J. C. Ryle · Expository Thoughts on the Gospels: St. John, Vol. I
John 8
106 excerpts on John 8, in order. Each links to its verse in the reader.
JOHN VIII. 1—11.
We learn, for one thing, the power of conscience. We read of the woman's accusers, that when they heard our Lord's appeal, " being convicted by their own conscience, they went out one by one, beginning at the eldest, even unto the last." Wicked* and hardened as they were, they felt something within which made them cowards. Fallen as human nature is, God has taken care to leave within every man a witness that will be heard.
Conscience is a most important part of our inward man, and plays a most prominent part in our spiritual history. It cannot save us. It never yet led any one to Christ. It is blind, and liable to be misled. It is lame and powerless, and cannot guide us to heaven. Yet conscience is not to be despised. It is 'the minister's best friend, when he stands up to rebuke sin from the pulpit. It is the mother's best friend, when she tries to restrain her children from evil and quicken them to good. It is the teacher's best friend, when he presses home on boys and girls their moral duties. Happy is he who never stifles his conscience, but strives to keep it tender ! Still happier is he who prays to have it enlightened by the Holy Ghost, and sprinkled with Christ's blood.
We learn, for another thing, the nature of true repentance. When our Lord had said to the sinful woman, "Neither do I condemn thee," He dismissed her with the solemn words, " go and sin no more." He did not merely say, " go home and repent." He pointed out the chief thing which her case required, — the necessity of immediate breaking off from her sin.
Jesus went...mount...Olives
The division of the chapter in this place is to be regretted. The last verse of the preceding chapter and the verse before us are evidently intended to be taken together. While the Pharisees and members of the council " went every man to his own house," our Lord, having no home of His own, retired "to the Mount of Olives," and there spent the night in the open air. In such a climate as that of Judea there was nothing remarkable in His doing this. The garden of Gethsemane, at the foot of the mount, would supply sufficient shelter. That this was our Lord's habitual practice, we are distinctly told in Luke xxi. 37.
Lampe remarks that we never read of our Lord lodging, sleeping, or tarrying a night in Jerusalem.
And early in the morning
This expression is worth noticing, because, according to some, it explains our Lord's subsequent use of the figure — " I am the light of the world." They think that it refers to the break of day, or rising of the sun.
[He came again. ..temple.] This means the outer courts of the temple, where it was customary for the Jews to assemble and listen to teachers of religion. In eastern countries and in the times when there was no printing, it must be remembered, much instruction was given in this way, by open-air addresses or conversations. Thus Socrates taught at Athens.
[All the people came unto Him.] " All " here must mean great multitudes of the people. After all that had happened in the last three or four days, we may easily understand that our Lord's appearance would at once attract a crowd. His fame as a teacher and speaker was established.
he sat down, and taught
That it was common for the teachers to sit, and the hearers to stand, is evident from other texts. "I sat daily with you teaching in the temple." (Matt. xxvi. 55.) In the synagogues of Nazareth, when our Lord began to preach, He first " gave the book to the minister, and sat down." (Luke iv. 20.) " He sat down and taught the people out of the ship." (Luke v. 3.) " We sat down and spake to the women." (Acts xvi. 13.)
the scribes and Pharisees
This is the only place in St. John's Gospel where he mentions the " Scribes " at all. He names the Pharisees twenty times — sixteen times alone, and four times in conjunction with the chief-priests.
This fact is thought by some to be an argument against the genuineness of the passage, but without just cause. St. Mark, in his Gospel, speaks twelve times of the Pharisees, and only twice mentions the Scribes in conjunction with them. Moreover, this is the only occasion recorded in St. John, when a formal attempt was made to entrap our Lord by a subtle question. That being so, there may be a good reason why the Scribes should be mentioned as well as the Pharisees, as principal agents in the attempt.
brought unto him a woman, &c.
It seems not improbable that this attempt to ensnare our Lord was one result of His enemies' failure to apprehend Him during the feast. Defeated in their effort to meet Him in argument, or to apprehend Him in the absence of any legal charge, they tried next to entrap Him into committing Himself in some way, and so giving them a handle against Him. No time was to be lost. They had failed yesterday, and found their own officers unwilling to apprehend our Lord. They resolved to try another plan to-day. They would ensnare our Lord into doing something illegal or indis-
[Set her in the midst.] This means in the middle of a ring or circle, composed of themselves and their followers, our Lord and His disciples, and the crowd listening to His teaching.
They say...this woman...taken, &c.
It throws some light on this charge to remember what immense crowds came up to Jerusalem at the great public feasts, and especially at the feast of tabernacles. At such a season, when every house was crowded, as at a fair time, when many consequently slept in the open air, and no small disorder probably ensued, we can well understand that such a sin as a breach of the seventh commandment would be very likely to be committed.
Now Moses...law commanded...stoned
This is the legitimate conclusion of the two texts, Lev. xx. 10 and Deut. xxii. 22, when compared. There seems no ground for the comment of some writers, that Moses did not command an adulteress to be put to death by stoning.
It is worth notice, that the expression, "Moses in the law," is not used either by Matthew, Mark, or Luke. But it is used by St. John both here and at chap. i. 45.
[But what sayest thou ?] This would be more literally rendered, "What therefore sayest thou?" The Greek word rendered " but " by our translators is hardly ever so rendered in the New Testament; and in most places is either "therefore," "then," "so," "now," or "and." John ix. 18, and Acts xxv. 4, are the only parallel cases.
Ecolampadius thinks the Pharisees were especially sore and irritated because our Lord had said that " publicans and harlots '* would enter the kingdom of God before Pharisees. (Matt. xxi. 31.)
This they said, tempting...accuse him
la what did this temptation consist ? How did the Jews hope to find ground for an accusation? The answer seems easy. — If our Lord replied that the woman ought not to be stoned, they would have denounced Him to the people as one that poured contempt on the law. — If our Lord, on the contrary, replied that the woman ought to be stoned, they would have accused Him to the Romans as one who usurped the prerogative of putting criminals to death. See John xviii. 31 : "It is not lawful for us to put any man to death." Moreover, they would have published everywhere our Lord's inconsistency in offering salvation to publicans and harlots, and yet condemning to death an adulteress for one transgression.
Let it be noticed that subtle ensnaring questions like these, putting the person questioned into an apparent dilemma or difficulty, whatever answer he might give, seem to have been favourite weapons of the Jews. The Pharisees' question about " tribute-money," the lawyer's question about " the great commandment of the law," and the Sadducees' question about "the resurrection," are parallel cases. The question before us is therefore quite in keeping with other places in the Gospels.
Augustine remarks, "They said in themselves, 'Let us put before Him a woman caught in adultery ; let us ask what is ordered in the law concerning her; if He shall bid stone her, He will not have the repute of gentleness : if He give sentence to let her go, He will not keep righteousness.' " Euthymius says the same.
But Jesus stooped down, &c.
Our Lord's intention in this remarkable sentence can hardly admit of doubt. He declined to answer the subtle question put to Him, partly because he knew the malicious motive of the questioners, partly because He had always announced that He did not come to be " a judge and divider" among men, or to interfere in the slightest degree with the administration of the law. His silence was equivalent to a refusal to answer.
But the peculiar action that our Lord employed, in " writing with his finger on the ground," is undeniably a difficulty. St. John gives no explanation of the action, and we are left to conjecture both why our Lord wrote and what He wrote.
(1) Some think, as Bede, Rupertus, and Lampe, that our Lord wrote on the ground the texts of Scripture which settled the question brought before Him, as the seventh commandment, and Lev. xx. 10, and Deut. xxii. 22. The action would then imply, "Why do you ask me? What is written in the law, that law which God wrote with His own finger as I am writing now? "
(2) Some think, as Lightfoot and Burgon, that our Lord meant to refer to the law of Moses for the trial of jealousy, in which an accused woman was obliged to drink water into which dust from the floor of the tabernacle or temple had been put by the priest. (Num. v. 17.) The action would then imply, " Has the law for trying such an one as this been tried? Look at the dust on which I am writing. Has the woman been placed before the priest, and drank of the dust and water? "
(3) Some think, as Augustine, Melancthon, Brentius, Toletus, and a Lapide, that our Lord's action was a silent reference to the text, Jer. xvii. 13: "They that depart from me shall be written in the earth."
(4) One rationalist writer suggests that our Lord " stooped down" from feelings of modesty, as if ashamed of the sight before Him, and of the story told to Him. The idea is preposterous, and entirely out of harmony with our Lord's public demeanour.
(5) Some think, as Euthymius, Calvin, Rollock, Chemnitius, Diodati, Flavius, Piscator, Grotius, Poole, and Hutcheson, that our Lord did not mean anything at all by this writing on the ground, and that He only signified that He would give no answer, and would neither listen to nor interfere in such matters as the one brought before Him.
Calvin remarks : " Christ intended, by doing nothing, to show how unworthy they were of being heard; just as if any one, while another was speaking to him, were to draw lines on the wall, or to turn his back, or to show by any other sign, that he was not attending to what was said."
I must leave the reader to choose which solution he prefers. To my eyes, I confess, there are difficulties in each view. If I must select one, I prefer the last of the five, as the simplest.
Quesnel remarks : " We never read that Jesus Christ wrote but once in His life. Let men learn from hence never to write but when it is necessary or useful, and to do it with humility and modesty, on a principle of charity, and not of malice."
So when they continued...lifted...said unto them
The Scribes and Pharisees seem to have been determined to have an answer, and to have made it necessary for our Lord to speak at last. But His first silence and significant refusal to attend were a plain proof to all around that He did not wish to interfere with the office of the magistrate, and had not come to be a judge of offences against the law. If they got an opinion from Him about this case, they could not say that He gave it willingly, but that it was extorted from Him by much importunity.
[He that is without sin. ..first cast a stone at her.'] This solemn and weighty sentence is a striking example of our Lord's perfect wisdom. He referred His questioners to Scripture. Deut. xvii.
7: " The hands of the witnesses shall be first upon him to put him to death." — It sent their minds home to their own private lives. " Whatever the woman may deserve, are you the people to find fault with her? " — It neither condemned nor justified the adulteress, and yet showed our Lord's reverence for the law of Moses. "I decline to pronounce sentence on this woman, because I am not the judge. You know yourselves what the law is in such cases as well as I do. You have no right to assume that I do not reverence the law as much as yourselves. But since you profess to honour the law of Moses so much, I remind you that this same law requires the witnesses to be the executioners. Now are you the persons who ought to punish this woman, however guilty she may be? Do you yourselves come before me with clear consciences about the seventh commandment?"
Many think that when our Lord said " he that is without sin," He meant the expression to be taken in a general sense. I cannot hold this view. It would involve the awkward conclusion that no one could be a judge at all, or punish a criminal, because no one is altogether and absolutely " without sin." I am decidedly of opinion that our Lord referred to sin against the seventh commandment. There is too much reason to think that such sin was very common among the Jews in our Lord's time. The expression " an adulterous generation " (Matt. xii. 39; xvi. 4; and Mark viii. 38) is full of meaning. (See also Rom. ii. 22; Luke xviii. 11; and James iv. 4.)
And again he stooped down, &c.
This repeated act would greatly add to the weighty solemnity of the sentence which had just fallen from our Lord's lips. " I have given my opinion ; — now what are you going to do? I wait for your reply."
And they which heard...conscience
This sentence seems to me to confirm the opinion, that when our Lord said " he that is without sin," He referred to sin against the seventh commandment. A general charge would hardly have produced the effect here described. A charge of breaking the seventh commandment would be just such an one as a man would shrink from, if made publicly. The sin is peculiarly one which brings with it afterwards a certain sense of shame. It is commonly a deed of darkness and done in secret, and the doer of it dreads the light.
The power of conscience stands out here in a very striking manner. It is a part of man's inward nature which is far too little remembered by ministers and teachers. Fallen and corrupt as man is, we must never forget that God has left him a certain sense of right and wrong, called conscience. It has no power to save, or convert, or lead to Christ. But it has a power to accuse, and prick, and witness. Such texts as Rom. ii. 15 and 2 Cor. iv. 2 should be carefully considered.
went out...beginning...eldest...last
The words "eldest "and " last " in this sentence are in the plural number, which does not appear in the English version. The oldest would probably have the greatest number of sins on their minds.
[Jesus was left alone, and the woman... midst.'] This must of course mean that the Scribes and Pharisees who accused the women were all gone away. It does not necessarily follow that the crowd of hearers who were about our Lord when the case was brought to Him had gone away. They must have stood by, and seen and heard all that passed.
When Jesus had lifted up himself, &c.
How long the pause must have been during which our Lord stooped down and wrote on the ground a second time, we are not told. But it must probably have been several minutes. When it says that our Lord " saw none but the woman," it must mean " none of the party which came and interrupted His teaching, except the woman." The accusers had disappeared, and the accused alone remained.
The question that our Lord put to the woman must have been for the satisfaction of the crowd around. Let them mark from the question and answer that the case had fallen to the ground. No evidence was offered. No accuser appeared. No sentence therefore could be pronounced, and none was needed.
She said, No man, Lord
We may observe here that our Lord, with merciful consideration, did not ask the woman whether she was guilty or not. Thus she could with truth reply to His question, and yet not criminate herself.
