God is faithful (Romans 3:1–8)
1 Then what advantage does the Jew have? What good is circumcision? 2 Much, in every way. To begin with, the Jews were entrusted with the very words of God. 3 What of it? If some were unfaithful, does their unfaithfulness cancel out God's faithfulness? 4 Certainly not! Let God be found true, even if every human being is a liar. As it is written, "So that You are shown to be right when You speak, and win Your case when You are judged." 5 But if our wrongdoing brings out God's righteousness more clearly, what are we to say? Is God unjust, then, when He brings His wrath on us? I am speaking as people do. 6 Certainly not! If that were so, how could God judge the world? 7 But if my falsehood makes God's truth shine out all the more, to His glory, why am I, too, still judged a sinner? 8 And why not do what some slander us by saying we teach: "Let us do evil so that good may come of it"? Such people deserve their condemnation.
Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.
90 excerpts from 8 commentators on Romans 3:1–8, from John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) to Frédéric Louis Godet (1812–1900).
What the church has said
Each excerpt opens with its first words. Follow its verse to read it in full.
What does Chrysostom say about Romans 3:1–8?
John Chrysostom
Romans 3:1 Homily VI. Rom. II. 17, 18
Chap. iii. ver. 1. “What advantage then hath the Jew?”
... For after setting before himself this objection, and saying, “what advantage then hath the Jew?” he says not, None, but he concurs with the statement, and confutes it again by the sequel, and shows that they were even punished…
Romans 3:2 Homily VI. Rom. II. 17, 18
Ver. 2. “Much every way: chiefly, because that they were entrusted with the oracles of God.”
Romans 3:3 Homily VI. Rom. II. 17, 18
Ver. 3. “For what if some did not believe?”
Romans 3:4 Homily VI. Rom. II. 17, 18
Ver. 4. “God forbid.” The word ἐπιστεύθησαν, then, proclaims God’s gift.
... Next, since he said, “For what if some did not believe?” (while clearly it was all of them that did not believe,) lest by speaking here too as the history allowed him, he should seem to be a severe…
Romans 3:5 Homily VI. Rom. II. 17, 18
Ver. 5. “But if our unrighteousness commend the righteousness of God, what shall we say? is God unrighteous Who taketh vengeance? I speak as a man.”
Romans 3:6 Homily VI. Rom. II. 17, 18
Ver. 6. “God forbid.”
Romans 3:7 Homily VI. Rom. II. 17, 18
Ver. 7. “For if the truth of God hath more abounded through my lie unto His glory: why yet am I also judged as a sinner?”
Romans 3:8 Homily VI. Rom. II. 17, 18
Ver. 8. “If not (as some affirm that we say,) Let us do evil that good may come? Whose damnation is just.”
What does Calvin say about Romans 3:1–8?
John Calvin
1. Though Paul has clearly proved that bare circumcision brought nothing to the Jews, yet since he could not deny but that there was some difference between the Gentiles and the Jews, which by that symbol was sealed to them…
Romans 3:2 Much in every way
2. Much in every way, etc.; that is, very much. He begins here to give the sacrament its own praise; but he concedes not, that on this account the Jews ought to have been proud; for when he teaches that…
Romans 3:2 First indeed, because, intrusted to them
First indeed, because, intrusted to them, etc. Some think there is here an unfinished period, for he sets down what he does not afterwards complete. But the word first seems not to me to be a note of number, but…
Romans 3:3 What indeed if some
3. What indeed if some, etc. As before, while regarding the Jews as exulting in the naked sign, he allowed them no not even a spark of glory; so now, while considering the nature of the sign, he testifies that…
Romans 3:3 Shall their unbelief
Shall their unbelief, etc. Καταργεῖν is properly to render void and ineffectual; a meaning most suitable to this passage. For Paul’s inquiry is not so much whether the unbelief of men neutralizes the truth of God, so that it should…
Romans 3:4 But let God be true
4. But let God be true, etc. Whatever may be the opinion of others, I regard this as an argument taken from the necessary consequence of what is opposed to it, by which Paul invalidates the preceding objection. For since…
Now this is a remarkable passage, and contains a consolation that is much needed; for such is the perversity of men in rejecting and despising God’s word, that its truth would be often doubted were not this to come to…
Romans 3:4 That thou mightest be justified
That thou mightest be justified, etc. The sense is, So far is it that the truth of God is destroyed by our falsehood and unfaithfulness, that it thereby shines forth and appears more evident, according to the testimony of David,…
The application then of this passage is the following: Since all the sins of mortals must serve to illustrate the glory of the Lord, and since he is especially glorified by his truth, it follows, that even the falsehood of…
Romans 3:5 But if our unrighteousness
5 But if our unrighteousness, etc. Though this is a digression from the main subject, it was yet necessary for the Apostle to introduce it, lest he should seem to give to the ill-disposed an occasion to speak evil, which…
Romans 3:6 By no means
6. By no means, etc. In checking this blasphemy he gives not a direct reply to the objection, but begins with expressing his abhorrence of it, lest the Christian religion should even appear to include absurdities so great. And this…
For though there are found among men unjust judges, yet this happens, because they usurp authority contrary to law and right, or because they are inconsiderately raised to that eminence, or because they degenerate from themselves. But there is nothing…
Romans 3:7 If indeed the truth of God
7. If indeed the truth of God, etc. This objection, I have no doubt, is adduced in the person of the ungodly; for it is a sort of an explanation of the former verse, and would have been connected with…
Romans 3:8 And not
8. And not, etc. This is an elliptical sentence, in which a word is to be understood. It will be complete, if you read it thus, — “and why is it not rather said, (as we are reproached, etc.) that…
Romans 3:8 (As we are reproached,)
(As we are reproached,) etc. Since Paul speaks so reverently of the secret judgments of God, it is a wonder that his enemies should have fallen into such wantonness as to calumniate him: but there has never been so much…
Romans 3:8 Whose judgment is just
Whose judgment is just. Some take this in an active sense, as signifying that Paul so far assents to them, that what they objected was absurd, in order that the doctrine of the gospel might not be thought to be…
What does Evans say about Romans 3:1–8?
