Logia

Cornelius a Lapide · The Great Commentary: S. John's Gospel

John 9

25 excerpts on John 9, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

John 9:1

Afid as Jesus passed by

Ver. I. — Afid as Jesus passed by, &c. Passing through the midst of His enemies and the crowd of the people. This signifies (though some deny it) that this cure took place immediately after Christ had withdrawn from the temple. As soon as He had escaped His enemies, He became visible again, and His disciples followed Him. "He mitigated their anger by His withdrawal, and softened their hardness by working a miracle" says S. Chrysostom.

He looked upon him tenderly and fixedly, as pitying him, and intending to restore his sight. And this intent look caused the disciples to inquire the cause of his blindness. "He Himself" (says S. Chrysostom) "saw that he was blind. The blind man did not come to Him, but He looked on him so stedfastly, that the disciples asked the question which follows." Mystically, sinners and unbelievers are blind, and are thus unable to see and seek for Christ. So that Christ must needs look on them first and enlighten them with the eyes of His grace.

John 9:1 · Open Word Bible

1As Jesus was passing by, He saw a man who had been blind from birth.

Report a mistake

John 9:2

And His disciples

Ver. 2. — And His disciples, &c. This question sprang out of the opinion of the ignorant multitude, who think that diseases are the punishments of sin, and, as S. Ambrose says, " They ascribe weaknesses of body to the deserts of their sins." But they are wrong in this ; for though it is often the case, yet not always. For Job, though innocent, was afflicted in order to try his patience, as Tobias also, and many others. S. Chrysostom and Theophylact say that this question was out of place and absurd.

Others think that the disciples were led to ask this question by what Christ said (v. 14), "Sin no more, lest a worse thing happen to thee."

A man's own fault, and not that of another, seems to be the cause of his own blindness, by way of punishment. Original sin is in truth the cause of all the evils and punishments which befal us in this life, and of the diseases of infants especially as S. Augustine teaches us {Co?tir. Julian iii. 4). But this was not the special reason why this man, above all other infants, was born blind. Whence S. Augustine says, " This man could not have been born without original sin ; nor yet have added nothing to it by his life. He therefore and his parents had sin, but the sin was not the cause of his being born blind."

John 9:2 · Open Word Bible

2His disciples asked Him, "Rabbi, who sinned, so that this man was born blind? Was it he, or his parents?"

Report a mistake

John 9:4

/ must work

Ver. 4. — I must work, &c. S. Chrysostom, Theophylact, and others understand by the word " day " the present life, and by " night " the future life. But this is what is common to all men. But Christ speaks of this day as specially relating to Himself and His own work. And therefore S. Augustine, Cyril, and Bede put a better and closer meaning on the word day, as speaking of the life of Christ on earth, and yiight as referring to His absence, meaning by this, that just as men cannot work at night on account of the darkness, so after death shall I no longer work as I do now for the salvation and redemption of men. "My day" (viii. 56) means in like manner My birth and My life amongst men. He says this, as preparing the way for the healing of the blind man. " I am sent into the world to do good to men : this blind man presents himself and I will restore his sight." Symbolically : Night, says the Interlinear Gloss, is the persecution of the Apostles, especially by antichrist, Tropologically : The time of life given to every one to gain eternal glory is his "day." Night is his death (see Eccles. ix. 10). ... Then will be the flight, when no man can work, but only receive for what he hath wrought. Work while thou art alive, lest thou be prevented by that night." It was common among poets and philosophers to call life day, and death night, and many instances and authorities are given from Pagan writers to this purpose. But to take some Christian ones, Messodamus, a very holy man, was once asked by a friend to dine with him on the morrow, ** I have had no morrow," he replied, " for many years : every day have I looked for the coming of death." And this is what S. Anthony (apud S. Athanasius) and Barlaam advised every devout and " religious " man to do.

John 9:4 · Open Word Bible

4While it is still day, we have to do the works of the one who sent Me. Night is on its way, and then no one can work.

Report a mistake

John 9:5

As long as I am in the world

Ver. 5. — As long as I am in the world, &c. And therefore I will give light to this blind man, to show that I am the Light of this world.

