Logia

Cornelius a Lapide · The Great Commentary: S. John's Gospel

John 8

50 excerpts on John 8, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

John 8:2

And early in the morning

Ver. 2. — And early in the morning, &c. He gave the night to prayer, the day to teaching, setting an example to apostolic men, as S. Paul, S. Francis Xavier, and others.

Report a mistake

John 8:6

Ver. 6. — This they said, tempting Him, that they might have to accuse Him, as being opposed to the law, if He said that she was not to be stoned, but as cruel and harsh if He said otherwise. But they rather supposed He would not order her to be stoned, "in order to keep up His appearance of gentleness, and not to lose the favour of the people." So Rupertus, Bede, and S. Augustine, who says, "They saw that He was very gentle ; they said therefore among themselves, If He rules that she be let go. He will not observe that righteousness wliich the Law enjoins. But not to lose His (character for) gentleness, by which He has already won the love of the people, He will say that she ought to be released. And we shall hence find occasion to accuse Him. But the Lord in His answer both observed justice, and did not forego His gentleness." They thought to accuse Him of violating the law by her acquittal, and would say to Him, says S. Augustine, " Thou art an enemy of the law, thou judgest contrary to Moses, or rather against Him who gave the law. Thou art guilty of death, and must be stoned together with her.'

Report a mistake

John 8:7

When therefore they continued asking Him

Ver. 7. — When therefore they continued asking Him. Because they did not see clearly what He had written, or pretended they did not. They therefore urge Him to reply explicitly to their captious question, believing that He could not escape from the horns of a dilemma by going against the law if He acquitted the woman or against His own compassion, were He to condemn her.

He lifted up Himself and said, He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her. Ye Scribes and Pharisees have committed greater sins than this woman, as your conscience testifies ; do not therefore so rigidly and importunately urge her condemnation, but rather have pity for her, as sinners for a sinner, as guilty for a guilty one, as criminals for a criminal. For otherwise, if ye condemn her, ye ought to condemn yourselves ; if ye wish to stone 296 S. JOHN. C. Vlll.

Report a mistake

John 8:9

But on hearing this they went out one by one

Ver. 9. — But on hearing this they went out one by one. Some Greek copies add, " Convicted by their own conscience," as being adulterers, or even worse. For what Jesus said was true, and ought to strike home to them. And hence S. Augustine says {Epist. liv.), " Methinks that even the husband himself who had been wronged, would on hearing these words have shrunk back from his desire for punishment."

" Went out. " By their very withdrawal," says S. Augustine, " confessing that they were guilty of like offences. For they were smitten with a keen sense of justice on looking within, and finding themselves guilty." They feared also lest Christ should proceed still further to expose their crimes.

Beginning at the eldest. As being more inveterate sinners, like the false accusers of Susanna, or because they first felt the force of His words. As says S. Ambrose, " They first felt the strength of His answer, which they could not reply to, and being quicker of apprehension, they were the first to go away."

Report a mistake

John 8:10

... Lifting up on her His eyes of gentleness, as He had repulsed His adversaries with the words of righteousness, as saith S. Augustine. He spoke to her, (i.) to show that He had driven away her accusers, and that she :ould acknowledge what Jesus had, in His mercy, done for her, md ask pardon from Him of her sin. (2.)

Report a mistake

John 8:11

She said

Ver. II, — She said. No man, Lord, &c. I who am alone free from all sin, and appointed by God to judge the world, might most justly condemn thee. But I do not, because I came not to judge, but to save the world. Thus S. Ambrose ; " See how He moderated His answer, so that the Jews could not accuse him for acquitting her ; but rather throw it back on themselves, if they chose to complain. For she is dismissed, not absolved ; inasmuch as no one accused her, she was not acquitted as innocent. Why then should they complain who had already withdrawn from prosecuting the charge and from enforcing the punishment ? Moreover Christ by these words absolved the woman not only in open court before the people, but in the court of heaven, before God, as is plain from what He subjoins. Go, as being certain that I have forgiven thy adultery. As He said to the Magdalene, " Go in peace " {Luke vii, 50), But Christ says not that openly, but secretly ; lest the Pharisees should have something to carp at, Christ therefore inspired in her secret sorrow for her sins and an act of contrition, and then pardoned her sins, condoning her sin and its punishment together, " He condemns not," says S, Ambrose, " as being our Redemption, but reproves her as our life, and cleanses her as our fountain," And Euthymius, " Such an exposure and shame before so many adversaries was a sufficient punishment, more especially when He knew that she was heartily penitent." So Janscn and others.

Report a mistake

John 8:12

Ver. 12. — Then said Jesus again unto them, J ajn the Light of the world. The Gloss connects these words with what had immediately preceded, in this way : — " He adds what His Divinity could effect, in order that no one should doubt His power of forgiving sin." Marvel not that I set free the adulteress from the darkness of sin, for I am the uncreated Light of the world, i.e., God. ... But others refer back His words to verse 2, where His discourse had been broken off by the Scribes. Having put them to shame. He resumes His teaching. So S. Chrysostom and others. S. Chrysostom adds, " The Jews objected to Christ that He was a Galilean ; He shows that He was not merely one of the Prophets, but the Lord of heaven and earth."

lam the Light of the world ; and hence the Manicheans thought that He was the sun. And S. Augustine, being a Platonist, at one time had his doubts about it (see Eiichir. Iviii.) But commenting on this passage He mentions and confutes their folly. " Christ the Lord was not the sun which was made. He was its Maker, ' For all thifigs were made by Him,' &c. He therefore is the Light, which made this light of ours. Let us love It, let us long to understand It, let us thirst for It, that so at length we may attain to the Light Itself, and so live therein that we may never die. For He is the Light, of whom the Psalmist foretold, ' Thou shalt save both man and beast, so multifold is Thy mercy.' " And further on, *' By this Light was the light of the sun made, and the Light Tfhich made the sun (beneath which He made us also) was reside beneath the sun for our sakes. He, I say who made the sun. Despise not the veil {nubem) of His flesh. The sun is covered by a cloud, not to obscure, but to temper its rays. ...

