Logia

Frédéric Louis Godet · Commentary on St. Paul's Epistle to the Romans

Romans 14

45 excerpts on Romans 14, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

Romans 14:1–2

The first three verses are a sort of heading, in which the apostle expounds the ground of difference, and gives the solution of it provisionally.

Yv. 1, 2. " Him ... ia veak in Uie faUh receive ye not to discussions of opinions. One helieveih that he map eat aU things; "but another, who is ... eateth herbs." — The participle ... being weak, ia not altogether synonymous with the adjective ... weak; it denotes one whose faith falters (becomes weak) at a given moment and in a special case. This expression better spares the sensibilities of those here ... of The imperative ... receive, addressed to the whole church, evidently assumes that those who are recommended to this favourable reception form only a very weak minority at Rome. The Oreek expression signifies to take to oneself with tenderness; comp. xv. 7 and John xiv. 3, where it is applied to Christ's conduct in relation to believers. — The last words of the verse have been explained in a multitude of ways, Luther, OlsL : '' but not so as to excite doubts ... in your neighbour's inward thoughts ... There are two reasons opposed to this medoiing'; Bidxpun does not ... doubt, wad ... cannot mean simply thought. The ... denotes in the K T. tlie ... of tiie undeistanding in the service of evil ; oomp. Luke ii 36, v. 22 ; 1 Got. iii 20 ; and in our Epistle, i. 21. — Beza, Vulgate: ''but not to ... with them ... regaiding the ideas whidi they form of things ... " But ... does not denote an idea ; it is a ... but not to leach a still profounder separation of opinions." But how could it be ... that this would be the result of the ... lecommended;- and how should the idea: still ... have been omitted by the apostle? — Meyer: ''but not so as to criticize the thoughts (of your weak brethren)." ...

Romans 14:1–2 · Open Word Bible

1Welcome anyone whose faith is weak, but not in order to quarrel over their opinions. 2One person believes it is right to eat anything, while another, who is weak, eats only vegetables.

Report a mistake

... This meaning would require the singular ... and it does not harmonize with the term ... which applies rather to the reasonings of a proud wisdom than to pious scruples. — • The following is the meaning which alone seems to me natural : " but not to get by this very reception into debates ... which would terminate in the end only in vain reasonings ... " This meaning suits the two substantives used, as well as the plural form of bodi. .Alter this general recommendation tiie apostle formulates the point of the question.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:1

The foUowing passage is a practical application of the law of love expounded, chaps, xii. and xiii. It is an immediate illustration of the self-sacrifice which Paul has just been requiring. This passage, from its connection with a local circumstance, is at the same time the first step of return from the treatiee to the Utter form; it is, consequently, the transition to the epistolary conclusion of the entire writing. Thus it is that everything is organically bound together in the compositions of the apostle

WAS tiie ... of the difference of view to which the ... following refers? Yer. 2 ... a certam number of Chiisfcians at Rome thought they should abstain fiom the use of meats and of wine ; and it is piobable, from vy. 5 and 6, that the same men joined to this abstinence the scrupulous observance ... certain days which seemed to them more holy than others. This party does not appear to have been considerable or influential ; and Paul, far from treating it as he treated those who ... the pure gospel in ... at Corinth, or at Colosse, seems rather inclined to take it under his protection as against the rest of the churcL The subject is one on which somewhat divergent views have been expressed. It is difficult to explain the principle which led these people to act thus.

Romans 14:1 · Open Word Bible

1Welcome anyone whose faith is weak, but not in order to quarrel over their opinions.

Report a mistake

Eichhom regarded tiie weak as former Gentiles, who had belonged previously to a school of philosophy with an ascetic tendency, the ... for example. They imported into the gospel, according to him, certain principles pertaining to their former philosophy. — This opinion is now generally rejected. Ist There are manifest indications of the Jewish origin of this party. Thus w. 5 and 6 appear to prove that these same men observed the Jewish feast days, like the heretics of Colosse (see the exegesis). Besides, if the passage, XV. 1-13, still forms part of this section, as appears to us imquestionable, it follows that we have to do with a ... party. For this whole passage closes with the celebration of the union of Christians of loth origins in one and the same salvation. 2d. Such men would not have taken the modest and timid attitude at Some which seems to have been that of the weak. On the ground of their pretended superi-. ority, either in holiness or in culture, they would much rather have affected haughty airs in relation to the rest of the church.

Origen and Chrysostom regarded these people as Christians of Jewish origin, and ascribe their kind of life to their attachment to the Mosaic law. But the law did not forbid the eating of flesh, except that of certain (unclean) animals, nor the use of wine, except to certain persons and in certain particular cases. It would therefore be difficult to explain how they could have come by the way of the Levitical ordinances to the principle of entire abstinence.

Report a mistake

This reflection and ... mth the passage, 1 Cor. ... have led ... (Clem, of ... Elatt, ... Philip., eta) to explain the abstinence of tiie loeak by the fear they felt of unwillingly eating, flesh, and drinking wines which had been offered to idok. Bather than ... such a risk, they preferred to dispense with them ... But it should have been easy to find means of avoiding this ... in private meals ; and it would be hard to understand how, if the ideas of these people had been the same as those of their scrupulous brethren in the church of Corinth, Paul should not give them any of those explanations which he had given to the latter, and should content himself with striving to preserve peace within tiie church of Rome. It appears to us very doubtful, besides, whether the weak at Corinth were of Jewish origin. The more we have examined the question, the more have we been led to regard them rather as formerly Gentiles. Finally, the text of ven 14 is ... with, this opinion. Paul says : " I am persuaded in the Lord that there is nothing imclean of itself J' These words : of itself, prove that the pollution • appeared ... the weak as attaching to the very nature of the meats, and not merely contracted by accident.

