Logia

Frédéric Louis Godet · Commentary on St. Paul's Epistle to the Romans

Romans 3

97 excerpts on Romans 3, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.

Romans 3:1–2

Yv. 1, 2. ' What then is the advantage of the Jew t or what is the profit of ... t Much every way : foremost in {hat unto them were committed the oracles of God" — It was a thing generally granted, that the elect people must have an advantage over the Gentiles ; hence the article ... the, before the word advantage. The Greek term ... literally denotes what the Jews have more than others. If they are judged in the same category as these, as the apostle in ments, reads after ... chap. IL, and particularly in w. 25-29, had just shown, what have they then more than they ? The ... then, precisely expresses this relation. One might infer from what precedes that every advantage of the Jew was denied. — The second question bears on the material symbol of Israel's election: circumcision. ''Will the people whom God has deded and marked with the seal of this election be treated exactly like the rest of the world ?" This objection is of the same nature as that which would be made in our day by a nominal Christian, if, when put face to face with God's sentence, he were to ask what advantage there accrueis to him from his creed and baptism, if they are not to save him from condemnation ?

Romans 3:1–2 · Open Word Bible

1Then what advantage does the Jew have? What good is circumcision? 2Much, in every way. To begin with, the Jews were entrusted with the very words of God.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:1

The order of thought in this piece, one of the most difficult,, perhaps, in the Epistle, is as foUows : — 1. If the Jew is judged absolutely, as the Grentiles are, what advantage has he over them ? Answer : The possession of the divine oracles (w. 1, 2).

2. But if this possession has not realized the end which it was intended to serve (the faith of Israel in the Messiah), is not the faithfulness of God toward this people annulled ? Answer: By no means ; it will rather be glorified thereby (vv. 3, 4).

3. But if God makes use of human sin to glorify Himself, how can He yet make sinners the objects of His wrath ? Answer: If the advantage which Gtod derives from the sin of man prevented Him from punishing sinners, the final judgment would become impossible (w. 5-8).

It is obvious that the reasoning is consecutive, even veiy compact, and that there is no need of expressly introducing an opponent, as many commentators have done. Paul does not here make use of the formula : But some one ... say. The objections arise of themselves from the ... and Paul puts them in a manner to his own account

Romans 3:1 · Open Word Bible

1Then what advantage does the Jew have? What good is circumcision?

Report a mistake

Romans 3:2

Ver. 2. Though the advantage of the Jew does not consist in exemption from judgment, he has an advantage, nevertheless, and it is very great As neuter, it is connected with the subject of the first proposition of ver. 1 : ... advantage ; the second question was in reality only an appendix calculated to strengthen the first — By adding ... way, Paul means that the advantage is not only considerable, but very varied, ''extending to all the relations of life " (Morison). — Of these numerous and varied advantages he quotes only one, which seems to him, if one may so speak, ... Commentators like Tholuck, Philippi, Meyer, suppose that when the apostle wrote the word ... he purposed to enumerate all the other advantages, but that he was diverted from fuUy expressing his thought To exemplify this style there are quoted, besides i 8 ... seq., which we have had ahready before us, 1 Cor. vL 12, 13, and xi 18 ... seq. But the apostle has too logical a minc and his writings bear the mark of too earnest elaboration, to allow us to admit such breaches of continuity in their texture. In the view of a sound exegesis, the passages quoted prove absolutely nothing of the kind. Others think that we may here give to ... the meaning of chiefly; but the Greek has words for this idea. The preceding words: every way, suggest the translation ; they signify : " I might mention many things under this head; but I shall confine myself to one which is in the front rank." This form of expression, far from indicating that he purposes to mention others, shows, on the contrary, why he will not mention them. They all flow from that which he proceeds to indicate. Neither has the particle fihf (from ... to remain) its ordinary counterpart ... in the sequel It therefore means : " Though this advantage were the only one, it nevertheless remains perfectly real.*' The yap, for, is omitted by several Mjj. of both families, and by the old Vss. ...

Romans 3:2 · Open Word Bible

2Much, in every way. To begin with, the Jews were entrusted with the very words of God.

Report a mistake

... If it were kept, the or which follows would require to take the meaning of because, which is unnatural — It is better, therefore, to reject it, and to translate ... by in that — This advantage, which takes the lead of all the others, so that after it, it is useless to announce them also, is the dignity granted to the Jews of being the depositaries of the divine oracles. The subject of ... understood, according to a well-known Greek construction; comp. 1 Cor. ix. 17. The meaning of the verb in the passive is strictly : " to be esteemed faithful, so that men will confide to you a deposit." — The deposit here is the divine oracles. The term ... oracle, has a graver meaning than ... ivord, of which it is not at all a diminutive (Philippi) ; for it comes from the adjective ... eloquent. It always denotes, even in the classics, a divine saying; so Acts vii 38, the law of Moses; Heb. v. 12, the gospel revelation; 1 Pet iv. 11, the immediate divine communications with which the church was then favoured. In our passage, where the subject in question is the privilege granted to the Jews over the Gentiles, the word must be taken as referring to the whole Old Testament ; but it is nevertheless true that the apostle thinks specially of the Messianic promises ... . — If Paul had intended to set forth the beneficial religious and moral influence exercised by these divine revelations on the national, domestic, and individual life of the Israelites, it is evident that he would have had a multitude of things to say. But it is equally clear that he would have been thus diverted from the object of this discussion. And hence he confines himself to ... the point from which all the rest flows. This is the first phase of the discussion. — But an objection immediately rises : Has not this advantage, the possession of the Messianic promises, been rendered void by Israel's unbelief? Here begins the second phase.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:3–4

Vv. 3, 4. " For what shall we say t If some did not believe shall their unbelief make the faUh of God without effect t Let it not be: yea, let God be found true, and every man a liar; as it" is written : That Thou mightest be justified in Thy sayings, and mightest overcoms ' when Thou art judged!* — Here again Paul is not intxoducing any opponent; the objection which he states springs logically from the fact he has just affirmed — It would be possible to put the point of interrogation after the word ... some : For what are we to think, if some did not believe ? '' But we think it preferable to put the point after ... for: *''Eot what is the ... and to connect the proposition: ''If some did not believe/' with the following question (see the translation). Paul likes these short questions in the course of discussion : for what t but what t fitted as they are to rouse attention. If he here uses the particle for instead of but, it is because he wishes from the first to represent the objection as no longer subsisting, but already resolved. — What is the unbelief of the Jews which the apostle has here in view ? According to some, Philippi for example, it is their old unbelief in respect of the ancient revelations. But the aorist ... did not believe, refers to a particular historical fact rather than a permanent state of things, such as Jewish unbelief had been imder the old covenant Besides, the faithfulness of God toward Israel, when formerly imbelieving and disobedient, was a fact which could not be called in question, since ... by sending them the Messiah had nevertheless fulfilled all His promises to them in a way so striking. ...

Romans 3:3–4 · Open Word Bible

3What of it? If some were unfaithful, does their unfaithfulness cancel out God's faithfulness? 4Certainly not! Let God be found true, even if every human being is a liar. As it is written, "So that You are shown to be right when You speak, and win Your case when You are judged."

Report a mistake

... Finally, the future will it ... void? does not suit this sense ; Paul would rather have said : did it ... void t The subject in question, therefore, is a positive fact, and one which has just come to pass, and it is in relation to the consequences of this fact that the question of God's faithfulness arises. What is this fact ? We find it, with the majority of commentators, in Israel's rejection of Jesus, its Messiah ; and we might even add: in the persevering rejection of apostolic preaching. The hostile attitude of Israel in relation to the gospel was now a decided matter. — The pronoun ... some, may seem rather weak to denote the mass of the people who found in the LXX.). bad rejected the Messiah; bat this pronoun denotes a part of the whole irrespectively of the proportion. In chap, xi 17 the unbelieving Jews are called '' some of the branches ; in Heb. iii 16, the whole people Caleb and Joshua only excepted, are described by this same pronoun ; comp. 1 Cor. x. 7. The phrase of Plato is also cited : ... ye. Morison rightly says : '' Many are only some when they are not the whole." — Questions introduced by a ... always imply an answer more or less negative ; so it is in this case : " This unbelief will not, however, make void " . . . ? Answer understood : " Certainly not." Hence the far at the beginning of the verse, which referred to this foreseen negative answer. — The verb ... which we have translated by make void, signifies literally : to deprive of action, or ... and the phrase ... in contrast to ... imbelief, can only designate ... faithfulness of God Himself, in a manner His good faith. This perfection consists in the harmony between God's words and deeds, or between His past acts and His future conduct ; it is his adherence to order in the line of conduct followed by Him. ...

Report a mistake

... The question thus signifies : '' Can Jewish imbelief in regard to the Messiah invalidate God's faithfulness to His people ? " The question might be asked in this sense : " K the Jews have not taken advantage of the salvation which the Messiah brought to them, will it follow that God has not really granted them all He had promised ? Will any one be able to accuse Him of having failed in His promises ? " The sense may also be : " Will He not remain faithful to His word in the future, even though after such an act on their part He should reject them ? " For, in fine, His word does not contain promises only, but threatenings ; comp. 2 Tim. ii 13 : " K we believe not. He abideth faithful " (by punishing unbelief, as He has said). — The first of these meanings does not agree naturally with the future ... will make void, which points us not to the past, but to the future. The second might find some countenance in ver. 4, where the example of David's sin and punishment is referred to, as well as in the term ... (taken in the sense of ... justice) and in the term ... ver. 5. Yet the very severe meaning which in this case must be given to the phrase ... faithfulness, would not be sufficiently indicated. We are led to another and more natural meaning : *' From the fact that Israel has rejected the Messianic salvation, does it follow that God will not fulfil all His promises to thein in the future ? By no means ; His faiti fulness will find a means in the very unbelief of His people of magnifying ... The apostle ... has before him the perspective which he will follow to its termination in chap, xi, that of the final salvation of the Jews, after their partial and temporary rejection shall have been instrumental in the salvation of the Gentiles.

Report a mistake

The negative answer to this question, as we have seen, was already anticipated by the interrogative ... When expressing it (ver. 4), the apostle enhances the simple negativa He exclaims : " Let that not be (the faithfulness of God made void) ! " And to this forcible negation he adds the counter affirmation : May the contrary be what shall happen : truth, nothing but truth, on God's side I AU the lying, if there is any, on man's side!" — There is an antithesis between ... that be far Temoved (the ... of the Hebrews), and the ... Be, but let this come to pass ! The imperative ... may he or it become, is usually understood in the sense : " May God be recognised as true " . . . ! But the term ... to become, refers more naturally to the fact in itself than to the recognition of it by man. The veracity of God becomes, is revealed more and more in history by the new effects it producea But this growing realization of the true God runs parallel with another realization, that of human falsehood, which more and more displays man's perversity. Falsehood denotes in Scripture that inward bad faith wherewith the human heart resists known and understood moral good. The apostle seems to allude to the words of ... cxvL 11 : ' I said in my haste : All men are liars." Only what the Psalmist uttered with a feeling of bitterness, arising from painful personal experiences, Paul affirms with a feeling of composure and profound humiliation in view of the sin of his people. He says even all ... and not only aU Israelites; all men rather than God. If the principle of falsehood is realized in history, let all that bears the name of man be found capable of falseness, rather than that a tittle of this pollution should attach to the divine character. For the idea of faithfulness (ver. 3) there is substituted that of veracity, as for the idea of unbelief that of falsehood. ...

Report a mistake

... In both cases the second is wider than the first, and includes it — The conflict between the promises of God and His veracity, raised by the present fact of Israel's unbelief, must issue in the glory of the divine faithfulnesa This necessary lesult is expressed by the apostle by means of a saying of David, uttered on the occasion of one of his giavest infidelities, Ps. IL 6 : " That according as it is ... Alarm has been taken at the that ; it has been sought to make it a simple so that (Osterv., Oltram.), as if what was spoken of were ah effect, not an end. The wish was to avoid making David say he had sinned in order thai God might be glorified. It cannot really be supposed that David means to ascribe to God responsibility for his trespass in any degree whatever, and that in a passage where he expressly affirms that the purity of the divine character must appear with new brightness on occasion of it. ... and after him Philippi, have recourse to the distinction between the sinful wUl of David, which belongs wholly to him, and the form in which his sin was outwardly realized, a form which falls under the direction of Tiovidence. But this distinction, which the theologian can make, could not present itself to the mind of David at the time, and in the disposition in which he composed his psalm. To explain the that, we have simply to take into accoimt the manner in which David expresses himself in the foregoing worda He had said not only : " I have sinned," but : " I have sinned against Thee ; " not only : " I have done the evil," but : " I have done that which is displeasing in Thy sight'' It is with the two ideas against Thee and ... is displeasing in Thy sight, which aggravate the confession: / have sinned, that the that is connected. ...

Report a mistake

... David means : " I was clear as to what I was doing ; Thou hadst not left me ignorant that when sinning I was sinning against Thy person, which is outraged by such misdeeds, and that I was doing what Thou hatest, — that if, in spite of this knowledge, I nevertheless did it, Thou mightest be pure in the matter, and that the guiltiness might belong to me only." This idea of the knowledge of the divine will possessed by David, is that which is anew forcibly expressed in ver. 6 : " Thou didst teach me wisdom in the hidden part" God had ... and warned David that if he sinned, he might be the only guilty one, and might not be able to accuse ... The that has therefore nearly the same meaning as the : '' to the end they might be without excuse/' L 20. We thus recognise the analogy of situation between David and Israel, which leads the apostle to quote these words here. Israel, the depositary of the divine oracles, had been faithfully instructed and warned, that if later, in spite of these exceptional revelations, giving themselves up to the falsehood (voluntary blindness) of their own hearts, they came to miss recognising the Messiah, they should not be able to accuse God for their rejection, but should be declared, to the honour of the divine holiness, the one party guilty of the catastrophe which might follow. — The words : " that Thou mayest be ... in or by Thy words," signify : " that Thou mayest be acknowledged righteous, both in respect of the warnings which Thou hast given, and in the sentences which Thou wilt pronounce (on David by the mouth of Nathan, on Israel by their rejection)." In the Hebrew, the second proposition refers exclusively to those sentences which God pronounces ; for it is said : and that Thou mayest be found ... ...

Report a mistake

... Thoujudgest But the LXX. have translated : " that Thou mayest be victor (gain Thy case) when Thou art judged," or : " when Thou hast a case at law." It is probably this last meaning to which the apostle adapts his words, giving the verb ... the middle sense, which it has in so many passages ; for example. Matt. v. 40 ; 1 Cor. vL 1, 6 : "that Thou mayest gain Thy case if Thou hast one to plead." Paul has obviously in view the accusation against God*s faithfulness which might be raised from the fact of the unbelief and rejection of the chosen people.

