Paul's grief for Israel (Romans 9:1–5)
1 I am telling the truth in Christ; I am not lying. My conscience, in the Holy Spirit, bears witness with me 2 that my sorrow is great and the pain in my heart never stops. 3 I could even wish that I myself were under a curse, cut off from Christ, on behalf of my brothers and sisters, my own people by human descent. 4 They are Israelites. Theirs is the adoption as God's children, theirs the glory, the covenants, the giving of the law, the worship and the promises. 5 The patriarchs are theirs, and from them, by human descent, comes Christ, who is God over all, blessed forever. Amen.
Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.
82 excerpts from 8 commentators on Romans 9:1–5, from John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) to Frédéric Louis Godet (1812–1900).
What the church has said
Each excerpt opens with its first words. Follow its verse to read it in full.
What does Chrysostom say about Romans 9:1–5?
John Chrysostom
Romans 9:1 Homily XVI. Rom. IX. 1
“I say the truth in Christ, I lie not, my conscience also bearing me witness in the Holy Ghost.”
Romans 9:2 Homily XVI. Rom. IX. 1
Ver. 2, 3. “That I have a great heaviness and continual sorrow in my heart. For I could wish that myself were accursed from Christ.”
... And so the separation is the same, and both the one and the other are equally removed from the generality. Still, the mode of separation is not the same, but in this case it is the opposite to what…
... And Phinees and Peter we shall implead for murder likewise. Nor is it in the case of the saints alone, but also of the God of the universe, that he who does not keep to this rule, will be…
Romans 9:4 Homily XVI. Rom. IX. 1
Ver. 4, 5. “To whom pertaineth the adoption, and the glory, and the covenants, and the giving of the Law, and the service of God, and the promises; whose are the father’s, and of whom as concerning the flesh Christ…
... Now since they said all this, and blasphemed God, Paul hearing it, and being cut to the heart, and vexed for God’s glory’s sake, wished that he were accursed, had it been possible, so that they might be saved,…
What does Calvin say about Romans 9:1–5?
John Calvin
In this chapter he begins to remove the offences which might have diverted the minds of men from Christ: for the Jews, for whom he was appointed according to the covenant of the law, not only rejected him, but regarded…
Romans 9:1 The truth I say in Christ
1. The truth I say in Christ, etc. As it was an opinion entertained by most that Paul was, as it were, a sworn enemy to his own nation, and as it was suspected somewhat even by the household of…
Romans 9:2 That I have great sorrow
2. That I have great sorrow, etc. He dexterously manages so to cut short his sentence as not yet to express what he was going to say; for it was not as yet seasonable openly to mention the destruction of…
Romans 9:3 For I could wish
3. For I could wish, etc. He could not have expressed a greater ardour of love than by what he testifies here; for that is surely perfect love which refuses not to die for the salvation of a friend. But…
Thus I consent not to the opinion of those who think that Paul spoke these words from regard to God only, and not to men; nor do I agree with others, who say, that without any thought of God, he…
The words, my kinsmen according to the flesh, though they contain nothing new, do yet serve much for amplification. For first, lest any one should think that he willingly, or of his own accord, sought cause of quarrel with the…
Romans 9:4 Who are Israelites
4. Who are Israelites, etc. Here the reason is now more plainly given, why the destruction of that people caused him so much anguish, that he was prepared to redeem them by his own death, namely because they were Israelites;…
Romans 9:4 Whose are the adoption
Whose are the adoption, etc. The whole drift of Paul’s discourse is to this purpose, — that though the Jews by their defection had produced an ungodly divorce between God and themselves, yet the light of God’s favor was not…
Romans 9:4 Glory
Glory means the excellency into which the Lord had raised up that people above all other nations, and that in many and various ways, and especially by dwelling in the midst of them; for besides many other tokens of his…
Romans 9:5 Whose are the fathers
5. Whose are the fathers, etc. It is indeed of some importance to be descended from saints and men beloved of God, since God promised to the godly fathers mercy with regard to their children, even to thousand generations, and…
Romans 9:5 From whom, is Christ
From whom, is Christ, etc. They who apply this to the fathers, as though Paul meant only to say that Christ had descended from the fathers, have no reason to allege: for his object was to close his account of…
We must further observe, that this ascription of praise belongs to none but only to the true and eternal God; for he declares in another place, (1 Timothy 1:17,) that it is the true God alone to whom honor and…
What does Evans say about Romans 9:1–5?
