of performance. Take up thy bed, our Lord saith, meaning, When thou wert…
John 5:4–5 For an angel went down at a certain season into the pool, and troubled the water: whosoever then first after the troubling of the water stepped in, was made whole of whatsoever disease he had.
AUG. So then Christ came to the Jewish people, and by means of mighty works, and profitable lessons, troubled the sinners, i. the water, and the stirring continued till He brought on His own passion. But He troubled the water,…
John 5:5–6 And a certain man was there, which had an infirmity thirty and eight years.
CHRYS. He did not, however, proceed immediately to heal him, but first tried by conversation to bring him into a believing state of mind. Not that He required faith in the first instance, as He did from the blind man,…
John 5:6–11 When Jesus saw him lie, and knew that he had been now a long time in that case, he saith unto him, Wilt thou be made whole?
BEDE; There is a wide difference between our Lord's mode of healing, and a physician's. He acts by His word, and acts immediately: the other's requires a long time for its completion. CHRYS. This was wonderful, but what follows more…
John 5:6–8 When Jesus saw him lie, and knew that he had been now a long time in that case, he saith unto him, Wilt thou be made whole?
... Nor the other hand did the lame man suspect any mockery in the question, to make him take offence, and say, Hast thou come to vex me, by asking me if I would be made whole; but he answered…
John 5:9 And immediately the man was made whole, and took up his bed, and walked : and on the same day was the sabbath.
CHRYS. Behold the richness of the Divine Wisdom. He not only heals, but bids him carry his bed also. This was to shew the cure was really miraculous, and not a mere effect of the imagination; for the man's limbs…
John 5:12–13 Then asked they him, What man is that which said unto thee, Take up thy bed, and walk ?
CHRYS. Had he been inclined to deal treacherously, he might have said, If it is a crime, accuse Him Who commanded it, and I will lay down my bed. And he would have concealed his cure, knowing, as he did,…
John 5:14 Afterward Jesus findeth him in the temple, and said unto him, Behold, thou art made whole : sin no more, lest a worse thing come unto thee.
CHRYS. The man, when healed, did not proceed to the market place, or give himself up to pleasure or vain glory, but, which was a great mark of religion, went to the temple: Afterward Jesus findeth him in the temple.…
John 5:14 Afterward Jesus findeth him in the temple, and said unto him, Behold, thou art made whole : sin no more, lest a worse thing come unto thee.
CHRYS. Here we learn in the first place, that his disease was the consequence of his sins. We are apt to bear with great indifference the diseases of our souls; but, should the body suffer ever so little hurt, we…
John 5:15 The man departed, and told the Jews that it was Jesus, which had made him whole.
... For he too was told, Thy sins are forgiven thee? The truth is, Christ does not find fault with the man here for his past sins, but only warns him against future. In healing others, however, He makes no…
John 5:16–17 And therefore did the Jews persecute Jesus, and sought to slay him, because he had done these things on the sabbath day.
AUG. This announcement enraged them. And therefore did the Jews persecute Jesus, because He had done these things on the sabbath day. A plain bodily work had been done before their eyes, distinct from the healing of the man's body,…
John 5:16–18 And therefore did the Jews persecute Jesus, and sought to slay him, because he had done these things on the sabbath day.
AUG. He says then, as it were to the Jews, Why think ye that I should not work on the sabbath? The sabbath day was instituted as a type of Me. Ye observe the works of God: by Me all…
John 5:17–18 But Jesus answered them, My Father worketh hitherto, and I work.
AUG. The words, My Father worketh hitherto, and I work, suppose Him to be equal to the Father. This being understood, it followed from the Father's working, that the Son worked: inasmuch as the Father doth nothing without the Son,…
John 5:17 But Jesus answered them, My Father worketh hitherto, and I work.
AUG. There will be a sabbath of the world, when the six ages, i. the six days, as it were, of the world, have passed: then will come that rest which is promised to the saints. AUG. The mystery of…
John 5:18 Therefore the Jews sought the more to kill him, because he not only had broken the sabbath, but said also that God was his Father, making himself equal with God.