John 9:5 · Open Word Bible

5While I am in the world, I am the light of the world."

Report a mistake

John 9:6

Ver. 6. — And when He had thus said, &c. He used clay, which naturally closes up the eyes, to show that He healed the man supernaturally. The symbolical reason was (S. Chrysostom says) to signify that He was the self-same (God) who formed man out of clay, and that it was His work to form and fashion again (by restoring his sight) a man who was formed by Him, but deformed by blindness. He showed thus that He was the Lord of all things, and of the Sabbath also, so as to work His cure on that day whatever outcry the Pharisees might make. So Cyril, Leontius, Theophylact. Accordingly the Interlinear Gloss says, " See, here is the eye-salve with which mankind is anointed, the thought, namely, of its own vileness, as being made of clay, so as to be cured of the pride which had blinded it. According to the saying, ' Remember, O man, that thou art dust, and into dust thou wilt return.' " Christ used His spittle, says Cyril, to show that even His Flesh had a supernatural power of healing. (2.) Because spittle is a symbol of recuperative power (several derivations of "saliva" are here suggested which are of no value, and several instances of cures by its use). (3.) He used it that no virtue should be ascribed to the pool of Siloam, but to the power of His own mouth from whence it came; for by the bidding of His own mouth He drove away the blindness. (4.) That thus this miracle might be the more fully attested. (5.) To test the faith and obedience of the blind man (see S. Chrysostom). Why did He send him to Siloam, that all men might see him going with the clay on his eyes ? But there was no reason to fear that the cure would be attributed to Siloam, because many had washed there without being cured. But the faith of the blind man was shown by his not saying a word or having a thought against it, but he simply obeyed.

John 9:6 · Open Word Bible

6When He had said this, He spat on the ground, made mud with the saliva, and spread the mud on the man's eyes.

Report a mistake

John 9:7

And said unto Him

Ver. 7. — And said unto Him, &c. Siloam is a stream at the foot of Mount Sion, which does not flow continuously, but at uncertain times of the day ; it bursts forth (says S. Jerome) with a loud noise, and is then silent. It hides itself under the earth, and by channels runs into the pool of Siloam, and hence is conveyed silently and gently into the royal gardens, which it waters. (See S. Jerome on Is. viii.) Epiphanius thus gives its history. " God made the fount of Siloam at the request of the Prophet (Isaiah), who shortly before his death prayed that He would grant the waters to flow from that place, and He immediately poured down from heaven living waters ; whence the place obtained the name Siloam, which means sent dmvn. And under king Hezekiah, before he built the pool, a small stream sprang up at the prayers of Isaiah (for they were hard pressed by the enemy), that the people might not perish for lack of water. The soldiers searched everywhere for water and could not tell where to find it. But when the poor Jews went to seek water it burst out for them in a stream. But strangers could not find it, for the water withdrew itself And even up to the present time it bursts forth secretly, thus signifying a mystery." Epiphanius records this in his life of the Prophet. Baronius compares it to a stream in Palestine called Sabbaticus, because it flowed only on the Sabbath. (See Baronius a.d. 33, cap. xxvi., and Josephus, de Bello Jud. cap. xiv.) S. Irengsus (iv. 19) says that Siloam effected its cures very frequently on the Sabbath,

John 9:7 · Open Word Bible

7Then He told him, "Go and wash in the pool of Siloam" (the name means Sent). So the man went and washed, and he came back able to see.

Report a mistake

John 9:8–9

... [Vulg.) "The greatness of the deed brought about incredulity," says S. Chrysostom. "And the opening of the eyes had changed the appearance of the blind man," says S. Augustine, " so that looking on him they doubted whether he who saw was the one who aforetime was blind ; but carefully watching him as he walked along the long way, they acknowledged him to be the same, and that it could not be denied." So S. Chrysostom.

