Logia

Cornelius a Lapide · The Great Commentary: S. John's Gospel

John 5

44 excerpts on John 5, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

John 5:2

Now there is

Ver. 2. — Now there is . . . sheep-Diarket : Vulgate, Probatica.

A pool : i.e., a place which contained fishes, or at least might have held them. ... The Vulgate has piscina. This pool was constructed by Solomon for the service of the Temple ; hence it is called by Josephus {Bell. Jud., vi. 6) Solomon's Fool. In it the Nethinims washed the victims which they handed over to the priests to be offered in the Temple.

Bethsaida: so read the Vulgate, and among the Greeks SS. Chrysostom and Cyril. And appositely, for Bethsaida means in Hebrew a house, i.e., a place of hunting, ox fishing. ... Hebrceis). Bethesda means in Hebrew a place of pouring forth, because the rain from the roofs of the houses, and streams of water from aqueducts, flowed into it.

Having five porches, or porticoes : these porches or porticoes were places covered above, but open below, either for walking, or taking rest in, that sick persons might rest in them secure from rain, or the heat of the sun, and immediately step out of them into the pool when its angel moved the water.

John 5:2 · Open Word Bible

2In Jerusalem, by the Sheep Gate, there is a pool with five porticoes; in Hebrew it is called Bethesda.

Report a mistake

John 5:3

In them

... Ver. sick folk ; withered (Vulg.) aridorum, dry, i.e., whose arm, or hand, or foot, or some other limb, was lifeless.

An angel of the Lord : either Raphael, or some other. ... Whence he cured Tobit of his blindness.

According to a lime (Vulg.), i.e., at a certain time determined by God, or the angel, but unknown to men. ... For if so, the sick folk would not have lain beside it (for so long a time), but would have waited at home until Pentecost was close at hand. As Euthymius says, " By speaking of a stated time, he showed that the miracle was not continually taking place, but at certain times, unknown indeed to men, though often, as I think, in the course of the year."

"The sound of moving signified that angels were present to sanctify the water," says S. Cyril. " The water was moved in order to show that the angel had descended," says S. Ambrose.

John 5:3 · Open Word Bible

3Many sick people used to lie in these porticoes: the blind, the lame and the paralyzed.

Report a mistake

John 5:5

A man having an infirmity

Ver. 5. — A man having an infirmity : Greek and Vulgate. S. Chrysostom and others say that this sick man was a paralytic.

Tropologically, this infirm man represents one who has grown old in a course of sin : who lies without strength in habits of vice, and is without any power to do good. For as palsy dissolves the bonds which knit the limbs together, so does a habit of sin enervate and dissolve the strength of the soul, so that men cannot arise out of it, and resist it, unless they are raised and strengthened by the mighty grace of God. Hence it is plain that such a palsy as this was naturally incurable ; and we see that for thirty-eight years it could not be healed by any skill. Christ therefore took upon Him.self to heal this palsy rather than the diseases of the other sick who were there, in order to show forth both His Almighty power and His infinite mercy. ... As S. Austin says, "The great Physician descended from heaven because one who was sick unto death lay on the earth." On the symbolical meaning of the thirty-eight years see S. Augustine in loc, where he says, amongst other things, that it was the symbol of weakness, as forty is the symbol of healing and i)erfection. "If therefore," he says, '• the numljer forty has the perfection ot the Law, and the Law is not fulfilled except by the twofold precept of charity, what wonder that he was sick, who lacked two of the forty ? " The twofold love, viz., of God and his neighbour, was lacking.

John 5:5 · Open Word Bible

5One man there had been ill for thirty-eight years.

Report a mistake

John 5:6

When Jesus saw

Ver. 6. — When Jesus saw, &c. Christ knew well that he had a desire to be healed, but He asked the question — i. To afford the sick man an opportunity for conversation, and from thence of being healed. As S. Cyril says, " Herein was a great proof of the compassion of Christ, that He did not (always) wait for the entreaties of those who were sick, but prevented them by His mercy."

2. That He might sharpen the man's attention to the instantaneous character of the miracle, and so to the words and deeds of Christ. From all these He might know with certainty that he was healed, not by the pool, nor by medicine, but by Christ alone, who was superior to all the virtue of the pool, or of medicine, and so might believe in Him as a prophet, and the Messiah, and might in penitence ask and obtain of Him remission of his sins. Wherefore He healed him beside the healing pool, but without touching it, that He might show that it was He who had given its virtue to the pool, and that He therefore, without the aid of the pool, could heal him by His word alone.

John 5:6 · Open Word Bible

6Jesus saw him lying there and knew that he had been in that condition for a long time, so He asked him, "Do you want to be well?"

Report a mistake

John 5:7

The sick man answered

Ver. 7. — The sick man answered, &c. The sick man does not answer Christ's question directly. He takes for granted that every one knew that he desired to be healed. Therefore he makes mention of the way of obtaining healing by means of the pool. As though he had said, " I am prevented by palsy from going into the pool, for I have none to carry me. I am a poor man. If therefore Thou canst help me in this matter, do so." For he thought that when Christ asked the question. Dost thou wish to be healedi He meant, " Dost thou wish that I should carry thee into the pool, when the angel moves the water, that thou mayest in it be healed?" As yet he did not know the power of Jesus, for he had never seen Him.

