John · Chapter 18 · Passages
Jesus before the high priest (John 18:19–24)
19 Meanwhile the high priest began to question Jesus about His disciples and about His teaching. 20 Jesus answered, "I have spoken openly to the world. I have always taught in synagogues and in the temple courts, where all the Jews come together. I have said nothing in secret. 21 Why do you question Me? Question those who heard what I said to them. Look, they know what I said." 22 When He had said this, one of the temple police who stood nearby slapped Jesus and said, "Is that the way You answer the high priest?" 23 Jesus answered him, "If I said something wrong, then testify to what was wrong. But if I spoke rightly, why do you strike Me?" 24 Then Annas sent Him on to Caiaphas the high priest, still bound.
Bible text: Open Word Bible (CC0), Balanced. An AI draft awaiting human review.
64 excerpts from 11 commentators on John 18:19–24, from John Chrysostom (c. 347–407) to B. F. Westcott (1825–1901).
What the church has said
Each excerpt opens with its first words. Follow its verse to read it in full.
What does Chrysostom say about John 18:19–24?
John Chrysostom
John 18:19 Homily LXXXIII. John xviii. 1
Ver. 19. “The high priest then asked Jesus of His disciples, and of His doctrine.”
John 18:20–21 Homily LXXXIII. John xviii. 1
Ver. 20. “I spake openly to the world, (not to the disciples privately,) I taught openly in the temple.”
John 18:22 Homily LXXXIII. John xviii. 1
Ver. 22. “And when he had thus spoken, one of the officers which stood by smote Him with the palm of his hand.”
John 18:23 Homily LXXXIII. John xviii. 1
Ver. 23. “And He saith, If I have spoken evil, bear witness of the evil.”
What does Augustine say about John 18:19–24?
Augustine of Hippo
John 18:18–21 Tractate CXIII. Chapter XVIII. 13–27.
3. “And the servants and officers stood beside the fire of burning coals, for it was cold, and warmed themselves.” Though it was not winter, it was cold: which is sometimes wont to be the case even at the vernal…
John 18:22–23 Tractate CXIII. Chapter XVIII. 13–27.
4. “And when He had thus spoken, one of the officers who stood by gave Jesus a blow with his open hand, saying, Answerest thou the high priest so? Jesus answered him, If I have spoken evil, bear witness of…
John 18:24 Tractate CXIII. Chapter XVIII. 13–27.
5. But let us return to what follows in the Gospel narrative. “And Annas sent Him bound unto Caiaphas the high priest.” To him, according to Matthew’s account, He was led at the outset, because he was the high priest…
What does Cyril say about John 18:19–24?
Cyril of Alexandria
John 18:19 The high priest therefore asked Jesus of His disciples, and of His teaching.
A teacher of the people, learned in the Law, one of those on whom the Divine bidding lays the duty, "Judge ye righteous judgment," after having taken the Lord, as though He had been a notorious robber, by a band…
It were fruitless labour, Christ says, to search out as obscure what is universally known; and how can it be seemly, where full knowledge is present, to set up a pretence of ignorance? This is what Christ seems to us…
John 18:21 Why askest thou Me? Ask them that have heard Me, what I spake unto them: behold, these know the things which I said.
He rebukes those learned in the Law, for that they themselves sinned against the Law in which they took pride. For before He had been condemned, they passed premature sentence upon Him, and yet busied themselves in seeking for errors…
John 18:22 And when He had said this, one of the officers standing by struck Jesus with his hand, saying unto Him, Answerest Thou the high priest so?
It had been foretold, by the mouth of the prophet, that with Christ this would come to pass: I gave My back to the scourge, and My cheeks to them that smite. He was being led on in truth to…
John 18:23 Jesus answered him, If I have spoken evil, bear witness of the evil: but if well, why smitest thou Me?
He proves the officer guilty of a gross wrong, even if He That was on His trial had been a man of obscure position. For he smote Him causelessly, contrary to his express duty; not urged thereto by legal commands,…
What does Aquinas say about John 18:19–24?
Thomas Aquinas
John 18:19 The high priest then asked Jesus of his disci- ples, and of his doctrine.
Chrys. As they could bring no charge against Christ, they asked Him of His disciples: The high priest then asked Jesus of His disciples; perhaps where they were, and on what account He had collected them, he wished to prove…
John 18:20 Jesus answered him, I spake openly to the world; I ever taught in the synagogue, and in the temple, whither the Jews always resort ; and in secret have I said nothing.
Theophyl. He asks Him moreover of His doctrine, what it was, whether opposed to Moses and the law, that he might take occasion thereby to put Him to death as an enemy of God. Alcuin. He does not ask in…
John 18:21 Why askest thou me? ask them which heard le, what I have said unto them : behold, they know diat I said.
Chrys. Or, He spoke in secret, but not, as these thought, from fear, or to excite sedition; but only when what He said was above the understanding of the many. To establish the matter, however, upon superabundant evidence, He adds,…
John 18:22–24 And when he had thus spoken, one of the officers which stood by struck Jesus with the palm of his hand, saying, Answerest thou the high priest so?
