Logia

Cornelius a Lapide · The Great Commentary: S. John's Gospel

John 21

15 excerpts on John 21, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

John 21:6

He saith unto them

Ver. 6. — He saith unto them, &c. For indeed Jesus by His hidden power had collected this multitude of fishes on the right side of the boat, and so the Apostles who had been fishing all night at the left side had taken nothing.

Hearken now to S. Augustine [Tract. 122) : "In the capture of the fish is set forth a sacrament of the Church, to wit, what shall be at the last resurrection : to set forth which it is signified that it is as it were the end of a book, which should be, as it were, the proemium of a narrative which is to follow. And the seven disciples by their number signify the end of time. For all time is included in seven days. The shore signifies the end of the world, for it is the boundary of the sea. And as the Church, such as it shall be at the end of the world, is here meant, so by another fishing is signified the Church such as it is now. Therefore on that occasion Jesus did not stand upon the shore, but went up into the ship. Then the nets were not cast at the right side, in order not to denote the good only ; nor yet at the left, not to denote the bad only : but indifferently on both sides, to signify that the good were mingled with the bad. But now the net is cast on the right side, to signify the good only, who

John 21:6 · Open Word Bible

6He said to them, "Throw the net out on the boat's right side, and you will find fish." So they threw it out, and now they could not haul it in because there were so many fish.

Report a mistake

John 21:7

Therefore that disciple

Ver. 7. — Therefore that disciple, &c. You will ask, how was it that John was the first to recognise Christ? Cyril attributes it to the keenness of his intellect. So does S. Chrysostom. Peter, he says, was the more fervent, but John had more sagacity, and therefore was the first to recognise Christ. But I reply that whilst Peter was occupied in drawing up the net full of great fishes, John more carefully looked at Jesus, and Jesus first presented His appearance to S. John, because He most chiefly loved him, and because he was most pure. Wherefore S. Jerome rightly says {Epist. ad Pammach.), "First is John's virginity to recognise the virgin form of Christ ' Blessed are the pure in heart, for they shall see God.' "

Mystically : the more familiar and intimate any one is with God by prayer, the more does he perceive, penetrate, contemplate, and admire God, and the attributes of God. In fine, as John because of his virginity was dear to Christ, so also he himself wonderfully loves those who are chaste and virgins. Hear what the Abbot Adelred writes in his life of King Edward the Confessor. "S. Edward never denied the petition of any one who asked in the name of S. John, for him after the Prince of the Apostles he chiefly loved. Once it happened that in the absence of the chamberlain a certain foreigner importunately asked the king for alms in the name of S. John. So the king gave him a precious ring, because he had nothing else at hand. After this it happened that two Englishmen went to Jerusalem to worship the tomb of the Saviour. One day it came to pass that they missed the high road, and were wandering out of the way when the sun went down, and all was dark. Not knowing what to do, or whither to turn, a certain venerable old man appeared to them, and led them to the city.

John 21:7 · Open Word Bible

7Then that disciple whom Jesus loved told Peter, "It is the Lord!" Hearing that it was the Lord, Simon Peter tied his outer garment around himself, since he had stripped for work, and threw himself into the sea.

Report a mistake

John 21:10

Ver. 10. — As soon as they were coiue to land, &c. Here was another miracle of Christ, that He for His disciples suddenly coming to Him cooked fish, and prepared a dinner. Cyril thinks that this fish had been speedily drawn from the depths of the sea. But Chrysostom thinks that it had been created out of nothing. With greater probability, Leontius and others say that Christ produced the fish, the coals, the fire, and the bread out of the atmosphere, or some other substance, as He did the loaves when He multiplied them. Christ did this to show (i.) that the great draught of fishes was His own work, and that it was He who had collected all those fishes at the right side of the ship. (2.) That He had no need of them for Himself, but had done it for the sake of His Apostles. Mystically, saith Bede, out of S. Augustine : The broiled fish is Christ in His Passion. He Himself deigned to lie hid in the waters of our human nature. He willed to be taken with the hook of a death like ours. And He who was made a fish in His Humanity, became the Bread that feeds us by His Divinity.

John 21:10 · Open Word Bible

10Jesus said to them, "Bring some of the fish that you have just caught."

Report a mistake

John 21:11

Jesus saith

Ver. II. — Jesus saith . . . Mng of the fish, &c. This He did that they all might perceive the multitude of the fish and the greatness of the miracle.