The Syriac translates a little differently : Even so, Lord (I do wish to be healed), but 1 have not a man. Beautifully does S. Augustine say, " In very deed was that man (Jesus) necessary for his salvation, but it was that man who is also God."

John 5:7 · Open Word Bible

7The sick man answered Him, "Sir, when the water is stirred up, there is no one to put me into the pool. And while I am on my way, someone else steps down before I do."

Report a mistake

John 5:8

... In saying Arise, He caused him to arise, and healed him. As S. Augustine says, " It was not a command of work, but an operation of healing." And S. Cyril, " Such power and virtue were not of man ; it is a property of God alone to command like this." Christ bade him take up his bed, that it might be evident to all that He liad healed him, yea, that he had been made instantly stout and strong, so as to be able to carry his bed. Wherefore Euthymius in this passage observes that Christ was accustomed, after the miracles which He wrought, to add something by which their truth and greatness might be perceived. Thus in this instance He bade the paralytic take up his bed, which he could not have done unless he was healed ; yea, stout and strong. So after the multiplication of the loaves. He ordered more fragments to be taken up than were originally in the bread. So He said to the leper whom He healed, " Go show thyself to the priest." So He ordered something to be given to eat to the girl whom He raised from the dead (Mark v. 43).

John 5:8 · Open Word Bible

8Jesus told him, "Get up, pick up your mat, and start walking."

Report a mistake

John 5:9

Ver. 9. — And immediately {Syndic) in that moment . . . for on thai day was the Sabbath. Christ designedly healed upon the Sabbath, both because the Sabbath was the highest festival of the Jews, which therefore it was right to sanctify above other days by good works, such as healing a sick man like this paralytic : and also because He hereby wished to show the Jews that He was the Lord of the Sabbath. For in bidding him take up his bed, which was a thing forbidden by the old Law, He showed that He was Messiah and God. Moreover, because the Sabbath was a day dedicated to rest and the praise of God, Christ gave rest from his pains to this sick man, and so afforded a notable occasion for praising God on this day.

John 5:9 · Open Word Bible

9Immediately the man became well. He picked up his mat and began walking about. And this happened on a Sabbath.

Report a mistake

John 5:10

The Jews therefore

Ver. 10. — The Jews therefore, &c. As Nonnus paraphrases, *' Clamorously they uttered an accusing charge, ' It is the Sabbath, which every one ought to keep wholly in rest : it is not lawful for thee to carry thy bed.' " Speaking generally, they say the truth ; for among the Jews it was a matter of the highest obligation to keep the Sabbath. All work was then forbidden, as appears from Exodus XX. 8. And especially the carrying of burdens on that day is forbidden by Jeremiah (xvii. 21, &c.). Christ, however, here says the contrary to the sick man whom He cured, because He, being Lord of the Sabbath, could dispense with its obligation. Moreover, what was forbidden by the Law upon the Sabbath was servile work, not a pious and Divine work like this. Christ bade the man who was healed take up his bed that the crowds of people who were flocking into the Temple on the Sabbath might become acquainted with the miracle, and acknowledge Jesus, its author, to be the Messiah, giving Him thanks.

John 5:10 · Open Word Bible

10So the Jewish leaders kept telling the man who had been healed, "It is the Sabbath. It is against the law for you to carry your mat."

Report a mistake

John 5:11

He answered them

Ver. II, — He answered them, &c. Understand, This was indeed a Divine man, and by Divine power has healed me. Therefore He is a friend of God, and would not bid me do anything except what is pleasing to Clod. As S. Augustine says, "Should I not receive a command from Him from whom I have received healing?" Just indeed was this defence of the sick man, which the Jews ought to have understood and accepted, but being blinded by pride they could not receive it, and so sinned by persecuting Christ and fell into hell.

John 5:11 · Open Word Bible

11But he answered them, "The one who made me well is the one who told me, 'Pick up your mat and start walking.'"

Report a mistake

John 5:12

Ver. 12. — llierefore they asked him, &c. Being indignant, they say with threats, " Who is that bold and insolent man, who dare bid thee, contrary to the Law, carry thy bed upon the Sabbath day? Verily, that man is not of God who does not keep the Sabbath which God has ordained." Thus they spoke through a blind prejudice derived from this Law, which they did not understand. Whereas, on the contrary, they ought to have understood that He who had miraculously healed the sick man, could not have done it except by the singular authority and help of God, and therefore that He had equally received from God the right to say on the Sabbath, Take up thy bed and walk.

John 5:12 · Open Word Bible

12So they asked him, "Who is this man who told you to pick it up and walk?"

Report a mistake

John 5:13

But he 7vho was healed

Ver. 13. — But he who was healed, &c. The man knew not the name of Jesus, nor whither He had gone, nor indeed who He was, for he had never seen Him before.

Departed. Euthymius gives the reason. " As soon as He had healed the man, He withdrew because of the crowd, partly to avoid the praise of the just, and partly to take away occasion for the envy of the unjust." S. Chrysostom gives another reason : That the man's testimony in the absence of Jesus might be less liable to suspicion. For if he who was healed had praised Christ to the Jews before His face, he might have seemed to have done it out of favour. But now tliat he praised Him in His absence, it is evident that he did so from the love of the truth.

John 5:13 · Open Word Bible

13But the healed man had no idea who it was, since there was a crowd in the place and Jesus had moved off without being noticed.

Report a mistake

John 5:14

Ver. 14. — Aftenvards Jesus, &c. The Arabic is, Now thou art healed, return not to sin, lest a worse evil be done thee.

