Logia

Cornelius a Lapide · The Great Commentary: S. John's Gospel

John 18

15 excerpts on John 18, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

John 18:1

Ver. I. — When Jesus had spoken these words, He went forth with His disciples over the brook Cedron, where was a garden, into the which He entered and His disciples. Jesus had now finished that glowing, and long discourse, in which He bade His disciples farewell, and was hastening to His Passion and Death. In fact. He offered Himself to it, voluntarily, by going into the garden, and there waiting for Judas and the Jews, by whom He knew He was to be taken. He gave thus an example of boldness of mind, by first choosing for Himself the very spot in which He was about to contend with death, sin, and the devil, as though sure of victory and triumph. It is hence inferred that Jesus, as soon as He had finished His discourse, crossed the Brook, and that the dispute of the Apostles about precedence (Luke xxii. 24) took place, not after this discourse (as S. Augustine thinks) but before it. When the hymn was sung is uncertain, for S. Matthew seems to intimate that it was sung at the end of the discourse (Matt. xxvi. 30). But reason seems to suggest that it was sung before it, as being a giving of thanks which was sung immediately after the supper, and the Eucharist, and before this discourse. So Chrysostora, Theophylact, Euthymius on Malt, xxvi., and Ribera on this passage.

John 18:1 · Open Word Bible

1When Jesus had said these things, He went out with His disciples and crossed the Kidron Valley. A garden was there, and He and His disciples went into it.

Report a mistake

John 18:4

... But Jesus did not wish to be taken when that sign was given, lest He should seem to be taken against His will. He then by the almighty power of His Godhead held back the soldiers, and fixed them to the spot, so that when the sign was given they did not dare to rush forward to take Him, and indeed could not. Christ accordingly boldly stepped forward of His accord to meet them, and challenged them, as it were, to seize Him, by asking, Whom seek ye 1

John 18:4 · Open Word Bible

4Jesus knew everything that was about to happen to Him, so He went out to them and asked, "Who is it you are looking for?"

Report a mistake

John 18:5

They answered Him, Jesus of Nazareth

Ver. 5. — They answered Him, Jesus of Nazareth. They said not, "We seek Thee," but they say, "We seek Jesus." And therefore they did not recognise Him, though pointed out by the traitor's kiss (because Jesus had smitten them with blindness), and though the officers of the chief Priests had often seen and heard Him before this. So S. Chrysostom says : " Thou seest His irresistible power, tliat standing in the midst of them He smote them with blindness." And S. Cyril, "His Divine Power shone f(jitli, tor though He put Himself in their way, He was not recognised by those who were seeking Him."

And Judas also, ivho betrayed Him, stood with them. Judas had preceded the soldiers in order to betray Jesus, but finding that they did not rush forward to take Him, he became conscious of his perfidy, and turned back in obstinate impenitence, not to the disciples, but to the soldiers, in order to be defended by them against Jesus, whose power he feared, and was therefore struck to the ground with them. So S. Augustine. But Euthymius and Ribera think that Judas came up to Christ and kissed Him, after he had been struck down. This is probable, and only proves the greater shamelessness of Judas,

John 18:5 · Open Word Bible

5They answered, "Jesus of Nazareth." He said to them, "I am He." Judas, who was betraying Him, was standing there with them.

Report a mistake

John 18:6

As soon then as He had said unto them, I am He, they went backward. They did not fall forward on their breasts, lest the power which threw them down should seem to have come from behind, but they fell backward, to make it plain that they were thrown down by the power of Christ's words, and that they could not bear to behold His face or hear His words. For the words " I am " reminded them of what God said to Moses (Ex. iii.) " I am that I am : this is My Name;" and I can annihilate you if I will. And therefore ye are those who are not : for all your being ye receive not from yourselves, but directly from Me. The tropological and allegorical meaning I have given Matt. xxvi. 50.

John 18:6 · Open Word Bible

6When Jesus said to them, "I am He," they stepped backward and fell to the ground.

Report a mistake

John 18:7

... Why was this? (i.) That He might by His own death alone redeem the world. " He removed His disciples out of danger," says S. Cyril, "as knowing that the contest and the work of our salvation pertained to Him alone, as being the work of a ruler and not of one under him." (2.) Because He destined the Apostles to succeed Him, and spread His truth over the world after His death and Resurrection. (3.) To show His great love and care for them, as a shepherd careth for his sheep, as S. John suggests in the next verse.

John 18:7 · Open Word Bible

7So He asked them again, "Who is it you are looking for?" "Jesus of Nazareth," they said.

