Logia

Ecclesiastes · Chapter 11 · Send your bread on the waters

Ecclesiastes 11:5

Just as you do not know the path of the breath of life into the bones in a pregnant woman's womb, so you do not know the work of God, who makes all things.

כַּאֲשֶׁ֨ר אֵֽינְךָ֤ יוֹדֵ֨עַ֙ מַה־דֶּ֣רֶךְ הָר֔וּחַ כַּעֲצָמִ֖ים בְּבֶ֣טֶן הַמְּלֵאָ֑ה כָּ֗כָה לֹ֤א תֵדַע֙ אֶת־מַעֲשֵׂ֣ה הָֽאֱלֹהִ֔ים אֲשֶׁ֥ר יַעֲשֶׂ֖ה אֶת־הַכֹּֽל׃ Word by word ↓

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

3 commentators in Logia comment on Ecclesiastes 11:5, from Matthew Henry (1662–1714) to A. R. Fausset (1821–1910): Henry, Bridges and Fausset.

Two voices on Ecclesiastes 11:5

Choose two:

What the church has said

See all 3 voices as a grid

Eras across, traditions down, each with its first words. An empty cell is a place the library has no voice yet.

Puritans and the 1700sThe 1800s
Protestant
  • Henry II. The reasons with which it is pressed upon…
  • Bridges Another humbling and valuable recollection of human ignorance! Man…
  • Fausset 5. spirit—How the soul animates the body! Thus the…

What does Henry say about Ecclesiastes 11:5?

Matthew Henry

1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume III (Job to Song of Solomon): Ecclesiastes

On Ecclesiastes 11:1–6

This comment begins at Ecclesiastes 11:1:

2. Our opportunity for well-doing is very uncertain: "Thou knowest not what evil may be upon the earth, which may deprive thee of thy estate, and put thee out of a capacity to do good, and therefore, while thou hast…

On Ecclesiastes 11:1–6

This comment begins at Ecclesiastes 11:1:

III. How he obviates the objections which might be made against this duty and the excuses of the uncharitable.

On Ecclesiastes 11:1–6

This comment begins at Ecclesiastes 11:1:

2. Some will say that their sphere of usefulness is low and narrow; they cannot do the good that they see others can, who are in more public stations, and therefore they will sit still and do nothing. Nay, says…

On Ecclesiastes 11:1–6

This comment begins at Ecclesiastes 11:1:

3. Some will object the many discouragements they have met with in their charity. They have been reproached for it as proud and pharisaical; they have but little to give, and they shall be despised if they do not give…

On Ecclesiastes 11:1–6

This comment begins at Ecclesiastes 11:1:

4. Some will say, "We do not see in which way what we expend in charity should ever be made up to us; we do not find ourselves ever the richer; why should we depend upon the general promise of…

On Ecclesiastes 11:1–6

This comment begins at Ecclesiastes 11:1:

... (2.) We know not how the bones are fashioned in the womb of her that is with child. We cannot describe the manner either of the formation of the body or of its information with a soul; both, we…

What does Bridges say about Ecclesiastes 11:5?

Charles Bridges

1794–1869 · Anglican (Evangelical) · An Exposition of the Book of Ecclesiastes

Another humbling and valuable recollection of human ignorance! Man prides himself upon what he knows, or fancies he knows—the extent of his knowledge. Much more reason has he to be humbled for the far wider extent of his ignorance. He does not see the harvest from the distribution of his charity. But his ignorance does not disprove the fact. How little does he know of the things before his eyes! How ignorant are we of our own being! So “ fearfully and wonderfully made!” so “curiously wrought!” (Ps. exxxix. 12-14.) The attempt to comprehend one’s self conquers our understanding. Anatomical experi- ments may bring out some facts. Questions may be asked. But they can only be answered by the confession of our ignorance—the way of the spirit, or the . human soul—how it is formed—whence it comes— whether by the immediate creation of God—how it is conveyed into and animates the body—the formation of the body itself—how the bones (without which we should only creep as worms) are jointed and grow in the womb—the union of the soul with the body—of the immaterial spirit with the gross corporeal substance .—in all this the soul is a mystery to itself. We know not the way.