But this very thought, that the veracity of God will come forth magnified from Israel's unbelief, raises a new objection, the examination of which forms the third phase of this discussion.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:5–6

Vv. 5, 6. ... if our unrighteousness commend the righteousness of God, what shall we say f Is not God unrighteous when He inflicts wrath t I speak as a man.. That he far: for then how shall God Judge the world t " — From the that, ver. 4 it seemed to follow that God wills the sin of man for His own glory. But in that case, has He the right to condemn an act from which He reaps advantage, and to be 228 ... by faith. angry with him who commits it ? This objection might ... put in the month of a Jew who, placing himself at Paul's view-point, and hearing him say that Israel's rejection of the Messiah will glorify God's faithfulness, and conduce to the accomplishment of His plans, judged God highly unjust for being angry with Israel on account of such conduct. Our ... would then signify the unbelief of us Jews. But the contrast which prevailed in ver. 4 was that between God and every ... and not between Jew and Gentile. It is therefore more natural to apply the term our unrighteousness to human unrighteousness in general, undoubtedly with special application to the Jewish unrighteousness which gives rise to the objection. It is from the depths of the human conscience that the apostle fetches his question. Is it righteous on God's part to judge an act which He turns to His own advantage ? As Paul had previously substituted the idea of ... for that of (God's) ... he here substitutes ... for ... This term in its most general sense denotes the perfection in virtue of which God cannot become guilty of any wrong toward any being whatever. Now this is what He seems to do to the sinner, when He at once condemns and makes use of him. It is from the word : that Thou mayest be acknowledged ... ver. 4, that Paul derives the term righteousness, ver. 5. — ... strictly : to cause to stand together, whence: to confirm, to establish. ...

Romans 3:5–6 · Open Word Bible

5But if our wrongdoing brings out God's righteousness more clearly, what are we to say? Is God unjust, then, when He brings His wrath on us? I am speaking as people do. 6Certainly not! If that were so, how could God judge the world?

Report a mistake

... The question ... what shall we say t does not occur in any other letter of the apostle's ; but it is frequent in this ... . It serves to ... the mind of the reader on the state of the question, at the. point which the discussion has reached. If it had been in the interest of a certain school of criticism to deny the authenticity of the Epistle to the Romans, it is easy to see what advantage it would have taken of this form so exclusively characteristic of this treatise. — The interrogative form with firi assumes, as it always does, that the answer will be negative: ''God is not, however, unjust in '' . . . ? It is certainly the apostle who is speaking, and not an opponent ; for the objection is thus expressed in the outset as one resolved in the negative. The phrase : to inflict wrath, alludes to ii. 4, 6, where the apostle ..threatened Israel with divine ... against the day of wrath; but the question is nevertheless put in a perfectly general sense. — There is always something revolting to a conscience enlightened from above in joining the epithet ... with the word Ghd, even hypothetically. This is why Paul adds : I ... as a man. By man he here understands man left to himself and his own reason, speaking with lightness and presumption of the ways of God. Some commentators would join this explanatory remark with what follows. But the following exclamation ... let it not be so), is absolutely opposed to this.

Report a mistake

The argument of ver. 6, according to Meyer, is this : How would God be disposed to judge the world, if there was no righteousness in Him ? For the troublesome consequences of sin could not impel Him to it, since He can turn them to good. It must be confessed that this would be a singularly wiredrawn argument To go to prove God's righteousness by the fact of the judgment, while it is the fact of the judgment which rests on divine righteousness I If the apostle had reasoned thus, ... would have been right in declaring that the argument was insufficient But the reasoning is quite different Meyer might have found it clearly stated by Olshausen : '' If God's drawing a good result from a bad deed were enough to destroy His right to judge him who committed it, the final judgment would evidently become impossible ; for as God is always turning to good the evil which men have devised, every sinner could plead in his defence : My sin has after all served some good end." — One might be tempted to apply the word the world exclusively to the Gentile world, which would lead us to the explanation whereby ver. 5 is put into a Jewish mouth. To this Jewish interlocutor, excusing the sin of his nation by the good fruits which God will one day reap from it, Paul would then answer: But at this rate God could as little judge the Gentiles ... toorld). For He brings good fruits from their sins also. This meaning is very plausible in itself. But yet it does not correspond with the apostle's thought For the word ... the loorld, would then have such an emphasis (as forming an antithesis to the Jews), that it would necessarily require to be placed before the verb. The idea is therefore more general: No final judgment is any longer possible if the beneficial consequences of sin, human or Jewish, justify the' sinner. This idea is exactly that which is expounded in the two following verses.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:7–8

Vv. 7, 8. "For if the truth of God hath more ... through my lie unto His ghry; why ... am I also fudged as a sinner? And not (as we are accused of doing, and as some falsely affirm that we ... Let us do evil, that good may come f whose damnation is just J' — Many commentators (Calvin, Grotius, Philippi) have fallen into a strange ... in regard to ver. 7. They imagine that this verse reproduces once more the objection of ver. 3. The for serves, they say, to justify the question: "Is not (Jod unrighteous ? " In reality the apostle is made to add: after the advantage which He has derived from my lie for His glory, how does He still judge me ? But for what reason should the for relate to ver. 5 rather than ver. 6, which immediately precedes? This would be to forget the answer given in ver. 6, and so to confess its weakness ! In this case we should require rather to adopt the reading ... if, of the Sinait. and Vatic., and to make ver. 7 an objection to the answer given in ver. 6. But this reading is inadmissible, because this new objection raised would remain without answer in the sequel. This same reason tells also against the explanation which makes ver. 7 a simple reaffirmation of the objection of ver. 5. How could an objection, reproduced so forcibly, possibly be left without any other answer than the relegating of those who dare to raise it to the judgment of God (ver. 8)? For a. mind like Paul's this would be a strange mode of arguing !*) Ver. 7 is simply, as the for indicates, the confirmation of the answer given in ver. 6 : " How would God judge the world? In reality (for) every sinner might come before the judge and say to Him, on his own behalf: And I too by my lie, I have contributed to Thy glory. ...

Romans 3:7–8 · Open Word Bible

7But if my falsehood makes God's truth shine out all the more, to His glory, why am I, too, still judged a sinner? 8And why not do what some slander us by saying we teach: "Let us do evil so that good may come of it"? Such people deserve their condemnation.

Report a mistake

... And he must be acquitted." — By the phrase truth of God Paul returns to the beginning of the discussion (w. 3 and 4). What is in question is the moral uprightness of God ; in like manner the term lie brings us back to the every man a liar (ver. 4). This lie consists in voluntary ignorance of goodness, to escape the obligation of doing it. The verb ... has abounded, strictly: ... over, denotes the surplus of glory which God's moral perfection extracts from haman wickedness in each case. ... yet, signifies: even after so profitable a result has accrued from my sin. ... I also : I who, as well as all the rest, have contributed to Thy glory/' It is as if one saw the whole multitude of sinners appearing before the judgment-seat one after the other, and throwing this identical answer in God's face; the judgment is therefore brought to nothing. Thus is confirmed the answer of ver. 6 to the objection of ver. 5. — This so suitable meaning appears to us preferable to a more special sense which might present itself to the mind, especially if one were tempted to apply the term the world (ver. 6) to the Gentile, in opposition to the Jeivish world (ver. 5). The sense would be : " For the judgment comes to nought for ... Gentile, as well as for thee Jew, since I can plead the same excuse as thou, my Gentilehood contributing to glorify God's truth as much as thy unbelief to exalt His righteousness." For the application to the Gentiles of the two expressions: ... truth, and lie, see i 25. But to make this meaning probable, Paul would require to have brought out in chap, i the idea that idolatry had contributed to God's glory ; and as. to the restricted meaning of ... the ... see at p. 229.

Report a mistake

The apostle pushes his refutation to the utmost (ver. 8) : Why even not go further? Why, after annihilating the judgment, not say further, to be thoroughly consequent: " And even let us furnish God, by sinning more freely, with richer opportunities of doing good ! Will not every sin be a material which He will transform into the pure gold of His glory?" The words ... not, should probably be followed by the verb : let vs do evU f ... as we have translated it. But in Greek the sentence is interrupted by the insertion of a parenthesis, intended to remind the reader that such is precisely the odious principle which Paul and his brethren are accused by their calumniators of practising and teaching. And when, after this parenthesis, he returns in ver. 8 to his principal idea: ... let us do, instead of connecting it with the conjunction, and (that) not, he makes it depend directly on the last verb of the parenthesis, tea: " Aa we are accused of teaching, let ... do evU The ... that, is the on recitative so 232 ... bt faith. common in Greek (transition from the indirect to the direct form of discourse). The construction which we have just indicated is a form of ... of which numerous examples are found in classic authors. — The verb we are accused has for its object the understood clause : of doing w, of practising this principle. If we understood : " Accused of teaching*' the following words would be a mere superfluous repetition. The term ... seems deliberately chosen to suggest the idea that the principle calumniously imputed to him is itself blasphemous in its nature. The second part of the parenthesis adds the idea of professing ... to that o{ practising. The words form a climax, for it is graver to lay down a blasphemous maxim as a principle than to put it into practice in a few isolated cases. ...

Report a mistake

... Hofmann has proposed another construction ; he understands ... after ... and makes the following ... dependent on it: ''And it is not the case with me, as we are accused of practising and teaching, that it only remains to do evil that " ... But it is harsh to make the teada depend on ... and Meyer rightly observes that Paul would have required to say ... and not ... /ii] ; comp. the interrogations, 1 Cor. vL 7; Luke xix. 23, etc. — The sort of malediction which closes the verse is applied by most commentators to those who really practise and teach the maxim which is falsely applied to ... But the apostle would not have confined himself in that case to the use of the simple relative pronoun ... whose; he would necessarily have required to indicate, and even characterize, the antecedent of the pronoun, which cannot refer to any substantive expressed or understood in the preceding proposition. It must have for its antecedent the preceding ... some, and we must apply this severe denunciation to the calumniators of the apostle's life and teaching. Those who raise such accusations wrongly and maliciously against his person and doctrine themselves deserve the condemnation which they call down on the head of ... But it should be well observed that the apostle does not express himself thus till he has satisfied all the demands of logical discussion.

Report a mistake

Observations on the passage, iii 1-8. — Notwithstanding its temporary application to the Jewish people, this passage, which will find its complete explanation in chap. xL, has a real permanent value. It has always been sought to justify the greatest crimes in histoiy by representing the advantages in which they have resulted to the cause of humanity. There is not a Bobespierre who has not been transformed into a saint in the name of utilitarianism. But to make such a canonization valid, one would require to begin by proving that the useful result sprang from the evil committed as its principle. Such is the teaching of Pantheism. Living Theism, on the contrary, teaches that this transformation of ... bad deed into a means of progress, is the miracle of God's wisdom and power continually laying hold of human sin to derive from it a result contrary to its nature. On the first view, all human responsibility is at an end, and the judgment becomes a nullity. On the second, man remains fully responsible to God for the bad deed as an expression of the evil will of its author, and despite the good which God is pleased to extract from it. Such is scriptural optimism, which alone reconciles man's moral responsibility with the doctrine of providential progress. The apostle has laid the foundations ... this true theodicie in the remarkable piece which we have just been studying. — It is curious to see how Holsten seeks to explain this passage, the meaning of which haa, aa we think, been made so clear by a polemical intention against the alleged Judeo-Christianity of the Christians of Rome. We do not waste time in giving a refutation which seems to us to arise of itself from the preceding.

Report a mistake

The apostle has drawn in two great pictures the reign of God's wrath — (1) over the Gentile world (chap, i); (2) over the Jewish people (chap. iL) ; and by way of appendix he has added a passage to this second picture, intended to sweep away the objections which, from the ordinary Jewish point of view, seemed opposed to the statement that this elect people could possibly become, notwithstanding their unbelief, the object of divine animadversion. Now, to the judgment which foUows from the preceding context with respect to the whole of ... the seal of Scripture sanction, without which he regards no proof as finally valid.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:9

After a general declaration, repeating the already demonstrated fact of the condemnation of Jews and Greeks (ver. 9), the apostle quotes a series of Scripture sayings which con firm thia truth (w. 10-18); then he formally states the conclusion (w. 19 and 20).

Ver. 9. " What then t are we sheltered t No, in no wise : for we have lefore proved all mem,, both Jews and Greeks, that they are under sin*' — If the words ... what then, be taken as an independent question, the meaning will be: " What, then, is tlie date of things t To what result are we thus brought?" But many commentators connect these two words with the following sentence, so as to form a single question. The meaning in that case is, according to the different acceptations of the verb ... What have we to allege as an excuse f or: In what, then, are we superior t But neither of these meanings agrees with the answer following. Indeed, instead of in no wise, it would require to be none whatever, or in ... There ... therefore two questions,, and not merely one. — What is the sense of the verb ... which by itself forms the second question ? We should first testify to the correctness of the Beceived reading. All the mss. are at one on this point except A L, which read the subjunctive instead of the indicative, obviously to convert the word into an exhortation, and D G, which read ... while adding the object ... these last, at the same time, reject the words ... This is the text which Chrysostom and Theodoret seem to have followed, as well as the Itala and Peschito. The meaning would be: What superiority do we possess f It is simply an attempt to escape from the difficulty of the Beceived reading. — The verb ... has two principal meanings in the active: to hold lefore (in order to protect), and to hold the first place. ...

Romans 3:9 · Open Word Bible

9What then? Do we Jews have an advantage? Not at all. We have already brought the charge that all, Jews and Greeks alike, are under the power of sin.

Report a mistake

... In the passive, the first meaning changes into to he protected ; the second meaning, as being intransitive, has no passive. In the middle, the verb signifies, according to the first meaning : to protect onesdf, to shelter ... to hold out a pretext; according to the second : to 'plaice onesdf at the head, to ... It is logically impossible to apply here the idea of superiority, either in the passive form : Are toe preferred f or in the middle form: Do we ... Undonbtedlj these two interpretations have both found their defenders; Osterv., for example : Are we preferable t Oltram. : Have we same ... But the question of ascribing a superiority to the Jews had been put at ver. 1 ; the apostle had resolved it affirmatively from the theocratic standpoint If, then, he now resolves it negatively, as he does in the following answer, it can only be from the ... point of view. But in this case he could not fail to indicate this distinction. The only appropriate meaning, therefore, is that of sheltering, which is also the most frequent in classic Oreek : " Have we a shelter under which we can regard ourselves ... delivered from wrath ? " This meaning seems to us to be perfectly suitable. The apostle has demonstrated that the Jewish people, as well as the Gentile world, are under God's wrath. He has put to himself the objection : But what in this case becomes of the Jew's advantage ? And he has proved that this advantage, perfectly real though it be, cannot hinder the rejection and judgment of this people. " What then ? " he now asks as a consequence from what precedes, "can we flatter ourselves that we have a refuge V "In no wise," such is his answer. All is closely bound together in the reasoning thus understood. — The phrase ... strictly signifies : not altogether; comp. 1 Cor. v. 10. ...

