Logia

Cornelius a Lapide · The Great Commentary: S. John's Gospel

John 2

18 excerpts on John 2, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

John 2:1

On the third day, &c. The third day, tliat is, from Christ's departure for Galilee, and the calling of Philip. For this was the last date mentioned by S. John.

The following is the sequence of these days in the life of Christ. ... On the same day, after dinner, He retired into the desert, where He fasted forty days. ... Then he returned to Nazareth, where He abode fifteen days. Directly afterwards, that is to say, on the fiftysixth day after His baptism, as S. Epiplianius says {Hares. 51), or the I St of March, tlie Jews sent messengers to Jolin the Baptist, to ask him whether he were the Christ or not? ... On the morrow, or March 4, Jesus went into Galilee, where He called Philip. Since this was the second day from the coming of Andrew with his brother Peter to Christ, it must have been on the third day, or March 5, when the wedding-feast took place. Wherefore S. Epiphanius, in the place already cited, says that it took place on the sixtieth day from Christ's bai)tism. ... He testifies this of the fountain of Gerasa in Arabia. He says that he himself had drank of the fountain of Cibyris in Cana thus turned into wine on the day and hour when the miracle was wrought. He says that many in Egypt bear the same testimony with regard to the Nile. ... But the chronological table given above shows this to be a mistake.

John 2:1 · Open Word Bible

1On the third day a wedding was held at Cana in Galilee, and Jesus's mother was there.

Report a mistake

John 2:4

... Meaning, What have I to do with thee in this matter ? {Quid mihi tecum in hac re est negotii?) Observe, the Blessed Virgin did not out of ostentation, or in an untimely, unbecoming, or indiscreet fashion ask this miracle of her Son, as S. Chrysostom, Theophylact, and Euthymius think : but out of necessary charity and piety, as SS.

Cyril, Bernard, and others say. Tiierefore there was no blame attaching to her. Therefore Christ did not really blame her. And yet He seems to reprove her, that He might teach, not her, but us, that in things pertaining to God, and miracles, parents have no right or authority. They must not be done in accordance with their affections and desires, but only for God and charity's sake. The meaning, therefore, is this, "Thou, O Mother, in this matter, art not My Mother, but as it were another woman. For, from thee I have received human nature, not Divinity. It belongs to My Divine nature to work this miracle, not in accordance with thy desires, and those of relations, but in accordance with the will of God My Father. According to that will I shall work, when the hour and time decreed by God shall come." Hear S. Augustine on this passage : " The word woman is used simply to express the female sex." "He, as God," says Euthymius, "said not 'Mother,' but 'woman.'" "He means," says S. Bede, "that He had not received in time from His Mother the Divinity by which He was about to perform a miracle, but that He had It eternally from the Father." "He means to say," says the Interlinear Gloss, "What is there in common between My Divinity and thee My Mother according to the flesh?" "Thou didst not beget, or produce {genuisti) My Divmity, which works the miracle," says S. Augustine. S. Chrysostom adds, " He speaks thus, lest the miracle should seem to be the result of collusion. He should have been asked by those who needed the wine, not by His Mother."

John 2:4 · Open Word Bible

4Jesus said to her, "Woman, is that a matter for you and Me? My hour has not yet come."

Report a mistake

John 2:5

Ver. 5. — His Afother saith, Sic. His mother modestly holds her peace, and rightly yields to her Son, as being the Son of God. Although the Son seems to deny His Mother, the Mother knows His filial piety. Therefore with all confidence she bids the servants what to do. S. Gaudentius comments in these words, " The Mother would not have said. Whatsoever He saith wito you do it, unless being full of the Holy Ghost from her birth she had foreseen the whole process of Christ's turning the water into wine." Wherefore S. Bernard on these words {Horn. 2) says, '* I see plainly that it was not as being wroth, or as wishing to confound the shrinking modesty of His Virgin Mother, that He said, What have I to do with thee-, but for our sakes, that the care of parents according to the flesh should not trouble those who are converted to the Lord." For Christ presently obeys His Mother, and to honour her performs the miracle. Hear S. Chrj'sostom : " Although He answered thus, yet He complied with His Mother's prayer, that He might give honour to her, and not seem stubborn {contianax) to her, nor put her to shame when so many were present." And Euthymius says, " How very greatly He honoured her is plain from many other reasons, and also from this, that He fulfilled her exhortation."

