Frédéric Louis Godet · Commentary on St. Paul's Epistle to the Romans
Romans 2
46 excerpts on Romans 2, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
In the midst of this flood of pollutions and iniquities which Ctontile society presents to view the apostle sees one who Uke a judge from the height of his tribunal sends a stem look over the corrupt mass, condemning the evil which reigns in it, and ... the wrath of God which punishes it It is this new personage whom he apostrophizes in the following words : —
Romans 2:1–29 · Open Word Bible
1So you have no excuse, whoever you are, when you pass judgment on others. In judging someone else you condemn yourself, because you, the judge, do the very same things. 2We know that God's judgment on those who do such things rests on the truth. 3When you judge those who do such things and yet do them yourself, do you really think you will escape God's judgment? …
Yer, 1. Therrforeihouart ... man, tohosoever thou art that judgest: for wherein thou judged another, thou eon ... thyself; for thou that judgeet doeet the eame things!' — Whom is the apostle addressing? (Gentile magistrates, say the old Oreek ... But a magistrate is appointed to judge crimes; he could not be reproached for filling his office. The best of the Oentiles, say the Beformers, and Hofinann in our own day. But what purpose would be served, in this vast survey of the general state of mankind, by such a slight moral warning given to the best and wisest of the Grentiles not to set themselves to judge others ? Besides, this precept could not be more than a parenthesis, while it is easy to see that ver. 1 is exactly like ver. 18 of chap, i, the theme of aU the development which immediately follows chap, ii Evidentiy the person apostrophized in these terms : man . . ., forms an exception among those ... Others to its bar. It is a bold enterprise. The apostle proceeds oautiously. He first expresses his thought abstractly: thou who judged, whosoever thou art, to unveil it folly afterwarda Chap, il is thus the parallel of the passage i 18-32 ; it is the trial of the Jewish after that of the Gentile world. And the first two verses are its theme.
The course followed by the apostle is this: — In the first part, w. 1-1 6, be lays down the principle of God's trtie ... In the second, w. 17-29, he applies it directly to the Jew. — The first part contains the development of three ideas. 1. Favours received, far from forming a ground for exemption from judgment, aggravate Hie responsibility of the receiver, w. 1-5. 2. The divine sentence rests on the ... w. 6-12. 3. Not on knowledge, w. 13-16.
Romans 2:1 · Open Word Bible
1So you have no excuse, whoever you are, when you pass judgment on others. In judging someone else you condemn yourself, because you, the judge, do the very same things.
The ... which conneets this passage with the preceding, presents a certain ... which Hofmann and Bitschl have used to justify their Ubit from natural explanations of the preceding. Meyer takes this connecting particle as referring to the whole preceding description from ver. 18. For if a man is guilty, if he commits such things without judging them, it follows that he is still more guilty if he commit them while judging them. Ver. 1 might, however, be connected more particularly with ver. 32. In point of fact, if sinning while applauding the sin of others is criminal, would not men be more inexcusable still if they condemned the sin of others while joining in it ? In the former case there is at least agreement between thought, and action, — the man does what he expressly approves, — while in the second there is an internal contradiction and a flagrant hypocrisy. In the act of judging, the judge condemns his own doing, — The word inexcusable, here applied to the Jews, is the counterpart of the same epithet already applied to the Gentiles, i. 20. — Whosoever ... art ... whatever name thou bearest, were it even the glorious name of Jew.
Ver. 2. "Now toe are sure that the judgment of God is ... to truth ... them which commit such things." — We might give the S an adversative sense : But God does not let Himself be deceived by this judgment which thou passest on others." It is more natural, however, to translate this ... by now, and to take this verse as the major of a syllogism. The minor, ver. 1 : thy judgment on others condemns thee ; the major, ver. 2 : now the judgment of God is always true ; the conclusion understood (between w. 2 and 3) : therefore thy hypocritical judgment cannot shelter thee from that of God. The connecting particle yap, far, in two Alex, is inadmissibla Tins for, to be logical, must bear on the proposition: thou ... is unnatural, as a new idea has intervened since then. — What is the subject in we ... According to some: we. Christians. But what would the knowledge of Christians prove against the Jewish point of view which Paul is here combating ? Others : we, Jews. But it was precisely the Jewish conscience which Paul was anxious to bring back to truth on this point The matter in question is a truth ... according to the apostle, on the human conscience as such, and which plain common sense, free from prejudices, ... us to own : '* But every one knows." — The term ... does not denote, like ... the act of judging, but its contents, the sentence. The sentence which God pronounces on every man is ... to truth. ...
Romans 2:2 · Open Word Bible
2We know that God's judgment on those who do such things rests on the truth.
... There would be no more truth in the universe it there were none in the judgment of God ; and there would be none in the judgment of God if, to be absolved ourselves, it were enough to condemn ... words ... have sometimes been explained in the sense of really : " that there is really a judgment of God ... those who " • . • But what the Jews disputed was not the fad of judgment ; it was its impartiality — that is to say, its ... They could not get rid of the idea that in that day they would enjoy certain immunities due to their purer creed, and the greatiy higher position which they held than that of other nations. — ... things, that is to say, those referred to by the same word, ver. 32. — But the apostle is not unaware that in the Jewish conscience there is an obstacle to the full application of this principle ; it is this obstacle which he now labours to remove. Vv. 3-5 develope the words : ... who do sfock ... (whoevee they are, should they even be Jews) ; w. 6-16 will explain what is meant by a judgment ... to truth,
Ver. 3. " But thou ihinked this, man, that judged them which do euch things, ... doed the same, that thou shalt escape the judgment of God f " — We might, with ... mann, take the verbs ... and ... {thou counted, thou despised) in an affirmative sense. But the , or indeed, at the beginning of ver. 4 would rather incline us, following Paul's ordinary usage, to interpret these words in the interrogative sense ; not, however, that we need translate the former in the sense of: thinked thout The interrogation is less abrupt: ''thou thinkest no doubt?" The word ... to reason, well describes the false calculations whereby the Jews persuaded - themselves that they would escape the judgment with which God would visit the Gentilea Observe the ... thou : that thofu ... escape, thou," a being by thyself, a privileged person I It was a Jewish axiom, that *' every one circumcised has part in the kingdom to coma" A false calculation. Such, then, is the first supposition serving to explain the security of the Jew ; but there is a graver still. Perhaps this false calculation proceeds from a moral fact hidden in the depths of the heart Paul drags it to the light in what follows.
Romans 2:3 · Open Word Bible
3When you judge those who do such things and yet do them yourself, do you really think you will escape God's judgment?
Vv. 4, 5. *' Or despised thou the riches of His goodness and forbearance and long-suffering ; not knowing that tiis goodness of God leadeih thee to repentance t But, after thy hardness and impenitent heart, treasured up unto thysdf wrath againd the day of toraih and revelation ... judgment of God,*' — "H, or even. The meaning ia : is there something even worse 'than an illusion; is there contempt? The case then would be more than foolish, it would be impious! The ... of goodness, of which the apostle speaks, embrace all God's benefits to Israel in the past: that special election, those consecutive revelations, that constant care, finally, the sending of the Messiah, all that constituted the privileged position which Israel had enjoyed for so memy ages. The second term, ... patience (from ... to restrain oneself ... denotes the feeling awakened in tiie benefactor when his goodness is put to the proof by ingratituda Paul has in view no doubt the murder of the Messiah, which divine justice might have met with the immediate destruction of the natioa The third term, ... refers to the incomprehensible prolongation of Israel's existence, in spite of the thirty consecutive years of resistance to the appeals of God, and to the preaching of the apostles which had elapsed, and in spite of such crimes as the murder of Stephen and James (Acts vii. and xii.). The three words form an admirable climax. ... The form : " what good there is " • . . leaves it to be inferred that there is something else in God, and that He will not let Himself be always treated thus with impunity. The time will come when He will act with rigour. — The word ... to bring to, implies the power possessed by man of yielding to or resisting the attraction exercised over him. If he could not resist it how could the Jews be accused of committing this ... at this very time ? ... repentance, is the act whereby man goes back on his fonner views, and changes his standpoint and feeling.
