Logia

Cornelius a Lapide · The Great Commentary: S. John's Gospel

John 19

25 excerpts on John 19, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

John 19:1

Then Pilate therefore took Jesus and scourged Him

Ver. I. — Then Pilate therefore took Jesus and scourged Him. That is after he had said (Luke xxiii. 22), "I will chastise Him and let Him go." The tradition is that He was first scourged with thick ropes, then with knotted ropes and iron scorpions, then with chains, and lastly with rods of thorns. But Ribera says that these traditions are of little account, as the inhabitants of the country have so often changed, and the old traciitions were not kept up.

John 19:1 · Open Word Bible

1Then Pilate took Jesus and had Him flogged.

Report a mistake

John 19:2

And they put on Him a purple robe

Ver. 2. — And they put on Him a purple robe. — See notes on S. Matt, xxvii. 30, also [Pseudo] Athanasius, de Cruce, who says that Christ bore in the purple robe the blood of men (because the devil had polluted the earth with murders), in the thorns their sins, in the reed the hand-writing with which the devil had enrolled us as his own ; for all these Christ took away by His Passion. He adds that when Christ took the reed, the devil armed him with a weapon against himself, for the reed is said to be fatal to serpents, and that Christ took the reed to deliver us from the serpent's subtilty.

John 19:2 · Open Word Bible

2The soldiers wove a crown out of thorns and set it on His head, and they dressed Him in a purple robe.

Report a mistake

John 19:7

He ought to die, because He made Himself the Son of God

Ver. 7. — He ought to die, because He made Himself the Son of God. As being a blasphemer, sacrilegious, and opposed to God. S. Augustine says, " See here a greater charge. It seemed but a light thing that He had aimed at sovereign power ; and yet He did not falsely claim anything ; for He is the Only Begotten Son of God, and is King placed by Him on the hill of Sion, and He would now give proof of both, unless, the more powerful He was, the more patient did He choose to be."

John 19:7 · Open Word Bible

7The Jewish leaders replied, "We have a law, and by that law He must die, because He made Himself the Son of God."

Report a mistake

John 19:11

Ver. II. — Thou wouldest have no power against Me, unless it were given thee from above : therefore he that delivered Me ufito thee hath the greater sin. The best explanation of this passage is that of Jansenius, Cajetan, and Ribera. Thou couldest have no power over Me, both because I am innocent, and because I could deliver Myself, if I so willed ; But My Father willed that I should submit to thee, in order to the work of redemption, and accordingly permitted thee to give way to the Jews in this matter, and to exercise thy power over Me. But this thou wouldest not have done, unless they had accused Me. Their sin is therefore greater than thine.

John 19:11 · Open Word Bible

11Jesus answered, "You would have no authority over Me at all unless it had been given to you from above. That is why the one who handed Me over to you carries the greater sin."

Report a mistake

John 19:12

Ver. 12. — And from thenceforth Pilate sought to release Him. He had sought to do so before. But he now more especially did so, after he had heard that He was the Son of God ; fearing to incur the vengeance of God on condemning Him. The fear of Csesar, however, prevailed over the fear of God. The Gentiles reckoned many sons of the gods, whom they worshipped as demigods. See S. Cyril in loc.

John 19:12 · Open Word Bible

12From then on Pilate tried to set Him free, but the Jewish leaders shouted, "If you let this man go, you are no friend of Caesar. Anyone who claims to be a king is setting himself against Caesar."

Report a mistake

John 19:13

Ver. 13. — In a place that was called the Pavement, but in the Hebrew Gabbatha. That is a High Place, the seat of judgment, being raised on many steps. These steps were sent to Rome, and placed near the Church of S. John Lateran. They are much reverenced by the faithful.

John 19:13 · Open Word Bible

13When Pilate heard this, he brought Jesus outside and took his seat on the judgment seat at the place known as the Stone Pavement, in Hebrew Gabbatha.

Report a mistake

John 19:14

It was the preparation of the Passover

Ver. 14. — It was the preparation of the Passover. That is of the Paschal Sabbath, the Sabbath which fell in the octave. On this day great preparations were made for the following Sabbath, on which no work could be done. This was the only Sabbath which had its preparation-day. The Greeks explain it as being the day before the offering of the Paschal Lamb. But according to the other Evangelists Christ was crucified on the day after the Passover, which S. John terms the day before the Paschal Sabbath.