Theophyl. When Jesus had appealed to the testimony of the people by, an officer, wishing to clear himself, and shew that he was not one of those who admired our Lord, struck Him: And when He had thus spoken, one…
John 18:24 Now Annas had sent him bound unto Caiaphas the high priest.
Aug. What can be Aug. truer, gentler, kinder, than this answer? He Who received the blow on the face neither wished for him who struck it that fire from heaven should, consume him, or the earth open its mouth and…
John 18:24 Now Annas had sent him bound unto Caiaphas the high priest.
Aug. He Aug. was the one to whom they were taking Him from the first, as Matthew says; he being the high priest of this year. We must understand that the pontificate was taken between them year by year alternately,…
What does Calvin say about John 18:19–24?
John Calvin
John 18:19 The high priest then asked Jesus
19. The high priest then asked Jesus. The high priest interrogates Christ, as if he had been some seditious person, who had split the Church into parties by collecting disciples; and he interrogates him as if he had been a…
John 18:20 I spoke openly in the world
20. I spoke openly in the world. It is a childish error into which some have fallen, who think that this reply of Christ condemns those who expound the word of God in private apartments, when the tyranny of wieked…
and again, when he declares that
John 18:22 When he had said these things
22. When he had said these things. This is added, in order to inform us, first, how great was the rage of the enemies of Christ, and how tyrannical their government was; and, secondly, what sort of discipline existed among…
John 18:23 If I have spoken evil
23. If I have spoken evil. That is, “If I have sinned, accuse me, that, when the cause has been tried, I may be punished according to the offense; for this is not a lawful mode of procedure, but very…
I answer, in Christian patience it is not always the duty of him who has been struck to brook the injury done him, without saying a word, but, first, to endure it with patience, and, secondly, to give up all…
John 18:24 Now Annas had sent him bound
24. Now Annas had sent him bound. This sentence must be read by way of parenthesis; for, having said that Christ was taken to the house of Annas, and having continued his narrative, as if the assembly of the priests…
What does Lapide say about John 18:19–24?
Cornelius a Lapide
Ver. 24. — Ninv Annas sent Him bound unto Caiaphas the High Priest. The Syriac and Arabic versions, as also S. Cyril, read " had sent Him," and so too English version. But it seems as if S. John had…
What does Henry say about John 18:19–24?
Matthew Henry
IV. Peter, Christ's friend, having begun to deny him, the high priest, his enemy, begins to accuse him, or rather urges him to accuse himself, v. 19-21. It should seem, the first attempt was to prove him a seducer, and…
John 18:19 The articles or heads upon which Christ was examined
1. The articles or heads upon which Christ was examined (v. 19): concerning his disciples and his doctrine. Observe,
John 18:19 The intention
(2.) The intention. The high priest then (oun—therefore, which seems to refer to v. 14), because he had resolved that Christ must be sacrificed to their private malice under colour of the public good, examined him upon those interrogatories which…
John 18:20–21 The appeal Christ made, in answer to these interrogatories
2. The appeal Christ made, in answer to these interrogatories. (1.) As to his disciples, he said nothing, because it was an impertinent question; if his doctrine was sound and good, his having disciples to whom to communicate it was…
he would say nothing to condemn them, and could say nothing to justify them. (2.) As to his doctrine, he said nothing in particular, but in general referred himself to those that heard him, being not only made manifest to…
[2.] He insists upon his fair and open dealing with them in the publication of his doctrine, and justifies himself with this. The crime which the sanhedrim by the law was to enquire after was the clandestine spreading of dangerous…
... When he was in the country, he preached ordinarily in the synagogues—the places of meeting for worship, and on the sabbath-day-the time of meeting; when he came up to Jerusalem, he preached the same doctrine in the temple at…
John 18:22–23 While the judges were examining him, the servants that stood by were abusing him
V. While the judges were examining him, the servants that stood by were abusing him, v. 22, 23.
John 18:22–23 He checked him in a haughty imperious manner
(2.) He checked him in a haughty imperious manner: Answerest thou the high priest so? As if the blessed Jesus were not good enough to speak to his master, or not wise enough to know how to speak to him,…
John 18:23 Christ bore this affront with wonderful meekness and patience
2. Christ bore this affront with wonderful meekness and patience (v. 23): "If I have spoken evil, in what I have now said, bear witness of the evil. Observe it to the court, and let them judge of it, who…
... Annas did not long detain them, being as willing as any of them to have the prosecution pushed on, and therefore sent him bound to Caiaphas, to his house, which was appointed for the rendezvous of the sanhedrim upon…
What does Bengel say about John 18:19–24?
