Cornelius a Lapide · The Great Commentary: S. John's Gospel
John 3
24 excerpts on John 3, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
There was a ma?i, &c. Nicodemus means in Greek the conqueror of the people. ... Wherefore Lucian thus writes concerning him in " Tiie Invention of the Body of S. Stephen," from the mouth of Gamaliel: "The Jews, knowing that Nicodemus was a Christian, removed him from his office and cursed him, and drove him out of the city. Then I Gamaliel, inasmuch as he had suffered persecution for Christ's sake, took him to my estate, ami fetl and clothed him to the end of his life ; and when he died I buried him honourably beside the loved Stephen."
The same came, &c., by night, for he was ashamed to approach the lowly Jesus by day, in the presence of others, and to become His disciple. For he was a master in Israel : and such a thing seemed beneath his authority and dignity. Another reason was that he might not incur the hatred of the Pharisees, who despised Christ. However, he found the light which he sought by night, as Rupcrti says, and drank of the great sacraments of salvation. He seems to have come alone, without servant or companion, by night, to Christ, to have spoken with Him face to face, and to have imbibed His spirit and doctrine.
John 3:1 · Open Word Bible
1Now there was a man named Nicodemus, a Pharisee and one of the leaders of the Jewish people.
Jesus answered, &c., Amen, Amen. John on many occasions doubles the Amen (Eng. Ver. Verily), when the other Evangelists have only one. Why was this? I answer (i.) because he had above the rest the most lofty revelations, and knew the deepest mysteries of the Deity. This was especially the case in his exile at Patmos, where he wrote the Apocalypse, which has, says S. Jerome, as many mysteries as it has words. And after this he wrote his Gospel when he was very old, and the sole survivor of the Apostolic College. Wherefore he was thenceforth the mouthpiece and oracle of the Church, the foundation and pillar of the faith, the patriarch of patriarchs. He saiih therefore, as it were with plenary authority, as it were the Elder of elders, Amen, Amen. It is as though he said, " I announce to you, with the utmost weight and confidence, things most lol'ty and sublime, which surpass all human understanding and belief, but which Christ has revealed to me, which are therefore most certain, and most salutary for you. For Christ really used this twofold Amen, to indicate the sublimity and certainty of what He said. But the other Evangelists, studying conciseness, included two under one : but I, John, because I, beyond the others, have weighed and penetrated both the words of Christ and their meaning, say. Amen, Amen, as Christ Himself spoke."
John 3:3 · Open Word Bible
3Jesus answered him, "Truly, truly, I tell you, unless someone is born from above, they cannot see the kingdom of God."
Nicodemus saith
Ver. 4, — Nicodemus saith, &c. " He knew," says S. Augustine, " but of one birth, that from Adam and Eve."
John 3:4 · Open Word Bible
4Nicodemus said to Him, "How can a man be born once he has grown old? He cannot go back into his mother's womb and be born a second time, can he?"
Jesus answered
Ver. 5. — -Jesus answered, &c. Calvin, in order to detract from the effect of justification by baptism, and therefore from the necessity of baptism (for he maintains that the children of believers are justified in the womb simply because they are the children of believers), denies that baptism is here spoken of. He says that by water, not water is to be understood, but the Holy Ghost, who, through faith, cleanses like water those who believe in Christ. He explains as follows, " unless any one be born again of water, and (that is, of) the Holy Ghost." Thus he says it is similarly spoken (S. Matt. iii. 11), He shall baptize you with the Holy Ghost and with fire, i.e., with the Holy Spirit, who, like fire, shall inflame you with the love of God.
Hut all this is absurd and perverse, and cnndcnmed by the Church as heretical.
John 3:5 · Open Word Bible
5Jesus replied, "Truly, truly, I tell you, unless someone is born of water and the Spirit, they cannot enter the kingdom of God.