The wondrous mercy of God healed most carefully those who were beggars, counting those who were mean of birth to be worthy of His providential care; for He came for the healing of all. Thus many poor people and of slender means obtain of the Blessed Virgin miracles of healing, at her shrines at Loretto and Sichem, both because they are in greater need than the rich, and are more innocent in their lives, also exhibit greater faith and devotion, and because she specially cares for them, as being destitute ; just as it is said, " The poor committeth himself to Thee [is left to Thy care] ; Thou art the helper of the orphan" (Ps. x. 14).

John 9:8–9 · Open Word Bible

8His neighbors, and others who had seen him earlier as a beggar, began asking, "Is this not the man who sat begging?" 9Some said, "That is the man." Others said, "No, it is someone who looks like him." The man himself kept saying, "I am the one."

Report a mistake

John 9:10

Therefore said they unto him

Ver. 10. — Therefore said they unto him, &c. "The man," says Euthymius and Theophylact, "knew not as yet that Jesus was God." The blind man had learned the name of Jesus from common report, or from asking the bystanders. That he called Him not Rabbi, must be ascribed partly to his simplicity and candour, and partly to his truthfulness. For in order that he might not give any weight to his own opinion respecting Christ, he spake only the bare truth, and merely called Him Jesus. Perhaps he did it, likewise, in order not to excite the Jews, who were opposed to Christ, the more against Him.

John 9:10 · Open Word Bible

10So they asked him, "How were your eyes opened?"

Report a mistake

John 9:12

And they said to him, Where is He? He said, I know not

Ver. 12. — And they said to him, Where is He? He said, I know not. For Jesus had withdrawn Himself, as shrinking from praise ; for He did not, says S. Chrysostom, "seek for glory, or selfdisplay."

John 9:12 · Open Word Bible

12They asked him, "Where is He?" "I do not know," he said.

Report a mistake

John 9:13

They brought to the Pharisees

Ver. 13. — They brought to the Pharisees, &c. They brought him to the Pharisees, that they might examine the matter. This was done by the purpose of God, that the miracle might be fully attested and made widely known, so that the Pharisees could not deny it. Whence S. Augustine says, "The blind man confessed, the heart of the wicked was broken." "They bring him to the Pharisees, as being judges, and therefore assembled in their house of judgment." This house seems to have been a synagogue, close to the temple ; for a question of religion and belief was at stake, which the Pharisees had to decide by examining the miracle, and to judge accordingly whether He who wrought it was the Messiah or not.

For in truth to make clay in order to give sight to the blind, is not a breaking but a sanctification of the Sabbath.

John 9:13 · Open Word Bible

13They took the man who had been blind to the Pharisees.

Report a mistake

John 9:17

Ver. 17. — They say unto the blind man again, What sayest thou of Him who hath opened thine eyes 1 He said. He is a Prophet. That is a specially holy man, a wonder-worker. So Abraham (Gen xx. 7) is called a Prophet (see what is said on i Cor. xiv. ad rem, and Eccius. xlviii. 12, on the various meanings of the word Prophet). " Being at present not anointed in heart, he did not confess Christ to be the Son of God. But yet he did not speak falsely of Him. For the Lord said of Himself, " A prophet is not without honour, save in His own country."

They asked the blind man the same question again and again, out of bitter hatred of Christ, and also to involve him in the same guilt with Christ. They wished also to elicit something out of his mouth to make him contradict himself, that so they might convict him of a lie. But God caught them in their own craftiness. For by this frequent examination, the consistent confession of the blind man, and consequently the glory of Christ, shone forth. S. Chrysostom wisely says, "It is the nature of truth to become stronger by the snares laid against it," And that was now the case, for the parents are brought forward, who fully acknowledged their son, and confirmed his words.

John 9:17 · Open Word Bible

17So they questioned the man who had been blind once more: "And you, what do you say about Him, since it was your eyes He opened?" He answered, "He is a prophet."