John 2:5 · Open Word Bible

5His mother said to the servants, "Do as He tells you, whatever it is."

Report a mistake

John 2:6

Ver. 6. — There were set, &c.

Purification : by which the Jews according to their traditions were accustomed at their feasts ceremonially to wash their hands, if they happened to touch anything unclean at the table. (See S. Mark vii. 3.)

Tropologically, S. Bernard expounds thus {Serm. i, itt Domin. i, post. Oct. Epiph.) : Tlie six waterpots are the six purifying virtues of the soul, " The first waterpot, and the first cleansing, is in compunction, of which we read, that in the very hour in which the sinner shall groan, I will no more remember all their iniquities. The second is confession ; for all things are washed by confession. The third is the giving of alms ; for we read in the Gospel, ' Give alms, and behold all things are clean unto you.' The fourth, forgiveness of injuries ; for we say when we pray, * Forgive us our debts, for we also forgive those who are indebted to us.' The fifth is affliction of the body ; for we pray that we, being purified by abstinence, may sing glory to God. The sixth is obedience to the commandments : even as the disciples heard what may we too deserve to hear, ' Ye are clean through the word which I have spoken unto you.' " He then applies the rest as follows : " They are filled with water, that they may be kept in the fear of God, since the fear of the Lord is a fountain of life." Then he adds: "But by the Divine power the water is changed into wine when perfect love casts out fear. Now the waterpots are said to be of stone, not because of hardness, but for steadfastness ; for they contained two or three firkins apiece,"

John 2:6 · Open Word Bible

6Six stone water jars stood there, kept for Jewish ritual washing; each held about 20 to 30 gallons.

Report a mistake

John 2:7

... S. Chrysostom asks, "But why did not He Himself fill the waterpots with water, and then turn it into wine?" He gives the right answer, saying, in order that He might have them as witnesses to the miracle who liad drawn the water, lest any fraud or trickery should be supposed.

John 2:7 · Open Word Bible

7Jesus said to them, "Fill the jars with water." They filled them up to the top.

Report a mistake

John 2:8

And Jesus saith

Ver. 8. — And Jesus saith, &c. Draw out of the great waterpots, and pour into smaller vessels, and carry it to the master of the feast, and let him judge how good the wine is. As Christ said this, He in one moment by His Almighty power changed the whole of the water in the six waterpots into wine. Listen to Nonnus : " Suddenly was the miracle wrought ; and the water, changing its colour, flowed with a ruddy glow instead of its own pale colour, and was changed into purple wine." As S. Cyril says, " What is difficult to Almighty God, or why should not He, who called all things into being out of nothing, much more easily change one thing into another ? "

From this conversion of water into wine, the Fathers prove the conversion of bread and wine in the Eucharist into the Body and Blood of Christ. And they add that it seems to be a greater miracle for Christ to turn water into wine than wine into blood. For wine is nearer akin to blood than water is to wine. So S. Cyril of Jerusalem {Cat. 4), S. Cyprian (Epist. cont. ... 3, c. 11). S. Isidore of Pelusium asks (/. i, Epist. 393) why Christ willed this to be His first miracle? He gives the answer mystically, that it was because He wished to supply what was wanting to the Law. " For the Law," he says, " only baptized with water, but He perfected the sacred initiation with His own Blood, joining both in Himself, and uniting the Law with grace." For water was the symbol of the old Law, which purified all things by water, but only with a corporeal cleansing. But wine is the symbol of the Blood of Christ, which, being shed upon the cross, cleanses souls. For Christ changes wine into His own Blood in the Eucharist.

