Logia

Where the churches differ · John

Feed my sheep: how has the church read John 21:15–17?

John 21:15–17

After they had eaten breakfast, Jesus said to Simon Peter, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me more than these?" Peter said to Him, "Yes, Lord, You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Feed My lambs." A second time he asked him, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me?" Peter said to Him, "Yes, Lord, You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Shepherd My sheep." A third time he asked him, "Simon, son of John, do you love Me?" Peter was hurt because Jesus asked him a third time, "Do you love Me?" Peter replied, "Lord, You know everything; You know that I love You." Jesus said to him, "Feed My sheep.

How the readings differ

AI draft, not yet reviewed Logia wrote this note; it is not commentary. It is a draft until a named reviewer approves it.

Held in common All read the passage as the risen Christ asking Peter three times whether he loves him, and charging him to feed his sheep.

Catholic

Catholic teaching reads Peter's threefold charge as making him shepherd of the whole flock, an office that continues in the bishops of Rome.

Orthodox

Orthodox readers honour Peter as first among the apostles but hold that the charge does not give one bishop authority over the whole church.

Protestant

Protestant readers see chiefly Peter's restoration after his three denials, and a charge that belongs to every pastor.

This passage is one of the places the traditions read John differently.

Every commentator in Logia on the passage (10)

All of them, in the order they died, each by the opening words of what they say. Logia chooses none of them, and publishes a page like this only when they come from enough traditions to be fair.

  • Early church 2
  • Catholic 2
  • Lutheran 1
  • Reformed 2
  • Methodist 1
  • Anglican 2
  1. John Chrysostom c. 347–407 · Patristic (Greek East)

    On John 21:17 · 2 excerpts on the passage

    Ver. 17. “Thou knowest all things,” meaneth, “things present, and things to come.” Seest thou how he had become better and more sober, being no more self-willed, or contradicting? For on this account he was troubled, “lest perchance I think that I love, and love not, as before when I thought and affirmed much, yet I was convicted at last.”…

    Read it all

  2. Augustine of Hippo 354–430 · Patristic (Latin West)

    On John 21:15–17 · 2 excerpts on the passage

    4. “So when they had dined, He saith to Simon Peter, Simon, [son] of John, lovest thou me more than these? He saith unto Him, Yea, Lord; Thou knowest that I love Thee. He saith unto him, Feed my lambs. He saith to him again, Simon, [son] of John, lovest thou me? He saith unto Him, Yea, Lord; Thou knowest…

    Read it all

  3. Thomas Aquinas 1225–1274 · Medieval Catholic

    On John 21:15–17 · 4 excerpts on the passage

    Chrys. That which most of all attracts the Divine love is care and love for our neighbour. Our Lord passing by the rest, addresses this command to Peter: he being the chief of the Apostles, the mouth of the disciples, and head of the college. Our Lord remembers no more his sin in denying Him, or brings that as a…

    Read it all

  4. John Calvin 1509–1564 · Reformed

    On John 21:17 · 5 excerpts on the passage

    17. Peter was grieved. Peter undoubtedly did not perceive the object which Christ had in view, in putting the same question so frequently; and therefore he thinks that he is-in-directly accused, as if he had not answered with sincerity. But we have already showed that the repetition was not superfluous. Besides, Peter was not yet sufficiently aware how deeply the…

    Read it all

  5. Cornelius a Lapide 1567–1637 · Roman Catholic (Jesuit)

    On John 21:17 · 3 excerpts on the passage

    ... Peter was grieved because He said unto him the third time lovest thou Me, and he said unto Him, Lord, Thou knowest all things ; Thou knowest that I love Thee. He saith unto him, Feed My sheep (Syriac, My lambs). Why does Christ thrice ask Peter if he loved Him, and thrice repeat, Feed My sheep ? I…

    Read it all

  6. Matthew Henry 1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian)

    On John 21:15–17 · 4 excerpts on the passage

    1. When Christ entered into this discourse with Peter.—It was after they had dined: they had all eaten, and were filled, and, it is probable, were entertained with such edifying discourse as our Lord Jesus used to make his table-talk. Christ foresaw that what he had to say to Peter would give him some uneasiness, and therefore would not say…

    Read it all

  7. Johann Albrecht Bengel 1687–1752 · Lutheran Pietist

    On John 21:15 · 5 excerpts on the passage

    when) During their eating there had been more than usual silence. Silence at the beginning of a feast is not only the part of politeness, but even of modesty and self-control. ... The Byz. and Lat. formerly omitted these words, as is evident from Augustine. Nor were they in the cod. ... lovest [amas] thou Me?) Thrice the Lord asks…

    Read it all

  8. John Wesley 1703–1791 · Anglican (Methodist)

    On John 21:17 · 2 excerpts on the passage

    17. Because he said the third time - As if he did not believe him.

    Read it all

  9. J. C. Ryle 1816–1900 · Anglican (Evangelical)

    On John 21:15–17 · 8 excerpts on the passage

    These verses describe a remarkable conversation "between our Lord Jesus Christ and the Apostle Peter. To the careful Bible reader, who remembers the Apostle's thrice-repeated denial of Christ, the passage cannot fail to be a deeply interesting portion of Scripture. Well would it be for the Church, if all " after-dinner " conversations among Christians were as useful and edifying…

    Read it all

  10. B. F. Westcott 1825–1901 · Anglican

    On John 21:17 · 6 excerpts on the passage

    When the Lord puts the question "the third time," He adopts the word which St Peter had used. Just as the idea of comparison was given up before, so now the idea of the loftiest love is given up. It is as if the Lord would test the truth of the feeling which St Peter claimed.

    Read it all