John · Chapter 11 · Passages
The plot to kill Jesus (John 11:45–54)
45 Many of the Jews who had come to Mary, and had seen what He did, believed in Him. 46 Some of them, however, went off to the Pharisees and reported what Jesus had done. 47 So the chief priests and the Pharisees called a meeting of the council. "What are we doing?" they said. "This man is doing many signs. 48 If we leave Him alone, everyone will end up believing in Him. Then the Romans will come and take from us both our holy place and our nation." 49 One of them, Caiaphas, who was high priest that year, said to them, "You do not know anything! 50 You have not worked out that it is to your advantage to have one man die for the people, instead of the whole nation perishing." 51 Caiaphas did not say this on his own. Because he was high priest that year, he prophesied that Jesus was going to die for the nation, 52 and not for the nation alone, but also to bring God's scattered children together into one. 53 So from that day on they plotted together to kill Him. 54 So Jesus stopped moving about in public among the Jews of Judea. He left and went to the countryside near the wilderness, to a town called Ephraim, and stayed there with His disciples.
Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.
112 excerpts from 10 commentators on John 11:45–54, from John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) to B. F. Westcott (1825–1901).
What the church has said
Each excerpt opens with its first words. Follow its verse to read it in full.
What does Chrysostom say about John 11:45–54?
John Chrysostom
John 11:45–47 Homily LXIV. John xi. 41, 42
When the sign had been wrought, some wondered, others went and told it to the Pharisees. What then did they? When they ought to have been astonished and to have admired Him, they took counsel to kill Him who had…
John 11:48 Homily LXIV. John xi. 41, 42
Ver. 48. “If we let him thus alone, the Romans will come, and will take away both our nation and city.”
John 11:49–50 Homily LXV. John xi. 49, 50
[1.] “The heathen are stuck fast in the destruction which they made; in the trap which they hid is their foot taken.” ( Ps. ix. 15 , LXX.) This hath been the case with the Jews. They said that they…
John 11:51–52 Homily LXV. John xi. 49, 50
Ver. 51. “And this spake he not of himself, but being High Priest he prophesied.”
John 11:51 Homily LXV. John xi. 49, 50
But what is, “being High Priest that year”? This matter as well as the rest had become corrupt; for from the time that offices became matters of purchase, they were no longer priests for the whole period of their lives,…
John 11:53–54 Homily LXV. John xi. 49, 50
Ver. 53. “From that day forth the Jews took counsel to put Him to death.”
What does Augustine say about John 11:45–54?
Augustine of Hippo
John 11:45–46 Tractate XLIX. Chapter XI. 1–54
25. “Then many of the Jews who had come to Mary, and had seen the things which Jesus did, believed on Him. But some of them went away to the Pharisees, and told them what things Jesus had done.” All…
John 11:47–48 Tractate XLIX. Chapter XI. 1–54
26. “Then gathered the chief priests and the Pharisees a council, and said, What do we?” But they did not say, Let us believe. For these abandoned men were more occupied in considering what evil they could do to effect…
John 11:49–52 Tractate XLIX. Chapter XI. 1–54
27. “And one of them, [named] Caiaphas, being the high priest that same year, said unto them, Ye know nothing at all, nor consider that it is expedient for us that one man should die for the people, and that…
John 11:53–54 Tractate XLIX. Chapter XI. 1–54
28. “Then, from that day forth, they took counsel together for to put Him to death. Jesus therefore walked no more openly among the Jews; but went thence unto a country near to the wilderness, into a city called Ephraim,…
What does Aquinas say about John 11:45–54?
Thomas Aquinas
John 11:45 Then many of the Jews which came to Mary, and had seen the things which Jesus did, believed on him.
Origen. Our Lord had said above, Because of the people that stand by I said it, that they may believe that Thou hast sent Me. It would have been ignorance of the future, if He had said this, and none…
John 11:45 Then many of the Jews which came to Mary, and had seen the things which Jesus did, believed on him.
Aug. Or, it is death within; when the evil 'thought has not come out into action. But if thou actually do the evil thing, thou hast as it were carried the dead outside the gate. Greg. And one there is…
John 11:47 Then gathered the chief priests and the Phari- sees a council, and said, What do we? for this man doeth many miracles.