John 8:12 · Open Word Bible

12Jesus spoke to them once more: "I am the light of the world. Those who follow Me will never walk in the darkness; they will have the light of life."

Report a mistake

John 8:13

Ver. 13. — The Pharisees therefot-e, &c. That is, is not worthy of credit. For no one is accepted as a witness in his own case, but must produce other witnesses (see above, v. 31).

These were not the same Pharisees as those who had accused the adulteress, but others, who wished to avenge the disgrace of their fellows, and in their malevolence against Christ, brought this charge against Him, to put Him to shame. " Being nurtured in ignorance," says S. Cyril, "and not knowing Him to be Emmanuel, they suspected Him of aiming at His own glory, and attack Him, as though one of ourselves."

John 8:13 · Open Word Bible

13The Pharisees then said to Him, "You are testifying on Your own behalf; Your testimony is not true."

Report a mistake

John 8:15

Ver. 15. — Ye judge after the ffesh. (i.) Ye judge of Me, not according to truth and equity, but from the carnal hatred ye have against Me ; as living according to the flesh is to live ill, so judging according to the flesh is to judge unjustly. (2.) From My Body, which ye see, ye count Me a mere man ; because I am in the flesh ye count Me mere flesh, judging wrongly. And thus ye rule that Truth can lie. For I am the Truth (S. Cyril).

(3.) Ye judge by your senses alone, by that which ye see of Me ; that I am a mean, poor, abject man, not the Messiah, not God who hides Himself in My flesh ; and therefore ye condemn Me as a proud blasphemer for asserting Myself to be the Son of God. And this ye would not do, if ye judged of Me by reason and the spirit of truth. For this would declare to you that I am what I assert, Messiah, the Son of God. "They saw the man," says S. Augustine, "but did not believe Him to be God." And the Gloss, "they thought Him to be a man, who was not to be believed when praising Himself." " Moreover," says S. Cyril, " He acts like a physician who heeds not the insults of his patients who are mad, but applies to them the fitting remedies ; fighting against disease, but not against the patient, whom he wishes to restore to health of body and mind."

John 8:15 · Open Word Bible

15You judge by human standards; I am not judging anyone.

Report a mistake

John 8:16

And yet if I judge (i

... S. Chrysostom explains, " If I judge, I should justly condemn you, because I should not judge by Myself, but I and the Father together." But the true meaning is that given in verse 15.

I and the Father that sent Me. " For I took the form of a servant, but lost not the form of God," says S. Augustine ; " Thy Incarnation was Thy mission." And the Interlinear Gloss, " Though I am a man, yet I left not the Father ; though sent in the flesh, yet I and the Father are ever One by Our Godhead ; the judgment of both and the will of both are alike One." As He says elsewhere, ** I do nothing of Myself," for I have never proceeded to any punishment, which was not in the mind of the Father. " For whatever thoughts the nature of the Father entertains, the same are completed in Me also, for I shine forth from His bosom, and am the true offspring of His substance," says S. Cyri!.

John 8:16 · Open Word Bible

16Yet even if I do judge, My judgment is true, because I am not alone in it: it is I together with the Father who sent Me.

Report a mistake

John 8:17

It is also written in your Law (Deut

Ver. 17. — It is also written in your Law (Deut. .xvii. 6, xix. 5), that the testimony oj two men is true: that is to be admitted by the judge, who can base on it a legal sentence, though the testimony may as a matter of fact be false. But a judge must go by the evidence ; and so his sentences may be legally right, but in reality wrong. If then the testimony of two men be true, how much more must the sentence of two Divine Persons, the Father and the Son, be accepted as most true, most equitable, and most just? Christ applies this to His own case. For that the Father is with Him, and witnesses to Him, and that He is the Son of the Father, He had more than sufficiently proved, and therefore assumes it. " It is," says

Augustine, "a grand and most mysterious question when God says ' in the mouth of two or three witnesses shall every word be established ; ' for Susanna was accused by two false witnesses, and all the people witnessed falsely against Christ. But in this way is the Trinity represented as in mystery ; for therein is the everenduring firmness of truth. If thou wishest to have a good cause, have three witnesses, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost."

John 8:17 · Open Word Bible

17Even in your own law it is written that the testimony of two people is true.

Report a mistake

John 8:18

/ am one that bear witness of Myself

Ver. 18. — I am one that bear witness of Myself, &c. But thou wilt say, no one's testimony is accepted in his own case, and therefore Christ's testimony to Himself ought not to be accepted. But the answer is, that Christ as God witnesses to Himself as man. But God and man are two beings, and in Christ God was different from man : in nature, I mean, not in person. And from this very passage the Fathers gather against both Nestorians and Eutycheans, THE father's witness.

that in Christ there was one Person, the Divine, but two natures, the Divine and the human. So Cyril, Chrysostom, and S. Ambrose {de Fide v. 2). Besides this, God the Father and God the Son bore witness that Jesus was the Christ by the miracles which they wrought both through Him and for Him (see chap. v. 31, 32). And especially when the Father spake in thunder out of heaven, This is My beloved Son. So Bede.

John 8:18 · Open Word Bible

18I am one who testifies about Myself, and the Father who sent Me also testifies about Me."

Report a mistake

John 8:19

Ver 19. — Then said they unto Him, Where is Thy Father? They said this, in order to elicit from Him a clear statement that God was His Father, in order to accuse Him of blasphemy, as they did, chap. V. 18, xix. 7. So Chrysostom and others.

But Cyril and Leontius less probably think that the Pharisees spoke contemptuously and sarcastically, as if He were the Son of some unknown father. S. Augustine and Bede think that they referred to Joseph, as being His father in the flesh. But the first is the best meaning.

Jesus answered, &c. Christ did not wish to answer clearly and directly, " My Father is in heaven," because He knew that the question was put in order to ensnare Him. He therefore, though answering their question directly, yet spoke so guardedly that the Pharisees could not bring any charge against Him. As if He said, Ye think that I am a man, and that I have only an earthly father. But ye are wrong, for ye know not that I am God as well as man. And therefore ye understand not that I have no other Father than God in heaven, though 1 hare proved this by so many miracles.