Report a mistake

John 9:18

Ver 1 8. — But the Javs did not believe, &c. ... Theophylact states that this was their dilemma. It is either false that your son now sees, or that he was blind at first. But it is admitted that he sees, it was therefore false that he was, as he says, previously blind. His parents reply cautiously. They knew him to be their son, and that he was born blind. But how he gained his sight they knew not. They speak with prudence so as not to deny the truth, nor yet incur the peril of excommunication. And hence they say, " He is of age," meaning, says S. Augustine, " we should justly be compelled to speak for an infant, for it could not speak for itself. But he is a man who can speak for himself, therefore (say they) ask him."

John 9:18 · Open Word Bible

18The Jewish leaders did not believe that he had been blind and had gained his sight, until they summoned the parents of the man who could now see.

Report a mistake

John 9:22

For the Jews

Ver, 22, — For the Jews, &c. " But it was no evil to be put out of the synagogue," says S. Augustine, " for they expelled, but Christ received him." " But the parents said this, because they were less 348 s. JOHN, c. tx.

firm than their son, wlio stood forth as an intrepid witness of the truth," says Theophylact.

John 9:22 · Open Word Bible

22His parents spoke in this way out of fear of the Jewish leaders, who had already agreed that anyone who confessed Him as the Christ would be expelled from the synagogue.

Report a mistake

John 9:24

Then again called they the man

Ver. 24. — Then again called they the man, &c. To give God the glory, is a form of obtestation or oath among the Jews (see Josh. vii. 19). Confess that this man is a sinner, and so wilt thou by this confession of the truth give glory to God, who is the chief and eternal truth. " To give glory to God " (says the Gloss) " is to speak the truth as in the presence of God." They wished to persuade him under the pretext of religion (says S. Chrysostom), to deny that he was cured by Christ, or if he were, it was by magic and sleight of hand. " Deny," says the Interlinear Gloss, " the benefit thou hast received by Christ. But this were to blaspheme, and not to give glory to God."

Whether He be a sinner. " He answers prudently and cautiously, ncitherlaying himsell'open to the charge, nor yet concealingthetruth," says the Interlinear Gloss. But S. Chrysostom objects, "How was it that just before he called Him a Prophet, and now he says, ' Whether he be a sinner I know not ? ' " He does not say this by way of assertion, or through fear, but because he wished Jesus to be acquitted of the charges by the evidence of the fact. " I do not wish to argue the point with you. But I know for certain, that though once blind, now I see."

John 9:24 · Open Word Bible

24So they summoned the man who had been blind a second time and said to him, "Give glory to God. We know that this man is a sinner."

Report a mistake

John 9:28

They then reviled him

Ver. 28. — They then reviled him, &c. Tliey cursed him, saying, Be thou accursed, or at all events heaped maledictions and reproaches upon him. But their curse was without efifect, and was turned by Christ into a blessing. For it is an honour to the godly, to be cursed by the wicked. Whence S. Augustine says, " It is a curse if thou look into the heart of the speakers, but not if thou weighest the words themselves. May such a curse be on us, and on our children."

But we know not this man whefice he is, whether sent by God, as was Moses, or by the devil. So Euthymius.

John 9:28 · Open Word Bible

28They insulted him and said, "You are a disciple of that man, but we are disciples of Moses.

Report a mistake

John 9:30

7 he man answered

Ver 30. — 7 he man answered, &c. It was your business, as doctors and learned in the Law, to know that Jesus, who works so many miracles, must have been sent by God only. For it is God who works miracles by Him. " He brings in everywhere the miracle of his recovery of sight," says S. Chrysostom, " because they could not gainsay that, but were convinced thereby."

John 9:30 · Open Word Bible

30The man answered them, "Well, here is something to wonder at: you do not know where He comes from, and still He opened my eyes!

Report a mistake

John 9:31

Now we know

Ver. 31. — Now we know, &c. How can this be? For if sinners penitently ask pardon God vouchsafes it, and frequently bestows on sinners temporal blessings, and spiritual blessings also, if they ask for them. But I reply (i.) God ordinarily does not hear sinners ; sinners, I mean, persisting in their sin. Yet sometimes, though rarely, He hears even them. So Jansen. ... 9; Ps. 1. 16; Mai. ii. 2), But of the just it is said, "The eyes of the Lord are over the righteous, and His ears are open to their prayers" (Ps. xxxii. 16). And, "The eyes of the Lord are on them that fear Him " (Ecclus. xv. 20).