CHRYS. And again, had it been that our Lord Himself did not mean this, but that the Jews misunderstood Him, He would not have overlooked their mistake. Nor would the Evangelist have omitted to remark upon it, as he does…
What does Calvin say about John 5:1–18?
John Calvin
John 5:1 There was a feast of the Jews
1. There was a feast of the Jews. Though the Evangelist does not expressly state what feast this was, yet the probable conjecture is that he means Pentecost, at least if what is here related took place immediately after that…
John 5:2 There was in Jerusalem, at the sheep-market, a pool
2. There was in Jerusalem, at the sheep-market, a pool. The circumstance of the place is added, from which we learn that the miracle was not concealed or known to a few persons only; for the five porches show that…
John 5:3 In these lay a great multitude
3. In these lay a great multitude. It is possible that diseased persons lay in the porches to ask alms when the people were passing there who were going into the temple to worship; and there, too, it was customary…
until Christ appear. God saw it to be advantageous to deprive them of the Prophets, and to keep them in suspense for a time, that they might be inflamed with a stronger desire for Christ, and might receive him with…
John 5:3 Of lame, blind, withered
Of lame, blind, withered. For the purpose of informing us that the diseases cured by our Lord were not of an ordinary kind, the Evangelist enumerates some classes of them; for human remedies could be of no avail to the…
John 5:4 For an angel went down
4. For an angel went down. It was, no doubt, a work peculiar to God to cure the sick; but, as He was accustomed to employ the ministration and agency of angels, so He commanded an angel to perform this…
John 5:4 At intervals
At intervals. God might have at once, in a single moment, cured them all:, but, as his miracles have their design, so they ought also to have their limit; as Christ also reminds them that, though there were so many…
John 5:4 And troubled the water
And troubled the water Yet the troubling of the water was a manifest proof that God freely uses the elements according to his own pleasure, and that He claims for himself the result of the work. For it is an…
John 5:5 And there was a man there
5. And there was a man there. The Evangelist collects various circumstances, which prove that the miracle may be relied on as certain. The long duration of the disease had taken away all hope of its being cured. This man…
John 5:6 Wilt thou be made whole?
6. Wilt thou be made whole? He does not inquire about it, as if it were a doubtful matter, but partly in order to kindle in the man a desire of the favor which was offered to him, and partly…
John 5:7 I have no man
7. I have no man. This diseased man does what almost all of us are wont to do; for he limits the assistance of God according to his own thought, and does not venture to promise to himself any thing…
John 5:9 And it was the Sabbath
9. And it was the Sabbath. Christ was well aware how great offense would immediately arise, when they saw a man walk along laden with burdens; for the Law expressly forbids
John 5:10 It is the Sabbath
10. It is the Sabbath. It was the duty of all to maintain the sanctity of the Sabbath, and, therefore, they justly and properly accuse the man. But, when the excuse offered by the man does not satisfy them, they…
We now see how far the Jews were in the wrong. It is, because they do not admit a reasonable defense. The defense is, that he who had been cured replies that he does nothing but by the command of…
John 5:13 And he who had been cured knew not who he was
13. And he who had been cured knew not who he was. Christ certainly did not intend that the glory of so great a work should pass away, but he intended that it should become generally known before that he…
John 5:14 After these things Jesus found him
14. After these things Jesus found him. These words show still more clearly that, when Christ concealed himself for a time, it was not in order that the remembrance of the kindness which he had conferred might perish, for he…
This admonition teaches us also, that all the evils which we endure ought to be imputed to our sins; for the afflictions of men are not accidental, but are so many stripes for our chastisement. First, then, we ought to…
John 5:14 Lest something worse befall thee
Lest something worse befall thee. If God does not succeed in doing us good by the stripes with which he gently chastises us, as the kindest father would chastise his tender and delicate children, He is constrained to assume a…
John 5:15 The man went away
15. The man went away Nothing was farther from his intention than to make Christ an object of their hatred, and nothing was farther from his expectation than that they would rage so furiously against Christ. His intention, therefore, was…
John 5:17 My Father worketh hitherto
17. My Father worketh hitherto. We must see what kind of defense Christ employs. He does not reply that the Law about keeping the Sabbath was temporary, and that it ought now to be abolished; but, on the contrary, maintains…
What is the use of the Sabbath, and for what reasons it was enjoined, I do not now argue at greater length. It is enough for the present passage, that the keeping of the Sabbath is so far from interrupting…
If it be objected, that the example of God is held out to men, that they may rest on the seventh day, the answer is easy. Men are not conformed to God in this respect, that He ceased to work,…
John 5:18 For this reason, therefore, the Jews sought the more to slay him
18. For this reason, therefore, the Jews sought the more to slay him. This defense was so far from allaying their fury that it even enraged them the more. Nor was he unacquainted with their malignity and wickedness and hardened…
What does Lapide say about John 5:1–18?
