The potter and the clay (Romans 9:19–29)
19 So you will say to me, "Why does God still find fault, then?" For who can stand against His will? 20 But who are you, a mere human being, to answer back to God? Will what was shaped say to the one who shaped it, "Why did you make me this way?" 21 Has the potter no right over the clay? From one and the same lump he may make one pot for honored use and another for common use. 22 What if God, wanting to show His wrath and to make His power known, has borne with great patience the vessels of wrath, made ready for destruction? 23 What if He did this to make known the riches of His glory to the vessels of mercy, which He prepared in advance for glory, 24 that is, to us, whom He has called not only from among the Jews but also from among the Gentiles? 25 As He says in Hosea, "Those who were not My people I will call 'My people,' and her who was not loved I will call 'loved.'" 26 "And in the place where they were told, 'You are not My people,' that is where they will be called children of the living God." 27 And Isaiah cries out about Israel: "Though the people of Israel are as many as the grains of sand by the sea, the remnant will be saved." 28 "For on the earth the Lord will carry out His sentence, fully and without delay." 29 And as Isaiah said earlier, "If the Lord of hosts had not left us some descendants, we would have become like Sodom and been made like Gomorrah."
Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.
113 excerpts from 8 commentators on Romans 9:19–29, from John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) to Frédéric Louis Godet (1812–1900).
What the church has said
Each excerpt opens with its first words. Follow its verse to read it in full.
What does Chrysostom say about Romans 9:19–29?
John Chrysostom
Romans 9:20 Homily XVI. Rom. IX. 1
Ver. 20. “Nay but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God?”
... This is what an excellent teacher does; he does not follow his disciples’ fancy everywhere, but leads them to his own mind, and pulls up the thorns, and then puts the seed in, and does not answer at once…
... And when he does go on to say, “Hath not the potter power over the clay, of the same lump to make one vessel unto honor, and another unto dishonor?” do not suppose that this is said by Paul…
... And yet not even is it on the potter that the honor and the dishonor of the things made of the lump depends, but upon the use made by those that handle them, so here also it depends on…
What he means is somewhat as follows. Pharaoh was a vessel of wrath, that is, a man who by his own hard-heartedness had kindled the wrath of God. For after enjoying much long-suffering, he became no better, but remained unimproved.…
... But after that he had shown long-suffering, that He might lead to repentance, but he did not repent, He suffered him a long time, that He might display at once His goodness and His power, even if that man…
... Because when he says, “it is not of him that willeth, nor of him that runneth,” he does not deprive us of free-will, but shows that all is not one’s own, for that it requires grace from above. For…
... God, however, being very good, shows the same kindness to both. For it was not those in a state of salvation only to whom He showed mercy, but also Pharaoh, as far as His part went. For of the…
Romans 9:25 Homily XVI. Rom. IX. 1
Ver. 25. “I will call them My people, which were not My people; and her beloved, which was not beloved.”
Romans 9:26 Homily XVI. Rom. IX. 1
Ver. 26. “For even they shall be called,” he says, “the children of the living God.”
Romans 9:27 Homily XVI. Rom. IX. 1
Ver. 27. “For Esaias,” he says, “crieth concerning Israel.”
Romans 9:28 Homily XVI. Rom. IX. 1
Ver. 28. “He will finish the work, and cut it short in righteousness,” he says, “because a short work will the Lord make upon the earth.” (Ib. 23, LXX.)
What does Calvin say about Romans 9:19–29?
John Calvin
Romans 9:19 Thou wilt then say
19. Thou wilt then say, etc. Here indeed the flesh especially storms, that is, when it hears that they who perish have been destined by the will of God to destruction. Hence the Apostle adopts again the words of an…
Romans 9:20 But, O man! who art thou?
20. But, O man! who art thou? etc. As it is a participle in Greek, we may read what follows in the present tense, who disputest, or contendest, or strivest in opposition to God; for it is expressed in Greek…
But they who say that Paul, wanting reason, had recourse to reproof, cast a grievous calumny on the Holy Spirit: for the things calculated to vindicate God’s justice, and ready at hand, he was at first unwilling to adduce, for…
Romans 9:20 Does what is formed?
