Logia

Cornelius a Lapide · The Great Commentary: S. John's Gospel

John 6

45 excerpts on John 6, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

John 6:1

After this

Ver. I. — After this, &c. Tiberias is here named, because the desert in which Christ fed the five thousand was near to Tiberias.

After this, not immediately, but almost a year afterwards. For the healing of the paralytic, and the dispute of Jesus with the Jews consequent upon it, which John had related in the foregoing chapter, took place in the beginning of the second year of Christ's ministry. But the things which he relates in this sixth chapter took place at the close of the same year. This is plain because Christ healed the paralytic at the Passover (v. 1). ... John therefore omits all that Christ did in the second year of His ministry, viz., His creation of Twelve Apostles, His Sermon on the mount, His sending His Apostles forth, as well as many other things. John omits them because they had been fully narrated by the other Evangelists. But he here inserts the narrative of the multiplication of the loaves, because, though related by the other Evangelists, it was the occasion of Christ's discourse concerning spiritual food, and the food of the Eucharist, which John here gives at length, and which was wholly passed over by them.

John 6:1 · Open Word Bible

1Some time later Jesus went away across the Sea of Galilee, which is also called the Sea of Tiberias.

Report a mistake

John 6:3

He saith unto Philip

Ver. 3. — He saith unto Philip, &c. Observe, this was the order of what was done. Christ beholding from the mountain the crowd which followed Him, came down to them and received them kindly, taught them, and healed their sick until the eventide. The evening being at hand. His disciples asked Christ to dismiss the multitude, and refresh Himself with food. But Christ bade them first feed the hungry throngs. This, they said, was impossible, because 200 denarii worth of bread would not suffice for so many. By and by Christ proposed the same thing to Philip, probably because he had been most anxious in asking Christ to dismiss the multitude.

Philip gave the same answer as the others with regard to the quantity of bread that would be required.

John 6:3 · Open Word Bible

3Jesus climbed up into the hills and sat there with His disciples.

Report a mistake

John 6:11

... Then He blessed them (as the other Evangelists relate), and the Syriac lias here, He distributed to those tvho had sat down, miraculously multiplying the loaves during their distribution. S. Dominic and S. Francis imitated Christ in this matter. When in the General Chapter of the Friars Minor there was nothing to eat, they being full of faith, said, "Let us go and pray to Almighty God, who satisfied five thousand men besides women and children in the desert. His power and His mercy are no less now than they were then, that we should despair of His goodness." They continued in prayer until they were assured concerning the Divine will. Then at the hour oi dinner S. Francis bade the brethren sit down in the refectory. This done, they see enter twenty young men of noble appearance, girded, and prepared for service. Tliese supplied bread, wine, and every kind of needful refreshment to the company, in number five hundred. ... 11.) S. Dominic did the same thing at Rome at S. Sixtus'. When there was no food in the house he commanded the brethren to sit down to the table, and blessed it. Then lo, there came in two angels, having the appearance of beautiful youths, who placed before each one of the hundred brethren a very white loaf. Then they bowed their heads, and departed. {See the Life of Dominic, lib. 3, c. 4.) I have visited and venerated the place at Rome where this was done, and seen a painting of it.

John 6:11 · Open Word Bible

11So Jesus took the loaves, gave thanks, and shared them out among the people sitting there, and the fish too, as much as anyone wanted.

Report a mistake

John 6:15

That they might take Him

Ver. 15. — That they might take Him, &c., i.e., the king Messiah, wlio, the Jews thought, would give them abundance of corn, wine and oil, gold and silver. This was why they wished to make Him a king, not for His advantage, but their own.

John 6:15 · Open Word Bible

15Jesus realized that they were about to come and carry Him off to make Him king, so He went back up into the hills, alone.

Report a mistake

John 6:21

They wished therefore

Ver. 21. — They wished therefore, &c. They wished Him, now that they recognised Him, whom they had before taken for a spectre, and been affrighted at. And immediately, i.e., by the power and virtue of Christ's presence, the ship was at the land. As Nonnus says, " By the Divine impulse the ship of her own accord touched at the distant port, as it were a soul with wings." This land was Genesar, as S. Matthew calls it (xiv. 34), or Genesareth, as S. Mark (vi. 53). The ancient name was Cenereth, from the city so called, which was near Capharnaum. From this place the whole sea of Galilee was called the Lake of Cenereth, or Genesareth. Moreover the city of Capharnaum was situated in this land of Genesareth, to which, John says expressly, Jesus sailed with His disciples (vi. 17, 24, 25). Here was uttered His prolonged discourse concerning heavenly bread and the Eucharist. ... These things He spake, teaching in the synagogue in Caphartiaum.

John 6:21 · Open Word Bible

21Now they wanted to take Him into the boat, and right away the boat arrived at the land they were heading for.

Report a mistake

John 6:22

... The meaning is, — The day after that on which Christ had fed the five thousand, the multitude who had been thus fed continuing in that place across the sea, when they knew that there was only one boat there, in which the disciples had embarked alone, Jesus being left on the land — they sought Jesus, must be understood. For they did not know that He had walked on the sea by night, and joined the ship.

John 6:22 · Open Word Bible

22The next day the crowd that had stayed on the other side of the sea saw that there had been only one boat there, and that Jesus had not gone on board with His disciples. The disciples had left by themselves.

Report a mistake

John 6:23

But there came

Ver. 23. — But there came, &c. We can see from this verse that the place where Christ multiplied the loaves was near Tiberias, and therefore that those who sailed from thence to Bethsaida and Capharnaum must have sailed past Tiberias. The meaning is, the report of the miracle being spread abroad, many both from other places as well as Tiberias, came to the place where the miracle was wrought, that they might see and hear Jesus who had done such great things.

John 6:23 · Open Word Bible

23Some boats from Tiberias, however, came in near the place where they had eaten the bread after the Lord gave thanks.