Mystically, S. Augustine {Tract. 123) says, "The broiled fish is Christ in His Passion. He is the Bread which came down from heaven. With Him the Church is incorporated for the attainment of everlasting bliss, according as it is said. Bring of the fish which ye have taken, that all we who have this hope through that seven-fold number of disciples, by which the whole company of the faithful is figured, might know that we have a share in so great a sacrament, and are partakers of the same blessedness."

Simon Peter went uj', i.e. into the ship, &c. Peter is mentioned as the leader of the rest. For he could not have drawn the net laden with so many great fishes (to land) by himself. Though indeed S. Gregory and Rupertus think that he did do this alone, though not by his own strength, but by Divine assistance. And thereby Peter's Primacy is intimated. For he is the first to call his companions to fish. He first came to Christ. He was the first also to draw up the net, that it might be signified that all fishes, that is to say, all the faithful, ought to be drawn and ruled by Peter. John therefore was the more beloved, but Peter the more honoured by Christ, and by Him set over the rest. So subjects (spiritual) are now and again more holy than their rulers, but rulers are more exalted, and more eminent in authority than their subjects.

John 21:11 · Open Word Bible

11So Simon Peter went aboard and hauled the net ashore, full of large fish, 153 of them. Even with so many, the net did not tear.

Report a mistake

John 21:13

And Jesus came and took bread

Ver. 13. — And Jesus came and took bread, &ic. That is, when the disciples by the command of Jesus had sat down at the table, He also came, and sat down with them.

John 21:13 · Open Word Bible

13Jesus came, took the bread and gave it to them, and the fish in the same way.

Report a mistake

John 21:14

... That is to say, reckoning those appearances which took place when several of the Apostles were present, for of such only S. John here makes mention. For of such this was the third. Otherwise, if we enumerate all the othei appearances of which the other Evangelists make mention, this was the seventh in order, as I have shown on Matt, xxviii. 10, where I have enumerated them all in order.

John 21:14 · Open Word Bible

14This was now the third time that Jesus was revealed to the disciples after He had been raised from the dead.

Report a mistake

John 21:15

Ver. 15. — When therefore they had dined, Jesus saith to Simon Peter — " Simon, son of Jonas, lovest thou Me more thati these ? " When Christ was about to go away into heaven, He here appoints Peter His vicar upon earth, and creates him Chief Pontiff, that the one church might be ruled by one shepherd. Christ had promised the same thing to Peter — Matt. xvi. 18 — but in this place He confers the gift, and constitutes him prince and ruler of the whole Church, lest any one, on account of Peter's threefold denial, should say that Christ had changed His decree concerning him. So Cyril. Mystically, Alcuin here says the Hebrew Simon means — obedient. John is grace. Peter is thus spoken of as obeying the grace of God ; because, indeed, he embraces Him with a burning love — the effect, not of human merit, but of a Divnie gift.

John 21:15 · Open Word Bible

15After they had eaten breakfast, Jesus said to Simon Peter, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me more than these?" Peter said to Him, "Yes, Lord, You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Feed My lambs."

Report a mistake

John 21:16

Ver. 1 6. — He saith to him the second time, Simon, son of Jonas, lovest thou Me t He saith unto Him, Yea, Lord, Thou knoiucst that J love Thee. Hear S. Chrysostom : " Again he dreads the former things, lest perchance, thinking himself to love, he should be corrected if he did not love, like as before he was corrected for thinking himself strong, and therefore he takes refuge in Christ Himself."

He saith unto him the second time, Feed My lambs. Thus the Arabic has it.

As S. Augustine says, " Let it be love's office to feed the Lord's flock, like as it was the mark of fear to deny the Shepherd." Hence S. Gregory (i Part. Pastor, c. v.) says, "He who is strong in virtue and refuses to feed the flock of God is proved not to love his Pastor."

John 21:16 · Open Word Bible

16A second time he asked him, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me?" Peter said to Him, "Yes, Lord, You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Shepherd My sheep."