John 2:8 · Open Word Bible

8Then He said to them, "Now dip some out and carry it to the man in charge of the feast." And they did.

Report a mistake

John 2:9

When the governor of the feast

Ver. 9. — When the governor of the feast. &c. Tasted: he did not give credit entirely to the smell and ruddy colour, but he tasted, and found that it was the very best and most excellent wine. For tasting was the surest way of judging.

Vers.), i.e., exhilarated. For intoxication in Scripture often means a liberal draught which gladdens the mind, but does not deprive it of the use of reason. For if these guests had been really drunk, surely Jesus would never have turned water into wine for them, for then He would have assisted and encouraged their drunkenness. Much rather would He have put a stop to tlieir potations, and sent them home. And the Blessed Virgin would have done the same.

Then that which is worse: because, when the stomach is filled with wine, it is a poor judge of the quality. This is a type of the deceitfulness of the world, which at the beginning presents things that are fair to the eye, and afterwards brings in what is vile and worthless, and so deceives and deludes its lovers.

John 2:9 · Open Word Bible

9The man in charge of the feast tasted the water that had become wine. He had no idea where it had come from, though the servants who had drawn the water knew. He called the bridegroom over

Report a mistake

John 2:11

This beginning

Ver. II. — This beginning, &c. ; glory, i.e., His Omnipotence and Divinity. And believed, i.e., their faith grew.

Beginning. From hence the Fathers gather passim that this miracle was absolutely the first which Christ publicly wrought. This is the refutation of the book on the " Infancy of the Saviour," condemned by Pope Gelasius, which was forged by the heretics ; and in which it is related that Christ publicly wrought miracles when He was yet a boy. Yet there is no reason, says Maldonatus, against our thinking that Christ may have wrought miracles privately before, and may by them have assisted the poverty of His parents. It might seem as if His Mother, animated by the recollection of such, had here asked for, and expected, a similar miracle. But Christ could have relieved His Mother's wants by some special providence short of a miracle.

You will ask why Christ willed this to be His first miracle ? I reply, because it was especially appropriate to the time, the place, and the persons. For wine is the most noble beverage, which makes glad both God and man (Judges ix. 13). Wherefore Noah, immediately after the Deluge, discovered wine, and was a type of Christ here making wine. Again, Christ by this miracle showed that He is the self-same Being who, year by year, does the same thing in the vines by converting their watery sap into wine. " The 90 s. JOHN, c. IT.

John 2:11 · Open Word Bible

11Jesus did this at Cana in Galilee as the first of the signs. In it He revealed His glory, and His disciples believed in Him.

Report a mistake

John 2:12

Ver. 12. — After this Jesus went dotvn, &c. After the marriage Jesus returned with His Mother and friends to their house at Nazareth. Nazareth was situated upon higher ground, so that He would descend from it to Capharnaum, which was on ground sloping down to the Sea of Galilee. The reason why He went was because He did not wish to make Nazareth, a poor and ignoble town, and by whose inhabitants He was despised as a carpenter, and the son of a carpenter, the headquarters of His preaching. For this He destined Capharnaum, which was by the sea-side, and famous for its commerce and concourse of people, so that He might have more fruit of His ministry.

Now this journey of Christ took place before the imprisonment of John the Baptist, as may be clearly gathered from chaps, iii. 24 and iv. I. It was different therefore from that of which S. Matthew speaks (iv. 13). For that took place after John was put in prison, when Christ actually transferred His place of abode to Capharnaum, and there opened a public school of His doctrine and teaching. The present occasion was only preparatory. This visit was only by the way, as it were in transitu, intending to proceed from hence to Jerusalem to keep the Passover, which was now nigh at hand. So Jansen.

John 2:12 · Open Word Bible

12After this He went down to Capernaum, together with His mother, His brothers and His disciples. They did not stay there many days.