Cornelius a Lapide
John 5:2 Now there is
Ver. 2. — Now there is . . . sheep-Diarket : Vulgate, Probatica.
John 5:3 In them
... Ver. sick folk ; withered (Vulg.) aridorum, dry, i.e., whose arm, or hand, or foot, or some other limb, was lifeless.
John 5:5 A man having an infirmity
Ver. 5. — A man having an infirmity : Greek and Vulgate. S. Chrysostom and others say that this sick man was a paralytic.
John 5:6 When Jesus saw
Ver. 6. — When Jesus saw, &c. Christ knew well that he had a desire to be healed, but He asked the question — i. To afford the sick man an opportunity for conversation, and from thence of being healed.…
John 5:7 The sick man answered
Ver. 7. — The sick man answered, &c. The sick man does not answer Christ's question directly. He takes for granted that every one knew that he desired to be healed. Therefore he makes mention of the way of obtaining…
... In saying Arise, He caused him to arise, and healed him. As S. Augustine says, " It was not a command of work, but an operation of healing." And S. Cyril, " Such power and virtue were not of…
Ver. 9. — And immediately {Syndic) in that moment . . . for on thai day was the Sabbath. Christ designedly healed upon the Sabbath, both because the Sabbath was the highest festival of the Jews, which therefore it was…
John 5:10 The Jews therefore
Ver. 10. — The Jews therefore, &c. As Nonnus paraphrases, *' Clamorously they uttered an accusing charge, ' It is the Sabbath, which every one ought to keep wholly in rest : it is not lawful for thee to carry…
John 5:11 He answered them
Ver. II, — He answered them, &c. Understand, This was indeed a Divine man, and by Divine power has healed me. Therefore He is a friend of God, and would not bid me do anything except what is pleasing to…
Ver. 12. — llierefore they asked him, &c. Being indignant, they say with threats, " Who is that bold and insolent man, who dare bid thee, contrary to the Law, carry thy bed upon the Sabbath day? Verily, that man…
John 5:13 But he 7vho was healed
Ver. 13. — But he who was healed, &c. The man knew not the name of Jesus, nor whither He had gone, nor indeed who He was, for he had never seen Him before.
Ver. 14. — Aftenvards Jesus, &c. The Arabic is, Now thou art healed, return not to sin, lest a worse evil be done thee.
John 5:15 The man went away, and told
Ver. 15. — The man went away, and told, &c. Not out of malevolence, but from gratitude, that he might not hide the author of so great a kindness. So Augustine, Chrysostom, and others. " He went away and told,"…
Ver, 1 6. — Wherefore the Jews perseaited Jesus, &c. Some Greek MS., also the Syriac and Arabic Versions, add, And sought to kill Him. Wherefore, i.e., on this pretext, for the true cause was envy. For the Jews, especially…
John 5:17 But Jesus answered
... And after an interval, "The power and virtue of the Creator is the cause of existence of every creature. And if this virtue were ever to cease from governing created things, their forms {species) would cease at the same…
John 5:18 Wherefore
Ver. 18. — Wherefore, &c.