Report a mistake

... When Paul means : not at all, he uses, in conformity with Greek custom, the form ... comp. 1 Cor. xvi 12. But the first meaning is evidently too weak after the preceding argument, and in consequence of that which followa Meyer even finds himself obliged here to abandon his philological rigorism, and to take the second meaning. And, in reality, this meaning is not incorrect. It is enough, as Morison says, to make a pause in reading after ... not, adding ... as a descriptive : no, absolvtely; or better : no, certainly. This meaning is that of the entirely similar phrase ... in Xenophon, Demosthenes, Lucian, and even that of ... in two passages quoted by Morison, the one taken from classic Greek, the other from patristic. 236 ... by faith.

Report a mistake

The apostle demonstrates this negation, which refers specially to the Jews, ... summing up in the following proposition the result of the long preceding indictment against the two divisions of mankind The term ... to accuse incriminate, belongs to the language of the bar. The ... before, previously, which enters into the composition of the verb, reminds the reader of the two great pictures which Paul had just drawn. — The phrase: to be ... sin, does not merely signify: to be under the responsibility (the guilt) of sins committed, but also to be under the power of sin itself, which like a perpetual fountain constantly reproduces and increases this guilt These ... meanings, sin as a trespass, and sin as a power, are both demanded by the context, the first by the preceding, and the second by the succeeding context In point of fact, God's wrath is not based solely on trespasses committed, which have something external and accidental in their character; it is founded, above all, on the permanent state of human nature as it is about to be described by Scripture. So long as the Scriptures had not spoken, Paul might be regarded as a simple accuser. But as soon as the voice of this judge shall be heard, the case will be determined, and the sentence pronounced. Vv. 10-18 enumerate, if one may 80 speak, the grounds of judgment; w. 19 and 20 give the sentence.

Paul first reminds his readers, in scriptural terms, of the most general characteristics of human corruption, w. 10-12. Then he presents two ... classes of the manifestations of this corruption, w. 13-17. Finally, he closes this description by a decisive feature which goes back to the very ... of evil, ver. 18.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:10–12

Vv. 10-12. '*As it is written. There is none righteous, no, not one : there is none thai understandeth, there is none that seeketh? after ... They are all gone out of the way, they are together become unprofitable ; there is none that doeth good, no, not — These six sentences are taken from Ps. xiv. 1-3. At the first glance, this psalm seems to be depicting the wickedness of the ... only ; comp. ver. 4 : *' They eat up my ... as if they were eating bread." But on looking at it more closely, it is clear that the term my people denotes the true people of Jehovah, " the ... (ver. 6), in opposition to the proud and violent as well within as without the theocracy. This delineation therefore applies to the moral character of man, so long as he remains beyond the influence of divine action. — Yer. 10 contains the most general statement. Instead of the word righteous, there is in the Hebrew : the man that doeth good, which comes to the same thing. — The two terms which follow in ver. 11 have a more particular sense. The first is related to the understanding : the knowledge of the Creator in His works ; the second to the will : the aspiration after union with this perfect being. The Sinait., like most of the Mjj., reads the article o before the two participles. This artide is in keeping with the meaning of the psalm. God is represented as seeking that one man and not finding him. We may accentuate ... as an unusual participle of ... from the verb awlm, which sometimes takes the place of the verb ... In the case where positive good is not produced (seeking after God), the heart immediately falls under the dominion of evU ; this state is described in general terms, ver. 12.

Romans 3:10–12 · Open Word Bible

10As it is written, "No one is righteous, not even one. 11No one understands; no one seeks God." 12"All have turned away; together they have become useless. No one does what is good, not a single one."

Report a mistake

to deviate, to go in a bad way, because one has voluntarily fled from the good (ver. 11). ... to "become useless, unfit for good, corresponds to the Hebrew alach, to become sour, to be spoiled. — The sixth proposition reproduces, by way of resume, the idea of the first Mankind resembles a caravan which has strayed, and is moving in the direction opposite to the right one, and whose members can do nothing to help one another in their common misery (do good).

Here begins a second and more particular description, that of human wickedness manifesting itself in the form of speech.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:13–14

Vv. 13, 14. ... throat is an open, sepulchre; with their ... they have used deceit ; the poison of asps is ... their lips : whose ... is full of cursing and bitterness " — These four propositions refer to the different organs of speech, and show them all exercising their power to hurt, under the dominion of sin. The throat (larynx) is compared to a sepulchre; this refers to the language of the gross and brutal man of whom it is said in common parlance : it seems as if he would like to eat you. The characteristic which follows contrasts with the former ; it is the sugared ... which charms you like a melodious instrument The imperfect ... (Alex, form) denotes the action as continually repeated. These two features are borrowed from Ps. v. 9, where they describe the behaviour of David's enemies. The third proposition is taken from Ps. cxL 3, which treats of the same subject ; what is meant is that calumny and falsehood which malignant lips give forth, as the serpent infuses its poison. The fourth (ver. 14) describes the wickedness which is cast in your face by a ... full of hatred or bitterness ; it is borrowed from Ps. x. 7, where the contrast is between the weak godly man and the powerful wicked man within the theocracy itself.

This picture of human depravity manifesting itself in word is completed by the description of the same wickedness shown in deeds.

Romans 3:13–14 · Open Word Bible

13"Their throat is a grave left open; with their tongues they deal in deceit. Snake venom lies behind their lips. 14Their mouths overflow with cursing and bitter words."

Report a mistake

Romans 3:15–18

Vv. 15-18. " TJieir feet are swift to shed blood : oppression and misery are in their ways : the way of peace they have not Tcnovm : there is no fear of God before their eyes'* — Of these four propositions the first three are borrowed from Isa. lix. 7, 8, in which chapter the prophet confesses the corruption of Israel The feet, as the emblem of walking, symbolize the whole conduct. Man acts without regard to his neighbour, without fear of compromising his welfare and even his life ; a saying taken from Prov. L 16. He oppresses ... his brother, and fills his life with misery ... so that the way marked out by such a course is watered with the tears of others. — ... peace can exist either in the heart of such men, or in their neighbourhood (ver. 17). And this overflow of depravity and suffering arises from a void: the absence of that feeling which should have filled the heart, the fear of God (ver. 18). This term is the normal expression for piety in the Old Testament ; it is that disposition in man which has always God present in the heart. His will and judgment. The words: before their eyes, show that it belongs to man freely to evoke or suppress this inward view of God, on which his moral conduct depends. This final characteristic is borrowed from Ps. xxxvi. 1, which marks the contrast between the faithful and the wicked even in Israel The apostle in drawing this picture, which is only a grouping together of strokes of the pencil, made by the hands of psalmists and prophets, does not certainly mean that each of those characteristics is found equally developed in every man. ...

Romans 3:15–18 · Open Word Bible

15"They rush to shed blood; 16wherever they go they leave ruin and misery, 17and the way of peace they have never known." …

Report a mistake

... Some, even the most of them, may remain latent in many men; but they all exist in germ in the selfishness and natural pride of the ego, and the least circumstance may cause them to pass into the active state, when the fear of God does not govern the heart Such is the cause of the divine condemnation which is suspended over the human race.

This is the conclusion which the apostle reaches ; but he limits the express statement of it, in w. 19, 20, to the Jews ; for they only could attempt to protest against it, and put themselves outside this delineation of human corruption. They could object in particular, that many of the sayings quoted referred not to them, but to the Grentiles. Paul foresees this objection, and takes care to set it aside, so that nothing may impair the sweep of the sentence which God pronounces on the state of mankind.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:19–20

Vv. 19, 20. ''Now we know ... what things soever the law ... it sfpeaks? for them who are ... the law: thai every mouth may he stopped, arid ail the world vnay become guilty "before God, For that by the deeds of the law there shall no flesh be justified in His sight: for by the law is the knowledge of — By his toe know, Paul appeals to the common sense of his readers. It is obvious, indeed, that the Old Testament, while depicting to the Jews the wickedness of the Gentiles, did not at aU mean to embitter them against the latter, but to put . them on their guard against the same sins, and preserve them from the same judgments ; a proof that God saw in their hearts the same germs of corruption, and foresaw their inevitable development if the Jews did not remain faithful to Him. Thus, while none of the sayings quoted might refer to them, they were nevertheless all uttered ... them, — The law here denotes the whole Old Testament, as being throughout the rule for ... life; comp. John x. 34 ; 1 Cor. xiv. 21, etc. — The difference of meaning between the words ... to say, and ... to speak, comes out clearly in this passage, — the first referring to the consents of the saying, the second to the fact of its utterance. — There is no reason for weakening the sense of the conjonction ... in order ... and making it signify ... that. The ... of all those declarations given forth by Scripture regarding the wickedness of the natural man, was really to close his mouth against all vainglory, as that to which a man filled with self-satisfaction gives himself up. Every ... even the Jews'. ... All the toorld: all mankind, Jew and Gentile ; ... placed under the stroke of justice, like one whom the jud has declared guilty, and who owes satisfaction to the law he has violated. ...

Romans 3:19–20 · Open Word Bible

19We know that what the law says is addressed to those who live under the law. It is said so that every mouth will be closed and the whole world will stand accountable to God. 20No one will be declared righteous before Him on the basis of works of the law. What the law does is make sin known.

Report a mistake

... The word is frequently used in this sense in the classics ; it is a judicial term, correspouding to the word Paul had used to denote the accusation ... ver. 9). The last word : to God, is full of solemnity ; it is into the hands of His justice that the whole guilty world falls.

The all ... true that the only possible exception, that of the Jewish people, is excluded (ver. 20). This people, indeed, could have alleged a host of ritualistic and moral works performed daily in obedience to the divine law. Did not such works establish in their case special merit and right to God's favour ? The apostle sets aside such a daim. ... for that. No flesh: no human creature (see on L 3). — Here for the first time we meet with the expression ... works of the law, one of the important terms in the apostle's vocabulary. It is found, however, only in the Epistles to the Romans ... and to the Galatians (ii. 16, iii 2, 5, 10). But, nevertheless, it expresses one of the ideas which lie at the root of his experience and of his view of Christian truth. It sums up the first part of his life. It may be understood in two ways. A work of law may mean : a work exactly conformed to the law, corresponding to all the law prescribes (Hodge, Morison, etc.) ; or it may mean : such a work as man can accomplish under the dispensation of the law, and with such means only as are available under this dispensation. In the first sense it is certainly unnecessaiy to explain the impossibility of man's finding his righteousness in those works by an imperfection inherent in the moral ideal traced by the law. ...

Report a mistake

... For Paul himself says, vii 14, that " ths law is spiritual;"* vii 12, that **the law is holy, and the commandment is holy, just, and good;'' viiL 4, that " the work of the Holy Spirit in the believer consists in fulfilling what the law has determined to be righteous." Much more, he goes the length of affirming positively, with Moses himself (Lev. xviiL 5), that if any one exactly fulfilled the law he would live by his obedience (Bom. x. 5 ; GaL iii 12). Taking this meaning, then, why cannot ihe ... of the law justify ? It can only be man's powerlessness to do them. St Paul would then say : ... man will be justified by the works of the law, because works really conformed to the spirit of the law are beyond his power to realize." Thus the kind of works referred to in the declaration : " not being justified by the works of the law /' would be ideal and not real This meaning is far from natural From Paul's way of speaking of the works of the law, we cannot help thinking that he ... a fact in view, — that he is reckoning with a real and not a fictitious value. We must therefore come to the second meaning : works such as man can do when he has no other help than the law, — that is to say, in fact, in his own strength. The law is perfect in itself. But it does not provide fallen man with the means of meeting its demands. Paul explains himself clearly enough on this hetd, GaL iii 21 : ''If there had been a law given which could have given life, verily righteousness should have been by the law." In other words, the law does not communicate the Spirit of God, and through Him the life of love, which is the fulfilling of the law (Bom. xiii. 10). Works wrought in this state, notwithstanding their external conformity to the letter of the law, are not therefore its real fulfilment. ...

Report a mistake

... Though agreeable to the legal statute, they are destitute of the moral disposition which would give them value in the eyes of God. Paul himself had groaned till the time of his conversion over the grievous contrast in his works which he constantly discerned between the appearance and the reality ; comp. the opposition between the state which he calls, vii. 6, oldness of ths letter and nevmess of spirit. He gives his estimate of the works of the law when, after saying of himself before his conversion, ... iii 6 :" As to the righteousness which is under the law, blameless," he adds, ver. 7 : " But what things were gain to me (all this from the human point of view blameless righteousness), these I counted loss for Christ's sake." — There remains one question to be examined.

Report a mistake

Is it true, as Theodoret/ ... and many modem critics have thought, that Paul is speaking here only of ceremonial works imposed by the law, and not of works implying moral obedience ? The meaning of the verse would then be this : The whole world is condemned; for the Jews themselves cannot be justified by the observance of the ceremonies which their law prescribes/' But such a distinction between two kinds of works is opposed to the context ; for the apostle does not contrast work with work — he contrasts work with faith. Then how could he add immediately, that by the law is the knowledge of sin ? From viL 7, 8, it appears that this saying applies above all to the moral law. For it was the tenth commandment which led the apostle to discern covetousness in his heart, and it was this discovery of covetousness which convinced him of sin. Hence it appears that the last words of our verse refer to the moral, and not the ceremonial law, which decides the meaning of the term : the works of the law. Besides, the expression ... which evidently embraces the Gentiles, could not be applied to them if the law were here taken as the ceremonial law, for in this sense they have never had it. In general, the distinction between the ritual and the moral elements of the law is foreign to the Jewish conscience, which takes the law as a divine unity. — It follows from this sajring of the apostle, that man ought never to attempt to put any work whatever between God and himself as establishing a right to salvation, whether a work wrought before his conversion proceeding from his natural ability, for it will lack the spirit of love which alone would render it good in God's sight; or even a work posterior to regeneration and truly good ... ...

Report a mistake

... Eph. ii. 10), for as such it is the fruit of the Spirit, and cannot be transformed into a merit of man. — The declarative meaning of the verb ... to justify, appears clearly here from the two subordinate clauses : by the works of the law, and before Him (see on i. 17).

By a short proposition (20) the apostle justifies the principle ... 20a. Far from having been given to sinful man to furnish him with a means of justification, the law was rather given to help him in discerning the sin which reigns over him; ... proof. — This thought is only indicated here; it will be developed afterwards. Indeed, Paul throughout the whole of this piece is treating of sin as guilt, forming the ground of condemnation. Not till chap, vii will he consider sin as a potoer, in its relation to the law, and in this new connection ; then will be the time for examining the idea with which he closes this whole passage.