Report a mistake

John 2:17

His disciples remembered

Yer. 17. — His disciples remembered, &c. This zeal of Christ was riguteous indignation, says Euthymius, or rather ardour to do away with what was repugnant to God's honour, so that He boldly exposed Himself, His life and PI is good name, to defend the honour of God, whom He loved above all things. For Christ did this before the proud and covetous Scribes and Pharisees, who opposed Him. The meaning then is, '' The zeal, that is, the burning desire, of caring for the glory of Thy Temple, in which thou, O Lord, dwellest as Thine abode, and the indignation which I have conceived against the traders who profane it, have eaten, that is, have absorbed Me." Symmachus translates consumed Me, as fire eats away iron, and so transmutes it into itself, that it no longer seems to be iron, but fire itself.

S. Augustine asks, " Who is eaten up with zeal for the house of God ? " and answers, " He who strives to amend everything which he sees amiss. He does not rest if he cannot rectify it. He groans and says within himself, ' My zeal has caused me to consume away because mine enemies have forgotten Thy words'" (Ps. cxix. 139). Wherefore Bede saith, on this passage, " Let us have zeal for the house of God, my brethren. If we see a brother who belongs to the house of God swelling with pride, given to detraction, a slave to drunkenness, enervated with luxury, disturbed by anger, or subject to any other fault, let us strive, so far as in us lies, to rebuke iiim, to amend what is corrupt and perverse. And if we are powerless to amend any of these things, let us not endure them without the most bitter grief. And especially in the house of prayer, where the Body of God is consecrated, where without doubt the angels are always present, let no folly take place, let us strive with all our might that nothing may hincier our own, or our brethren's prayers."

John 2:17 · Open Word Bible

17His disciples remembered that it is written: "Zeal for Your house will devour Me."

Report a mistake

John 2:18

... Meaning, what miracle dost Thou show, that Thou takest upon Thyself, contrary to the custom, to cast the sellers out of the Temple, as having received authority from God : for from man. that is, from pontiff or governor, we know Thou hast none ? For Christ had intimated that He was sent by God, yea, that He was the Son of God ; for He had said (ver, 16), Make fwt My Father's house a house of merchandise. They ask Him therefore to prove that He was the Son of God, and Messiah, even as Moses had shown signs and prodigies from heaven, by which he demonstrated to Pharaoh and the Egyptians that he was sent by God. So Ruperti.

John 2:18 · Open Word Bible

18The Jewish leaders then said to Him, "What sign do You show us to justify doing these things?"

Report a mistake

John 2:19

Jesus answered

Ver. 19. — -Jesus answered, &c. Appositely does He prove His authority over the Temple by His power of rebuilding the Temple.

This Temple, viz., His body, which Christ pointed out by moving His hand to His breast. Observe : the Body of Christ is called a temple because in It dwelt the fulness of the Deity, not merely by grace as it dwells in us, but corporeally and personally (Col. ii. 9). So S. Cyril. As though He said, " You, O ye incredulous Jews, ask of Me a sign, or a miracle ; lo, I give you one, even My resurrection from the dead. This thing is now indeed dark unto you, because ye are unbelieving. But after a little while ye will understand it, or at least ye might easily understand, when ye shall see that I am risen on the third day. For then ye shall understand who I am, and how great I was, that I was in truth the Lord of My own Body, that of My own will I gave Myself to die, and rose to life again. Thus, in consequence, ye may understand that much more am I the Lord of this Temple, which is only a type and shadow of My Body ; and therefore that I have power to cast out of it the buyers and sellers." So Bede.

John 2:19 · Open Word Bible

19Jesus replied, "Tear this temple down, and I will raise it up again within three days."

