Logia

Matthew · Chapter 19 · Passages

A question about divorce (Matthew 19:3–9)

3 Some Pharisees came to Him to put Him to the test. "Does the law allow a man to divorce his wife for any reason at all?" they asked. 4 Jesus answered, "Have you never read that the Creator, at the beginning, made them male and female? 5 And He said, 'That is why a man will leave his father and his mother and cling to his wife, and the two will be one flesh.' 6 So they are not two any longer; they are one flesh. What God has yoked together, then, no human being may pull apart." 7 They said to Him, "Then why did Moses order a man to give his wife a written notice of divorce and send her away?" 8 Jesus answered, "It was because your hearts were so hard that Moses permitted you to divorce your wives. That is not how things were at the beginning. 9 And I tell you this: a man who divorces his wife for any reason other than sexual unfaithfulness and then marries someone else commits adultery, and the man who marries a divorced woman commits adultery."

Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.

45 excerpts from 4 commentators on Matthew 19:3–9, from Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274) to J. C. Ryle (1816–1900).

Two voices on A question about divorce (Matthew 19:3–9)

Choose two:

What the church has said

Each excerpt opens with its first words. Follow its verse to read it in full.

What does Aquinas say about Matthew 19:3–9?

Thomas Aquinas

1225–1274 · Medieval Catholic · Catena Aurea: Commentary on the Four Gospels, Collected out of the Works of the Fathers. Vol. I: St. Matthew · 13 excerpts

  • Matthew 19:3

    Whence it follows; “And the Pharisees cause to him, tempting him, and saying, Is it lawful for a man to put away his wife for every cause?”

  • Matthew 19:4 And he answered and said unto them, “Have ye not read, that he which made them at the beginning made them male and female,

    Jerome: But He so frames His answer as to evade their snare. He brings in the testimony of Holy Writ, and the law of nature, and opposing God’s first sentence to this second, “He answered and said unto them, Have…

  • Matthew 19:5 And said, For this cause shall a man leave father and mother, and shall cleave to his wife: and they twain shall be one flesh?

    Chrys.: But not by the law of creation only, but also by the practice of the law, He shews that they ought to be joined one and one, and never put asunder; “And he said, For this cause shall a…

  • Matthew 19:5

    Chrys.: See the wisdom of the Teacher. Being asked, “Is it lawful,” He said not straight, It is not lawful, lest they should be troubled, but establishes it through a proof. For God made them from the beginning male and…

  • Matthew 19:5

    Remig.: The Apostle says ... that this is a mystery in Christ and the Church; for the Lord Jesus Christ left His Father when He came down from heaven to earth; and He left His mother, that is, the synagogue,…

  • Matthew 19:6 Wherefore they are no more twain, but one flesh. What therefore God hath joined together, let not man put asunder.”

    Chrys.: When He had brought forward the words and facts of the old law, He then interprets it with authority, and lays down a law, saying, “Therefore they are no more twain, but one flesh.” For as those who love…

  • Matthew 19:6

    Aug., Cont. Faust., xix, 29: Behold now out of the books of Moses it is proved to the Jews that a wife may not be put away. For they thought that they were doing according to the purport of Moses’…

  • Matthew 19:7 They say unto him, “Why did Moses then command to give a writing of divorcement, and to put her away?”

    Pseudo-Chrys.: This sentence of chastity seemed hard to these adulterers; but they could not make answer to the argument. Howbeit, they will not submit to the truth, but betake themselves for shelter to Moses, as men having a bad cause…

  • Matthew 19:8

    Chrys.: Had the Lord been opposed to the Old Testament, He would not thus have contended in Moses’ behalf, nor have gone about to shew that what was his was in agreement with the things of old. But the unspeakable…

  • Matthew 19:8

    Pseudo-Chrys.: Therefore said He well, Moses suffered, not commanded. For what we command, that we ever wish; but when we suffer, we yield against our will, because we have not the power to put full restraint upon the evil wills…

  • Matthew 19:9

    Chrys.: Having stopped their mouths, He now set forth the Law with authority, saying, “But I say unto you, that whosoever shall put away his wife, except for fornication, and marrieth another, committeth adultery.