Report a mistake

If, then, we cannot know him in his ordinary works of nature—in his works near at home—much less can we know the works of God, who maketh all. Truly he “doeth great things and unsearchable; marvellous things without numbers.” (Job, v. 9.) ‘Our wisdom is but as a drop in the bucket—yea, but a drop in the ocean. Can our drop compare with his ocean? A bucket shall soon take in the ocean, as man the wisdom of God.’} And ought not this sense of ignorance to furnish a convincing reply to many things that are called objections to Revelation? When tempted to pry— On such subjects’—said a serious thinker—‘ I have no confidence in reason. . I trust only in faith ; and as far as we ought to inquire, I have no guide but Revelation.’ ’ We should indeed be prepared in this Terra incognita to expect difficulties ; nor should we forget our own nature, by insisting upon a view of things to our be- ' Caryl on Job, xxviii. 14. * Sir Humphry Davy’s Collected Works, vol. ix. p. 381. clouded reason wholly free from difficulty. If we have not complete evidence according to our measure, should we not be thankful for any measure that may be vouchsafed ; instead of rejecting the guidance of the lesser light, because it was not the sun itself?' Knowledge of God’s works is valuable, just so far as it is connected with a sense of our own ignorance, and an earnest application for Divine Teaching and practical obedience. We have been well reminded— To dare to believe less, or to pretend to understand more, than God has expressly revealed, is equally profane presumption. We should study to be wise—not above Scripture, but im Scripture ; not in the things which God has concealed, but what he has revealed.’ *

Report a mistake

What does Fausset say about Ecclesiastes 11:5?

A. R. Fausset

1821–1910 · Anglican (Evangelical) · A Commentary, Critical and Explanatory, on the Old and New Testaments: Ecclesiastes

5. spirit—How the soul animates the body! Thus the transition to the formation of the body "in the womb" is more natural, than if with Maurer we translate it "wind" (Ec 1:6; Joh 3:8).

bones … grow—(Job 10:8, 9; Ps 139:15, 16).

knowest not the works of God—(Ec 3:11; 8:17; 9:12).

Report a mistake

Cited on other verses

Commentators citing Ecclesiastes 11:5 while explaining another verse. The sentence is copied as the excerpt reads.

  • Matthew Henry · Luke 1:35

    The formation of every babe in the womb, and the entrance of the spirit of life into it, is a mystery in nature; none knows the way of the spirit, nor how the bones are formed in the womb of her that is with child, Eccl. xi. 5.

  • Matthew Henry · Matthew 1:18–25

    If we know not the way of the Spirit in the formation of common persons, nor how the bones are formed in the womb of any one that is with child (Eccles. xi. 5), much less do we know how the blessed Jesus was formed in the womb of the blessed virgin.

  • Matthew Henry · Proverbs 27:1

    A good consideration, upon which this caution is grounded: We know not what a day may bring forth, what event may be in the teeming womb, of time; it is a secret till it is born, Eccl. xi. 5.

  • Matthew Henry · Psalms 35:9–10

    The formation of our bones so wonderfully, so curiously (Eccl. xi. 5; Ps. cxxxix. 16), the serviceableness of our bones, and the preservation of them, and especially the life which, at the resurrection, shall be breathed upon the dry bones and make them flourish as a herb, oblige every …

  • Matthew Henry · John 3:8

    Which way went the Spirit? 1 Kings xxii. 24. See Eccl. xi. 5, and compare it with Ps. cxxxix. 14.

  • John Evans · Romans 1:20

    He works in secret (Job xxiii. 8, 9; Ps. cxxxix. 15; Eccl. xi. 5), but manifests what he has wrought, and therein makes known his power and Godhead, and others of his attributes which natural light apprehends in the idea of a God.

  • Johann Albrecht Bengel · John 3:8

    The Spirit, in the proper sense; for it is He, not the wind (concerning which, however, comp. Eccles. 11, 5), that has a will ... and it is of Him we are born, and he who is born of Him is such as He is.