Report a mistake

John 6:25

And when they had found Him

Ver. 25. — And when they had found Him . . . across the sea, that is to say in the synagogue of Capharnaum, as is plain from verse 59. When, and how earnest Thou hither? " For we know that yesterday Thy disciples went into the ship by themselves at the desert of Bethsaida, and that Thou remainedst there on the land." They did not know that Jesus had walked upon the sea in the middle of the night

John 6:25 · Open Word Bible

25When they found Him on the other side of the sea, they asked Him, "Rabbi, when did You get here?"

Report a mistake

John 6:26

Ver. 26. — festis answered, &c. Through modesty He did not answer their question directly, lest He should be forced to say that He had come walking upon the sea. He gave a reply therefore, which had more direct concern for His questioners, namely, that they were seeking food for their bodies rather than for their souls. "Ye ask Me, not because ye saw the miracles by means of which I labour to teach you faith and repentance, and the other evangelical virtues, by which ye may arrive at everlasting life. Ye seek Me, not that ye may receive of Me the food of the soul, but because ye did eat of the loaves, which I miraculously multiplied, and which I made pleasant to your taste, in order that ye may again have a like experience." For many are the lovers of the loaves and fishes rather than of Christ and eternal salvation. For the carnal have a taste only for carnal things, because they do not receive spiritual things.

John 6:26 · Open Word Bible

26Jesus answered them, "Truly, truly, I tell you, you are looking for Me, not because you saw signs, but because you ate your fill of the loaves.

Report a mistake

John 6:27

Labour not

Ver. 27. — Labour not, &c. ... Wherefore the Arabic translates, labour not on account of the food ivhich perisheth, but on account of the food which endureth unto eternal life. As Euthymius says, " Labour with the whole mind, with all your care continually. He does not command to labour for the food of the soul only, but He admonished them to care for the food of the body by the way, but for that of the soul with their whole heart."

Christ rises and draws the multitude from that corporeal bread with which a little while before He had fed them in the desert, to the far belter, and far more needful spiritual bread. As though He had said, " I have given you barley bread without any labour of yours, but work ye, and labour with all your might, that ye may obtain spiritual bread, to nourish you, and bring you to everlasting life." In like manner, from the water of the well He led the Samaritan woman to spiritual water, that He might teach His faithful followers, and especially Priests and Religious, to do the same, so that in their colloquies they may lead the people from corporeal to spiritual things. Wherefore from this saying of Christ Cyril rightly says, " We must have no care for the flesh, but we must watch for things that are needful for eternity. For he who follows after bodily pleasures differs in no respect from the beasts, but he who cleaves to nature, and leads his life according to the spiritual law, and is wholly given up to those things which are given us by God, and prepare our way for the things above, such a one seems to me to know himself, nor to be ignorant that he is a reasonable being, made in the image of his Creator."

John 6:27 · Open Word Bible

27Do not work for food that passes away, but for the food that remains for eternal life, the food the Son of Man will give you. For He is the one God the Father has marked with His seal."

Report a mistake

John 6:28

They said

Ver. 28. — They said, &c. Cyril thinks that the Jews asked this from arrogance, as being angry with Christ because He would have reproved them as being careless about their souls. As though they said, " Thou reprovest us for seeking after earthly bread and despising the Food of the soul. Tell us then what new work of God Thou affordest, by which we may please God and feed our souls, in addition to those works which Moses gave us to do, and wrote in the Pentateuch."

But S. Chrysostom thinks they said these words out of gluttony, because they were again hungering after the loaves of Christ, with which they had been fed. That they asked what were the works of God, with which Christ wished them to feed their souls, not because they intended to do them, but because they would gain His good-will, and so invite Him to renew the multiplication of the loaves.

John 6:28 · Open Word Bible

28So they asked Him, "What are we to do, to be doing the works that God asks of us?"

Report a mistake

John 6:30

They said

Ver. 30. — They said, &c., i.e., those of the crowd who were bolder than the rest, who knew and thought less of Jesus, For they had seen the miracle of the multiplication of the loaves the day before, whereby Christ had fed five thousand men, but upon this they set small value, and ask for one still greater and more wonderful. As though they had said, " Thou, O Jesus, askest of us a great, nay a stupendous thing, namely that we should believe in Thee as the Messiah and the Son of God. But for this the miracle of the loaves which Thou wroughtest yesterday, does not suffice. For Moses did a similar, yea, a greater work. Show us therefore a heavenly and Divine and worthy sign, by whicli God may attest that Thou art His Son, and our Messiah." Therefore they acid by way of explanation,

John 6:30 · Open Word Bible

30So they said to Him, "Then what sign will You perform for us to see, so that we will believe You? What work are You doing?

Report a mistake

John 6:31

Our fathers

Ver. 31. — Our fathers . . . as it is written (Ps. Ixxviii. 24). As though they said, " Moses fed our fathers in the desert, even more than six hundred thousand men, with heavenly and most sweet food, even the manna, and that daily for forty years, which was a greater thing than Thy multiplication of the loaves yesterday : and yet Moses did not w ish to be accounted, or believed to be Messiah, and the Son of God, Bread of heaven. 209

Since then you, Jesus, desire to be so accounted of, it is necessary that you should work greater miracles than Moses." So SS. Augustine and Cyril. The latter adds, " Such was the sign they asked of Christ, and thinking it a small matter that they had been miraculously fed for one day, they ask for food for a long period without labour. On such terms they seem to promise that they will assent to His doctrine." As though they said, " Feed us all our lives, as Thou didst feed us yesterday, and as Moses fed our fathers for forty years. Then we will believe Thee when Thou declarest that Thou art Messiah, the Son of God." So reasoned the Jews, as being animal and carnal, when they ought rather to have reasoned according to the spirit, thus, " This Jesus has multiplied bread, He heals whatsoever sick persons He pleases. He casts out devils, He raises the dead, and does many other miracles which Moses did not do. And He does them with this very end and object, that He may by them prove that He is the Messiah sent by God : therefore He must be truly the Messiah." When Moses gave the manna, and showed other signs, he did not do them in order that he might prove that he was the Messiah, but only a leader of the people, and a lawgiver sent by God.

