Frédéric Louis Godet · Commentary on St. Paul's Epistle to the Romans
Romans 8
108 excerpts on Romans 8, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
Vv. 1—4 describe the restoration of holiness by the Holy Spirit; and w. 5-11 show how from this destruction of sin there follows that of death. Thus are destroyed the two last enemies of salvation. '
Yv. 1, 2. There is therefore now no condemnation to them ... are in Christ Jesus} For the law of the Spirit of life in ... made me free from the law of sin and — The word ... has here its temporal, and not its logical sense, as Philippi would have it (to be in keeping with the application which he makes of ... 7-25 to the ... Bj this word Paul contrasts the new state with the old, which has passed awaj. — The therefore is not merely connected, as Meyer thinks, with the preceding verse : ''As I am no more in myself, bnt in Christ, there is no'' . . .; for then but would have been required rather than therefore. This therefore takes up the thread, which had been for the moment broken, of the exposition of Christian sanctification ; for the passage vii. 7-25 was, as we have seen, a retrospective glance at the moral effects of the law in fallen man, and consequently a sort of parenthesis. Now Paul resumes at the point where he had interrupted himself, that is, at vil 6, and raises the superstructure, the foundation of which he had laid in the section vL 1— vii 6. Hence the therefore : " Since ye ... dead to sin and alive to God, and so subject to grace, and mode free from the law, all condemnation has disappeared." The expression : no ... does not apply to any one form of condemnation, and, indeed, Paul takes into view first that which has been lifted off by the grace of justification, diaps. i-v. : the abolition of guilt; and next, that which is made to disappear by the destruction of sin itself (chaps, vi. ... 6). ...
Romans 8:1–2 · Open Word Bible
1So then, those who are in Christ Jesus now face no sentence of condemnation. 2For in Christ Jesus the law of the Spirit who gives life has freed you from the law of sin and death.
... After therefore the believer has foimd reconciliation with God, and thereby death to sin, he can really exclaim : There is now no condemnation." Only sin must not recover its dominion ; otherwise condemnation would infallibly revive. For we have seen at the close of chap, vi that sin entails death on the justified, in whom it regains the upper hand, as well as on the unjustified (viii 12, 13). There is therefore only one way of preventing sin from causing us to perish, that is, that it perish itself. ... It ought to be so after sin is pardoned as gidit and destroyed as a power, if always this power remains broken. The Tiew of Paul extends even it ... seem to a third condemnation of which he has not yet spoken, that which has overtaken the body, death, the ... of which he proceeds also to explain, ver. 1 1. — The -woids : them ... are in Christ Jesus, form a contrast to the expression ... I, as I am in ... vii 25. — Our translations, following the received text, give us at the end of the verse this addition : who walk not after the flesh, het after the Spirit. These words are, according to numerous authorities, and according to the context itself, an interpolation borrowed by anticipation from ver. 4 : " A precautionary gloss against the fieeness of salvation," says M. Bonnet very happily. It was needful to proclaim deliverance before explaining it — Sow has it been effected ? This is what is expounded w.
Yer. 2. It is strange that Paul should speak of the law of the Spirit, Are these two expressions not contradictory? We shall not understand the phrase unless we bear in mind what has been said (iii 27, vii. 21, etc) of the general sense which the word law often takes in Paul's writings : a controlling power imposing itself on the will, or, as in the case before us, appropriating the very ... The complement t ... may be understood as the genitive of cause : The Spirit which proceeds firom the life (that of Jesus Himself) ; " or as the gen. of effect : '* The Spirit which produces life (in the beUever)." But is it possible wholly to sever these two relations ? If the Spirit produces spiritual Ufe in the believer's heart, is it not because He is the breath of the living and glorified Christ ? He ... of that which belongs to Jestis, John xvl 15, and communicates it to ... The regimen: in Jestis Christ, is connected by several commentators with the verb hath made free : The Spirit of life made us free as soon as we entered into communion with Jesus Christ." But in this sense would not Paul rather have said in Him, ... aur, simply referring to the in Christ Jesus of the previous verse ? It is therefore more natural to make the regimen dependent on the immediately preceding phrase : the law of the Spirit of life. The only question is what article is to be understood, to serve as the link of this regimen. Should it be 6, relating to ... the law, or ... referring to ... the Spirit, or finally ... referring to ... life f The first connection, that adopted by Calvin, seems to us the preferable one. The apostle has no special reason for recalling here that life or ths Spirit are given in Jesus Christ, which is understood otherwise of itself. ...
Romans 8:2 · Open Word Bible
2For in Christ Jesus the law of the Spirit who gives life has freed you from the law of sin and death.
... But it is important for him to remind us that, in opposition to the reign of the letter, which made us slaves, the reign of the Spirit of life, which sets us free, was inaugurated in Jesus Christ. The absence of the article o before the regimen ... X. 'J. arises from the fact that the latter is regarded as forming only one and the same idea with the phrase on which it dependa — Instead of the pronoun ... me, read by the T. B. with the majority of the Mss., there is found in the Sinalt and the Vatic., as well as in two Greco-Latins, ... thee: " hath made thee free." This reading must be very ancient, for it is found so early as in the Feschito and Tertullian. It has been admitted by Tischendorf in his eighth edition. But it is nevertheless very improbable. Why the sudden appearance of the second person at the very close of this argument 1 This a-e has evidently arisen, as Meyer thinks, from the repetition of the last syllable of ... The ... me, is the continuation of the form of expression which the apostle had used throughout the whole of the second part of chap. viL Indeed, the figure used by him in w. 23 and 24, that of a prisoner calling for help, with the cry : " Who shall deliver me ? " still continues and reaches its close in our verse, as is seen by the choice of the term ... haih made free. Our ver. 2 is the true answer to this cry of distress, ver. 23. It is ... of life communicated in Jesus to the justified Christian which causes the chains of sin and death to fall from him. — We must beware of following several commentators in applying the phrase : the law of sin and death, to the law of Moses. ...
... Paul has just called the latter the law of God, and has declared that he took pleasure in it after the inward man ; this would not be the time to abuse it in this fashion. The true explanation follows from ver. 23, where he has spoken of the law which is in his members, and which renders him the captive of sin. The word law is therefore still used here in that general sense in -which we have just seen it taken in the banning of the verse. The apostle deliberately contrasts law with law, that is to say here : power with power. — The two combined terms, sin and death, form the antithesis to life ; for the latter includes the notions of holiness and resurrection. Death is the state of separation from God in which sin involves ... but that while understanding physical as the transition to eternal death. The two words: sin and death, control the following development down to ver. 11. And first: deliverance from sin, vv. 3 and 4.
Vv. 3, 4. " For — what the law could not do, in thai it was weak through the flesh — God sending his own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh, and for sin, condemned sin in the flesh, that the righteousness of the law might ... in us, who walk not after the flesh, ... after the ... The fact and agent of the deliverance had just been mentioned in ver. 2 ; w. 3 and 4 describe its mode ; ver. 3 its condition, ver. 4 its realization. The for of ver. 3 extends its force to the close of ver. 4. — Our translation shows to what construction we hold in explaining the words : ... the law could not do. We make them, with Meyer, Philippic and others, a nominative, in apposition to the divine act, to be enunciated immediately afterwards : " God condemned sin, a thing which the law was powerless to accomplish." This construction is to be preferred for its simpUcity and deamess to all others : to that of Schott, who, by means of a harsh inversion, thus explains the words: '' seeing that ... the impotence of the law was weak through the flesh ; " that is to say, the weakness of the law was still further increased through the influence of the flesh — the meaning is as forced as the construction ; — or to that of Hofmann, who understands the verb v, was, and makes the whole a principal proposition. The weakness of the law was (consisted) in that it was weak through the flesL" But such an ellipsis is inadmissible, and the asyndeton between this and the followiag proposition is without explanation. It would be better to understand, with Luther (comp. the translations of Ostervald and Oltramare), the words ... ''What the law could not do, God did by sending'' . . . When Paul was about to write this verb, he is held to have substituted the mention of the act itself thus announced:
Romans 8:3–4 · Open Word Bible
3The law was powerless, since the flesh had left it weak. So God acted. He sent His own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh, as an offering for sin, and in the flesh He passed sentence on sin. 4He did this so that the law's righteous requirement would be fully met in us, who conduct our lives by the Spirit and not by the flesh.
But the most important word in this verse is the conjunction that. In this word is contained Paul's real notion of .sanctification. How does the fulfilment of the law in believers follow from the fact expounded in ver. 3 : the condemnation of sin wrought in the person of Christ ? The strangest answer to this question is that of Holsten : The power of the flesh in humanity was destroyed by the death-blow which slew the flesh of Christ on the cross." But how could sin of nature, objective sin, in humanity, be destroyed by the fact of Christ's death ? If sin is inherent in the flesh, the flesh which needs to be destroyed is not only Christ's, but that of the entire human race. As Wendt rightly observes, nothing but the death of all men could secure the desired result — -Gess thinks that the part played by Christ's death in sanctification was to render possible the gift of the Spirit, who alone has power to sanctify (comp. GaL iii. 13, 14). But Paul does not say in ver. 4 : " that the Spirit might be given " (as he does GaL iii. 14 : that we might receive the Spirit). He passes directly from the condemnation of sin in Christ (ver. 3) to the fulfilment of the law in believers (ver. 4). This mode of expression supposes another relation. And this relation is easy to comprehend if the right meaning of ver. 3 has been taken. The believer's holiness is nothing else than that which Jesus Himself realized during His earthly existence. '' For their sakes I sanctify myself/* says Jesus, John xvii. 1 9, " that they also might be sanctified through the truth." Here, as in other respects, the Spirit only takes what is His, to communicate it to us (John xvL 14). Our Lord's holy life on the earth is the type which the Holy Spirit is commissioned to reproduce in us, the treasure from which He draws the renewing of our life (Col. iii. 10 ; 2 Cor. iii. 17, 18). ...
... The holiness of all of us is only this one holiness which the Spirit makes ours : ... is our sanctificaiion as well as owr ... the latter by His death (which faith makes our death), the former by His holy life (which the Spirit makes our life). Witness the two ... through, hy, of v. 1, 2 ; and the mysterious ... His life, ... of v. 10. Such is the rich and profound sense of the that, ver. 4. — The expression ... in us, perfectly suits this meaning. It says first, that therein we are receptive; then it contains also the ly us. — The term ... to walk, is Paul's usual figure for moral conduct. — The subjective negation ... is used because Paul is speaking not of the fact in itself, but of the fact as being the assumed condition of the preceding affirmation.
Thus the first idea of this passage has been developed : emancipation from the law of sin. What the law condemns was condemned in Christ, that henceforth through His Spirit the law might be fidly carried out in us. No doubt the power of sin is not annihilated within, but it cannot control the active part of our being and determine the ... (the ... There remains the second idea : deliverance from the last condemnation, that of death: death spiritual, vv. 5— 10 and finally also from todily death, ver. 11.
What was impossible , ... God condemned." But does not that biing ns back to Meyer's construction which leaches the goal by a shorter course ? Comp. Heb, ... 1. — The powerlessness of the law to accomplish ... work did not come from any intrinsic imperfection, but from the fact that it found resistance in man's sinful nature : ... of the flesh. The law could certainly condemn sin in writing, by engraving its condemnation on stone ; but not by displaying this condemnation in a real human life. And yet this was the necessary condition of the destruction of the sinful tendency in mankind, and in order to the restoration of holiness. The expression : the powerlessness or ... of the law, ia easily understood, notwithstanding Hofinann's objection, in the sense of: ''What it is impossible for the law to realize.'' Meyer quotes the expression of Xenophon : to ... what the city can make or give, — The words cv , in this that, evidently open up the explanation of this wealmess. The depraved instinct which th law encounters in man, the fiesh, prevents it from obtaining the cordial obedience which the law demands from him. The flesh here as so frequently, in the moral sense which rests on the physical : self-complacency. The participle ... sending, though an aorist, nevertheless expresses an act simultaneous with that of the finite verb condemned (see Meyer) : condemned by sending." The term sending by itself would not necessarily imply the pre-existence of Christ ; for it may apply to the appearance of a mere man charged with a divine mission ; comp. John L 6. But the notion of pre-existence necessarily follows from the relation of this verb to the expression: JEKs own Son, especially if we take account of the regimen: in the likeness of sinful flesh. It is evident that, in the view of one who speaks thus, the existence of this Son preceded His human existence (comp. the more emphatic term ... ...
... GaL iv. 4). — The expression : His own Son, literally, tiie Son of Himself, forbids us to give to the title Son, either the meaning of eminent man, or theocratic king, or even Jtessiah, It neoessarily refers to this ... personal relation to God, and indicates that Him whom God sends. He takes ficom His own bosom ; comp. John i 18. Paul marks the oontrast between the lature of the envoy (the true Son of God) and the manner of His appealing here below: in the likeness of ... flesh. — This expression: sinful flesh ... flesh of sin), has been understood by many, especially most ... by Holsten as implying the idea that sin is inherent in the flesh, that is to say, in the bodily nature. It would follow ... and this critic accepts the consequence — that Jesus Himself according to Paul, was not exempt from the natural sin inseparable from the substance of the body Only Holsten adds that this ... sin never controlled the will of Jesus, nor led him to a positive tranagression ... the pre-existing divine Spirit of Christ constantly kept the flesh in obedience. We have abeady seen, vi 6, that if the body is to the soul a cause of its, fall, it is only so because tiie will itself is no longer in its normal state. If by union with God it were inwardly upright and firm, it would control the body completely; but being itself since the fedl controlled by selfishness, it seeks a means of satisfaction in the body, and the latter takes advantage therefrom to usurp a malignant dominion over it Thus, and thus only, can Paul connect the notion of sin so closely with that of hody or ... Otherwise he would be obliged to make ... Himself, as the creator of the body, the author of sin. ...
... What proves in our very passage that he is not at all regarding sin as an attribute inseparable from the flesh, is the expression he uses in speaking of Jesus : in the likeness of a flesh of sin. Had he meant to express the idea ... to him by Holsten, why speak of likeness ? Why not say simply : in a ... of sin, that is to say, sinful like ours? While ... similarity of ... between the flesh of Jesus and ours, the very tiling the apostie wishes here is to set aside the idea of likeness in qwality respect of siriy This is done clearly by the expression which he has chosen. It will be asked, might he not have said more briefly : in the likeness ... or of our ... But by expresaing himself thus, he would have favoured the idea that the body of Jesus was a mere ... And this is the very consequence which Mardon has sought to draw from our passage. One cannot help admiring the nicety of the phrase formed by the apostie, and the pliability of the language which lent itself so readily to the analysis and expression of such delicate shades. — Wendt, while rightiy criticizing Holsten's 64 ... opinion, escapes it only by another inadmissible explanation. He nnderstands the word flesh in the sense in which it is taken in that frequent expression : all ... that is to say, eveiy man, eveiy creature. Paul means here, he thinks, that Jesus appeared on the earth in the likeness of the ... creature} But should we then require to take the word flesh in the preceding proposition : " The law was weak through the flesh" in the sense of creature? It seems to us that M. Sabatier is right in saying : ' "No doubt the word flesh sometimes denotes man taken in his entirety. But even then it never absolutely loses its original signification ; the notion of the material oiganism always remains the fundamental notion." ...
... We have no need of ... expedient to account for the phrase of the apostle. Here is its meaning, as it seems to us : God, by sending His Son, meant to provide a human life in that same flesh, under the influence of which we sin so habitually, such that it might complete this dangerous career without sin ... Heb. iv. 15) ; comp. 2 Cor. v. 21: He who knew no sin '* . . . — What then was the reason why God sent His Son in this form? Jesus, Paul tells us in PhiUppians, might in virtue of His God-form, of His divine state in the presence of God, have appeared here below as the equal of God. The reason it was not so is explained by the words ical ... and for sin. If man had still been in his normal state, the appearance of the Son would also have had a normal character. But there was an extraordinary thing to be destroyed, sin. And hence the necessity for the coming of the Son in a flesh like our sinful flesL As the expression : for sin, is sometimes taken in the O. T. (LXX. version) as a substantive, in the sense of sacrifice for sin ... and has passed thence into the N. T. (Heb. x. 6-18), some commentators have thought that Paul was here ... priating this Alexandrine form. But there are two reasons opposed to this idea : 1. This very special sense, which might present itself naturally to the mind of the readers of such a book as the Epistle to ... Hebrews, filled throughout with allusions to the ceremonies of the Levitical worship, could hardly have been understood, without explanation, by the Christians of Rome, who were for the most part Gentiles. 2. The context does not require the idea of ... because the matter in question is not guilt to be expiated, but solely the evil tendency to be uprooted. ...