About the sixth hour. That is, says the Arabic version, six hours after sunrise. S. Mark says it was the third hour. Some consider that S. John should here be corrected by S. Mark. But all the MS. and versions read " the sixth hour."

2. S. Jerome (on Ps. Ixxvii.) thinks that S. Mark should be corrected by S. John. But here all the MS. of S. Mark agree in reading the third hour.

John 19:14 · Open Word Bible

14It was the day of Preparation of the Passover, about noon. Pilate said to the Jewish leaders, "Look, here is your King!"

Report a mistake

John 19:17

Bearing His cross

Ver. 17. — Bearing His cross. After the Roman custom. S. Augustine writes, "A noble spectacle: a great jest for the ungodly, but a great mystery to the godly ; a great mark of disgrace to the wicked, a great evidence of faith to the godly; ungodliness, as it looks on, laughs at a King bearing His cross of punishment instead of His sceptre : while the godly behold a King bearing the cross on which He was to be nailed, and which He would afterwards fix on the brows of kings ; scorned in the eyes of the ungodly for that very thing in which the hearts of the saints would thereafter glory." Gal. vi. 14.

John 19:17 · Open Word Bible

17Carrying the cross by Himself, He went out to what is called the Place of the Skull (in Hebrew, Golgotha).

Report a mistake

John 19:23

Ver. 23. — But His coat was without seam, woven from the top throughout. Euthymius says it was said to have been woven by the Blessed, Virgin.

Allegorically. This was a type of Christ's Church, which it is not lawful to rend, and thus cause a schism.

Tropologically. S. Bernard regards it as the Divine Image, so implanted and impressed on nature that it cannot be torn asunder.

John 19:23 · Open Word Bible

23When the soldiers had crucified Jesus, they took His clothes and divided them into four shares, one share for each soldier. They also took His tunic. The tunic was seamless, woven in a single piece from top to bottom.

Report a mistake

John 19:25

... Christ wished it so to be, that He might suffer the more by witnessing the sorrows of His mother, and that she by sharing His sufferings might give us a perfect example of patience and charity: as Damascene says {Lib. iv. 13), "The pangs of child-birth which she escaped she suffered at the time of His Passion, by her motherly compassion, bearing Him afresh in beholding His wounds." For the holier she was, and the nearer to Christ, the larger was the cup of suffering which He offered her. Euthymius states that she stood quite close to the cross, her ardent love overmastering her fear of the Jews. She stood therefore firm and erect in her body, more erect in her mind, looking and wondering at this great mystery of godliness, God hanging on the cross. Hence Sophronius {S. Jerojfie. Sertn. de Assump.) calls the Blessed Virgin a martyr ; nay, more than a martyr, " Because," he says, " she suffered in her mind. Her love indeed was stronger than death, because she made the death of Christ her own." And S. Ildephonsus {Serm. ii. de Assnfnpt.), " She was more than a martyr, because there was in her no less love than sorrow. She was wounded with a sword within, for she stood prepared, though the hand to smite her was wanting. And she was rightly more than a martyr, for, wounded with overpowering love, she witnessed His death, and in her inward grief she bare the torture of the Passion."

John 19:25 · Open Word Bible

25Meanwhile, near the cross of Jesus stood His mother, her sister, Mary the wife of Clopas, and Mary Magdalene.

Report a mistake

John 19:26

Ver. 26. — When Jesus therefore saw His Mother, and His disciple standing by whom He loved, He saith unto His Mother, Woman, behold thy son 1 Christ pierced her heart with the wound both of love and sorrow, for He meant, Mother, I am, as thou seest, dying on the Cross : I shall not be able to be with thee, to attend to thee, to provide for thee, and assist thee as I have hitherto done. I assign to thee, in my place, John to be thy son ; a man in the place of God, a disciple for a master, an adopted son instead of thine own by nature ] in order that he, as a virgin, and most beloved by thee as the Virgin Mother of God, may bestow on thee all the solace, and all the devotion, which both thy dignity and thy advancing age demand, and which the zeal and love of John promises and assures to thee. Christ therefore here teaches that children should care for their parents even to the last, says Theophylact from S. Chrysostom. Hear S. Augustine : " Here is a passage of moral teaching. Our good Teacher instructed His own by His own example, that pious children should have a care for their parents ; as if that wood on which His limbs were fastened when He was dying, were also the chair of the teacher." For, as S. Cyril says, " We ought to learn from Him, and through Him, first of all, that parents must not be neglected, even when intolerable sufferings are hanging over us." " But wonder, with Theophylact, at the calmness with which He does everything on the cross ; caring for His mother, fulfilling prophecies, promising paradise to the thief; but before He came to it, how burdened was He, pouring forth His sweat, and full of trouble." For, as Euthymius says, "in the one case the weakness of nature was seen, in the other His great power of endurance."