In the Temple. From this it appears that this man who was healed by Christ, as soon as he had carried his bed to his house, went to the Temple to give God thanks for His great benefit of healing. As Chrysostom says, " Assuredly a great mark of piety and reverence. He did not go to the market-place, or the porch; he did not indulge in pleasure, or ease ; he was occupied in the Temple."

Sin no more. From hence it is plain that God often sends diseases upon sick persons on account of their sins; and that this man had been afflicted because of his sins. Thus this paralytic, who had been sick for thirty-eight years, from a time before Christ was born, had committed some crime, which God wished him to suffer for, and expiate, by this protracted disease. ... At the same time He intimates that He, being a Prophet, knew this by Divine revelation. Wherefore when sickness is sent by God upon any one, let him examine his conscience, and blot out by repentance and confession the sin for which God has sent the sickness, and let him pray to God to pardon his sin, and take away the disease.

John 5:14 · Open Word Bible

14Afterward Jesus found him in the temple area and said to him, "Look, you are well now. Do not sin any longer, or something worse could come upon you."

Report a mistake

John 5:15

The man went away, and told

Ver. 15. — The man went away, and told, &c. Not out of malevolence, but from gratitude, that he might not hide the author of so great a kindness. So Augustine, Chrysostom, and others. " He went away and told," says Euthymius, "not as being wicked, that he might betray, but as being grateful, to disclose who was his benefactor. Because he thought he should be guilty of a crime if he kept silence, therefore he proclaimed the benefit."

John 5:15 · Open Word Bible

15The man went off and told the Jewish leaders that the one who had made him well was Jesus.

Report a mistake

John 5:16

Ver, 1 6. — Wherefore the Jews perseaited Jesus, &c. Some Greek MS., also the Syriac and Arabic Versions, add, And sought to kill Him. Wherefore, i.e., on this pretext, for the true cause was envy. For the Jews, especially the scribes and Pharisees, were envious at this glory of Jesus, and grieved that the people should prefer Him to themselves. They were indignant that their wickedness was reproved by Him, and condemned by His holiness. For they wished to be paid court to as Rabbis, and doctors of the Law, and oracles of wisdom and sanctity.

John 5:16 · Open Word Bible

16For this reason the Jewish leaders began to persecute Jesus, since He kept doing such things on the Sabbath.

Report a mistake

John 5:17

But Jesus answered

... And after an interval, "The power and virtue of the Creator is the cause of existence of every creature. And if this virtue were ever to cease from governing created things, their forms {species) would cease at the same time, and all nature would come to an end." Like as the light in the air vanishes if the sun withdraw his rays, by which light is produced. The meaning is, "You, O ye scribes, object against Me the law of Sabbatical rcsi, wiiich God commanded you because He Himself rested on the Sabbath from all His work. But I answer that God on the Sabbath only rested from producing new species of things. Rut He did not rest in such a manner that He is not every Sabbath continually working, that is to say, governing and preserving the world, and all the things that are in it, moving the heavens, bringing forth one thing out of another, feeding and healing all living things, &c. This, which is work of the highest beneficence, is not servile work, but pious and Divine. Such work is indeed lawful ; yea, it adorns and hallows the Sabbath. So too I, who am the co-equal Son of the Father, always work, and always have wrought the same things with Him. For neither do I work without the Father, nor the Father without Me." So S. Augustine and others.

John 5:17 · Open Word Bible

17Jesus answered them, "My Father has been at work right up to now, and I am at work as well."

Report a mistake

John 5:18

Wherefore

Ver. 18. — Wherefore, &c.

Making Himself equal with God, because He had said that not merely like things, but that the self-same things which the Father works, were wrought by Him, and therefore that He in all things co-operated, not as a servant, but as a Son, of the same substance with the Father. As Cyril says, "Seeing that He was a man, and not knowing that God dwelt in Him, they could not bear that He should call God His Father in a special manner." The chief priests and scribes therefore wished to kill Jesus, because they feared lest, as His glory increased, their authority should decrease ; indeed lest Jesus, persuading the people that He was God, should be preferred by the people to the priests, and should deprive them of their authority, and should bring in His own new priests and pontiffs, which we see He actually did do.

John 5:18 · Open Word Bible

18So the Jewish leaders were even more determined to kill Him. Besides breaking the Sabbath, He was speaking of God as His own Father, and so was making Himself equal to God.

Report a mistake

John 5:19

Verily, Verily

Ver. 19. — Verily, Verily, &c. . . . cannot: "not from defect of power," says Euthymius, " but on account of inseparability. For it is impossible that the Son should do anything which the Father does not." So S. Chrysostom and S. Augustine. Except, or unless. This word is not here exceptive, signifying the same as but only. It has the same meaning in Matt. xii. 4.

For it is not before He worketh, but as soon as He seeth the Father working, that He, Christ, worketh with Him. For Christ as God does not produce what is similar, but what is identical with the work of the Father. For the action of the Father, which both see and work together, is the same. I say action, but not the Hypostatic Union, nor the things which depend upon it, for this union has not to do with action, but with the terminus in quo. Wherefore, although the whole Blessed Trinity, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, by their Divine action, have brought about this Hypostatic Union, yet the union itself is terminated in the Son, and does not extend to the Father and the Holy Ghost. Wherefore the Son only, not the Father and the Holy Ghost, became incarnate, and died, &c.