Report a mistake

Baur, in his Apostel Pavius (I. p. 361 ... seq.), has attempted to connect the party of the weak with the ... who, according to the description given by Epiphanius, abstained ... all animal food, or even from food prepared with animal matter. He also cites the Cleinentins Homilies (dating firom Rome in the last third of the second century), in which tiie Apostie Peter thus describes his mode of life : " I use only bread and oil and a littie pulse,'* and where: it is taught that the use of flesh is contrary to nature, and of diaboliced origin. He cites also the saying of Hegesippus ... James the brother of our Lord : " He ate nothing ... {animated)''' As to wine, this critic refers to the fact that, according to Epiphanius, the most austere of the Ebionites celebrated the Eucharist only with unleavened bread and water; ... seems to prove that they abstained wholly from wina Bitschl {Enst. der ... Kirehe, 2d ... p. 184 ... seq.) has given out a somewhat different hypothesis, which has been, adopts by many modems. (Mey., Mang., etc.). ... According to this critic, the fandamental idea of the Essene order was to realize a permanent priestly life. Now, it is known that the priests were forbidden ... to drink wine while they were officiating; the Essene must therefore have abstained ... it entirely. Moreover, the priests, being required to eat only food consecrated to God, and Essenism rejecting at the same time the practice of bloody sacrifices, it followed that they could eat no flesh. If, therefore, such men had been sold as prisoners, and carried to Home as the result of previous wars, then set free and converted to the gospel, they might have carried with them into the church their former mode of life as superior in holiness to that of ordinary Christians. An analogous origin ought probably to be assigned to the sect which some years later troubled the church of Colosse. ...

Report a mistake

... In general, it is clear that a certain ascetic dualism was in the air at this period. And this was the common source of all the different tendencies which we have mentioned. — Only the question arises — (1) Whether, supposing the weak had belonged to one of these parties, Paul could have attached so little importance to the question considered in itself (comp. his ... in the ... to the Colossiand) ; and (2) whether the attitude of such Christians would have been so modest as the following passage supposes ?

Perhaps there is a simpler way of explaining the origin of such ideas. We must go back even beyond the law. According to the narrative of Genesis, animal food was not originally allowed to man (Gen. i. 29). It was not till after the deluge that it was expressly authorized (ix. 3). The invention of wine dates also from this latter epoch, and the abuse of this drink was immediately connected with its discovery. It is easy to understand how such Biblical precedents might have taken hold of serious readers of the 0. T., and led them to the abstinence of which our text speaks. In this conduct no Christian principle was seriously compromised. It was simply an attempt to return to the primitive regimen/ which easily presented itself to the mind as the most normal. And thus is explained why the apostle does not even touch the root of the question, and treats it solely on the side on which it ... the ... of harmony between the members of the ... To finish at once the exposition of our view, we shall add that, as appears to us, it was in the love -feasts that the difference broke out and gave rise to certain painful manifestations to which the apostle desired to put an end. We think we can give the proof of this as we study chap, xiv.

Report a mistake

It has been sometimes thought that in the first part of this chapter, w. 1-12, the apostle was addressing the weak, with the view of checking their unjust judgments upon the strong ; and in the second, w, 13—23, the ... to call them to the exercise of charity toward the weak. This view does not seem to me exact, at least as to the first part Bather Paul begins by addressing both in this part, in order to point out to them the duty of muttud toleration; then he turns specially to the strong in the second part, to remind them of the con siderate hearing which love claims of them toward the weak.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:2

Yer. 2. The meaning of ... to hdiem, is determined by its opposition to ... being ... ''who has a ... firm enough to be able to eat anything without scruple." — Eateth herbs, that is to say, nothing else.

Romans 14:2 · Open Word Bible

2One person believes it is right to eat anything, while another, who is weak, eats only vegetables.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:3

Yer. 3. **Let not him that eateth, despise him that eaieth not; and let not him which eateth not, judge him that ... for God Jiath received Aim."— This verse contains the theme which is about to be developed down to ver. 12. The two propositions aie connected in the T. S. by and, and in the Alex, by but. The second reading more strongly, perhaps too strongly, contrasts the two views. The term despise applies wdl to one who feels ... strong, and ... with a disdainful eye the timid attitude of the weak ; the term ... suits the latter, who, not understanding the liberty used by the strong, is disposed to confound it with licence. — The last ... God hath received him, may refer to both, or to the latter only (the ... 831: strong). ... A Bemg whom God has taken to ... whom He: ... one of ... own, ... not to be judged lightly by his brother, aff if he were without master. This is what is developed in the following Tessa . . '

Romans 14:3 · Open Word Bible

3The one who eats must not look down on the one who abstains, and the one who abstains must not pass judgment on the one who eats, because God has welcomed that person.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:4

Yer. 4. ' ... art thau ... To his awn master he standeth ... Tea, he shall stand ; far God is powerful ... him — The idea is : It is ... the advantage or ... of his master, not of his fellow servants, that a servant fulfils or negleets bos task The terms standing and ... not to the servant's absolution or condemnation at the judgment, but to his daily faithfulness or ... and to the ... or weakening of his inward relation to Christ What proves this, is the ground for confidence indicated in ... Yea, he shall stand; for God is powerful to hold him up/' There is no more need of being held up, or at least of being so by the-power of God, in the judgment day. Of course the ... in the line of conduct which he has adopted, is assumed, even if he were in error on a particular point Paul affirms that the Lord will be able to hold him in communion with Himself. — Here tiie Lord is probably, as generally in the 17 T., Christ. It is He, indeed, who is Master of the house, and for whom the servants labour (Luke ziL 41-48). — There is a slight touch of irony in this reason : '' Yea he shall be held up." It is as if Paul said to the weak : Thou mayest assure thyself about him ; for, erven if he is mistaken, his Master is powerful enough to avert the bad effects of a piece of flesh/' This argument applies, of ... only to things which arise exdusively on the domain of the individual conscience.— In the last proposition, the Greco-Lat reading o ... ...

Romans 14:4 · Open Word Bible

4Who are you to judge someone else's servant? It is to their own master that they stand or fall. And they will stand, because the Lord has the power to keep them standing.

Report a mistake

... God, it seems to me, ought to be preferred to that of the other documents ... the Lord ; for the act in question is that of strengthening, which is naturally ascribed to God. The reading o ... has probably arisen from the ... which precedes. — How easily do these yerses find their explanation if we imagine the ehurch assembled for the love-feast I The majority gives an affectionate welcome to the minority They sit down all together for the feast; then immediately the difference breaks out between neighbours. It is the moment for watching: *' Well ! " says the apostle, *' no perverse debates on this occasion ; but let each beware of the danger which threatens him at this instant, the one of despising, the other of judging."