Report a mistake

John 21:17

... Peter was grieved because He said unto him the third time lovest thou Me, and he said unto Him, Lord, Thou knowest all things ; Thou knowest that I love Thee. He saith unto him, Feed My sheep (Syriac, My lambs). Why does Christ thrice ask Peter if he loved Him, and thrice repeat, Feed My sheep ? I answer, the first reason is, that Peter, by a triple and constant profession of his singular love, might expiate and change his three-fold denial of Christ. So Cyril, Leontius, I'heophylact, Bede, and S. Augustine, which last thus writes (Iract. 123): "For a threefold denial a threefold confession is rendered, that the tongue might not seem to serve love less than fear, and that impending death might not seem to elicit more speech than Present Life. Let it be the office of love to feed the Lord's flock, if it was the mark of fear to deny the Shepherd. If any feed Christ's sheep with this disposition, that they wish them to be their own sheep rather than His, they are proved to love not Christ but themselves, either from the desire of boasting, or ruling, or acquiring, not from the love of obeying, and helping, and pleasing God. Against such, therefore, the Word of Christ, many times enjoined, gives warning, and of them the Apostle complains that they seek their own, not the things which be of Jesus Christ. For to say, ' If thou lovest Me, feed My sheep,' what else is it but to say, If thou lovest Me, do not study to feed thyself, but My sheep ; feed them as Mine, not as thine : seek My glory in them, not thine : My dominion, not thine own ? " From hence let bishops learn to examine suspended priests and others a second and third time, concerning their amendment, that they may be safe in restoring them to their office.

John 21:17 · Open Word Bible

17A third time he asked him, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me?" Peter was hurt because Jesus asked him a third time, "Do you love Me?" Peter replied, "Lord, You know everything; You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Feed My sheep.

Report a mistake

John 21:18

... For by the rational will Peter desired this above all things. S. Chrysostom says. Christ predicts his martyrdom, showing him in what way and how much he ought to love Christ and His sheep, even unto His cross.

When thou wast young: by this is shown, says S. Chrysostom, that Peter was neither a young, nor an old, but a perfect man. For such a one it behoved the Pontiff and prince of the Apostles to be, that his age might win him authority, and yet be apt and strong for apostolic labours.

The meaning is. When thou wast young, and hadst bodily strength, thou wast free, and didst rise from thy couch, and clothedst thyself, and walkedst at thine own pleasure whither thou wouldest; but when thou shalt be old, at the time when men seek rest and ease, thou shalt by no means rest, but shalt have harder labours. For they shall bind thee, and bring thee to the cross, where thou shalt stretch forth thy hands, i.e. shalt be crucified.

John 21:18 · Open Word Bible

18Truly, truly, I tell you, when you were younger you fastened your own belt and went wherever you wished. But when you have grown old, you will stretch out your hands, and then someone else will fasten a belt on you and take you where you do not wish to go."

Report a mistake

John 21:19

This Be spake, signifying

Ver. 19. — This Be spake, signifying, &c. Peter therefore by his death upon the cross glorified God, and so his death was not shameful, as Nero and the Romans thought, but was for the honour and glory both of God and Peter. The first reason was because Peter was crucified for the truth of the Faith. And this was glorious.

2. He glorified God, because for God and His Son Jesus Christ, whom he preached, he suffered crucifixion. But what is more glorious than to die for God ?

3. Because in the death of the cross he was like Christ, so that as he was like Him in his life and pontificate, he might also be like Him in his cross and death. As S. Chrysostom observes, Christ does not say, thou slialt die, but thou shalt glorify, because to suff'er for Christ is honour and glory. Hence the martyrdom of the cross is more honourable than other kinds of martyrdom, for which reason it was desired by many who were crucified. S. Maximus {Serm. 1, de Natal. Apost.) says, "Such was Peter, who when as a disciple of Christ he was brought to the cross, asked that he might be crucified upside down. He feared not the suffering, but he shrunk from equality with the Lord's cross, manifesting unto all men the power of his marvellous humility, and preserving amidst his torments the discipline of the mystery (of the cross)."

John 21:19 · Open Word Bible

19He said this to show by what kind of death Peter would glorify God. After saying this, He told him, "Follow Me."