(2.) Secondly, and more befittingly to the case in point. He hears not sinners, so as to work miracles to establish their sanctity as He did by Jesus, to testify that He was the Messiah. So Maldonatus on this passage. (See also Suarez, torn. ii. de Relig., lib. de Oral. cap. XXV.) " God heareth not sinners if they pray with an evil intention," as e.g., to confirm their hypocrisy or lies.

John 9:31 · Open Word Bible

31We know that God does not listen to sinners. But if someone reveres God and does His will, He listens to them.

Report a mistake

John 9:32

... Granted that Moses and the Prophets wrought many miracles, yet they never restored sight to one who was born blind. Jesus who has restored my sight must needs be a greater Prophet than they. He retorted the words of the Pharisees on themselves, " Ye prefer Moses to Christ, but I prefer Christ. Ye choose to be Moses' disciples, I am Christ's."

John 9:32 · Open Word Bible

32In all the ages, no one has ever heard of anyone opening the eyes of someone born blind.

Report a mistake

John 9:33

— If this man were tiot of God, He could do nothing

Ver. ii- — If this man were tiot of God, He could do nothing, i.e., for curing my blindness. " He says this freely, stedfastly, and truly"

John 9:33 · Open Word Bible

33If this man were not from God, He would not be able to do anything at all."

Report a mistake

John 9:34

... For they held the tenet of Pythagoras that the soul existed before the body, and that it was in consequence of its sins thrust down into a deformed {i.e., a blind) body. So Cyril, Leontius, and others. Maldonatus explains, " Thou hast done nothing but sin from thy birth." So S. Chrysostom and Theophylact. And dost thou teach us? Thou blind sinner, wilt thou teach us who have our sight, and are wise and righteous ?

And they cast him out of the private house in which they were, as not deserving to be disputed with by such just teachers, says Maldonatus. Or out of the temple, as says S. Chrysostom, and consequently out of the synagogue, adds Leontius. That is, they excommunicated him. " But the Lord of the temple found him," says Chrysostom, "and took him up." Both statements are credible : that they drove him out of the house, and also excommunicated him, for this latter they had decided to do. As if they said, " Begone, thou apostate, and go to thine own Jesus." But this leads us to suppose that all this took place in the House of Judgment, a public place (see on verse 31). And that he was expelled from the synagogue appears more plainly from our Lord's own words in the next chapter, I am the door.

John 9:34 · Open Word Bible

34They answered him, "You were born in sin through and through, and now you are teaching us?" And they threw him out.

Report a mistake

John 9:35

Jesus heard that they had cast him out

Ver. 35. — -Jesus heard that they had cast him out, &c. Christ received him kindly, and rewards his constancy. Having given sight to his body, He now enlightens his mind. In giving him bodily sight, He had cast in some scattered seeds of faith, which He now particularly forms into perfect shape : so as to make him believe, that He whom he looked upon as a mere prophet, for having given him sight, was God also, and the Son of God. The Gloss says, "The blind man had already a heart prepared to believe, but knew not in whom he had to believe." This, in answer to his question, he learns from Christ

Christ took trouble to find him in the place, where He knew he was. It is the part of a good shepherd to seek for a wander mg sheep, who cannot by itself come back into the right way. "Tliey expel," says S. Augustine {in loc), " the Lord receives, and he becomes a Christian, even the more because he was expelled."

John 9:35 · Open Word Bible

35Jesus heard that they had thrown the man out, and when He found him, He said, "Do you believe in the Son of Man?"

Report a mistake

John 9:38

Ver. 38. — And he said, Lord, I beliroe. And he worshipped Him, as the Son of God, and very God, to be worshipped as God with the worship due to Him {latria). Moreover, the blind man, inwardly enlightened (and moved to it by Christ), by saying, " I believe," brought out acts of hope, contrition, charity, devotion, and adoration towards Christ, and was by them cleansed from his sins and justified. He consequently became a holy and apostolic man. He was said to have been one of the seventy disciples, and to have become Bishop of Aix, in Provence, where he died and was buried by the side of Maximinus, to whom he had been coadjutor (see Peter de Natalis in Cat. Sanctorum, lib. v. cap. 102).