Romans 2:4–5 · Open Word Bible
4Or do you make light of how rich He is in kindness, tolerance and patience? Do you not see that God is kind to you in order to bring you to repentance? 5But your heart is hard and will not repent, and so you are piling up wrath for yourself against the day of wrath, when God will make His righteous judgment known.
Ver. 5. The ... biU, contrasts the result of so many favours received with the divinely desired effect. The contrast indicated arises from the fact that the Jews in their conduct are guided by a wholly different rule from that to which the mercy of God sought to draw them. This idea of rule is .indeed what explains the preposition ieard, according to, which is usually made into a by. The word denotes a line of conduct long followed, the old Jewish habit of meeting the calls of God with a hard and impenitent heart ; what Stephen so forcibly upbraided them with, Acts vii. 61 : "Ye stiffnecked ... and uncircumcised in heart and ears, ye do always resist the Holy Ghost ; as your fathers did, so do ye." — Hardness relates to insensibility of heart to divine favours ; ... to the absence of that change of views which the feding of such goodness should have produced. — But it must not be thought that these favours are purely and simply lost Instead of the good which they should have produced, evil results from them. Every favour trampled under foot adds to the treasure of torath which is already suspended over the heads of the impenitent people. There is an evident correlation between the phrase riches of goodness, ver. 4, and the Greek word ... to treasure up. The latter word, as ... as the dative (of favour I) ... for thyself, have certainly a tinge of irony. What an enriching is that I Wrath is here denounced on the Jews, as it had been, i 18, on the Gentiles. The two passages are parallel ; there is only this difference between them, that among the Gentiles the thunderbolt has already fallen, while the storm is still gathering for the Jewa The time ... it will burst on them is called the day of wrath. ...
Romans 2:5 · Open Word Bible
5But your heart is hard and will not repent, and so you are piling up wrath for yourself against the day of wrath, when God will make His righteous judgment known.
... In this phrase two ideas are combined : that of the great national catastrophe which had been predicted by John the Baptist and by Jesus (Matt, iii 10 ; Luke xi 50, 51), and that of the final judgment of the guilty taken individually at the last day. The preposition ... in the day ") may be made dependent on the substantive wrath : " the wrath which ... have its ... course in the day when " ... But it is more natural to connect this regimen with the verb: ''thou art Leaping up a treasure which shall be paid to thee in the day when " ... The writer transports himself in thought to the day itself; he is present then: hence the i instead of ... The three Byz. Mjj. and the correctors of the SinaU. and of the ... read a ... and, between the two words ... jnd fudgment, and thus give the word ''day" tiiree complements : day of ... and of ... judgment. These three names would correspond well with the three of ver. 4 : goodness, patience, long-suffering ; and the term revdation, without complement would have in it something mysterious and threatening quite in keeping with the context. This reading is, however, improbable. The ... (and) is omitted not only in the Mjj. of the two other families, but also in the ancient versions (Syriac and Latin) ; besides, the word revelation can hardly be destitute of all qualification. The ... therefore says : the revelation of the righteous ... thus indicating that wrath (righteous judgment) ia still veiled so far as the Jews are concerned (in contrast to the ... is revealed, i. 18), but that then it will be fully unveiled in relation to them also. — Only two passages are quoted where the word ... jiidgment, is used: in a Greek translation of Hos. iv. 5, and in the Testaments of the Twelve ... ...
... The word recalls the phrase of ver. 2 : " The judgment of God according to truth," It dissipates beforehand the illusions cherished by the Jews as to the immunity which they hoped to enjoy in that day in virtue of their theocratic privileges. It contains the theme of the development which immediately follows. The just judgment of God (the judgment ... to truth, ver. 2) will bear solely on the moral ... of each individual, vv. 6-12, not on the external fact of being the hearer of a law, w. 13-16. These are the positive and negative characteristics of a judgment according to righteousness. — It would be unaccountable how Bitschl could have mistaken the obvious relation between w. 5 and 4 so far as to connect ii. 5 with the notion of wraih, i. 18, had not a preconceived idea imposed on him this exegetical violence.
Ver. 6. ' Who will render to every one ... to his deeded — No account will be taken of any external circumstance, but solely of the aim which has governed the man's moral action. It has been asked how this maxim can be reconciled with the doctrine of justification by faith. Fritzsche finds in them two different theories presenting an insoluble contradiction. Others think that in the judgment the moral imperfections of believers will be covered by their faith; which would convert faith into a means of sinning with impunity. What a just ... that would be ! Melanchthon, Tholuck, and others hold that this standard is purely hypothetical; it would be the standard which God would have applied if redemption had not intervened. But the future, " ... render" is not a conditional (wouid render). Besides, judgment according to the deeds done, is attested by many other passages, both from Paul (Rom. xiv. 12 ; 2 Cor. v. 10 ; GaL vi 6), from Jesus Himself (John V. 28, 29 ; Matt xii. 36, 37, etc.), and from other writings of the New Testament ... . Bitschl thinks that throughout this passage it is a Pharisee whom Paul introduces as speaking, and who starts from a narrow idea of divine justice — the idea, viz., of retributive justice. But what trace is there in the text of such an accommodation on the apostle*8 part to a standpoint foreign to his own ? The logical tissue of the piece, and its relation to what precedes and follows, present no breach of continuity. There is only one answer to the question raised, unless we admit a flagrant contradiction in the apostle's teaching: that justification by faith alone applies to the time of entrance into salvation through the free pardon of sin, but not to the time of judgment When God of free grace receives the sinner at the time of his conversion. ...
Romans 2:6 · Open Word Bible
6He will give each person what their deeds deserve.
... He asks nothing of him except faith ; but from that moment the believer enters on a wholly new responsibility ; God demands from him, as the recipient of grace, the fruits of grace. This is obvious from the parable of the talents. The Lord commits His gifts to His servants freely ; but from the moment when that extraordinary grace has been shown, He expects something from their labour. Comp. also the parable of the wicked debtor, where the pardoned sinner who refuses to pardon his brother is himself replaced under the rule of justice, and consequently under the burden of his debt The reason is that faith is not the dismal prerogative of being able to sin with impunity ; it is, on the contrary, the means of overcoming sin and acting holUy ; and if this ... is not produced, it is dead, and will be declared vain.
"Every barren tree will be hewn down and cast into the fire " (Matt iii 10). Gomp. the terrible warnings, 1 Cor. vi 9, 10, GaL vL 7, which are addressed to believers. — The two following verses develope the idea of the verb ... render.