That which is born (produced)
Ver. 6. — That which is born (produced), &c. Christ says this both to show the necessity of regeneration by water and the Holy Ghost, and at the same time to declare the reason for it, its excellence and its profit. His argument then is as follows : Flesh and blood cannot possess the kingdom of God, for they are carnal, but the kingdom of God is spiritual. Since therefore of carnal generation only flesh is born, that is, the animal and carnal man, bound under sin, and prone to sin, and so unfitted lor the kingdom of God, it follows that if such an one would enter into God's spiritual kingdom, he must be spiritually bom again of water and the Spirit, that he may become a spirit, that is, spiritual, and so fitted for the kingdom of God. Wherefore you have no cause for wonder, O Nicodemus, at what I said, that thou must be born again of water and tlie Holy Ghost. For as flesh generates flesh, that is, corporeal and carnal substance, so does the Spirit generate spirit, that is, spiritual substance : for like generates like. The Holy Spirit transmits His own substance into that which He begets, so far as it can be transmitted. For the Holy Spirit cannot transmit, or transfuse His own substance, or His Deity, into the baptized, for that would be to make them really and truly gods, as He Himself is really and truly God, which would be impossible. Therefore He transfuses Himself mto them as far as is possible, by His grace and spiritual gifts, by which He makes the baptized like unto Himself, that is, spiritual, holy, heavenly, and divine. So SS. Cyril, Chrysostom, and others. Let us add that the Holy Spirit gives Himself with His sevenfold gifts to the soul which He sanctifies, and adopts for His child ; and therefore that His justification is truly spiritual regeneration, by which we are born again as sons, and partakers of the Divine nature, as I have shown at large in Hosea i.
John 3:6 · Open Word Bible
6Whatever is born of the flesh is flesh, and whatever is born of the Spirit is spirit.
Marvel not
Ver. 7. — Marvel not, &c. As S. Chrysostom says, "We are not disputing concerning flesh, but concerning spirit. Do not think either that the Spirit begets flesh, or flesh the Spirit." Therefore it is necessary to be born again of the Spirit, if thou seekest to become spirit, or spiritual, and a candidate for heaven.
The Spirit bloweth where it willeth, &c. Christ proceeds to unfold to Nicodemus the reason and nature of spiritual regeneration, and to take away his wonder how such a thing could be possible.
You will ask what Spirit is here to be understood, i. Plainly and simply wif.d is the Spirit. For He compares the Holy Spirit to the wind, as is plain from what follows, So is every one that is born of the Spirit The meaning is, As the wind blows where its own will, that is, its natural propensity to blow, leads it, and yet you can see neither it, nor its determined place, but only its effects, and voice, or sound ; so much more neither thou, nor any one else, however clever and sharp-sighted, can perceive by natural understanding this spiritual regeneration, its end and term. They can only be known by tlie revelation and inspiration of the Holy Ghost, even though the outward symbols of water and the washing in baptism may be seen with the body's eyes. Thus S. Chrysostom says, If thou knowest not the way of the wind which thou feelest, how canst thou search out the operation of the Divine Spirit ? Christ here plays upon the analogical meaning of the word spirit. For first He takes spirit for wind ; then He takes it as the Holy Spirit. For wind is the index and symbol of the Holy Ghost.
John 3:7 · Open Word Bible
7Do not be surprised that I told you, 'All of you must be born from above.'
... "The Divine mysteries of God, of the Holy Ghost, and His spiritual regeneration, which I declare unto thee, I know most truly and most certainly, because I, as God, have seen them by Divine knowledge, and as man by the Beatific Vision. Wherefore ye ought to believe My testimony ; but the greater part of the Jews are unbelieving, and receive not My witness. Indeed, thou thyself dost not as yet believe, or thou wouldst not argue with Me about them." Christ tacitly exhorts Nicodemus not to scrutinise these mysteries by reason in order to understand them, but to view them by faith. Christ here speaks of Himself in the plural, IVe speak that we do know ; because of the weight of the testimony which is wont to be afforded by more than one ; and because He intimates that the Father and the Holy Ghost bore witness together with Him, for they spake by His mouth. For "in Him dwelt all the fulness of the Godhead bodily " (Col. ii. 9).