John 19:26 · Open Word Bible

26Jesus saw His mother there, and near her the disciple whom He loved. He said to His mother, "Woman, look, here is your son."

Report a mistake

John 19:27

Ver. 2 7. — Then saith Re to His disciple, Behold thy mother ! Love her, attend to her, help her, as thy moihen And, on the other hand, betake thyself to her, as thy mother in every difficulty, temptation, jjersecution, and affliction. She will cherish thee with motherly affection, will console and protect thee, and ask help for thee from her Son. And these words of Christ are not mere lip words, and without effect, like those of men : but as the words of God they are real and efficacious, and effect that which they declare. And accordingly they impressed on S. John a filial affection and spirit towards the Blessed Virgin, as though she were his mother. Theophylact exclaims, " How wonderful ! how doth He honour His disciple, in making him His brother? How good is it to stand by the cross, and to abide close to Christ in His sufferings ! " And S. Chrysostom : '• What honour does He confer on His disciple ! Fot when He was about to depart He left the care of His mother to His disciple. For when it was natural for her to sorrow as His mother, and to seek for protection, He most fitly commends her to His beloved disciple, to whom He says, ' Behold thy mother ! ' that so they might be bound together in love."

John 19:27 · Open Word Bible

27Then He said to the disciple, "Look, here is your mother." From that time on the disciple took her into his own home.

Report a mistake

John 19:28

Ver. 28. — After this, Jesus knowi?ig that all things were now accomplished, that the scripture might be fulfilled, saith, I thirst. After about three hours. It was at the beginning of the crucifixion that He commended His mother to S. John. The scripture was Ps. Ixix. 22. He said this that He might suffer the further torment of being offered the vinegar. As S. Augustine says, " Ye have not yet done this. Give Me that which ye are yourselves — for ye are full of acidity and bitterness ; give Me vinegar, and not wine."

Christ thirsted, because He had neither eaten nor drunken since His supper the night before, and He had moreover poured forth all the moisture and blood in His body, by His scourging and crucifixion. And His most bitter pains also caused Him great thirst ; for, as S. Cyril says, " Sorrows enkindle the heat within us, dry up our moisture from its very depths, and burn us up with fiery heat." Hence our jaws are dried up, and are parched with thirst. The words of the Psalmist (xxii. 6) were fulfilled in Christ's person. The Chancellor of Louvain, when he was dying forty years ago, said in my presence, that he never fully untlerstood those words, as he did when he was himself suffering from like drought and thirst, and thence learned how great the thirst of Christ was. Mystically, Christ thirsted for the salvation of souls. See Bellarmine on "The seven words of Christ on the cross." " Gotl tliirsleth to be thirsted for," says Nazianzen in Tefrastichisis, in order that we may insatiably love and desire Him, and say with the Psalmist, '• My soul is athirst for God, yea, even for the living God : when shall I come to appear before the presence of God?" Ps. xlii. 2.

John 19:28 · Open Word Bible

28After this, Jesus knew that everything had now been finished. So that the Scripture would be completed, He said, "I am thirsty."

Report a mistake

John 19:30

Ver. 30. — When Jesus therefore had received the vinegar, He said, It is finished: and He bowed His head, and gave up the ghost. All the suffering and all the mysteries which the Father decreed from all eternity that I should suffer and carry out, as He ordered from My very birth, and willed, moreover, that the prophets should foretell concerning Me, There remains only the final issue of death, to complete My course of suffering, to expiate thereby the penalty of death, which Adam incurred by sin, and to restore mankind to life. I therefore embrace it, and resign My spirit into the hands of My Father. (Matt, xxvii. 48, seq.)

Christ spake seven words on the cross, three recorded by S. John, the four others by the other Evangelists.

John 19:30 · Open Word Bible

30When Jesus had taken the sour wine, He said, "It is finished." Then He bowed His head and handed over His spirit.

