Logia

Romans · Chapter 7 · Passages

The law and sin (Romans 7:7–13)

7 What then are we to say? Is the law sin? Certainly not! But it was the law that taught me what sin is. I would never have recognized wrong desire for what it is unless the law had said, "You shall not covet." 8 Sin found its opening in the commandment and used it to rouse every kind of wrong desire in me, for without the law sin is dead. 9 There was a time when I lived without the law. Then the commandment arrived, sin woke up and came alive, 10 and I died. The commandment was given for life, yet for me it led to death. 11 Sin found its opening in the commandment, deceived me, and used the commandment to kill me. 12 The law, then, is holy. The commandment is holy, just and good. 13 Did something good, then, become death to me? Certainly not! Sin was the cause. It used what was good to work death in me, so that sin would be seen for what it really is. Through the commandment sin showed itself sinful past all measure.

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

82 excerpts from 8 commentators on Romans 7:7–13, from John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) to Frédéric Louis Godet (1812–1900).

Two voices on The law and sin (Romans 7:7–13)

Choose two:

What the church has said

Each excerpt opens with its first words. Follow its verse to read it in full.

What does Chrysostom say about Romans 7:7–13?

John Chrysostom

c. 347–407 · Patristic (Greek East) · Homilies on the Epistle of St. Paul the Apostle to the Romans · 11 excerpts

  • Romans 7:7 Homily XII. Rom. VI. 19

    Ver. 7. “What then? is the Law sin? God forbid.”

  • Romans 7:7

    ... What the Law is not, he has set down by way of objection, so that by removing this, and thereby doing the Jew a pleasure, he may persuade him to accept the less alternative. And what is this? Why…

  • Romans 7:8 Homily XII. Rom. VI. 19

    Ver. 8. “But sin, taking occasion by the commandment, wrought in me all manner of concupiscence.”

  • Romans 7:8

    ... But if he treats the discussion about the Law with somewhat of vehemence, do not feel surprise. For Paul is making a stand against the present exigency, and suffers not his language to give a handle even to those…

  • Romans 7:8

    ... Seest thou that to the wicked in all cases occasions of greater punishment result from good things? But we shall not in this accuse the benefits of God, but rather upon this even admire them the more: but we…

  • Romans 7:9 Homily XII. Rom. VI. 19

    Ver. 9. “For I was alive without the Law once.”

  • Romans 7:11 Homily XII. Rom. VI. 19

    Ver. 11. “For sin taking occasion by the commandment deceived me, and by it slew me.”

  • Romans 7:12 Homily XII. Rom. VI. 19

    Ver. 12. “Wherefore the law is holy, and the commandment holy, and just, and good.”

  • Romans 7:12

    ... Now neither Adam, nor any body else, can be shown ever to have lived without the law of nature. For as soon as God formed him, He put into him that law of nature, making it to dwell by…

  • Romans 7:13 Homily XII. Rom. VI. 19

    Ver. 13. “Was then that which is good made death unto me? God forbid. But sin that it might appear sin.” (4 mss. om. ἡ.)

  • Romans 7:13

    ... But when you hear me speak of sin, do not think of it as a substantial power, but evil doing, as it comes upon men and goes from them continually, and which, before it takes place, has no being,…

What does Calvin say about Romans 7:7–13?

John Calvin

1509–1564 · Reformed · Commentaries on the Epistle of Paul the Apostle to the Romans · 13 excerpts

  • Romans 7:7 What then shall we say?