Vv. 7, 8. To them who, by patiemt ... in well-doing, seek for glory and honowr and immortality, [to such] eternal life : hit unto them that are ... and do not obey the truth, but obey ... [for such] ... and indignation!" The Jews divided men into circumcised, and consequently saved, and uncircumcised, and consequently damued. Here is a new classification, which Paul substitutes, founded solely on the moral aim. — There are two principal ways of construing ver. 7. Sometimes the three words : glory, honour, immortality, are made the objects of the verb : urill render (ver. 6), understood. The phrase : patient continuance in well-doing, is thus taken to qualify the pronoun roU ... to them, and the last words : ... become merely an explanatory appendix : *' to wit, to them who seek eternal life." The meaning of the verse thus taken is : ''to them who live in patient continuance in well-doing [He will render] glory and honour and immortality, [to wit, to those] who seek eternal life." But this construction is very forced. 1. The subordinate clause : " in continuance," is rather the qualification of a verb than of a pronoun like ... 2. The participle ... would require the article ... and would make a clumsy and superfluous appendix. The construction, as given in our translation, is much more simple and significant The ... Koff ... literally, according to the standard of patient continuance in wdl-doing, corresponds with the seek, on which it depends ; seeking must be in a certain line. And the weighty word eternal life, at the close of this long sentence, depicts, as it were, the final and glorious issue of this long and laborious practice of goodness. ...
Romans 2:7–8 · Open Word Bible
7Those who persist in doing good, seeking glory, honor and immortality, He will reward with eternal life. 8But for those who are driven by selfish ambition, who reject the truth and follow wrongdoing instead, there will be wrath and fury.
... This accusative is the object of the verb: will render, understood (ver. 6). — The notion of patient ... is emphasized here, not only in opposition to the idea of intermittent moral efforts, but to indicate that there are great moral obstacles to be met on this path, and that a persistent love of goodness is needed to surmount them.
The apostle says literally: perseverance in good work. In ver. 6 he had used the plural works. He now comprehends this multiplicity of works in the profound principle which constitutes their unity, the permanent determination to realize goodness. What supports a man in this course is the goal which he has constantly before him : glory, an existence without defilement or weakness, resplendent throughout with the divine brightness of holiness and power ; honour, the approbation of God, which forms the eternal honour of its object; immortality {incorruptibility), the absolute impossibility of any wound or interruption or end to this state of being. The ands, ical, before the last two substantives, show a certain degree of emotion; the accumulation of terms arises from the same cause. In all human conditions there are souls which con template the ideal here described, and which, ravished with its beauty, are elevated by it above every earthly ambition and the pursuit of sensual gratifications. These are the men who are represented under the figure of the merchant seeking goodly pearls. For such is the pearl of great price, lifs eternal ! This last word, laden as it were with all divine riches, denotes the realization of the ideal just described ; it worthily closes this magnificent propositioa But is it asked again, where, in this description of a normal human life, are faith and salvation by the gospel to be found ? Does Paul then preach salvation by the work of man ? ...
... The apostle has not to do here with the means whereby we can really attain to ... he merely affirms that no one will be saved apart from the doing of good, and he assumes that the man who is animated with this persistent desire will not fail, some time or other, in the journey of life, to meet with the means of attaining an end so holy and glorious This means is faith in the gospel, — a truth which Paul reserves for proof at a later stage. '' He thai doeth ... said Jesus to the same ... comeih to the light I' as soon as it is presented to him (John iii 21; comp. vii. 17). The love of goodness, which is the spring of his life, will then lead him to embrace Christ, the ideal of goodness ; and, having embraced Him, he will find in Him the triumphant power for well-doing of which he was in quest The desire of goodness is the acceptance of the gospel by anticipation. The natural corollary of these premisses is the thought expressed by Peter : the preaehing of) the gospel before the judgment to every human soul, either: in this life or in the next (1 Pet iiL 19, 20, iv. 6). ... Matt xii 31, 32. And if the apostle has spoken of patient con ... in this pursuit, it is because he is well aware of that power of self-mastery which is needed, especially in a Jew, to break with his nation, and family, and all ... and to' remain faithful to the end to the supreme love of goodness.
Paul knew well from experience the tendency of Babbinical dis- cussions, and he characterizes it by a single word. The term ... is here used abstractly ; but Paul has, nevertheless, ia view the concrete realization of this notion in the gospel revelation. ... which he contrasts with ... (exactly as Jesus does, John vii 18), denotes the selfisk passions, vain ambitions, and unrighteous prejudices, which lead a mem to close his eyes to the light when it presents itself, and thus produce unbelief. Unrighteousness leads to this result as certainly as moral integrity leads to faith. Jesus developes precisely the same thought, John iiL 19, 20. The words icrath and indignation, which express the wages, earned by such conduct, are in the nominative in Greek, not in the accusative, like the word eternal life (ver. 7). They are not, therefore, the object of the verb will render, which is too remote. We must make them either the subject of a verb understood ... will be, there will be), or, better still, an exclamation : " for them, wrath I " The three Byz. Mjj. follow the psychological order, indignation and wrath ! First the internal emotion (indignation), then the external manifestation {wrath) ; bat the other two families present the inverse order, and rightly so. For what is first perceived is the manifestation ; then we pass upwards to the feeling which inspires it, and which gives it all its gravity. ... is the emotion of the soul; ... comprehends look, sentence, chastisement — Why does the apostle once again repeat this contrast of vv. 7 and 8 in w. 9 and 10? Obviously with the view of now adding to each term of the contrast the words : to the Jew first, and also to the Oreek, which expressly efface the false line of demarcation drawn by Jewish theology.
Vv, 9, 10. Tribtdatum and anguish, upon every soul of man that doeth evil, of the ... and also of the Greek; but glory and honour and peace to every man thai worketh good, to the Jew first, and also to the Greek ! " — The asyndeton indicates, as it always does, the more emphatic reassertion of the previous idea : " Tes, tribulation and anguish ! " — The antithesis of w. 7, 8 is reproduced in inverse order, not only to avoid the monotony of a too exact parallelism, but chiefly because, following up ver. 8 ... and indignation), the idea of ver. 9 ... and anguish) presented itself more naturally than that of ver 10 {glory and honowr and peace) ; comp. the same arrangement, Luke i. 51-53. The terms ... and anguish describe the moral and external state of the man on whom the indignation cmd ... of the judge fall (ver. 8). Tribulation is the punishment itself (corresponding to wrath); anguish is the wringing of the heart which the punishment produces ; it corresponds to the judge's indignation. The soid is mentioned as the seat of feeling. The phrase, every soul of man, expresses the equality and universality of the treatment dealt out Yet within this equality tiiere is traced a sort of pieference both as to judgment and salvation respectively (ver. 10), to the detriment and advantage of the Jew. When he says first, the apostle has no doubt in view (as in i. 16) a priority in time ; comp. 1 Pet iv. 17. Must we not, however, apply at the same time the principle laid down by Jesus, Luke xii. 41-48, according to which he who receives most benefits is also the man who has the heaviest responsibility ? In any case, therefore, whoever escapes judgment, it will not be the Jew ; if there were but one judged, it would be ... Such is the apostle's answer to the claim alleged, ver. 3 : ... that thou, tlum alane, ... escape,
Romans 2:9–10 · Open Word Bible
9There will be trouble and anguish for every human being who does evil, the Jew first and also the Greek. 10But there will be glory, honor and peace for everyone who does good, the Jew first and also the Greek.
Ver. 10. The third term: peace, describes the subjectiye feeling of the saved man at the time when glory and honour are conferred on him by the judge. It is the profound peace which is produced by deliverance from wrath, and the possession of unchangeable blessedness. The simple ... to do, is substituted for the compound ... to perpetrate (ver. 9), which implies something ruder and more violent, as is suited to evil ; comp. the analogous though not identical difference between ... and ... John iii, 20, 21. — On the word first, comp. the remarks made L 16, ii 9.