The Hebrew words

WordDictionary formGlossGrammar
כַּ
ka
כְּjustPreposition
אֲשֶׁ֨ר
ʾăšer
אֲשֶׁרasParticle · relative
אֵֽינְאַיִןnotParticle · negative
ךָ֤הוּאyouSuffix · pronoun · 2nd person masculine singular
יוֹדֵ֨עַ֙
yôḏēʿa
יָדַע[are].knowingVerb · Qal · participle · masculine singular absolute
מַה
mah-
מָהwhat?Particle · interrogative
דֶּ֣רֶךְ
dereḵ
דֶּרֶךְ[is].the.wayNoun · common · masculine or feminine singular construct (of ...)
הָ
hā
הַofParticle · definite article
ר֔וּחַ
rûᵃḥ
רוּחַthe.windNoun · common · masculine or feminine singular absolute
כַּ
ka
כְּlikePreposition
עֲצָמִ֖ים
ʿăṣāmiym
עֶצֶםbonesNoun · common · feminine plural absolute
בְּ
bə
בְּinPreposition
בֶ֣טֶן
ḇeṭen
בֶּטֶןthe.wombNoun · common · feminine singular construct (of ...)
הַ
ha
הַofParticle · definite article
מְּלֵאָ֑ה
mməlēʾāh
מָלֵאthe.full.[woman]Adjective · feminine singular absolute
כָּ֗כָה
kāḵâ
כָּכָהthusAdverb
לֹ֤א
lōʾ
לֹאnotParticle · negative
תֵדַע֙
ṯēḏaʿ
יָדַעyou.knowVerb · Qal · imperfect (yiqtol) · 2nd person masculine singular
אֶת
ʾeṯ-
אֵת(et)Particle · direct object marker
מַעֲשֵׂ֣ה
maʿăśēh
מַעֲשֶׂהthe.workNoun · common · masculine singular construct (of ...)
הָֽ
hā
הַof.(the)Particle · definite article
אֱלֹהִ֔ים
ʾĕlōhiym
אֱלֹהִיםGodNoun · common · masculine plural absolute
אֲשֶׁ֥ר
ʾăšer
אֲשֶׁרwhoParticle · relative
יַעֲשֶׂ֖ה
yaʿăśeh
עָשָׂהhe.makesVerb · Qal · imperfect (yiqtol) · 3rd person masculine singular
אֶת
ʾeṯ-
אֵת(et)Particle · direct object marker
הַ
ha
הַ(the)Particle · definite article
כֹּֽל
kōl:
כֹּלeverythingNoun · common · masculine singular absolute

From MACULA (CC BY 4.0), as the Open Word Bible reads them.

How the Open Word Bible translates Ecclesiastes 11:5

Word for word: Just as not you know what [is the] way of the breath, to [the] bones in [the] womb of the pregnant [woman], so not you know the work of the God who makes the all.

the breath: the breath of life that comes to an unborn child Word senseUncertain

Not: the wind

The word (*ruach*) means wind, breath or spirit. Verse 4 uses it for the wind. Here, with the bones in the womb, it most likely means the breath of life that God gives (12:7; Psalm 104:30). The two senses play against each other: no one knows the way of the wind, nor how life comes to a child.

to the bones: into the bones of the child as it forms GrammarUncertain

Not: as the bones (grow): a second example, separate from the wind

A small letter before "bones" can mean "to" or "like". Read as "to", the verse speaks of one mystery: how the breath of life enters the body in the womb. Read as "like", it gives two: the way of the wind, and the way bones grow in the womb.

the bones in the womb: God's hidden work in forming a child Allusion

Psalm 139:13-15 and Job 10:10-12 speak of God forming a person in the womb, where no one can see.

you do not know the work of God, who makes everything Theology

God is the maker of all, and his work is beyond human knowing (3:11; 8:17).

the breath of life Supplied words

Not: the breath · the wind

Balanced and Readable say which breath is meant (m1).

Cross-references

  • John 3:8 10 voices The wind blows where it wants to. You hear its sound, yet you do not know where it has come from or where it is heading. That is how it is with everyone who is born of the Spirit."
  • Psalms 92:6 6 voices LORD, how great the things You do! How very deep Your plans!
  • Ecclesiastes 8:17 2 voices then I saw all that God has done: no one can find out the work that is done under the sun. However hard people work to search it out, they will not find it. Even if the wise claim to know it, they cannot find it out.
  • Romans 11:33 8 voices How deep are the riches and the wisdom and the knowledge of God! How impossible to search out His judgments, and how impossible to trace His ways!
  • Isaiah 40:28 Do you not know? Or have you not heard? The LORD is the God of all ages, the maker of the earth to its farthest edges. He does not tire or wear out, and His understanding is beyond all searching.

Cross-references from OpenBible.info (CC BY), most voted first.

Read Ecclesiastes 11 with all its commentary