... Not that the notion of expiation should be wholly excluded from the contents of so general an expression as ... sin. It is undoubtedly contained in it, but it is not here the leading idea. Paul means in a wide sense, that it is the fact of sin and especially the intention to destroy it (by every means, ... and ... which have caused the coming of Christ here below, in this form so unlike His glorious nature.
This coming is only the means of the means ; the latter is the decisive act expressed by the words : He condemned sin. To condemn, is to declare evU, and devote to destruction ; and we see no occasion to depart from this simple and usual meaning. ... Other commentators have felt this, and have again found here the idea of expiation, developed in chap. iii. : God condemned sin in Christ crucified, as its representative, on the cross (Biick., Olsh., Philip., Hofm., Gess) ; to this idea many add that of the ... of sin, evidently demanded by the context; so Philippi: " to destroy by expiating ; " Gess : " a destruction of the power of sin founded on a judicial sentence/' which is included in " Christ's expiatory death." But that powerlessness of the law in consequence of the flesh, of which Paul was speaking, did not consist in not being able to condemn sin ; for it did condemn and even punish it ; but it was powerless to destroy it, to render man victorious over its power. Besides, would it not be surprising to find Paul, after developing the subject of expiation in its place in chap, iii., returning to it here, in very unlike terms! ... Paul has in ... neither the destruction of sin by the Holy Spirit (ver. 4), nor its ... on the cross; he is regarding Chrisfs holy life as a living condemnation of ... ...
... The flesh in Him was like a door constantly open to the temptations both of pleasure and pain ; and yet He constantly refused sin any entrance into His will and action. By this persevering and absolute exclusion He declared it evil ... unworthy of exiating in humanity. This is what the law. because of the flesh, which naturally sways every human will, could not realize in any man. This meaning, with an important shade of difference was that to which Menken was led ; it is that of Wendt ; it was certainly the idea of Theophylact when he said : He sanctified the flesh, and crowned it by condemning sin in the flesh which He had appropriated, and by showing that the flesh is not sinful in its nature *' (see the passage in de Wette). ... Not only, indeed, in the former case would the article ... be necessary after ... but still more this regimen : in the flesh, ... be superfluous, when connected with the word sin; now it becomes very significant if it refers to the verb. It might even be said that the whole pith of the thought centres in the regimen thus understood. In fact, the law could undoubtedly overwhelm sin with its sentences, and, so to speak, on paper. But Christ accomplished what it could not do, by condemning sin in the flesh, in a real living, human nature, in a humanity subject to those same conditions of bodily existence under which we aU are. Hence the reason why He must appear here below in flesh. For it was in the very fortress where sin had established its seat, that it behoved to be attacked and conquered. We must beware of translating with several : " in His flesh," as if there were the pronoun ... of Him, In this case the pronoun could not be want- ing; and the ... itself would be ... ...
... For the ... in Sis flesh, would only denote the particular historical fact, whereas the latter : in the flesh, while reminding us of the particular fact, expresses the general notion which brings out its necessitf . like the hero spoken of in the ... He required, if one may venture so to speak. Himself to descend into the infected place which He was commissioned to deansa — Thus from the perfectly holy life of Jesus there proceeds a conspicuous condemnation of sin ; and it is this moral tact, the gzeatest of the miracles that distinguished tlus life, which the Holy Spirit goes on reproducing in the life of every believer, and ... throughout the entire lace. This will be the victory gained over the law of sin (ver. 2). Thus we understand the connection between the condemned of ver. 3, and the no ... ver. 1. In His life He condemned that sin, which by remaining master of ours,, would have brought into it condemnation. The relation between w. 3 and 4 becomes also very simple: The condemnation of sin in Christ's life is the means appointed by God to effect its destruction in ours. Yer. 4 The relation we have just indicated between w. 9 and 4 forbids us to give here to ... what the law ... down ... meaning of: senten of ... which some,, and Philippi most recently, have given to it The matter in question here is not ... to be removed ; and to say that the law itself can henceforth declare us just, the term ... to he fulfilled, would not be very suitable. The matter in question, according to the context and the terms employed, is ... the law demands of man. ...
... All the postulates contained in the righteousness demanded by the law (comp. the Sermon on the Moimt, for example) are ... in us, as soon as we ... no more after the flesh, but after the Spirit, For, as we have seen, the law being ... must coincide at all points in its statutes with the impulses of the Spirit. The participle ... wlio waik, expresses the condition on which Paul can affirm of believers what he has just said (comp. the toU ... John i. 12). — Commentators differ as to the meaning of the word ... spirit. Does it denote, as Lange thinks, the spiritual life in believers ? But would this be a very sure standard, and does ver. 2 admit of this subjective sense ? Most, therefore, understand by the expression : the Holy Spirit. This meaning does not seem to us open to question (comp. also w. 9 and 11). Only from the use of the word spirit in the sequel (w. 5-8), it follows that the apostle is not speaking of the Holy Spirit, independently of His union with the human ... but of the former :iis dwelling in the latter, or of the latter as wholly directed by the former. And hence the reason why the one and the -other idea becomes alternately the dominant one in the following passage.
Vv. 5, 6. " For they that are after the flesh aspire after the things of the flesh ; hut they that are after the Spirit aspire after the things of the Spirit. For the aspiration of the flesh is death ; hvt the aspiration of the Spirit is life and peace/* — To understand the for which connects this verse with the ... we must begin with paraphrasing the first clause by adding : " For, while they that are after the flesh," . . . then complete the second clause by adding to the words : " aspire after the things of the Spirit/' the following: ''and consequently wdk after the Spirit with the view of obtaining those spiritual blessings." — To ie after the flesh, is to be inwardly governed by it, as the natural man always is. The part here referred to is the deepest source of the moral lile whence the will is constantly drawing its impulses and direction. Hence the consequence : ... tbey are preoccupied with the things of the flesh, aspire after them. The word ... is one of those terms which it is difficult to render in English, because it includes at once thinking and ... Oomp. the well -known Greek expressions ... to aim high, to have a high ... !nie ... the aeration, of which our verse speaks, proceeds from the ... leing, and produces the ... the walking, of ver. 4, the moral necessity of which Paul wishes to demonstrate, whether it be on the side of the flesh or on that of the Spirit. — The /, ego, is distinct from both tendencies; but it yields itself without fail to the one or the other — to the former, as the / of the natural man ; to the latter, as the I of the regenerate man. As its state, so is its tendency ; as its tendency, so is its conduct.
Romans 8:5–6 · Open Word Bible
5Those who are under the rule of the flesh have their minds fixed on the concerns of the flesh, but those under the rule of the Spirit, on the concerns of the Spirit. 6The outlook of the flesh means death, but the outlook of the Spirit means life and peace.
Ver. 6 explains (yap, for) the moral necessity with which this motion constantly proceeds, from the inward moral state to aspiration, and from aspiration to action. There is on both sides, as it were, a fated end to be reached, which acts at a distance on the will by an attraction like that which is exercised by a precipice on the current of a river as it approaches it No doubt one might take the words death and life as characterizing the two tendencies themselves. But the argument does not find so natural an explanation thus, as if we take the two words to express the inevitable goal to which man is inwardly impelled in both ways. This goal is death on the one hand, life on the other. The flesh tends to the former ; for to gain the complete liberty after which it aspires, it needs a more and more complete separation from God ; and tiliis is death. The spirit, on the contrary, thirsts for life in God, which is its element, and sacrifices everything to succeed in enjoying it perfectly. Neither of these two powers leaves a man at rest till it has brought him to its goal, whether to that state of death in which not a spark of life remains, or to that perfect life from which the last vestige of death has disappeared.— Death is here, as in rer. 2, separation from God, ... by a ... at length ... death in eternal perdition (vi 23). Life, in ... denotes a fully satisfied existence, in ... aU the faculties find their full exercise and their true occupation. Han's spirit, become the abode and organ of the Divine Spirit, zealizes this life with a growing perfection to eternal life. Peace is ... inward feeling of tranquillity which accompanies such an existence ; it shows itself particularly in the absence of aH fear in negard to death and judgment (v. ... ...
... There is no changing the nature of these two states and walks (ver. 5), and no arresting the latter in its onward march (ver. 6). The way of salvation is to pass from the first to the second, and not to relapse thereafter from the second to the first The two theses of ver. 6 are justified in the following verses, the former in w. 7 and 8, the latter in w. 9 to 11.
Vv. 7, 8. '* Beeofuee the aspiration of the flesh is enmity againtt God : for it is not subject to the law of God, neither can it he. And they that are in the ... cawnot please God!' — The flesh tends to death (ver. 6) ; for it is in its essence hatred of God, The conjunction ... literally, ... cf the fact that, announces an explanation which indeed follows. The flesh, the life of the / for itself, must be hostile to God ; for it feels that all it gives its idol it takes from God, and all it would bestow on God it would take away from its idol. Emnity to God is therefore only the reverse side of its attachment to itself, that is to say, it belongs to its essence. This enmity is proved by two] facts, the one belonging to man as related to God (ver. ... the other to God as related to man (ver. 8). The first is the revolt of the flesh against the divine will ; this feeling is mentioned first as a simple fact. The flesh wishes to satisfy itself: most frequently the law withstands it ; hence inward revolt always, and often external revolt. And this ... need not surprise us. The ... is what it is ; it eannot change its nature, any more tiian God can change the nature of His law. Hence an inevitable and perpetual conflict, which can only come to an end with the dominion of the flesh over the will Kow this conflict is the way of death ; oomp. GaL vi. 8.
Romans 8:7–8 · Open Word Bible
7That is because the outlook of the flesh is at war with God. It does not bow to God's law, and in fact it is not able to. 8People who are in the flesh have no power to please God.
Yer. 8. On the other hand God is no more the friend of the flesh than the flesh is of Him. The ie has been understood in all: sorts of ways from Meyer, who understands it in the sense of now then, to Calvin and Flatt, who give it the sense of therefore (ergo) ! It is a simple adversative : and on the other hand. The enmity is as it were natural For the abstract principle, the flesh, Paul here substitutes the carnal individuals ; he thus approaches the direct application to his readers which follows in ver. 9. — To he in the ... is a still stronger expression than to he after the flesh, ver. 5. According to this latter, the flesh is the standard of moral existence ; according to the former, it is ... or sourca Now, how could God take pleasure in beings who have as the principle of their life the pursuit of self ? Is this not the principle opposed to His essence ? — Thus, then, carnal beings, already involved in spiritual death, plunge themselves in it ever deeper and deeper; and consequently for them condemnation remains, and is all that remains ; while spiritual men rise on the ladder of life to that perfect existence wherein the last trace of condemnation, physical death itself, will disappear (w. 9 to 11).
Romans 8:8 · Open Word Bible
8People who are in the flesh have no power to please God.
Ver. 9. " ... as for you, ye are not under the dominion of the flesh, ... under that of the Spirit, if the Spirit of God really dwell in you. But if any man have not the Spirit of Christ, he is none of His'' — In thus apostrophising his readers directly, the apostle wishes to bring them to examine themselves, in order to know which of these two currents they are obeying ; for we easily apprehend these truths with the understanding, but we are slow to apply them to ourselves personally. He begins with expressing a feeling of confidence in regard to their state ; but he adds a restriction fitted to excite their vigilance : ... if really. This word does not positively express a doubt, as ... would do, if at least (Col. i. 23). Paul proceeds on their Christian profession to draw from it a sure consequence in the supposed case of their profession being serious. To them it belongs to verify the truth of the supposition. The expression : to duxll in yott, denotes a permanent fact; it is not enough to have some seasons of impulse, some outbursts of enthusiasm, mingled with practical infidelities — This first proposition of ver. 9 is the foundation of an argument ... will be prolonged to the dose of ver. 11. Before continuing it the apostle throws in by the way the serious warning contained in ver. 9b, which raises the supposition contrary to that of the ... if really, and shows also the consequence which would flow from it It is remarkable that the Spirit of Christ is here used as the equivalent of the Spirit of God in the preceding proposition. The Spirit of Jesus is that of God Himself, whom He has converted by appropriating Him perfectly here below into His personal life, so that He can communicate Him to His own. It is in this form that the Holy Spirit henceforth acts in the Church. Where this vital bond does not exist between a soul and Christ, it remains a stranger to Him and His salvation. After this observation, which every one is expected to apply to himself, the argument recommences, connecting ... with the favourable supposition enunciated ver. 9a.
Romans 8:9 · Open Word Bible
9But you are not in the flesh; you are in the Spirit, if God's Spirit really does live in you. If anyone lacks the Spirit of Christ, that person is not His.
Ver. 10. " Now if Christ he in you, the hody is dead "because of sin ; but the spirit is life because of — As the apostle had substituted the Spirit of Christ for the Spirit of God, he now substitutes for the Spirit of Christ His person : Now if Christ be in you, " Where the Spirit of Christ is," says Hofinann, " there He is also Himself." In fact, as the Spirit proceeds from Christ, His action tends to make Christ live in us. "1 shall come again to you," said Jesus (John xiv. 17, 18), when He was describing the work of the Spirit. This new expression brings out more forcibly than the preceding the solidarity between the person of Jesus and ours, and so prepares for ver. 11, in which the resurrection of Jesus is set forth as the pledge of ours. — This hope of sharing His resurrection rests on the fact that even now His life has penetrated the spiritual part of our being (ver. ... No doubt this spiritual life will not prevent the body from dying ; but it is the earnest of its participation in the resurrection of Christ From chap. v. 12, 15, and 17, we know the apostle's view respecting the cause of death: "Through one man's ofience rnany are dead." The fact of universal death does not therefore arise from ... sins of individuals, but from the original transgression. The meaning of these words : because of sin, is thus fixed ; they refer to Adani's sia It is some- 74 ... times asked why believers still die if Chiist leally died for them ; and an aigoment is drawn hence against the doctrine of expiation. But it is forgotten that, death not being ... individnal punishment, there is no connection between this fact and the pardon of sins granted to believing individuals. ...
Romans 8:10 · Open Word Bible
10But if Christ is in you, the body is marked for death because of sin, but the Spirit is life for you because of righteousness.
... Death, as a judgment on humanity, bearing on the apedes as such, remains till the general consummation of Christ's work ; comp. 1 Cor. xv. 26. — The term dead here signifies: ... smitten with death. The human body bears within itself from its formation the germ of death ; it begins to die the instant it begins to live. Commentators who, like Chrys., Er., Grot., explain this term dead, as dead ... am (in a good sense), evidently do not ... the course of thought in these verses, 9-1 1 — But if the believers ... cannot 'be prevented, there is a domain in him where life has already established its reign, the ... in which Christ dwells. ... mann insists strongly that the term spirit should here be applied to the Spirit of .God. In that case the words : the ... is life, must be understood in the sense: the spirit produces and sustains life in the soul. But this sense is unnatural, and the contrast between spirit and lady leads us rather to apply the former term to the spiritual element in the believer. In the passage, 1 Thess. v. 23, Paul distinguishes these three elements in man : body, said, and spirit. By the third term he denotes the organ with which the soul of man, and of man alone of all animated brings, is endowed, whereby he perceives and appropriates the divine ; by this spiritual faculty it is that the Spirit of God can penetrate into the soul, and by it rule the body. Hence arises the sanctification of the body (vi 11-13), not its deliverance from death. But Paul can already say, nevertheless, that in consequence of its union with the Spirit of God the Bpint of the believer is life. This expression no doubt sounds somewhat strong ; why not say simply : living f This peculiarity seems to have been observed very eaxly ; it ... certainly the origin of the reading S, lives, instead of ... life, in two Greco-Latia MSS. ; but Paul's thought went further. ... ...
... We nnut theiefore take the word ... in the sense ... as in chaps. L-Y. To this meaning we are also led by the meaning of the ... whidi forms an antithesis to this in the first propositkm : lecause of ... As the body dies becanse of a sin which is not ours individually, so the spirit lives in ... of a righteousness which is not ours. — But will tiiis body, given over to death, be abandoned to it for ever ? If o ; the last trace of condenmation behoves to be effaced
Yer. 11. '* Now, if the Spirit of Him that raised up Jesus from the dead dwell ... you, He that raised up Christ Jesus from the dead shall also ' ... yowr mortal bodies, because of His Spirit that dwelleth in you" — The 5, now, denotes the progress of the life which, after penetrating the spirit, takes hold even of the body. That body in which, as well as in Jesus, the Spirit of God has dwelt, will be judged worthy of the same honour as the body of Jesus Himself — In the first proposition the apostle uses the name Jesus, because the reference is to His person merely ; in the second he says Christ, or Christ Jesus, because the subject in question is the office He fills as Mediator between God and us. As Hofmann remarks, the personal resurrection of Jesus merely assures us that God am raise us ; but His resurrection, regarded as that of the Christ, assures us that He trill do so actually. Once again we see how ... Paul weighs every term he uses. We have a new proof of the same in the use of the two expressions ... to awake (applied to Jesus), and ... to qwicken (applied to believers). The death of Jesus was a sleep, unaccompanied with any dissolution of the body . . . ; it was ... enough to awake Him. In our case, the body, being Tfaiee principal readings: T. R, with E L P: w ... K A B:
• The 8d ... of Stephens, with ... 10 Mnn. It. ... Ciop.