Here again the apostle indicates the result finally reached, whether evil or good, without expressly mentioning the means by which it may be produced ; on the one hand, the rejection of the gospel (ver. 9), as the supreme sin, at once the effect and the cause of evil-doing; on the ... its acceptance (ver. 10), as effect and cause of the determination to follow goodness and of its practice. But what is the foundation of such a judgment ? One of God's perfections, which the Jew could not deny without setting himself in contradiction to the whole Old Testament, the imparttality of God, whose judgment descends on evil wherever it is found, ... or without law (vv. 11, 12).
Romans 2:10 · Open Word Bible
10But there will be glory, honor and peace for everyone who does good, the Jew first and also the Greek.
Vv. 11, 12. "For there is no respect of persons with God. For as many as have sinned withaut law shall also perish without law: and as many as have sinned in the law shall be judged by the law!' — The principle stated in ver. 11 is one of those most frequently asserted in the Old Testament ; comp. Deut. X. 17 ; 1 Sam. xvi. 7 ; 2 Chron. xix. 7 ; Job xxxiv. 19. Accordingly, no Jew could dispute it — The phrase ... literally : to accept the ... to pay regard to the external appearance, belongs exclusively to Hellenistic Greek (in the LXX.) ; it is a pure Hebraism ; it forcibly expresses the opposite idea to that of just judgment, which takes account only of the moral worth of persons and acts. With God signifies, in that luminous sphere whence only just sentences emanate. But is not the fact of the law being given to some, and refused to others, incompatible with this divine impartiality ?
Romans 2:11–12 · Open Word Bible
11For God does not favor one person over another. 12Those who sin without having the law will be lost without the law, and those who sin while living under the law will be judged by the law.
No, answers ver. 12 ; for if the GentUe perishes, he will not perish for not having possessed the law, for no judgment will canse him to be sifted by the Decalogue and the Mosaic ordinances; and if the Jew should sin, the law will not exempt him from punishment, for the code will be the veiy standard which judgment will apply to all his acta Thus the want of the law no more destroys the one than its possession saves the other. The aorist ... sinned, transports us to the point of time when the result of human life appears as a completed fact, the hour of judgment The ... also (** will also perish without law "), brings out the congruity between the mode of the sin and that of the perdition. In the second proposition, this also is not repeated, for it is a matter of course that where there is a law, men should be judged by it The absence of the article in Greek before the word law, makes this word a categorical term, ''A mode of living over which a law presides ; " as applied : the Mosaic law. — ... by law, that is to say, by the application of a positive code (the Mosaic code). We must beware of regarding the difference between the two verbs: ... shall perish, and ... shall he judged, ... accidental (Meyer). The very thing the apostle wishes is by this antithesis to emphasize the idea that the Jews alone shall be, strictly speaking, subjected to a judgment, a detailed inquiry, such as arises from applying the particular articles of a code. ...
... The Gentiles shall perish simply in consequence of their moral corruption; as, for example, ruin overtakes the soul of the vicious, the drunken, or the impure, under the deleterious action of their vica The rigorous application of the principle of divine impartiality thus brings the apostle to this strange conclusion : the Jews, far from being exempted from judgment by their possession of the law, shall, on the contrary, be the ... people ... (in the strict sense of the word). It was the antipodes of their claim, and we here see how the pitiless logic of the apostle brings things to such a point, that not only is the thesis of his adversary refuted, but its opposite is demonstrated to be the only true one. — Thus all who shall be found in the day of judgment to have ... shall perish, each in his providential place, a result which establishes the divine impartiality.
It is evident that in the two propositions of this verse there is the idea understood : unless the amnesty offered by the gospel has been accepted, and has produced its proper fruits, the fruits of holiness (in which case the word ... sinned, would cease to be the summing up and ... word of the earthly life). — And why cannot the possession of the law preserve the Jews from condemnation, as they imagine ? The explanation is given in ver. 13, and the demonstration in vv. 14-16.
Ver. 13. '* Far not the hearers of the law are fust before God; ... the doers of the law, they shall he fustified," — Why hearers rather than possessors or readers ? To describe the position of the Jews who heard the reading of the law in the synagogue every Sabbath, and who for the most part knew it only in this way (Luke iv. 16 ... seq. ; Acts xiiL 15, xv. 21). — Before God, says Paul ; for before men it was otherwise, the Jews ascribing righteousness to one another on account of their common possession of the law. If such a claim were well founded, the impartiality of God would be destroyed, for the fact of knowing the law is a hereditary ... and not the fruit of moral action. The judicial force of the term ... in Paul's writings, comes out forcibly in this passage, since in the day of judgment no one is made righteous morally speaking, and can only be recognised and declared such. This declarative sense appears likewise in the use of the preposition ... (before God), which necessarily refers to an act of God as ... (see on i. 17). The artide ... before ... law, in the two propositions, is found only in the Byz. Mjj. ; it ought to be expunged : the hearers, the doers of a law. No doubt it is the Mosaic law which is referred to, but as law, and not as Mosaic. Some think that this idea of justification by the fulfilment of the law is enunciated here in a purely hypothetical manner, and can never be realized (iii. 19, 20). Paul, it is said, is indicating the ... standard of judgment, which, in consequence of man's sin, will never admit of rigorous applicatioa But how in this case explain the future " shall be justified ? ...
Romans 2:13 · Open Word Bible
13Hearing the law does not make anyone righteous before God; those who do what the law says are the ones God will declare righteous.
... Gomp. also the phrase of ver. 27: *' uncircumcision when it fulfUs the law/' words which certainly refer to concrete cases, and the passage viii 4, in which the apostle asserts that the ... what the law declares righteous, is ... in the ... believers life. It will certainly, therefore, be required of us that we he righteous in the day of judgment if God is to recognise and declare us to be such ; imputed righteousness is the beginning of the work of salvation, the means of entrance into the state of grace. But this initial justification, by restoring ... between God and man, should guide the latter to the ... possession of righteousness — that is to say, to the fulfilment of the law ; otherwise, this first justification would not stand in the judgment (see on ver. 6). And hence it is in keeping with Paul's views, whatever may be said by an antinomian and unsound tendency, to distinguish two justifications, the one initial, founded exclusively on faith, the other final, founded on faith and its fruiis. Divine imputation beforehand, in order to he true, must necessarily become true — that is to say, be converted into the recognition of a real righteousness. But if the maxim of ver. 13 is the rule of the divine judgment, this rule threatens again to overturn the principle of divine impartiality; for how can the Gentiles fulfil the law which they do not possess ? Yv. 14 and 15 contain the answer to this objection. .
Yv. 14, 15. *' For when Cfentiles, which have not the law, do by nature the things contained in the law, these, having ... the law, are a law unto themselves : for they show thereby the work of the law written in their hearts, their conscience also bearing witness to it, and their thoughts the meanwhile acetising or else excusing one another!* — There are four principal ways of connecting ver. 14 with what precedes.
1. Calvin goes back to ver. 12a: "The Gentiles will perish fustly, though they have not the law (ver. 12) ; for they have a law in their hearts which they knowingly violate " (ver. 14). The explanations of Neander, de Wette, Hodge, etc., are to the same effect But the number of important intermediate propositions and ideas intervening between this and ver. 12a renders it unnatural to connect the "for'* of ver. 14 with this declaration. Besides, was it necessary to prove to the Jews the righteousness of the punishment which would he inflicted on the Oentiles I 2. Meyer connects the ... with the immediately preceding proposition, ... "It is only doers of the law who can be justified, for this rule can be applied even to the Gentiles, since they too have a law engraved on their hearts." The connection is simple and logical But can the apostle really mean to say that a Gentile can obtain justification by observing the law of nature 1 That is impossible. We should require in that case to revert to the purely abstract explanation of ver. ... to regard it as a hypothetical maxim, and consequently to take v v. 14, 15 as an abstract proof of an impracticable maxim. These are too many abstractions.