[Jesus said... neither do I condemn... sin no more.] The mingled kindness and perfect wisdom of this sentence deserve special notice. Our Lord says nothing of the question whether the woman deserved punishment, and what kind of punishment. He simply says " I do not condemn thee. It is not my province or offence to judge or pronounce any sentence." — Nor yet does He tell the woman that she may go away without stain or blemish on her character. On the contrary He implies that she had sinned and was guilty. But in the absence of witnesses she might go away clear of punishment. — Nor yet does He say " Go in peace," as in Luke vii. 50, and viii. 48.
"Go," He says, "and sin no more." How anyone, in the face of this text, can say that our Lord palliates and condones the woman's sin, it is rather hard to understand. That He refused to condemn her is clear and plain, because it was not His office. That He ignored or connived at her sin, as Hengstenberg says, (in his argument against the genuineness of the whole passage,) can never be proved. The very last words show what he thought of her case : — " Sin no more." She had sinned, and had only escaped from lack of evidence. Let her remember that, and' "sin no more."
Augustine remarks, "How, Lord? Dost thou then favour sin? Not so, assuredly. Mark what He says : Go, henceforth sin no more. You see then that the Lord condemned, but He condemned sin, not man. For were He a favourer of sin, He would say, neither will I condemn thee, go, live as thou wilt."
The remark of Euthymius that our Lord considered the public shame and exposure sufficient punishment for the woman's sin, is thoroughly unsatisfactory, and not warranted by anything in the context. — The view of Bullinger and some others, that one principal object of the passage is to teach our Lord's mercy and readiness to pardon great sinners, appears to me quite destitute of foundation. Christ's abounding mercy is a great truth, but not the truth of this passage. — There seems no parallel between this woman and the Samaritan woman in John iv.
Poole observes that our Lord does not merely say " Commit adultery no more. No partial repentance or sorrow for any particular sin will suffice a penitent that hopes for mercy from God; but a leaving off all sin, of what kind soever it is."
JOHN VIII. 12—20.
Let us notice, for one thing, in these verses, what the Lord Jesus says of Himself. He proclaims, " I am the light of the world."
These words imply that the world needs light, and is naturally in a dark condition. It is so in a moral and spiritual point of view : and it has been so for nearly 6,000 years. In ancient Egypt, Greece, and Rome, in modern England, France, and Germany, the same report is true. The vast majority of men neither see nor understand the value of their souls, the true nature of God, nor the reality of a world to come ! Notwithstanding all the discoveries of art and science, " darkness still covers the earth, and gross darkness the people." (Isai. lx. 2.)
For this state of things, the Lord Jesus Christ declares Himself to be the only remedy. He has risen, like the sun, to diffuse light, and life, and peace, and salvation, in the midst of a dark world. He invites all who want spiritual help and guidance to turn to Him, and take Him for their leader. What the sun is to the whole solar system — the centre of light, and heat, and life, and fertility — that He has come into the world to be to sinners.
John 8:12–20 · Open Word Bible
12Jesus spoke to them once more: "I am the light of the world. Those who follow Me will never walk in the darkness; they will have the light of life." 13The Pharisees then said to Him, "You are testifying on Your own behalf; Your testimony is not true." 14Jesus replied, "Even if I do testify on My own behalf, My testimony is true, since I know where I came from and where I am going. You, however, have no idea where I come from or where I am going. …
Then spake Jesus again...them
The expression " spake again " exactly fits in with the preceding narrative. It carries us back to the 2nd verse, where we read that our Lord was sitting in the temple and teaching the people, when the woman taken in adultery was brought before Him. This naturally interrupted and broke off His teaching for a time. But when the case was settled, and both accuser and accused had gone away, He resumed His teaching. Then the expression comes in most naturally, " He spake again." Once admit that the narrative of the woman is not genuine and must be left out, and there is really nothing with which to connect the words before us. We are obliged to look back as far as the 37th verse of the last chapter.
The same remark applies to the word "them." The natural application of it is to " the people " whom our Lord was teaching, in the 2nd verse, when the Scribes and Pharisees interrupted him. Leave out the narrative of the woman, and there is nothing to which the word "them " can be referred, except the angry council of the Pharisees at the end of the seventh chapter.
John 8:12 · Open Word Bible
12Jesus spoke to them once more: "I am the light of the world. Those who follow Me will never walk in the darkness; they will have the light of life."
I am...light...world
In this glorious expression, our Lord, we cannot doubt, declares Himself to be the promised Messiah or Saviour, of whom the prophets had spoken. The Jews would remember the words, — " I will give thee for a light of the Gentiles." (Isai. xlii. 6 ; xlix. 6.) So also Simeon had said, he would be a " light to lighten the Gentiles." (Luke ii. 32.) Why He used this figure, and what He had in His mind in choosing it, is a point on which commentators do not agree. That he referred to something before His eyes is highly probable, and in keeping with His usual mode of teaching.
(1) Some think, as Aretius, Musculus, Ecolampadius, Bullinger,and Bp. Andrews, that He referred to the sun, then rising while He spoke. What the sun was to the earth, that He came to be to mankind.
(2) Some think, as Stier, Olshausen, Besser, D. Brown, and Alford, that He referred to the great golden lamps which used to be kept burning in the temple courts. He was the true light, able to enlighten men's hearts and minds. They were nothing but ornaments, or at most, emblems.
(3) Some think, as Cyril and Lampe, that He referred to the pillar of cloud and fire which gave light to the Israelites, and guided them through the wilderness. He was the true guide to heaven, through the wilderness of this world.
The first of these three views seems to me most probable, and most in harmony with the context.
Rupertus remarks, that two grand declarations of Christ followed each other on two successive days at Jerusalem. On the last day of the feast He said, — "If any man thirst let him come unto Me and drink." (John vii. 37.) The very next day He said,—" I am the light of the world."
he that followeth me
This means " following " as a disciple, servant, traveller, soldier, or sheep. What the teacher is to the scholar, the master to the servant, the guide to the traveller, the general to the soldier, the shepherd to the sheep, that is Christ to true Christians. " Following" is the same as " believing." See Matt. xvi. 24; xix. 21; John x. 27; xii. 26. Following here, we must always remember, does not mean copying and imitating, but trusting, putting faith in another.
Musculus and Henry observe, that it is of no use that Christ is the light of the world if we do but follow Him. " Following " is the point on which all turns. It is not enough to gaze upon and admire the light. We must " follow" it.
The Pharisees...said unto him
These "Pharisees were probably some of the multitude who had come together to hear our Lord's teaching, and not those who brought the woman taken in adultery to Him. The Pharisees were a powerful and widely spread sect, and members of their body would be found in every crowd of hearers, ready to raise objections and find fault with anything our Lord said, wherever they thought there was an opportunity.
[Thou barest record of thyself.] This would be more literally rendered, " thou dost witness about thyself."
[Thy record is not true.] This means, — " thy testimony is not trustworthy, and deserving of attention." The Pharisees evidently could not mean "thy testimony is false." They only meant that it was an acknowledged principle among men that a man's testimony to his own character is comparatively worthless. Our Lord Himself had admitted this on a former occasion, when he said before the council, — " If I bear witness of myself my witness is not true." (John v. 31.) Solomon had said, — "Let another praise thee, and not thine own mouth; a stranger, and not thine own lips." (Prov. xxvii. 2.)
John 8:13 · Open Word Bible
13The Pharisees then said to Him, "You are testifying on Your own behalf; Your testimony is not true."
Jesus answered...Though I bear record...true
Our Lord meant by these words that even if He did testify of Himself, and make assertions about His own office and mission, His testimony ought not to be despised and disregarded as not trustworthy. Whether His enemies would hear it or not, what He said deserved credit, and was worthy of all acceptation. — " The testimony that I bear is not the testimony of a common witness, but of one who is thoroughly to be depended on."
[For I know whence I came, etc.'] Our Lord here gives a solemn and weighty reason why His testimony to Himself ought to be reverently received by the Jews, and not refused. That reason was His divine nature and mission. He came to them and stood before them not as a common prophet and an everyday witness, but as one who knew the mysterious truth that He was the Divine Messiah, that should come into the world. — " I know whence I came : — I came forth from the Father, to be His Messenger to a lost world. I know whither I go : — I am about to return to my Father when I have finished His work, and to sit down at His right hand after my ascension. Knowing all this, I have a right to say that my testimony is trustworthy. You, on the other hand, are utterly ignorant about me. You neither know nor believe my Divine origin nor mission. Justly, therefore, I may say that it matters little whether you think my testimony deserving of credit or not. Your eyes are blinded, and your opinion is worthless."
Chrysostom observes that our Lord " might have said, I am God. But He ever mingleth lowly words with sublime, and even these He veileth."
John 8:14 · Open Word Bible
14Jesus replied, "Even if I do testify on My own behalf, My testimony is true, since I know where I came from and where I am going. You, however, have no idea where I come from or where I am going.
Bucer, Chemnitius, and Quesnel observe that our Lord's argument is like that of an ambassador from a king, who says, — "I know my commission and Who sent Me, and therefore I claim attention to my message."
Webster paraphrases the sentence : " I speak in the full consciousness of my previous and future existence in the glory of the Father; and I therefore feel and assert my right to be believed on my own testimony. If you knew whence I came and whither I go, you would not want any other witness than myself. And this you might know if you were spiritual; but you are carnal, and judge after the flesh."
Ye judge after the flesh
The meaning of this sentence seems to be, — " You judge and decide everything on fleshly and worldly principles, according to the outward appearance. You estimate Me and my mission according to what you see with the eye. You presume to despise Me and set light by Me, because there is no outward grandeur and dignity about Me. Judging everything by such a false standard, you see no beauty in Me and my ministry. You have already set Me down in your own minds as an impostor, and worthy to die. Your minds are full of carnal prejudices, and hence my testimony seems worthless to you."
Calvin thinks that "flesh" is here used in opposition to " spirit," and that the meaning is, " You judge on carnal wicked principles," and not "You judge after the outward appearance." Most commentators think that the expression refers to our Lord's humble appearance.
John 8:15 · Open Word Bible
15You judge by human standards; I am not judging anyone.
I judge no man
In these words onr Lord puts in strong contrast the difference between Himself and His enemies. "Unlike you, I condemn and pass judgment on no man, even on the worst of sinners. It is not my present business and office, though it will be one day. I did not come into the world to condemn, but to save." (John iii. 17.) It is useless, however, to deny that the connection between the beginning and end of the verse is not clear. It seems to turn entirely on the twice- repeated word "judge," and the word appears to be used in two different senses.
Some have thought that our Lord refers to the case of the woman taken in adultery, and contrasts His own refusal to be a judge in her case, with the malicious readiness of the Pharisees to judge Him and condemn Him even when innocent. "I refuse to condemn even a guilty sinner. You on the contrary are ready to condemn Me, in whom you can find no fault, on carnal and worldly principles."
Some, as Bullinger, Jansenius, Trapp, Stier, Gill, Pearce, and Barnes have thought that the sentence before us means, — " I judge no man according to the flesh, as you do." But this view does not seem to harmonize with the following verse.
Bishop Hall paraphrases the verse thus: "Ye presume to judge according to your own carnal affections, and follow your outward senses in the judgment ye pass on Me. In the mean time ye will not endure Me, who do not challenge or reconcile that power which I might in judging you."
And yet if I judge, my judgment, &c.
This verse seems to come in parenthetically. It appears intended to remind the Jews, that if our Lord did not assume the office of a judge now, it was not because He was not qualified. The sense is as follows : "Do not however suppose, because I say that I judge no man, that I am not qualified to judge. On the contrary, if I do pass judgment on any person's actions or opinions, my judgment is perfectly correct and trustworthy. For I am not alone. There is an inseparable union between Me, and the Father that sent Me. When I judge, it is not I alone, but the Father with Me that judges. Hence, therefore, my judgment is and must be trustworthy." The reader should compare John v. 19, and 30. The doctrine is the same. That mighty truth, — the inseparable union of the Father and the Son, — is the only key that unlocks the deep expression before us. Our Lord's frequent reference to that truth, in St. John's Gospel, should be carefully noted.
John 8:16 · Open Word Bible
16Yet even if I do judge, My judgment is true, because I am not alone in it: it is I together with the Father who sent Me.
It is also written, &c.
Our Lord, in this verse, reminds the Jews of an admitted principle of the law of Moses,— that the testimony of two witnesses deserved credit. (Deut. xvii. 6; xix. 15.) " You will admit that the testimony of two witnesses deserves credit at any rate, although one witness alone may prove nothing. Now, admitting this, hear what testimony I can adduce to the divine character of my mission."
Let it be noted, that where our Lord says " in your law," He did not mean that He was above the law and did not recognize its authority. He only intended, by laying stress on the word "your," to remind the Jews that it was their own honoured law of Moses, to which they were continually professing to refer, that laid down the great principle to which He was about to direct their attention. "It is written in the law that you speak of so much, and that you so often quote."
It admits of consideration whether our Lord did not mean to use the expression " of two men " emphatically. It may be that He would put in strong contrast the testimony of two mere men, with the testimony of Himself and his Father in heaven. It is like the expression, " If we receive the witness of men, the witness of God is greater." (1 John v. 9.) At any rate the word rendered " men " is emphatic in the Greek.
John 8:17 · Open Word Bible
17Even in your own law it is written that the testimony of two people is true.
am one, &c.