Does what is formed? etc. We see that Paul dwells continually on this, — that the will of God, though its reason is hid from us, is to be counted just; for he shows that he is deprived of his…
Romans 9:21 Has not the worker of the clay?
21. Has not the worker of the clay? etc. The reason why what is formed ought not to contend with its former, is, that the former does nothing but what he has a right to do. By the word power,…
Romans 9:22 And what
22. And what, etc. A second answer, by which he briefly shows, that though the counsel of God is in fact incomprehensible, yet his unblamable justice shines forth no less in the perdition of the reprobate than in the salvation…
But if we wish fully to understand Paul, almost every word must be examined. He then argues thus, — There are vessels prepared for destruction, that is, given up and appointed to destruction: they are also vessels of wrath, that…
Romans 9:23 That he might also make known the riches of his glory
23. That he might also make known the riches of his glory, etc. I doubt not but the two particles καὶ ἵνα, is an instance of a construction, where the first word is put last; (ὕστερον πρότερον) and that this…
Romans 9:24 Whom he also called
24. Whom he also called, etc. From the reasoning which he has been hitherto carrying on respecting the freedom of divine election, two things follow, — that the grace of God is not so confined to the Jewish people that…
Romans 9:25 As he says in Hosea
25. As he says in Hosea, etc. He proves now that the calling of the Gentiles ought not to have been deemed a new thing, as it had long before been testified by the prediction of the prophet. The meaning…
They who have hitherto been most successful in untying this knot have supposed that Paul meant to adopt this kind of reasoning, — “What may seem to be an hinderance to the Gentiles to become partakers of salvation did also…
... And this is what is chiefly included in the present prophecy: for when the Jews were banished from God’s family, they were thus reduced to a common class, and put on a level with the Gentiles. The difference being…
Romans 9:26 I will call them my people which are not a people
26. I will call them my people which are not a people This is said with respect to the divorce, which God had already made with the people, by depriving them of all honor, so that they did not excel…
Romans 9:27 And Isaiah exclaims
27. And Isaiah exclaims, etc. He proceeds now to the second part, with which he was unwilling to begin, lest he should too much exasperate their minds. And it is not without a wise contrivance, that he adduces Isaiah as…
Romans 9:28 For I will finish and shorten the matter
28. For I will finish and shorten the matter, etc. Omitting various interpretations, I will state what appears to me to be the real meaning: The Lord will so cut short, and cut off his people, that the residue may…
Romans 9:29 And as Isaiah had before said
29. And as Isaiah had before said, etc. He brings another testimony from the first chapter, where the Prophet deplores the devastation of Israel in his time: and as this had happened once, it was no new thing. The people…
What does Evans say about Romans 9:19–29?
John Evans
The apostle, having asserted the true meaning of the promise, comes here to maintain and prove the absolute sovereignty of God, in disposing of the children of men, with reference to their eternal state. And herein God is to be…
Romans 9:19 It might be objected, Why doth he yet find fault
II. It might be objected, Why doth he yet find fault? For who hath resisted his will? v. 19. Had the apostle been arguing only for God's sovereignty in appointing and ordering the terms and conditions of acceptance and salvation,…
Romans 9:20 By reproving the objector
1. By reproving the objector (v. 20): Nay but, O man. This is not an objection fit to be made by the creature against his Creator, by man against God. The truth, as it is in Jesus, is that which…
Romans 9:21 He gives us the comparison
(1.) He gives us the comparison, v. 21. The potter, out of the same lump, may make either a fashionable vessel, and a vessel fit for creditable and honourable uses, or a contemptible vessel, and a vessel in which is…
Romans 9:22–24 The application of the comparison
(2.) The application of the comparison, v. 22-24. Two sorts of vessels God forms out of the great lump of fallen mankind:—[1.] Vessels of wrath—vessels filled with wrath, as a vessel of wine is a vessel filled with wine; full…
... The spring of all the joy and glory of heaven is that mercy of God which endures for ever. Vessels of honour must to eternity own themselves vessels of mercy. Observe, First, What he designs in them: To make…
Having explained the promise, and proved the divine sovereignty, the apostle here shows how the rejection of the Jews, and the taking in of the Gentiles, were foretold in the Old Testament, and therefore must needs be very well consistent…
1. One is Isa. x. 22, 23, which speaks of the saving of a remnant, that is, but a remnant, which, though in the prophecy it seems to refer to the preservation of a remnant from the destruction and desolation…
... (2.) That he will contract it; not only finish it, but finish it quickly. Under the Old Testament he seemed to tarry, and to make a longer and more tedious work of it. The wheels moved but slowly towards…
2. Another is quoted from Isa. i. 9, where the prophet is showing how in a time of general calamity and destruction God would preserve a seed. This is to the same purport with the former; and the scope of…
What does Bengel say about Romans 9:19–29?