John 8:19 · Open Word Bible

19So they asked Him, "Where is Your father?" Jesus answered, "You do not know Me, and you do not know My Father either. If you knew Me, you would know My Father as well."

Report a mistake

John 8:20

... Rupertus thinks that the reason why no man laid hands on Him was because the treasury was a remote spot, frequented only by the Priests who wished to take money out, and the lay people who wished to pay it in. But it was in fact a public and muchfrequented place, being a large portico close to the court of the temple, and in it were preserved all the treasures of the temple. Christ then spake all these things openly and boldly in a place where He could easily have been taken. But He by His Divine power restrained their hands and their resolve, because the destined hour had not yet come. Adrichoniuus {Descript. Hieros. 103) describes the treasury as a chest wherein all requisites were kept foi the sacrifices, the support of the poor, repair of the temple, &c. ... It was afterwards plundered by the Romans. Here also the poor woman cast in her two mites. It was from this chest that the whole porch where it stood was called the treasury.

John 8:20 · Open Word Bible

20He spoke these words in the treasury area while He was teaching in the temple courts. Yet no one arrested Him, because His hour had not yet come.

Report a mistake

John 8:22

Then said the Jews

Ver, 22. — Then said the Jews, &c. '1 he officers made a wiser inquiry (vii. 35), Will He go to the dispersion of the Gentiles 1 But the Pharisees, blinded by their hatted, thought He had no way of escape but by killing Himself. Wherever He may go, we will follow Him up. If He goes to the Gentiles, we will drag Him back. He must therefore mean that He will kill Himself, so as to escape our hands. A presumptuous and foolish thought, suggested, however, by their malice. He might have withdrawn Himself from them in various ways, as He had already done. But He meant that He would go up to heaven, whither the Pharisees could not come. But His words, says S. Augustine, referred not to His going to death, but to where He was going afterwards.

John 8:22 · Open Word Bible

22At this the Jewish leaders said, "Surely He is not going to kill Himself? Is that why He says, 'You cannot come where I am going'?"

Report a mistake

John 8:23

And (therefore) He said unto them

Ver. 23. — And (therefore) He said unto them, &c. Ye cleave to your sins and will go to the lowest depth, while I shall return to heaven, and therefore ye will seek Me and will not find Me. For I am like the soaring eagle, dwelling in the loftiest mountains of eternity, while ye are as worms and insects creeping on the earth. So Rupertus and S. Augustine, who says, " Ye are from beneath ; ye savour of the earth ; serpent-like, ye eat the earth. But what is meant by eating the earth ? Ye feed on things of earth, ye delight in things of earth, are greedy for things of earth, ye lift not up your hearts above."

S. Chrysostom and others, and S. Augustine and Bede among the Latins, think that the Pharisees misunderstood the words of Christ by reason of their earthly minds. Morally : — Ye are from beneath, as descended from Adam, and deriving from him your earthly desires, and inflamed by evil passions, thus hankering only after worldly things. ... And therefore My feelings. My love, My desires are all heavenly. And to these ye cannot attain, unless ye are born again; and thus from earthly become heavenly and spiritual, as I said to Nicodemus.

John 8:23 · Open Word Bible

23He went on to say to them, "You come from below; I come from above. You are from this world; I am not from this world.

Report a mistake

John 8:24

I said therefore unto you, that ye shall die in your sins

Ver. 24. — I said therefore unto you, that ye shall die in your sins. The sin of unbelief, and all your other sins, for there is no forgiveness of sin, save through faith in Christ, whom ye reject.

For if ye believe not that J am the Saviour of the world, as I constantly affirm and prove also by so many miracles. So Lyra.

But S. Augustine, Bede, and Toletus more ingeniously : " Because I am that I am ; i.e., God. But Rupertus thus subtilly : " Because I am from above." Ye shall die in your sins, because there is no one but Myself, whom ye despise, who can pardon and take away sin.

John 8:24 · Open Word Bible

24That is why I told you that you will die in your sins. For unless you believe that I am, you will die in your sins."

Report a mistake

John 8:25

Ver. 25. — They said therefore to Him, Who art Thou? Because they did not understand, or pretended they did not, they appositely ask, Who art Thou ?

Jesus said to them, the Beginning (Vulg.), I who am speaking to you. S. Augustine, Bede, Rupertus, and S. Ambrose {De Fide, iii. 4), consider the word, the Beginning, to be in the nominative case, explaining it, I am the Beginning, the First and the Last, or the Beginning of all things, for all things were made by the Word of God.

S. Augustine and S. Ambrose explain it (2.) by supplying the word " credite," which is not in the text. ... I am from the beginning, i.e., from eternity {before Abraham, as He said Himself, verse 58), Very God of Very God. And therefore I am the beginning of time, and age, and of all things. And yet I am speaking to you ; that is, it is I who announce this to you, for I assumed flesh, and was made man in order to announce it, and save those who believe in it. I am from the beginning, which very thing I solemnly declare to you. Or rather, since I am the Word, which the Father spake from all eternity, I having been made man to announce to you the same truth. For the Son is the Word by whom the Father speaks, and the Son is also the Word which speaks to us. The word "beginning," therefore, is more appropriate to the Son than to the Holy Spirit, for the Son is together with the Father the source {principium) of the Holy Spirit, but the Holy Spirit is not the source of any other Divine Person, but only of creatures ; and further, because He is the beginning {principiutn) proceeding from the beginning, that is to say, from the Father. And accordingly this word signifies His origin, as being begotten of the Father. This is clear from what is said below, verse 27.

John 8:25 · Open Word Bible

25So they asked Him, "Just who are You?" Jesus said to them, "Why am I even talking to you at all?

Report a mistake

John 8:26

/ have many things

Ver. 26. — I have many things, &c. I have many things to say against you, and to accuse you of. And in the day of judgment I will do so. As S. Cyril says, "I will accuse you not of one thing but of many, and of nothing falsely. For I can condemn you as unbelieving, as arrogant, as insulting, as opposers of God, as impudent, as ungrateful, as malignant, as lovers of pleasure rather than lovers of God, as courting the praise of men, and not seeking the glory of God."