Romans 2:14–15 · Open Word Bible
14Gentiles do not have the law. Yet when, by nature, they carry out what the law says, they become their own law, though the law was never given to them. 15Their conduct shows that the work of the law is written in their hearts. Their conscience bears witness too, and their thoughts argue with one another, now accusing them, now defending them,
3. Tholuck, Lange, Schaff likewise join the for with ... but they hold at the same time that this for will be veritably realized: "The doers of the law shall be justified, for God will graciously take account of the ... observance of the law rendered by the Gentiles " (here might be compared Matt XXV. 40, X. 41, 42); so Tholuck. Or: "Those Gentiles, partial doers of the law, will certainly come one day to the faith of the gospel, by which they will be fully justified ;'' so Lange, Schafil But these aie expedients ; for there ia nothing in the text to countenance such ideas. In ver. 15, Paul takes pains to prove that the Gentiles ?uive the law, but not that they observe it ; and about faith in the gospel there is not a word. This could not possibly be the case if the thought were an essential link in the argument 4. The real connection seems to me to have been explained by ... The for refers to the general idea of ver. 13 : " It is not having heard the law, as the Jews think, but having observed it, which will justify ; for if the hearing of it were enough, the Gentiles also coidd claim this advantage, since positive features in their moral life testified to the existence of a law engraved on their hearts, and the very definite application of it which they are able to make.** This connection leaves nothing to be desired ; and Meyer's objection, that it is necessary in this case to pass over ... in order to connect the for with 13a, is false; for the idea of 136 is purely restrictive: "The doers of the law shall alone be justified/' while the real affirmation is that of 13a ; " Those who have been only hearers shall not be jastified.** It is on this essential idea of ver. 13 that the for of ver. 14 bears. — Oraif, when it happens thai. ...
... These are sporadic cases, happy eventualities. — The word ... has no article: " people belonging to the category of the ... The logical relation included in the subjective negative ... is that which we should express by : " without having the law," or : " though they have it not." — ... literally : the things which are of the law, agreeable to its prescriptions. They do not observe the precept as such, for they have it not ; but they fulfil its contents; for example, Neoptoleinus in Philoctetes, when he refuses to save Greece at the expense of a lie ; or Antigone, when she does not hesitate to violate the temporary law of the city to fulfil the eternal law of fraternal love ; or Socrates, when he rejects the opportunity of saving his life by escaping from prison, in order to remain subject to the magistrates. Sophocles himself speaks of these eternal laws ... and contrasts this internal and divine legislation with the ever changing laws of man. — twre, by ... spontaneously, by an innate moral instinct. This dative cannot be joined with the preceding participle ... it qualifies the verb ... do ; the whole force of the thought is in this idea : do instinctively what the Jew does in obedience to precepts. The readings ... and ... may be corrections of ... with the view of conforming the verb to the following pronoun ... the Byz. reading ... may also, however, be a correction to make the verb agree with the rule of neuter plurals. In this case the plural of the verb is preferable, since Paul is speaking not of the Gentiles ... masse, but of certain individuals among them. Hence also the following ... these Oentiles. This pronoun includes and repeats all the qualifications which have just been mentioned in the first part of the verse ; comp. the ... ...
... John L 2. — Tlie logical relation of the participle ... not having law," and of the verb ela-iv, " are law,'* should be expressed by for ; not having law, they therefore serve as a law to themselves. The negative 17, placed above before the participle and the object ... is here placed between the two. This separation is intended to throw the object into relief : " This law (top ... for the very reason that they have it not ... they prove that they have it in anotber way." This delicate form of style shows with what painstaking care Paul composed But so fine a shade can hardly be felt except in the original language. The phrase : to he a law to oneself, is explained in ver. 15.
The descriptive pronoun ... as people who/' is meant to introduce this explanation ; it is in consequence of what is about to follow that Paul can affirm what he has just said of them, ver. 14. The relation of the verb ... show, and its object ... the work of the law, may be thus paraphrased : show the work of the law (as being) written ; " which would amoimt to : prove that it is written. But it is not even necessary to assume an ellipsis ... . What the Gentile shows in such cases is the law itself written (as to its contents) within his heart Paul calls these contents ... work of the law, because all the law commanded was meant to become work; and he qualifies ... by the article {the law), because he wishes to establish the identity of the Gentile's moral instinct with the contents of the Mosaic law strictly so called. But this phrase: the work of the law, does not merely designate, like that of ver. 14, ... {the things agreeable to the law), certain isolated acts. It embraces the whole contents of the law ; for ver. 15 does not refer to the accidental fulfilment of some good actions ; it denotes the totality of the moral law written in the heart The figure of a written law is evidently borrowed from the Sinaitic law graven on the tables of stone. The heart is always in Scripture the source of the instinctive feelings from which those impulses go forth which govern the exercise of the understanding and will It is in this form of lofty inspiration that the law of nature makes its appearance in man. The plural : their hewrt, makes each individual the seat of this sublime legislation. The last propositions of the verse have embarrassed commentators not a littie. ...
... They have not sufficiently taken account of the starting-point of this whole argument St Paul, according to the connection of ver. 14 with ver. 13, does not wish merely to prove that the Gentile possesses the law; he means to demonstrate that he ... it, just as the Jew heard it at Sinai, or still hears it every Sabbath in the synagogue ... hearer of the law, ver. 13a). And to this idea the appendix refers which closes ver. 15. That the Oentile has the law (is a law to himself), is already demonstrated But does he hear this law distinctly? Does be give ... of it to himself f If it were not so, he would certainly remain inferior to the Jew who brings so much sagacity to bear on the discussion of the sense and various applications of the legal statute. But no ; the Gentile is quite as clever as the Jew in this respect He also discusses the data of the moral inotinct which serves as his guide. His conscience joins its approving testimony ... to that of the moral instinct which has dictated a good action; pleaders make themselves heard within, for and against, before tliis tribunal of conscience, and these discussions are worth all the subtleties of Babbinical casuistry. — ... the conscience (from ... to know with or within oneself). This word, frequently used in the New Testament, denotes the ... (the ... for it is a ... which is in question), applied to the distinc tion of good and evil, as reason (the ... is the same ... applied to the discernment of truth and falsehood. It is precisely because this word denotes an act of knowledge that it describes a new fact different from that of the moral instinct described above. What natural impulse dictated without reflection, conscience, studying it afterwards, recognises as a good thing. Thus is explained the a-w, ivith, in the compound verb ... to bear witness with another. ...
... Conscience joins its testimony to that of the heart which dictated the virtuous action by commending it, and proves thereby, as a second witness, the existence of the moral law in the Gentile. Yolkmar: ''Their conscience bears testimony besides the moral act itself which already demonstrated die presence of the divine law." Most really, therefore, the Gentile has a law, — law not only published and written, but heard and understood It seems to me that in the way in which the apostle expresses this assent of the conscience to the law implanted within, it is impossible not to see an allusion to the amen uttered aloud by the people after hearing the law of Sinai, and which was repeated in every meeting of the synagogue after the reading of the law. — But there is not only hearing, there is even judging. The Babbins debated in opposite senses every kind of acts, real or imaginary. The apostle follows up the compaiison to the end. The soiil of the Gentile is also an arena of discossions. The ... denote the judgments of a moral nature which are passed bj the Gentiles on their own acts, either (as is most usually the case) acknowledging them guilty ... or also sometimes (such is the meaning of ... comp. ver. 14 : when H happens that . . .) pronouncing them innocent Most commonly the voice within says : That was bad I Sometimes also this voice becomes that of defence, and says : No, it was good I Thus before this inner code, the different thoughts accuse or justify, make replies and rejoinders, exactly as advocates befoire a seat of judgment handle the text of the law. And all this forensic debating proves to a demonstration not only that the code is there, but that it is read and understood, since its application is thus discussed. — The ... between them (among themselves). Some, like Meyer, join this pronoun with ... the Gentiles; he would refer it to the debates carried on ... ...