What does Henry say about John 5:1–18?
Matthew Henry
John 5:1 The time when this cure was wrought
I. The time when this cure was wrought: it was at a feast of the Jews, that is, the passover, for that was the most celebrated feast. Christ, though residing in Galilee, yet went up to Jerusalem at the feast,…
John 5:2–4 The place where this cure was wrought
II. The place where this cure was wrought: at the pool of Bethesda, which had a miraculous healing virtue in it, and is here particularly described, v. 2-4.
John 5:3 How it was frequented with sick and cripples
4. How it was frequented with sick and cripples (v. 3): In these lay a great multitude of impotent folks. How many are the afflictions of the afflicted in this world! How full of complaints are all places, and what…
John 5:4 What virtue it had for the cure of these impotent folks
5. What virtue it had for the cure of these impotent folks (v. 4). An angel went down, and troubled the water; and whoso first stepped in was made whole. That this strange virtue in the pool was natural, or…
(1.) The preparation of the medicine by an angel, who went down into the pool, and stirred the water. Angels are God's servants, and friends to mankind; and perhaps are more active in the removing of diseases (as evil angels…
John 5:4 The operation of the medicine
(2.) The operation of the medicine: Whoever first stepped in was made whole. here is, [1.] miraculous extent of the virtue as to the diseases cured; what disease soever it was, this water cured it. Natural and artificial baths are…
Now this is all the account we have of this standing miracle; it is uncertain when it began and when it ceased. Some conjecture it began when Eliashib the high priest began the building of the wall about Jerusalem, and…
John 5:5 The patient on whom this cure was wrought
III. The patient on whom this cure was wrought (v. 5): one that had been infirm thirty-eight years. 1. His disease was grievous: He had an infirmity, a weakness; he had lost the use of his limbs, at least on…
John 5:6 The cure and the circumstances of it briefly related
IV. The cure and the circumstances of it briefly related, v. 6-9.
John 5:6 He asked him, Wilt thou be made whole
3. He asked him, Wilt thou be made whole? A strange question to be asked one that had been so long ill. Some indeed would not be made whole, because their sores serve them to beg by and serve them…
4. The poor impotent man takes this opportunity to renew his complaint, and to set forth the misery of his case, which makes his cure the more illustrious: Sir, I have no man to put me into the pool, v.…
... But a step between him and a cure, and yet he continues impotent. None had the charity to say, "Your case is worse than mine, do you go in now, and I will stay till the next time;" for…
John 5:8 The word he said
(1.) The word he said: Rise, take up thy bed, v. 8. [1.] He is bidden to rise and walk; a strange command to be given to an impotent man, that had been long disabled; but this divine word was…
... First, To make it to appear that it was a perfect cure, and purely miraculous; for he did not recover strength by degrees, but from the extremity of weakness and impotency he suddenly stepped into the highest degree of…
John 5:9 The efficacy of this word
(2.) The efficacy of this word (v. 9): a divine power went alone with it, and immediately he was made whole, took up his bed, and walked. [1.] He felt the power of Christ's word healing him: Immediately he was…
(1.) The Jews quarrelled with the man for carrying his bed on the sabbath day, telling him that it was not lawful, v. 10. It does not appear whether they were magistrates, who had power to punish him, or common…
John 5:11 The man justified himself in what he did by a warrant that would bear him out
(2.) The man justified himself in what he did by a warrant that would bear him out, v. 11. "I do not do it in contempt of the law and the sabbath, but in obedience to one who, by making…
John 5:12 The Jews enquired further who it was that gave him this warrant
(3.) The Jews enquired further who it was that gave him this warrant (v. 12): What man is that? Observe, How industriously they overlooked that which might be a ground of their faith in Christ. They enquire not, no, not…
John 5:13 The poor man was unable to give them any account of him
(4.) The poor man was unable to give them any account of him: He wist not who he was, v. 13.