But He that sent Me, &c. I will omit many points and will merely say this, in refutation of your unbelief, that the Father who hath sent Me is true, and whatever therefore I say is true, and worthy of belief by all. "I am true" (says S. Augustine) "in judgment, because I am the Son of Truth, and the Truth Itself" But others explain differently, (i.) Toletus : "I have many things to say against you. But I will not do so now, for the Father sent Me into the world, not to judge but to save it, and therefore, in obedience to Him, I say only those things which concern its salvation." (2.) ... (3.) Rupertus refers it to what He had said before, that He was the Beginning, " These are not My own words, but what the Father bade Me say of Myself." (4.) Ye do not believe in Me as the Messiah, but this is what the Father wishes Me to proclaim. (5.) Ye do not believe Me now, but My Father is true. He will fulfil His own word that I shall be your judge, and reward you according to your deeds. But the first meaning is the best. Which I have heard of Him, both as God and as man. The Interlinear Gloss says, "To hear from Him, is the same as though being from Him." " The co-equal Son gives glory to the Father, why then dost thou set thyself against Him, being only His servant?" So S. Augustine.

John 8:26 · Open Word Bible

26I have much to say about you, and much to judge. But the one who sent Me is true, and I tell the world what I have heard from Him."

Report a mistake

John 8:27

They knew not

Ver. 27. — They knew not, &c. For Jesus spake covertly and obscurely, for fear of exciting the hatred of the Pharisees. But some of the more acute of them began to suspect the true meaning of His words, though they did not clear'.v understand them, and could not refute Him. None of them fully knew it. And God so ordered it, that the Passion of Christ, and the consequent redemption of the world, might not be hindered. (See i Cor. ii. 8.) " I withhold the knowledge of Myself," says S. Augustine, " that My Passion may be effected " by your hands.

John 8:27 · Open Word Bible

27They did not understand that He was speaking to them about the Father.

Report a mistake

John 8:28

Then said Jesus

Ver. 28. — Then said Jesus, &c. When ye have lifted Me up on the Cross. He calls it His exaltation, for though it seemed to be His greatest degradation and disgrace, yet it was made to be, by God's Providence, His greatest exaltation and glory, that all nations should adore Christ crucified, and hope for pardon from Him. For this Christ won for Himself by His great humility (see Phil. ii. 8 seq.) And thus does God deal with every follower of Christ who humbles himself for Christ's sake, as He says, " Every one that exalteth himself shall be humbled," &c.

Then shall you know that I am Messiah, the Son of God, whom I declare Myself to be, and not a mere man, as ye now think Me. For many of the Jews, when they saw in the Cross, Death, and Resurrection of Jesus Christ, such patience, charity, zeal, and such great prodigies and miracles, were moved with compunction to believe in Him. Christ had obtained all this by His Cross, and obtained it from His Father (see Acts ii. 41). As S. Augustine says, " He saw that many would believe after His Passion. And this He says that no one who is conscious of guilt should despair, when even His own murder was condoned." See S. Cyril, and others.

John 8:28 · Open Word Bible

28So Jesus said, "When you have lifted up the Son of Man, then you will know that I am, and that I do nothing on My own, but I say these things just as the Father taught Me.

Report a mistake

John 8:29

And He that sent Me is with Me

Ver. 29. — And He that sent Me is with Me. He adds this (says S. Chrysostom) lest He should be accounted inferior to the Father who taught Him. The one relates to the Incarnation {dispensationem), the other to the Godhead. "The Father," says S. Augustine, "sent the Son, but did not leave Him." Moreover, the Father is ever with the Son, not only by the inseparable essence of Deity, which continues ever in number the same, but also by the special providence and guidance vouchsafed to the manhood which He assumed, the Godhead guiding and directing it in every work, to make all His work perfect and divine.

John 8:29 · Open Word Bible

29The one who sent Me is with Me. He has not left Me alone, because at all times I do what is pleasing to Him."

Report a mistake

John 8:30

As He spake these words many

Ver. 30. — As He spake these words many, &c. ; i.e., many of the simple-minded, candid and teachable people, but few or none of the proud Pharisees. And they believed, not only as convinced by the force of His arguments, but charmed by the grace and power of His words. "Never man spake like this man."

John 8:30 · Open Word Bible

30While He was saying this, many people came to believe in Him.

Report a mistake

John 8:31

Then said Jesus

Ver. 31. — Then said Jesus, &c. He wished to confirm them in the faith they had accepted. If ye are so faithful and constant as to follow Me through persecutions and crosses, even to heaven itself, ye will be worthy not only of the name and title of My disciples, but also of their deserts and reward.

John 8:31 · Open Word Bible

31Then Jesus said to the Jews who had believed Him, "If you remain in My word, you really are My disciples.

Report a mistake

John 8:32

And ye shall know the truth

Ver. 32. — And ye shall know the truth, &c. The Greek Fathers understand by the Truth, Christ Himself; meaning ye shall know Me to be the Truth, shadowed forth by the figures of the old Law, from which I will set you free, that ye may serve God not with bodily ceremonies, but in the Spirit and truth of faith, hope, and charity (see above, iv. 23).

(2.) Hence, in accordance with the mind of Christ, If ye abide in My doctrine, ye shall taste by experience how sweet it is, and it will free you from the yoke of sin (see below, verse 34). For faith in Me will lead you to penitence, contrition, and charity, which does away with all sin. " If the Truth pleaseth thee not, let liberty please thee." He clearly restored liberty, and took away iniquity.

Analogically: My doctrine will deliver you from the corruption of this place of mortality, change, and exile, because it will bring you to the liberty of a blessed immortality, and the glory of the children of God. Thus S. Augustine on this passage: "What doth He promise to those who believe ? Ye shall know the truth. But did they not know it, when the Lord spake? for if they knew it not, how did they believe ? ... But the truth is, to see that which thou hast believed." There is a fourfold bondage which Christ did away with, and a fourfold liberty which He bestowed, (i.) The bondage of the Law which Christ did away with by the liberty of the Gospel. (2.) Bondage under sin, which He took away by the liberty of righteousness. (3.) Bondage under the dominion of concupiscence, which He took away by the liberty of the Spirit, and the dominion of charity and grace. (4.) Bondage under death and mortality, which He will take away by the liberty and glory of the resurrection.