Report a mistake

John 19:31

Ver. 31. — The Jews therefore (because it was the preparation) that the bodies should not remain on the cross on the sabbath day (for that sabbath-day was an high day) besought Pilate that their legs might be broken, and that they might be taken away. See Deut. xxi. 22. This was done, in order that they might not pollute and make gloomy this most solemn festival, by the horror of their sufferings, as St. Augustine says. It was necessary therefore that they should die and be buried before sunset, at which time the sabbath began. "That," as Theophylact says, "the sun might not set on their sufferings."

For this was the sabbath within the octave of the Passover, and for this reason a more solemn day than other sabbaths.

Their legs were to be broken with the strong blows of a mallet or iron bar, to make them die the sooner, from the intensity of the pain, or the loss of blood, or because the vital force resides in the knees and legs. (See Pliny, N. H. xi, 45.)

John 19:31 · Open Word Bible

31It was the day of Preparation, and the Jewish leaders did not want the bodies to stay on the crosses over the Sabbath, because that Sabbath was a day of special importance. So they asked Pilate to have the men's legs broken and the bodies removed.

Report a mistake

John 19:33

Ver. 33. — But when they came to Jesus (evidently to break His legs. Euthymius says, " They came to Him last, as wishing to please the Jews by treating Him with greater insult) and saw that He was dead already, they brake not His legs. He did not wish His legs to be broken, for He wished to rise again with an unmutilated body. As Lactantius says (iv. 26), " His body is taken down from the cross entire, and carefully laid in the tomb, lest by the loss of any limb it might be rendered less seemly for resurrection."

Instead, then, of His legs being broken. His side was pierced with the spear. This was after He was dead, not while He was alive, as some have thought. This error was condemned in the Council of Vienne. For as Christ, while alive, gave up His whole Body for us, so did He in His death wish to give us His heart. For this it was that was pierced by the spear, and blood and water flowed forth from it, so that He gave Himself entirely to us.

John 19:33 · Open Word Bible

33But when they reached Jesus, they saw that He had already died. So they did not break His legs.

Report a mistake

John 19:34

But one of the soldiers opened His side

Ver. 34. — But one of the soldiers opened His side. As somewhat doubting, says S. Cyril, whether He were really dead ; and if He were not, to hasten His death. P'or it was the duty of these soldiers to carry out the sentence, and to see that criminals were not taken away before it was certain that they were dead. S. Chrysostom adds, " To please the Jews, they lay open His side and insult Him when dead. O most evil and most atrocious wish." Some suppose that this soldier was the centurion, who cried out " Truly this was the Son of God !" (Matthew xxvii. 54.) But it is not likely that he who so cried out would dare to commit such an act. Nazianzen in his "Christus Patiens " suggests that he was blind, and that he then regained his sight. Many stories on this matter were collected by Barradius, which Baronius rejects as apocryphal. Here note — 1. That the soldier was one of the guard who brake the legs of the two malefactors, and would have broken Christ's also had he been alive. But they pierced His side, to show that He was dead, and this was why they brake not His legs. 2. Some say it was a spear, others a sword which was used. 3. ... 4. This wound was so large that a hand could have been thrust into it. See John xx. 27. 5. It was on the right side, as represented by painters. Some think it was so foretold by Ezekiel xvii. 2. S. Francis also received his wound on the right side. See S. Bonaventura, Ribadeaeira, &c. 6. Christ therefore received six wounds. 7. This wound seems to have pierced through both sides, as Prudentius says in several passages. As, e.g..

John 19:34 · Open Word Bible

34One of the soldiers, however, drove a spear into His side, and at once blood and water flowed out.

Report a mistake

John 19:35

And he that saw it bare record

Ver. 35. — And he that saw it bare record. Probably John himself, who speaks of himself unassumingly in the third person.

John 19:35 · Open Word Bible

35The one who saw this has testified to it, and his testimony is true. He knows that what he says is true, and he has told it so that you also may believe.

Report a mistake

John 19:36

... A bone, i.e. of the Paschal Lamb (Fa. xii. 46). The literal reason was, that they had to eat it in haste, and had not time to break the bones and extract the marrow. The allegorical reason was, because that lamb was a type of Christ, and God willed that a bone of Him should not be broken, in order that His sacred Body, which was to rise again, should remain complete in every limb. Symbolically, it signified — (i.) That the Godhead of Christ, which was (as it were) the bone which supported His Body, remained entire and uninjured in His Passion (see Rupertus on Ex. xii.)