John 5:13 For the present he kept himself unknown
[2.] For the present he kept himself unknown; for as soon as he had wrought the cure he conveyed himself away, he made himself unknown (so some read it), a multitude being in that place. This is mentioned to show,…
John 5:14 What passed between him and our Lord Jesus at their next interview
2. What passed between him and our Lord Jesus at their next interview, v. 14. Observe here,
John 5:14 What he said to him
(2.) What he said to him. When Christ has cured us, he has not done with us; he now applies himself to the healing of his soul, and this by the word too. [1.] He gives him a memento of…
... The misery we were made whole from warns us to sin no more, having felt the smart of sin; the mercy we were made whole by is an engagement upon us not to offend him who healed us. This…
John 5:15 Now, after this interview between Christ and his patient, observe in the two following verses, 1
VI. Now, after this interview between Christ and his patient, observe in the two following verses, 1. The notice which the poor simple man gave to the Jews concerning Christ, v. 15. He told them it was Jesus that had…
John 5:17 The doctrine laid down, by which he justified what he did on the sabbath day
I. The doctrine laid down, by which he justified what he did on the sabbath day (v. 17): He answered them. This supposes that he had something laid to his charge: or what they suggested one to another, when they…
... Now God rested only from such work as he had done the six days before; otherwise he worketh hitherto, he is every day working, sabbath days and week-days, upholding and governing all the creatures, and concurring by his common…
John 5:18 The offence that was taken at his doctrine
II. The offence that was taken at his doctrine (v. 18): The Jews sought the more to kill him. His defence was made his offence, as if by justifying himself he had made bad worse. Note, Those that will not…
What does Bengel say about John 5:1–18?
Johann Albrecht Bengel
a feast) The following authorities recognise this feast to be Pentecost: Epiphanius, Chrysostom, Cyril, Euthymius, Theophylact, the old Gospel harmony published by ... Erasmus in his paraphrase, Maldonatus, Calvin, Piscator, Bullinger in his Acts, p. 4; comp. ... And that…
a pool) About baths there is frequently the ... in the Hebrew tongue) This book, therefore, was not written in Hebrew; otherwise this adverb would be redundant. They were therefore Hellenists,! for whose sake John wrote in Greek, and perhaps…
lay) Therefore many were there during the whole time :” such at least was the case with this impotent man whom the Lord healed; for he had no one [to put him in], ver. 7. ... the moving) by which…
lying) He seems by this time to have habitually given up the attempt to get before others. ... knowing) though no one informed Him. ... He saith) of His own accord. Christ gives both a handle for His seeking aid,…
rise) Jesus heals the sick man, without entering the pool. He was therefore greater than the angel ... take up) This work, which was the more conspicuous on the Sabbath day, tended to the greater glory of God in Jesus…
withdrew) use this verb to express ... Jesus shunned noise. Matt. xii. 16, etc., “ He charged them that they should not make Him known ;—He shall not strive, nor cry, neither shall any man hear His voice in the…
reported) He wished to please the Jews, who had asked him the question, ver. 12: nor however did he bring them back word with bad intention ; for whereas he had said at ver. 11, 6 ... He who made…
More modern copies have inserted this here from ver. 18.1 The attempt to kill is opposed to persecution, properly so called. ... My Father) In what sense Jesus said, My Father, even the Jews themselves understood better than the ...…
the more) There is a gradation : lately they were persecuting Him; now further they seek to kill Him. ... He was breaking) by act, ver. 8, “ Take up thy bed ;” and by word, ver. 17, “ My…
What does Wesley say about John 5:1–18?