  • Matthew 19:9

    Aug., De Conjug. Adult., ii, 9: For a reunion of the wedlock, even after actual commission of adultery, is neither shameful nor difficult, where there is an undoubted remission of sin through the keys of the kingdom of heaven; not…

  • Matthew 19:9

    Gloss. ord.: He says this to the terror of him that would take her to wife, for the adulteress would have no fear of disgrace.

What does Calvin say about Matthew 19:3–9?

John Calvin

1509–1564 · Reformed · Commentary on a Harmony of the Evangelists, Matthew, Mark, and Luke: Matthew · 14 excerpts

  • Matthew 19:3 And the Pharisees came to him, tempting him

    Matthew 19:3. And the Pharisees came to him, tempting him. Though the Pharisees lay snares for Christ, and cunningly endeavor to impose upon him, yet their malice proves to be highly useful to us; as the Lord knows how to…

  • Matthew 19:4 Have you not read?

    4. Have you not read? Christ does not indeed reply directly to what was asked, but he fully meets the question which was proposed; just as if a person now interrogated about the Mass were to explain faithfully the mystery…

  • Matthew 19:4

    Now the meaning of the words is this: God, who created the human race, made them male and female, so that every man might be satisfied with his own wife, and might not desire more. For he insists on the…

  • Matthew 19:5 Therefore shall a man leave his father and mother

    5. Therefore shall a man leave his father and mother. It is uncertain whether Moses represents Adam or God as speaking these words; but it is of little consequence to the present passage which of these meanings you choose, for…

  • Matthew 19:5 And the two shall be one flesh

    And the two shall be one flesh. This expression condemns polygamy not less than it condemns unrestrained liberty in divorcing wives; for, if the mutual union of two persons was consecrated by the Lord, the mixture of three or four…

  • Matthew 19:6 What God therefore hath joined

    6. What God therefore hath joined. By this sentence Christ restrains the caprice of husbands, that they may not, by divorcing their wives, burst asunder the sacred knot. And as he declares that it is not in the power of…

  • Matthew 19:7 Why then did Moses order?

    7. Why then did Moses order? They had thought of this calumny, if, which was more probable, Christ should demand a proper cause to be shown in cases of divorce; for it appears that whatever God permits by his law,…

  • Matthew 19:7

    But it is asked, Ought Moses to have permitted what was in itself bad and sinful? I reply, That, in an unusual sense of the word, he is said to have permitted what he did not severely forbid; for he…

  • Matthew 19:7

    Let us take a familiar instance. The laws grant to us a greater liberty of litigation than the law of charity allows. Why is this? Because the right cannot be conferred on individuals, unless there be an open door for…

  • Matthew 19:9 But I say to you. Mark

    9. But I say to you. Mark relates that this was spoken to the disciples apart, when they had come into the house; but Matthew, leaving out this circumstance, gives it as a part of the discourse, as the Evangelists…

  • Matthew 19:9

    But an exception is added; for the woman, by fornication, cuts herself off, as a rotten member, from her husband, and sets him at liberty. Those who search for other reasons ought justly to be set at nought, because they…

  • Matthew 19:9 For the sake of avoiding fornication

    For the sake of avoiding fornication, says Paul, let every man marry a wife, (1 Corinthians 7:2.) He who has done so, though he may not succeed to his wish, has done his duty; and, therefore, if any thing be…

  • Matthew 19:9

    But the exception which Christ states appears to be superfluous. For, if the adulteress deserve to be punished with death, what purpose does it serve to talk of divorces? But as it was the duty of the husband to prosecute…

  • Matthew 19:9 And whosoever shall marry her that is divorced

    And whosoever shall marry her that is divorced. This clause has been very ill explained by many commentators; for they have thought that generally, and without exception, celibacy is enjoined in all cases when a divorce has taken place; and,…

What does Henry say about Matthew 19:3–9?