Johann Albrecht Bengel
"En, as yet) even still. This particle well expresses the peevish outcry. To the objection here put, Paul answers in two ways. I. The power of God over men is greater than the power of the potter over the clay,…
Oman) weak, ignorant of righteousness [i.e. the true way of justification]. ... Isa. xxix. 16 ... . The same prophet, ch. xlv. 9 ... Touts ... 6? ... Shall ye not be reckoned as the potter's clay ? Shall the…
particle of interrogation [an?]. ... power) construed with, over the clay. The potter does not make the clay but digs it out; God makes man, therefore He has greater power [over man], than the potter [over the clay]. But absolute…
but if) This particle has this as its apodosis to be supplied at the end of ver. 23 from ver. 20: God has much greater cause to complain concerning man, and man has less cause to expostulate with God [than…
with much long -suffering) viz: in order that it might allure the wicked [the reprobate] from their state of alienation from Him to repentance, ch. ii. 4; 2 Pet. iii. 9. God endures many bad men, in the enjoyment of…
that) Denotes more distinctly the end and aim, without excluding means. ... might make known) This verb is applied to things not formerly known; it is therefore put both here and in the preceding verse, but ... to show, is…
whom also) ... also, in chap. viii. 30 ... whom (having been previously prepared for glory) He hath also called. ... called) in some respects an antithesis to, He endured, ver. 22. Again ... will call, occurs in the next…
saith) God. Paul asserted the prior right of God in calling the Gentiles, and their actual calling, and now at last that the event is shown, he brings in one testimony from the Old Testament, and ch. xv. 9, etc.,…
Hos. ii. 1, LXX ... . ... there: So it is not necessary for them to change their country and betake themselves to ... comp. Zeph. ii. 11. ... crieth. See Isa ... . 22, where the accents also may…
a thing heard, and therefore spoken, Isa. xxviii. 22. ... supply, as is often necessary in Hebrew, the word is, comp. Acts xxiv. ... The Lord ... will consummate His ... word [decree] concerning Israel, in respect to the appointed…
Is. i. 9, LXX.
What does Wesley say about Romans 9:19–29?
