The law and those without it (Romans 2:12–16)
12 Those who sin without having the law will be lost without the law, and those who sin while living under the law will be judged by the law. 13 Hearing the law does not make anyone righteous before God; those who do what the law says are the ones God will declare righteous. 14 Gentiles do not have the law. Yet when, by nature, they carry out what the law says, they become their own law, though the law was never given to them. 15 Their conduct shows that the work of the law is written in their hearts. Their conscience bears witness too, and their thoughts argue with one another, now accusing them, now defending them, 16 on the day when God, through Christ Jesus, judges the hidden things in people's lives, as the gospel I preach says.
Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.
65 excerpts from 8 commentators on Romans 2:12–16, from John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) to Frédéric Louis Godet (1812–1900).
What the church has said
Each excerpt opens with its first words. Follow its verse to read it in full.
What does Chrysostom say about Romans 2:12–16?
John Chrysostom
Romans 2:12 Homily V. Rom. I. 28
Ver. 12. “For as many,” he says, “as have sinned without law shall also perish without law: and as many as have sinned in the law shall be judged by the law.”
Well doth he add “before God;” for haply before men they may be able to appear dignified and to vaunt great things, but before God it is quite otherwise—the doers of the Law alone are justified. You see with what…
Romans 2:14 Homily V. Rom. I. 28
Ver. 14. “For when the Gentiles,” he says, “which have not the law, do by nature the things contained in the law, these, having not the law, are a law unto themselves.”
Romans 2:15 Homily V. Rom. I. 28
Ver. 15. “Which show the work of the Law written in their hearts, their conscience also bearing witness, and their thoughts the meanwhile accusing or else excusing one another.”
Romans 2:16 Homily V. Rom. I. 28
Ver. 16. “In the day when God shall judge the secrets of men by Jesus Christ, according to my Gospel.”
... For this topic was very needful for him to prove owing to those who say, Why ever is it, that Christ came but now? And where in times before was the (most mss. this mighty) scheme of Providence? Now…
... But he does not do barely this, but even here, after having made mention of the Father, he so introduceth Him. And by the same things he raises the dignity of his preaching. For this preaching, he means, openly…
What does Calvin say about Romans 2:12–16?
John Calvin
Romans 2:12 Whosoever have sinned without law
12. Whosoever have sinned without law, etc. In the former part of this section he assails the Gentiles; though no Moses was given them to publish and to ratify a law from the Lord, he yet denies this omission to…
Romans 2:13 For the hearers of the law
13. For the hearers of the law, etc. This anticipates an objection which the Jews might have adduced. As they had heard that the law was the rule of righteousness, (Deuteronomy 4:1,) they gloried in the mere knowledge of it:…
Romans 2:14 For when the Gentiles
14. For when the Gentiles, etc. He now states what proves the former clause; for he did not think it enough to condemn us by mere assertion, and only to pronounce on us the just judgment of God; but he…
Romans 2:15 Who show the work of the law written
15. Who show the work of the law written, etc.; that is, they prove that there is imprinted on their hearts a discrimination and judgment by which they distinguish between what is just and unjust, between what is honest and…
Nor can we conclude from this passage, that there is in men a full knowledge of the law, but that there are only some seeds of what is right implanted in their nature, evidenced by such acts as these —…
Romans 2:15 Their conscience at the same time attesting
Their conscience at the same time attesting, etc. He could not have more forcibly urged them than by the testimony of their own conscience, which is equal to a thousand witnesses. By the consciousness of having done good, men sustain…
Romans 2:16 In which God shall judge the secrets of men
16. In which God shall judge the secrets of men Most suitable to the present occasion is this periphrastic definition of judgment: it teaches those, who willfully hide themselves in the recesses of insensibility, that the most secret thoughts and…
He adds, according to my gospel, intimating, that he announced a doctrine, to which the judgments of men, naturally implanted in them, gave a response: and he calls it his gospel, on account of the ministry; for the authority for…
What does Evans say about Romans 2:12–16?
John Evans
In the former chapter the apostle had represented the state of the Gentile world to be as bad and black as the Jews were ready enough to pronounce it. And now, designing to show that the state of the Jews…
V. He proves the equity of his proceedings with all, when he shall actually come to Judge them (v. 12-16), upon this principle, that that which is the rule of man's obedience is the rule of God's judgment. Three degrees…
... They did by nature the things contained in the law. They had a sense of justice and equity, honour and purity, love and charity; the light of nature taught obedience to parents, pity to the miserable, conservation of public…
Their thoughts the meanwhile, metaxy allelon—among themselves, or one with another. The same light and law of nature that witnesses against sin in them, and witnessed against it in others, accused or excused one another. Vicissim, so some read it,…
Romans 2:12 The light of the law
2. The light of the law. This the Jews had, and by this they shall be judged (v. 12): As many as have sinned in the law shall be judged by the law. They sinned, not only having the law,…
Romans 2:16 The light of the gospel
3. The light of the gospel: and according to this those that enjoyed the gospel shall be judge (v. 16): According to my gospel; not meant of any fifth gospel written by Paul, as some conceit; or of the gospel…
What does Bengel say about Romans 2:12–16?