John 8:32 · Open Word Bible

32You will know the truth, and the truth will free you."

Report a mistake

John 8:33

They answered Him

Ver. 33. — They answered Him, &c. Christ in what He had said indirectly charged the Jews with ignorance and bondage. But as glorying in their descent from Abraham, they felt wounded; and putting aside the charge of ignorance, they proudly deny the charge of bondage, and say that they had no need of the liberty of Christ. We are slaves neither by birth, nor by condition. " And in like manner," says S. Chrysostom, " men when charged with impurity and wickedness put it aside, but when their family and work are impugned, they start up, as if they were mad." But the Jews did not understand Christ, for He spake not of civil, but of spiritual bondage, and that He would set them free from the bondage of sin by the liberty of grace. But did the Jews say truly that they were never in bondage to any man ? S. Chrysostom and others say that they spoke too boastfully, but that they veiled their falsehood, because though often conquered they had never been sold as slaves.

John 8:33 · Open Word Bible

33They answered Him, "We are descended from Abraham, and we have never been slaves to anybody. What do You mean, 'You will become free'?"

Report a mistake

John 8:34

Verily, verily

Ver. 34. — Verily, verily, &c. Most assured, i.e., the saying is, and specially commended to their notice. But our Lord speaks to them modestly and becomingly, using only general terms and the third person. He might have said, Ye commit many sins, and are therefore the servants of sin, and from this bondage no one but Myself can deliver you. " A miserable bondage," exclaims S. Augustine in loc, and adds the reason. "A man slave, when worn out by his master's cruel treatment, can at length escape and be at rest. But whither can the servant of sin flee ? He carries with him himself, whithersoever he flies. A wicked conscience cannot fly from itself; it has no place to go to, it follows itself. It cannot withdraw from itself; for the sin which causes it is within." (2.) S. Peter (11. ii. 19) gives a further reason. "Of whom a man is overcome, of the same is he brought in bondage." (3.) He who committeth sin is the servant of the devil, who instigates to sin, and he is a cruel tyrant, who drives on sinners, as though they were his slaves, ever drawing them on from one sin to another, and in the end to hell. (4.) Every sin leaves behind it a desire and inclination to repeat the sin, and this concupiscence remains, even after the sin has been given up, for our punishment and temptation. Whence the Apostle says that he was sold under sin, that he did what he would not (ns feeling against his will the motives of concupiscence), and that he cannot do the things he would. (5.) Because the sinner is bound by the chains of the sin he "nas committed, so that he cannot free himself, unless Christ sets him free by His grace, according to the saying (Prov. v. 22), "His own iniquities take the wicked himself, and he is bound with the cords of his sins."

John 8:34 · Open Word Bible

34Jesus answered, "Truly, truly, I tell you, everyone who goes on sinning is a slave of sin.

Report a mistake

John 8:35

The servant abideth not

Ver. 35. — The servant abideth not, &c. He who is the servant of sin, like you Jews, has not the right of remaining in his Master's house (that is the Church of God) for ever : for after death he will be cast into the outer darkness of hell, as ye too will be cast out. But the Son abideth for ever in His Father's house, that is, I ever abide with My Father in heaven. But if through Me and My grace ye have been delivered from the bondage of sin, ye will abide for ever with Me, as adopted children, in the house of God, that is in the Church militant by grace, and in the Church triumphant, for ever happy and glorious in heaven. So S. Augustine, Bede, and others.

John 8:35 · Open Word Bible

35A slave does not remain in the household for good; a son remains for good.

Report a mistake

John 8:36

If therefore the Son

Ver. 36. — If therefore the Son, &c. I alone can make you free, not Abraham or Moses, though most beloved servants of God. So S. Chrysostom and others.

John 8:36 · Open Word Bible

36So if the Son frees you, you will be truly free.

Report a mistake

John 8:37

I know

Ver. 37. — I know, &c. By nature ye are Abraham's children, but in your deeds ye are degenerate. Your descent from Abraham will not therefore profit you. It will increase your damnation, for he will say at the last day, I acknowledge you not as my children, for ye have crucified Christ, my son and your brother.

Because My word, &c. Because ye will not take it in. Origen and S. Chrysostom think that these words were said to those who had before feebly believed in Christ, but who, on hearing themselves called "servants," were incensed against Him and wished to kill Him. But it is more probable that they were addressed to unbelievers who had before that plotted His death.

John 8:37 · Open Word Bible

37I know that you are descended from Abraham. Yet you are trying to kill Me, because My word is making no headway in you.

Report a mistake

John 8:38

I speak

Ver. 38. — I speak, &c. Ye not only speak, but do that which ye have learnt from your father, the devil, especially in seeking to kill Me, implying that Abraham was not tlieir father. See this more clearly declared verse 44.

John 8:38 · Open Word Bible

38I speak of what I have seen in the Father's presence, and you, in the same way, do what you have heard from the father."

Report a mistake

John 8:39

They answered

Ver. 39. — They answered, &c. Because Christ seemed to imply that they had another father, they wished to learn from Him who he was. We own Abraham, and none other as our father.

Jesus saith unto them. If ye are the children of Abraham, do the works of Abrahatn. It is so in the Vulgate. But some Greek MSS. read as in the English version. He does not deny their extraction, but condemns their doings. Says S. Augustine, "Your flesh may be from Abraham, but not so your life."

John 8:39 · Open Word Bible

39They replied, "Abraham is our father." Jesus said to them, "If you are Abraham's children, then you would be doing what Abraham did.

Report a mistake

John 8:40

But now ye seek

Ver. 40. — But now ye seek, &c. Abraham did not injure any one, but saved Lot, and as many as he could. But the Jews were eager to kill Christ. The Jews {Ferke. Avoth. cap. v.) draw the same contrast between a disciple of Abraham and of Balaam.

John 8:40 · Open Word Bible

40But now you are trying to kill Me, a man who has spoken to you the truth I heard from God. That is not what Abraham did.

Report a mistake

John 8:41

Ye do the works of your father

Ver. 41. — Ye do the works of your father. He persists in saying that they were not Abraham's children, but does not say whose children they were.