John 6:31 · Open Word Bible

31Our ancestors ate the manna in the wilderness; as it is written, 'He gave them bread from heaven to eat.'"

Report a mistake

John 6:33

Ver. 33. — Foy the Bread of God, &c. Christ proves that not the manna, but His own Bread, i.e., He Himself, is true Bread, i.e., truly heavenly and Divine, by two arguments, i. Because He alone really came down from heaven. 2. Because He alone gives true life to the world, i.e., the blessed and eternal life, which only is true life. Observe : this Bread is called the Bread of God, because formed by God alone, and the property of God alone. Because God lives by Himself and His own Divinity : and because this Bread is truly the Son of God, and God Himself.

Cometh down : not in the past, but the present tense. ... The expression therefore signifies the perpetual descent of Christ upon the Eucharistic altar even to the end of the world. For whensoever the priest consecrates the Eucharist, Christ, who after His death ascended into heaven, comes down from thence to the consecrated species of bread, and in them declares His presence {Se present em sistit et exhibet).

John 6:33 · Open Word Bible

33For the bread of God is the one that comes down from heaven and gives life to the world."

Report a mistake

John 6:34

They said therefore

Ver. 34. — They said therefore, &c. "Without labour, in pleasant ease let us eat joyfully this Bread, that It may prolong our life, like the tree of life in Paradise, that we may reach the years of Methuselah." For the carnal Jews did not yet understand that the Bread of Christ was spiritual, and thought only of earthly things. "As yet," says S. Chrysostom, " they were looking for something material. as yet they were expecting the satisfying of their appetite." As S. Augustine says, "Give us bread which may refresh, and never fail." For as Cyril says, " Although by many words the Saviour drew them away from the carnal sense, they profited nothing, nor ai all drew back from carnality, for when they heard of the Bread which is given for the life of the world, they understood it of earthly bread.

John 6:34 · Open Word Bible

34Then they said to Him, "Sir, give us this bread all the time."

Report a mistake

John 6:36

... Said, elsewhere, even if it had been nowhere recorded by S. John. So S. Chrysostom and others. Again said, i.e., sufficiently, and more than sufficiently, I have shown and proved to you, because ye have seen, i.e., have known, i.e., by the many signs and miracles which I have wrought, ye could and ought to have known Me. And yet through the obstinacy of your minds ye do not believe in Me. For {c. v. v. 3, lic.) He at length confutes the Jews, because though they had seen so many signs they did not believe in Him. As Euthymius says, "Ye have seen Me, or ye have known who I am, both from the witness 01 John, and the miracles which I have wrought, and the witness of the Scriptures which I have unfolded to you ; but voluntarily doing evil ye believe not."

John 6:36 · Open Word Bible

36But I said it already: you have seen Me, yet you do not believe.

Report a mistake

John 6:37

Every thing

Ver. 37. — Every thing, &ic. There is an anticipation, thus, " Ye will object against Me, ' If Thou knewest that we would not believe Thy preaching, why dost thou preach to us?' 1 reply, 'Because theie are some of vou who will believe in Me, namelv tiiose whom the Father hath chosen, and hath given Me to be My disciples and children.' " By this He tacitly intimates that most of the Jews on account of their incredulity had not been given to Him, nor elected to the Faith by God, but that in their stead God had elected many others, especially of the Gentiles. Wherefore He saith, every thing, in the neuter gender, which the Father giveth Me, not the masculine, the rather to express the universality of all nations. Every thing {onine), i.e., all of every nation, every race, every age and sex, on whom the Father breathes the spirit of faith, that they may of their own free will believe in Me, these by faith shall come to Me, and become Christians and my disciples. Wherefore I will not repel them from Me, nor banish them from My house, i.e., my Church : but you, O ye unbelieving and rebellious Jews, I do repel from Me and My Church, and will banish you to hell : but those I will lovingly embrace, and take with Me to the Church triumphant in heaven.

John 6:37 · Open Word Bible

37Everyone the Father gives Me will come to Me, and I will never send away anyone who comes to Me.

Report a mistake

John 6:38

... Christ gives the reason why He will not cast out him whom the Father hath given Him, viz., because He Himself came in flesh, and into the world, for this end alone, that He might do the Father's will, which is, that those whom the Father wills to give to Him, and to save, Christ should accept and save. This is why He adds in explanation, This is His zvill, &c.

John 6:38 · Open Word Bible

38For I have come down from heaven not to carry out My own will, but the will of the one who sent Me.

Report a mistake

John 6:39

Bui this is His will

Ver. 39. — Bui this is His will, &c. Everything, i.e., all altogether, of every nation, rank, age, or sex, as I have said, verse 37. I will not lose {pei'davi), i.e., I will not suffer to perish. He explains what He had said, I will not cast out. This He expounds and completes by adding, but will raise it up at the last day, i.e., at the day of judgment, that I may admit (my servant) into heaven, and there bless him with immortality and glory both of body and soul for ever. Then indeed shall come to an end the motion of the heavens, and by consequence time, which is the measuring of their motion, shall cease. Wherefore then shall be the stay and the end of all days and months and years.

John 6:39 · Open Word Bible

39And the will of the one who sent Me is this: that I should lose nothing of all that He has given Me, but raise it all up on the last day.

Report a mistake

John 6:40

Ver. 40. — And this is the ivill, &c. ... Lactantius (HI'.

Christ teaches the Resurrection because " the hope of Christians is the resurrection of the dead," as Tertullian says. Hear S. Chrysostom {Horn. 46): "Everywhere He makes mention of life: for we are drawn by the desire of it, and there is nothing sweeter than not to die. In the OUl 'I'estament, indeed, long life and many days were promised : but now is promised not merely a long life, but endless life. At the same time also He wishes to show that He now revokes the punishment produced by sin, by remitting the sentence of death, and bringing in eternal life, contrary to the decree of the former times."

John 6:40 · Open Word Bible

40For what My Father wills is this: everyone who sees the Son and believes in Him will have eternal life, and I Myself will raise them up on the last day."