    7. What then shall we say? Since it has been said that we must be freed from the law, in order that we may serve God in newness of spirit, it seemed as though this evil belonged to the law,…

  • Romans 7:7 For coveting I had not known

    For coveting I had not known, etc. This is then an explanation of the former sentence, by which he proves that ignorance of sin, of which he had spoken, consisted in this — that he perceived not his own coveting.…

  • Romans 7:7

    Augustine says, that Paul included in this expression the whole law; which, when rightly understood, is true: for when Moses had stated the things from which we must abstain, that we may not wrong our neighbor, he subjoined this prohibition…

  • Romans 7:8 But an occasion being taken

    8. But an occasion being taken, etc. From sin, then, and the corruption of the flesh, proceeds every evil; the law is only the occasion. And though he may seem to speak only of that excitement, by which our lusting…

  • Romans 7:8 For without the law

    8. For without the law, etc. He expresses most clearly the meaning of his former words; for it is the same as though he had said, that the knowledge of sin without the law is buried. It is a general…

  • Romans 7:9 For I was alive

    9. For I was alive, etc. He means to intimate that there had been a time when sin was dead to him or in him. But he is not to be understood as though he had been without law at…

  • Romans 7:9

    It may be here asked, what time was that when through his ignorance of the law, or as he himself says, through the absence of it, he confidently laid claim to life. It is indeed certain, that he had been…

  • Romans 7:9 But when the commandment came

    But when the commandment came, etc. So now, on the other hand, he sets forth the law as coming when it began to be really understood. It then raised sin as it were from be dead; for it discovered to…

  • Romans 7:10 Was found by me

    10. Was found by me, etc. Two things are stated here — that the commandment shows to us a way of life in the righteousness of God, and that it was given in order that we by keeping the law…

  • Romans 7:11 Led me out of the way

    11. Led me out of the way, etc. It is indeed true, that while the will of God is hid from us, and no truth shines on us, the life of men goes wholly astray and is full of errors;…

  • Romans 7:12 So then the law is indeed holy

    12. So then the law is indeed holy, etc. Some think that the words law and commandment is a repetition of the same thing; with whom I agree; and I consider that there is a peculiar force in the words,…

  • Romans 7:13 Has then what is good

    13. Has then what is good, etc. He had hitherto defended the law from calumnies, but in such a manner, that it still remained doubtful whether it was the cause of death; nay, the minds of men were on this…

  • Romans 7:13 But sin

    But sin, etc. With no intention to offend others, I must state it as my opinion, that this passage ought to be read as I have rendered it, and the meaning is this, — “Sin is in a manner regarded…

What does Evans say about Romans 7:7–13?

John Evans

1680–1730 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume VI (Acts to Revelation): Romans, by John Evans · 8 excerpts

  • Romans 7:7–14

    To what he had said in the former paragraph, the apostle here raises an objection, which he answers very fully: What shall we say then? Is the law sin? When he had been speaking of the dominion of sin, he…

  • Romans 7:7–14

    III. The ill use that his corrupt nature made of the law notwithstanding. 1. Sin, taking occasion by the commandment, wrought in me all manner of concupiscence, v. 8. Observe, Paul had in him all manner of concupiscence, though one…

  • Romans 7:7–14

    ... The worst thing that sin does, and most like itself, is the perverting of the law, and taking occasion from it to be so much the more malignant. Thus the commandment, which was ordained to life, was intended as…

  • Romans 7:7 The great advantage that he had found by the law

    II. The great advantage that he had found by the law. 1. It was discovering: I had not known sin but by the law, v. 7. As that which is straight discovers that which is crooked, as the looking-glass shows…

  • Romans 7:7

    ... We never see the desperate venom or malignity there is in sin, till we come to compare it with the law, and the spiritual nature of the law, and then we see it to be an evil and a…

  • Romans 7:7

    ... Paul then saw that in sin which he had never seen before; he then saw sin in its causes, the bitter root, the corrupt bias, the bent to backslide,—sin in its colours, deforming, defiling, breaking a righteous law, affronting…

  • Romans 7:12 The great excellency of the law in itself

    I. The great excellency of the law in itself. Far be it from Paul to reflect upon the law; no, he speaks honourably of it. 1. It is holy, just, and good, v. 12. The law in general is so,…

  • Romans 7:12

    ... Other laws may forbid compassing and imagining, &c., which are treason in the heart, but cannot take cognizance thereof, unless there be some overt act; but the law of God takes notice of the iniquity regarded in the heart,…

What does Bengel say about Romans 7:7–13?