Report a mistake

Romans 14:5–6

Vv. 5, 6. ' One man ... one day from another, the other edeemeth every day alike: let every man be fully persuaded in his own mind. He thai regardeth the day, regardeth it ... the Lord; and he that regardeth not the day, to the ... he does not regard it. He that eaieth, eateth to the Lord, for he giveth God tiianks; and he that eaieth not, to the Lord he eateth not, and ... God thanked — Paul here adduces an example taken from the same domain of external practices, and in which the two opposite lines of conduct may be also followed with equal fidelity. The days are those of the Jewish feasts, which ... continued for the most part to observe : Sabbaths, new moons, etc. (Col ii 15)* Did this example reaUy exist at Rome, or did the apostle choose it from the life of the church in general, to have the opportunity of better explaining his thought ? The first is the more natural supposition. For there must have been in the church of Home a certain number of Judeo- Christians though they did not form the majority. — The for, which is read in some MSS., is probably owing to a copyist's habit The word ... to pidge, frequently takes the sense of distinguiehing. To judge one day ... others, may therefore signify : to ... it favour ably from the others ; to set it apart as more worthy to be sanctified. There is a little irony in the second alternative : to discern every day. For it is evident that there is no longer any distinction when all are ... To set apart every day as holy, is no longer to sanctify any one specially. Between the two modes of acting thus expressed, the apostle does not decide. All he asks of any one is, that his practice should obey a personal and deliberate conviction. The expres- with L P Syr., is omitted by K A B C D E F G, It sion ... vot, in ... mind, contains the idea of a serious examination ; and the term ... strictly : to be fUed to the brim, denotes a state of conviction which leaves no more room for the least hesitation.

Romans 14:5–6 · Open Word Bible

5One person regards one day as more important than another, while someone else regards every day as the same. Each person must be fully convinced in their own mind. 6Whoever observes the day does so for the Lord. Those who eat do so for the Lord, since they give thanks to God; and those who abstain do so for the Lord, and they too give thanks to God.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:6

Ver. 6. The apostle states the reason why the two lines of conduct are equally admissible It is because opposed as they are, they are inspired by one and the same desire, that of serving the ... The second proposition : " He that regardeth not the day " . . ., is omitted in the Alex, and Greco-Lat. texta Notwithstanding all the efforts of commentators, and of Hofmann in particular, to justify the absence of this parallel proposition, this reading appears to me untenable. It is necessary strangely to force the meaning of the first alternative : He that regardeth . . . regardeth unto the Lord,'* to bring it into logical relation to the two ways of acting explained in ver. 5. And it ia impossible to refer it only to one of them. The confounding of the two ... by a careless copyist must have caused the omission, as in so many other similar cases. — The apostle means that the man who, in his religious practice, keeps the Jewish feast-days, does so for the purpose of doing homage to the Lord by resting in Him, as the man who does not observe them does so for the purpose of labouring actively for Him.

Romans 14:6 · Open Word Bible

6Whoever observes the day does so for the Lord. Those who eat do so for the Lord, since they give thanks to God; and those who abstain do so for the Lord, and they too give thanks to God.

Report a mistake

It has been concluded from these sayings of Paul, that the obligation to observe Sunday as a day divinely instituted, was not compatible with Christian spirituality, as this was understood by St Paul The context does not allow us to draw such a conclusion. The believer who observes Sunday does not in the least do so imder the thought of ascribing to this day a superior holiness to that of other days. To him all days are, as the apostle thinks, equal in holy consecration. As rest is not holier than work, no more is Sunday holier than other days. It is another form of consecration, the periodical return of which, like the alternations of sleep and waking, arises from the conditions of our physico-psychical existence. The Christian does not cease to be a man by becoming a spiritual man. And as one day of rest in seven was divinely instituted at the creation in behalf of natural humanity, one does not see why the believer should not require this periodical rest as well as the unregenerate man. The Sabbath was ... man;" so long as the Christian preserves his earthly nature, this saying applies to him, and should turn not to the detriment, but to the profit of his spintual lifia. The keeping of Sunday thiis understood has nothing in common ... the Sabbatical observance which divides life into two parts, the one holy, the other profane. It IS this legal distinction which Paxil excludes in our ver. 6 and ... ii In the second part of veft, 6, Paul returns to the principal case. He does so simply by the copula teal, and, and not by a ... likewise; which seems to prove that the example taken from the keeping of days was not a simple comparison chosen at pleasure from the general life of the churchy but a case which was really found at ... itself. As proof that he who eats (of everything), eats to the Lord, the apostle adduces ... the fact that he gives thanks for those meats. ...

Report a mistake

... The object of this giving of thanks is God, as the author of nature. — In speaking of him who does not eat (of everything), Paul does not say, as in the previous case : *'for he giveth thanks," but : '' and he giveth thanks." It was unnecessary, indeed, to prove that by abstaining he did ... for the Lord; that was understood of itself. The real meaning of this proposition is therefore : " And he does not the less give thanks he too, for tUs frugal repast" — Aa to these two ... which mark the two ... ways of acting with a seal of equal holiness, how much more of a dramatic character do they take when we imagine them as offered by these two classes of believers at the same moment and at the same table !

This so remarkable saying of the apostle furnishes us with the true means of deciding all those questions of casuistry which so often adse in Christian life, and cause the believer so much embarrassment: May I allow myself this or that pleasure? Yes, if I can enjoy it to the Lord, and while giving Him thanks for it ; no, if I cannot receive it as a gift from His hand, and bless Him for it. This mode of solution respects at once the righte of the Lord and those of individual liberty.

The contrast between these two ways of acting, ... and abstaining, which we must beware of converting into a contrast of faithfulness and unfaithfulness, was only the special application of a more general contrast which pervades the whole of human Ufe : that between living and dying. Paul, always finder the ... of embracing ... in all their ... extends in the foUowing verses that which he has juat ... treating to the entire domain of life and deaiL

Report a mistake

Romans 14:7–8

Yv. 7, 8. ... Tione of us Iweih to ... and ... man ddeth to ... For, ... we live, we live ... the Lord; whether 'we die} we die unto the Lord, Whether we live, ... or die} ufe are the — In everything that concerns the active use of life (such as the enjoyment of a kind of food), as well as in everything connected with the wasting of it, of which death is the ... (such as abstinence), the Gbriistian depends not on his own will, but on the Lord's. Paul does not mean to say thereby how we ... to act. For in that (iase ... following verse would require to be connected with this one by therefore, and not by for. It is ... he expresses ; he supposes it reali in the life of his readers. The truth of this supposition follows from the meaning of the word ... us believers. Faith, if it is real, implies this consequence. Once we axe believers, the Current of life with all it embraces, and the current of death with all that accelerates it, tend no longer self-wards, as in our natural existence. Consequently we cannot be called by men to give account of our conduct, though it may differ from theirs.