John Evans
I. Here the apostle answers several objections, which might be made, to clear his way. No truth so plain and evident but wicked wits and corrupt carnal hearts will have something to say against it; but divine truths must be…
Romans 3:2 Answer
Answer. The Jews are, notwithstanding this, a people greatly privileged and honoured, have great means and helps, though these be not infallibly saving (v. 2): Much every way. The door is open to the Gentiles as well as the Jews,…
... The Jews had the means of salvation, but they had not the monopoly of salvation. Now this he mentions with a chiefly, proton men gar—this was their prime and principal privilege. The enjoyment of God's word and ordinances is…
Answer. It is very true that some, nay most of the present Jews, do not believe in Christ; but shall their unbelief make the faith of God without effect? The apostle startles at such a thought: God forbid! The infidelity…
... When they speak vanity every one with his neighbour, it is very comfortable to think that the words of the Lord are pure words, Ps. xii. 2, 6. For the further proof of this he quotes Ps. li. 4,…
Object. 3. Carnal hearts might hence take occasion to encourage themselves in sin. He had said that the universal guilt and corruption of mankind gave occasion to the manifestation of God's righteousness in Jesus Christ. Now it may be suggested,…
Answer. God forbid; far be it from us to imagine such a thing. Suggestions that reflect dishonour upon God and his justice and holiness are rather to be startled at than parleyed with. Get thee behind me, Satan; never entertain…
Romans 3:7–8 Object
Object. 4. The former objection is repeated and prosecuted (v. 7, 8), for proud hearts will hardly be beaten out of their refuge of lies, but will hold fast the deceit. But his setting off the objection in its own…
Answer. He says no more by way of confutation but that, whatever they themselves may argue, the damnation of those is just. Some understand it of the slanderers; God will justly condemn those who unjustly condemn his truth. Or, rather,…
What does Bengel say about Romans 3:1–8?
Johann Albrecht Bengel
ivhat) Paul's usual form of bringing in an objection. ... then. Since circumcision is unprofitable without observing the law, and since being a Jew outwardly is of no avail, what advantage does the latter possess, and of what profit is…
much) In the neuter gender; supply ... It rather refers to the concrete, concerning the Jew, than to the abstract, concerning circumcision, ver. 1; this will be treated of at ch. iv. 1, 9, etc. So, ch. ii. 29 ...…
LXX., Job xxi. 4. — si, if) Thus might the Gentile rival easily object. ... The words derived from a common root are ... some) [for many, most of the Jews], a form of expression to avoid what is disagreeable…
Paul alone uses this form of expression, and only in his epistles to the Romans and the Galatians. ... let him be made) in judgment. — 6 ... God true) See Ps. cxvi. 12, where God's most faithful retribution is…
God at once both ... and ... [implead in judgment] has the meaning of the middle voice, such as verbs of contending usually have ... applies to those who dispute in a court of law. LXX., Is. xliii. 26; Judg.…
but if) This new argument, urged through a Jewish person, is elicited from the verb thou mayest be justified, in the preceding verse. ... unrighteousness) of which a man is guilty through unbelief. — n ... what shall we say)…
otherwise) The consequence is drawn [bound, connected] from the less to the greater, as it ought to be in the case of negatives. If God were to act unrighteously, in taking vengeance on the Jew who acts unrighteously, a thing…
for if) An ... [a sentiment, with the grounds on which it rests subjoined] set forth in the form of a dialogue, for the purpose of strengthening the objection which was introduced at the beginning of ver. 5. ... through…
and not) supply, act so, as [and why should I not act so, as, etc.]; but a change of number or person is introduced, such as in ch. iv. 17. ... as) Some were in the habit of calumniating Paul;…
What does Wesley say about Romans 3:1–8?