Johann Albrecht Bengel

1687–1752 · Lutheran Pietist · Gnomon of the New Testament, Vol. III (Romans, I and II Corinthians) · 5 excerpts

  • Romans 7:7

    He, who has heard the same things predicated of the law and of sin, will perhaps make this objection: is, then, the law sin, or the sinful cause of sin ? comp. ver. 13, note. ... sin) We must again…

  • Romans 7:8–9

    by the commandment) The construction is with the following ... wrought concupiscence by the commandment. Not as Engl. V., Taking occasion by the commandment, here and at ver. 11]; as in ver. 11 twice. ... without — dead) A self-evident…

  • Romans 7:10–11

    I died) I lost that life, which I [fancied that I] had. ... was found) So ... I find, ver. 21. ... v, to life) on the ground of the original intention of God, and in another point of view,…

  • Romans 7:12 holy

    supply from what follows, and just and good; although it was necessary to accumulate these synonymous terms chiefly in defence of the commandment, with its stinging power [rather than of the law]: holy, just, good, in relation respectively to its…

  • Romans 7:13

    To) therefore what is good. — The power of the article is to be noticed. ... death) the greatest evil, and the cause of death, the grestest evil ... working [death in me]. ... but sin) namely, was made death…

What does Wesley say about Romans 7:7–13?

John Wesley

1703–1791 · Anglican (Methodist) · Explanatory Notes upon the New Testament: Romans · 7 excerpts

  • Romans 7:7 What shall we say then

    7. What shall we say then - This is a kind of a digression, to the beginning of the next chapter, wherein the apostle, in order to show in the most lively manner the weakness and inefficacy of the law,…

  • Romans 7:8 But sin

    8. But sin - My inbred corruption. Taking occasion by the commandment - Forbidding, but not subduing it, was only fretted, and wrought in me so much the more all manner of evil desire. For while I was without the…

  • Romans 7:9 And I was once alive without the law

    9. And I was once alive without the law - Without the close application of it. I had much life, wisdom, virtue, strength: so I thought. But when the commandment - That is, the law, a part put for the…

  • Romans 7:10 The commandment which was intended for life

    10. The commandment which was intended for life - Doubtless it was originally intended by God as a grand means of preserving and increasing spiritual life, and leading to life everlasting.

  • Romans 7:11 Deceived me

    11. Deceived me - While I expected life by the law, sin came upon me unawares and slew all my hopes.

  • Romans 7:12 The commandment

    12. The commandment - That is, every branch of the law. Is holy, and just, and good - It springs from, and partakes of, the holy nature of God; it is every way just and right in itself; it is…

  • Romans 7:13

    13. Was then that which is good made the cause of evil to me; yea, of death, which is the greatest of evil? Not so. But it was sin, which was made death to me, inasmuch as it wrought death…

What does Haydock say about Romans 7:7–13?

George Leo Haydock

1774–1849 · Roman Catholic · Catholic Family Bible and Commentary: Romans · 4 excerpts

  • Romans 7:7 Is the law

    Ver. 7. Is the law (of Moses) sin? God forbid. The apostle declares, that the law itself was far from being sinful; on the contrary, that it was good, spiritual, holy: but, saith he, I should not know concupiscence to…

  • Romans 7:8 Sin

    Ver. 8. Sin, taking occasion. Sin, or concupiscence, which is called sin, because it is from sin, and leads to sin, which was asleep before, was awakened by the prohibition; the law not being the cause thereof, nor properly giving…

  • Romans 7:9

    Ver. 9. &c. I lived some time without the law; i.e. without the knowledge of the law. This some understand of S. Paul in the time of his childhood, before he came to the knowledge of what was forbidden by…

  • Romans 7:13 That it may appear sin

    Ver. 13. That it may appear sin, or that sin may appear; viz. to be the monster it is, which is even capable to take occasion from that which is good to work death. Ch.