Theophyl. Such a miracle as this should have drawn forth wonder and praise. But they make it a reason of plotting against His life: Then gathered the chief priests and Pharisees a council, and said, What do we? Aug. tjjey…
John 11:48–51 If we let him thus alone, all men will believe on him: and the Romans shall come and take away both our place and nation.
Aug. Or, they were Aug. afraid that, if all believed in Christ, none would remain to defend the city of God and the temple against the Romans: since they thought that Christ's teaching was directed against the temple, and their…
John 11:48 If we let him thus alone, all men will believe on him: and the Romans shall come and take away both our place and nation.
Origen. This speech is an evidence of their city and blindness: of their audacity, because they testified that He had done many miracles, and yet thought that they could contend successfully against Him, and that He would have no power…
John 11:49–50 And one of them, named Caiaphas, being the high priest that same year, said unto them, Ye know nothing at all,
Aug. How is it that he is called the High Priest of that year, when God appointed one hereditary High Priest? This was owing to the ambition and contention of parties amongst the Jews themselves, which had ended in the…
John 11:49 And one of them, named Caiaphas, being the high priest that same year, said unto them, Ye know nothing at all,
Origen. Not every one that prophesieth is a prophet; as not every one that does a just action is just, he, for example, that does one for vainglory. Caiaphas prophesied without being a prophet, as did Balaam. Perhaps some will…
John 11:51–52 And this spake he not of himself: but being- high priest that year, he prophesied that Jesus should die for that nation;
... And He died for the people, in that He took upon Himself, made away with, blotted out the sins of the whole world. And this spake he not of himself Hence we see, what men say sometimes proceeds from…
John 11:51–52 And this spake he not of himself: but being- high priest that year, he prophesied that Jesus should die for that nation;
... Thus Paul too speaks of some teachers Tim. of the law, who understand neither what they say, nor 'whereof they affirm. Aug. We learn hence that even bad Aug. men may foretell things to come by the spirit of…
John 11:51 And this spake he not of himself: but being- high priest that year, he prophesied that Jesus should die for that nation;
Theophyl. He said this with a bad intention, yet the Holy Spirit used his mouth as the vehicle of a prophecy: And this spake he not of himself: but being high priest that year, he prophesied that Jesus should die…
John 11:53 Then from that day forth they took counsel together for to put him to death.
Greg. His persecutors accomplished this wicked purpose, and put Him to death, thinking to extinguish the devotion of His followers; but faith grew from the very thing which these cruel and unbelieving men thought would destroy it. That which human…
John 11:54 Jesus therefore walked no more openly among the Jews; but went thence unto a country near to the wilderness, into a city called Ephraim, and there con- tinued with his disciples.
Origen. Mystically, Jesus walked openly among the Jews, when the Word used to come to them by the Prophets. But this Word ceased, i. Jesus went thence. And He went to that town near the wilderness, whereof Isaiah says, More…
What does Calvin say about John 11:45–54?