The connection and sense of this verse are as follows : " Admitting that the testimony of two witnesses is trustworthy, I bid you observe that there are two witnesses to My divine nature and mission. I myself, the Eternal Son, am one of these witnesses : I am ever testifying concerning myself. The Father that sent Me into the world is the other witness : He is ever testifying concerning Me. He has testified by the mouth of the Prophets in the Old Testament. He is testifying now by the miraculous works which He is continually doing by My hands." The reader should compare John v. 31 — 39.
There is undeniably something very remarkable about this verse. It seems a singular condescension on our Lord's part to use the train of argument that it contains. The true solution probably lies in the very high dignity of the two witnesses, whom He places together before the Jews. The Greek words beginning the verse are peculiar, and can hardly be rendered in English. They will almost bear to be translated, — " I, the great I am, am the person witnessing about myself; and the Father," etc.
Chrysostom and Theophylact both remark that our Lord here claims equality of honour with the Father, by putting His testimony and the Father's side by side.
Poole remarks : " Our Saviour must not be understood here to distinguish Himself from His Father in respect of His divine being, for so He and His Father are one; but in respect of His office, as He was sent, and His Father was He who sent Him."
John 8:18 · Open Word Bible
18I am one who testifies about Myself, and the Father who sent Me also testifies about Me."
Then said they...Where is thy Father
This question of the Jews was probably not asked in a tone of serious inquiry, or from real desire to know. It was more likely sneering and sarcastic.
Calvin observes, "By these words they meant that they did not so highly value Christ's Father as to ascribe anything to the Son on His account."
Hengstenberg bids us observe that they did not ask, "Who is thy Father? " but " Where is thy Father? " It sounds as if they looked round in contempt, as if scornfully expecting an earthly father to stand forth and testify to Christ.
[Jesus answered. Ye neither know me... Father.] Our Lord here tells His enemies that they were ignorant both of Himself and of His Father in heaven. With all their pride of knowledge and fancied high attainments they knew nothing rightly either of the Father or the Son. The expression certainly favours the idea that the expression " Ye know me," (John vii. 28,) must be taken as a slight sarcasm.
Let it be noted that great familiarity with the letter of Scripture is perfectly compatible with gross spiritual darkness. The Pharisees knew the Old Testament prophecies well; but they neither knew God nor Christ.
John 8:19 · Open Word Bible
19So they asked Him, "Where is Your father?" Jesus answered, "You do not know Me, and you do not know My Father either. If you knew Me, you would know My Father as well."
if ye had known me...my Father also
These words teach plainly that ignorance of Christ and ignorance of God are inseparably connected. The man who thinks he knows anything rightly of God while he is ignorant of Christ is completely deceived. The God whom he thinks he knows is not the God of the Bible, but a God of his own fancy's invention. At any rate he can have a most imperfect conception of God, and can have but little idea of His perfect holiness, justice, and purity. The words teach also that Christ is the way by which we must come to the knowledge of God. In Him, through Him, and by Him, we may come boldly into the Father's presence, and behold His high attributes without fear.
He that would have saving, soul-satisfying religion, and become a friend and servant of God, must begin with Christ. Knowing Him as his Saviour and Advocate, he will find it easy and pleasant to know God the Father. Those that reject Christ, like the Jews, will live and die in ignorance of God, however learned and clever they may be. But the poorest, humblest man, that lays hold on Christ and begins with Him, shall find out enough about God to make him happy forever. In the matter of becoming acquainted with God it is the first step to know Jesus Christ, the Mediator, and to believe on Him.
rht here is the same as that in the words spoken to Philip, when in reply to Philip's question, "Lord, show us the Father," Jesus said, "He that hath seen Me hath seen the Father." (John xiv. 8, 9.) I think this is at least doubtful. The thing that Philip needed to know was the precise relation between the Father and Son. The thing that the Jews needed was a right knowledge of God altogether.
These words spake Jesus...treasury...temple
This sentence seems meant to mark a pause or break in the discourse, and to show also how publicly and openly our Lord proclaimed His Messiahship. It was in a well-known part of the temple called the treasury that He declared Himself to be " the light of the world," and defended His testimony.
Calvin thinks that " the treasury was a part of the temple where the sacred offerings were laid up, and therefore a much frequented place."
[No man laid hands on him.] The remark made on a former occasion applies here. (John vii. 30.) A divine restraint was laid on our Lord's enemies. They felt unable to lift a finger against Him. They had the will to hurt, but not the power.
John 8:20 · Open Word Bible
20He spoke these words in the treasury area while He was teaching in the temple courts. Yet no one arrested Him, because His hour had not yet come.
his hour was not yet come
The same deep thought that we remarked in ch. vii. 30, comes up here again. There was a certain fixed time during which our Lord's ministry was to last, and till that time was expired His enemies could not touch Him. When the time had expired, our Lord said, "This is your hour, and the power of darkness." (Luke xxii. 53.)
The expression should be carefully noticed, and remembered by all true Christians. It teaches that the wicked can do no harm to Christ and His members until God gives them permission. Not a hair of a believer's head can be touched until God in His sovereign wisdom allows it. — It teaches that all times are in God's hand. There is an allotted " hour " both for doing and for suffering. Till the hour comes for dying no Christian will die. When the hour comes nothing can prevent his death. These are comfortable truths, and deserve attention. Christ's members are safe and immortal till their work is done. When they suffer it is because God wills it and sees it good.
Quesnel remarks : " A man enjoys the greatest peace of mind when he has once settled himself in a firm and steadfast belief of God's providence, and an absolute dependence upon His design and will."
JOHN VIII. 21—30.
We learn, for one thing, that it is possible to seek Christ in vain. Our Lord says to the unbelieving Jews, " Ye shall seek Me, and shall die in your sins." He meant, by these words, that the Jews would one day seek Him in vain.
The lesson before us is a very painful one. That such a Saviour as the Lord Jesus, so full of love, so willing to save, should ever be sought " in vain," is a sorrowful thought. Yet so it is ! A man may have many religious feelings about Christ, without any saving religion Sickness, sudden affliction, the fear of death, the failure of usual sources of comfort — all these causes may draw out of a man a good deal of " religiousness." Under the immediate pressure of these he may say his prayers fervently, exhibit a strong spiritual feelings, and profess for a season to " seek Christ," and be a different man. And yet all this time his heart may never be touched at all ! Take away the peculiar circumstances that affected him, and he may possibly return at once to his old ways. He sought Christ " in vain," because he sought Him from false motives, and not with his whole heart.
John 8:21–30 · Open Word Bible
21Once more He said to them, "I am going away, and you will search for Me, and you will die in your sin. You cannot come where I am going." 22At this the Jewish leaders said, "Surely He is not going to kill Himself? Is that why He says, 'You cannot come where I am going'?" 23He went on to say to them, "You come from below; I come from above. You are from this world; I am not from this world. …
Then said Jesus again unto them
There seems a break or pause between this verse and the preceding one. It is as if our Lord resumed discourse with a new leading thought or key-note. The other idea, viz., that " again "refers to chap. vii. 34, and means that our Lord impressed on His hearers a second time that He would soon leave them, does not seem probable. — It seems not unlikely that in the first instance our Lord spoke of " going" to the officers of the priests and Pharisees, and that here He speaks to their masters, or at least to a different set of hearers.
[I go my way.] This must mean, " I am soon about to leave this world. 'My mission is drawing to a close. The time of My decease and sacrifice approaches, and I must depart, and go back to My Father in heaven* from whence I came. " — The leading object of the sentence appears to be to excite in the minds of the Jews thought and inquiry about His divine nature. " I am one who came from heaven, and am going back to heaven. Ought you not to inquire seriously who I am?"
Chrysostom thinks our Lord said this, partly to shame and terrify the Jews, and partly to show them that His death would not be affected by their violence, but by His own voluntary submission.
John 8:21 · Open Word Bible
21Once more He said to them, "I am going away, and you will search for Me, and you will die in your sin. You cannot come where I am going."
ye shall seek me...die in...sins
This means that His hearers would seek Him too late, having discovered too late that He was the Messiah whom they ought to have received. But the door of mercy would then be shut. They would seek in vain, because they had not known the day of their visitation. And the result would be that many of them would die miserably " in their sins," — with their sins upon them unpardoned and unforgiven.
[Whither I go ye cannot come.] This must mean heaven, the everlasting abode of glory which the Son had with the Father before He came into the world, which He left for a season when He became incarnate, and to which He returned when He had finished the work of man's redemption. To this a wicked man cannot come. Unbelief shuts him out. It is impossible in the nature of things that an unforgiven, unconverted, unbelieving man can go to heaven. The words in Greek are emphatic, — " Ye cannot come."
The notion of Augustine and others that " ye shall seek Me" only means " ye shall seek Me in order to kill Me, as ye are wishing to do now, but at last I shall be withdrawn from your reach," — seems to me quite untenable. The "seeking," to my mind, can only be the too late seeking of remorse. — The theory of some, that it refers exclusively to the time of the siege of Jerusalem by the Romans, seems to me equally untenable. My belief is that from the time that our Lord left the world down to this day, the expression has been peculiarly true of the Jewish nation. They have been perpetually, in a sense, " seeking" and hungering after a Messiah, and yet unable to find Him, because they have not sought aright. — In saying this we must carefully remember that our Lord did not mean to say that any of His hearers were too sinful and bad to be forgiven. On the contrary, not a few of them that crucified Him found mercy on the clay of Pentecost, when Peter preached. (Acts ii. 22 — 40.) But our Lord did mean to say prophetically that the Jewish, nation, as a nation, would be specially hardened and unbelieving, and that many of them, though an elect remnant might be saved, would "die in their sins." In proof of this peculiar blindness and unbelief of the Jewish nation we should study Acts xxviii. 25 — 27 ; Romans xi. 7, and 1 Thess. ii. 15, 16. The Greek expression for " sins" in this verse confirms the view. It is not, literally rendered, "sins," but "sin," — your special sin of unbelief.
Then said the Jews, &c.
It is plain that this last saying of our Lord perplexed His enemies. It evidently implied something which they did not understand. In the preceding chapter (vii. 34) they began speculating whether it meant that our Lord was going forth into the world to teach the Gentiles. Here they start another conjecture, and begin to suspect that our Lord must mean His going into another world by death. But by what death did He think of going? Did He mean to "kill Himself?" It seems strange that they should start such an idea. But may it not be that their minds were occupied with their own plan of putting Him to death? " Will He really anticipate our plan, by committing suicide, and thus escape our hands?"
Origen suggests that the Jews had a tradition about the manner in which Messiah would die: viz., "that He would have power to depart at His own time, and in a way of His own choosing."
Rupertus observes that afterwards, at the siege of Jerusalem by Titus, many of the desperate Jews did the very thing they here said of our Lord — they killed themselves in madness of despair.
Melancthon remarks that nothing seems to anger wicked men so much as to be told they cannot come where Christ is.
John 8:22 · Open Word Bible
22At this the Jewish leaders said, "Surely He is not going to kill Himself? Is that why He says, 'You cannot come where I am going'?"
And he said unto them, Ye are from beneath, &c.
Our Lord's argument in this case appears to be as follows : ""There is no union, harmony, or fellowship between you and Me. Your minds are entirely absorbed find buried in earth and objects of a mere earthly kind. You are from beneath, and of this world ; while I came from heaven, and My heart is full of the things of heaven and My Father's business. No wonder, therefore, that I said you cannot come where I go, and will die in your sins. Unless your hearts are changed, and you learn to be of one mind with Me, you are totally unmeet for heaven, and must at last die in your sins."
The expressions "from beneath" and "from above" are strong figurative phrases, intended to put in contrast earth and heaven. (See Col. iii. 1, 2.) The Greek phrases literally rendered would be, — " Ye are from the things beneath : I am from the things above.
The expression " of this world " means bound up with, and inseparably connected by, tastes, aims, and affections, with this world, and nothing else but this world. It is the character of one utterly dead and graceless, who looks at nothing but the world, and lives for it. It is a character utterly at variance with that of our Lord, who was eminently " not of this world;" and therefore those who were of this character were incapable of union and friendship with Him.
John 8:23 · Open Word Bible
23He went on to say to them, "You come from below; I come from above. You are from this world; I am not from this world.
Let it be noted that what our Lord says of Himself here is the very same thing that is said of His true disciples elsewhere. If a man has grace he is " not of this world." (See John xv. 19; xvii. 16; and 1 John iv 5.) Christ's living members always have more or less of their Master's likeness in this respect. They are always more or less separated from and distinct from this world. He that is thoroughly worldly has the plainest mark of not being a member of Christ and a true Christian.
Theophylact observes that the strange notion of the Apollinarian heretics, that our Lord's body was not a real human body, but came down from heaven, was built on this verse for one of its reasons. But, as he remarks, they might as well say the Apostles had not common human bodies, since the same thing is said of them — " not of this world."
I said therefore, &c.
This verse seems elliptical, and must be filled up in some such manner as this: " It is because you are thoroughly earthly and of this world, that I said, Ye cannot come where I go. You are not heavenly minded, and cannot go to heaven, but must go to your own place. The end will be that you will die in your sins. Not believing in Me as the Messiah, you cut yourselves off from all hope, and must die in your sins. This, in short, is the root of all your misery — your unbelief."
Let it be noted that unbelief is the thing that specially ruins men. All manner of sin may be forgiven. But unbelief bars the door against mercy. (Mark xvi. 26, and John iii. 36.)