Report a mistake

John 6:41–42

The Jews therefore murmured

Ver. 41, 42. — The Jews therefore murmured, &c. Murmuring at benefits, says Cyril, is a sort of ancestral inheritance with the Jews, coming down from their fathers under Moses to Christ. Theophylact gives the cause of the murmuring, " Up to this point they thought He was speaking of material bread, and listened to Him cheerfully, but now when He revealed to them that He was speaking to them of spiritual bread, they despised Him, and murmured." They did not understand how Christ was Living Bread, and how He had descended from heaven, and how they might eat Him, for they craved for something for their throats.

It is intimated that some were for Him, and others against Him : and through some attacking Him, and others defending Him, they murmured among themselves.

Murmur not : for I give you no occasion of murmuring ; I tell you the simple truth, and if on account of its sublimity you do not receive it, it is ye who are in fault, both because ye carp at and rebel against Me, and do not ask Me for an explanation of My words; and also because ye do not ask God for light to understand My words : wherefore He subjoins,

John 6:41–42 · Open Word Bible

41Then the Jews started grumbling about Him, because He had claimed, "I am the bread that came down from heaven." 42They kept saying, "Surely this is Jesus, the son of Joseph? We know His father and mother. So what does He mean by saying now, 'I have come down from heaven'?"

Report a mistake

John 6:44

A'o one am come to Me

Ver. 44. — A'o one am come to Me, &c. Observe, (i.) Christ might, as S. Chrysostom observes, have answered and said, " It is not man's free will. 219

But He prefers to answer more sweetly and divinely, thus, that no one could believe in Him unless it were given them of His Father; that so, those who believed might not contend against the others who did not believe ; and that the unbelievers might acknowledge that they were in want of Divine light, as needful plainly to believe ; and that they should ask for this by humble prayer to God in Christ and not murmur, or certainly they would be without the light of God which was offered to them.

But those are not yet drawn of the Father. Do not therefore be indignant with them, but ask the Father to draw them as He has drawn you. For so will they equally with you believe in Me. You too, O ye unbelieving, do not murmur against Me, and My words, and those who do believe in Me. For the Father has drawn them to believe in Me. Rather, therefore, ask the Father that He may draw you also. For so will ye, equally with them, believe in Me, and will be of one mind with them in My faith, and doctrine, and Church. Say ye therefore with the Spouse, " Draw me after Thee," for those who are so drawn "will run in the odour of Thine ointment" (Cant.

John 6:44 · Open Word Bible

44Nobody can come to Me unless the Father who sent Me draws them. And on the last day I will raise them up.

Report a mistake

John 6:45

... He quotes Isa. liv. 13, "All thy children shall be taught of the Lord." Jeremiah (xxxi. 33) has a similar prophecy, and Joel (ii. 28). Because what Christ said seemed strange to the Jews, No one can come to Me, except My Father draw him, Christ confirms it out of Isaiah and the Prophets, who assert that all the children or disciples of Christ would be taught of God.

Now, they will be taught by God in that He will at the external voice of Christ and His disciples teach their minds inwardly, illuminate and inspire them, to believe in and obey Him. Whereas previously in the ancient Law, God taught the people exteriorly rather than interiorly, by prophets, priests, and by the Holy Scriptures. Wherefore "where God is the Teacher," says S. Leo, "there are the lessons quickly learned." Hear S. Augustine {in Epist. I S. Jo. Tract. 3), " The sound of our words strikes the ear, the Master is within. I have spoken to all, but to whomsoever that unction speaketh not inwardly, whom the Holy Ghost teacheth not within, such depart untaught. The outward instructions and admonitions are some sort of aid ; but it is He who sitteth in heaven who teaches the heart. Wherefore He saith Himself in the Gospel, 'Call no one your master upon earth, for one is your Master, Christ.' He indeed speaks to you inwardly when no mortal man is by. Where His inspiration, His unction is not, outward words are an empty breath."

John 6:45 · Open Word Bible

45In the Prophets it is written, 'They will all be taught by God.' Everyone who has heard the Father's teaching and learned it comes to Me.

Report a mistake

John 6:46

Ver. 46. — Not that any ofie, &c. "Lest the dense and ignorant Jews should imagine," says Euthymius, "that any one could hear or see the Father in a sensible manner, He saith not that any one, &c." We must understand, " But let a man hear God unseen, speaking in the soul, illuminating it, and persuading to the truth in Christ." God is the invisible Master. God is the Teacher, not of eyes and ears, but of hearts and minds.

Save Him who is of God, viz. Myself, who am the Son of God, born of Him, and most intimate with Him, who continually see and behold Him as He is in His essence. And as man I was indeed formed by Him without man's agency, and always enjoy the beatific vision of Himself. As Cyril says, " Being consubstantial with the Father, He will assuredly see Him from whom He is." And as Euthymius says, " Being of the same nature, substance and knowledge, He is in the bosom of the Father."

John 6:46 · Open Word Bible

46This does not mean that anyone has seen the Father. Only the one who has come from God has seen Him.

Report a mistake

John 6:48

Ver. 48. — I am the Bread of life, nourishing those who eat Me unto life eternal. As though He said, " I give eternal life to those by whom I am eaten with true and living faith." He often repeats and confirms the same, that He might not seem to have spoken rashly, because to the Jews this thing seemed plainly impossible.

John 6:48 · Open Word Bible

48I am the bread of life.

Report a mistake

John 6:49–50

Your fathers

Ver. 49, 50. — Your fathers, &c., in the desert, " signifying," says S. Chrysostom, " that the manna did not long continue, nor come to the land of promise ; for as soon as they reached it the manna ceased." But this Bread of Christ endureth for ever. Listen to the words of Josue (v. 12): "And the manna ceased on the morrow after they had eaten of the old corn of the land ; neither had the children of Israel manna any more ; but they did eat of the fruit of tlie land of Canaan that year." For as God fails us not in things neediul. so He gives not an abounding of superfluities.

And died : i.e., manna fed your fathers after the way of other food, and neither did, nor was able to protect them from death ; but My Bread will save from death.