John 5:19 · Open Word Bible

19So Jesus gave them this answer: "Truly, truly, I tell you, the Son cannot do anything on His own; He does only what He sees the Father doing. For what the Father does, the Son does as well, and in the same way.

Report a mistake

John 5:20

For the Father

Ver. 20. — For the Father, &c. Showeth, not as a master to a disciple, says Euthymius, but as a father to a son, as God to God. Showeth therefore means gives, communicates, especially because, as I have said, the Son by demonstration, i.e., by understanding and vision, proceedeth as the Word from the Father. To show in the sense oi give, exhibit, attribute, is used in i Sam. xiv. 12; Exod. xxxiii. 19; Ps. iv. 6, &c. That this is the meaning here is plain from what follows. Moreover, the Father showeth, i.e., communicates all things to the Son in that He is God, not by free love, but by nature, out of the fecundity of the Divine Essence, of which the greatest sign among men is love. For he who among men communicates all things to his son, by so doing gives an eminent token that he loves him in the highest degree. Moreover, the Father communicates all things to the Son in that He is Man, of which communication love is not the sign, but the cause. "For the Father to show to the Son," says Bede, "is by the Son to do what He doeth."

John 5:20 · Open Word Bible

20For the Father loves the Son and shows Him everything He Himself is doing. And there are greater works than these that He will show Him, so that you will be astonished.

Report a mistake

John 5:21

Ver. 21. — Fat as the Father, &c. Behold here is the first greater work which Christ said the Father would show, that is, communicate, to the Son. As S. Cyril says, " Marvel not that one who was utterly weakened by long disease was strengthened by a word, and took up his bed, and went away, for I am about altogether to destroy death, and to judge the whole world."

So also the Son, &c. He tacitly signifies that He is God, equal to the Father in power and liberty to raise and quicken whom He will.

Whom He will.

is conformable, yea, the same as the will of the Father. So Augustine.

Quickeneth, i.e., raiseth from the dead, both in this life, as He raised Lazarus, and in the day of judgment, when He will raise all mankind.

John 5:21 · Open Word Bible

21For the Father raises the dead and brings them to life, and in the same way the Son brings to life whomever He chooses.

Report a mistake

John 5:22

Ver. 22. — For ndther doth the Father judge, &c. The Arabic omits for, but the Greek has it, and appositely. For this is the second reason by which Christ proves that He is God, and the second greater work which He said the Father would show Him. As Cyril says, " He brings forward another Divine and excellent argument, by which He shows that He is by nature truly God. For to whom else does it belong to judge the world but to God only?"

To His Son. One God with Himself, but by His Incarnation made man. As S. Austin says (lib. i, de Trin., c. 13), " No one shall see the Father at the judgment of the quick and the dead, but all shall see the Son, because He is the Son of Man, that He may be seen by the wicked also, when ' they shall look on Him whom they pierced.' "

John 5:22 · Open Word Bible

22Nor does the Father judge anyone; He has given the whole work of judging to the Son,

Report a mistake

John 5:23

That all

Ver. 23. — That all, &c. For the Jews who would not then honour the Son of God, or acknowledge Him to be such, when they shall see His Divine power and majesty in the day of judgment, will be compelled to acknowledge, honour, and adore Him as God.

Like as they honour the Father : the words like as signify equality, not similitude.

He who honoureth not the Son, &c. Because by denying the Son he denies also the Father ; for father and son are correlative terms : and he who has not a son cannot be a father. With regard to God, he who denies that the Son is the Son of God, denies that God the Father is truly and properly the Father, and has begotten. Tacitly he asserts that He could not beget a consubstantial and co-equal Son. Moreover he denies the Father, because the Father sent the Son into the world, that by Him He might be honoured, in such a manner that He should be acknowledged to be the Father properly so called, and to have begotten a Son of the same substance with Himself, and to be adored with the same latria as Himself He therefore who denies that the Son is God, denies that the Father begat God, which is the highest blasphemy of the Father. For he deprives the Father of that offspring which is His equal, and worthy of Himself, and instead of a Divine and uncreated offspring assigns to Him one that is created and mean. Wherefore he denies Him to be a proper and Divine Father.

John 5:23 · Open Word Bible

23so that everyone will honor the Son just as they honor the Father. Whoever refuses honor to the Son refuses it to the Father who sent Him.

Report a mistake

John 5:24

Verily, verily

Ver. 24. — Verily, verily, &c. See what has been said on iii. 3. Heareth, so as to believe and obey My word. Thus He subjoins, and believeth in Him that sent Me, and by consequence believeth in Me as His Son, sent by the Father into the world to save it. He saith not, and believeth in Me, but speaks with greater amplitude. For in saying, and believeth in Him that sent Me, He implies the mystery of the Trinity, and the Incarnation, which two things are the chief articles of the Faith, and chiefly necessary to salvation. For He who sent the Son is God the Father ; the Father and the Son together necessarily breathe the Holy Ghost. Lo, you have the whole Trinity.

Hath, i.e., by right, deservedly, and in hope. See on iii. 16.

For although the reprobate who will be damned will also be raised again to life, that they may burn in hell, yet that life in hell is rather a continual death, than life. For, as St. Austin saith, {de Civ., lib. 6, c. 12), "There is no more complete and worse death, tnan where death dieth not." For in hell there will be living death, and deathly life, that is, always dying, but never dead. Again He speaks yet more plainly. He who believeth and obeyeth God the Father, and the Son who is sent by Him, hath passed from the death of the soul, dead through sin, to the spiritual life of grace, that he may after the death of the body pass to the life of glory.