What does Hodge say about Romans 7:7–13?

Charles Hodge

1797–1878 · Reformed (Presbyterian) · A Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, designed for students of the English Bible · 12 excerpts

  • Romans 7:7 What shall we say then

    (7) What shall we say then? Is the law sin? Far from it, &e. The apostle asks whether it is to be inferred, either from the general doctrine of the preceding section, respecting the necessity of deliverance from the law,…

  • Romans 7:7

    Nay, I had not known sin, but by the law. The word rendered nay very often signifies on the contrary, and may be so translated here. ‘So far from the law being evil, it is, on the contrary, of the…

  • Romans 7:7

    ... At least, that the apostle designedly referred to an inward, spiritual ... sin, in order the more clearly to confirm his declaration. That certain outward actions were wrong, he and all other Pharisees knew, and were ready to admit;…

  • Romans 7:8 But sin

    (8) But sin, taking occasion by the commandment, wrought in me all manner of concupiscence, &c. This verse is not to be connected logically with the last member of the preceding one. It is rather co-ordinate with it, and is…

  • Romans 7:8

    The words by the commandment may be connected either with the preceding or the following clause. If the former mode of construction be adopted, the passage means, ‘Sin, taking advantage of the commandment, wrought in me, &c.’ If the latter,…

  • Romans 7:8

    For without the law, sin was dead.t To say that a thing is dead, is to say that it is inactive, unproductive and unobserved. All this may be said of sin prior to the operation of the law. It is…

  • Romans 7:9 For I was alive without the law once

    (9) For I was alive without the law once; but when the commandment came, sin revived, and I died. The word for connects this verse logically with the two preceding. ‘The law produces conviction of sin, for I was alive,…

  • Romans 7:10 And the commandment which was unto life

    (10) And the commandment which was unto life, I found to be unto death. Life and death are here, as often elsewhere, opposed to each other; the one standing for happiness, the other for misery. The commandment, which was designed…

  • Romans 7:11 For sin

    (11) For sin, taking occasion by the commandment, deceived me, and by it slew me. This verse assigns the reason of the law’s being the cause of death, and hence is connected by jor with v. 10. The proper pointing…

  • Romans 7:12 Wherefore the law is holy, and the commandment holy, just and good

    (12) Wherefore the law is holy, and the commandment holy, just and good. The conclusion from the foregoing exhibition of the effect of the law is, that it is not to be blamed for the evil which it incidentally produces.…

  • Romans 7:13

    (13) Was then that which is good made death unto me 2 God forbid, &c. With a view to prevent the possibility of its being supposed that he thought disrespectfully of this holy law of God, the apostle again denies…

  • Romans 7:13

    But sin, that it might appear sin, working death in me by that which is good; that sin by the commandment might become exceeding sinful. The grammatical construction of this part of the verse is, in the original, very doubtful,…

What does Godet say about Romans 7:7–13?

Frédéric Louis Godet

1812–1900 · Reformed (Swiss Protestant) · Commentary on St. Paul's Epistle to the Romans · 22 excerpts

  • Romans 7:7–13

    This whole exposition is introduced by the objection which consists in identifying the law with sin. But it must not be thought that the apostle's aim is really to exonerate the law from such a suspicion. Who, in the circle…

  • Romans 7:7

    Ver. 7. " What shall we my then f Is the law sin f Let it not he ! Nay, I did riot learn to hnow sin, but by the law; for I ... not known lust, except the law…

  • Romans 7:7

    ... It is a fact: "I did not learn to judge of sin otherwise than by the light of the law." — The notion of ... ledge, contained in ... has been here explained in many 18 ... ways. ...…

  • Romans 7:7

    ... If he discovered sin by the law, it was because one of the commandments made palpable to him the presence of lust, of whose abnormal existence in his inner man he would otherwise have remained for ever ignorant. —…