Romans 8:11 · Open Word Bible
11And if the Spirit of the one who raised Jesus from the dead has made a home in you, then God, who raised Christ Jesus from the dead, will bring your mortal bodies to life as well, because His Spirit lives in you.
Why does he here substitute the term mortal, ... It has been thought that he used this word, which has a wider meaning, to embrace those who shall he alive at the Lord's coming, and whose bodies shall be not raised, but transformed. Hofzoann takes the term mortal, of ver. 1 0, as referring to the ... state of the body, the state of death to which it is still only destined, and from which the resurrection will rescue it The true explanation of the term seems to me simpler : In ver. 10, Paul means to speak of the fact (death) ; in ver. 11, of the quality (mortal). For the resurrection will not only change the fact of death into that of life, but it will transform the ... of the body, which from being mortal will become incorruptible (1 Cor. xv. 43, 44).
The last words of this verse played a somewhat important part dogmatically in the first ages of the church. Those who maintained the divinity and personality of the Holy Spirit were more inclined to read, as is done by some ancient Alex. Mjj., ... Holy Spirit who dwelleth in you." — In fact, by this mode of expression the apostle would ascribe the ... operation of raising from the dead (John v. 21) to the Holy Spirit, which would imply His power of free causation as well as divinity. The opponents of this doctrine alleged the other reading, which is that of Stephens, and which ... here from the received reading : ... because of the Spirit thai ... in you!' This reading is found in authorities of the three families in the oldest versions, the Itala and the Peschito, and in some very ancient Fathers, such as ... and Origen. Such being the case, we can only ascribe it to Tischendorf ... provoking predilection for the Sinatt., that he adopts the first reading in his eighth edition. Indeed, so far as external authorities are concerned, the decisive fact is the well-attested existence of a reading in the documents of the various countries of the church ; now in this case we find the reading ... to . . ., because of, in Egypt (Vatic), in the West (It. Fathers) in Syria (Feschito), and in the Byzantine Church ... while the received reading is represented by little more than three Alexandrines and a Father of the same country (Clement). The meaning also decides in favour of the best supported reading. The Buz with the accusative, because of, follows quite naturally the two similar Sea of ver. 10: ''because of sin death; because of righteousness, the life of the Spirit ; and because of the life of the Spirit, the resurrection of the body. The entire course of thought is summed up in this thrice repeated ... of. Besides, Paul is not concerned to explain here by what agent the resurrection is effected. ...
... What is of importance in the line of the ideas presented from ver. 5 onwards, is to indicate the moral state in consequence of which the granting of resurrection will be possible. That to which God will have respect, is the dwelling of His own Spirit in the believer; the holy use which he shall have made of his body to glorify Him ; the dignity to which the Spirit shall have raised the body by making it a temple of God (1 Cor. vL 19). Such a body He will treat as He has treated that of His own Son. This is the glorious thought with which the apostle closes this passage and completes the development of the word : no ... This difference of reading is the only one in the whole Epistle to the Romans which is fitted to exercise any influence on Christian doctrine. And yet we do not think that the question whether the resurrection of the body takes place by the operation of the Holy Spirit, or because of His dwelling in us, has been very often discussed in our Dogmatics or treated in our Catechisms.
The apostle does not speak of the lot reserved for the bodies of imbelievers, or of unsanctified believers. The same is the case in the passage 1 Cor. xv. 20-28. But the word of ver. 13: " If ye live after the flesh, ye shall die/' should suffice. That is not, especially after aU that precedes, a word of salvation. Besides, what would be meant by the sharp contrast between the two propositions of w. 5 and 6 ? We have to explain his silence by his aim, which was to expound the work of salvation to its completion. It is the same with 1 Cor. XV. 20-28.— We believe, finally, that after that it is quite unnecessary to refute the opinion of those who, like de Wette, Philippic Eolsten, think the expression : to quichen ... hody, ver. 11, should be applied in whole or in part to the ... of the Christian's body ; Paul does not ... up questions so; he spoke, in rer. 2, of two laws to be destroyed, that of sin and that of death. And he has rigorously followed the order which he traced for himself.
Yv. 12, 13. Thus then, brethren, we are imder obligation, not to ... to live after the flesh; for if ye live after the flesh, ye shall die ; but if ye through the Spirit do mortify the deeds of the body} ye shall live.** — It is not enough to have received the Spirit ; it is also necessary to walk according to Him. The thtu then refers to the thought of the preceding passage : ' Since the Spirit has set you free from the law of sin and death, do not replace yourselves under this curse/' The address : ... reappears every time the apostle wishes to bring home to his readers a practical and personal warning. — When saying: we are under obligation, literally, debtors, Paul meant to continue in the words : to the Spirit, to live according to Him. As soon as the Spirit comes to dwell in ... hearty we are tmder debt to Him for ... and for a life ... to His wishes. But the apostle breaks off his sentence to set aside the opposite ... one ... whidh cannot be passed over in silence, and be makes haste to add: ... to ths flesh. The nattoral man/' ... observes " imagines that he owes it to his flesh to satisfy if' The care of his person, from the most earthly point of Tiew, appears to him the first and most important of his obligationa Now it is this tendency which is combated by the Spirit as soon as He takes possession of ns (Gal. t. 1 7). llus is the debt which should neither be acknowledged nor paid. The apostle says why in the following verse.
Romans 8:12–13 · Open Word Bible
12So then, brothers and sisters, we are under an obligation, but not to the flesh, to live as the flesh dictates. 13If you live as the flesh dictates, you are headed for death. But if by the Spirit you keep putting the body's practices to death, you will live.
Freed from Sin and Death, the Christian hecomes Son and Seir.
Victory over sin and death once decided by the reign ... the Holy Spirit, condemnation is not only taken away, it is replaced by the benediction which is given to us in all its degrees: in the present, Hie filial state, adoption; in the future, the divine inheritance.
Yv. 12 and 13 form the transition from the ... passage to this. The life of the Spirit is not realized in the believer without his concurrence merely from the fact that the Spirit has once been communicated to him. There is needed on man's part a persevering decision, an active docility in giving himself over to the guidance of the Spirit For the guidance of the Spirit tends constantly to the sacrifice of the flesh ; and if the believer refuses to follow it on this path, he renounces the life of the Spirit and its glorious privilegea
Romans 8:12–17 · Open Word Bible
12So then, brothers and sisters, we are under an obligation, but not to the flesh, to live as the flesh dictates. 13If you live as the flesh dictates, you are headed for death. But if by the Spirit you keep putting the body's practices to death, you will live. 14Those whom God's Spirit is leading are God's children. …
Yer. 1 3. In this way the regenerate man himself would go on to death. So the flesh will reward us for our fldelity in discharging our debt to it — ... there is nothing for you but to die ;*such is the only future which awaits you." Now was the time to resume the sentence which had been begun : '' Ye are under obligation . . , to the Spirit!* But the apostle supposes this idea to come out clearly enough from the expressed contrast : not to the ... and continues as if he had expressed it : " But if through the Spirit etc. Whither does this principle, whose impelling power takes the place of the flesh, lead us ? To death also ; to the death of the flesh, and thereby to life : ye shall live. The rhythm of this verse is quite similar to that observed by Calvin in vii. 9, 10 ; 13a, the life of the flesh is the death of man ; ... the death of the flesh is the life of man. Why does the apostle say : the works of the body, and not of the flesh t This difference already struck certain Greco-Latin copyists, who have sought to correct the text in this direction. But it is unnecessary. The complement : of the iody, is not here the genitive of the instrument, but that of ... avthor. The acts of which the body is the simple ... are not its ... Paul would suppress those of which it is the independent author, and wherein, consequently, it ... from the dominion of the Spirit. These should come to an end, because in the Christian the Spirit should direct and penetrate aS, even his eating and drinking, according to the example quoted by the apostle, 1 Cor. X. 31. In all these acts of life the body should not goide but be guided. ...
Romans 8:13 · Open Word Bible
13If you live as the flesh dictates, you are headed for death. But if by the Spirit you keep putting the body's practices to death, you will live.
... Every act of sacrifice whereby the independence of the body is denied, and its submission to the Spirit forcibly asserted, secures a growth of spiritual life in man. It is only as a void is cleared in the domain of the flesh, that the efficacy of the Spirit shows itself with new force. Thus is explained the ye shall live, which applies to every moment of the believer's existence on to the state of perfection. — This last word : ye shall live, becomes the theme of the following passage. For the two attributes son and heir of God, which are about to be developed, the one in v v. 14-16, the other in ver. 17, exhaust the notion of life,
Vv. 14, 15. " For all they who are led by the Spirit of God, they are the sons of God. For ye have not received a spirit of bondage again to fear ; ... ye have received a Spirit of adoption, whereby we cry ; ... Father ! " — ... literally : " as Tnany as there are of them who are led , . , they are " ... The ... refers to the promise : ye shall live. It is impossible for one who is a Son of God, the source of life, not to live. Now he who gives himself to be guided by the Spirit of God, is certainly a son of God. The thought expressed in this verse may be understood in two ways. Does Paul mean that living according to the Spirit is the proof that one possesses the rank of a child of God ? In that case this would follow from the grace of justification ; and the gift of the Spirit would be a subsequent gift coming to seal this glorious acquired position. In favour of this view there might be quoted Gal. iv. 6 : " Because ye are sons, God hath sent forth the Spirit of His Son into your hearts." But it must not be forgotten that Paul 13 not here speaking of the gift of the Spirit, but of the believer's surrender to His influences. The reference therefore is to a more advanced stage of the Christian life. The other possible meaning is this : " Ye have a right to the title of sans as soon as ye let yourselves be led by the Spirit" And this meaning evidently suits the context better. Though one becomes a son by justification, he does not possess the filial staie, he does not really enjoy adoption until he has become loyally submissive to the operation of the Spirit. ...
Romans 8:14–15 · Open Word Bible
14Those whom God's Spirit is leading are God's children. 15What you received was not a spirit of slavery that would put you back under fear. You received the Spirit of adoption as children, and in the Spirit we call out, "Abba, Father!"
... The meaning is therefore this : " If ye let yourselves be led by the Spirit, ye are ipso facto sons of Godr — Meyer gives the pronoun ohro, they, an exclusive sense : " they only." But we are no longer at the warning ; the apostle is now proving the : ye shall live (for). The restrictive intention is therefore foreign to his thought, he is making a strong affirmation. — In the term ... are led, there is something like a notion of holy violence ; the Spirit drags the man where the flesh would fain not go. The verb may be taken in the passive : are driven, or in the middle : ... be driven. — The intentional repetition of the word God establishes a close connection between the two ideas: obeying the Spirit and being sons. A son obeys his father. The term ... son, implies community of nature and all the privileges which flow from it ; consequentiy, when God is the father, participation in life, — The apostle gives in what follows two proofs of the reality of this state of sonship : the one, partiy subjective, the filial feeling toward God experienced by the believer, ver. 15 ; the other, objective, the testimony of the Divine Spirit proclaiming: the divine fatiierhood within his heart, ver. 16.
Ver. 15. The ancients were much perplexed to ... expression : Ye have not received a spirit of bondage. It. seemed to them to imply the idea, that a servile spirit ... been given to the readers previously by God Himself. . Hence the explanation of Ghiysostom, who applied the spirit of bondage to the law. This meaning is inadmissible. It would be preferable to understand it of the mercenary and timidn spirit which accompanied legal obedience. But could Paul possibly ascribe this to a divine communication? If we connect the adverb ... again, as we should do, not with the verb ... ye received, but only with the regimen ... to fear, there is nothing in the expression obliging us to hold that Paul has in view an anterior divine communication; for the meaning is this: ''The Spirit which ye have received of God is not a servile spirit ... you back into the fear in which ye formerly lived." Comp. 2 Tim. L 7. The character of heathen religions is in fact the sentiment of fear ... Acts xvii 22). And was it not in some respects the same among the Jews, though with them the fear of Jehovah took a more elevated character than the fear of the gods among the Gentiles ? The feeling with which the Spirit of God fills the ... heart is not fear, suited to the condition of a slave, but the confidence and liberty which ... a son. — The word spirit might here be ... as denoting ... disposition ; as in that word of the Lord in leference to Sennacherib (Isa. xzxvii. 7) : '' I will put ... a spirit in him, that he will return to his own land ;" oomp. ... Here it would be the ... in relation to God. What might support this subjective meaning of the word spirit, is the strongly emphasized contrast between this verse and the following, where the objective meaning is evident : " The Spirit Himself beareth witness " ... ...
Romans 8:15 · Open Word Bible
15What you received was not a spirit of slavery that would put you back under fear. You received the Spirit of adoption as children, and in the Spirit we call out, "Abba, Father!"
... Nevertheless it is impossible, if we consider the connection between ver. 15 and the preceding verse, not to see in the Spirit of adoption, of which Paul here speaks, the Spirit of God Himself; comp. especially GaL iv. 6, a passage so like ours, and where there is no room for uncertainty. The difference between w. 15 and 16, so far as the meaning of the word spirit is concerned, is not the difference between an inward disposition and the Spirit of God, but rather that which distinguishes two different modes of acting, followed by one and the same Holy Spirit In the former case, the operation ... the Spirit makes itself felt by means of a personal disposition which He produces in us ; in the second case it is still more direct (see on ver. 16). — The Spirit of adoption is the Spirit of God, in so far as producing the spiritual state ... to sonship ; He may even be called : the Spirit •f the Son Himself, ... iv. 6. He puts us relatively to God in the same position as Jesus, when He said : Father ! ... To become ... we must be incorporated into Him by faith ... . — The pronoun ... in whom, shows that it is wider the in spiration of the filial sentiment produced in us by this Spirit that we thus pray, and the term cry expresses the profound emotion with which this ... of adoration goes forth from the believing heart. — Ahba is the form which the Hebrew word ... father, had taken in the Aramaic language, commonly •poken in Palestine in the time of Jesus. It was thus Jesus spoke to God when He called Him Father ; comp. Mark ziv. 36. It has been thought Paul employed the form Here, because he made use of it habitually in his own prayers, and that he added the Greek translation : o ... in writing to ... Romans and to the Galatians, because the Aramaic was ... to them as former Gentiles. ...
... But the employment of the expression (which occurs in three writings of the K. T.) must ... on a more general usage. like the terms Amen, Sbsanna, Hidldujdh, this word Abba had no doubt passed from the ... language of the primitive ... church into general ecclesiastical language. By adapting this sacred form of address, which had passed through the mouth of Jesus ... to the worship of Christians, not only was there a compliance with the command : '' When ye pray, say: ... Alia ... art in heaven" but the feeling of the whole church seemed to blend with that of its High Priest, who had prayed, using the same term for Himself and His brethren. From regard to Greek-speaking Christians, and neophytes in particular, the custom was probably followed of adding the Gieek translation : 6 ... father, as is done by Mark. Augustine and Calvin suppose that it was meant, by using these two forms in juxtaposition, to express the union of Jewish and Gentile-Christians in one spiritual body. This hypothesis has no great probability.
Vv. 16, 17. " The /Spirit itadf ... to our spirit, that we are the children of God. Now if children, then heirs of God, ... with Christ; if so he thai we ... with Sim, that we may he also glorified ... with Sim" — The asyndeton form (the absence of a connecting particle) between w. 15 and 16 indicates here, as always, profound emotion; it announces the more forcible reaffirmation of the same fact, but presented in a new aspect. The expression ... does not signify th same Spirit ... but the Spirit ... as the immediate organ of God All who , are not strangers to the experience of divine things, know that there is a difference between a state formed in us by tiie Divine Spirit, and expressing itself in the form of prayer (ver. 15), and the language in which God answers us directly by means of the ... This difference comes out in the following passage, when the apostle expressly distinguishes the groaning cf tiie Spirit Himself in those who have received ... first-fruits of the Spirit (ver. 26), from their own groaning (ver. 23). We observe a similar difference in the life cf Jesus Himself when it is He who says : 971 Father (Luke ii 84
Romans 8:16–17 · Open Word Bible
16The Spirit Himself joins our own spirit in testifying that we are God's children. 17If we are children, we are also heirs. We are God's heirs, and we inherit alongside Christ, if we suffer together with Him so that we will also be glorified together with Him.
al.), or when it is God who says to Him : Thou art my Son (Luke iii. 12). So, in this case the apostle means that we are sons of God, not only because our heart cherishes a filial disposition toward God, and inspires us with the cry of love: my Father; but — and this is still more sublime — because from the heart of God Himself there comes down the answer by the voice of the Holy Spirit : my child. It is not only our arms which are stretched out to take hold of God who gives Himself to us in Christ, but His at the same time which embrace us and draw us to His bosom — The ... with, in the verb ... to hear ... with should evidently preserve its natural meaning : '' bears witness conjointly with our spirit," the feeling of which was expressed in ver. 15. But the dative: ... to our spirit, is not to be regarded as the regimen of ... with (" bears witness with our rit")) it is our spirit which here receives the divine testimony. The term ... child, differs from ... son, ver. 14, in this, that the latter expresses rather the personal dignity and independence, the official character of the representative of a family, while the second has a more inward sense, and indicates rather community of life. In the one what is expressed is the position of honour, in the other the relation of nature.