Romans 14:7–8 · Open Word Bible

7For not one of us lives for ourselves, and not one of us dies for ourselves. 8If we live, we live for the Lord; if we die, we die for the Lord. So, living or dying, we belong to the Lord.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:8

Ver. 8. The proof of ver. 7 is given. in ver. 8 {for). Our life and death beiag through the fact of faith at the Lord's service, the contrast between living and dying is thus completely dependent on the higher direction impressed on our being. Gomp. 2 Cor. v. 15 and Bom. xiL 1. For the believer to live, is to serve Christ ; to die, is to be united to Him more perfectly ... i 21-24; 2 Cor. v. 6-9). Hence it follows ... therefore) that he remains in every state of the case the Lord's property. As the dative ... to the Lord, in the first part of the verse, expressed consecration ; so the genitive rot) ... literally, of the Lord, in the last proposition, expresses possession. We remain His in both cases. The bond which unites us to Him can only be strengthened by the so varied circumstances summed up in the two words : life and death. — The first and third time we should probably read the subjunctive ... for ... if, whether is ... strued in the N. T. only with the subjunctive. But the second time the indicative ... must certainly be read ; for it is a fact which Paul is stating. Those who have read the subjunctive, have mistaken it for an exhortation.

The solidity of the bond of possession which unites the believer to the Lord, rests on his side on the subjective fact of faith, but on the Lord's side on an objective fact which nothing can shake : the sovereignty of the glorified Christ, in virtue of which He evermore controls the contrast between life and death (ver. 9).

Romans 14:8 · Open Word Bible

8If we live, we live for the Lord; if we die, we die for the Lord. So, living or dying, we belong to the Lord.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:9

Ver. 9. " For to this end Christ dUd and revived ;* that He might he Lord loth of the dead and living'* — With the view of securing the possession of His own, whether as living or dead, Jesus began by resolving in His own person the contrast between life and death He did so by dying and reviving. — For what is one raised again except a dead man living t Thus it is that He reigns simultaneously over the two domains of being through which His own are called to pass, and that He can fulfil His promise to them, John X. 28 : ''None shall pluck them out of my hand." ... also John xL 25, 26. Of the three principal readings presented by the documents, the simplest and most agreeable to the context is certainly the Alexandrine reading : He died and revived." These two terms correspond to the living and the dead. This very simple relation has been changed in the other readings. The word rose again, in the Byz. reading, has evidently been introduced to form the transition between these : died and revived. The reading of two Greco-Lats. and of ... lived, died, and rose again," has certainly arisen from the desire to call up here the earthly life of Jesus ; which was not necessary, since the domain of the living belongs now to Jesus, not in virtue of His earthly existence, but in consequence of His present life as the glorified One. To understand this saying rightly, Eph. iv: 10 should be compared, where the apostle, after pointing to Christ " descended into the lowest parts (the abode of the dead}," then "ascended to the highest heavens," adds : ''that He might fill all things." Which signifies that by traversing all the domains of existence Himself, He has so won them, that in passing through them in our turn as believers, we never cease to be His, and to have Him as our Lord. Hence the inference expressed ver. 10.

Romans 14:9 · Open Word Bible

9This is why Christ died and came to life: so that He would be Lord of both the dead and the living.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:10

Yer. 10. " But thou, why dost thou judge thy brother ? and thou also, why dost thou set at nought thy broths f For we shall all stand at the — The ... hut, contrasts the incompetent judgment of a broths, with the judgment of this one Lord. — The first question is addressed to the weak ; comp. ver. 3. The second, connected by : or thou also, to the strong. The also is explained by the fact that contempt is likewise a mode of judging. No one ought to be withdrawn from his rightful judge, who is the Lord alone. — The all is prefixed to remind us that no one will escape bonk that judge. It is well said, no doubt, John v. 24, that the believer '' shall not come into judgment ; " but that does not mean that he shall not appear before the tribunal (2 Cor. v. 10). Only he will appear there to be owned as one who has already voluntarily judged himself by the light of Christ's word and under the discipline of His Spirit ; comp. John xiL 48 and 1 Cor. xl 3 1. — The Alexs. and ... read ... the judgment-seat of God." This expression must then be explained in the sense : the divine tribunal, where Christ will sit as God's representativa For never is God Himself represented as seated on the judgment throne. But is it not the two following verses which have given rise to this reading ?

Romans 14:10 · Open Word Bible

10You, then, why do you pass judgment on your brother or sister? Or you, why do you look down on your brother or sister? We will all stand before God's judgment seat.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:11–12

Vv. 11, 12. " For it is written, As I live, saith the Lord, every knee shall bow to me, and every tongue shall confess to God. So then,* every one of us shall give account of himself to God." ' — In ver. 11, Paul quotes Isa. xlv. 23, where the imiversal ... B D F G P, ... omit ... then.

is described, which all creatures will render to God ... the end of the world. This homage supposes and implies .the judgment, by whidi they shall all have been brought to ffis feet. If we read of ... and !not of Chd, at the ... of Ter. 10, it must be held that the apostle sees tiliis Jifit royal manifestation of Jehovah, proclaimed by Isaiah, finding its realization in Christ ; comp., indeed, ... ii 10, 11, where the words of Isaiah in our verse are applied to Jesus glorified — The form of affirmation in the original text is : / Jtave sworn by mysdf Paul substitutes, unintentionally no doubt, a somewhat different form of oath, but one which is also frequent in the O. T. : ''I am living that '' . . . the meaning of which is : *' As truly as I am the eternally living One, ... truly shall this come to pass." The words : ... the Lordy . are here added by the apostle. Then he substitutes for the expression : ... moear by me ... the one true God), the term *' shall do me homage " ... . This word, which strictly signifies to confess, might allude to the judgment which will lay every man low in the conviction of his guilt, and •draw forth firom the heart of all an acknowledgment of God's holiness and righteousness. But all that this term expresses ,may simply be the homage of adoration, which proclaims God as the one being worthy to be glorified ; comp. Luke ii. 38 ; ... ii. 11. — The words to God are the paraphrase of the to me, in Isaiah.

Romans 14:11–12 · Open Word Bible

11For it is written: "As I live, says the Lord, every knee will bend before Me, and every tongue will openly acknowledge God." 12So each of us will have to give an account of ourselves.