Let it be noted that unbelief was the secret of the Jews being so thoroughly " of the world." If they would only have believed in Christ, they would have been " delivered from this present evil world." The victory that overcomes the world is faith. Once believing on a heavenly Saviour a man has a portion and a heart in heaven. (Gal. i. 4 ; 1 John v. 4, 5.)
Let it be noted that there is nothing hard or uncharitable in warning men plainly of the consequences of unbelief. Never to speak of hell is not acting as Christ did.
The expression "believe not that I am He" would be more literally rendered " believe not that I am." Hence some think that our Lord refers to the great name, well known to the Jews, under which God revealed Himself to Israel in Egypt, — " Say unto the children of Israel, I AM hath sent you." (Ex. iii. 14.)
John 8:24 · Open Word Bible
24That is why I told you that you will die in your sins. For unless you believe that I am, you will die in your sins."
Augustine remarks that "the whole unhappiness of the Jews was not that they had sin, but to die in sins." He also observes : "In these words, Except ye believe that I am, Jesus meant nothing short of this, Except ye believe that I am God, ye shall die in your sins. It is well for us, thank God, that He said except ye believe, and not except ye understand."
Quesnel remarks: "It is a mistaken prudence to hide these dreadful truths from sinners, for fear of casting them into despair by the force of God's judgments. We ought, on the contrary, to force them, by the sight of danger, to throw themselves into the arms of Christ, the only refuge for sinners."
And Jesus saith...Even the same...beginning
Our Lord's reply here seems so guarded and cautious, that it increases the probability of the Jews' question being put with a malicious intention. He knew their thoughts and designs, and answered them by reminding them what He had always said of Himself: " Why ask Me who I am? You know well what I have always said of Myself. I am the same that I said to you from the beginning. I have nothing new to say."
Scott thinks it simply means, " I am the same that I told you at the beginning of this discourse, — the Light of the World."
There is an undeniable difficulty and obscurity about the sentence before us, and it has consequently received three different interpretations. The difficulty arises chiefly from the word " beginning."
(a) Some think, as our own English version, Chrysostom, Calvin, Bucer, Gualter, Cartwright, Rollock, and Lightfoot, that "beginning" means the beginning of our Lord's ministry. " I am the same person that I told you I was from the very first beginning of My ministry among you." This view is confirmed by the Septuagint rendering of Gen. xliii. 18, 20.
(b) Some think, as Theophylact, Melancthon, Aretius, and Musculus, that "beginning" is an adverb, and means simply, " as an opening or beginning statement." " First of all, as a commencement of My reply, I tell you that I am what I always said I was."
(c) Some think, as Augustine, Rupertus, Toletus, Ferus, Jansenius, Lampe, and Wordsworth, that " beginning " is a substantive, and means the Beginning of all things, the personal Beginning, like " I am the Alpha and the Omega, the Beginning and the End." (Rev. i. 8; xxi. 6; xxii. 13.) It would then mean, " I am the great beginning of all things, the eternal God, as I always said."
John 8:25 · Open Word Bible
25So they asked Him, "Just who are You?" Jesus said to them, "Why am I even talking to you at all?
The reader must exercise his own judgment on these three views. The extreme brevity and conciseness of the Greek words make it very hard to give a decided opinion upon them. On the whole, I prefer the view taken by our translators. In three other places in St. John's Gospel our Lord speaks of His early ministry as "the beginning." (John vi. 64; xv. 27; xvi. 4.) In no place in St. John's Gospel does He ever call Himself "the beginning." As to the second view, that it only means, "First of all, as an opening statement," it seems to me so meagre, flat and bald, that I cannot think it is correct.
Rollock, who takes the view of our English version, observes what a bright example onr Lord here sets to all Christians, and especially to ministers, of always telling the same story, and witnessing one and the same confession without variation.
I have many things, &c.
This verse again is very elliptical. This meaning seems to be as follows: "You marvel and are angry at My saying that you are from beneath, and will die in your sin, and cannot come where I go. You ask who I am that speak and judge in this manner. But I tell you that I have many other things that I might say, and other judgments that I might pronounce about you. But I forbear now. Yet I tell you that He who sent Me is the one true God ; and I only speak to the world things which I have heard of Him, and am commissioned by Him to proclaim. He that sent Me will prove them to be true one day."
The general idea seems to be that our Lord defends His right to speak decidedly and pronounce judgment on His enemies' conduct on the ground of His divine mission. " I have a right to say what I have said ; and I might say much more, because I am not a common prophet, but am commissioned and sent as the Word of the Father."
The frequency with which our Lord speaks of Himself as " sent by the Father," in St. John's Gospel, should be carefully noticed.
When our Lord speaks of Himself as " hearing" things from the Father, we must remember that His language is accommodated to our understanding. The relation between the Father and the Son in the Trinity is something too mysterious for us fully to comprehend. The Son does not really and literally need the Father to " speak " to Him, and does not himself need to "hear" Him. The first and second Persons in the Trinity are ineffably united, though two distinct Persons.
John 8:26 · Open Word Bible
26I have much to say about you, and much to judge. But the one who sent Me is true, and I tell the world what I have heard from Him."
Lightfoot thinks the latter part of this verse means: "He that sent Me hath of old said and judged of you, and He is true, and they are true things that He said. Of this kind are the passages Isaiah xi. 10, and xxix. 10, and from such predictions Christ concludes thus — " ye shall die in your sins."'
They understood not, &c.
Why the Jews who heard these words did not comprehend that our Lord spoke of the " Father" is not clear. They must have thought that " He that sent Me " meant some earthly sender. The extent to which our Lord's hearers sometimes understood Him, as in John v. 18, and sometimes did not understand Him, as here, is a curious subject.
Alford observes : " There is no accounting for the ignorance of unbelief; as any minister of Christ knows by painful experience."
John 8:27 · Open Word Bible
27They did not understand that He was speaking to them about the Father.
Then said Jesus, &c.
This verse is phrophetical. Our Lord predicts that after His crucifixion the Jews would know that He was the Messiah, that He had done all he had done not of His own private authority, but by God's commission, and that He had spoken to the world only such things as the Father had taught and appointed Him to speak. But whether our Lord meant that His hearers would really believe with the heart and really confess His Messiahship, or that they would know it too late and be convinced when the day of grace was past and gone, is a nice and difficult question.
My own opinion, judging from the context and the analogy of other places, is in favour of the latter view: viz., that our Lord predicted the Jewish nation would know the truth and discover their own mistake too late. I think so because our Lord seems so frequently to allude to the light which would come on the minds of the Jewish nation at large after His death. They would be convinced, though not converted.
Chrysostom thinks that our Lord meant, " Do you expect that you shall certainly rid yourselves of Me, and slay Me ? I toll you that then ye shall most surely know that I am, by reason of the miracle of my resurrection, and the destruction of Jerusalem. When ye have been driven away from your place of worship, and it is not even allowed you to serve God as hitherto, then ye shall know that He doth this to avenge Me, and because He is wroth with those who would not hear Me."
Augustine takes the other side, and says: "Without doubt Jesus saw there some whom He knew, whom in His foreknowledge lie had elected together with His other saints before the foundation of the world, that after His passion they should believe."
John 8:28 · Open Word Bible
28So Jesus said, "When you have lifted up the Son of Man, then you will know that I am, and that I do nothing on My own, but I say these things just as the Father taught Me.
Euthymius, agreeing with Chrysostom, remarks how the crowds that saw our Lord crucified, and returned home smiting their breasts, — the centurion who superintended His crucifixion,— the chief priests who tried in vain to stifle the report of His resurrection, — and Josephus the historian, who attributed the misfortunes of the nation to their murder of Christ, — were all witnesses to the truth of this verse. When too late they knew who our Lord was.
Alford thinks that the words admit of a double fulfilment, and that the Jews were to " know " that Jesus was the Christ, in two different ways. Some would know by being converted, some by being punished and judged.
The expression " lifted up," both here and elsewhere in St. John's Gospel, can mean nothing but our Lord's crucifixion and lifting up on the cross. (John iii. 14, and xii. 32.) It is never used in any other sense, and the modern habit of talking of Christ as " lifted up," when magnified and exalted in the pulpit, is a total misapprehension, and a play upon words.
Rollock and others think that the phrase "lifted up" may fairly include all the consequences and effects of our Lord's crucifixion, such as His second advent to judge the world, and that this will be the time when the unbelieving will at last know and be convinced that Christ is Lord of all. But the idea seems far-fetched.
The expression " then ye shall know" may possibly refer both to our Lord's resurrection as well as his crucifixion. Certainly the rising again from the dead silenced our Lord's enemies in a way that nothing else ever did.
The expression "that I am he," here as elsewhere, might be equally well rendered " that I am ; " that I am the great " I AM," the Messiah.
The phrase " that I do nothing of myself" is the same that we have had frequently before, as in John v. 19, 30. It means "that I do nothing of My own independent authority." The reference is to the perfect union between the Son and the Father.
The expression, " as my Father hath taught Me I speak these things," again bears special reference to the divine commission of our Lord and the perfect union between Himself and His Father. " I do not speak the things I speak of Myself and by My own authority only. I speak nothing but what My Father has taught, commissioned, and appointed Me to speak." Compare 7th, 16th, and 26th verses of this chapter.
Augustine says here : " Do not as it were represent to yourselves two men, the one father, the other son, and the father speaking to the son, as thou doest when thou sayest certain words to thy son advising and instructing him how to speak, that whatever he has heard from thee he may commit to memory, and having committed to memory utter also with the tongue. Do not so conceive. Stature and motion of the body, the office of the tongue, distinction of sounds, do not go about to conceive them in the Trinity." Again : " incorporeally the Father spake to the Son, because incorporeally the Father begat the Son. And He taught Him not, as if He had begotten Him ignorant and in need of teaching; but this ' taught' is the same as begat Him knowing."
And he that sent me, &c.
This verse contains once more that deep and oft-repeated truth, the entire unity between God the Father, and the Lord Jesus Christ, and the consequent entire and complete harmony between the mind of the Father and the mind of the Son. It contains moreover that entire and complete performance of the Father's will by the Son, and that perfect righteousness, obedience, and holiness, wherewith the Father is well-pleased.
When we read such words as "he that sent Me is with Me," and " hath not left Me alone," we must remember that there is much in them which we cannot fully explain. We must be content to believe that the Father was " with " the Son, and never "left" Him during the whole period of His incarnation, in an ineffable and inscrutable manner. Perhaps also there is a reference to Isai. 1. 7, 8, 9.
Augustine remarks: "Albeit both are together, yet one was sent, and the other did send. The Father sent the Son, yet quitted not the Son."
When we read such words as " I do always those things that please Him," we must see in the expression a description of that spotless perfection with which the Son during His incarnation constantly pleased the eternal Father.
Let Christians never forget the practical lesson that in this verse, as in many other places, Christ is their example and their encouragement. Like Him, however short they may come, let them aim at " always doing what pleases God." Like Him, let them be sure that so doing they will find the Father " with them," and will never be left quite " alone."
John 8:29 · Open Word Bible
29The one who sent Me is with Me. He has not left Me alone, because at all times I do what is pleasing to Him."
Calvin remarks : " This is the courage with which we ought to be animated in the present clay, that we may not give way on account of the small number of believers: for though the whole world be opposed to His doctrine, still we are not alone. Hence it is evident how foolish is the boasting of the Papists, who, while they neglect God, proudly boast of their vast numbers."
As he spake these words, many believed on him
There can be little doubt that " these words " in this place, refer to the whole discourse which was delivered at this time, and not to the [single verse which immediately precedes this one. It is possible that the reference to Isai. 1-. 7, 8, 9, may have brought light to the Jews' minds, and explained our Lord's relation to the Father, and His claim to be received as the Messiah.— Otherwise it is not very clear what it was that made " many believe" on Him at this juncture. There is, however, no reason to think that the " belief " here was anything more than a head belief that our Lord was the Messiah. That many did so believe whose hearts remained unchanged, there can be little doubt. The same expression occurs at x. 42, and xi. 45, and xii. 42. The extent to which men may be intellectually convinced of the truth of religion, and know their duty, while their hearts are unrenewed, and they continue in sin, is one of the most painful phenomena in the history of human nature. Let us never be content with believing things to be true, without a personal laying hold on the living Person, Christ Jesus, and actually following Him.
Chrysostom observes : " They believed, yet not as they ought, but carelessly and by chance, being pleased and refreshed by the humility of the words. For that they had not perfect faith, the Evangelist shows by their speeches after this, in which they insult him again." Theophylact, Zwingle, and Calvin take the same view.
John 8:30 · Open Word Bible
30While He was saying this, many people came to believe in Him.
JOHN VIII. 31—36.
These verses show us, for one thing, the importance of steady perseverance in Christ's service. There were many, it seems, at this particular period, who professed to believe on our Lord, and expressed a desire to become His disciples. There is nothing to show that they had true faith. They appear to have acted under the influence of temporary excitement, without considering what they were doing. And to them our Lord addresses this instructive warning, — " If ye continue in My word, then are ye My disciples indeed."