Yer. 17. The apostle has proved the fact of our being sons or children, first by the filial feeling produced in us by the Spirit, and then by the direct witness of the Spirit Himself. He can now conclude his argument ; for even in expressing the most exalted sentiments, his exposition always assumes a logical form. He had said, w. 13 and 14: ''Ye shall live, for ye are sons ; " then he demonstrated the reality of this title son; and he now infers from it the condition of heirship. Thus the reasoning is concluded ; for to be an heir of God is identical with being a possessor of lifa — ... doubt God does not die, like those who leave an inheritance ; it is from the heart of His glory that He enriches his sons by communicating it to them, that is, by imparting Himself to them. For, rightly taken, His ... is Himself. The best He can give His children is to dwell in them. St. Paul expresses it when he describes the perfect state in the words (1 Cor. xv. 28) : God all in all. — But he here adds an expression particularly fitted to impress us with the sublimity of such a state : coheirs with Christ. The loftiness of the title heir of God might easily be lost in vagueness, unless the apostle, with the view of making this abstract idea palpable, added a concrete fact. To be an heir with Christ is not to inherit in the second instance, to inherit from Him ; it is to be put in the same rank as Himself; it is to share the divine possession ... Him. ...
Romans 8:17 · Open Word Bible
17If we are children, we are also heirs. We are God's heirs, and we inherit alongside Christ, if we suffer together with Him so that we will also be glorified together with Him.
... To get a glimpse of what is meant by the title ... of God, let us contemplate the relation between Christ and God, and we shall have an idea of what we are led to hope from our title sons of God; comp. ver. 29. — Only to reach the possession of the inheritance, there is yet one condition to be satisfied: if we suffer with Him. Paul knows well that, ambitious as we are of glory, we are equally ready .to recoil from the necessary suffering. Now it is precisely in suffering that the bond between Christ and us, in virtue of which we shall be able to become His co-heirs, is closely drawn. We only enter into possession of the common heritage of glory, by accepting our part in the common inheritance of suffering ; ... if so he ... are called to it, we have the courage to " . . . These last words are evidently the transition to the passage immediately following, in which are expounded, first the miserable state of the world in its present condition, but afterwards the certainty of the glorious state which awaits us.
Completion of the Plan of Salvation, ... the Miseries of our present Condition.
In speaking of the full victory gained by the Spirit of Christ over the last remains of condemnation, Paul seemed to assume that the work had already reached its goal, and that nothing remained but to pass into gloiy. But in the words : " If so be we suffer with Him," he had already given it to be understood that there remained to the children of God a career of suffering to be gone through in communion with Christ, and that the era of glory would only open to them after this painful interval. These two thoughts : the present state of suffering, and the certain gloiy in which it is to issue are the theme of the following passaga This piece, as it appeals to me, is one of those, the tenor of which has been most ... erven in the latest commentaries. It has been ... as a series of ... themes, presented by the apostle to suffering believera. They are the following three, according to Meyer : 1. The preponderance of future glory over present ... (w. 18-25) ; 2. the aid of the Holy Spirit (w. 26 and 27); 3. the working together of all things for the good of those who love God (w. 28-30). M. Beuss says on reaching ver. 28 : After hope (w. 18-25) and the ... (w. 26 and 27), the apostle mentions yet a third ... which is of a nature to support us, namely, '' that everything contributes to the good of them that love God." A little further on he adds : " To this end. Paul recapitulates the series of acts whereby God interposes in the salvation of the individual" A third ... this end ! Such expressions hardly suit our apostle's style ; and when one is obliged to have recourse to them, it simply proves that he has not grasped the course of his thoughts. ...
Romans 8:18–30 · Open Word Bible
18I have weighed it up: what we suffer in this present time does not begin to balance the glory that is going to be revealed to us. 19The created world cranes its neck in longing, waiting for God's children to be revealed. 20Creation was made subject to futility. This was not its own choice; it was because of the one who subjected it. Yet there was hope: …
... The same is the case with the division recently offered by Holsten, who here finds the hope of the Christian founded : 1. on the state of creation ; 2. on the groaning of believers ; 3. on the groaning of the Spirit ; 4. on the consciousness of believers that their very sufferings must turn to their good. How can one imagine that he has understood St Paul, when he lacerates his thoughts in this fashion ?
The following passage developes two ideas: the world's state of misery in its present condition, a state demonstrated by the groaning of the whole creation, by that of believers themselves, and finally by that of the Holy Spirit ; then in contrast, the certainty, ... all, of the perfect accomplishment of the glorious plan eternally conceived by God for our glory. The transition from the first idea to the second is found in the ... but we know, of ver. 28, where the adversative particle Be, hut, expressly establishes the contrast between the second idea and the first And first of all, the general theme, ver. 18, enunciating the two ideas to be developed : 1. The sufferings of (he ... time (the ... to suffer with, ver. 17), and 2. The glory yet to he revealed in us (the ... heing glorified ... with, ver. 1 7).
Yer. 18. ... the ... of this present time are not worthy to he compared with the glory ... shall he revealed in us." — The ... I reckon, here signifies: I judge after calculation made." The expressions which follow imply, indeed, the idea of a calculation. The adjective ... worthy, comes, as the old lexicographeis say, fiom the verb ... to drive, to cause to move, and denotes strictly a thing which is heavy enough to produce motion in the scale of the balanca The preposition ... is used here, as frequently, to denote proportion. Consequently, the apostle means that when, he compares the miseries imposed on him by the present state of things with the glory awaiting him in the future, he does not find that the former can be of any weight whatever in the balance of his resolutions. Why does he use the first person angular, I reckon, instead of speaking in the name of all Christians ? No doubt because he would have them verify his calculation themselves, each making it over again for himself. And he has good right to take the initiative in comparison with them, as evidently suffering more than all of them. — This present time denotes the actual conditions of our earthly life in contrast with those of the new world which succeeds it. These are, on the one hand, the miseries arising from bodily infirmities and the necessities of life ; on the other, those caused by the enmity of man and the sins of believers themselves. Paul, who endured more than any other of these two kinds of sufferings, yet calls them, 2 Cor. iv. 17 : the light affliction of the present rtuiment, in opposition to the ... weight of glory which he sees before him. — This ... is to be revealed ; it is therefore already ; and indeed it exists not only in the plan of God decreeing it to us, but also in the ... of Christ glorified, with whose appearing it will be visibly displayed. ...
Romans 8:18 · Open Word Bible
18I have weighed it up: what we suffer in this present time does not begin to balance the glory that is going to be revealed to us.
... The apostle adds ... in and for us. He ... have written ... in us; but this expression would have been insufficient For the glory will not consist only in our own transformation, but also in the coming of the Lord Himself, and the ... of the universe. Thus it will be displayed at onoe for us and in us; this is expressed by the ... Being unable to render the two relations into ... by a single preposition, we have preferred to express the second, which is the most comprehensive.
Yer. 19 begins the development of this general state of misery and waiting in which the church still participates, and which was denoted by the term : tlie sufferings ... this present time ... .
Yer. 19. "Far the earnest ... of the creation longeth for tlie manifestation of the sons of Godr — The for is usually made to refer to the idea of the glory yet to he revealed ver. 18. And this view is supported either by the greatness of this gloiy (de W., Hofmann), or by its certainty (Meyer), or by ita futurity (Philip.), or by the imminence of its manifestation (Eeiche). But not one of these affirmations is really proved in what foUows. What Paul demonstrates is simply the fact, that if we are already saved spiritually, we are far from being so also outwardly. In Biblical language : As to the spirit, we are in the age to come ; as to the body, in the present age. The for therefore refers to the sufferings of this present time. This strange discord forms the basis of our present condition; and this is what ver. 19 demonstrates by the waiting attitude which all nature betrays. Holsten, ever preoccupied with the alleged application of our Epistle to the Judeo-Christians of Rome, thus introduces the subject : ' The Judeo-Christians ask : But, if all wrath is taken away, why so much suffering still ? " We in turn ask : Is it only ... is it not ... Christian conscience which asks the question ?
Romans 8:19 · Open Word Bible
19The created world cranes its neck in longing, waiting for God's children to be revealed.
The Greek term which we have translated by the word eapectation, is one of those admirable words which the Oreek language easily forms. It is composed of three elements : ... the head ; ... to wait for, espy ; and ... from, from afar ; so : " to wait with the head raised, and the eye fixed on that point of the horizon from which the expected object is to come." What a plastic representation ! An artist might make a statue of hope out of this Greek term. The verb ... which we have translated by longeth for, is not less remarkable; it is composed of the simple verb ... to receive, and two prepositions : ix, ... of the haiids of and ... from, from afar ; so : " to receive something from the hands of one who extends it to you from ... This substantiye and verb together vividlj describe the attitude of the suffering creation, which in its entirety turns as it were an impatient look to the expected future. — What is to be understood here by the creation (Eng. version, ... creature) ? There is an astonishing variety of answers given to this question by commentators. The word 17 ... itself denotes either the creative act, or its result, the totality of created things. But very often it takes a more restricted meaning, which is indicated by the sense of the whole passage. Thus in this context we must ... with excluding believers from the creation. For in ver. 23 they are mentioned as forming a class by themselves. We must likewise cut off from it uvbelieving men, whether Jews or Gentiles. For of two things one or other must happen: either they will be converted before the expected time, and in that case they will themselves be found among the children of God, and will not form part of the creation (end of the ver. and ver. 21). Or if they are not then converted, they will not participate (even indirectly) in the glorious condition of the children of God. ...
... Consequently, since there can be no question in this context either of good angels or devils, it only remains to us to restrict the application of the word the creation to all the unintelligent beings which we usually comprise in the expression nature (in opposition to ... Thus are excluded the explanation of St Augustine, who understood by it unconverted men, and that of Locke and others, who applied it to unconverted Jews; that of Bohme, who applied it to the heathen ; the Arminian explanation, which took the word the creation in the sense of the new creation, and applied this term to Christians only; that of Luther, who in some passages seems to have restricted it to inanimate nature ; that of ... who sees in this term a designation of the flesh in the regenerate, etc. The explanation we have given is that most generally adopted (Er., Calv., Grot, ThoL, de Wette, Philip., Hofm., eta). It is confirmed by the following parallels: Matt xix. 28, where Jesus speaks of the palingenesia, or universal renovation which is to take place; Acts iiL 21, where Peter announces the restoration of all things ; and ... xxi. 1, where this event is described as the substitution of a new heaven and a new earth for the present heaven and earth.
The same ... of an ... renovation in the last timea is already opened up in the O. T. (Isa. xi. 1 ... seq., Ixv. ... 34) ; it follows from the fact of the fall of man in which nature was inyolved. Solidarity in the matter of restoration is naturally associated with solidarity in the ... In this prophetico-poetical passage the destination of nature is represented as its own expectation. This figurative expression becomes a truth in proportion as the beings themselves suffer from the general disorder.— The hour of ... is called the time of ... of the sons of God. This expression is explained by CoL iii 4: " When Christ, our life, shall be manifested, then ye also shall be manifested with Him in glory/' The appearing of the sons of God in their true sanctified nature, will break the bonds of the curse which stiU to this hour hold the creation in fetters ; oomp. Matt xiiL 43 ; 1 John iii 2. And Nature herself is impatient to see those new guests arrive, because she knows that to receive them she will don her fairest apparel. — In the following verses, Paul developes more fully that abnormal character of the present creation which he has just declared in ver. 19.
Yv. 20-22. "For the creation was made ... to vanity, not willingly, but by reason of him who hath ... the same in hope, because the creation itself also shall be delivered from the bondage of corruption into the glorious liberty of the children of God. For we know thai the whole creation groaneth together and travaileth as it were until now!* — The vanity to which nature is now subject, is the state of frailty to which all earthly beings are subjected. Everywhere,'' says M. Beuss, " our eyes meet images of death and decay ; the scourge of barrenness, the fury of the elements, the destructive instincts of beasts, the very laws which govern vegetation, everything gives nature a sombre hue " ... This reign of death which prevails over aU that is bom cannot be the normal state of a world created by God. ... suffers from a curse which it cannot have brought upon itself, as it is not morally free. It is not with its goodwill, says the apostle, that it appears in this ... but because of him who hath subfected it to such a ... does he meaxt ? According to most modern commentators: God. Was it not He who pranounced the sentence of doom : Cuised is the groond for thy sake " (Gren iii 17) ? ... This consideration has led one critic, Hammond, to apply the term to Saian, the prince of this world (as Jesus caUs him), who, either by his own fall or by that of man, dragged the creation into the miserable state here described The only room for hesitation, as it appears to me, is between the two latter meanings. — The regimen : in Jiope, can only refer to the term : ... haih subjected, if we apply it to (rod, which, as we have seen, is unnatural It depends therefore on the principal verb : was made subject to vanity, and signifies that from the first, when this chastisement was inflicted, it was so only with a future restoration in view. This hope, precisely like the ... ver. 1 9, is attributed to nature herself; she possesses in the feeling of her ... merited suffering a sort of presentiment of her future deliveranee.
Romans 8:20–22 · Open Word Bible
20Creation was made subject to futility. This was not its own choice; it was because of the one who subjected it. Yet there was hope: 21creation itself will also be released from its slavery to decay and will enter the freedom that comes with the glory of God's children. 22We know that all creation, to this very day, groans as one and suffers the pains of giving birth together.
Yer. 21. The conjunction or ... may be made directly dependent on the words in hope: ''in hope that'* Yer. 21 would then state wherein the hope itself consists. But we may also take it in the sense of because, and find in ... 21 the reason of the hope: "I say: with hope, because This indeed would be the only possible meaning if, with ... adopted the reading of the Sinait and the Greco-Latins : Ston, seeing that. In any case it is the natural sense ; for why otherwise would the apostle repeat in extenso the subject of the sentence : ... the creation itself t No writer will say : nature was made subject in the hope that Nature herself would be delivered. — The pronoun itself glances at a natural objection : one would not have expects such a fact in a being like Nature. The ical, also, even, refers to the same thought : the unintelligent creation ... less than men, — In the expression : the "bondage of corruption, the complement may signify : '' the bondage which consists of corruption*" But this complement may also be taken as the genitive of the object, subjection to ... as a law. This second meaning is undoubtedly better ; for the idea of enslavement is thus rendered more emphatic, in opposition to the idea of liberty in what ... term ... corruption, putrescence, is more forcible than the word vanity, and serves to define it more exactly. — Paul does not say that nature will participate in the glory, but only in the liberty of the glory of the children of God. Liberty is one of the elements of their glorious state, and it is the only one to which nature can lay claim. It expresses the unchecked development of the free expansion of all the powers of life, beauty, and perfection, wherewith this new natiure will be endowed. ...
Romans 8:21 · Open Word Bible
21creation itself will also be released from its slavery to decay and will enter the freedom that comes with the glory of God's children.
... Thera is nothing to show that the apostle has in view the return to life of the individual beings composing the present system of natura In the domains inferior to man, the individual is merely the temporary manifestation of the species. We have therefore to think here only of a new nature in its totality, differing from the old system in its constitution and laws.
Ver. 22. The hope expressed in ver. 21 is justified in ver. 22. By the word we know, Paul appeals, not as Ewald supposes, to an old book that has been lost, but to a book always open to those who have eyes to read it, nature itself, the daily sight of which proclaims loudly enough all the apostle here says. Is there not a cry of universal suffering, a woful sigh perpetuaUy ascending from the whole life of nature? Have not poets caught this vast groaning in every age ? has not their voice become its organ ? As ... said : On the loveliest spring day, while Nature is displaying aU her charms. does not the heart, when drinking in admiration, imbibe a poison of gnawing melancholy ? The preposition ... with, which enters into the composition of the two verbs, can only refer to the ... of all the beings of nature in this common groaning. But there is more than groaning in the case; there is effort, travail This is forcibly expressed by the second verb ... literally, to travail in hirth. It seems as if old Nature bore in her bosom the germ of a more perfect nature, and, as the poet says, sente bondir ... die ... univers " (feels in her womb the leaping of a new universe). — We should beware of giving to the expression until now the meaning assigned to it by de Wette and Meyer : from the first of time, or without interruption. This would be a superfluous observation. The context shows what Paul means: Until now, even after redemption is already ... plished. The renovating principle has transformed the domain of the Spirit ; for it became penetrated therewith at Pentecost. But the domain of nature has remained till now outside of its action. Comp. the ... apri, 1 Cor. iv. 13. It is in this respect with the whole as with the individual; comp. ver. 10.