John Calvin
John 11:45 Many therefore of the Jews believed on him
45. Many therefore of the Jews believed on him. Christ did not permit the miracle which he had wrought to be without fruit, for by means of it he drew some persons to the faith. For we ought to understand…
John 11:46 But some of them went away to the Pharisees
46. But some of them went away to the Pharisees. In those who accuse Christ we behold detestable ingratitude, or rather horrible rage, from which we infer how blind and mad is their impiety. The resurrection of Lazarus ought undoubtedly…
John 11:47 Then the chief priests and the Pharisees assembled the council
47. Then the chief priests and the Pharisees assembled the council. Not less monstrous is the blindness of the priests, which is here described. If they had not been exceedingly stupid and brutish, they would at least have been impressed…
John 11:48 If we let him alone thus
48. If we let him alone thus. What if they do not let him alone? In that case, as we have already said, they are fully convinced that it lies in their power to block up Christ’s path, so that…
John 11:48 The Romans will come
The Romans will come. They cloak their wickedness by a plausible disguise, their zeal for the public good. The fear that chiefly distressed them was, that their tyranny would be destroyed; but they pretend to be anxious about the temple…
John 11:48 The Romans will come
The Romans will come. The Evangelist means, that the chief object of their consultation was, to guard against imminent danger. “If the Romans,” they say, “knew that any innovation was made in public matters, there is reason to fear that…
John 11:49 Then one of them, named Caiaphas
49. Then one of them, named Caiaphas. It was a short consultation, for Caiaphas did not allow them to hesitate long. He holds out that there is but one way of purchasing safety, and that is, to slay an innocent…
John 11:51 Now he spoke this, not of himself
51. Now he spoke this, not of himself. When the Evangelist says that Caiaphas did not speak this of himself, he does not mean that Caiaphas — like one who was mad, or out of his senses — uttered what…
But it is highly ridiculous in the Papists to infer from this that we ought to reckon as an oracle whatever the Roman high priest may think fit to pronounce. First, granting what is false, that every man who is…
John 11:51 That Jesus would die
That Jesus would die. First, the Evangelist shows that the whole of our salvation consists in this, that Christ should assemble us into one; for in this way he reconciles us to the Father, in whom is the fountain of…
John 11:52 And not for that nation only
52. And not for that nation only. The Evangelist means that the reconciliation effected by Christ is also extended to the Gentiles. But how comes it that they who, in consequence of being wretchedly scattered and wandering, became the enemies…
John 11:53 They consulted to put him to death
53. They consulted to put him to death. The Evangelist relates that Christ again fled, knowing that his enemies sought him with so great rage. Yet let us remember that he did not fly in order to withdraw from his…
John 11:54 Which is called Ephraim
54. Which is called Ephraim. As to the name of the town which is mentioned here, I think that either it was pronounced at that time in a corrupted manner, or it was entirely new. For we know how greatly…
What does Lapide say about John 11:45–54?
Cornelius a Lapide
John 11:45 Then many of the Jews
Ver. 45. — Then many of the Jews . . . believed on Him. For they were convinced by the evidence of the miraculous raising of Lazarus, so great and wonderful, that Jesus was a prophet, yea, more, the Messiah,…
... S. Augustine doubts whether they did this with good or evil intention ; whether to announce to them that they might believe, or to betray Him that they might use severity, as says the Gloss. For they might do…
... What do we ? (What does it behove us to do ? Syriac, What shall we do ?)
... I.e., the Romans will destroy Judea and the whole Jewish race. ... But Maldonatus understands the Temple ; for the chief priests feared that this with its victims and temporal gains should be taken from them by the Romans.
... While the rest were consulting and not grasping the case nor finding what it was needful to do, Caiaphas as high priest proffers advice, and clearly defines the matter. It is said, high priest thai year, because, although according…
... Note, that Caiaphas, with the other chief priests being most )iostile to Christ, wished out of private hate towards Him to speak out distinctly the same thing which the others secretly hinted at, but did not expressly state ;…
John 11:52 And not for that nation only
Ver. 52. — And not for that nation only, &c. It is expedient that Christ should die ; not only for His and our nation, that is, for the Jews, but also for all the nations dispersed throughout the whole…
John 11:53 Then from that day forth
Ver, 53. — Then from that day forth, &c. See here plainly appears the unrighteous disposition and meaning of Caiaphas and his associates.
Ver. 54. — -Jesus therefore walked no more openly among the Jetvs, I.e., freely, openly, publicly. S. Cyril says : " As God He knew what the Jews had determined on, though none of them declared it j as man…
What does Henry say about John 11:45–54?