John 6:49–50 · Open Word Bible

49Your ancestors ate the manna in the wilderness, and yet they died. 50Here, by contrast, is bread coming down from heaven: whoever eats it will not die.

Report a mistake

John 6:52

If any one shall eat

Ver. 52. — If any one shall eat, &c. For this Bread gives to the soul the life of grace, which endures even to the life of glory for all eternity. And It shall make the body to rise from death to live together with the soul gloriously for ever.

Calvin and the heretics contend that this Bread is not the Body of Christ in the Eucharist, but mystical food ; for that we mystically eat the Body of Christ by faith when we believe in Him. Of Catholics the same opinion was held by Jansen on this passage, Cajetan, Gabriel, Ruardus Tapper, Nicolas Casanus and Hesselius, who are cited by Baronius (Jib. i, de Eucharist, c. 5). Against these authors Didacus Castillus has written a whole book. Nicholas Sanders another, and Toletus, Maldonatus and Bellarmine refute them at length.

I say then that Christ from this place onward speaks expressly of the Eucharist, This is so certain that Maldonatus says, to deny it is rash, and almost heretical (erroneum).

John 6:52 · Open Word Bible

52At this the Jews began to quarrel fiercely among themselves. "How can He give us His flesh to eat?" they said.

Report a mistake

John 6:53

The Jeivs therefore

... How : when the question enters in, how a thing is done, unbelief enters in at the same time, says S. Chrysostom. "For when it behoved them," says Cyril, " who by a miracle had perceived the Divine virtue of the Saviour, and the power of His miracles, readily to receive His words, and if any seemed too hard to seek for their solution, they did altogether the opposite. How can this man, &c. S. Chrysostom says, "if thou inquirest this, why didst thou not say the same in the miracle of the loaves, as to how He so greatly increased them? For from that it ought to have caused this more easily to be believed. The expression hotv, therefore, is a Judaic word, and the question of unbelievers." Let the heretics hear this, who say, " How can so great a Christ be whole in so small a host ? " Rather let them say, " How can an angel be wholly in a point ? " " How is God everywhere ? " " How is the soul whole in the whole body, and whole in all its parts ? " And if they can neither understand, nor express these things, how can they understand the mystery of the Eucharist? Let them believe Almighty God giving assurance of the fact, although they do not understand the mode. " God can do more than man can understand," says S. Augustine. " It behoves us therefore," says Theophylact, " when we hear, Ufilessye cat the Flesh of the Son, ye shall not have life, to maintain undoubting faith in the reception oi" the Divine Mysteries, and not to ask. By what means? " In like manner Cyril, "But let us depart far away from the sins of others, having firm faith in the Mysteries. ... For this is a Judaic word, and a cause of extreme punishment." Therefore he wisely concludes, "When God works, let us not ask ' how ? ' but let us ascribe to Him alone both the way and the knowledge of His own work."

John 6:53 · Open Word Bible

53Jesus answered them, "Truly, truly, I tell you, if you do not eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood, there is no life in you.

Report a mistake

John 6:55

He that cometh

Ver. 55. — He that cometh, &c. Eateth, i.e.., says Ruperti, worthily, with due preparation and purification, with a previous act of contrition and sacramental confession, if a man have any mortal sin upon his conscience. For if, after examination, a man be not conscious of any mortal sin, even though he may really be in some mortal sin unknown to himself, the communion of the Eucharist will blot out that sin, and restore the communicant to the grace and love of God. This is the teaching of Suarez, and Theologians, passim. Moreover, the sixth General Council {Act 8) understands this verse of the Eucharist, and asserts that in it the Flesh of Christ is called life-giving, because It is the proper Flesh of the Word, and hypostatically united to the Word.

Hath life eternal: because by the Eucharist he receives grace to preserve him, and bring him unto life eternal. As Dion Carthu sianus says, " He hatli eternal life, because he hath Me : and he hath the life of grace which is continued by this Sacrament, until he arrive at the life of everlasting glory." S. Cyril gives the reason — " Because the Flesh of Christ is the Flesh of God, which is united to the Word of God, who is, by His nature, Life, and thus is made life-giving. The Eucharist therefore quickens the soul, because It preserves, feeds, augments grace. Also It blots out venial sins, and even mortal sins, if a man has forgotten them. And It will raise up the body from death. Wherefore it follows. And I tvill raise him up. Moreover, S. Bernard thus explains these words of Christ tropologically {Trad, de Diligend. Deo). He that eateth, &c., "That is, he who recalls to mind My death, and after My example mortifies his members which are upon the earth, hath eternal life."

John 6:55 · Open Word Bible

55For My flesh is genuine food, and My blood is genuine drink.

Report a mistake

John 6:56

For My Flesh

Ver. 56. — For My Flesh, &c., truly, i.e., not parabolically nor figuratively, as Euthymius says from S. Chrysostom, but really and properly, according to the plain meaning of the words. Hence S. Chrysostom {Horn. 61. ad Pop.) teaches that we in the Eucharist are united and commingled with the Flesh of Christ, not only by love and consent of will, but also really and substantially. " Wherefore," saith he, " He hath commingled Himself with us, and united His Body to ours, that we should be made one whole, even as a body is connected with its head. This is the desire of ardent lovers. It is this which Job hinted at, saying to his servants, to whom he was beyond measure desirable, because they showed their desire, saying, 'Who will give us to be filled with his flesh?'" (Job xxxi.) "Not only does Christ afford Himself to be seen by those who desire Him, but even to be handled and eaten, to have our teeth fastened in His Flesh, and to fulfil every desire. As lions therefore breathe out fire, so let us depart from that Table, made terrible to the devil, and contemplating our Head in our minds, and the charity which He has manifested towards us."

John 6:56 · Open Word Bible

56Anyone who eats My flesh and drinks My blood remains in Me, and I remain in them.

Report a mistake

John 6:57

... Observe (i.) S. John delights in the word abide. By it he sometimes signifies dela)', and duration of time (as i. 33), upon whom thou shalt see the Spirit descending and abiding. Sometimes, however, by the exj)ression abides he expresses, moreover, indwelling and intimate union, as here and in his ist Epistle (iii. 9), " His seed," i.e. of the grace of God, "abides in him." And iv. 16, " He that abideth in love abideth in God, and God in him."