... OentUes and ... as to the moral worth of an action. But it is grammatically more natural, and suits the context better, to connect the pronoun between themselves with ... judgments. For this internal scene of discussion proves still more clearly than a debate of man with man the fact of the law toritten in the heart. Holsten proposes to imderstand the participle ... (borrowed firom ... with ... "their conscience bearing witness, and the judgments which they pass on one another's acts in their mutual relations also bearing witness." This construction is very forced, and it seems plain to us that the two participles accusing or else excusing refer to the thoughts, just as the participle bearing witness referred to their conscience.
How can one help admiring here, on the one hand, the subtle analysis whereby the apostle discloses in the Gentile heart a real judgment-hall where witnesses are heard for and against, then the sentence of the judge ; and, on the other hand, that largeness of heart with which, after drawing so revolting a picture of the moral deformities of Gentile Ufe (chap, i), he brings into view in as striking a way the indestructible moral elements, the evidences of which are sometimes irresistibly presented even by this so deeply sunken life ?
Ver. 16. "In the day when God AdU judge the secrets of men by Jesm Christ according to my gospel — In this final proposition there is expressed and summed up the idea of the whole preceding passage (from ver. 6), that of the final ... But what is the grammatical and logical connection of this dependent proposition? It would seem natural to connect it with what immediately precedes ... as Calvin does : " Their inward thoughts condemn or approve them in the day when" ... for: "till the day when" . . . But this sense would have required ... Tholuck and Flulippi employ another expedient; they understand: and that especially in the day when " . . . ; or : and that mare completely still in the day when " ... Others : " as will be seen clearly in the day when" . . . But if Paul had ineant to say all that, he would have said it Hofmann and Lange, also connecting this proposition with ver. 15 (Hofmann especially with ... manifest), regard the judgment of ver. 16 as being only the internal and purely moral judgment which is produced in the human conscience every time the gospel ia preached to man. ... The phrase : in ihe day when, would therefore denote, not the last judgment, but every day that a man hears the gospel for the first time. There is a context in which this explanation would be possible ; but here, where the dominant idea firom ver. 6 has been the final judgment, it is inadmissible. Besides, the phrase : by Jesus Ckrist, is not exactly suitable to any but the last judgment ; comp. the words, Acts x. 42, xvii 31; Matt xxv. 31 ... seq.; and especially the very similar phrases in 1 Cor. iv. 5. More over, ver. 29 can leave no doubt as to the apostle's meaning. ...
Romans 2:16 · Open Word Bible
16on the day when God, through Christ Jesus, judges the hidden things in people's lives, as the gospel I preach says.
... The only tolerable explanation, if it were wished to connect ver. 16 with ver. 15, would be to take the verbs of ver. 15 as expressing the permanent present of the idea : " The manifestation of the presence of the law, written within their hearts, takes place, for: will certainly take place, in the day when " . . . ; but this meaning of the verbs in the present in ver. 15 could not be guessed till after reading ver. 16. The time of the manifestation would have required to be indicated immediately to prevent a misunderstanding. The only natural connection of the words : in the day when, is to join them to the end of ver. 13 : " The doers of the law shall be justified . . . in the day when ... No doubt w. 14, 16 thus become a sort of parenthesis. But, notwithstanding, Paul has not deviated for a moment firom his principal thought. These two verses contained an explanatory remark, such as we now-a-days would put in a note ; it was intended to show that the Gentiles also would be entitled to believe themselves justified, if all that was necessary for this end were to possess and hear a law without doing it This false idea set aside, Paul resumes the thread of his discourse at ver. 16. To explain this verse, there is clearly no need of the two ex pedients proposed, the one by ... join it with ver. 4, the other by Laurent, to regard it as an interpolation. — The phrase : hidden things {seerets), is only to be explained by the understood contrast to external ... legal or ceremonial, in which the Jews put their confidence. None of those fine externals of piety or morality will deceive the eye of God in that day of truth. ...
... He will demand holiness of heart ; comp. the expression, ver. 29: 6 ... the Jew who is one inwardly, and : the circumcision of the heart ; comp. also, in the Sermon on the Mount, Matt v. 20-48, and vi. 1-18. This idea was indispensable to complete what had been said of judgment ... to deeds. — The word men sets the whole body of the judged face to face with the Judge, and reminds the Jews that they also will be there, and will form no exception. — At the first glance the phrase : according to my gospel, is surprising, for the expectation of the final judgment by Jesus Christ belongs to the apostolic teaching in general, and not to ... gospel in particular. Nevertheless, it is this apostle who, in consequence of his personal experience, and of the revelation which had been made to him, has brought out most powerfully the contrast between the ... legal and purely external works, wanting the truly moral principle of love, and good works, the fruits of faith working by love (EpL ii 9, 10 ; Gal. v. 6). This antithesis was one of the foundations of Paul's preaching. — The last words : by Jesus Christ, recall all the sayings in which Jesus announced His advent as judge. If it is really He who is 212 ... bt faitil to preside in the great act of final ... it is plain that, being such as He has made Himself known to ns, He will not be satisfied with a parade of external righteousness, and that He will demand a holiness like that which He realized Himself, which, taking its origin in consecration of heart, extends over the whole life.
The second part of the chapter, w. 17-29, contains the ... of the principles laid down in the first. After expressing himself in a general and more or less abstract way, Panl addresses himself directiy to the person whom he had in view from ver. 1, and finally designates him by name. Yet he still proceeds with the utmost caution ; for he knows that he is giving a shock to inveterate prejudices, prejudices which he long shared ... The way is slowly paved for the conclusion which he wishes to reach ; hence the length of the following sentence, which contains as it were the preamble of the judgment to be pronounced.
Vv. 17-20. "Now if thou art caUed a Jew, and ... in the law, and ... hoast of God, and hnowest Hie will, and canst discern the things that differ, being instructed ... of the law; and art confident that thou thyself art a guide of the blind, a light of them which are in darkness, an instructor of the foolish, a ... because thou hast the form of knowledge and of the truth in the law " . . . — Instead of ... behold, which the T. B. reads, with a single Mj., we must certainly read ... if; this is the natural form of transition from principles to tiieir application ; the other reading seems to be a consequence of itacism (pronouncing ... as 0- — Where are we to find the principal clause to ... this now if is subordinate ? Some, Winer for example, think that the same construction continues as far as the beginning of ver. 21, where it is abandoned on account of the length of the sentence, and where an entirely new proposition begina But we must at least meet again somewhere in the sequel with the idea which was in the apostle's mind when he began with the words now if. Meyer regards ver. 21 itself as the principal clause; he understands the ... as a particle of recapitulation. But, in an argument like this (now if, ver.