This sentence contains a mine of wisdom. To make a beginning in religious life is comparatively easy. Not a few mixed motives assist us. The love of novelty, the praise of well-meaning but indiscreet professors, the secret self-satisfaction of feeling " how good I am/' the universal excitement attending a new position, — all these things combine to aid the young beginner. Aided by them he begins to run the race that leads to heaven, lays aside many bad habits, takes up many good ones, has many comfortable frames and feelings, and gets on swimmingly for a time. But. when the newness of his position is past and gone, when the freshness of his feelings is rubbed off and lost, when the world and the devil begin to pull hard at him, when the weakness of his own heart begins to appear, — then it is that he finds out the real difficulties of vital Christianity. Then it is that he discovers the deep wisdom of our Lord's saying now before us. It is not beginning, but " continuing " a religious profession, that is the test of true grace.
John 8:31–36 · Open Word Bible
31Then Jesus said to the Jews who had believed Him, "If you remain in My word, you really are My disciples. 32You will know the truth, and the truth will free you." 33They answered Him, "We are descended from Abraham, and we have never been slaves to anybody. What do You mean, 'You will become free'?" …
Then said...Jews...believed...him
It is clear, I think, from the tone of the conversation that runs from this verse uninterruptedly to the end of the chapter, that this "believing " was not faith of the heart. These Jews only " believed " that our Lord was One sent from heaven, and deserved attention. But they were the same Jews to whom He says by and by, "Ye are of your father the devil."
[If ye continue... my word. ..disciples indeed.] This sentence does not mean that these Jews had really begun to receive Christ's word into their hearts. Such a sense would be contradictory to the context. It must mean : " If you take up a firm stand on that Gospel and Word of Truth which I have come to proclaim, and go on sticking firmly to it in your hearts and lives, not merely convinced and wishing, but actually following Me, then you are truly My disciples."— The word rendered " indeed " is more literally, "truly." The converse throws light on our Lord's meaning: "You are not truly disciples, unless you continue steadfast in My doctrine."
Our Lord teaches the great principle, that steady continuance is the only real and safe proof of discipleship. No perseverance, no grace ! No continuance in the word, no real faith and conversion ! This is one of the meeting-points between Calvinist and Arminian. He that has true grace will not fall away. He that falls away has no true grace, and must not flatter himself he is a disciple.
John 8:31 · Open Word Bible
31Then Jesus said to the Jews who had believed Him, "If you remain in My word, you really are My disciples.
Let us note, that it is not the "word continuing in us," but " our continuing in the word," which makes us true disciples. The distinction is very important. The word " might continue in us," and not be seen. If we " continue in the word," our lives will show it. In John xv. 7, we have both expressions together: " If ye abide in Me, and My words abide in you."
And ye shall know the truth
The expression, " the truth." here cannot, I think, mean the Personal Truth, the Messiah. It must be the whole doctrinal truth concerning Myself, My nature, My mission, and My Gospel. Steady continuance in My service shall lead to clear knowledge. It is a parallel saying to the sentence, "If any man will do His will, he shall know of the doctrine." (vii. 17.) Honest obedience and steady perseverance in acting up to our light, and doing what we learn, are one grand secret of obtaining more knowledge.
Chrysostom however thinks that our Lord means by " truth," Himself. " Ye shall know Me, for I am the truth." So also Augustine, Theophylact, Euthymius, and Lampe.
John 8:32 · Open Word Bible
32You will know the truth, and the truth will free you."
the truth shall make you free
This freedom can only mean spiritual freedom, — freedom from the guilt, burden, and dominion of sin, — freedom from the heavy yoke of Pharisaism, under which many Jews were labouring and heavy laden. (Matt. xi. 28.) " The Gospel I preach, and its good news, shall deliver you from spiritual bondage, and make you feel like men set at liberty."
I think these words must have been spoken with special reference to the bondage and spiritual slavery in which the Jews were kept by their principal teachers, when our Lord came among them.' In the synagogue at Nazareth He had said, that He came " to preach deliverance to the captives." (Luke iv. 18.) This, however, is the first place in the Gospels where He openly declares that His Gospel will give men freedom.
Until truth comes into a man's heart, he never really knows what it is to feel true spiritual liberty.
Augustine says, " To Christ let us all flee. Against sin let us call on God to interpose as our Liberator. Let us ask to be taken on sale, that we may be redeemed by His blood."
They answered him, We be Abraham’s seed
Here we see the usual pride of carnal descent coming out in the Jewish mind. It is just what John the Baptist told them when he preached, "Think not to say that we have Abraham to our father." (Matt. iii. 19.)
[And to ere never in bondage to any man.] This is the blindness of pride in its strongest form. The seed of Abraham were in bondage to the Egyptians and Babylonians for many years, to say nothing of the frequent bondages to Philistines, and other nations, as recorded in the book of Judges. Even now, while they spoke, they were in subjection to the Romans. The power of self-deception in unconverted man is infinite. These Jews were not more unreasonable than many now-a-days, who say, " We are not dead in sin, — we have grace, we have faith, we are regenerate, we have the Spirit," while their lives show plainly that they are totally mistaken.
John 8:33 · Open Word Bible
33They answered Him, "We are descended from Abraham, and we have never been slaves to anybody. What do You mean, 'You will become free'?"
how sayest thou...made free
This question was partly asked in anger and resentment, and partly in curiosity. Angry as the Jews were at the idea of being subject to any one, they yet caught at the expression "be made free." It made them think of the glorious kingdom of Messiah foretold in the Prophets. — ■ " Art Thou going to restore the kingdom to Israel? Art Thou going to set us free from the Romans? "
We should observe here, as elsewhere, the readiness of our Lord's hearers to put a carnal sense on spiritual language. Nicodemus misunderstanding the new birth, the Samaritan woman and the living waters, the Capernaites and the bread from heaven, are all illustrations of what I mean. (See John iii. 4; iv. 11; vi. 34.)
Pearce thinks the Jews here spoke of themselves individually, and not of the Jewish nation. Yet surely, even when they spoke, they were subject to the Romans.
Henry observes : " Carnal hearts are sensible of no other grievances than those that molest the body and injure their secular affairs. Talk to them of encroachments on their civil liberty and property, — tell of waste committed on their lands, or damage done -to their houses, and they understand you very well, and can give you a sensible answer : the thing touches and affects them. But discourse to them of the bondage of sin, or captivity to Satan, and a liberty by Christ, — tell them of wrong done to their souls, and you bring strange things to them."
Jesus answered, &c.
In this verse our Lord shows His hearers what kind of freedom He had meant, by showing the kind of slavery from which He wished them to be delivered. Did they ask in what sense He meant they should be made free? Let them know, first of all, that in their present state of mind, wicked, worldly, and unbelieving, they were in a state of bondage. Living in habitual sin they were the "servants of sin." This was a general proposition which they themselves must admit. The man that lived wilfully in habits of sin was acknowledged by all to be the slave of sin. Sin ruled over him, and he was its servant. This was an axiom in religion which they could not dispute, for even heathen philosophers admitted it. (See Rom vi. 16—20; 2 Pet. ii. 19.)
" Committeth," we must remember here, does not mean " commits an act of sin," but habitually lives in the commission of sin. It is in this sense that St. John says, " He that committeth sin is of the devil," and " He that is born of God doth not commit sin." (1 John iii. 8, 9.)
John 8:34 · Open Word Bible
34Jesus answered, "Truly, truly, I tell you, everyone who goes on sinning is a slave of sin.
And the servant abideth not, &c.
This is a difficult, because a very elliptical verse. The leading object in our Lord's mind seems to be to show the Jews the servile and slavish condition in which they were, so long as they rejected Him, the true Messiah, and the free and elevated position which they would occupy if they would believe in Him and become His disciples. — " At present, living under the bondage of the ceremonial law, and content with it and Pharisaic traditions, you are no better than slaves and servants, liable, like Hagar and Ishmael, to be cast out of God's favour and presence at any moment. — Receiving Me and believing on Me as the Messiah, you would at once be lifted to the position of sons, and would abide forever in God's favour, as adopted children and dear sons and daughters. — You know yourselves that the servant has no certain tenure in the house, and may be cast out at any time; while the Son is heir to the Father, and has a certain tenure in the house forever.—Know that I wish you to be raised from the relation of servants to that of sons. Now, under the bondage you are in, you are like slaves. Receiving Me and My Gospel you would become children and free."
John 8:35 · Open Word Bible
35A slave does not remain in the household for good; a son remains for good.
Something like this seems the leading idea in our Lord's mind. But it is vain to deny that it is a dark and difficult sentence, and requires much filling up and paraphrasing to complete its meaning. The simplest plan is to take it as a parenthesis. It then becomes a comment on the word " servant," which to a Jew, familiar with the story of Hagar and Ishmael, would be very instructive, and would convey the latent thought that our Lord wished them to be not servants but sons. I cannot for a moment think that " the Son" in the last clause means the Son of God, or that the whole clause was meant to teach His eternity.
It is certainly possible that a deep mystical sense may lie under the words " servant " and " son " in this verse. " Servant" may mean the Jew, content with the inferior and servile religion of Moses. " Son " may mean the believer in Christ, who receives the adoption and enjoys Gospel liberty. He that is content with Judaism will find his system and religion soon pass away. He that enters into Christ's service will find himself a son forever. But this is at best only conjectural, and a somewhat questionable interpretation.
One thing, at any rate, is very clear to my mind. The latent thought in our Lord's mind is a reference to the story of Hagar and her son Ishmael being cast out as bond-servants, while Isaac the son and heir abode in the house. He wished to impress on His hearer's minds, that he desired them, like Isaac, to have the privilege of sons forever, and to be free to all eternity. Keeping this thought in view, and regarding the verse as a parenthesis, its difficulties are not insuperable.
Chrysostom says : " ' Abideth not' means ' hath not power to grant favours, as not being master of the house; ' but the Son is master of the house." The Jewish priests were the servants, and Christ was the Son. The priests had no power to set free;
the Son of God had. Theophylact and Euthymius take the same view.
Maldonatus calls attention to the expression in Hebrews, where Moses and Christ are put in contrast, and each in connection with the word " house," Moses as a servant, Christ as a Son. St. Paul certainly seems there to refer to this passage. (Heb. iii. 2, 5, 6.)
If the Son therefore shall make you free, &c.
In this verse our Lord explains what He had meant by freedom. It was a freedom from sin, its guilt, and power, and consequences, which believers in Him were to receive. " If I, the Son of man, make you free, in the sense of delivering you from the burden of sin, then you will be free indeed ! " This was the freedom that He wished them to obtain. Here, as elsewhere, our Lord carefully avoids saying anything to bring on Himself the charge of rebelling against constituted authorities, and of heading a popular rise for liberty.
The word rendered " indeed " here is not the word so rendered at the 31st verse. Here it means " really, in reality," from the participle of the verb "to be." There it means " truly."
Let us not forget in these days that the only liberty which is truly valuable in God's sight is that which Christ gives. All political liberty, however useful for many purposes, is worthless, unless we are children of God, and heirs of the kingdom, by faith in Jesus. He only is perfectly free who is free from sin. All beside are slaves. He that would be free in this fashion has only to apply to Christ for freedom. It is the peculiar office and privilege of the Lord Jesus, to enfranchise forever all who come to Him.
Augustine carries the freedom here promised far into the future. He remarks, " When shall there be full and perfect liberty? When there shall be no enemies, when the last enemy shall be destroyed, even death."
John 8:36 · Open Word Bible
36So if the Son frees you, you will be truly free.
JOHN VIII. 37—47.
We are taught for one thing the ignorant self-righteousness of the natural man. We find the Jews pluming themselves on their natural descent from Abraham, as if that must needs cover all deficiencies : " Abraham is our father." We find them going even further than this, and claiming to be God's special favourites and God's own family : " We have one Father, even God." They forgot that fleshly relationship to Abraham was useless, unless they shared Abraham's grace. They forgot that God's choice of their father to be head of a favoured nation was never meant to carry salvation to the children, unless they walked in their father's footsteps. All this in their blind self-conceit they refused to see. " We are Jews. We are God's children. We are the true Church. We are in the covenant. We must be all right." This was their whole argument !
Strange as it may seem, there are multitudes of so-called Christians who are exactly like these Jews. Their whole religion consist of a few notions neither wiser nor better than those propounded by the enemies of our Lord. They will tell you " that they are regular Church people ; they have been baptized ; they go to the Lord's table ;" — but they can tell you no more. Of all the essential doctrines of the Gospel they are totally ignorant. Of faith, and grace, and repentance, and holiness, and spiritual mindedness they know nothing at all. But, forsooth ! they are Churchmen, and so they hope to go to heaven ! There are myriads in this condition. It sounds sad, but unhappily it is only too true.
John 8:37–47 · Open Word Bible
37I know that you are descended from Abraham. Yet you are trying to kill Me, because My word is making no headway in you. 38I speak of what I have seen in the Father's presence, and you, in the same way, do what you have heard from the father." 39They replied, "Abraham is our father." Jesus said to them, "If you are Abraham's children, then you would be doing what Abraham did. …
I know that ye are Abraham’s seed
In this verse our Lord takes up the arrogant boast of the Jews, that they were Abraham's seed. He had replied to their assertion, " We were never in bondage to any man," by showing the nature of true bondage and true liberty. He now returns to their opening saying, " We be Abraham's seed,' and begins by telling them that He knew, and fully admitted, their carnal descent from Abraham.
[But ye seek to kill me.] This must mean, "Your relation to Abraham does you no good, for ye are seeking to murder Me at this very moment, though I have come to fulfil the promises made to Abraham."
