Cornelius a Lapide · The Great Commentary: S. John's Gospel
John 20
28 excerpts on John 20, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
On the first day of the week
Ver. 1. — On the first day of the week. Literally, of the Sabbath, the week being called the Sabbath, alter its principal day, or the day of the Pasch. (see on Matt, xxviii.)
Mary Magdalene cajnc. The other gospels speak of the other women, but she only is mentioned here, as being their leader, and more zealous and active than the rest.
When it was yet dark. ... Note here her activity, watchlulness, and ardour.
She seeks Christ in the dawn, and hence she is the first to see Him as the rising sun. As S. Ambrose says on the title of Ps. Iv.,* " For the morning undertaking." This morning undertaking we can ascribe to Mary Magdalene, who went very early in the morning to watch at the tomb, and first greeted the resurrection of the Lord, and as the sunlight grew brighter, she only, and before the rest, recognised the rising of the Sun of righteousness, and as by this morning greeting she rejoiced at the return of daylight, so did she rejoice the more that Christ was raised from the dead, and in her was fulfilled the prophecy, In the evening weeping will tarry {see Vulg.) (heaviness may endure for the night, E. V.) but at morning is joy
John 20:1 · Open Word Bible
1On the first day of the week Mary Magdalene came to the tomb in the early morning, while it was still dark, and found that the stone had been taken away from it.
Ver. 2. — Then she runneth, and cometh to Simon Peter, as the Chief Apostle, and as designated by Christ as His Vicar and successor, {Matt, xvi.), and that other disciple whom Jesus loved., i.e. S. John, who wuuld be more diligent than the rest in searching for the Body of Christ.
John 20:2 · Open Word Bible
2She ran off, then, to find Simon Peter and the other disciple, whom Jesus loved. "They have removed the Lord from the tomb," she told them, "and we do not know where they have laid Him."
So they ran both together
Ver. 4. — So they ran both together. Before the rest, as loving Him above the rest, says S. Gregory.
And he (John) did outrun Peter, as the younger and more active, and moreover as more desirous oi seeing that Body which he had just before seen marred on the cross.
John 20:4 · Open Word Bible
4The two of them ran together, but the other disciple was faster than Peter and got to the tomb ahead of him.
Ver. 5. — And he stooping down, to look into the tomb, saiv the linen clothes with which the Body of Christ had been wrapped. Yet went he not in, paying deference to Peter, as his senior and more
* It is nol the title ui Ps. iv. in fact, but of Ps. xxi. — 'J ran: worthy, says Lyranus, or else hindered by fear, or seized with a kind of sacred dread at the Body of Christ which was buried there.
John 20:5 · Open Word Bible
5Bending down to look in, he saw the linen cloths lying there; he did not, however, go in.
Ver. 6. — Then cometh Simon Peter follotving him, and went into the sepulchre. Peter (says S. Chrysostom) entered with ardour, and carefully inspected everything. For the soldiers who guarded the tomb, when they saw the angel and the earthquake, ran away through fear. See also S. Jerome, Qucest. vi. ad Hedib. And seeth the linen clothes lie, and the napkin which was about His head (covering His face, as is generally done to the dead, for the sake of seemliness). not lying with the linen clothes, but wrapped together in a place by itself. "This," says S. Chrysostom, "was a sign of His Resurrection, for if they had removed the body they would not have stripped it, and if they had stolen it, they would not have been so careful to fold up the napkin, and put it aside by itself; for John had said before that He was buried with myrrh, which makes linen clothes cling close to the body, so that no one would be deceived by those who said that It was stolen away; for what thief would trouble himself so much about an unnecessary matter?"
John 20:6 · Open Word Bible
6Then Simon Peter, who had been following him, came and went into the tomb. He saw the linen cloths lying there,
Ver. 8. — Then went in also that other disciple, whicli came first to the sepulchre.
Tropologically, Toletus says that by John are signified all Christians, but by Peter the Pontiffs, Vicars of Christ. Peter then entered the tomb first as the highest in dignity, as the Vicar of Christ; but John came last, because it is possible that he who is first in rank, is behind others in desert and holiness.