17), this meaning of ... It is better than, with Hofmann, to hold that the series of propositions dependent on now if is prolonged to the end of ver. 24, where the principal proposition resulting from all these considerations is understood as a self-evident consequence: what good in this case (that of such sitis, vy. 21-24) will accrue to thee from all those advantages (w. 17-20) ? It is to this understood conclusion, which we would replace with lacuna-points (..•), that the /or of ver. 2S very naturally refers. By this figure of rhetoric (aposiopesis) the apostle dispenses with expressing a conclusion himself, which must escape spontaneously from the conscience of every reader.
Romans 2:17–20 · Open Word Bible
17Now you call yourself a Jew. You rely on the law and take pride in God. 18You know His will, and because the law has taught you, you can tell what matters most. 19You are sure that you can guide the blind and be a light to people in the dark, …
The propositions dependent on **now ... taken together, embrace two series of four verses each ; the one, that from w. 17-20, is intended to enumerate all the advantages of which the Jew boasts; the other, from vv. 21-24, contrasts the iniquities of his conduct with those advantages.
The advantages are distributed into three categories. 1. The gifts of God, ver. 17. 2. The superior capabilities which these gifts confer on the Jews, ver. 18. 3. Hie part which he somewhat pretentiously thinks himself thereby called to play towards other nations, w. 19, 20. There is something slightly ironical in this accumulation of titles on which the Jew bases the satisfaction which he feels as he surveys himself.
Ver. 17. The name Jew, ... is probably not used without allusion to its etymological meaning : Jehoudah, the praised one. The preposition hri, which enters into the composition of the verb, converts this name into a real title. But Israel possesses more than a glorious name ; it has in its hands a real gift : the law. Here is a manifest sign of the divine favour on which it may consequently rest. Finally, this token of special favour makes God its God, to the exclusion of all other nations It has therefore whereof to glory in God. To the gradation of the three substantives: Jew, law, God, that of the three verbs perfectly corresponds : to call oneself, to rest, to glory.
Hence there result (ver. 18) two capabilities which distinguished the Jew from every other man. He knows God's will, and so succeeds in discerning what to others is confused. One is always entitled to be proud of hnawing; but when 214 ... bt faith. that knowing is of will, that is to ... the absolute and perfect will which ordains all, and judges of all sovereignly, such a knowledge is an incomparable advantage. By this knowledge of the divine will the Jew can discern and appreciate ... the most delicate shades of the moral life. — Th ... might signify the things that are ... from the meaning of surpass, which is often that of the verb ... But here it is better to translate : the things that differ (from the sense of differing, which is also that of ... for the apostle seems to be alluding to those discussions of legal casuistry in which the Jewish schools excelled, as when the two eminent doctors Hillel and ... gravely debated the question, whether it was lawful to eat an egg laid by a hen on the Sabbath day. — The last words of the verse : ... of {he law, indicate the source of that higher faculty of appreciation. The term ... from ... to be penetrated by a sound, makes each Jew law personified.
Romans 2:17 · Open Word Bible
17Now you call yourself a Jew. You rely on the law and take pride in God.
From this knowledge and faculty of appreciation flows the part which the Jew claims in regard to other men, and which is described in w. 19, 20 with a slight touch of ridicule. The first four terms set forth the morsd treatment to which the Jew, as the bom physician of mankind, subjects his patients, the Gentiles, to their complete cure. The term ... thou art confident, describes his pretentious assurance. And first, he takes the poor Grentile by the hand as one does a blind man, offering to guide him ; then he opens ... eyes, dissipating his darhness by the ... of revelation ; then he rears him, as one would bring up a being yet without reason ; finally, when through all this care he has come to the stage of the ... child, ... (who cannot speak; this was the term used by the Jews to designate proselytes; see Tholuck), he initiates him into the full knowledge of the truth, by becoming his teacher. — The end of the verse serves to explain the reason of this ministry to the Oentile world which the Jew exercises. He possesses in the law the pre cise sketch ... the exact outline, the rigorous formula of the knowledge of things which men should have (the idea which every one should form of them), and of the truth, that is to say, the moral reality or substance of goodness. ... The Jew possesses in the law not only the truth itself but its exact formula besides, by means of which he can convey this truth to others. We need not then, with Oltramare, make these last words an appendix, intended to disparage the teaching of the Jew : " though thou hast but the shadow of knowledge.'' The drift of the passage demands the opposite sense: ''as possessing the truth in its precise formula."
Vv. 21-24. " And if ... tlum who teachest another, teaehest not thyself f ... preaching a man should not steal, thou stealest t if, while saying a man dumld not commit adultery, ... com mittest ... t if, ... idols, thou committest sacrilege f if thou thai ... thy ... law, ... God through breaking the ... for the name of God is ... among the Gentiles through you, as it is written . . . — On the one side, then, the Jews are proud of the possession of their law ; but, on the other, how do they put it in practice ? It is to set forth this contradiction that the second series of propositions is devoted, w. 21-24. The ... then, ironically contrasts the real practical ... produced in the Jews by their knowledge of the law, and that which such an advantage should have produced. The term teach includes all the honourable functions toward the rest of the world which the Jew has just been arrogating. 'O ... Thou, the so great teacher! — The apostle chooses two examples in the second table of the law, theft and adultery ; and two in the first, sacrilege and dishonour done to God. Theft comprehends all the ... and deceptions which the Jews allowed themselves in commercial affairs. Adultery is a crime which the Talmud brings home to the three most illustrious Babbins, ... Mehir, and Eleazar. Sensuality is one of the prominent features of the Semitic character. The pillage of sacred objects cannot refer to anything connected with the worship celebrated at Jerusalem ; such, for example, as refusal to pay the temple tribute, or the offering of maimed victims The subject ... the proposition: thou who abhorrest idols, proves clearly tiiat the apostle has in view the pillage of idol temples. The meaning is: "Thy horror of idolatry does not go the length of preventing thee from hailing as a good prize the precious objects which have been used in idolatrous worship. when thou canst make them thine own." ...
Romans 2:21–24 · Open Word Bible
21So you teach others; will you not teach yourself? You preach that people should not steal; do you steal? 22You say that people should not commit adultery; do you commit adultery? You detest idols; do you rob temples? 23You take pride in the law; do you dishonor God by breaking it? …
... The Jews probably did not pillage the Gentile temples themselves; but they filled the place of resetters ; comp. besides, Acts xix. 37. Tlie dishonour done to God arises firom their greed of gain, their deceits and hypocrisy, which were thoroughly known to the Gentile populations among whom they lived. Paul weaves the prophetic rebuke into the tissue of his own language, but by the as it 18 written he reminds his readers that he is borrowing it firom the inspired Scriptures. His allusion is to Isa. liL 5 (which resembles our verse more in the letter than the sense), and to Ezek. zxxvL 18-24 (which resembles it more in the sense than in the letter).
We have regarded the whole passage, w. 17-24, as dependent on the conjunction ... now if, ver. 17 : "Now if thou callest thyself . . . (w. 17-20) ; and if teaching so and so, thou . . . (w. 21-24)." Thereafter, the principal clause is easily expressed as a proposition to be understood between w. 24, 25: ''What advantage will this law be to thee, of which thou makest thy boast before others, and which thou dost violate thyself with such effrontery?" For, in fine, according to the principle laid down, ver. 13, it is not those who ... the law, but those who do it who shall be pronounced righteous by the judgment of ... The idea understood, which we have just expressed, is that to which the for of ver. 25 refers : " For it is wholly in vain for thee, if thou art disobedient, to reckon on circumcision to exculpate thee. A disobedient Jew is no better before God than a Gentile, and an obedient Gentile becomes in God's sight a true Jew." Such is the meaning of the following passage, w. 25-29.