Judaism was living under a great illusion, which holds it to this very hour, to wit, that it is called to save the Gentile world by communicating to it the legal dispensation which it received through Moses. "Propagate the law," says the apostle, " and you will have given to the world not the means of purifying itself, but the means of seeing better its real corruption." These for us are commonplaces, but they axe become so through our Epistle itself. At the time when it was written, these commonplaces were rising on the horizon like diviue beams which were to make a new day dawn on the world.

Report a mistake

On the order of ideas in ... section, according to ... and Volkmar. — Hofmann finds the principal division of this section between w. 4 and 5 of chap, iii Up to ver. 4, the apostle is proving that God's wrath rests on mankind, whether Gentile ... or Jewish ... but from that pointall the apostle says applies specially to ... thus : " As we are not ignorant, we Christians (iii 5), that man's sin, even when God is glorified by it, can be justly judged (w. 5-7), and as we do not teach, as we are accused of doing, that the good which God extracts from evil excuses it (ver. 8), we bow, with all other men, before the Scripture declarations which attest the common sin, and we apply to ourselves the sentence of condemnation which the law pronounces on the whole world. Only (iii 21 ... seq.) we do not rest there ; for we have the happiness of knowing that there is a righteousness of faith through which we escape from wrath." — This construction is refuted, we think, by three principal facts— 1. The man who judges, ii 1, is necessarily the Jew (see the exegesis). 2. The objection, iii. 5, is closely connected with the quotation from Ps. li, and cannot be the beginning of a wholly new development. 3. The question : What then ? have we a shelter ? " (ver. 9), is too plainly a reference to that of ver. 1 (" what then is the advantage of the Jew ? ") to be applied otherwise than ... to the Jew. ...

Report a mistake

... This is confirmed by the end of ver. 9, in which the apostle gives the reason for the first proposition in this general sentence : *' Far we have proved both Jews and Greeks" It is clear, therefore, that as chap. L from ver. 18 describes the wrath of God displayed on the Gentiles, chap. iL describes and demonstrates the wrath of God as accumulating over the Jewish world, and that the passage iii 1-8 is simply intended to set aside the objection which the Jew might draw from his exceptional superiority. Yv. 9-20 are the scriptural ... and demonstration of this double condemnation of Jews and Gentiles. — According to Volkmar, chap. L from ver. 18 describes the wrath 'of God against all sin, and chap. ii. that same wrath against ail sinners, even against the Jew, notwithstanding his excuses ... and his advantages, which he is unable to turn to moral account (w. 17-29), and finally, notwithstanding the greatest of his privileges, the possession of the Messianic promises (iii 1-8). Here, iii. 9, Volkmar places the banning of the new section, that of the righteousness of faith, "Since the whole world is perishing, w. 9-20, God saves the world by the righteousness of faith, which is confirmed by the example both of Abraham and Adam, the type of Christ." This construction differs from ours only in two points, which are not to its advantage, as it appears to me — (1) The antithesis between aU sins (chap, i.) and all sinners (chap, ii), which is too artificial to be ... (2) The line of demarca tion between the preceding and the new section fixed at iii. 9 (instead of iii. 21), a division which awkwardly separates the section on ... in its entirety ... from its scriptural summary (w. 9-20).

Report a mistake

Romans 3:21–22

Yv. 21, 22a. "But now ihe righteousness of God is ... fested wUhout the law, being vritnessed by the law and the prophets; even the righteousness of God by faith in Jems Christ for and upon all them that believe" — The Be, but, is strongly adversative ; it contrasts the revelation of righteousness widi that of wrath. The former is presented as a new fact in the history of mankind ; so that one might be led to give the word now a temporal sense ; comp. the at this time, ver. 26, and Acts zvii 30. This, however, is only apparent. The contrast with the preceding is moral rather than temporal ; it is the contrast between the condemnation pronounced by the law (ver. 20) and the new righteousness acquired without the law (ver. 21). It is therefore better to give the word ... the logical meaning which it has so frequently in the New Testament (vii 17 ; 1 Cor. xiii. 12, xiv. 6, etc.) and in the classics : ''The situation being suoh." The words : without the law, stand foremost, as having the emphasis. They evidently depend on the verb is manifested, and not on the word righteousness (a righteousness without law, Aug.). The absence of the article before the word law does not prove that the 246 ... apostle does not mean the term to denote the Mosaic law ; only the law is excluded from co-operating in the new righteousness not because it is Mosaic, but because it is law. Under the old dispensation, righteousness came to man through the thousand channels of legalism ; in the new, righteousness is given him without the least co-operation of what can be called a law. — We know what Paul calls the righteousness of God : it is the state of reconciliation with God in which man is placed by the sentence which declares him just (see on L 17). — The verb ... in the light, differs from the verb ... to reveal, used L 17, in the figure, not in the sense. ...

Romans 3:21–22 · Open Word Bible

21But now God's righteousness has come to light apart from the law, though the Law and the Prophets bear witness to it. 22It is God's righteousness through faith in Jesus Christ, for all who believe. No one is treated differently.

Report a mistake

... The second applies to an object which was hidden by a veil, and which is made known by withdrawing the veil ; the former, to an object placed in the shade, and on which rays of light are let ... The only real difference from i. 17 is therefore this: there, the verb was in the present, for it denoted the permanent revelation of the gospel by means of evangelical preaching ; while here, the verb is in the perfect, because it refers, as' Morison says, " to the fact itself, which that preaching proclaims.'' That fact now finished is the subject expounded in w. 25 and 26 ; it is through it that the righteousness of (rod is set in the light for all times.

But if legal observances are excluded from all co-operation in this righteousness, it does not follow that the latter is in contradiction to the Old Testament revelation in its double form of law and prophecy. These two manifestations of the divine will, commandment, and promise, understood in their true sense, contain, on the contrary, the confirmation of the righteousness of faith, as the apostle will prove in the sequel of this section, ver. ... 25. The law by unveiling sin opens up the void in the heart, which is filled by ... righteousness of faith; prophecy completes the work of preparation by ... this righteousness. Thus, there is no objection to be drawn from the old revelation against the new. As the new fulfils the old, the latter confirms the former.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:21–26

We have already proved that ver. 21 is directly connected in sense with i 17 (see pp. 163, 164). In the interval from L 18 to iiL 20, the apostle has shown that the wrath of God rests on mankind, whence it follows that if the world is not to perish, a divine manifestation of an opposite kind, and able to overcome the first, is indispensabla It is this new revelation which forms the subject of the following passage. Yv. 21 and 22 contain the theme of the first piece, and at the same time of the whole section. Ver. 23 once more sums up the thought of the preceding section; and w. 24-26 are the development of the subject, the exposition of the new way of justification.

Romans 3:21–26 · Open Word Bible

21But now God's righteousness has come to light apart from the law, though the Law and the Prophets bear witness to it. 22It is God's righteousness through faith in Jesus Christ, for all who believe. No one is treated differently. 23Everyone has sinned, and all come short of God's glory. …

Report a mistake

Romans 3:22

Ver. 22. The new righteousness, then, being given without any legal work, what is the means by which it is conferred ? Ver. 22 answers: faith in Jesm Christ. Such is the true means opposed to the false. The ... now, which the translation cannot render, is explanatory, as ix. 30 ; GaL ii 2 ; ... iL 8, eta It takes the place of a scilicet, to wit. Osterv. and Oltram. have well rendered it by : say I: " The righteousness, / say, of God." Here, again, the absence of the article serves to indicate the category : a righteousness of divine origin, in opposition to the legal dispensation, in which righteousness proceeds from human worka. — This righteousness is granted to ... not assuredly because of any merit inherent in it, — for this would be to fall back on works, the very thing which the new dispensation wishes to exclude, — but because of the ... of faith. Therefore it is that this object is expressly mentioned : Jesus Christ. The omission of the word Jesm by Marcion is perhaps to be explained by the fact that this heretic denied the humanity of Jesus, and attached importance only to His ... The omission of this word in the one ... B, cannot bring it into suspicion. It has been attempted to make this complement: ... Christ, a gen. suibjecti : the faith which Jesus Christ Himself had, whether His faith in God (Benecke : ... fiddUy to God) or His fidelity to us (Lange). The parallel, i 17, suffices to refute such interpretations. The only possible sense is this: ... in Jesus Christ; comp. Mark xi 22 ; Gal iL 16 ; Jas. iL 1, eta — This clause : by faUh in Jems Christ, is the reproduction and development of the first clause: iic Trlarefn, by faith, L 17. The following: far and ... all them that believe, is the development of the second clause in the same verse: ... for faith. Faith, indeed, as we have seen, ... a | double part in justification. ...

Romans 3:22 · Open Word Bible

22It is God's righteousness through faith in Jesus Christ, for all who believe. No one is treated differently.

Report a mistake

... It is the disposition which God accepts, and which He imputes as righteousness ; and it is at the same time the instrument whereby every one may ... priate for his own personal advantage this ... of faith. The first office is expressed here by the clause : by faith ; the second by the clause : for and upon all (hem (hat believe. — The words ... upon all them, are wanting in the four Alex., but they are found in the Mjj. of the other two families (except P), and in the ancient ... Meyer and ... justly remark that it would be impossible to account for their interpolation, as ... was nothing in the clause : for ail (hem, to demand this explanatory addition It is easy to imderstand, on the contaaiy, how these words were omitted, either through a confusion of the two ... by the copyists, 248 ... bt faith.

Report a mistake

It is quite in keeping with Panl's manner thus to accumulate subordinate clauses to express by a change of prepositions the different aspects of the moral fact which he means to describe. These two aspects in this case are those of general destinaiion ... for) and personal ... upon) : As to this righteousness, God sends it far thee that thou mayest believe in it ; and it will rest an thee from the moment thou believest" Comp. ... iiL 9. Theodoret, Bengel, etc., have thought that the clause : far all them, applied to the Jews, and the clause : upan all them, to the Grentiles. But the very object the apostle has here in view is to efiace every other distinction save that of believing. This same reason prevents us also from allowing the explanation of Morison, who, after Wetstein, Flatt, Stuart, puts a comma after ... for all, that is to say, for aU men, absolutely speaking, inasmuch as this righteousness is really universal in destination, and who applies the participle : ... that believe, only to the second clause : upan aU, inasmuch as real ... in this righteousness is granted to believers only. But in this case the second ... all, should of course have been omitted. Then we shall see in ver. 25 that the condition of faith is included from the beginning in the very decree of redemption. Fuially, these two clauses : far all them, and upan all them that believe, are plainly the unfolding of the contents of the words ... trior ... for faith, L 17; whence it follows that the words toho believe belong equally to the two pronouns all. — To pronounce one righteous, God does not then any more ask : Hast thou kept the law ? but : Believest thou, thou, whoever thou art ? ...

Report a mistake

... The first clause : for aU, contrasts this believer, Jew or Gentile, with the Jews, who alone could attain to the righteousness of the law. llie second clause : upon all, contrasts this righteousness as a gift of God fully made, with that of the law of which man himself must be the maker.

These two verses are, as we shall see, the theme which ... be developed in the whole following section. But, first, ver. 23 sums up the preceding section ... re-stating the ground on which every human being needs the righteousness of faitL Vv. ... 23. "-For ... is no difference: far all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God.*' — By denying aU difference the apostle means here that there are not two ways by which men can be justified, the one that of works, the other of faitL The first is closed ... all, even the Jews, by the fact of universal condemnation, which has just been demonstrated. The second, therefore, alone remains open. The old Genevan version, Ostervald, and Martin put all ver. 23 into ver. 22, and thus reckon only thirty verses instead of thirty-one in the chapter. The object of this change was to make ver. 23 a simple parenthesis, that the participle ... justified might be directly connected with ver. 22. But this grammatical connection is certainly incorrect and we should preserve the reckoning of the verses as it stands in the Greek text

Report a mistake

Romans 3:23

Ver. 23. This absence of difference in the mode of justification rests on the equality of all in respect of the fact of sin. In the aorist ... have committed sin, no account is taken of the question whether they have done so once or a hundred times. Once suffices to deprive us of the title of righteous, and thereby of the glory of God. — ... and in consequence. — The verb ... to lade, expresses in general the idea of a deficit, which consists either in remaining below the normal level, or in being behind others. Paul therefore means that they all want more or less a normal state, which he calls the ghry of God. By this term some have understood the favourable opinion which God has of the just man, ... approbation or favour ... . This meaning is far from natural; John xiL 43 does not suffice to justify it. Others understand by this expression : glory in ... sight, that which we should possess if we were righteous ... . This meaning is not much more natural than that which appears sometimes in Luther : the act of glorying in God ; or than that of (Ecumenius and Chalmers: the destination of every man to ... God. There are really only two . senses possible. The first is that of the many commentators 250 ... bt taitil who understand the glory of God as the ... and eternal glory ... . But in this case we mnst give to the verb ... forced meaning : ... lack the ... qualifications for ... this glory. The second meaning, and the only one which we think ... is this : the divine splendour which shines forth from God Himself, and which He communicates to all that live in union with Him (see Hofinann, Meyer). This meaning includes that of Btickert and Obhausen, who understand it too specially, no doubts to mean the original image of God in man. The complement ... of God, is at once a gen, posseu. and a gen, ... ...

Romans 3:23 · Open Word Bible

23Everyone has sinned, and all come short of God's glory.

Report a mistake

... God can communicate this glory, because He possesses it Himself, and it belongs to His nature. He had communicated a ray of it to man when He created him pure and happy ; it was intended to shine more and more brightly in him as he rose from innocence to holiness. By sinning, man lost both what he had received of it and ... he was yet to obtain. A dispossessed king, the crown has fallen from his head. — The consequence of this state of things is indicated, in dose connection with the context, in ver. 24.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:24

Ver. 24. "Being ... freely by His grace through the redemption that is in Chriet Jeeue!* — The participle ... being justified, takes us by surprisa Why give this idea, which is the principal one in the context, a subordinate place, by using a participle to express it ? To explain this unexpected form, it must be remembered that the idea of justification had already been solemnly introduced, w. 21, 22. Ver. 23 had afterwards explained it by the fact of the flail ; and now it can reappear as a simple corollary from this great fact We might paraphrase : " being ... justified, as we have just declared freely " ... The present participle ... refers to every moment in the history of man kind when a sinner comes to believe. There is no need therefore to add, as Ostervald and others do, a new conjunction: "and tJiat they are justified." Neither is it necessary to take this participle, with Beza and Morison, as the demonstration of the fact of sin, ver. 23. It is impossible that the essential idea of the whole passage should be given in proof of a secondary idea. The most erroneous explanation seems to us to be that of Oltramare, who here begins a wholly new period, the principal verb of which must be sought in ver. 27 : "Since we are justified fireely ... is there here, then, any cause for boasting ? " The most important passage in the whole Epistle, vv. 24-26, would thus be degraded to the rank of a simple incident. And, moreover, ... asyndeton between w. 23, 24 would be without the ' slightest justification.