And he saw and believed. Both of them, that is, believed that what Mary Magdalene said was true, namely, that the Body of Christ had been taken away. So says S. Augustine, Theophylact, and Jan sen. S. Cyril, Chrysostom, Euthymius, and Nyssen add that both believed that Christ had risen. But this word "believed" more clearly and correctly applies only to S. John, who remembered the words of Christ, that He would rise on the third day. But Peter, on account 01 the strangeness of a Resurrection, and from His earnest desire to see Him alive again, was more slow to believe that Christ had risen.
John 20:8 · Open Word Bible
8Then the other disciple, who had arrived at the tomb first, went in too; and he saw and believed.
Ver, 9. — For as yet ihey knew ?iot the scriptures, that He must rise again from the dead. For although He had solemnly assured them that He would rise, yet on account of its strange and wonderful nature they believed it not, but thought that He spoke in a figure and parable, as He was wont to do.
John 20:9 · Open Word Bible
9For as yet they did not understand the Scripture, that He must rise from the dead.
Ver. 10. — Then the disciples wejit away again unto their own home. Peter wondering, John believing He had risen, the Magdalene alone remaining at the sepulchre, to learn something more certain about the Body of her beloved Christ. See S. Augustine {in loc.) "And hence it came to pass that she alone saw Him, she who remained to seek for Him, for perseverance in a good work is a virtue," says S. Gregory, Hom. xxv.
John 20:10 · Open Word Bible
10Then the disciples went back to where they were staying.
Ver. 1 1. — But Mary stood without at the sepidchre weepittg. Because she anxiously looked about on every side for the Body of Jesus, as glowing in love for Him, and was beside herself; and not finding Him, wept for grieif. "The eyes {says S. Augustine in loc.) who sought, but found Him not, had leisure to weep, and sorrowed more for His being taken from the tomb than that He had died on the Cross, because not even a memorial remained of so great a Teacher, whose life had been taken away."
And as she wept, she stooped down, and looked itito the sepulchre. Though she looked in before and saw that the sepulchre was empty. ... The power of love increases the earnestness of the inquiry : she persevered in seeking, and accordingly she found. And so it was that her desires expanded and increased, and could thus take in that which they found."
John 20:11 · Open Word Bible
11Mary, however, stood outside the tomb, weeping. Still weeping, she stooped to look into the tomb.
... All these were tokens of His glorious Resurrection, and prepared the mind of the Magdalene to believe it. One sat at the head and the other at the feet, to signify that the whole Body of Christ had risen, and that, by assuming the immortal form and glory of angels, He had entered into their company, and had left these two angels, as guardians of the tomb, to announce the fact to the Magdalene.
Origen says that, mystically, the angel at the feet represented the active, the angel at the head the contemplative, life. For they are both of them from Jesus, about Jesus, through Jesus, and on account of Jesus.
John 20:12 · Open Word Bible
12There she saw two angels in white clothes, sitting where the body of Jesus had been lying, one at the head, the other at the feet.
Ver. 13. — They say unto her, Woman, why weepest thou 7 This is no place for weeping, but rather for rejoicing, and being glad. Because thou seest not here the dead Body of thy Beloved One, thou oughtest to infer that Jesus has risen, and is no longer among the dead, but among the living ; and more than this, that He is passing a blessed and heavenly life among the glorious angels, such as we are ourselves.
I weep for three reasons, (i.) Because of the ignominious death of my Lord. (2.) ... (3.) Because I do not know where to look for It. For did I know, I should haste to the spot, embrace It, and overwhelm It with kisses. See here how Jesus suffers the souls of those that love Him to remain in ignorance for a while, in order to sharpen and enkindle their desire for Him ; and when it is thus sharpened and enkindled, to comfort and make them glad with the full revelation of Himself.
John 20:13 · Open Word Bible
13They said to her, "Woman, why are you weeping?" "My Lord has been taken away," she answered, "and I do not know where they have laid Him."