Yv. 25-27. *' For ... verily profiteth, if ... keep the law : hut if thou be a breaker of the law, thy ... is made ... TJierefore ... the ... keep the righteous ... of the law, shall not his wncircumcision be counted for circumcision t And shall not ... which is by nature, if it fulfil the law, judge thee, who urith the letter and ... doU transgress the lawf" — Paul knocks from under the Jew the support which he thought he had in his theocratic position, with its sign circumcision. We have seen it ; the adage of the Babbins was : " AU the circumcised have part in the world to come," as if it were really enough to be a Jew to be assured of salvation. Kow, ... had been given to Israel as a consecration to circumcision of hearty an engagement to holiness, and not as a shelter from judgment in favour of disobedience and pollution. Taken then in this sense, and according to the mind of God, it had its use ; but employed in the Babbinical sense, it formed only an external wall of separation requiring to be overturned. The prophets never ceased to work in this direction ; comp. Isa. i 10-15 and Levi 1 ... seq. — ... strictly: '*has become, and remains henceforth uncircumcision," in the eyes of God the righteous judge.
Romans 2:25–27 · Open Word Bible
25Circumcision is worth something if you keep the law. If you break the law, though, you are as good as uncircumcised. 26So if an uncircumcised man keeps what the law requires, will God not count him as circumcised? 27The man who is uncircumcised by birth but carries out the law will judge you, who have the law in writing and are circumcised, yet break the law.
Vv. 26, 27 describe the opposite case: the transformation of the obedient Gentile into a Jew, according to the judgment of God. This transformation, being the logical consequence of the preceding, is connected by ... therefore, with ver. 25. — The apostle is not now speaking, as in w. 14, 15, of a simple sporadic observance of legal duties. The phrase is more solemn : keeping the jud ordinances of the law ... all that the law dedares righteous). In viiL 4, the apostle uses a similar expression to denote the observance of the law by the Christian filled with the Holy Spirit How can he here ascribe such an obedience to a Gentile ? Philippi thinks he has in view those many proselytes whom Judaism was making at this time among the Gentiles. Meyer and others seek to reduce the meaning of the phrase to that of ver. 14. This second explanation is impossible, as we have just seen ; and that of Philippi faUs to the ground before the preceding expressions of the apostle, which certainly contain more than can be expected of a proselyte ... fulfil the law, ... rap ... w. 26, 27). The comparison of viiL 4 shows the apostle's meaning. He refen to those many Gentiles converted to the gospel who, all uncircumcised as they are, nevertheless fulfil the law ... virtue of the spirit of Christ, and thus become the true Israel, the Israel of God, ... vi 16. Paul expresses himself in abstract tetma, because here he has to do only with the principle, and not with the means by which it IS realized ; compare what we have said on w. 7, 10. The future ... will be counted, transports us to the hour of judgment, when God, in order to declare a man righteous, will demand that he ie so in reality.
Romans 2:26 · Open Word Bible
26So if an uncircumcised man keeps what the law requires, will God not count him as circumcised?
We might begin ver. 27 aa an affirmative proposition : and so ... will judge thee. Bat perhaps it is more in keep ing with the lively tone of the piece to continue in ver. 27 the interrogation of ver. 26, as we have done in our translation: "And so (in virtue of this imputation) will not He judge thee" . . .) The thought is analogous to Luke zl 31, 32, and Matt zii. 41, 42, though the case is different For there it is Gentiles who condemn the Jews by the example of their repentance and their love of truth ; here, it is the case of Christians of Gentile origin condemning the Jews by their fulfilment of the law. — Ostervald and Oltramare substitute for ... used by the apostle, the term candenm. This is wrong ; for the claim of the Jews is to escape, not only from condemnation, but from judgment ; and it is bitter for them to hear, not only that they shall be judged like the Grentiles, but that they shaJl be judged ly them. — ... to fulfil the law, is a phrase ... real and persevering fulfilment The love which the gospel puts into the believers heart is in fact ... of the law. Bom. xiii 10. — The preposition ... strictly {acroes the length of) : through, hero denotes, as it often does, the date, the circumstances in which an act is accomplished ; comp. 2 Oor. ii 4 ; 1 Tim. ii 15 ; Heb. ii 15. So : '' in faU possession of the letter and ciroumcision.'' This double transformation of the disobedient Jew into a Gentile, and of the obedient Grentile into a Jew, in the judg-* ment of God, is explained and justified by vv. 28 and 29.
Yv. 28, 29. For he ie not a Jew, which is one outwardly; neither is that circumcision, ... in the flesh : tut lie is a Jew, which is one inwardly; and circumcision is of the heart, by the spirit, and not by the letter; whose praise is not of men, hit of God,'* — The double principle laid down here by Paul was the sum of prophetic theology ; comp. Lev. xxvi. 41 ; Deut z. 16; Jer. iv. 14; Ezek. zliv. 9. And hence it is that the apostle can make it the basis of his argument Ver. 28 justifies the degradation of the Jew to the state of a Gentile, proclaimed in ver. 25 ; and ver. 29 the elevation of the Gentile to the rank of a Jew, proclaimed in w. 26 and 27. The two words which justify this double transformation are ... in secret, inwardly, and ... liar I, of the heart, by the spirit For if there is a principle to be derived from the whole of the Old Testament, i is that God has regard to the heart (1 ... xvi. 7). Paul himself referred in ver. 16 to the fact that in the day of judgment by Jesus Christ, it would be the hidden things of men which would form the essential ground of His sentence. There ia only one way of explaining naturally the grammatical construction of these two versea In ver. 28, we must borrow the two subjects ... and ... from the predicate ; and in ver. 29, the two predicates ... from the subject — The complement ... of the heart, is the gen. object.: the circumcision which cleanses the heart; the clause i' ... denotes the means : by the Holy Spirit The Spirit is the superior force which, by transforming the feelings of the heart, produces true inward purification. ...
Romans 2:28–29 · Open Word Bible
28For a person is not a Jew because of what is outward, and circumcision is not something outward in the body. 29No, the one who is a Jew inwardly is the Jew, and the circumcision that counts is of the heart, by the Spirit and not by the letter. That person's praise comes from God, not from people.
... The letter, on the contrary, is an outward rule which does not change either the heart or the will; comp. vii 6. Meyer thinks we should take ... of which, as a neuter, referring to Jvdaiem in general But to what purpose would it be to say that the praise of Judaism comes not from men, but from God ? That was sufficiently obvious of itself, since it was God who had established it, and all the nations detested it; we must therefore connect this pronoun with the Jew which precedes, and even with the feminine term ... which is used throughout this whole piece for the ... circumcised. — The word praise is again an allusion to the etymological meaning of the word ... (see on ver. 1 7) ; comp. Gen. xliz. 8. God, who reads the heart, is alone able to allot with certainty the title Jew in the true sense of the word — that is to say, one praised. The idea of praise coming from God is opposed to that whole Jewish vainglory which is detailed w. 17-20. — What a remarkable parallelism is there between this whole passage and the declaration of Jesus, Matt viiL 11, 12: "Many shall come from the east and from the west, and shall sit down in the kingdom of heaven," etc. . . . And yet there is nothing to indicate imitation on Paul's part The same tnith creates an original form for itself in the two cases.
Yet the apostle anticipates an objection to the truth which he has just developed. If the sinful Jew finds himself in the same situation in regard to the wrath of God as the sinful Grentile, what remains of the pierogative which divine election Beemed to assure to him ? Before going further, and drawing the geneitd conclusion following from the two preceding passages, L 18-32 and ii 1-29, Paul feels the need of obviating this objection ; and such is the aim of the following passage.