Observe (2.) the abiding and union of the soul with Christ in the Eucharist not only takes place by the Eucharist Itself, but by the Eucharist in such manner that Christ being therein hidden, really and corporally enters into our body, and so Christ with us, and we with the flesh of Christ, and by consequence with His Person Divinity and omnipotence are really united and commingled, even as food is really united and commingled with our flesh. So S. Chrysostom observes, " He saith, abideth in Me, that He may show we are commingled with Himself." ... Theophylact, "In this place we aie taught the Sacrament of communion. For he who eats and drinks the Flesh and Blood of the Lord, abides in the Lord Himself, and the Lord in Him. For there is a new sort of commingling, and one beyond understanding, that God is in us, and we in God." S. Cyril in this verse brings forward the apt similitude of wax. " It is as if when any one should pour wax into liquefied wax ; it must be that the one should commingle with the other throughout. So if any one receive the Flesh and Blood of the Lord, he is so conjoined with Him, that Christ is found in him, and he in Christ." And shortly afterwards, " As a little leaven, as Paul says, leaventh the whole lump, so a little benediction draws the whole man into Himself (Christ), and fills him with His grace : and thus Christ abides in us, and we in Him.

John 6:57 · Open Word Bible

57The living Father sent Me, and I live because of Him; in the same way, anyone who feeds on Me will live because of Me.

Report a mistake

John 6:58

As the living Father

Ver. 58. — As the living Father, &c. . . . hath sent Me, in the Flesh into the world, through the Incarnation, for the salvation of men. The living Father, who is Himself Divine Life, uncreated Substance, and therefore in begetting Me hath communicated to Me the same Substance, that I might communicate the same to the Humanity, which He sent Me to assume, that I might communicate similar spiritual, holy, blessed and eternal life to the faithful who eat of Me.

And I live because of (propter) the Father, i.e., through the Father, of the Father. For the Father in begetting Me communicates to Me His own Divinity, which is the essence of life. For God hath begotten God, the Living One hath begotten the Living One. " The Son therefore," saith Cyril, " is as Light of Light, and as Life of Life. And as the Father gives light through the Son to the things which need light, and through Him does wisely, so through the Son as through His life which proceeds from Him, He quickens those things which have need of Hfe." And again, "I live by (propter) the Father: for since My Father is Life by nature, and because I am by nature His Son, I naturally possess this property of His nature, that is life."

John 6:58 · Open Word Bible

58This, then, is the bread that came down from heaven. It is not like the food the ancestors ate, for they died; anyone who eats this bread will live forever."

Report a mistake

John 6:59

This is the bread

Ver. 59. — This is the bread, &c. He intimates the same thing which I have said at the end of the foregoing verse. For Christ came down from heaven not as man, but as God. Wherefore he who eateth Him in the Eucharist shall live for ever, because in truth he eateth God and the Godhead, which being ever present with him who eateth, continually breathes into him His own life. Hear S. Ambrose {Serin. 18 in Ps. cxviii.), "How shall he die whose food is Life ? " And presently, describing its wonderful effects, " Draw nigh unto Him, and be filled, for He is Bread. Draw nigh unto Him, and drink, for He is a Fountain. Draw nigh unto Him, and be enlightened, for He is Light. Draw nigh unto Him, and be free, for where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty. Draw nigh unto Him, and be absolved ; for He is remission of sins." And S. Bernard [Serm. de Ccena. Dotn.) says, "Two things that Sacrament worketh in you : it diminishes the sense (of sin) in the least matters, and in graver sins it wholly takes away consent." And again he says, " If any of you feel neither so frequently nor so severely the motions of anger, envy, lust, and such like passions, give thanks to the Body and Blood of the Lord, forasmuch as the virtue of the Sacrament worketh in you." And S. Chrysostom on Ps. xxii. 5 (Vulg.), saith upon the words, "Thou hast prepared a table before me, against them that trouble me," " Let those who have trouble of the flesh come to the table of the Mighty One, and tribulation shall be turned into consolation." Lastly, S. Cyril says, " The body of Christ quickens, and by our participation of it restores us to incorruption. For it is the body of none other than of the Life itself. It retains the virtue of the Word Incarnate, and is full of the power of Him by whom all things live and have their being."

John 6:59 · Open Word Bible

59All this He said as He taught in the synagogue in Capernaum.

Report a mistake

John 6:60

This spake He

Ver. 60. — This spake He, &c. Christ taught these things, not in secret, not in a corner, but publicly in the synagogue in the presence of the Scribes, the Priests, and the whole people who had flocked together. For the synagogue was a sort of church.

In Capharnaum, " where," says S. Chrysostom, " He had done so many miracles, and where He had the best right to be heard. Because the things which Christ spake concerning eating His flesh, and His being about to raise us up from death unto life eternal, seemed paradoxical and incredible to the Jews, He wished to proclaim them from that place, where by His many miracles He had gained faith and authority for Himself and His doctrine."

John 6:60 · Open Word Bible

60When they heard this, many of His disciples said, "This message is harsh. Who can bear to listen to it?"

Report a mistake

John 6:61

Many therefore went back

Ver. 61. — Many therefore went back. ... The Arabic has difficult : Euthymius, cati scarcely be admitted. And who can hear it ? " Who can," we do not say, ' do such a thing, but even bear to hear it ? " What Jesus said concerning His Flesh, and especially the command to eat It (ver. 54), except ye eat, &c., seems too difficult to be believed, and too horrible to be done. For what butcher will slay Christ ? Who can bear to eat human flesh, or drink human blood ? These are the feasts of cannibals, such as the heathen who did not understand the mystery of the Flesh of Christ in the Eucharist in after times reproached Christians with, and so were imitators of those Capharnaites, as Tertullian and other Fathers testify.