Here, as well as at the 40th verse, and chapter vii. 19, our Lord shows His perfect knowledge of all the designs of His enemies. He gives us an example of steady perseverance in God's work, even though we know our lives are in peril.
John 8:37 · Open Word Bible
37I know that you are descended from Abraham. Yet you are trying to kill Me, because My word is making no headway in you.
because my word hath no place in you
This means, "Because the Gospel I preach, the message I brought from my Father, makes no way or progress in your hearts, or among you." — The Greek word, which our translators have rendered "hath place," is never so rendered elsewhere. The idea here seems to be that of " going forward, spreading, and marching on."
This describes literally the condition of many who hear Christ's word in every age. It seems to come to a dead standstill or halt in their hearts, and to make no way with them.
I speak that, &c.
The sense of this verse appears to be filled up thus: "The truth is, that there is an entire gulf and breach between you and Me. I speak, and am ever speaking, the doctrine which I have seen with My Father, in our eternal councils about mankind, and which I am sent by Him to proclaim to the world. You, on the other hand, do and are always doing the things which your father the devil presents to your minds, and which you have seen and imbibed into your characters, under his influence."
When our Lord speaks of what He has "seen" with His Father, we must remember, as elsewhere, that He uses language accommodated to our weak capacities, to describe the relation between Himself and the first Person in the Trinity. Compare John iii. 32 and v. 19.
There can be no doubt that the "father" of the Jews, to whom our Lord here refers, is " the devil," when we read the verses following. It conveys an awful idea of the state of unbelieving and wicked men, that they are doing what they have seen and learned from the devil. There may, however, be special reference to the design of the Jews to kill Christ. Our Lord's meaning may be, "Ye are doing what ye have seen with the devil your father. He has suggested to you to kill Me, and you are listening to his suggestion."
John 8:38 · Open Word Bible
38I speak of what I have seen in the Father's presence, and you, in the same way, do what you have heard from the father."
They answered...Abraham is our father
This is a repetition of what the Jews had already said. Startled at what our Lord said about their " father," they reassert emphatically their relationship to Abraham.— "What do you mean by thus speaking of our father ? Abraham is our father."
[Jesus saith...if Abraham's children... works of Abraham.] Our Lord here tells them that it is possible to be Abraham's children according to the flesh, and yet not Abraham's children according to the Spirit. — "If ye were true spiritual descendants of Abraham, you would show it by doing such things as Abraham did. Your works would be like his, because springing from a like faith."
The distinction here drawn by our Lord is a very important one for Christians to notice. The utter uselessness of carnal relationship, or formal outward succession, is a truth which man does not like to admit, but one that needs to be constantly taught in the Churches. How common to hear men say, " we belong to the one true Church; we are in the direct succession from the Apostles." Such claims are utterly useless, if not accompanied by " works."
We must never forget the importance of " works," if put in their right place. They cannot justify us. They are at best full of imperfection. But they are useful evidences, and serve to show whose we are, and what our religion is worth.
John 8:39 · Open Word Bible
39They replied, "Abraham is our father." Jesus said to them, "If you are Abraham's children, then you would be doing what Abraham did.
But now ye seek to kill me, &c.
Our Lord in this verse confirms the charge made in the preceding one, — that His enemies were not Abraham's spiritual children, although carnally descended from Abraham. — " At this very moment you are wishing and endeavouring to put Me to death, not for any crime, but simply because I have spoken to you that mighty message of truth which I heard from My Father, and am sent to proclaim to the world as the Messiah. This is the very opposite of what your great forefather Abraham would have done. He longed to see My day. He rejoiced in the prospect of it. He would have hailed My appearance and message with delight. Your conduct, therefore, is an unanswerable proof that you are not Abraham's spiritual children."
Our Lord's argument is the same that St. Paul uses to the Romans. " He is not a Jew which is one outwardly." — " They which are the children of the flesh are not the children of God." (Rom. ii. 28, 29 ; ix. 8.) The importance of it cannot be overrated. It establishes the great principle that fleshly relationship, or ecclesiastical connection, is nothing without grace in the heart, and indeed only adds to a man's condemnation.
The expression " this did not Abraham " is a Hebraism. Of course literally Abraham could not " seek to kill " Christ, because he never lived with Him on earth. The meaning must be " your conduct is the very opposite of what Abraham would have done, and utterly contrary to the general tenor of what he did while he lived." Compare Deut. xvii. 3; Jer. vii. 22 — 31 : xix. 5 ; xxxii. 35, where the same form of speech is used.
John 8:40 · Open Word Bible
40But now you are trying to kill Me, a man who has spoken to you the truth I heard from God. That is not what Abraham did.
When our Lord calls Himself here simply " a man," He uses an expression which He nowhere else employs in the Gospels. As a rule, He calls Himself" the Son of man," when speaking of His human nature. Here, however, He seems to speak of Himself in the point of view in which His unbelieving enemies ought to have regarded Him, if they could not yet acknowledge His divinity. " I am among you a man speaking the truth : and yet ye seek to kill Me." — The attempt of Jews and Socinians to show that our Lord was not really God, founded on this text, is futile. Our Lord's real and true humanity no sound Trinitarian thinks of denying.
Ye do the deeds of your father
This means "You are doing the things that your' father the devil approves and suggests to you. You are showing yourselves genuine children of the devil, by doing his works." The word "ye" in the Greek is emphatic, and may possibly be intended to contrast with " I," at the beginning of the 35th verse.
[Then said they... not born of fornication.'] These words can hardly be taken literally. Our Lord was speaking to the Jews not as individuals, but as a nation and a class, and was speaking of their descent in a religious point of view. The question was, " Who was their father"? From whom did they get their spiritual character? To whom were their proclivities and tendencies to be traced?" This our Lord's hearers understood, and said, " We be not born of fornication ; we are not heathens and idolaters at any rate, even if we are not as good as Abraham."— That idolatry was called fornication, because it was unfaithfulness to the covenant God, a forsaking Him for false gods, is, I think, clear from many places in the Old Testament. See for instance Jeremiah ii. 1—20, and iii. 1 — 3. I think this was in the minds of the Jews, when they spoke to our Lord here. This is Augustine's view.
The notion of Euthymius, Rupertus, and others, that the Jews refer to other children of Abraham, by Hagar and Keturah, and boast themselves his true children by Sarah, is not satisfactory. It is surely too much to charge Abraham with the sin of fornication, because he took Hagar to be his wife, at the instance of Sarah, and married Keturah after Sarah's death !
The notion of some, that the Jews refer here to the many marriages between Jews and Gentiles in the Old Testament times, (as seen in Ezra x. 1, etc.,) and repudiate them, is not probable.
John 8:41 · Open Word Bible
41You are doing the works of your own father." They said to Him, "We were not born out of sexual sin. We have one Father: God."
Some have thought that the Jews insinuated wicked doubts of our Lord's legitimate birth in this phrase. But it seems unlikely.
[We have one Father, even God.] The Jews here lay claim to be regarded as God's children. That God is called "the Father " of Israel in several places in the Old Testament, is undeniable. See Deut. xxxii. 6; 1 Chron. xxix. 10; Isai. lxiii. 16 and lxiv. 8 ; Mal. i. 6. But it is very clear that these texts specially refer to God's relation to Israel as a nation, and not to Israelites as individuals. The Jews, however, in their pride and self-righteousness, made no such nice distinction. They did not see that national sonship and covenant sonship without spiritual sonship, are nothing worth. Hence they brought on themselves the stern rebuke of the next verse.
Jesus said...If God...your Father...love me
Our Lord here tells the Jews, that although they might be children of God by covenant and nationality, they were evidently not God's children by grace and spiritual birth. If God was really their Father, they would show it by loving the Son of God, even Himself.
Let us note carefully the great principle contained in this sentence. Love to Christ is the infallible mark of all true children of God. Would we know whether we are born again, whether we are children of God? There is one simple way of finding it out. Do we love Christ? If not, it is vain and idle to talk of God as our Father, and ourselves as God's children. No love to Christ, no sonship to God !
The favourite notion of many, that baptism makes us sons and daughters of God, and that all baptized people should be addressed as God's children, is utterly irreconcilable with this sentence. Unless a baptized person loves Christ, he has no right to call God Father, and is not God's child. He has yet to be born again, and brought into God's family. Before the point and edge of these words, the doctrine that spiritual re generation always accompanies baptism cannot stand.
The modern notion about God's universal Fatherhood, which finds such favour with many, is no less irreconcilable with this sentence than baptismal regeneration. That God the Father is full of love, mercy, and compassion to all is no doubt true. But that God is really and truly the spiritual Father of any one who does not love Christ can never be maintained without contradicting our Lord's words in this place.
John 8:42 · Open Word Bible
42Jesus said to them, "If God were your Father, you would love Me, because I came out from God and have arrived here. I have not come on My own authority; it was He who sent Me.
The sentence is full of condemnation to all who know nothing experimentally of Christ, and neither think, nor feel, nor care anything about Him. Crowds of so-called Christians are in this unhappy state, and are plainly not God's children, whatever they may think. — The sentence is equally full of comfort for all true believers, however weak and feeble. If they feel drawn towards Christ in heart and affection, and can truly say "I do love Him," they have the plainest mark of being God's children, and "if children then heirs." (Rom. viii. 17.)
[For I proceeded forth, etc.] Our Lord here shows the Jews His own divine nature and mission. He had proceeded forth, and come from God — the eternal Son from the eternal Father. He had not come of His own independent will and without commission, but specially sent and appointed by the Father, as His last and dearest Messenger to a lost world. Such was His nature. Such was His position and relation to the Father.— If therefore they really were children of God the Father, they would love Him as the Father's Sod, the Father's Messenger, the Father's promised Messiah. Not loving Him, they gave the plainest proof that they were not God's children. — A true child of God will love everything belonging to God, and specially he will love God's only begotten and beloved Son. He can see and find nothing nearer to the Father than the Son, who is the •' brightness of His glory and the express image of His person." (Heb. i. 3.) If, therefore, he does not love the Son, it is clear that he is no true child of the Father.
Why do ye not understand, &c.
In this verse, our Lord seems to me to draw a distinction between "speech" and "word." The expression " word " is deeper than " speech." By " speech," He means " My manner of speaking and expressing Myself." By "word," He means generally " My doctrine. " — The sense is, " How is it that ye do not understand My manner of expressing Myself to you, when I speak of such things as freedom and of 'your father' ? It is because ye will not receive and attend to My whole message, — the word that I bring to you from My Father." — Lightfoot takes this view.
This explanation seems to me to describe most accurately the state of things between our Lord and His hearers. They were continually misunderstanding, misinterpreting, and stumbling at, the expressions and language that He used in teaching them. Did He speak of " bread" ? They thought He meant literal bread. — Did He speak of " freedom " ? They thought He meant temporal and political freedom. — Did He speak of " their Father"? They thought He meant Abraham. — How was it that they so misunderstood His language and dialect? It was simply because their hearts were utterly hardened and closed against the whole " word of salvation" which He came to proclaim. Having no will to listen to and receive His doctrine, they were ready at every step to misconstrue the words and figures under which it was conveyed and placed before them.
Any one who preaches the Gospel now must often observe that precisely the same thing happens in the present day. Hearers, who are strongly prejudiced against the Gospel, are constantly perverting, wresting, and misinterpreting the language of the preacher. None are so blind as those who will not see, and none so stupid as those who do not want to understand.
John 8:43 · Open Word Bible
43Why do you not understand what I am saying? It is because you cannot bear to listen to My word.
The "cannot" here is a moral inability. It is like "no man can come unto Me," and " His brethren could not speak peaceably unto him." (John vi. 44; Gen. xxxvii. 4.) It means, "Ye have no will to hear with your hearts."
Chrysostom remarks : " Not to be able here means not to be willing."
Ye are of your father the devil, &c.
This verse deserves special attention, both for the sternness of the rebuke it contains, and the deep subject which it handles. The general sense is as follows: "Ye are so far from being spiritual children of Abraham, or true children of God, that, on the contrary, ye may be rightly called the children of the devil; and ye show it, by having a will set on doing the evil things which your father suggests to you. He, from the beginning of creation, was a being set on the destruction of man, and abode not in the original truth and righteousness in which he was created ; for now truth is not in his nature. When he now speaks and suggests a lie, he speaks out of his own peculiar inward nature, for he is emiently a liar, and the father of a lie."
When our Lord says to the wicked Jews, " Ye are of your father the devil," He does not mean that the wicked are made wicked by the devil in the same sense that the godly are made godly by God, created anew and begotten of God ; but He uses a common Hebraism, by which persons who are closely connected with, or entirely under the influence of, another, are called "his children." It is in this sense that the wicked and unbelieving are truly the children of the devil. This must be carefully remembered. The devil has no power to " create" the wicked. He only finds them born in sin, and, working upon their sinful nature, obtains such an influence, that he becomes practically the " father of the wicked." (See Matt. xiii. 38 and 1 John iii. 8; Matt. xiii. 19 ; Luke xvi. 8; xx. 34; Isai. lvii. 4; Numb. xvii. 10.)
John 8:44 · Open Word Bible
44Your father is the devil, and you choose to do what your father wants. He was a murderer from the beginning, and he never stood in the truth, because there is no truth in him. Whenever he tells a lie, he is speaking from what is his own, because he is a liar and the father of lies.