Ver. 14. — Aftd when she had thus said, she turned herself back, and saw Jesus standing, and knew ?iot that it was Jesus. Christ appeared behind the Magdalene, so that the angels who beheld Him rose up, and bowed their heads, and exhibited other tokens of reverence and adoration towards Him. And this was why she turned about, viz., to see who it was whom the angels saluted so reverently. So S. Chrysostom {Horn. 85), and the author of the Qucest. ad Antioch {Qucest. Ixxviii.), [Pseudo-Athanasian]. Some think that Christ made a noise with His feet to attract her attention.
And saw Jesus. "The first to share the joy: as loving more than all."
And knew not that it was Jesus. As appearing in the form of the gardener. Just as He appeared in the form of a stranger at Emmaus. For glorified bodies can put on any appearance they please, not by changing their own appearance, but by presenting only a refracted appearance to the sight of others. Christ did this, in order that she should not be startled. He appeared to her in consequence of her intense love to Him. But because she did not believe that He was alive, He veiled Himself from her, and presented Himself to her outward sight as the person she fancied Him to be. So S. Gregory {Ho?n. xxiii.), speaking of the disciples at Emmaus.
John 20:14 · Open Word Bible
14With these words she turned around and saw Jesus standing there, though she did not know that it was Jesus.
Ver. 15. — Jesus saith unto her, Woman, why weepest thou? whom seekest thou? S. Ambrose {Lib. iii. de Virg.) explains the whole passage minutely : " Woman, why weepest thou ? He who believeth not is a woman ; for he that believes rises up into the ' perfect man, into the measure of the stature of the fulness of Christ.' It is a reproach not on her sex, but on her slowness of belief. It is well said a woman hesitated, though a virgin had already believed. Why weepest thou ? Thou thyself art in fault, as being incredulous. Dost thou weep because thou seest not Christ? Believe, and thou wilt see Him. Christ is close by thee. He never fails those that seek Him. Thou shouldest not weep, but have ready faith, as God requires. Think not of mortal things, and thou wilt not sorrow; think not of perishing things, and thou wilt have no cause for weeping. Thou weepest for that, at which others are glad. Whom seekest thou ? seest thou not that Christ is at thy side ? "
John 20:15 · Open Word Bible
15Jesus said to her, "Woman, why are you weeping? Who is it you are looking for?" Supposing He was the gardener, she said to Him, "Sir, if You are the one who has carried Him off, tell me where You put Him, and I will take Him away."
Jesus saith unto her, Mary
Ver. 1 6. —Jesus saith unto her, Mary. She turned herself, and saith unto Him, Rabboni, which is to say. Master. He called her not merely by her own name, but with that tone of voice, that sweetness, grace, and efficacy, with which He used to speak to her ; and she at once recognised Him. ... My great grief is turned into great joy ; the tears of sorrow are changed into the tears of love. ... Her spirit then revived and her senses returned, and when He wished to add something more, she could not wait, but from excess of joy she interrupted Him, saying, Rabboni. For she thought that having found the ' Word ' she did not require a single word more, and she deemed it more profitable to touch the ' Word ' than to hear any words whatever. O vehement and impatient love ! It was not enough for her to see Jesus and to talk with Him ; unless she also touched Him, for she knew that virtue went out from Him, and healed all."
John 20:16 · Open Word Bible
16Jesus said to her, "Mary!" She turned and said to Him in Hebrew, "Rabbouni!" (which means Teacher).