John 5:24 · Open Word Bible

24Truly, truly, I tell you, anyone who hears My word and believes the one who sent Me has eternal life. Such a person does not come under condemnation, but has already moved out of death into life.

Report a mistake

John 5:25

Verily, verily

Ver. 25. — Verily, verily, &c. "Lest thou shouldst think that this is to come to pass after a very long time. He subjoins, and now is. For if He were only announcing things future, there might not unreasonably be doubt, but He saith that these things shall come to pass whilst He is still conversant upon earth." So Chrysostom. For, as Theophylact says, " He is speaking here of those three whom He was about to raise, the widow's son, the daughter of the ruler of the synagogue, and especially of Lazarus. For this last He was about to raise in Judea. And Christ is here speaking in Judea to Jews. This then is the signification of now is. Christ then rises from the spiritual resurrection of souls from sin to the life of grace, to the resurrection of those bodies which He was about to raise whilst He lived on earth. From this He rises to the full resurrection glory of the bodies which He will raise in the day of jucigment. For from His power to raise souls from the death of sin to the life of grace, as from a thing greater ami more difficult, Christ proves that He has power 10 raise the body, a thing less difficult. So Toletus, Jansen, and others. But S. Cyril and others think that the reference in this place is to the general resurrection, and they take the expression, and now is, to refer to the last judgment.

John 5:25 · Open Word Bible

25Truly, truly, I tell you, an hour is coming, and in fact it has already begun, when the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear it will live.

Report a mistake

John 5:26

For as the Father

Ver. 26. — For as the Father, &c. ... To have life from Himself and from His own Essence, and from no other source. For the Essence of God is life, and His life is His Essence. God therefore essentially, and by His Essence, is essential, uncreated, and infinite life. 2. That God has life in Himself, is that He is the fountain of all life, of angels, men, and animals. As Euthymius says, To have life in Himself means that after the manner of a living fountain He is the Author of life, according to the words, " With Thee is the well of life " (Ps. xxxvi. 10). 3. Which follows from the two previous meanings, to have life in Himself mesins to have life in His own power, to be the Lord of life to all things living, so that He according to His own good pleasure gives them life, preserves it, and takes it away. This makes plain the unity of Essence, ie., of Deity, in the Father and the Son. For if the Son had a different Essence from the Father, then He would have life in another, that is to say, in the Father, who gave Him life. But now He hath life in Himself, ie., in His own Divine Essence, which He hath altogether in common with the Father. So S. Chrysostom. "Behold," he says, "how they differ not in any respect whatsoever, save that the one is the Father, and the other the Son."

John 5:26 · Open Word Bible

26For just as the Father has life in Himself, so He has given the Son life in Himself as well.

Report a mistake

John 5:27

... The word because must here be taken specifically, and means ivasmuch as. But it may be taken even more expressively in a reduplicative and causative sense, as giving the express reason why God gave Christ judicial authority. That reason is because Christ is the Son of Man, i.e., because He deigned to become Incarnate. As though it were said, "God hath willed to judge men by Christ a man, that judgment Uiight take place in a congruous manner, that is, after a sensible and human manner, that as He Himself saved the world by the man Christ, so He would also judge it by the same, by that man, I say, who is God, who took human life, and laid it down for man's salvation."

Wherefore it is that He by this great emptying of Himself, by which He willed to become man, merited this exaltation of judicial power, that He who was the Saviour of all should be the Judge oi all. So Maldonatus and others. S. Augustine gives also a twofold reason. The first is, "that those who are to be judged might see their Judge. For those who shall be judged will be both good and bad. It was right that in the judgment the form of a servant should be shown both to the good and the bad, but the form of God should be reserved for the good only." The second reason is, " because the Judge shall have that form in which He stood before His judge. That form which was judged shall judge : unrighteously was it judged, but righteously shall it judge."

John 5:27 · Open Word Bible

27He has also given Him authority to pass judgment, since He is the Son of Man.

Report a mistake

John 5:28

Marvel not

Ver. 28. — Marvel not, &c. . . . the hour, i.e., the time of the Evangelical Law, which is the last, and in the end of which shall be the resurrection of the dead, and the final judgment

In their graves: those who are dead and buried, including also the unburied dead. For as S. Augustine says, " By those who are buried in ordinary course. He signified also those who do not receive ordinary burial."

The voice of the Son of God : this shall be the sound of the archangel's, probably Michael's trumpet, Arise, ye dead, come to Judgment. This shall be accompanied by the sound of the trumpets and voices of other angels. The sound is spoken of as the voice of God, because by His command, through the ministry of angels, an effect shall be produced on the air which shall resound throughout the whole world, and be effectual as at least a moral instrument to raise the dead. For it is not necessary to attribute to this trumpet any physical power of raising the dead.

John 5:28 · Open Word Bible

28Do not be astonished at this. An hour is coming when everyone in the tombs will hear His voice

Report a mistake

John 5:29

... Christ here sets before the unbelieving Jews His authority to judge, that through fear of it He may make them fear, may make them contrite, and convert them. He did the same at the end ot His life, when, being adjured by Caiaphas, the High Priest, to say if He was the Son of God, He answered that He was, and added (Matt. xxvi. 64), " Hereafter shall ye see the Son of Man sitting on the right hand of power, and coming in the clouds of heaven."