Matthew Henry
John 11:45 Some were invited by it, and induced to believe
I. Some were invited by it, and induced to believe. Many of the Jews, when they saw the things that Jesus did, believed on him, and well they might, for it was an incontestable proof of his divine mission. They…
John 11:46 The informers were so
1. The informers were so (v. 46): Some of them, who were eye-witnesses of the miracle, were so far from being convinced that they went to the Pharisees, whom they knew to be his implacable enemies, and told them what…
John 11:47 A special council is called and held
(1.) A special council is called and held (v. 47): Then gathered the chief priests and Pharisees a council, as was foretold, Ps. ii. 2, The rulers take counsel together against the Lord. Consultations of the sanhedrim were intended for…
[1.] The matter to be debated was what course they should take with this Jesus, to stop the growth of his interest; they said What do we? For this man doeth many miracles. The information given about the raising of…
[2.] That which made this matter weighty was the peril they apprehended their church and nation to be in from the Romans (v. 48): "If we do not silence him, and take him off, all men will believe on him;…
a. They take on them to prophecy that, in a little time, if he have liberty to go on, all men will believe on him, hereby owning, when it was to serve their purpose, that his doctrine and miracles had…
b. They foretel that if the generality of the nation be drawn after him, the rage of the Romans will be drawn upon them. They will come and take away our place; the country in general, especially Jerusalem, or the…
... There was more danger of the Romans' being incensed against the Jewish nation by the priests than by Christ. Note, Pretended fears are often the colour of malicious designs. (b.) Had there really been some danger of displeasing the…
John 11:49–50 The malice of it appears evident at first view
[1.] The malice of it appears evident at first view, v. 49, 50. He, being the high priest, and so president of the council, took upon him to decide the matter before it was debated: "You know nothing at all,…
Thirdly, This is plausibly insinuated, with all the subtlety as well as malice of the old serpent. 1. He suggests his own sagacity, which we must suppose him as high priest to excel in, though the Urim and Thummim were…
... Caiaphas craftily insinuates that the greatest and best man, though major singulis—greater than any one individual, is minor universis—less than the collected mass, and ought to think his life well spent, nay well lost, to save his country from…
[2.] The mystery that was in this counsel of Caiaphas does not appear at first view, but the evangelist leads us into it (v. 51, 52): This spoke he not of himself, it was not only the language of his…
[1.] He explains what he said, and shows how it not only was, but was intended to be, accommodated to an excellent purpose. He did not speak it of himself. As it was an artifice to stir up the council…
John 11:51–52 He prophesied, being high priest that year
Secondly, He prophesied, being high priest that year; not that his being high priest did at all dispose or qualify him to be a prophet; we cannot suppose the pontifical mitre to have first inspired with prophecy the basest head…
Thirdly, The matter of his prophecy was that Jesus should die for that nation, the very thing to which all the prophets bore witness, who testified beforehand the sufferings of Christ (1 Pet. i. 11), that the death of Christ…
John 11:52 The persons Christ died for
First, The persons Christ died for: Not for the nation of the Jews only (it would have been comparatively but a light thing for the Son of God to go through so vast an undertaking only to restore the preserved…
John 11:52 The purpose and intention of his death concerning those persons
Secondly, The purpose and intention of his death concerning those persons; he died to gather in those who wandered, and to gather together in one those who were scattered; to invite those to him who were at a distance from…
John 11:53 The result of this debate is a resolve of the council to put Jesus to death
(5.) The result of this debate is a resolve of the council to put Jesus to death (v. 53): From that day they took counsel together, to put him to death. They now understood one another's minds, and so each…
John 11:54 Christ hereupon absconded, knowing very well what was the vote of their close cabal
(6.) Christ hereupon absconded, knowing very well what was the vote of their close cabal, v. 54.
[2.] He withdrew into an obscure part of the country, so obscure that the name of the town he retired to is scarcely met with any where else. He went to a country near the wilderness, as if he were…
... The prince of teachers was now removed into a corner (Isa. xxx. 20); there was no open vision of him; and it was a sad presage of that thick darkness which was shortly to come upon Jerusalem, because she…
What does Bengel say about John 11:45–54?
Johann Albrecht Bengel
feet) two feet had been swathed up together, or else each separately. ... The same word occurs in LXX., Prov. vii. 16, “I have decked my bed with coverings” ... who had come) ver. 19, “to comfort them concerning their…
all men) and indeed with good reason. ... the Romans) Their supposition was, that the Romans would regard that [the adhesion of the people to ... And yet [with all their scheming] the Jews did not escape that which they…
expedient) Caiaphas is thinking of mere ... tical expediency ; but the Spirit of prophecy so directs him, as that he uses words suited to express what was spiritually expedient. Caiaphas and Pilate condemned Jesus; yet both gave a testimony…
of his own self) as men, who deliberate, otherwise are wont. ... said not) By this is explained the verb ... said, which was used in ver. 49. ... nation) Caiaphas had said, izip rod ... for the people, ver.…
that had been [were] scattered abroad) The Preterite denotes, not those who are in the dispersion, but those who have come into a state of dispersion. Gen. x. 32, “The nations were divided in the earth after the flood;” xi.…
therefore) This refers to ver. 50, taken in connection with what went before. ... no more) This was not the result of fear. ... Ephraim) See 2 Sam. xiii. 23, “ Baal-hazor, beside Ephraim.” ... out of that region, ver.…
What does Wesley say about John 11:45–54?