John Wesley
In this chapter St. Paul, after strongly declaring his love and esteem for them, sets himself to answer the grand objection of his countrymen; namely, that the rejection of the Jews and reception of the gentiles was contrary to the…
Romans 9:19 Why doth he still find fault
19. Why doth he still find fault - The particle still is strongly expressive of the objector's sour, morose murmuring. For who hath resisted his will - The word his likewise expresses his surliness and aversion to God, whom he…
Romans 9:20 Nay, but who art thou, O man
20. Nay, but who art thou, O man - Little, impotent, ignorant man. That repliest against God - That accusest God of injustice, for himself fixing the terms on which he will show mercy? Shall the thing formed say to…
Romans 9:21 Hath not the potter power over the clay
21. Hath not the potter power over the clay - And much more hath not God power over his creatures, to appoint one vessel, namely, the believer, to honour, and another, the unbeliever, to dishonour? If we survey the right…
Romans 9:22 What if God, being willing
22. What if God, being willing - Referring to ver. 18, 19. That is, although it was now his will, because of their obstinate unbelief, To show his wrath - Which necessarily presupposes sin. And to make his power known…
Romans 9:23 That he might make known
23. That he might make known - What if by showing such longsuffering even to "the vessels of wrath," he did the more abundantly show the greatness of his glorious goodness, wisdom, and power, on the vessels of mercy; on…
Romans 9:24 Even us
24. Even us - Here the apostle comes to the other proposition, of grace free for all, whether Jew or gentile. Of the Jews - This he treats of, ver. 25. Of the gentiles - Treated of in the same…
Romans 9:25 Beloved
25. Beloved - As a spouse. Who once was not beloved - Consequently, not unconditionally elected. This relates directly to the final restoration of the Jews. Hosea ii, 23
Romans 9:26 There shall they be called the sons of God
26. There shall they be called the sons of God - So that they need not leave their own country and come to Judea. Hosea i, 10
27. But Isaiah testifies, that (as many gentiles will be accepted, so) many Jews will be rejected; that out of all the thousands of Israel, a remnant only shall be saved. This was spoken originally of the few that were…
Romans 9:28 For he is finishing or cutting short his account
28. For he is finishing or cutting short his account - In rigorous justice, will leave but a small remnant. There will be so general a destruction, that but a small number will escape.
Romans 9:29 As Isaiah had said before
29. As Isaiah had said before - Namely, Isaiah i, 9, concerning those who were besieged in Jerusalem by Rezin and Pekah. Unless the Lord had left us a seed - Which denotes,
What does Haydock say about Romans 9:19–29?
George Leo Haydock
Ver. 19. &c. Thou wilt say, therefore, to me, &c. The apostle makes objection, that if God call some, and harden, or even permit others to be hardened, and no one resisteth, or can hinder his absolute will, why should…
Romans 9:22–23 And if God
Ver. 22-23. And if God, &c. He now gives the reason why God might, without any injustice, have mercy on some, and not on others; grant particular graces and favours to his elect, and not equally to all; because all…
Ver. 24. &c. Whom also he hath called, &c. That is, he hath called some of the Jews, and many of the Gentiles, to be vessels of election, as he foretold by his prophet Osee, (2:24.) I will call them…
What does Hodge say about Romans 9:19–29?
Charles Hodge
Romans 9:19 Thou wilt then say unto me, why doth he yet find fault
(19) Thou wilt then say unto me, why doth he yet find fault? for who hath resisted his will? This is the second leading objection to the apostle’s doctrine. If it is true, as he had just taught, that the…
... To this objection the apostle gives two answers; 1. That it springs from ignorance of the true relation between God and men, as Creator and creatures, and of the nature and extent of the divine authority over us, vs.…
Romans 9:20 Nay, but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God
(20) Nay, but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God? Shall the thing formed, &c. In these words we have both a reproof and an answer. The reproof is directed against the irreverent spirit, whence such cavils always…
... It is the cavil of a sinful creature against his Creator, that he is answering; and he does it by showing that God is under no obligation to give his grace to any, but is as sovereign as the…
Romans 9:21 Hath not the potter power over the clay
(21) Hath not the potter power over the clay, out of the same lump, to make one vessel, &c. &c. The word rendered power means also authority and right. In this case it means, the lawful power or right; he…
Romans 9:22–23 But what if God