John Wesley
Romans 3:1 What then, may some say, is the advantage of the Jew, or of the circumcision
1. What then, may some say, is the advantage of the Jew, or of the circumcision - That is, those that are circumcised, above the gentiles?
Romans 3:2 Chiefly in that they were intrusted with the oracles of God
2. Chiefly in that they were intrusted with the oracles of God - The scriptures, in which are so great and precious promises. Other prerogatives will follow, chap. ix, 4-5. St. Paul here singles out this by which, after removing…
Romans 3:3 Shall their unbelief disannul the faithfulness of God
3. Shall their unbelief disannul the faithfulness of God - Will he not still make good his promises to them that do believe?
4. Psalm ii, 4.
5. But, it may be farther objected, if our unrighteousness be subservient to God's glory, is it not unjust in him to punish us for it? I speak as a man - As human weakness would be apt to speak.
Romans 3:6 God forbid
6. God forbid - By no means. If it were unjust in God to punish that unrighteousness which is subservient to his own glory, how should God judge the world - Since all the unrighteousness in the world will then…
Romans 3:7 But, may the objector reply, if the truth of God hath abounded
7. But, may the objector reply, if the truth of God hath abounded - Has been more abundantly shown. Through my lie - If my lie, that is, practice contrary to truth, conduces to the glory of God, by making…
Romans 3:8 Whose condemnation is just
8. Whose condemnation is just - The condemnation of all who either speak or act in this manner. So the apostle absolutely denies the lawfulness of " doing evil," any evil, "that good may come."
What does Haydock say about Romans 3:1–8?
George Leo Haydock
Romans 3:1 What advantage then
Ver. 1. What advantage then? &c. The apostle, not to offend the Jews, by insisting too long in reprehending them, turns his discourse to the advantages they have hitherto had above other nations. As first, that the words of God,…
Romans 3:4 God only is essentially true
Ver. 4. God only is essentially true. All men in their own capacity are liable to lies and errors: nevertheless God, who is the truth, will make good his promise of keeping his Church in all truth. See S. John,…
Romans 3:5–6 But if our injustice
Ver. 5-6. But if our injustice, &c. S. Paul here puts this objection, that if men’s sins and iniquities, make the justice of God commendable, that is, make his justice more apparent and known; if the truth of God, as…
What does Hodge say about Romans 3:1–8?
Charles Hodge
Romans 3:1 What advantage then hath the Jew
(1) What advantage then hath the Jew? or what profit is there of circumcision 2 The conclusion at which the apostle had arrived at the close of the preceding chapter was, that , the Jews, as well as Gentiles, are…
Romans 3:2 Much every way
(2) Much every way: chiefly because unto them were committed the oracles of God. This is the answer to the objection presented in the first verse. It consists in a denial of the correctness of the inference from the apostle’s…
Romans 3:3 But what
(3) But what, if some did not believe 2 Shall their unbelief muke the faith of God without effect? This verse is very difficult. The apostle’s manner of reasoning is often so concise, his transitions so abrupt, and his sentences…
It seems, therefore, more natural to consider this verse as expressing the sentiment of an objector, and that which follows as the apostle’s answer. The objection is, that Paul’s doctrine of the exposure of the Jews to condemnation, is inconsistent…
... 100, in nearly the same words, and the reason assigned for it, “ That all Israel has a portion in eternal life.”” This is a favourite Jewish phrase, and is frequently recurring in their writings. Justin Martyr, as quoted…
Romans 3:4 God forbid
(4) God forbid: yea, let God be true, but every man a liar; as itis written, &c. The objection presented in the preceding verse is, that the apostle’s doctrine, as to the condemnation of the Jews, is inconsistent with the…
God forbid. 'These words, which occur so often in our version, are a most unhappy rendering of the original, which means simply det it not be, equivalent, therefore, with by no means, or far from it. It is a mode…
... The sacred writers of the New Testament frequently quote passages from the Old, careful only to give the sense, without adhering strictly to the words. According to that view of this passage, which makes vy. 3 to express the…
Romans 3:5 But tfour unrighteousness commend the righteousness of God, what shall we say
(5) But tfour unrighteousness commend the righteousness of God, what shall we say? Is God unrighteous, who taketh vengeance? I speak as a‘man. This is another cavilling objection of the Jew. ‘ Not only is God’s fidelity pledged for our…
... 2: 5, is rendered wrath, and here is obviously taken for its effect, i. e. punishment; ‘who inflicts punishment.’ In order to make it evident that he was not expressing his own sentiments in using the language of this…
Romans 3:6 God forbid, for then how shall God judge the world
(6) God forbid, for then how shall God judge the world ? The apostle denies that there is the least ground for this objection, and shows that if it is well founded, God cannot judge the world at all. By…
(7) For tf the truth of God hath more abounded through my lie unto his glory, why yet am I also judged as a sinner? This is a repetition, in a more definite form, of the sentiment of the 5th…
According to another interpretation, ‘the truth of God’ is taken for the true majesty of God; Ue for idolatry, see Is. 57: 11. 59: 13, and sinner for idolater, see Gal. 2:15. The sense would then be, ‘If the divine…
Romans 3:8 And not rather (as we be slanderously reported
(8) And not rather (as we be slanderously reported, and as some affirm that we say) Let us do evil, that good may come? whose damnation is just. The sense of this verse is obvious, though the grammatical construction of…
Whose condemnation, &c., that is, the condemnation of those who adopt the principle, that it is right to do evil that good may come; not those who slandered the apostle. This verse contains Paul’s answer to the principle on which…
What does Godet say about Romans 3:1–8?