Romans 3:24 · Open Word Bible

24Yet they are declared righteous as a free gift, by His grace, through the redemption found in Christ Jesus.

Report a mistake

This notion : leing justified, is qualified in three directions : those of the Tnode, the origin, and the meaThs. The mode is expressed by the adverb ... freely. It is not a matter of wages, it is a free gift. — The origin of this gift is : Sis grace, God's free goodwill inclining Him to sinful man to bestow on him a favour. There is no blind necessity here ; we are face to face with a generous inspiration of divine love. The means is the ... wrought in Jestie Christ. ... "So doubt the New Testament writers often use it in the general sense of deliverance, apart from all reference to a price paid ; so viii 23 ; Luke xxL 28 ; 1 Cor. i 30. But in these passages, as Morison observes, the matter in question is only one of the particular ... of the fundamental deliverance obtained by Christ The idea of the latter is usually connected with that of the ransom paid to obtain it; comp. Matt. xx. 28, where it is said that Jesus gives His life a ransom ... in the room and stead ... of many ; 1 Tim. ii 6, where the term signifying ransom forms one word with the preposition ... in the place of ... 1 Pet i 18: "Ye were ransomsd as by the precious blood of the Lamb, without spot" This notion of purchase, in speaking of the work of Christ, appears also in 1 Cor. vi 20, vil 23 ; GaL iii 13. It is obvious that this figure was most familiar to the apostle's mind ; it is impossible to get rid of it in the present passage. — The title Christ is placed before the name Jesus, the main subject here being His mediatorial office (see on i 1). — After thus giving the general idea of the work, the apostle expounds it more in detail by defining exactly the ideas he has just stated. ...

Report a mistake

... That of divine grace reappears in the words : whom He had set forth beforehand, ver. 25 ; that of deliverance, in the words : to be a propitiation through faith ; that of Christ JesuA in the words: in His hlood; and, finally, the principal term : being jtidified, in the last words of ver. 26 : ... of him who believdh in Jesus. This condosion thus brings us back to the starting-point of the passage.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:25–26

Yv. 25, 26. " Whom ... had established beforehand as the means of propitiation through faith by His blood, for the demonstration of His righteousness on ... of the tolerance shown ... sins that toere past, during ths forbearance of God, for the demonstration of His righteousness at the present time; that He might be fust, and the justifier of him who is of the faith in Jesus — It is not without reason that these two verses have been called " the marrow of theology." Calvin declares ''that there is not probably in the whole Bible a passage which sets forth more profoundly the righteousness of God in Christ" And yet it is so short that the statement seems scarcely to have begun when all is said, within so few lines are the most decisive thoughts concentrated! It is really, as Yitringa has said, the brief summary of divine wisdom." *

Romans 3:25–26 · Open Word Bible

25God put Him forward as the means of atonement, by His blood, to be received through faith. He did this to show His righteousness, since He had passed over the sins committed before, 26when God held back His judgment. He did it to show His righteousness at the present time, so that He would be righteous and also the one who declares righteous whoever has faith in Jesus.

Report a mistake

... Otherwise the sovereign majesty of God on the one side, and the criminal character of the sinner on the other, would remain shrouded in the conscience of the pardoned sinner ; and such a pardon, instead of laying a foundation for his restoration, would consummate his degradation and entail his eternal ... Thus are justified the two qualifications of the means of propitiation indicated here by the apostle : in hlood and by faith ; in other terms— 1. The judgment of God on sin by the shedding of Uood ; 2. The adherence of the guilty to this judgment by faith. The apostolic utterance may consequently be paraphrased thus : Jesus Christ, whom God settled beforehand as the means of propitiation on the condition of faith, through the shedding of His blood."

Blood does not certainly denote the holy consecration of life in general It is purely arbitrary to seek any other meaning in the word than it naturally expresses, the fact of a violent and bloody death. This signification is specially obvious in a passage where the word is found in such direct connection with ... in which there is concentrated the whole symbolism of the Jewish sacrifices.

Report a mistake

The relation commonly maintained between propitiation (the act which renders God favourable) and blood is this : the blood of the Messiah, shed as an equivalent for that of sinners, is the indemnity ... to God's justice to purchase the pardon granted by love. But it must be observed that this relation is not stated by the apostle himself, and that the term ... to render propitious, does not necessarily contain the idea of an indemnity paid in the form of a quantitative equivalent The word denotes in general the act, whatever it be, in consequence of which God, who was displaying His wrath, is led to display His grace, and to pardon. This propitiatory act is, Luke xviii. 13, 14, the cry of the penitent publican; Ps. IL 17, the sacrifice of a broken and contrite heart. In the supreme and final redemption which we have in Christ, the way of propitiation is more painful and ... The apostle has just told us in what it consists ; he proceeds in the words which follow to explain to us its object : for the demonstration of His righteousness.

Report a mistake

The term demonstration is remarkable. If the apostle had in view a payment offered to justice in compensation for the death which sinful men have merited, he would rather have said : '' for the satisfaction of His righteousness.'' The word manifestation seems to belong to a somewhat different order of ideaa But let ... begin with fixing the meaning of the principal expression : the righteousness of God. Luther has connected it with justification. But in this case the contrast with the time of ... ver. 26, becomes unintelligible, and the two last terms of the same verse : " that He ... be just and the ... could not be distinguished from one another. So all interpreters agree to take the word as indicating a divine attribute ... long veiled, was put in the light of day by the cross. Which attribute is it ? ... sometimes denoting ... perfection in general, each commentator has taken the term used by Paul as expressing the special attribute which agreed best with his system in regard to the work of redemption It has been taken to express — (1) Goodness (Theodor., Abel., Grot., ... etc.) ; (2) Veracity or fidelity (Ambr., Beza, Turret) ; (3) Holiness ... (4) Righteousness as justifying and sanctifying (the Greek Fathers, ... Calv., Oltram.), — this meaning is almost identical with Luther's ; (5) Bighteousness in so far as it carries the salvation of the elect to its goal ; such is the meaning of Bitschl, which comes very near No. 3 ; (G) Betributive justice in God, considered here specially as the principle of the punishment of sin (de Wette, Mey., Philip.). The first five meanings all fall before one common objection ; the Greek language, and Paul's vocabulary in particular, have special terms to express each of those particular attributes : ... goodness ; ... veracity ; ... faithfulness ; ... grace ; ... holiness. ...

Report a mistake

... Why not use one of these definite terms, instead of introducing into this so important didactic passage a term fitted to occasion the gravest misunderstandings, if it was reaUy to be taken in a sense different from its usual and natural signification ? Now this signification is certainly that of No. 6 : righteousness, as the mode of action whereby God mcintains the right of every being, and consequently ... throughout the whole moral universe, blessing him who has respect to this order, visiting with punishment him who violates it. The essence of God is the absolute love of the good, His holinesa (Isa. vL 3 : " Holy, holy, holy " . . .). Now, the good is order, the normal relation between all free beings/ from God Himself to the last of them. The attribute of ... eternally latent in holiness, passes into the active state with the appearance of the free creature. For in the fact of freedom there was included the possibility of disorder, and this possibility soon passed into reality. God's horror at evil. His holiness, thus displays itself in the form of righteousness preserving order and maintaining right. Now, to maintain order without suppressing liberty, there is but one means, and that is punishment Punishment is order in disorder. It is the revelation of disorder to the sinner's conscience by means of suffering. It is consequently, or at least may be, the point of departure for the re-establishment of order, of the normal relation of free beings. Thus is explained the notion of the ... of God, so often proclaimed in Scripture (John xvii. 25 ; 2 Thess. L 5; 2 Tim. iv. 8; Eev. xvi 5, xix. ...

Report a mistake

... 2, 11, etc.); and especially Bom. iL 5 ... seq., where we see the ... the Just judgment, distributing among men ... and ... tion (vv. 8, 9), glory and ... (w. 7-10). — This meaning, which we give with Scripture to the word righteousness, and which is in keeping with its generally received use, is also the only one, as we shall see, which suits the context of this passage, and especially the words which follow.

How was the cross the manifestation of the righteousness of God t In two ways so closely tinited, that either of them separated from the other would lose its value. 1. By the very fact of Christ's sufferings and bloody death. If Paul does not see in this punishment a ... equivalent of the treatment which every sinner had incurred, this is what clearly appears from such sayings as 2 Cor. v. 21 : "God made Him sin for ns; " GaL iii 13 : " Christ hath redeemed us from the curse of the law, being ... a curse for ... Now, herein precisely consists the manifestation of the righteousness wrought out on the crosa God is here revealed as See ... Naville, ... mat, tint ... one against whom no creature can revolt without meriting death ; and the sinner is here put in his place in the dust as a malefactor worthy of death. Such is the objective manifestation of righteousness. 2. This demonstration, however striking, would be incomplete without the subjective or moral manifestation which accompanies it Every sinner might be called to die on a cross. But no sinner was in a condition to undergo this punishment as Jesus did, accepting it as deserved. This is what He alone could do in virtue of His holiness. ...

Report a mistake

... The calm and mute resignation with which He allowed Himself to be led to the slaughter, manifested the idea which He Himself formed of the majesty of God and the judgment He was passing on the sin of the world ; from His cross there rose the most perfect homage rendered to the righteousness of God. In this death the sin of mankind was therefore doubly judged, and the righteousness of God doubly manifested, — by the external fact of this painful and ignominious punishment, and by the inward act of Christ's conscience, which ratified this dealing of which sin was the object in His person. — But now it will be asked what rendered such a demonstration necessary : Because, says St Paul, of the tolerance exercised in regard to sins past.

Report a mistake

For four thousand years the spectacle presented by mankind to the whole moral universe (comp. 1 Cor. iv. 9) was, so to speak, a continual scandal With the exception of some great examples of judgments, divine righteousness seemed to be asleep ; one might even have asked if it existed. Men sinned here below, and yet they lived. They sinned on, and yet reached in safety a hoary old age I . . . Where were the ... of sin f It was this relative impunity which rendered a solemn manifestation of righteousness necessary. Many commentators have completely mistaken the meaning of this ... by giving to the word ... which we have translated tolerance, the sense ... pardon (Orig., Luth., Calv., ... see also the Geneva translation of 1557, and, following it, Osterv. etc.). This first mistake has led to another. There has been given to the preposition Bid the meaning of ... which it cannot have when governing the accusative, or it has been 262 ... by paitil translated in view of, which would have required the preposition ... The first error lies in confounding the term ... (tolerance, impunity) with ... (remission, pardon). The second of these substantives comes from the verb ... to send away, dismiss, pardon (remittere); while the first used here comes from the verb ... to let pass, neglect not to occupy oneself with ... nearly the same idea as that expressed by the word ... to dose the eyes to, Acts xviil 30. The signification of the verb ... appears clearly from the two following passages : Sir. xziii. ... The real sense of ... is therefore not doubtful It has been given by Theodor., Grot, Beng. ; it is now almost universally received (ThoL, Olsh., Mey,, Fritzs., Rlick., de Wette, Philip, etc.). ...

Report a mistake

... The Bid can thus receive its true meaning (with the accusative) : on account of; and the idea of the passage becomes clear : God judged it necessary, on account of the impunity so long enjoyed by those myriads of sinners who succeeded one another on the earth, at length to manifest His righteousness by a ... act ; and He did so by realizing in the death of Jesus the punishment which each of those sinners would have deserved to undergo. — Ritschl, who, on account of his theory regarding the righteousness of God (see on 1. 18), could not accept this meaning, supposes another interpretation (II. p. 217 ... seq.). Tolerance ... is not, according to him, contrasted with merited punishment, but with the pardon which God has finally granted. Yer. 25 would thus signify that till the coming of Jesus Christ, God had ordy exercised patience without pardoning, but that in Christ the righteousness of God (His ... to the salvation of His elect) had advanced BO far as to give complete pardon. But where then, asks Gess, is this ... so necessary to indicate the advance from tolerance to pardon 1 The natural contrast to impunity is not pardon but punishment ; comp. ii 4, 5, and the parallel passage to ours, Acts xvii. 30, 31 : " The times of ignorance God winked at, but now commandeth men to repent, lecause He hath appointed a day in which He will ... the world in ... Finally, it is impossible on this interpretation to give a natural meaning to the words ... account of. For pardon was not given because of the impunity exercised toward those sins. Paul would have required to say, either : ... of those sins themselves, or : following up the long tolerance exercised toward them.

Report a mistake

Several commentators (Calovius, for example) refer the expression : sins thai are past, not to the sins of mankind who lived before Christ, but to those committed by every believer ... his conversion. It is difficult in this sense to explain the words which follow : at this time which form an antithesis to the former. We must apply them to the moment when each sinner in particular believes. But this meaning does not correspond to the gravity of the expression : at this time, in which the apostle evidently contrasts the period of completion with that of general impunity, and even with the eternal decree (the

Report a mistake

It may be further asked if those sins that ... past are those of all mankind anterior to Christ, or perhaps, as 1 hilip )i thinks, only those of the Jews. The argument which this commentator derives from the meaning of ... the lid of the ark, the propitiatory so called, has of course no weight with us. Might one be foimd in the remarkable parallel, Heb. ix. 15 : " The transgressions that were tmder the first testament f No, for this restricted application follows naturally from the particular aim of the Epistle to the Hebrews (comp. for example, ... 16). It may even be said that the ... of which the apostle speaks was less necessary for Israel than for the rest of mankind. For the sacrifices instituted by God were already a homage rendered to His righteousness. But this homage was not ... for there was wanting in it that which gives value to the Bocrifice of Christ ; the victim underwent death, but did not ... it. Hence it was that the death of the Messiah necessarily closed the long series of the Levitical sacrifices. No more can we receive the opinion of ... Cocceius, Morison, who think the sins ... are past are those of the faithful of the Old Testament whom God pardoned from regard to the future sacrifice of Christ. The article ... the sins ") does not admit of this restriction, which there is nothing else to indicate. And the sacrifice of Christ cannot be explained here by an end so special.

Report a mistake

It is God Himself who, according to this passage, is to be regarded as the author of the whole work of redemption. The salvation of the world is not therefore wrested from Him, as is sometimes represented by the mediation of Christ The We may be aUowed here to borrow from Morieon the account of an experience of the ... poet Cowper, calculated to give an impression of the wealth of this passage. It was a time when Gowper was brought to the rery verge of despair. He had walked up and down in his room a long while profoundly agitated. At last he seated himself near Us window, and seeing a Bible there he opened it, to find if possible some consolation and strength. " The passage which met my eye," says he, "was the twenty-fifth verse of the third chapter of Romans. On reading it I immediately received power to believe. The rays of the Sun of Righteousness fell on me in all their fulness ; I saw the complete sufficiency of the expiation which Christ had wrought for my pardon and entire justification. In an instant I believed and received the ... of the gospel." " If," adds he, *' the arm of the Almighty had not supported me, I believe I should have been overwhelmed with gratitude and joy ; my eyes filled with tears ; transports choked my utterance. I could only look to heaven in silent fear, overflowing with love and wonder." But it is better to describe the work of the Holy Spirit in his own words : " it was the joy which is unspeakable and full ... (1 Pet. i 8).— ... qf Cowper, by Taylor. same thought is expressed elsewhere ; for example, 2 Cor. v. 18 : All is of God, who hath reconciled us to Himself by Jesus Christ;'' and John ilL 16 : "God so loved the world, that He gave His only-begotten Son." ...