Report a mistake

John 18:9

Ver. 9. — That the saying might be fulfilled, ivhich He spake, Oj them which Thou gavest Me have I lost none, i.e. of the eleven Apostles which Thou gavest Me : for Judas, as the son of perdition, was not given Him absolutely of the Father. But of what loss and death does Christ here speak: of the soul or of the body? Some say one, some another. But I say, both of body and soul. For they would have perished in the body if they had been seized and slain together with Jesus, more especially because Peter had withstood them and had wounded Malchus. They would have also perished in their souls, because they would have denied Christ in their weakness, and from fear of the threats of the Jews, just as Peter denied Him. And so, when killed by the Jews they would have perished both in body and soul. For they would have died in the mortal sin of denial. So Rupertus, Cajetan, Ribera, F. Lucas, Toletus, and others.

John 18:9 · Open Word Bible

9This was so that His own word would be fulfilled: "I have not lost a single one of those You gave Me."

Report a mistake

John 18:10

Ver. lo. — But there was a servant named Malchus. He mentions the name of the servant to signify the mystery. F'or Malchus is the same as " king." But as the servant of the High Priest he signifies the Jewish people, which was formerly a kingly and free power, but afterwards became subject to the Priesthood, which burdened it with its traditions and ceremonies, and also preyed upon it. See Matt, xxiii. Now this man, when S. Peter and the Apostles preached the Gospel, lost his right ear on account of his unbelief and hatred of Christ : that is, he became deaf to the Gospel, and to those things which were necessary to salvation, till the Lord converted him, and healed his ear. ... S. Ambrose adds that S. Peter wished to imitate the zeal of Phinehas, who slew a prince of Israel who committed fornication with the daughters of Moab : and thus obtained the High Priesthood {Num. xxv.) The love therefore of S. Peter, and his zeal for Christ, lessened his fault. And yet he sinned in drawing his sword without consulting Christ, more especially when he had heard just before from His own lips, that He was going of His own accord to His Passion and Death.

John 18:10 · Open Word Bible

10Simon Peter had a sword. He pulled it out and struck the high priest's servant, slicing off his right ear. The servant's name was Malchus.

Report a mistake

John 18:12

Bound Him

Ver. 12.— Bound Him. By Whom they should have wished to be set free. And maybe they were of the number of those who, when afterwards set free by Him, said, " Thou hast burst my bonds in sunder" (Ps. cxvi. 14), says S. Augustine. ... But He would not— (i.) In order to expiate the sin of Adam which he committed with His hands. For since the first Adam too readily stretched forth his hands to the forbidden fruit, Christ the second Adam was willing to be bound in order to expiate the sins of Adam and his posterity, which are most commonly wrought with the hands.

(2.) To fulfil the type : for Isaac, who was a type of Christ, was bound when about to be offered by Abraham. For the victims were bound, lest they should struggle against being offered (Gen. xxii. 9).

(3.) That by having taken on Him these bonds from love of us, He might bind us with the cords of love, as is said (Hos. xi. 4), " I will draw them with cords of a man, with bands of love."

John 18:12 · Open Word Bible

12Then the detachment of soldiers with its commander, and the temple police sent by the Jewish leaders, arrested Jesus and tied Him up.

Report a mistake

John 18:13

Ver. 13. — And they led Him away to Annas first, for he was fatherin-law to Caiaphas, which was the High Priest that same year. But why did Judas and the Jews lead Him first to Annas, and not to Caiaphas, when He had to be judged by Caiaphas (as High Priest), and not by Annas ?

I answer (i.) To pay honour to Annas, as being the elder, and father-in-law to Caiaphas, whom " Caiaphas honoured as father," says Euthymius, and by whose counsel he governed the people. (2.) The house of Annas was in the way to that of Caiaphas, (3.) Because Annas especially wished and arranged for the seizure of Christ. And hence the soldiers lead Him as it were in triumph, in order to delight him, and that they, in return, themselves might obtain some reward for so doing. (4.) To summon Annas (who on the previous evening had gone to his own house, on account of the cold) to attend the council which was about to be held the next morning at the house of Caiaphas to try Jesus. (5.) And specially, because Annas had promised Judas the reward of his betrayal, Judas therefore takes Jesus to his house, to obtain from him the thirty pieces he had promised, and, as S. Cyril thinks, he then actually received. And this is inferred from the fact that in the first agreement with the Rulers, the money was only promised, not paid (see Matt, xxvi. 15). Judas therefore received them this very night at the house of Annas, and shortly afterwards, in sorrow at what he had done, threw them down in the temple (Matt, xxvii. 3). For he could not receive them at the house of Caiaphas, who was so engaged in finding false witnesses, in examining Christ, in summoning the Council, &c., that he had no time to treat with Judas.

John 18:13 · Open Word Bible

13They took Him first to Annas, the father-in-law of Caiaphas, who was high priest that year.

Report a mistake

John 18:24

Ver. 24. — Ninv Annas sent Him bound unto Caiaphas the High Priest. The Syriac and Arabic versions, as also S. Cyril, read " had sent Him," and so too English version. But it seems as if S. John had forgotten to mention the sending of Jesus from Annas to Caiaphas, and here inserted it out of place, whereas it should come in after ver. 13.

John 18:24 · Open Word Bible

24Then Annas sent Him on to Caiaphas the high priest, still bound.