John Wesley
John 5:1 A feast
1. A feast - Pentecost.
John 5:2 There is in Jerusalem
2. There is in Jerusalem - Hence it appears, that St. John wrote his Gospel before Jerusalem was destroyed: it is supposed about thirty years after the ascension. Having five porticos - Built for the use of the sick. Probably…
John 5:4 An angel
4. An angel - Yet many undoubtedly thought the whole thing to be purely natural. At certain times - Perhaps at a certain hour of the day, during this paschal week, went down - The Greek word implies that he…
John 5:7 The sick man answered
7. The sick man answered - Giving the reason why he was not made whole, notwithstanding his desire.
John 5:14 Sin no more
14. Sin no more - It seems his former illness was the effect or punishment of sin.
John 5:15 The man went and told the Jews, that it was Jesus who had made him whole
15. The man went and told the Jews, that it was Jesus who had made him whole - One might have expected, that when he had published the name of his benefactor, crowds would have thronged about Jesus, to have…
John 5:17 My Father worketh until now, and I work
17. My Father worketh until now, and I work - From the creation till now he hath been working without intermission. I do likewise. This is the proposition which is explained ver. 19-30, confirmed and vindicated in ver. 31 and…
John 5:18 His own Father
18. His own Father - The Greek word means his own Father in such a sense as no creature can speak. Making himself equal with God - It is evident all the hearers so understood him, and that our Lord…
What does Ryle say about John 5:1–18?
J. C. Ryle
John 5:1–15 JOHN V. 1—15.
We are taught, for one thing, in this passage, what misery sin has brought into the world. We read of a man who had been ill for no less than thirty-eight years ! For eight-and-thirty weary summers and winters he…
John 5:1 After this
Literally translated, this would be, "after these things." Some think that when St. John is telling some event which follows immediately after the last thing narrated, be uses the expression, " after this thing " (as John ii. 12), but…
The matter is really of no peculiar importance. In one point of view only it is interesting. — If the "feast" was the passover, it proves that there were four passovers during the period of our Lords ministry on earth.…
John 5:1 Jesus went up
The frequency of our Lord's attendance at Jewish feasts, and the respect He showed for Mosaic ordinances, should always be noticed. They were appointed by God. and so long as they lasted, He gave them honour. It is an important…
John 5:2 there is at Jerusalem
These words, it is thought, show that Jerusalem was yet standing, and not taken and destroyed by the Romans, when John wrote his Gospel. Otherwise, it is argued, he would have said, " There was at Jerusalem."
John 5:2 called in the Hebrew tongue Bethesda
The word "Bethesda," according to Cruden, means " house of effusion," or " house of pity or mercy." It is not mentioned anywhere else in the Bible. The mention of the " Hebrew tongue," shows again that John did not…
John 5:3 In these lay a great multitude
The context seems to show that the multitude were assembled at this particular feast in this place, expecting a certain miracle to be wrought, which only took place at this particular time of the year.
John 5:4 For an angel went down, &c.
The thing we are here told is very curious. There is nothing like it in the Bible, Josephus, the Jewish writer, does not mention it. The simplest view is that it was a standing miracle wrought once every year, as…
All other attempts to get over the difficulties of the passage are thoroughly unsatisfactory. To condemn the passage as not genuine, is a lazy way of cutting the knot, and not at all clearly warranted by the authority of manuscripts.…
After all there is no more real difficulty in the account before us, than in the history of our Lord's temptation in the wilderness, the various cases of Satanic possession, or the release of Peter from prison by an angel.…
John 5:5 infirmity thirty and eight years
This means the length of time during which the sick man had been ilL How old he was we do not know.
John 5:6 When Jesus saw...knew...long time
We need not doubt that our Lord knew this man's history by that divine knowledge which, as God, He possesses of all things in heaven and earth. To suppose that He ascertained by inquiry the state of his case before…
John 5:6 Wilt thou be made whole
The English language here fails to give the fuU force of the Greek. It means, "Hast thou a will? Dost thou wish? Dost thou desire to be made whole?" The question was perhaps meant to awaken desire and expectation in…
John 5:7 The impotent man answered him, Sir
The word rendered "Sir" is the same that is more commonly rendered "Lord." It is the same that is rendered " Sir " all through the fourth chapter, in the history of the Samaritan woman.