(22, 23) But what if God, willing to show his wrath, and to make his power known endured with much long suffering the vessels of wrath fitted to destruction; and that he might make known the riches of his glory…
The attentive reader will perceive that even with the insertion of the word what which has nothing to answer to it in the original, and with a sign of interrogation at the end of y. 24, the construction of the…
Much in the same way Wrner explains the passage, connecting the xol ive of v. 23, immediately with the verb 4 'veyxev of v. 22, “ Wenn Gott beschliessend mit aller Langmuth die Gefiisse seines Zornes trug * auch in…
The two objects which Paul here specifies as designed to be answered by the punishment of the wicked, are the manifestation of the wrath af God, and the exhibition of his power. The word wrath is used here as in…
Fitted to destruction. The word here used admits of being taken either as passive or middle, and may, therefore, be rendered as it is in our version, or who have fitted themselves for destruction. If the passive sense be adopted…
Romans 9:23 And that he might make known the riches of his glory
(23) And that he might make known the riches of his glory, &c. See the preceding verse for the different views of the grammatical connexion of this verse with v. 22. The sense is plain, ‘What right have men to…
On the vessels af mercy, which he had afore prepared unto glory. On the phrase vessels of mercy, see the preceding verse. The word rendered he had afore prepared has this signification frequently; indeed, it is its common and proper…
Romans 9:24 Even us
(24) Even us, whom he hath called, not of the Jews only, but also of the Gentiles. We are the vessels of his mercy, even we whom he hath called, i. e. effectually introducéd by his Spirit into the kingdom…
Romans 9:25 The first part of the general conclusion
(25) The first part of the general conclusion, contained in the 24th verse, is, that the Gentiles are eligible to the blessings of Christ’s kingdom. This the apostle confirms by two passages from the prophecies of Hosea, which express the…
... In this view, it is perfectly applicable to the apostle’s object, which was to convince the Jews, that the blessings of Christ’s kingdom were not to be confined within the pale of the Old Testament economy, or limited to…
Romans 9:26 And it shall come to pass
(26) And it shall come to pass, that in the place where it was said to them, ye are not my people, &e. This quotation is more strictly conformed to the Hebrew, than the preceding. It is from Hos. 1:…
Romans 9:27–28 The second part of the apostle’s conclusion, v
(27, 28) The second part of the apostle’s conclusion, v. 24, is that the Jews, as such, were not to be included in the kingdom of Christ, which of course is implied in all those predictions which speak of them…
28, is an amplification, or states the converse of the preceding proposition. ‘ Most of the Jews should be cut off.’ The passage in Isaiah, therefore, is strictly applicable to the apostle’s object. Our version of v. 28 is consistent…
Romans 9:29 The second passage quoted by the apostle is from Is
(29) The second passage quoted by the apostle is from Is. 1: 9, Except the Lord of hosts had left us a seed we had been as Sodom, been made like unto Gomorrah. The object of this quotation is the…
Paul here again follows the Septuagint. The only difference, however, is that the Greek version has ... a seed, instead of a@ remnant, as it is in the Hebrew. The sense is precisely the same. The Hebrew word means that…
What does Godet say about Romans 9:19–29?
Frédéric Louis Godet
The apostle opens this passage with a preface expressing the profound grief he feels in view of the mysterious fact which is about to occupy him (w. 1-5) ; then he shows how the liberty of God is set in…
Vv. 19-21: ... wUt say then unto me, Why doth he yet ... t For who can resist His mil t Much ... 0 man, who art thou (hat ... Shall the vessd of day ... to him that formed…
Yer. 20. Most commentators do not hold that in the following answer Paul comes seriously to discuss the objection. Abrumpit ... says Melanchthon. ... observes that Paul raises the question, not to resolve it, which would be impossible, but to…
... Moreover, endowed as he is with sensibility to pleasure and pain, he cannot be manipulated like worthless matter. And certainly, if the question addressed by the vessel to the potter : " Why hast thou made me thus?" signified:…
... As it belongs only to the potter, in virtue of the knowledge he has of his art, to determine the use which he shall make of the different parts of the mass in his hands to extract from each…
... The work of the skilful potter 13 not the emblem of an arbitrary use of strength; but, on the contrary, of a deliberate and intelligent employment of the matter at his disposal Such is the apostle's complete view. But…