An atrocious statement, which the Pharisees studiously propagated, to detract from our Lord's credit and authority. But it would have been atrocious blasphemy. (2.) Euthymius and Rupertus suppose it to be only an assertion of their descent from Sarah, and not from Hagar, and thus not spurious, or in a secondary rank. (3.) We are not born of spiritual fornication, i.e.., idolatry. We are not Hagarenes, who were idolaters. Rupertus objects that to make out this meaning the word "but" should have been inserted. But Maldonatus maintains that such particles are often omitted, adding that fornication in the prophets means idolatry, as being spiritual fornication, drawing away the soul from its true Spouse (see Hos. i. 2). Theophylact explains it to mean, " VVe are not born of mixed marriages of Jews and Gentiles, which were forbidden, and counted illegitimate by the Jews." (4.) The Jews reply in a straightforward manner, Abraham is our true earthly father ; and one is our Father, even God in heaven. Your charge is therefore false. You unjustly claim the God of Abraham for thyself alone, and exclude us from sonship with Him, and hand us over to another father, the devil, making us spurious, and consequently infamous.

John 8:41 · Open Word Bible

41You are doing the works of your own father." They said to Him, "We were not born out of sexual sin. We have one Father: God."

Report a mistake

John 8:43

Why do ye not understand

Ver. 43. — Why do ye not understand, &c. Because cleaving to your pride, avarice, hatred, and enmity against Me, ye will not hear Me and understand. "They could not hear," says S. Augustine, " because they refused to be corrected by what they heard ; " but (as says the Gloss) ye are of the devil, and have elected to go on with him. ... (See Matt. xix. 12.) But secondly, and more properly and forcibly, " Ye do not understand My words because ye cannot endure My teaching, and will not let My words enter your ears, so hateful arn I to you, and so obstinately have you from hatred hardened your hearts against Me." Thus Emmanuel Sa.

John 8:43 · Open Word Bible

43Why do you not understand what I am saying? It is because you cannot bear to listen to My word.

Report a mistake

John 8:44

Ye are of your father the devil

Ver. 44. — Ye are of your father the devil. "Not by descent but by imitation," says S. Augustine, quoting Ezek. xvi. 4; and adding, " The Jews, by imitating their impieties, found for themselves parents, not of whom to be born, but with whom they would be lost, by following their evil ways."

S. Epiphanius {Her. 38, 40) by the devil in this place understands Judas Iscariot, whom our Lord also calls a devil. ... Augustine) understands Cain. But it is certain that it must be taken literally to mean Lucifer. For the Jews in persecuting Jesus followed him as their father; "not by succession in the flesh, but in sin," says S. Ambrose {Lib. iv. in loc.)

He explains that they are of the devil, by following his suggestion. S. Chrysostom says he speaks not of " works," but of desires (or lusts), showing that both he and they greatly delighted in murders. For the devil has an ardent desire to destroy all men, both because he grudges them the glory from which he himself fell, but also to injure God, whom he hates as his torturer, and wishes to tear away men from Him whom He created in His own image, and called and predestinated to His own eternal grace and glory.

John 8:44 · Open Word Bible

44Your father is the devil, and you choose to do what your father wants. He was a murderer from the beginning, and he never stood in the truth, because there is no truth in him. Whenever he tells a lie, he is speaking from what is his own, because he is a liar and the father of lies.

Report a mistake

John 8:46

Which of you

Ver. 46. — Which of you, &c. This is to anticipate an objection of the Jews. For they might say, "We do not believe thee, because thou art a violater of our law, in healing the sick on the Sabbath-day."

Produce any other charge against Me, and I will submit to your disbelieving Me. My healing on the Sabbath was not a violation, but a sanctification of the Sabbath. I leave any further charge to be decided by you who are my sworn enemies. So confident was Christ in His innocence that no one could lay anything to His charge which bore the slightest resemblance to sin. For He was Himself sinless, both on account of the Beatific Vision which He enjoyed, as the Blessed in heaven are incapable of sin for the same reason (for seeing God to be the Supreme Good, they necessarily love Him with all their strength, and hate whatever displeases Him) and likewise from the hypostatical union with the Word. For because His humanity existed in the Person of the Word, the Word kept His humanity free from all sin, and in perfect holiness. For if the humanity of Christ had sinned, the Person of the Word would have sinned ; which is impossible. For virtuous or vicious actions relate to persons, and are attributed to them. Hence S. Ambrose (on Ps. xl. 13) brings in God the Father thus addressing Christ, "Thou wert conversant with sinners, Thou didst take on Thee the sins of all. Thou wast made sin for all, but yet no practice of sin could reach Thee. Thou didst dwell among men, as if among angels, Thou madest earth to be like heaven, that even there also Thou mightest take away sin."

John 8:46 · Open Word Bible

46Which of you can prove that I have sinned? If it is the truth I speak, why do you not believe Me?

Report a mistake

John 8:47

He that is of God

Ver. 47. — He that is of God, &c. He here assigns the true reason for the unbelief of the Jews, because they were born not of God, but of the devil ; that is, ye do not listen to the spirit and instinct of 326 s. JOHN, c. vm.

God, but of the devil. For the devil has blinded your hearts with covetousness, hatred, and envy of Me. And ye therefore listen not to the words of God which I, who am sent from Him, announce to you, because ye will not hear and understand them. Because then ye are not the children of God who is true, but of the devil who is a liar, ye listen to his lying suggestions, but will not give a hearing to the true words of God which are uttered by Me,

He who is predestinated and elected hears the words of God, ye hear them not because ye are reprobate. But this is not the literal and genuine sense of the word, but merely an adapted one. For as Toletus and Maldonatus observe, many of those who at that time did not believe in Christ afterwards believed at the preaching of S. Peter and the Apostles ; and on the other hand, some who then believed in Christ afterwards fell away from the faith, and became reprobates (see John vi. 67).

John 8:47 · Open Word Bible

47Anyone who comes from God listens to God's words. You do not listen, and this is why: you are not from God."