John 5:8 Rise, take up thy bed, and walk
Here, as in other similar cases, it is evident that miraculous healing power went forth with the words of our Lord. Thus, " Stretch forth thy hand " (Mark iii. 5) ; " Go show yourselves to the priests "…
- Augustine finds in the command, " Take up thy bed," an exhortation to the love of our neighbours, because we are to bear one another's burdens; and in the command, " walk," an exhortation to love God ! Such…
John 5:10 The Jews
Here, as in many places in St. John's Gospel, the expression, " the Jews," when used of the Jews at Jerusalem, means the leaders of the people, — elders, rulers, and scribes. It does not mean vaguely the "Jewish crowd"…
John 5:11 He that made me whole, the same said, &c.
The answer of the man seems simple. But it contains a deep principle. " He that has done so great a thing to me was surely to be obeyed, when He told me to take up my bed. If He…
John 5:12 What man is that which said...Take up thy bed, &c.
Ecolampadius, Grotius, and many others, remark what an example this question is of the malevolent and malicious spirit of the Jews. Instead of asking, " who healed thee ?" they asked " who told thee to carry thy bed ?"…
John 5:13 wist not who it was
It is most probable that the cripple really knew not who it was that had healed him, and had only seen our Lord that day for the first time. He was ignorant of His name, and only knew Him as…
John 5:14 Afterward...temple
It is not clear how long a time elapsed before our Lord found the man whom He had healed in the Temple. If the theory be correct to which I adverted in the note on the first verse, there must…
Besser remarks, — "It is a dreadful thing, when the correction and mercy of Divine love wearies itself with a man in va'n. You that are sick, write over your beds, when you rise up from them in renewed health,…
John 5:15 departed, and told the Jews
There is no proof that the man did this with anj evil design. Born a Jew, and taught to reverence his rulers and elders, he naturally wished to give them the information they desired, and had no reason to suppose,…
John 5:16–23 JOHN V. 16—23.
We learn, for one thing, from the verses before us, that there are some works which it is lawful to do on the Sabbath day.
John 5:16 therefore...Jews persecute, &c.
The verbs in this verse are all in the imperfect tense. It may be doubted whether the meaning is not, strictly speaking, something of this kind : — " The Jews from this time began to persecute Jesus, and were…
John 5:17 But Jesus answered
This seems to have been the first reply which our Lord made when charged with breaking the fourth commandment. It was a short, simple justification of the lawfulness of doing works of mercy on the Sabbath. There seems to have…
Two things should be observed in this sentence. One is the plain practical lesson that the Sabbath was not meant to be a day of total idleness, and of entire cessation from all kinds and sorts of work. " The…
Chrysostom remarks on this verse : — " If any one say, ' How doth the Father work, who ceased on the seventh day from all His works ? ' let him learn the manner in which He worketh. What…
John 5:18 Therefore the Jews sought the more to kill him
This short defence which our Lord made seems to have rankled in the minds of the Jews, and to have made them even more bitter against Him. What length of time is covered by this verse is not very plain.…
John 5:18 said also...his Father...equal with God
It is clear that our Lord's words about His Sonship struck the Jews in a far more forcible way than they seem to strike us. In a certain sense all believers are " sons of God." (Rom, viii. 14.) Bat…
Ferus remarks that the Jews probably took notice of our Lord calling God " My Father," and not " our Father." — Cartwright also thinks that there is much weight in the expression "my," and that the Jews gathered from…
What does Westcott say about John 5:1–18?
B. F. Westcott
John 5:1 After this...
There is a slight difference between after this ..., and after these things .... The former implies a connexion of some kind (of time or dependence) between the preceding and subsequent events, which is not suggested by the latter.