Report a mistake

John 2:20

The Jews then said

Ver. 20. — The Jews then said, &c. There were three buildings of the Temple of Jerusalem. The first was by Solomon, and occupied seven years. The second was the rebuilding after its destruction by the Babylonians, by Zorobabel and his companions, under Cyrus, King of Persia. This rebuilding occupied fifteen years only, though many ancient and modern writers have erroneously supposed it to have occupied forty-six years, and to have been here referred to by the Jews. The third was the rebuilding of the Temple by Herod of Ascalon, who murdered the innocents of Bethlehem. He built the Temple afresh for the Jews, in order that he might secure the kingdom for himself and his posterity, and that he might be accounted by them as the true Messiah. And it is exceedingly probable that the Jews were here referring to this rebuilding from their use of the pronoun this. For "this" points out an existing Temple. And inasmuch as the two former Temples were destroyed, they could not be thus pointed out. Herod began his erection of the third Temple in the eighteenth year of his reign. For it was at that time he made known his intention of rebuilding the Temple, as Josephus testifies {Ant., lib. 15, c. 14). Wherefore, since Christ was born in the thirty-fifth year of the reign of Herod, as I have shown on Luke ii. i, it follows that from his beginning to build until the birth of Christ, sixteen years had elapsed. Add thirty years of the life of Christ and you have forty-six. For it was in His thirtieth year, in which also He was baptized, that Christ had this disputation with the Jews.

John 2:20 · Open Word Bible

20The Jewish leaders said, "Forty-six years this temple has been under construction, and You will raise it up in three days?"

Report a mistake

John 2:21

Ver. 21. — Btit He spake, &c. S. Chrysostom asks, "Why He did not explain to them, being in doubt, that He called His flesh the Temple?" and answers that "since they had no belief in Him, even if He had explained the Jews would have derided Him, and treated Him still worse."

John 2:21 · Open Word Bible

21But the temple He meant was His own body.

Report a mistake

John 2:22

When therefore He ivas risen

Ver. 22. — When therefore He ivas risen, &c. They believed the Scripture, which foretold that Christ would rise from the dead. This, which they did not previously understand, they understood when they saw it actually fulfilled in the resurrection of Christ. Such a Scripture is that verse of the Psalms (xvi. 10), "Thou shalt not leave My soul in hell, nor suffer Thine Holy One to see corruption."

John 2:22 · Open Word Bible

22Later, when He had been raised from the dead, His disciples remembered that He had said this, and they believed the Scripture and what Jesus had said.

Report a mistake

John 2:23

But when He was at Jerusalem

Ver. 23. — But when He was at Jerusalem, &c. They believed in His name, that is, that He bore truly the name of Messiah, or Christ, as He Himself named Himself, and was so publicly named and celebrated by the faithful.

John 2:23 · Open Word Bible

23During the Passover festival, while He was in Jerusalem, many came to believe in His name as they watched the signs He was doing.

Report a mistake

John 2:24

Ver. 24. — But Jesus didvoi, I'vrc. ... For although He knew that they believed in Him, yet He also knew that they were fickle, and would easily fall back from this faith, and be perverted by His numerous enemies, the Scribes and Pharisees. For the authority and power of those men was great. For this reason Christ neither securely, nor for long, conversed with them, but went away into other parts of Judea, for He knew not only what they were then doing and thinking, but what they were hereafter about to think and do against Him, to persecute Him even unto the death of the cross.

John 2:24 · Open Word Bible

24But Jesus, for His part, would not trust Himself to them, because He knew all people.

Report a mistake

John 2:25

For He had no need

Ver. 25. — For He had no need, &c. For He was searching the heart of each, whether it were constant, or fickle and inconstant. Wherefore, as S. Chrysostom says, " He did not regard outward words who enters into the mind itself, who penetrates human thoughts, who knew how soon their fervour would grow cold. Jesus had no need of testimony to know the minds which He had formed." Augustine adds, "That the Maker knew better what was in His work than the work what was in itself. Man's Creator knew what was in man."

John 2:25 · Open Word Bible

25He did not need anyone to testify to Him about people, for He Himself knew what was in a person.

Report a mistake