(2.) That the strength and vigour of Christ as man (of which the bones were a symbol) were not diminished, but rather increased, by His Passion. For His mind was steadfastly fixed on God, and His will remained firmly and constantly united to the Divine Will. So the Martyr Hippolytus says. See Theodoret, Dialog, iii.

John 19:36 · Open Word Bible

36These things took place so that the Scripture would be fulfilled: "Not one bone of His will be broken."

Report a mistake

John 19:37

Ver. 37. — And again another scripture saith, They shall look on Him whom they pierced. See Zech. xii. 10.

John 19:37 · Open Word Bible

37And another passage of Scripture also says, "They will look on the one they pierced."

Report a mistake

John 19:38

Ver. 38. — But after this Joseph of Arimathcea {I'eijig a disciple of Jesus, but secretly for fear of the Jews) besought Pilate that he might take away the body of Jesus : and Pilate gave him leave. He came therefore, and took the body of Jesus. See notes on Matt, xxvii. 58. He took away the Body of Jesus to be buried (says S. Chrysostom), "not as that of a criminal, but of a great and wonderful prophet. For he did not believe thai He was God, and that He would rise again on the third day. He had faith in Jesus, but yet an imperfect faith." But see here, how God exalts the humble. For the more ignominious was His Passion and death, the more glorious was His sepulchre. See Is. xi. to. " His sepulchre will be glorious." (See Vulg.)

John 19:38 · Open Word Bible

38After this, Joseph of Arimathea, a disciple of Jesus who had kept it hidden because he feared the Jewish leaders, asked Pilate for permission to take away the body of Jesus, and Pilate granted it. So Joseph came and took His body away.

Report a mistake

John 19:39

Ver. 39. — And there cajne also Nicodemus, which at the first came to Jesus by tiight. He came first by night, but afterwards to hear Him, and become His disciple, (See S. Augustine in loc.)

Bearing a mixture of myrrh and aloes, about a hundred pounds" weight. To embalm and bury nobly so great a prophet. He wished not only to pour the ointment over the whole body, but to embalm, and cover it over with it. He probably did not use the whole of it, but only what was necessary, Nicodemus obtained an ample reward for this kind office to Christ, for by His grace he became not only a Christian, but a Confessor.

Lucian, in his epistle De Invent. Corp. ... "The Jews, learning that he was a Christian, removed him from his ofiice, excommunicated and banished him. Then I, Gamaliel, brought him into my own place, fed and clothed him, and buried him honourably near to S. Stephen" [see also S. Augustine, Serm. 316-324]. In the martyrology he is enrolled with S. Stephen among the saints.

John 19:39 · Open Word Bible

39Nicodemus came too, the man who had first come to Jesus at night. He brought a mixture of myrrh and aloes weighing about 70 pounds.

Report a mistake

John 19:40

... See on Matt, xxvi, 59.

This mode of burial the early Christians imitated, who incurred lavish expense in their burial and embalming. ... Meletii ; Nazianzen, Epist. xviii.

The Christians adopted this practice from the Jews, the Jews from the Egyptians.

John 19:40 · Open Word Bible

40They took Jesus's body and wrapped it with the spices in linen cloths, which is how the Jews prepare a body for burial.

Report a mistake

John 19:41

Ver. 41. — Noiu in the place where He was crucified there was a garden (for where could Jesus, the Author of all verdure and vigour, be buried, except in a garden?) See notes on Matt, xxvii. 60. And in the garden a new sepulchre, zvherein was ?iever man yet laid ; as S. Augustine says, " As no one before or after Him was conceived in a virgin's womb, so no one either before or after Him was buried in that tomb."

John 19:41 · Open Word Bible

41There was a garden at the place where He had been crucified, and in that garden there was a new tomb where no one had ever been laid.

Report a mistake

John 19:42

... Uut God wished Him to be buried near Golgotha and Jerusalem. S. Chrysostom gives the reason : "That the disciples might the more readily betake themselves thither, and observe what was going on thereabouts, and also that not only they, but their enemies also, might be witnesses of His burial. The seal also, and the guards who were placed over the sepulchre, were witnesses to the same. Christ wished that His death should be witnessed no less than His Resurrection, for if His death had been a matter of doubt, the proof of His Resurrection would not hold good. And not only did He wish, for these reasons, to be buried nigh at hand, but also that no one might falsely allege that His Body had been stolen away."

( 253 )

John 19:42 · Open Word Bible

42The tomb was close at hand, and it was the Jewish day of Preparation, so they laid Jesus there.

Report a mistake