John 3:11 · Open Word Bible
11Truly, truly, I tell you, we speak of what we know and testify to what we have seen, and still you people do not accept our testimony.
If I have told you earthly things
Ver. 12. — If I have told you earthly things, &c. "If thou understandest not Divine things by means of the earthly similitudes of human generation of flesh and spirit, how wilt thou understand them, if I were to set them before thee without any figures? For this I might do, since I have seen them as they are in themselves, and beheld them with the eyes of the mind. But thine eyes would be blinded by such light as that, and couldst not look upon it. Wherefore I advise thee not to dispute with Me about them, but to believe them by simple faith."
He calls such. It means, If you do not understand My earthly baptism, how will you understand the Divine mysteries of the Holy Trinity, the eternal generation of the Word, the procession of the Holy Ghost? Do not therefore curiously inquire into those things, or dispute with Me about them, but simply believe Me, who am, as it were, a Divine Witness.
John 3:12 · Open Word Bible
12If you do not believe when I tell you about things on earth, how will you believe when I tell you about things in heaven?
Ver. 13. — And no man hath ascefided, &c. And is put instead of hotuever. The meaning is, Ye do not believe Me, and yet no other person hath ascended into heaven, and there beheld the things which I declare, except Myself, who am God and man, and as God have come down to the earth that I might teach them to you. Christ raises the mind of Nicodemus so that he should not regard Him as only a man, but that in this man God lay hidden, who filleth heaven and earth, and therefore that he should have full faith in Him.
Ascended: so in the Greek, in the perfect tense. Wherefore this passage cannot be understood of Christ's future ascension into heaven. Besides, He says expressly that no one else but He hath ascended into heaven ; by which He tacitly declares that He has been there, and has there beheld God and all the Divine mysteries. So Toletus.
John 3:13 · Open Word Bible
13No one has gone up into heaven except the one who came down from heaven, the Son of Man.
Ver. 1 6. — For God so lot'ed, &c. ... So S. Chrysostom and Theophylact.
Observe that every word of Christ in this sentence has a great and special emphasis, in order to magnify to the utmost the love of God. For (i.) He says, So, with such vehemence, such excess of love. 2. Not a king, or an angel, loved, but God. 3. Loved, i.e., first, and as it were gratuitously ; without merit, yea, even without desire on our part. 4. The world, His enemy, and under the sentence of damnation. 5. Gave not another man, not an angel, not another world, but His Son ; and that not an adopted Son, but His own Son : and again not one Son of many, but His only Son, His Only Begottefi Son. 6. ... 7. Christ did not do it for Himself, to gain any advantage for Himself, but that He, the Creator, might give life to us His creatures by His own death, that by His humility He might exalt us, that by His emptying Himself He might heap upon us eternal glory, and an infinite weight of wealth and goodness. This is the love of God towards man, which the Apostle celebrates (Titus iii. 5).
John 3:16 · Open Word Bible
16For God's love for the world was such that He gave His one and only Son, so that everyone who believes in Him may not perish but have eternal life.
For God sent not
Ver. 17. — For God sent not, &c. He confirms and intensifies the assertion of the infinite love of God to men, as proved by Christ's being crucified. For God might justly have sent His Son into the world to destroy it for its great wickedness. For this was what His justice demanded, but the infinite love of God overcame justice in that it bestowed the highest blessing upon the world, which deserved the utmost extremity of punishment, in giving it salvation through Him.
Observe : the expression judge the world, as it is in the Vulgate, means to condemn, and destroy it in hell. It is opposed to the word saved. Hence S. Augustine observes that this was the end of Christ's Incarnation, that all men might be saved, and that He earnestly desired and willed this.