John Wesley
John 11:45 Many believed on Him
45. Many believed on Him - And so the Son of God was glorified, according to what our Lord had said, ver. 4.
John 11:46 But some of them went to the Pharisees
46. But some of them went to the Pharisees - What a dreadful confirmation of that weighty truth, If they hear not Moses and the prophets, neither will they be persuaded though one rose from the dead!
John 11:47 What do we?
47. What do we? - What? Believe. Yea, but death yields to the power of Christ sooner than infidelity.
John 11:48 All men will believe
48. All men will believe - And receive him as the Messiah. And this will give such umbrage to the Roman that they will come and subvert both our place - Temple; and nation - Both our Church and state.…
John 11:49 That year
49. That year - That memorable year, in which Christ was to die. It was the last and chief of Daniel's seventy weeks, the fortieth year before the destruction of Jerusalem, and was celebrated for various causes, in the Jewish…
John 11:50 It is expedient that one man should die for the people
50. It is expedient that one man should die for the people - So God overruled his tongue, for he spake not of himself, by his own spirit only, but by the spirit of prophecy. And thus he gave unawares…
John 11:52 But that, he might gather into one
52. But that, he might gather into one - Church, all the children of God that were scattered abroad - Through all ages and nations.
What does Ryle say about John 11:45–54?
J. C. Ryle
John 11:38–46 JOHN XI. 38—46.
These verses record one of the greatest miracles the Lord Jesus Christ ever worked, and supply an unanswerable proof of His divinity. He whose voice could bring back from the grave one that had been four days dead, must indeed…
John 11:45 Then many of the Jews...believed on him
This verse describes the good effect which the raising of Lazarus had on many of the Jews who had come from Jerusalem to comfort Mary and Martha. Their remaining prejudices gave way. They were unable to resist the extraordinary evidence…
John 11:46 But some of them went...Pharisees, &c.
We see in this verse the bad effect which the raising of Lazarus had on some who saw it. Instead of being softened and convinced, they were hardened and enraged. They were vexed to see even more unanswerable proofs that…
(a) We should observe that we are not told of anything that Lazarus said about his state while in the grave, and nothing of his after history. Tradition says that he lived for thirty years after, and was never known…
John 11:47–57 JOHN XI. 47—57.
"We, should observe, for one thing, in these verses, the desperate wickedness of man's natural heart. A mighty miracle was wrought within an easy walk of Jerusalem. A man four days dead was raised to life, in the sight of…
John 11:47 Then gathered...priests...Pharisees...council
This council was probably the great sanhedrim, or consultative assembly of the Jewish Church. It was for purely ecclesiastical, and not for civil or political purposes. It is the same assembly before which, it is conjectured with much show of…
John 11:47 for this man doeth many miracles
This is a marvellous admission. Even our Lord's worst enemies confess that our Lord did miracles, and many miracles. Can we doubt that they would have denied the truth of His miracles, if they could? But they do not seem…
John 11:48 If we let him thus alone
This means, " If we continue to treat Him as we do now, and take no more active measures to put Him down, — if we only dispute and reason and argue and cavil and denounce Him, but let Him…
John 11:48 the Romans shall come...take away...place...nation
The process of reasoning by which the Pharisees arrived at this conclusion was probably something of this kind. " This man, if let alone, will gather round Him a crowd of adherents, who will proclaim Him a Leader and King.…
That there was an expectation throughout the East, at the time of our Lord's ministry, that some remarkable person was about to arise, and become a great leader, is mentioned by Roman historians. Bat there is no evidence that the…
John 11:49 And one of them, named Caiaphas
This man, by comparing Acts v. 17, would seem to have been of the sect of the Sadducees. We also know that he was son-in-law to Annas, of whom Josephus specially mentions that he was a Sadducee. If this view…
John 11:49 said...Ye know nothing at all
The word rendered "ye" is here emphatic in the Greek. It seems not unlikely that it expresses Caiaphas' contempt for the ignorance and helplessness of the Pharisees' question. "You and all your party do not understand what the situation of…
John 11:50 Nor consider
The word thus rendered is almost always translated " reason," and is nowhere " consider," except here. It seems to imply that Caiaphas wished the Pharisees to know that they had not reasoned out and properly weighed the right thing…
Let us carefully note here what crimes and sins may be committed on the ground of expediency. None are so likely to be tempted to commit such sins as rulers and governors. None are so likely to do things unjust,…
John 11:51–52 And this spake he not of himself, &c.