Report a mistake

In ver. 12, Paul applies to every individual in particular what has just been said of aU in general. The preceding context signified : " Judge not thy brother, for God will judge ... this verse signifies: "Judge thyself, for God will ... thee" — Paul here repeats the expression ... to God, jather than say ... to Christ, because he wishes to contrast in a general way divine, the alone truly just ... with human judgments.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:13–23

After having addressed the strong and the weak simultaneously, the apostle further addresses a warning to the former, to induce them not to use dieir liberty except in conformity with the law of love. As is - observed by Hofinann, ... had nothing ... to the 'weak ; for he who is inwardly bound cannot change his ... while the strong man who feels himself free ... at pleasure make nse of his right or waive it in ... To induce the strong believer to make sacrifice of his libeit ... the apostle brings to bear on him the two following motives : — 1st Yv. ... duty of not wounding the heart of the weak or producing inward irritation; ... Vv. 195-28, the fear of destroying God's work within him by leading him to do something against his

Romans 14:13–23 · Open Word Bible

13So let us stop judging one another. Use your judgment for this instead: never to put a stumbling block or a snare in the way of a brother or sister. 14I know, and in the Lord Jesus I am fully persuaded, that nothing is unclean in itself. But if someone considers a thing unclean, then for that person it is unclean. 15If your brother or sister is being hurt by what you eat, you are no longer walking in the way of love. Do not let what you eat bring ruin on someone for whom Christ died. …

Report a mistake

Romans 14:13

Yer. 13. *' ... us net, therefore, judge one another any more, but judge this ... thai no man put a dumbling - block or an occasion to faU in hds — The first proposition sums up the whole of the first part of the chapter ; for it is still addressed to both parties ; it forms at the same time the transition to the second. The object of the verb : one another, proves that the term judge here includes the contempt of the strong for the weak, as well as the condemnation which these take the liberty of pronouncing on the former. — From the second proposition of the verse onwards, the apostle turns to the strong exclusively. He makes a sort of play on the meaning of the word ... to judge : " Do not judge one another ; but, if you will judge absolutely, judge as follows." Judge the second time has the meaning of decide; comp. Tit iii 12. — The wise decision to take is, according to Paul, to avoid anything that might cause a shock ... or even a fall ... to yova neighbour. There must be, whatever Meyer may say, a ... of meaning between the two substantives; not only because Paul does not use pleonasms, but also on account of the particle , or, which undoubtedly expresses a gradation: or even. One strikes against ... the result is a ... but one stumbles against an obstacle ... the result is ... The second case is evidently graver than the first It is easy even to recognise ... these two terms the theme of the two following developments : the first relates to the ... feding of the weak, with all its vexing ... second to the sin which one is in danger of making him commit by leading him into an act contrary to his conscience. The first of these ' evils, as we have said, is referred to in' w.

Romans 14:13 · Open Word Bible

13So let us stop judging one another. Use your judgment for this instead: never to put a stumbling block or a snare in the way of a brother or sister.

Report a mistake

''I know, and am persuaded in the ... Jems, tJiai nothing is unclean of itself: except that to him that esteemeth anything to he unclean, it is unclean. Now ' if (hy brother he grieved with a meat, thou ... no more charitably. Destroy not him with thy ... for ... Christ died!* — Paul does not wish to discuss the matter ; but yet he cannot conceal his conviction; and he expresses it in passing, in ver. 14, as a concession he must make on the side of the strong. At bottom, it is they who are right ... himo, indicates a rational, theoretic conviction, such as even a Jew, trained by the 0. T. to a true spirituality, might reach. The second verb ... I am ... goes further; it indicates that this conviction has penetrated to his very conscience, and set it practically free from all perplexity. The words : in the Lord Jesus, remind us that it is He who has put an end to the obligations imposed by the ceremonial law. The emancipation which faith finds in Him arises not only from His doctrine (Matt XV. 11, for example), but above aU from the redemption wrought by Him. This regimen : in the Lord Jesus, bears on the second verb ; there is nothing except the possession of salvation which can practically give ... liberty to the soul. — Several ancient commentators have referred the words ... to Jesus Christ : " Through Him there is no longer ... unclean." But the negative form of the proposition is not favourable to this sense. Paul would rather have said : *' everything is dean through Him."

Report a mistake

Romans 14:15

Yer. 15. If this verse be connected with the preceding by ... with the majority of the Mjj., it is veiy ... to understand their logical rdation. Meyer paraphrases thus : " It is not without reason that I remind you of that (the preceding restriction) ; for love is bound to take accoimt of such a scruple." Hofmann rightly judges this explanation of the ... impossible ; but is his own less so ? He takes the phrase following in the interrogative sense : '' ... if thy brother is grieved thereby, wouldest thou for this error on his part henceforth cease to walk toward him in love ? " It is ... cult to imagine anything more forced. We must therefore, though the T. B. ... now then or hut, has only a single Mj. (L) in its favour, prefer this reading (Seiche, Bilck., de W., Philip.). This ... may be taken in the sense of now then, or in that of ... The adversative sense seems to me preferable. The but refers to the first part of ver. 14 : ''I know that nothing is unclean . . ., but if, nevertheless " ... The meaning is excellent, and the construction the more admissible because the second part of ver. 14 was a simple parenthesis. — ... is grieved, hurt; this word expresses the painful and bitter feeling produced in the heart of the weak by the spectacle of the free and bold eating of the strong. — With the words : '' Thou walkest no more ... charitably," we must evidently understand the idea : when thou actest thus. The threat, added by the apostle, of compromising thereby our neighbour's salvation, is so grave, that it is not explicable at the first glance, and one is tempted to refer it to the sin which the weak believer would commit by imitating the strong; comp. ver. 20. ...

Romans 14:15 · Open Word Bible

15If your brother or sister is being hurt by what you eat, you are no longer walking in the way of love. Do not let what you eat bring ruin on someone for whom Christ died.

Report a mistake

... But it is not till afterwards that Paul comes to this side of the question, and it is far from probable that the weak man, at the very time when he is wounded by the conduct of the strong, could be tempted to imitate him. These words therefore refer to the profound irritation, the hurtful judgments, the breach of brotherly ties, which must result from such wounding. The asyndeton is striking: it shows Paul's emotion when writing these last words . . . : ' By thy meat make him perish whom Christ saved by His death I "

The whold scene sappos by this veise is infinitelj better' understood if it is placed in the foil love-feast, than if ... strong and the weak are supposed taking their meal at their own ... The following verses ... complete by some secondary ... the. principal motive which has been expressed at the end of ver. 15.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:16

Yer. ... But all these meanings want appropriateness. The context itself shows that the subject in question is Chris tian liberty (Orig., Calv., ThoL, etc.). The you applies not to all believers, but to the strong only. Paul recommends them not to use their liberty so as to provoke the indignation and blame of their weaker brethren. The blessing they enjoy ought not to be changed by their lack of charity into a source of ... Carefully comp. 1 Cor. viiL 9—11, and x. 29, 30.