He that believeth . . . is not judged, shall not be condemned, but saved. ... "He shows," says S. Cyril, "how dreaiiiul a crime unbelief is, because He is the Only Begotten Son of God. For by how much greater is the excellence of that which is despised, by so much will he who despises be liable to severer punishment. Especially, because such persons make God a liar, because they believe not the witness which God hath testified of His Son" (i John v. 10).
John 3:17 · Open Word Bible
17For God sent the Son into the world, not to condemn the world, but so that through Him the world might be saved.
Ver. 19. — This is the judgment, &c. ... This is the cause why those are already condemned who believe not on Me, because they have preferred darkness, and ignorance of God, and of what they ought to do, and their own pleasures and lusts and sins upon the earth, rather than light, that is, Christ, who hath brought the knowledge of God and salvation into the world. For light and darkness are the symbols of these things. ... Moreover, light came into the world to arouse men, says the Gloss : to admonish them to know their evils, says S. Chrysostom. " For they themselves would not admit the light of truth and holiness, which He preached by His word and example." In like manner many at the present day become heretics that they may follow their carnal will, which heresy permits, but the faith forbids. Therefore to convert a heretic make use of this method : first persuade him to lead an honest life, moral, chaste, and holy. Thus will you the more easily bring him to the true faith.
John 3:19 · Open Word Bible
19And this is how the judgment falls: the light has come into the world, but people loved the darkness more than the light, because the things they did were evil.
... " For," as S. Chrysostom observes, "it marks those who still persevere in their wickedness, and are zealous to do evil to their last breath ; who persevere in evil deeds, and always wallow in the mire of vice."
John 3:20 · Open Word Bible
20For anyone who does what is wrong hates the light and will not come near it, so that what they do will not be exposed.
But he that doeth
Ver. 2 1. — But he that doeth . . . in God, i.e., according to God's will and law, and by His guidance, light, and help. The truth, i.e., practically by doing what is right and just, and pleasing to God. For as there is truth of the heart and mouth, so is there of deed, by which it comes to pass that an honest and holy work corresponds to the practical rule of reason and prudence, or virtue, and the will of God. Thus (viii. 43), it is said of Lucifer, he abode not in the truth, i.e., in equity, justice, and sanctity. So also the Apostle exhorts us to do the truth, i.e., what is truly good, and holy, and pleasing to God.
And if they be otherwise, He will correct them, and amend them in accordance with the will of God. " He shows," says S. Chrysostom, "that none of those who are in error will submit to the truth, unless a man will first persuade himself to lead a correct life ; and that no one will persist in unbelief unless he be wholly given up to wickedness."
John 3:21 · Open Word Bible
21But whoever practices the truth comes to the light, so that it may become plain that their deeds have been done in God."
After this
Ver. 22. — After this, &LC. This means that Jesus went from Jerusalem, a citizen of which Nicodemus appears to have been, to some other part of the land of Judea, because He would avoid the sects and enmities of the chief men of Jerusalem. So S. Chrysostom and others. As the former saith, " He was accustomed to come into the city at the solemn feasts, that He might publicly make known the doctrine of God : from thence He often retired to the river Jordan."
Baptized, not so much by Himself as by His disciples, as is said in iv. 2. Yet He first Himself baptized there. He baptized by others for several reasons — i. To show that His baptism was different from that of John. For the latter was conferred by John alone ; but Christ's baptism was conferred by others also, His disciples, Christ in them and by them working mightily. 2. To show that the authority, power, and continuance of His baptism were to extend through all succeeding ages. So SS. Augustine and Cyril. 3. Because He Himself was occupied in the greater works of teaching, healing the sick, and working miracles. Moreover, when the disciples of Christ baptized, they were not yet apostles. For they were made apostles after John's imprisonment. But those things happened before it, as is evident from verse 24. These disciples therefore were not yet apostles, nor even priests, for they were afterwards created priests by Christ at His Last Supper.