John Evans
We have here the apostle's solemn profession of a great concern for the nation and people of the Jews—that he was heartily troubled that so many of them were enemies to the gospel, and out of the way of salvation.…
II. He backs it with a very serious imprecation, which he was ready to make, out of love to the Jews. I could wish; he does not say, I do wish, for it was no proper means appointed for such…
... He could wish himself no more remembered among the saints, his name blotted out of the church-records; though he had been so great a planter of churches, and the spiritual father of so many thousands, yet he would be…
Romans 9:1 He asserts it with a solemn protestation
I. He asserts it with a solemn protestation (v. 1): I say the truth in Christ, "I speak it as a Christian, one of God's people, children that will not lie, as one that knows not how to give flattering…
Romans 9:4–5 Especially because of their relation to God
2. Especially because of their relation to God (v. 4, 5): Who are Israelites, the seed of Abraham, God's friend, and of Jacob his chosen, taken into the covenant of peculiarity, dignified and distinguished by visible church-privileges, many of which…
... Observe, The promises accompany the giving of the law, and the service of God; for the comfort of the promises is to be had in obedience to that law and attendance upon that service. (7.) Whose are the fathers…
What does Bengel say about Romans 9:1–5?
Johann Albrecht Bengel
truth) Concerning the connexion, see on ch. i. 16, note. The article is not added here; comp. 2 Cor. vii. 14, xi. 10, because his reference is not to the whole truth, but to something true in particular [a particular…
grief, [heaviness]) In spiritual things grief and (see the end of the eighth chapter) joy in the highest degree may exist together. Paul was sensible, from how great benefits, already enumerated, the Jews excluded themselves, and at the same time…
could wish) A verb in the imperfect tense, involving in it a potential or conditional signification, involving the condition, if Christ would permit. His grief was unceasing [continual], but this prayer does not seem here to be asserted as unceasing,…
Romans 9:3 to be accursed
It will be enough to compare this passage with Gal. iii. 13, where Christ is said to have been made a curse for us. The meaning is, I could have wished to bring the misery of the Jews on my…
from Christ) So ... from 1 Cor. i. 30; or, as Christ, being made a curse, was abandoned by the Father; so Paul, filled with Christ, wished in place of the Jews to be forsaken by Christ, as if he…
inasmuch as being those icho) He now explains the cause of his sorrow and grief: viz. the fact that Israel does not enjoy so great benefits. He uses great ... euphemia' [softening of an unwelcome truth. Append.] in words. ...…
Romans 9:4 and the service of God and the promises
Acts xxvi. 6, 7; Eph. i. 13; Heb. viii. 5, 6. Here the giving of the law and the service of God, the covenants and the promises correspond by chiasmus. For the promises flow from the covenants; and the service…
whose are the fathers, etc ... . has both written a dissertation on this passage, and has added it to his Exposition of this Epistle. All, that is of importance to me in it, I have explained ... 157, etc.…
Artemonius objects: I. Christ is nowhere in the sacred Scriptures expressly called God. Ans. Nowhere? Doubtless because Artemonius endeavours to get rid of all those passages either by proposing a different reading, or by a different mode of interpreter tion.…
... By this phrase, he has somewhat incautiously described the Sabellians, and next to them he immediately places the Artemonites in the same class. In other respects the fathers often apply the phraseology of Paul respecting Christ to the Father,…
over all) The Father is certainly excepted, 1 Cor. xv. 27. Christ is of the fathers, according to the flesh; and at the same time was, is, and shall be over all, inasmuch as fie is God blessed for ever.…
What does Wesley say about Romans 9:1–5?
John Wesley
In this chapter St. Paul, after strongly declaring his love and esteem for them, sets himself to answer the grand objection of his countrymen; namely, that the rejection of the Jews and reception of the gentiles was contrary to the…
Romans 9:1 In Christ
1. In Christ - This seems to imply an appeal to him. In the Holy Ghost - Through his grace.
Romans 9:2 I have great sorrow
2. I have great sorrow - A high degree of spiritual sorrow and of spiritual Joy may consist together, chap. viii, 39. By declaring his sorrow for the unbelieving Jews, who excluded themselves from all the blessings he had enumerated,…
Romans 9:3 I could wish
3. I could wish - Human words cannot fully describe the motions of souls that are full of God. As if he had said, I could wish to suffer in their stead; yea, to be an anathema from Christ in…
4. Whose is the adoption, &c. - He enumerates six prerogatives, of which the first pair respect God the Father, the second Christ, the third the Holy Ghost. The adoption and the glory - That is, Israel is the first-born…
5. To the preceding, St. Paul now adds two more prerogatives. Theirs are the fathers - The patriarchs and holy men of old, yea, the Messiah himself. Who is over all, God blessed forever - The original words imply the…
What does Haydock say about Romans 9:1–5?