  • Romans 7:7

    ... For tiie abstract terms : ... and ... (in the first ... there are substirtuted in the second tiie two ... terms : ... and commandment. Sin appears in lust, as law in tiie commandment. This is what is…

  • Romans 7:8

    Ver. 8. " Then sin, taking occasion, wrought in me by the commandment all ... of concupiscence; for without the law sin is dead'* — After revealing to him the presence of sin, the law itself intensified in him the…

  • Romans 7:8

    ... The point in question here is the well-known experience already remarked by the ancients, that man always inclines to forbidden finiit Comp. Prov. ix. 17. The prohibition has for its ... to fix the object strongly on the imagination,…

  • Romans 7:8

    And in what state, then, was sin before the law had thus made it abound in all manner of particular lusts ? It was dead, says ... This expression, far from signifjring that it did not exist, proves, on the…

  • Romans 7:9–10

    Vv. 9, 10a. "And I ... alive when I ... out law; ... when the ... came, ... revived, and I died ; " — Calvin well expresses the rhythm of these verses : " The death of sin is…

  • Romans 7:9–10

    ... But where, then, is this ... of the interposition of Christ, and of the profoimd crisis of which he speaks elsewheie as a new creationf And was the understanding of the commandment then the sole or even the principal…

  • Romans 7:9–10

    ... There was here a real beginning of lift in, God, a pure flame, which was ... no doubt afterwards by self-righteousness and by the inward strife inseparable from it, but which burst forth at last ... at the breath…

  • Romans 7:9–10

    ... In John ix. 11, the meaning is doubtful. If we translate: "recovered life," what is the previous life of sin present to the mind of the apostle ? Origen discovers here his system of the pre-existence of souls, and…

  • Romans 7:10–11

    Yv. 10b, 11. "And the ... which was ordained to guide me to life, I found, turned me to death; for sin, taking occasion, deceived ... commandment, and ly U — This coming into activity on the part of sin,…

  • Romans 7:10–11

    Yer. 11 is intended to explain what reaUy took place. It throws back the blame of the sad experience related, on its true author, sin as was already dene in ver. 8, while reproducing this explanation more forcibly after the…

  • Romans 7:10–11

    12, 13. So ihat the law assuredly is Jioly, and the ... holy, just, and good. Was then that ... is good Tiuzde death unio me t Let it not ... so ! ... sin, that it wight appeatr sin,…

  • Romans 7:10

    The transition of sin from its latent state to that of an active force was to Saul a mortal stroke. The internal divorce between God and him was consummated : to infantine liberty there succeeded fear, to filial feeling the…

  • Romans 7:13

    Yer. 13. Here was the place strictly speaking for the hut ... answering to the ... assuredly of ver. 12. But Paul interrupts himself; he feels the need of yet again stating the problem in all its difficulty. This is…

  • Romans 7:13

    ... But this return to the present tense would be singular after the past ... then it would require rather the present ... may appear, than the aoxist ... might appear. Paul is not speaking of what is, he is…

  • Romans 7:13

    ... Then what relation are we to establish in this sense between the two thats t Are they parallel as two distinct and simultaneous ends : Sin turned me. to death, 1st, that it might appear sin ; 2d, that…

  • Romans 7:13

    It seems to me that to obtain a result in haimony ... with the requirements of language and of logic, it is enoo to ... construction No. ... combine it so modified with "So. 2. We need to understand not…

  • Romans 7:13

    Thus we have three ideas — (1) sin slays by that which is good ; (2) ihat thereby it may accomplish an act worthy of its ... (3) and ihat ... (final end) this natove may he manifetied clearly. It…

  • Romans 7:13

    Those who, from ... to our day (p. 15), apply this passage to the ... people, find in the words I ioas alive an indication of the ... period when the promiae was the bond between God and man, and…

Read Romans 7 with all its commentary