Report a mistake

But if it is asked why Paul gives as the reason for this sacrifice only the past and not the future sins of mankind, as if the death of Christ did not apply equally to the latter, the answer is easy, from the apostle's standpoint : the righteousness of God once revealed in the sacrifice of the cross, this demonstration remains. Whatever happens, nothing can again efface it from the history of the world, nor from the conscience of mankind. Henceforth no illusion is possible : all sin must be pardoned— or judged.

Begarded from the point of view here taken by the apostle, the death of Jesus is in the history of humanity, something like what would emerge in the life of a sinner had he a time of perfect lucidity when, his conscience being miraculously brought into one with the mind of God ... sin, he should judge himself as God judges him. Such a moment would be to this man the starting-point of a total transformation. Thus the demonstration of righteousness given to the world by the cross of Christ at the dose of the long economy of sin tolerated, founded the new epoch, and with the possibility of pardon established the principle of the radical renewal of humanity.

Report a mistake

... This point should never be forgotten in the idea which we form of expiation. — The verb ... before, may signify in the middle, either : to ... present publicly (in view of oneself), or to set hefore oneself in the innermost shrine of the spirit; to decide, to design beforehand within ... Por the preposition ... may have the local meaning in front of, or the temporal meaning before. Both significations of the verb have been used here, and in favour of both numerous examples may be quoted in classic ... The second sense is obviously the prevailing one in the New Testament ; comp. Bom. i 13, Eph. i 9, etc., as well as the common use of the word ... to denote God's eternal plan (viii. 28 ; Eph. iii 11); see also Acts xxvii. 13. In favour of the first meaning, there may be quoted, indeed, the phrase ... the ... in the LXX. If we use it here, it would make the apostle say: ''whom God set forth publicly as a propitiatory victim." This act of public showing forth would refer either to the exhibition of Jesus on the cross, or to the proclamation of His death by the apostolic preaching. The middle form (to set forth for oneself) would find its explanation in the clause following : '' for the demonstration of His ... This meaning is not impossible. It is adopted by the Vulgate, Luth., Beng., ThoL, de Wette, Philip., Meyer, Hofm., Morison. But this idea of a public exhibition of the person of Jesus appears to us to have about it something at once theatrical and superfluous. Independently of what we have just been saying of the ordinary meaning of the words ... in the ... Testament, the context speaks strongly in favour of the other meaning. The fundamental idea of the passage is the contrast between the time of God's forbearance in regard to sin, and the decisive moment when at once He carried out the universal expiation. ...

Report a mistake

... It is natural in this order of ideas to emphasize the fact that God had foreseen this final moment, and had provided Himself beforehand with the victim by means of which the expiation was to be accomplished. Thus the phrase: to set forth beforer 254 ... bt faith. hiikd, already gives a hint of the contrast : ... the present time, ver. 26. Placed as it is at the head of the whole passage, it brings out forcibly, at the same time, the incomparable gravity of the work about to be described. The middle of the verb refers to the ... resolution of God. In adopting this meaning, we find ourselves at one with the ancient Greek interpreters, Chrys., (Ecum., Theoph. ; see, among the modems, ... The word ... belongs to that host of Greek adjectives whose termination ... signifies what serves to. The meaning therefore is : " what serves to render propitious, favourabla'* The verb ... corresponds in the LXX. to kipper the Piel of ... to cover. Applied to the notion of sin, this Piel has a double sense : either to pardon — the subject is then the offended one himself, who, as it were, covers the sin that he may see it no more, for example, Ps. Ixv. 4— or to expiate, — the subject is then the victim which covers (effaces) the sin with its blood, that the judge may see it no more, for example, Ex. xxix. 36. In the New Testament this verb occurs twice, Luke xviii. 13, where the publican says to God : ... show Thysdf propitious to me, which is equivalent to: forgive me; and Heb. iL 17 : ... rct ... the sins of the people. We find in these same two passages the two meanings of the term in the Old Testament. The etymology of this verb ... is the adjective ... pro pitious (probably connected with 09, ... To explain the word ... in our text, very many commentators, Grig., Theoph., Er., ... Calv., Grot, Yitringa, and among the modems, ... ...

Report a mistake

... ThoL, Philip., etc., have had recourse to the technical meaning which it has in the LXX., where it denotes the propitiatory, or lid of the ark of the covenant With this meaning the substantive understood would be ... lid, which is sometimes joined to the adjective, for example, Ex. xxv. 17. As is well known, the high priest, on the day of atonement, sprinkled this lid with the blood of the victim (Lev. xvi 14 ... seq.). On this account these commentators hold that it was here regarded by Paul as the type of Christ, whose shed blood covers the sin of the world. The term is found in this sense, Heb. ix. 5. We do not, however, think this interpretatidn admissible. 1. If the matter in question were a weU-known definite object, the only one of its kind, the article to could not be omitted. 2. The Epistle to the Romans is not a book which moves, like the Epistle to the Hebrews, in the sphere of Levitical symbolism ; there is nothing hero to indicate that the term is applied to an object bdonging to the Israelitish cultus. 3. Gess justly observes that if this type had been familiar to St. Paul, it would have been found elsewhere in his letters ; and if it were not so, the term would have been unintelligible to his readers. 4. In all ... the figure would be a strange one. What a comparison to make of Jesus Christ crucified with a lid sprinkled with blood I 6. Give to the verb ... whichever of the two meanings you choose, the figure of the propitiatory remains unsuitable. In the sense of exhibUing ... there is a contradiction between this idea of publicity and the part assigned to the propitiatory in the Jewish cultus; for this object remained concealed in the sanctuary, the high priest alone could see it, and that only once a year, and through a doud of smoke. ...

Report a mistake

... And if the verb be explained in the sense which we have adopted, that of ... before' hand, it is still more impossible to apply this idea of an eternal purpose, either to a material object like the propitiatory itself, or to its typical connection with Jesus Christ We must therefore understand the word ... in a very wide sense : a means of ... After reading Morison, we cannot venture to define more strictly, and to translate : a victim of propitiation, as if there were to be understood the substantive ... For this meaning of the term used here does not seem to be sufficiently proved by the passages alleged (see the examples quoted by ThoL, de Wette, Meyer, with Morison's criticism). The English commentator himself takes the word ... as a ... adjective, agreeing with the relative ... Jesus Christ, whom God set forth as making propitiation*' Such is the explanation of the Peschito, Thomas Aquinas, Er., Mel., etc. It is certainly allowable. But in this sense would not Paul rather have used the masculine substantive ... The word ... is indeed found, not ... We therefore hold by the generally received interpretation, which makes the term ... a neuter substantive (originally the neuter of the adjective ; comp. ... etc.). As to the idea of sacrifice, if it is not in the word itself, it follows from its connection with the following clause : by His blood (see below). For what is a ... of propUiation by blood, if it is not a sacrifice ? A question may here be raised : if it is God Himself who, as we have just said, has established this means of pardon of His free grace, what purpose then was this means to serve ? For it cannot obtain for us anything else than we possessed already, the Divine love. This objection rests on the false idea that expiation is intended to originate a sentiment which did not exist in God before. ...

Report a mistake

... What it produces is such a change in the relation between God and the creature, that God can henceforth display toward sinful man one of the elements of His nature rather than another. The feeling of the divine mind shows itself in the foundation of the expiatory work as compassion. But the propitiation once effected, it can display itself in the new and higher form of intimate communion. As Gess says : " Divine love manifests itself in the gift of the Son, that it may be able afterwards to diffuse itself in the heart by the gift of the Spirit" There are therefore — 1. The love which precedes the propitiation, and which determines to effect it ; and 2. Love such that it can display itself, once the propitiation is effected.

Report a mistake

The clause ii [t] ... by faith, is wanting in the Alex., which, however, is not enough to render it suspicious. Five Mjj. (Alex, and Greco-Lat) omit the article ... (the, before faith). It would be impossible to explain why this word had been rejected if it existed originally in the text It has therefore been added to give the notion of faith a more definite sense : the well-known faith in Jesus. But it was not on this or that particular faith the aposde wished here to insist ; it was on faith in its very idea, in opposition to worka — On what does the clause depend : ... by faith 1 According to some ancients and Philippi : on ... (He set forth, or established beforehand). But it is difficult to conceive what logical relation there can be between the ideas of setting forth, or establishing, and a clause such as by faith. The only natural connection of this clause is with the word ... (means of propitiaiion) : " God has established Jesus beforehand as the means of propitiation through faith/' which signifies that the efficacy of this means was from the first bound by the divine decree to the condition of faith. God eternally determined within Himself the means of pardon, but as eternally He stipulated with Himself that the condition on which this means should become available for each individual should be faith, neither more nor less. This idea is important ; the subjective condition of faith entered as an integral element into the very decree of amnesty (the ... This is what we shall find afterwards expressed in the words ... whom Be foreknew (as His own by faith), viii. 29. The clause following : in or ... His blood, is connected by most commentators (Luth., Calv., Olsh., Thol., Morison) with the word faith : " by faith in Sis blood.'* Grammatically this connection is possible ; comp. Eph. i. 15. And it is the interpretation, perhaps, which has led to the article Try: being added before ... ...

Report a mistake

... But it should certainly be rejected. The idea requiring a determining clause is not faith, which is dear of itself, but the means of propitiation. In a passage entirely devoted to the expounding of the fact of expiation, Paul could not possibly fail to indicate the manner in which the means operated. We therefore find the notion of propitiation qualified by two parallel and mutually completing clauses : the first, by faith, indicating the subjective condition ; and the second, by His blood, setting forth the historical and objective condition of the efficacy of the meana Propitiation does not take place except through faith on the part of the saved, and through blood on the part of the Saviour. The attempt of Meyer, Hofmann, etc., to make this clause dependent on ... He set Him forth or established Him beforehand . . . through His blood ") is unnatural To present or establish a person through or in his blood, would not only be an obscure form of speech, but even offensively harsh. — According to Lev. xviL 11, the soul of man, the principle of life, is in the blood. The blood flowing forth is the life exhaling. Now the wilful sinner has deserved death. Having used the gift of life to revolt against Him from whom he holds it, it is just that this gift should be withdrawn from him. Hence the sentence : In the day thou sinnest, thou shalt die." Every act of sin should thus, in strict justice, be followed by death, the violent and instant death of its author. The sinner, it is true, no longer understands this ; for sin stapifies the conscience at the same time that it ... the heart and perverts the will Snch, then, is the law which must be set in the light of day before pardon is granted, and that it may be granted. ...

Report a mistake

Romans 3:26

Ver. 26. The first words of this verse : during the forbearance of God, depend naturally on the word ... tolerance : "the tolerance (exercised) during the forbearance of God." It is less simple to connect this regimen with the participle ... committed formerly during the forbearance of God." For the principal idea in what precedes, that which needs most to be explained, is that of the tolerance, and not that expressed by this participle. Meyer gives to the preposition ... the meaning of by: "the tolerance exercised toward the sins that are past by the forbearance of God." But tLe following antithesis: at this time, imperatively requires the temporal meaning of the clause ... avo)(. — At the first glance it seems strange that in a proposition of which God is the subject, the apostle should say, not : " during His forbearance," but : " during the forbearance of God" The reason of this apparent incorrectness is not, as has been thought, the remoteness of the subjedt, nor the fact that Paul is now expressing himself as it were from his own point of view, and not from that of God ... . Bather it is that which is finely given by Matthias : by the word God the apostle brings more into relief the contrast between ... conduct (their constant sins) and ... (His long-suffering).

Romans 3:26 · Open Word Bible

26when God held back His judgment. He did it to show His righteousness at the present time, so that He would be righteous and also the one who declares righteous whoever has faith in Jesus.

Report a mistake

... But if it is true that a holy God cannot pardon, except in so far as the pardon itself establishes the absolute guilt of sin and the inviolability of the divine majesty, and so includes a guarantee for the re-establishment of order in the relation between the sinner and God, and if this condition is only found in the punishment of sin holily undertaken and humbly accepted by Him who alone was able to do so, is not the necessity of expiation in relation to the absolute Good, to God Himself, demonstrated? ... holiness would protest against every pardon which did not fulfil the double condition of glorifying His outraged majesty and displaying the condemnation of sin. Now, this double end is only gained by the expiatory sacrifice. But the necessity of this sacrifice arises from His whole divine character, in other words, from His holiness, the principle at once of His love and righteousness, and not exclusively of His righteousness. And, in truth, the apostle nowhere expresses the idea of a conflict between righteousness and love as requiring the expiation. It is grace that saves, and it saves by the demonstration of righteousness which, in the act of expiation, restores God to His place and man to his. Such is the condition on which divine love can pardon without entailing on the sinner the final degradation of his conscience and the eternal consolidation of his sin.

Report a mistake

This view also evades the grand objection which is so generally raised in our day against a satisfaction made to righteousness by means of the substitution of the innocent for the guilty. No doubt the ordinary theory of expiation may be defended by asking who would be entitled to complain of such a transaction : not God who establishes it, nor the Mediator who voluntarily sacrifices Himself, nor man whose salvation is effected by it. But, anyhow, this objection does not apply to the apostolical conception as we have expounded it. For whenever it ceases to be a question of legal satisfaction, and becomes a simple demonstration of God's right, no ground remains for protesting in the name of righteousness. Who could accuse God of ... for having made use of Job and his sufferings to prove to Satan that He can obtain from the children of the dust a disinterested homage, a free submission, which is not that of the mercenary ? Similarly, who can arraign the divine righteousness for having given to sinful man, in the person of Jesus, a convincing demonstration of the judgment which the guilty one deserved at His hand ? Deserved, did I say ? of the judgment with which He will visit him without fail if he refuses to join by faith in that homage solemnly rendered to God's rights, and rejects the reconciliation which God ... him in this form.

It seems to us, then, that the true apostolical conception, while firmly establishing the fact of expiation, which is, historically speaking, — as no one can deny, — the distinctive feature of Christianity, secures it from the grave objections which in these days have led so many to look on this fundamental dogma with suspicion.