Jesus saith unto her, Touch Me not
Ver. 17. — -Jesus saith unto her, Touch Me not ; for I am not yet ascended to My Father, &c. This is a difficult passage, and the connection between the two parts is even more difficult, (i.) S. Augustine explains the connection thus, " Touch Me not, for as yet thou art not worthy to touch Me ; for in thy thoughts regarding Me, I have not as yet ascended to My Father, for as yet thou dost not perfectly believe that I am the Son of God, and that I ascend to My Father." ... But this is a mystical rather than a literal explanation. As also is that of S. Leontius {Serm. ii, de Ascens.), "I do not wish you to approach Me bodily, or recognise Me with thy bodily senses. I reserve thee for higher things. I am preparing for thee greater things. When I shall have ascended to My Father, then wilt thou touch Me more perfectly and truly, for thou wilt comprehend that which thou touchest not, and believe that which thou seest not." (2.) ... But, on this ground neither would the other women, or Thomas, or the rest have been able to touch Him — which yet they did. (3.) S. Chrysostom {in loc), Theophylact, and Euthymius say that He forbade her to touch Him, because He wished to be touched with greater reverence than heretofore : since He would not henceforth hold converse with men, but with angels and blessed spirits. But it does not appear that the Magdalene failed in reverence. And after all, what connection has this with the reason given, "I have not yet ascended to My Father"? (4.) ... But this explanation is not clear, and requires many things to be supplied, besides misinterpreting the reason given. (5.) The best explanation is this, " Do not waste any more time in thus touching Me. Go and bear the glad tidings of My Resurrection to My disciples at once. I do not just yet ascend into heaven.
John 20:17 · Open Word Bible
17Jesus said to her, "Do not keep holding on to Me, because I have not yet ascended to the Father. Go instead to My brothers and sisters with this message: 'I am ascending to My Father and your Father, My God and your God.'"
Ver. 18. — Mary came a fid told the disciples, I have seen the Lord, and He has said these things to me. She thus became an apostle and evangelist to the Apostles. And accordingly, when she was driven into exile by the Jews, and arrived at Marseilles, she preached the gospel to the people there. And she fully deserved this honour, by her glowing love to Christ, her faith and constancy, which led her to the sepulchre by herself at early dawn, where she waited patiently till she saw her Jesus.
John 20:18 · Open Word Bible
18Mary Magdalene went and brought the disciples the news: "I have seen the Lord!" And she reported to them what He had said to her.
Ver, 19. — Then the same day at evening, on the first day of the week. Or the feast of the Pasch. (See notes on Matt, xxviii. i.)
When the doors were shut. Calvin says that Christ opened the doors, or entered through an open window, so as not to be compelled to admit that one dimension could penetrate another — peneiratio dimensionum, or that two bodies could exist together in the same place, which Durandus (Jn iv. dist. 44, Qiicest. vi.) says is even beyond the power of God. But S. John here intimates the contrary, for he says that the doors were shut, to signify that Christ passed through the closed doors, as He did both at His conception and nativity, and passed through the stone when He rose from the grave, thus manifesting the almighty power of His Godhead, and the gifts conferred upon His glorified Body. On this subject see Bellarmine, de Eucharistia, iii. 6, who quotes both Greek and Latin fathers on this point. As S. Augustine, "The closed doors opposed not His Body. Let us grant that God can do anything, which we admit, though we cannot understand. It all turns on the power of the Creator." (S. Ambrose on Luke xxiv ; S. Hilary, de Trin. lib. iii. ; S. Justin Martyr, Resp. ad Grcecor Qucbs- Hones ; Epiphanius, Haresi, Ixiv.) "As our Lord rose from the grave, not by raising up another Body, but the very same, changing it into the subtile nature of a spirit, thus He entered the closed doors, a thing impossible to our gross bodies," &c. (Origen). And S. Cyril, " The Lord entered suddenly, the doors being closed, overcoming the ordinary nature of things by His omnipotence ; for being true God, He is not under the power of nature." And Euthymius, quoting S. Chrysostom, " He did not knock at the doors, lest they should be alarmed, but as God entered through them, though closed."
John 20:19 · Open Word Bible
19On the evening of that day, the first day of the week, the disciples were behind locked doors because they feared the Jewish leaders. Jesus came and stood among them and said, "Peace to you."
Ver. 21. — Then said Jesus to them again, Peace be unto you. Why again? The Interlinear Gloss says, " It was a repeated confirmation, Peace upon peace, according to the prophet." Bede says, " He repeats it, because the virtue of charity is twofold, or because He is the peace who makes both one." The Gloss, " He offers peace, who came for the sake of peace; and He repeats His words to show that all things whether in heaven or in earth are restored to peace through Him." S. Chrysostom, " Because they were waging an unappeasable contest with the Jews." He proclaims peace in order to console them, and sets forth also the power of the cross, by which He drave away all sorrow, and conferred every good, which is peace. But a further joy was announced to the women, for they had to bear the curse, " in sorrow shalt thou bring forth," and they were indeed in sorrow.