John 9:38 · Open Word Bible

38He said, "I believe, Lord." And he worshiped Him.

Report a mistake

John 9:39

... But others explain it better, not of condemnation, but of inquiry and discrimination. I have come into the world to discriminate and separate believers from unbelievers, good from evil, godly from ungodly ; in order that the i)eoi)le, wiio before had lived in ignorance of God and of salvation, and in darkness of mind, like this blind man, might by believing in Me be enlightened with the knowledge of God, and of things which concern their salvation ; and that I might sutler the proud who refuse to believe in Me (like the Pharisees who are puffed up by their knowledge of the law) to be blinded, and might convict them of their blindness.

(2.) But judgment might possibly here mean the secret counsel and mysterious decree of God, determined and fixed by His righteous decree, whereby God ordained that the Gentiles who knew not God, and consequently were blind, might behold the Light of Faith in Christ, and humbly and eagerly accept it ; while the Scribes and Pharisees and wise men of the world, puffed up by their own knowledge, might become darkened in unbelief, and reject the faith and enlightenment of Christ. Humility, therefore, enlightened by faith the unlearned Gentiles, who submitted themselves to Christ, while pride darkened with unbelief the learned Scribes who rejected Him. So S. Cyril, or rather Clictoveus, who filled up what was wanting in his commentary. (See Rom. xi. 33.) " His judgments are a great deep." Theodoret applies this to Paul and Judas. For S. Paul having been blind received his sight, and Judas, after seeing, became blind. The words "that," "therefore," &c., frequently signify not the cause, but the result or consequence. For Christ came not in order that the Scribes should be made blind ; but their blindness was a result of Christ's preaching, not from anything on His part, but from their own pride and fault. So Cyril and others,

John 9:39 · Open Word Bible

39Jesus said, "I came into this world to bring judgment, so that those who cannot see will see, and those who see will become blind."

Report a mistake

John 9:40

And some of the Pharisees

Ver. 40. — And some of the Pharisees, &c. The Pharisees felt themselves sharply touched by our Lord's words, which they understood to speak not of the blindness of the body, but of the mind. They knew that they were not bodily blind, and therefore if He had said this, they would have hooted Him down as a fool. They said, Are we blind also ? Hast thou come to give sight to those who are blind in body, and to make out that we who spiritually see, and are doctors of the law, are blind and foolish ? Show us our blindness and foolishness.

John 9:40 · Open Word Bible

40Some of the Pharisees who were with Him heard this and said to Him, "You do not mean that we are blind too, do you?"

Report a mistake

John 9:41

Ver. 41. — Jesus said to thefn, &c. (i.) S. Chrysostom, Theophylact, and Euthymius explain this of bodily blindness; meaning, If ye were blind in your bodies, ye would be less proud and sinful. For bodily blindness would humble your mind. (2.)

(3.) Accurately and scholastically, If ye were blind through ignorance of Scripture and the law of nature, ye would not have sin, by acting according to this ignorance and not acknowledging Me as your Messiah. That is to say, If your ignorance were clearly without blame and invincible, ye would have some sin, but one which was less serious, and more excusable, and therefore ye might easily be enlightened and cured by Me, since My doctrine would dispel your ignorance. But now ye say to yourselves, "We see," that is, ye think ye see, and are so wise as to be excellent judges of Christ's advent and person. And therefore ye from your arrogant and evil thoughts continue in the sin of unbelief against Me ; ye obstinately set your mind against Me, and thus refuse to believe in Me as the Messiah, though I have demonstrated that I am by very many signs and miracles. And therefore, ye cannot by any possibility be enlightened and healed by Me, because ye obstinately refuse to hear Me. So Jansen and others.

John 9:41 · Open Word Bible

41Jesus said to them, "If you were blind, you would have no sin. But you say, 'We can see,' so your sin remains."

Report a mistake