John 3:22 · Open Word Bible
22After this, Jesus went with His disciples into the Judean countryside. There He stayed with them for a while and baptized people.
Now John
... Near to Salim. There were two Salims, or Salems ; one which was afterwards called Jerusalem, the other near Scythopolis, which was called, in S. Jerome's time, Salumius, as he tells us in his Locis 11 eh raids. Salem means in Hebrew, health, peace, perfection. For these penitents received from John, being transmitted to Christ, who baptized not far from John. There was much water there. From this we may gather that John baptized so as not only to lave the head, for which only a moderate quantity of water was needed, but the whole body.
John 3:23 · Open Word Bible
23John too was baptizing, at Aenon near Salim, where there was plenty of water, and people kept coming to be baptized.
For John had not yet been sent (Vulg
... This implies, says S. Chrysostom, that John baptized up to the time of his being cast into prison. For until his death he persevered in the office for which God hath sent him, namely, that by baptizing and preaching he might prepare the way for Christ. And when he had done this superabundantly, God allowed him to be cast into prison, that he might give way to Christ, and send all his disciples to Christ, as in fact he did.
The Evangelist adds this verse to show that he was supplying the history of all the preceding events, and adding them to the narratives of the other Evangelists, who began from the imprisonment of John.
Now there arose, &c. ... Because indeed John baptized with Jesus, since John preceded, there arose a question, that is, a strife and controversy, from John's disciples. This they raised out of zeal for the honour and authority of their master John, lest he, through the baptism given by Jesus, should be little thought of. For many were flocking to Jesus, John himself sending them, preferring Jesus to himself.
John 3:24 · Open Word Bible
24This was before John had been put in prison.
And they came
Ver. 26. — And they came, &c. Who was wiih thee beyond Jordan : viz., Jesus, who came to thee to be baptized. He now ungratefully makes Himself equal to thee, and usurps thine office of baptizing. You ought therefore to restrain Him ; otherwise all will flock from thee to Him, to thy shame as well as ours. Thus Euthymius, " He exercises thine own office against thee, and seizes on thy renown." Wishing further to exasperate John, they added. All men leave thee, and go to Him.
John 3:26 · Open Word Bible
26They came to John and said to him, "Rabbi, the man who was with you on the other side of the Jordan, the one you testified about: look, He is baptizing, and everyone is going to Him."
Ye yourselves bear me witness
Ver. 28. — Ye yourselves bear me witness, &c. That I said I went before Him, that as His forerunner, minister, and herald, I should precede His advent. " You know that I have always professed that I am not the Christ, but His forerunner. Why then do you urge me to revoke what I have said, and prefer myself to Jesus, and steal away from Him the name of Christ ? Truly this would be intolerable pride, inconsistency, and blasphemy. Suffer me then to live contented with my office, and with me prepare His way, and follow and serve Him the Messias, both your and my Lord and God."
John 3:28 · Open Word Bible
28You yourselves are my witnesses that I said, 'I am not the Christ; rather, I have been sent ahead of Him.'
He that hath the bride
Ver. 29. — He that hath the bride, &c. " Jesus Christ by His Incarnation hath betrothed unto Himself the Church, which is the whole company of believing people ; and God hath given her to Him as a bride to a bridegroom. Jesus therefore is the true husband of the Church, a husband which must be received, and loved, and worshipped in the highest degree by all who believe. What wonder then if all the people leave me and flock to Him ? For I am not the bridegroom, but Christ's, the Bridegroom's, friend. Wherefore I greatly rejoice that I should be counted worthy of so great a ministry, that I should be the paranymph of the Bridegroom, and that I should convey the bride, that is, the faithful, to Him, that all may acknowledge, love, and reverence Him as the Messias, and look for all grace and glory from Him, as the Head and Prince of the whole Church."