John 20:21 · Open Word Bible
21Jesus said to them again, "Peace to you. In the way that the Father has sent Me, I am sending you."
... Why did He breathe on them.? (i.) To signify the nature of the Holy Spirit, as proceeding both from Him and the Father. For as a man by breathing on another imparts to him his breath, so the Father and the Son by breathing produce the Holy Spirit, and communicate to Him their Spirit and Godhead. So S. Augustine {ifi loc), Cyril, Bede, and others. This breathing was not the Holy Spirit Himself, but a sign of Him : so that it means. Receive by this breathing, as by a sign and instrumental cause, the gift of the Holy Spirit.
(2.) To signify that the ?Ioly Spirit was consubstantial with Himself and the Father. (3.) To show that it was He wlio first breathed into Adam the breath of life. As if He would say, I first gave Adam his natural life by breathing on him, so by breathing on you, do I give you that Holy Spirit which bestows on you supernatural and divine life. I who first created men, am now their re-creator and restorer. See S. Cyril {Lib. xii. 56), Leontius, Euthymius, and S. Athanasius {Qiicest. Ixiv. ad Antiochuni). (4.) S. Cyril and S. Basil {de Spir. ... He seems to say, Receive ye the Spirit which ye lost in Adam's person by sin. Breathe Him forth on penitents in the sacrament of penance, remit through Him their sins and restore them to the life of the Spirit by grace. Hear S. Cyril : " Man was at first made by the Word of God, and God breathed into him the breath of life, and strengthened him by the imparting of His Spirit. But since he fell by disobedience, God the Father refashioned him, and brought him to new life by His Son. And we may learn that as it was He who in the beginning created our nature, and sealed it by His Holy Spirit, so when He began the renewal of our nature.
John 20:22 · Open Word Bible
22Having said this, He breathed on them and told them, "Receive the Holy Spirit."
... Calvin twists and turns this to make it mean tiie preaching of the Gospel, namely, that they to whom ye preach the Gospel, if they believe it, will have their sins forgiven by their mere belief. But every one sees that this explanation is strained, forced, foolish, and ridiculous. For in this way it would not be the Apostles, but believers themselves who would themselves remit their own sins, which is absurd. For no one is judge in his own case, or stands higher than himself, so as to remit his own sins. (2.) These two things, viz., preaching the Gospel and remitting sins, are clearly dissimilar and distinct, the one being the work of an Apostle in preaching, the other the judicial act of a judge. (3.) The Gospel must be preached to all: and consequently this absolution of Calvin's must be given even to all the wicked. But Christ wishes not that all sins should be remitted, but orders that some should be retained, and that the Apostles and their successors should be judges in this matter. (4.) Christ had already given the Apostles power to preach (Luke x. i), and commanded them to preach to every creature. Why then should He repeat all this in such obscure and unintelligible words ?
John 20:23 · Open Word Bible
23Whose sins you forgive, they stand forgiven; whose sins you retain, they stand retained.
But Thomas
... Diciynuis means a twin. See notes on chap. xi. 16. But here he is so called (double, doubtful) because he wavered and doubted as to Christ's resurrection. He was at that time weaker than the other Apostles, but afterwards (after Christ again appeared) was bolder and more full of faith than all of tliem, inasmuch as he alone traversed nearly the whole world in preaching the Gospel. Stapleton {de Vita Thomce) says that he went to the furthest part of India, to Abyssinia and China, and even to America.
Was jiot with them. S. Chrysostom, Theophylact, and Euthymius suppose that having fled away with the other Apostles, he had not yet returned. But S. Augustine, Bede, Lyranus, D. Thomas, and others say in reply that he was with the other Apostles when the two disciples returned from Emmaus, but that he disbelieved their story, and went away. It is supposed that when S. Luke says (xxiv. ir), "their words seemed to them as idle tales," he was referring to S. Thomas.