This saying was not hard in itself, but hard to the stupid Jews, who imagined that the Flesh of Christ was to be cut by a butcher, and mangled by the teeth like the flesh of an ox. But they greatly erred, for Christ neither said this, nor meant it. But He wished us to eat His Flesh sacramentally, i.e., hidden in the Sacrament under the species of bread and wine, a thing which is not dreadful, but which we who daily offer and communicate find by experience to be most easy and sweet. The Jews ought therefore humbly to have asked Christ to unfold to them the manner of doing this. If they would have done this, they would have heard it, and might have received it, and not thought the saying hard. ... Such were their thoughts as to how the flesh of this man would bestow eternal life, and bring them to immortality."

John 6:61 · Open Word Bible

61Jesus was aware that His disciples were grumbling about this, so He said to them, "Does this make you stumble?

Report a mistake

John 6:62

... That His disciples jnurmured at this. He saith unto them, Doth this scandalize you ? As though he said, " I do so many and wonderful things because I am sent by the Father for this purpose, as I have proved to you by My miracles ; ye ought not therefore to be scandalized and offended at My words and deeds, but ye ought rather to ask God who sent Me for light and grace, that ye may be able to receive them."

John 6:62 · Open Word Bible

62Then what if you were to see the Son of Man going up to where He was before?

Report a mistake

John 6:63

Ver. 63. — Jf therefore ye shall see, &c. " He is speaking," says Euthymius, "concerning His future assumption into heaven." For some of them, such as the Apostles, beheld this. And others, who did not believe, although they saw it not, might have heard, and certainly leamt from those who did see.

Where He was before, as regards His Divinity, says Euthymius. For He ascended into heaven, as regards His humanity. What will ye say, must be understood, as Euthymius observes. " Will ye be still scandalized ? I trust not. Certainly I know ye will not rightly be so. For by My ascension into heaven by My own power ye will be able to know that I came down from heaven, and that I return whither I was before, and therefore that I am not only true and a prophet, but that I am also God, and the Son of God, to whom all things are possible, yea easy, and therefore that I am able to give My Flesh for food, and by It to raise the dead. From the miracle of His ascension into heaven Christ riijhtly i)roves His Divinity and omnipotence, and from them the mystery of the Eucharist. For to the Deity nothing is impossible, nothing strange, nothing paradoxical. Yea, it is becoming to Deity to do things strange {nova) and paradoxical, which are above nature and human reason. As S. Cyril says, " By another wonderful thing He urges them to faith," and that appositely. For the ascension of Christ into heaven signified that He came down from heaven (for He went back from whence He came), and therefore that He was the Living Bread which came down from heaven, which was what He here wished to persuade the Capharnaites.

John 6:63 · Open Word Bible

63The Spirit is the one who gives life; the flesh is of no benefit at all. The words I have spoken to you are spirit, and they are life.

Report a mistake

John 6:64

It is the spirit which quickeneth

... The Calvinists bring forward against us these words of Christ to show that in the Eucharist there is not the Flesh of Christ really and corporeally, but only spiritually and figuratively by representation and faith, because, say they, the flesh profiteth nothing. But if this be true, then in vain was the Word made Flesh, then in vain did the Flesh of Christ suffer and was crucified, and died. God forbid. And who does not see that the Flesh of Christ is more profitable than the mere bread of Calvin, even though it were seasoned with sugar and honey out of Calvin's throat? For in his bread there is no spirit, except the spirit of error and satanic madness.

First then SS. Cyril and Austin learnedly expound these words, thus : they are as if Christ said, " My Flesh alone profits not to preserve him who eats It unto life eternal, because it is not My mere Flesh which confers life and resurrection, but it is the Spirit, i.e., My Divinity united to the Flesh which quickens first the soul, and then the body at the Resurrection. And thus My Flesh profiteth very exceedingly, forasmuch as being united to the Spirit of the Word, it derives from It its quickening power." By a similar form of speech we are wont to say, The eye doth not see, the ear doth not hear, nor the body feel, but it is the spirit, ie., the soul, which sees through the eye, and hears through the ear. ... That is, My Deity, which is a pure Spirit, is a living and quickening Spirit. For It will give you liie in the Eucharist, not My bare Flesh. So S. Augustine says, " This Flesh alone profiteth not, but let the Spirit be joined to the Flesh, and It profiteth greatly. For if the Flesh profiteth nothing, the Word would not have become Flesh." The same {lib. lo, de. Civit. Dei) says, "The Flesh ofitselfcleanseth not, but through the Word by which it hath been assumed."

John 6:64 · Open Word Bible

64Yet some among you do not believe." For Jesus had known from the start who the ones were that did not believe, and who would be the one to betray Him.

Report a mistake

John 6:65

But there are some

Ver. 65. — But there are some, &c. The reason why some of you do not receive, but oppose. My words concerning the Eucharist, is not because My saying is hard, as ye say, but because ye are faithless, and will not believe My many miracles and signs. For here there is need of humble faith, which ought by lowly prayer to be asked and waited for from God the Father. But ye lack humility both of prayer and faith, and therefore ye neither pray to God, nor believe in Me. So S. Augustine, Bede and Rupert.

For Jesus knew, &c. It means that Christ as God knew from eternity what would happen, and this foreknowledge He communicated to His Humanity from the beginning of His conception. And who should betray Him. By this John intimates that Judas the traitor was one of those who did not believe ; indeed, that he was offended at Christ's sayings concerning the eating His flesh : that he conceived and cherished a dislike to Christ, which at last broke out into treachery against Him. 'i'he connection makes this conclusion necessary. Otherwise this mention of the traitor would be inopportune, unless from this discourse of Christ Judas had taken the first initiative of his unbelief and subsequent treachery. So S. Augustine, Bede, &c.

John 6:65 · Open Word Bible

65And He added, "This is the reason I told you that no one is able to come to Me unless it has been given to them by the Father."