There is nothing more terrible, and at the same time more effectual for rousing the minds of men to repentance and leading a holy life than a lively representation of the last judgment. So Christ, when He ascended into heaven, commanded His apostles by the angels to preach his return to judgment (Acts i. 11). S. Paul pressed the same thing upon the Areopagites (Acts xvii. 31). For in that judgment shall the destiny of each be finally decided for everlasting happiness or everlasting woe. " In all thy works," therefore, "remember thy last end, and thou wilt never sin " (Ecclus. vii. 40). In very deed that fateful day will be the last of this world, and the horizon of eternity, which shall separate the just from the unjust, and set them far apart, heaping upon the just utmost felicity, and weighing down the unjust with calamity, and that for ever and ever. Think constantly of this wonderful difference, be zealous for holiness, live for eternity.

John 5:29 · Open Word Bible

29and come out. Those who have done good will come out to a resurrection that brings life; those who have done evil, to a resurrection that brings condemnation.

Report a mistake

John 5:31

Ver. 31. — If I bear witness of Myself, that I am the Son of God, and therefore as man altogether conformed to the judgment and will of God, My witness is not true, that is, legitimate, judicial, worthy of credit. The word true here is not opposed io false, but to untrustworthy, uncertain. ... For it may be that a man may utter most true testimony concerning himself, and yet may fail to gain credit because of a suspicion that he has too great love of himself, as Kuiiiymius says.

But we will not believe Thee unless Thou shalt prove what Thou sayest by the testimony of God, or of men worthy of credit. This testimony of Thine in a matter which peculiarly concerns Thyself appears to us open to suspicion." Jesus replies, " I grant you that My testimony concerning Myself is not legitimate, nor worthy of credit, if I alone bear witness of Myself. I grant therefore that you need not believe Me alone ; but I am not alone, but others worthy of credit bear witness of Me, as will appear by what follows." Christ is here speaking of the common opinion of the Jews, not uttering His own sentiments, as appears from chap. viii. 13, where the Jews openly object to Christ, Thou bearest tesiitnony of Thyself, Thy testimony is not true. Then Christ answers, My testimony is true, &c., because I am not atone, but I, and the Father who sent Ale. So S. Cyril.

John 5:31 · Open Word Bible

31If I testify on My own behalf, My testimony is not true.

Report a mistake

John 5:32

There is another who beareth

Ver. 32. — There is another who beareth, &c. Another, viz., God the Father, who at My baptism spoke in thunder from heaven. This is My beloved Son. So S. Cyril, Bede. Again, another, i.e., John the Baptist, testifies to Me. So S. Chrysostom and others. Another then here means, there are others who testify that I am the Son of God, namely, God the Father, John the Baptist, Moses and the Prophets, also My Divine works and miracles. For all of these Christ proceeds to adduce as witnesses to prove that He is Messiah, and the Son of God.

And I know that it is true. So far as I Myself am concerned, I do not need these witnesses, for by Divine knowledge I know that what they testify is true, that I am the Son of God. But I bring forward their testimony for your sakes, that ye may believe what is attested by so many witnesses.

John 5:32 · Open Word Bible

32Someone else is testifying about Me, and I know that the testimony He gives about Me is true.

Report a mistake

John 5:33

Ye sent unto John

Ver. 33. — Ye sent unto John, &c. Ye sent messengers to him as a man in your estimation holy, and worthy of all credit, to ask him if he were the Messias. John answered that not he, but I, am the Messias. This testimony he gave not out of friendship, or favour to Me, but to the truth. ... V.

the truth, ye yourselves thoutilit, when ye were willing to receive him as the Messiah. Therefore ye cannot reject his testimony, says Euthymius.

John 5:33 · Open Word Bible

33You yourselves sent messengers to John, and he has testified to the truth.

Report a mistake

John 5:34

Ver. 34. — But I receive not, Szc I do not require the witness of John, for 1 am God, and the Son of God, to whom John, Moses, and the Prophets ought to yield, and be taught by, and receive authority from.

But since John, whom ye admire as a pro])het, is of so great authority with you, when ye do not believe Me working miracles, I bring back to your remembrance his testimony, that I may draw you and save you."

John 5:34 · Open Word Bible

34Yet I do not accept testimony from a human being; I say these things so that you may be saved.

Report a mistake

John 5:35

He was a burning and shining lamp

... John was not the light itself, shining of itself (for this was what Christ Himself was), but he was the lamp or lantern which, receiving light from Christ, burnt in himself with the knowledge and love of God, and afforded light to others by the example of his sanctity, and the fervour of his preaching. For God sent John after a long silence for ages of all the prophets, as it were a heavenly prophet, to be a lamp to illuminate the dark ignorance of the Jews, and to show them the true Light, Christ the Lord, and to bear a torch before Him. So S. Cyril and others. For the Only Begotten One is Light by nature, who, out of Light, that is, the Substance of the Father, hath shone forth. John indeed was a lamp, because he shone with light derived from Him. ... Wherefore the type of John was the lamp of oil burning before God in the Temple in the Holy of Holies. For so did John shine before Christ. Therefore was John the Baptist always a burning and shining lamp in the tabernacle of witness, as Cyril says.

John 5:35 · Open Word Bible

35John was the lamp that burned and shone, and for a little while you were glad to rejoice in his light.