John 20:24 · Open Word Bible
24But Thomas, one of the Twelve, also called Didymus (which means Twin), was not with them when Jesus came.
Ver. 25. — The other disciples therefore said Jinto hitn, We have seen the Loj-d. But he said unto them, Except I shall see in His hands the print of the ?iails, and put my finger i?ito the pri?it of the tiails, and thrust my hand into His side, I will not believe.
(See Origen, Lib. ii. Contr. Celsum ; S. Augustine, Lib. xvi. Contra Faust, cap. 33 ; and S. Gregory, Hofn. xxvi.)
Besides, this unbelief of S. Thomas' arose partly from his not believing Christ to be God. For had he believed this, he would easily have understood that Christ could have raised His Body to life again, and it is surprising that Cyril should say that Thomas believed Him to be God ; and it partly arose from His excessive sorrow, especially because he alone had not seen Christ at the same time as the other Apostles. This wounded him much, and caused him to utter these bitter words. So Cyril, xii. 57. But God allowed it to be thus, in order that Thomas and we should be confirmed in humility, and in belief in the resurrection by this fresh appearance of Christ.
John 20:25 · Open Word Bible
25So the other disciples kept telling him, "We have seen the Lord!" But he told them, "I will never believe it unless I see the marks the nails made in His hands, and put my finger into those marks, and put my hand into His side."
And after eight days
Ver. 26 — And after eight days. The eighth day after the Lord's resurrection, the Octave of the Passover, when we commemorate this mystery, and read this Gospel. And from this S. Cyril observes that the Apostles, from these appearances of Christ, began from this time to hold the assemblies of the Church on the Lord's day, and to consecrate it, as it were, because He rose on that day, and thus guided the Apostles to observe the Lord's day instead of the Sabbath.
Again His disciples were within, in that upper chamber before mentioned. It is therefore far from probable, as S. Jerome (in Matt, ult.), Rupertus, and Ribera here suppose, that Christ appeared to S. Thomas and the Apostles, not in Jerusalem, but in Galilee, where He afterwards appeared, not only to the Apostles, but to all the disciples.
Notice here, the wondrous condescension of Christ, who, in order to convert this unbelieving and obstinate Thomas, offered Himself a second time, not only to be seen, but also to be handled by him. And this He did, not for his sake only, but for the sake of the other Apostles, to strengthen both them and us also in the belief of His resurrection.
John 20:26 · Open Word Bible
26A week later His disciples were indoors again, and Thomas was with them. Though the doors were locked, Jesus came and stood among them and said, "Peace to you."
Ver. 27. — Theji saith He to Thomas, Reach hither thy finger, and behold My hands, and reach hither thy hand, and thrust it into My side. Behold the kindness of Christ in humbling Himself to all Thomas' requests, and in all things complying with his wishes, in order to convert him. See, says S. Chrysostom, how for one single soul He displays His wounds, and because he was somewhat dull of comprehension seeks to give him proof by means of the dullest of his senses, I mean his touch.
And be not faithless, bid believing. Thou thinkest, forsooth, that I did not know what thou saidst of Me when I was not present. But rest assured that I knew, and was present to hear thy words of unbelief. Do then as thou hast said, I offer thee My wounded hands and side to touch and handle, nay more, that thou mayest measure them with thy hand, that so thou mayest lay aside thy unbelief, and believe henceforth that I have risen, I the very same that hung on the Cross, and no other. And in this way Christ heals another wound of unbelief, for He shows that He knows even all secrets, and is a searcher of hearts, and consequently God. He therefore radically cures the disease, for Thomas did not believe that Christ had risen, because he did not believe Him to be God.
John 20:27 · Open Word Bible
27Then He said to Thomas, "Put your finger here; see My hands. Bring your hand and put it into My side. Do not be unbelieving any longer, but believing."
Thomas answered and said unto Him, My Lord and my God
Ver. 28. — Thomas answered and said unto Him, My Lord and my God. This was after he had fully ascertained that it was indeed Christ Himself, who had received these wounds on tlie cross, and who was now alive again. See Tertullian, de Anima, cap. xxviii. ; S. Ambrose, iti Ps. xliii. (xliv.) ; S. Hilary, de Trinit.