Romans 8:22 · Open Word Bible
22We know that all creation, to this very day, groans as one and suffers the pains of giving birth together.
On the passage viii. 18-22. — In following the exposition of the work of salvation, the apostle touches a domain, that, namely, of nature, where he comes into contact with the labours of science. Is there harmony or variance between his teaching and the results of scientific study ? There is a first point on which the harmony is complete. For a century past the study of our globe has proved that the present condition of the earth is only the result of a series of profound and gradual transformations ; which leads us naturally to the conclusion that this state is not final, and should only be regarded as a temporary phase destined to pave the way for some other new transformation. So it is precisely that our earth appears to the view of the apostle enlightened by the Holy Spirit. But there is a second point on which the harmony does not seem so complete. The apostle traces the present state of ... and death to a catastrophe which has intervened, first in the moral world, and which has reacted on external nature. Kow modem science seems to prove that the present condition of the earth is a natural result of its whole previous development, and that the miseries belonging to it are rather remains of the primitive imperfection of matter than the efiects of a ... which intervened at a given moment Is death, for example, which reigns 94 ... over mankind, anything else than the continiiation of that to which the animal world was subject in the epochs anterior to man ? This is a serious objection. Putting ourselves at the apostle's point of view, we may answer it in two ways. ...
... If we apply to man the expression 6 ... he who ... (nature to vanity), it must be held that man placed in a privileged position, exempt from miseries in genersd and from death, with a body which life in God could raise above the law of dissolution, was called as the king of nature to free this magnificent domain from all the imperfections and miseries which it had inherited from previous ages. After developing all his faculties of knowledge and power in the favoured place where he had been put for this purpose, man should have extended this prosperous condition to the whole earth, and changed it into a paradise. . Natural history proves that a beneficial influence even on the animal world is not an impossibility. But in proportion as man failed in his civilising mission to nature, if one may so speak, it fell back under that law of vanity from which it should have been freed by him, and which weighed on it only the more heavily in consequence of man's corruption. Thus the apostle's view may be justified on this explaiiation. But if the term 6 ... he who ... refers to Satan, there opens up to our mind a still vaster survey over the development of nature. Satan is called — and Jesus Himself gives him the title — ... prince of this world. He who believes in the personal existence of Satan may therefore also hold that this earth belonged originally to his domain. Has it not been from the first steps of its development the theatre of the struggle between this revolted vassal and his divine liege-lord ? The history of Immanity is constantly showing us, both in great things and small, God taking the initiative and laying down some good, but that good hasting to alter its character by a progressive deviation, which leads slowly to the most enormous monstrosities. ...
... Might not primitive nature have been subject to a similar law, and the crisis of its development have resulted also from conflict between a beneficent force laying down a normal state, and that power of deviation which immediately takes hold of the divine product to guide it to the most abnormal result, till the salutary principle again interpose to establish a new point of departure superior to the former, and which the malignant ... will corrupt anew? From tiiis unceasing struggle proceeded the constant progress which terminated in man, and in the relatively perfect condition in which he originally appeared But the power of deviation showed itself immediately anew on tlie very theatre of paradise, and in the domain of Uberty produced ... which involved all again under the law of death, which is not yet finally vanqnished. It belongs to Chiisty to the children of God, the seed of the woman, man victorious over the serpent, his temporary tictor, to work out a deliverance which would have been the work of the race of mankind had it remained united to God. Perhaps this second point of view explains more fully the thought of the apostle expressed in this passage. — There is a third point on which science seems to us to harmonize readily with St. Paul's view ; I mean the close solidarity which exists between man and the whole of nature. The physiologist is forced to see in the human body ... intended ... of animal ... which appears as nothing else than a long effort to reach this consummation. As the breaking of the bud renders sterile the branch which bore it, so the fedl of man involved that of the world. As Schelling said in one of his admirable lectures on the philosophy of revelation: "Nature, with its melancholy ... resembles a bride who, at the veiy moment when she was fully attired for marriage, saw the bridegroom to whom she was to be tmited die on the very day fixed for the marriage. ...
... She still stands with her fresh crown and in her bridal dress, but her eyes are full of teais." The soul of the poet-philosopher here meets that of the ... The ancient thinkers spoke much of a sonl of the world. The idea was not a vain dream. The soul of the world is man. The whole Bible, and this important passage in particular, rest on this profound idea. The groaning of nature, of which the apostle has just spoken, is the expression and proof of the abnormal state to which it is subjected, with all the beings belonging to it. But it is not the only ... from this state of imperfection Other beings of a ... order, and which have already been restored to their normal state, also suffer from the same, and mingle their groaning with that of nature. This is the truth devdoped in w. 23-26.
Ver. 23. **And not only ... which have the ... of the Spirit, we ... groan ... for the adoption, the redemption of our lody." — The ... between this passage and the preceding one is 1 This was the Tiew-polnt of Steffeus in his ... on " Anthropology. "
* We quote ... memory.
96 ... obvious at a glance ; it is found in the idea of groaning. The groaning of believers themselves, men already animated with the breath of God, rises as it were on that of nature. Of the three or even four readings presented by the documents, we must first, whatever Volkmar may say to the contrary, set aside that of the Vatic,, which rejects the ... we, in the middle of the verse; this pronoun is indispensable to emphasize the contrast between believers and nature. And whence could it have come into all the other texts ? We may also set aside the Greco-Latin reading (D F G). By putting the pronoun : we ourselves also, at the beginning of the sentence, after the words : not only ... it obliterates the forcible ... which these words contain when placed in the middle of the sentence : " We also , . , we ourselves also ... The two other readings differ only in this, that the Alexandrine (t( A C) places the ... we, before ... ainol, while the Byzs. place it between the two words : and we ourselves. The difference of meaning is almost imperceptible (we ourselves also ; also we ourselves). It is probable that the Alexs. have displaced the ... toe, to bring it next the participle ... This is the reason why we have translated according to the received reading. — Several commentators have thought that in saying first we, then adding we ourselves also, the apostle meant to speak of two different subjects, for example. Christians and apostles ... or Christians and ... himself (Reiche). ...
Romans 8:23 · Open Word Bible
23And not creation alone. We ourselves, who have the Spirit as the first share of the harvest, also groan within ourselves while we long for our adoption as children, when our body will be redeemed.
... But in this case the article ... before the participle ... would be indispensable ; and what object could there be in such a distinction in the context ? — The logical connection between the participle ... having, possessing, and the verb ... we groan, should be rendered by the conjunction though : " Though already possessing, we still groan (ipsi nos habentes)** — The expression: the Jirst-- fruits of ilie Spirit, is so clear that it is difficult to understand how it should have given rise to dispute. How has it occurred to commentators like de Wette, Olshausen, Meyer, to apply it specially to the Spirit bestowed on the apostles and first believers, to distinguish it from the Spirit afterwards bestowed on other believers ? What importance can this difference have for the spiritual life, and where is a trace of such a distinction to be found in the K T. ? It would be preferable to regard the word ... (with Chrys., Calv., ThoL, Philip., Bonnet) as leferring to the fact that Christians here below receive only a beginning, while there will be given to them above the entire fulness of the Spirit In this sense the genitive would be the complement of the object : ... first-fruits of that gift which is the Spirit. But the apostle is not here contrasting an imperfect with a more perfect spiritual state ; he is contrasting an ... state already relatively perfect, with an ... state which has not yet participated in the spiritual renewal ; this appears clearly from the last words : ... for the redemption of our body. The genitive is therefore the complement of quality or apposition : " The first-fruits which consist of the Spirit Himself." This meaning is proved, besides, by the attentive comparison of 2 Cor. i 22 and Eph. i. 14. ...
... The apostle means : " We ourselves, who by the possession of the Spirit have already entered inwardly into the new world, still groan, because there is a part of our being, the outer man, which does not yet enjoy this privilege." — Hofmann joins the regimen : ... ourselves, to the participle ... we who have within ourselves. But is it not superfluous to say that the Holy Spirit is possessed inwardly ? This regimen is very significant, on the contrary, if we connect it, as is grammatically natural, with the verb we groan : We groan often inwardly, even when others do not suspect it, and when they hear us proclaiming salvation as a fact already accomplished." The disharmony between the child of God and the child of the dust therefore still remains; and hence we wait for something.— This something St. Paul calls adoption, sad he explains it by the apposition : the redemption of our body. No doubt our adoption is in point of right an acquired fact (GaL iv. 6). It is so in reality on its spiritual side, for we already possess the Spirit of ... Father, as Paul has developed it, vv. 14-16. But the state of sons of God will not be fully realized in us until to the holiness of the Spirit there be added the glory and perfection of the body. It needs hardly be said that the expression : the redemption of our body, is not to be interpreted in the sens : that we are to be delivered from our body (Oltram.). For this idea, applied to the body itself, would be anti-biblical ; faith waits for a new body ; and if it applied to the body only as the body of our humiliation, as
Paul says, ... iiL 21, this specification would require to be added, or at least Paul would require to say ... present tody. The complement of the body is therefore eyidently the genitive, not of the object, but of the subject : it is the body itself which is to be ... from the miseries of its present corruption. We see from 2 Cor. ... 4 that Paul desired not to be ... but to he clothed ... that is, to receive his glorified body, by the power of which ... mortal body was to be as it were swallowed up. It is by the transformation of the body only that we shall become completely sons of God. Comp. the ... which is not identical, but analogous, made in reference to Christ Himself, i
Vv. 24, 25. "For we are saved ... hit hope ... is net hope; for what a ... seeth, why would he yet hope fort Now if we hope for that toe see not, then do we with patience wait for it'' — Yer. 24 uses one of the three constituent elements of the Christian life, namely hope (1 Cor. xiii 13), to demonstrate the reality of that state of groaning and expectation which has just been ascribed to believers On the one hand, undoubtedly salvation is a thing finished; this is indicated by the aorist ... we were saved. But, on the other hand, this salvation having as yet penetrated only to the spiritual part of our being, is not fully realized, and leaves room for awaiting a more complete realization. Hence the restrictive specification ... hope. This word, from its position at the beginning of the sentence, evidently has the emphasis. This dative is, as ... says, a dativus modi, signifying: *'in the way of hope.*' The meaning therefore is :'' If we are saved, which is certain, this holds true only when we ... account of the element of hope which continues always in our present state." We must not, like Chiys., de Wette, Bilck., identify hope with faith, and find here the idea of salvation by faith. The whole context shows that it is really of hope in the strict and special meaning of the word that Paul is speaking. Already in the apostolic age we find persons who, intoxicated with a feeling of false spiritualism, of ... gave oat that salvation ... only man's higher nature, and who abandoned the bod ... to everlasting destruction ; so those ... of Connth who denied the resurrection of the body ... and those heretics of Asia Minor who alleged that the ... was already past (2 Tim, ii. 18), probably because they confounded it with moral regeneration. Were there such men at Some ? Paul must have had some reason for insisting, as be does here, on the outward and future consummation of the edifice of salvation. ...
Romans 8:24–25 · Open Word Bible
24It was in hope that we were saved. But a hope that is already in sight is no hope at all. Who goes on hoping for what is already in front of them? 25But if what we hope for is something we do not yet see, we keep waiting for it with endurance.
... The meaning of the last two propositions of ver. 24 is clear : '* Now, hope implies non-possession." In the words : ... that is seen, the term hope is taken for the object hoped for, as is often the case, CoL i. 5 for example. In the worda following, the tarm resumes its subjective meaning. The last proposition has been amended by the copyists in all sorts of ways. In our translation we hove rendered the T. R The Greco-Latin text rejecting the luU, yet, signifies : " For what one sees, why would he hope ... The SmaU. : *' What one sees, he also hopes for/* or ' does he also hope for 1 — a reading which in the ... has no meaning. The Vatie. : What one sees, does he hope for ? " This is the reading which Yolkmar prefers ; for in regard to the Vatie. he gives himself up to the same predilection with which he rightly charges Tischendorf in regard to the Siruat This reading is impossible. It would require ... instead of what : " When one sees, does he hope ? " — The zeal, yet, ia by no means superfluous : yet, after sight has begun, along with sight, hope has no more place.
Yen 25. This verse is not, as Meyer thinks, a deduction fitted to dose the first reason of encouragement In this case an ... would have been necessary ... than ... now, or but. The meaning but (Osterv., Oltram.) well suits the contrast between the ideas of hoping (ver. 25) and seeing (ver. 24). Yet it seems to me that the meaning ... is preferable. It is not a conclusion ; it is a step in the argument intended to prove the painful state of waiting attaching even to believers. The emphasis is on the words Bt ... with patience, and the general meaning is this : '* Now, obliged as we yet are to hope without seeing, waiting necessarily takes the character of ... To understand this ... it is enough to recall the etymological meaning of the vord ... to hold out under a hurden. We wait wUh patience amounts therefore to saying : '' It is only by holding out under the burden of present sufferings that we can expect with certainty the hoped-for future." The conclusion is this : We are not therefore yet in our normal condition; otherwise why endurance ?
Vv. 26, 27. ''And likewise the Spirit also helpeth our infirmity ; for we know not what we should ask in order to pray as we ought, ... the ... itself ... intercession with groanings which cannot he uttered. But He that searcheth the hearts knoweth what is the aspiration of the Spirit, because He ... intercession for the saints — As the apostle had passed from the groaning of imiversal nature to that of the children of God, he now rises from the latter to that of the Holy Spirit Himself. This gradation is so evident that one is astonished it could have remained unobserved by so many commentators (see for example Meyer). But we must remark the significant difference between this second transition and the former. In passing from the groaning of nature to that of believers, he said: not only , . , but also. Now he simply says : and likewise also. There is no contrast indicated here ; for the groaning of the Spirit is homogeneous with that of believers {likewise), though distinct from it notwithstanding (also), and though there is a gradation from the one to the other ... which we have rendered by arid). —If, with the Byzs., we read the plural ... our ... the word would denote the moral infirmities of believers. But so general an idea is out of place in the context. We must therefore prefer the Alex, reading: t ... our infirmity. This expression refers to a special infirmity, the fainting condition with which the believer is sometimes overtaken under the weight of present suffering ; it is the want which makes itself felt in his ... that constancy, the necessity of which had been ... in the pre- ... a word to which F G add: ... Terse. The reading of F G : owr toeakness in prayer, would refer to our ignorance as to what should be asked (the proposition following). But this so weakly supported reading is certainly a gloss. ...
Romans 8:26–27 · Open Word Bible
26In the same way, the Spirit also lends a hand in our weakness. What we should pray for, and how, we do not know. But the Spirit Himself pleads on our behalf, with groans that no words carry. 27And God, who looks deep into hearts, knows what the Spirit intends, because the Spirit pleads for God's holy people in line with what God wants.
... Iniinnityin prayer enters into the weakness of which the apostle speaks, but does not constitute the whole of it. The verb ... to support, come to the help of, is one of those admirable words easily formed by the Greek language ; ... (the middle), to take a burden on oneself; ... wUh some one ; ... in his place ; so: to share a burden with one with the view of easing him ; comp. Luke x. 40. This verb is usually followed by a ... sonal regimen, which leads us to take the abstract substantive here : our weakness, for : us weak ones ... The Spirit supports us in the hour when we are ready to faint. The end of the verse will explain wherein this aid consists. — Before describing it the apostle yet farther examines the notion : our infirmity. The case in question belongs to those times in which our tribulation is such that in praying we cannot express to God what the blessing is which would allay the distress of our heart We ourselves have no remedy to propose. The article to defines the whole following proposition taken as a substantive : " The : what we ... ask!' This is what we know not ourselves. The words as we ought do not refer to the Trumner of prayer (this would require ... but to its object, Jesus Himself was once in the perplexity of which the apostle here speaks. " Now is my soul troubled," says He, John xiL 27," and what shall I say ? Father, save me from this hour : but for this cause came I unto this hour." After this moment of trouble and hesitation. His mind became fixed, and His prayer takes form : " Father, glorify Thy name." In our case the straggle usually lasts longer. ... It does not take place in the heavenly sanctuary, like that of the gloiified Christ (Heb. vii 25). ...