These two verses contain a parenthetical comment by St. John, on the address of Caiaphas to the Pharisees. It is a peculiar passage, and not without difficulty. That a man like Caiaphas should be said to prophesy, and that his…
John 11:51–52 this spake he not of himself
He spoke these words, though he was not aware of it, under the influence of an overruling power, making him say things of far deeper meaning than he was conscious of himself. As Ecolampadius says, " God used him as…
John 11:51–52 die for that nation, &c.
And He also foretold what was practically fulfilled afterwards, though in a way marvellously unlike what he thought, — that Jesus would not only die for the Jewish nation, but for the benefit of all God's children at present scattered…
John 11:53 Then from that day...counsel...death
We see here the result of Caiaphas' counsel. His stern, bold, outspoken proposal carried all the council with him, and even if Gamaliel, Nicodemus, and Joseph were there, their voices were silenced. From that very day it became a settled…
John 11:54 Jesus therefore walked...Jews
From this time our Lord found it necessary to give up appearing openly at Jerusalem, and came there no more till the week of his crucifixion. He knew the result of the council just held, either from His own Divine…
John 11:54 went thence...wilderness...Ephraim...disciples
Nothing whatever is known for certain of the distinct locality to which our Lord retired, or of the city here named. It seems, purposely, to have been a quiet, isolated, and little frequented place. The probability is that it was…
What does Westcott say about John 11:45–54?
B. F. Westcott
John 11:45–46 45—46.
Men judge of the sign according to their nature.
John 11:45 Then...which came...had seen
Many therefore of the Jews, even they that came . . . and beheld. "The Jews," as a general term here (comp. v. 37), seems to include others in addition to the friends of Mary. Curiosity may readily have led…
John 11:46 some of them
of " the Jews," that is, and not as A.V. seems to express, of " the Jews who had come to Mary."
John 11:47–53 47—53.
The decision of the Sanhedrin.
John 11:47 Then...chief priests
The chief priests therefore, inasmuch as it was evident that this last work could not but create a popular crisis at the coming feast.
John 11:47 What do we
Not simply " What must we do?" ... as if there were room for quiet deliberation ; but, "What are we doing ? What course are we taking ? (rt iroiovpfv ; Vulg. Quid facimus ?) The crisis for action…
John 11:48 If we let
It is assumed that the multitude will place their own interpretation upon the miracles, and set Jesus at their head, and that He will lend Himself to their zeal. This being so, they argue that the Romans will interfere with…
John 11:49 And one of them, named Caiaphas
Comp. xviii. 13, note; Matt. xxvi. 3, note; Acts v. 17.
John 11:50 the people...the...nation
The former title ... marks the divine relationship: the latter ... the civil organization. Comp. Acts xxvi. 17, 23; 1 Pet. ii. 9 f.; ....
John 11:51 And...spake...that nation
Now this he said... the nation. The high-priest represented the divine headship of the Jews, and it was through him that an inspired decision was given on questions of doubt : Num. xxvii. 21. The true priest is, as Philo…
John 11:52 that nation
the nation. St John does not repeat the word " people." The Jews at this crisis had ceased to be " a people." They were a "nation" only, as one of the nations of the world. The elements of the…
John 11:53 Then from...took counsel together
So from. ..took counsel. That which had been a decree before (v. 18), now became a settled plan. St John marks the growth of the hostility step by step: v. 16 ff., (vii. 1), vii. 32, 45 ff., viii. 59,…
John 11:54–57 54—57.
A space of retirement and suspense.
Jesus therefore . . . J withdrawing Himself from unnecessary perils.