John 3:29 · Open Word Bible
29It is the bridegroom who has the bride. But the bridegroom's friend, who stands by and listens for him, rejoices with great joy at the sound of the bridegroom's voice. This, then, is my joy, and it has been made complete.
He must increase, viz
Ver. 30. — He must increase, viz., by the flocking of the people to Him, by the abundance and glory of His miracles, in adoration and worship, that the whole world may love and worship Him as Christ. So S. Cyril, to whom listen. " So long as the profundity of the sethei is obscured by the shades of night, every one speaks with the greatest admiration of the morning star, as it shines with the full glory of its golden splendour. But when the sun is seen to hasten to his rising, and when his light somewhat illumines this our earth, the day star yields gradually to the greater luminary, and the words of John might not improperly be applied. ... Likewise S. Chrysostom says, " Christ increases in that He by degrees manifests Himself by signs and miracles : not because He makes increase in virtue, — God forbid ; for this would be the madness of Nestorius."
John 3:30 · Open Word Bible
30He must grow greater, but I must grow less.
He that is of the earth
Ver. 32. — He that is of the earth, &c. John prefers Christ to himself, as what is heavenly to what is earthly. As much therefore as heaven is higher than the earth, so greatly is Christ superior to John, according to the words, "The first man is of the earth, earthy; the second man is of the heaven, heavenly" (i Cor. xv. 47, Vulg.)
The meaning is, " He that is born of the earth, as I John am formed from it, as Adam was, he is earthy, and of the earth he speaketh, i.e., of earthly things. Now this was true of John (i.) if you have regard to his bare nature, as apart from the grace and calling of God. For apart from that, John was only earthy, and savoured of the earth. " For if thou hast heard anything Divine from John, it is of Him who gave him the light, not of him who only received the light," as S. Augustine says.
John 3:32 · Open Word Bible
32What He has seen and heard is what He bears witness to, but no one accepts His testimony.
Ver. 35. — He that hath received, or that receiveth His testimony (by believing), hath signed (Vulg.), &c. ... He who receives Christ's testimony, and believes in Him, testifies by so doing, and as it were attaches a seal to his profession of faith, that God the Father is true, who by His Son, as by His own mouth, speaks things most true and Divine. For the Son heard them, and received them from the Father. Or, as S. Cyril says, such an one testifies that God the Son is true, who declares these very things. He who believes in God and in His Son gives great honour to God, because by his belief he professes that God is true, yea, primal and infallible Truth. On the contrary, he that believeth not greatly dishonours God, because in reality he makes Him out false, which is the highest possible contemjjt and blasphemy of God. S. John says in his Epistle (i John v. 10, 11), "He that believeth on the Son of God hath the witness in himself : he that believeth not God, hath made Him a liar ; because he believeth not the record that God gave of His Son. And this is the record, that God hath given to us eternal life, and this life is in His Son." Alcuin explains somewhat differently. He hath sealed, i.e., he hath put a sign, as it were something peculiar and especial, in his heart, that this is the true God, who hath been sent for the salvation of the human race.
John 3:35 · Open Word Bible
35The Father loves the Son and has handed everything over to Him.
He that believeth
Ver. 36. — He that believeth, &c. ... He hath faith and grace, which give him the right to glory. But it is grace begun in the spiritual knowledge and love of God, which will be perfected after death in heaven. As it is said (John xvii, 3), This is life eternal (the way and commencement of life), that they may know Thee, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom Thou hast sent.
Wrath of God abideth, the vengeance of God, and hell, shall eternally punish him. Hear Cyril, " They shall not see life, i.e., not even as far as the bare sight of it pertains, shall they be able to attain to the life of the saints. They shall not taste of those joys, they shall not see that true life. They shall be tormented with sufferings worse than any kind of death, and only retain their souls in their bodies through the sense of pain."
John 3:36 · Open Word Bible
36Anyone who believes in the Son has eternal life, but anyone who refuses to obey the Son will not see life. Instead, the wrath of God remains on them."