George Leo Haydock
Romans 9:3 I wished myself to be an anathema from Christ
Ver. 3. I wished myself to be an anathema from Christ. 1 The word anathema, according to its derivation, signifies a thing separated or laid apart for some particular use. Hence it was put to signify things given and consecrated…
Romans 9:4–5 To whom belongeth the adoption of children
Ver. 4-5. To whom belongeth the adoption of children. Lit. whose is the adoption. He mentions the favours which God had done to his people, the Jews. As, 1. That God had adopted them for his elect people. 2. That…
What does Hodge say about Romans 9:1–5?
Charles Hodge
Romans 9:1 L say the truth in Christ, I lie not
(1) L say the truth in Christ, I lie not, &c. There are three ways in which the words in Christ, or by Christ, may here be understood. 1. They may be considered as part of the formula of an…
... Phil. 2: 29, “Receive him therefore in the Lord;’’ Eph. 6: 1. Col. 3: 18. The sense of the passage is much the same whether we adopt the one or the other of the last two modes of explanation.…
Romans 9:2 That Ihave great heaviness
(2) That Ihave great heaviness, &c. This it is which Paul so solemnly asserts. He was not an indifferent spectator of the sorrew, temporal and spiritual, which was about to come on his countrymen. All their peculiar national advantages, and…
(3) #or I could wish that myself were accursed from Christ for my brethren, &c. The word anathema, which is used in this verse by the apostle, properly means something set up or consecrated, and is applied frequently to votive…
In the New Testament the use of the Greek word is very nearly the same. The only passages in which it occurs besides the one before us, are the following; Acts 23: 14, “ We have bound ourselves under a…
1. As those men or animals pronounced anathema in the Old Testament were to be put to death, many consider the apostle as having that idea in his mind, and meaning nothing more than “I could wish to die for…
3. Others render the verb which, in our version, is translated *T could wish,’ J did wish. The sense would then be, ‘I have great sorrow on account of my brethren, because I can sympathize in their feelings, for I…
4, The common interpretation, and that which seems most natural, is, ‘I am grieved at heart for my brethren, for I could wish myself accursed from Christ, that is, I could be willing to be regarded and treated as anathema,…
Romans 9:4 The object of the apostle in the introduction to this chapter
(4) The object of the apostle in the introduction to this chapter, contained in the first five verses, is to assure the Jews of his love and of his respect for their peculiar privileges. The declaration of his love he…
“ind the glory. ‘These words are variously eesti They may be connected with the preceding, as explanatory of the adoption or as qualifying it, and the two words be equivalent to glorious adoption. But as every other specification in this…
The covenants. The plural is used because God at various times entered into covenant with the Jews and their forefathers; by which he secured to them innumerable blessings and privileges; see Gal. 3: 16,17. Eph. 2:12. The giving of the…
Romans 9:5 Whose are the fathers
(5) Whose are the fathers, and of whom, as concerning the flesh, Christ came, &c. The descent of the Jews from men so highly favoured of God as Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, was justly regarded asa great distinction. “&ndofwhom. The…
... Certainly Christ, as every one must acknowledge.t 2. The context requires this interpretation, because, as Paul was speaking of Christ, it would be very unnatural thus suddenly to change the subject and break out into a doxology to God.…
... But this is not only opposed by the reasons already urged, that such doxologies suppose God to be the immediate subject of discourse, or are preceded by some particle which breaks the connexion, and shows plainly what the reference…
... 2 Cor. 11: 31, “The God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who is blessed for evermore.”? <A second method of pointing the verse, also, proposed by Erasmus, and followed by many others, is to place the pause…
What does Godet say about Romans 9:1–5?