Matthew Henry

1662–1714 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian) · Commentary on the Whole Bible, Volume V (Matthew to John): Matthew · 14 excerpts

  • Matthew 19:3–12

    We have here the law of Christ in the case of divorce, occasioned, as some other declarations of his will, by a dispute with the Pharisees. So patiently did he endure the contradiction of sinners, that he turned it into…

  • Matthew 19:3–12 Christ's answer to this question

    II. Christ's answer to this question; though it was proposed to tempt him, yet, being a case of conscience, and a weighty one, he gave a full answer to it, not a direct one, but an effectual one; laying down…

  • Matthew 19:3–12

    1. The creation of Adam and Eve, concerning which he appeals to their own knowledge of the scriptures; Have ye not read? It is some advantage in arguing, to deal with those that own, and have read, the scriptures; Ye…

  • Matthew 19:3–12 Christ's answer to this objection, in which

    IV. Christ's answer to this objection, in which,

  • Matthew 19:3–12

    But Christ tells them there was a reason for this toleration, not at all for their credit; It was because of the hardness of your hearts, that you were permitted to put away your wives. Moses complained of the people…

  • Matthew 19:3–12 He reduces them to the original institution

    2. He reduces them to the original institution; But from the beginning it was not so. Note, Corruptions that are crept into any ordinance of God must be purged out by having recourse to the primitive institution. If the copy…

  • Matthew 19:3 The case proposed by the Pharisees

    I. The case proposed by the Pharisees (v. 3); Is it lawful for a man to put away his wife? This they asked, tempting him, not desiring to be taught by him. Some time ago, he had, in Galilee, declared…

  • Matthew 19:3

    Their question is, Whether a man may put away his wife for every cause. That it might be done for some cause, even for that of fornication, was granted; but may it be done, as now it commonly was done,…

  • Matthew 19:5

    2. The fundamental law of marriage, which is, that a man shall leave father and mother, and shall cleave to his wife, v. 5. The relation between husband and wife is nearer than that between parents and children; now, if…

  • Matthew 19:6 The nature of the marriage contract

    3. The nature of the marriage contract; it is a union of persons; They twain shall be one flesh, so that (v. 6) they are no more twain, but one flesh. A man's children are pieces of himself, but his…

  • Matthew 19:6

    From hence he infers, What God hath joined together, let not man put asunder. Note, (1.) Husband and wife are of God's joining together; synezeuxen—he hath yoked them together, so the word is, and it is very significant. God himself…

  • Matthew 19:7 An objection started by the Pharisees against this

    III. An objection started by the Pharisees against this; an objection not destitute of colour and plausibility (v. 7); "Why did Moses command to give a writing of divorcement, in case a man did put away his wife?" He urged…

  • Matthew 19:9 He settles the point by an express law

    3. He settles the point by an express law; I say unto you (v. 9); and it agrees with what he said before (ch. v. 32); there it was said in preaching, here in dispute, but it is the same,…

  • Matthew 19:9

    The law of Moses allowing divorce for the hardness of men's hearts, and the law of Christ forbidding it, intimate, that Christians being under a dispensation of love and liberty, tenderness of heart may justly be expected among them, that…

What does Ryle say about Matthew 19:3–9?

J. C. Ryle

1816–1900 · Anglican (Evangelical) · Expository Thoughts on the Gospels: St. Matthew · 4 excerpts

  • Matthew 19:1–15

    In these verses we have the mind of Christ declared on two subjects of great moment. One is the relation of husband and wife; the other is the light in which we should regard little children in the matter of…

  • Matthew 19:1–15

    Our Lord brings forward a widely different standard for the guidance of his disciples. He first founds his judgment on the original institution of marriage. He quotes the words used in the beginning of Genesis, where the creation of man…

  • Matthew 19:1–15

    With respect to little children, we find our Lord instructing us in these verses both by word and deed, both by precept and example. “Little children were brought to him that he should put his hands on them and pray.…

  • Matthew 19:1–15

    Let us learn from these verses that the Lord Jesus cares tenderly for the souls of little children. It is probably that Satan specially hates them: it is certain that Jesus specially loves them. Young as they are, they are…

Read Matthew 19 with all its commentary