Report a mistake

John 5:36

... This greater testimony is My works, My miracles which the Father hath given Me, that by them I may show that He hath sent Me. " For one might find fault with John's testimony, as if it were given out of favour," says Euthymius ; " but the works being free from all suspicion stop the mouths of the contentious," says S. Chiysostom. " For the works might convince even the insane."

I speak of My supernatural works, which could not be effected by any natural cause, but are peculiar to God alone. Wherefore they are as it were the seal of God, by which He bears testimony to Me, and seals and confirms My doctrine. So S. Chrysostom and others.

From this it follows that the Jews both could and ought to have known of a certainty that Jesus was the Messiah, or the Christ, and the Son of God, by the miracles which He wrought, i. ... 2. Because Jesus did all the miracles which the prophets had foretold would be done by Christ. 3. Because although certain of the prophets and holy men had done some miracles, they had done neither so many nor so great as Jesus had done. Again, the prophets had wrought miracles, not by their own power, but through invoking God ; but Christ did them by His own power, and His own authority, as being the Lord. Whence it was easy to discern that He was the Messiah and God.

John 5:36 · Open Word Bible

36But I have a testimony greater than John's. The works the Father has given Me to bring to completion, the works themselves that I am doing, testify about Me: they show that the Father has sent Me.

Report a mistake

John 5:37

... Again, He hath borne witness concerning Me, through the Scriptures by Moses and the prophets.

Observe, Christ in this place, besides the testimony of John, adduces three other and greater witnesses to show that He is the Messiah : i. By His miracles (ver, 36) ; 2. By the Father's voice at His baptism ; 3. By the Scriptures (ver. 39).

John 5:37 · Open Word Bible

37And the Father who sent Me has testified about Me Himself. Not once have you heard His voice or seen His form.

Report a mistake

John 5:38

Ve have not His word abiding (Arabic, made strong) in you

Ver. 38. — Ve have not His word abiding (Arabic, made strong) in you, &c. The connection and subsequent argument of these words is obscure, which different writers explain in different ways.

1. You may explain them as a sort of concession, thus : " You, O ye scribes, when I allege the testimony of God My Father concerning Me, make objection that ye have not heard it, that ye have neither seen His face, nor His appearance, as Moses saw, whom ye profess to believe. I grant what you say, but I add that no one, not even Moses, heard God's own voice, nor saw His appearance, nor His face. They only beheld that immense fire by which God was concealed, and heard a sound formed in the air by an angel, instead of God's voice. For I alone, whf) am the Son of God by nature, have heard His real voice, and seen His appearance, or His Divine face, which I see continually. Nevertheless I urge upon you that ye have heard the voice of God giving attestation to Me, when at My baptism the Father publicly declared, This is My beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased. Again, ye have heard the word of God concerning Me in the Holy Scriptures, Moses and the prophets, who bear witness that I am the Messiah. But ye, although ye have heard this word and testimony of God concerning Me, yet have it not abiding in you, because ye receive not in your minds, nor understand, nor believe it, inasmuch as ye do not believe in Me, as sent by God. In this ye gravely err and sin. For if ye have heard the word of an angel in God's stead speaking with Moses as His servant, and believe him, much more ought ye to believe the Word of God bearing witness to Me that I am His Son, especially since Moses bears witness to Me, and bids you to hearken unto Me, as follows. So Euthymius. This meaning seems clear, plain, and true.

John 5:38 · Open Word Bible

38And His word does not remain in you, since you do not believe the very one He sent.

Report a mistake

John 5:39

... The word for Search in Greek, as well as Latin, may be taken either in the indicative, or the imperative mood. Cyril takes it in the indicative : " Ye, O ye scribes, assiduously turn and search the Scriptures which bear testimony concerning Me, but ye do not care to understand them, because ye will not come unto Me." But SS. Augustine and Chrysostom, Theophylact, Euthymius, and others, take it in the imperative : "Search ye the Scriptures, and in them ye will find God the Father bearing witness to Me."

Moreover, by the word Search, Christ, says S. Chrysostom, pressed upon the Jews not merely the bare reading of the Scriptures, but a thorough and diligent examination of them. He did not say, Jiead the Scriptures, but Search them. Dig out the hidden treasures which they contain concerning Me and Divine things, just as those who search for veins of gold and silver dig in the earth to find them. Thus the Bergeans to whom Paul preached (Acts xvii.) searched the Scriptures, with a sincere desire to know nothing but the truth. Therefore in the Scriptures they found Christ whom Paul preached to them.

John 5:39 · Open Word Bible

39You pore over the Scriptures, since you think that eternal life is to be found in them; and they are the ones that testify about Me.

Report a mistake

John 5:40

And (yet), ye will ?iot

Ver. 40. — And (yet), ye will ?iot, &c. " Ye do not wish to cleave to Me, to believe in Me, to receive My doctrine and My law."

John 5:40 · Open Word Bible

40But you do not want to come to Me so that you can have life.

Report a mistake

John 5:41

I receive not brightness (Vulg

... There is an anticipation, "Ye, O ye Scribes, suspect, and object that I preach such great things of Myself, and so carefully endeavour to prove My dignity and authority out of the desire of vain glory, that I may catch the breeze of popularity, being desirous of being taken to be the Son of God. I answer that 1 do not preach these things about Myself in order that I may get glory from men, but for your own sakes, that I may save you. For I am even athirst for your salvation. For I know that no one can be saved, and possess eternal life, but by Me, whom God has appointed the Saviour of the world." So S. Cyril.