Augustine says : " Whence are those Jews sons of the devil?— By imitation, not by birth." He also refers to Ezek. xvi. 3, as a parallel case.
When our Lord says, " Ye will do the lusts of your father," we must remember that "ye will " is emphatic in the Greek. " Ye have a will, and mind, and purpose, and disposition." — By " doing the lusts," lie means "ye follow those evil inclinations and desires " which are peculiarly characteristic of the devil, and according to his mind, — such as to commit murder, and to love and tell a lie. The desire of the devil can only be for that which is evil.
When our Lord says the devil was a "murderer from the beginning," I do not think He refers exclusively to Cain's murder of Abel, -though I think it was in His mind. (See 1 John iii. 12.) I rather think He means that the devil, from the beginning of creation, was set on bringing death into the world, and murdering man both body and soul.
Origen remarks : " It was not one man only that the devil killed, but the whole human race, inasmuch as in Adam all die. So that he is truly called a murderer."
When our Lord says that the " devil abode not in the truth," I think He teaches that the devil is a fallen spirit, and that he was originally made very good and " perfect," like all other works of God's hands. But he did not continue in that state of truth and righteousness in which he was originally created. He kept not his first estate, but fell away. " Truth " seems to stand for all righteousness, and holiness, and conformity to the mind of God, who is "Truth itself." This verse, and Jude 6, are the two clearest proofs in the Bible that the devil fell, and was not created evil at the beginning.
The word "abode" would be more literally rendered, "stood."
When our Lord says, " Because there is no truth in him," He does not mean that this was the reason why the devil " abode not in the truth." If this had been His meaning, He would have said, " Truth was not in him." But He says, "is." — His words are meant to describe the present nature of the devil. "He is now a being in whom truth is not." — It seems to me a somewhat similar expression to that of St. Paul, when he says, " I obtained mercy, because I did it ignorantly ; " where " because " does not mean the reason why he obtained mercy. (1 Tim. i. 12.) The Greek word for " because " in both cases is the same.
And because I tell, &c.
Our Lord in this verse puts in strong contrast His own teaching and the lying suggestions of the devil, and the readiness of the wicked Jews to disbelieve Him and believe the devil. — "The reason why you do not believe Me is, your thorough dislike to the truth of God. You are genuine children of your father the devil. If I told you things that are false, ye would believe Me. But because I tell you things that are true, you believe me not."
We see here how little cause faithful ministers of Christ have to feel surprise at the unbelief of many of their hearers. If they preach the truth, they must make up their minds not to be believed by many. It is only what happened to their Master. " If they have kept My saying, they will keep yours also." (John xv. 20.)
John 8:45 · Open Word Bible
45But as for Me, it is because I tell the truth that you do not believe Me.
Which of you convinceth me, &c.
Our Lord in this verse asks two questions, to which it was impossible for them to give an answer : " Which of you can reprove or convince Me as an offender concerning sin of any kind? You know that you cannot lay any offence to My charge. Yet if I am free from any charge, and at the same time speak to you nothing but what is right and true, what is the reason that ye do not believe Me ? "
Let us note here the perfect spotlessness and innocence of our Lord's character. None but He could ever say, "I have no sin. I challenge any one to find out any imperfection or fault in Me." Such a complete and perfect Sacrifice and Mediator is just what sinful man needs.
John 8:46 · Open Word Bible
46Which of you can prove that I have sinned? If it is the truth I speak, why do you not believe Me?
He that is of God, &c.
Our Lord in this verse supplies an answer to His own questions, and conclusively proves the wickedness and ungodliness of His hearers. — "He that is a true child of God hears with pleasure, believes, and obeys God's words, such as I bring to you from My Father. You, by not hearing, believing, and obeying them, prove plainly that you are not God's children. If you were, you would hear gladly, believe, and obey. Your not hearing proves conclusively that you are what I said, children, not of God, but of the devil."
Let us note here that the disposition to hear and listen to truth is always a good sign, though not an infallible one, about a person's soul. It is said, in another place, "My sheep hear my voice." (John x. 26, 27.) When we see people obstinately refusing to listen to counsel, and to attend to the Gospel, we are justified in regarding them as not God's children, not born again, without grace, and needing yet to be converted.
Let us note here, as elsewhere, how carefully our Lord speaks of His teaching as " God's words." It consisted of words and truths which God the Father had commissioned Him to preach and proclaim to man. It was not " His own words " only, but His Father's as well as His own.
Rollock observes, that there is no surer mark of an unsanctified nature than dislike to God's Word.
Musculus, Bucer, and others maintain here that the phrase, " He that is of God, heareth God's Words," must be confined to God's election; and means, " He that was chosen of God from all eternity." I cannot, however, see reason for confining the sense so closely. I prefer to consider " of God " as including, not only election, but calling, regeneration, adoption, conversion, and sanctification. This is Rollock's view.
John 8:47 · Open Word Bible
47Anyone who comes from God listens to God's words. You do not listen, and this is why: you are not from God."
JOHN VIII. 48—59.
We should observe, first, in this passage, what blasphemous and slanderous language was addressed to our Lord by His enemies. We read that the Jews " said unto Him, Say we not well that thou art a Samaritan, and hast a devil ? " Silenced in argument, these wicked men resorted to personal abuse. To lose temper, and call names, is a common sign of a defeated cause.
Nicknames, insulting epithets, and violent language, are favourite weapons with the devil. When other means of carrying on his warfare fail, he stirs up his servants to smite with the tongue. Grievous indeed are the sufferings which the saints of God have had to endure from the tongue in every age. Their characters have been slandered. Evil reports have been circulated about them. Lying stories have been diligently invented, and greedily swallowed, about their conduct. No wonder that David said, "Deliver my soul, O Lord, from lying lips, and from a deceitful tongue." (Psalm cxx. 2.)
The true Christian in the present day must never be surprised to find that he has constant trials to endure from this quarter. Human nature never changes. So long as he serves the world, and walks in the broad way, little perhaps will be said against him. Once let him take up the cross and follow Christ, and there is no lie too monstrous, and no story too absurd, for some to tell against him, and for others to believe. But let him take comfort in the thought that he is only drinking the cup which his blessed Master drank before him. The lies of his enemies do him no injury in heaven, whatever they may on earth. Let him bear them patiently, and not fret, or lose his temper. When Christ was reviled, " He reviled not again." (1 Peter ii. 23.) Let the Christian do likewise.
John 8:48–59 · Open Word Bible
48The Jews who were arguing with Him answered, "Are we not right to say that You are a Samaritan and have a demon?" 49Jesus answered, "I do not have a demon. Rather, I honor My Father, and you dishonor Me. 50But I do not seek My own glory. There is one who seeks it, and He judges. …
Then answered the Jews...Samaritan...devil
This verse seems to contain nothing but personal abuse and blasphemous slander. Unable to answer our Lord's arguments, the unbelieving Jews lost their temper, and resorted to the last weapon of a disputant, — senseless invective and calling of names. The extent to which calling names is carried by Oriental people, even in the present day, is something far greater than in this country we can imagine.
"When the Jews called our Lord " a Samaritan," they meant much the same as saying that He was no true Jew, and little better than a heathen. "The Jews have no dealings with the Samaritans." (John iv. 9.) When they said, "Thou hast a devil," I think it meant rather more than "thou art mad," as in John vii. 20, if we observe the following verse. It probably implied, " Thou actest and speakest under the influence of the devil. The power Thou hast is from Satan, and not from God."
Let us learn here how little cause Christians have to be surprised, if hard names and insulting epithets are applied to them. It is only what was done to their Master, and is no ground for discouragement in doing God's work.
John 8:48 · Open Word Bible
48The Jews who were arguing with Him answered, "Are we not right to say that You are a Samaritan and have a demon?"
Jesus answered, I have not a devil, &c.
Our Lord's answer to the coarse invective of His enemies amounts to this : " In saying that I have a devil you say that which is not true. I am simply honouring My Father in heaven by delivering His message to man, and you by your violent language are dishonouring Me, and in effect dishonouring and insulting my Father. Your insults do not strike Me only, but my Father also."
Let us note our Lord's calmness and equanimity under insult. A solemn denial of the blasphemous charge laid against Him, and an equally solemn reminder that He was honouring the God whom they themselves professed to worship, are the only reply He condescends to make.
John 8:49 · Open Word Bible
49Jesus answered, "I do not have a demon. Rather, I honor My Father, and you dishonor Me.
And I seek not mine own glory
This sentence seems to arise out of the last verse.—" Ye dishonour Me; but you do not move or hurt Me, for I did not come to seek my own glory, but the glory of Him that sent Me. I receive not honour from men." (See John vii. 18 and v. 41.) Here, as elsewhere, our Lord points to the great principle, " that a true messenger from heaven will never seek his own glory, but his Master's."
[ There is one that seeketh and judgeth.] There is a very solemn warning in these words. They mean, "There is One, however, even my Father in heaven, who does seek and desire my glory; and not only seeks, but judges the conduct of all who dishonour Me, with deep displeasure, and will punish it at the last day."
There is comfort here for all Christ's members as well as for their Head. Though they may not think of it, there is One in heaven who cares deeply for them, sees all they go through, and will one day plead their cause. The latent thought seems the same as in Eccles. v. 8 — "He that is higher than the highest regardeth." A believer may cheer himself with the thought, " There is One that judgeth. There is One that sees all, that cares for me, and will set all right at the last day."
Euthymius remarks on this verse that we should not heed things said against ourselves, but should vindicate the honour of God if things are said against God.
John 8:50 · Open Word Bible
50But I do not seek My own glory. There is one who seeks it, and He judges.
Verily...If a man keep my saying...never see death
The mighty promise contained in this verse seems intended to wind up the whole conversation. All that our Lord had said had produced no effect. He therefore closes His teaching for the present by one of those mighty sayings which tower above everything near them, and of which St. John's Gospel contains so many. — " Whether you will hear or not, whether you choose to know Me or not, I solemnly tell you that if any man receives, believes, and keeps My doctrine, he shall never see death. Despised and rejected as I am by you, life or death, heaven or hell, blessing or cursing, depend and hinge on accepting the message I proclaim to you. I am the way, the truth, and the life." — It is like Moses taking leave of Israel and saying, " I call heaven and earth to record against you, that I have set before you life and death." (Deut. xxx. 15, 19.) Just so our Lord seems to say, " I tell you once more, for the last time, that to keep My saying is the way to escape death."
The expression is parallel to the one our Lord uses in the synagogue of Capernaum. There He says, " He that believeth in Me, hath everlasting life." Here it is " shall never see death." (John vi. 47.)
We should notice here, as elsewhere, that when our Lord uses the expression, "Verily, verily, I say unto you," which is familiar to all careful readers of St. John's Gospel, He is always about to say something of peculiar gravity and solemnity. See John i. 51; iii. 3, 5, 11; v. 19, 24, 25; vi. 26, 32, 47, 53; viii. 34, 51, 58; x. 1, 7; xii. 24; xiii. 16, 20, 21, 38; xiv. 12; xvi. 20, 23; xxi. 18.
John 8:51 · Open Word Bible
51Truly, truly, I tell you, if anyone keeps My word, they will never see death."
The expression " keep my saying," means " receive into his heart, believe, embrace, obey, and hold fast the doctrine or message which I am commissioned to teach." — The phrase " my saying," means much more than the " words I am speaking at this moment." It is rather the whole doctrine of My Gospel.
The expression " never see death " cannot be taken literally. Our Lord did not mean that His disciples would not die and be buried like other children of Adam. We know that they did die. The meaning is probably threefold: (1) "He shall be completely delivered from that spiritual death Of condemnation under which all mankind are born ; his soul is alive and can die no more : (2) He shall be delivered from the sting of bodily death; his flesh and bones may sink under disease and be laid in the grave, but the worst part of death shall not be able to touch him, and the grave itself shall give him up one day : (3) He shall be delivered entirely from the second death, even eternal punishment in hell; over him the second death shall have no power."
The width and greatness of this promise are very remarkable. Ever since the day of Adam's fall death has been man's peculiar enemy. Man has found the truth of the sentence, " In the day thou eatest thou shalt surely die." (Gen. ii. 27.) But our Lord boldly and openly proclaims that in keeping His saying there is complete deliverance from death. In fact, He proclaims Himself the One greater than death. None could say this but a Redeemer who was very God.
Augustine says : " The death from which our Lord came to deliver us was the second death, eternal death, the death of hell, the death of damnation with the devil and his angels. That is indeed death; for this death of ours is only a migration. What is it but a putting off a heavy load, provided there be not another load carried, by which the man shall be cast headlong into hell. This is the death of which the Lord says, * He shall not see death.' "
Let us note the breadth and fulness of this promise. It is for any one who keeps Christ's sayings. " If a man," or rather it should be rendered, " If any man," etc.
Let us beware of putting a meaning on this promise which it was not intended to convey. The idea of some that it means " believers shall be so completely delivered from death that they shall neither feel bodily pain nor mental conflict," is one that cannot be supported. It is not borne out by other passages of Scripture, and, as a matter of fact, it is contradicted by experience. The Gospel delivers believers from that " fear of death " which unbelievers feel, no doubt. (Heb. ii. 15.) But we have no right to expect believers to have no bodily conflict, no convulsion, no struggle, and no suffering. Flesh and blood must and will feel. " I groan," said holy Baxter on his deathbed, "but I do not grumble." Death is a serious thing, even though the sting is taken away.