Frédéric Louis Godet
Yv. 1, 2. ' What then is the advantage of the Jew t or what is the profit of ... t Much every way : foremost in {hat unto them were committed the oracles of God" — It was a…
The order of thought in this piece, one of the most difficult,, perhaps, in the Epistle, is as foUows : — 1. If the Jew is judged absolutely, as the Grentiles are, what advantage has he over them ? Answer…
Ver. 2. Though the advantage of the Jew does not consist in exemption from judgment, he has an advantage, nevertheless, and it is very great As neuter, it is connected with the subject of the first proposition of ver. 1…
... If it were kept, the or which follows would require to take the meaning of because, which is unnatural — It is better, therefore, to reject it, and to translate ... by in that — This advantage, which takes…
Vv. 3, 4. " For what shall we say t If some did not believe shall their unbelief make the faUh of God without effect t Let it not be: yea, let God be found true, and every man a…
... Finally, the future will it ... void? does not suit this sense ; Paul would rather have said : did it ... void t The subject in question, therefore, is a positive fact, and one which has just come…
... The question thus signifies : '' Can Jewish imbelief in regard to the Messiah invalidate God's faithfulness to His people ? " The question might be asked in this sense : " K the Jews have not taken advantage…
The negative answer to this question, as we have seen, was already anticipated by the interrogative ... When expressing it (ver. 4), the apostle enhances the simple negativa He exclaims : " Let that not be (the faithfulness of God…
... In both cases the second is wider than the first, and includes it — The conflict between the promises of God and His veracity, raised by the present fact of Israel's unbelief, must issue in the glory of the…
... David means : " I was clear as to what I was doing ; Thou hadst not left me ignorant that when sinning I was sinning against Thy person, which is outraged by such misdeeds, and that I was…
... Thoujudgest But the LXX. have translated : " that Thou mayest be victor (gain Thy case) when Thou art judged," or : " when Thou hast a case at law." It is probably this last meaning to which the…
Vv. 5, 6. ... if our unrighteousness commend the righteousness of God, what shall we say f Is not God unrighteous when He inflicts wrath t I speak as a man.. That he far: for then how shall God Judge…
... The question ... what shall we say t does not occur in any other letter of the apostle's ; but it is frequent in this ... . It serves to ... the mind of the reader on the state…
The argument of ver. 6, according to Meyer, is this : How would God be disposed to judge the world, if there was no righteousness in Him ? For the troublesome consequences of sin could not impel Him to it,…
Vv. 7, 8. "For if the truth of God hath more ... through my lie unto His ghry; why ... am I also fudged as a sinner? And not (as we are accused of doing, and as some falsely affirm…
... And he must be acquitted." — By the phrase truth of God Paul returns to the beginning of the discussion (w. 3 and 4). What is in question is the moral uprightness of God ; in like manner the…
The apostle pushes his refutation to the utmost (ver. 8) : Why even not go further? Why, after annihilating the judgment, not say further, to be thoroughly consequent: " And even let us furnish God, by sinning more freely, with…
... Hofmann has proposed another construction ; he understands ... after ... and makes the following ... dependent on it: ''And it is not the case with me, as we are accused of practising and teaching, that it only remains…
Observations on the passage, iii 1-8. — Notwithstanding its temporary application to the Jewish people, this passage, which will find its complete explanation in chap. xL, has a real permanent value. It has always been sought to justify the greatest…
The apostle has drawn in two great pictures the reign of God's wrath — (1) over the Gentile world (chap, i); (2) over the Jewish people (chap. iL) ; and by way of appendix he has added a passage to…