Report a mistake

John 18:28

... To the house and hall of Pilate ; for he was Praetor, that is, both civil and criminal judge of Judsea.

Every magistrate who had an army under him, was called Praetor, a prceeundo. And the place in which he held trials was called Prsetorium ; a place in which criminals were tried, for which purpose Jesus was brought thither by the Chief Priests.

But they themselves entered not into the judgment-hall lest thev should be defiled (by entering the house of the heathen governor), but that they might (as pure and clean) eat the Passover. The Passover does not here mean the Paschal Lamb (as SS. Chrysostom and Cyril suppose), for that they had eaten the day before ; but the Paschal victims, which were sacrificed during the whole seven days, which could be eaten only by those who were clean. ... S. Augustine exclaims, "O impious and foolish blindness! for forsooth they would be defiled by a dwelling which was another's, and not be defiled by a crime which was their own." See S. Cyril.

John 18:28 · Open Word Bible

28Then they led Jesus from Caiaphas to the governor's headquarters. It was early morning. They did not go into the headquarters themselves, to avoid becoming ritually unclean, since they wanted to eat the Passover.

Report a mistake

John 18:31

... For the

Romans, it appears, had deprived the Jews, as a conquered people,

of the power of capital punishment, and claimed it for themselves.

This is the meaning of the words. See Rupertus, S. Thomas, Jansen, Suarez, and others. You will say the Jews stoned S. Stephen, and threw down S. James headlong. But this was not in course of law, but in a popular tumult. ... But you will urge that Pilate had already given the Chief Priests liberty to judge and to put Him to death, when he said, "Take ye Him and judge Him according to your law." I answer, that they could have done so, but were unwilling to accept his offer. They said, as it were, in their minds, Ye Romans have taken away from us altogether the power of the sword. We therefore do not wish to exercise it in this particular case. Either restore us this power absolutely, or else take your part in the deed. This they said as wishing Jesus to suffer the most ignominious death, that of crucifixion as a seditious person, and aiming at kingly power. And they wished to transfer from themselves to Pilate the unpopularity of His death. For they feared they should be stoned by the people, who were in favour of Jesus, or else be assailed by their revilings.

John 18:31 · Open Word Bible

31So Pilate told them, "You take Him, then, and try Him under your own law." The Jewish leaders replied, "We are not permitted to execute anyone."

Report a mistake

John 18:32

Ver. 32. — That the saying of Jesus might be fulfilled which He spake signifying by what death He should die., viz. that He was to be delivered up to the Gentiles, and to be crucified by them. See John xii. 32 and Matt. xx. 18.

John 18:32 · Open Word Bible

32This was so that the word Jesus had spoken would be fulfilled, the word that showed what kind of death He was going to die.

Report a mistake

John 18:37

Thou say est that I am a King

Ver. 37. — Thou say est that I am a King, i.e. I am in truth the King of the Jews, to rule in the faithful by faith and grace, and bring them to My heavenly Kingdom.

To evangelical truth, which mainly consists in these things — (i.) In the true knowledge of God, namely, that He is One in Essence, and threefold in Person.

For every being is true, that is a true and not an imaginary thing, and is true in itself. Wherefore God, who is Very Being (I am that I am) is also truth, and good itself. Because His essential Being is Truth and Goodness. Again, the Son who proceedeth from the Father, as His Word, is Truth Itself, not merely of existence but of mind. Whence S. Augustine says, when Jesus bears witness to the truth, He bears witness to Himself, for He Himself is truth.

John 18:37 · Open Word Bible

37Pilate said to Him, "So You are a king after all?" Jesus answered, "You are the one who says that I am a king. I was born for this, and I came into the world for this: to testify to the truth. All who belong to the truth listen to My voice."

Report a mistake

John 18:38

... And therefore he asked Him what that truth was to which He was born to bear witness. But this was not much to tlie point which he was aiming at, viz., the deliverance of Jesus, who was a grave, wise, and innocent man. And therefore he thought on a very fitting means for His deliverance. For he was about to set free one at the feast ; and therefore compared Jesus and Barabbas, in order that the Jews should rather ask for Jesus than Barabbas. He therefore rushed out to propose it to them.

Symbolically. What is truth ? S. Augustine answers {in Senteiiiice, 386), "Truth is God Himself, who is the primal source of life, and the primal essence, as He is the highest wisdom. For He is that unchangeable truth which is rightly termed 'the law of all arts, and the art of the Almighty Artificer.' " And also {Epist. ix.), •' The truth held by Christians is incomparably more beautiful than Helen of Greece. For our martyrs contended more boldly in its behalf against this Sodom of ours, than these heroes fought for her against Troy." Nay, Christ Himself died as the first martyr for the truth.

John 18:38 · Open Word Bible

38Pilate said to Him, "What is truth?" After saying this, he went back out to the Jewish leaders and told them, "I find no case against Him.

Report a mistake