Report a mistake

John 8:48

The Jews answered arid said

Ver. 48. — The Jews answered arid said, &c. They used to say it, though it is written nowhere else. But why did they call Him a Samaritan? (i.) Because He associated with the Samaritans. (2.) Because He came from Galilee, which was near Samaria. (3.) Because the Samaritans were partly Jews and partly Gentiles, and Christ seemed to them to be the same, as bringing in a new faith and religion ; and He thus seemed to be mixing up the traditions of the elders with the Gospel. (4.) And lastly, because He seemed to be making a schism, like the Samaritans. A Samaritan was, moreover, a term of reproach.

And hast a devil, (i.) Because they said He cast out devils through Beelzebub, the chief of the devils. (2.) Because He made Himself God, transferring to Himself the glory due to God, as Lucifer strove to do. So Leontius. Our Lord so understood it, and answered, " I seek not My own glory." (3.) Thou art mad, Hke lunatics, and those possessed with devils (see x. 20, and vii. 20). This was an atrocious blasphemy. How wondrous, then, the patience of Christ ! For He answered,

John 8:48 · Open Word Bible

48The Jews who were arguing with Him answered, "Are we not right to say that You are a Samaritan and have a demon?"

Report a mistake

John 8:49

I have not a devil

Ver. 49. — I have not a devil, &c. As loving truth He denies the false charge, but though all-powerful He returns not their reproach, " God, though receiving an injury, replies not with words of contumely ; and thou, when insulted by thy neighbours, shouldest abstain from their evil words, lest the exercise of just reproof should be turned into weapons of anger." And Chrysostom, "When it was necessary to teach, and to inveigh against their pride. He was severe. But in bearing with those who reproached Him, He exercised great gentleness, to teach us to resent any wrongs done to God, to overlook the wrongs done to ourselves." And S. Augustine, "Let us imitate His patience, that we may attain to His powers."

Christ took no notice of the term Samaritan, because it was a reproach directed only against Himself, and not against God. He refused therefore to avenge His own wrongs, but would defend the honour of God. All knew He was a Galilean, and not a Samaritan, and by saying that He had not a devil. He refuted at the same time the charge of being a Samaritan. For the Samaritans, as schismatics, were the bond slaves of the devil. S. Gregory {Horn, xviii.) gives a mystical reason for His silence. " A Samaritan," he says, "means a guardian, and He is truly our guardian, of whom the Psalmist speaks, ' Except the Lord keep the city, they watch in vain who guard it ' (Ps. cxxvii. 2) ; to whom moreover it is said by Isaiah, ' Watchman, what of the night? ' He would not therefore say, ' I am not a Samaritan,' lest he should deny also that He was our guardian."

John 8:49 · Open Word Bible

49Jesus answered, "I do not have a demon. Rather, I honor My Father, and you dishonor Me.

Report a mistake

John 8:50

/ seek tiot

Ver. 50. — I seek tiot, &c. It is God the Father who will most sharply punish those who seek not My glory, but in every way dishonour and discredit Me. S. Chrysostom.

But there Christ speaks of the public and general judgment, here He speaks of the private and daily judgment with which He avenges the wrongs done to His Son and His saints, as by the destruction of Jerusalem by Titus for the death of Christ ; as He here seems to hint. So Maldonatus and others.

But the Gloss says, " There is one that judgeth who distinguishes My glory from yours ; as David says, ' Judge Me, O God, and distinguish My cause from that of the ungodly people ' " (Ps. xliii. i, Vulg.)

John 8:50 · Open Word Bible

50But I do not seek My own glory. There is one who seeks it, and He judges.

Report a mistake

John 8:51

Verily, verily, I say

Ver. 51. — Verily, verily, I say. He says this not from indignation but from pity of the Jews, showing that He is seeking not His own glory, but their salvation. " I say in very truth," and as S. Augustine thinks, he means I swear, "that if ye keep My commandments ye shall never die the death of the soul ; ye shall never sin, for sin is the death of the soul. But ye shall ever live, here in the grace of God, and in heaven in His glory. Ye shall die indeed in the body, but I will raise you up in the day of judgment, and ye shall live in happiness of body and spirit for all eternity." So S. Augustine,

John 8:51 · Open Word Bible

51Truly, truly, I tell you, if anyone keeps My word, they will never see death."

Report a mistake

John 8:52

Now we know

Ver. 52. — Now we know, &c. "The devil suggests to Thee such proud and absurd boasting, that Thy word will drive away death from those who believe in Thee, when we see that Prophets and holy men, as Abraham, all died. But as says S. Gregory (Horn, xviii.), looking only to the death of the body, they were dark to the word of truth. For as Bade saith, " Abraham, though dead in the body, was alive in his soul." Learn from this, thou Religious, thou Preacher, thou Christian, from thy Master to receive calumnies for thy good deeds, curses and ill-will for thy kindnesses. Learn also to be good to the ungrateful. For Christ, though unweariedly teaching the Jews, healing them, delivering them from evil spirits, yet patiently endured these contumelies and reproaches, ingratitude in return for kindnesses, blasphemies for miracles, and for His teaching derision and reprehension, and yet did not cease to benefit those who were ungrateful, the very highest point of patience and charity.

John 8:52 · Open Word Bible

52The Jews there said to Him, "Now we are sure that You have a demon. Abraham died, and so did the prophets, yet You say, 'If anyone keeps My word, they will never taste death.'

Report a mistake

John 8:53

Art thou greater 1

Ver. 53. — Art thou greater 1 &c. They considered it most absurd, and even blasphemous, for Christ to prefer Himself to Abraham, as He really did ; for He was both God and man, though the Jews knew it not, or rather refused to believe it,

John 8:53 · Open Word Bible

53Surely You are not greater than our father Abraham? He died. The prophets died too! Who do You think You are?"

Report a mistake

John 8:54

Jesus answered

Ver. 54. — -Jesus answered, &c. This was in answer to their question, Whom makest thou Thyself 1 He refers all His glory to His Father from whom He is, and who is God. What I say of Myself is of no value or weight, and that not only with you, as S. Chrysostom says, but with others. For in every court no one is believed on his own word but on the testimony of others, who witness for him (see chap. v. 31). Solomon also says, "Let another praise thee, and not thine own lips " (Prov. xxvii. 2). The Arians objected that the Father glorifies the Son. He is therefore greater than the Son. S. Augustine replies, " Thou heretic, readest thou not that the Son Himself said that He glorifies His Father? But He also glorifies the Son, and the Son glorifies the Father. Put aside thy pernicious teaching, acknowledge their equality, correct thy perversity."