Johann Albrecht Bengel
for as many) the Gentiles: and as many, the Jews. ... This word occurs twice by antanaclasis, in the sense, not in the law, not by the ... did ... as is evident from the antithesis. ... sinned: the past…
for not) A Proposition ... Subject] clearly standing forth, the. words of which have respect also to the Gentiles, but are particularly adapted to the Jews; concerning the former, ver. 14, etc. treats; concerning the latter, ver. 17, etc.; wherefore,…
Romans 2:14 when
After Paul has finished the refutation of the perverse judgment of the Jews against the Gentiles, he next proceeds to show the true judgment of God against the latter. He treats here of the Gentiles more directly, for the purpose…
Not ... some individuals of the Gentiles; and yet there is no man, who does not fulfil some of the requirements of the law ... He did not choose to say ... which is usually taken rather in a bad…
these) This little word turns the collective ... Gentiles, to a distributive sense [so far to wit as they really do it. — V ... . ... a law) What the law is to the Jews, that the Gentiles are…
tliey show) [demonstrate] to themselves, to others, and, in some respects, to God Himself. ... the work of the law}, the law itself, with its practical [active] operation. It is opposed to the letter, which is but an accident [not…
in the day) It is construed with show, for the present tense is no objection; ver. 5 employs the present in the same general way. And Paul often says, in the day of the Lord, which implies more than against…
Romans 2:16 according to
i.e. as my Gospel teaches. Paul adds this short clause, because he is here dealing with a man, who does not yet know Jesus Christ. The Gospel is the whole preaching as to Christ; and Christ will be the Judge;…
What does Wesley say about Romans 2:12–16?
John Wesley
Romans 2:12 For as many as have sinned
12. For as many as have sinned - He speaks as of the time past, for all time will be past at the day of judgment. Without the law - Without having any written law. Shall also perish without the…
Romans 2:13 For not the hearers of the law are, even now, just before God, but the doers of the law shall be justified
13. For not the hearers of the law are, even now, just before God, but the doers of the law shall be justified - Finally acquitted and rewarded a most sure and important truth, which respects the gentiles also, though…
Romans 2:14 For when the gentiles
14. For when the gentiles - That is, any of them. St. Paul, having refuted the perverse judgment of the Jews concerning the heathens, proceeds to show the just judgment of God against them. He now speaks directly of the…
Romans 2:15 Who show
15. Who show - To themselves, to other men, and, in a sense, to God himself. The work of the law - The substance, though not the letter, of it. Written on their hearts - By the same hand which…
Romans 2:16 In the day
16. In the day - That is, who show this in the day. Everything will then be shown to be what it really is. In that day will appear the law written in their hearts as it often does in…
What does Haydock say about Romans 2:12–16?
George Leo Haydock
Romans 2:12 Whosoever have sinned without the law
Ver. 12. Whosoever have sinned without the law. That is, without the written law of Moses, against their reason and conscience, &c. And also those who being Jews, have sinned under this written law, shall be judged, even with greater…
Romans 2:14–15 When the Gentiles
Ver. 14-15. When the Gentiles ... do by nature, or naturally, that is, without having received any written law, these men are a law to themselves, and have it written in their hearts, as to the existence of a God,…
What does Hodge say about Romans 2:12–16?