Report a mistake

John 6:66

And said, Sec, except it be given him

Ver. 66. — And said, Sec, except it be given him, &c., i.e., except My Father draw him, as He said in verse 44. Graciously does Christ not attribute the unbelief of the Jews to their fault, but excuses them on the ground that it was not given them of the Father : at the same time He consoles Himself, as it were, thus — " I do not distress Myself because many do not believe in Me, but I console Myself because the Father will cause to believe in Me those whom He hath chosen, and will cause them to come to Me. With these I am content. I am not ambitious of others. For whom the Father willeth (to come), those I also will ; and those whom He willeth not (to come), those likewise I do not will." ... 3, ad. Cornel.)

John 6:66 · Open Word Bible

66At this, many of His disciples drew back and stopped going about with Him.

Report a mistake

John 6:67

From this time, say Euthymius and others

... These disciples were not the Apostles, for Christ excepts them in the following verse. Neither were they the seventy-two disciples. For those had not yet been designated and chosen by Christ. But they were His more constant hearers and followers, "who," as Theophylact says, " followed Him in the rank ot His disciples, and remained with Him longer than the multitudes, and so, compared with the rest of the crowd, were called His disciples. These persons therefore up to this time being allured by the sweet doctrine of Christ, fed by the loaves miraculously multiplied, and hoping to be fed in future by similar food, when they heard Christ substituting His own Flesh in the place of bread, and willing that they should eat It, thought either that He was mad, or else was contriving some horrible and savage scheme, or perchance a conspiracy against the Romans, and would inaugurate it by their tasting His flesh and blood, as Cataline had done before at Rome. Thus, to provide for their own safety, they fell away from Christ.

John 6:67 · Open Word Bible

67So Jesus asked the Twelve, "Surely you do not want to leave as well?"

Report a mistake

John 6:68

Jesus said therefore

Ver. 68. — Jesus said therefore, &c. For when the others were scandalized and went away from Christ *' the Twelve remained," says S. Augustine, " for not even did Judas go away : " partly for shame's sake, not to be the only Apostle to go away, and be called an apostate ; partly that he might be fed by Christ without labour on his part, as he had been hitherto ; and that as he bore the bag and was a sort of purveyor for Christ's family, he might steal and enrich himself. For he was a thief.

Christ asks the question of the Apostles for five reasons. The first was that He might leave them their liberty. As though He said, " I give you your choice : if ye wish to go away, depart : if ye wish to remain with Me, remain. I will not retain you either by force, or shame." Listen to S. Chrysostom. "Jesus neither flattered, nor drove away : but He asked the question, not because He despised them, but that they might not seem to be retained by compulsion." For if they had remained unwillingly, He would have been in exactly the same condition as if they had gone away.

John 6:68 · Open Word Bible

68Simon Peter answered Him, "Lord, to whom would we go? You have words that bring eternal life.

Report a mistake

John 6:69

Ver, 69. — Simon Peter therefore afiswered, &c. Peter, as greater in rank {prdine major), says S. Cyril, firmer in faith, more loving to Jesus, more fervent in spirit, answered in the name of the rest of the Apostles, thinking that this was the mind and feeling of all. For that which he himself thought of Jesus he believed his colleagues thought likewise.

To whom shall we go ? Meaning, says S. Augustine, " Do you send us from Thee ? Give us another such as Thou art. To whom shall we go, if we leave Thee ? " Wherefore S. Chrysostom says, •* This is an answer of great affection. For Christ was preferable to both father and mother."

Thoti hast the words of eternal life. First, as it were said, " Thy words, O Jesus, are sweet and life-giving, because they promise the very eternal life. Who therefore, save a fool, would leave them, and go elsewhere ? " S. Cyril saith, " Not hard are the words, as those Capharnaites say, but Thou hast the words of eternal life, which are able to lead those who believe to the incorruptible life."

John 6:69 · Open Word Bible

69We have believed, and we know, that You are the Holy One of God."

Report a mistake

John 6:70

Atid we believe

Ver. 70. — Atid we believe, &c. ... And we being conjoined by likeness to Him, are called sons."

We know, from the testimony of John the Baptist, our prophet and master, from the many and great miracles which Thou hast wrought, from Thy heavenly doctrine, and the holiness of Thy life, which we who are in constant intercourse with Thee, know to be heavenly and Divine.

The meaning is. We believe that Thou art the Son of God. Wherefore, we also believe that all Thy sayings are Divine and most true, even when we do not understand them, and therefore that they are life-giving, and confer salvation and eternal life.

John 6:70 · Open Word Bible

70Jesus answered them, "Did I not choose the twelve of you myself? Still, one of you is a devil."

Report a mistake

John 6:71

Ver. 71. — -Jesus answered, Thou, O Peter, answerest in the name of all the Apostles, as if all believed in Me, and were My faithful friends. But know that thou art deceived, for one of them is a devil, unbelieving, and faithless to Me, who also will betray Me.

Have chosen Twelve, as to the Apostleship according to their present state apt and meet. Whence it seems that Judas the traitor, even when he was first chosen by Christ, was good and honest. For prudence and charity forbid the choice of one who is dishonest. So S. Cyril, Maldonatus and others. Also S. Jerome {lib. 3, cont. ... Some, however, think that Judas, when he was bad, as Christ knew, was yet chosen by Him t(; be an Apostle, with this object, that it might be one of His own who should betray Him, and so afford the occasion and the way for His passion and death, and from them the redemption of men. This opinion is attributed to SS. Bede and Augustine, yet neither says so expressly. Indeed, both rather intimate that Judas was chosen by Christ when he was good, even though he was known to be about to become bad by his own fault. Hear S. Augustine : " Their number of Twelve was consecrated, who through the four quarters of the world were to proclaim the Trinity. And because one of them perished, not on that account was the honour of that number taken away from them. For in the room of him who perished another was chosen." And after a While he says, " He was chosen, from whom, albeit unwilling, and knowing it not, a great good was to proceed. For as wicked men wickedly use the good works of God, so, on the contrary, God for good uses the wicked works of men. The Lord used for good the wicked Judas, and delivered Himself to be betrayed that He might redeem us." Hear also Bede: "To one end He chose eleven, to another end one.

John 6:71 · Open Word Bible

71He meant Judas, son of Simon Iscariot. Judas was one of the Twelve, and he was going to betray Him.

Report a mistake