John 5:2–9 The sign (vv. 2—9 a).
The healing of the impotent man was a work wrought by the Lord spontaneously. He chose both the object of it and the occasion. The malady of the sufferer was not urgent in such a sense that the cure could…
John 5:2 there is at Jerusalem
The use of the present tense does not prove that the narrative was written before the destruction of Jerusalem. It is quite natural that St John in recalling the event should speak of the place as he knew it. It…
John 5:2 in the Hebrew
that is, in the language " of those beyond the river " brought from Babylon, and not in the classical language of the Old Testament. Compare Lightfoot ad loc. Bethesda] The original reading and the meaning of the name are…
John 5:3–4 3—4.
The words from waiting for. ..he had are not part of the original text of St John, but form a very early note added to explain v. 7, while the Jewish tradition with regard to the pool was still fresh.…
A similar scene is still presented by the hot sulphureous springs near Tiberias (Hammath, Josh. xix. 35) : Tristram, ' Land of Israel,' 416.
John 5:4 an angel
Comp. Rev. xvi. 5.
John 5:5 thirty and eight years
This period of time, corresponding with the period of the punishment of the Israelites in the wilderness, has led many, from a very early date, to regard the man as a type of the Jewish people paralysed by faithlessness at…
John 5:6 saw him lie, and knew
by the information of bystanders, or (more probably) by His divine intuition (see p. 46). The life of this sick man was open to Him (v. 14), just as the life of the Samaritan woman (iv. 1 8). It is…
The sufferer answers the thought which underlay the inquiry. The delay in his healing was due, as he explains, not to want of will but to want of means.
John 5:8 bed
The word ..., said to be of Macedonian origin, which is used here, occurs Mark ii. 4 ff. (note), vi. 55; Acts v. 15, ix. 33. It describes technically the bed of the poor — "a pallet."
John 5:9–18 The immediate sequel of the sign (9^—18).
In this section the various elements of the coming conflict .are brought out distinctly; the significance of the cure as a work of power and judgment (v. 14), the accusations of the Jews (vv. 10, 1 6, 1 8), the…
John 5:9 and on...the sabbath
A new paragraph begins with these words : Now on that day was a sabbath, which prepares the way for the subsequent discourse. The form of the phrase is very remarkable (comp. ix. 14, xix. 31), and suggests the idea…
John 5:10 The Jews
See Introd. pp. ix, x. unto him that was (had been) cured] The word and tense are contrasted with those found in v. 13.
John 5:11 He answered them
... The authority of One who had wrought the miracle seemed to him to outweigh any legal enactment. He felt instinctively the presence of that which was greater than the sabbath.
John 5:12 Then asked they...What man...which said
They asked, Who Is the man that said... The introduction of the man marks the spirit of the inquiry, and suggests the contrast between the Divine Law and this (assumed) human teacher, who claimed to deal with it by his…
John 5:13 And he that...in that place
But he that... in the place.
John 5:14 Afterward
After these things. Comp. v. 1, note.
John 5:15 The man departed
It is difficult to understand the motive of the man in conveying this information to the Jews, since he knew the hostile spirit in which they regarded the cure. He was certainly not ungrateful, for he still speaks of Jesus…
John 5:16 And therefore
This is the first open declaration of hostility to Christ (though the words and sought to slay him, which are wrongly added in this verse from v. 18, must be omitted) ; and it is based upon the alleged violation…
The answer (see v. 19, note) of Christ contains in the briefest possible space the exposition of His office: My Father (ii. 16, xx. 17) worketh hitherto ..., even until now, and I work. That is to say, the rest…
John 5:17 hitherto
even until now. The work of Christ which had excited the hostility of the Jews was, however little they could see it, really coincident with a working of God which knows no interruption.
The Jews rightly interpreted the words of the Lord. They saw that He claimed the power of abrogating the law of the Sabbath in virtue of His absolutely special relation to God: He called God His own Father (Rom. viii.…