Romans 14:16 · Open Word Bible

16So do not let the good thing you have be slandered.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:17

Ver. 17. " For the kingdom of God is not meat or drink, ... and peace and joy in the Holy Spirit!* — Nothing could ... simpler than the connection of this verse with the' preceding. The force from above, which is the essence of the kingdom of God, does not consist in being able to eat or drink more or less freely and regardlessly toward our neighbour, but in realizing in life the three dispositions mentioned, by triumphing over our own tastes and vanity. The three terms : ... peace, joy, ought, according to the context, to be taken in the social sense, which is only an application of their religious sense Bighteoueness : moral rectitude whereby we render to our neighbour what is his due, — here particularly neapect for his convictions. Peace: good harmony between all the members of the church. Joy: that individual and collective exultation which prevails among believers when brotherly communion makes its sweetness felt, and no one is saddened. By such dispositions the soul finds ... raised to a sphere where all sacrifices become easy, and charity reigns without obstacle. Such is the reality of the kingdom of God on the earth. ... He carries tiiem with Him. — It is incomprehensible how this passage has not succeeded in moving Meyer from the interpretation of the term kingdom of God, which he has adopted ... for all in his commentary applying it invariably to ... future Messianid kingdom.

Romans 14:17 · Open Word Bible

17For the kingdom of God is not about eating and drinking. It is righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Spirit.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:18

Ver. 18. "For fie that in these things ... Chrigt, ... acceptable to God and- approved of Tuen," — So true is it that it is in these dispositions the kingdom of God consists, that the goodwill of God and men rests only on him who ... them. If we read ... tovt, we may refer the pronoun (him or that) either to the principle expressed in ver. 17 ("thus") or to the Holy SpirU. The first meaning is forced ; it ... have required ... according to (this principle). Nor is the second less so ; for it would be the merest common place to say that he who serves Christ in the Holy ... is acceptable to God. We must therefore read, with the T. B. and the Byzs., ... in these ... Such a man is acceptable to God, who reads the heart, and he enjoys merited consideration even in the judgment of men. 'Sivety one. Christian or non-Christian, recognises him to be a man really animated with power from above, the opposite of a fool or a boaster ; ... an . approved Christian, who has stood the test of trial

Romans 14:18 · Open Word Bible

18Anyone who serves Christ in this way pleases God and wins the approval of others.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:19–20

Vv. 19, 20. " Let ... therefore follow after the things which make for peace, and things wherewUh one may edify anoth? For meat destroy ... ths work of God ; aU things indeed are ... but a thing ... evil for that ... who eateth with offence." — Yer. 19 forms, the transition from the first to the second reason; 19a repeats the first: the obligation to preserve harmony in the church ; ... introduces the second : the obligation to do nothing which might be injurious to our neighbouir's edification. The call, therefore, is no longer merely read ... to avoid what may wound and vex our neighbour, but also to respect and not compromise the ... of God already wrought in his heart It is obvious, as Meyer acknowledges, that we must read ... let us seek, and not ... we seek. The Greco-Latin reading, according to which we should require to read ... let us keep, as the verb of the last proposition of the verse: ''Let us keep the things which are for edification/' may veiy probably be authentic The omission of this verb would be explained by the fact that the copyists did not understand that the apostle was passing to a new reason.

Romans 14:19–20 · Open Word Bible

19So let us pursue whatever makes for peace and whatever builds one another up. 20Do not pull down God's work just for the sake of food. All food is clean, it is true, but it is wrong for anyone to eat in a way that makes another stumble.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:20

Ver. 20. The ... between w. 19 and 20 proves how acutely the apostle is alive to the responsibility of the strong : destroy the work of God ! In ver. 14, where it was personal pain, wounding, which was refeired to, the apostle spoke of making the brother himself perisL Here, where the occasioning of a scandal is the matter in question, he does not speak any more of the person, but of the ... of God in the person. — It matters not that food is free from uncleanness in itself; it is no longer so as soon as man uses it against his conscience. Siickert has taken the word ... evil, as the attribute of a verb understood: "Eating becomes evil for the man who does it against his conscience.'' Meyer prefeis to take from the preceding proposition the understood subject TO ... what is dean in itself: ''Even the food which is dean of itself becomes evil when it is eaten thus." But it seems to me simpler to make ... the subject : " There is ... (sin) for him who eateth in such circumstances." — ... in a state of scandal. On this use of the hid, comp. ii 27. Is the reference to the strong man, who eats while occasioning scandal, or to the weak brother, who lets himself be drawn into eating by ... to the scandal ? Evidently the second. Paul is not speaking here of the evil which the strong believer does to himself, but of that which he does to his brother cairied away into sin. — We may be astonished to find the apostle regarding the salvation of the weak as compromised by this one trespass. But is not one voluntary sin interposing between Christ and the believer enough to disunite them, and if tins sin is not blotted out, and the state is prolonged, to plunge him again in death ?

Yer. 21 is the summing up of the whole warning addressed to the strong from ver. 13.

Romans 14:20 · Open Word Bible

20Do not pull down God's work just for the sake of food. All food is clean, it is true, but it is wrong for anyone to eat in a way that makes another stumble.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:21

Yer. 21. " It is good riot to ... and not to drink wine, and [to do ... whereby thy brother stumbleth, or is offended, or even is made — The word ... it is good, honourable, is tacitly opposed to the notion of humiliation, which in the eyes of the strong attached to abstinence. There is nothing except what is honourable, Paul means, in abstaining when we sacrifice our liberty to charity. — Before the pronoun ... wherein, we must ... the verb ... to do anything. — Of the three verbs which the T. B. reads, the first refers to the wounding of the heart caused to our neighbour by conduct which he disapproves ; the second, to the sin which he would be led to commit by being drawn away to do what his conscience condemns ; the third, to the want of regard for the scruples with which he is affected through weakness of faith. So : to make him judge ill of you ; to make him do what he condemns, or to do in his presence something which raises a scruple in him. The , or, which connects the two last verbs, should be translated by : or even only, — The reading ... is grieved, instead of ... is offended, in the Sinait., is certainly mistaken. As to the omission of the last two verbs in the Alex, text, it is probably the effect of an over sight ; for the verb ... to be offended, would not completely sum up the warning given to the strong (see at ver. 13).

The last two verses are the conclusion and summary of the entire chapter. Yer. 22 applies to the strong; ver. 23 to the weak.