Then said the Jews, &c.
The argument of the Jews in this verse seems to be as follows : " We know now by Thy own words that Thou art mad and hast a devil. Our great father Abraham and the prophets, holy and good as they all were, are all dead, and yet Thou presumest to say that if a man keep Thy saying he will never die. In short, Thou makest Thyself greater than Abraham, for Abraham could not escape death, while keeping Thy saying enables a man to escape death. To talk in this way is a plain" proof that thou art mad."
The phrase " to have a devil," in this place can hardly mean anything but "to be mad or crazy."
The Jews, it will be observed, do not quote our Lord's words correctly. He had said, " shall never see death." They report Him as saying, " shall never taste of death."Whether this was a wilful perversion of His words is rather difficult to decide. Some think that the Jews intentionally exaggerated the promise, and put "taste" for " see," in order to magnify the offence our Lord had committed. Others think that the difference means nothing, and that it only shows how thoroughly the Jews misunderstood our Lord, and thought that He referred to nothing but bodily death.
Here, as elsewhere, we may remark how ready the Jews were to pervert and warp our Lord's meaning, and to put a carnal and gross sense on spiritual language.
John 8:52 · Open Word Bible
52The Jews there said to Him, "Now we are sure that You have a demon. Abraham died, and so did the prophets, yet You say, 'If anyone keeps My word, they will never taste death.'
Art thou greater, &c.
The question in this verse shows that our Lord had again succeeded in arousing the curiosity of the Jews, and stirring them to inquire about His nature and person. — "Who art Thou that talkest in this way? Whom dost Thou make Thyself? To say that those who keep Thy saying shall never die is to make Thyself superior to Abraham and the prophets, who are all dead. Who and what art Thou? Art thou really some one greater than Abraham? "
Chrysostom observes that the question of the Jews reminds us of the Samaritan woman's question: "Art thou greater than our father Jacob? " (John iv. 12.)
John 8:53 · Open Word Bible
53Surely You are not greater than our father Abraham? He died. The prophets died too! Who do You think You are?"
If I honour myself...nothing, &c.
Our Lord's meaning in this verse seems to be as follows : " If at any time I take to myself and claim honour, such honour would be worthless. He who puts honour on Me, and commissions Me to say that keeping My saying shall deliver a man from death, is My Father in heaven, — that very Being whom you profess to call your God. It is your own God, the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, who has put such honour on Me, that life or death turn on keeping My sayings, and believing on Me."
Here, as elsewhere, we should mark the carefulness with which our Lord disclaims all self-exaltation, and desire for glory and honour from man. If, in claiming for Himself to hold the keys of life and death, He seemed to claim honour, He carefully reminds the Jews that it is an honour put on Him by the Father in heaven, even by their own God. He desired no honour independent of Him, or in rivalry to Him.
When our Lord says, " My Father honoureth Me," the expression must include all the works, and signs, and miracles, which the Father gave Him to do ; as well as the words which He gave Him to speak. (John v. 26; xiv. 10, 11.)
John 8:54 · Open Word Bible
54Jesus answered, "If I glorify Myself, My glory means nothing. The one who glorifies Me is My Father, the one of whom you say, 'He is our God.'
55. — [Yet ye have not known him, etc.] The meaning of this verse seems to be as follows : " Although you say of My Father in heaven that He is your God, you do not really know Him, and are plainly ignorant of His character, His will, and His purposes. Professing to know Him, in works you deny Him. But I, on the contrary, know Him perfectly : for I am indeed one with Him from all eternity, and came forth from Him. So perfectly do I know Him, that I should be a liar, and a child of the devil, like yourselves, if I said I did not know Him. But I repeat that I know Him perfectly, and in all My words and works here on earth I carefully keep His sayings, and observe the commission he gave me."
John 8:55 · Open Word Bible
55You have never known Him, but I know Him. If I said that I did not know Him, I would be a liar like you. But I do know Him, and I keep His word.
There is undeniably a great peculiarity in the language of this verse. But- it is probably a Hebrew mode of putting in strong contrast the Jews' thorough ignorance of God, notwithstanding their high profession of being His chosen people, — and our Lord's perfect knowledge of God, notwithstanding the repeated assertions that He had a devil, was a Samaritan, and was consequently an enemy to the God of Israel. — The phrase, " I should be a liar, like yourselves, if I said I did not know the Father," was just the phrase to convey the strongest idea to the Jews' minds of our Lord's knowledge. — In arguing with some men, nothing but the strongest language, and the most paradoxical expressions, have any effect.— Even God himself thinks it good to make such an asseveration as "I swear by myself," and " as I live," in order to command attention. (Jer. xxii. 5; Heb. vi. 13; Ezek. xxxiii. 11.) Those who blame ministers and preachers for using strong language, and say that they should never use any but gentle, tame, and mild phrases, can hardly have studied human nature or the style of Scripture with thorough attention.
Your father Abraham, &c.
Our Lord, in this verse, takes up the question of the Jews, as to His being greater than Abraham, and boldly gives an answer. " You ask Me whether I am greater than Abraham. I tell you in reply that I am He whose coming and whose day of glory Abraham rejoiced to think he should see. Moreover by faith he even saw it, and when he saw it he was glad."
The precise meaning of the words of this verse is rather difficult to discover, though the general idea of it is plain and unmistakable. It is clear that our Lord implies that He is the promised Messiah, the Seed of Abraham, in whom all the generations of the earth should be blessed, — and of whom when Abraham first heard, " he laughed " for joy. (Gen. xvii. 17.)
(a) Some think, as most of the Fathers and Reformers, that it means, " Abraham rejoiced in the prospect of seeing, at some future time, My day, the clay of Messiah ; and by faith he did see it afar off."
(b) Some think, as Maldonatus, Lampe, Stier, and Bloomfield, that it means, " Abraham rejoiced when he was told that he should see My clay ; and he actually has seen it in Paradise, and has been gladdened there in the separate state by the sight."
(c) Some think, as Brown, Olshausen, Alford, Webster, and Hengstenberg, that it means, " Abraham's great desire and joyful expectation was to see My clay, and he actually saw Me when I appeared to him and talked with him on earth."
John 8:56 · Open Word Bible
56Your father Abraham was full of joy at the hope of seeing My day. He saw it, and it made him glad."
Of these three views the first appears to me the most probable, and most in keeping with the history of Abraham, in Genesis. It should be carefully observed that our Lord does not say that "Abraham saw Me," but that "he saw My day." The cause of Abraham's joy seems to have been, that there was to be of his seed a Messiah, a Saviour; and that he should see His clay, — the day of the Lord, the triumphant day of Messiah's complete victory and restitution of all things. This day he even saw by faith afar off, and was glad at the sight.— Our Lord's object does not seem to be to tell the Jews that Abraham had seen Him, but that He was " the Seed," the Messiah, who was promised to their father Abraham. The Jews had asked whether he was greater than Abraham? "Yes," he replies, " I am. I am that very Messiah whose day Abraham rejoiced to hear of, and saw afar off by faith. If you were like Abraham you would rejoice to see Me."
Chrysostom and Euthymius think that " My day," in this verse, means "the day of the crucifixion, which Abraham foreshowed typically by offering the ram in Isaac's place." This however seems a very cramped and limited view.
Rupertus thinks that Abraham " saw the day of Christ " when he entertained the three angels who came to him.
Augustine thinks it may refer to both the advents of Christ : first in humiliation, and second in glory.
Then said the Jews, &c.
It is plain that the Jews here put a wrong meaning on our Lord's words, and suppose Him to say that Abraham had seen Him, and He had seen Abraham. Yet our Lord had only said, " Abraham saw My day." It is another instance of their readiness to pervert His words.
When the Jews said, " Thou art not yet fifty years old," I believe they only meant, " Thou art not yet a middle-aged man." Fifty years old was the turning point in life, at which the Levites and priests were excused from further active service in the tabernacle. (Numbers iv. 3.) I fancy the reference is to this.— Our Lord was at this time about thirty- three years old, or at most thirty -four. The notion of Irenaeus and Papias that He really was fifty before He was crucified, is utterly without warrant, and absurd.
Some think that our Lord's countenance was so marred and aged by sorrow and care, that He looked much older than lie really was, and that hence the Jews supposed Him to be nearly fifty. But I prefer the former view.
Euthymius thinks that the Jews thought our Lord was fifty years old, on account of His great wisdom and experience. This, however, seems a weak and untenable view.
John 8:57 · Open Word Bible
57So the Jews there said to Him, "You are not even fifty years old, and You have seen Abraham?"
Jesus said...Before Abraham was, I am
This famous verse, I believe, can only receive one honest interpretation. It is a distinct assertion of our Lord's eternity, — His existence before all creation. '• I solemnly declare unto you that before Abraham was and existed I was, the great I AM, the same yesterday, to-clay, and forever, — the eternal God." All attempts to evade this explanation appear to me so preposterous that it is waste of time to notice them. The man who can think the words only mean, " I am He who was promised to Adam before Abraham was born," seems past the reach of reasoning. — The name " I AM," we must remember, is the very name by which God revealed Himself to the Jews, when He sent Moses to them : " Say unto the children of Israel, I AM hath sent me." (Exod. iii. 14.)
Let us carefully note what a strong proof we have here of the pre-existence and divinity of our Lord Jesus Christ. He applies to Himself the very name by which God made Himself known when He undertook to redeem Israel. It was " I AM " who brought them out of the land of Egypt. It was "I AM" who died for us upon the cross. The amazing strength of the foundation of a sinner's hope appears here. Believing on Jesus we rest on divinity, on One who is God as well as man.
There is a difference in the Greek verbs here employed, which we should carefully notice. The Greek for "was" is quite different from the Greek for " am." It is as if our Lord said, " before Abraham was born, I have an existence individual and eternal."
John 8:58 · Open Word Bible
58Jesus said to them, "Truly, truly, I tell you, before Abraham was, I am."
Chrysostom observes: "He said not before Abraham was, I was, but, I AM. As the Father useth this expression I AM, so also doth Christ, for it signifieth continuous being, irrespective of all time. On which account the expression seemed to the Jews blasphemous."
Augustine says: "In these words acknowledge the Creator and discern the creature. He that spake was made the Seed of Abraham ; and that Abraham might be, He was before Abraham."
Gregory remarks : " Divinity has no past or future, but always the present ; and therefore Jesus does not say before Abraham was I was, but I am."
Then took they up stones to cast at him
It is clear that the Jews at any rate had no doubt what our Lord meant in the preceding verse, whatever modern Socinians may think. They saw and knew at once that He who spake to them boldly claimed to be Jehovah, and One far greater than Abraham, being very God. This they did not believe, and therefore regarded Him as a blasphemer who ought at once to be stoned. In their rage and fury they immediately took up stones, which were probably lying about on account of repairs of the temple, in order to stone Him. The whole proceeding appears to have been a tumultuous and disorderly one, not regularly conducted, but sudden and unauthorized, like the stoning of Stephen afterwards. (Acts vii. 58.)
John 8:59 · Open Word Bible
59At this they picked up stones to throw at Him, but Jesus hid Himself and went out of the temple courts.
but Jesus hid himself, &c.
I think this withdrawal can only be regarded as miraculous. The Greek word rendered "hid Himself" is literally "was hid." It seems most improbable that our Lord could " pass by " and " go through the midst " of an angry crowd, whose eyes had for a long time been fixed and concentrated on Him, without being seen and stopped, unless there was a miraculous interposition. I believe that the eyes of His enemies were holden, and that they did not know Him for a season, or that by His own almighty power He rendered Himself temporarily invisible. It is only what He did at Nazareth on a similar occasion ; (Luke iv. 30 ;) and if we once concede that our Lord could work miracles at His will, there seems no reason to suppose that He would not work one on this occasion.
Let us note that our Lord's enemies could do nothing to Him until His hour was come for suffering. When He was at last taken prisoner, brought before Pilate, and crucified, it was not because He could not escape, but because He would not. What He did here He might have done there.
Let us note that it is not always the path of duty and of real obedience to God's will to sit still and submit to sufferings and death. It may be the will of God that we should " flee to some other city " and avoid death. (Matthew x. 23.) To court martyrdom and throw away life, when it might be saved, is not always the duty of a servant of Christ. Some of the martyrs of the primitive Church appear to have forgotten this.
Augustine says : "Jesus did not hide Himself in a corner of the temple as if He were afraid, or take refuge in a house, or run behind a wall or a pillar; but by His heavenly power He made Himself invisible to His enemies, and went through the midst of them."
The argument of Maldonatus, that this verse proves the possibility of Christ being corporally present in the Lord's Supper in the bread, is so preposterous that it requires no refutation. There is no positive proof that our Lord was actually invisible here. It is quite possible that the eyes of His enemies were " holden that they could not know Him." (Luke xxiv. 16.) If He was invisible, Maldonatus proves too much. The bread in the Lord's Supper is seen, and after consecration the Roman Catholic says its substance is changed. But it is not invisible.
In leaving this remarkable chapter, we should not fail to notice the difficulties under which our Lord's public ministry was carried on. Ten times, between the 12th verse and the 59th, we find His enemies interrupting, contradicting, or reviling Him. Our Master's calm dignity and perfect meekness under all this " contradiction of sinners " ought to be a never forgotten example to His disciples.