Report a mistake

But some would perhaps say : Such a view rests, as much as the so-called orthodox theory, on notions of right and justice, which belong to a lower sphere, to the Ugal and juridical domain. A noble and generous man will not seek to explain his conduct by reasons taken ... so external an order ; how ... less should we have recourse to them to explain that of God ? — Those who speak thus do not sufficiently reflect that we have to do in this question not with God in His essence, but with God in His relation to free man. Now, the latter is not holy to begin with ; the use which he makes of his liberty is not yet regulated by love. The attribute of righteousness (the firm resolution to maintain order, whose existence is latent in the divine holiness) must therefore appear as a necessary safeguard as soon as liberty comes on the stage, and with it the possibility of disorder ; and this attribute must remain in exercise as long as the educational period of the life of the creature lasts, that is to say, until he has reached perfection in love. Then all those factors, right, law, justice, will return to their latent stata But till then, God, as the guardian of the normal relations between free beings, must keep by law and check by punishment every being disposed to trample on His authority, or on the liberty of his fellows. Thus it is that the work of righteousness necessarily belongs to God's educating and redeem ing work, without which the world of free beings would soon be no better than a chaos, from which goodness, the end of creation, would be forever banished. ...

Report a mistake

... Blot out this factor from the government of the world, and the free being becomes Titan, no longer arrested by anything in the execution of any caprice. God's place is overthrown, and the creatures destroy one another 272 ... mutually. It is common to ... lave as the fundamental feature of the divine character ; and in this way it is very difficult to reach the attribute of righteousness. Most ... indeed, do not reach it at ... Tbia one ... should serve to show the error in which they are entangled. Holy hoiy, holy, say the creatures nearest to God, when celebrating His perfection (Isa vi.), and not good, good, good. Holiness, such is the essence of God ; and holiness is the absolute love of the good, the absolute horror of evil Hence it is not difficult to deduce both love and righteousness. Love is the goodwill of God toward all free beings who are destined to realize the good. Love goes out to the individuals, as holiness to the good itself which they ought to produce. Bighteousness, on the other hand, is the firm purpose of God to maintain the normal relation between all these beings by His blessings and punishmenta It is obvious that righteousness is included no less necessarily than love itself in the fundamental feature of the divine character, holiness. It is no offence therefore to God to speak of His justice and His ... The exercise of a right is only a shame when the being who exercises it makes it subservient to the gratification of his egoism. It is, on the contrary, a glory to one who, like God, knows that in preserving his place he is securing the good of all others. For, as Gess admirably expounds it, God, in maintaining His supreme dignity, preserves to the creatures their most precious treasure, a God worthy of their respect and love.

Report a mistake

Unjustified antipathy to the notions of light and justice, as applied to God, has led contemporary thought to very divergent and insufficient explanations of the death of Christ Some see nothing more in this event than an inevitable historical result of the conflict between the holiness of Jesus and the immoral character of His ... This solution is well answered by Hausratb himself: " Our faith gives to the question : Why did Christ require to die on the cross ? another answer than that drawn from the history of his time. For the history of the ideal cannot be an isolated and particular fact ; its contents are absolute ; it has an eternal value which does not belong to a given moment, but to the whole of mankind Every man should recognise in such a history a mystery of grace consummated also for him {Neutest. Zeitgesch. L 450).

Report a mistake

Wherein consists this mystery of grace contained in the Crucified One for every man ? In the fact, answer many, that here we find the manifestation of divine love to mankind. " The ray of love," says ... such is the true saviour of mankind. . . . And as to Jesus, He is the sun, the focus in whom all the rays of this light scattered elsewhere are concen- trated'* (Wisienseh. ... On this view, Jesus sacrificed Himself only to attest by this act of devotion the full greatness of divine ... But what, then, is a devotion which has no other object than to witness to itself? An exhibition of love, which might be compared to that of the woman who committed suicide, a few years ago, to awake, as she said the dormant genius of her husband by this token of her love. Besides, how could the sacrifice of hiis life made by a man for his fellow-men demonstrate the love of God ? We may, indeed, see in it the attestation of hrotherly love in its most eminent degree, but we do not find the love of the Father. Others, finally, regard the death of Christ only as the culminatmg point of His consecration to God and men, of His holiness. These texts," says Sabatier, after quoting Bom. vi and 2 Cor. v., '' place the value of the death of Jesus not in any satisfaction whatever ofTered to God, but in the annihilation of sin, which this death brings about*' {Lap, Paul, p. 202). To the saime effect M. de Pressens expresses himself thus : '' This generous suffering, which Jesus voluntarily accepts, is an act of love and obedience ; and hence its restoring and redeeming character. ... In the name of humanity Christ reverses the rebellion of Eden; He brings hack, the Jieart of man to Chd, . . . In the person of a holy victim, humanity returns to the God who waited for it from the first days of the world" {Vie de Jisus, pp. 642 and 643). ...

Report a mistake

... Most modem theories (Hofmann, Bitschl), if we mistake not, are substantially the same, to wit, the spiritual resurrection of humanity through Christ. By the holiness He so painfully realized, and of which His bloody death was the crown, Jesus has given birth to a humanity which breaks with sin, and gives itself to God ; and God, foreseeing this future holiness of believers, and regarding it as already realized, pardons their sins from love of this expected perfection. But is this the apostle's view ? He speaks of a demonstration of righteousness, and not only of holiness. Then he ascribes to death, to Uood, a peculiar and independent value. So he certainly does in our passage, but more expressly still in the words, v. 10 : " If, when we were enemies, we were reconciled {justified, ver. 9) by His death (His blood, ver. 9), much more, being reconciled, we shall be saved ly His life ... Him, ver. 9)." It is by His death, accordingly, that Jesus reconciles or justifies, as it is by His life that He sanctifies and perfects salvation. Finally, the serious practical difficulty in the way of this theory lies, as we think, in the fact that, like the Catholic doctrine, it makes justification rest on sanctification (present or future), while the characteristic of gospel doctrine, what, to use Paul's language, may be called its felly, but what is in reality its divine wisdom is its founding justification on the atonement perfected by Christ's blood, to raise afterwards on this basis the work of sanctification by the Holy Spirit

Report a mistake

We have seen that ver. 26 should begin with the words reproduced from ver. 25 : for the demonstration of His righteous ness. To what purpose this repetition ? Had not the reason which rendered the demonstration of righteousness necessary been sufficiently explained in ver. 25 ? Why raise this point emphatically once more to explain it anew ? This form is surprising, especially in a passage of such extraordinary conciseness. De Wette and Meyer content themselves with saying : ... of the ... (for the demonstration) ver. 25. But again, why the -change of preposition: in ver. 25, ... here, ... We get the answer: a matter of style ... or of euphony (Gess), wholly indifferent as to meaning. With a writer like Paul — our readers, we hope, are convinced of this — such answers are insufficient. Bilckert and Hofmann, to avoid these difficulties, think that the words : for the demonstration . . . should not be made dependent, like the similar words of ver. 25, on the verb ... had established, but on the ... forbearance : "during the time of His forbearance, a forbearance which had in view the manifestation of His righteousness at a later period." De Wette replies, with reason, that were we to connect these words with so subordinate an idea, the reader's mind would be diverted from the essential thought of the entire passage. Besides, how can we fail to see in the ... (for the ... tion) of ver. 26 the resumption of the similar expression, ver. 25 ? The fact of this repetition is not, as it seems to us, so difficult to explain. The moral necessity of such a manifestation had been demonstrated by the tolerance of God in ... the pad ; for it had thrown a veil over the righteousness of God But the ... was not completa The object to be gained in the ... by this ... mnst also be indicated. And tliis is the end served ... the repetition of this same expression in ... 26 : ''for the ... ...

Report a mistake

... I say, in view of . . . Thus at the same time is explained the change of preposition. In ver. 25 the demonstration itself was regarded as an end: " whom He set forth ... as a propitiation for the demonstration ... with a view to) " . • . But in ver. 26 this same demonstration becomes a nuam, with a view to a new and more remote end : *far the demonstration of His righteousness, that He ... he (literally, with a ... to being) just, and the ... The ... ia always the end, no doubt, but now it is only the near and immediate object — sach is exactly the meaning of the Greek preposition ... which is substituted for the ... of ver. 25 — compared with a more distant and final end which opens up to view, and for which the apostle now reserves the ... (with a view to) : " with a view to being just, and the jostifier." Comp. on the relation of these two prepositions, Eph. iv. 12 : for ... the perfecting of the saints wUh a view to a {w) work of ministry." Here we may have a convincing proof that nothing is accidental in the style of a man like ... Never did jeweller chisel his diamonds more carefully than the apostle does the expression of his thoughts. This delicate care of the slightest shades is also shown in the addition of the article ... before ... in ver. 26, an addition ... attested by the four Alex. Mjj., and by a Mj. from each of the other two families (D P). In ver. 25 the notion of demonstration was yet abstract: "in demonstration of righteousness." ...

Report a mistake

... In ver. 26 it is now known; it is a concrete fact which should conspire to a new end ; hence the addition of the article : for that manifestation of which I speak, with a view to " . . • The following words : at this time, express one of the gravest thoughts of the passaga They bring out the full solemnity of the present epoch marked by this unexampled appearance, preordained and in a sense awaited by God Himself for so long. For without this prevision the long forbearance of the forty previous centuries would have been morally impossible; comp. Acts xvii 30 (in ... to the Gentiles), and Heb. ix. 26 : *' But now once in the end of the ages hath He appeared, to put away sin by the ... of Himself" (in regard to Israel).

Report a mistake

And what was the end with a view to which this demonstration of righteousness was required at this time? The apostle answers: thai He might he just, and a ... that is to say, " that while being and remaining just, God might justify." It was a great problem, a problem worthy of divine wisdom, which the sin of man set before God — to remain just while justifying (declaring just) man who had become unjust. God did not shrink from the task. He had even solved the difficulty beforehand in His eternal counsel, before creating man free ; otherwise, would not this creation have merited the charge of imprudence ? ... Gess rightly objects to this attenuation of the word he. ... If God did not once show Himself perfectly just, would He be so in reality ? Gess rightly says : " A judge who hates evil, but does not judge it, is not just : if the righteousness of God did not show itself, it would not exist" In not smiting those sinners at once with the thunderbolt of His vengeance, those who had lived during the time of forbearance, God had not shoum Himself just; and if He had continued to act thus indefinitely, mankind and the entire moral universe would have had good right to conclude that He ... not just It is obvious that the words : that He might be Just, do not, strictly speaking, express a new idea ; they reproduce in a different form the reason for the demonstration of righteousness already given in ver. 25 in the words: "because of the tolerance exercised toward sins that were past" If this tolerance had not at length issued in a manifestation of righteousness, righteousness itself would have been annihilated. The thought is nevertheless of supreme importance here, at the close of this exposition. Men must not imagine, as they might easily ... especially with pardon before them, that the righteousness 268 ... of God is somehow completely absorbed in His grace ... the act of justifying. ...

Report a mistake

... There is in the - firm and immoveable will of God to maintain right and order in the universe— His justice, that is to say — the principle of the ... of believers no doubt, but not less certainly that of the judgment of the impenitent Now, if God did not show Himself jusi at the moment when He justifies the unjust, there would be in such a pardon what would plunge sinners into the most dangerous illusion. They could no longer seriously suppose that they were on their way to give in an account ; and judgment would burst on them as a terrible surprise. This is what God could not desire, and hence He has exercised the divine privilege of pardon only through means of a striking and solemn manifestation of His righteousness. He would really have given up His justice if, in this supreme moment .of His manifestation. He had not displayed it brightly on the earth.

Report a mistake

After having secured His righteousness. He is able to justify the unjust ; for He has, in Christ, the means ... justifying him justly. We have seen that the cross re-establishes order by putting each in his place, the holy God on His throne, rebellious man in the dust. So long as this homage, making reparation for the past, remains without us, it does not save us ; but as soon as we make it ours by faith in Jesus, it avaih for us, and God can jtistly absolve us. This is what is expressed by the last words, to which the passage pointed from the first: and ... of him who is of the faith in Jesus, By adhering to this manifestation of divine righteousness accomplished in Jesus, the believer makes *it morally his own. He renders homage personally to the right which God has over him. He sees in his own person the malefactor worthy of death, who should have undergone and accepted what Jesus underwent and accepted. He exclaims, like that Bechuana in bis simple savage language: Away from that, Christ ; that's my place ! Sin is thus judged in his conscience, as it was in that of the dying Jesus — that is to say, as it is by the holiness of God Himself, and as it never could have been by the ever imperfect repentance of a sinner. ...

Report a mistake

... By appropriating to himself the homage rendered to the majesty of God by the Crucified One, the believer is himself crucified as it were in the eyes of God ; moral order is re-established, and judgment can take end by an act of absolution As to the impenitent sinner, who refuses to the divine majesty the homage contained in the act of ... the demonstration of righteousness given on the cross remains as the proof that he will certainly meet with this divine attribute in the judgment — The phrase : to be of the faith, has nothing surprising in Paul's style ; comp. the ... ix, ii. 8 ; Qal. iii 7, 10, etc. It forcibly expresses the new mode of being which becomes the believer's as soon as he ceases to draw his righteousness from himself and derives it wholly from Jesus. — Three Mjj. read the accusative ... which would lead to the impossible sense : " and the justifier of Jesus by faith." This error probably arises from the abridged form IT in the ancient Mjj., which might easily be read IN. Two MSS. (F G) wholly reject this name (see Meyer).* The phrase : " him who is of the faith," without any indication of the object of faith, would not be impossible. This reading has been accepted by Oltramare. But two MSS. of the ninth century do not ... to justify it Nothing could better close this piece than the name of the historical personage to whose unspeakable love mankind owes this eternal blessing.

We have endeavoured to reproduce exactly the meaning of the expressions used by the apostle in this important passage, and to rise to the sum of the ideas which it contains. In what does the apostolical conception, as we have understood it, difier from the current theories on this fundamental subject ?

Report a mistake

If we compare it first with the doctrine generally received in the church, the point on which the difference seems to us to bear is this: in the ecclesiastical theory God demands the punishment of Christ as a satisfaction to Himself, inasmuch as His justice must have an equivalent for the penalty merited by man, if divine love is to be free to pardon. From the point of view to which the exposition of the apostle brings us, this equivalent is not intended to satisfy divine justice except by manifesting it, and so ... the normal relation between God and the guilty creature. By sin, in short, God loses His supreme place in the conscience of the creature ; by this demon- ... of righteousness He recovers it In consequence of sin, the creature no longer comprehends and feels the gravity of his rebellion ; by this manifestation God makes it palpable to him. On this view it is not necessary that the sacrifice of reparation should be the equivalent of the penalty incurred by the multitude of sinful men, viewed as the sum of the merited sufferings ; it is enough that it be so as regards the physical and moral character of the sufferings due to sin in itsell The defenders of the received theory will no doubt ask if, on this view, the expiation is not pointed simply to the conscience of the creature, instead of being also a reparation offered to God Himself. ...

Report a mistake

Romans 3:27–28

Vv. 27, 28. *' Where is the boasting then t It is excluded. By what law t of works t Nay, luthy the law of faith. For we judge that man is justified by faUh without works of law."