... It has for its theatse the believeer's own heart The very tenn groaning implies this, and ver. 27, by speaking of God who ... tiie ... it — The epithet ... which we have translated unutterable, may be explained in three ways. 1. Beza and Grotins have given it the meaning of mute, that is to say, purely inward and ... But what end would such a. qualification serve here ? 2. ... nnder stand ... such is the meaning of our translation ; that is to say, that the understanding cannot fully grasp its object, nor consequently express it in ... terms. Only, 3, we should have preferred to translate, had the language permitted it, by the word ... In every particular case, he who is the object of this assistance feels that no distinct words fully express to God the infinite good after which he sighs. The fact proves that the aspiration is not his own, but that it is produced in his heart by the ' Spirrt of Him of whom John said, '' that He is greater than our heart" (1 John iii. 20). We here find ourselves in a domain analogous to that of the ... speaking in tongues, to which 1 Cor. xiv. refers ; comp. w. 14 and 15, where Paul saysr "When I pray in a tongue, my spirit ... indeed, but my understanding ... is ... The understanding cannot control, nor even follow the movement of the spirit, which, exalted by the Spirit of God, plunges into the depths of the divine. Thus, at the moment when the believer already feels the impulse of hope failing within him, a groan more elevated, holy, and intense than anything which can go forth even from his renewed heart is uttered within him, coming from ... and going to God, like a pure breath, and relieves the poor downcast heart.
Ver. 27. The W, ... contrasts the knowledge of God, which thoroughly imderstands the object of this groaning, with the ignorance of the heart from which it proceeds. God is often called in- the 0. T. the ... the ... of hearts. As to the blessing to which the aspiration of the Spirit goes forth in the believers heart, he knows its nature, he discems its sublime reality. Why ? This is what is told us in the second part of the verse : Because this supreme object of the Spirilf ... aspiration is what God Himself has prepared for us. The groaning of the Spirit is tcark ... according to €hd. The preposition ... to, denotes the standard ; God does not require the man who prays to express to Him the things he needs, since the groaning ... the Spirit is in conformity with the plan of God which is to be realized. If it is so, how should not God understand such a groan ? For the Spirit fathoms the divine plans to the bottom, 1 Cor. iL 10. It is obvious how far Meyer and Hofmann are mistaken in alleging that on should signify that and not because. They have not apprehended the bearing of the ... to God; Paul has a reason for making this word the opening one of the proposition. What is according to Him cannot remain unintelligible to Him. It is impossible to conceive a more auperfluous thought than the one here substituted by the two commentators referred to : " God knows that the Spirit intercedes, and that He does so according to Him for the saints." Did this ... require to be affirmed ? The last words, ... literally, "for saints," are very weighty. These saints are beings in whom the Spirit already dwells. ...
Romans 8:27 · Open Word Bible
27And God, who looks deep into hearts, knows what the Spirit intends, because the Spirit pleads for God's holy people in line with what God wants.
... After what He has already done in them, is it not natural for Him to interest Himself in the completion of their salvation ? — In the words : according to God and for saints, there is already enunciated a thought which is now to become that of the following passage, the thought of a divine plan conceived from all eternity in favour of the elect. It is to the accomplishment of this plan that the operation of the Spirit tends.
What a demonstration of the unutterable disorder which reigns throughout creation, and consequently of the state of imperfection in which it still is, notwithstanding the redemption which has been accomplished! Nature throughout all her bounds has a confused feeling of it, and from her bosom there rises a continual lament claiming a renovation firom heaven. The redeemed themselves are not exempt from this groaning, and wait for their own renewal which shall be the signal of universal restoration ; and finally, the Spirit who is intimate with the plans of ... for our glory (1 Cor. il 7), and who distinctly beholds the ideal of which we have but glimpses, pursues its realization with ardour. Thus is exhausted the first of the two leading ideas of this passage, that of the ... sufering ... Christ, The apostle now passes to the second, that of the ... being glorified with Him, The first was the condition ... if so be, ver. 17) ; the second is the final aim.
Ver. 28. "BiU we know that all things work together for good to them that love God, to them who are the called according to His purposed — We have shown how mistaken those expositors are who take the ... as a simple particle of transition : then, and say : third or fourth ground of encouragement The ... is adversative : but With this universal groaning which he has just described, and the source of which is in the sufferings of the present tim, the apostle contrasts the full certainty already possessed by believers of the glorious goal marked out beforehand by the plan of God. This result, which they await with assurance, is the luminous point on which their eye is already fixed, and the brilliance of which is reflected on the obscurities of the way which they have yet to traverse : " We groan, no doubt ; we know not how to pray . . ... we know . . . The regimen : to them ... love God, is placed at the beginning, as expressing the condition under which the prerogative about to be enunciated is realized in man. This characteristic of love to God is associated with the attribute of saints which he ascribed to believers, ver. 27, and more particularly with the cry: Abba, Father, the expression of their filial feeling, ver. 15. Those who belong to this class will never fail to be strengthened, and even to gain progress, by everything which can happen them; for in this normal path obstacles even become means of help. The end of the verse will explain why. — The term ... all things, includes all that comes on us, especially everything painful in consequence of the miseries of the present time and of the sins of our neighbours. But it would be wrong to embrace under it what we may do ourselves in opposition to God's will, since that would contradict the idea : them that love God. — The ... with, in the verb ... to work together with, has been variously explained. ...
Romans 8:28 · Open Word Bible
28We know that, for people who love God, all things work together and lead to good. They are the ones called in keeping with His purpose.
... According to some, it means, that all things work in concert (comp. the ... ver. 22) ; according to others. All things work in common with God under His direction. Others, finally : All things work in common with the believer who is their object, and who himself aspires after the good. This last sense, which is well developed by Philippi, is undoubtedly the most natural The Alex, and the Vatic, have added o 6609, God, as the subject of the verb. In that case we must give, to ... a causative sense : " God makes all things ... together." But this meaning is foreign to the N. T., and probably to classic Greek ; Passow does not quote a single example of it. — The regimen : ... for good, has a more precise meaning in the apostle's language than that usually given to it. It means not only any good result whatever in which everything issues for the believer, but that constant progress to the final goal to which the plan of God leads us, and which constitutes our real destination. Everything is fitted to hasten our progress in this direction, when the heart has once been subjected to God. The last words of the verse give the reason. Those who have come to take God as the object of their life and activity, and to live for Him like Jesus Himself (vi 10), are exactly those in whose favour God has formed the universal plan. All therefore which happens according to this plan must turn out in their favour. Two reasons explain the co-operation of all things for the believer's good: a subjective reason — he has entered into the true current (loving God) ; and an objective reason — all things are ordered in his favour in the plan of God ; this is indicated by the second regimen. — The notion of the divine plan is expressed by the term ... the design fixed beforehand. ...
... Paul often uses this expression in a more or less extended sense; thus, 2 Tim. i. 9, he applies it specially to salvation by grace without works; Eph. i 11, this term is applied to the election of the people of Israel ; Bom. iii 24, the design of God has for its object Christ's expiatory sacrifice. The classic passages, as they may be called, where this term is taken in its most general signification, are found in the Epistle to the Ephesians: i 3-10 and 106 ... iii. 11. We aee here that the design of God is eternal ... the offea), for it rests on Christ {in Jetiu Christ), and that it was conoeived freely, solely on account of the divine love (the decree of Sis vrill, ... to His good pleasure) — In Has plan of salvation there were comprehended at tiie same time the individuals in whom it was to be realized ; hence they axe designated here as the called ... to His purpose. The call is the invitation addressed by God to man, when by the preaching of His gospel He ... him salvation in Christ This call by the Word is always ... with an inward operation of the Spirit which tends to sender the preaching effectual Those theologians who hold absolute predestination have no doubt denied the generality of this intemal operation of grace ; they have alleged that it does not accompany the outward call except in the case of the elect Some have even gone the length of distinguishing between a serious and consequently effectual calling, and a ... and consequently ineffectual calling. But it will be asked. What could God have in view with a non-serious call, that is to say, one which He did not Himself seek to render effectual ? It has been answered, that its object was to render those to whom it was addressed inexcusable. But if God Himself refuses to give the grace necessary for its acceptance, how is he who refuses ... rendered more inexcusable ? ...
... It muat then be held that when the apostle in his Epistle speaks of the divine call, he always embraces imder the term the two notions of an outward call by the Word and an inward call by grace, and that the apostle's expression : the called ... to His ... is not at all intended to distinguish two classes of called persons, those who are so according to His purpose, and those who are not All are alike serioucly called. Only it happens that some consent to yield to the call and others refuse. This distinction is indicated by Jesus in the saying: ''Many are called, but few are chosen," Matt xx. 16. The chosen in this passage are those who accept the caU, and who are thereby rescued from the midst of this perishing world ; the called are those who, not accepting the call, remain called and nothing more, and that to their condemnation. In the Epistles, the apostles, addressing Christians, do not require to make this distinction, since the individuals whom they ... are assumed to have ... the call, fiom the very ... tibat they ham ... entered the church. The case ifi like that of a man ... should say to his ... when assembled in his honse: ''Use ... that is here, for you are my ... It is ... that by expressing himself thna, he would not be distingoishing invitation from acceptance the latter being implied in the veiy fact of their presence ; ... 1 Cor. i 23, 24. What the apostle means to say then is this : There is something prior to the present ... of believers ; that is the eternal purpose in virtue of which their calling took place. ... But in the context it is ... divine side of salvation only which is meant to be emphasized, as it is the only side which is expounded in the two following verses. The ground of the calling could not really be the believer's disposition to accept it.
The idea of God's purpose is developed in the two verses, 29 and 30. Yer. 29 indicates its final aim; ver. 30 marks off, as it were, the path along which it reaches its realization.
Ver. 29. "For whom He did foreknow, He also did ... to he conformed to ihe image of His Son, that He might he a ... among many hrethren" — The for bears on the principal idea of ver. 28 : AH things must turn to the good of them that are called according to God's eternal plan. Why so? Because once individually foreknown. He has determined to bring them to the glorious consummation of perfect likeness to His Son. This is the end with a view to winch He has ordered the plan of all things beforehand. — By the ... whom He did foreknow, Paul evidently 108 ... expresses the ... of the ... Be predestinated. The decree of predestination ... is founded on the act of foreknowledge ... What does St Paul understand by this last word ? Some have given to the word foreknow the meaning of ... choose destine, beforehand ... Calv., Buck., de Wette, etc.). Not only is tins meaning arbitrary, as being without example in the N. T., and as even in profane Greek the word ... to know, has the meaning of deciding only when it applies to a ihing, as when we say : ... dune cause, to judge of a case, and never when applied to a person ; [in this case ... would be absolutely necessary, to decide regarding (the person)]; but what is still more decidedly opposed to this meaning is what follows : He also did predestinate ; tor in that case the two verbs would be identical in meaning, and could not be connected by the particle of gradation ... also, especially in view of ver. 30, where the successive degrees of divine action are strictly distinguished and graduated. ...
Romans 8:29 · Open Word Bible
29Those God knew beforehand He also marked out beforehand to be shaped into the image of His Son, so that the Son would be the firstborn among many brothers and sisters.
... Others give to the word know a sense borrowed from the shade of meaning which it sometimes has in the biblical style, that of loving ... comp. xi 2 ; Jer. i. 5 ; Amos iiL 2 ; Hoa xiii. 5 ; GaL iv. 9, etc. The meaning according to this view is : "whom He loved and privileged beforehand." With this class we may join those who, like Beza, give the word the meaning of approving. It is certain that with the idea of knowledge, Scripture readily joins that of approbation, intimate communion, and tender affection; for it is only through mutual love that intelligent beings really meet and know one another. Besides, no one can think of separating from the word ... here, any more than xi. 2, the notion of love. Only it is still less allowable to exclude from it the notion of knowledge, for this is the first and fundamental meaning ; the other is only secondary. There is not a passage in the N. T. where the word know does not above all contain the notion of knowledge, properly so called. The same is the case with the word foreknow; comp. Acts xxvi 5 ; 2 Pet iiL 17. In the passage Acts ii 23, foreknowledge is expressly distinguished from the faoed decree, and consequently can denote nothing but prescience; and as to xi. 2: "His people whom God foreknew/' the idea of knowledge is the leading one in the woid foreknew ; that of love is expressed in the pronoon His, The meaning then to which we are brought seems to me to be this : those on whom His eye fixed from all eternity with love ; whom He eternally contemplated and discerned as His. In what respect did God thus ... them ? Obviously it is not as being one day to exist. For the foreknowledge in that case would apply to all men, and the apostle would not say: "whom He foreknew." ...
... Neither is it as future saved and glorified ones that He foreknew them; for this is the object of the decree o{ predestination of which the apostle goes on to speak ; and this object cannot at the same time be that of ... foreknowledge. There is but one answer: foreknown as sure to fulfil the condition of salvation, viz. faith ; so : foreknown as His by faith. Such is the meaning to which a host of commentators have been led, St Augustine himself in early times, then the Lutheran expositors ; Philippi explains : prcecognovit ... Only Philippi, after frankly acknowledging this meaning, instantly adds, that the faith which God foresees He also creates ; and so by this door a return is provided into the system of predestination which seemed to have been abandoned. But this view is not compatible with the true meaning of the word know, especially when this word is contrasted, as it is here, with the term predestinate. The act of knowing, exactly like that of seeing, supposes an object perceived by the person who knows or sees. It is not the act of seeing or knowing which creates this object ; it is this object, on the contrary, which determines the act of knowing or seeing. And the same is the case with divine prevision or foreknowledge; for in the case of God who lives above time, foreseeing is seeing ; knowing what shall be is knowing what to Him already is. And therefore it is the believer's faith which, as a future fact, but in His sight already existing, which determines His foreknowledge. This faith does not exist because God sees it ; He sees it, on the contrary, because it will come into being at a given moment, in time. We thus get at the thought of the apostle : Whom God knew beforehand as certain to believe, whose faith He beheld eternally. ... Bat will in God is neither arbitrary nor bUnd ; it is based on a principle of light, on knowledge. ...
... In relation to the man whose fedth God forenes. He decrees salva tion and glory. Beass is certainly mistaken, therefore, in saying of these two verbs that substanttally they denote *' one and the same act" The object of the decree is ... faith at all, as if God had said : As for thee, thoa shalt ... as for thee, thoa shalt not believe.. The object of predestination is ... ''I see thee believing . . ., I will therefore that thou be glorified like my Son." Such is tho meaning of the decree. The ... of which Paul ... is not a predestination to ... but a predestination to glory, fdonded on the prevision of faith. Faith is in a sense the work of God ; but it contains a factor, in virtue of which it reacts on God, as an object reacts on the mind whidi takes cognizance of it; this is the free adherence of man to the solicitation of God. Here is the element which distingnishes the act of foreknowledge from that of predestination, and because of which the former logically precedes the latter. — It is hardly necessary to refute the opinion of Meyer, who gives the verb foreknow the same object as the verb 'predestinaie : ''Whom He foreknew as conformed to the image of His Son, He also did predestinate to be conformed to the image of His Son." Has this any meaning % It would be more intelligible if the order were reversed; ''Whom He predestinated to . . ., He also ... as " .
What the decree of predestination embraces is the realization of the image of the Son in all foreknown bdievers. The ... conformed, is directiy connected with the verb He predestinated; the ellipsis of the verb to be, or to become, is obvious and common Paul does not say : conformed or like to His Son," but: "to the image of His Son." By using this form of expression, he undoubtedly means that Christ has realized in Himself ... type ... image), which we are to realize after Him. This is the existence of the God-man, aa we behold it in Christ ; such is the glorious ... which God takes from the person of His Son, that therewith He may clothe ... What, in point of fact, was the aim of God in the creation of man ? He wished to ... for Himself a ... of sons ; and therefore He determined in the first place to make His own Son onr brother. Then in His person He raises onr humanity to the divine state ; and finally. He makes all believing men sharers in this gloriona form ... existence. Such are the contents of the decree. It is obvioos that Christ Himself is its first object ; and hence He is called the Elect, absolately speaking, Isa. xliL 1 ; Luke ix. 35 (most approved reading). His brethren are elect in Him EpL i 4—6. The ... intention in acting thus is to glorify the Son by causing His beauty to be reflected in a family of living likenesses. — llie term ... no doubt denotes primarily a relation of time : Jesus preceded all the others in glory, not only because of His eternal ... but also as a man by His resurrection and ascension; comp. CoL L 15 and 18. But the decree of predestination carries us into an eternal sphere, where the idea of priority has no more place, and is transformed into that of superiority. ...