John 5:41 · Open Word Bible

41Glory from people is not something I accept.

Report a mistake

John 5:42

But I know you

Ver. 42. — But I know you, &c. " I know and penetrate the inmost recesses of your hearts (for I, being God, am the Searcher of hearts), and I see in them nothing of Divine love, but that they are full of ambition, avarice, and pride. And this is the reason why ye will not receive those clear testimonies which I bring forward in My favour. The root from whence your unbelief and obstinacy spring is not ambition of glory in Me, but your own lack of charity. For if ye truly loved God, ye would indeed acknowledge that I have been sent by Him, and am clearly described in the Scriptures." Thus even now the cause of heresy in many is a vitiated love, because indeed many love the liberty of the flesh which heresy teaches, and do not love God, who forbids it.

Cyril connects this verse with what precedes, thus, — " I have not proclaimed these great things about Myself for the sake of glory, that I may gain human praise, but that ye may learn (as I know) that the love of God is not in you, deprived of which, how can ye come to Me who am the Son of God ? "

John 5:42 · Open Word Bible

42But I know you, and there is no love for God in you.

Report a mistake

John 5:43

/ am come

Ver. 43. — I am come, &c., in My Father's name, as the Son sent by God the Father, that by His authority I may fulfil those things which He has promised to you concerning Messiah, to His alone praise and glory, so that through Him there may be showered upon you the knowledge of God, grace, salvation, and eternal life. This I have clearly proved to you by the many testimonies which the Father hath given Me. Yet ye do not receive Me, but treat Me as a false prophet. Wherefore by the just judgment of God it shall come to pass, that if another, who is really a false prophet, shall come to you, one who is not sent by God, but who shall come in his own name, i.e., in his own authority, falsely boasting himself to be the Messiah, such an one ye will receive. Another therefore will be that Antichrist whom the Jews will receive, though they rejected Christ. To this apply the words of Paul (2 Thes. ii. 10), "Therefore God shall send upon them the working of error, that they may believe a lie, that all may be judged, who have not believed the truth, but have consented to iniquity." ... Again, another may mean any false prophet, pretending to be Christ, and therefore a forerunner of Antichrist, like that Egyptian, shortly after the time of Christ, who led thousands of men to destruction {see Jos. Bell. Jud. lib. 2, c. 12).

John 5:43 · Open Word Bible

43I have come in the name of My Father, yet you do not accept Me. Should someone else come in his own name, him you will accept.

Report a mistake

John 5:44

How can ye believe

Ver. 44. — How can ye believe, &c. " Ye love human glory, brief and poor : wherefore ye contemn Me, who despise human glory, and teach that it ought to be contemned ; and that the Divine and eternal glory ought to be aimed at, which God will begin in the saints on earth, and bring to perfection in Heaven."

John 5:44 · Open Word Bible

44How could you believe? You accept glory from one another, while the glory that comes from the only God is something you do not seek.

Report a mistake

John 5:45

Think not

Ver. 45. — Think not, &c. Listen to Cyril, "He declares that there was no need of any other accuser, for that although all others were silent, the law of Moses by itself was sufficient for the condemnation of the Jews who diil not believe in Him." He names Moses because the Jews placed all their faith and trust in him. As they said, " We know that God spake unto Moses : as for this fellow, we know not from whence He is" (John ix. 28).

John 5:45 · Open Word Bible

45Do not imagine that I will be the one to accuse you before the Father. You already have an accuser: Moses, in whom you have put your hope.

Report a mistake

John 5:46

For if ye had believed Moses, perchance (Vulg

... Perchance ; so the Vulgate often translates the Greek, an : but it is here used in the sense of assuredly. It is an expression of confirmatio?i, not of doubt. " Assuredly ye would have believed Me." Hence some copies omit the word perchance.

For he wrote of Me : both in Leviticus, and the whole Pentateuch; for all his ceremonies and narrations prefigured Me. Also he clearly and expressly wrote of Me (Deut. xviii. 15, 18), saying, "The Lord thy God will raise up unto thee a Prophet from the midst of thee, of thy brethren, like unto me ; unto him ye shall hearken ; I will raise them up a Prophet from among their brethren, like unto thee, and will put my words in his mouth ; and he shall speak unto them all that I shall command him."

Again Moses wrote of Christ (Gen. xlix. 10), when he speaks of the time at which Messiah was to come. " The sceptre shall not be taken away from Judah, nor a leader from his thigh, until He that is to be sent shall come : and the same shall be the expectation of the nations" (Vulg.)

John 5:46 · Open Word Bible

46If you really believed Moses, you would believe Me, because what he wrote was about Me.

Report a mistake

John 5:47

But if

Ver. 47. — But if &c. This is an argument ad hominem. For the Jews preferred Moses to Christ. Wherefore He rightly reasons against them thus : ** If ye do not believe the writings of Moses (of whom ye make the highest account) which he wrote concerning Me, far less will ye believe My own words. In vain therefore do I bring so many testimonies, since I see you confirmed and obstinate in your hatred and rebellion against Me. Therefore I conclude My discourse. I will keep silence and depart.'

( 196 )

John 5:47 · Open Word Bible

47But if you do not believe the writings of Moses, how will you ever believe My spoken words?"

Report a mistake