Romans 14:21 · Open Word Bible

21It is right not to eat meat or drink wine or do anything else that makes your brother or sister stumble or fall or become weak.

Report a mistake

Romans 14:22–23

Yv. 22, 23. "As to thee, thou hast faith ; have it to thyself before God. Happy is he that judgeth not himself in that thing which he ailoweth ! But he thai dovbteth is condemned if he eat, because he eateth iiot ... Whatsoever is not of faith is sin." ' — The proposition : thou hast faith, might be taken in the interrogative sense ; but there is more force in the simple affirmation. The Alexs. read ... which, after ... faith. documents form the ... of the Epistle, ... 25-27 ; G ... here hare a blank •pace ; A P have these three yeraes here and at the end of chap.

Romans 14:22–23 · Open Word Bible

22Whatever faith you have about these things, keep it between yourself and God. Blessed are those who do not condemn themselves by what they approve. 23But anyone who has doubts and eats anyway stands condemned, because the eating does not come from faith. Whatever does not come from faith is sin.

Report a mistake

Here, according to M. Benan, we return to the text of the copy addressed to the church of Rome ; for, according to him. ... formed ... of tbe Episde destined for ... church. ' If this view were well ... the first verse of chap. XV. must haye ... followed, the last of chap, xi.*; for chaps, xii. xilL' and xiv. ... belonged to the copies intended for other churches. ; Is this hypothesis probable ? What conr nection is there between the end of chap, zl celebrating the wisdom of God in the course of history, and this distinction between the strong and the weak with which chap. xv. begins ? This contrast fits in, on the contrary, in the closest possible way to the subject of chap. xiv. Schiultz feels this so much, that though sharing Eenan's opinion in regard to the three preceding chapters, up to a certain point, he ... makes the first six verses of chap. xv. the continuation and conclusion of the passage chap, xiv., and not till ver. 7 does he find the resumption of the true Epistle to the Eomans, which closed, according to him, with our .ver. 13. Thus in the apostolic copy it was ver. ,7 : *' Wherefore receive ye one another as Christ also received you," which immediately followed the dose of chap, xi But this sudden transition to a hortatory application, after so vast a development as that of chap, xi, is somewhat too abrupt to be probable ; and especially when we recognise, as this author does, the dose connection between the first six verses of chap. xv. and the whole development of chap, xiv., it must also be seen that the exhortation : *' Wherefore receive ye one another" (ver. 7), is only the •resumption of that which began chap. xiv. in these terms : *' Receive ye him that is weak in faith." Not only is it in both cases the same verb that is used : ... to take to oneself. ...

Report a mistake

... But, moreover, the following words of ver. 7 : " as Christ took you to Himself," reproduce exactly the end of xiv. 3 : '-For God hath taken him to Himself" (thy brother, weik or strong). ... ver. 7 is ... the dose of the cyde of teaching opened xiv. |.-3 ; and Paul sums up in ver. 7 the general. exhortation to connect with it the invitation to union between the two parts of the church which fonns the subject of w. 8-13. Thus is dosed the. practical part begun in chap. xii. Everything is so strongly compacted, and forms so fine a whole; that it is hard to understand how t should have entered the mind of ... i '

* We ... alieady said tiiat with chap. xv. there begins, ... to Baur, ... of oar Epistle. We shall ... step by step the objections to which the composition of these two chapters by the Apostle Paul seems to him to be exposed. . We ... have to study likewise the reasons which have led a great number of critics, snch as Semleif, Griesbach, Eichbom, Beuss, ... Ewald, and others ... 'dispute, not the ... origin of the whole or part of the last two chapters, but their original connection with the Epistle to the Somana As we have stated these very diveise opinions in the Introduction, voL L pp. 109-113, we think it unnecessary to reproduce them here.

Report a mistake

From the particular question which has just occupied the apostle, he now passes to a more general subject, that of the perfect union which, notwithstanding the difference between the two elements of which it is composed, ought to unite the whole church in a common song of praise to the God of salvation. . The goodwill with which all Jews and ... have been received by God, ought to make them, as it were, one heart and one mouth to magnify the Lord, while awaiting patiently the consummation of the work He has begun. Such are the contents of this passage, which admirably crowns the practical part. It is really impossible to understand Baur's affirmation : '.' This piece contains nothing which had not been much better said before," or that of M. Benan, who, adhering to this judgment, thus expresses himself : " These verses repeat and weakly sum up what precedes." ... He has not before expressed anything like this. :

Report a mistake

The ancient versions do not favour this reading, and neither is it in keeping with the context, which requires that the two cases treated should be put expressly face to fiace with one another, with a view to the definitive counsel to be stated for each. ... words heep ... allude to the sacrifice which Paul had asked the strong to make in his external conduct Paul reminds him that he does not in the least ask the abandonment of his intemal conviction, and invites him to ... it intact in his heart under the eye of God. — By the last words : Sappy . . ., he gives him to understand that it is a feeling of gratitude and not of pride, with which he ought to be inspired by the degree of ... and of liberty in faith, to which he has attained. Here, as elsewhere, the word ... must be translated by judge, and not by condemn, ''To condemn oneself in what he adopts as good," would be a contradictory idea. The subject in question is a ... as to the course which has been adopted once for ... Happy the man who no longer feels any scruple, nor puts any question of conscience to himself regarding the resolution he has taken. ... to find good after examination, Yer. 23 applies to the opposite case : that of doubt in regard to the line to be followed. Conscience has not reached oneness with itself; hence the term ... to be divided into two men, the one of whom says yes, the other no. — Many give to the word ... the abstract sense of ... But there is nothing to authorize us to take ficom the word so common in Paul its religious signification. ...