Report a mistake

John 21:20–21

... Peter, in obedience to Christ, was beginning to follow Him, — presently John also, and the rest of his companions followed. Peter then, being anxious about John and his companions, turned and looked back. Seeing them following, he omitted mention of the rest, and asked Christ what was to become of John, whet'ner, namely, John was to follow Christ in the same way as himself, and to die upon a cross. Peter asked this, both because he loved John above the rest, and also because he knew that Christ loved him above tiie rest, and that he had reclined upon Plis breast at supper. He wondered that Christ should pass over this very dearly beloved John ; and so he calls him to His remembrance. As though he said, " What will be the fate of Thy well-beloved John ? Surely, as Thou didst prefer him to me at the supper, Thou mightest now rightly prefer him in the pastoral office, and subject me to him as a pastor. But since it has seemed good to Thee to do otherwise, at least I would desire to know what is to be the history of his life and death." Finally, the question was asked, because Peter here pays back, as it were, to John, the question which John at his instigation had asked at the last supper, when he asked Jesus who should betray Him ? Peter asked Jesus concerning John, thinking that John desired to know what was to be his future lot, and yet did not dare to ask Christ. Listen to S. Chrysostom. " Because the Lord had foretold him great things, and had committed the whole world to him, and prophesied his martyrdom, and testified larger love, desiring also to receive John as his partner, he said, But this man, ivhat {of hivi 1) For Peter dearly loved John, and thinking that he wished to ask a question concerning himself, but did not dare, he undertook to ask for him."

John 21:20–21 · Open Word Bible

20Peter turned around and saw the disciple whom Jesus loved following them, the same disciple who at the supper had leaned back against Jesus's chest and said, "Lord, who is it that is going to betray You?" 21When Peter saw him, he said to Jesus, "Lord, and what about him?"

Report a mistake

John 21:22

Ver. 22.— Jesus saith uftto htm, So I ivill him to tarry till I come, tvhat to thee 1 There is a threefold reading here. The first, the Greek, and from it the Syriac, Arabic and Ethiopic versions, If I will him to tarry. The second is, S. Jerome's {lib. 2, cont. Jovin) and others, If so. The third is the Latin, and especially the Roman, codices, So 1 will him to tarry. This is the reading of S- Augustine, Bede, Rupert, the Gloss, S. Thomas, Lyra, and others. George Trapezuntius endeavours, although a Greek, to defend this reading by many arguments. Cardinal Bessarion refutes him, and defends the first reading. It is in favour of the first reading that the Latin si is easily changed into sic. ... Again, the first reading gives a plain sense : thus, " If I will that John should remain in life, and not be crucified as I will thee to be, what is it to thee ? Follow Me, and leave John to My care." For Christ wishes only to repress Peter's curiosity, that, intent upon himself alone, he should leave the care of John to Christ. So S. Cyril, &c.

John 21:22 · Open Word Bible

22Jesus said to him, "If I want him to remain until I come, what is that to you? As for you, follow Me!"

Report a mistake

John 21:23

Yet Jesus said not

Ver. 23. — Yet Jesus said not, &c. This is the correction. John corrects the mistaken opinion of the disciples concerning himself, that he should not die. Whence it may be gathered that the meaning of Christ's words was different, and that John really died, as I have shown upon verse 22.

John 21:23 · Open Word Bible

23So the saying spread among the brothers and sisters that this disciple would not die. But Jesus had not told Peter that the disciple would not die; He had said, "If I want him to remain until I come, what is that to you?"

Report a mistake

John 21:24

This is that disciple

Ver. 24. — This is that disciple, &c., viz. John, who for the sake of modesty speaks of himself in the third person. As though he said, "This is not the testimony of myself alone, but I, and all who have been conversant with Christ, all who have been their hearers and disciples, know that this disciple testifies and writes the truth. For at that time tnere were but few survivors of those who liad conversed with Christ, but many survived who had heard the same things from them. For John wrote this Gospel against Cerinthus, Meander, Ebion, and other rising heretics, who denied that Christ was God, and therefore detracted from His preaching and Gospel, as though it were false and feigned.

There are also many other things, &c. After the words the world itself, the Syriac version adds, as I think. First, S. Augustine, Bede, S. Thomas, and others explain the words, the world itself could not contain the books, not of local space, but of the capacity of readers. As it were, " The whole world could not receive, i.e. could not understand, could not penetrate the mysteries of the doctrine and life of Christ, because they are too profound and Divine." But in this sense who is able to contain, in the sense of thorougiily penetrating, one single sentence of Christ concerning the mysteries of the Holy Trinity, the Incarnation, the Eucharist, &c,?

John 21:24 · Open Word Bible

24This is the disciple who is testifying about these things and who has written them, and we know his testimony is true.

Report a mistake