Charles Hodge
Romans 2:12 For as many as have sinned without law
(12) For as many as have sinned without law, shall perish without law; and as many as have sinned in the law, shall be judged by the law. In the preceding verse it was stated that God is impartial and…
... By the law, i. e. by means of the law, by it as the rule or standard; see the same preposition so used, James 2: 12. 2 Cor. 8:8. Paul no more asserts in this passage that all who…
Romans 2:13 For not the hearers of the law are just before God
(13) For not the hearers of the law are just before God, but the doers of the law shall be justified. The reason is here assigned for the declaration contained in the last clause of the preceding verse, ‘Those who…
Though this verse, with the 14th and 15th, form a parenthesis, as is evident from the 16th, which requires to be immediately connected with the 12th, yet they are intimately related to what immediately precedes. The 13th is the ground…
Romans 2:14 For when the Gentiles
(14) For when the Gentiles, which have not the law, do by nature the things of the law, &c. The word for does not indicate the connexion between this and the preceding, but: between this and the first clause of…
Paul says, the heathen “do dy nature the things of the law.” The word rendered nature, often signifies the natural constitution, innate tendency or disposition. Thus Xenophon (Cyrop. Lib. 2. p. 42) says, ‘all animals are taught by nature to…
Romans 2:15 Who show the work of the law written on their hearts
(15) Who show the work of the law written on their hearts, &c. The relative pronouns, when used in this way at the beginning of a clause, are often intended to introduce a reason for a preceding declaration. So here,…
The other clause of this verse is very variously explained. The word rendered in the mean while, is sometimes an adverb, and sometimes a preposition. Our translators take it here as the former. The sense then is, ‘ Their conscience,…
Romans 2:16 In the day that God shall judge the secrets of men
(16) In the day that God shall judge the secrets of men, by Jesus Christ, according to my gospel. Calvin places only a comma at the close of the preceding verse, and connects this with it, ‘Their thoughts accusing or…
The secrets of men, not their works of parade, done to be seen and admired, but those hidden deeds of heart and life, which form the true criterion of character. Thus simply does he describe the great day, the day…
... 5. Men shall be judged by the knowledge of duty which they severally possess. God is therefore perfectly impartial. These are the principles on which men are to be tried, in the last day, by Jesus Christ, and those…
What does Godet say about Romans 2:12–16?
Frédéric Louis Godet
In the midst of this flood of pollutions and iniquities which Ctontile society presents to view the apostle sees one who Uke a judge from the height of his tribunal sends a stem look over the corrupt mass, condemning the…
Vv. 11, 12. "For there is no respect of persons with God. For as many as have sinned withaut law shall also perish without law: and as many as have sinned in the law shall be judged by the law!'…
No, answers ver. 12 ; for if the GentUe perishes, he will not perish for not having possessed the law, for no judgment will canse him to be sifted by the Decalogue and the Mosaic ordinances; and if the Jew…
... The Gentiles shall perish simply in consequence of their moral corruption; as, for example, ruin overtakes the soul of the vicious, the drunken, or the impure, under the deleterious action of their vica The rigorous application of the principle…
Ver. 13. '* Far not the hearers of the law are fust before God; ... the doers of the law, they shall he fustified," — Why hearers rather than possessors or readers ? To describe the position of the Jews…
... Gomp. also the phrase of ver. 27: *' uncircumcision when it fulfUs the law/' words which certainly refer to concrete cases, and the passage viii 4, in which the apostle asserts that the ... what the law declares righteous,…
Yv. 14, 15. *' For when Cfentiles, which have not the law, do by nature the things contained in the law, these, having ... the law, are a law unto themselves : for they show thereby the work of the…
3. Tholuck, Lange, Schaff likewise join the for with ... but they hold at the same time that this for will be veritably realized: "The doers of the law shall be justified, for God will graciously take account of the…
... These are sporadic cases, happy eventualities. — The word ... has no article: " people belonging to the category of the ... The logical relation included in the subjective negative ... is that which we should express by :…
... John L 2. — Tlie logical relation of the participle ... not having law," and of the verb ela-iv, " are law,'* should be expressed by for ; not having law, they therefore serve as a law to themselves.…
The descriptive pronoun ... as people who/' is meant to introduce this explanation ; it is in consequence of what is about to follow that Paul can affirm what he has just said of them, ver. 14. The relation of…
... They have not sufficiently taken account of the starting-point of this whole argument St Paul, according to the connection of ver. 14 with ver. 13, does not wish merely to prove that the Gentile possesses the law; he means…
... Conscience joins its testimony to that of the heart which dictated the virtuous action by commending it, and proves thereby, as a second witness, the existence of the moral law in the Gentile. Yolkmar: ''Their conscience bears testimony besides…
... OentUes and ... as to the moral worth of an action. But it is grammatically more natural, and suits the context better, to connect the pronoun between themselves with ... judgments. For this internal scene of discussion proves still…
Ver. 16. "In the day when God AdU judge the secrets of men by Jesm Christ according to my gospel — In this final proposition there is expressed and summed up the idea of the whole preceding passage (from ver.…
... The only tolerable explanation, if it were wished to connect ver. 16 with ver. 15, would be to take the verbs of ver. 15 as expressing the permanent present of the idea : " The manifestation of the presence…
... He will demand holiness of heart ; comp. the expression, ver. 29: 6 ... the Jew who is one inwardly, and : the circumcision of the heart ; comp. also, in the Sermon on the Mount, Matt v. 20-48,…
The second part of the chapter, w. 17-29, contains the ... of the principles laid down in the first. After expressing himself in a general and more or less abstract way, Panl addresses himself directiy to the person whom he…