My Lord and my God. That is, Thou art my Lord and my God. Thus showing that He was Very and true God by nature. Thomas here humbly and penitently confesses and condemns his former incredulity, with great profession of faith, hope, penitence, and love. By the word " Lord " he confesses Christ's human nature, by the word "God " His divine nature. " I," he would say, " because I believed not that thou wast God, did not believe that Thou hadst risen. But now I both believe that Thou art God, and that by the power of Thy Godhead Thou didst raise Thy Body to life again." So St. Hilary {Lib. vii. de Tri?iit.), and S. Ambrose {i?i Ps. xliii.), who also adds that the word " Lord " signifies that Christ is our Redeemer as having purchased us by His Blood, and thus becoming our Lord by the right of purchase and redemption. By these words, Suarez says that Thomas offered Christ the adoration of Latria. As S. Augustine said, " He saw and touched the man," &c. (see above on ver. 27). Consequently the fifth CEcumenical Council {in Constii.
John 20:28 · Open Word Bible
28Thomas answered Him, "My Lord and my God!"
Ver. 29. — Jesus saith unto him, Because thou hast seen Me (that is, touched and thus surely known), thou hast believed. Blessed are they who have ?wt seen, atid yet have believed. Because there " faith has greater merit, where human reason does not afford a test," says S. Gregory. He used the past tense, because many had already believed, but does not exclude the present and the future. They both are, and will be blessed, who believe in Me, without seeing. S. Augustine {in loc.) adds that they who will believe, did already believe in God's foreknowledge and predestination. But this remark is more subtle and acute than solid.
Hence S. Gregory {Hofn. xxvi.), S .Hilary {de Trinit. lib. xii.), and S. Augustine {in loc), say that Thomas saw one thing and believed another : he saw that Christ had risen, he believed that He was God, and consequently had raised Himself. By touching My human nature which has been raised (Christ would say) thou hast believed My Godhead which lay hid within, and which raised it up. For the resurrection of Christ had confirmed all His teachings, one of which was that He was the Messiah the Son of God, who would die on the cross for the salvation of men, and on the third day rise again. All which Thomas believed. Again, that which comes under our senses, which we see and touch, we can believe on divine authority, but for another formal reason. We see a thing because we behold it with our eyes, but we believe it because God has revealed it, especially if our senses can err, or if the matter involve anything which is not seen, as was the case with the resurrection of Christ, which was already past, for Thomas here doubted and was convinced of Christ's resurrection.
John 20:29 · Open Word Bible
29Jesus said to him, "Have you believed because you have seen Me? Blessed are those who have believed without having seen."
... Both through His whole life, and specially after His resurrection (say S. Chrysostom and Theophylact). These latter in the presence of the Apostles only, the others before all the people. Besides these signs which I have just recorded, others were wrought to confirm the truth of the resurrection. And these I have omitted (says S. John) for brevity's sake, and because many of them are recorded by the other evangelists. So S. Thomas, Lyranus, Cajetan, Ribera, Toletus, and others.
S. John seems here to finish his Gospel, as S. Augustine says. The next chapter relates to the mysteries of the Church, and the primacy of S. Peter, to show how rapidly the disciples multiplied, over whom S. Peter was placed as Vicar. Jansenius considers, most improbably, that S. John added some things here, which subsequently occurred to him. But it would seem that the Holy Spirit, and John too, added them for an express purpose, and not merely from memory.
John 20:30 · Open Word Bible
30Jesus did many other signs as well while the disciples looked on, signs that are not written down in this book.
... We must therefore believe — (i.) That He is the Saviour of the world. (2.) Tiie long-expected Messiah. (3.) That He is God the Son of God. (4.) That He will give eternal life to those who believe in, and obey Him. " For," as S. Gregory says, " He truly believes, who sets forth his belief in his life."
John 20:31 · Open Word Bible
31These, though, are written down so that you may believe Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and by believing have life in His name.