... It will be vain for us to take on His likeness ; we shall never be equal to Him ; for the likeness which we shall bear will be His. Thus what comes out as the end of the divine decree is the creation of a great family of men made ... of the divine existence and action, in the midst of which the glorified Jesus shines as the prototype.
But how are we, we sinful men, to be brought to this sublime state ? Such a work could not be accomplished as it were by the wave of a magician's wand. A complete moral transformation required to be wrought in us, paving the way for our glorification. And hence God, after fixing the end, and ... the decree in eternity, set His hand to the work in time to realize it. He beheld them at their haven, all these foreknown ones, before launching them on the sea ; and once launched. He acted ; such is the meaning of ver. 3 0.
Ver. 30. ... whom He did predestinate, them He also tailed; and whom He called, {hem He also justified; antd whom ... them He also — Here are the successive acts wheieby the eternal decree is executed in time. They stand, as it were, between the eternity in which this decree is pronounced, and the eternity in which it is finished. It is to be remarked that the apostle only points out in its accomplishment the acts pertaining to God : ... glorificationy because he is only setting forth that side of the work of salvation which is contained in the decree of predestination, and which consequently depends solely on divine causation. If his intention had been to explain the order of salvation in all its elements divine and human he would have put faUh between calling and justification, and holiness between justification and glorification.
Romans 8:30 · Open Word Bible
30And those He marked out beforehand, He also called. Those He called, He also declared righteous. And those He declared righteous, He also glorified.
The ... then, moreover, at the beginning of the verse is progressive ; it indicates the transition from the eternal decree to its realization in time. He who wishes the end must employ the means ; the first mean which God puts in operation is His coil, which, as we have seen, embraces the outward invitation by preaching, and the inward drawing by the Spirit of grace. Paul does not mean that God addresses this call only to those whom He has predestined to glory, but he affirms that none of those who are predestinated fail to be also called in their day and hour. Not one of those foreknown shall be forgotten. They form a totality, which, once introduced from eternity into time, is faithfully led by God from step to step to the goal fixed beforehand. God would be inconsequent if He acted otherwise. — The plural pronouns whom . . . them, imply knowledge of the individuals as such. AU were present to the mind of God when He decreed the height to which He would raise them. — The call once accepted — and it could not fail to be so, since we have to do here only with those whose faith God foreknew — a second divine act followed : justification. The ... also, indicates the continuity of the divine work, the ... acts of which follow, and mutually involve one another. Each successive grace is as it were implied in the preceding. Grace upon grace, says John i. 16. On those who have been called and have become believers, there has been passed the sentence which declares man righteous, that is to say, put relatively to God in the position of one who has never done any evil nor omitted any good. — The third step, glorification, is no longer connected with the preceding by ... also, but by ... Tnoreover. ...
... This change indicates a shade of difference in the thought The apostle feds that he is nearing the goal, foreseen and announced in ver. 29 ; and this Be consequently signifies : and finally. The feeling expressed is that of one "who, after a painful and perilous journey, at length reaches the end — We might be tempted to include holiness here in glorification ; for, as has ... said, holiness is only the inward side of glory, which is its outward manifestation. But when we remember chaps, vi.-viii, it seems to us more natural to make holiness the transition from justification to glory, and to regard it as implicitly contained in the former. Once justified, the believer receives the Spirit, who sanctifies him in the measure of his docihty, and so prepares him for glory. — There is nothing surprising in the fact that verbs in the past are used to denote the first two divine acts, those of calling and justification ; for at the time Paul wrote, these two acts were already realized in a multitude of individuals who were in a manner the representatives of all the rest But how can he employ the same past tense to denote the act of glorification which is yet to come ? Many expositors, Thol., Mey., Philip., think that this ... expresses the absolute certainty of the event to come. Others, like Reiche, refer this past to the eternal fulfilment of the decree in the divine ... Or again, it is taken ... an aoiist of anticipation, like that of which we have a striking example, John xv. 6 and 8. Hodge seems to have sought to combine those different senses when he says : '' Paul uses the past as speaking from God's point of view, who sees the end of things from their beginning.'' But if it is true that the use of the two preceding aorists was founded on an already accomplished fact, should it not be the same with this ? ...
... If believers are not yet glorified, their Head already is, and they are virtually so in Him. This is the completed historical fact which suffices to justify the use of the past Does not Paul say, Eph. iL 6: *' We have been raised up together with Him, and made to sit together with Him in heavenly places"? When the head of a body wears a crown, the whole body wears the same with it Paul has thus reached the goal he had set from the beginning, in the last words of the preceding passage (ver. 17): " that we may be glorified together with Him." For he had proposed to himself (ver. 1) to show the final abolition of all condemnation, even of that of death, by the law of the Spirit of life which is in Jesus Christ; and he has fulfilled this task. It only remains for him to celebrate in a hymn this unparalleled victory gained in our behalf.
It is obviously too nairow an interpretation of the passage to apply it merely, as Calvin does, to the victory over the sufferings of this present time (ver. 18). We have here the consummation of that salvation in Christ, the foundation of which Paul had laid (chaps, i— v.) in the demonstration of the ... of faith, and the superstructure of which he had raised ... the exposition of ... (chaps. vL-viii). Hereafter it will only remain to follow this salvation, thus studied in its essence, as it is unfolded on the theatre of history.
On predestination as taught w. 28-30. — Wlierein consists the divine predestination undoubtedly taught by the apostle in this passage ? Does it in his view exclude the free will of man, or, on the contrary, does it imply it ? Two reasons seem to us to decide the question in ... of the second alternative : — 1. The act ... which the apostle makes the basis of predestination, proves that the latter is determined by some fact or other, the object of this knowledge. It matters little that the knowledge is eternal, while the fact, which is its object, comes to pass only in time. It follows all the same from this relation, that tihe ... must be considered as due in some way to a factor distinct from divine causation, which can be nothing else than human liberty. 2. The apostle avoids making the act of believing the object of the decree of predestination. In the act of predestination faith is already assumed, and its sole object is, ... to the apostle's words, the final participation of believers in the glory of Christ. Not only then does Paul's view imply that in the act of believing full human liberty is not excluded, but it is even implied. For it alone explains the distinction which he clearly establishes between the two divine acts of foreknowledge and predestination, both as to their nature (the one, an act of the understanding ; the other, of the will) and as to their object (in the one case, faith ; in the other, glory).
Human liberty in the acceptance of salvation being therefore admitted, in what will predestination, as understood by St Paul, consist ? It contains, we think, the three following elements : — 1. The decree ... whereby God has determiued to bring to the perfect likeness of His Son every one who shall believe. What more in keeping with His grace and wisdom than such a decree : Thou dost adhere by faith to Him whom I give thee as thy Saviour ; He will therefore belong to thee wholly, and I shall not leave thee till I have rendered thee perfectly like Him, the God-man"?
2. The prevision ... ia consequence of the divine foreknowledge, of all the individuals who shall freely adhere to the divine ... to participate in this salvation. What more necessary than this second element ? Would not God's plan run the risk of coming to nought if He did not foresee both the perfect fidelity of tiie Elect One on whom its realization rests, and the faith of those who shall believe in Him ? Without a Saviour and believers there would be no salvation. God's plan therefore assumes the assured foreknowledge of both.
3. The ... of all the laws and all the circumstances of history with a view to realizing the glorious plan conceived in favour of those foreknown. It is this arrangement which St Paul describes in ver. 28, when he says that '* all ... must work together for good to them who are the called according to the eternal purpose.** What more magnificent ! Once believers, we may be tossed on the tempests of this present time ; not only do we know that no wave can ... us, but we are assured that every one of ... has its place in the divine plan, and must hasten our course.
Thus we have three points: 1. The end indicated by the decree ; 2. The personally known ... who are to reach it ; 3. The ... by which they are to be led to it.
If any one does not find this predestination sufficient, he may make one to his taste ; but, according to our conviction, it will not be that of the apostla
Vv. 31, 32. " What shall we then say to these things t If God ... us, who can he against ... He that spared not His own San, hit delivered Him up for ics aU, how shall He not unth Him also freely give us all things i " — The question : What shall toe then say? does not introduce an objection, as in other passages ; it invites the readers to take account of the position made theirs by the divine acts which have been thus far expounded, and to seek language ... to such benefits ... then). It would be incorrect to give to the words ... to these things, the meaning of besides, as Bengel does ; this would have required ... here signifies in regard to : " What shall we say when we consider these things ?" The apostle seeks to make himself and us thoroughly familiar with the nature of the new situation which is made ours. God has put Himself henceforth on our side . . . ; for that reason alone all adversaries will be powerless. ''Not that there are none," says Calvin, " but with such a defender none of them is to be dreaded : Hie mums nobis est
Romans 8:31–32 · Open Word Bible
31So what is our response to all this? If God is on our side, who can stand against us? 32God did not hold back even His own Son, but handed Him over for us all. How could He fail, then, to give us everything along with Him as a free gift?
This passage is a conclusion. The then of ver. 31 indicates this. This conclusion is directly connected with the previous teaching on predestination (w. 28-30) ; but as this passage only sums up all that the apostle had expounded before : 1st, on justification by fedth (chaps, i-v.), 2d, on sanctification by the Spirit of Christ (chaps, vi-viii.), it follows that it is the conclusion of the entire portion of the Epistle now completed. It is presented in the form of questions which are, as it were, a challenge thrown out to all the adversaries of that salvation, the certainty of which Paul would here proclaim. This form has in it something of the nature of a triumph ; it gives us the idea of what was meant by him when he used the expression in the previous context : ... to ghry in God.
Vy. 31 and 32 contain a question of an entirely general character; vv. 33-37 enumerate the different kinds of adversaries; vv. 38 and 39 are as it were the shout of victory on the battle-field now abandoned by the enemy.
Romans 8:31 · Open Word Bible
31So what is our response to all this? If God is on our side, who can stand against us?
Yer. 32. This absolute assurance in God, Paul derives from the great act of mercy toward us which has been accomplished. The expression 09 76, literally, who at least, is undoubtedly used in Greek in the sense of who assuredly. It is allowable, however, to seek the more precise sense of this restrictive form, and we think it may be expressed by the paraphrase : " Who though he had done nothing else than that.'* There is a striking contrast between the expression : His own ... and the verb spared not (so to say, did not treat delicately). — It is very clear here that the meaning of the word Son cannot be identified with that of Messiah — King. What would be meant by the expression : His own Messiah ? The being in question is evidently one who is united to Him personally and who shares His nature, whom He brings, as it were, from His own bowels (/c rot; ... The apostle's expressions certainly reproduce those of the angel of the Lord to Abraham, after the sacrifice of Isaac : '' Because thou hast not spared thy son, thine only son " (Gen. xxii. 12). Meyer denies this parallelism, but without sufficient reason. There was, as it were, a victory gained by God over Himself, when He gave up His well-beloved to that career of pain and shame, just as there was a victory gained by Abraham over himself when with Isaac he climbed the mount of sacrifica The inward sacrifice consummated, God gave Him up for us. — For us all, says ... These words might here embrace the totality of hiiman beings. But the us ought undoubtedly to have the same meaning as that of ver. 31, unless, indeed, the word all, which is added here, be meant to indicate an extension to be given to the circle denoted by the preceding us. But is it not more natural to hold that tiiis all contrasts the totality of believers with the one being whom God has given to be their Saviour? ...
Romans 8:32 · Open Word Bible
32God did not hold back even His own Son, but handed Him over for us all. How could He fail, then, to give us everything along with Him as a free gift?
... "One for all" (2 Cor. V. 14). — As all were the object of this ... so all things were comprehended in this gift The word ... all things, with the article, denotes a definite totality. This means all the gifts of grace previously enumerated. If, with the Greco-Lats., we reject the article, it is all things, absolutely speaking; which in the application amounts to the same thing. There is a very marked shade of difference between the verb : fredy give ... and the preceding verbs : no sparing, giving up. While the latter express something painful, the former denotes an act full of pleasure to the heart of him who does it How, after carrying through the sacrifice, would He not do the pleasant part of a gracious giver ? Thus it is that all possible gifts, however great or small they may be, whether for this life or the next, are virtually comprised in the gift of the Son, just as the gift of all Abraham's possessions and of his person even were implicitly contained in that of Isaaa To give all things is a small matter after the best has been given. This is precisely what was expressed beforehand by the 76, ... least, at the beginning of the verse, and what is confirmed by the ... also, added to the verb ... give. This particle indeed is connected with the verb, and not with the regimen taith Him (see Philippi, in opposition to Meyer). He being once given, God ... also bestow on us, in the course of our life, all other blessings.
The three questions which follow axe only varioiis ... tions of the question in ver. 31 : " Who can be against us ? The fiist two (w. 33 and 34) refer to attacks of a judicial nature ; they contemplate enemies who contest the believers ... to pardon and salvation. The third (w. ... refers to a violent attack in which the enemy has recourse to brute force, to break the bond between Christ and the believer. The whole passage vividly recalls the words of Isa. L 7-9 : I know that I shall not be ashamed. He is near that justifietb me : who will contend with me ? Let us stand together : who is mine adversary? Let him come near to me! Behold, the Lord God will help me ; who is he that shall condemn me?"
Ver. 33. " Who dudl lay anything to the charge of ... elect t It is God thai — Paul is not ignorant how many accusers every believer has: conscience, the law Satan, the accuser of the elect, the persons we have offended or scandalized by our ... all so many voices rising against us. Did Paul himself, when writing these words, not think of the cries of pain uttered by the Christians whom he had cast into prison and scourged, and especially of the blood of Stephen, which, like that of Abel the righteous, called for vengeance against him? All these charges are only too real. But from the mouth of God there has gone forth a declaration which serves as a buckler to the beUever, and against which those fiery darts are quenched, as soon as he takes shelter under the sentence : God haih declared him ... Here we clearly see the juridical meaning of the ... justify as used by St. ... These words : It is God that justifieth, which paralyze every accusation uttered in His presence, are the summary of the whole first part of the Epistle (chaps. i.-v.). The expression : the elect of God, literally, dect of God, has an argumentative value; it serves to demonstrate beforehand the powerlessness of the accusation. This expression recalls what has just been said (w. 28-30) of the eternal predestination of believers to salvation and glory; ... eled, from ... to draw ... of Rescued by His own call from identification with a world plunged in evil, could God thrust them back into it ?
Romans 8:33 · Open Word Bible
33Who will bring any accusation against those God has chosen? God is the one who declares them righteous.
From the time of St. Augustine several commentators (most — ... lately Olshansen, de Wette Beuss) Jsave taken the last proposition of the verse in an interrogative sense : " Who will accuse ? Would it be God ? How could He do so, ... who ... f " The apostle would thus be using an argument ... This meaning is ingenious, and seems at the first glance to be more forcible. But can the part of accuser be ascribed even by supposition, to God ? The function of God is more elevated. Besides, it is simpler, graver, and in reality more forcible to regard this proposition as a calm and decided affirmation. It is the rock against which every wave of accusation breaks ; compare also the parallel Isa. L, which speaks decidedly in ... of the affirmative form (Philippi).
The accusers are reduced to silence ... for the present ; but will it also be so at the final moment when the tribunal will be set, in the day of the ... of the just judgment of God," when sentence will be given without '' acceptance of persons " and '' according to every man's work " QL 5, 6, 11) ? Will the absolution of believers then still hold good ? Let it be remembered this was the question put at the close of the first part (w. 9 and 10), and resolved in the second ... . St Paul raises it again in this summary, but in a tone of triumph because on this point also he knows that victory is won
Yer. 34. '' Who is he that condenmeth t It is Christ ... that died, yea raiher thai is risen againf who is also at the right hand of €hd, who also ... us.*' — The form ... literally, who will be the condemning one f supposes only one judge possible, while the form of the previous question. Who wUl accuse t admitted a plurality of accusers. Why this difference ? When accusing is the Udatter in question, all creatures may raise their voice. But as to judging t One only is appointed for that office. He who is called (Acts x. 42) by St Peter " the judge of quick and dead ; *" comp. also Acts xvii. 31 and Eom. xiv. 10; so that the question put amounts to this : Will Christ, at the day of judgment, condemn us? The verb understood must be ivill be, not is; comp. w. 33 and 35. The negative answer arises from the following enumeration of the acts done by Christ in our behalf. There would be a contradiction between this series of merciful interpositions and a final condemnation. It has excited surprise that when saying Christ died, Paul did not add for ... But he is not speaking here of the death of Christ from the ... of expiation ; in this respect it was already implied in the answer to the previous question, "It is God that justifieth." The death of Christ is mentioned here from the same standpoint as in chap, vi., implying, for the man who appropriates it, death to sin. The article o, literally, the (one who died), reminds us that one only could condemn us, but that it is ... very one who died that we might not be obliged to do it. ...
