Logia

Where the churches differ · Romans

Jacob I loved, Esau I hated: how has the church read Romans 9:10–24?

Romans 9:10–24

And that is not all. Rebecca also conceived children by one man, our forefather Isaac. The children were not yet born and had done nothing good or bad. Yet so that God's purpose in choosing might stand, a purpose that rests not on works but on the one who calls, Rebecca was told, "The older will serve the younger." As it is written, "I loved Jacob, but Esau I hated." What then are we to say? Is there injustice on God's part? Certainly not! For God says to Moses, "I will have mercy on whomever I have mercy, and I will show compassion to whomever I show compassion." So it is not a matter of what a person wants or how hard a person strives, but of God, who shows mercy. For Scripture says to Pharaoh, "This is the very reason I raised you up: to display My power in you, and so that My name would be made known through the whole earth." So then God has mercy on whomever He chooses, and He hardens whomever He chooses. So you will say to me, "Why does God still find fault, then?" For who can stand against His will? But who are you, a mere human being, to answer back to God? Will what was shaped say to the one who shaped it, "Why did you make me this way?" Has the potter no right over the clay? From one and the same lump he may make one pot for honored use and another for common use. What if God, wanting to show His wrath and to make His power known, has borne with great patience the vessels of wrath, made ready for destruction? What if He did this to make known the riches of His glory to the vessels of mercy, which He prepared in advance for glory, that is, to us, whom He has called not only from among the Jews but also from among the Gentiles?

How the readings differ

AI draft, not yet reviewed Logia wrote this note; it is not commentary. It is a draft until a named reviewer approves it.

Held in common All read the passage as teaching that God's call rests on his mercy, and not on anything people have done.

In the line of Augustine; Reformed

Readers in the line of Augustine, Reformed readers above all, take the passage of God's choice of particular persons to salvation, made before they were born and resting on his mercy alone, not on anything foreseen in them.

Greek Fathers, Arminian and Wesleyan

Many Greek Fathers, with Arminian and Wesleyan readers, read it of God's freedom to choose peoples and callings in his plan, Israel and the nations, and hold that his choice of persons takes account of the faith he foresees.

Catholic

Catholic theologians have held views across this range, all teaching that grace goes before every good act and that the will freely consents to it.

These readings differ within churches as well as between them.

Every commentator in Logia on the passage (8)

All of them, in the order they died, each by the opening words of what they say. Logia chooses none of them, and publishes a page like this only when they come from enough traditions to be fair.

  • Early church 1
  • Catholic 1
  • Lutheran 1
  • Reformed 4
  • Methodist 1
  1. John Chrysostom c. 347–407 · Patristic (Greek East)

    On Romans 9:10 · 22 excerpts on the passage

    The subject in question was an important one. Hence he turns to several arguments, and endeavors by all means to solve the difficulty. For if it was at once strange and new for them to be cast out after so great promises, it is much more strange that we even should come into their good things, who did not expect…

    Read it all

  2. John Calvin 1509–1564 · Reformed

    On Romans 9:13 · 27 excerpts on the passage

    13. As it is written, Jacob I loved, etc. He confirms, by a still stronger testimony, how much the heavenly answer, given to Rebecca, availed to his present purpose, that is, that the spiritual condition of both was intimated by the dominion of Jacob and servitude of Esau, and also that Jacob obtained this favor through the kindness of God,…

    Read it all

  3. John Evans 1680–1730 · English Nonconformist (Presbyterian)

    On Romans 9:6–13 · 17 excerpts on the passage

    The apostle, having made his way to that which he had to say, concerning the rejection of the body of his countrymen, with a protestation of his own affection for them and a concession of their undoubted privileges, comes in these verses, and the following part of the chapter, to prove that the rejection of the Jews, by the establishment…

    Read it all

  4. Johann Albrecht Bengel 1687–1752 · Lutheran Pietist

    On Romans 9:12–13 · 19 excerpts on the passage

    to her) It was often foretold to mothers before conception or birth, what would happen to their sons. — on 6 ... Gen. xxv. 23, LXX. ... I ... the elder, who, it might be reasonably thought, should command, as the younger should obey. ... shall serve) and yet not so for ever, Gen. xxvii. 40. ... as) The word…

    Read it all

  5. John Wesley 1703–1791 · Anglican (Methodist)

    On Romans 9:1–33 · 15 excerpts on the passage

    In this chapter St. Paul, after strongly declaring his love and esteem for them, sets himself to answer the grand objection of his countrymen; namely, that the rejection of the Jews and reception of the gentiles was contrary to the word of God. That he had not here the least thought of personal election or reprobation is manifest,

    Read it all

  6. George Leo Haydock 1774–1849 · Roman Catholic

    On Romans 9:10 · 8 excerpts on the passage

    Ver. 10. &c. And not only she (Sara) brought forth Isaac, who was the only child of Abraham, to whom the promises descended, though he was the father of Ismael, by Agar, and of all the Ismaelites. And lest the Jews should say that the Ismaelites, though descending from Abraham, according to the flesh, were not to be reputed as…

    Read it all

  7. Charles Hodge 1797–1878 · Reformed (Presbyterian)

    On Romans 9:13 · 34 excerpts on the passage

    (13) As it is written, Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I hated. These words are quoted from Malachi 1: 2, 3, where the prophet is reproving the Jews for their ingratitude. Asa proof of his peculiar favour, God refers to his preference for them from the first, “ Was not Esau Jacob’s brother, saith the Lord; yet I…

    Read it all

  8. Frédéric Louis Godet 1812–1900 · Reformed (Swiss Protestant)

    On Romans 9:1–29 · 45 excerpts on the passage

    The apostle opens this passage with a preface expressing the profound grief he feels in view of the mysterious fact which is about to occupy him (w. 1-5) ; then he shows how the liberty of God is set in its full light by the theocratical antecedents (w. 6—13), and by the most unequivocal scriptural declarations (w. 14-24) ; and…

    Read it all