Johann Albrecht Bengel
Peter) He had become cold on the Mount of Olives. ... doctrine) The High Priest asks the question, just as if the doctrine of Jesus had crept in (spread gradually) in secret. ... in ch, xix. 38, and who, from…
to the world) Language (i.e. ... ever, or always, the time ; in synagogue and in the temple, the place. ... as presently after we have the expression, ... But the Lord is speaking of the synagogues of the whole…
Why ask Me, whom thou dost not believe? [It was suitable neither to the time nor to the place, for Him to set forth the particular dogmas of faith.—V. ... these) He points to the multitude then present, even these…
Hirs. Goth. Lat. in MS. Bodl. vet. and Luther, omit this word. ... bear witness) If I have spoken evil, then, and not till then, ... (presuming that there are no other objections to that course of proceeding), bear witness,…
sent) One or two editions supply ot, or 6:, or ... There is no need of doing so... That Jesus had been led by Annas to Caiaphas, had been indicated by John, in ver. 15, by the verb ... and…
What does Wesley say about John 18:19–24?
John Wesley
John 18:20 I spake openly
20. I spake openly - As to the manner: continually - As to the time: in the synagogue and temple - As to the place. In secret have I said nothing - No point of doctrine which I have not…
John 18:21 Why askest thou me
21. Why askest thou me - Whom thou wilt not believe?
John 18:22 Answerest thou the high priest so?
22. Answerest thou the high priest so? - With so little reverence?
John 18:24 Now Annas had sent him to Caiaphas
24. Now Annas had sent him to Caiaphas - As is implied ver. 13. Bound - Being still bound, ver. 12.
What does Ryle say about John 18:19–24?
J. C. Ryle
John 18:12–27 JOHN XVIII. 12—27.
We should mark, for one thing, the amazing hardness of unconverted men. We see this in the conduct of the men by whom our Lord was taken prisoner. Some of them most probably were Roman soldiers, and some of them…
John 18:19 The high priest...asked...disciples...doctrine
This verse describes the first judicial examination that our Lord underwent. He was questioned concerning " His disciples," — that is, who they were, how many, what position they occupied, and what were their names. And concerning " His doctrine,"…
(b) What was the examination recorded in this verse ? It seems to be one entirely passed over by Matthew, Mark, and Luke. They only record what took place before Caiaphas, which, on the other hand, is a part of…
John 18:20 Jesus answered him, I
This verse contains a calm, dignified statement from our Lord, of the general course of His ministry. He had done nothing in a clandestine or underhand way. He had always spoken openly " to the world," and not confined His…
John 18:21 Why askest thou me, &c.
This verse is a remonstrance against the gross injustice of Annas's line of examination. Our Lord appeals to him whether it is reasonable, and just, and fair to call upon a prisoner to criminate himself, and to supply evidence which…
John 18:22 And when he had thus spoken, &c.
This verse mentions an event which John alone has recorded. One of the attendants standing by rudely interrupts our Lord by striking Him, and coarsely taxing Him with impertinence and disrespect in so speaking, as He had spoken to the…
There is a striking resemblance between the treatment our Lord received here, and the treatment which Latimer, Ridley, Rogers, and other English martyrs, received at their examination before the Popish bishops.
John 18:23 Jesus answered him, &c.
Our Lord's reply to him who smote is a calm and dignified reproof. " If I have spoken wickedly, bear witness in a just and orderly way becoming a court of law; but do not strike Me. If on the…
John 18:24 Now Annas had sent him...Caiaphas...priest
This verse undoubtedly contains a difficulty. Most commentators seem to think that it states a fact which ought to come in after the thirteenth verse ; and that the questioning and smiting of the last four verses took place before…
If I must give an opinion, I must say that I agree with Stier, Ellicott, and Alford, and consider that this twenty-fourth verse describes our Lord's first appearance before Caiaphas, — that for some wise reason John entirely omits, and…
(d) Last, but not least, the Greek of the twenty-fourth verse cannot fairly and honestly bear the same sense which our translators have put upon it. They have really strained the words to make the sense square with their evident…
What does Westcott say about John 18:19–24?
B. F. Westcott
John 18:19 The high priest then
i.e. probably Caiaphas. See v. 15, note. The narrative is connected with v. 14. The Master is now contrasted with the disciple. It is probable that a better acquaintance with the history of the time would remove the difficulty which…
The Lord leaves unnoticed the question as to His disciples (comp. v. 8), and fixes the attention of the questioner upon Himself alone. Hence an emphatic pronoun stands at the head of each clause. / (ey")? whatever others may have…
' course mean that the Lord's teaching was confined to these public places, but that at all times He used opportunities of speaking in them.
John 18:21 Why askest
The accusers are bound to establish their charge independently.
John 18:22 with...his hand
Or, " with a rod." This latter sense suits perhaps better with the word used for "smiting" ..., though the sense given in the text appears to be more appropriate to the circumstances. Comp. xix. 3 ; Acts xxiii. 2…
John 18:23 If I have spoken evil
The Lord addresses the servant as one who had heard Him, and as such He challenges him to bear just evidence as to His words, and not to use mere violence. The reference (as it appears) is not to the…
Now Annas had sent him...] Annas therefore sent him... The words cannot be rendered otherwise. See Additional Note. The private interrogation at which Caiaphas had assisted led to no decisive result. Annas therefore sent Jesus to the high-priest officially, but…