Romans 8:34 · Open Word Bible
34Who is going to condemn them? Christ is the one who died; still more, He was raised, and He is at the right hand of God, where He pleads on our behalf.
... The ... is likewise mentioned from the same point of view as in chap, vi, as the principle whereby a new life is communicated to believers, even the life of Christ Himself, of which, when once justified, we are made partakers (Eph. iL 5 and 6). — His sitting at the right hand of God naturally follows, first as the principle of the outpouring of the Holy Spirit, and then as haviug put into the hands of Christ the government of the world and the direction of all the events of our life. — Finally, by His ... cession we are assured of His precious interposition at such moments of spiritual weakness, as that in reference to which He declared to Peter : '* I have prayed for thee, that thy faith fail not.'* How, with such support, should the Christian not become the conqueror of the sin which still cleaves to him, and how should he not succeed in presenting himself before the judgment-seat in a state which will not dishonour his Lord? This is what the apostle had called (ver. 1 0), *' being saved by His life," in contrast to " being reconciled by His death " (same verse).
After the example of Erasmus, Meyer divides the ... and answers contained in this passage quite differently. ... 2. A then would be indispensable in the two questions : who shall condemn (ver. 34)? and who shall separate (ver. 35) ? intended, according to Meyer, to express the two conclusions. 3. The question : Who shall separate (ver. 35) ? is so far from being intended to express the conclusion from what precedes, that it finds its answer in all that follows, and particularly in the words of ver. 39, which close the whole passage: Nothing shall separate vs. 4. This same question: Who shall separate f is followed by a long enumeration of the sufferings calculated to separate the believer from his Saviour, which absolutely prevents us from taking this question as expressing a conclusion.
A more seducing proposition is that of the expositors who, after taking the words ... interrogatively : God who justifiethi give the same turn to ver. 34: ''Who is he that shall condemn? Will it be Christ, He who died, who" . . . ? This form has something lively and piquant ; and if it applied only to a single question, one might be tempted to hold by it. But the series of questions which would then succeed one another in the same interrogative, and almost ironical sense, does not seem to us to be compatible with the profound feeling of this whole passage.
The numerous variants (ver. 34) which we have indicated in the note have no importance. The name ... added to the title Christ by several Mjj., is in thorough keeping with the context ; for in what follows there are summed up the phases of His existence as a historical person. It is the same with the Italy also, in the second and third proposition. It may even be said that the ... of the third does not admit of any doubt 122
It is clearly seen how the logical form does not for an instant slip from the mind of Paul, even at the time when the most overflowing feeling charges his pen.
Vy. 35-37. "Who ... us from the laoe of Christ t shall ... or distress, or persecution, or famine, or ... ness, or peril, or sword f As it is written. For Thy sake we are killed all the day long ; we are ... as sheep for the daughter. But in all these things we are more than conquerors through Him that loved us." — The pronoun ... who, refers properly to persons ; here it is applied to all the sufferings about to be enumerated, as if Paul saw in each of them an enemy bearing a grudge at the bond uniting him to Christ— The love of Christ, from which nothing will separate him, is not the love which we have to Him ; for we are not separated from our own personal feeling. It is therefore the love which He has to us ; and this is confirmed by the dose of ver. 37 : " through Him that loved ns.** We might, with Calv., ThoL, ... understand : nothing will separate us from the feeling we ... of the love of Jesus to us. But is not Paul rather representing this love itself as a force which takes hold of and possesses us? Comp. 2 Cor. ... 14: 'The love of ... constraineth us (holds us pressed)." ... To imderstand the words : ... feril, it is enough to refer to the sketch of St. Paul's life, given in 2 Cor. xi 23 ... seq. The sword: the symbol of capital punishment When Paul writes this word, he designates, as Bengel observes, his own future mode of death.
Romans 8:35–37 · Open Word Bible
35Who can tear us away from the love of Christ? Trouble, or anguish, or persecution? Hunger, or lack of clothing, or danger, or the sword? 36As it is written, "On Your account we are being killed the whole day through; we are looked on as sheep for the butcher." 37But in all of this we are winning, and winning by far, through the one who loved us.
Yer. 36. The apostle here quotes the sorrowful lament put by a psalmist in the mouth of the faithful under the old covenant, during a time of cruel oppression, Ps. xliv. 22. The quotation follows the LXX. AU the day: every hour of the day (Meyer). Any hour is serviceable for dragging them to slaughter. Far Thy love's sake: Jehovah in the 0. T. corresponds to Christ in the New. We arc ... long since sentence has been pronoimced by hatred, and has hung over their head, though it is not yet executed.
Romans 8:36 · Open Word Bible
36As it is written, "On Your account we are being killed the whole day through; we are looked on as sheep for the butcher."
Yer. 37. Paul expresses his certainty that none of these efforts will avail to tear the believer from the ... arms of Christ's love. There is in this love a power which will overcome all the weaknesses of despondency, all the sinkings of doubt, all the fears of the flesh, all the horrors of execution. Paul does not say merely ... we are ... but ... we are more than conquerors ; there is a surplus of force; we might surmount still worse trials if the Lord permitted them. And in what strength ? The apostle, instead of saying: through the love of the Lord, expresses himself thus : Hwrough the Lord that loved us. It is His living person that acts in us. For it is He Himself in His love who sustains us. This love is not a simple thought of our mind ; it is a force emanating firom Him. The Oreco-Latin reading : ... on account of ... would make Jesus merely the moral cause of victory. This is evidently too weak. — It will perhaps be asked if a Christian has never been known to deny his fedth in suffering and persecution. Yes, and it is not a mathematical certainty the apostle ... to state here. It is a fact of the moral life which is in question, and in this life liberty has always its part to play, as it had from the first moment of faith. What Paul means is, that nothing will tear us from the arms of Christ against our will, and ... long as we shall not refuse to abide in them ourselves ; comp. John x. 28-30.
Romans 8:37 · Open Word Bible
37But in all of this we are winning, and winning by far, through the one who loved us.
Vv. 38, 39. ' For I am permaded, that ... death, nor life, nor ... nor things present, nor things to conie, nor powers,* nor height, nor ... nor any other creature, shall he able to separate us from the love of God, which is in Christ Jesus our Lordr — The challenge which the apostle had just thrown out to condemnation, and sin and suffering of every kind, he now extends to aU the ... powers of the universe which could threaten the bond of love whereby Christ, and God Himself, are united to the believer. The for expresses an argument a fortiori: "none of the enemies mentioned is to be feared, for not even throughout the whole universe is there a being to be dreaded." — Paul reverts to the form /, which he had dropped after ver. 18 ; the reason being that here, as well as in ver. 38, the ... in question is a personal conviction of a moral rather than a systematic nature. We must not forget the : *'if ... least you persevere," which Paul himself wrote, CoL i 23, nor examples such as that of Demas, 2 Tim. iv. 10. It is by ... (ver. 25), perseverance in believing in the love of Christ to us, that this love exercises its irresistible power over us. The conviction here expressed by Paul does not apply to himself only, but to all believers ... ver. 39).
Romans 8:38–39 · Open Word Bible
38For I am fully persuaded that not death and not life, not angels and not rulers, not what is here now and not what is yet to come, not any powers, 39not what is high above and not what is deep below, nor any other created thing, will be able to cut us off from God's love, which is ours in Christ Jesus our Lord.
The adversaries who rise before his view seem to advance in pairs. The first pair is death and life. Death is put first, in connection no doubt with vv. 35 and 36. The inverse order which we find 1 Cor. iiL 22, is occasioned there by the difference of the context Death: the apostle is thinking of martyrdom, the fear of which may lead to apostasy. With death and its agonies, he contrasts life with its distractions, its interests and seductions, which may lead to luke warmness and unfaithfulness, as in the case of Demas. — The second pair : angels and principalities. Undoubtedly principalities, ... might be regarded as an order of angels superior to common angels — archangels. But in the otiier pairs there is always found a contrast of character: it is therefore natural to apply these two terms to splits of opposite kinds ; the first to good angels (though this sense is not ... the meaning of ... as Meyer alleges; comp. 1 Cor. iv. 9 and vi. 3) ; the second to malignant angels, as 1 Cor. ... 24 and Eph. vi. 12 (Hofmann). It will be asked how good angels could labour to separate us from Christ ; but this may only be a hypothesis like that of GaL i 8. And may not what is of itself good contribute to lead us astray, if our attachment or admiration stops short at the creature, instead of rising to God ? — The Byzs. here read a ... term almost synonymous : ... powers ; and a Mj. (C) with some Mnn. even adds a fourth : ... dominations. This last term is evidently an interpolation to form a pair with the third. As to the latter, according to the Mjj. of the other two families, it has its place, if it is really authentic, after the following pair. — Third pair: things present and things to come. The first term embraces all earthly eventualities, death included ; the second, all that await us in the future life. ...
... The word ... which strictly signifies what is imminent, when contrasted with things to come, takes the meaning : all that is already present. — If the term pothers is authentic, it must be taken as embracing in one idea the two terms of the following pair : height and depth. These are all tlie powers of the invisible world, whether those which exalt tis to the third heaven (height), but which in an instant, by reason of pride or even violently excited sensuality, may occasion the most frightful falls to the poor human heart ; or those which plunge us into the most mysterious and unspeakable agonies {depth), like that of Jesus at Grethsemane, when He exclaimed: ''My soul is sorrowful even unto death;" comp. what He added soon after: ''This is your hour and the power of darkness It is scarcely necessary to refute the following interpretations which have been proposed: good fortune and bad; or honour and disgrace; the wisdom of heretics and vulgar prejudices ... the heights from which martyrs were precipitated, and the depths of the ocean where they were buried (Thomas Aquinas) ; or finally, the opposite dimensions of ... (Meyer). — The last term, ... trepa, is usually translated by the expression : any other creature, and made a sort of ... camera. This meaning would certainly be ... rather poor after expressions of such ample ... as those which precede. But more than that, it hardly ... the word ... which signifies ... and not merely ... as the word ... would do (for the distinctian between these two adjectives, comp. 1 Cor. xv. 37-41). It seems, then, that the word ... signifies here, not creature, as if the reference were to a particular being, to be put side bj side with several others, but creation. ...
... Paul sees in thought this whole creation disappear, on the theatre of which there has been wrought the greatest wonder of divine love ; and he asks whether, if a new creation arise, and more magnificent marvels are displayed before the eyes of man, the cross in those new ages will not run the risk of being eclipsed, and the love of God in Jesus Christ of being relegated to the oblivion of the past And he boldly ... that whatever new creations may succeed one another, the first place in the heart of believers will ever remain for the redeeming love of which they have been the object here below. — Paul here speaks of the love of Jesus as being the love of God Himself; for it ia in the former that the latter is incarnated for us, and becomes the eternal anchor of which our faith lays hold for eternity; comp. v. 15 and Luke XV., where the compassion of God is completely identified with the work of Jesus on the earth.
Nowhere has the feeling of St Paul been displayed in such overflowing measure, and yet the thread of logical deduction is not broken for an instant This passage sums up, as we have seen, all that Paul has hitherto expounded in this Epistle. He leaves us at the end of this chapter face to face with this divinely wrought salvation, which is complete, and assured, and founded on faith alone, to be apprehended, and ever apprehended anew by the same means. Then, after a moment of contemplation and ... he takes us again by the hand to gnide us to the theatre of history, and show us this divine work unfolding itself on a great scale in the human raca
In stating the theme which he proposed to discuss (L 16 and 1 7), the apostle had introduced an element of a historical nature which he could not ... at some point or other of his treatise. It was this : "to the Jew Jirst, and also to the Greek.'" In what relation did salvation as set forth in his Gospel, stand to those two great sections of the human race looked at from the standpoint of its religious development ? And particularly, how did it happen that the Jewish people, to whom salvation was destined in the first place, showed themselves the most rebellious to this final levelation of divine mercy ? Did not the fact give rise to a grave objection to the truth of the gospel itself, and to the Messiahship ascribed to the person of Jesus by the new faith ? A Jew might, reason thus : Either the gospel is true and Jesus really the Messiah, — but in this case the divine promises formerly made to this Jewish people who reject the Messiah and His salvation are nullified ;— or Israel is and remains for ever, as should be the case in virtue of its election, the people of God, and in this case the gospel must be false and Jesus an impostor. Thus the dilemma seemed to be: Either to affirm God's faithfulness to His own election and deny the gospel, or to affirm the gospel, but give the lie to the ... election and faithfulness.
The apostie must have found this problem in his way every time he bore testimony to the gospel of Christ; and his demonstration of salvation by faith without the law would have contained a grave omission if it had not presented a solution suitable to the nature of God of the greatest enigma in histoiy : the ... of the elect people.
Generally, when a new doctrine presents itself, after demonstrating its intrinsic truth, it has a double task to discharge to mankind whom it professes to save — (1) to prove that it is capable of realizing what ... to he, moral good ; this Paul has done by showing, chaps, vi.— viii., that the doctrine of justification by faith (expounded chapa ... was capable of producing holiness; (2) to demonstrate that it can account satisfactorily for what has "been, for histoiy ; this the apostle proceeds to do chaps. ... The domain upon which the apostle here enters is one of the most difficult and profound which can be presented to the mind of man. It is that of theodicy , or the justification of the divine government in the course of human affairs. But he does not enter on it as a philosopher, and in its totality ; he treats it in relation to a special point, the problem of tiie lot of Israel, and he does so as a part of his apostolic task.
There are two ways in which mistakes have been committed in expounding the thought of Paul in this passage. Some have taken it as a dogmatic and general statement of the doctrine of dection, as an element of Christian teaching. This view finds its refutation in the entire course of this great exposition, in which the apostle constantly reverts to the people of Israel, the antecedents of their history ... the prophecies concerning them (ix. 27-29 and x. 19-21), and their present and future destiny (see the whole of chap, xi., and particularly the conclusion, w. 25-31). It is therefore a problem of histoiy and not of doctrine, strictly speaking, which he proposes to treat. Calvin himself is perfectly aware of this. Here is the dilemma which, according to him, St Paul resolved in these chapters : Either God is unfaithful to His promises (in regard to the Jews), or Jesus whom Paul preaches is not the Lord's Christ particularly promised to that people."
The other erroneous point of view in regard to these chapters is to take them as intended to reconcile the ... majority of the church of Some to the apostle's mission to the Gentiles (Baur, Mangold, Holsten, lipsius, with various shades). Weizsacker, in hia excellent work on the primitive Roman church, asks with reason why, if the apostle was addressing Judeo-Christians, he should designate the ... ix. 3, " as his brethren," and not rather as our brethren ; " and how it is that in xL 1 he alleges as a proof of the fact that all Israel is not rejected, only his own conversion and not that of bis readers. He likewise demonstrates beyond dispute, in our opinion, that in the passage, xi. 13, tbe words: ''I speak unto you. Gentiles/' are necessarily addressed to the whole church, not merely to a portion of the Christians of Home (see on this passage). If it is so, it is impossible to hold that, addressing himself to former Gentiles, Paul should think himself obliged to demonstrate in three long chapters the legitimacy of his mission among the Gentiles. No ; it is not his mission, and still less his person, which Paul means to defend when he traces this vast scheme of the ways of God ; it is God Himself and His work in mankind by the gospel He labours to dissipate the shadow which might be thrown on the character of God or the truth of the gospel by the unbelief of the elect people. The Tubingen school commits the same mistake in regard to this part of our Epistle as in regard to the Book of the Acts. ...
... This latter writing it views in general as the product of an ecclesiastical piece of management, intended to accredit Paul's person and ministry among Christians of Jewish origin, while it is meant to demonstrate by a simple statement of facts the painstaking and faithful manner in which God has proceeded toward His ancient people in the foundation of the churcL Comp. besides, that remarkable passage in the Gospel of John, xiL 37-43, in which this apostle takes a general survey of the fact of Jewish unbeliel, immediately after describing its development, and seeks to fathom its causes. This, indeed, was one of the most important questions at the period of the foundation of the church. In this question there was concentrated the subject of the connection between the two revelations.
How, at a given point in time, can God reject those whom He has elected ? Is the fact possible ? The apostle resolves this problem by putting himself successively at three points of view — 1. That of God's absolute ... in regard to every alleged acquired right, upon Him, on man's part ; this is the subject of chap. ix. 2. That of the legitimacy c the iise which God has made of His liberty in the case in question; such is the subject of chap, x., where Paul shows that Israel by their want of imderstanding drew upon ... the lot which has overtaken them. 3. That of the. utility of this so unexpected measure; this forms the 'subject of ... xi,
I Bcat ... where the beneficent consequences of Israel's rejection down to their glorious final result are unfolded. — This passage does not contain a complete philosophy of history ; but it is the finest specimen, and, so to speak, the masterpiece of this science.