Let not Israel therefore say to ... Thoa iiast no right to make of me ... else than a Tessel of honour ; and Thou hast no ... to make of that other ... the Gentiks, anything else than a…
Vv. 22-24. "Now if Chd, willing to show His wrath, and to make His power known, ... with much tong-mffering ike vessels of wraih fitted to destruction: And [if] that He might make known the riches of His glory on…
... For Paul means thereby that God has not even dealt with Israel as the potter with his vessel We seek the ... proposition on which depends the sentence : Ifino, if willing . . ., and we do not…
Ver. 22 describes God's dealing with the vessels unto dishonour; w. 23 and 24 will describe His dealing with the vessels of value. The relation between the participle ... willing, and the verb ... He emdured, may be explained in…
... We might refer the manifestation of God's poioer to the mighty efficacy of God's Spirit creating a new people in Israel from the day of Pentecost onwards, and thus preparing the spiritual Israel, which was to replace the carnal…
... But it is difficult to suppose that Paul, who, according to 1 Thess. iL 16, was expecting the destruction of the Jewish people as close at hand, and who yet, according to chap, xi., placed the conversion of all…
... In chap. iL Panl stood, it is true, at the ... of human liberty ; but here he starts from the standpoint of absolute divine ... But is it probable that a mind so logical as Paul's should accept…
... The perfect participle used by the apostle denotes a present ... which has been previously formed in a certam manner; but this participle indicates absolutely nothing as to the mode in which this state has been produced ; hence…
... After such a history this people deserved the judgment of hardening which overtook them (xi 8—10), more even than ... Perdition, ... does not merely denote external punishment, the destruction of Jerusalem and the dispersion of the people ;…
Yer. 23. Here God is presented to us as the potter, labouring to form the vessels of honour. — How are we to construe the proposition: And that He might make ... The most forced construction is that of Ewald,…
... But how make the idea of the manifestation of grace, which is one of the two fundamental ideas of the whole passage, dependent on an expression so subordinate as this participle ? — There remains only one possible construction,…
... By this relative ... whom, as well as by the ... also, added to the verb He called, ver. 24, the apostle means to bring out the close bond which connects with one another the two acts of preparing…
By the words : to Tnake ... the riches of Sis glory, Paul alludes to the example of Moses, ver. 15, who had asked God to show him His glory, exactly as by the expression of ver. 22 he had…
... 2. There the passive form, instead of the active used heia 3. Here the aonst, relerring to the eternal act, as in viiL 29, instead of tha perfect (ver. 22), which denoted the present fact 4. Here the verb…
Ver. 24. And those predestined to glory. He has drawn by long-suffering, not only from the midst of the lost mass of the Jews, but also from among the Grentiles. This was what Jesus had declared : " I have…
Here should be placed ... the principel ... which is ... but understood, on which lest the two preceding subordinate ... beginning with now if, ver. 22, and atnd if, Ter. 23 : ' And if those Jews, alieady ripe…
The word of God has not therefore ... made of no effect by the fact of the rejection of the Israelitish nation (ver. 6). For, 1st, the principle of divine sdection which controlled the early destinies of the patriarchal family…
And first, w. 25 and 26 : the proclamation by the prophets of the calling of the Gentiles; tlien w. 27-29 : that of the rejection of the mass of the Jewish people.
... And, indeed, in the mouth of God the expressions: " that which is not of my people ;" "her which is not beloved ; " "I will call them my people . . ., beloved /' express a principle…
Ver. 26. The second saying quoted (Hos. L 10) is attached to the preceding as if it followed it immediately in the prophet More than once in the following chapters we find this combination of originally distinct sayings. Some apply…
Vv. 27-29. ... Eeaiae crieth concerning Israel, Though the nwniber of the children of Israel leas the sand of the sea, the remnant [only] shall he saved : for the Lord ... make a short and summary reckoning on the…
... In the context, both of Isaiah and of the apostle, there is a contrast between tiie innumerable multitude ... as it seemed ought to form Jehovah's people and which perishes, and the poor remnant which alone remains to enjoy…
... The meaning of this saying is, that without a quite peculiar exercise of grace on the part of the Lord, the destruction announced w. 27 and 28 would have been more radical still, as radical as that which overtook…