— ... then : in consequence of the great fact which has heen explained, and of the means of justification which it implies ... . — ... Ixxiding, vainglory; this term denotes not the ... boasted of but the act of self-glorification The article i, the, marks this boasting as well known ; it is therefore the boasting of the Jews which is referred to. The word might be connected with the ... ii 17, and understood of the glory which the Jews sought to borrow from their exceptional position ; but the context, and especially the following verse, prove that the apostle has in view the pretension of the Jews to justify themselves by their own works, instead of deriving their righteousness from the work of Christ. — This pretension has been excluded for ever by the work described, vy. 24-26. There remains nothing else for man to do than to lay hold of it by faith. This question has something of a triumphant character; comp. the similar (oun, 1 Cor. L 20. The self-righteousness of the Jews is treated here as the wisdom of the Greeks is in that passage. The apostle seeks it, and before the cross it vanishes. Hofinann understands this exclamation of the vainglory to which even Christians might give themselves up : '' Have we then, we Christians, thus justified, whereof to boast T' This interpretation is bound up with that of the same author, according to which the question, iil 9 : '' Have we any advantage (over those whom judgment will overtake) ? " is also put in the mouth of Christians. But it is evident that, like the question of ver. 9, this refers specially to Jewish prejudice ; for it is expressly combated in the following words, ver. 29, and it is alluded to by the article i}, the, before ... ...

Romans 3:27–28 · Open Word Bible

27So what room is left for boasting? It has been shut out. By what law? A law of works? No, by the law of faith. 28For we are convinced that a person is declared righteous by faith, apart from works of the law.

Report a mistake

... Only the question arises. What leads the apostle to put such a question here 2 The answer seems to us to be this. His intention in these few verses is to show the profound harmony between the law and the ... Kow the conclusion to which he had been led by the searching study of the law, w. 9-20, was, that it was intended to shut the mouths of all men, and of the Jews in particular, before God, by giving them the knowledge of sin. Hence it followed that the mode of justification which best agreed with the law was that which traced the origin of righteousness not to the works of the ... by means of which man thinks that he can justify himself, buib to faith ; for, like the law itself, the righteousness of faitli brings all boasting to silence, so that the righteousness of works, which lays a foundation for boasting, is contrary to the law, while that of faith, which excludes it, is alone in harmony with the law. And this is exactly what Paul brings out in the following questions. — In these two questions the term law is taken in a general sense. This word is often used by Paul to denote a mode of action which is imposed on the individual, a ... to which he is subject, a principle which determines his conduct Sometimes when thus understood it is taken in a ... sense ; for example, viii 2 : "the law of the spirit of life which is in Jesus Christ ; again it is used in a bad sense ; so vii. 23 : " the law which is in my members ; " or, again, it is applied in both ways good and bad at once ; comp. viL 21. As Baur well says, the word law denotes in general *' a formula which serves to regulate the relation between God and man."

Report a mistake

That glory which man derives from his self-righteousness, and which the law had already foreclosed has been finally excluded. And by what means? By a ... of works? Certainly not, for such a means would rather have ... it, but by that of faith (ver. 26). The apostle thus reaches the striking result that the rule of works would contradict the law, and that the ... of faith is that which harmonizes with it — He here uses the word ... probably because he was speaking of excluding, and this requires something firm.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:27

The Sarmony of this Mode of Justification with the true Meaning of the Law.

The apostle had asserted, ver. 21, that the law and (he 'prophets themselves bear witness to the mode of justification revealed in the gospel This he demonstrates, first generally, from the spirit of the law, then specially, from the example of Abraham, in the two following pieces : chap. iiL 27-31 and chap. iv. As the theme of the preceding piece was expressed in the words of w. 21 and 22 : righteousness of God revealed without law ... in Jesus Christ, that of the following development is found in the words of ver. 21 : witnessed by the law and by the prophets. We see how rigorously the apostle adheres to order in his work.

The piece, w. 27-31, argues from all that precedes to the harmony of justification by faith with the Old Testament — 1. Inasmuch as the law and the gospel equally exclude justification by works, w. 27 and 28; this is the negative demonstration ; and 2. Inasmuch as only justification by faith harmonizes with the Monotheism which is the doctrinal basis of the whole Old Testament, w. 29-31 ; such is the positive demonstration.

Romans 3:27 · Open Word Bible

27So what room is left for boasting? It has been shut out. By what law? A law of works? No, by the law of faith.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:28

Yer. 28. The relation between this verse and the preceding rests on the contrast between the two ideas ... and ... boasting and being justified by faith. '* ... exclude boasting in proportion as we affirm justification by faith." — Several commentators read ... then, after T. R, which is supported by the Vat. and the Byzs. In that case this verse would form the conclusion from what precedes: " We conclude, then, tibat man " . . ... But if the apostle were concluding findly in ver. 28, why would he recommence to argue in the following verse ? We must therefore prefer the reading of the other Alexs. and the Greco-Lats., yap, for: " For we deem, we assert that " ... Another question is.

Whether, with the ... we are to put the word ... by faith, before the verb ... to he ... or whether it it is better to put it after, with the other two families, and so give the idea of justification the dominant place over that of the means of obtaining it. The connection with ver. 27 certainly speaks in favour of the Byz. reading, which has the Peschito for it. It is the idea ... being justified hf faith, and not that of being ... in general, which excludes boasting. — It is worth remarking the word ... man. This general term is chosen designedly : '' whatever bears the name of man, Jew as well as Gentile, depends on the justification which is of faith, and can have no other/' If it is so, it is plain that boasting is finally ... The apostle adds : vrithout works of law, that is to say, without participation in any of those works which are wrought in the servile and mercenaiy spirit which prevails under the rule of law (see on ver. 20). The. matter in question here is neither final salvation nor works as fruits of faith (good works, Eph. ii. 10; Tit iii. 8). For these will be necessary in the day of judgment (see on ii. 13).

Romans 3:28 · Open Word Bible

28For we are convinced that a person is declared righteous by faith, apart from works of the law.

Report a mistake

If it were otherwise, if the works of the law had not been excluded by the great act of expiation described vv. 24-26, and by the rule of faith involved in it, it would be found that God' provided for the salvation of a part of mankind only, and forgot the rest The unity of God is not compatible with this difference in His mode of acting. Now the dogma ... the unity of God ia the basis of the law, and of the whole of Judaism. On this point, too, therefore the law is at one with faith, w. 29-31.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:29–30

Vv. 29, 30. '* Or is He the God of the Jews ... is He not also of the Gentiles t Tes, of the ... also : seeing it is one God, who shall bring ... the fustification of the circum ... faith, and who shall bring about that of the ... through faith!* — The meaning of the , or, when prefixed to a question by Paul, is familiar to us : '' ... if you do not admit that " . • . ? This question therefore goes to show, that the negation of what precedes violates the Monotheism 80 dear to the Jews, and in which they gloried The genitive ... of Jews, nsed without the article, denotes the ... Meyer refuses to take this word as the complement of the predicate ... understood; but wrongly; the natural meaning is : ' Is God the God of the Jews ? " Comp. ii 29, 1 Cor. xiv. 33, and Luke zz. 38 (with Matt. ... 32). Otherwise we should require to apply here the phrase ... Tivo, to be the property of (to belong to), which does not correspond to the relation between ... and man. — To the question : Is He not also (he God of the Gentiles t Taul could answer with assurance : yes, of the Cfentiles also ; loit the entire Old Testament had already drawn from Monotheism this glorious inference. The psalms celebrated Jehovah as the God of all the earth, before whom the nations walk with trembling ... . Jeremiah called Him (x. 7) the King of nations ; and the apostle himself had demonstrated in chap. L the existence of a universal divine revelation, which is the first foundation of universalism.

Romans 3:29–30 · Open Word Bible

29Or is God the God of Jews only? Is He not the God of Gentiles too? Yes, of Gentiles too, 30since God is one. He will declare the circumcised righteous by faith and the uncircumcised through that same faith.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:30

Ver. 80. The Alex, read ... if truly. This readily might suffice if the apostle were merely repeating the principle of the unity of God as the basis of the preceding assertion : '' if indeed God is ... But he goes further ; this principle of the unity of God serves him as a point of departure from which to draw important inferences expressed in a weighty proposition : who ... Justify*' To wairant him in doing so, it is not enough that he has asserted the unity of God as an admitted supposition: '* if indeed," He must have laid it down as an indubitable fact which could serve as a basis for argument We must therefore prefer the reading of the other two families: ... seeing that. Monotheism has as its natural corollary the expectation of one only means of justification for the whole human race. No doubt this dogma is compatible with a temporary particularism, of a pedagogic nature ; but as soon as the decisive question arises, that of final salvation or condemnation, the unity must appear. A dualism on ... point would imply a duaUty in God's essence : " who (in consequence of His unity) will justify.*' The future : ... justify, has been variously explained. Some think that it expresses logical consequence (Rtick. Hofin.) ; others, that it refers to the day of judgment ... ; a third party refer it to cUl the particular cases of justification which have taken or shall take place in history. The last sense seems the most natural : the whole new development of history, which is now opening, appears to the apostle as the consequence of the fundamental ... of Judaism. — Meyer alleges that the difference of the two prepositions ix and Sui, from and by (which we have sought to render in our translation), is purely ... Is it also accidental that the article ... the, which was wanting in the first proposition before the word ... faith, is added in the second ? ...

Romans 3:30 · Open Word Bible

30since God is one. He will declare the circumcised righteous by faith and the uncircumcised through that same faith.

Report a mistake

... Experience has convinced us that Paul's style is not at the mercy of chance, even in its most secondary elements. On the other hand, must we, with Calvin, find the difference a pure irony : '' If any one insists on a difference between Jews and (Gentiles, well and good I I shall make over one to him ; the first obtains righteousness ... faith, the second by faith." No; it would be much better to abandon the attempt to give a meaning to this slight difference, than to make the ... a poor wit The following, as it seems to 'me, is the shade of meaning which the apostle meant to express. With regard to the Jew, who laid claim to a righteousness of works, he contrasts category with category by using the preposition ... from out of, which denotes origin and nature : a righteousness of faith. Hence, too, he omits the article, which would have described the concrete fact, rather than the quality. But when he comes to speak of the Gentiles, who had been destitute till then of every means of reaching any righteousness whatever, he chooses the preposition ... by : by means of, which points to faith simply as the way by which they reach the unexpected end; and he adds the article because faith presents itself to his mind, in this relation, as the well-known means, besides which the Gentile does not dream of any other.

The harmony between the Mosaic law and justification by faith has been demonstrated from two pointa of view — 1. That of the universal ... (the exclusion of all boasting), which results from the former and constitutes the basis of the latter (vv. 27, 28). 2. That of UU unity of God, which is the basis of Israditish Mosaism and prophetism, as well as that of evangelical universalism (w. 29, 30).

Thereafter nothing more natural than the conclosion drawn in ver. 31.

Report a mistake

Romans 3:31

Yer. 31. ... toe then make void the law through faith t That he far from us I Tea, we ... the law — This verse has been misonderstood by most commentators. Some (Aug., Luth.| ... Calv., Philip., Biick) apply it to the sanctification which springs from faith, and by which the gospel finally realizes the fulfilment of the law. This is the thesis whidi will be developed in chaps. vi.-viii. We do not deny that the apostle might defer the ... development of a maxim thrown out beforehand, and, as it were, by the way ; comp. the sayings, iii. 3 and ... But yet he must have been logically led to such sentences by their necessary connection with the context Now this is not the case here. What is there at this point to lead the apostle to concern himself with the sanctifying power of faith ? Let us remark, further, that ver. 31 is connected by then with what precedes, and can only express an inference from the passage, vv. 27—30. Finally, how are we to explain the then at the beginning of chap. iv. ? How does the mode of Abraham's justification follow from the idea that faith leads to the fulfilment of the law ? Hofmann offers substantially the same explanation, only giving to the word law the meaning of moral law in general (instead of the Mosaic law). But the difficulties remain absolutely the same. — Meyer and some others regard ver. 31 as the beginning, and, in a manner, the theme of the following chapter. The term law, on this view, refers to the passage of Genesis which the apostle is about to quote, iv. 3: ''The harmony of justification by faith with the law is about to be explained by what the law says of Abraham's justification." But it is difficult to believe that Paul, without the slightest indication, would call an isolated passage of the Pentateuch the law. ...

Romans 3:31 · Open Word Bible

31Does this faith mean, then, that we do away with the law? Certainly not! On the contrary, we uphold the law.

Report a mistake

... Then, if the relation between ver. 31 and iv. 1 were as Meyer thinks, it should be expressed logically by /or, not by (hen, Holsten, if we understand him rightly, tries to get rid of these difficulties by applying the term law in our verse to the law of faith (ver. 27), in which he sees an absolute rule of righteousness holding good for all men, and consequently for Abraham. One could not imagine a more forced ... Our ... is already indicated ; it follows naturally from the interpretation which we have given of the preceding versea Paul's gospel was accused of ... void the law by setting aside legal works as a means of justification; and he has just proved to his adversaries that it is his teachings on the contraiy, which harmonizes with the true meaning of the law while the opposite teaching overturns it by keeping up the vainglory of man, which the law was meant to destroy, and by violating Monotheism on which it is based. Is it surprising that he concludes such a demonstration with the triumphant affirmation: "Do we then overturn the law, as we are accused of doing ? On the contrary, we establish it" The true reading is probably ... the most ancient form, which has been replaced by the later form ... The verb signifies, not to preserve, maintain, but to cause to stand, to estailish. This is what Paul does with regard to the law ; he ... it as it were anew by the righteousness of faith ; which, instead of overturning it, as it was accused of doing, faithfully maintains its spirit in the new dispensation, the fact which he had just proved.

This verse forms a true period to the whole passage, w. 21—30. The law had been called to give witness on the subject of the doctrine of universal condemnation; it had borne witness, w. 7-19. It has just been cited again, and now in favour of the new righteousness; its testimony has not been less favourable, w. 27-31.

Report a mistake

After demonstrating in a general way the harmony of his teaching with Old Testament revelation, the apostle had only one thing left to desire in the discussion : that was to succeed in finding in the Old Testament itself a sajring or an illustrious example which, in the estimation of the Jews, would give the sanction of divine authority to his argument There was such a saying, and he was fortunate enough to find it It was written by the hand of the legislator himself, and related to what was in a manner the typical example of justification with the Jews. It therefore combined all the conditions fitted to settle the present question conclusively. Thus it is that Gen. xv, 6 becomes the text of the admirable development contained in chap. iv. This piece is the counter- 282 ... bt faith. part of the scriptural demonstration which had closed the delineation of universal condemnation, iii. 9-20. It belongs, therefore, to the exposition of the thesis of ver. 21: the righteousness of faith vritnessed by the law and the prophets.

Report a mistake