Where the churches differ · John
Forgiving and retaining sins: how has the church read John 20:21–23?
Jesus said to them again, "Peace to you. In the way that the Father has sent Me, I am sending you." Having said this, He breathed on them and told them, "Receive the Holy Spirit." Whose sins you forgive, they stand forgiven; whose sins you retain, they stand retained.
How the readings differ
AI draft, not yet reviewed Logia wrote this note; it is not commentary. It is a draft until a named reviewer approves it.
Held in common All read the passage as the risen Christ breathing the Holy Spirit on his disciples and sending them out as the Father sent him.
Catholic and Orthodox
Catholic and Orthodox teaching finds here the authority Christ gave the apostles and their successors to forgive sins in his name, exercised in the sacrament of confession.
Protestant
Protestant readers generally take it as the authority of the whole church to declare God's forgiveness through the preaching of the gospel; Lutherans and some Anglicans also keep private confession and absolution, without counting it a sacrament in the Catholic sense.
This passage is one of the places the traditions read John differently.
Every commentator in Logia on the passage (11)
All of them, in the order they died, each by the opening words of what they say. Logia chooses none of them, and publishes a page like this only when they come from enough traditions to be fair.
- Early church 3
- Catholic 2
- Lutheran 1
- Reformed 2
- Methodist 1
- Anglican 2
John Chrysostom c. 347–407 · Patristic (Greek East)
On John 20:21–23 · 1 excerpts on the passage
“Ye have no difficulty, owing to what hath already come to pass, and to the dignity of Me who send you.” Here He lifteth up their souls, and showeth them their great cause of confidence, if so be that they were about to undertake His work. And no longer is an appeal made to the Father, but with authority He…
Augustine of Hippo 354–430 · Patristic (Latin West)
On John 20:18–23 · 1 excerpts on the passage
4. “Mary Magdalene came and told the disciples, I have seen the Lord, and He hath spoken these things unto me. Then the same day at evening, being the first day of the week, when the doors were shut where the disciples were assembled for fear of the Jews, came Jesus, and stood in the midst, and saith unto them,…
Cyril of Alexandria c. 376–444 · Patristic (Greek East)
On John 20:22–23 · 2 excerpts on the passage
After dignifying the holy Apostles with the glorious distinction of the apostleship, and appointing them ministers and priests of the Divine Altar, as I have just said, He at once sanctifies them by vouchsafing His Spirit unto them, through the outward sign of His Breath, that we might be firmly convinced that the Holy Spirit is not alien to the…
Thomas Aquinas 1225–1274 · Medieval Catholic
On John 20:19–25 · 4 excerpts on the passage
Chrys. It is wonderful that they did not think him a phantom. But Mary had provided against this, by the faith she had wrought in them. And He Himself too shewed Himself so openly, and strengthened their wavering minds by His voice: And saith unto them, Peace be unto you, i. Be not disturbed. Wherein too He reminds them of…
John Calvin 1509–1564 · Reformed
On John 20:23 · 9 excerpts on the passage
23. To all whose sins you shall remit. Here, unquestionably, our Lord has embraced, in a few words, the sum of the Gospel; for we must not separate this power of forgiving sins from the office of teaching, with which it is closely connected in this passage. Christ had said a little before, As the living Father hath sent me,…
Cornelius a Lapide 1567–1637 · Roman Catholic (Jesuit)
On John 20:23 · 3 excerpts on the passage
... Calvin twists and turns this to make it mean tiie preaching of the Gospel, namely, that they to whom ye preach the Gospel, if they believe it, will have their sins forgiven by their mere belief. But every one sees that this explanation is strained, forced, foolish, and ridiculous. For in this way it would not be the Apostles,…
Matthew Henry 1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian)
On John 20:23 · 8 excerpts on the passage
(5.) One particular branch of the power given them by their commission particularized (v. 23): "Whosesoever sins you remit, in the due execution of the powers you are entrusted with, they are remitted to them, and they may take the comfort of it; and whosesoever sins you retain, that is, pronounce unpardoned and the guilt of them bound on, they…
Johann Albrecht Bengel 1687–1752 · Lutheran Pietist
On John 20:23–24 · 4 excerpts on the passage
who is called) A formula of explaining or translating, similar to that in ver. 16, which is to say. Among the Greeks Thomas was better known by his Greek name ... a twin, answering to the Heb. ... had not been with them) because perhaps he had his dwelling at a greater distance, and had been late in hearing of…
John Wesley 1703–1791 · Anglican (Methodist)
On John 20:23 · 3 excerpts on the passage
23. Whosoever sins ye remit - (According to the tenor of the Gospel, that is, supposing them to repent and believe) they are remitted, and whosoever sins ye retain (supposing them to remain impenitent) they are retained. So far is plain. But here arises a difficulty. Are not the sins of one who truly repents, and unfeignedly believes in Christ,…
J. C. Ryle 1816–1900 · Anglican (Evangelical)
On John 20:19–23 · 9 excerpts on the passage
We should observe, for one thing, the remarkable language with which our Lord greeted the apostles, when He first met them after His resurrection. Twice over he addressed them with the kindly words, " Peace be unto you." We may dismiss as untenable, in all probability, the cold and cautious suggestion, that this was nothing better than an unmeaning phrase…
B. F. Westcott 1825–1901 · Anglican
On John 20:23 · 6 excerpts on the passage
The pronouns in this case are unemphatic. The main thought which the words convey is that of the reality of the power of absolution from sin granted to the Church, and not of the particular organization through which the power is administered. There is nothing in the context, as has been seen, to shew that the gift was confined to…