John 8:54 · Open Word Bible

54Jesus answered, "If I glorify Myself, My glory means nothing. The one who glorifies Me is My Father, the one of whom you say, 'He is our God.'

Report a mistake

John 8:55

Yet ye have not known Him

Ver. 55. — Yet ye have not known Him, &c. (i.) Ye know not the true God whom ye worship ; ye know Him not to be one in essence and threefold in person, for ye think Him to be one in Person, as He is one in essence. Ye know not that God is a Father, and that He begat Me His Son, and that we two by our Breath produced the Holy Ghost. For had ye known it, ye would certainly have known and believed Me to be the Messiah, the Son of God ; and conversely, " if ye had known Me, ye would assuredly have known My Father," says S. Ciirysostom.

(2.) S. Augustine says. Ye believe that there is one God, though ye neither see nor hear Him (see chap. v. 37). Ye ought therefore equally to believe in Me His Son, on account of the many signs and wonders which I work, though ye see not the Godhead which is hid within. (3.) Ye have not known Him, ye have not believed His testimony. This is My behnn-d Son : for ye knew not, or rather would not know, that this was the true voice of God. (4.) Euthymius explains, "Ye have not shown that ye know Him, because ye live wickedly, not as worshippers of God, but like idolatrous Gentiles, professing, as S. Paul says, to know Him (Tit. i. 16), but in works denying Him."

John 8:55 · Open Word Bible

55You have never known Him, but I know Him. If I said that I did not know Him, I would be a liar like you. But I do know Him, and I keep His word.

Report a mistake

John 8:56

Ver. 56. — Your father Abrahatn, &c. He longed for it with exulting mind ; " He feared not, but exulted," says S. Augustine. " Believing he exulted with hope, that he might see by understanding." It is a catachresis. But what day? S. Augustine understands by it, that day of ail eternity, wherein from all eternity the Son was begotten of the Father. " He wished to know My eternal generation and My Godhead, that he might believe in it, and be thereby saved." " He saw," says S. Augustine, " My day, because he acknowledged the mystery of the Trinity." (Bede follows him, as usual.)

(i.) But others generally refer it to the day of His Humanity, and thus understand it of the day of His Passion, Crucifixion, and death. See S. Chrysostom, &c. (2.) It is more simple to understand it of the day of His Incarnation. ... "To see" (says John Alba) " is to enjoy the happiness and blessings brought by Christ." The word has often that meaning, as in the Psalm "to see the goodness of the Lord in the land of the living," i.e., to enjoy it

John 8:56 · Open Word Bible

56Your father Abraham was full of joy at the hope of seeing My day. He saw it, and it made him glad."

Report a mistake

John 8:57

Thou art not yet

Ver. 57. — Thou art not yet, &c. So that Abraham on his part could have seen Thee, and rejoiced at the sight. Irenseus hence infers that Christ lived fifty years on earth {adv. Hcer, ii. 39, 40). But it is the common opinion that He was on earth for only thirtyfour (and those not complete) years. S. Chrysostom and Euthymius read forty years, but the common reading is fifty. The Jews seem to have been thinking of the Jubilee. " Thou hast not reached one Jubilee, how then canst Thou say that Thou hast seen Abraham, who lived forty Jubilees before ? " (So Severus of Antioch in Catena.) But Euthymius thinks that Christ seemed to the Jews, by reason of the maturity of His judgment and the gravity of His bearing, and also from the labours He had undergone in journeying and preaching, to be fifty years old. But you may easily say that the Jews, in order to avoid exception or mistake, put His age much higher than they knew He had attained to.

John 8:57 · Open Word Bible

57So the Jews there said to Him, "You are not even fifty years old, and You have seen Abraham?"

Report a mistake

John 8:58

... The word am denotes eternity, which is ever present, and has no past or future. I am eternal, immutable, and ever the same. So S. Augustine, Bede, S. Gregory. I as God exceed the age of Abraham not by fifty years, but by infinite durations of years. For as Tertullian {de Trinit) says, unless He had been God, He could not, as being descended from Abraham, have been before him. ... He said not, 'Before Abraham was, I am,' but Before Abraham was made, lam. Nor did He say, 'Before Abraham was made, I was made.' For in the beginning God made heaven and earth; for in the beginning was the Word. Before Abraham was viade, I am. Acknowledge the Creator, distinguish the creature. He who spake was made of the seed of Abraham ; and in order that Abraham might be made. He was (existed) before Abraham."

John 8:58 · Open Word Bible

58Jesus said to them, "Truly, truly, I tell you, before Abraham was, I am."

Report a mistake

John 8:59

Ver. 59. — Theti they took up, &c., as a blasphemer, who placed Himself above Abraham, and made Himself equal to God. Blasphemers were ordered to be stoned (Lev. xxiv. 16). It is clear that these Jews were not those who were said to have believed in Him (as Theophylact supposes), but the others who were opposed to Christ. ... "They sought to crush Him, whom they could not understand," says S. Gregory {Horn, xviii.)

But Jesus hid Himself, &c. He made Himself invisible, and thus passed unharmed through the midst of them. So Leontius and others. S. Gregory says, " Had He willed to exercise His power. He would have bound them in their sins, or would have plunged them into the pains of eternal death. But He who came to suffer, would not exercise judgment." And S. Augustine, " He would rather commend to us His patience, than exercise His power. He forsakes them, since they would not accept His correction. He hides not Himself in a corner of the temple, as if afraid, or running into a cottage, or turning aside behind a wall or column : but by His Divine Power making Himself invisible, He passed through their midst. As man He fled from the stones, but woe to them from whose stony hearts God flies away.

John 8:59 · Open Word Bible

59At this they picked up stones to throw at Him, but Jesus hid Himself and went out of the temple courts.

Report a mistake