Frédéric Louis Godet
Paul expresses all the intensity of his grief on account of his people (vv. 1-3), and he justifies it by the magnificent prerogatives wherewith this unique people had been honoured (w. 4 and 5).
... There is between these two parts a bitter contemplation in which the misery of rejected Israel appears to him like the sombre reverse of the iucomparable blessedness of the faithful who are adopted in Jesus Christ — The apostle…
... The ... with, in the verb ... to testify with, signifies : in concert with my own declaration. " In the mouth of two or three witnesses shall every word be established; " it seems as if Paul wished…
The apostle opens this passage with a preface expressing the profound grief he feels in view of the mysterious fact which is about to occupy him (w. 1-5) ; then he shows how the liberty of God is set in…
Yer. 2. Yv. 2 and 3 contain the matter of that truth so solemnly announced in ver. 1. The parallelism of the two propositions of the verse, as always, is the indication of a rising feeling. A triple gradation has…
Yer. 3. " For I could wish that myself were anathema away from Christ for my brethren, my kinsmen according to the — This inward fact is the proof of the intensity of the feeling expressed in ver. 2 {for)…
... But it is not of what he was formerly, it is of what he is now, as the apostle of the OentUes, that Paul wishes to bear testimony ; and that the expression : far from Christ, may prove…
... Paul himself declares that it is an impossibility ; but if its accomplishment depended only on his love, he would certainly express such a wish before the Lord. The word ... anathema, from ... to expose, to set in…
... Bat if, with the other documents, it he placed after the words : to be anathema, it serves to contrast the real with the alleged Paul, who was made the mortal enemy of the Jews in consequence of the…
Ver. 4. " Who are Israelites ; to whom pertaineth the ... and the glory, and the covenants, and the giving of the law and the service, and the promises" — The pronoun ohive, who, characterizes them in the context…
What led to it ... the term : the old ... the giving of tlie law : this tenn embraces along with the gift of the law itself, the solemn promulgation of it on Mount Sinai ; ... sajring of…
Ver. 5. " Whose are the fathers, and of whom, as concerning the flesh, Christ came, who is over all, God Uessed for ever, amen" — To blessings of an impersonal nature Paul adds, as crowning them, the gifts which…
1 Cor. viii. 6. The reasoning of this critic may be valid against those who refuse to admit the subordination of the Son to the Father. But for those who prefer the true thought of Scripture to a theological formula,…
... How could God be included in the ... all things f Gess, while holding with us that the conclusion of the verse applies to Christ, divides it into three clauses, placing a first comma after ... and a second…
Schultz, after demonstrating with the tone of a master the necessity of applying this whole conclusion (from the word flesh) to Jesus Christ, insists notwithstanding on this point: that according to Paul's view this affirmation of Christ's divinity applies only…
And yet such prerogatives did not exempt the Israelitish nation from the possibility of a rejection. In the very history of this people so peculiarly blessed there were antecedents fitted to put them on their guard against this terrible danger.…
The antithesis to the word fledi in all these cases is not ... but God; comp. ... L 16 : ' I confeired not with flesh and blood" (men in contrast to God) ; Matt xxiv. 22 ; Bom, iii.…
Many commentators dose the sentence with the words: ... to the flesh (Semi, Fritzs., ... van Heng., Meyer, Banr, Tischendorf, 8th edition). In that case it only remains to take the following words as an exclamation of thanksgiving to the…
... If, besides, the participle o ... who is, referred to a subject not mentioned in the previous proposition (God), this transition from one subject to another would require to be indicated in some way, either by the addition of…
Erasmus, who first proposed to end the period after ... had likewise put the question ... the sentence might not close with the word ... {all things, or all) : " of whom is the Christ according to the fiesh,…
... Then, as Meyer observes, the doxology comes on us with intolerable abruptness : " God be blessed for ever and ever ! " And more than all, the sole reason which would make it possible to explain to a…
... God ; comp. Isa. xxxi 3. And if it is certain that Paul recognises in the divine being who appeared in Jesus the creator of all things (1 Cor. viii. 6 ; CoL i. 16, 17), the Jehovah of…
But it is precisely because of this word God that objections are raised to the application of such utterances to the person of Christ. It is objected that nowhere else does Paul designate Jesus in this way (Meyer), and that…
... God, it is in eveiy case without the article, and that the designation 6 ... is reserved for the one God and Father. This rule does not apply to the case before us, for the article 0 belongs not…