Report a mistake

... It refers, as always, to the acceptance of the salvation won by Christ What a man cannot do as His redeemed one and in the joy of His salvation, must not be done at all Otherwise this ... of which faith is not the soul, becomes sin, and may lead to the result indicated ver. 20 : the total destruction of God's ... Of the position of the ... xvi. 25-27, at the end of chap, xiv. — A considerable number of documents place ... after ver. 23, the three doxological verses which, in the generally Beceived text, close the Epistle (xvi 25-27). These are the Mj. L, nearly 220 Mnn., the Leetionaria the Philoxenian Syriac version, spme ancient mss. mentioned by Origen, finally, ... Fathers of the Grciek Cinuch (Ghrysostom Cyril, Theodoret ... There may be added the MS. G and the Latin translation which accompanies it ... which leave a blank here, as well as the Mjj. A and P and three Mnn., which read Ihese three verses in hath places. We shall complete these indications when we come to xvi. 25. Should it be held that these verses have their original place here, and were afterwards transposed from it to the eqd of the Epistle ? Or did they, on the contrary, form originally the conchision of the letter, and have certain copyists transferred tiliem to this place for some reason or other ? Or, finally, should we regard this passage as a later interpolation, which was placed sometimes at the end of chap, xiv., sometimes at the end of chap. xvL ? There might be a fourth supposition, viz., that the apostle himself repeated at the end of his letter this passage, placed originally at the end of our chapter. But such a repetition would be witiiout example or object As to the apostolic origin of the passage, we shall examine it at

Report a mistake

The question has more importance than appears at the first glance ; for it has a somewhat close connection with that of the authenticity of chaps, xv. xvi. If the apostle closed chap. xiv. with this formula of adoration, it is probable that he meant thereby ... terminate his Epistie ; consequently all that follows would be open to the suspicion of being unauthentic. True, Beuss says, that even though the last three verses were placed at the end of chap, xiv., "there would arise therefrom no prejudice ... to the authenticity of chap. xv. ;" the apostle might have intended " to lay down the pen and dose his discourse with a short prayer ; then he bethought himself to add a few pages." We doubt, however, whether a real example of such procedure can be quoted, and we think that if the tnie position of these three verses was indeed at the end of chap, xiv., the fact would prove indirectly either that chaps, xv. and xvi. are the work of an interpolator, or that, if they proceeded from the apostie's pen, they belonged originally to some other writing, whence they were transferred to tUs.

Report a mistake

Let us examine the different hypotheses made on this subject : — 1st. Hoimann has attempted to bring these three verses into the apostolic text by making them the transition from chap. xiv. to chap. XV. According to him, the expression : *' To Him that ia of power to stabUsh you" (xvi. 25), is in clos connection with tne ... of chap. xiv. relative to the strong and the weak ;. and the dative ... to Him that %$ of power . . . is dependent on the verb ... 1) : / We owe to Him that is- of power, ito stablish us ... concur in His work by bearing the burdens of the weak." The relation is ingeniously. discovered ; but this explanation is nevertheless inadmissible. Not only would this dative : to Him that is of power be separated from the verb on which it depends by a doxological amplification out of all proportion, but ... the ... now ... which accompanies the verb vfe otoe, indicates clearly the beginning of a new sentence.

Report a mistake

2d. Baur, Volkmar, Lucht, place the doxology here, but as a later interpolation, and infer from this bud the total or almost total unauthenticity of chaps, zv. and xvi. According to Lucht, the true conclusion of the Epistle, which immediately followed xiv. 23, was suppressed by the elders of the church of Rome as too severe for the weak of chap. xiv. But it was discovered again afterwards in the archives of this church, and amplified in two different ways, in the form of the doxology xvi 25-27, and in the more extended form of the passage xv. ... 24 ; these two conclusions, at first distinct, were afterwards fused into one, which produced the now generally received form. Yolkmar enters still more into detail The true apostolic conclusion may, according to him, be found with certainty and in a complete form in chaps, xv. and xvL It consists of the two passages xv. ... 2, and xvi. 21-24. The rest of these two chapters embraces additions intended to co-operate in the pacification of the church. They proceed principally from two authors, the one in the east, who added the doxology about 145 ; the other in the west, who composed nearly all the rest about 120. — We are struck at once with the arbitrariness there is in the hypothesis of Lucht. What ! elders take the liberty of ... the end of the apostolic writing! Then they preserve it in the archives of the church, and it becomes in the hands of some writer or other, along with some fragments of an Epistle to the Ephesians, the theme of our last two chapters ! This is a romance which in any case could only gain some historical probability if we were to discover in chaps, xv. and xvi. very positive proofs of their unauthenticity. Volkmar holds that the authentic conclusion has been wholly preserved, though mixed with a conglomerate of diverse interpolations. But would this close be ... The apostle had introduced his didactic treatise with a long preamble in the letter form (i 1-15). ...

Report a mistake

... Was it possible that in closing the writing he should not return, at least for a few moments, to the epistolary form with which he had begun ? Now it is evident that the few words which Yolkmar preserves as authentic by no means correspond to a preamble at once so grave and affectionate as the beginning of the Epistle. . And it is impossible to understand how Paul could pass suddenly from the end of the practical treatise : '' Whatsoever is not of faith is sin " (xiv. 23), to the words which, according to Yolkmar, immediately followed: " The God of peace be with you all ! Amen. I commend unto you Phoebe" . . . No, it was not thus the apostle composed.

Report a mistake

3d. Since, then, it is impossible to find a place for this doxology in the didactic tissue of chaps, xiv. and xv.; and since, on the other hand, it cannot be held that it indicates the conclusion of the Epistle (at the end of chap, xiv.), — it only remains to have recourse to a third solution. The weight of critical authorities makes the balance incline in favour of the position of these three verses at the end of chap. xvL What circumstance could have led to their migration, in a certain number of documents, to the end of chap. xiv. ? If we keep account of the fact demonstrated by the study of the text of the whole N. T., that most of the errors of the Byz. documents arise from the tendency to adapt the text to the necessities of public reading, we shall be led to the supposition that in very ancient times the reading of our Epistle in the assemblies of the church stopped at the end of chap, xiv., because from that point the didactic part, properly so called, terminated. But the reading could not end so abruptly. There was written therefore on the margin, for the use of the reader, the doxology which closed the entire Epistle ; and, as has so often happened, it passed from the margin into the text at this place. So it has come about that it is found here in the documents of Byz. origin, and particularly in the ... or collections of passages intended for public reading. It is objected, no doubt, that chaps, xv. and xvi. appear in all our ancient lectionaries. But the period at which the omission of these two chapters would have taken place is long anterior to the date of the collections of pericopes which have been preserved to us. This way of explaining the transposition of the doxology seems to us preferable to the reasons stated by Meyer. ...

Report a mistake

... If it is so, we imderstand how this doxology is found in both places at once in some documents, and how it is wholly wanting in some others. Certain copyists, doubtful about the position to be given to it, put it in both places ; certain others, made suspicious by this double position, rejected it altogether. It is ... we acknowledge, that it was not rather placed after ver. 13 of chap, xv., so as to embrace also in the public reading the passage we are now going to study (xv. 1-13). It is impossible at this date to discover the circumstance which has led to the choice rather of the end of chap. xiv.

Report a mistake